No no, when he says “go to the gunsmith and pick out an item on my tab”, you go to the gunsmith and get a very nice weapon, walk outside and show it to him… intimately.
What are you guys on about? Did you even understand the story? They literally plan on running off together during the story but then Arthur gets TB (if you help her that is)
Something interesting is that you can't achieve full low honor until chapter 6. Every other chapter before there's a limit before the bottom of the bar
@@angoodold OK not kidding I just got back from guarma and FINALLY got the lowest honor possible. I just happened to finally see this comment an hour after doing so
@@theYT_moderator congrats, you're now in the best/most confusing chapter ever. Please make sure to do every stranger mission and don't speedrun like I unfortunately did
@@TheSuperQuail if you don't help her she won't respect you but she will still try to take advantage of your cababilities. She learns she cannot and you don't see her again. But remember this is just a game and romance in games and movies are far from reality :p I would have said no if it was real life and she would probably chase you then because girls are fucked like that 😂
Not helping Mary is completely valid. Replaying the game and having my heart broken, I refused to help her because I wouldn't do that if I was in Arthur's situation. Arthur has every right to say no to Mary.
I recently started the game again, and this time I noticed something that I've never seen anyone comment on or make a video about, but in Strauss' first mission, when you arrive at Valentine, and you have to collect the money from 3 debtors, after leaving the cash register, if you stay there for a while, you can see the bill approaching the cash register, look everywhere to see if anyone is there, and open the cash register and take out money, this happened to me during the night
I never went to see Mary after saving her little brother and she ended up sending a letter saying that this will be the last time they correspond and that she wishes Arthur well. Pretty much everything she said right here but in letter form.
Bethesda: "You can't just kill children! That's horrible! No, you can't kill ANY child here!" Rockstar: "Uh-huh, yeah. Child murder's terrible. So DON'T kill these teenage boys that constantly hurl insults at you, or your honor'll drop."
stranger: wheres the train station? 0:47 john: head that a way cant misd it 0:51 lost honor john follows stranger 1:15 after a while swim with him & dies
I think that for helping Mary Arthur would say no 1st time around and yes the second time around because as the game progresses he realises how short life is
"I've really missed you, you know." "I've missed _you_ for a long time.." It's truly incredible just how much pain a man can keep under wraps and subtly convey with words.. I know a lot of this was meant to be funny on some scale, but this single moment is just so heart wrenching. 💔
No no, when he says “go to the gunsmith and pick out an item on my tab”, you go to the gunsmith and get a very nice weapon, walk outside and show it to him… intimately.
LOL. What a way to say thank you, eh?
Exactly what I had in mind, are we a psychopath?
when you get out the gunsmith he dissappers
@@GarretTheStealer no he doesn’t lol sometimes they just move benches
Accept Jesus Christ he loves u died n rose again for ur forgiveness 🙏🏽❤️
1:23 "Wonder if he can swim" John proceeds to drown
“Neither can you bitch 💀”
Peak comedy right there😂
😂😂😂 How do you expect a drunk guy to swim 😂
you are the proof that the dead internet theory is real
@@sebhhh the way he said it after he was already dead had me rolling 😂
random dude: this is the kind soul that saved me
Aurthor: throws knife into balls
It's spelled "Arthur," if you didn't know.
@@not.bruce_wayne39 i know but my brain was not working when i created the account
@@AurthorMorgan- it's actually better this way. Just like when Arthur got drunk in valentine.
@@AurthorMorgan- no you got it correct it's Author (the one who posted video) + Arthur = Aurthur
@@AurthorMorgan- You can Change the Name anytime, no Prob....🤠
the alligator went blind as well
I think thats natural alligator behaviour running around so the victim doesnt escape
@@galaxiiprotogen Ah yes, the totally natural behaviour of eating a tied up man
@@galaxiiprotogen Ah yes, the totally natural behaviour of eating a tied up man
@@rokukou Reptiles are weird. They do a lot of loopy and snappy
@@rokukou they cant tell the difference goober
Man the snakebite victim is especially cruel, guy even thought to properly repay you.
I got a free Springfield rifle from him 😂
@@a_life_of_aviationdoes he say anything if we purchase expensive or cheap gun?
@@mannnnuuu nope he just lets it slide 👺
Man was good as dead, so he’s very thankful of you.
Seeing someone shoot him after all this is insanely upsetting too
They didn't even give Arthur voicelines when he does it
The drunk guy genuinely believing and thanking Arthur only to end up drowning horribly actually breaks my heart
@@celestialdancer6293 it was john. John doesn’t know how to swim.
@@dimitrifyodorovickaramazov I’m pretty sure the random event can happen with both John and Arthur, don’t quote me though
@@Bobthesnob391 It can, yes, but in that instance, it's John because he drowns.
@@dimitrifyodorovickaramazov I’m pretty sure Arthur can drown too, but I don’t know how quickly John drowns because I haven’t reached the epilogue yet
@@firebasetv arthur maybe only drowns when u deplete the whole stamina bar which makes health go down as well
Its not a sin to kill saint Denis's Allyway kids
Is it even Possible ?
@@lulubee5555 with mods
@@lulubee5555 nope I tried several times to kill that that shit but I can't 😂💀
Same
@@himanshuop5072 same
5:00 I like Arthur watching the gang flying through the air after the train slams them. 😂
He thinks: "Where you going, friends?"
Arthur was nice enough to spare the horses
Mary: "Please help me Arthur."
Arthur: "No."
Mary: "Okay."
okay 👍
Understandable, have a great day✌
Okay I’ll catch later then!
Everything that's dishonorable that's really not dishonorable at all you do not owe that woman anything you are not longer married to her
@trublacking8572 Arthur and her were never married though?
05:20
“Hi we’re the Van Der Linde gang welcome to Jackass”
Underrated comment bro😂😂
This needs more likes
@@Glapert_7 No it's not.
@@HamFlare_12345 Yes it is
This cracked me up. lol
"Tell it straight, father"
Jumps into the casket and dies
Ngl not helping Mary twice is a choice her and Arthur have a complicated past and Arthur not willing to her is completely normal
I agree I don't help her either.
But then you miss the best song at the theatre at the end of the mission
What are you guys on about? Did you even understand the story? They literally plan on running off together during the story but then Arthur gets TB (if you help her that is)
@@felixalexios Finally someone understood
@@felixalexiosgood man
I've done ever thing I can to lower my honor since I first started playing. There's always a little smudge of honor left that never goes away
Something interesting is that you can't achieve full low honor until chapter 6. Every other chapter before there's a limit before the bottom of the bar
@@angoodold OK not kidding I just got back from guarma and FINALLY got the lowest honor possible. I just happened to finally see this comment an hour after doing so
@@theYT_moderator congrats, you're now in the best/most confusing chapter ever. Please make sure to do every stranger mission and don't speedrun like I unfortunately did
@@theYT_moderator Bro’s a menace, respect
@@theYT_moderatorcompleted?
Saying no to an old love twice is in the same video with the cold murder of children in the streets.
@@MiguelPerez-ui2gy “God Help me
4:59 Betrayal went so hard he fainted
Rdr2 is a game where you genuinely feel bad for the npcs after doing this kind of stuff to them
4:30 that Olympic level front flip 👏
1:40 best feeling
@@zvqbutter1389 true
Drowning
4:20 oh man that’s evil
Right😢
0:17 Should've jumped up and down to establish dominance.
@@For_Greenies fr
Wonder what the law woulda said about that?
Noone would have me 😂
1:41 this has to be the best addition to a game ever
+rep for every killed?
5:02 the horses just stood there 🔥
The *horses* just standing there is what got you? 😅
2:47 crocodile: "looks like a delicious meal! Better get my laps in first. I'm watching my figure after all"
Bro put a baby in the thumbnail I can't
Bro thinks he's Walter white
FR
That ain't a baby. That's a homemade football
Baby? Have you seen Jack before 💀
that ain’t a baby, bro
"What are you doing arthur?" *train rams the wagon*
I don’t want to get crushed by train mates.
5:21 Omg...the sound the horse made..
"Be well Mary... 😔"
"OKAY I'll catch you later then😃"
I still love the fact they kept John's inability to swim.
Also, the irony of killing the snake bite guy by throwing a knife right where he was bitten
Kinda seems like Mary respects you more if you don't help her.
No. It's the opposite. Did you not understand the story? If you help her they literally plan on running of together but Arthur gets TB
🤠
@@TheSuperQuail if you don't help her she won't respect you but she will still try to take advantage of your cababilities. She learns she cannot and you don't see her again. But remember this is just a game and romance in games and movies are far from reality :p I would have said no if it was real life and she would probably chase you then because girls are fucked like that 😂
@@felixalexiosholy dude who hurt u
@@felixalexios Based
“You’re a good man, Arthur.”
2:15
"If i unalived your son in this town, chances are he had it comin"
Never knew Anakin, I mean Arthur could kill younglings.
@@alexblankenship7737 he cant, unless you change the fabric of his entire reality, aka modding the game
4:55 "what are you doing Arthur?" BAM 🚂
“Oh, well, thanks!” *throws knife* 💀💀💀💀💀
This is probably the only videogame that can make me feel absolutely disgusted at what things you can do here
@@Code-002 right this shit is evil. Just hope some people won't replicate it in real life
@@Residence0fUtopiadon’t be such a twat
2:12 well that was uncalled for
Very called for
02:45 Even the Aligator become blind
Saying no to Mary is honestly alright on his part. It’s his choice
Not helping Mary is completely valid. Replaying the game and having my heart broken, I refused to help her because I wouldn't do that if I was in Arthur's situation. Arthur has every right to say no to Mary.
6:05 dawg was so angry he had to look back at him 💀
That drunk still swam better than john😂
Mary sure likes to say "Okay" alot.
4:29 dude thinks he's Foxy from FNaF
At 4:19 I remember just buying the most expensive gun available. 😂
3:10 This is the closest you get to Dennis Nedry´s death in Jurassic Park. Blind and eaten by a lizard.
Lmao
Lmao bro
That's a GREAT movie. Haven't seen it in years, though.
@@WednesdayAddamsMW Well what are you waiting for? Go rewatch it! 😊
The baby in the thumbnail...
What about it? 😂
how to kill a baby?
That’s not a baby.
That’s a man
It’s a boy
5:00 love how they CANNOT stop the train in that amount of distance yet being closer to the curve somehow did.
1:22 Most hypocritical thing I've heard John say in my entire life lmao.
6:59
Mary: You came.
Arthur: Yes, I came.
6:11 the way the scientist died starting at Arthur 😂😂
I recently started the game again, and this time I noticed something that I've never seen anyone comment on or make a video about, but in Strauss' first mission, when you arrive at Valentine, and you have to collect the money from 3 debtors, after leaving the cash register, if you stay there for a while, you can see the bill approaching the cash register, look everywhere to see if anyone is there, and open the cash register and take out money, this happened to me during the night
The reverend steals money too
saying no to mary isnt even dishonorable to me imo, her whole family treated arthur like shit but now they want his help?
Fr, when he cut her off at the end with "be well mary" that seemed so realistic and something any sane guy would say
To be honest Mary was using Arthur and playing with his feelings
@@tzvetasadovsky6410 nah. She had feelings for him. No offense but your comment suggests that you don't know anything about female and male psychology
@@allister25287 bro she insulted him like a million times
@@allister25287 AND she's using him to help her with things she can do herself
1:12 a bit hard to take seriously when the sound just abruptly cuts off and there's no splash sound effect.
4:54 is just the funniest shit ever im so upset i never did that
"Huh, wonder if he can swim"
Knowing john would drown the second he sees water is the funny part😂
1:27 I saw that coming a mile away 🤣
“Shut your mouth or I’ll shut it for you!” _Arthur roared as he killed the younglings_
I never went to see Mary after saving her little brother and she ended up sending a letter saying that this will be the last time they correspond and that she wishes Arthur well. Pretty much everything she said right here but in letter form.
5:05 bro made sure the horses dont survive again 😭😭😭😭
The baby had me in the first half
Unaliving any kid in saint denis should lock you into an extra bad ending for the rest of your playthrough
Arthur: murders 2 children
The game: assault
Didn’t even think you could kill kids in that game
Always say no to Mary Linton.
yeah.. stupid b''
Hell yeah fuck Mary
Why?
@@samsimonson4644 she is a b. she using arhur
@@samsimonson4644bc she only uses arthur, AINT NO LOVE THERE
8:16 seemed a bit cold I guess the ok I'll catch you later then made it alright haha
“You can’t be in there- what is wrong with you!”🤣🤣
3:51 what horse do you have? it’s beautiful
Missouri fox trotter
I don't feel bad for those street kids. They're so annoying. 😂
“You are a good man Arthur Morgan”
To be fair, i actually think that Mary didn't deserve Arthurs help
Why?
1:40 Straight out of a horror movie
1:52 bro lost all of his teeth from that punch
What teeth?
@@Moheadie_Editshuman teeth
Bethesda: "You can't just kill children! That's horrible! No, you can't kill ANY child here!"
Rockstar: "Uh-huh, yeah. Child murder's terrible. So DON'T kill these teenage boys that constantly hurl insults at you, or your honor'll drop."
4:30 RIP the dumb horse
4:20 “same goddamn leg!”
0:14 lmfao never thought about doing that
2:18 carpenter minding his own damn business lmao
"Hope for the Future" had me rolling! haha
stranger: wheres the train station? 0:47
john: head that a way cant misd it 0:51
lost honor
john follows stranger
1:15 after a while swim with him & dies
4:04 I was expecting you to kill him with the gun you selected from the gun shop on his tab
“Tell it straight, father” 😆
just sub'd your channel! Love these! The poor drunk NPC that was mislead! LMAO I remember that guy but I helped him of course. LOL
Sir🎩🤝🫡
I like how, by Rockstar logic, parking the wagon 12 feet farther up the tracks leads the engineer to just YEET through the wagon instead of stopping.
4:20 "Why me" LOL
The "Huh wonder if he can swim" got me rollin
4:23 IN THE NO NO SQUARE??? Insane
4:57 - "The Gang Robs a Train" queue IASIP title card
The train scene made laugh so much. braindead ai that cant get out of the way lol. even the horse got it.
"I missed you for a long time, but it's done now" these words weighted a ton
The thud when he steps on the coffins 🤣🤣
"your a good man Arthur"
0:18 when i saw "Aim Weapon" i thought he was gonna shoot him
I think that for helping Mary Arthur would say no 1st time around and yes the second time around because as the game progresses he realises how short life is
3:36, i learned my lesson give him the medicine, never again 😅
"Most psychotic things you can do in RDR" 🤣
Oh father, what do we say to a man who lost his way so awfully
*PROCEEDS TO JUMP ON IT LIKE A TRAMPOLINE*
Lmao bro did everything expect the most law honor thing you can do 😂
2:59 took him long enough jesus
"I've really missed you, you know." "I've missed _you_ for a long time.."
It's truly incredible just how much pain a man can keep under wraps and subtly convey with words.. I know a lot of this was meant to be funny on some scale, but this single moment is just so heart wrenching. 💔
The gator got stuck running around in circles around him 😂 never seen that before. This was a funny video 😂 i always do high honor so funny seeing it
5:50 absolutely brutal way to go!