If you want a quick way to get a "ballpark" estimate for your roof replacement, you can use the free tool on our website www.homesteadroofingcolorado.com/ Look for the bright, yellow tab on the right side that says "Instant Roof Quote" It will only take you about 30 seconds and it will give you a pretty good idea of what a new roof may cost you.
I went with a black roof, black trim, gutters, garage doors, black beading around my windows, and a black metal door to compliment my cream-stone and brick home here in Texas. I fell in love with this color scheme on a trip to Paris many years ago. Now it seems to be all the rage. Who knew??🤩 Some have commented on the heat a black roof generates. Our home is wrapped in foam insulation, and we have a heat pump and is always comfortable even during the past two years of seasonal extremes. Our builder was Couto Homes, the best in our area.
I watched this video a couple of weeks ago and jotted down “certainteed burnt sienna” as I have a red brick facade on front and beige siding on the rest of the house. I sat down with my contractor yesterday and was happy to see this as an option so I chose it. I appreciate your suggestion and hope I made the right call!
I prefer black as well. I just had my home done in Owens Corning High Definition Duration architectural shingle in black onyx. It looks great & I’ve already gotten lots of complements on it.
I’ve decided to have a black roof installed this spring. My house is a ranch style, hip roof and has dark frame windows with security bars. The siding is a light tan; with rock at the bottom around the fountain. Have had two roof’s ( I’m old ) both in the brown tones. It looked fine. The change in contrast will make the biggest difference. Was surprised at the people who chose black, since I’d already decided to go with black before watching. When I drive around, I don’t see very many black roofs. Thanks
You don’t see many black roofs because that’s the worst color you could possibly pick for your roof it’s not going to repel the sun and your house is going to be very hot in the summertime
FYI: Live in CA and the temps can get over 100+. Have lived in my house for 30 year’s. Upgraded insulation, and plan on adding a product that blocks the heat in the attic, Eagle shield. Also have a whole house fan. Fantastic, to remove the heat in the evening. Also, thinking about adding a solar attic fan that works during the daytime. My father built my home and it isn’t a track home, it’s custom build. I’ve done the research and from what I found the temperature difference is a very slight. Depending on many factors a black roof is completely fine. Like all things it’s important to do your own due diligence. Thanks
Yes-one color was missed. I have a 1967 salmon pink brick house. I’m considering the Midnight Plum color from Owens Corning, and either Traditional Blue or Tuxedo Grey gutters from Spectra Gutter Systems.
Most "black" shingles are actually a charcoal color. . . .and is a very classic "Tuxedo" look on a red brick, hip roof executive house. . . .meets most HOA color schemes.
I have a dark blue house but not too dark and white trim and I chose Owens Corning Black Onyx. It’s been one week I’ve had the roof done and It turned out great. I don’t regret it at all but I wish I could have had a chance at using that app or program that shows your house with the shingles on it! that sounds like it would really help if you we’re struggling to pick a color. I didn’t really have that issue so all good. Thanks for the video!
We are Texans and because of a hailstorm in June we're getting another new roof. The last one was in 2009, and, as you're aware, the cost has soared since then. In 2009 I selected Weathered Wood but later decided it looked too much like our street color, just plain ol' asphalt gray. So this time I contemplated changing to something else. We even toured some of the neighborhood to see other roofs. Well, guess what? After all that, I'm picking Weathered Wood again. Our home is a light stone with shades of gray and a little bit of rust in it. Our trim is Country Blue. I was afraid to try any other color. At least I know I can live with this choice.
I just picked out weathered wood also for our home. It's beige with cream trim and some grey stone in front. I like dark roofs but was afraid to go darker. Hope we like it, they are putting it on soon!
my house is white with black trim, black around the windows and wooden shutters. A modern farm house style. I'm in between owens corning black sable and sand dune.
Our home is a dark red brick with different color shades of bricks, kind of mottled. We were thinking of a black roof. Also, if you drive around and see a house with a roof that you like, it's much easier to find the house on Google Earth and get a screen capture of it from their Street View. That way you don't look suspicious driving around taking photos of people's homes. 😄
Thanks for the awesome, educative and very comprehensive video. My favorite shingles color also is Heather Blend. My house wall colors are lighter shade Beige body paint color. So, hopefully the contrast looks good with Heather Blend color. Keep up the great job you are doing for the UA-cam community. I appreciate it.
My roofing contractor gave me local addresses of roofs he installed in the two colors I was deciding between. If your roofer can’t do this, you need to find someone else. BTW, I’m signing the contract with him today.
My house is light almond brick, white doors and trim. Garage white garage door and light grey entry door. The shed is an almond vinyl door is light grey. I would love new doors and color.
I have a beige earthtone home with beige natural brick. I want a white shingle roof. Probably not a popular color with the color of my home or with many people, but I live in a hot southern state and I am thinking about energy efficiency. A darker color roof may look appealing but it helps to hold heat inside the home once the sun goes down. And I thought it would be cool for it to look as if I have snow on my roof.
I just had a new roof put in...Owens Corning Duration shingles in Amber. Color turned out to be lighter than I expected and now having a hard time deciding which shade of beige to go with for the house...yellow, orange, or gray understones.
And, what if you live in an area (like Texas) that can have 100+ temps over the summer, isn't a light color better for not absorbing all that heat? Especially for 3 story townhomes where the shingle are not so visible.
Hi You asked for favorite color shingles. My house is warm cream brick---we have selected Timberline HD Hickory. I was happy to hear this is very similar to Burnt Sienna color which you recommended for cream house. I hope you are reading this and able to provide any feedback quickly.
Hi! I have wicker siding and a red/orange brick. Getting a new roof. Going with atlas pristine. Weathered wood. It’s safe. Plus I have no shade. My house gets so hot!
I look at all brown or lighter colored roofs in my neighborhood and all show really bad weathering/streaking (they just look dirty) after several years of weather, pollen, smog (light, but always present), sap, other contaminants. I think that is why black is so popular in the poll, it has same weathering, but beign black, those dark streaking stains aren't observable from the curb/street. I want to go with that heather he noted for my light tan/beige vinyl siding home, but not sure after seeing other dark/medium brown roofs looknig a bit ratty on nearby homes.
My house is dark brown on the upper siding with cream trim & cream lower level on a 2 story house l; The cottage is also cement block with cream exterior & dark brown nearest the roof line. I was thinking of using GAF Hickory that has dark brown & reddish rust hues (which is the darkest color & I think would look stunning) or Shakewood which is a light brown 3-tone with a little rust tones to match but contrast & not retain as much heat ; because I live in Arizona & it is HOT, some think I should use Golden Amber which I think will look white from a distance & would look weird. What do you think ?
Pure red brick facade, with white siding, (faded) black shutters. Has to be GAF. Torn between HDZ Pewter, Charcoal, Canadian Driftwood, and Appalachian Sky. Your expert opinion would be greatly appreciated! Hover app makes me feel like the Canadian Driftwood ties the black shutters to the red brick really nicely. Wish I could paste the pic.
What Certainteed Landmark roofing color would you recommend with an orange brick home (think 1950’s brick- not red brick) with a warm brown/gray trim color?
We are in the throes of choosing a roof color for our 1950s orange brick ranch (not orange red). I’m thinking darker, multi shaded shingles would work, but I know basically nothing about these things. Any help/ ideas would be appreciated.
I have a dark red house with white trim and white garage doors. Last time I went with a light gray. I need to replace the roof again because of hail damage. Not sure what color would look the best. Light gray seems to be what keeps the house cooler in summer.
Light tan in some lights almost looks like it’s yellowish but it’s light tan it has weathered wood gaf now and id like to replace it with desert sand from tamko(we live at the beach) shutters are blue, we need to upgrade those and the door which will be blue or wood. But they don’t have desert sand in gaf timberline and I want the better shingle so I was thinking of doing shakewood? Or barkwood? But I don’t know it’s tough…
I'm going to do vinyl siding on my house, probably a darker grey, not very dark, but also not light grey. I will go with OC Durations. Trying to figure out what color shingles. Will consider anything that isn't black.
Manufacturers make different colors available for different areas. You should check the manufacturer's website to see what colors are available where you live. I prefer shingles that contract with the siding color. Dark shingle on light siding and visa versa. Personal preference.
One thing to consider about a black roof is that black holds heat. The sun beats down on your roof all day every day and makes it hot, in turn making your house hotter. That makes your air conditioning work harder and costs more to cool your house. Or if you have an older air conditioner that isn't up to snuff or even don't have air conditioning, you might be uncomfortable when it's hot outside
I watched a video on here from a shingle contractor in Florida. During the hottest part of a 90 degree day the black shingle was 160 degrees, the light colored grey was 156.
@@peterdallman4550 did that roofer video test the temp on a very light almost white shingle?? That's what I currently have and I wonder if light or dark color really makes a big difference. Thanks
@@BNM-b7t In the middle of a 94 degree day in Florida the light gray (very light colored) shingle was something like 6-8 degrees cooler than the black shingle.
@@peterdallman4550 So there is some difference but not enough to continue to use such a light colored shingle. Currently the very light shingle on a white house does not offer much contrast/curb appeal. And since I am having them install a complete ridge vent because it currently has a partial, it should help eliminate more heat from the attic space. Thanks for your reply, I appreciate it.
Fixing to reroof using Malarkey Vista AR. Will be using the Weathered Wood... it's a "safe" color choice knowing I'll be looking at it for the next 20 years. Unfortunately, Malarkey has decided to start making most of their color schemes using multiple contrasting shades built into their shingles... gives a roof a "pixelated" look... definitely DO NOT like the aesthetics of those roofs. My roofer did provide addresses of homes with the various shades I was possibly interested in... that helped tremendously. Thanks for your great videos, knowledge and advice...
brother, I ran into the same issue when considering malarky vista.. the specs and durability sold me and we were going to go with weathered wood also, but the "pixelated" look best describes what their shingles tend to look like... I dont like it at all and ended up passing on malarkey altogether... going with owens corning duration cool series and probably mojave or golden meadow for our light faded yellow siding, brown gutter house..
@@skip741x3... Malarky has (had) the Weathered Wood which doesn't have the pixelated design, which is what I decided on. They also have the Weathered Wood Plus which is pixelated. I think the original Weathered Wood may be being discontinued as an option, but was still available when my roof was done.
@karlarentz7694 You nailed it 100%!! The roof is done! I chose Oyster Gray, and when the roofer ripped open that first bundle, I wanted to cry, thought I really messed this up. It's on the roof and it is gorgeous!! And when the sun is on the roof, it literally sparkles! I can see it coming down the road! Yes, some blues, little silver, iridescent like the inside of an oyster shell. It enhances the sage color (which I never liked) of my siding to the point I like the sage now. I asked my roofer, he said nobody hardly picks that color. So glad I went with that instead of pewter gray for my house. Thank you! 😊
what color roof shingle?? cream (not beige) siding with black window shutters . A sprawling ranch - no dormers- lots of roof without anything to break it up but 2 peaks and a chimney.
I just had my roof replaced and I am displeased with the color I chose. i have a house with brown wood siding. The previous roof was black with the highlights of grays and slight blues, I think. I replaced it with charcoal black which I thought looked great when we saw the samples. However, now that the roof is on, the contrast to me is too stark compared to the rest of the house. I'm also disappointed in that I did not foresee how the black roof would disrupt how my house would blend with the trees which surround my house on almost all sides. I enjoy the hidden quality of my home that has a, "cottage in the woods feel" as the home blends well with the surrounding trees. My choice of the charcoal roof disrupts that. Sadly, this was a very costly mistake not easily resolved. 😞
Maybe too much green, but... if you choose another color, then you have 4 colors on your house. That could be a little overwhelming to look at. If your roofer offers a brand that has a color called Thunderstorm Gray, take a look at that. You may like it.
Just got a new roof on our house. Got a lighter shade of tan. My neighbors just had a black roof put on theirs. Looks very nice, but on a typical summer day in Texas, theyll be able to use their roof for a giant frying pan, no thanks.
I have a lemon-yellow rambler, which looks quite cheery. I was thinking of a medium grey shingle like the Landmark Driftwood, weathered wood, or Pewter. What do you think?
I am in Texas Home built late 70s brick is redish with beige, charcoal and black.. I have black trim and gutters and siding is light beige (thinking of changing siding color to gray beige and trip a little lighter to charcoal gray..) Looking at timberline charcoal? Not sure if that will be too dark or if pewter gray would be better? Home is 1600 sq ft and 1 story
My beach house inspired house is a bright blue green with white trim and coral door. Do you think Atlas Cool Sand or Owens Corning Amber would look better with it for a sandy look?
What color certainteed shingle would look good with James hardie boothbay blue (a light blue gray blue) with white trim? We also have field stones on lower half of house with grays and browns. Considering driftwood or Georgia gray - any opinions on either of those or other suggestions?
I have a ballatyne brick on my house and planning to go with the Malarkey Legacy Brilliant Black colour. Am I crazy with all the heat it can absorb? For that reason also considering their ivory mist or Silverwood…..
I have a light gray house with white trim. trying to decide between pewter gray or weathered wood. I want it to match but also have some warmth to it as we have natural brick in front of the house
@@homesteadroofing thanks for replying, unfortunately that is not a color offered by me. In Wisconsin. I think I like the weatherwoood but in some pictures it looks brown and some it looks like a warm gray. I want to keep the appearance warm and neutral which is why I'm nervous about the pewter gray.
I have a red brick house with a forest green door and garage doors. Beige window trim and gutters. What would be your recommendation of roof shingle in andmark pro series?
I have beige siding, my shingles are a brown, my siding has lightened and due to the sun, S-W, my deck can reach temperatures of 110-129, all my black light fixtures are now an ugly ashen color. No way would I put black shingles on my roof, so I got to find a brownish shingle to match my garage roof. My gutters are a dark brown.
My house is limestone. I choose Corning Owen terra cotta shingles and will paint the fascia and sofit the terra cotta color shade too (but little bit darker). What do you think?
I have a brown English Tudor with white & blue accents. What color would you suggest. I am leaning towards Heather Blend but not sure of CertainTeed. I also like Brownwood & Teak by OC.
We have storm damage to our house and need to replace the roof. The house has pale yellow siding which we cannot replace in the near future. It also has dark brown shudders but we will likely go with a different color for them or remove them. I’m wondering about a gray roof but don’t want too strong of a contrast with the pale yellow. What shade (or other colors) would you suggest?
I think you would like Heather Blend by CertainTeed. But if Thunderstorm Gray is available in your area, that would look good, too (after you take off the brown shutters). Let me know what you think.
I have a two story home built in 1802 surrounded by mature treess. What color would you choose for a tan/yellow home with large white columns in the front?
What Certainteed Manour house colour would you recommend for a white house? Trying to avoid black and go with a grey. Would you recommend stonegate gray?
@@SavingOurRepublic Understand, and tiles may not suit most houses due to the weight. But I was referring to just the terracotta color, there're shingles and even metal roof that come in the terracotta color these days (although metal roofs are expensive also but the price may come down eventually).
I have natural cedar siding with charcoal and grey fireplace and grey stucco trim on the house and garage. I am replacing cedar shacks and need advice on asphalt shingles color. The greys seem to lean toward blue or green. Please help!
Mine is a sage green sided house with a cedar front getting a new roof and very confused on which color to go. I would appreciate your input. Thank you.
I have a white stone home . Not bright white but with a very slight yellow limestone undertone throughout. Which makes it a warm. Gutters and doors are Spanish moss. Deep brown. Siding is Nantucket dune which we could change if needed. What would be the best color matches ?
The colors that are available here will be different than what is available in your region. You can go onto any of the shingle company's websites and enter your zip code and it will show you what's available in your area.
I have a medium greenish/teal colonial house, 12pitch. I like CertainTeed Landmark Moire Black, Charcoal Black, or Pewter. Recommend? Is black a problem with getting too hot in New England summers?
I am planning to use Owens Corning High Definition Duration Shasta White, and my roofer is trying to talk me out of it. My house is light colored brick. I will be changing trim colors to get some contrast. What do you think?
Our house is white trim and brown brick with a millennium color stager stacked chimney. On our roof we wanted to go with Natural Wood Malarkey AR Vista shingle. Is this acceptable? Thanks for your knowledge on roofs.
Here in NY we have clay color siding. Not a tan clay or dark gray clay but a very neutral clay. We have something resembling a weathered wood roof now but are considering black. I'm hoping to find a black that's warm toned not cool. Any suggestions?
My house is SW9130 - Evergreen Fog which has an LRV of 31.15 (on the dark side); white trim-Alabaster; and shutters in Urban Bronze Choices: Owens Corning in Driftwood or GAF in Weathered Wood?
Great videos, just found your channel. Framing complete on our Craftsman home in South Carolina. Need to choose shingle brand and color. House colors are: main lap siding SW Dill green, shake accent siding SW Haven which is a lighter green, white windows, light brown trim, and dark brown rain gutters. Liking the Certainteed Landmark Pro Sunrise Cedar. Any help to get the shingle color correct would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.
We are building a new house and we are using mitten brownstone for board & batten and vinyl siding, Margaux beige stone veneer. Builder has asked us to choose between gag charcoal or Canadian driftwood shingle. Can you suggest which one should we pick
We actually have a roof company coming by today wanting to pick the color we're going with. We're in a ranch style light limestone. I thought I was set on darker/med shade of gray. Now I'm wondering about darker brown. Help! 😊
If you want a quick way to get a "ballpark" estimate for your roof replacement, you can use the free tool on our website www.homesteadroofingcolorado.com/
Look for the bright, yellow tab on the right side that says "Instant Roof Quote" It will only take you about 30 seconds and it will give you a pretty good idea of what a new roof may cost you.
I went with a black roof, black trim, gutters, garage doors, black beading around my windows, and a black metal door to compliment my cream-stone and brick home here in Texas. I fell in love with this color scheme on a trip to Paris many years ago. Now it seems to be all the rage. Who knew??🤩 Some have commented on the heat a black roof generates. Our home is wrapped in foam insulation, and we have a heat pump and is always comfortable even during the past two years of seasonal extremes. Our builder was Couto Homes, the best in our area.
I watched this video a couple of weeks ago and jotted down “certainteed burnt sienna” as I have a red brick facade on front and beige siding on the rest of the house. I sat down with my contractor yesterday and was happy to see this as an option so I chose it. I appreciate your suggestion and hope I made the right call!
That's great!! 👍
@@homesteadroofing It looks awesome! Thank you!
what color did you choose for red brick & front brown stone?
I prefer black as well. I just had my home done in Owens Corning High Definition Duration architectural shingle in black onyx. It looks great & I’ve already gotten lots of complements on it.
Peruvian orange house white trim terracotta roof? Lots of redwood stockade fencing lots of green and pink in the raised garden bed, flowers etc
Yeah, black heat absorbing shingle in Phoenix on a 110 degree day would be just perfect. I like the dark gray with blue highlights. SoCAL
Blue is what I just got. Only wish it was more blue, but it's nice.
What color gutters?
@@ibealion1 Thanks, what color blue did you choose?
Owens Corning driftwood is a neutral shingle and looks great on my house.
What color is your house?
@@leecarter1691 beige is the color with dark bronze trim and gutters . Compliment from neighbor. Looks classy.
I’ve decided to have a black roof installed this spring. My house is a ranch style, hip roof and has dark frame windows with security bars. The siding is a light tan; with rock at the bottom around the fountain. Have had two roof’s ( I’m old ) both in the brown tones. It looked fine. The change in contrast will make the biggest difference. Was surprised at the people who chose black, since I’d already decided to go with black before watching. When I drive around, I don’t see very many black roofs. Thanks
Thank you for the input. I hope you love your new roof!
You don’t see many black roofs because that’s the worst color you could possibly pick for your roof it’s not going to repel the sun and your house is going to be very hot in the summertime
@@dcwatashi Depends where you live.
FYI: Live in CA and the temps can get over 100+. Have lived in my house for 30 year’s. Upgraded insulation, and plan on adding a product that blocks the heat in the attic, Eagle shield. Also have a whole house fan. Fantastic, to remove the heat in the evening. Also, thinking about adding a solar attic fan that works during the daytime. My father built my home and it isn’t a track home, it’s custom build.
I’ve done the research and from what I found the temperature difference is a very slight. Depending on many factors a black roof is completely fine.
Like all things it’s important to do your own due diligence. Thanks
@@waitingwatching1291 My experience is also that the temp difference is marginal if any at all.
Yes-one color was missed. I have a 1967 salmon pink brick house. I’m considering the Midnight Plum color from Owens Corning, and either Traditional Blue or Tuxedo Grey gutters from Spectra Gutter Systems.
Yes! I’m a serial commenter! My house is very light beige ( sorta) and you nailed it, I went with something similar to weathered wood 👍🏼🍺
Am going with a light color, Amber. Only because the weather is getting hot, We are in October and It's 95 this week, Crazy.
I’m going with the midnight plum shingle by owens Corning
What color house & what color gutters did you go with? I’m looking at that for my salmon pink brick.
I couldn’t agree more about brochures and sample boards! In this wonderful age, it’s so much easier to get it right👍🏼
My house is James Hardie evening blue. I'm leaning towards the Owens Corning Bourbon.
Cream siding. White shutters and trim..im thinking either weathered wood...OR a charcoal for contrast hmmmm
OC Pacific Wave blue. On blue near-beach house in Florida.
Most "black" shingles are actually a charcoal color. . . .and is a very classic "Tuxedo" look on a red brick, hip roof executive house. . . .meets most HOA color schemes.
I have a dark blue house but not too dark and white trim and I chose Owens Corning Black Onyx. It’s been one week I’ve had the roof done and It turned out great. I don’t regret it at all but I wish I could have had a chance at using that app or program that shows your house with the shingles on it! that sounds like it would really help if you we’re struggling to pick a color. I didn’t really have that issue so all good. Thanks for the video!
We are Texans and because of a hailstorm in June we're getting another new roof. The last one was in 2009, and, as you're aware, the cost has soared since then. In 2009 I selected Weathered Wood but later decided it looked too much like our street color, just plain ol' asphalt gray. So this time I contemplated changing to something else. We even toured some of the neighborhood to see other roofs. Well, guess what? After all that, I'm picking Weathered Wood again. Our home is a light stone with shades of gray and a little bit of rust in it. Our trim is Country Blue. I was afraid to try any other color. At least I know I can live with this choice.
I just picked out weathered wood also for our home. It's beige with cream trim and some grey stone in front. I like dark roofs but was afraid to go darker. Hope we like it, they are putting it on soon!
my house is white with black trim, black around the windows and wooden shutters. A modern farm house style. I'm in between owens corning black sable and sand dune.
Good choices!
Our home is a dark red brick with different color shades of bricks, kind of mottled. We were thinking of a black roof. Also, if you drive around and see a house with a roof that you like, it's much easier to find the house on Google Earth and get a screen capture of it from their Street View. That way you don't look suspicious driving around taking photos of people's homes. 😄
Black sounds good! I also like your idea of using Google!
The brick sounds identical to ours... I'm considering a green roof. I see it so rarely but it's gorgeous, imo!
I'm going with Certainteed Pro Espresso next spring.
Thanks for the awesome, educative and very comprehensive video. My favorite shingles color also is Heather Blend. My house wall colors are lighter shade Beige body paint color. So, hopefully the contrast looks good with Heather Blend color. Keep up the great job you are doing for the UA-cam community. I appreciate it.
Thank you. That was a very encouraging comment to read after seeing so many unkind ones.
Hi! We have a dark grey siding, black shutters and then an accent of grey / slate / dark purplish stone.
My roofing contractor gave me local addresses of roofs he installed in the two colors I was deciding between.
If your roofer can’t do this, you need to find someone else.
BTW, I’m signing the contract with him today.
My favorite is GAF HDZ Pewter Gray, for a light blue siding.
why not UHDZ ?
My house is light almond brick, white doors and trim. Garage white garage door and light grey entry door. The shed is an almond vinyl door is light grey. I would love new doors and color.
I like the gray roofs. I think the black are too hot in this hot/humid area.
I have a beige earthtone home with beige natural brick. I want a white shingle roof. Probably not a popular color with the color of my home or with many people, but I live in a hot southern state and I am thinking about energy efficiency. A darker color roof may look appealing but it helps to hold heat inside the home once the sun goes down. And I thought it would be cool for it to look as if I have snow on my roof.
I white roof may make the rest of your house look dirty
Have you read something that demonstrates that a darker color would make your house warmer?
Getting certainteed weather wood installed tomorrow
I just had a new roof put in...Owens Corning Duration shingles in Amber. Color turned out to be lighter than I expected and now having a hard time deciding which shade of beige to go with for the house...yellow, orange, or gray understones.
And, what if you live in an area (like Texas) that can have 100+ temps over the summer, isn't a light color better for not absorbing all that heat? Especially for 3 story townhomes where the shingle are not so visible.
I'm not convinced that there's any substantial evidence that a darker color makes your house hotter.
Hi You asked for favorite color shingles. My house is warm cream brick---we have selected Timberline HD Hickory. I was happy to hear this is very similar to Burnt Sienna color which you recommended for cream house. I hope you are reading this and able to provide any feedback quickly.
Hi! I have wicker siding and a red/orange brick. Getting a new roof. Going with atlas pristine. Weathered wood. It’s safe. Plus I have no shade. My house gets so hot!
I look at all brown or lighter colored roofs in my neighborhood and all show really bad weathering/streaking (they just look dirty) after several years of weather, pollen, smog (light, but always present), sap, other contaminants. I think that is why black is so popular in the poll, it has same weathering, but beign black, those dark streaking stains aren't observable from the curb/street.
I want to go with that heather he noted for my light tan/beige vinyl siding home, but not sure after seeing other dark/medium brown roofs looknig a bit ratty on nearby homes.
My house is dark brown on the upper siding with cream trim & cream lower level on a 2 story house l; The cottage is also cement block with cream exterior & dark brown nearest the roof line. I was thinking of using GAF Hickory that has dark brown & reddish rust hues (which is the darkest color & I think would look stunning) or Shakewood which is a light brown 3-tone with a little rust tones to match but contrast & not retain as much heat ; because I live in Arizona & it is HOT, some think I should use Golden Amber which I think will look white from a distance & would look weird. What do you think ?
Orangy pinkish brick. More orange than terra cotta. Trim, soffits was cedar tree green. Want to use maybe a grey instead.
Pure red brick facade, with white siding, (faded) black shutters. Has to be GAF. Torn between HDZ Pewter, Charcoal, Canadian Driftwood, and Appalachian Sky. Your expert opinion would be greatly appreciated!
Hover app makes me feel like the Canadian Driftwood ties the black shutters to the red brick really nicely. Wish I could paste the pic.
What Certainteed Landmark roofing color would you recommend with an orange brick home (think 1950’s brick- not red brick) with a warm brown/gray trim color?
We are in the throes of choosing a roof color for our 1950s orange brick ranch (not orange red). I’m thinking darker, multi shaded shingles would work, but I know basically nothing about these things. Any help/ ideas would be appreciated.
I have a dark red house with white trim and white garage doors. Last time I went with a light gray. I need to replace the roof again because of hail damage. Not sure what color would look the best. Light gray seems to be what keeps the house cooler in summer.
Medium gray... I think it would be good.
My whole neighborhood has black roofs. York PA.
Light tan in some lights almost looks like it’s yellowish but it’s light tan it has weathered wood gaf now and id like to replace it with desert sand from tamko(we live at the beach) shutters are blue, we need to upgrade those and the door which will be blue or wood. But they don’t have desert sand in gaf timberline and I want the better shingle so I was thinking of doing shakewood? Or barkwood? But I don’t know it’s tough…
I'm going to do vinyl siding on my house, probably a darker grey, not very dark, but also not light grey. I will go with OC Durations. Trying to figure out what color shingles. Will consider anything that isn't black.
We have a log home, new construction that is dark brown. Looking for advice on what color of shingle to use.
Manufacturers make different colors available for different areas. You should check the manufacturer's website to see what colors are available where you live. I prefer shingles that contract with the siding color. Dark shingle on light siding and visa versa.
Personal preference.
One thing to consider about a black roof is that black holds heat. The sun beats down on your roof all day every day and makes it hot, in turn making your house hotter. That makes your air conditioning work harder and costs more to cool your house. Or if you have an older air conditioner that isn't up to snuff or even don't have air conditioning, you might be uncomfortable when it's hot outside
I watched a video on here from a shingle contractor in Florida. During the hottest part of a 90 degree day the black shingle was 160 degrees, the light colored grey was 156.
@@peterdallman4550 Good info her... thanks
@@peterdallman4550 did that roofer video test the temp on a very light almost white shingle?? That's what I currently have and I wonder if light or dark color really makes a big difference. Thanks
@@BNM-b7t In the middle of a 94 degree day in Florida the light gray (very light colored) shingle was something like 6-8 degrees cooler than the black shingle.
@@peterdallman4550 So there is some difference but not enough to continue to use such a light colored shingle. Currently the very light shingle on a white house does not offer much contrast/curb appeal. And since I am having them install a complete ridge vent because it currently has a partial, it should help eliminate more heat from the attic space.
Thanks for your reply, I appreciate it.
Fixing to reroof using Malarkey Vista AR. Will be using the Weathered Wood... it's a "safe" color choice knowing I'll be looking at it for the next 20 years. Unfortunately, Malarkey has decided to start making most of their color schemes using multiple contrasting shades built into their shingles... gives a roof a "pixelated" look... definitely DO NOT like the aesthetics of those roofs. My roofer did provide addresses of homes with the various shades I was possibly interested in... that helped tremendously.
Thanks for your great videos, knowledge and advice...
brother, I ran into the same issue when considering malarky vista.. the specs and durability sold me and we were going to go with weathered wood also, but the "pixelated" look best describes what their shingles tend to look like... I dont like it at all and ended up passing on malarkey altogether... going with owens corning duration cool series and probably mojave or golden meadow for our light faded yellow siding, brown gutter house..
@@skip741x3... Malarky has (had) the Weathered Wood which doesn't have the pixelated design, which is what I decided on. They also have the Weathered Wood Plus which is pixelated.
I think the original Weathered Wood may be being discontinued as an option, but was still available when my roof was done.
Very helpful video, thank you! Our home has dark brown cedar siding, and it's octagon-shaped. What color roof would you recommend?
I'm going crazy between oyster gray and pewter gray. Sage colonial with black front door, shutters and white trim.
Oyster gray is very cool and shows blue tones
@karlarentz7694 You nailed it 100%!! The roof is done! I chose Oyster Gray, and when the roofer ripped open that first bundle, I wanted to cry, thought I really messed this up. It's on the roof and it is gorgeous!! And when the sun is on the roof, it literally sparkles! I can see it coming down the road! Yes, some blues, little silver, iridescent like the inside of an oyster shell. It enhances the sage color (which I never liked) of my siding to the point I like the sage now. I asked my roofer, he said nobody hardly picks that color. So glad I went with that instead of pewter gray for my house. Thank you! 😊
I keep using Estate Gray..on my tan ranch house... Its very hot here...not sure what else would look nice
what color roof shingle?? cream (not beige) siding with black window shutters . A sprawling ranch - no dormers- lots of roof without anything to break it up but 2 peaks and a chimney.
I have a cedar house. Can’t pick a color. Thinking of driftwood
I just had my roof replaced and I am displeased with the color I chose. i have a house with brown wood siding. The previous roof was black with the highlights of grays and slight blues, I think. I replaced it with charcoal black which I thought looked great when we saw the samples. However, now that the roof is on, the contrast to me is too stark compared to the rest of the house. I'm also disappointed in that I did not foresee how the black roof would disrupt how my house would blend with the trees which surround my house on almost all sides. I enjoy the hidden quality of my home that has a, "cottage in the woods feel" as the home blends well with the surrounding trees. My choice of the charcoal roof disrupts that. Sadly, this was a very costly mistake not easily resolved. 😞
I’d go with colonial slate, of course that’s an OC 😂
But of course the house matters, like you said
Recommendation for a red brick home?
cornmeal yellow house with hunter green shutters and white trim
please let me know best roof color - i was looking at hunter green from GAF but maybe too much green?
Maybe too much green, but... if you choose another color, then you have 4 colors on your house. That could be a little overwhelming to look at. If your roofer offers a brand that has a color called Thunderstorm Gray, take a look at that. You may like it.
Limewashed white brick with neutral taupe siding accents?
Just got a new roof on our house. Got a lighter shade of tan. My neighbors just had a black roof put on theirs. Looks very nice, but on a typical summer day in Texas, theyll be able to use their roof for a giant frying pan, no thanks.
I have a lemon-yellow rambler, which looks quite cheery. I was thinking of a medium grey shingle like the Landmark Driftwood, weathered wood, or Pewter. What do you think?
What about a medium gray siding would black look good
I have a dark blue home. What color roof would look best? The one I chose is drab looking
I am in Texas Home built late 70s brick is redish with beige, charcoal and black.. I have black trim and gutters and siding is light beige (thinking of changing siding color to gray beige and trip a little lighter to charcoal gray..) Looking at timberline charcoal? Not sure if that will be too dark or if pewter gray would be better? Home is 1600 sq ft and 1 story
My beach house inspired house is a bright blue green with white trim and coral door. Do you think Atlas Cool Sand or Owens Corning Amber would look better with it for a sandy look?
How about for an 80’s orange brick house. Has some color variations in it.
Black
Great videos...our siding is a darker green. What's your roofing color suggestion?
Heather Blend
White and black black shingles or gray shingles?
What color certainteed shingle would look good with James hardie boothbay blue (a light blue gray blue) with white trim? We also have field stones on lower half of house with grays and browns. Considering driftwood or Georgia gray - any opinions on either of those or other suggestions?
My house is painted off white and my shuttered are. Dark mohagany what color roof do you suggest.
I have a ballatyne brick on my house and planning to go with the Malarkey Legacy Brilliant Black colour. Am I crazy with all the heat it can absorb? For that reason also considering their ivory mist or Silverwood…..
I have a light gray house with white trim. trying to decide between pewter gray or weathered wood. I want it to match but also have some warmth to it as we have natural brick in front of the house
I think you would like Georgetown Gray also.
@@homesteadroofing thanks for replying, unfortunately that is not a color offered by me. In Wisconsin. I think I like the weatherwoood but in some pictures it looks brown and some it looks like a warm gray. I want to keep the appearance warm and neutral which is why I'm nervous about the pewter gray.
i have a weathered hand split cedar shake shingle ranch house what would you recommend? currently black asphalt.....Thanks
I have a red brick house with a forest green door and garage doors. Beige window trim and gutters. What would be your recommendation of roof shingle in andmark pro series?
I have beige siding, my shingles are a brown, my siding has lightened and due to the sun, S-W, my deck can reach temperatures of 110-129, all my black light fixtures are now an ugly ashen color. No way would I put black shingles on my roof, so I got to find a brownish shingle to match my garage roof. My gutters are a dark brown.
My house is limestone. I choose Corning Owen terra cotta shingles and will paint the fascia and sofit the terra cotta color shade too (but little bit darker). What do you think?
What color if you live in the desert heat?
I have a brown English Tudor with white & blue accents. What color would you suggest. I am leaning towards Heather Blend but not sure of CertainTeed. I also like Brownwood & Teak by OC.
Heather Blend is my favorite color. It's what I have on my own house.
We have storm damage to our house and need to replace the roof. The house has pale yellow siding which we cannot replace in the near future. It also has dark brown shudders but we will likely go with a different color for them or remove them. I’m wondering about a gray roof but don’t want too strong of a contrast with the pale yellow. What shade (or other colors) would you suggest?
I think you would like Heather Blend by CertainTeed. But if Thunderstorm Gray is available in your area, that would look good, too (after you take off the brown shutters). Let me know what you think.
I have a two story home built in 1802 surrounded by mature treess. What color would you choose for a tan/yellow home with large white columns in the front?
Thunderstorm gray is a good color for that color house
What Certainteed Manour house colour would you recommend for a white house? Trying to avoid black and go with a grey. Would you recommend stonegate gray?
I don't care what color of the house walls are, I just love the terracotta / Spanish tile color.
Most can't afford that
@@SavingOurRepublic Understand, and tiles may not suit most houses due to the weight. But I was referring to just the terracotta color, there're shingles and even metal roof that come in the terracotta color these days (although metal roofs are expensive also but the price may come down eventually).
I have natural cedar siding with charcoal and grey fireplace and grey stucco trim on the house and garage. I am replacing cedar shacks and need advice on asphalt shingles color. The greys seem to lean toward blue or green. Please help!
red brick with white trim
I have a White House, I’m torn between Certainteed coastal blue or black-please help!
Mine is a sage green sided house with a cedar front getting a new roof and very confused on which color to go. I would appreciate your input. Thank you.
I like Heather Blend for that scheme
I have a white stone home . Not bright white but with a very slight yellow limestone undertone throughout. Which makes it a warm.
Gutters and doors are Spanish moss. Deep brown.
Siding is Nantucket dune which we could change if needed.
What would be the best color matches ?
The colors that are available here will be different than what is available in your region. You can go onto any of the shingle company's websites and enter your zip code and it will show you what's available in your area.
I have a medium greenish/teal colonial house, 12pitch. I like CertainTeed Landmark Moire Black, Charcoal Black, or Pewter.
Recommend?
Is black a problem with getting too hot in New England summers?
I doubt it.
I am planning to use Owens Corning High Definition Duration Shasta White, and my roofer is trying to talk me out of it. My house is light colored brick. I will be changing trim colors to get some contrast. What do you think?
Our house is white trim and brown brick with a millennium color stager stacked chimney. On our roof we wanted to go with Natural Wood Malarkey AR Vista shingle. Is this acceptable? Thanks for your knowledge on roofs.
That sounds like a good option
What about a Navy Blue or Teal color house with white trim?
CertainTeed Heather Blend would look really good I think.
Here in NY we have clay color siding. Not a tan clay or dark gray clay but a very neutral clay. We have something resembling a weathered wood roof now but are considering black. I'm hoping to find a black that's warm toned not cool. Any suggestions?
I am going with moire black is this good for white painting house?
Yes
My HOA requires weather wood. Owen’s Corning doesn’t have this color, but they have driftwood. How does that compare in the Duration true def series?
It's basically the same.
My house is SW9130 - Evergreen Fog which has an LRV of 31.15 (on the dark side); white trim-Alabaster; and shutters in Urban Bronze
Choices: Owens Corning in Driftwood or GAF in Weathered Wood?
I'm not a fan of either of those brands.
Great videos, just found your channel. Framing complete on our Craftsman home in South Carolina. Need to choose shingle brand and color. House colors are: main lap siding SW Dill green, shake accent siding SW Haven which is a lighter green, white windows, light brown trim, and dark brown rain gutters. Liking the Certainteed Landmark Pro Sunrise Cedar. Any help to get the shingle color correct would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.
Feel free to send a photo of your house, in full sun, to me at info@homesteadroofingcolorado.com
What about white siding with olive green trim?
Consider Heather Blend or Driftwood?
I have red & black brick with white trim, currently with hickory color shingles, what color shingles to replace.
I think brown or black
We are building a new house and we are using mitten brownstone for board & batten and vinyl siding, Margaux beige stone veneer. Builder has asked us to choose between gag charcoal or Canadian driftwood shingle. Can you suggest which one should we pick
My house is white and maroon. What color Roof should I get?
Black
We actually have a roof company coming by today wanting to pick the color we're going with. We're in a ranch style light limestone. I thought I was set on darker/med shade of gray. Now I'm wondering about darker brown. Help! 😊
Ask your roofer to use Hover to show you the different colors on your house.