1) Any attempt from the Indian national Government to successfuly make Hindi as the 'national' language of India will automatically make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi- belt speaking people as 'second-class citizens' in their own country. Hindi is not the mother-tongue of majority of Indians in the country. It will not come naturally to them when speaking or listening or reading or writing Hindi and the behaviour will always be subjected to accent mockery and ridicule. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is foreign to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi speaking people. So, everyone has the equal opportunity to compete. Replacing English with Hindi will give massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi speaking people. 2) Hindi language practically has no use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor or an engineer or a technician by just learning Hindi. Hindi is just for knowing entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on th global level and has more value to science, technology, communication etc than any other language. English acts as an insurance policy and ensures that discrimination does not happen. Once upon a time there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. Now, many people all over the world have accepted English and in today's globalised world nationalism is an out-dated concept. 3) If numbers is the criteria for greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be the national bird of India and not the peacock or that the 'dog' should be the national bird of India and not the tiger. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of speakers then he/she fails to look in the other way that majority of Indians don't communicate in Hindi. Spoken and understood Hindi is different from read and understood Hindi. Hindi can mostly be understood in North India, Pakistan and Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, a Dravidian language is recognised and official not only in the state of Tamil Nadu but also in Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore and South Africa. Hindi lags behind compared to Tamil. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history before Hindi. 4) At independence, the states in India were mostly formed on linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have so many states even when they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajastani, Awadhi, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. This is what happens when Hindi imposition happens. Marathi used to be written in Mudi lipi (script) before but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi lost its influence. The Marathi written in the Mudi script can be found in some places like Pune in Maharashtra but it will be a futile effort now to revive the status. The only stupid defence is that the government will say that the mudi script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is a stupid logic as the press could type write all other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and just could not do the same thing for Marathi? This is making Maharashtrians fall to hypocrisy in trying to please the centre as well as fight for the Marathi identity existence. Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own in official use. 5) The two language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can understand English? English is sufficient practical as a link language. We are typing comments on UA-cam and social media platforms in English, aren't we? So, English is the only link that works. 6) Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, the 1960s and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language etc. all this oneness stems out from the RSS ideology which was inspired in turn from the Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality. The tolerant nature of the average Indian ensured that India did not face any violent revolution since independence that would have had broken the country apart. But this patience is now tested to the limit by the BJP Government. 7) Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how much grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt.
I was worried people would've replied "oh so now you're glorifying Angrezi bhasha blah blah blah" when all you did was a perfectly logical analysis but now I feel satisfied knowing there aren't assholes in this community😌
I am from South India very fluent in Hindi and I love Hindi language but it doesn't mean we should criticise or degrade other state languages as Akash rightly said all languages got its own history and glory. So respect and support all languages because that's what makes us unique people around the globe. JAI HIND. Thanks Akash and entire Deshbhakth team for this episode. Kudos.
I am a Bengali... I am really big fan of South movies (specially Malayalam movies)... I fully support Kichha Sudeep Sir!! Ajay Devgan is fully insecured for the day by day success of South Industry!! Even his career is full of remake of South movies... Shame on his behaviour...though he was a great actor...
Broo like south toh dudh ka dhula hai na aur ajey sir ne kafi sari badiya movies banayi hai like tanhaji Shivay and many more but u guys will still watch that overrated kgf
@@ShaluSharma-ib7iu ha...kafi sari badi movie...like Singham(south remake),Drishyam(south remake).... Kafi sari bade directors,Ram Gopal Verma,Mani Ratnam(south Directors) k sath kaam v kiye hain.... Fir v South k logo k sath faltu bakwas kar rahe hain... awr bhai... please...aap mat dekhna "OVER RATED KGF".... PLEASE....kuch nhi hoga,apke na dekhne se....Highest grossing second Hindi movie ho gayi hain....
@@upasanadas9540 Abe jao yaar don't do bullshit yep go on blind hating bollywood , like I am not saying south Industry is bad but u just always do south south cuz of this many great talented actors in bollywood are getting unnecessary hate . And u don't realise because of ppl saying that south industry is better than bollywood is creating a hate for north indians everywhere I go ppl say north indians are illiterate cuz they watch bollywood and by saying south industry and north industry ppl do start to hate ppl of North . I am not against u but I hope u understand this problem I support both of the industries but I would prefer bollywood cuz actors like srk Akshay hritik Shahid are my childhood I can't hate them
@@ShaluSharma-ib7iu please tell me,where was such 'Mahatma's of bollywood when a shining star Sushant got murdered!?? Please tell me... No one ,not SRK,not Sahid, no one said a single word against them...They actually earned the hatred...I even brought up watching Bollywood movies... Bollywood once was on top in our country...But the days are gone,bcz the people haved changed... and yes, It's not a parameter to measure literacy. Those who does this kind of statement ("north Indians are illiterate bcz they watch bollywood"),is no doubt illiterate...
Mana ki ajay devgn vimal ki advertisement karke galat kar raha hai par yeh bhi samajhna hoga desh ke andar ek common language honi jaruri hai kyunki woh ek thread in the pearls ki tarah kaam karti hai
*Hindu Muslim Mandir Masjid 80% 20% Hijab Namaz Azaan GOBAR cow Hindi Telugu Malayalam Kannada Tamil Bengali* *Right wing communal Hindus have an endless list of boycotts and issues.*
But rajnikant and kamal hasan work Bollywood 40 year se kaam kar rahe hai uske bare me BHI batao dono hi industry ke log ek dusre ke industy me work kar rahe hai isme koi galat nahi hai
Ajay Devgan unnecessarily stirred the 'muddy waters' of language debate going on for decades. His career is full of south indian movies remake and yet he wants to make controversial statements. Actor Sudeep had the audacity to put his cents to the discussion. Bravo - well done.
He even acted in his careers biggest film RRR which is a south Indian film & also has the audacity to tease south film industry. It's just an act to promote his upcoming film by using sentiments of Hindi speaking people He didn't raise his voice in shushant's incident . Now he's jealous of South film industry killing bullywood. He's playing dirty politics for the first time just to promote his already destined to flop film.
smart but also cunning...in one of his old videos, promoting his film in north, he said that hindi is the national language to gain hindi audience and now he is saying something else...yella gimmick bro.
@@Madhuryamshetty27 aa tym li avrge adu national language antha andkondidreno ivatthigu eshtond jana ade andkondirthare bro jzt like ajay devgn andkondilva aage... eega sudeep avrge nija gothagiratthe adanna helirthare ashte.. nxt vr hindi li release agutthe antha gotthidru statement kottilva
@@user-qm2lm6ou6l nam school alli aa tara prashne ne kelirlilla and namge chikk vayassindanu ondhe helkottiradu 'Hindi is the language spoken in the majority part of india, it is not the national language of India' antha.
When I was teenager I used to believe that everyone in India speaks Hindi and all other languages are local dialects. I was ignorant. But when I grew up and learnt about our linguistic diversity I corrected my thought process.
I heard one person say just because the majority of people speak a language, that doesn't mean it should be the national language if that was a case crow should have been our national bird. Respect every language and culture.
Being a south indian, i did understand this video without even switching on caption!! Its not that we hate hindi, we just dont want someone tell us what to learn and what not learn!!
I'm a kannadiga, I like hindi ,I really love old hindi filmi songs sung by great "Mohamed rafi" saab BUT I am strictly against imposition of hindi. My language is having history of more than 2000 years . Comparatively hindi is a language of about 200 ,300 years and the language itself is a mixture of Persian, Arabic and sanskrit and doesn't even have a script which uses devanagari...
@@ritik7906 Bruhhhh,Finally...this is the apt answer for that.. These morons think india is secular no we are not.. Our constitution is secular but not our society..
Please Seculars read Quran surah 2 ayat 98 Allah non Muslim ka shatru he surah 4 Ayat 101 kafir (nonmuslimtumhare dushman he surah 5 ayat 51 iahudi or isai ko na banay surah 2 ayat 223 tumhare aurat khete he jaysa chahe gaman karo Surah 109 Al kafirun the disbeliever or non surah 3 ayat 85 islam ke alwa Anya religion acceptable nahi surah 3 ayat 19 islam hi ekmatra religion he Jo ayat oka inker karega Allah unse badla lega surah 8 ayat 55 abiswasi kafir sabse nich janwar he worst animal are kafir surah 9 ayat 5 murtipujo (mushriqs) ko jaha Pao katal karo surah 2 ayat 191kafir ko jaha Pao katal karo
I'm South Indian who lives in Maharashtra. After Amit Shah started promoting Hindi as the national language I've stated speaking in Marathi to the fruit vendors who comes from the Northern states like UP, MP, Bihar etc. Maybe they should also learn to make an effort to learn the language of the state in which they earn their income.
Maybe just maybe someone who's a fruit vendor is not capable of picking up new languages or maybe they are but they have other things to prioritize in order to survive . Not sure about rest of maharashtra but everyone understands hindi in Mumbai. Plus I would rather they learn English, it opens up the world, Marathi or any south Indian language not so much, and it's a hard fact.
Nobody has the guts to speak against Kashmir files as it is in Hindi also. Thank god the British gave India the English language.or we could never understand eachother. Long live English language for .Education jobs visa application etc
Nobody has the guts to speak against Kashmir files as it is in Hindi also. Thank god the British gave India the English language.or we could never understand eachother. Long live English language for .Education jobs visa application etc
India has no national language, if the national language is to be kept then the oldest language of the world Tamil or the sweetest language Bengali should be made the national language.
Education, Rationalism & Constitutional Awareness is missing from our country. The country's unity, sovereignty must be stood up. The issue of Linguistic Cold War should not be raised.
The road to unity of our country lies in our diversity ,you should understand that first. Your concept of nationalism is flawed and should never be accepted.
I wanna ask something. If we made everything one, then what's remaining for us to boast about? India is very well known for it's diversity and let it be! ✌🏻
Well said! If all speak the same, dress the same, build homes the same way, believe in same higher power(all human imaginations btw) etc then the whole idea of India is gone 😒 the only one getting benefitted will be the political party who will mind control the massess
I really miss those days when Doordarshan used to telecast regional language movies every week. It was a nice way to show the diversity of Indian culture at national platform.
Agree there use to be sign language news to cover whole week followed by regional films with subtitles. That was the best way to showcase our language diversity.
I am from Assam and when I was studying and working in Bangalore I tried to learn the Kannada language because I loved and respected the culture of Karnataka. Hindi is also a language but it should not be imposed on other states. We can use English.
@@SoniSingh-fl8cf if someone go to north india ..mostly they have to speak in hindhi ...if someone came to Tamilnadu ..they have to give some respect to their language and try to learn and speak in Tamil only..
@༼ཆ༽ daksina bharatiyan not only virodhi of hindi bhasha all dakshin bhartiyan virodhi of sanskrit bhasha i am shudh hindi speakar (sanskrit) and i understand all sabadarth of dakshin bharatiyan bhasha😊😊😊 visesa kannada bhasha and telugu ksama sahodara i don't understand tamil bhasha because it is a kathin bhasha it is not sanskrit it is a bhinna bhasha of sansakrit
Im feared that there are chances for civil wars over the language imposition, which may finally cause the nation to spilt between North and South😔...I don't want separate South Indian nation😔😔 but if the central govt which predominantly controlled by Hindi politicians tries to impose their thoughts on us forcefully then I will definitely fight for my separate South Indian country
As a South Indian I know 6 languages including Hindi.. it's the same with most of the south indians. We converse with each other which ever language the other person is comfortable with. That's how we respect each other's cultures and languages. We never thought one Language is inferior than the other Until they have started to claim Hindi as a superior one .
@@parmodrana3913 but Hindi is not Common nor comfortable to South Indians and not even nost part of India .. so it cant be classified as a national language. The day hindi is declared as national language all east indians and south Indians will form seperate countries.. we have our own culture and traditions that comes with our language. Bless you too. 🙂
@@sugardust4136 bro. I didn't say that Hindi should be a national language nor we have to fight for this creepy thing .. m just saying that the language which speak commonly is superior language that's all.. soo read properly before u speak anything .. 😂😂😂
I felt so happy to be able to understand what Shashi Tharoor said in the end cause Malayalam is not my mother tongue but I learned it out of interest. Learning new language is a very good thing but it should be out of interest not because of imposition. One can say English also imposed. But people are getting jobs based on their English speaking skills. Learning Hindi would be useful only for those who wanna go to the Hindi belt.
We haryanvis accepted hindi as our first language which resulted in degradation of haryanvi and soon our culture will die with it as language is soul of culture.
Their movie are already dubbed in many languages in order to being watched like Hollywood movies 🎥🍿 are dubbed in many multi national languages across the world
This debate will always go on till Hindi is the official language of the Union. English is in no way superior to any language in our country, but it is the only language that makes sense in a diverse nation such as ours. We have 28 nations inside this Union. And the language uniting us should be a global one.
जब तुम अंग्रेजी स्वीकार कर सकते हो तो हिन्दी क्यों नही है ? हिन्दी भारतीय लोगों की सम्पर्क भाषा है । क्या भारतीय लोगों के लिए हिन्दी सीखना सरल है या अग्रेजी ? इस बात पर भी ध्यान दिया करो कि भारत के किसी नागरिक को यदि पूरा भारत घूमना है तो वो किस भाषा को सम्पर्क भाषा बना करके अपनी बात समझायेगा । मुझे जहां तक पता है भारत की आधी से ज्यादा जनसंख्या हिन्दी समझती है । हिन्दी की जो छवि आप ने बनाई है अपने वीडियो में वह बहुत ज्यादा संकीर्ण है । पाकिस्तान नेपाल बांगला देश और अफगानिस्तान में भी लोग हिन्दी बोली को समझ सकते है। जो कल्पना लेकर के आप और दक्षिण के कुछ स्वार्थी राजनैता अपनी रोटियां सेक रहे है । जितनी मेहनत किसी तमिल भाषी को english सीखने में लगती है उसके 5 % में वो हिन्दी सीख सकता है । क्यों की यह भारतीय भाषा है ।भारतीय भाषा एक दूसरे में नजदीक है ।
Because English is equidistant to everyone in India. As a South Indian, I won't feel subordinated when I speak English, as even my buddies from the North have to do the same, while if it's Hindi, the North Indians are treated as a standard for South Indians to follow.
@@premvarmavlogs2276 toh aake jao meri jaan bhot mohabbat hai apne sheron Purane shehar me ancient old cultural ideas rehte aur new city me advance tech life milti Aao kabhi haveli PE.
I am a tamilian.And I can speak ,read and write hindi very well.we respect hindi and north indians in tamil nadu .And we expect same from north indians
@UCV4AAXUpZ4wiUiHRCYypXHA no ethnic group is slave of other ethnic group like Bangladesh got freedom from pakistan because of Urdu language imposition to Bengali muslims by Punjabi muslims of pakistan so we shouldn't repeat those same mistake
@@TanmayaPati how dare who ignorant compare to history.. Entire division of India was on basis of hate . And No one is imposing .. there is difference. And it was India who liberated east Pakistan and help it be Bangladesh
@@rishabhsingh9902 religion and ethnicity are 2 different things Bangladesh got separated from pakistan because of ethnic division between Bengalis Punjabis and muhajirs even though both followed Islam religion and I'm not supporting anyone
Same is happening with Punjabi.. They have degraded the level of Punjabi which a child learns.. While all students learn hindi.. And they learn about hindi's poetic devices etc till class 9-10th..The Punjabi which is taught doesn't even have the poem's for which Punjabi Literature is known. (I am talking about cbse schools) And the level of Punjabi has severly dipped from last 10 years.. Moreover the BJP led government has tried to super impose hindi.. Punjabi is restricted to be taught in army schools, and sanskrit in introduced ahead.. (Although Punjab is the state that provides a significant share of defence personnel for india.. !!) Punjabi was removed as a recognized language in jammu and kashmir.. While after urdu, dogri, hindi etc.. Punjabi was also spoken in hilly areas.. And they have removed it.. It's is like they are trying to completely right off a Punjabi personality from a Punjabi person too.. Children here from non sikh families have started speaking hindi as the communal divide is being propagated by the government controlled media.. (Even a language now has a religion.. Wow.!!🥲.) BJP is killing the essence of India itself.. And they claim to love india.. !!. 🥲 Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai.!!
Abe bale bale Punjab me hamesha se hi Congress ka government Raha tha aur situation 8 - 10 saal me change nahi hota cbse me Hindi compulsory subject nahi padhna toh state government me padh leta
have you ever read about linguistic policies of india made after partition by congress which are effective till date.i know you are hurt but please learn about the history and who distorted it.
Meanwhile here in 🇵🇰 urdu(north Indian language having 2-3% speakers mainly migrants who came from UP,bihar during partition) is imposed on us nd our native languages r declared 2nd class.. that's one of the big mistakes of Jinnah nd the reason why 🇧🇩 got independence..
Hindi is not compulsory in Tamilnadu, but in some matriculation schools they are forcing us to learn. I tried but I couldn't learn at all so left the school and later studying only two languages was stress free and now I will learn learn Hindi out of interest.
Yes ,, and Bangladesh became the only Country formed on linguistic basis,, A country of 20 crore formed on the basis of only one slogan"Joy bangla", 3 million people died,, :16-17 old years teenagers gave slogan of jay bangla in front of Pakistani soldiers🔥,, when the army ask to say pakistan Zindabad...
Any of the current regional languages are alive because they are being carried out over generations because of parents teaching their kids and being used in their daily communication. Being a telugite i know how to learn and write Telugu . But im like only one out of my 10 school friends who can do this. In my school we had hindi as primary language and Telugu as secondary language. Lets say is this is being carried forward, most of new gen kids will never have enough resources to learn and write Telugu and eventually it will die . And this is how a hindi imposition will effect regional languages if we do not teach them importance of mother tongue or its culture. I really appreciate how tamil people be stubborn about their language or priorities. We are already aware of how other regional languages of Bihar and Rajasthan similarly suffered because of Hindi imposition.
Hindians don't want Indians be togather. Hindians are only Hindi speaker. Indians can speak Hindi but they love their mother language. Also a Language is amalgamation of common intelligible dialects. Gujarati is a language, Marathi is a language, Kashmirean is a language, Gadwali is a language, Madhesi (Bhojpuri) is a language, Maithili is a language, Magadhi (Magahi) is a language, Odishi (Oria) is a language, Sanskrtam is a language, Prakrtam is a language, Kannada is a language, Tamil is a language, Malyalam is a language, Nepali is a language, Bangali is a language, Assamese is a language, Rajaputani is a language, Malawi is a language, Chhattragarhi is a Language. India is diverse. Hindia is divisor. Hindians please Respect non-Hindian India. Otherwise we will be separated. I love speaking Hindi but I love speaking Punjabi and Kaurawi too. And I am a non-Hindian. I am Gadwali which is spoken from Himachal Pradesh to Uttarakhand and Eastern Nepal. Although Gadwali is still struggling to enter 8th schedule of Constitution of India. But we are hopeful and strong belief in Republican values. One day our language Gadwali will be in 8th schedule and official language of state of Gadwall. (under republic of republics of India) Please don't try to impose Hindi. We don't hate it. But we surely will hate you Hindians. Let India be diversed not divided. Thanks & Regards
It's foolish to fight on languages. Everyone has own mother tongue. A movie with a good script will be understood in any language. So where is the need to debate on movies on the basis of language?
There is a difference between mother tongue and national language. My mother tongue is Bengali but there should be one unified language in India for transparency and which is well understandable among us. Humare yaha mother tongue leke itna ego h logo me which is barier to unity and dangerous 😄
@@DarthVader-no9cc English hai to. It's also a global language which allows our workforce to be competitive globally. People say that it is the language of our colonizers, but the reality of today is that English is the link language of the world. In a day and age where even China is shedding it's insularity to English, we, who have the competitive edge in English historically are going in the opposite direction, led by chauvinistic and idiotic politicians. These morons aren't gonna lose anything, they have a lot of money hoarded up. It's the common man like you and I, brother, who will suffer from this misguided direction that the country is going in. English is the global present, fortunately or unfortunately, and India cannot change that about the world.
@@samarthraizada English is necessary but it it is not our own language. Btw you don't need English to become successful. Japan , china south korea all these countries prefer their own languages. They are all successful.
No India is not a union of state it is a country and it has 22 official language ... Bcz u r a bangladeshi u r spreading propaganda so stop it ... Yes some none seanse said Hindi is national language bcz they have no idea what constitution said ... We must short our internal problems ... Don't interfere in our internal matter .....
@@kamleshnarayan3286 भाई भारत देश अमेरिका के जैसे कोई राज्यों से बना जरूर है पर अमेरिका के राज्य कभी भी अमेरिका से अलग हो सकता है पर भारत के राज्य (जल्दी) अलग नहीं हो शकते है क्योकी भारत के लौह पुरुष सरदार वल्लभ भाई पटेल है और अमेरिका का लौह पुरुष टोनी स्टार्क है किसी का परवाह नहीं होता है
@@chuichi15 Hindi is first language of nine states plus second or third language of few states. Thought hindi is not national language yet it is Raj Bhasha.
@@kamleshnarayan3286 Hey man you have not studied constitution properly ... Thought india is called a federal democracy yet is not totally federal like us. India is called quasi federal and now we call it cooperative federal. India is not united states of india..mind it
Covered nicely most points... I'm form South and I loved this conversation... Yes I learnt in school and watching movies like any other subject because of 3 language policy. And I did watch lot of movies so I can easily talk or understand this convo
Iam a kanndiga and I would like to say what sudeep said is very accurate. There are many north Indians who stay in Bangalore and completely deny to learn kannada and disrespect our language. North Indians shows superiority over their language . We respect all languages and so only I'm able to watch u and we expect all these people to respect out language. Forget about cinema ,they should respect our language in all perspective.
@udit singh He has more to lose than gain by saying what he said. He is so damn popular in Karnataka already that he does not need this controversy to gain political mileage at all. He can chose any constituency and any party through out Karnataka and can position himself to win. He has more to lose by what he said than gain - His multi-crore investment movie "Vikrant Rona" is coming out and Hindi dubbing is a big market. Why would he dent his own money making prospect at this time by raking up a controversy. All he meant to say was - Don't call only Hindi movies Indian movies and all non-Hindi and South Indian movies as pan-Indian. All are Indian movies and Hindi is not THE national language of India for only it to be called Indian movie and all others pan-Indian.
I am a Hindi speaker & I firmly believe that Hindi is NOT my national language. Every Indian is my brother/sister regardless which part of the country you belong to.
India has more than 1600 languages, 22 scheduled languages and 2 official languages. No language should be declared national language. We must respect all languages. We are the citizens of India, it is our duty to keep this country united without any discrimination. Jai Hind 🇮🇳💖
Those scheduled languages that you are talking about is also official languages. The 2 official languages that you are talking about is actually link languages or connecting languages or common languages to interact between different states of this country. It is just that instead of link or connecting or common - official languages words are coined.
Long time ago I used to think English was the first language in European Union as well, just like Hindi is our first language! I later travelled through Europe and learned that local language is always the first language and each country learns at least 2 more languages in school. I have also talked to locals there and they have mutual respect for other languages as well. That's when I decided to learn local language in South India which my family was reluctant to learn. Today I can speak and write in local language and am encouraging my kids to do the same as well. For the harmony of our diverse nation, imposition of any language is detrimental. Diversity and inclusion of all languages and local cultures at grassroots level is a necessity, not a choice.
I was born in Karnataka but being north Indian . I have always respected kannada before hindi because a place can only be developed until and unless it is connected to its grass roots jai Karnataka jai hind bharat mata ki jai
@Gaurang Sharma - भाई तो क्या दिल्ली, उत्तर प्रदेश, मुंबई, मध्य प्रदेश, गुजरात ये सब क्या विकशीत नहीं है क्या तुम को यह कहना चाहिए की मैं जहां पैदा हुआ हूं वह स्थान मुझे बहुत प्यारा है और बचपन से कन्नड़ सुनने और बोलने से मैं हिंदी भाषा से ज्यादा कन्नड़ भाषा को पसंद करता हूं सब को अपना जन्म स्थान प्यारा होता है और होना चाहिए मेरे देश के 28 राज्य है तो इसलीये अपने देश में एक राष्ट्रीय भाषा होना चाहिए और हमारे देश में हिंदी भाषा सबसे ज्यादा बोली जाती है तो इसलीये राष्ट्रीय भाषा हिंदी होनी चाहिए
@@dreambig990 what if we don't have national language in India? Does country fall? Indian constitution itself told there no national language for India. What's your problem now? There are many peoples spoke hindhi that is why hindhi is official language of india. We respect hindhi always and forever no doubt in that. Don't impose on us as national language. What Ajay Devgan said it's completely false. Lets respect eachother language.
@@dreambig990 national language rakhna is not a priority . Instead go ask to government that where are jobs and why petrol is becoming expensive if you really want to see your country to be developed then ask questions to central government
@@dreambig990 aurr haaan aise toh dogs ki population 30 million hai toh kya national animal dogs ko hona chaiye kya? Be logical and sensible bro plzz grow up
Being from Kerala lived my whole life in Delhi and Now in FRANCE, i got influence by multiple language andits customs. Language is a pride of the region and helps uniting and understanding the culture. I have nothing against HINDI. it is a beautiful language but shoving it forcefully in the mouth of others is totally wrong and people are bound to hate it. Sure india needs a common language accessible for all but not at the cost of degrading other regional language. Nice video Deshbhakt as always
We are proud Kannadiga and we love our Language , culture and at the same we respect other languages also. I found ajay devgan is rude, arrogant and ignorant. May God bless with wisdom.
Well, I am a north indian from Bihar and we belong to the so called hindi belt, but if I am being honest there are more people who don't speak hindi than hindi speakers in bihar, they speak region languages like Bhojpuri, Magahi, Maithili, Angika and Vajjika(and I am not gonna call them dialects, they are languages, they have their own history) they are not recognized by goi just to increase hindi speakers on paper, but this fact can't be ignored.Even my own grandma can't speak hindi she does understand it...
@NEET ASPIRANT exactly, And same happened to me I was never taught my languages too, not because my parents thought of it as inferior but nobody spoke it around me so I never learned... But I sometimes try to learn it on my own.
Yes bro I also agree...I am from UP every farmer here speaks bhojpuri....but due to hindi imposition.. bhojpuri is killed here day by day....now slowly everybody wants to speak fluent Hindi which is bad... disrespecting your identity is the worst thing can happen to you.... 🇮🇳
That's the reason I don't like Hindi much, being from northeast we got against it coz it might threaten our own languages and our language may end up like Awadhi and others which are now under Hindi belt considered as dehati languages.
Also because Bollywood is racist, I am from Nepali community every time bollywood shows a Nepali character, either they show Nepali women as prostitutes or show Nepali men as watchmen, spreading racism more and more against my community hence the reason I never watch bollywood.
@@gurnoor05 bro watch Ajay's runway 34. its damn good 🔥 aur acchi films nahi aa rahi matlab 2 months se sab bas Jersey ke naam se bollywood ko badnaam kar rahe hai aur vo flim bhi acchi hai aise blindly hate mat karo audience ke iss chutiype ki wajah se attack jaisi acchi sci fi action movie flop ho gayi bollywood acchi movies banata tha aur aage bhi banayega bas 2-3 kharaab movies se hate mat karo aur jaha Kgf aur RRR ki taaref kar rahe he jo karni bhi chahiye usi industries ne Radhe Shyam aur Beast jaisi ghatiya movies bhi banayi hai lekin use ignore kiya jaayega...kisi industry ko politics se judge mat karo unke films se karo🙏
@@Bk-be4zq 1. English is a global language, thus fetches more opportunities. 2. It doesn't give undue advantage to the Hindi speaking states when it comes to professional proficiency. 3. And last but not the least, nobody associates subtle Nationalism with English, as many do wrt Hindi. Thus it doesn't undermine the history and importance other Indian languages.
Each and every country has its own language , like-- China- Chinese Japan- Japanese Russia- Russian France- French Germany- German Korea- Korean Spain- Spainish Bhutan- Donzkha Malyesia- Malay etc. These countries don't give importance to English language and pursue their education in their own language.. so we can say English is not a global language..it is language of Britain, America and Australia only.
16:34 All Bollywood actors are busy in doing nepotism whereas R Madhavan encouraged his son in swimming and he is trying his best to give India a medal in swimming in Olympics which India has never got.This clearly shows the difference between Bollywood and South Industry.
I am from Mumbai. My mother tongue is Marathi and i can speak Hindi and English as well. I regret that I know only 3 languages. I would have loved to learn more languages to connect with fellow Indians. However, now it's difficult considering age and work but if I move to any other state i would make sure that i learn that state language.
English kohi zaroorat nahi Marathi aur Hindi kaafi hai kyon tum log nahi samajh parahi hai ki English baat karne se hum apni bhasha bhool te jaare hai. Hame apne bhasha ko bhi zaroorati dekhni chaiye.
@@mjc8891 हिंदी बोलणे ही वाईट गोष्ट नाही, मी सुद्धा मराठी कुटुंबातील आहे, माझे आई वडील दोन भाषांत बोलू शकतात, पण आम्ही त्यांच्याशी इंग्रजीवर बोलतो तेव्हा त्यांना समजत नाही, आम्ही भारताचे नागरिक आहोत.इंग्रजी बोलण्याची गरज नाही इंग्रजी बोलणे म्हणजे इंग्रजांचे तळवे चाटणे.
@@alfiemandella2258 haa mag shudh hindi bolayla jamnar ahe ka? Urdu misrit hindi mhanje mughalanche talve chatne.... marathi sanskrit la sarvat javal ahe ani english global bhasha ahe
Fun fact - Ajay devgans biggest hits are remakes of malyalam n tamil movi Drishiyam n Singham..He might be high on Vimal that day. He is also set to make two more telugu remakes.
@@rtiripshi4432 golmaal was the remake of malyalam film - kakkakuyil...sin of sirdar was remake of telugu movie - maryada ramanna...even his 99s hit kachhe dhage was a remake of kache dhage from the 70s .his 90s hits are shitty where he mostly played a jilted lover which the chapri audience still make tik tok videos of..the only movie which is good not a renake is 'gangajal'...
We have Soooo much time to discuss about religion, language, speakers etc etc etc in a country but no time for developmental and real issues……….??? !!!’🤦🏻♂️
If Marathi speaking people have no problem in learning Hindi why South Indians don't speak Hindi but atleast learn it.It's really a pain traveling to non-hindi speaking states if they atleast don't know even basic Hindi
So as per your logic if we south people travelling to north then north people must learn our southern languages....then we feel painless right!!!??? Have some sense man...
South people have no problem to learn english because every information about studies and sciences etc is available in English.... so no need to learn hindi because no use in it... and we south people can speak and understand english very well so learn english that is very useful to you to travel not only south India but throughout the world....
If you want to travel anywhere then you must learn their regional language but don't ask them to learn your language for your sake bcz its just meaningless....
I am from Karnataka. I fluently speak more than 3 Indian Languages. I do not know Bengali but have watched and enjoyed few Bengali movies without translation. Language is a beautiful medium that helps us connect with different cultures. Bollywood is going downhill also because of the recent controversies/ incidents lile Sushanth singh Rajput case, Drug abuse cases and many more.
Honestly, Hindi or any other language speaking group should not get any unfair advantage or disadvantage in any exam or opportunity.. all languages are great.. trying to learn Kannada being a Bengali. It's a challenge but it's such a sweet language...
Upper class English medium students always get some advantage. But underprivileged non-Hindi students gets the massive disadvantage in this. Someones disadvantage is other's advantage. Now is it fair or ethical In 21st century India? I felt the same years back when appeared for IIT JEE.
Hindi language itself has no origin. The language is a register of hindustani which was culmination of multiple language spoken in the so called hindi belt we call today. The standardized hindi that everyone learns today was standardized in 1949, which begs the question How can you make a language that is so new to the country a national language. If they wanna make it a national language then they need to make Hindustani or khariboli national as well because that's what hindi and urdu uses as its base and then sugarcoats with either persian loan words or sanskrit loan words. Like, Bollywood Actors should only focus on acting as they are not really bright from what i've seen so far. And ajay devgan should also know that most of the bollywood movies are using Hindustani language not the Modern Standardized Hindi he is talking about, This is so that both India and pakistan can understand. If they start making movies in shudh hindi, nobody will ever watch it.
right wing ki kangana aur left wing ki swara pata nahi yeh dono khud sochte hai bolne se pehele par kam se kam kangana acchi flim toh karleti hai swara toh puri politiician bane ki teyari me hai
I respect hindi and all other regional languages but I'm borne Marathi, My mother tongue is Marathi and I always find myself comfortable speaking in Marathi. I always take pride in my Marathi language. Even when I speak Hindi my tone of speaking hindi comes Marathi. I speak hindi only and when it is necessary as every regional language speaker does. I'm not too good at speaking english but I try speaking it as and when it is necessary. I'm indian🇮🇳 and this is my identity as Indian National but I'm Indian because I'm Marathi and that's how Marathi represent India's language diversity as one language amongst many regional languages like, Telgu, Marwari, Odia etc. which again represents India as a Linguistical diverse nation which makes India 🇮🇳 one and complete India. Proud to be Indian.. Proud to be Maharashtrian Marathi speaker.
@Drithi madam dangal china alli release aggirlilla andre irthitha??? 2000 crores? and aamir khan was already an established actor who had a lot of fame unlike a new actor like prabhas
@Drithi You need an explainer ?! With due respect to every Film industry in this country, don't take the word 'slap' as an offense. The word 'slap' was used as a wake-up call to Bollywood at one point of time, specially after the popularity of Bahubali. Because, Bollywood was making shitty movies barring a few exceptions (Sanjay Leela Bhansali). Of course, Dangal as an exception made big on international arena. But the movie is not about Creativity, special effects, and storyline. It is rather based on social issues. And its not about how many crores it made. Bahubali is known for its great special effects, Big scale, storyline and creativity, which Bollywood movies (and for that matter Southern film industry) hugely missed for long time. Bahubali was a Game-changer and it made a huge International audiences. In fact, it was Karan Johar who first said that Bahubali is a 'beautiful slap' on our faces.
I hate the fact that hindi speaking is considered as superior to other regional languages... I do understand hindi but not fluent in speaking... so I face problems every time I called customer care or even local shops in Kolkata... they don't seem make any efforts to learn local language just because they are hindi speakers...
Hindi is hybrid language... already it has destroyed bhojpuri,Orissa,Marathi,rajastini,Punjabi, Gujarati film industry...etc...in future South films will be dubbed in all above languages and Hindi will automatically will get less screens...
Look how Riots, Azaan, Hanuman Chalisa and Bulldozer made us forgot everything, Inflation, Unemployment, Petrol, Diesel School fees, Expensive Courses and Experience Medicines. Sri Lankans had also forgotten.
I understand and support your point but not your profile name. You are again showing the same mentality of abusing people with other ideologies(irrespective of whether they are right or wrong). My humble suggestion - please change your profile name brother, and put a respectable one and promote an environment where we can all discuss and debate peacefully, only then can things be better, when people understand what is right and what's wrong rather than falling for propaganda. Otherwise, what would be the difference between you and any other IT Cell troll(except for ideology, but still, we can't fall to their level, right?).
My mother tongue is Hindi, i speak Kannada and Tamil. Hindi should not be imposed on non Hindi speakers. Respect all languages but hate colonization. Hindi or any language should not be our National language. Rather government should include more languages in the list of official languages.
Bhai may be your mother tongue is Urdu or more specifically dakhni dialect of urdu not hindi, mine also dakhni Urdu but iam also fluent in kannada and Telugu....
1) Any attempt from the Indian national Government to successfuly make Hindi as the 'national' language of India will automatically make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-
belt speaking people as 'second-class citizens' in their own country. Hindi is not the mother-tongue of majority of Indians in the country. It will not come naturally to them when
speaking or listening or reading or writing Hindi and the behaviour will always be subjected to accent mockery and ridicule. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a
good leveler in the sense that it is foreign to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi speaking people. So, everyone has the equal opportunity to compete. Replacing English with
Hindi will give massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi speaking people.
2) Hindi language practically has no use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor or an engineer or a technician by just learning Hindi. Hindi is just for knowing
entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on th global level and has more value to science, technology, communication etc
than any other language. English acts as an insurance policy and ensures that discrimination does not happen. Once upon a time there was a colonial power but it's all in the past.
Now, many people all over the world have accepted English and in today's globalised world nationalism is an out-dated concept.
3) If numbers is the criteria for greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be the national bird of India and not the peacock or that the 'dog' should be the national bird of India
and not the tiger. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of speakers then he/she fails to look in the other way that majority of Indians don't communicate in Hindi.
Spoken and understood Hindi is different from read and understood Hindi. Hindi can mostly be understood in North India, Pakistan and Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, a Dravidian
language is recognised and official not only in the state of Tamil Nadu but also in Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore and South Africa. Hindi lags behind compared to Tamil. Also, Tamil, Telegu,
Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history before Hindi.
4) At independence, the states in India were mostly formed on linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for
Tamil-speaking people and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have so many states even when they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajastani, Awadhi,
Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. This is what happens when Hindi
imposition happens. Marathi used to be written in Mudi lipi (script) before but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit,
etc. Marathi lost its influence. The Marathi written in the Mudi script can be found in some places like Pune in Maharashtra but it will be a futile effort now to revive the status.
The only stupid defence is that the government will say that the mudi script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press -
which is a stupid logic as the press could type write all other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and just could not
do the same thing for Marathi? This is making Maharashtrians fall to hypocrisy in trying to please the centre as well as fight for the Marathi identity existence. Marathi people are facing
the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own in official use.
5) The two language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi
speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for
communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should
someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can understand English?
English is sufficient practical as a link language. We are typing comments on UA-cam and social media platforms in English, aren't we? So, English is the only link that works.
6) Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, the 1960s and might happen now or later in the future.
The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language etc. all this oneness stems out from the RSS ideology which was inspired in turn from the Nazi Germany. It is
harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi
imposition ever becomes a reality. The tolerant nature of the average Indian ensured that India did not face any violent revolution since independence that would have had broken the
country apart. But this patience is now tested to the limit by the BJP Government.
7) Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how much grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt.
Perfect analysis 🙏🙏🙏
brilliant!!
Beautifully summed up👍👍
Word dude 🙏🏾🇮🇳✊🏾
I was worried people would've replied "oh so now you're glorifying Angrezi bhasha blah blah blah" when all you did was a perfectly logical analysis but now I feel satisfied knowing there aren't assholes in this community😌
I am from South India very fluent in Hindi and I love Hindi language but it doesn't mean we should criticise or degrade other state languages as Akash rightly said all languages got its own history and glory. So respect and support all languages because that's what makes us unique people around the globe. JAI HIND.
Thanks Akash and entire Deshbhakth team for this episode. Kudos.
I support you
I am RSS ka sanghi
Bollywood is shit
It only teaches to eat shit like gutkha where as south film industry gloryfies our culture
What is there to love in hindi bro?
@@simbanagpal7588 What's not ???
You are using tarkan pic on your display 😂
Agree
When the Hindu was sleeping, then Petrol was Rs. 65 per liter and Ever since awakened, it has reached Rs. 118 par liter
Wah Modiji Wah 😂😂😂
But Bjp supporters ko koun samjae ga ye
@@everything336 fun fact bjp never had any SUPPORTERS, all they have are andhbhakt's.
@@waitwha683 kya bhai 🤷
Rumhara jalega🔥
Modika us sehi chalega 😆
@UCe_khaM64XzfVZLyEuC4uCA when u don't believe in it why do you read it?
Aree koonn bateyga andhbhakt ko
ಜೈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ಜೈ ಭಾರತ....ನಮ್ಮ ಭಾಷೆ ನಮಗೆ ಹೆಚ್ಚು 😮❤❤❤
यह भाषा समझ नहीं आ रहा है।
It's Kannada @@mahekas6546
I am a Bengali... I am really big fan of South movies (specially Malayalam movies)... I fully support Kichha Sudeep Sir!!
Ajay Devgan is fully insecured for the day by day success of South Industry!! Even his career is full of remake of South movies...
Shame on his behaviour...though he was a great actor...
Malayalam movies are best, they are so natural to watch.
Btw I'm Telugu❤ native .
Broo like south toh dudh ka dhula hai na aur ajey sir ne kafi sari badiya movies banayi hai like tanhaji Shivay and many more but u guys will still watch that overrated kgf
@@ShaluSharma-ib7iu ha...kafi sari badi movie...like Singham(south remake),Drishyam(south remake)....
Kafi sari bade directors,Ram Gopal Verma,Mani Ratnam(south Directors) k sath kaam v kiye hain....
Fir v South k logo k sath faltu bakwas kar rahe hain...
awr bhai... please...aap mat dekhna "OVER RATED KGF".... PLEASE....kuch nhi hoga,apke na dekhne se....Highest grossing second Hindi movie ho gayi hain....
@@upasanadas9540 Abe jao yaar don't do bullshit yep go on blind hating bollywood , like I am not saying south Industry is bad but u just always do south south cuz of this many great talented actors in bollywood are getting unnecessary hate . And u don't realise because of ppl saying that south industry is better than bollywood is creating a hate for north indians everywhere I go ppl say north indians are illiterate cuz they watch bollywood and by saying south industry and north industry ppl do start to hate ppl of North . I am not against u but I hope u understand this problem I support both of the industries but I would prefer bollywood cuz actors like srk Akshay hritik Shahid are my childhood I can't hate them
@@ShaluSharma-ib7iu please tell me,where was such 'Mahatma's of bollywood when a shining star Sushant got murdered!??
Please tell me...
No one ,not SRK,not Sahid, no one said a single word against them...They actually earned the hatred...I even brought up watching Bollywood movies... Bollywood once was on top in our country...But the days are gone,bcz the people haved changed...
and yes, It's not a parameter to measure literacy. Those who does this kind of statement ("north Indians are illiterate bcz they watch bollywood"),is no doubt illiterate...
Ajay Devgan should have focused on making his zubaan kesari not his tweets.
He should be called Vimal Devgn. Suits more
Absolutely Right bro 😂
😀😀
👍👍👍
Mana ki ajay devgn vimal ki advertisement karke galat kar raha hai par yeh bhi samajhna hoga desh ke andar ek common language honi jaruri hai kyunki woh ek thread in the pearls ki tarah kaam karti hai
We Indians are pro at one thing - we can find endless reasons to fight with one other.
And these fight is the time of need for the BJP
THAT KICHDA STARTED
*Hindu Muslim Mandir Masjid 80% 20% Hijab Namaz Azaan GOBAR cow Hindi Telugu Malayalam Kannada Tamil Bengali*
*Right wing communal Hindus have an endless list of boycotts and issues.*
This is the beauty of democracy. If you do not want people to fight over thoughts then go to dictatorships like North Korea or Saudi Arabia.
Hahaha rightly said
That moment when Ajay Devgn talks about Hindi, and works in RRR, a Telugu masterpiece😑
It his politics of Bollywood
But rajnikant and kamal hasan work Bollywood 40 year se kaam kar rahe hai uske bare me BHI batao dono hi industry ke log ek dusre ke industy me work kar rahe hai isme koi galat nahi hai
@@ambujupadhyay1865 Rajinikanth aur Kamal Hassan ne Tamil ko kabhi national language nahi bola
Our south,our culture,our language, ಆದ್ರೂ ಐ ಲವ್ ಇಂಡಿಯಾ.....❤️🙌❣️😘✨🙏🙏🙏🙏
Ajay Devgan unnecessarily stirred the 'muddy waters' of language debate going on for decades. His career is full of south indian movies remake and yet he wants to make controversial statements. Actor Sudeep had the audacity to put his cents to the discussion. Bravo - well done.
He even acted in his careers biggest film RRR which is a south Indian film & also has the audacity to tease south film industry.
It's just an act to promote his upcoming film by using sentiments of Hindi speaking people
He didn't raise his voice in shushant's incident . Now he's jealous of South film industry killing bullywood. He's playing dirty politics for the first time just to promote his already destined to flop film.
@@pokemonitishere202 bro jo bola thik but susant ki incidents ghusa kar galti kardi ... Dumb lagte ho 🙄
Bla bla
@@pokemonitishere202 tum logo ka whi ssr ka rona chal hi rha h🤣🤣.....usne thodi mara h....uska naukar h jo bolega...tweet Kiya whi boht h
@@pokemonitishere202 atleast his film runway 34 is far better than cringe only slow mo herogiri movies like bullshit RRR and KGF...
I'm from Karnataka,Sudeep is a very smart guy. He says every word smartly.
smart but also cunning...in one of his old videos, promoting his film in north, he said that hindi is the national language to gain hindi audience and now he is saying something else...yella gimmick bro.
@@Madhuryamshetty27 aa tym li avrge adu national language antha andkondidreno ivatthigu eshtond jana ade andkondirthare bro jzt like ajay devgn andkondilva aage... eega sudeep avrge nija gothagiratthe adanna helirthare ashte.. nxt vr hindi li release agutthe antha gotthidru statement kottilva
@@Madhuryamshetty27 ನೀವು ಶಾಲೆಲಿ ಇರ್ಬೇಕಾದ್ರೆ 'ನಮ್ಮ ರಾಷ್ಟ್ರ ಭಾಷೆ ಯಾವುದು? ಅಂತ ಕೇಳ್ದಾಗ ಏನಂತ ಉತ್ರ ಬರ್ದಿದ್ದೆ
@@user-qm2lm6ou6l nam school alli aa tara prashne ne kelirlilla and namge chikk vayassindanu ondhe helkottiradu 'Hindi is the language spoken in the majority part of india, it is not the national language of India' antha.
@@manojkm1596 mostly..
When I was teenager I used to believe that everyone in India speaks Hindi and all other languages are local dialects. I was ignorant. But when I grew up and learnt about our linguistic diversity I corrected my thought process.
Please spread this correct thought process amongst your locals
Me too 💞
Good..
In south India we used to think only Muslims speak Hindi , and it was true.
I heard one person say just because the majority of people speak a language, that doesn't mean it should be the national language if that was a case crow should have been our national bird. Respect every language and culture.
Sudeep is such a genuine person. I've met him once when I was kid through a school friend. Really great guy
Both are Propoganda Masters
Being a south indian, i did understand this video without even switching on caption!! Its not that we hate hindi, we just dont want someone tell us what to learn and what not learn!!
exactly!
@@thedeshbhakt why are you making your videos in Hindi ?
@@SonuSinghmirzapur Hindi me video bna ke famous hote hai
Fir Hindi ko support nhi krte
Aise logo ko dogla kha jata hai
@@magadh513 kal se tu ghar se bahar rehana foothpaath pe sona
@@SonuSinghmirzapur then why are you typing in English?
Hats off to the maturity & wisdom of Sudeep Kiccha. No wonder south movies are doing well.
If south Indian has to learn hindi
Then north Indians should also learn atleast one south Indian language
Ajay devgan :- bolo zuban kesari
Kiccha sudeep sir :- sorry bolo pehle
😂😂
🤣
😂😂 yeh sahi tha guru😂
🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
I'm a kannadiga, I like hindi ,I really love old hindi filmi songs sung by great "Mohamed rafi" saab BUT I am strictly against imposition of hindi.
My language is having history of more than 2000 years .
Comparatively hindi is a language of about 200 ,300 years and the language itself is a mixture of Persian, Arabic and sanskrit and doesn't even have a script which uses devanagari...
ನಿಜ 💯👌👌👌
Aahaa.. entha maatu..
Kiccha Sudeep 🔥🔥🔥🔥
If there was no Godi Media, the Country wouldn't have been ruined.
Who believes 🙏🙏🙏
If partition is properly followed, then.... 🙄
@@ritik7906 Bruhhhh,Finally...this is the apt answer for that..
These morons think india is secular no we are not..
Our constitution is secular but not our society..
@@ritik7906 Pdf file in hell,i hope...
💯💯💯💯💯💯
Please Seculars read Quran surah 2 ayat 98 Allah non Muslim ka shatru he surah 4 Ayat 101 kafir (nonmuslimtumhare dushman he surah 5 ayat 51 iahudi or isai ko na banay surah 2 ayat 223 tumhare aurat khete he jaysa chahe gaman karo Surah 109 Al kafirun the disbeliever or non surah 3 ayat 85 islam ke alwa Anya religion acceptable nahi surah 3 ayat 19 islam hi ekmatra religion he Jo ayat oka inker karega Allah unse badla lega surah 8 ayat 55 abiswasi kafir sabse nich janwar he worst animal are kafir surah 9 ayat 5 murtipujo (mushriqs) ko jaha Pao katal karo surah 2 ayat 191kafir ko jaha Pao katal karo
I'm South Indian who lives in Maharashtra. After Amit Shah started promoting Hindi as the national language I've stated speaking in Marathi to the fruit vendors who comes from the Northern states like UP, MP, Bihar etc. Maybe they should also learn to make an effort to learn the language of the state in which they earn their income.
Maybe just maybe someone who's a fruit vendor is not capable of picking up new languages or maybe they are but they have other things to prioritize in order to survive . Not sure about rest of maharashtra but everyone understands hindi in Mumbai. Plus I would rather they learn English, it opens up the world, Marathi or any south Indian language not so much, and it's a hard fact.
i understand your frustration but taking it out on fruit vendors wont do shit. this dumb govt should be thrown outttt
@@doyouknowdeweyy6291 +1
Nobody has the guts to speak against Kashmir files as it is in Hindi also.
Thank god the British gave India the English language.or we could never understand eachother. Long live English language for .Education jobs visa application etc
Nobody has the guts to speak against Kashmir files as it is in Hindi also.
Thank god the British gave India the English language.or we could never understand eachother. Long live English language for .Education jobs visa application etc
India has no national language, if the national language is to be kept then the oldest language of the world Tamil or the sweetest language Bengali should be made the national language.
Hindi was created by British to divide, isn't common man's language ...
Education, Rationalism & Constitutional Awareness is missing from our country. The country's unity, sovereignty must be stood up.
The issue of Linguistic Cold War should not be raised.
Bla bla bla bla
First Shove Foreign Mother Tongue to Kannadigas… Than Say Issues of linguistic Cold war should not be Raised!!!!
@Shri Tudor - This 'linguistic cold war', as you put it, is a direct consequence of a lack of education, rationalism and constitutional awareness.
Bhaad me jaye Tami kannad telugu....apne ko kya....apne ko toh bs Hindi and English se hi mtlb h na
The road to unity of our country lies in our diversity ,you should understand that first. Your concept of nationalism is flawed and should never be accepted.
I wanna ask something. If we made everything one, then what's remaining for us to boast about?
India is very well known for it's diversity and let it be! ✌🏻
I echo to what you said bruhh👍
right ❤
Well said! If all speak the same, dress the same, build homes the same way, believe in same higher power(all human imaginations btw) etc then the whole idea of India is gone 😒 the only one getting benefitted will be the political party who will mind control the massess
You change my mind sir thank you
Ok i wanna ask you one question where was your diversity bullshit when an entire religion was wiped out from kashmir
Every language in India have their own values , we should respect that and when it comes to South they deserves Recognition
Hindi as national language is not acceptable for us Indians of the South of our great country Bharat
I really miss those days when Doordarshan used to telecast regional language movies every week. It was a nice way to show the diversity of Indian culture at national platform.
I do too, it created lot of awareness about the diversity of our culture.
Agree there use to be sign language news to cover whole week followed by regional films with subtitles. That was the best way to showcase our language diversity.
Chitramala on mondays, songs from all languages. I wait for that one tamil song.
I am from Assam and when I was studying and working in Bangalore I tried to learn the Kannada language because I loved and respected the culture of Karnataka. Hindi is also a language but it should not be imposed on other states. We can use English.
Thanks brother
Yes. Lose your own culture over a foreign language. Did English also destroy your culture like Hindi.
It’s actually Hindi speakers who are attacked physically in Tamil Nadu for speaking Hindi.
@@SoniSingh-fl8cf if someone go to north india ..mostly they have to speak in hindhi ...if someone came to Tamilnadu ..they have to give some respect to their language and try to learn and speak in Tamil only..
@@nikolatesla399 but if someone can not speak Tamil then you will attack them physically??
Fun Fact: Hindi what Bollywood use contains a lot of Arabic, Latin, Farsi etc Languages.
@༼ཆ༽ daksina bharatiyan not only virodhi of hindi bhasha all dakshin bhartiyan virodhi of sanskrit bhasha i am shudh hindi speakar (sanskrit) and i understand all sabadarth of dakshin bharatiyan bhasha😊😊😊 visesa kannada bhasha and telugu ksama sahodara i don't understand tamil bhasha because it is a kathin bhasha it is not sanskrit it is a bhinna bhasha of sansakrit
Im feared that there are chances for civil wars over the language imposition, which may finally cause the nation to spilt between North and South😔...I don't want separate South Indian nation😔😔 but if the central govt which predominantly controlled by Hindi politicians tries to impose their thoughts on us forcefully then I will definitely fight for my separate South Indian country
🔥🔥🔥
As a South Indian I know 6 languages including Hindi.. it's the same with most of the south indians. We converse with each other which ever language the other person is comfortable with. That's how we respect each other's cultures and languages. We never thought one Language is inferior than the other Until they have started to claim Hindi as a superior one .
If one language is common nd comfortable then it is a superior language . . Hope u understand bro. else god bless u .. 😂
@@parmodrana3913 but Hindi is not Common nor comfortable to South Indians and not even nost part of India .. so it cant be classified as a national language. The day hindi is declared as national language all east indians and south Indians will form seperate countries.. we have our own culture and traditions that comes with our language. Bless you too. 🙂
@@sugardust4136 bro. I didn't say that Hindi should be a national language nor we have to fight for this creepy thing .. m just saying that the language which speak commonly is superior language that's all.. soo read properly before u speak anything .. 😂😂😂
Great that u know 6 languages i know 3 (Telugu,Hindi,English) i want to learn Japanese and Sanskrit,if possible malyalam in future
Through Hindi language we connect easily without knowing any regional language .. soo yess it is a common language ..
I felt so happy to be able to understand what Shashi Tharoor said in the end cause Malayalam is not my mother tongue but I learned it out of interest. Learning new language is a very good thing but it should be out of interest not because of imposition. One can say English also imposed. But people are getting jobs based on their English speaking skills. Learning Hindi would be useful only for those who wanna go to the Hindi belt.
But Hindi people getting job in non Hindi regions do not speak local language.
@@ashitmukherjee5934 they speak English
We haryanvis accepted hindi as our first language which resulted in degradation of haryanvi and soon our culture will die with it as language is soul of culture.
Learning Hindi will primarily benifit bollywood.....
Their movie are already dubbed in many languages in order to being watched like Hollywood movies 🎥🍿 are dubbed in many multi national languages across the world
I am happy that our South Indian movie stars are recognised for the movies and work they are doing.
Respect to Sudeep - Kichha 🙏
He can't even make one video without targeting BJP, isme bhi BJP ghusa diya bc😂
@R K nonsens...
@R K I got your point...🤣🤣
@Desi#krishna FF jarur hoga. 🤣🤣🤣
We don't need a national language, we need jobs, school, good health care and we need to learn how to respect everyone who is different from us!
You are correct but our politicians debate it to divert the people
You are right 👍
Job ke liye padai karni padati hai anpad
when you go in job and you r not able to understand your colleagues language or he speaks in broken English then you will understand the problem.
This debate will always go on till Hindi is the official language of the Union. English is in no way superior to any language in our country, but it is the only language that makes sense in a diverse nation such as ours. We have 28 nations inside this Union. And the language uniting us should be a global one.
जब तुम अंग्रेजी स्वीकार कर सकते हो तो हिन्दी क्यों नही है ? हिन्दी भारतीय लोगों की सम्पर्क भाषा है ।
क्या भारतीय लोगों के लिए हिन्दी सीखना सरल है या अग्रेजी ?
इस बात पर भी ध्यान दिया करो कि भारत के किसी नागरिक को यदि पूरा भारत घूमना है तो वो किस भाषा को सम्पर्क भाषा बना करके अपनी बात समझायेगा ।
मुझे जहां तक पता है भारत की आधी से ज्यादा जनसंख्या हिन्दी समझती है ।
हिन्दी की जो छवि आप ने बनाई है अपने वीडियो में वह बहुत ज्यादा संकीर्ण है ।
पाकिस्तान नेपाल बांगला देश और अफगानिस्तान में भी लोग हिन्दी बोली को समझ सकते है।
जो कल्पना लेकर के आप और दक्षिण के कुछ स्वार्थी राजनैता अपनी रोटियां सेक रहे है ।
जितनी मेहनत किसी तमिल भाषी को english सीखने में लगती है उसके 5 % में वो हिन्दी सीख सकता है । क्यों की यह भारतीय भाषा है ।भारतीय भाषा एक दूसरे में नजदीक है ।
Because English is equidistant to everyone in India. As a South Indian, I won't feel subordinated when I speak English, as even my buddies from the North have to do the same, while if it's Hindi, the North Indians are treated as a standard for South Indians to follow.
Ajay Devgan started his career with Kannada remake movie. This man is forgetting the roots.. Be grounded Ajay Devgan.
South will always stand as beacon of hope and pride in our NATION.
Proud to be HYDERABADI
Main bhi🙋♂️
I love hyderabadi people talented ones
@@premvarmavlogs2276 toh aake jao meri jaan bhot mohabbat hai apne sheron
Purane shehar me ancient old cultural ideas rehte aur new city me advance tech life milti
Aao kabhi haveli PE.
@@md.sohailali7961 Lagta hai char Minar ke pas rehte ho, Asaduddin owaisi wali seat 🤣
@@md.sohailali7961 i was in Hyderabad for few months working there. It is an Awesome place.
Language is a medium to connect people & here we are using it to divide people!
I miss the old India🥺
I totally agree with Sudeep
I am a tamilian.And I can speak ,read and write hindi very well.we respect hindi and north indians in tamil nadu .And we expect same from north indians
Ajay Devgan: "Hindi is the national language"
The constitution of India:
*"Meh kya karu fir?Job Chordu?"*
@UCV4AAXUpZ4wiUiHRCYypXHA no ethnic group is slave of other ethnic group like Bangladesh got freedom from pakistan because of Urdu language imposition to Bengali muslims by Punjabi muslims of pakistan so we shouldn't repeat those same mistake
@@TanmayaPati how dare who ignorant compare to history..
Entire division of India was on basis of hate . And
No one is imposing .. there is difference.
And it was India who liberated east Pakistan and help it be Bangladesh
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Constitution has already left the chat.
@@rishabhsingh9902 religion and ethnicity are 2 different things Bangladesh got separated from pakistan because of ethnic division between Bengalis Punjabis and muhajirs even though both followed Islam religion and I'm not supporting anyone
Same is happening with Punjabi.. They have degraded the level of Punjabi which a child learns.. While all students learn hindi.. And they learn about hindi's poetic devices etc till class 9-10th..The Punjabi which is taught doesn't even have the poem's for which Punjabi Literature is known. (I am talking about cbse schools)
And the level of Punjabi has severly dipped from last 10 years..
Moreover the BJP led government has tried to super impose hindi.. Punjabi is restricted to be taught in army schools, and sanskrit in introduced ahead.. (Although Punjab is the state that provides a significant share of defence personnel for india.. !!)
Punjabi was removed as a recognized language in jammu and kashmir.. While after urdu, dogri, hindi etc.. Punjabi was also spoken in hilly areas.. And they have removed it..
It's is like they are trying to completely right off a Punjabi personality from a Punjabi person too.. Children here from non sikh families have started speaking hindi as the communal divide is being propagated by the government controlled media.. (Even a language now has a religion.. Wow.!!🥲.)
BJP is killing the essence of India itself.. And they claim to love india.. !!. 🥲
Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai.!!
Abe bale bale Punjab me hamesha se hi Congress ka government Raha tha aur situation 8 - 10 saal me change nahi hota cbse me Hindi compulsory subject nahi padhna toh state government me padh leta
Agree
Punjab is loosing its heritage because of Congress's no doubt
Same with Haryanavi bro 😂
have you ever read about linguistic policies of india made after partition by congress which are effective till date.i know you are hurt but please learn about the history and who distorted it.
Meanwhile here in 🇵🇰 urdu(north Indian language having 2-3% speakers mainly migrants who came from UP,bihar during partition) is imposed on us nd our native languages r declared 2nd class.. that's one of the big mistakes of Jinnah nd the reason why 🇧🇩 got independence..
Hindi is not compulsory in Tamilnadu, but in some matriculation schools they are forcing us to learn. I tried but I couldn't learn at all so left the school and later studying only two languages was stress free and now I will learn learn Hindi out of interest.
Fun fact Hindi language is not even 200 years old 🤣🤣
We know and it is not funny and that does not make any other language supreme
I feel like Hindi is slangs from prakrit language. It doesn't sound sweet or soothing whereas bengali nd marathi sound sweet.
hindi is not even a major first language of india , various languages which are considered its dialect can be identified as a separate lnguage
Oldest language
Tamil
Telugu
Kannada
What happens it older , matter to it to understand easy , people speak
One of the main reasons for the Bengalis losing confidence in the state of Pakistan was the imposition of urdu on the Bengalis.
And thank God for that. Bangladesh is so much better off now
Bhasha andolan ekhaneo hoteh choleche ekhon 😆
@@child_of_lilith 😂sahi baat hai. Lekin India k inherent unity k upar mujhe bharosha hai. Yeh ek dark phase hai... Ek time pe zaroor samjh aayega.
Yes ,, and Bangladesh became the only Country formed on linguistic basis,, A country of 20 crore formed on the basis of only one slogan"Joy bangla", 3 million people died,, :16-17 old years teenagers gave slogan of jay bangla in front of Pakistani soldiers🔥,, when the army ask to say pakistan Zindabad...
dont make this issue anti india.
Any of the current regional languages are alive because they are being carried out over generations because of parents teaching their kids and being used in their daily communication. Being a telugite i know how to learn and write Telugu . But im like only one out of my 10 school friends who can do this. In my school we had hindi as primary language and Telugu as secondary language. Lets say is this is being carried forward, most of new gen kids will never have enough resources to learn and write Telugu and eventually it will die . And this is how a hindi imposition will effect regional languages if we do not teach them importance of mother tongue or its culture. I really appreciate how tamil people be stubborn about their language or priorities. We are already aware of how other regional languages of Bihar and Rajasthan similarly suffered because of Hindi imposition.
Hindians don't want Indians be togather. Hindians are only Hindi speaker. Indians can speak Hindi but they love their mother language. Also a Language is amalgamation of common intelligible dialects. Gujarati is a language, Marathi is a language, Kashmirean is a language, Gadwali is a language, Madhesi (Bhojpuri) is a language, Maithili is a language, Magadhi (Magahi) is a language, Odishi (Oria) is a language, Sanskrtam is a language, Prakrtam is a language, Kannada is a language, Tamil is a language, Malyalam is a language, Nepali is a language, Bangali is a language, Assamese is a language, Rajaputani is a language, Malawi is a language, Chhattragarhi is a Language.
India is diverse. Hindia is divisor.
Hindians please Respect non-Hindian India. Otherwise we will be separated.
I love speaking Hindi but I love speaking Punjabi and Kaurawi too.
And I am a non-Hindian. I am Gadwali which is spoken from Himachal Pradesh to Uttarakhand and Eastern Nepal. Although Gadwali is still struggling to enter 8th schedule of Constitution of India. But we are hopeful and strong belief in Republican values. One day our language Gadwali will be in 8th schedule and official language of state of Gadwall. (under republic of republics of India) Please don't try to impose Hindi. We don't hate it. But we surely will hate you Hindians.
Let India be diversed not divided.
Thanks & Regards
It's foolish to fight on languages. Everyone has own mother tongue. A movie with a good script will be understood in any language. So where is the need to debate on movies on the basis of language?
exectly.this is getting dangerous now.people are hating each other within country.
Petrol price is over Rs100. BJP needs new issues to distract people 😂
There is a difference between mother tongue and national language. My mother tongue is Bengali but there should be one unified language in India for transparency and which is well understandable among us. Humare yaha mother tongue leke itna ego h logo me which is barier to unity and dangerous 😄
@@DarthVader-no9cc English hai to. It's also a global language which allows our workforce to be competitive globally. People say that it is the language of our colonizers, but the reality of today is that English is the link language of the world. In a day and age where even China is shedding it's insularity to English, we, who have the competitive edge in English historically are going in the opposite direction, led by chauvinistic and idiotic politicians. These morons aren't gonna lose anything, they have a lot of money hoarded up. It's the common man like you and I, brother, who will suffer from this misguided direction that the country is going in. English is the global present, fortunately or unfortunately, and India cannot change that about the world.
@@samarthraizada English is necessary but it it is not our own language. Btw you don't need English to become successful. Japan , china south korea all these countries prefer their own languages. They are all successful.
Hindi Is Not A National Language.
Basically , India Is " The Union Of States".
Every State Has It's Own Language.
No India is not a union of state it is a country and it has 22 official language ... Bcz u r a bangladeshi u r spreading propaganda so stop it ... Yes some none seanse said Hindi is national language bcz they have no idea what constitution said ... We must short our internal problems ... Don't interfere in our internal matter .....
@@kamleshnarayan3286 भाई भारत देश अमेरिका के जैसे कोई राज्यों से बना जरूर है पर अमेरिका के राज्य कभी भी अमेरिका से अलग हो सकता है पर भारत के राज्य (जल्दी) अलग नहीं हो शकते है क्योकी भारत के लौह पुरुष सरदार वल्लभ भाई पटेल है और अमेरिका का लौह पुरुष टोनी स्टार्क है किसी का परवाह नहीं होता है
Hindi is first language of nine states plus second or third language of few states. Thought hindi is not national language yet it is Raj Bhasha.
@@chuichi15 Hindi is first language of nine states plus second or third language of few states. Thought hindi is not national language yet it is Raj Bhasha.
@@kamleshnarayan3286 Hey man you have not studied constitution properly ... Thought india is called a federal democracy yet is not totally federal like us. India is called quasi federal and now we call it cooperative federal. India is not united states of india..mind it
Covered nicely most points... I'm form South and I loved this conversation... Yes I learnt in school and watching movies like any other subject because of 3 language policy. And I did watch lot of movies so I can easily talk or understand this convo
The way of expressing is very good 👌👌👌 from Tamil Nadu
Iam a kanndiga and I would like to say what sudeep said is very accurate.
There are many north Indians who stay in Bangalore and completely deny to learn kannada and disrespect our language.
North Indians shows superiority over their language .
We respect all languages and so only I'm able to watch u and we expect all these people to respect out language.
Forget about cinema ,they should respect our language in all perspective.
True that's the weakness of South Indians we always welcome and learn North Indian languages and we have sense of welcome to their culture.
@udit singh He has more to lose than gain by saying what he said. He is so damn popular in Karnataka already that he does not need this controversy to gain political mileage at all. He can chose any constituency and any party through out Karnataka and can position himself to win. He has more to lose by what he said than gain - His multi-crore investment movie "Vikrant Rona" is coming out and Hindi dubbing is a big market. Why would he dent his own money making prospect at this time by raking up a controversy. All he meant to say was - Don't call only Hindi movies Indian movies and all non-Hindi and South Indian movies as pan-Indian. All are Indian movies and Hindi is not THE national language of India for only it to be called Indian movie and all others pan-Indian.
@@bw8026 He is not right.
@@bw8026 yes in continuation he said that for only its movies to be called Indian and all others pan Indian.
And this is also truth that south Indians try to be superior than north Indians.
I am a Hindi speaker & I firmly believe that Hindi is NOT my national language. Every Indian is my brother/sister regardless which part of the country you belong to.
Appreciate your viewpoint.👍
When u r going to join al Qaeda?
Thanx bro welcome from Bengal
But you have to agree that it's our major and a important language
Aap believe karen ya na karen..Hindi hai hi nahin national language. Official language hai.
India has more than 1600 languages, 22 scheduled languages and 2 official languages. No language should be declared national language. We must respect all languages. We are the citizens of India, it is our duty to keep this country united without any discrimination. Jai Hind 🇮🇳💖
Those scheduled languages that you are talking about is also official languages. The 2 official languages that you are talking about is actually link languages or connecting languages or common languages to interact between different states of this country. It is just that instead of link or connecting or common - official languages words are coined.
Those two languages are official languages of Union government, not India.
22 scheduled are the official languages of India.
@@chethands3862 ss every state has ammended their own languages for assembly
Exactly
Long time ago I used to think English was the first language in European Union as well, just like Hindi is our first language! I later travelled through Europe and learned that local language is always the first language and each country learns at least 2 more languages in school. I have also talked to locals there and they have mutual respect for other languages as well.
That's when I decided to learn local language in South India which my family was reluctant to learn. Today I can speak and write in local language and am encouraging my kids to do the same as well.
For the harmony of our diverse nation, imposition of any language is detrimental. Diversity and inclusion of all languages and local cultures at grassroots level is a necessity, not a choice.
Salute.. India need people like you sir.
I was born in Karnataka but being north Indian . I have always respected kannada before hindi because a place can only be developed until and unless it is connected to its grass roots
jai Karnataka jai hind bharat mata ki jai
@Gaurang Sharma - भाई तो क्या दिल्ली, उत्तर प्रदेश, मुंबई, मध्य प्रदेश, गुजरात ये सब क्या विकशीत नहीं है क्या तुम को यह कहना चाहिए की मैं जहां पैदा हुआ हूं वह स्थान मुझे बहुत प्यारा है और बचपन से कन्नड़ सुनने और बोलने से मैं हिंदी भाषा से ज्यादा कन्नड़ भाषा को पसंद करता हूं सब को अपना जन्म स्थान प्यारा होता है और होना चाहिए मेरे देश के 28 राज्य है तो इसलीये अपने देश में एक राष्ट्रीय भाषा होना चाहिए और हमारे देश में हिंदी भाषा सबसे ज्यादा बोली जाती है तो इसलीये राष्ट्रीय भाषा हिंदी होनी चाहिए
@@dreambig990 what if we don't have national language in India? Does country fall?
Indian constitution itself told there no national language for India. What's your problem now?
There are many peoples spoke hindhi that is why hindhi is official language of india.
We respect hindhi always and forever no doubt in that.
Don't impose on us as national language.
What Ajay Devgan said it's completely false. Lets respect eachother language.
@OMG yaaa of course
@@dreambig990 national language rakhna is not a priority . Instead go ask to government that where are jobs and why petrol is becoming expensive if you really want to see your country to be developed then ask questions to central government
@@dreambig990 aurr haaan aise toh dogs ki population 30 million hai toh kya national animal dogs ko hona chaiye kya? Be logical and sensible bro plzz grow up
Being from Kerala lived my whole life in Delhi and Now in FRANCE, i got influence by multiple language andits customs. Language is a pride of the region and helps uniting and understanding the culture. I have nothing against HINDI. it is a beautiful language but shoving it forcefully in the mouth of others is totally wrong and people are bound to hate it. Sure india needs a common language accessible for all but not at the cost of degrading other regional language.
Nice video Deshbhakt as always
Very true 👍👍
U are right brother.
Absolutely !!!!
English k bina future possible hi nhi
So let english be the connecting language.🙏🙏
That's why make English as India's official language
No more wars
Great Akash, the way situations are analyzed and the facts are conveyed is interesting!!! Becoming a fan of your work.
We are proud Kannadiga and we love our Language , culture and at the same we respect other languages also. I found ajay devgan is rude, arrogant and ignorant. May God bless with wisdom.
Wherever the seeds of such hatred and religions poison have been sown, that country has never progressed. History is witness 🙏
Unequivocally true
Well,that's because the law and order and indian politics after independence is a joke..
That kind of country did not made only progress is true but that kind of country has also been destroyed also.
i prefer constitutional monarchy like in UK and japan
This is why SC Bose wanted to have dictatorship in India during the initial days of independence.
Well, I am a north indian from Bihar and we belong to the so called hindi belt, but if I am being honest there are more people who don't speak hindi than hindi speakers in bihar, they speak region languages like Bhojpuri, Magahi, Maithili, Angika and Vajjika(and I am not gonna call them dialects, they are languages, they have their own history) they are not recognized by goi just to increase hindi speakers on paper, but this fact can't be ignored.Even my own grandma can't speak hindi she does understand it...
@NEET ASPIRANT exactly,
And same happened to me I was never taught my languages too, not because my parents thought of it as inferior but nobody spoke it around me so I never learned...
But I sometimes try to learn it on my own.
Yes bro I also agree...I am from UP every farmer here speaks bhojpuri....but due to hindi imposition.. bhojpuri is killed here day by day....now slowly everybody wants to speak fluent Hindi which is bad... disrespecting your identity is the worst thing can happen to you.... 🇮🇳
Pure Hindi sirf Up and Mp hi bolta hai. Baki saare Northern states ki apni apni alag bhasha hai. Aur woh Hindi nahi hai.
@@sanjeet.bhattacharjee.6657 UP bhojpuri in East and haryanvi hindi in west
That's the reason I don't like Hindi much, being from northeast we got against it coz it might threaten our own languages and our language may end up like Awadhi and others which are now under Hindi belt considered as dehati languages.
Also because Bollywood is racist, I am from Nepali community every time bollywood shows a Nepali character, either they show Nepali women as prostitutes or show Nepali men as watchmen, spreading racism more and more against my community hence the reason I never watch bollywood.
Hindi was not a national language and will not be a national language.
OPINION: bollywood has became dumb, bollywood has given many brilliant movies but now money and politics has ruined bollywood movies
@Drithi arre ajay devgan ki vajah se ni vaise hi jo movies ajj kal ati h uski story kuch khaas ni hoti Just My Opinion
@@gurnoor05 bro watch Ajay's runway 34. its damn good 🔥 aur acchi films nahi aa rahi matlab 2 months se sab bas Jersey ke naam se bollywood ko badnaam kar rahe hai aur vo flim bhi acchi hai aise blindly hate mat karo audience ke iss chutiype ki wajah se attack jaisi acchi sci fi action movie flop ho gayi bollywood acchi movies banata tha aur aage bhi banayega bas 2-3 kharaab movies se hate mat karo aur jaha Kgf aur RRR ki taaref kar rahe he jo karni bhi chahiye usi industries ne Radhe Shyam aur Beast jaisi ghatiya movies bhi banayi hai lekin use ignore kiya jaayega...kisi industry ko politics se judge mat karo unke films se karo🙏
Proud Bengali. Proud Indian. Not a Hindian. India is not India without its diversity.
Perfect comment👏
And sadly in many non Hindi state...hindians try to impose Hindi...
English se takleef nahi hai...hindi se takleef hai tumlogo ko..kya doglapan hai..
@@Bk-be4zq 1. English is a global language, thus fetches more opportunities.
2. It doesn't give undue advantage to the Hindi speaking states when it comes to professional proficiency.
3. And last but not the least, nobody associates subtle Nationalism with English, as many do wrt Hindi. Thus it doesn't undermine the history and importance other Indian languages.
Each and every country has its own language , like--
China- Chinese
Japan- Japanese
Russia- Russian
France- French
Germany- German
Korea- Korean
Spain- Spainish
Bhutan- Donzkha
Malyesia- Malay etc.
These countries don't give importance to English language and pursue their education in their own language.. so we can say English is not a global language..it is language of Britain, America and Australia only.
why do south Indians learn English? that too crooked..if they can learn english..what's the problem with learning Hindi?
Why should we learn Hindi is it some special or what.
16:34 All Bollywood actors are busy in doing nepotism whereas R Madhavan encouraged his son in swimming and he is trying his best to give India a medal in swimming in Olympics which India has never got.This clearly shows the difference between Bollywood and South Industry.
Bhaiya Telugu Film Industry is full of Nepotism. Ram Charan, Jr NTR, Allu Arjun, etc are all products of nepotism.
I am from Mumbai. My mother tongue is Marathi and i can speak Hindi and English as well. I regret that I know only 3 languages. I would have loved to learn more languages to connect with fellow Indians. However, now it's difficult considering age and work but if I move to any other state i would make sure that i learn that state language.
Barobar she pan baki loka marathi shikat nahit ani aplyala hindi bolavi lagte he chukta 🚩
English kohi zaroorat nahi Marathi aur Hindi kaafi hai kyon tum log nahi samajh parahi hai ki English baat karne se hum apni bhasha bhool te jaare hai. Hame apne bhasha ko bhi zaroorati dekhni chaiye.
@@alfiemandella2258 hindi was never our language its half urdu so we'll speak only marathi &english
@@mjc8891 हिंदी बोलणे ही वाईट गोष्ट नाही, मी सुद्धा मराठी कुटुंबातील आहे, माझे आई वडील दोन भाषांत बोलू शकतात, पण आम्ही त्यांच्याशी इंग्रजीवर बोलतो तेव्हा त्यांना समजत नाही, आम्ही भारताचे नागरिक आहोत.इंग्रजी बोलण्याची गरज नाही इंग्रजी बोलणे म्हणजे इंग्रजांचे तळवे चाटणे.
@@alfiemandella2258 haa mag shudh hindi bolayla jamnar ahe ka? Urdu misrit hindi mhanje mughalanche talve chatne.... marathi sanskrit la sarvat javal ahe ani english global bhasha ahe
Don't Hate Hindi In The Name Of Bollywood
Here in USA, English is NOT the "official" language while overwhelming majority speaks English.
Fun fact - Ajay devgans biggest hits are remakes of malyalam n tamil movi Drishiyam n Singham..He might be high on Vimal that day.
He is also set to make two more telugu remakes.
Golmaal, 90s films, singh , many hits he have given
@@rtiripshi4432 golmaal was the remake of malyalam film - kakkakuyil...sin of sirdar was remake of telugu movie - maryada ramanna...even his 99s hit kachhe dhage was a remake of kache dhage from the 70s .his 90s hits are shitty where he mostly played a jilted lover which the chapri audience still make tik tok videos of..the only movie which is good not a renake is 'gangajal'...
@@rtiripshi4432 when u get to know these all movies are remake of South movie
@@rtiripshi4432 Ab bol mc
@@vihaangowda1922 tanaji was original
Raid was original
It's so amazing that since years Bollywood is making films remakes of South films and now they consider themselves superior .... Irony ✌️
Well said Ravinder
Hindi is not the national language.
Every language in India is a national language
Ajay devgn's tweet showed arrogance and ignorance which was never expected from him.
We have Soooo much time to discuss about religion, language, speakers etc etc etc in a country but no time for developmental and real issues……….??? !!!’🤦🏻♂️
Real fact bro
It's very sad thing that even educated,talented ppl are getting trapped in the mess of devide and rule politics.
Because of money
Being a telugu speaker I'm so happy
I would say we don't hate or push hindi to the hill side but please don't mandate it. We want true entertainment.
If Marathi speaking people have no problem in learning Hindi why South Indians don't speak Hindi but atleast learn it.It's really a pain traveling to non-hindi speaking states if they atleast don't know even basic Hindi
So as per your logic if we south people travelling to north then north people must learn our southern languages....then we feel painless right!!!??? Have some sense man...
South people have no problem to learn english because every information about studies and sciences etc is available in English.... so no need to learn hindi because no use in it... and we south people can speak and understand english very well so learn english that is very useful to you to travel not only south India but throughout the world....
If you want to travel anywhere then you must learn their regional language but don't ask them to learn your language for your sake bcz its just meaningless....
I am from Karnataka. I fluently speak more than 3 Indian Languages. I do not know Bengali but have watched and enjoyed few Bengali movies without translation. Language is a beautiful medium that helps us connect with different cultures.
Bollywood is going downhill also because of the recent controversies/ incidents lile Sushanth singh Rajput case, Drug abuse cases and many more.
This is beauty of our country. Very few country have language diversification
Rajesh hai
Must be Feluda and byomkesh is it?
exactly same here... i totally stopped watching Hindi movies after SSR demise, am also from Karnataka 😇
Which Bengali movies you have watched?? Please let me know!!!
Honestly, Hindi or any other language speaking group should not get any unfair advantage or disadvantage in any exam or opportunity.. all languages are great.. trying to learn Kannada being a Bengali. It's a challenge but it's such a sweet language...
Questions in Upsc are only printed in English and Hindi.
@@SonuSinghmirzapur Exactly
Most of Central govt job exams are only in Hindi and English, its unfair.
Upper class English medium students always get some advantage. But underprivileged non-Hindi students gets the massive disadvantage in this. Someones disadvantage is other's advantage. Now is it fair or ethical In 21st century India? I felt the same years back when appeared for IIT JEE.
@@newtd2988 me too
Hindi language itself has no origin. The language is a register of hindustani which was culmination of multiple language spoken in the so called hindi belt we call today. The standardized hindi that everyone learns today was standardized in 1949, which begs the question How can you make a language that is so new to the country a national language. If they wanna make it a national language then they need to make Hindustani or khariboli national as well because that's what hindi and urdu uses as its base and then sugarcoats with either persian loan words or sanskrit loan words. Like, Bollywood Actors should only focus on acting as they are not really bright from what i've seen so far. And ajay devgan should also know that most of the bollywood movies are using Hindustani language not the Modern Standardized Hindi he is talking about, This is so that both India and pakistan can understand. If they start making movies in shudh hindi, nobody will ever watch it.
Finally, Someone said it!
Love and respect for all southern language ❤️🙏
ಲವ್ ಯು ❤😊
Meanwhile kangana : "Sanskrit should be national language".
🤣🤣🤣🤣 Iska alag hi chalta hai
right wing ki kangana
aur left wing ki swara
pata nahi yeh dono khud sochte hai bolne se pehele
par kam se kam kangana acchi flim toh karleti hai swara toh puri politiician bane ki teyari me hai
Sanskrit is our national language
@@rushikeshtitare8826 No
@@rushikeshtitare8826 no, it's not
@@rushikeshtitare8826 just asking out of curiosity.. can you converse in sanskrit?
I respect hindi and all other regional languages but I'm borne Marathi, My mother tongue is Marathi and I always find myself comfortable speaking in Marathi. I always take pride in my Marathi language. Even when I speak Hindi my tone of speaking hindi comes Marathi. I speak hindi only and when it is necessary as every regional language speaker does. I'm not too good at speaking english but I try speaking it as and when it is necessary. I'm indian🇮🇳 and this is my identity as Indian National but I'm Indian because I'm Marathi and that's how Marathi represent India's language diversity as one language amongst many regional languages like, Telgu, Marwari, Odia etc. which again represents India as a Linguistical diverse nation which makes India 🇮🇳 one and complete India. Proud to be Indian.. Proud to be Maharashtrian Marathi speaker.
Well said. Wish all the marathi manus would be as mature and wise as you are.
I am from Karnataka. I LOVE Bengali, Punjabi, Bhojpuri and Santhali.
Moral of the story :- this UA-camr just trying to say that Hindi is nothing more important for India🙂🙏B's KR Bhai
This Southern success is the Second 'Slap' that Bollywood received after Bahubali !!
@Drithi saw a comment that made sense after a long time.
@Drithi madam dangal china alli release aggirlilla andre irthitha??? 2000 crores? and aamir khan was already an established actor who had a lot of fame unlike a new actor like prabhas
@Drithi kannadigaru baahubali nodi urkondru antha yaar heldru maam...
@Drithi dangal become highest grossing in 2018 after releasing in China. Before that bahubali was highest grosser
@Drithi You need an explainer ?! With due respect to every Film industry in this country, don't take the word 'slap' as an offense. The word 'slap' was used as a wake-up call to Bollywood at one point of time, specially after the popularity of Bahubali. Because, Bollywood was making shitty movies barring a few exceptions (Sanjay Leela Bhansali). Of course, Dangal as an exception made big on international arena. But the movie is not about Creativity, special effects, and storyline. It is rather based on social issues. And its not about how many crores it made. Bahubali is known for its great special effects, Big scale, storyline and creativity, which Bollywood movies (and for that matter Southern film industry) hugely missed for long time. Bahubali was a Game-changer and it made a huge International audiences. In fact, it was Karan Johar who first said that Bahubali is a 'beautiful slap' on our faces.
Spanish should be the national language of India 🤣🤣🤣🤣👌👌
😂🤣🤭
hola de corazon
Hablas Espanol ?
french krrlo bhai saal lagakar seekhi hai maine but abhi bhi meri frech panjabi accent wali hai
@@laba3423 🤣🤣😂👍
Guys Don't force Hindi to your nonspeaking Hindi Indian friends
we are all Indians If I am comfortable I speak English or Tamil
I hate the fact that hindi speaking is considered as superior to other regional languages... I do understand hindi but not fluent in speaking... so I face problems every time I called customer care or even local shops in Kolkata... they don't seem make any efforts to learn local language just because they are hindi speakers...
Hindi is hybrid language... already it has destroyed bhojpuri,Orissa,Marathi,rajastini,Punjabi, Gujarati film industry...etc...in future South films will be dubbed in all above languages and Hindi will automatically will get less screens...
Look how Riots, Azaan, Hanuman Chalisa and Bulldozer made us forgot everything,
Inflation, Unemployment, Petrol, Diesel School fees, Expensive Courses and Experience Medicines.
Sri Lankans had also forgotten.
You remember😅
I understand and support your point but not your profile name. You are again showing the same mentality of abusing people with other ideologies(irrespective of whether they are right or wrong).
My humble suggestion - please change your profile name brother, and put a respectable one and promote an environment where we can all discuss and debate peacefully, only then can things be better, when people understand what is right and what's wrong rather than falling for propaganda. Otherwise, what would be the difference between you and any other IT Cell troll(except for ideology, but still, we can't fall to their level, right?).
Mission mitroooooon successful!
@@moubhattacharyya1141 OLA HU UBER
U can't escape from kiccha sudeep,,, he is larger than life..... If u mess with him, he will make sure that u have to pay the price..... ✌✌✌🔥
bas ek chiz bolne yahan aaya hun hindi hmari national language banke hi rahegi 😂😂
My mother tongue is Hindi, i speak Kannada and Tamil. Hindi should not be imposed on non Hindi speakers. Respect all languages but hate colonization. Hindi or any language should not be our National language. Rather government should include more languages in the list of official languages.
Bhai may be your mother tongue is Urdu or more specifically dakhni dialect of urdu not hindi, mine also dakhni Urdu but iam also fluent in kannada and Telugu....
@@khabibnurmagomedov8581 bhai usko behter pata hoga na uska mother tongue kya hai? just saying.
No one is imposing Hindi, on the contrary it is Hindi speakers who are physically attacked in Tamil Nadu for spea in Hindi.