LIVE Ruby Franke Full Court Hearing, Guilty Plea and Plea Agreement. Lawyer Reacts.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 751

  • @sherryvera2639
    @sherryvera2639 8 місяців тому +387

    I hope that the “parents” who were following this family and potentially copying their “parenting” understand that it’s abuse and can land you in jail

    • @hfrisch007
      @hfrisch007 8 місяців тому +19

      They won't , they hope she gets off🙄

    • @zxs7170
      @zxs7170 8 місяців тому +45

      There is a commenter on a lot of Ruby’s case videos, who is constantly defending her. Her user name is Sharflife4. I checked her channel. Her main content is her children’s injuries, hospital visits, ailments….. very disturbing and very suspect. I wonder if she is a part of/one of “the mothers of truth” nonsense and is practicing the same a*busive type of behavior Ruby & Jodi were preaching. There are a lot of extremely disturbing people out there having children & a*busing the life out of their children who support each other’s way of “parenting.”

    • @ThePolypam
      @ThePolypam 8 місяців тому

      ​@@zxs7170 wow. Can you report her somehow?

    • @zxs7170
      @zxs7170 8 місяців тому +18

      I meant Sharplife4- the commenter who seems to be defending Ruby & Jodi on this channel and others. Her own channel has some disturbing content as well. Mostly videos of her children’s ailments, hospital visits & medical emergencies….very concerning!

    • @samantham4351
      @samantham4351 8 місяців тому +21

      Anyone who sees this if you see crimes against children online, find the state they are in and mass report them to police immediately(not UA-cam etc they do nothing), please! I’m not in the USA so can’t yet y’all can whom are.

  • @SuzanTisdaleCheekyWench
    @SuzanTisdaleCheekyWench 8 місяців тому +283

    Ruby was abusing these children long before Jody came into the picture. Jody just gave her permission to amp up the abuse. My heart breaks for these children.

    • @LovelyHope2
      @LovelyHope2 8 місяців тому +15

      I agree with you 💯%. I can’t even imagine how this would’ve ended up had that baby not escaped 💔

    • @CustomPortraitArtist
      @CustomPortraitArtist 8 місяців тому +10

      Actually, that's not true. Jodi has been in the Frankie's lives long before 'Connections'. Jodi was the therapist to the oldest son and several others in the family. Jodi was also the therapist to a general authority and several others in the leadership of the Mormon/LDS church. Go listen to the talks given by president Richard Scott. As a female teen in the Mormon church we were told that it would better for us to die fighting back if raped then to allow the rape to happen. You would be responsible for the second sin next to murder... Sex was second to murder. Jodi has been a horrific influencer in the Mormon church. Many of the torture and mind manipulation Jodi practices and taught Ruby is MKUltra techniques. Jodi's father was military.... I believe Jodi is an MKUltra child and now a therapist that practices mk ultra.

    • @DidgiPuddy
      @DidgiPuddy 8 місяців тому +2

      Thank you, I didn't know that. Interesting to learn a bit about Jodie's upbringing background and I've never heard of mk ultra before x

    • @kenyonbissett3512
      @kenyonbissett3512 8 місяців тому

      @@CustomPortraitArtistinteresting, when I was coming up, we were told to lay passively so as not to be injured. That advice has since change. With that came the common use of drugs (ketamine, GHB and rohypnol) by predators.

    • @wmdkitty
      @wmdkitty 8 місяців тому +7

      @@CustomPortraitArtist Yeah... no. This conspiracy BS isn't it.

  • @murphyudx
    @murphyudx 8 місяців тому +160

    Ruby has been withholding food from her children as punishment way BEFORE Jody came on the scene. Neither Ruby nor Kevin should ever get custody of the children. 😢

    • @RestingBeachFace721
      @RestingBeachFace721 8 місяців тому +23

      In regards to Kevin, how you got 6 kids and you don’t know what’s going on?

    • @murphyudx
      @murphyudx 8 місяців тому +19

      Exactly. Kevin is a deadbeat dad. He was there when the vlog was active and knew about Ruby's abuse. Kevin has no spine.😢

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому +9

      AbSoLuteLy Correct !!!
      The # 1 concern is that those kids NEVER have to see or hear from Ruby, Kevin, or Jodi again. EVER.
      When they are each over 21 years old, they can decide for themselves if they want to talk to mom or dad on the phone, OR Not.

    • @InternetJury
      @InternetJury 8 місяців тому +2

      No, this isn't true. Jodi has been an influence on the family for much longer than people think. They just didn't advertise it.

    • @wmdkitty
      @wmdkitty 8 місяців тому +3

      @@InternetJury Wow. Nope. Wrong.

  • @_Churchy
    @_Churchy 8 місяців тому +91

    Deprogramming from coercive control/brainwashing takes longer than 3 months. I know. I was raised within a religious group that fosters cognitive dissonance and relies heavily on suppressing individual thought. I left when I was 19 and at 47 I still have to work at listening to my own conscience and not falling back into the distorted world view I was taught as a child.
    In my opinion Ruby Franke is entirely responsible for what she did to HER children (Jodi is also entirely responsible for her actions). Your job as a parent is to PROTECT your children from danger, not be the source of it!
    And again, imo, Ruby Franke has plead guilty because she's ashamed...not of her actions but because she got found out. My heart goes out to her kids ❤

    • @TJ-wz3tt
      @TJ-wz3tt 8 місяців тому +5

      Indeed

    • @bluebell1
      @bluebell1 8 місяців тому +5

      I agree 💯

    • @Linda-dr7vp
      @Linda-dr7vp 8 місяців тому

      Jodi is in prison in St. George. Ruby is in prison in North Utah (Salt Lake area).

    • @gustavedore1073
      @gustavedore1073 8 місяців тому +2

      Happy that you got away ❤️‍🩹

  • @GruntyHerder
    @GruntyHerder 8 місяців тому +50

    I never thought I would see this day. I suffered so many of the same abuses as the Franke children. Sometimes hearing coverage has been so triggering I've almost vomited. Adults in my childhood knew what was going on but there was never an intervention until I ran away as a minor and never went back. I'm in tears here, listening to Ruby pronounce "guilty, guilty, guilty."
    I feel awful that it's felt so healing for me to hear the public demonize these people for what they did to those children. My abusers will never see their day in court. They don't even think they did anything wrong. I'm certain Ruby and Jodi don't think they're in the wrong. I hope they get help. I hope they will see what they've done and why it's wrong and feel true remorse.
    I hope more than anything that all of the Franke kids are safe forever now, that they get the therapy they need, and the love and cherishing they've always deserved. This has never been their fault and I hope they can know that truly.

    • @Vixenspirit
      @Vixenspirit 8 місяців тому +9

      I'm so sorry that happened to you. I hope you've been able to find some healing ❤

    • @GruntyHerder
      @GruntyHerder 8 місяців тому +6

      @@Vixenspirit Thank you 💜 It's a work in progress, and it feels like it got worse before it started getting marginally better. Almost have to mentally relive it so it can be reprocessed and recontextualized. I have a therapy session today and we are definitely going to talk about this

    • @gracemiller3861
      @gracemiller3861 8 місяців тому +6

      I'm sorry you had to go through that! I hope that you are able to find some peace and I wish and hope that you get justice. No one should be hurting anyone!

  • @adramatree
    @adramatree 8 місяців тому +278

    she was guilty of child abuse way before she started hanging around with Jodi. This is rediculous.

    • @SharpLife4
      @SharpLife4 8 місяців тому

      Wrong and that can be proven with the church records

    • @TJ-wz3tt
      @TJ-wz3tt 8 місяців тому

      What's the plea deal,anyone know yet??

    • @kahsindra
      @kahsindra 8 місяців тому +1

      THIS!!!!!!!!! 👆

    • @kristinbyers6275
      @kristinbyers6275 8 місяців тому +13

      ​@@TJ-wz3ttthe plea deal was that she dropped 2 charges and will serve consecutive sentences but the time per sentence is left up to the judge minimum 4 years maximum 15 (16-60).

    • @sallycinnamon5370
      @sallycinnamon5370 8 місяців тому +20

      @@kristinbyers6275I know everyone online feels like every person should serve a life sentence. Personally I am in favour of any sentence that will see her put away for enough time that her children can grow to be adults without having to worry about that they will have to go testify about their mom and in a worst case scenario she is found not guilty and pursues them retuning to her custody as children.

  • @valentinat3250
    @valentinat3250 8 місяців тому +93

    They should keep her in prison until her youngest child is 18, at least.

    • @dawn5227
      @dawn5227 8 місяців тому +12

      Longer than that

    • @athanksgivingbaby570
      @athanksgivingbaby570 8 місяців тому +10

      I think that's likely. 1 - 15 years per charge. Mid - Range would be 7 per charge and she plead to 4. 4 terms of say 5 years each would be 20 years. The youngest is 9 or 10 years old.

    • @carochan86
      @carochan86 8 місяців тому +16

      I like 32 years because then her youngest will be Frankie's current age.

    • @molliwilson5639
      @molliwilson5639 8 місяців тому +7

      She will have to go to FAMILY COURT ( after prison) to see if she even has visitation. Again, this is CRIMINAL COURT. They are separate .

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому +1

      Amen!!!

  • @gigi2k326
    @gigi2k326 8 місяців тому +61

    I'm glad the children will not have to testify against their mother that is great for them but I doubt she did it for that reason she was saving herself the shame and embarrassment

  • @ndgrandma2124
    @ndgrandma2124 8 місяців тому +235

    Kevin is guilty also. The starvation began before Jodi entered the scene.

    • @SharpLife4
      @SharpLife4 8 місяців тому +5

      Wrong. Jody has been around through the church for years and years. And gave her books to read on how to discipline

    • @MeganSpruce90
      @MeganSpruce90 8 місяців тому +7

      Was thinking the same thing!

    • @MeganSpruce90
      @MeganSpruce90 8 місяців тому +8

      ​@@SharpLife4I believe that, but her presence in the Franke family was definitely more so in the last couple of years

    • @TJ-wz3tt
      @TJ-wz3tt 8 місяців тому +14

      ​@therealz360z7He should be going to trial too

    • @RestingBeachFace721
      @RestingBeachFace721 8 місяців тому +4

      @therealz360z7 he’s doing it to get custody of their kids. They’ll probably reunite.

  • @Ms.Prairie
    @Ms.Prairie 8 місяців тому +161

    Swoop sent me!
    I’m a survivor and it’s so hard to find intellectual coverage / legal content on these troubling topics. That’s not an easy get these days and it’s so refreshing to have found you!
    Thank you for your compassion and knowledge-sharing! (You also seem like a BAMF and I’m excited to get to know your vibe 😂❤)

  • @loveboxers7554
    @loveboxers7554 8 місяців тому +68

    These two women were abusive control freaks and are equally culpable of this horrible abuse of these poor children.

  • @maryland2213
    @maryland2213 8 місяців тому +109

    For personal MH reasons, I’ve avoided this case, I knew EDB would cover without sensationalizing it. Thank you.

    • @Julie-si3hi
      @Julie-si3hi 8 місяців тому +3

      Please take care of yourself x

  • @walela
    @walela 8 місяців тому +39

    I hope she is never allowed to be around her children again until they are adults and it is up to them to decide. A forty some year old woman with 4 kids needs to take responsibility for her actions! Also, the husband should be held accountable. How sad for those children.

  • @BellaRenee7514
    @BellaRenee7514 8 місяців тому +12

    As much as I agree that not testifying against a parent is more beneficial to the kiddos at this time. In the long run, the kids won’t have as much time free from her in the future. As a survivor of severe sexual and physical abuse at the hands of the person who gave birth to me, 17 years seemed like a long time when the plea deal was offered. Now, I hate the fact that the defendant in my case only received less than half of what she could have received if we had gone to trial and I testified against her. It’s a catch 22 either way. My heart breaks for these kiddos and am also so glad the older kiddo was able to get away and save them both. Kudos to you buddy! You are a hero!

  • @gemini6166
    @gemini6166 8 місяців тому +36

    She walked in all smug and smiling and you could tell that she grudgingly pled guilty. She faked feeling bad or sorry when she spoke. She deserves harsh prison time. Clearly she is going to testify against her co defendant, even though she has been guilty of child neglect and abuse for years before ever meeting the other abuser who I refuse to say her name.

  • @AngelEowyn
    @AngelEowyn 8 місяців тому +53

    She hasn't learned a thing. She is doing what she always did - avoiding accountability. Wow!

    • @kevinstrother8712
      @kevinstrother8712 8 місяців тому +2

      At least she didn't pull out a ukulele and start singing her plea deal, although she did blame Jodi for everything.

  • @Daaaanielle
    @Daaaanielle 8 місяців тому +101

    It's so eerie seeing her plead "Gulty" even if we already knew she was.

  • @Angelface11
    @Angelface11 8 місяців тому +115

    Jody didn't make her leave her kids for weeks at a time. Jody didn't make her starve them. I mean Jodi's culpable for her own things but this is just nuts. Children are not plants children are special and precious and I sincerely hope she really gets it because she treated them like things. That's how Narcs treat kids

    • @HughMadBro
      @HughMadBro 8 місяців тому +7

      This 💯🤷🏼‍♀️ Some people push their body's & do IVF to never get a child & she popped them out to be her "workers" & live in "TRUTH" 🤦🏼‍♀️😣 Them children didn't deserve that!!!

    • @SharpLife4
      @SharpLife4 8 місяців тому +3

      People can be brainwashed. It’s a real thing.

    • @ethanknox8
      @ethanknox8 8 місяців тому +1

      @therealz360z7 Jody still influenced her for years and years.

    • @Sarahgw
      @Sarahgw 8 місяців тому +1

      Jody worked in the capacity as a marriage professional with a license authorized by the church she was someone giving her guidance there have been videos and Jody has a history of this and this is not the first time Jody has been in legal trouble and she did have her professional license suspended previously. I don’t blame ruby 100% but I do Jody.

    • @Sarahgw
      @Sarahgw 8 місяців тому

      Jody worked in the capacity as a marriage professional with a license authorized by the church she was someone giving her guidance there have been videos and Jody has a history of this and this is not the first time Jody has been in legal trouble and she did have her professional license suspended previously. I don’t blame ruby 100% but I do Jody.

  • @IWantToRideMyBike
    @IWantToRideMyBike 8 місяців тому +58

    This just tells me that she REALLY does not want the details to come out

    • @hopefulhuman
      @hopefulhuman 8 місяців тому +8

      I bet it would be really difficult to present this to a jury and ask them to find her not guilty. There's no way.

    • @InternetJury
      @InternetJury 8 місяців тому +3

      ...or it means they offered her a deal in exchange for testifying against Jodi, who is, by far, the much bigger target, here. Jodi's history is long, and deeper than people think it is.

    • @sad.jackfr00t
      @sad.jackfr00t 8 місяців тому

      Unfortunately for her, there's no way that Jodi is going to plead guilty -- she's way too corrupt. Some of her information will be dragged out regardless.

    • @IWantToRideMyBike
      @IWantToRideMyBike 8 місяців тому

      @@InternetJury no, the plea does not include any limits and guarantees consecutive sentences

    • @InternetJury
      @InternetJury 8 місяців тому +2

      @whitneyc5295 Um, when I did I say otherwise? I said her deal was likely part of a bigger plan regarding Jodi. She got quite a deal... still harsh, but far better than what she would likely have received.

  • @ThePolypam
    @ThePolypam 8 місяців тому +39

    I don't have children. I understand it can be difficult. But I don't understand how you can be so angry as to harm your children, or any child, not once in a fit of rage, but repeatedly, systematically and sadistically. I watched the Shanda Vander Ark case and to me it looks like these children could have ended up dead, too. My heart breaks for all children that are tortured by their parents.

  • @dee-deelove9310
    @dee-deelove9310 8 місяців тому +18

    I’m so glad she’s done this….those kids don’t need the added trauma of having to testify against their mother regardless of how much we want to throw the book at her !

  • @North_West1
    @North_West1 8 місяців тому +76

    Her guilty plea can be used against her in any child custody cases.

    • @TJ-wz3tt
      @TJ-wz3tt 8 місяців тому +3

      🎯💯

    • @TheEmilyDBaker
      @TheEmilyDBaker  8 місяців тому +38

      Yes it can.

    • @mariee.5912
      @mariee.5912 8 місяців тому +1

      But if she will be in jail...

    • @Ausgar-yc1yl
      @Ausgar-yc1yl 8 місяців тому

      @@mariee.5912 She can NOT go to jail
      Jail is county. She committed crimes against the state.

    • @LockeDemosthenes2
      @LockeDemosthenes2 7 місяців тому

      Hopefully all of her children will be over 18 when she gets out of prison anyway, so this is probably not relevant.

  • @zxs7170
    @zxs7170 8 місяців тому +67

    Few things I noticed…Ruby looks at her attorney with looks of anger, a hateful sort of look. She does not address the judge with “your honor.” Her parents clearly came back from their mission but it seems very recently as Ruby’s sisters continued to claim the parents were still on their mission a couple weeks ago. Meaning they didn’t come back for their grandchildren they came back for Ruby. Her sister Julie seems to flash a slight smile at Ruby as Ruby is leaving the courtroom. Does not seem that her sisters Bonnie nor Ellie were there. Ruby’s guilty admission is delivered with an angry look, she is not convinced she’s done anything wrong. There is no look or facial expressions of remorse or sadness only a look of anger.

    • @Ms.Prairie
      @Ms.Prairie 8 місяців тому +23

      > But came back for ruby
      Ma’aaaaaaaam. This is absolutely disturbing. Thank you for pointing this out. Disgusting!

    • @RestingBeachFace721
      @RestingBeachFace721 8 місяців тому +6

      Just an ego as big as the room.

    • @TJAnderson
      @TJAnderson 8 місяців тому +7

      That look of anger was at the prosecutor. Watch close, it softens to something submissive/doe eyed as her eyes drift to her own attorney. Gave me the heeby jeebies. 😳

    • @wmdkitty
      @wmdkitty 8 місяців тому +6

      The sisters are just as bad as Ruby, IMO.

    • @inuchan74
      @inuchan74 8 місяців тому +3

      ​@wmdkitty her sisters are nutter butters too, but unless they are doing something comparable to holding their kids heads under water or hog tying them, then I'm they're not even close.

  • @SukiLondon
    @SukiLondon 8 місяців тому +4

    Just terrible. I really feel that anyone that has been involved with Jody's 'therapy' and has children needs to have CPS go and interview their kids too because I'm sure there are a lot more victims suffering this torture.
    Thank you Emily for covering this.

  • @alekandhisdogs
    @alekandhisdogs 8 місяців тому +15

    When you read the statement of truth where Victim 1 & 2 were forced to do physical labor I thought of the 16 & 14 year old children doing “chores” for Pam Bodthner. When the police arrived, the girls were both barefoot although Pam and her husband were in shoes/appropriate footwear.
    I feel like Pam is also involved in “punishing” Ruby’s children.
    Even Jesse Hildebrandt spoke about Pam watching and reporting back to Jodi about behavior.
    All three of these women are guilty and should be in prison.

    • @MRSFeeX
      @MRSFeeX 8 місяців тому +5

      slavery..childslavery.

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому +2

      True. We keep forgetting good ole Pam. And the two middle kids. Still in the middle/muddle of Ruby's brainwashing.

  • @Feline_Frenzy53
    @Feline_Frenzy53 8 місяців тому +37

    I was very surprised to hear "consecutive." I was afraid they would give her a pass. But, we don't know how many years for a while yet. Ruby was breathing pretty hard during the plea. I think she was scared alright.

    • @axemangang1584
      @axemangang1584 8 місяців тому +10

      Hopefully 30 years without early release.

  • @megknitsstuff1727
    @megknitsstuff1727 8 місяців тому +21

    She used the word “distorted” in her statement (or allowed it to be used, which is the same to me).
    That tells me everything I need to know about any supposed self reflection or “reset of her moral compass.”

    • @InternetJury
      @InternetJury 8 місяців тому +2

      That just means she's still quoting Jodi's ideas. Jodi is big on "distortion".

  • @explore_with_em_x
    @explore_with_em_x 8 місяців тому +53

    It’s wild to me that her family were there. She alienated them and abused her children and they’re there to support her. Gross.

    • @BeachNanny
      @BeachNanny 8 місяців тому +17

      I seriously doubt they are there to support her. One of her sisters, Julie, who is sitting next to her mom and her brother, has spoken out against Ruby.

    • @LadyInTheTree
      @LadyInTheTree 8 місяців тому +9

      I think it’s a very complicated situation for the family. If one of my sisters were charged I would probably show up because I would want to hear from her and the guilty plead…. However unless the family was told where to sit I wouldn’t have sat on her side, but that could be where they had to sit. I just hope the whole blame isn’t placed on Jodi - by Ruby and the family.

    • @QueenMadradena
      @QueenMadradena 8 місяців тому +1

      Buster was there at his dad's trial so...

    • @Itscannatella
      @Itscannatella 8 місяців тому +8

      They’re probably there to see for themselves what’s happening. I think it’s a bit unnecessary to speculate if they’re there in support of her. I doubt they are.

    • @moondropflower9957
      @moondropflower9957 8 місяців тому +1

      I think it's to hear what she did because police wouldn't release the information to them outside of court since they aren't guardians

  • @eatmyoctopus
    @eatmyoctopus 8 місяців тому +8

    This makes me feel more fortunate than ever that I was adopted by two great parents and had such a blessed upbringing. I feel equally as sad for the kids in this case. I only hope they go on to live happy and healthy lives in the future.

  • @kimmaree9610
    @kimmaree9610 8 місяців тому +34

    I’m getting Martyr vibes from Ruby. I’m sure when she can speak freely, the justifications will start flowing. I don’t think she is sorry .

  • @suehatton
    @suehatton 8 місяців тому +39

    She just regrets and sorry she got caught!

    • @ccccarriemchardy9216
      @ccccarriemchardy9216 8 місяців тому +2

      Don't they all!

    • @skkeech
      @skkeech 8 місяців тому +5

      Exactly! I wish the older kids would be able to testify because this has been going on since the older kids were little.

  • @ShaunaLiTheStarcaller
    @ShaunaLiTheStarcaller 8 місяців тому +13

    when we got to the part of what she admitted to, i cried. thats so awful. how could anyone ever do that to a child? i will never be able to understand. i wish i could give those kids a hug and tell them they are so worthy of love, self love and love from others.

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому +1

      Unfortunately, the part that Emily didn't read is even worse. Way worse. 😢😢😢

  • @user-vn3kb1zu3o
    @user-vn3kb1zu3o 8 місяців тому +45

    Am I the only one thinking that it’s a bit gross for her to seem like she spent a lot of time and energy thinking about how to make her hair look good? I get that there’s a level of wanting to have some dignity and feel like yourself but seriously? Her kids were starved and bound. Same with Laurie daybell. Makes me think they are sitting in a cell thinking about themselves, not what they’ve done.

    • @RestingBeachFace721
      @RestingBeachFace721 8 місяців тому +5

      I’m the victim mentality. Even Ruby herself. It’s sickening to say the least.

    • @k-avocado395
      @k-avocado395 8 місяців тому +4

      Totally agree!

    • @LauraSweet99
      @LauraSweet99 8 місяців тому +1

      You are not alone. She worked on that hairdo for about an hour total, half hour the night before, half hour in the morning.

  • @chibimitchi
    @chibimitchi 8 місяців тому +36

    The Franke parents were abusing and exploiting their children long before Jodie came along. Ruby’s lawyer can try to spin it all he wants but we’ve all seen the video evidence on her “family channel”.

    • @SharpLife4
      @SharpLife4 8 місяців тому

      Just because that’s what you felt you saw on her channel was not the case Jody was her church leader for years before. She gave books on how to discipline and council etc

    • @TJ-wz3tt
      @TJ-wz3tt 8 місяців тому +3

      ​@@SharpLife4I bet she did

    • @BumbletheBea
      @BumbletheBea 8 місяців тому +14

      @@SharpLife4 I don’t know many people who would abuse their children just because prominent members of their church said so- but either way Ruby is an adult and shouldn’t blame anyone else for what she did to those kids

    • @zxs7170
      @zxs7170 8 місяців тому +8

      @@SharpLife4- I this channel and many others, you seem in full support of Ruby & Jodi’s actions. Question; are you/were you a part or “student” of this Connexions counseling. We’ve noticed your channel featuring your very young children’s injuries, hospital visits and ailments as your main content.

    • @SharpLife4
      @SharpLife4 8 місяців тому

      @@zxs7170 are you still going off on crap. If you slander me I can sue. You can’t assume. There are over 200 videos. Maybe 2 or 3 with one being 10 seconds long that have kids. They respect their
      Privacy. They were posted when kid could
      Consent and to help people because I wanted to help people as other videos like that helped me. It didn’t show other people or anything else.
      So get off your high horse. No one supports tying up kids. But I respect the penal system because there are so many dumb people that act on emotion and are unreasonable. Thank goodness for judges because people
      Like you have no logic. People do act out of being brainwashed. Even victims often protect abusers. But also kids do better with parents. Even ones that are addicted to drugs. It’s just how it is. Does that mean she should have her kids no. But should they allow her kids to heal and ask questions and see her, I would not weigh in as I am not a social worker with all facts. But socials workers will know what to do. But no I don’t support connections. I’ve never watched it unless on learning aboiht what this arrest was about where people posted
      Clips and links. So get off your self. Just because I don’t agree with you doesn’t mean you can slander me and Accuse me of things which is liable

  • @taylogan5826
    @taylogan5826 8 місяців тому +14

    Judge Walton IS NOT an easy judge especially when it comes to children. I am friends with 3 of the law partners he worked with. Judge Walton served as a Deputy Washington County Attorney. He was an associate with Jones Waldo Holbrook & McDonough probably the most highly regarded firm in St George, Ut. IMO this won’t be a cakewalk for Ruby. Most likely she would serve at Salt Lake or Gunnison both state prisons. Gunnison is a smaller maximum security so IMO it will be Salt Lake which is min-max.

    • @bobbic9868
      @bobbic9868 8 місяців тому +5

      Good to hear! Someone in the chat said that sentencing goes through a board and not up to the Judge (of course witching guidelines)…is that true?

    • @MRSFeeX
      @MRSFeeX 8 місяців тому

      Is he also into "this" church? Utah Right?

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому

      Very good to hear!

    • @janicesellers3618
      @janicesellers3618 8 місяців тому

      ​@@MRSFeeX you have no idea what you are talking about. 👍

  • @darcfaze6482
    @darcfaze6482 8 місяців тому +19

    If you think about it, it is rather hard for her to say, she didn't know about the malnutrition. Malnutrition doesn't happen overnight. It takes as little as 3 months and even less if they aren't eating at all.

    • @chrissiebabe234
      @chrissiebabe234 8 місяців тому +3

      There’s video evidence from her sick video blog that she deliberately used food withdrawal as punishment. You could even see her sadistic demeanor whilst talking about that.

    • @kellyewers5692
      @kellyewers5692 8 місяців тому +1

      She used food denial as a punishment for years. She put it all over UA-cam. It’s obviously her ‘thing’.

  • @rosemarythyme8595
    @rosemarythyme8595 8 місяців тому +9

    As I’m hearing you read that off, I can’t see a judge in the world that’s gonna go easy on her when they read what she did to them little kids.
    She deserves what is coming to her. I can’t even comprehend, I couldn’t imagine doing that to someone I hated much less my own children.

  • @hfrisch007
    @hfrisch007 8 місяців тому +10

    I watched her first time ever ,she was talking about how her 6 year old. Should make better choices tommorow,she forgot to make her lunch and Mom would take her food cause she needed to learn a lesson😮 Well RUBY! MAKE BETTER LIFE CHOICES ❤

  • @lifewithvalerie21
    @lifewithvalerie21 8 місяців тому +15

    I’m a new subscriber. About. 20 some years ago my dad did a plea deal for abuse and the judge had me go see him in his chambers while he determined what the sentence would be. I was scared to death, as I was taught judges and police and others in authority were to be looked to with respect, and it scared the crap out of little me.

  • @emilyflotilla931
    @emilyflotilla931 8 місяців тому +18

    Her actions were akin to the treatment of prisoners of war before the Geneva convention. I'm amazed her son, especially, is alive. Cruel and unusual punishment to be sure. This comes on the heels of Shanda Vander Ark, in Michigan, whose son was sadly a victim of malnutrition and hypothermia and didn't survive. I hope she gets the max!

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому

      That would be sweet. But even 8 years would be better than nothing.

  • @InvisibleVicky
    @InvisibleVicky 8 місяців тому +24

    Let’s hope she gets a longgggggg sentence.

  • @mizmo2431
    @mizmo2431 8 місяців тому +11

    The Morman church will never let this go to trial. Jody will plea.

  • @wmdkitty
    @wmdkitty 8 місяців тому +8

    This guilty plea is the kindest thing Ruby has ever done for her children.

  • @teriwelshanscp3528
    @teriwelshanscp3528 8 місяців тому +19

    Ugh, I missed the live, but I heard she took a plea deal yesterday. Thank you EDB for covering the hearing 💜

  • @yocelin1087
    @yocelin1087 8 місяців тому +19

    No Christmas for her just like she took it away from her younger children. Wow! How things really do come around!

    • @kjh6903
      @kjh6903 8 місяців тому +5

      Yes I thought about that !! I hope she spends many holidays in prison .

    • @icravedeath.1200
      @icravedeath.1200 8 місяців тому +2

      My mum constantly threatened to take things like that away from me.

    • @yocelin1087
      @yocelin1087 8 місяців тому

      @@icravedeath.1200 so sorry you had to go through that. I totally can relate because my mom did too.

    • @icravedeath.1200
      @icravedeath.1200 8 місяців тому

      @@yocelin1087 she doesn't do it anymore because she realised how much it was hurting me, but she still has yet to apologise for it.
      Also *hugs* thnx

  • @dragons_flight
    @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому +7

    Emily: Many thanks for covering this Ruby F debacle today. I was afraid that we wouldn't hear from you on it at all due to the Christmas break. So good to be grounded (and entertained) by your unique approach.

  • @CuriousMouseExploration
    @CuriousMouseExploration 8 місяців тому +17

    Adam Steed was successful at getting Hildebrandt's license suspended. Unfortunately, that was all he got out of his case with her, where she was coaching his ex-wife to get him convicted of child and wife abuse and expelled from his Mormon school and church. After the board looked further into that case, they apologized to Steed for not taking him more seriously. The Mormon church backed Hildebrandt all the way, recommended couples to her, and were even involved in the boy scout child abuse case in which Steed as a child had to go thru. Double victim of abuse. Guess we can't bust the Mormon leaders to aid and abetted Hildebrandt. But we get her busted this time. Hopefully, she can never harm anyone else. Thank you for covering this - it is vital to take Hildebrandt out b4 she harms anyone else or possibly kills someone. There are so many quiet victims of abuse who never get any attention or rescue. We have to bust as many as we can.

    • @kellijanssen1171
      @kellijanssen1171 8 місяців тому +4

      I’m glad Adam got that though I still hope he goes after her in Civil Court.

  • @deborahshipman8888
    @deborahshipman8888 8 місяців тому +23

    She takes no blame or responsibility...jodi's fault, fault, fault.

  • @jodyschmeltz6174
    @jodyschmeltz6174 8 місяців тому +8

    I was wondering, what about CPS accountability for these children and all the visits by the police?

  • @deannalynn445
    @deannalynn445 8 місяців тому +15

    She is not going to have it easy in prison. Women in prison do not welcome women who abuse their kids. I'm sure all the inmates know who she is and are probably just waiting!

    • @MRSFeeX
      @MRSFeeX 8 місяців тому +6

      A natural outcome..I think this children could be dead, if the boy did not escape.. can you imagine what happened to him, if he was found "trying" to escape? Would they still be alive today?? If the boy did not succeed in escaping?

    • @dragons_flight
      @dragons_flight 8 місяців тому +2

      Unfortunately I can't say that I am sorry in the least that, for what she did and allowed, she will experience some tiny bit of what Russell and Evie experienced for no reason at all. 😡 😢 💔

  • @nickit7655
    @nickit7655 8 місяців тому

    So I was watching the Law and Crime Network interview of a lawyer in Utah. She said that the parole board, not the judge, will be determining the length of the sentence. She postulated that Ruby will only get 4 years sentence with 40% time served.

  • @nonstopmom36
    @nonstopmom36 8 місяців тому +9

    EDB got the scoop - whoop whoop 🙌 - Frankie statement sounded more like when an addict is talking about making amends with those hurt.
    NOT a statement that was about the ABUSE of her own children and she allowed it ! 😡

  • @sharonlewis6258
    @sharonlewis6258 8 місяців тому +6

    I often think of the little boy that was tied up and went to the neighbor. I hope and pray he is doing well. His little sister, also.

  • @gryffent
    @gryffent 8 місяців тому +5

    I hope the judge sentences her to the maximum for each count. So 60 years which if the good time is even 50% she’d still be over 70 years old when she gets out. I’d prefer that she is never allowed to be free again. These charges are heinous as is her actions towards her children so I would be satisfied if she is never free again.

  • @irenetorkel2186
    @irenetorkel2186 8 місяців тому +15

    The inmates in custody in the female unit I supervised used sugar water to hold curls in their hair. They were very good at improvisation when needed.

    • @onwednesdayswewearpink2761
      @onwednesdayswewearpink2761 8 місяців тому

      I did notice the waves in her hair were very uniform and done well@therealz360z7

    • @CitizenCardigan
      @CitizenCardigan 8 місяців тому

      Curlers made with toilet paper are a thing.

    • @PamsPrettyPlants
      @PamsPrettyPlants 8 місяців тому +1

      It’s a French braid guys 😂 not that deep

  • @Infantfaire
    @Infantfaire 8 місяців тому +1

    As a child that experienced some abuse and neglect, if it were 11 year old me, I would WANT to testify. It’s not for the comfort of the child, it’s for the adults’ comfort. These kids suffered for YEARS while the whole world watched. I would have wanted every adult to listen to my every word. And then I would have looked directly at the judge every time I recounted each time I asked for help. It’s not to save the children. It’s to hide our own guilt

  • @janicegreene3599
    @janicegreene3599 8 місяців тому +7

    She and Jodi tortured those poor babies! No way anyone could convince me to do any of these things to my children or to allow the other person to do them! Sooo wrong! 😡 This house was located in the desert…very close to Death Valley!

  • @ashleyhall919
    @ashleyhall919 8 місяців тому +7

    Accidentally said "what the f***" out loud about the part where she loves her children. All that she did to her children, before and after meeting Jodi, was not love.

  • @dawn5227
    @dawn5227 8 місяців тому +17

    I do believe she was influenced by jodi, but she allowed and was open to that influence. She wasnt ever a devoted mother, she was a dog lead by the bone. Jodi offered her the bone and Ruby took it willingly.

  • @applejuicyjuice
    @applejuicyjuice 8 місяців тому +6

    I’m just happy the children don’t have to be put on the stand and testify to these traumatic events.

  • @CuriousMouseExploration
    @CuriousMouseExploration 8 місяців тому +10

    My opinion of what I've heard is Ruby was bad b4 Hildebrandt, but I'm willing to let her plead because the person who has done so much more damage is Hildebrandt. She needs to be taken out. I credit Ruby for not making her children testify against her - the whole thing is a nightmare for those kids. They're likely to suffer complex PTSD the rest of their lives - suffering from that myself, I know it is difficult and heartbreaking. I hope Adam Steed will be able to heal better when Hildebrandt gets prison time. I feel so much for him and his family - he is a double victim, which is really awful.

    • @Vixenspirit
      @Vixenspirit 8 місяців тому

      I agree with everything you said, although I struggle to believe that Ruby pled guilty to spare her children. She seems sadistic and cruel when she comes to her kids. So I find it more likely she did it to spare herself the shame of all the evidence coming out and potentially more than we already know about through testimony

  • @LynnatLRTranscripts
    @LynnatLRTranscripts 8 місяців тому +5

    Replay here this time. What a tragic story, blinded by greed, exploiting her children, and the resulting trauma to their physical and mental health and wellbeing.

  • @bobbic9868
    @bobbic9868 8 місяців тому +3

    EDB - thanks for going over this. I work in a criminal division in AZ (Superior/Phoenix), and have worked in San Luis Obispo (CA)…this plea is so lenient compared to what we would see here in either of those Courts for the same thing (even with no priors). Apparently the Judges in Utah also don’t set the sentences - someone mentioned a board does this. Why would they use this method? AZ and CA are much more similar (though AZ has lower Courts). I really appreciate your great mind, thoughts, and explanations:). ❤

  • @ianclark2665
    @ianclark2665 8 місяців тому +10

    Wow, I'd forgotten what a wonderful channel this is, thank you.

  • @shilohivy4590
    @shilohivy4590 8 місяців тому +6

    Omg those poor kids. And this is just what she’s pleading to. What else went on? When I see these cases involving children I think about my mom. She couldn’t have kids. She adopted me from birth and she would say “these people can have kids easily and look what they did”

  • @fuchsialocks592
    @fuchsialocks592 8 місяців тому +8

    I'm so annoyed that the malnutrition charges got dropped. 😠

    • @onwednesdayswewearpink2761
      @onwednesdayswewearpink2761 8 місяців тому +2

      she was also charged with making the little boy exercise outside, without water and his skin ended up in blisters from the sunburn. Hopefully that is one of the 4 counts that she will gets sentenced to...harshly I hope

  • @Puggz666
    @Puggz666 8 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for breaking this down, I was confused when I first heard it because I didn’t understand what she was getting out of this plea deal. But the fact her kids don’t have to testify against her makes a lot of sense

  • @zappa-happy
    @zappa-happy 8 місяців тому +1

    Altho Yes I had to *breathe breathe breathe* at certain times, TYSM Emily 4 doing an Amazing job at explaining this 💖💖 from UK

  • @briannahatcher9422
    @briannahatcher9422 8 місяців тому +4

    Well... this is worse than I was anticipating. I'm glad the kids don't have to go through a trail. Hopefully, they are able to start their long road to healing.
    Edit: I also hope the kids know the whole world is behind them. I can't imagine what it would be like to have to testify against Jody, so if they do, I hope they know we are with them. ❤

  • @lindala2602
    @lindala2602 8 місяців тому +1

    A 14yo girl on my bus (Denmark) was watching this hearing on tiktok. Young people are much more awsome than we give them credit for.

  • @jamesbillington9280
    @jamesbillington9280 8 місяців тому +2

    THANK YOU, Emily, for going through this.

  • @sharonlewis6258
    @sharonlewis6258 8 місяців тому +6

    I sure hope she gets at least 10 years. She deserves longer.

    • @kellijanssen1171
      @kellijanssen1171 8 місяців тому

      I was thinking 60 because they are consecutive (15 years for each count).

    • @emilyflotilla931
      @emilyflotilla931 8 місяців тому

      ​@@kellijanssen1171Yes, but those are maximum.

  • @hfrisch007
    @hfrisch007 8 місяців тому +6

    Did the kids get a plea deal 😮😮😮😮😮 ???? That's absolute crap. I don't care what she gets it's not enough ,I'm so tired of these cults abusing these babies and getting away with it

  • @CallMeCthUwU
    @CallMeCthUwU 8 місяців тому

    I was a victim of abuse by my mother and I just want to hug these babies and tell them how strong they are, that this is their hero backstory, and noone will hurt them like this ever again. I just want to hug and cry with them. Because I know how damaging this is. I want them to know they are not alone. These babies are so strong. My heart is with them as a fellow survivor of abuse and neglect

  • @annetterose8948
    @annetterose8948 8 місяців тому +6

    I hope these poor babies get far, far away from Ruby and Kevin. Kevin is not innocent or a good father. I pray they get all the love and therapy they deserve.

    • @axemangang1584
      @axemangang1584 8 місяців тому

      His lawyer has written as much BS for Rubie. In fact there is so much BS on both of their lawyers papers/statement are similar to used TP.

  • @chetyoubetya8565
    @chetyoubetya8565 8 місяців тому +6

    I can't imagine what she will say to her children.I am sure at one point both younger kids begged her for food and water.What will she say to that.

  • @l.baughman1445
    @l.baughman1445 8 місяців тому

    I need to send healing, emotional healing and real love of spirit to all of those children, and prayers of healing and love to all children in the world who are or have suffered in any way. Peace to all. ❤

  • @ScratchyGirl
    @ScratchyGirl 8 місяців тому +3

    It’s usually very healing for victims to be able to state how their abuser affected them-- to their abuser directly.
    I wonder if the children will get that chance.

    • @jenniboo9441
      @jenniboo9441 8 місяців тому

      This isnt just an abuser. This is their mother and they are both still small children.. there's no way any benefit of being able to "call her out" would outweigh the trauma of having to testify against their own mother.

  • @Freebritney911
    @Freebritney911 8 місяців тому +4

    NO REMORSE

  • @kenyonbissett3512
    @kenyonbissett3512 8 місяців тому +1

    I can always count on you to share and interpret the legal news stories. Thanks for this update! Hoping she gets 2 years each charge consecutively to prevent her being near her children as minors. I don’t know how parole works in Utah, but I hope however it works she does 6yr and whatever on parole. Before release for any parole, she needs a mental evaluation to determine if she might abuse her grandchildren as she will probably have some by then. I don’t want her abusing or starving babies or influencing her children in parenting.
    The lawyer’s statement is tone deaf. He needed a lawyer with public relations understanding to help. Total disaster to me. And, it seems to Emily.

  • @victoriaroberts7034
    @victoriaroberts7034 8 місяців тому +1

    When i was on a jury in the uk a screen was put up so the victim could only see the judge and barristers is there no way this can be done in the US court?

  • @kateg6029
    @kateg6029 8 місяців тому

    Thankyou Emily for covering this case. It is important that these kids know that the world doesn’t agree with the treatment they have been put through.
    Ruby was an abusive parent before Jodi came along. And she made millions on it. Ruby is a perpetrator and not a victim.
    The kids are the victims and Kevin, Rudy and Jodi should not be allowed near children and animals ever again.
    I can remember getting the cane as a 5th grader and laughed afterwards. We were interrogated as kids then given the old jug cord. If she was in a foul mood we were made to have a cold shower first. Back in the days where the kid was charged with neglect, and we would keep our mouths shut and could block pain. Trauma is for life

  • @kelliepatterson1142
    @kelliepatterson1142 8 місяців тому +4

    It is my opinion that she's not doing anything to protect her kids she plead to keep the kids off the stand I think the kids should be asked if they want to testify.

  • @katiearcher4475
    @katiearcher4475 8 місяців тому +4

    I cant believe her sisters showed up to support her.
    I would fully hope my family (parents and older sister) would NOT support me in any shape, way, or form if i was arrested for abusing my children!!!

    • @icravedeath.1200
      @icravedeath.1200 8 місяців тому +1

      You'd think if her family actually supported her they'd get the children separated from her and get her some actual help before she ended up in the slammer!

    • @justapanpirate
      @justapanpirate 8 місяців тому

      Could be that they showed up because they wanted to hear her actually plead guilty. (I have no idea what the sisters are like, only found out about the YT channel when the videos of admitting abuse as if it was nothing started to get more attention).

  • @hopefulhuman
    @hopefulhuman 8 місяців тому +1

    It never ceases to amaze me with some of the questions ppl ask.

  • @skkeech
    @skkeech 8 місяців тому +16

    Since Jodi's hearing is off the calendar now, what does that mean? Also, if they find Ruby to lie when testifying against Jodi, could the plea deal be taken away?

    • @neurotoxicity
      @neurotoxicity 8 місяців тому

      it’s on dec 27th

    • @skkeech
      @skkeech 8 місяців тому

      @@neurotoxicity It's been taken off the Utah court calendar.

    • @neurotoxicity
      @neurotoxicity 8 місяців тому

      @@skkeech do you have a source for that? i can’t find any official thing saying that so far (not that i doubt you specifically i just want to be able to see the release that has that info if you have it!) :)

    • @skkeech
      @skkeech 8 місяців тому

      @@neurotoxicity Jodi is back on the schedule for next Wednesday. It was weird it wasn't there yesterday. In Ruby's plea, it was VERY specific she has to testify against Jodi and not lie. I think that will be hard for Ruby considering the circumstances and their weird relationship. If Ruby lies the plea deal can be dismissed and she'd be back in court.

    • @skkeech
      @skkeech 8 місяців тому

      @@neurotoxicity The judge said that.

  • @mosaicgirl4002
    @mosaicgirl4002 8 місяців тому

    Must say - such an excellent show!❤ thank you Emily- you are terrific.🎉 ❤❤❤

  • @andromeda7758
    @andromeda7758 8 місяців тому

    I work in Child Welfare - I preface I am not trying to invalidate what these children have gone through, its horrible. However, I have seen so many children put through similar or worse and their parents don't even get charged. Then scream at us that we took their kids away and tore their family apart. I don't think it will ever fail to baffle me the ways some people feel entitled to treat their children. All children deserve parents, not all parents deserve kids. It's almost impossible to not become numb to what people like Ruby do when you see it lots. You'd lose your mind if you didn't. Nonetheless, it is unforgivable what she's done. I hope all her children find peace and healing.

  • @jillly62
    @jillly62 8 місяців тому +3

    Hi Emily, I would love if you would look into and talk about the Troubled Teen Industry. Hundred of thousands of kids have been abused on a daily basis by mainly Mormon ran facilities (similar methods to this case). I wish there was something legally I could do to get justice for the abuse I suffered but they legally cover their asses so well and hide their abuse very well.

  • @crazyamericanredhead
    @crazyamericanredhead 8 місяців тому

    Truly hope everyone has a wonderful and safe holiday. This year I will be be just chilling with my cats

  • @carina-jaipaul1342
    @carina-jaipaul1342 8 місяців тому +1

    Both Ruby and Jodie are both in the Purgatory Corrections Facility in Washington County and have been housed in different units.. They can not see each other nor are they allowed to communicate with each other..

  • @mosaicgirl4002
    @mosaicgirl4002 8 місяців тому

    Cheers from Wollongong! (And where is that ?!❤) Enjoy your break.

  • @jrs2024
    @jrs2024 8 місяців тому

    Haven’t watched you in awhile.. your hair is FABULOUS!!!! Inspires me to cut mine. Happy new year, Emily!

  • @RhiWJ
    @RhiWJ 8 місяців тому +2

    Could the other children come forward in some capacity and get Ruby against for the things she did to them? Could they get justice against Kevin and his involvement? 🤔

  • @stacyfernandes2860
    @stacyfernandes2860 8 місяців тому +3

    I totally sgree woth you Emily I am a mother and this makes me severly sngry

  • @siobhanomalley1968
    @siobhanomalley1968 8 місяців тому

    Horrifying 😢 those poor kids. The litany of crimes here is really distressing. As a survivor of CA myself, I wanna hug these kids and say things will can and will get better, and I sincerely hope they get the peace, care and healing time they need and deserve 💖

  • @dawn5227
    @dawn5227 8 місяців тому +6

    I think the judge will sentence 5yrs per charge. At least I hope thats the minimum the judge will sentence and not just a year becuse that is disgusting.

  • @deawnnamontoya897
    @deawnnamontoya897 8 місяців тому +1

    I shouldn't have paused to read this. I hope the kids can find peace and get the help they need to heal emotionally

  • @yourjealous0223
    @yourjealous0223 8 місяців тому +7

    I'm so surprised her sister, brother and parents were there

  • @JessieBanana
    @JessieBanana 8 місяців тому +7

    She can wet braid or twist it for waves. An absurd priority for a woman with straight hair in custody for such charges, but it’s definitely doable.