@@Rikegile Only Micah would have a problem with Arthur trying to change for the better, after all his own brother also did the same thing. And Bill just sees it as defying Dutch and going soft. The rest are already fed up with Dutch but too afraid or unwilling to go behind his back like Arthur
Bill was talking about the story missions like saving John helping Sadie and saving Abigail that had nothing to do with free roam he says that to arthur no matter your actions when you reach a certain point in the story
Mary-Beth: “So, what’s going on Arthur.” Arthur: “I think I’ve lost my mind.” Mary-Beth: “How so?” Arthur: “I’ve been picking plants and watching animals and hunting for treasure.” Mary-Beth: “Oh my!! That’s really bad.”
@@victorotaviocardoso959 Mainly because if #9 where you need to some from New Austin and because it doesn’t keep track of which plants you’ve picked or not. You could use the “Buggy Method@ or the chapter 4 Angelo Bronte mission or a mod if you have the PC version and just Gun it through the Great Planes around Black Water and then keep a note pad handy. Still a pain though.
I KNOW. im literally chilling being innocent and getting my honour up and Arthur’s like “I’ve been robbing, killing and hurting folk for no reason. I’m even killing animals needlessly. And robbing trains, burning buildings down, antagonising people and helping criminals” WHEN HAVE I DONE THAT?
@@IlIusive it’s either default, or includes missions, or it might have something to do with just causing trouble in general. I mean like antagonizing an NPC after they antagonized Arthur, or accidentally running into things and people. Any type of trouble and negative attention in general. I mean that’s basically how I play it. Go after the other gangs, stop npcs who made trouble for other npcs, antagonize the odd fool that made a rube comment to Arthur or knocked him off his horse since they got impatient (some of these types start shooting) and killing the predators before they get Arthur. The rest of the time is just hunting (only 3* and Legendaries for upgrades, clothes, crafting supplies and meat) and gathering, exploring, collecting, treasure hunting and missions. Though I also manage to get arrested a few times a chapter for trying to tick off the Challenges (which is probably the cause of some of that.
The irony of Dutch telling Arthur to calm down and stop acting like a fool, when he's literally the one getting the gang involved in shootouts and unnecessary trouble throughout the whole game.
Dutch: Why'd you free John Marston!? It'll put a lot of attention on us! By the way, meet us and Micah in the nearby town. Arthur: Why's that? Dutch: I'm about to murder one of the wealthiest men in the entire country in broad daylight! Arthur: Wait, what the fu- Dutch: HAVE FAITH ARTHUR!
I love that Grimshaw never gives up on Arthur, even when the gang is on its last legs about to be destroyed, she still tries to lead Arthur to being a better man. I think she goes underappreciated
@@RacerRidicule I always play low honor, with Arhur till the end of Chapter 4 after that i became soft and help folks makes the most sense to me.. called Redemtion :D
Me too I killed like a thousand bad guys they act like just cuz dude working the dock and doesn't have a gun and was provoked by me don't make them innocent once you fight back or gimme lip that's automatic self defense I always get out the next day cuz the case can't stick you don't talk back to me or dare raise ya hand you better with the bullet cuz them hands lethal
Can I just say that whenever Susan starts aggressively walking towards my direction, she is like the scariest character in the game. Just in the fact that I can't go a playthrough without her complaining about something multiple times. you can avoid it with some others but she is like the Snape of rdr2 bro. Bad, and looks scary but is actually deep down a very nice person. Snape is walking through hallways spotting class skippers but Susan going around spotting every little tiny thing wrong in camp from the girls and Arthur.
I hate her she got my hate all the way back in valentine I literally got enough money to max camp for that chapter I don’t pay for 3 days and she starts bitching about not paying in the stupid box anytime she comes up to me I click the not now button and walk off I can’t stand her the only time I like her was when she points a repeater at Micah for hitting on her
@@EzioAuditore7283 i find it kinda hilarious tho. I just start panicking and quickly move to my horse, sometimes failing and sometimes not. It's actually funnier if you don't say not now because your challenging yourself not to get jumpscared. Sometimes she is right behind you when your talking to somebody and sometimes you see her stand up from a chair on the other side of camp storming towards your direction. It's more my own joy but this made me love her way more. 😅
@@TalkativeGoofball if I didn’t find her annoying I’d probably think the same way it’s just the complaining I always found stupid like you pay for everything and she still bitches if she didn’t say anything and just did stuff like that I’d find it hilarious plus I found a camp argument where she was basically looking down on Mary Beth’s dreams and I just couldn’t stand her for it Mary is a sweet girl and she just treats her like shit then she kills Molly who was one of my favorites of the group not for any big reason but because she’s actually a sweet person who just got dealt a bad hand cause Dutch is a worthless playboy she just does things that made me not like her and find her enjoyable any time she got up and marched up to me I turned around and left camp to do something else
Probably because she was Dutch's girl before Molly. Like Molly, she probably got a little bitter about Dutch tossing her aside, she just didn't go down nearly the same downward spiral.
I didn't know Micah would react if you help folk in free roam 'cause i play high honor on every playthrough and Micah never talked to me like that for once.
Yes it has consequences lol. The one that i find the most annoying is the fact that the price for everything is about 5x higher if you play low honor. Its only worth playing low honor if you finished the story and has a lot of money with you.
Not really, the whole camp is functioning because of her, she’s basically the mother to the gang. She served her purpose, the only underutilized aspect of her was the lack of mention of her after her death, not to mention how even during her death nobody seemed to care. It should’ve been the Pinkertons that shot her if anything it makes no sense that Micah shot her and there was 0 reaction or consequence from Dutch or literally anyone else
@josephstalin2606 well it happened what you expect Dutch killing her. And she got distracted when Havier was informing the something was coming(it's been a while since I'd played the game
@@assassin8636 No did you even read my comment? I said it would’ve been better for the Pinkertons to shoot her it makes no sense that Dutch didn’t even acknowledge how Micah shot Ms Grimshaw although he’s the one being accused of treason, and the fact how it’s never brought up again you’d think Micah being the one to kill her would be significant but no
Micah's opinion on Arthur Low Honor: you are my dear friend and only Arthur, you are awesome. High Honor: soft heart will get you nowhere in the world Arthur.
I completed the game twice, one just the career mode, and the another one up down to 100%, and i always play with good honor, with Arthur and also with John, never killing inocent folk and trying to help everybody. But i never see any of those dialogues...
On my first play through murdered everyone i came cross at the end of the game i still murdered everyone i came cross no one was save in any town in rdr2 you could probably say that i am a psychopath
maybe you didn't spend much time at camp? i mean i didn't either (did the same as you, 1st playthrough was story and second was for 100%) but i still got them.... weird....
Lower your honor for a wile. It will prock. You have to be bad and gain a bad reputation, as mika said "you've gone soft" suggesting you were bad before now your not
This was probably already said, but I'll say anyway, I don't know if there's a specific trigger, but in Chpt 6, if you help people, at least for me, Javier also nags Arthur for going behind Dutch's back
Yep but that seems more story related, more specifically it seems to be triggered after helping Rains Fall, and it always happens, unlike these convos which are triggered specifically from your actions in free roam
Such great quotes Ms. Grimshaw: Ur too close to the end to not change!! Micah: That heart of urs is going to get u killed. Micah was completely right but he also didnt realize that Arthur's heart would get him killed as well. John, Sadie, and Charles went after him because Arthur truly cared about them. Even Dutch felt he had to do right by Arthur in the end. A good heart may get u killed but it often changes people for the better. And ironically enough if Arthur had a word in it he would have begged them to spare Micah and live their lives free and in peace.
3:20 this is sad when you think about the gangs morales during chapters 1-3. They specifically said they wanted to help people and now they entirely go against it.
Micah genuinely believing that surviving is the one and only thing that matters to the point he genuinely advises Arthur to go down that road as a "friendly" advice actually is pretty sad. It's the words of a man who tried to change but couldn't.
I watched the story back in 2019, but the more I see the possible interactions with the game members, the more I want to play it. The one thing preventing is the ending and the loss + departure of the gang itself. Which makes me want to never advance after Hosea and Lenny's death.
Not at this point in the story. After Arthur saves John, he’s basically replaced by Micah at being the right hand man of Dutch. He was demoted and treated like another gunman for the gang, which also helps Arthur realize Dutch was using him the entire time and therefore goes behind his back to do what’s right
I've always played honorably (I only ever lost honor when rescuing Micah in Strawberry, but I always make sure to keep that honor up, up, up instead of it going down, down, down)...I never lose honor and always make the right choice.
Its sad knowing that the gang will talk shit to arthur no matter if hes good or bad, being bad gets you in trouble, being good gets you killed and is breaking the rules
Micah shoots up an entire town and gets a pat on the back. Arthur shoots a bunch of innocent folk and he gets scolded. Guess we all know who the teacher's pet is here.
Dutch and Grimshaw are like “stop killing folks! We got enough problems” and Micah’s like “Where’s that spirit?!!” Bad deeds reactions are understandable and serve as a reminder to up your honor but being too good gets Micah to point it out’s like hilarious. It could’ve been any of the five antagonists but it had to be Micah saying “you’re not killing anymore?”
0:10 I got this all because the murfree brothers attacked me while I was camping, Later I shot a person kidnapping a woman near Braithwaite manor , Two o'driscoll's who were beating up a helpless guy in valentine and lemoyne raiders who were robbing a coach outside of Rhodes. I'm a bad guy now.
God Micah is so tragic in these moments because I enjoy -most- of his banter -most- of the time. He almost sounds concerned for Arthur in the middle of giving him shit in the second one. In the first one, I also like the implication that Arthur really is, or was one mean sumbitch even to Micah.
![Дон ДОН, Алаудинов и СБЕЖАВШИЕ из под Курска ахматовцы 😁 [Пародия]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dEfCf5IK26Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Micah mocking you for gaining honor is the smartest case of positive reinforcement in game!
Yet, it can be seriously dumb hearing it from goddamn Micah. I’d rather hear it from anyone else but him.
@@Rikegile Only Micah would have a problem with Arthur trying to change for the better, after all his own brother also did the same thing. And Bill just sees it as defying Dutch and going soft. The rest are already fed up with Dutch but too afraid or unwilling to go behind his back like Arthur
Yup
Yup
Bill was talking about the story missions like saving John helping Sadie and saving Abigail that had nothing to do with free roam he says that to arthur no matter your actions when you reach a certain point in the story
It's funny how Dutch complains that Arthur is killing people and will give Micah a free pass lmaoooo
Arthur has more bounty on his head,that is probably why.
@@assshaking dude is worth 500,000 dollars the whole gang is worth damnear as much as an aircraft
@Farexa 😂😂
Fr after he killed ms grimshaw and Arthur and many more
@@assshaking no Micah has more than that because what he did
2:17 i love how micah casually steps in shit, tells arthur he's soft and walks away
Poor shit, having to be stepped on by an even more rotten shit
Clever eye
The fact he says Arthur ain't about smoke and walks away when Arthur says you wanna prove it
💀
Ahahaha the sound of his foot squishing into that shit 🤣 😂 😆 hahaha micah goin smell funky for a while
Mary-Beth:
“So, what’s going on Arthur.”
Arthur:
“I think I’ve lost my mind.”
Mary-Beth:
“How so?”
Arthur:
“I’ve been picking plants and watching animals and hunting for treasure.”
Mary-Beth:
“Oh my!! That’s really bad.”
Doing BBC Documentaries, solving long unsolved treasure hunts, and testing the effects of some of the most nutritious plants in the world: *ding*
I mean, the herbalist challenges do be quite evil in their design so I guess it is kinda terrible
@@victorotaviocardoso959 Mainly because if #9 where you need to some from New Austin and because it doesn’t keep track of which plants you’ve picked or not.
You could use the “Buggy Method@ or the chapter 4 Angelo Bronte mission or a mod if you have the PC version and just Gun it through the Great Planes around Black Water and then keep a note pad handy. Still a pain though.
I KNOW. im literally chilling being innocent and getting my honour up and Arthur’s like “I’ve been robbing, killing and hurting folk for no reason. I’m even killing animals needlessly. And robbing trains, burning buildings down, antagonising people and helping criminals” WHEN HAVE I DONE THAT?
@@IlIusive it’s either default, or includes missions, or it might have something to do with just causing trouble in general. I mean like antagonizing an NPC after they antagonized Arthur, or accidentally running into things and people. Any type of trouble and negative attention in general. I mean that’s basically how I play it. Go after the other gangs, stop npcs who made trouble for other npcs, antagonize the odd fool that made a rube comment to Arthur or knocked him off his horse since they got impatient (some of these types start shooting) and killing the predators before they get Arthur. The rest of the time is just hunting (only 3* and Legendaries for upgrades, clothes, crafting supplies and meat) and gathering, exploring, collecting, treasure hunting and missions. Though I also manage to get arrested a few times a chapter for trying to tick off the Challenges (which is probably the cause of some of that.
The irony of Dutch telling Arthur to calm down and stop acting like a fool, when he's literally the one getting the gang involved in shootouts and unnecessary trouble throughout the whole game.
Well, he has a goddamn PLAN
Have some goddamn FAITH
“We need to make a lot of noise, a lot of money, and then we get to Tahiti and become mango farmers. Yes this plan does make sense somehow.” - Dutch
Dutch: Why'd you free John Marston!? It'll put a lot of attention on us! By the way, meet us and Micah in the nearby town.
Arthur: Why's that?
Dutch: I'm about to murder one of the wealthiest men in the entire country in broad daylight!
Arthur: Wait, what the fu-
Dutch: HAVE FAITH ARTHUR!
Context? Someone tell me?
I love that Grimshaw never gives up on Arthur, even when the gang is on its last legs about to be destroyed, she still tries to lead Arthur to being a better man. I think she goes underappreciated
and the fact that she stood up with arthur until the very end...
@@nctsgrass exactly, one of the most loyal to the gangs values
@@nctsgrassoh hi again...
She literally told Abigail to become a wh0r£ again bruh
And she took his side during the standoff with Micah
I love those "Me?" "What are you talking about?" "What do you mean".
Arthur, they ain't that dumb 😂
Arthur on the other hand is the more rational person here, so I don't blame him for considering them stupid
he really pulled out the "who, me?".
2:18 i love how you intentionally made him walk through horse shit lmao
*Arthur puts money in the box*
Dutch: That's my boy
*Arthur leaves camp and stays gone for a week*
Dutch: HAVE SOME GOD DAMN FAITH!
few moments later we need more money arthur😂😂
When somebody more give 0.01 ¢ an Arthur put 500 $
Relax he’s been bending over backwards
don’t use Gods name in vajn
@@savagescorpion83 It's a voicelines in the game he's quoting it
1:34 the delivery on that line gets me every time 😂
Frrrr lmaooooo
So casual 😂
And the Irony, too.
Dutch: calls out arthur for mass murder
Also Dutch: "we need more noise"
Micah : wtf do you think I’m doing-
"Ain't no one innocent in this world" I like Evil Arthur lol
I always play with good honor, with Arthur and also with John, but i have to agree that bad honor Arthur have the coldest talks in the game LMAO
Just yesterday shot a lawmans horse and then looted the saddlebags ,, and all i got was cocaine gum and arthur said "well that wasn't worth it"
@@RacerRidicule I always play low honor, with Arhur till the end of Chapter 4 after that i became soft and help folks makes the most sense to me.. called Redemtion :D
compared to him everyone might as well be a nun
@@Zok1988The game is called Red Dead *Redemption* after all.
My Arthur only kills in self defense, but they still consider it murdering innocent people. They were not innocent!
Same they were in the same saloon as me and I blew them up (in self defence) and apparently that's a 'multiple homicide'
Got to close to someones camp by accident and their first reaction is pull their gun out and blow me away unfortunate for them
Me too I killed like a thousand bad guys they act like just cuz dude working the dock and doesn't have a gun and was provoked by me don't make them innocent once you fight back or gimme lip that's automatic self defense I always get out the next day cuz the case can't stick you don't talk back to me or dare raise ya hand you better with the bullet cuz them hands lethal
That’s just rdr2 for you
The guy with the racoon hat is asking to be killed
"...I thought maybe it was Bill!"
Bill: HEY!
"Then I realized that Bill would have probably got arrested after two minutes!"
Bill: HEY!
Arthur got that Tsar drip 💀💀💀
That's the guarma guy
@charlesburns7391
Moneysir(I forgot how to say it.) Fussar?
Nah, that's the austrian archduke drip💀
yankee joke ligma balls
2:18 are we gonna ignore Micha just stood in himself?
Clever
He instantly absorbed it
You know you're supposed to play as good Arthur when Micah is the one that don't like it. Lol
Supposed to?
You're not the boss of me.
@@KyleEvraLooks like you're doing a low honor playthrough of life eh?
@@KyleEvraplease play as good arthur, I Insist.
@@LifeSaloon”He insists upon it”
@@F_Han6 "insists"
Can I just say that whenever Susan starts aggressively walking towards my direction, she is like the scariest character in the game. Just in the fact that I can't go a playthrough without her complaining about something multiple times. you can avoid it with some others but she is like the Snape of rdr2 bro. Bad, and looks scary but is actually deep down a very nice person. Snape is walking through hallways spotting class skippers but Susan going around spotting every little tiny thing wrong in camp from the girls and Arthur.
I hate her she got my hate all the way back in valentine I literally got enough money to max camp for that chapter I don’t pay for 3 days and she starts bitching about not paying in the stupid box anytime she comes up to me I click the not now button and walk off I can’t stand her the only time I like her was when she points a repeater at Micah for hitting on her
@@EzioAuditore7283 i find it kinda hilarious tho. I just start panicking and quickly move to my horse, sometimes failing and sometimes not. It's actually funnier if you don't say not now because your challenging yourself not to get jumpscared. Sometimes she is right behind you when your talking to somebody and sometimes you see her stand up from a chair on the other side of camp storming towards your direction. It's more my own joy but this made me love her way more. 😅
@@TalkativeGoofball if I didn’t find her annoying I’d probably think the same way it’s just the complaining I always found stupid like you pay for everything and she still bitches if she didn’t say anything and just did stuff like that I’d find it hilarious plus I found a camp argument where she was basically looking down on Mary Beth’s dreams and I just couldn’t stand her for it Mary is a sweet girl and she just treats her like shit then she kills Molly who was one of my favorites of the group not for any big reason but because she’s actually a sweet person who just got dealt a bad hand cause Dutch is a worthless playboy she just does things that made me not like her and find her enjoyable any time she got up and marched up to me I turned around and left camp to do something else
@@EzioAuditore7283 Yeah, I totally get you man.
Probably because she was Dutch's girl before Molly. Like Molly, she probably got a little bitter about Dutch tossing her aside, she just didn't go down nearly the same downward spiral.
2:18 I laughed when Micah stepped into shit
Stepped into a pile of what he is
My bad he’s a rat (but he’s also a piece of shit)
I was going to say dat
I didn't know Micah would react if you help folk in free roam 'cause i play high honor on every playthrough and Micah never talked to me like that for once.
Low honor is the way to go.
@@jax467 low honor is for John 😂
@@trevorphilips2947low honor has no consequences
@@parklez3250 it does. it affects your interaction with NPC or something.
Yes it has consequences lol. The one that i find the most annoying is the fact that the price for everything is about 5x higher if you play low honor. Its only worth playing low honor if you finished the story and has a lot of money with you.
Bill's reaction was hilarious, He needs to worrying about what he needed that hair pomade for
I think bill's dialogue is about Arthur helping Rains Fall
And I love how much of an asshole bill is claiming this aint his gang when he tries to help people out
Bill: This ain't your game, Arthur.
Arthur: Yes it is Bill
Gang*
@@UGLYBOYwrld that's what he said? Whoops my bad I completely misheard him.
@@KhepriProductions2022 I like at the very end Bill just goes, Abigail.
Dutch:
Stop killing people Arthur!
Dutch in chapter 4:
Angelo Bronte I’m gonna drown you then feed you to the crocodiles
Alligators
@@danielkrohn4980 I’m very sorry you care
Also Dutch: NOISE ARTHUR! WE GOTTA MAKE NOISE!!!!
Dutch tells you not to kill normal people. Bronte is a mob boss
@@discodjdj2300 It's just basic biology.
Are we going to ignore the Colonel Allende drip that Arthur has at the beggining of the video?
How do you get the fit?
"I'm too near the end to change."
"You're too near the end not to."
Ms Grimshaw was the most shamelessly underutilized character in this fucken game.
Not really, the whole camp is functioning because of her, she’s basically the mother to the gang. She served her purpose, the only underutilized aspect of her was the lack of mention of her after her death, not to mention how even during her death nobody seemed to care. It should’ve been the Pinkertons that shot her if anything it makes no sense that Micah shot her and there was 0 reaction or consequence from Dutch or literally anyone else
@josephstalin2606 well it happened what you expect Dutch killing her. And she got distracted when Havier was informing the something was coming(it's been a while since I'd played the game
@@assassin8636 No did you even read my comment? I said it would’ve been better for the Pinkertons to shoot her it makes no sense that Dutch didn’t even acknowledge how Micah shot Ms Grimshaw although he’s the one being accused of treason, and the fact how it’s never brought up again you’d think Micah being the one to kill her would be significant but no
When you know about Dutch's history, it makes it kind of tragic what Grimshaw ended up doing to Molly.
"That heart will be the death of you"
Quite the contrary Micah, that heart is what saved him in the end
2:03 Hits hard when you know the ending..
Exactly what I thought
EXACTLY WHAT I WAS THINKING BRO
3:33 That line is amazing
Micah's opinion on Arthur
Low Honor: you are my dear friend and only Arthur, you are awesome.
High Honor: soft heart will get you nowhere in the world Arthur.
2:33 Arthur: You wanna see how soft I've gone?
😳
💀
I wanna see
Damn Arthur Morgan got the drip with the general suit! I wish I could get RDR2 someday
0:23 "We don't need unnecessary problem, we have enough real ones". Let the unnecessary ones can turn real.
When i start a fight in school and principle calls my parents to inform my parents
Arthur is like that student
I completed the game twice, one just the career mode, and the another one up down to 100%, and i always play with good honor, with Arthur and also with John, never killing inocent folk and trying to help everybody.
But i never see any of those dialogues...
On my first play through murdered everyone i came cross at the end of the game i still murdered everyone i came cross no one was save in any town in rdr2 you could probably say that i am a psychopath
maybe you didn't spend much time at camp? i mean i didn't either (did the same as you, 1st playthrough was story and second was for 100%) but i still got them.... weird....
Lower your honor for a wile. It will prock. You have to be bad and gain a bad reputation, as mika said "you've gone soft" suggesting you were bad before now your not
@@vortex7733 That kinda makes sense, there's no reason for micah to say that if Arthur already has high honor since chapter 2
How often do you talk to Micah? Screw that guy!
This was probably already said, but I'll say anyway, I don't know if there's a specific trigger, but in Chpt 6, if you help people, at least for me, Javier also nags Arthur for going behind Dutch's back
Yep but that seems more story related, more specifically it seems to be triggered after helping Rains Fall, and it always happens, unlike these convos which are triggered specifically from your actions in free roam
1:06 Arthur: "I'm too near the end of the game to change, I don't have enough time to greet enough people in saint denis"
Grimshaw: 🤨
2:17 I love that Micah steps on shit right there. Appropriate for him
Such great quotes
Ms. Grimshaw: Ur too close to the end to not change!!
Micah: That heart of urs is going to get u killed.
Micah was completely right but he also didnt realize that Arthur's heart would get him killed as well. John, Sadie, and Charles went after him because Arthur truly cared about them. Even Dutch felt he had to do right by Arthur in the end. A good heart may get u killed but it often changes people for the better. And ironically enough if Arthur had a word in it he would have begged them to spare Micah and live their lives free and in peace.
Not that deep
@@enb80808It kind of is that deep,Rockstar intended it with in depth writing flow the way they often make the games,it’s their style of writing.
Arthur aint a saint. Never was. How come you think he would have spared micah???
@@kaanseyhun7041 "Revenge is a fool's game" -Arthur
@@masterblaster2678 micah was more of a threat to everyone. Sooner or later he would have come to john. John did the right thing by ending it first
3:38 bill - Abigal
Micah was right when he said the way your heart acts is the way he dies
Arthur " it's the O'driscoll
😂
3:20 this is sad when you think about the gangs morales during chapters 1-3. They specifically said they wanted to help people and now they entirely go against it.
Micah genuinely believing that surviving is the one and only thing that matters to the point he genuinely advises Arthur to go down that road as a "friendly" advice actually is pretty sad. It's the words of a man who tried to change but couldn't.
"Can you stop killing people?"
"Dutch, There is nothing we can do"
Micah looks fatter in the last chapter than the first, clever detail
My heart dropped when I heard micah say I feel bad for u
2:17 look where his feet is going
Homelander in 1899. (For the first outfit Arthur wears in this video)
Thats fussar
I was playing all peaceful (besides the missions, of course) and still got Ms. Grimshaw telling me that I had been killing innocent people.
I watched the story back in 2019, but the more I see the possible interactions with the game members, the more I want to play it.
The one thing preventing is the ending and the loss + departure of the gang itself. Which makes me want to never advance after Hosea and Lenny's death.
I adore how the the only ones that react negatively to Arthur's high honor free roam are Micah and Bill
I never get Micah to tell me I've gone soft no matter how good deeds I do in the game.
Bro has that allende drip
Generalissimo Arturo must rule with an iron fist, to keep the peasants in line
Bill seems to forget Arthur is one of the gangs founding heads he can make more choices than bill is aloud
Not at this point in the story. After Arthur saves John, he’s basically replaced by Micah at being the right hand man of Dutch. He was demoted and treated like another gunman for the gang, which also helps Arthur realize Dutch was using him the entire time and therefore goes behind his back to do what’s right
All they do is complain. It doesn't matter if it's right or wrong behavior, they just have complaints, never praise. Pretty true to life actually.
Aurthor being a menace: Stop it
Aurthor being a functional member of society: Stop it
Why was Arthur dressed like a Russian tsar for the first few 😂
i get most of the bad deed interactions because i keep accidentally running into people with my horse
of course it was me, I came back from time travel in 1815 during the war with Britain.
just realised you got arthur looking like homelander
Arthur… you are not Leopold we have talked about this🤦♂️
Awesome video.
I've always played honorably (I only ever lost honor when rescuing Micah in Strawberry, but I always make sure to keep that honor up, up, up instead of it going down, down, down)...I never lose honor and always make the right choice.
bro walkin around with that augusto pinochet drip 💀
"I'm too near the end to change."
"You're too near the end not to!"
Goddamn, that line actually hits pretty damn hard.
Jack, are you serious? That’s for dinner.
Love how Bill FR just says “Abigale (Derogatory)” at the end
Bro got so lectured he turned into Alberto fussar
"Miss Grimshaw, that was a robbery gone bad, come on."
Its sad knowing that the gang will talk shit to arthur no matter if hes good or bad, being bad gets you in trouble, being good gets you killed and is breaking the rules
Bill has no right to talk when he went and betrayed Dutch and got his own gang in RDR1
Weird. I’ve never had Micah comment on my actions, and my Arthur is always extremely high honor.
“This ain’t your game Morgan” if only he knew
Micah shoots up an entire town and gets a pat on the back. Arthur shoots a bunch of innocent folk and he gets scolded. Guess we all know who the teacher's pet is here.
Arthur dressed like napoleon, fransico,umberto,nicholas II
I like how Arthur going on murder sprees is just something the gang is generally okay with and they just slap him on the wrists 🤣
Dutch: “You trynna get us all killed? Cause that’s my job!”
Dutch and Grimshaw are like “stop killing folks! We got enough problems” and Micah’s like “Where’s that spirit?!!” Bad deeds reactions are understandable and serve as a reminder to up your honor but being too good gets Micah to point it out’s like hilarious. It could’ve been any of the five antagonists but it had to be Micah saying “you’re not killing anymore?”
Micah: "That heart will be the death of you...."
Arthur, coughing violently: "Wrong organ, Micah"
0:10
I got this all because the murfree brothers attacked me while I was camping, Later I shot a person kidnapping a woman near Braithwaite manor , Two o'driscoll's who were beating up a helpless guy in valentine and lemoyne raiders who were robbing a coach outside of Rhodes. I'm a bad guy now.
Meanwhile I'm dressed as a viking running around acting like a complete goblin. I am the 13%
"Im too near the End to change". "Your to near the End not too!".
I got the first one with Grimshaw my first playthrough lmaooo I laughed so hard that the game was actually acknowledging me shooting everyone xD
This is why I think it's canon for Arthur to start off with low honor but then go high honor once he becomes sick
I didn't know Micah and Bill will comment about Arthur helping folks. I'll have to play it for the 4th time. 😁
Im on the tenth playthrough
I just got the first one on my current playthrough
God Micah is so tragic in these moments because I enjoy -most- of his banter -most- of the time. He almost sounds concerned for Arthur in the middle of giving him shit in the second one. In the first one, I also like the implication that Arthur really is, or was one mean sumbitch even to Micah.
Ah yes. Napoleon Bonarthurparte was in America.
Arthur got that grand admiral drip🥶
Bro got that Alberto Fussar outfit
0:00 captain arthur
In my case, my Arthur ends up killing because people try to kill me, only for the bounty system to punish me for self-defense.
*Arthur aint a pet*
@@HANKSANDY69420 When did I say he was?
@@apollojustice5589 _"'my arthur' is a good boy"_
@@HANKSANDY69420 "good BOAH"
@@aarchunterontheinternet9918 _yes, yes_
Why is no one talking about Napoleon Arthur ?!!
The way he says "It wans't me" 😂😂😂
I feel like rockstar made these as a warning so you wont end up in bad honor at the end.
Damned in you do. Damned if you don't
it’s 1899 and there were no breaking news back then but why everyone knows in the camp that arthur did something when they didn’t have tvs back then
“You wanna see how soft I’ve gone Micah!” *undoes zipper*
Arthur in that homelander suit 😂😂😂😂
I just protect my self