السلام عليكم ورحمة الله I pray you are well Shaykh, someone made a comment saying that Ibn Hajar Al Asqalani and As Suyuti came hundreds of years after the Prophet ﷺ and they are not used as proof of the Quran and Sunnah. What is made from this?
اللهم صل صلاه كامله وسلم سلاما تامه على سيدنا محمد الذي تنحل به العقد وتنفرج به الكرب وتقضى به الحوائج وتنال به الرغائب وحسن الخواتم ويستسقى الغمام بوجهه الكريم وعلى اله وصحبه في كل لمحه ونفس بعدد كل معلوم لك
Al-‘Izz Ibn ‘Abdus-Salaam, may Allaah have mercy upon him, divided Bid’ah into five categories: obligatory, recommended, permissible, disliked and prohibited. Refutation: Ash-Shaatibi, may Allaah have mercy upon him, said: "This categorisation of Bid’ah is something new which has no supportive evidence to it, moreover, it contradicts the definition of Bid’ah, because any deed which has an evidence which legislates it to be obligatory, recommended or allowed is by definition not an innovation, and it would have been included in the general recommendation of good deeds. Therefore, considering a matter to be a Bid’ah yet claiming the existence of an evidence to recommend it is a contradiction in terms." For more Read the Book of Ibn Rajab al-Hambali on Bidah
Knowledge. This why lay person should not speak about haram halaal and bidah’. Forbid the Evil Muslims who have little knowledge ALWAYS use the “enjoin the good forbid the evil” incorrectly. Aisha (RA) said if prohibition of Alcohol came in the first 10 years, the Sahaba would have ran away. Alcohol is hundreds times worse sin. Sahaba are the best of the generations. So Muslims going around haram policing other Muslims is NOT what forbidding evil means. BEFORE one can forbid evil, he/she MUST first befriend the person. Take care of them in some way. Bring them to your home and feed them. Smile with them. Enjoin the good with them first. THEN he/she may advise them. Some Muslims go around comment sections of videos saying brother don’t do that; sister don’t d that. That is is NOT forbidden evil. Those who do this are being lazy and/or are ignorant. One cannot just skip to advising someone without going through all those necessary steps. remember how Allah says to not pick and choose things from the Quran that benefit you. If we are going to advise someone, we cannot pick and choose the rules without doing the prerequisites first, which, as stated earlier, involves befriending them. Otherwise that’s just being lazy and behaving self-righteously. Again, knowledge of this deen is absolutely essential. May Allah (S.W.T.) shower His Mercy and Blessings upon you; Ameen.
@Iraniansunnimuslim the general rule is if any belief or thought or practice goes against the established beliefs established harams and established halaals and faraids and waajibaat or disregards to follow the principles of legislation and without religious basis legalizes something that's established.... The need for Innovation is an inevitable ... the scholars from among the sahaba knew how the Prophet dealt with them and he trained them to perfection ... there had been two styles of comprehending the Prophet even among them one was literal the other was circumstantial ... both of which were approved by the Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam Unfortunately there came about from the likes of Harqous bin Zuhair Who saw and believed and yet the Prophet warned that he and those who will come after from his ilk... their main trait was they disregarded the authority of the Khulafa the 3rd and the 4th and neither the new leaders Muawiyya or Amro bin Al Aas and this Harqous ended up among those who fought with Abdullah bin Saba and AbdurRahman bn Muljim and their gangs against Uthman Ali and Muawiyya and Amr and regarded all as Kuffar , regarding them so for committed major sin , in their part for fighting among themselves in the two civil wars that took place between the companions and their followers. These Harqousi's and his ilk like Abdullah bin Saba2, Malik bin alHaarith bin AlAshtr , AbdurRahman bn Muljim, and many others were known by different names but they fall under the Khawarej and they took it upon themselves to judge and rule and execute disassociating from the Companions they saw as Kuffars and their ultra-literalist approach lead them to anthropomorphicism and to extending their takfir to fiqhi matter like the following one where Muslims no matter how knowledgeable they are and how strong they were in Faith seeking Allah SWT's Mercy through calling out to Him through the righteous starting with the Prophet down to the Righteous ones and the Martyrs in between indirectly or directly for aid in some way or form as polytheists and grave worshippers even though this has no actual Shirk in it. As the one who is actually asked is Allah SWT and these means are but permissible means set as per the Fuqaha of the 4 Sunni Schools (except for Ibn Taymiyya) all agree on its permissibility. And on the permissibility of visiting the Prophet And on the permissibility of gathering to commemorate the Prophet and his life and his lifework from Birth to every minute Sunnah on a regular annual (Rabi Awwal) or weekly basis (perhaps once or twice at least) whether free of permissible forms or free of impermissible forms or free of totally impermissible forms of celebrations or with either of them
using microphone for salah, writing down the hadith, opening a quran class etc... cannot be used as "look its a good bidiah". bidiah we are talking about is bidiah in terms of acts of worship which has not be done by prohet or sahaba. like some shia hitting their chests, people asking the dead for help, jumping and doing the dikr and so on, these are some extreme versions, mowlid can also be called a bidiah as it wasnt done by prophet pease be up on him and his companians, and the people doing it is considering it as something of huge reward and they consider people who dont do it as kafir, when they considering mowlid like this then dont tell me its not a bidiah. now many people are literally playing songs with music on the streets and dancing to it. this is the problem with bidiahs, you may start it with some good intentions but as time passes it will change and change and chage until it becomes unrecognisable. Allah knows best.
Is inventing a NEW SALAH like the Pakistani group dawati Islami practice, a good bidah or a bad one? They call salat ghaosia, after sh. Abdulqadir jilani
It is reported on the Imaam Maalik, that he said: "Whosoever introduces into Islaam an innovation, which he deems is good, then he has claimed that Muhammad (saws) has betrayed (the trust of conveying) the Message. Read the saying of Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic: 'This day I have completed your Religion for you, and I have perfected My favor upon you, and I am pleased with Islaam as a Religion for you.' [Surat-ul-Maa’idah:3] So whatever was not (part of) the Religion on that day, is not (part of) the Religion on this day.
Umar (ra) gathered the people for Tarawee and said this is a "good bidah". According to your words, Umar (ra) refuted the Prophet and is a loser. Now, either you delete your comment out of shame or you Google excuses to use to defend your words. Don't speak out of ignorance.
@@QuranSprouts the only reason Umar (ra) said that was because the Sunnah of the khulafa ar rashidun was something pre-endorsed by the Prophet (asws) in Sunan ibn majah. By that condition, nothing Umar did was biddah, let alone a good biddah.
its clear u didnt understand anything this video was saying. he himself mentions this hadeeth and is explaining that yes the hadeeth is true. but u cant ignore context within the hadeeth. as the word bidah has many meanings, we have to know which one the mensenger was talking about. bidah is innovation so which type is he talking about. its clear hes not talking about worldy innovation like phones and rockets. so now that we establish that the mesenger meaning of bidah is specifque because we estabpish there are many meanings and categories. whoch one did he mean. here in the video he presents the different types and then tells u that the bidah the mesenger was talking about is the one that takes you out of the fold of islam
@@QuranSproutsUmar r.a. didn't innovate something new. Even the prophet used to pray taraweeh. It's just that after sometime he restarted it and called it a biddah. But it's not.
You know Minarets were never there in time of Muhammed ﷺ or Khulafa e Rashidun. This is where it becomes important for us to classify Bid’ah into Good and Bad(Imam Shafi’ee did this classification based on a Hadith by Umar RA where he calls Tarawih in Congregation as Good Bid’ah - Buqari).
@@alishahin3101 I'm not saying its a bid'ah. Tarawih in congregation was called Good Bid'ah by Umar RA. There's a hadith in Sahih Buqari. There is the base on how we classify bid'ahs are good and bad.
@@alishahin3101 Okay, how about in subcontinent there's a ritual of Ashrah wherein whole Qur'an is finished in 10 days of Taraweeh for 3 times(30 days)? I want to see how long you can drag it. And if minarets aren't part of Islam then shouldn't they be demolished? And they contribute to high amounts in construction as well.
THIS is misguidance lol. Every innovation is misguidance. Every misguidance is in the fire. Bidah is not using a phone or car. It is newly created acts of worship and commemorations the prophet pbuh, his family, his companions, the best generations, the great imams of fiqh and all their students never did or heard of.
@@MuhammadIshmaeelexactly 👍and the shaykh here is just relaying what other scholars have said about it.. but then people just go and give their own opinions.. 🤔
@@MuhammadIshmaeel So how do you differ from a jew for example? They too followed their scholars and this is how they became mushrik.... so please tell us why are you different? because ibn hajar is infallible? or maybe nawawi?, how do you differ from the twelver Shias? what is the meter by which you measure what is true or false because I can cite many many scholars who say there isn't such thing as good bida....
@@MuhammadIshmaeel ill make it easier for you, the ashab al sabt in the Quran thought it was halal to cast their nets on Saturday and pick them up on Sunday and thought they were safe from kufr but what they did was made halal what is haram through trickory. do you understand how many kufr acts would occur by changing the MEANING of bida? this is how you completely frameshift haram into halal and vice versa!!! good luck avoiding shirk after this.
@@pursuingpurity596 I was referring to the constant refrain “kulu bidahtin Dalal” that is used like baton in every Friday sermon, But Alas to each their own
@@Asce.-ol2fg I only quote the prophet if I heard it myself 😂, since I am 1400 years removed from the actual saying, I will use my Allah-given faculty (ie the brain) to discern if something is useful or not In the case of “bidah”, I think it has done more harm to the Muslim mind then anything else But that is just my opinion You could have a difference of opinion And it would be okay Salam and much love
Listen to the talk. Those 6 classical scholars understand the issue better than us. I assume your Arabic or knowledge of the Quran & hadith isn't up to their level? Some people may not believe it, but there really is nuance in our deen.
Yeah you're right, we should believe your understanding of this hadith rather than the understanding of Ibn Ḥajar al-ʿAsqalānī rahimullah, who wrote the greatest tafseer of Sahih Al Bukhari of his time, known as Fath al Bari. The arrogance of these psuedo salafis is just funny
Watch full episode: ua-cam.com/video/xU_PDHJbd0k/v-deo.html
Study Islam online: www.arkview.org
here before somebody, out of ignorance and not watching the video, quotes the hadith that every innovation is misguidance.
Nailed it
😂 very specific
they did it an hour after your comment
The title goes against it and this argument.
@@247Chaos-o9u you haven't understood Islam yet
All brother praise Allah almighty say tasbih, takbir, hamd, and send blessings on prophet (peace and blessings of God almighty be upon him ♥️).
1st comment
Everyone recite salawat
اللهم صلى على محمد وآل محمد
There's no yaa' habibi, its اللهم صل على محمد
May Allah bless you shaykh
Ayyy Barca fan
صلوا على الحبيب
SubhanAllah Beautiful explaination. JazakAllah. Keep teaching us Dear Shaykh.
Salaam Shaykh, can you please provide the references for the books you used in this video? Jazakallah khair
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله
I pray you are well Shaykh, someone made a comment saying that Ibn Hajar Al Asqalani and As Suyuti came hundreds of years after the Prophet ﷺ and they are not used as proof of the Quran and Sunnah. What is made from this?
اللهم صل صلاه كامله وسلم سلاما تامه على سيدنا محمد الذي تنحل به العقد وتنفرج به الكرب وتقضى به الحوائج وتنال به الرغائب وحسن الخواتم ويستسقى الغمام بوجهه الكريم وعلى اله وصحبه في كل لمحه ونفس بعدد كل معلوم لك
Al-‘Izz Ibn ‘Abdus-Salaam, may Allaah have mercy
upon him, divided Bid’ah into five categories:
obligatory, recommended, permissible, disliked and
prohibited.
Refutation:
Ash-Shaatibi, may Allaah have mercy upon him, said:
"This categorisation of Bid’ah is something new which
has no supportive evidence to it, moreover, it contradicts
the definition of Bid’ah, because any deed which has an
evidence which legislates it to be obligatory,
recommended or allowed is by definition not an
innovation, and it would have been included in the
general recommendation of good deeds. Therefore,
considering a matter to be a Bid’ah yet claiming the
existence of an evidence to recommend it is a
contradiction in terms."
For more Read the Book of Ibn Rajab al-Hambali on Bidah
How can identify which is the wrong innovation?
Knowledge. This why lay person should not speak about haram halaal and bidah’.
Forbid the Evil
Muslims who have little knowledge ALWAYS use the “enjoin the good forbid the evil” incorrectly. Aisha (RA) said if prohibition of Alcohol came in the first 10 years, the Sahaba would have ran away. Alcohol is hundreds times worse sin. Sahaba are the best of the generations. So Muslims going around haram policing other Muslims is NOT what forbidding evil means.
BEFORE one can forbid evil, he/she MUST first befriend the person. Take care of them in some way. Bring them to your home and feed them. Smile with them. Enjoin the good with them first. THEN he/she may advise them.
Some Muslims go around comment sections of videos saying brother don’t do that; sister don’t d that. That is is NOT forbidden evil. Those who do this are being lazy and/or are ignorant. One cannot just skip to advising someone without going through all those necessary steps. remember how Allah says to not pick and choose things from the Quran that benefit you. If we are going to advise someone, we cannot pick and choose the rules without doing the prerequisites first, which, as stated earlier, involves befriending them. Otherwise that’s just being lazy and behaving self-righteously.
Again, knowledge of this deen is absolutely essential.
May Allah (S.W.T.) shower His Mercy and Blessings upon you; Ameen.
Follow a madthab and stick to it 😃 repent for yo sins meanwhile
Thanks for the info
@Iraniansunnimuslim the general rule is if any belief or thought or practice goes against the established beliefs established harams and established halaals and faraids and waajibaat or disregards to follow the principles of legislation and without religious basis legalizes something that's established....
The need for Innovation is an inevitable ... the scholars from among the sahaba knew how the Prophet dealt with them and he trained them to perfection ... there had been two styles of comprehending the Prophet even among them one was literal the other was circumstantial ... both of which were approved by the Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam
Unfortunately there came about from the likes of Harqous bin Zuhair Who saw and believed and yet the Prophet warned that he and those who will come after from his ilk... their main trait was they disregarded the authority of the Khulafa the 3rd and the 4th and neither the new leaders Muawiyya or Amro bin Al Aas and this Harqous ended up among those who fought with Abdullah bin Saba and AbdurRahman bn Muljim and their gangs against Uthman Ali and Muawiyya and Amr and regarded all as Kuffar , regarding them so for committed major sin , in their part for fighting among themselves in the two civil wars that took place between the companions and their followers. These Harqousi's and his ilk like Abdullah bin Saba2, Malik bin alHaarith bin AlAshtr , AbdurRahman bn Muljim, and many others were known by different names but they fall under the Khawarej and they took it upon themselves to judge and rule and execute disassociating from the Companions they saw as Kuffars and their ultra-literalist approach lead them to anthropomorphicism and to extending their takfir to fiqhi matter like the following one where Muslims no matter how knowledgeable they are and how strong they were in Faith seeking Allah SWT's Mercy through calling out to Him through the righteous starting with the Prophet down to the Righteous ones and the Martyrs in between indirectly or directly for aid in some way or form as polytheists and grave worshippers even though this has no actual Shirk in it. As the one who is actually asked is Allah SWT and these means are but permissible means set as per the Fuqaha of the 4 Sunni Schools (except for Ibn Taymiyya) all agree on its permissibility.
And on the permissibility of visiting the Prophet
And on the permissibility of gathering to commemorate the Prophet and his life and his lifework from Birth to every minute Sunnah on a regular annual (Rabi Awwal) or weekly basis (perhaps once or twice at least) whether free of permissible forms or free of impermissible forms or free of totally impermissible forms of celebrations or with either of them
Anything that directly goes against the Shari'ah
using microphone for salah, writing down the hadith, opening a quran class etc... cannot be used as "look its a good bidiah". bidiah we are talking about is bidiah in terms of acts of worship which has not be done by prohet or sahaba. like some shia hitting their chests, people asking the dead for help, jumping and doing the dikr and so on, these are some extreme versions, mowlid can also be called a bidiah as it wasnt done by prophet pease be up on him and his companians, and the people doing it is considering it as something of huge reward and they consider people who dont do it as kafir, when they considering mowlid like this then dont tell me its not a bidiah. now many people are literally playing songs with music on the streets and dancing to it. this is the problem with bidiahs, you may start it with some good intentions but as time passes it will change and change and chage until it becomes unrecognisable. Allah knows best.
Is inventing a NEW SALAH like the Pakistani group dawati Islami practice, a good bidah or a bad one?
They call salat ghaosia, after sh. Abdulqadir jilani
It is reported on the Imaam Maalik, that he said: "Whosoever introduces into Islaam an innovation, which he deems is good, then he has claimed that Muhammad (saws) has betrayed (the trust of conveying) the Message. Read the saying of Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic: 'This day I have completed your Religion for you, and I have perfected My favor upon you, and I am pleased with Islaam as a Religion for you.' [Surat-ul-Maa’idah:3] So whatever was not (part of) the Religion on that day, is not (part of) the Religion on this day.
هذا بدعة في العقيدة
The Messenger said every Bidah is misguidance. You refute the Messenger?
What a loser anyone who rejects what the Messenger said.
Umar (ra) gathered the people for Tarawee and said this is a "good bidah".
According to your words, Umar (ra) refuted the Prophet and is a loser.
Now, either you delete your comment out of shame or you Google excuses to use to defend your words.
Don't speak out of ignorance.
@@QuranSprouts the only reason Umar (ra) said that was because the Sunnah of the khulafa ar rashidun was something pre-endorsed by the Prophet (asws) in Sunan ibn majah. By that condition, nothing Umar did was biddah, let alone a good biddah.
@@dylansnowrove3732 So Umar (ra) was lying then?
its clear u didnt understand anything this video was saying. he himself mentions this hadeeth and is explaining that yes the hadeeth is true. but u cant ignore context within the hadeeth. as the word bidah has many meanings, we have to know which one the mensenger was talking about. bidah is innovation so which type is he talking about. its clear hes not talking about worldy innovation like phones and rockets. so now that we establish that the mesenger meaning of bidah is specifque because we estabpish there are many meanings and categories. whoch one did he mean. here in the video he presents the different types and then tells u that the bidah the mesenger was talking about is the one that takes you out of the fold of islam
@@QuranSproutsUmar r.a. didn't innovate something new. Even the prophet used to pray taraweeh. It's just that after sometime he restarted it and called it a biddah. But it's not.
You know Minarets were never there in time of Muhammed ﷺ or Khulafa e Rashidun. This is where it becomes important for us to classify Bid’ah into Good and Bad(Imam Shafi’ee did this classification based on a Hadith by Umar RA where he calls Tarawih in Congregation as Good Bid’ah - Buqari).
What has minerts to do with religion? Nothing
Sunnah is enough to follow has Allah and his messenger said
Taraweeh is not a bid'ah this has been refuted countless times, and minarets have nothing to do with the deen.
@@alishahin3101 I'm not saying its a bid'ah. Tarawih in congregation was called Good Bid'ah by Umar RA. There's a hadith in Sahih Buqari. There is the base on how we classify bid'ahs are good and bad.
@@aaquibraza5600 Nor is the congregation a bid'ah. The Prophet (saaw) approved of both in his life.
@@alishahin3101 Okay, how about in subcontinent there's a ritual of Ashrah wherein whole Qur'an is finished in 10 days of Taraweeh for 3 times(30 days)? I want to see how long you can drag it.
And if minarets aren't part of Islam then shouldn't they be demolished? And they contribute to high amounts in construction as well.
this is what happens when mubtadi with philosophy explains bidah
Rasulullah saw: every innovation is misguidance
Maturidiyya: no
Najdi wahabi salafi : yes
Wahhabis agreeing w the Prophet ﷺ?
Slippery slopes.
Brothers fear Allah كل بدعة الضللة
THIS is misguidance lol. Every innovation is misguidance. Every misguidance is in the fire.
Bidah is not using a phone or car. It is newly created acts of worship and commemorations the prophet pbuh, his family, his companions, the best generations, the great imams of fiqh and all their students never did or heard of.
So you think your understanding of Bidah is better than the understanding of Imam Shafi’i and Hafiz Hajar Al Asqalani and the great ulema of old?
@@MuhammadIshmaeelexactly 👍and the shaykh here is just relaying what other scholars have said about it.. but then people just go and give their own opinions.. 🤔
@@MuhammadIshmaeel So how do you differ from a jew for example? They too followed their scholars and this is how they became mushrik.... so please tell us why are you different? because ibn hajar is infallible? or maybe nawawi?, how do you differ from the twelver Shias? what is the meter by which you measure what is true or false because I can cite many many scholars who say there isn't such thing as good bida....
@@MuhammadIshmaeel ill make it easier for you, the ashab al sabt in the Quran thought it was halal to cast their nets on Saturday and pick them up on Sunday and thought they were safe from kufr but what they did was made halal what is haram through trickory. do you understand how many kufr acts would occur by changing the MEANING of bida? this is how you completely frameshift haram into halal and vice versa!!! good luck avoiding shirk after this.
Honestly, the word “bidah” should be deleted out of our tradition, since the word “bidah” itself is an innovation.
How? Did you hear the hadith that he opened with?
@@pursuingpurity596 I was referring to the constant refrain “kulu bidahtin Dalal” that is used like baton in every Friday sermon,
But Alas to each their own
Why would u not quote it when the prophet said it? @@Nazmanga
@@Asce.-ol2fg I only quote the prophet if I heard it myself 😂, since I am 1400 years removed from the actual saying,
I will use my Allah-given faculty (ie the brain) to discern if something is useful or not
In the case of “bidah”, I think it has done more harm to the Muslim mind then anything else
But that is just my opinion
You could have a difference of opinion
And it would be okay
Salam and much love
@@Asce.-ol2fg the Prophet (upon him be peace) said many other things, yet people don't mention them. Don't use his name to justify a Dhani hadith.
"Not every innovation is misguidance"?? LOL
The prophet pbuh clearly said: "KULLI BIDATUN DALALAH (every religious innovation is misguidance)."
Listen to the talk. Those 6 classical scholars understand the issue better than us. I assume your Arabic or knowledge of the Quran & hadith isn't up to their level? Some people may not believe it, but there really is nuance in our deen.
Learn Arabic.
If you're understanding from bidah " كل بدعة " Every innovation at all aspects at every level then nothing will remain ..
Yeah you're right, we should believe your understanding of this hadith rather than the understanding of Ibn Ḥajar al-ʿAsqalānī rahimullah, who wrote the greatest tafseer of Sahih Al Bukhari of his time, known as Fath al Bari. The arrogance of these psuedo salafis is just funny
Top comment predicted this 😂