Are There "Male" and "Female" Brains?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 жов 2024
  • If you looked at a male and female brain side by side, would you be able to see any differences?
    Hosted by: Hank Green
    ----------
    Support SciShow by becoming a patron on Patreon: / scishow
    ----------
    Dooblydoo thanks go to the following Patreon supporters:
    Lazarus G, Sam Lutfi, Nicholas Smith, D.A. Noe, alexander wadsworth, سلطا الخليفي, Piya Shedden, KatieMarie Magnone, Scott Satovsky Jr, Charles Southerland, Bader AlGhamdi, James Harshaw, Patrick D. Ashmore, Candy, Tim Curwick, charles george, Saul, Mark Terrio-Cameron, Viraansh Bhanushali, Kevin Bealer, Philippe von Bergen, Chris Peters, Justin Lentz
    ----------
    Looking for SciShow elsewhere on the internet?
    Facebook: / scishow
    Twitter: / scishow
    Tumblr: / scishow
    Instagram: / thescishow
    ----------
    Sources:
    www.ncbi.nlm.n...
    www.ncbi.nlm.n...
    academic.oup.c...
    www.ncbi.nlm.n...
    academic.oup.c...
    www.ncbi.nlm.n...
    www.pnas.org/co...
    www.pnas.org/co...
    www.pnas.org/co...
    www.ncbi.nlm.n...
    www.ncbi.nlm.n...
    stanmed.stanfo...
    www.sciencemag....
    sciencenordic.c...
    Image Sources:
    commons.wikime...
    academic.oup.c...
    commons.wikime...
    academic.oup.c...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,5 тис.

  • @zombieblood1675
    @zombieblood1675 6 років тому +2225

    I am a zombie and I can't taste the difference. But if you give me more I might find something.

    • @andy56duky
      @andy56duky 6 років тому +16

      zombie blood *spread zombie legs*

    • @Μιτζι
      @Μιτζι 6 років тому +32

      zombie blood what is it like to be a zombie? Is it any better than being a human?

    • @istandwithjkrowling3098
      @istandwithjkrowling3098 6 років тому +3

      :O

    • @AntonConstanti
      @AntonConstanti 6 років тому +22

      zombies can't speak they can only say brains brains brains

    • @shieh.4743
      @shieh.4743 6 років тому +6

      😆

  • @AntonConstanti
    @AntonConstanti 6 років тому +991

    I hate people saying that he's trying to be politically correct, when it seems to me he's just trying to be clear and logical, and explain this science from the data that's been collected in an accurate way.

    • @YourFaceisPretty
      @YourFaceisPretty 6 років тому +146

      I know. Like, saying "We don't know yet" isn't exactly a crazy stance to take when it comes to neuroscience as we understand it so far. Very young field of study.

    • @hannahc3317
      @hannahc3317 6 років тому +60

      AlfredAskew And he doesn't want people to misunderstand about what we do know.

    • @benbrinkhurst8722
      @benbrinkhurst8722 6 років тому +30

      Anton-Constantin the people who wrote his script were trying to be politically correct

    • @VeronicaGorositoMusic
      @VeronicaGorositoMusic 6 років тому +6

      I was expecting Hank to talk ''something'' even a little reference about the stria terminalis in the hypothalamus but....
      OK.....

    • @chaoticdanor
      @chaoticdanor 6 років тому +49

      I feel like he was bouncing around his own questions because the answer doesn't fit the current social climate, else he would've said "Are male and female brains different: Yes, yes they are and we've known that for decades."
      But that's not something you can say these days even though it's true. Today the truth isn't as important as people's opinions and safe space and that's regrettable.

  • @cavalrycome
    @cavalrycome 6 років тому +1246

    Differences also don't imply that one kind is better than the other. Apples and oranges are different but they aren't on an ordered scale.

    • @d_wang9836
      @d_wang9836 6 років тому +11

      cavalrycome Yes. Each has functions that work with the others

    • @zxt327
      @zxt327 6 років тому +52

      Oranges are far superior ;)

    • @ArawnOfAnnwn
      @ArawnOfAnnwn 6 років тому +39

      'Different but equal' is a popular clarion call nowadays, since pushing the superiority agenda has fallen out of favor. It may be true, however, the interesting thing is how so many people advance it as a non-problematic thing to say i.e. as if it has no consequences and hence shouldn't be controversial. It very much has consequences. You can, for instance, quite readily claim that the female deficit in engineering is a direct consequence of 'different but equal', even without claiming that engineers are superior. But is it? Or is it due to cultural or sociological factors? From the other side, women could claim that the male deficit in nursing (one of the few jobs expected to grow massively in our automated future) is due to men simply being not suited to it. Both claims being 'on average', of course, so as to inure them anecdotal counterclaims. Whether you think 'different but equal' is true or not, and I'm not arguing one way or the other on that, it's important that we accept that it ISN'T some innocuous claim that has no consequences.

    • @cavalrycome
      @cavalrycome 6 років тому +44

      @Mendicant Bias
      I'm not entirely sure, but you seem to be using the phrase 'different but equal' with the meaning of treating people equally even if there is an average difference between the sexes in some ability, which I agree is controversial (the differences-in-abilities part, not the treating-people-equally part). Although, even if there are detectable differences in _average_ ability in the kind of skills required to solve engineering problems, that wouldn't justify excluding anyone from pursuing a career in that field.
      What I'm actually talking about is something else though. My experience is that most people automatically interpret differences between the sexes as ordinal differences that involve men (on average) being better or worse on some scale than women. Proficiency in the kind of skills required to solve engineering problems would actually be an example of that rather than what I'm talking about, whereas differences in preferences between the sexes that lead them to pursue different kinds of jobs or activities would not be an ordinal difference. Men and women could have exactly the same level of competence in the various skills required to be a good engineer while having different views about whether that would be a fulfilling career.
      It seems to be true that men are on average more interested in pursuing jobs that are viewed as high-status and women are on average more drawn to jobs that are more social. Personally, the more social option seems like a more fulfilling life because the pursuit of high status often involves working long hours, sacrificing time with friends and family, and dying alone on an expensive sofa, but if men are disproportionately pursuing the high status option, they will always have more power over women (on average), which isn't good either. Excepting this problem, I think the goal we should be striving for is a society where everyone is allowed to pursue, and is encouraged to pursue, whatever they want to do, and that goal could in principle be satisfied without the sexes being equally represented in every field of work (depending on whether there are real differences between the sexes in preferences on average).

    • @jonathanodude6660
      @jonathanodude6660 6 років тому +11

      cavalrycome, that is probably the most eloquently I have ever seen this opinion expressed and I wish I more people see this the way you do and I wholeheartedly agree with every single point.

  • @Chiphunk
    @Chiphunk 6 років тому +797

    I don't understand why brain size is the leading hypothesis for how intelligent a creature is. Wouldn't brain *complexity* be more important? Why is it believed that the *volume* of a brain makes any difference?
    That's like saying: "My computer is bigger and requires more electricity than yours, therefore it's faster."
    We have smaller and faster computers than ever before, and they run on electrical signals, much like the brain. It's not a perfect comparison, but I don't see why we haven't learned from this anyway.

    • @Chiphunk
      @Chiphunk 6 років тому +73

      Octopus have a large brain to body ratio. They're very clever for sea creatures, but I would hardly put them on the same scale as great apes and humans.

    • @pawnap666
      @pawnap666 6 років тому +58

      They have lower body to brain ration. Also when you consider inteligence you need to understand that you are looking at it from your human perspective. Octopus intelligence for example could be something different your human brain cannot comprehend.

    • @Chiphunk
      @Chiphunk 6 років тому +46

      I see what you're saying, but I'm going to stick with the human scale for intelligence since the animal kingdom hasn't come up with a scale yet. lol.

    • @user-ev5gj8xe2b
      @user-ev5gj8xe2b 5 років тому +5

      i think it's a mix of how large and how dense it is, i completely agree

    • @Electric0eye
      @Electric0eye 5 років тому +51

      This is an old comment and I'm no expert but see the thing is, it's like with computers; the more you have to process, the more processing power you need. So if male brains are, on average, slightly bigger than female brains... and male bodies are, on average, slightly bigger than female bodies, that makes sense.
      Whales don't have bigger brains because they are smarter than us, they have bigger brains because they have much bigger bodies and you need something to manage all of that chonk, there's so much going on inside your body that the brain has to manage.
      I can't say whether or not there are significant differences in male and female human brains, but based on the information in this video it would totally make sense if our brains functioned more or less the same despite being different sizes, since they are both more or less adjusted to be the same relative to our own body size.

  • @erikdk321
    @erikdk321 6 років тому +794

    It's only controversial if you think the conclusion backs the idea that one gender is ultimately better than the other, which it doesn't.

  • @indigodragon0613
    @indigodragon0613 6 років тому +1908

    Conclusion: every brain is unique and differs slightly.

    • @jeff86ing
      @jeff86ing 6 років тому +79

      Conclusion: there isn't enough data to definitively say how sex, and possibly gender, affect the brain.
      *other then average overall size.

    • @valeriobertoncello1809
      @valeriobertoncello1809 6 років тому +10

      Duh?

    • @rhoharane
      @rhoharane 6 років тому +41

      What data has been gathered on traits shows a significant overlap between sexes, so though females and males averages may have differences in certain traits, the differences found within groups so far are so large that even if the difference reaches statistical difference, those traits in a *random individual* can't be comfortably predicted just based on sex.

    • @FilmBuffBros
      @FilmBuffBros 6 років тому +11

      Conclusion: men & women brains differ slightly.

    • @ArawnOfAnnwn
      @ArawnOfAnnwn 6 років тому +19

      "every brain is unique"? Err...did you watch the same video? He specifically mentioned throughout the whole vid that there are differences between the sexes on average. We just aren't sure what causes them or what to make of them yet.

  • @dmarsub
    @dmarsub 6 років тому +703

    The better question how big is the impact of hormones and other things that interact directly or indirectly with the brain.

    • @LePedant
      @LePedant 6 років тому +103

      After I started hormones I feel differently but don't think differently. I still have the same likes and dislikes. What has changed is how I act in any given situation because how I feel about the situation.
      I'm sure my brain will be different in 5 years then it would be if I didn't start hormones.

    • @dmarsub
      @dmarsub 6 років тому +36

      Kristi Marie thank you for your insight, this is what i assumend,
      i guess you agree that the hormones won't change your sexual preference right?
      So what do you think where this oreference is if not in the hormones or (as the video claimed) the brain?

    • @LePedant
      @LePedant 6 років тому +77

      I don't think hormones will change your sexual preference. It might make you more comfortable accepting who you like. So, from the outside it could look like your sexual preferences changed but I don't feel like there are any fundamental changes to who you are attracted.
      There may be differences in the brain between males and females but I think it's more complicated then that. I feel like society plays a huge roles. I'm treated much more delicate now, men take time to help me with things that never would of happened when I was still a dude. It makes me wonder if I would be as independent as I am now, since I never would of needed to be in the 1st place. I really wonder about newborns brains, are they the same at birth and devlop differently as they get older due to society or is it because of what is predetermined by ones sex?
      Sorry kinda ranblmed at the end.

    • @angeldude101
      @angeldude101 6 років тому +108

      What is this? A reasonable comment on a video about sex differences? And a _polite discussion following it?!_

    • @robintaylor3713
      @robintaylor3713 6 років тому +35

      *dramatically inserts half baked angry comment*

  • @iAmTheSquidThing
    @iAmTheSquidThing 6 років тому +294

    It's a bit like asking _"Are there Male and Female heights?"_ Most of the tallest people are men, and most of the shortest people are women. But around the averages the individual variation outweighs the group trends.

    • @potatolegs3505
      @potatolegs3505 6 років тому +6

      Andy Brice great analogy, thanks

    • @rahel5318
      @rahel5318 3 роки тому +18

      I don't think that you can say "the average man is smarter than the average woman " or did you mean it in a different way?

    • @leemoore5212
      @leemoore5212 3 роки тому +21

      "But around the averages the individual variation outweighs the group trends" - this is a common remark, but it doesn't really mean anything much, beyond reminding us that averaging things clips off the extreme values.
      But human height is not really a good analogy, if the object is to demonstrate that human sexual dimorphism isn't a thing. Adult women span the range 4' 8" to 6'. There are virtually no women outside that range. Adult men span the range 5' to 6'6". There are virtually no men outside that range.
      Moreover the average male height is about two standard deviations above the female. Which means that only about 2% of women are taller than the average man. And only about 2% of men are shorter than the average woman.
      None of this proves anything about the brain of course, but height is not a good trait to show the lack of sexual dimorphism in humans. Using it shows that the standard of "no overlap at all" between the two populations is not a sensible standard. It excludes things - like height - which are plainly dimorphic.

    • @shalyfemusic
      @shalyfemusic 3 роки тому +14

      @@leemoore5212 What is suprising is that they are more men under 4'10 than women.Which means they are more male dwarves

    • @spronkthesprinter273
      @spronkthesprinter273 2 роки тому +1

      i dont get the individual variation outweighs the group trends around the averages. Wouldn't saying around the averages mean that people would be more generic and similar to each other as thats the average, and the average is the grouping of people with the most similar traits and characteristics. Or am i misinterpreting this?

  • @jwhite5008
    @jwhite5008 6 років тому +219

    I think we now have to expand this proverb:
    "Man are from dead cold irradiated desert, women are from melting acid-packed hell"

    • @Ruby321123
      @Ruby321123 4 роки тому +16

      Sounds accurate.

    • @lewisho8114
      @lewisho8114 4 роки тому +7

      Lmaoooo

    • @Cujo5
      @Cujo5 4 роки тому +6

      That explains a lot, actually.

    • @Rationalist101
      @Rationalist101 3 роки тому +3

      Interesting

    • @Amy_the_Lizard
      @Amy_the_Lizard 3 роки тому +5

      Best descriptions of Mars and Venus that I've seen in a while

  • @Danieldrylie
    @Danieldrylie 6 років тому +70

    "I don't think we should be playing with brains." Ugh, okay, Mom.

  • @rutyqutykandi1361
    @rutyqutykandi1361 4 роки тому +356

    The part about how women are more often diagnosed with depression and anixety made me wonder how the study was concluded. Mainly because it's common to not socialize men into admitting mental health problems so I'm wondering if that has any bias.

    • @haroldlemar5569
      @haroldlemar5569 4 роки тому +31

      It 100% does. Plus, women think that them getting anxiety once a month is them having a horrible disorder.

    • @SatumainenOlento
      @SatumainenOlento 4 роки тому +71

      And in women's lives, there is a lots of subconcious worry about sexual/physical safety which men generally do not need to feel. And level of it depends of the enviroment and influences that you are born in. That could explain how women are more prone to anxiety.
      (And I am sure that this is not full reason (it is just a theory) and I am sure that many people will be eager to deny that this has anything to do with it, but sometimes the reason could be the most simple one. It is not THAT long ago that women were property of a man and could been sold by their husband in England. Not legally. But that did not stop it happening.)

    • @meerchlocxk
      @meerchlocxk 4 роки тому +88

      @@haroldlemar5569 just because men are socialized to not show weakness and therefore don't admit to any problems they may be having doesn't mean a women's problem is lesser or a joke, both can be equally true, it's not a competition. What's up with the 'feeling anxiety once a month thing' dude? Also women do actually live in a world where they are more at risk for danger and (mostly physical) harm

    • @haroldlemar5569
      @haroldlemar5569 4 роки тому +5

      mmm whatcha say That’s the point I’m trying to make, they are equal. The obvious problem is that men’s mental state isn’t taking seriously. I’m not saying all women do this, but I’m talking about the ones that only do it for attention and overreact

    • @barbarastrayhorn4667
      @barbarastrayhorn4667 4 роки тому +11

      Men in my family didn't get depressed, they got drunk.

  • @thankyu2827
    @thankyu2827 6 років тому +261

    There was such a missed opportunity to call this channel psyshow

    • @ewan.cartwright
      @ewan.cartwright 6 років тому +9

      izzy yu This is even worse than “Now You See Me 2”

    • @MinecraftMasterNo1
      @MinecraftMasterNo1 6 років тому +9

      TheRecreator
      Yeah but now you see #metoo

  • @Hellooo134
    @Hellooo134 5 років тому +296

    It annoys me when people are accused of being politically correct when theyre just being factually correct

    • @IWantToMature85
      @IWantToMature85 5 років тому +14

      God of Beans why do you think that this is factually correct?

    • @mephisto2872
      @mephisto2872 5 років тому +23

      Zechariah Cameron Because he looked at studies.

    • @Hellooo134
      @Hellooo134 5 років тому +22

      @Gao Zhan I don't think theres much evidence that prehistorical societies predominantly had matriarchies, while there is evidence some did I think mostly it was more patriarchal or didn't really have a clear leader. I dont think its impossible to just celebrate our diversity and what it contributed instead of hating on it, after all weve been getting so much better at it over time, and while I'm sure setbacks are bound to happen that general trend seems likes its continuing.

    • @lockandloadlikehell
      @lockandloadlikehell 5 років тому +15

      @Gao Zhan
      How are females "oppressed in today's society"?
      How were males oppressed in prehistoric times?

    • @lillyehrlich2816
      @lillyehrlich2816 5 років тому +3

      @Neil Mo i really hope you are joking

  • @KellySmith555
    @KellySmith555 5 років тому +236

    Moral Solution: Judge people as individuals, and not as representatives of their sex. You'll get more accurate results about someone if you do!
    Keep going science. You'll get there, but until then, let's just treat each other right and not worry about it.

    • @shmeet
      @shmeet 5 років тому +6

      _____________You see being called a male or a female as a judgement?

    • @zalvian22
      @zalvian22 5 років тому +12

      Wish I could do that, but some people force their gender onto you. Idc what your gender is, if you're nice I'll be nice and try to respect your pronouns, but if you're mean why should I try to be nice and use words outside of my normal vocabulary. I know I SHOULD be nice but so SHOULD they, right? Why is the burden on me to accommodate them if they cant accommodate me? And I dont mean accommodate them by recognizing their gender identity as part of who they are, I mean accomodate their wishes for me to respect them. You cannot demand my respect or kindness, especially if you are not respectful or kind.

    • @shmeet
      @shmeet 5 років тому +5

      @@zalvian22
      __________________Using their choice of pronouns is not a showing of respect. It's a showing of compliance.

    • @sywitz
      @sywitz 4 роки тому +4

      Bro true. Like my sexuality is based on many many things and not necessarily gender. I think we all have cultural compulsions to create gendered dichotomies in the way we think and perceive things

    • @driveasandwich6734
      @driveasandwich6734 4 роки тому +7

      @Praise The Masculine Flames That would probably come from both society and the fact that people tend to see their group as more diverse and generalize the other. So, you, being a man, most likely interacts more with other men, and thus knows their nuances better than you know women's.

  • @konstantinamichail1203
    @konstantinamichail1203 4 роки тому +163

    "Even if size does matter, bigger isn't necessarily better."
    -Hank Green, 2018 AD

    • @SatumainenOlento
      @SatumainenOlento 4 роки тому +8

      So accurate! 😁😁😁

    • @rise7056
      @rise7056 Рік тому

      bigger is better if the reason one gets big is because of muscles; the strongest punch recorded was done by francis nganouu and he was a heavyweight fighter in ufc

  • @NewMessage
    @NewMessage 6 років тому +204

    "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus"
    Sure.. just leave out all of us from Europa. Typical.

    • @annanicholson5309
      @annanicholson5309 5 років тому +28

      Pluto... poor Pluto

    • @user-qx4nk5sp7c
      @user-qx4nk5sp7c 5 років тому +12

      I'm from Pluto were are like ten feet tall. Big people small planet no privacy at all .

    • @jules2446
      @jules2446 4 роки тому +5

      thanks for a non binary lol

    • @anonymousmobster2444
      @anonymousmobster2444 3 роки тому +2

      But what if I'm from earth

    • @AAYLV
      @AAYLV Рік тому

      What?

  • @mazocco
    @mazocco 6 років тому +117

    We must evaluate also neuron density and interconnectivity. There is some evidence that those are much more important than size.

    • @mazocco
      @mazocco 6 років тому

      Juan D. M. Wat? Lul

    • @markhenryramsey9132
      @markhenryramsey9132 5 років тому

      Marcelo Mazocco much more.

    • @SackyBalls444
      @SackyBalls444 4 роки тому +9

      That would still put men ahead, so that's not gonna happen. They considered doing the same thing with gray matter, but the results didn't really agree with current year dogma so they're not widely publicized. The only reason size was ever even discussed was because it was so physically obvious.

    • @bilalshafique5898
      @bilalshafique5898 4 роки тому +17

      @@SackyBalls444
      Actually though?
      Does neural connectivity favour men?

    • @bilalshafique5898
      @bilalshafique5898 4 роки тому +6

      @Rockstar Games Launcher
      Yup.
      Thing is, differences in brain structures imply differences in learning styles and methods to acquire knowledge.
      It's not like there aren't intelligent people with learning difficulties who accomplished much more than those without.

  • @BA-rm1mi
    @BA-rm1mi 4 роки тому +107

    I still don’t get why people are so angry about this? Are people mad because they are running out of excuses to be sexist? We are very alike; many of our differences are due to socialization.

    • @shalyfemusic
      @shalyfemusic 3 роки тому +18

      Men and Women's brains are different, it has been shown by scientists.
      Our differences do not stop at the neck.
      In gender equalitarian countries the gap between genders in jobs, crimes, , personality, e.t.c has been shown to be higher than in non equalitarian

    • @karteltheinterrex4335
      @karteltheinterrex4335 3 роки тому +7

      Shiloh can you specify where did you get those statistics? I want to verify them

    • @peterjackoville4272
      @peterjackoville4272 3 роки тому +2

      *most of our differences

    • @shalyfemusic
      @shalyfemusic 3 роки тому +2

      @@karteltheinterrex4335 just google it but get it from a scientific research website with citations not some buzzfeed feel good article

    • @Xxrocknrollgod
      @Xxrocknrollgod 3 роки тому +5

      They’re mad bc they know they’re bending the truth in fear of retaliation

  • @GMPranav
    @GMPranav 4 роки тому +213

    Question: Are male and female brains different?
    Answer: Funny of you to assume 50% of the people have similar brains.

    • @soheil527
      @soheil527 4 роки тому +6

      more funny, that these 50% have no duties as their 50% to build roads, invent stuff and fight on the battlefield

    • @randdiamond8090
      @randdiamond8090 4 роки тому +18

      Suhel Mullick funnier that 50% bother to care for children that think they have no duties. Fools, and brainwashed to be emotionally cripples.

    • @skywayve7473
      @skywayve7473 4 роки тому +22

      Suhel Mullick Yikes.

    • @GMPranav
      @GMPranav 4 роки тому +29

      It's scary when there are creeps in your reply section.

    • @soheil527
      @soheil527 4 роки тому +2

      @@GMPranav really scary when simps and thots crowd the comment section pretending to be normal sentient human beings?

  • @Norimarisu
    @Norimarisu 6 років тому +41

    Grew up with teachers constantly saying math and science were for boys and making me feel guilty for knowing all the answers.
    Made me hate my class. Umm still good at it and never got less than a B on math classes and was the only woman to pass the AP tests in my HS but I hate math class. It's sad.

    • @Seageass01
      @Seageass01 3 роки тому +7

      Males in general tend to be better at tasks that involve mathematical abilities and spatial awareness,it's just a statistic,that's the main reason why men are generally more represented in jobs that require physical activity such as construction work for example.

    • @Norimarisu
      @Norimarisu 3 роки тому +37

      @@Seageass01 , no , they aren't.
      They just happen to already have those jobs while women have been taught to go for jobs with the roles of care takers like nurses, teachers, social workers, etc. Not because they are statistically better at jobs with emotional labor for being women but because what society told them made them chose those careers that then show up in statistics as "preferred" by women and then people create the correlation that they must be at those jobs more because they are better at it than men... Which is not true.
      The same applies to men and math and spatial awareness.

    • @Seageass01
      @Seageass01 3 роки тому +4

      @@Norimarisu : If there are mostly men working in technical fields I assure you there must be an underlying reason which is linked to anatomy and brain wiring,your statement does not have a point.

    • @Seageass01
      @Seageass01 3 роки тому +2

      @@Norimarisu : I'm not saying that women lack technical competence but,looking at the big picture,it's undeniable that technology has always been,for the most part,a male domain,of course there are women engineers but they are a minority compared to the amount of men who are involved in this sector,try to visit a building site and see how many women are present.

    • @Norimarisu
      @Norimarisu 3 роки тому +31

      @@Seageass01 , there reason is society, not biology.
      They thought the same things about most jobs before men were sent to war and women had to take their place in the workforce.
      They thought the same things about black people and jobs that weren't manual jobs
      For centuries women could not have jobs, houses under their name, loans, etc. so when they could finally have jobs they were only allowed the less threatening ones that would not deviate from their roles as care takers. They could not be doctors, they had to be nurses. They could not be lawyers , they had to be secretaries. Schools would not even admit them so how could they?
      Now we can all apply to the university of our choosing but it wasn't always like that. And it doesn't help that until recently boys grew up with the cool toys about building castles and doing slime while girls grew up taking care of dolls.
      The things that are taught to you growing up have a long lasting effect.
      Also, up until the 60s the tech field was full of women before men took over like they did with comic books and video games for like 40 years.

  • @toby3307
    @toby3307 6 років тому +254

    Newsflash: The world isn’t just black or white.
    TIL

    • @mousysaint9143
      @mousysaint9143 6 років тому +19

      That concept is just too revolutionary for our edgy 12 year olds.

    • @jeff86ing
      @jeff86ing 6 років тому +6

      It's not just black or white, but there are many things in it that are. That's why we can have math and science.

    • @angeldude101
      @angeldude101 6 років тому +5

      Peanutbudda
      A few problems: 1. Math has no relation to reality, 2: Science tries to use math to approximate reality, but will likely never perfectly describe reality.

    • @shimmypost852
      @shimmypost852 5 років тому +3

      its not black and white, and its not gray, its a RAINBOW, unless your blind or colorblind.

    • @sadiqs5104
      @sadiqs5104 5 років тому +14

      @@angeldude101 math has a magnitude of relation to reality what are you talking about

  • @FroehligGirlz
    @FroehligGirlz 6 років тому +129

    Lots of studies have attributed the greater prevalence of anxiety and depression in women to social influences.

    • @sasak369
      @sasak369 5 років тому +77

      And beyond that, the rates of diagnosis. Men are pretty strongly disincentivised socially from admitting to emotion or vulnerability, as well as seeking help.

    • @jelayastewart4804
      @jelayastewart4804 4 роки тому +8

      Not just social influences but hormonal

    • @preciousinfinity
      @preciousinfinity 4 роки тому +14

      @audiosamples I'm calling bollox unless you have proof.

    • @sywitz
      @sywitz 4 роки тому +23

      Yes I believe women are more apt to go to therapy and therefore more likely to get diagnosed

    • @alext5497
      @alext5497 4 роки тому +8

      @@preciousinfinity you need proof that women dont want girly men???

  • @lucienseamm1267
    @lucienseamm1267 6 років тому +50

    This video successfully answered the question with non-answer 😂😂😂

    • @alacnaythegreat1054
      @alacnaythegreat1054 4 роки тому +5

      That's most of psychology

    • @sylvesteruchia5263
      @sylvesteruchia5263 3 роки тому +2

      I mean they answer erything, they talk bout ladies having regions which are more thick and they also talk bout males having larger brains.
      And how basically these differences are pretty much insignificant once scaled to size and insignificant when tryna predict behavior. So differences exist but are very small. Not large enough to have complete certainty in every brain 🧠 but maybe large enough to invest money into it 👀.

    • @inmyexpression19
      @inmyexpression19 4 місяці тому

      @@sylvesteruchia5263great point. Whatever the differences are they aren’t showing itself to be significant

  • @jacquelinenicole1932
    @jacquelinenicole1932 5 років тому +37

    Why are people so bitter in the comment section? Psychology and studies about nutritional biology are pretty similar in the way that each individual has their own differences, but generalizations can be made and more accurate conclusions can be drawn should we look into a person's individual characteristics more. It's just one variable isnt enough to draw conclusions about a person, but getting more of the puzzle pieces, the information, really help in analyzing a person.

  • @toxin5702
    @toxin5702 3 роки тому +40

    I'm gonna agree with the fact that males and females are more alike than different, from a common sensical perspective and the statistics that this guy laid out for us.
    For the common sense part, I'm referring to sociology. If you're tought growing up that you're a boy, and because you're a boy, you have to be violent and like cars, then of course you're going to believe that and live by that. I'm a straight male, yet I can't go two second without telling my friends "I love you" or "you're a sweetie pie." The truth is, if men had different brains, I wouldn't be acting like that. If you just look in regular society, with your friends, they're all different and not roppes into one category of interests or behavior because they are female.
    At the end of the day, we are all human with different personalities and interests. How we got those is shaped by the world around us, growing up in specific ways, there's literally no other way to explain it. We are not a bunch of copy and paste droids, we are people with sentients and emotions all differing from person to person.

    • @rascle_star7015
      @rascle_star7015 2 роки тому +7

      I truly agree with you. I am glad to to another individual agree with this point.

    • @TitaniumTronic
      @TitaniumTronic 2 роки тому +6

      So glad to find a comment without a stain of misogyny and radical feminism.. The hope for humanity is still alive!!!

    • @toxin5702
      @toxin5702 2 роки тому +1

      @@TitaniumTronic A sliver of hope but maybe we can make it grow! Lol

    • @alexiaokeregbe7484
      @alexiaokeregbe7484 Рік тому

      Simple. End of discussion.

  • @icequeen9
    @icequeen9 6 років тому +23

    Hank: "All those extra neurons gotta be doing something!"
    Me: doubt.jpg

  • @dustinproffitt9824
    @dustinproffitt9824 5 років тому +32

    "There are clear specific male and female characteristics, but most people are a collage of both"
    So in other words "there are no clear specificic male or female characteristics"

    • @jelayastewart4804
      @jelayastewart4804 4 роки тому +1

      ehh, there are things the seperate us and make us different actually.

    • @socialdeviant13
      @socialdeviant13 4 роки тому +4

      There are characteristics that they find MOST OFTEN in one sex's brain than another. However, if you look at hormones, males ALSO make estrogen, and females ALSO make testosterone, it's just that one sex tends to make more than the other.
      Like this: the midsaggittal plane of the corpus callosum TENDS to be larger in females than males. About 4x larger in comparison to the rest of the brain. Like he said, it could be because female brains are compensating for smaller size. However, they've found similar ratios in transgender people. Transwomen's tend to be comparatively larger, and transmen's tend to be comparatively smaller.
      All that being said, we still don't fully understand the brain yet, or how it all works to create individual personalities. We've barely scratched the surface.

    • @theophanyfd5422
      @theophanyfd5422 4 роки тому

      How did you get that interpretation out of that statement?

    • @soheil527
      @soheil527 4 роки тому +1

      @Robert what about your lie experience? you never see any actual life difference. men are doing the important stuff. eg, military, building and inventing. we havent seen any women doing much inventing since the last 4 decades women entered the workfield

  • @thomasfieschi-rose3705
    @thomasfieschi-rose3705 4 роки тому +69

    "Size doesn't really matter."
    I think we all know where I'm going with this.

    • @reta56
      @reta56 Рік тому

      It does , Men have larger brains so their brain cells are far from each other , and women's are close together , This lead me to conclusion why Women may be more stubborn

    • @thomasfieschi-rose3705
      @thomasfieschi-rose3705 Рік тому

      @@reta56 My guy, I think your brain cells are too far from each other.

  • @SaraAnneMiller
    @SaraAnneMiller 6 років тому +63

    “Hotly debated by scientists” is one of the sexiest things I’ve heard today.

  • @lwcaexii
    @lwcaexii 5 років тому +15

    Thanks for defining the parameters of the video so carefully, often these videos make generalisations without really going into the details!

  • @loopycrocodile3950
    @loopycrocodile3950 6 років тому +569

    Brains are squidgy hehe 🧠

  • @j73991
    @j73991 6 років тому +92

    SciShow you're all fantastic I feel like you explained the answer to this question very well! I'm sorry you have to deal with such a hellish comment section.

    • @benbrinkhurst8722
      @benbrinkhurst8722 6 років тому +1

      j they explained the issue but not anything we might have learned from its study

  • @kyrahglaze7813
    @kyrahglaze7813 6 років тому +217

    Did they actually put "ish" in a scientific study...

    • @FilmBuffBros
      @FilmBuffBros 6 років тому +57

      This is a youtube video - not a scientific-study.

    • @kyrahglaze7813
      @kyrahglaze7813 6 років тому +15

      Alex Delarge I'm aware of the video, but Mr. Green was referring to a scientific study about brains.

    • @unpaintedcanvas
      @unpaintedcanvas 6 років тому +6

      Kyrah Glaze SciShow also once talked about a paper where it included the phrase "one ___ to rule them all". Obviously I forget what it was about.

    • @hammerpark
      @hammerpark 6 років тому +28

      Probably went something like the study said something like "it is however not apparent that..." -> scishow read that -> translated it to "ish"

    • @Drixel5
      @Drixel5 6 років тому +12

      Francesca Neibel-Spruill Definitely! Why say something so shallow and simple as "-ish" or "sort of," when you can say the same thing in ten or more words, and sound like you mean anything significant at all! Scientific writing is an art form that specializes in expansive, technical jargon that has been stripped of emotionality and imbued with the existential angst to sound "knowledgeable" above all else.

  • @baxssy6345
    @baxssy6345 5 років тому +30

    thanks for including the sources, a lot of your videos will be helpful for my psychology exams! :}

  • @BenjaminCronce
    @BenjaminCronce 5 років тому +19

    In a nutshell, males and females are more alike than they are different. But when most people think about how they're different, they think of the extreme outliers. There are plenty of women stronger than most men, but if you compare the strongest of men to the strongest of women, you'll see many more men. And this is what people think of when they compare differences. Not how most people are different, but how the most extreme of people are different.

    • @leemoore5212
      @leemoore5212 3 роки тому +5

      "There are plenty of women stronger than most men" - it depends what you mean by "plenty."
      Obviously on a planet of 7 billion people, there will be millions of women stronger than some men. But in terms of percentages, other than number of testes, strength is just about the worst trait you could have picked to demonstrate overlap between the sexes. There's much much less overlap than for height. A recent study measured hand grip strength and classified by hand, sex and age. For all age groups the male average was at least 50% stronger than the female average. The average for males over 70 was still higher than the average for females aged 20-29. Almost all men are stronger than almost all women. If you wish to demonstrate that humans are not really very sexually dimorphic, you need to pick a different trait.

  • @redsprites5216
    @redsprites5216 6 років тому +263

    I haven't seen better dodging since the Matrix.

    • @justlivin3998
      @justlivin3998 6 років тому +1

      Red Sprites 🤣🤣

    • @gl129
      @gl129 6 років тому +4

      Best comment.

    • @nathanboolin1081
      @nathanboolin1081 6 років тому +2

      Yo Foreal 😂😂😂

    • @nicolepavon2392
      @nicolepavon2392 5 років тому +7

      So true you can tell hes being careful cause if somethin like there are only two genders was said, all hell would break loose. Oh god the world we live in these days!!!

    • @leone41ll
      @leone41ll 5 років тому

      😂😂😂😂

  • @Katie-hj5eb
    @Katie-hj5eb 6 років тому +62

    It's almost like everyone has there own unique DNA...

    • @Katie-hj5eb
      @Katie-hj5eb 6 років тому

      Juan D. M.
      Your gibberish is very convincing. I am now certain your brain never completely formed.

    • @Katie-hj5eb
      @Katie-hj5eb 6 років тому

      Juan D. M.
      Do you enjoy being pathetic? or is it just a consequence of the whole undeveloped brain thing?

    • @Katie-hj5eb
      @Katie-hj5eb 6 років тому

      Juan D. M.
      *pat pat* Don't worry, we all can't be good at everything. You tried I guess

    • @joaogarcia6170
      @joaogarcia6170 3 роки тому +9

      It's almost like everyone's DNA are 99.9% similar and biology has effects on psychology 🤔 who'd imagine that like every other animal humans have a psychological difference between sexes that even though it's just a slight one can make a difference on how we act... Hm beats me

    • @Katie-hj5eb
      @Katie-hj5eb 3 роки тому +3

      @@joaogarcia6170 maybe you should actually listen to scientists instead of pretending your an expert for ones in your life. Social conditioning is not natural. And "evolutionary psychology" only exists to explain away what is already believed.

  • @poorplayer9249
    @poorplayer9249 6 років тому +99

    The patient's family gathered to hear what the specialists had to say.
    "Things don't look good. The only chance is a brain transplant. This is an experimental procedure. It might work, but the bad news is that brains are very expensive, and you will have to pay the costs yourselves."
    "Well, how much does a brain cost?" asked the relatives.
    "For a male brain, $50,000, For a female brain, $2,000."
    Some of the younger male relatives tried to look shocked, but the men nodded in understanding, and a few actually smirked.
    Then the patient's daughter asked, "Why the difference in price between male brains and female brains?"
    "Oh, that's just a standard practice," said the head of the team. "Used brains cost less."

    • @RexxyRobin
      @RexxyRobin 5 років тому +17

      Oh dear.
      That took an unexpected turn^^

    • @daha3074
      @daha3074 3 роки тому +5

      I like it!

    • @seanryan3020
      @seanryan3020 2 роки тому +1

      I once heard one of my my female coworkers tell this joke at a staff meeting:
      Why are men's brains so small? So they can fit into their penises.
      To which I said, "So by that logic, women have no brains at all."
      My boss (a woman) excused me from attending meetings for the rest of the year.

    • @TitaniumTronic
      @TitaniumTronic 2 роки тому +5

      And this right here, is why we can never achieve true equality...

    • @critikasalihmeylani
      @critikasalihmeylani Рік тому +5

      ..That was rather cringe.

  • @gymleader797
    @gymleader797 6 років тому +10

    What if certain brain processes make the male/female brain develop differently. Girls and boys grow and treated differently as well as put into roles that might change how their brain develops.

  • @originate2464
    @originate2464 4 роки тому +9

    I think number of connections between neurons might be more important than size of the brain. So I think it might have more to do with synapses, which are actually a gap where neurotransmitters are released to and where they are received.

    • @originate2464
      @originate2464 3 роки тому

      @ axons and dendrites don't require a lot of space.
      New neurites or new connections between existing ones form when we learn something.
      There is a saying: "neurons that fire together wire together"
      This 'wiring together' of neurons might be more important to intelligence than large brain size.
      Even if there were more neurons in a larger brain, which is not necessarily true, if they could not form connections, intelligence might be less in such a hypothetical larger brain.

    • @logicalanonymous1639
      @logicalanonymous1639 3 роки тому

      @@originate2464 I heard that surface area is good estimate of intelligence as well.

    • @originate2464
      @originate2464 3 роки тому +1

      @@logicalanonymous1639 I have heard that a possible reason the cortex has such a folded surface is to increase the surface area in a smaller space

    • @logicalanonymous1639
      @logicalanonymous1639 3 роки тому

      @@originate2464 Yes, or you can call it gyrification.

  • @aarondeifel6357
    @aarondeifel6357 6 років тому +17

    So what I don't understand is, how can you say there are only minute differences that may or may not be there, then say we have a mix of "female and male brains." If there is no pattern when you account for relative size, how would you say one brain is more female and one is more male?

    • @user-ev5gj8xe2b
      @user-ev5gj8xe2b 5 років тому +14

      they found certain key things that females are more likely to have, and found key things that men are more likely to have. most people on average have a mix of these, so we have bi-gendered brains.

    • @meh.9605
      @meh.9605 5 років тому +5

      Mace Windu he..literally recapped what the video said. That used sources, shocker.

    • @o76923
      @o76923 5 років тому +2

      That's actually how almost all characteristics work regarding almost any attempt to form categories of things. It's a messy problem that is easier to just gloss over.
      Basically, there are some traits where the mean is higher for males than females. So we assign a higher value to be more "male" and lower values to be more "female".
      But that's just the mean value. If you made ranges around those means that captured 95% of all people, there would be substantial overlap in observed values in males and females. So there are plenty of females that have higher values than males on a trait even though we label high values on that trait as more masculine.
      In fact, if the traits are not bound together by some underlying csusal link, it fairly quickly becomes unlikely that anyone will have all of their values in one trait correspond with the way that their sex indicates is more likely.

  • @LisaBeergutHolst
    @LisaBeergutHolst 5 років тому +18

    Take that, Lobster Man! 🦀

  • @pinkcripps2749
    @pinkcripps2749 5 років тому +7

    Yes, males and females have brains next question

    • @lilyfox2981
      @lilyfox2981 5 років тому +1

      Bud, I think you misunderstood the question

    • @dark_attribute
      @dark_attribute 5 років тому +1

      @@lilyfox2981 Bud, I think it was a joke.
      I really really hate to be this person but r/woooooosh

  • @leifgiering
    @leifgiering 5 років тому +5

    Everyone is assuming that he's trying to avoid offending by giving vague answers, but has anyone considered that maybe the answer really is simply "We don't know."?

    • @leifgiering
      @leifgiering 5 років тому

      I'm not sure what your point is.

    • @downsjmmyjones101
      @downsjmmyjones101 5 років тому

      @@mike-0451 Isn't that assuming that he has a detaioes and specific answer in the first place?

  • @Snowlily01
    @Snowlily01 4 роки тому +4

    *_"bigger bodies, bigger bodyparts"_* i see whatchu did there......dirty mind activated

  • @ynntari2775
    @ynntari2775 3 роки тому +25

    We have to consider that certain life conditions during your development affect the development of your brain areas, and there are a lot of conditions in which only women typically grow in and certain conditions that only men typically grow in because of society's gender roles and expectations. So the differences may not be because of the sexual cromossomes, but because of the experience pattern during your development and what your environment requested of you.

    • @Ever00
      @Ever00 Рік тому

      @@RoddyPipersCorneas No , You know what I think?
      Environment, genes, personality, hormones, habits and mother tongue All determine your brain , Environment and nature are friends in our formation journey! Don't make them enemies

  • @PoeticProse7
    @PoeticProse7 3 роки тому +9

    Also, women are more likely to report psychological symptoms and seek medical treatment for anything than men which is why the wellness industry markets predominantly to women. It isn't that women have more depression or anxiety, necessarily, it's that the practice of getting help is more acceptable for women.

    • @loveself6396
      @loveself6396 3 роки тому +1

      Females are more likely to have depression VS males commit the most homicides. Why didn’t he mention this?? Interesting.....
      Meaning females internalize our emotions, vs Males externalize their emotions.

    • @PoeticProse7
      @PoeticProse7 3 роки тому +1

      @@loveself6396 I agree on a large scale, but I think research shows that has more to do with gender roles and expectations than cerebral structure. I really hope we can get more work done on brain imagery to better study things like that, though! It's a pertinent observation you made!

  • @Cornfedcryptid
    @Cornfedcryptid 6 років тому +15

    Awesome video scishow psych team! Keep up the good work and great content!

  • @notbill666
    @notbill666 6 років тому +26

    Hank's brain will always be bigger than ours

    • @brianisme6498
      @brianisme6498 4 роки тому +1

      Yu Zhen unless you I use my shrink ray

  • @sophieen6145
    @sophieen6145 4 роки тому +11

    This was so comprehensive and great. I love you guys.

  • @jaynedavis3388
    @jaynedavis3388 5 років тому +3

    I thought women had more connections between the 2 hemispheres of the brain leading to a better grasp of emotional impact on logical thought & behaviour. If you ask a guy how he feels & he says “I don’t know”, it may be because he honestly can’t tell what he’s feeling

    • @Seageass01
      @Seageass01 3 роки тому +1

      This statement is pretty biased,there are males who are good at discussing feelings and emotions and females who,on the contrary,come across as very blunt and unemotional,it really depends on the individual.

  • @MichaelChin1994
    @MichaelChin1994 6 років тому +5

    3:56 Damn. Dude rolled those R's like a champ!

  • @sywitz
    @sywitz 4 роки тому +4

    I've always heard that surface area (i.e. Brain folds) matters rather than volume

  • @xm377Moyocoyatzin
    @xm377Moyocoyatzin 6 років тому +1

    I have never seen Hank dance over so many eggshells.

  • @shmeet
    @shmeet 5 років тому +5

    If "gender" isn't synonymous with "biological sex" then please answer the following questions:
    1. Sex Discrimination vs Gender Discrimination - what's the difference?
    2. Gender Bias vs Sex Bias - what's the difference?
    3. Sex Determination vs Gender Determination - what's the difference?
    4. What's the word "gender" referring to in "Gender Pay Gap"?

    • @polyesterShark
      @polyesterShark 2 роки тому

      Gender by definition is how one self-identifies, but the US still finds ways to twist that. Like state issued IDs have a "gender marker", which the government still thinks means sex.

    • @shmeet
      @shmeet 2 роки тому +1

      @@polyesterShark
      _________ The process of saying "I 'identify' as a _________ . " is not gender. The 4 examples i gave are just normal every-day usages of the words, nothing about them is twisted into something they're not. Please explain what you have an issue with and why. 1 - 4.
      Better yet, have your Gender Studies or Sociology "professors" try to explain them for you and watch them squirm in their chairs.

  • @farangisehsani592
    @farangisehsani592 3 роки тому +3

    Even the brains of two people in the same gender can be different. Like a female artist, and a female athlete

  • @stemmlsi
    @stemmlsi 5 років тому +4

    Another conclusion is that extremes of sizes of certain areas (very thin or thick) can be attributed to one Gender with very high probability, at least according to the graphs at 4:10 . This is in accordance with many findings on extreme behaviors in some directions by females and males. Correlations might be interesting :)

  • @felixhenson9926
    @felixhenson9926 5 років тому +8

    From what I've heard, the number of neurones doesn't really result in any increase in intelligence or anything like that - we are born with not a huge amount off the number of neurones we'll have as a full grown adult - the difference is in myelineation, basically how we form pathways representing skills or whatever. Myelin is an insulator which is white in colour (hence, white matter) and say we are learning to ride a bike, as we practice, the sequence of processes in the brain becomes more familiar, transforming the grey matter in the area to white and increasing our aptitude at cycling through practice.
    Anyway, the relevance of this being that I've heard that at birth there is no difference, however there ARE differences in fully grown adult males or females. The issue being whether you believe institutional gender oppression exists, as, as I just explained, the structure of the brain is essentially altered by what skills you practice, and if you are a woman in a society where sexism exists, your brain might then look different, right? It'd be super interesting to see a study comparing male and female brains between patriarchal and matriarchal societies to see the difference, if there is any.

  • @timkruse4548
    @timkruse4548 4 роки тому +2

    This is the longest disclaimer I've ever heard.
    The short version- "we ain't touchin' this with a ten foot pole".

  • @bunsenn5064
    @bunsenn5064 2 роки тому +1

    Chemically, sure. Behaviorally, it depends on the individual, since everyone is slated differently as far as behavior extents.

  • @purplefire2834
    @purplefire2834 6 років тому +16

    Careful in the comments section. It gets dicey. You probably don't want to scroll further.

    • @mousysaint9143
      @mousysaint9143 6 років тому +6

      Literally just a bunch of people getting triggered and raging over feminists that don't even exist. Can't wait till they find one comment and start unleashing all their bigotry lol.

  • @meritafjetland673
    @meritafjetland673 6 років тому +16

    i can recommend the book "Testosterone rex" and "gender delusions" by Cordelia Fine! Really good scientific books debunking a lot of the myths we have about gender and so called "natural" differences.

    • @leagueofdead569
      @leagueofdead569 2 роки тому +1

      Far left propaganda? There are differences between men and women and I really wish you dumbasses would just accept that. I'm not saying either of the 2 genders (yes, 2) are better than the other but acting like there aren't natural differences is stupid. Compare male humans to female humans and you will see the differences in how their brains function. Hell, compare a male animal to a female animal and you can clearly see they function differently.

    • @Nic-xr8sd
      @Nic-xr8sd 2 роки тому +2

      I have two dogs, a female and a male. Their behaviours are pretty different cause of their hormones. My male dog is very aggressive to other male dogs, my female dog never fight with other dogs.. Then, the conclusion is that hormones really matter in males and females behaviour.

    • @vietta6424
      @vietta6424 Рік тому

      ​​​@@Rrrrahhhh You can take the whole of the animal kingdom if you wanted to, this is the result you'll get most of the time, and as of now, there's no reason to think that we're any different.

  • @timeformegaman
    @timeformegaman 6 років тому +11

    Maybe in an upcoming episode you guys can dig into fMRI analysis of biological male and female brains in action. My understanding is that there does seem to be, on average, mild variations in how the brains operate between the sexes.

    • @SymmetricalDocking
      @SymmetricalDocking 6 років тому

      That would be an extremely rough video that makes this one seem tame and politically neutral. You don't have to dig far to find results that even the scientists who found them flinch at.
      I also don't want to have to see more suffering and confliction from the hosts at cognitive dissonance.
      Why live unhappy when you only live once?

    • @roseofsharon3593
      @roseofsharon3593 5 років тому +4

      Yes but they don’t necessarily prove male and female brains. There have been studies that have shown that behaviour can change brain’s activity. And behaviours aren’t static.

    • @ruthlesslistener
      @ruthlesslistener 2 роки тому +1

      The issue with this is mostly that brains aren't static, hormones influence mood which in turn influence brain activity, and that different gender-based socialization would also affect which regions of the brain are more developed/used more, so while you might be able to find certain similar trends between sexes, it would be hard to isolate their exact cause. The plasticity of the brain is fascinating, but it also makes attempting to categorize specific things quite difficult

  • @DagAreHalland
    @DagAreHalland 6 років тому +1

    @SciShowPsych You somehow managed to make this video as interesting as a plain milk carton.

    • @o76923
      @o76923 5 років тому +1

      Sometimes the truth (or at least what has been discovered by research) isn't sensational.

  • @RogersJimmy-n4q
    @RogersJimmy-n4q 7 місяців тому +1

    In short, it’s extremely complicated, and highly debated if men and women are born with different brains.

  • @ARKAEOPTREX
    @ARKAEOPTREX 6 років тому +3

    yes, but you can be as sceptical about everyone, who tells you, that everything is just the result of cultural influence. (btw even if so, the act to deconstruct those "traits" and to stigma anyone affected by it, is also not very tolerant and pretty discriminating, just fyi)
    also to mention: you can see that by all those gaussian curvatures of the spread of samples, there are always overlaps, but sometimes the not overlapping regions are bigger than the overlapping ones, which leads me to the following: it's assumably better to treat anyone as an individual and watch for theirs individualities, but when doing broader approaches and you don't factor in the significant differences for a whole group of a distinct sex, then your approach mistreats a whole lot more of people than those few individuals, which fall in between.

  • @wuzziuzzi9344
    @wuzziuzzi9344 6 років тому +4

    0:42 like being in the middle of a minefield but worse...

  • @J7Handle
    @J7Handle 6 років тому +6

    I had something really freaky happen recently. So everyone knows that if you stand up too quickly from a resting position you can temporarily lose vision. Normally how it happens by my vision just graying out before returning, but this time, I swear I saw a kaleidoscope-like image of the room I was standing in. It was like the room had shrunk by a scale factor of 200 and that images of that size were plastered all over my vision in random orientations without any pattern. It was really disturbing. It's like my retinas were still functioning perfectly fine, but the optical nerves were freaking out with the input and outputting total nonsense to my brain.

    • @kstar1489
      @kstar1489 Рік тому

      That’s really interesting, I’m sure it’s nothing to worry about tho lol

  • @t091293
    @t091293 3 місяці тому

    This video was very informative, and it makes total sense, thanks a lot for it!

  • @SirMatthew
    @SirMatthew 5 років тому +2

    This guy knows how to avoid controversy

  • @withlove312
    @withlove312 6 років тому +31

    This is a well presented overview given the stickiness of the topic. There is a very real fear that investigations like these are really about trying to read the social created of differences into biology or politicizing the existence of differences as justification for oppression. It's a well based fear: even the most cursory history of science as a discipline shows that science has been instrumentalized this way for centuries, right up to the present.
    Basically my rule of thumb is if you are using contested differences to explain and justify inequality and oppression, odds are you are no longer in the realm of rationally objective science, but are in the domain of biased ideology instead. To view it otherwise is to take a eugenicist approach that believes there is indeed a biological causation and natural logic to hierarchy.

  • @azuritepug7533
    @azuritepug7533 6 років тому +3

    You can tell how hard he’s trying to not offend anyone haha

  • @arifakyuz7673
    @arifakyuz7673 5 років тому +8

    Ya coulda just said “Well yes but actually no” /s

  • @JosieDrake1995
    @JosieDrake1995 3 роки тому +1

    How did these researchers define “male-ish” and “female-ish” brain characteristics? Did they use anatomical structures or size? Or did they define this factor by behavior and cognition?

  • @gentlemandemon
    @gentlemandemon 5 років тому +1

    I wonder how much the differences in male/female diagnosis of conditions like Alzheimer's and depression comes from neurology and how much comes from sociological differences, like help-seeking social conditioning and tendencies of psychiatrists to formally diagnose one sex over the other.

  • @artblack01
    @artblack01 5 років тому +5

    Conclusion = difference is negligible...

  • @Viperzka
    @Viperzka 3 роки тому +8

    The best way I've always heard this described is that there is a statistical difference between the two groups, but that the variation within each group is wider than the differences between the groups. So women, as a whole, might be more X than men but there will be millions of men who are more X than millions of women.

  • @77Catguy
    @77Catguy Рік тому +3

    LOL An excellent example of how "ideology" trumps actual "science" in today's academia. Although he is technically correct in the matters he mentioned, he completely avoided mentioning differences that occur with the different sex-steroid hormones that influence male and female cognition and the different neural pathways in the brain affected by each. For a more detailed understanding reference actual neurobiologic studies on thje matter.

  • @zvipatent
    @zvipatent 7 місяців тому +1

    The results of how men and women act, IMO, essentially proves our brains are different.

  • @GMPranav
    @GMPranav Рік тому +1

    Brain to itself - You are one of a kind that will exist only once in the entire existence of the universe.

  • @barbarahouk1983
    @barbarahouk1983 6 років тому +7

    There are TWO cadaver studies on transgender people & controls, but both were small number. Amazingly both had 100% mid size basal striatum. Both had 100% match with the estrogen/testosterone receptor site ratios for identified gender. It was amazing bc seldom in science is there 100% matches!

  • @Mystravian
    @Mystravian 6 років тому +5

    Women get altzheimers more often...but they also live longer. Right?

    • @1am636
      @1am636 5 років тому

      ye, they live longer, but i mean, why wouldnt you want to die when you suck at life?

    • @yea4952
      @yea4952 5 років тому

      1am bruh

  • @goldenfloof5469
    @goldenfloof5469 6 років тому +5

    Honestly, I've always wondered what would happen if, at birth, you switched the brains of a boy and girl.
    What would they be like?

    • @nachtegaelw5389
      @nachtegaelw5389 5 років тому +1

      Melon Collie a lot of what shapes our brains is input, experiences, what we learn, etc. it would depend when you switched the brains.

    • @fabianojeda3078
      @fabianojeda3078 2 роки тому +6

      You made a trans person

    • @TitaniumTronic
      @TitaniumTronic 2 роки тому

      @@fabianojeda3078 LMAO

    • @lifewitholga_
      @lifewitholga_ 2 роки тому

      @@fabianojeda3078 😂

    • @Shade-Spark
      @Shade-Spark Рік тому

      @@fabianojeda3078 Possibly (in case you weren't ironic.)
      It works in the sense that trans people have the brain structure of their gender, which is known fact now, but we can't know if forcing the brain structure of the opposite sex to a baby create enough deterministic inputs while evolving in an environment, to make them trans^^

  • @ems7623
    @ems7623 2 роки тому +1

    Okay last i checked in on this topic was two decades ago. Let's see where it stands now.
    Not expecting big changes

  • @CitrusCapra
    @CitrusCapra 6 років тому +1

    I am curious as to whether which hand or side an organism favors has any effect on how strongly their eyesight may be on that particular side in comparison to their other side. For instance, does the right eye of a right handed person usually have a more severe deformation in the length of the eye (stronger myopia/hyperopia, or near-sightedness/far-sightedness)? And what other body structures or systems might the handedness of an organism affect, if that does actually have at least a somewhat significant effect on anything?

  • @everywhere3301
    @everywhere3301 5 років тому +5

    Psychology 101 : Well yes but actually no

  • @Chewy427
    @Chewy427 2 роки тому +3

    "Outdated stereotypes, like the idea that males are better at math, aren't one of them."
    This is literally true though

    • @whygzty6108
      @whygzty6108 Рік тому

      Women are more empathic than men
      Women produce 4 times more oxytocin than men
      Men can't bond through sex, but women can
      Women value long-term relationships
      Men value casual sex over LTR
      Men are incapable of making strongs
      bonds with their partners or offspring

    • @vietta6424
      @vietta6424 Рік тому

      ​​​@jael This argument ignores one very big point, is that society had to actually develop. At one point in our history, society wasn't really a thing, according to your argument, how did men and women who at one point did not have gender roles eventually get them if you suppose they just did what they always did? I'd say that the answer is still, deeply rooted in biology. We are society after all, men are more powerful, but also more expendable, so they hunt, and because of this, developed spacial skills better than their female counterparts, and because they took more risk, they often had to consider and calculate to not get themselfs killed. Women on the other hand are very valuable in an ancient world, and are soft and weaker, so they stayed at home to do less risky things, and had more time to socialize and make connections, through out history, women often dominated courts, this might explain it. Overall, this is just a theory, we don't know if it's true or not.😅

    • @vietta6424
      @vietta6424 Рік тому

      @jael You did not understand my point, I did not make the connection between hunting and being better at math, I said that because men had more uses for math in their daily life they developed better math skills to live their life better, like merchants, did you know that around 15% of them died at sea? Almost all of them were male, traders, they traveled across continents and as a result got injured very often, even most accountants back in the day were male because all the women were busy in their courts, do you get it now? It's an evolutionary trait, not some social treatment.
      There is no discrimination in any math course or STEM field right now, if a woman wants to and have the capability she can get a degree and that field, infact women actually have special treatment when it comes to acceptance because the schools want to get rid of their 'sexism' (By BEING SEXIST), guess what, no women are showing up still. But there are actually more women than men in Biology fields, a decent amount in medical fields,... You should know why.

    • @vietta6424
      @vietta6424 Рік тому

      @jael You use a STEM degree to get a job, not to do the job, they don't promote any kind of gender role, they're just a male dominated space, that's it, if the women don't like being near men they can choose other fields but if they want to pursue STEM there's nothing to suggest that they're just inherently sexist towards women.
      Because societies must develop for gender roles to become 'socially acceptable', you see? They must start from somewhere, we as humans didn't always lived in societies, but rather in small groups of familiars, they know nothing of what we know today, yet they still accepted some things we don't even know is true or not. Even in matriachal societies, the men still did the scientific work, it's just that the women had control of diplomatic relations and internal policies, like the Confederation of Iroquois, this is a pattern we've seen across history, the difference between matriarchal and patriarchal societies is the ones in power, not gender roles, women are still caretakers and mothers, men are still miners, soldiers, hunters, and researchers in matriarachal societies.
      The reason for gender roles might be biology, or it might just be something else we haven't thought of yet, we don't know, but it is definitely not social, we're not advanced enough to tell the difference between male and female brains yet, but we are advanced enough to ask a simple 'Why?' to the question of gender roles, to which the people supporting them have no answer, which is why we decided that it is not true, there's a flaw in their logic.
      The believe that gender roles only became what they are because of society is false, even if we don't really know what caused them but to say that women only became care takers because society enforced that idea is not only stupid, it also doesn't take into account the opinions of women who actually wanted to do such jobs, which there are alot of, even for animals. Men and women have entirely different beliefs, they may be equal, but they are not the same, even from birth.

    • @vietta6424
      @vietta6424 Рік тому

      @jael I'm not making stuff up, just look it up, in every field the percentage of women accepted to rejected compared to men is always higher, that is just fact, some schools don't even want to show this percentage because it might seem sexist.
      And as for black people, it is because of their circumstance, black people are poor because their parents weren't rich either, if you start later in a race it is not a surprise that you end up losing, that is their situation, and that leads to worse performance in school. Asian parents are very education minded, and you may not know it but only the best of Asians ever leave their country, abroad Asians always do better than their counterparts in the home country, it's that simple.
      Who is the best cook in the world? Many would say Gordon Ramsey, and I can see why. Men were not discouraged by society not to cook, they just didn't have time for it, and believe it or not single men cook for themselves, the fact that Ramsey is the best chef has more to do with his perfectionism and hard work than being of a certain gender, but on average, men **are** worse cooks, why? Because of natural selection. Men who are good cooks didn't always reproduce, being a cook is a lowly job, and that comes with being poor, only the best of cooks ever got to live comfortably, meanwhile women who can cook are almost always already married in ancient societies. There's alot in cooking, but some people just had better characteristics for it than other people, and if they are actively desired, they get to pass on their genes, you might not know this, but most of us humans have almost completely identical DNA, it is only a tiny fraction that define who we are in society, and in that, daughters are more likely to adopt more of the mother's gene than the father's, likewise, the opposite is true, and if men who aren't good at cooking are the boy's father which is more than likely, they will likely be worse than their sisters at cooking. Ancient cooking was literally hanging food on a stick on top of a fire, modern cooking as we know it only started around 3000 years ago.

  • @zukigray
    @zukigray 6 років тому +6

    Good video, however I studied under a neuropsychologist as part of an internship for about four years while earning my bachelors degree. Sex differences do generally exist between male and female brains: females tend to have thicker corpys callosums, and therefor are more readily able to share information between their lobes, while men do not, hence their information is generally not shared between lobes to the same degree. Men are also consistently more skilled at spacial tasks than women (evolutionary adaptation/advantage of being the primary hunter of the sexes) while women tend to be more skilled at tasks that require dexterity.

  • @thelibyanplzcomeback
    @thelibyanplzcomeback Рік тому +1

    If they are different, it literally doesn't even matter because they are so similar that it's not noticeable... and even if it was noticeable, exceptions exist.

  • @rsrt6910
    @rsrt6910 6 років тому +1

    I couldn't help noticing that Mister Green left out the rather large and overwhelming data collected from fMRI and PET scans of male and female brains in action that seem to conclude that yes, male and female brains exist and operate differently in many ways when performing the same tasks (use of mirror neurons, functioning of the anterior cingulate gyrus in pain regulation and emotional communication between the amygdala and the executive areas. Hell, male and female brains even process music using completely different brain areas for crying out loud!)

  • @Rachel-sw2pw
    @Rachel-sw2pw 6 років тому +3

    Thanks for helping me better understand such a complex (and still developing) topic!

  • @d4rk0v3
    @d4rk0v3 6 років тому +4

    I think hormones themselves have a much larger role in governing behavior than brain structure. Mood, thought, personality, literally everything about a person can change because of different balances of chemicals in the brain. I think that has a larger impact than physical structure. They're so powerful, in fact, that they even govern physical development! Our mind - hormone interaction is so remarkably (and fascinatingly) complicated. I just love this field of research!
    If there's any data for this, please guide me in the direction to find it. People mock you for using the internet to do research these days, so I would like physical sources. Books and publications, etc.
    I think it's destructive and toxic to use equality as a front to push a forced expectation of *sameness.*
    We are not the *same* we are different and *that* is beautiful. We should celebrate our differences and use our strengths to bolster each other's weaknesses. Alas, that seems only possible in a fairy tale.

    • @inmyexpression19
      @inmyexpression19 4 місяці тому

      Helen Fischer hormone personality theory. It appears to be sound explanation for myers Briggs Personality typing in my opinion. Dr dario nardi told me about her. He is a psychologist and he has linked her analysis to myers Briggs.
      Hormones causing 4 out of 8 personality traits.
      Introvert/Extrovert
      Intuitive/Sensor
      Thinker/Feeler
      Judger/Perceiver
      Are linked to the hormones Testosterone, Estrogen, Oxytocin, Dopamine, and Serotonin

  • @Holobrine
    @Holobrine 6 років тому +12

    All I know is if transgender is optional, why would anyone choose to be discriminated against? Not that they'd get any judgement from me, but generally speaking, the transgender community does unfortunately encounter tons of discrimination. So why in the hell would they make that choice? That's why I think there must be some underlying biological mechanism in the brain that distinguishes male and female.

    • @IceFireofVoid
      @IceFireofVoid 6 років тому +9

      This assumption is correct. Trans people, that being people who experience gender dysphoria, have differences in how their brains work. Which is why I despise all these "transtrenders" we see nowadays. They act like a condition that legit makes people suffer is some fun glamorous thing, treating gender like something you can pick and choose like your clothes in the morning. It goes to show how ignorant and disrespectful they are towards true trans people. And how entitled they are that they can think they can get some kind of attention and glory out of appropriating the suffering of others.

    • @user-ev5gj8xe2b
      @user-ev5gj8xe2b 5 років тому +6

      hello, trans-male here and i agree. i think there's a part of the brain that develops and says "you should have a penis/be growing facial hair etc" but i think that's the limit of male-female brains. i think we have mosaic brains.

    • @dark_attribute
      @dark_attribute 5 років тому +2

      How I (a questioning but definitely not cis person) look at it is, which is probably wrong:
      There was a misunderstanding in development. As the child develops, the body is told that it is one sex (so it develops as such) and the brain is told that it is the other. I don't think the brain itself is necessarily male or female, just that the brain believes the body is going to develop as the sex it was told that it would. When it isn't, the brain knows something is wrong, and inducing gender dysphoria.
      I bet this made NO sense, but I tried

    • @user-ev5gj8xe2b
      @user-ev5gj8xe2b 5 років тому

      @@dark_attribute that makes perfect sense, that's what I said too and you put it into better words!

    • @dark_attribute
      @dark_attribute 5 років тому

      @@user-ev5gj8xe2b oh, thanks! Uhhhhhhmmm have a nice day!

  • @iloveplasticbottles
    @iloveplasticbottles 3 роки тому +2

    Basically we are all the base model with a skin on top.

  • @luisfabricio6439
    @luisfabricio6439 2 роки тому +1

    I once heard that the size of the brain doesn’t matter but what matters is the brain to body ration and both males and females have the same ration (on average)

  • @manaphyshipper
    @manaphyshipper 6 років тому +66

    I just want to point out that toxic masculinity will stop males from seeking help for things like depression and anxiety so even though females get diagnosed more there might be lots of males suffering without help.

    • @ianmetzger20
      @ianmetzger20 6 років тому +12

      Sure toxic masculinity.... My FEMALE shrink laughed when I told her I was raped by a woman 30 years older than me and commented "great practice for kid".I was 11. F#€kin toxic femininity... I don't see a shrink anymore. My mental health improved in my late 20s when I found a good male role model.
      i went to jail for domestic violance when a woman beat me when I was in my early 20s and a neibor called the police. My mother taught me never to hit a girl so I didn't fight back. The cops couldn't believe I was the one being abused so I was arrested... it messed me up for a long time.
      Those instances and a few more caused serious depression. I Nearly killed myself over it. I couldn't have a decent relationship with a woman till I learned to be a man.
      I Love my mother but a single mother can't teach a boy to be a man. Being a male raised like a girl crippled me and stereotypes nearly killed me.
      Yes the hormonal soup that our brains soak in do cause differences. Yes some is social structure as well.... Don't rely on UA-cam. Use Google. Read all of the studies and research papers yourself. Use arxiv app for Android or iOS.
      Neuroscience is a far better barometer than psychology for predictive theory. It's a good place to start if you're interested.
      Men and women are different. Neither is superior. We complement each other and can't live without one another as individuals(well there are exceptions) or as a species.
      My best wishes to all of you out there. Wether you agree or no. 😁 Have fun till the zombies come for all of our squishy brains.

    • @fluffyingable
      @fluffyingable 6 років тому +5

      You are correct, our expectations to be strong lead us to not seek help and hide our feelings, and so the apparent statistic of females being more depressed then males could absolutely be false.

    • @fluffyingable
      @fluffyingable 6 років тому +4

      However I wouldn't label it toxic, although disadvantages include not seeking help and hiding feelings, there is also a lot of positives aswell

    • @sylendraws1249
      @sylendraws1249 6 років тому +2

      Charlot-sweetie
      Don’t males have drastically higher sucked rates than females. That has got to mean something. I think it’s just that it’s harder for males to understand and express their genuine emotions than females. There’s nothing a guy is more afraid of than being vulnerable.

    • @fluffyingable
      @fluffyingable 6 років тому +2

      higher sucked rates? true.

  • @smadak
    @smadak 6 років тому +3

    P sure women are more often diagnosed with depression/anxiety because they're more likely to go seek help for mental health problems... At least, that's what I remember reading somewhere

    • @Moesie
      @Moesie 3 роки тому

      Not really more females are offere too open up emotionally and be taken care of. Meanwhile men are spit on and hate by societyb

    • @Moesie
      @Moesie 3 роки тому

      A women can divorce and take 50% men

  • @thelastcube.
    @thelastcube. 6 років тому +4

    I think it's just like other organs, like there is no male or female heart, it's just a heart and different for everyone aka adaptable.
    But again can't say much until more research is done

    • @pawnap666
      @pawnap666 6 років тому +2

      You would be wrong then. Thing logically for a second. Where is you hormonal production management ? When you grow up why suddenly boys start to change tone of voice ? Why if male looks at naked female his penis rises up ?
      All those things are regulated by brain and are not something you can change by behavior. So while structurally it looks similar in actual use it is different.
      But like Hank said. There are more things common between sexes than dividing them AND while groups at large are similar individuals vary more between each other than between groups. So while differences exist it is not like you have 100% assurance than if you are male you will be better at spacial tasks.

  • @diamondinvr
    @diamondinvr 5 років тому +1

    Whether or not there are male or female brains is meaningless. Its all about how these brains are treated and nurtured.

  • @shreksspawn2359
    @shreksspawn2359 5 років тому +1

    The size of the brain *DOES NOT* matter! It is the amount of neurons and their neural connections that matter.