Some jazz player did a similar thing in a busy subway. He played all morning for free and only a small handful of people stopped to listen. He had a sold out concert that night with very expensive tickets.
brilliant move from banksy - both commercial and artistic; reminds me of when he stuck a piece of his in a museum in london next to a classic painting. great artists constantly challenge the definition of art and the way we see it
Exactly, I was also shocked that not many people RECOGNIZED his work. I mean, I would have gone insane realizing I can but his work. But people spend millions on a canvas with a dot. And I am so glad he continues to create in the cities !! And not in galleries
To all the people saying "I don't get it". - Banksy is a guerilla artist who has kept his identity a secret for years. His artwork is iconic in London. He makes statements with all of his work, old man selling black and white canvases for $60, eating his sandwiches on the street in New York and then giving the customers hugs... This video is another piece of artwork.
I would have asked the old man, if he could make a small version of the picture with the little bear looking up the tree for the next day, as I had only 20$ to spend. What a wonderful and crazy idea - thanks Banksy merry Christmas to all of us.
Interesting concept. Not sure about the art truly being worth thousands, or more, like people are saying though!! A stencil, once created is reproduced quickly and easily, who says he even sprayed them - or ANY of his works for that matter? The main thing adding to the value is the fact that by buying the canvases, the customer actually became part of Banksy's artwork (the stall itself) for that moment. They not only scored the art but unknowingly joined in on his performance piece!
Banksy set up the whole thing (this was featured on his blog)... how is it leeching money? You clearly do not understand. It was all a setup, a statement on the stupidity of the art consumers world in general...
Dear bansky I live in the us I been drawing you master pieces by hand for a little bit. And I love spray painting. I just want to say thank you for the inspiration you have gave me.
I believe this to be real art of Bansky's I am constantly on his website being inspired! I love what he stands for, I love his anonymity, I think anyone who can't enjoy his beautiful, meaningful, expression is just missing out in their lives. All of his work has meaning, and is beautiful! I would have purchased all of them on the spot, and if my fiance disagreed I would have traded him in for a couple! I may just have to go to NYC in the next week or so just to see if he is still set up!!!
I would love to own one of his piece I've been a fan of his since 13. I'm 24 now. An I've get to see a genuine Banksy piece in person. Every time I go to the locations its been painted over or cant find it. The times he is in nyc its over. :( well keep it up Banksy I'm your biggest fan.
Spray paint on canvas = $5. Watching the elderly, uninterested street vendor sell a few = perhaps a bit more. Being one of the purchases watching this vid on the news when you got home or on UA-cam, now knowing you have tens of thousands of $ of art on your wall? Priceless! Thanks Banksy - Quite sublime
What this really says is that Banksy's work is not worth much more than $60. What people are really paying for is his name. That's how art works, art by itself is never worth more than a few hundred dollars more than the raw materials and time put into it. What makes art expensive is the name behind it. It's why shit can be sold for thousands of dollars.
You idiots don't realism the time and effort that goes into making art. Not only that banksy and other street artists risk being caught which would mean years behind bars.
Yes maybe but that still doesn't explain why Gursky's Rhein II was sold for 4.3 Million dollars.. and that's a photograph. Doesn't ask much time to make it does it? Art gets expensive because of supply & demand, unicity and eventually also because of the name behind it as qwertyuiopaaaaaaa7 already mentioned.
This is a testament to the low level of public‘s knowledge and appreciation of the arts. It also is a result of the constant and sense numbing pursuit for customer’s attention by the marketing establishment.
Ever heard of the possibility of to talk to another person? In this example you could always ask the person selling these pieces, where they are from and let this person give you a proof etc.etc. or you could of course act within the possibility of your prejudices without opening yourself. So of course this experiment gives you the chance to think about a view things, perhaps about other ones than you first suggested.
ins't part of the point? Are you buying it for its 'market value' or 'personal aesthetic value? Its pretty safe to assume everyone in the video is buying it simply because they like it. Not because they know who 'he' is.
It's sad how people will be so impressed with seeing his work on a wall but or even in a frame in a gallery and our willing to spend gobs of money to buy his work but when. It's for sell on canvas for $60, and people walk past it. Like we'd people. Are you so high strung on buying the highest bidder art work that you can't stop for 2 mins to appreciate or help out artist who could really use the confidence self esteem boost.
+chase speer Not quite, do you think that every person on those streets are capable of purchasing art pieces for four or five figures? Most people cannot, if anything it is a nice give away for those people unable to otherwise afford his work.
+Jon Goshe You're statement is the purpose for this experiment. The point was to see how the perspective of the artwork changes when one small aspect changes, such as his name. Those people who bought the work can sell it for a ton of money if they wanted to and I bet that the people who didn't are probably wishing that they would've bought it.
Honestly, there's a lot of fake and unauthorized banksy prints (I have a few on my wall at home) but shit for 60 bucks for any size canvas?! Can't beat that even if it's fake lol
Banksy you my friend are amazing....thankyou for proving to the world that regardless of name and price tag that no matter what type of art it is people will buy it if they like it..regrdless of who has made it..not too mention when these people cotton on to the fact that you have just changed their lives...well done.... Let life be lived as if you are creating a piece of art.
10 років тому
Sr. Bansky, you are a genius...thank you for your art.
I get the point to of this however I also understand why people wouldn't pay the $60, maybe for something unique but it just looks like someone's trying to charge $60 for a banksy knock off, it they weren't stuff he'd done before and really some of his famous ones than i think it would make a much more powerful point
I agree sir but the point of this is to highlight a reason which you give in your argument: unless people see a brand on the product they don't see worth.
To be completely honest I would have to know more about something to place any value on it. I mean you can't expect everyone to have an extensive knowledge of a single subject. Plus, he's selling them on the street. When people do that it usually means the art is hand crafted and holds no value since it can be easily recreated. I mean you never needed to do an experiment to remind people of the fact that looks aren't everything when it comes to art.
I would have recognized Bansky's work immediately! I wouldnt have cared too much that I thought it was fake. I would have potentially found a clue like "this is not a photo shoot", and pondered that. Banksy is a genius, and this prank is totally something he would and could pull off! I would have been on to him had I passed by this stand...
Would you have paid $60 for what you thought was a reprinted Banksy canvas that you could make yourself for $20? I probably would have walked right by and i'm familiar with his work.
Exit through the gift shop was classic..I think it was due to anonymity!!! This really shows the human condition bravo Banksy, I share your sentiment on the Twin Towers and shame on the hypocrites because at last check this was still America, where you can voice your opinion. I live down the street from it and at first I thought there were two being built I guess the other one is truly in Canada?
god i wish i was in that part of town that day i would have bought a bunch just on the sheer chance they weren't knock offs, and already knowing he is in town right. If the old guy hugged me like that after my purchase i would have totally known they were most likely real. No random old guy selling Banksy knock off is going to just give you a hug on 59th st like that. Brilliant
Banksy, Спасибо тебе за твое искусство и чувство того, чего людям не хватает. Люди порой не замечают того что у них перед носом. У тебя всегда получается на это указать в твоей неповторимой форме. Спасибо тебе еще раз. text translation: "Thank you for your art and a sense of what people lack. People sometimes do not overlook the fact that in front of them. You always manage to specify this in your unique shape. Thank you once again." Greetings from Russia :)
Wow! it is amazing what many viewers didn’t learn from this video. This is a good case study to be used in art schools around the country. It fused the myths about the NY art marketplace, if you want to make it as an artist just go to NYC and you can make it just by putting your art out there. Of course people want to buy a piece now, his campaign was an effective PR/Sale success. Except for the people who just walked on by an annoy the art.
EXACTLY.This whole "bansky" phenomenon is about the mystique of his character.His anonymity and the subsequent online fascination is what MAKES him.And this why I think the art world is going down the drain (same with music film,etc),somewhere along the line it ceased being about the work and became more about the artist.Many people could even name one piece by Andy Warhol but they know him.Modern artist and entertainers are being recognized for how strange and outlandish they are, see Lady Gaga
I'd have asked to buy the one that said $60. A Banksy that depicts no image but merely says "$60" has to be the most brilliant one of the bunch. And I'm POSITIVE I saw a Banksy painted above a shop on a road in Central Java as I sped after going to Borobudur. Banksy, was that you?!
I think it shows us about expectations and context ... all values are about context. It also shows that some people still have curious taste even without knowing anything about background.
A lot of the messages are very powerful in his art, but are mostly presented in a very simple but often very creative and cleaver way, I guess thats one of the reasons. Also some of his messages he portrays in his art has got a touch of humour (or irony), in it even if its a serious issue. He seems to pick up on current social issues very fast and create something that makes people think. Google images of Banksy in google, honestly hes amazing.
I walked by this as me and my friend were discussing how Bansky was in New York right now. We thought they were reproductions. If I knew they were original Banksy pieces I would have bought them all that moment.
Just returned from our awesome honeymoon in New York!! We were in central park a day earlier. My wife and I wonder if we would have paid for a canvas if we saw this stand. I would like to think we would, hell, we paid for some in Venice Beach. : )
Exactly and people still bought all his canvases the next time he sold them, even though he told them that these ones were fake. People still bought them though.
Thing is, many shops sell these paintings or copies all around the UK, possibly the world- The original art on the walls is valuable, not these copies- you wouldn't buy a copy of the mona lisa or Rembrandt's night watch for the price of the original! Furthermore, the original has the value of being satirical and sending a message- it isn't the same when it is hanging in someone's corridor, instead of on the street for the public to see.
![A Day in New York 1940s in color [60fps, Remastered] w/sound design added](/img/n.gif)
Only the people who truly valued the images and not the artist's name and hype bought the works. Great stuff.
Is that why he had it shreded in actions?
"Signed original stencil artwork"
People just do not look or read!
The crazy part is the guy who bought 4 'because he needed to decorate his house' now holds about $124,000+ in Banksy Artwork. So crazy...
+Lemon Lorraine Eh. It's only worth $124,000+ when you don't have it. However when you do, it's worth -$124,000.
Thats not how actives work at all
Four paintings at $60 a pop, it's worth $240 😄
My favorite part of the video is of the elderly man yawning and spreading his sunshine by giving all the hugs and kisses to the ones that purchased
Tis a very interesting concept. Just goes to show that an artist's name is worth more than his works.
And yet the artworks were signed.
Some jazz player did a similar thing in a busy subway. He played all morning for free and only a small handful of people stopped to listen. He had a sold out concert that night with very expensive tickets.
brilliant move from banksy - both commercial and artistic; reminds me of when he stuck a piece of his in a museum in london next to a classic painting. great artists constantly challenge the definition of art and the way we see it
Exactly, I was also shocked that not many people RECOGNIZED his work. I mean, I would have gone insane realizing I can but his work. But people spend millions on a canvas with a dot. And I am so glad he continues to create in the cities !! And not in galleries
"total made: 420"
haha I knew banksy was a bro, nice reference man :DD!
What
Weeeeeeed @@MaxPower-rj3mq
To all the people saying "I don't get it". - Banksy is a guerilla artist who has kept his identity a secret for years. His artwork is iconic in London. He makes statements with all of his work, old man selling black and white canvases for $60, eating his sandwiches on the street in New York and then giving the customers hugs... This video is another piece of artwork.
What if that old man is Banksy lol
nice to finally meet you irl, sherlock!
What if it's his grandfather
Man, if someone noticed and bought every one of these they'd be a millionaire now.
I would have asked the old man, if he could make a small version of the picture with the little bear looking up the tree for the next day, as I had only 20$ to spend.
What a wonderful and crazy idea - thanks Banksy
merry Christmas to all of us.
This is very cool of banksy to do, some people are very lucky $60 purchase just become around $50k!
Be hilarious if the older guy is Banksy's father, just across the pond for a day.
Interesting concept. Not sure about the art truly being worth thousands, or more, like people are saying though!! A stencil, once created is reproduced quickly and easily, who says he even sprayed them - or ANY of his works for that matter? The main thing adding to the value is the fact that by buying the canvases, the customer actually became part of Banksy's artwork (the stall itself) for that moment. They not only scored the art but unknowingly joined in on his performance piece!
No, it's just trying to leech off money from Banks' work, nothing else.
Pathetic
Banksy set up the whole thing (this was featured on his blog)... how is it leeching money? You clearly do not understand. It was all a setup, a statement on the stupidity of the art consumers world in general...
lol dude. :D lol
@@LeDeux11 stall set up by Banksy. *Signed* original stencil art. For sale for $60.
I cannot see a "leech" ??
Wow ! I'm from Brazil, i love the Banksy art ! Hope to see Bansy one day in my country!
to fair the people just thought that they were copies of the originals.
I really Love You Banksy, come in my little - big town Reggio Emilia in Italy, I waiting you :-*
Dear bansky I live in the us I been drawing you master pieces by hand for a little bit. And I love spray painting. I just want to say thank you for the inspiration you have gave me.
I believe this to be real art of Bansky's I am constantly on his website being inspired! I love what he stands for, I love his anonymity, I think anyone who can't enjoy his beautiful, meaningful, expression is just missing out in their lives. All of his work has meaning, and is beautiful! I would have purchased all of them on the spot, and if my fiance disagreed I would have traded him in for a couple! I may just have to go to NYC in the next week or so just to see if he is still set up!!!
If I was there I would've brought something instantly! Love Banksy's work!
But how would you have known it’s his work and not just knockoffs?
a picture of the anarchist throwing flowers, went through sotherbys for 140,000
:o
I would love to own one of his piece I've been a fan of his since 13. I'm 24 now. An I've get to see a genuine Banksy piece in person. Every time I go to the locations its been painted over or cant find it. The times he is in nyc its over. :( well keep it up Banksy I'm your biggest fan.
Spray paint on canvas = $5. Watching the elderly, uninterested street vendor sell a few = perhaps a bit more. Being one of the purchases watching this vid on the news when you got home or on UA-cam, now knowing you have tens of thousands of $ of art on your wall? Priceless! Thanks Banksy - Quite sublime
What this really says is that Banksy's work is not worth much more than $60. What people are really paying for is his name. That's how art works, art by itself is never worth more than a few hundred dollars more than the raw materials and time put into it. What makes art expensive is the name behind it.
It's why shit can be sold for thousands of dollars.
Um or it could show that art is subtle and contextual. But I guess that doesn't mean anything to you. :/
U try and do one in 2 minutes bitch u don't even know who banksy is so stop talking SHIT MATE
You idiots don't realism the time and effort that goes into making art. Not only that banksy and other street artists risk being caught which would mean years behind bars.
Yes maybe but that still doesn't explain why Gursky's Rhein II was sold for 4.3 Million dollars.. and that's a photograph. Doesn't ask much time to make it does it? Art gets expensive because of supply & demand, unicity and eventually also because of the name behind it as qwertyuiopaaaaaaa7 already mentioned.
You forgot about provenance if someone very famous owned the painting before, it can make the price much more
This video proves to me it's worth making art. $420 a day!!
oh yes.. and marketing is everything haha
Totally agree! :)
I have never heard of Bansky. I appreciate most art, and am truly amazed at what can be done with spray paint.
This is a testament to the low level of public‘s knowledge and appreciation of the arts. It also is a result of the constant and sense numbing pursuit for customer’s attention by the marketing establishment.
To be realistic, as a fan of your art, if I saw these, I'd assume they were illegal prints and ignore them. Don't infer too much from your experiment.
Why care as long as it looks nice i would always buy them
If you thought they were illegal copies you would still buy them? Ok.
Ever heard of the possibility of to talk to another person? In this example you could always ask the person selling these pieces, where they are from and let this person give you a proof etc.etc. or you could of course act within the possibility of your prejudices without opening yourself.
So of course this experiment gives you the chance to think about a view things, perhaps about other ones than you first suggested.
ins't part of the point? Are you buying it for its 'market value' or 'personal aesthetic value? Its pretty safe to assume everyone in the video is buying it simply because they like it. Not because they know who 'he' is.
kixr But would you really want to pay someone for someone else's work that they just copied?
It's sad how people will be so impressed with seeing his work on a wall but or even in a frame in a gallery and our willing to spend gobs of money to buy his work but when. It's for sell on canvas for $60, and people walk past it. Like we'd people. Are you so high strung on buying the highest bidder art work that you can't stop for 2 mins to appreciate or help out artist who could really use the confidence self esteem boost.
+Jon Goshe thats kinda the point of it though isn't it?
+chase speer Not quite, do you think that every person on those streets are capable of purchasing art pieces for four or five figures? Most people cannot, if anything it is a nice give away for those people unable to otherwise afford his work.
+Jon Goshe You're statement is the purpose for this experiment. The point was to see how the perspective of the artwork changes when one small aspect changes, such as his name. Those people who bought the work can sell it for a ton of money if they wanted to and I bet that the people who didn't are probably wishing that they would've bought it.
Honestly, there's a lot of fake and unauthorized banksy prints (I have a few on my wall at home) but shit for 60 bucks for any size canvas?! Can't beat that even if it's fake lol
That's why I never buy an expensive frame work from a gallery let alone with street vendors art too
Genius always goes unnoticed
these are beautiful works of art and the people don't even know it!
Sixty bucks each? Sounds like a ripoff.
They are worth a few thousand.
+Enivneerig 12 bucks for the canvas frame, fifty cents for the ink cost. I could screen print far better images using a polyester screen.
+Mistermax30 its banksy though
I saw what you did there LOL
I know right? it's a total ripoff!! I can't believe they charged Banksy's art work for only $60. they are ripping him off!!
This proves that "modern" art is only valuable because of the name of the artist, not from the quality of the art.
Why say modern? All art is because of the name associated.
How could they not but them Banksy is amazing
That artwork is so beautiful.
Bruh lmao :)) he is selling this here gor 60$ and others are cutting his artworks from walls and selling it for 6 figures :)))
lol 420
Banksy you my friend are amazing....thankyou for proving to the world that regardless of name and price tag that no matter what type of art it is people will buy it if they like it..regrdless of who has made it..not too mention when these people cotton on to the fact that you have just changed their lives...well done....
Let life be lived as if you are creating a piece of art.
Sr. Bansky, you are a genius...thank you for your art.
This is his point..
some1 who gets it
I get the point to of this however I also understand why people wouldn't pay the $60, maybe for something unique but it just looks like someone's trying to charge $60 for a banksy knock off, it they weren't stuff he'd done before and really some of his famous ones than i think it would make a much more powerful point
I agree sir but the point of this is to highlight a reason which you give in your argument: unless people see a brand on the product they don't see worth.
A good art capture a unique time, place or emotions. Which mean we do need insight in order to appreciate and relate to it.
Keep up the good work on keeping the nypd on there toes love the work x
60$. That's to expensive
Haha! Expensive for me too!
They're actually worth around 40k each.
***** No. They aren't.
$60 for the larger canvases is pretty cheap in the art world.
To be completely honest I would have to know more about something to place any value on it.
I mean you can't expect everyone to have an extensive knowledge of a single subject. Plus, he's selling them on the street. When people do that it usually means the art is hand crafted and holds no value since it can be easily recreated. I mean you never needed to do an experiment to remind people of the fact that looks aren't everything when it comes to art.
You don't realize it but you gave yourself the answer.
carnage2112029 Wait... I asked a question?
I didn't even realize I asked a question. :S
Max L. Thomas i don't about the ques bt there's an answer there
No it really can't ne recreated easily as art is very detailed and tiniest details matter.
Context is everything
Great art!!!
I would have recognized Bansky's work immediately! I wouldnt have cared too much that I thought it was fake. I would have potentially found a clue like "this is not a photo shoot", and pondered that. Banksy is a genius, and this prank is totally something he would and could pull off! I would have been on to him had I passed by this stand...
Would you have paid $60 for what you thought was a reprinted Banksy canvas that you could make yourself for $20? I probably would have walked right by and i'm familiar with his work.
Dear Banksy,
We need your commentary on the pipeline.
With love,
a fan
Because it's an incredible situation. It's the Joshua Bell subway violin experiment, but done with art.
I'd totally buy the guy throwing roses, it can be everywhere and look good.
I probably would've bought the whole booth if I saw an artsale like this.
Exit through the gift shop was classic..I think it was due to anonymity!!! This really shows the human condition bravo Banksy, I share your sentiment on the Twin Towers and shame on the hypocrites because at last check this was still America, where you can voice your opinion. I live down the street from it and at first I thought there were two being built I guess the other one is truly in Canada?
puñalada certera directo a la ironía del mecanismo del arte.
god i wish i was in that part of town that day i would have bought a bunch just on the sheer chance they weren't knock offs, and already knowing he is in town right. If the old guy hugged me like that after my purchase i would have totally known they were most likely real. No random old guy selling Banksy knock off is going to just give you a hug on 59th st like that. Brilliant
Banksy, Спасибо тебе за твое искусство и чувство того, чего людям не хватает. Люди порой не замечают того что у них перед носом. У тебя всегда получается на это указать в твоей неповторимой форме. Спасибо тебе еще раз.
text translation:
"Thank you for your art and a sense of what people lack. People sometimes do not overlook the fact that in front of them. You always manage to specify this in your unique shape. Thank you once again." Greetings from Russia :)
Holy crap! I would buy the whole stand lol.
Wow! it is amazing what many viewers didn’t learn from this video. This is a good case study to be used in art schools around the country. It fused the myths about the NY art marketplace, if you want to make it as an artist just go to NYC and you can make it just by putting your art out there. Of course people want to buy a piece now, his campaign was an effective PR/Sale success. Except for the people who just walked on by an annoy the art.
EXACTLY.This whole "bansky" phenomenon is about the mystique of his character.His anonymity and the subsequent online fascination is what MAKES him.And this why I think the art world is going down the drain (same with music film,etc),somewhere along the line it ceased being about the work and became more about the artist.Many people could even name one piece by Andy Warhol but they know him.Modern artist and entertainers are being recognized for how strange and outlandish they are, see Lady Gaga
those are so cool why did so many people not stop and take a look at them they're awesome!
This is amazing!! Original illustration by Bansky and no one really even noticed or cared
Art/beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
I heared about it at TV.
Omg, if I be there, I'll buy some of this picture. They're so unusual.
Banksy I love you! You have changed my life into an original!
Namaste! My Angel
thanks i did think that understood art a little BEFORE I WATCH THIS VIDEO
I'd have asked to buy the one that said $60. A Banksy that depicts no image but merely says "$60" has to be the most brilliant one of the bunch.
And I'm POSITIVE I saw a Banksy painted above a shop on a road in Central Java as I sped after going to Borobudur. Banksy, was that you?!
Banksy I love you I have your book and I go to most of your art your an Inspiration to me And what makes you even better is that your British
I was thinking the same thing until the end too.
I think it shows us about expectations and context ... all values are about context.
It also shows that some people still have curious taste even without knowing anything about background.
I love this experiment.
bRAVO bANKSY. i LIKE THE EVENT. You are smart and kind for people.
Beautiful.
Beautiful Video! Someone with no patience would have got up and left... but he stayed and got paid... good job! NICE WORK ;)
A lot of the messages are very powerful in his art, but are mostly presented in a very simple but often very creative and cleaver way, I guess thats one of the reasons. Also some of his messages he portrays in his art has got a touch of humour (or irony), in it even if its a serious issue. He seems to pick up on current social issues very fast and create something that makes people think. Google images of Banksy in google, honestly hes amazing.
I would still have bought one if I thought they were fake...still looks awesome.....
I walked by this as me and my friend were discussing how Bansky was in New York right now. We thought they were reproductions. If I knew they were original Banksy pieces I would have bought them all that moment.
Just returned from our awesome honeymoon in New York!! We were in central park a day earlier. My wife and I wonder if we would have paid for a canvas if we saw this stand. I would like to think we would, hell, we paid for some in Venice Beach. : )
now this is great viral marketing, I want ONE Now!!!
Exactly and people still bought all his canvases the next time he sold them, even though he told them that these ones were fake. People still bought them though.
that was bankys that brought his own painting if anyone was wondering .
thank u very much
Wow! What an opportunity =)
That was a really nice response :)
Wish I had one
Thing is, many shops sell these paintings or copies all around the UK, possibly the world- The original art on the walls is valuable, not these copies- you wouldn't buy a copy of the mona lisa or Rembrandt's night watch for the price of the original!
Furthermore, the original has the value of being satirical and sending a message- it isn't the same when it is hanging in someone's corridor, instead of on the street for the public to see.
True, I didn't realize the amount he could sell at art galleries when I wrote that. Thank you!
jeez, if I were in NY that day I would have bought a whole lot. not for profit, or a pure love of his works.
no artist is better than the other its the people who put prices on it that make a certain artist look better than the rest
My art professor showed me this a few weeks ago! I cant believe it went viral!
wish i passed by that stand
I like how this man kept waiting'
Next time banksy makes a sale like this, he should announce it somewhere, I would buy it out in a second.
Excellent !
This is amazing
Great Art Design! it tell me do something and time will pay....
this itself is a work of art. Banksy is dope
Was on the news the other day...
Wow. That was really interesting.
brilliant and amazing