South Indians (Tamil/Telugu/Kannada/Malayalam) make Pan India movies. Ajay Devgan makes Pan Parag advertisement. By the way, he shouldn't have opted South scripts like Singham, Kaidhi, Drishyam etc.... We support Sudeep sir from Tamilnadu..🙏
India should follow the European Union model to respect every member State language & culture. In India everything is politics. That's why the most deserving Candidate Kamal Haasan didn't get Dada Saheb Balke award yet. Kamal Haasan's only fault is that he is born in South India. This is prejudice.
@@flawless_papaya I too feel it would be be better if we are a union of independent states or at least a true federation like the US. In the present scenario, the states that do well have to part with their revenue to support the weak states. The states that control population lose their political bargaining power. A southern politician has to work twice as hard to become the PM. For someone in Kanyakumari, reaching the National Capital is tougher than visiting a foreign country. The faultlines in the Northern polity and society are affecting the harmonious existence in the south. All in all, we must give more autonomy to the states if we want to progress.
yes thats what you south indians have been doing since few hundred years. follow the mughals afghans nizams and then follow the colonials. nothing of your own. well even your English accent sucks.
Learning hindi for a gujarati or punjabi is easier than for a malayali or tamilian. If somebody wants to speak hindi, it should be a matter of choice. The problem starts when it becomes mandatory in schools and colleges or for competitive exams. Let there be two main languages. There is no need of national language in a multilingual nation.
Hindi js already mandatory in south indian states for students from 5th upto 10th standard. But no mandatory learning of any other india lnguages let alone a south indian languages in hindi related states. Hindi speaking states themselves think hindi as a second class language amd send their vhildren to enhlish medijm schools.
Even as a kannadiga if i speak Hindi with my Hardcore hindi brothers then they start laughing at my accent and struggle to speak Hindi, which by itself is demotivating to speak with these Hindi speaking guys. These guys live in Karnataka for more than 5 years but cannot even take a shot at speaking even bit of Kannada such a shame on these Hindi speaking guys and make fun of us trying to speak Hindi. We are happy with our Mother tongue and our identity and English as a link language. Please do not enforce Hindi on us and make us feel second class citizen in my own country. Also these weird North Indians who come to South and pretend that everyone speaks Hindi such a shame and ignorance...
@@noconversionpage8466 India does not need a national language and cannot have one. Because each state is linguistically different. It needs a link language and an official language when dealing with interstate affairs , English is the language of modern science and world link language, so we should go with English
@@aandy450 then lol there is no scientific language 😂😂 first understand that and India absolutely need a national language currently English is national language but not declare by govt if people oppose Hindi imposition why they don't oppose English imposition 😂😂😂
@@noconversionpage8466 no we don't need any national language. Why we need one language with such diverse nation can our Bollywood actors can tell let's not talk Marathi in Mumbai only talk Hindi? Every one will be kicked out
Hindi is also a regional language spoken by few states. It's our choice to decide what we want to talk or learn, outsiders cannot dictate us just like we cannot dictate them to speak Kannada or Telugu.
nobody is dictating you, even your fellow ppl can speak or understand some forms of hindi but your ego is denying that. you can keep your language's pride even if you use some forms of hindi to communicate with rest of India.
@@buntyskb Your cunningness is denying that you are imposing Hindi on Non Hindi states to make us 2nd class citizens. Though 73% of people are Chinese in Singapore still the founding father Lee Kuan Yew made English as the official language of Singapore to create a equal platform for all ethnicity in Singapore. This is the True Democracy & show of statesmanship. Do not impose your language on us for Your benefit. Follow the Singapore Model.
@@kovalant6400 okay using Hindi as link language is imposing but using English is not?? is English your mother tongue? did it originate here in India??? you south indians are egoistic bunch who would love to be colonial slaves rather than speak a few hindi words to communicate with ppl of other states.
Hindi was brought into existence during the Mughal Rule. South Indian languages are far more ancient. Specially Tamil which is recognised as the oldest language in the world. So I don't understand what Cancer promoter is talking about.
@@k-popdistribution2392 Nope. There are clear evidences for Tamil being several thousands of years older than sanskrit. I'm a Tamil Brahmin. My supposed ancestors brought sanskrit to South India. But there's no doubt Tamil is much much older than sanskrit. There are undeniable evidences throughout the world
Due to south languages English flourished as a link language in the south. Because of this people can find good paying jobs abroad and be updated with the world. Tell me who’s offering jobs in the Hindi belt? Rather the North Indians should learn south languages when they are looking for jobs in places like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Chennai, Trivandrum and Goa. As simple.
Pakistani's also understand Hindi that's why they got to know every moment in India. Hindi is a language and it is influenced by Islamic countries and culture. Moghuls brought Hindi to India not Gandhi or modi. People know how Moghuls are cruel. They destroyed north Indian temples, architectures, libraries, culture then replaced their culture. Now north Indians following Moghuls culture. Crime is more, no women safety, all time chewing pan, jarda, Drugs what not everything.
I can’t fathom about the stupidity of people who associate Hindi to India those who speak hindi are Indian and patriotic and those who don’t aren’t!….such great points by Kasthuri, I am not sure why is it even a debate about this.
what i oppose is when North Indians come to South India even after staying for years like a decade.. they don't make an effort to speak one word in the local language
Very true. And they do goondaism and ask us to speak in Hindi as if we are in their state. If they are staying in Karnataka, using our water, our land food then what is the harm in learning kannada? Make kannada national language.
@@smitajain2k some times brain goes for a walk.. South Indians don't talk in their mother tongue to usa persons.. no body is saying North or East Indians should not talk in Hindi but they don't learn the South Indian language.. a kannada person does not talk in Kannada in Uttar Pradesh like even on day one he starts staying there..
@@smitajain2k brain is going for a walk here is it not.. and yes there is ego that stays.. is it not.. North Indians will learn English to go to Canada.. they will strive hard to clear the ielts.. they will work hard to learn French to settle in Quebec.. they will be able to pronounce Chinese words properly.. but staying in Bangalore for 10 years they can't even say a few words in Kannada.. Even to a village guy.. and if the village guy does not answer in Hindi, the North Indians will call him bc,mc gawar etc.. i have witnessed this . So if you have the ego to not learn South Indian language staying in South India.. You bet i will have the ego to not speak Hindi staying in South India.. Compremendo?
@@smitajain2k And by Avoiding english language the whole north india has progressed very well. Idiots.. All hindi speaking States because are the most backward and undeveloped States. Most of the communal riots and crime against women happen in hindi belt. Because you people are uneducated. We prefer english not for appeasing british. It's for our own knowledge. You people will never understand that unless you go to school.... Useless idiots go and keep on shouting jai shree ram.
In Tamil Nadu, there is no need for Hindi, because we are well versed in English. The Pani puri sellers and others from the North must learn to speak Tamil when they come to work in Tamil Nadu. It isn't very difficult after all. Look at actresses Kushbu, Simran and many others from the North. They are so fluent in Tamil. Tamil language is taught in government schools in Malaysia, Singapore, Canada and some states of Australia, Europe and the USA. Prime Minister Modi ji has acknowledged the value of Tamil language. It is the only Indian language that has official status in 4 countries outside India. Hence our preference for Tamil over Hindi. It is definitely better for all Indians to learn English and go global rather than be Hindi -educated and restricted within India.
@@karnraaat836 because English gives you a job and money Hindi does not. I can connect with a lot of people on the internet even beyond my country's border if I can speak English but Hindi is only limited to India + it has no benefits.
Pakistan lost Bangladesh just becoz it imposed Urdu on Bengali speaking people . Stop imposing anything , its not at all necessary !! Lets not waste time in dividing India . Federalism is the beauty of India . India is not communist country !!
Stop this whining about petrol diesel prices. The global prices have risen almost 10 times. And the 100% plus taxes on fuel is absolutely required to pay for police and military and so many other things that are run by the government. No one's denying the presence of some corruption. But considering that 95% of the country does not fall under the income tax bracket, it is even more essential to levy heavy taxes on fuel. And coming to the language row, the current government is committing a huge blunder with this hindi nonsense. Nothing good can come of this
@@ashokseshadri8331 so u think politicians will not divert public ,😂😂😂 common on ,if u have friend in any party IT wing ,go and ask he will tell how bad these politicians are ,if they want to divert an issue ,they will do any kind of stupidity ,u have to grow man ,politicians always ahead in folling us ,
@@praveenpinacle3753 Who's denying those tactics? That's politics. I'm talking about fuel prices specifically. Stop whining about it. If you're getting distracted by something that's obvious and whining about it you're the fool here. Not the general public
Oldest spoken language is Tamil. Can we make Tamil as national language? Yes we can if we make it mandatory for next 10 years, people will start speaking Tamil. Is it necessary? No. The fact today is none of the northern people can speak proper Tamil. Our own PM or HM can't even speak a proper one word in Tamil unlike otherwise from Tamil to Hindi. Today English is common language across globe. Let's keep English as spoken language and at the same time let every state promote their own regional language. When need be when a person moves from one state to another for various reason let he or she learn that language and to bridge the barrier, the common language English is always there to fill-in. By the way, the fact is Hindi is spoken only on UP and Delhi, rest all have their own regional language.
Most of Europeans thinking Indian people only speak Hindi. Once a Pakistani asked me ' kya bayya aapko Hindi kyun nahi aatha'. Then I Said bro I am from Andhra Pradesh, no one in my region speak Hindi, everyone speak in Telugu why would I learn Hindi, then he said it is your national language. Then I said to him it is only official language not national language. I will learn Hindi if I need it, right now I don't need to learn it. Better make Telugu as national language 🙂. దేశ భాషలందు తెలుగు లెస్స.
We are already in the middle of a tug o' war between Hindus and non-Hindus. We simply can't afford further conflicts between Hindi-speakers and non-Hindi speakers, between the north and the south. Unity in diversity is our motto. We cannot change it to 'Unity in uniformity.'
Hindi is not a national language.we won't accept Hindi impose in india.we support to sudeep sir 🙏👌👍👌👍 respect regional languages.kannada is our usooru.(kannada is our life) Ram from Bangalore.
@@ramchandran.g8805 That's my opinion as well. Language is a very sensitive issue. The Union Government shouldn't do anything to upset the delicate linguistic balance we are maintaining in the country.
The major difference btw Hindus and Muslims is that many Hindus believe in the philosophy of pantheism I.e "everything is God,-the tree is God ,the sun is God ,the moon is God, the snake is God, the monkey is God Muslims believe that "everything is God's G-O-D with an apostrophe 's' .Everything belongs to the one and the only unique eternal God,the snake belongs to God ,the monkey belongs to the God, the moon ,sun,sky ,Cow belongs to the God .The glorious Quran says "come to common terms as btw us and you".Which is the first term? "That we worship none but Allah",so let's come to common terms by analyzing the scriptures of Hindus and Muslims. UPANISHADS (chandogya upanishad chapter 6 sec 2 verse 1) "He is one only, without a second" 2.Shwetashvatara upanishad chapter 6 verse 9 'Of him there are neither parents nor lord' 3.chapter 4 verse 20 'his form cannot be seen,no one sees him with the eye" Bhagwat Gita most popular amongst all hindu scriptures 7.20 "those who are materialistic,they worship demigods I.e others as deities besides the true God 2. Bhagwat Gita 10:3 "He who knows me as the unborn,as beginningless,as the Supreme lord of the worlds" 3. YAJURVEDA chapter 32 verse3 "there is no image of him" 40:8 "he is image less and pure ,yet there are various other verses mentioned in different vedas ,e.g In rigveda book 6,hymn 45 ,verse 16 "praise him who is the matchless and alone Concept of God in islam ,the best and most concise definition of God is given (AL Quran 112:1-4 ) Say:He is Allah,the one and only;Allah,the Eternal,absolute;He begets not ,nor is he begotten;and there is non like him
நீங்கள் ஹிந்தியை திணிப்பது போல் நாங்களும் வட இந்தியாவில் சொன்னால் என்னவாகும், தமிழ், தெலுங்கு, மளையாளம், கன்னடம், இது நாங்கள் பேசும் மொழி உனக்கென்னடா பிரச்சனை
They need foreign education, weapons to defend the country, dresss, inventions, culture, eating on table, etc., As if ENGLISH is the only foreign. Tamil is an International language Singapore, Moritious, Srilanka, Malaysia etc., Make Tamil as National Language. None of the people studied in CBSE don't know Hindi, but they have certificates. Hindi speaking Percentage arrived is wrong. English is a 26 letter MAGIC, right or wrong easy to learn, speak, travel around world.....
tamil, malayalam, telugu, kannada, hindi all national language one india, 5 language national language in india , i respect indian culture indian mother languages
South actors like Mahesh babu, Prabhas, Allu Arjun, NTR, Ram charan, chiranjeevi e.t.c will understand and speak neighbour languages like Tamil, Malayalam, kannada and even Hindi but any bollywood actor can tell even a single dialogue of any south Indian language.
Being a doctor, our medicine literature is thought in English only. Not in hindhi, Tamil or kannada. Prioritise your children to learn the need of language(English) for vocation with love for their mother language. Yeah hindi is out.
I'm kannadiga...💯 I'm learning Telugu,tamil, English.. We are not accept Hindi 💯 I'm not learning Hindi I have not interested... you are hindi waste of time.
English is a world language where we can communicate any where in the world. So it a must language. What advantage hindi will give? How many languages a South Indians want to learn ? If someone is not want to learn hindi then why need to make it a mandatory language in schools? How may North Indians learn a south language apart from just saying "we are ready to learn" .. We don't want to impose any language on us. If someone want to learn by own interest let him learn.
@@deesanjupere we will learn hindi if we want to work in hindi belt. If the hindi speaking people find it difficult to survive in south belt without knowing local language its not our problem. Learning english coz technology is driven by english not hindi
So by your logic Crow should be our national bird cause they are more in number than peacock....... I know hindi because i had to study it compulsorily in school....if it was a choice it would definitely be different for many of us.....we would have spent the time in learning other better prominent useful language of our choice
We have our own mother tongue language if we want a link language to communicate with other states or other countries i choice English not Hindi even in my dreams
@@smitajain2k when u are narrow minded who can't learn any other language(especially South Indian) other than Hindi then it doesn't make any point. Stop imposing amd give equal importance to all languages in India. I am from Karnataka but my mother tongue is Telugu and my native is in Tamil Nadu but I choose Kannada cuz Karnataka gave me everything. Jai Karnataka Mate, Jai Hind.
We will become "USSI".... United States of South India" and we will be the richest .......All north indians come to south india like Hyderabad, Banglore and chennai for jobs......Most illiterates are in north india....our taxes are being spent in north india...... Its better to divide North vs South......South will prosper
I always learn which will benifit to me , whether it is technology or a language . No one can't dictate us what to learn I like to learn C ,Java ,python languages instead of put my efforts on Hindi
10:40, 'yes and we celebrated the diversity' this is what Jawaharlal Nehru said "The pathan and tamils were the two extreme examples:the others lie somewhere in between.All of them have their distinctive features,all of them have still more the distinguishing mark of India" _ The variety and Unity of India,from The Discovery of India,1946.(Unity in Diversity a motto adopted in many nations) we oppose only when imposed not against any language its freedom of choice.
Stop being a mouthpiece for the Central Govt. When Hindi speaking people go to live in non hindi speaking states they expect the locals to speak hindi instead of respecting them and learning the local language. Pure arrogance.
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 they are practically the same languages lol, Bengali, Hindi, Punjabi, Assamese, Mahrati and Gujurati are similar languages... easy to pick up and learn
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 probably never lol, I thought people of Kanakata understand Hindi, I was in the state for 2 days in 2014 and I managed with Hindi and English lol
If any one of the regional languages is made compulsory apart from their mother tongue up to XII level of education for a twelve or fifteen years continuously, then we can think of a national language.
Rahul, You are the only decent Anchor on Times Now. The other's are simply acting holier than thou on secularism but know that this only applies to Sanatana Dharma followers. Whether it is Self Loathing Hindus, practising muslims or missionaries on the show, they are all bigoted and communal.
That has already been sorted out in Article 343 of the Indian constitution which deals with link languages (Bridge languages, communicating languages or lingua franca(common language throughout the country)). It is Hindi Article 343 1A and English Article 343 1B. It is not mandatory to know both but highly advantageous. Either of the languages should be known to communicate between different provinces (States) and union territories of India. So Northern India follows Hindi. Southern India follow English as that link language. Period. End of the story. Not sure why this Amit Shah and BJP/RSS is creating a needless fuss about it. I guess they want everyone from Kashmir to Kanyakumari to know Hindi laden with Sanskrit not Urdu. Since it is a cultural issue RSS has jumped into the bandwagon. But I guess you should provide the liberty to people who do not want Hindi or uncomfortable with Hindi to let them speak whatever languages they are comfortable to speak in.
@@Uu12574 then what about racism we all face in name of regional language and bullies and all do u think these r not serious issues then just saving culture, not treating people nicely and ganging up because of regional language will take you nowhere. English is a bahana no one talks in English in Tamilnadu , it’s a big big lie. Otherwise who can stop someone for just learning an extra language hindi , jasa chalta hn wase hi chalega you need to speak Hindi only wen you come outside of state , no one iis imposing in the state .this clearly shows the hypocrisy. Let me tell you all people in south knows hindi they just act that they don’t know it’s a fact too.
The thing that most people do not understand is that National language does not means that who speak the language or how many people speaks that language but it means how many understands , , hindi is understood by more than 90% of indian population as compared to any other language of india , thats why it is National language , take we one example Telgu is undertood by a specific regieon outside that region even telgu people has to use hindi to talk to the others who can not Telgu . it does not matter how big or old is Telgu but it is not understood by only 30 to 40% of indina population not more than that , this ratio is exacktly the same with other languagaes , and once again Nation languge mean a langugae that the whole country UNDERSTAND not speak and that is Hindi
Rahul can be the most entertaining tv anchor with the regular candy in his mouth doing the magic if he conducts like this without any political leaning. Any left ,right or centre leaning media houses must be shamed
Hindi illa ,works for the Cow belt and that's just fine with everybody. Neither does the N E or Western India want this. There are more important things in this country like yhe state of the economy and unemployment.
All Bollywood actors works under Dawood Ibrahim and all north Indians follows Moghuls policies. Hindi is a Islamic language it's not a Indian language. Moghuls won't respect women northies too. No women safety in Moghuls time and now also NCR NATIONAL CRIME REGION Delhi, Gurugram, Noida. Always people having drugs dangerous pans, no humanity. That is northies.
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 oru mozhi a muzhu tanam a pesanum na yevalo kaalam kadandu varanam nu ungalukku puriyum nu nenekarein. minnadi naraiya per andha Samaskrutam a kathikataum aparama adha desiya mozhi aakalam. India le yevanukam yevalukum aarvam kadayadhu samaskrutam kathikarthuku.
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 Naan Hindi a kathikanum nu solla varale. Indha mozhi prachanai yerk mindiye niyamikka pattachu. Vev vera maanilam kudai pesanum na Hindi mattum Englsih irruku. Vadakku India Hindi a payan padhtardhu. Tech pakkam English payan padthardhu. Avalav dhaan vishayam e. Idhu veena andha Amit Shah kalapi vittadhu. English ku badla Hindi a payan padhtanum nu tu.
Sir in 10th textbook it is written Hindi is official language not national and if this it is declared then india will no longer be secular and diverse country. I think those who think Hindi is national language they should go and study 10th civics
Tamil is older than Sanskrit, all South Indian languages are Dravidian languages and don't have any link with Sanskrit. Sanskrit is almost now a dead language cuz of Hindi and we are not ready for that to happen to our language.
@@yatishv8063 Kili Kili language is older than all languages..Do you buy that argument?? There should be some sense in making any argument.. In which language Vedas, Upanishads, and Puranas were written?
ANY INDIAN WHO HAS TO PLAY A ROLE AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL HAS TO BE WELL VERSED IN HINDI. KAMARAJ LOST THE CHANCE TO BECOME A PM BECAUSE OF LACK OF KNOWLEDGE OF HINDI. GANDHI WAS NO A GREAT ORATOR IN HINDI BUT HE REALIZED THAT IF HE HAS TO TALK TO INDIANS HE HAS TO SPEAK IN HINDI. THE CHOICE IS YOURS.
You argument is valid if you want to be at the seat of power in the center. Here we are talking about imposing hindi in the different states especially TN, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra.
Everywhere in the World Counties are United because of their one Language Identity and of course Language is a parameter of Unity. We always have been fighting among each other because of Culture differences and more importantly different Languages that we speak. Todays Bharat needs only one Language to remain United or else we would again fight and get divided I am sure of that. Different Languages means different cultures, different opinion and different histories which would surely become a reason of Conflict in years to come and then fight for Independence from Bharat. Why Hindi? Well because Hindi is a direct Descendant from Sanskrit. Pure Hindi is a basic evolution of Sanskrit and that it keeps Sanskrit alive. Other languages might be also children of Sanskrit but they are difficult to be spoken and represent a culture sect. While Hindi doesn't represent a culture sect but represent the Philosophy of Bharat Varsh and is like the eldest Child of Sanskrit. Pure Hindi should surely become the National Language of Bharat because it would help to keep Bharat United for years to come and stop the unstoppable division of this country again due to so many languages and culture divisions.
"Different Languages means different cultures, different opinion and different histories which would surely become a reason of Conflict in years to come and then fight for Independence from Bharat" You really think forcing people to learn a language because of majority will unite India and everyone should just forget their lingual identity? Whatever the reason is, every single person in this country should have the right to choose which language to converse in. You guys are just making this a larger issue than what it is.
Practically majority of India uses Hindi as a link language, I have noticed this outside India as well like in countries like Bhutan, Nepal. How many people can speak and understand English in India as compared to Hindi? Hindi is the most spoken and understood language around India, so practically it has to be linked language or you can say as a national language, this will only help us in our unity.
Pakistani's also understand Hindi that's why they got to know every moment in India. Hindi is a language and it is influenced by Islamic countries and culture. Moghuls brought Hindi to India not Gandhi or modi. People know how Moghuls are cruel. They destroyed north Indian temples, architectures, libraries, culture then replaced their culture. Now north Indians following Moghuls culture. Crime is more, no women safety, all time chewing pan, jarda, Drugs what not everything.
I don't understand why people debate about this. I'm from South India and I don't think there is any problem with Hindi. Of course we should respect every culture and language but it doesn't mean to disregard Hindi. In most of the countries they have two official languages, that's the same with India we have two official languages- English and Hindi. Also Hindi is spoken comparatively by majority of people and in majority of areas. And we should proud about the fact that MANY FOREIGNERS STUDY HINDI and when Chinese is also spoken and learnt by many people like English, Hindi is also (although not prevalent as Chinese) respected to that extent. In India, we can't consider every Indian language as official language as we have so many languages in our country and it's diverse. Hindi is the best choice for this, Sanskrit and Hindi has route in our history and culture also. It's shame to see that Indians are arguing each other in this issue when foreigners are learning Hindi. I'm a South Indian and I know in South India, most people think INABILITY TO SPEAK IN ENGLISH as unknowledgeable or uneducated and Inability to speak Hindi is not an issue at all. We should either think inability to speak both languages ( English and Hindi) as nothing wrong or either think inability in both as unknowledgeable.
I am from another country ,really surprised to see you all even debating this issue by having the most oldest precious language TAMIL origin from India 🤣🤣...No other country in this world got that pride you fools..
Where is South Bangalore MP? What stand is yours? It is high time that you need to carry the voice of your region you represent. You need to be straightforward, bold, frank, come out, show your guts and be outspoken and be candid in your opinions. You just can't hide and participate in West Bengal issues and forget and ignore core issues of regional concerns. Escapism shall not be excused. Not only opposition, even we, the public, oppose Hindi. Instead, we prefer English. Doesn't matter even if it is a foreign language. Just because BJP leaders don’t understand or they are poor in English, they can’t push Hindi. We south Indians are not comfortable in Hindi, because southern regional languages do not resemble Hindi. Imposing is totally wrong and a sin. Hindi is also a regional language, so is every other regional language. It is just that many of the north Indian languages resemble Hindi language. We can’t make one regional language a national language and ignore the rest. We need to embrace all languages equally. It is nonsense to have a national language in India. India is unique, unlike than other nations. The nation urges to leave it as it is. Who have asked for it? Leave it as it is, it is perfectly fine now. What are the BJP leaders trying to achieve? Is it that BJP leaders want to push any of their personal agenda? We have elected BJP to perform on greater agendas. We have better things to worry about. This whole initiative is unnecessary and not called for. We need not waste our precious time and energy with this stupid idea. As many of the north Indian languages, more or less, resemble Hindi language, it is easier for them to catch-up, learn and possess command over the language. For rest of all south Indians it shall be like an extra language to learn from scratch and shall struggle to have command over language. This unequal status of command over the language shall be unfair while a communication takes place between a north Indian and a south Indian. Instead, to be fair, Sanskrit can be made as a national language, so that everybody in the nation will have to learn a new neutral language with all its fairness. Already 100’s of languages are dying in the world every day. Home minister is trying to kill regional languages of India. What nonsense is he up to? Doesn’t he have any other business? He is promoting majoritarianism and damaging India's pluralism. India is unity in diversity. Seriously, it is idiotic and doesn’t this home minister have any other better business? Ask him to focus on other better matters and leave the languages as they are.
Official language is not the same as National language. After independence English in India was the official language. English was never accepted as national language and Hindi is not the national language of India, as per any section of Indian constitution. India does not need one national language and is not the same as having national flag, national anthem etc. which are in the nature of distinctly identifying and unifying aspects of the nation and it's citizens. Example is Pakistan which had to eventually disintgrate when language became one of the key issues by strong opposition to the implementation of urdu. Vasudeva Kutumbakam! Vandematram!! Jai Hind!!!
Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics': (1) Based on discrimination: The attempt from any Indian national Government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, everyone gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages. (2) Based on practicality: Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is just for entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on UA-cam entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English. (3) Based on uniqueness: If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi. (4) Based on imposition: After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'. (5) Based on the two v/s three language formula: The two-language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language. (6) Based on the existing concept of India: Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality. (7) Based on statistics: Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. Also, why is the taxpayer's money spent more on the promotion of Hindi and less or negligible for other non-Hindi languages? 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0; why? This is an utter disgrace! (8) Based on pride and politics: Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave diplomatically two-faced as some kind of an illogical balance in the policy of appeasement for vote bank politics. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional. (9) Based on nationalism: India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by a single language when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to somehow economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have started to aggressively teach their citizens English. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back. (10) Based on globalization: Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The English people are called 'gentlemen' for a reason - although colonial they were not as racist as Germans. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more leading to an increase in the demand for globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.
The ruckus made my social media should be initially put to an end. This is an unnecessary debate , there are other social issues to be addressed such as poverty and unemployment. When you can't find a solution for such issues how come hindi becomes a national issue. Language is just tool for communication. But when in a democratic country like India, is trying to impose it on people this is not advisable. There is no need of a national language in our country.
First, its not Hindi film industry. It's Hindustani film industry. We need Roman characters because thelanguage used is not Hindi. It is Hindustani (a mix of Hindi and Urdu). Words like khamoshi, tehzeeb, mazhab, dil, sanam, mehsoos, intezaar, inam, azaad, lofzo, istemaal, wadiyo, intehaan and musaafir are all used in Bollywood. It's a shame to call it Hindi film industry. Even Pakistanis can watch Bollywood films. In fact, Bollywood has a large fan-following in Pakistan because most Pakistanis can understand Bollywood.
That is true not only of movies but also of the common people in the Hindi belt (Delhi, NCR, UP, MP, Bihar, Jharkhand etc.). Their Hindi is laden with Urdu words. So if at all there comes a whip to learn Samaskrutam (Sanskrit). I think there will be an unrest in these parts than Southern India (Exception might be Tamilnadu).
LoL these Bollywood actors don't even know that the Indian National Anthem was first written in "BENGALI" not Hindi 🙄
Ajay devgan made a fool of himself, ultimate moron🤣
South Indians (Tamil/Telugu/Kannada/Malayalam) make Pan India movies. Ajay Devgan makes Pan Parag advertisement. By the way, he shouldn't have opted South scripts like Singham, Kaidhi, Drishyam etc.... We support Sudeep sir from Tamilnadu..🙏
You should not have opted 3 idiots, kahaani, oh my god and lots of 90's movies of big b
@@53manaskumardas6 and u shldnt have opted to show thise movies to south indians rather enjoy it in hindi belt oly😊
I don't support both of them both enterpreneted in wrong way 😂😂😂
Same like you borrows script from South Koreans.
@tarunbhadana2722 wtf you guys just blabber😂
India should follow the European Union model to respect every member State language & culture. In India everything is politics. That's why the most deserving Candidate Kamal Haasan didn't get Dada Saheb Balke award yet. Kamal Haasan's only fault is that he is born in South India. This is prejudice.
Why the heck we need to follow? Have you lost your mind?
@@flawless_papaya why I don’t think it’s a bad idea at all.
@@flawless_papaya
I too feel it would be be better if we are a union of independent states or at least a true federation like the US. In the present scenario, the states that do well have to part with their revenue to support the weak states. The states that control population lose their political bargaining power. A southern politician has to work twice as hard to become the PM. For someone in Kanyakumari, reaching the National Capital is tougher than visiting a foreign country. The faultlines in the Northern polity and society are affecting the harmonious existence in the south. All in all, we must give more autonomy to the states if we want to progress.
That is very vaoid point. There is ahuge bias towrds south indian states
yes thats what you south indians have been doing since few hundred years. follow the mughals afghans nizams and then follow the colonials. nothing of your own. well even your English accent sucks.
Learning hindi for a gujarati or punjabi is easier than for a malayali or tamilian. If somebody wants to speak hindi, it should be a matter of choice. The problem starts when it becomes mandatory in schools and colleges or for competitive exams. Let there be two main languages. There is no need of national language in a multilingual nation.
Hindi js already mandatory in south indian states for students from 5th upto 10th standard. But no mandatory learning of any other india lnguages let alone a south indian languages in hindi related states. Hindi speaking states themselves think hindi as a second class language amd send their vhildren to enhlish medijm schools.
@@TheMalllu No not mandatory...
@@TheMalllu hindi should not be mandatory
mother tongue and english is enough
Even as a kannadiga if i speak Hindi with my Hardcore hindi brothers then they start laughing at my accent and struggle to speak Hindi, which by itself is demotivating to speak with these Hindi speaking guys. These guys live in Karnataka for more than 5 years but cannot even take a shot at speaking even bit of Kannada such a shame on these Hindi speaking guys and make fun of us trying to speak Hindi.
We are happy with our Mother tongue and our identity and English as a link language. Please do not enforce Hindi on us and make us feel second class citizen in my own country.
Also these weird North Indians who come to South and pretend that everyone speaks Hindi such a shame and ignorance...
So why study in English then ?? A language of a different continent is given more importance then your own next state language
Let us make india into 2 counties south and north. We South Indians can happily speak our languages and we can become richest country in Asia 😉🤣😎
There West India too. We don't comes in North belt at all.
Actually north is the mixed race so they create problems I suppose .. rest of India is more civilized
Who is asking you leave your language??
The United States of South India 😌
Sometime even i feel same bro...these people are imposing Hindi on us.. But they dont know Our South Regional languages...
The day Hindi become National language, it will break. It will not remain as one nation. We don't need one nation and one language
So govt should declare English as national language 😂😂😂 according to you
@@noconversionpage8466 India does not need a national language and cannot have one. Because each state is linguistically different. It needs a link language and an official language when dealing with interstate affairs , English is the language of modern science and world link language, so we should go with English
@@aandy450 then lol there is no scientific language 😂😂 first understand that and India absolutely need a national language currently English is national language but not declare by govt if people oppose Hindi imposition why they don't oppose English imposition 😂😂😂
I'll burn Hindi around me
@@noconversionpage8466 no we don't need any national language. Why we need one language with such diverse nation can our Bollywood actors can tell let's not talk Marathi in Mumbai only talk Hindi? Every one will be kicked out
Hindi is also a regional language spoken by few states. It's our choice to decide what we want to talk or learn, outsiders cannot dictate us just like we cannot dictate them to speak Kannada or Telugu.
Bhonsadi tell me those few state name
+1
nobody is dictating you, even your fellow ppl can speak or understand some forms of hindi but your ego is denying that. you can keep your language's pride even if you use some forms of hindi to communicate with rest of India.
@@buntyskb Your cunningness is denying that you are imposing Hindi on Non Hindi states to make us 2nd class citizens. Though 73% of people are Chinese in Singapore still the founding father Lee Kuan Yew made English as the official language of Singapore to create a equal platform for all ethnicity in Singapore. This is the True Democracy & show of statesmanship. Do not impose your language on us for Your benefit. Follow the Singapore Model.
@@kovalant6400 okay using Hindi as link language is imposing but using English is not?? is English your mother tongue? did it originate here in India??? you south indians are egoistic bunch who would love to be colonial slaves rather than speak a few hindi words to communicate with ppl of other states.
Hindi was brought into existence during the Mughal Rule. South Indian languages are far more ancient. Specially Tamil which is recognised as the oldest language in the world. So I don't understand what Cancer promoter is talking about.
Urdu is tulukkans language n hindi spoken these days have borrowed many words from urdu. 😊
Hey, I respect you and Tamil culture. I have keen interest in southern culture too. But the oldest known Language is Sanskrit, not Tamil.
@@k-popdistribution2392 Nope. There are clear evidences for Tamil being several thousands of years older than sanskrit. I'm a Tamil Brahmin. My supposed ancestors brought sanskrit to South India. But there's no doubt Tamil is much much older than sanskrit. There are undeniable evidences throughout the world
@@ashokseshadri8331 any evidence you can tell?
@@k-popdistribution2392 Google it your majesty. I cannot dig up the earth and get you everything. What are you? A king?
Due to south languages English flourished as a link language in the south. Because of this people can find good paying jobs abroad and be updated with the world. Tell me who’s offering jobs in the Hindi belt? Rather the North Indians should learn south languages when they are looking for jobs in places like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Chennai, Trivandrum and Goa. As simple.
Add western states also Maharashtra n Gujarat
@@RS-zh1vc Marathi n Gujarati in that case
@@RS-zh1vc above vindyas ranges central asian rulers rape culture
Pakistani's also understand Hindi that's why they got to know every moment in India. Hindi is a language and it is influenced by Islamic countries and culture. Moghuls brought Hindi to India not Gandhi or modi. People know how Moghuls are cruel. They destroyed north Indian temples, architectures, libraries, culture then replaced their culture. Now north Indians following Moghuls culture. Crime is more, no women safety, all time chewing pan, jarda, Drugs what not everything.
Facts 🤔🤔🤔
U put ur shetty in ur name back Nd don't talk about hindu
Hindi and Urdu sounds similar when I see the neighbouring country speak Urdu and I'm confused if it's Hindi or urdu
Lol
@@rag12307 it's almost the same language.
I can’t fathom about the stupidity of people who associate Hindi to India those who speak hindi are Indian and patriotic and those who don’t aren’t!….such great points by Kasthuri, I am not sure why is it even a debate about this.
Why does India need a national language...!!!!! Unity in diversity... Many languages one country that's our Bharata 💪
It's impossible there is always a link language currently English is national language but not declare by govt 😂😂😂😂
I traveled to Nepal. Everybody speaks fluent Hindi over there. They don't even understand English.
@@ahmedzakikhan7639 u should stay in Nepal if u love Hindi
@@ahmedzakikhan7639 tomo they will announce Hinduism as the national religion will you accept? Stup!d Ahmed.
@@ahmedzakikhan7639 English is the most spoken language in India. English should be out national language
In Maharashtra,for many years cbse schools didn't let their students learn Marathi.
Let that sink in.
Hindi is a regional language of Northern part of India, Indian government is also run by Non Hindi speaking tax payers money.
Idiot first thing first you have no Idea about this country.. Delhi is the only city which speaks Hindi
Well said .very true....
Run and also delhi useless departments like environment etc full above vindyas ranges people
Tax and non tax paying sorry i fall of the floor laughing out loud fucker
In Maharashtra, Marathi and English are just enough for us.
what i oppose is when North Indians come to South India even after staying for years like a decade.. they don't make an effort to speak one word in the local language
Very true. And they do goondaism and ask us to speak in Hindi as if we are in their state. If they are staying in Karnataka, using our water, our land food then what is the harm in learning kannada? Make kannada national language.
@@smitajain2k some times brain goes for a walk.. South Indians don't talk in their mother tongue to usa persons.. no body is saying North or East Indians should not talk in Hindi but they don't learn the South Indian language.. a kannada person does not talk in Kannada in Uttar Pradesh like even on day one he starts staying there..
@@smitajain2k if you're in Karnataka you must learn Kannada period!
@@smitajain2k brain is going for a walk here is it not.. and yes there is ego that stays.. is it not..
North Indians will learn English to go to Canada.. they will strive hard to clear the ielts.. they will work hard to learn French to settle in Quebec.. they will be able to pronounce Chinese words properly.. but staying in Bangalore for 10 years they can't even say a few words in Kannada.. Even to a village guy.. and if the village guy does not answer in Hindi, the North Indians will call him bc,mc gawar etc.. i have witnessed this .
So if you have the ego to not learn South Indian language staying in South India.. You bet i will have the ego to not speak Hindi staying in South India..
Compremendo?
@@smitajain2k And by Avoiding english language the whole north india has progressed very well. Idiots.. All hindi speaking States because are the most backward and undeveloped States. Most of the communal riots and crime against women happen in hindi belt. Because you people are uneducated. We prefer english not for appeasing british. It's for our own knowledge. You people will never understand that unless you go to school.... Useless idiots go and keep on shouting jai shree ram.
In Tamil Nadu, there is no need for Hindi, because we are well versed in English. The Pani puri sellers and others from the North must learn to speak Tamil when they come to work in Tamil Nadu. It isn't very difficult after all. Look at actresses Kushbu, Simran and many others from the North. They are so fluent in Tamil. Tamil language is taught in government schools in Malaysia, Singapore, Canada and some states of Australia, Europe and the USA. Prime Minister Modi ji has acknowledged the value of Tamil language. It is the only Indian language that has official status in 4 countries outside India. Hence our preference for Tamil over Hindi. It is definitely better for all Indians to learn English and go global rather than be Hindi -educated and restricted within India.
English is universal language and it must prioritize. Without English nothing will happen
If Hindi is imposed south will lead towards separation. We have to be united India.
Yes
So why English over hindi ?? It's like all states want there state person to be the pm so we are telling queen of England to be the head
@@karnraaat836 if Hindi is sufficient why are we learning English? Why we SI have to learn more languages?
@@ranjithmoovarasu1808 exactly hindi in sufficient all languages will be learned in hindi not a foreign language like English
@@karnraaat836 because English gives you a job and money Hindi does not. I can connect with a lot of people on the internet even beyond my country's border if I can speak English but Hindi is only limited to India + it has no benefits.
Pakistan lost Bangladesh just becoz it imposed Urdu on Bengali speaking people .
Stop imposing anything , its not at all necessary !! Lets not waste time in dividing India .
Federalism is the beauty of India . India is not communist country !!
Sudeep is right why should Hindi be national language..... its just one among all other Indian languages......
Now we all forget petrol diesel price😂😂guys politicians are very much wiser than us
Stop this whining about petrol diesel prices. The global prices have risen almost 10 times. And the 100% plus taxes on fuel is absolutely required to pay for police and military and so many other things that are run by the government. No one's denying the presence of some corruption. But considering that 95% of the country does not fall under the income tax bracket, it is even more essential to levy heavy taxes on fuel.
And coming to the language row, the current government is committing a huge blunder with this hindi nonsense. Nothing good can come of this
@@ashokseshadri8331 so u think politicians will not divert public ,😂😂😂 common on ,if u have friend in any party IT wing ,go and ask he will tell how bad these politicians are ,if they want to divert an issue ,they will do any kind of stupidity ,u have to grow man ,politicians always ahead in folling us ,
@@praveenpinacle3753 Who's denying those tactics? That's politics. I'm talking about fuel prices specifically. Stop whining about it. If you're getting distracted by something that's obvious and whining about it you're the fool here. Not the general public
Oldest spoken language is Tamil. Can we make Tamil as national language? Yes we can if we make it mandatory for next 10 years, people will start speaking Tamil. Is it necessary? No. The fact today is none of the northern people can speak proper Tamil. Our own PM or HM can't even speak a proper one word in Tamil unlike otherwise from Tamil to Hindi. Today English is common language across globe. Let's keep English as spoken language and at the same time let every state promote their own regional language. When need be when a person moves from one state to another for various reason let he or she learn that language and to bridge the barrier, the common language English is always there to fill-in. By the way, the fact is Hindi is spoken only on UP and Delhi, rest all have their own regional language.
Most of Europeans thinking Indian people only speak Hindi. Once a Pakistani asked me ' kya bayya aapko Hindi kyun nahi aatha'. Then I Said bro I am from Andhra Pradesh, no one in my region speak Hindi, everyone speak in Telugu why would I learn Hindi, then he said it is your national language. Then I said to him it is only official language not national language. I will learn Hindi if I need it, right now I don't need to learn it. Better make Telugu as national language 🙂. దేశ భాషలందు తెలుగు లెస్స.
Hindi is just one of the 22 languages... nothing more, nothing less. Shameless BJP neither have common sense nor sense of constitution.
We are already in the middle of a tug o' war between Hindus and non-Hindus. We simply can't afford further conflicts between Hindi-speakers and non-Hindi speakers, between the north and the south. Unity in diversity is our motto. We cannot change it to 'Unity in uniformity.'
Hindi is not a national language.we won't accept Hindi impose in india.we support to sudeep sir 🙏👌👍👌👍 respect regional languages.kannada is our usooru.(kannada is our life) Ram from Bangalore.
@@ramchandran.g8805
That's my opinion as well. Language is a very sensitive issue. The Union Government shouldn't do anything to upset the delicate linguistic balance we are maintaining in the country.
I'm a malayalee living in TN and i want telegu as a second language in kerala
The major difference btw Hindus and Muslims is that many Hindus believe in the philosophy of pantheism I.e "everything is God,-the tree is God ,the sun is God ,the moon is God, the snake is God, the monkey is God
Muslims believe that "everything is God's G-O-D with an apostrophe 's' .Everything belongs to the one and the only unique eternal God,the snake belongs to God ,the monkey belongs to the God, the moon ,sun,sky ,Cow belongs to the God .The glorious Quran says "come to common terms as btw us and you".Which is the first term? "That we worship none but Allah",so let's come to common terms by analyzing the scriptures of Hindus and Muslims.
UPANISHADS (chandogya upanishad chapter 6 sec 2 verse 1) "He is one only, without a second" 2.Shwetashvatara upanishad chapter 6 verse 9 'Of him there are neither parents nor lord' 3.chapter 4 verse 20 'his form cannot be seen,no one sees him with the eye"
Bhagwat Gita most popular amongst all hindu scriptures 7.20 "those who are materialistic,they worship demigods I.e others as deities besides the true God 2. Bhagwat Gita 10:3 "He who knows me as the unborn,as beginningless,as the Supreme lord of the worlds"
3. YAJURVEDA chapter 32 verse3 "there is no image of him" 40:8 "he is image less and pure ,yet there are various other verses mentioned in different vedas ,e.g In rigveda book 6,hymn 45 ,verse 16 "praise him who is the matchless and alone
Concept of God in islam ,the best and most concise definition of God is given (AL Quran 112:1-4 )
Say:He is Allah,the one and only;Allah,the Eternal,absolute;He begets not ,nor is he begotten;and there is non like him
Yah its more dangerous than Hindu Muslim fight😅
நீங்கள் ஹிந்தியை திணிப்பது போல் நாங்களும் வட இந்தியாவில் சொன்னால் என்னவாகும், தமிழ், தெலுங்கு, மளையாளம், கன்னடம், இது நாங்கள் பேசும் மொழி உனக்கென்னடா பிரச்சனை
Very true. Iva yaar?
Third language?
3 language formula implemented in North? Bollywood is not nation.
North Indian learn South Indian language as 3rd language?
They need foreign education, weapons to defend the country, dresss, inventions, culture, eating on table, etc., As if ENGLISH is the only foreign. Tamil is an International language Singapore, Moritious, Srilanka, Malaysia etc., Make Tamil as National Language. None of the people studied in CBSE don't know Hindi, but they have certificates. Hindi speaking Percentage arrived is wrong. English is a 26 letter MAGIC, right or wrong easy to learn, speak, travel around world.....
India is probably the only country in the world where people constantly talk about North & South India as though they're two seperate countries.....
tamil, malayalam, telugu, kannada, hindi all national language one india, 5 language national language in india , i respect indian culture indian mother languages
22
Tamil as national language.. wht a joke 😂😂😂
@@manya_575 Hindi is big joke.......
@@manya_575 What are the 22 national languages of India?
1) Assamese, (2) Bengali, (3) Gujarati, (4) Hindi, (5) Kannada, (6) Kashmiri, (7) Konkani, (8) Malayalam, (9) Manipuri, (10) Marathi, (11) Nepali, (12) Oriya, (13) Punjabi, (14) Sanskrit, (15) Sindhi, (16) Tamil, (17) Telugu, (18) Urdu (19) Bodo, (20) Santhali, (21) Maithili and (22) Dogri.
@@acco1646 these are official language not national language
Someone should correct RSS. The language is Kannada NOT Kannadiga.
LOL. Such a blunder is not pardonable when your grandfather is a Kannadiga.
Punjab will not remain part of india if Hindi imposition take place. We will not lose our culture.
First time seeing a Punjabi fighting for their language
I thought you guys speak Hindi
@@lilstar3705 Actually Hindi is not mother tongue of any North Indian state. We have just accepted it as a common and connecting language.
Same goes for West Bengal
I love hearing Punjabi language.
Good pls divide north and south not able to tolerate all these pani Puris from north
LoL
South actors like Mahesh babu, Prabhas, Allu Arjun, NTR, Ram charan, chiranjeevi e.t.c will understand and speak neighbour languages like Tamil, Malayalam, kannada and even Hindi but any bollywood actor can tell even a single dialogue of any south Indian language.
Being a doctor, our medicine literature is thought in English only. Not in hindhi, Tamil or kannada. Prioritise your children to learn the need of language(English) for vocation with love for their mother language. Yeah hindi is out.
Hindi is, was & will be a national language
Which nation? Imagination of northies 😂😂😂
English cannot be replaced by any politicians on earth an open challenge to those politicians who think they can remove English
I'm kannadiga...💯
I'm learning Telugu,tamil, English..
We are not accept Hindi 💯
I'm not learning Hindi I have not interested... you are hindi waste of time.
In bollywood 99.999 percent language spoken is urdu , the smart guys of bollywood to maintain their identity give stress to Hindi.
Every songs sounds like urdu songs
For the past 70+ years South Indians were imposed to learn HIndi. This is the reason 40% speaks Hindi now.
You guys are ok to learn English but not hindi?
English is a world language where we can communicate any where in the world. So it a must language. What advantage hindi will give? How many languages a South Indians want to learn ? If someone is not want to learn hindi then why need to make it a mandatory language in schools? How may North Indians learn a south language apart from just saying "we are ready to learn" .. We don't want to impose any language on us. If someone want to learn by own interest let him learn.
@@deesanjupere we will learn hindi if we want to work in hindi belt. If the hindi speaking people find it difficult to survive in south belt without knowing local language its not our problem.
Learning english coz technology is driven by english not hindi
@@deesanjupere Why you guys dont learn Tamil, kannada, telugu, malayalam??
@@deesanjupere you guys are ok to learn English but not Tamil,Telugu,Kannada,malayalam,Manipuri,kashmiri??
So by your logic Crow should be our national bird cause they are more in number than peacock.......
I know hindi because i had to study it compulsorily in school....if it was a choice it would definitely be different for many of us.....we would have spent the time in learning other better prominent useful language of our choice
We have our own mother tongue language if we want a link language to communicate with other states or other countries i choice English not Hindi even in my dreams
@@smitajain2k yes we don't want your Hindi... Keep it in your Bimaru states
@@smitajain2k when u are narrow minded who can't learn any other language(especially South Indian) other than Hindi then it doesn't make any point.
Stop imposing amd give equal importance to all languages in India.
I am from Karnataka but my mother tongue is Telugu and my native is in Tamil Nadu but I choose Kannada cuz Karnataka gave me everything.
Jai Karnataka Mate, Jai Hind.
Make kannada, as National Language.
Why we should learn your language, you learn our language.
Hindi is not the national language of India from Kerala കേരള,
The funny part is that hindi actors themselves don't talk in hindi, south indian actors speak much more hindi than hindi actors.
Hindi Will Never be a National Language
We will become "USSI".... United States of South India" and we will be the richest .......All north indians come to south india like Hyderabad, Banglore and chennai for jobs......Most illiterates are in north india....our taxes are being spent in north india...... Its better to divide North vs South......South will prosper
Hindi imposition is a curse on India. Hindi should be removed from all non-Hindi states.
Surprisingly... Marvadis, rajstanis, haryana people, biharis in North India registered their mother-toungue as Hindi.. god save the languages..
I always learn which will benifit to me , whether it is technology or a language . No one can't dictate us what to learn
I like to learn C ,Java ,python languages instead of put my efforts on Hindi
Proud malayali speaks in English for Hindi.real embarrassment to malayali Rahul easwar.
Rahul easwar thinks with his mouth.
English should be the main language of communication for all
I agree.. Any South Indian language is ok for me...
10:40, 'yes and we celebrated the diversity' this is what Jawaharlal Nehru said "The pathan and tamils were the two extreme examples:the others lie somewhere in between.All of them have their distinctive features,all of them have still more the distinguishing mark of India" _ The variety and Unity of India,from The Discovery of India,1946.(Unity in Diversity a motto adopted in many nations)
we oppose only when imposed not against any language its freedom of choice.
Stop being a mouthpiece for the Central Govt. When Hindi speaking people go to live in non hindi speaking states they expect the locals to speak hindi instead of respecting them and learning the local language. Pure arrogance.
I speak Hindi in West Bengal,Tripura and Assam and the locals understand me
@@das8713 you should be learning the local language is your stay in that state for more than 5 years
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 they are practically the same languages lol, Bengali, Hindi, Punjabi, Assamese, Mahrati and Gujurati are similar languages... easy to pick up and learn
@@das8713so when you plan to stay in say Karnataka.. learn kannada
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 probably never lol, I thought people of Kanakata understand Hindi, I was in the state for 2 days in 2014 and I managed with Hindi and English lol
Then why are you babbling in British language??? Sanskrit should be the national language of India'
Hindi is the national language of his imagination.
Doctors and engineers if they study in hindi they have to work in just few states and doubt any private corporate hospital would employ them
If any one of the regional languages is made compulsory apart from their mother tongue up to XII level of education for a twelve or fifteen years continuously, then we can think of a national language.
Unfair.
@@gautamghosh7088
Yes, the idea of a national language, at this stage looks unfair to many...
@@AshokKumar-cz5vl Remain unfair for ever.
Rahul Eeshwar is just a mouthpiece of bjp. Don't know why he ended up representing Kerala
Rahul,
You are the only decent Anchor on Times Now.
The other's are simply acting holier than thou on secularism but know that this only applies to Sanatana Dharma followers.
Whether it is Self Loathing Hindus, practising muslims or missionaries on the show, they are all bigoted and communal.
The anchor is run away kid from kashmir.
😂.
Didnot fight back.
Art of "selling an idea" does not seem to be a virtue of the Hindikaris.
There should be no national language in a country of multiple languages but we definitely need a common spoken language around the nation.
That has already been sorted out in Article 343 of the Indian constitution which deals with link languages (Bridge languages, communicating languages or lingua franca(common language throughout the country)). It is Hindi Article 343 1A and English Article 343 1B. It is not mandatory to know both but highly advantageous. Either of the languages should be known to communicate between different provinces (States) and union territories of India.
So Northern India follows Hindi. Southern India follow English as that link language. Period. End of the story. Not sure why this Amit Shah and BJP/RSS is creating a needless fuss about it. I guess they want everyone from Kashmir to Kanyakumari to know Hindi laden with Sanskrit not Urdu. Since it is a cultural issue RSS has jumped into the bandwagon. But I guess you should provide the liberty to people who do not want Hindi or uncomfortable with Hindi to let them speak whatever languages they are comfortable to speak in.
LEARNING ONE MORE LANGUAGE CAN NOT BE A BURDEN FOR ANYONE.
yes please learn kannada
learn Kannada then
Learn kannada or Tamil or Telugu or Malayalam Mera beta 😂
@@Uu12574 come up with 1 single language for the whole of south india then we will talk.
@@Uu12574 then what about racism we all face in name of regional language and bullies and all do u think these r not serious issues then just saving culture, not treating people nicely and ganging up because of regional language will take you nowhere. English is a bahana no one talks in English in Tamilnadu , it’s a big big lie. Otherwise who can stop someone for just learning an extra language hindi , jasa chalta hn wase hi chalega you need to speak Hindi only wen you come outside of state , no one iis imposing in the state .this clearly shows the hypocrisy. Let me tell you all people in south knows hindi they just act that they don’t know it’s a fact too.
Mohandas Pai Sir totally agree on your comments
No. Hindi should not be imposed on the rest of the country.
Hindi can’t never be a national language.
Boss even i know hindi ....to speak and write but i disagree hindi to be national language.
English must be national language
Mentally u r still slave
Hindi is Indias a national language .....
@@ritz6172 who said that.....Tamil Nadu never agreed it.
As an Indian i will accept english as link language
The thing that most people do not understand is that National language does not means that who speak the language or how many people speaks that language but it means how many understands , , hindi is understood by more than 90% of indian population as compared to any other language of india , thats why it is National language , take we one example Telgu is undertood by a specific regieon outside that region even telgu people has to use hindi to talk to the others who can not Telgu . it does not matter how big or old is Telgu but it is not understood by only 30 to 40% of indina population not more than that , this ratio is exacktly the same with other languagaes , and once again Nation languge mean a langugae that the whole country UNDERSTAND not speak and that is Hindi
Even dogs are more than tigers then why it cannot be national animal dont play this majority game with us.
Tamil is very classical language and and it has all the speciality of grammar, great literature.... LEARN TAMIL to move forward....
Rahul can be the most entertaining tv anchor with the regular candy in his mouth doing the magic if he conducts like this without any political leaning.
Any left ,right or centre leaning media houses must be shamed
I want to challenge Kajol to speak one sentence in pure Hindi. Or show me one interview where she completed a full sentence in Hindi.
😆😄😆😄😆😄
Tamilnadu is the only state that never use Hindi in official purposes.
Then kannada must be national language. Learn kannada
Hindi illa ,works for the Cow belt and that's just fine with everybody. Neither does the N E or Western India want this. There are more important things in this country like yhe state of the economy and unemployment.
No need hindi as a national language
Hindi is Indias a national language ...............
@@ritz6172 Keep it with yourself
@@ritz6172 😂 Kannada is India's national language.
All Bollywood actors works under Dawood Ibrahim and all north Indians follows Moghuls policies. Hindi is a Islamic language it's not a Indian language. Moghuls won't respect women northies too. No women safety in Moghuls time and now also NCR NATIONAL CRIME REGION Delhi, Gurugram, Noida. Always people having drugs dangerous pans, no humanity. That is northies.
Declare Sanskrit as National language
Not even 2% of the population know Sanskrit. How can you make it as a national language??
@@RaviKumar-ii6cb that is why we need Sanskrit..b the only way India will retain its culture
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 oru mozhi a muzhu tanam a pesanum na yevalo kaalam kadandu varanam nu ungalukku puriyum nu nenekarein. minnadi naraiya per andha Samaskrutam a kathikataum aparama adha desiya mozhi aakalam. India le yevanukam yevalukum aarvam kadayadhu samaskrutam kathikarthuku.
@@RaviKumar-ii6cb ippa Hindi yean kathukunum.. Hindi vandu 90 percent Urdu.. Nan Urdu kathukkardukku virubala
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 Naan Hindi a kathikanum nu solla varale. Indha mozhi prachanai yerk mindiye niyamikka pattachu. Vev vera maanilam kudai pesanum na Hindi mattum Englsih irruku. Vadakku India Hindi a payan padhtardhu. Tech pakkam English payan padthardhu. Avalav dhaan vishayam e. Idhu veena andha Amit Shah kalapi vittadhu. English ku badla Hindi a payan padhtanum nu tu.
Sir in 10th textbook it is written Hindi is official language not national and if this it is declared then india will no longer be secular and diverse country. I think those who think Hindi is national language they should go and study 10th civics
It is better to make Sankrit as National Language and should be made as mandatory..
@Chachu P FYI: Sanskrit is mother of all languages in this world..The same language is basis for our vedas, upanishads, puranas etc.,
@Chachu P Vedas were written in Tamil?
@Chachu P
That's not the question asked..Iam asking again...
Vedas, upanishads, puranas were written in Tamil?
Tamil is older than Sanskrit, all South Indian languages are Dravidian languages and don't have any link with Sanskrit.
Sanskrit is almost now a dead language cuz of Hindi and we are not ready for that to happen to our language.
@@yatishv8063
Kili Kili language is older than all languages..Do you buy that argument?? There should be some sense in making any argument..
In which language Vedas, Upanishads, and Puranas were written?
ask maharastrians, Bengalis, Odia , NE states - we understand hindi but not in favor of making it national language, never.
ANY INDIAN WHO HAS TO PLAY A ROLE AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL HAS TO BE WELL VERSED IN HINDI. KAMARAJ LOST THE CHANCE TO BECOME A PM BECAUSE OF LACK OF KNOWLEDGE OF HINDI. GANDHI WAS NO A GREAT ORATOR IN HINDI BUT HE REALIZED THAT IF HE HAS TO TALK TO INDIANS HE HAS TO SPEAK IN HINDI. THE CHOICE IS YOURS.
You argument is valid if you want to be at the seat of power in the center. Here we are talking about imposing hindi in the different states especially TN, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra.
This is why India should become two different countries
@@Youthuba even if it becomes a two countries
Losses for northies
They need south indian money so they never separate India
@@jayasri5114 exactly
@@jayasri5114 they also have deal with Pakistan, Bangladesh and China alone. While south india will have access to the Ocean
Everywhere in the World Counties are United because of their one Language Identity and of course Language is a parameter of Unity. We always have been fighting among each other because of Culture differences and more importantly different Languages that we speak. Todays Bharat needs only one Language to remain United or else we would again fight and get divided I am sure of that. Different Languages means different cultures, different opinion and different histories which would surely become a reason of Conflict in years to come and then fight for Independence from Bharat. Why Hindi? Well because Hindi is a direct Descendant from Sanskrit. Pure Hindi is a basic evolution of Sanskrit and that it keeps Sanskrit alive. Other languages might be also children of Sanskrit but they are difficult to be spoken and represent a culture sect. While Hindi doesn't represent a culture sect but represent the Philosophy of Bharat Varsh and is like the eldest Child of Sanskrit. Pure Hindi should surely become the National Language of Bharat because it would help to keep Bharat United for years to come and stop the unstoppable division of this country again due to so many languages and culture divisions.
"Different Languages means different cultures, different opinion and different histories which would surely become a reason of Conflict in years to come and then fight for Independence from Bharat" You really think forcing people to learn a language because of majority will unite India and everyone should just forget their lingual identity? Whatever the reason is, every single person in this country should have the right to choose which language to converse in. You guys are just making this a larger issue than what it is.
Practically majority of India uses Hindi as a link language, I have noticed this outside India as well like in countries like Bhutan, Nepal. How many people can speak and understand English in India as compared to Hindi? Hindi is the most spoken and understood language around India, so practically it has to be linked language or you can say as a national language, this will only help us in our unity.
Just because you north Indians don't go to school dont think everybody is like.
Pakistani's also understand Hindi that's why they got to know every moment in India. Hindi is a language and it is influenced by Islamic countries and culture. Moghuls brought Hindi to India not Gandhi or modi. People know how Moghuls are cruel. They destroyed north Indian temples, architectures, libraries, culture then replaced their culture. Now north Indians following Moghuls culture. Crime is more, no women safety, all time chewing pan, jarda, Drugs what not everything.
That's why North Indians should stop playing free fire and go to school
@@monieshrajs5217 lol ...muh Diya toh kuch bi bakwas karni hai naa
@@rajivshetty6436 Shetty bhai history likhlo Romila Thapar ke bete ban jao
I don't understand why people debate about this. I'm from South India and I don't think there is any problem with Hindi. Of course we should respect every culture and language but it doesn't mean to disregard Hindi. In most of the countries they have two official languages, that's the same with India we have two official languages- English and Hindi. Also Hindi is spoken comparatively by majority of people and in majority of areas. And we should proud about the fact that MANY FOREIGNERS STUDY HINDI and when Chinese is also spoken and learnt by many people like English, Hindi is also (although not prevalent as Chinese) respected to that extent. In India, we can't consider every Indian language as official language as we have so many languages in our country and it's diverse. Hindi is the best choice for this, Sanskrit and Hindi has route in our history and culture also. It's shame to see that Indians are arguing each other in this issue when foreigners are learning Hindi. I'm a South Indian and I know in South India, most people think INABILITY TO SPEAK IN ENGLISH as unknowledgeable or uneducated and Inability to speak Hindi is not an issue at all. We should either think inability to speak both languages ( English and Hindi) as nothing wrong or either think inability in both as unknowledgeable.
Hindi never was a national language ...
I am from another country ,really surprised to see you all even debating this issue by having the most oldest precious language TAMIL origin from India 🤣🤣...No other country in this world got that pride you fools..
Where is South Bangalore MP? What stand is yours? It is high time that you need to carry the voice of your region you represent. You need to be straightforward, bold, frank, come out, show your guts and be outspoken and be candid in your opinions. You just can't hide and participate in West Bengal issues and forget and ignore core issues of regional concerns. Escapism shall not be excused.
Not only opposition, even we, the public, oppose Hindi. Instead, we prefer English. Doesn't matter even if it is a foreign language.
Just because BJP leaders don’t understand or they are poor in English, they can’t push Hindi. We south Indians are not comfortable in Hindi, because southern regional languages do not resemble Hindi. Imposing is totally wrong and a sin. Hindi is also a regional language, so is every other regional language. It is just that many of the north Indian languages resemble Hindi language. We can’t make one regional language a national language and ignore the rest. We need to embrace all languages equally. It is nonsense to have a national language in India. India is unique, unlike than other nations. The nation urges to leave it as it is. Who have asked for it? Leave it as it is, it is perfectly fine now. What are the BJP leaders trying to achieve? Is it that BJP leaders want to push any of their personal agenda? We have elected BJP to perform on greater agendas. We have better things to worry about. This whole initiative is unnecessary and not called for. We need not waste our precious time and energy with this stupid idea.
As many of the north Indian languages, more or less, resemble Hindi language, it is easier for them to catch-up, learn and possess command over the language. For rest of all south Indians it shall be like an extra language to learn from scratch and shall struggle to have command over language. This unequal status of command over the language shall be unfair while a communication takes place between a north Indian and a south Indian. Instead, to be fair, Sanskrit can be made as a national language, so that everybody in the nation will have to learn a new neutral language with all its fairness.
Already 100’s of languages are dying in the world every day. Home minister is trying to kill regional languages of India. What nonsense is he up to? Doesn’t he have any other business? He is promoting majoritarianism and damaging India's pluralism. India is unity in diversity.
Seriously, it is idiotic and doesn’t this home minister have any other better business? Ask him to focus on other better matters and leave the languages as they are.
First we should Dubb any movie, TV serials, sign boards, name boards in Kannada...
Official language is not the same as National language. After independence English in India was the official language. English was never accepted as national language and Hindi is not the national language of India, as per any section of Indian constitution.
India does not need one national language and is not the same as having national flag, national anthem etc. which are in the nature of distinctly identifying and unifying aspects of the nation and it's citizens. Example is Pakistan which had to eventually disintgrate when language became one of the key issues by strong opposition to the implementation of urdu.
Vasudeva Kutumbakam!
Vandematram!!
Jai Hind!!!
1)- When MNS do "Maharashtra / Marathi 1st" , media 🦁 .
2)- When Dravidi people do "Region/Language 1st" , media 🐣.
Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics':
(1) Based on discrimination:
The attempt from any Indian national Government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, everyone gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages.
(2) Based on practicality:
Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is just for entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on UA-cam entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English.
(3) Based on uniqueness:
If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi.
(4) Based on imposition:
After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'.
(5) Based on the two v/s three language formula:
The two-language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language.
(6) Based on the existing concept of India:
Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality.
(7) Based on statistics:
Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. Also, why is the taxpayer's money spent more on the promotion of Hindi and less or negligible for other non-Hindi languages? 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0; why? This is an utter disgrace!
(8) Based on pride and politics:
Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave diplomatically two-faced as some kind of an illogical balance in the policy of appeasement for vote bank politics. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional.
(9) Based on nationalism:
India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by a single language when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to somehow economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have started to aggressively teach their citizens English. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back.
(10) Based on globalization:
Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The English people are called 'gentlemen' for a reason - although colonial they were not as racist as Germans. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more leading to an increase in the demand for globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.
Every language should be respected .
Not applicable to TN read constitution first..for tn only Tamil and English are communication lamguage
The ruckus made my social media should be initially put to an end. This is an unnecessary debate , there are other social issues to be addressed such as poverty and unemployment.
When you can't find a solution for such issues how come hindi becomes a national issue.
Language is just tool for communication. But when in a democratic country like India, is trying to impose it on people this is not advisable.
There is no need of a national language in our country.
Who the hell is Ajay Devgan to decide which language should be the National language...
Hindi is just regional language.
First, its not Hindi film industry. It's Hindustani film industry. We need Roman characters because thelanguage used is not Hindi. It is Hindustani (a mix of Hindi and Urdu). Words like khamoshi, tehzeeb, mazhab, dil, sanam, mehsoos, intezaar, inam, azaad, lofzo, istemaal, wadiyo, intehaan and musaafir are all used in Bollywood. It's a shame to call it Hindi film industry. Even Pakistanis can watch Bollywood films. In fact, Bollywood has a large fan-following in Pakistan because most Pakistanis can understand Bollywood.
That is true not only of movies but also of the common people in the Hindi belt (Delhi, NCR, UP, MP, Bihar, Jharkhand etc.). Their Hindi is laden with Urdu words. So if at all there comes a whip to learn Samaskrutam (Sanskrit). I think there will be an unrest in these parts than Southern India (Exception might be Tamilnadu).
In hindi cinema just see our performance that great Ashok becomes Joker in Shahrukh Khan, great Bajirao become joker as Ranbir singh