Porcupine Tree - Arriving Somewhere But Not Here (Pianist listens to metalhead’s suggestion)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 лют 2024
- Judson’s first experience with @PorcupineTreeOfficial. @StevenWilsonHQ
Richard’s shirt - / grave - topic
Judson’s piano intro:
@MarcyPlaygroundVEVO - Sex & Candy
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research.
Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of financial fair use.
#porcupinetree #porcupinetreereaction #react #arrivingsomewherebutnothere #reaction #reactionchannel #reactionvideo #reactionchannel #greatmeasures #proceedrichard #deadwing #uk #english #england #greatbritain #stevenwilson #opeth #progressive #progressivemetal #progressivemusclerelaxation #marcyplayground #sexandcandy #2005 #prog #progmetal #heavymetal #metal #metalreaction #thecharismaticvoice #lostinvegas #rickbeato #thedailydoug #niknocturnal #drumeo #metalinjection #metalsucks #loudwire #revolver #decibelmagazine #jre #mrbeast #pewdiepie #noisey #rockfeed #kerrang #gavinharrison
#richardbarbieri #guitar #guitarist #guitarsolo #bass #bassist #bassplayer #popularreaction #music #musica #drums #drummer #drumming #pinkfloyd #sing #singer #singing #vocals #vocalist #guitarriff #riff #riffsandruns #riffs #pianote #piano #pianist #pianomusic #classicalmusic #classicalmusician #classicalpiano #pianocover #pianocovers #newtrending #newtrendingvideo #newreactionvideo #trendingvideo #reactionvideo #popularreaction #popularvideo #TwoMinutestoLateNight #MetalTitans
#MetallicaLivePerformances #SlayerTV
#HeadbangersKitchen #GhostCultMagazine
#MetalInsider #MetalHeadbangers #Brutalitopia
#MetalheadsForeverMagazine #MetalSucks
#TheArtOfGuitar #rockfeed #MetalBladeRecords #NapalmRecords
#EaracheRecords #RockMetalCombatPodcast
#RockForeverMagazine #TheNeedleDrop
#RockAndMetalNewz #NuclearBlastRecords
#MetallicaTV #Slipknot #RevolverMagazine
#loudwire #kerrang #MetalInjection #BangerTV
#CenturyMediaRecords #MetalHammer #Pianist
#PianoAnalysis #HeavyMetalSong #MusicAnalysis #MusicReaction #HeavyMetalMusic #SongAnalysis #HeavyMetalGenre #PianoCover #MusicReview
#MusicTheory #MetalMusicAnalysis #PianistReacts #FirstTimeReaction
#PianoInterpretation #HeavyMetalComposition
#MusicBreakdown #PianoPerformance
#HeavyMetalAnalysis #PianoPlayer
#MetalSongBreakdown #MetalMusicReview #PianistPerspective #HeavyMetalPiano
#MusicDiscovery #PianoSkills #MetalGenreAnalysis #AnalyzingMusic
#PianistReview #MusicAppreciation
#Metallica #IronMaiden #BlackSabbath
#judaspriest #Slayer #Megadeth #Pantera
#Slipknot #Motorhead #SystemofaDown #Tool
#Opeth #Nightwish #Korn #AvengedSevenfold
#Anthrax #Disturbed #Mastodon #Ghost
#LambofGod #InFlames #DreamTheater
#Meshuggah #Gojira #FiveFingerDeathPunch
#Epica #ArchEnemy #ChildrenofBodom
#Sabaton #Trivium #Kreator #CannibalCorpse
#Sepultura #BulletForMyValentine #ParkwayDrive #AmonAmarth #Testament
#Behemoth #SymphonyX #Deftones #Rammstein #MachineHead #Amorphis
#helloween #Sepultura #Slipknot #DarkTranquillity #Powerwolf #Ensiferum
#Wintersun #drumeo #180Drums
#StephenTaylorDrum #MeinlCymbals
#DrumBeatsOnline #JaredFalkDrumming
#AdamTuminaro #LukeHolland #MikeJohnston
#RobBeatdownBrown #DorotheaTaylor
#Cooperdrummer #DrumChannel #SinaDrums
#AnikaNilles #CaseyCooper #JPBouvet
#MikeDolbear #Drumsfield #CaisSoliDrum
#JoshSteffen #DrummerEDrums #JordanWest
#DaveAtkinsonDrum #KyleAbbott #JaredDines
#GroovinDrums #SamusPaulicelli #EmilyDrums
#AustinBurcham #classicalmusicanreactstometal #classicalmusicianreacts #metallicaanalysis #deadheadreaction #meshuggahanalysis #HeavyMetal #creepingdeathmetallica #bestmetalguitarist #firsttimehearingreaction #vocalanalysis
As soon as we finished this video, I realized that completely forgot to mention that Mikael Åkerfeldt sings backup and plays the 2nd guitar solo on this song. That’s my bad!
Stick around for Judson’s beautiful piano rendition when the song ends.
**If you or someone you know is struggling with substance abuse and they’re ready to get help, contact us via email.**
thegreatmeasures@gmail.com
And here I was, going to come here to tell you about Mikael... xD
Hm, a peace offer to Judson after the recent Slayer experience? 😅
@@AN-nt3uv Naah, I have not watched that since I do not care that much about Slayer.. x) But yeah, do more PT and especially the LIVE performances.. Amazing! Best band you have never heard of. And not in the hipster way. ;)
The ability to hear a 12 minute song and then just send it on Piano. Judson is a rare talent.
Amen. Impressive. Thanks for recommending giving it a listen. Quirky dude but a serious talent.
Just pleae don't stop here with Porcupine Tree. It's a gold mine.
and Steven's solo work
As I’m sure many have mentioned you have to do Anesthetize Live. Fantastic performance and will allow you to appreciate how well they play together.
I think everyone familiar with the band knows what should be the next song , Anesthetize. maybe even their live .
love your channel guys 🤘
Totally agree
Yes! Finally some porcupine tree! Please, don't quit it here, check out Anesthetize (live in tilburg version is the best).
After checking this out I must say that I guessed Judson might like it. And the piano rendition is my favorite thia far. Great stuff again, guys!
Yes! These guys play such amazing live performances that's unbelievable!
Would recomend Time Flies too, such a beautiful song..
Yeees! Best suggestion
“Way out of here” is another awesome track! Halo being in 17/16 time May break Judson’s brain.😅
This is the best next suggestion, 100%.
17:11 When you remember why having a friend like this is fucking cool lol
😂
Judson: "Yeah they kinda did something like" ...proceeds to absolutely nail it
From Steven Wilson solo check Drive Home and Raven that refused to sing
Raven and Hand Cannot Erase are peak Steven WIlson solo albums IMO.
Drive Home, especially with the visuals in the music video is next level. The emotion in Guthrie's solo absolutely ruins me every time.
Blackest Eyes and Trains are incredible songs and both off my favorite album of theirs, In Absentia.
Word
Bro, Blackest eyes, the sound of muzak, wedding nails. Their old stuff is gold.
Oh you got to do anesthetize! Maybe even the live version, its just as good as on the album, surprisingly.
It's better than the album version. Live in Tilburg version is the best. Imho.
I actually prefer the live (in Tilburg) version.
@@jarmake1923 On second thought, indeed, it is. Its just such a rare thing! Most live clips is fun to watch, but it always takes a toll on the song and quality. Not this one :)
The only thing I miss about the live version is that it doesn't have the guest solo from Alex Lifeson (Yes, the one from Rush) that's on the studio version.
Gavin Harrison (also producer on this album) is such a genius drummer. The Sound of Muzak is another good, more popular one (from the previous album) that shows off more of Harrison's skills.
Anesthetize needs to be next for sure, yet I'm confident it will be among the top suggestions along with Trains.
I think at this point it’s safe to say Steven Wilson is fairly well known. In my opinion, the most talented British performer that you haven’t heard of is Bruce Soord, main songwriter, singer, lyricist and guitar player for the band The Pineapple Thief. Gavin Harrison who plays drums for Porcupine Tree also plays for The Pineapple Thief. The Pineapple Thief has made 14 studio records, with the earlier offerings being a bit more experimental.
Next should be Anethetize (live in Tilburg)
The coolest thing about these videos is the friendship between these guys.
Please don’t ever stop with Judson’s piano playing at the beginning of each video. It’s so calming and I love it!
Superb piano version, simply superb.
Got to do Anaesthetize live in Tilburg now :)
Judson at the piano gives me Charlie Brown vibes.
I am very honored by this compliment!
Wow, i’ve never heard of them, but I thoroughly enjoyed this! Love the guitartone. Slightly haunting vibe with a really great drive you just get caught up in. Hope you do lots more of Porcupine Tree.
Not to make unsolicited comments about your appearances, but I dig the fresh cut! I was starting to miss Judson’s bowl cut à la Ringo circa ’67.
Happy to hear PT / Steven Wilson may have a new fan. :)
Many PT songs are beautiful but with very dark lyrics. And how I love them.
I became a fan during their (PT) downtime and man was I happy for the Closure/Continuation album and that I was able to see them live during that tour.
@@EiriUesugiKun Oh man, i’m all about this band now! I’m listening to the songs you mentioned in your other comment, they’re all great so far. I hope PT haven’t hung up their touring hats yet. I can see they came by and sold out my neck of the woods during that tour, so here’s hoping for a repeat🤞🏼
I just cried listening to this piano version... Absolutely brilliant , thank you for that
Thanks for listening
oh yeah lets go porcupine tree fuck yeah
Nailed it. It's more about always being alive in the present and not focusing on where your going
Wow Judson nailed that one on the piano
Porcupine Tree is just pure talent! No need to fancy technicalities.
Thank you Judson for that amazing rendition!
And yeah, as many have said, they are almost better live so from now on I would almost in every case suggest taking a live version over studio.
Anesthetize, Trains, Hatesong, Blackest Eyes, Way out of here, Fear of a Blank Planet ... well. I'm not going to list their entire catalogue here. xD
So many good songs, so many amazing live performances, so many good memories with this music.
Sex and candy!!😂
YES!! MORE PT!!
Pretty sure I heard Wilson mention the song alluded to the transition between adolescence and adulthood: teenager thought becoming an adult would be like such-and-such, but became an adult and it was quite different. Then just played on that theme of “not what you expected”
I love this song !!! awesome choice . I love your interpretation on piano , please post a video of your entire version of the song , you're a genius on piano .
by the way i like the piano version of " sex and candy " lol
Don't sleep on SW solo stuff, he has a penchant for attracting top talent. His solo stuff with Guthrie Govan, Adam Holtzman, Nick Beggs, and Marco Minnemman are exceptional compositions as well.
Jud is so talented, holy cow
Im honored..
Whoa it’s PT spreading their musical journey to some more new listeners!
👍🏻✌🏻💪🏻😎
I think we need a full cover of this song by Judson now 🤔
Wilson did an offshoot type album with the guy from Opeth called Storm Corrosion, that surprised the shit out of me. I really love the last song on it.
Yessss now Luminol!!! And awesome commentary I was not expecting such a nice sharing of ideas
Great Measures
what an effin' banger of a song. It's also a joy to play on the guitar. You guys are awesome!
I’m from Syria and I watch every single video you make .. look how far you’ve reached .. keep it up guys!
Man his improv after was so good, bravo, incredible pianist.
DAMYUM, see Judsons linking this song to the uncertainty theory of Heisenberg and some quantum physics after absolutely nailing the song on the piano was awesome!!!
Love your reaction guys, keep going
In 2008 I have the privilege of seeing these guys live and it was one heck of a show. Everyone has already said what you should check out next. It’s a little heavier than this. I’m just gonna go ahead and tell you that going in. But if you truly want a showcase of this band’s skills, definitely listen to anesthetize live. Also, another thing that I think I should mention it is a long song about 17 minutes, so you might want to have some popcorn on hand. What I heard it played live. I was infatuated by the end of it. I normally get up and dance to songs during live shows but with this one, I was absolutely glued to my seat, because of the amazing talent that was being displayed.
Judson, you fricking blow my mind every frucking time !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
First, i am late, second, i love that piano intro by Judson, third, i am just overall happy to see you listening to Porcupine Tree.
A little tidbit to this song. Mikael Ackerfeldt from Opeth plays the bluesy guitar solo after the fast part ends!
You can really tell, too, when you listen to a song like Hours of Wealth by Opeth. Which makes sense because the albums came out around the same time; Akerfeldt used a similar style, phrasing, etc. on both.
One of the best solos I have heard, especially the second solo that is played by Mikael Akerfeldt from Opeth!
stumbled on here from going through a Metallica moment w/ Justice and your piece on "To Live is to Die". Great concept & interactions. And Judson's insights on the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics is hilarious juxtapose the melancholy nature of the music, lyrics. keep it up, you have a new subscriber and I've shared your channel with my friends
So glad you guys discovered PT. The piano interpretations...love 'em! They are among my all time favorite bands. Welcome aboard!
Judson, your playing @ the end of the song was brilliant. I could've easily listened to you expanding on that.
Sound of Muzak is perfect for this cat for production values for sure though
Damn, this song sounds great on piano
Steven Wilson - Drive Home with Guthrie Govan's solo of the ages is also a great one. I am once again asking for your support - I mean get him to listen to some Symphony X. :D Awakenings, or for an "easy listen" Paradise Lost (song). I'd say The Odyssey but that's a 24 minute song - It'd be well worth it as it is an amazing song, but I assume you'd prefer something shorter.
This song is a masterpiece. It's hard to believe that so few other reactors don't cover it. I thoroughly enjoyed this thank you
Great reaction guys, take the journey down the rabbit hole that is porcupine tree, you won’t be disappointed, as a few have already said, their live performances are fantastic.. look forward hearing more.. Side note, steven Wilson’s solo music is also fantastic .
Gavin Harrison - 19 days, is the best. I used to play it for my son when he was in the womb and it would instantly stop him from crying when he was being fussy. Of course outside the womb
You should go old school and play Autum Offering.... either Embrace the Gutter or Silence and Goodbye
First time hearing this, but the beginning definitely gives me pink floyd vibes. 10:56 I was not expecting that, I was enjoying the flow and then it got aggressive and I'm not complaining! I'm a huge Opeth and radiohead fan and it's almost like a mix between them two (with a sprinkle of pink ployd). Nice soft guitar mini solo towards the end, great feel. I'm really digging this.
Also how cool was Judson's quick interpretation and playthrough.
Great content, as always! Porcupine Tree is one of my favorite bands. Steven Wilson is a brilliant composer, and Gavin Harrison is an amazing drummer. Check out the song Anesthetize Live from Tilburg. Amazing
Have been thinking recently what you'd make of this song and boom! Great minds Great Measures. You've got so many great albums to sink your teeth into now they've piqued your interest. Fear of a Blank Planet, Lightbulb Sun and Deadwing are probably my favourite in that order, and as others have mentioned, Anesthetize off the first I mention should definitely be Judson's next taste. Feels almost mean to keep the whole albums from him as I'm almost certain he'll love them all.
Beautiful little piano rendition at the end from ol' ear hands, and a little bit of quantum physics and specific mention of Richard Feynman?! If I were a lady, I'd be changing panties right now.
😂😂
My man..
Another option thats not Anesthetise (which is one of my favorite songs) is Watchmaker from Steven Wilsons solo project
It’s confirmed. Curiosity didn’t kill the cat. Judson did.
Dead
Should check out "Anesthetize" from their live album also called Anesthetize. I would watch the live video. An amazing performance and song.
This album started as the soundtrack to a film project that didn't find a backer, so it was finished off as a standard rock record. Main songwriter Steven Wilson has/had a career fixation on death, ghosts, dead-end youth culture, etc., which this song and album (yes, released in 2005) slots into. Credit where credit is due -- that opening ambient thing was mainly Richard Barbieri, who isn't your typical 'twiddly synth' keys guy. He's much more into textures and sound color, more along the lines of Brian Eno rather than Jordan Rudess. And Judson hits on something important about P-Tree (and a lot of prog metal), in that there's usually not a lot of harmonic complexity or super tricky chords going on. It's often more about instrumental richness and depth. That might explain why P-Tree -- which was a Pink Floyd-sounding indie-psych group in their early days -- put so much work into that side of things when they moved into their prog-metal phase.
BTW, the band name started as a joke between Steven Wilson and a buddy who were wanted to record some Syd Barrett-flavored psychedelic music. They thought it would be funny to adopt outrageous made up names, and the band name needed to be equally silly. As for where to go next, if you want to stick with the prog metal genre, the three albums to listen to are 'In Absentia', 'Deadwing', and 'Fear of a Blank Planet'. Their recent comeback album, 'Closure/Continuation', is also recommended, but those three albums are the core of that period.
Just for a laugh, you should show Judson some of Gavin Harrison's big band rearrangements of some PT songs. Very cool!
First time I recognized Juds intro song!
Same.
Definitely keep the king Diamond coming ! Especially anything from the spiders lullaby or graveyard
They have some incredible music. I'm partial to the album In Absentia, but they are all awesome.
You know what else Judson has been missing out on? Archspire! 😊
Two porcupine tree songs that a Pianist would appreciate are Lazarus and Cheating the Polygraph
I was not expecting a discussion on quantum mechanics here...
I really liked this song and I'm a metalhead. I also play piano but I'm nowhere near Judson. He picked that up and just started playing. Good ear! 👍 I also find theoretical physics fascinating.
Another band right along these lines would be Riverside. I suggest the tracks Volte-Face or Parasomnia from the Reality Dream album.
It would also be interesting to see Judson's response to The Mars Volta, maybe the track Tetragrammaton from the album Amputechture.
U deserved my sub 👑
They go to the G. Yeah but that is exactly what is Wilsons sound. That chord change. It is beautiful, maybe because I expect it somewhere 😊
great reaction lads,"check out "let's sleep together" live.it's just pure power
The Start of Something Beautiful is another great track on the Deadwing album. In Absentia is also a great album to explore. You really can't go wrong with anything from PT, other than perhaps their 1st album (but even on that album Radioactive Toy & Nine Cats are decent).
I think Judson would really enjoy "Lazarus" by the same band
Hell yes!!! Some PPT!!! Would love to see you guys to Anesthetize too. The vocal arrangement is something I think Judson would love.
What an amazing body of work these guys have to tap into. Hope that you do more. ‘Anesthetize’, ‘Hate Song’ or “the start of something beautiful’ would be good next steps - oh and LIVE is even better with PT if available.
Steven Wilson is one of the best in the business at mixing and happens to be an amazing multi instrumentalist and composer. There is nothing he cannot do and the early Porcupine Tree records were just him. Check out his solo records, he explores many different genres and they are more progressive, especially "Hand Cannot Erase" and "The Raven That Refused To Sing".
guys that was great! love the piano after too beautiful!
I love porcupine tree! please check out dark matter or trains both live or studio versions are great!
oo porcupine tree
Wow the ending was too good. Thanks for this. Loved the discussion. Did not expect a reference to Feynman but it oddly fits 😂
Such a great reaction, you guys need to react to Steven Wilson - Routine, the official video, quite a sad song but it's beautiful, a must listen
Hearing the reactor discuss quantum physics in a prog rock reaction video was not on my bingo board 😂
Great band!! 🤙👏👏👏👏
That was a nice ride. First time hearing. 🐉
Small solo in the middle of the song was played by Mikael Akerfeldt from Opeth. Another PT -> Opeth connection :)
Cool song, I'm just now beginning my exploration of PT as well. Thumbs up here ! 👍
Also, you really need to watch their whole live in Teilburg set and witness their musical genius.
There were a lot of steps leading up to it, but discovering this band back in '07 really sent me on the path to my favorite style of music. There's so many great songs to check out, like Anesthetize, The Start of Something Beautiful, and Hatesong, and there are so many bands in a similar vein with great music of their own, like The Pineapple Thief and Riverside. Keep on going!
Pineapple Thief also has the same drummer
@@lexievv Yep, Gavin's one of the best to ever do it, but Bruce and Pineapple Thief made good music even before Gavin took over. No doubt that they've been elevated by him, though.
@@Bonzoso21 yeah, very true. I wasn't trying to say they were bad before Gavin joined, only pointing out that they now have the same drummer:)
It is concluded that Steven Wilson when decided to give the name for the band opted for the name Porcupine because of that parable, I believe that in his youth he feel like a porcupine because he want to do what he wants in music, and not what others want
Your video came into my home feed due to the Porcupine Tree content, and I have instantly subscribed. Fantastic content, love the premise and discussions. I hope to see lots more porcupine tree content - I agree with Anesthetize, or as fans dubbed it when it premiered in concert prior to album release, "The Beast". Perhaps at a later date we could even hear some Dream Theater feedback. What a rabbit hole of potential that would unleash!
Judson would probably really like something from "Agalloch". Their first album, Pale Folklore (1999) is amazing.
I was hoping that you guys would do some PT at some point. I haven't watched through to the end yet, so I'm looking forward to Judson's opinion. You should have him listen to something from one of Steven Wilson's solo albums, like Luminol or Ancestral.
Steve Wilson of porcupine tree is a musical genius
I love Porcupine Tree and this song is amazing.
Thanks for react, guys!
I recommend Anesthetize. 🤘
I love Porcupine Tree. Twenty years ago I went from never having heard of the band to owning half a dozen albums in the space of a few weeks. The band is fronted by, and the brainchild of, Steven Wilson; along with his many solo releases they comprise some of the best music of the last 30 years - indeed, his/the band's discography runs to many hundreds of pages! I'd suggest ...
Porcupine Tree tracks to try:
'Trains' from 'In Absentia' [2002] - ua-cam.com/video/cjK5BATARUo/v-deo.htmlsi=mXxWRPwkKNTf0ZXn
'Dark Matter' from 'Signify' [1996] - ua-cam.com/video/tLzguJzXyBc/v-deo.htmlsi=w73kqFxLtLycCGS8
'The Sky Moves Sideways Phase 1' from 'The Sky Moves Sideways' [1995] - ua-cam.com/video/rwKOrA-9d10/v-deo.htmlsi=hSDJ4wGolkq74XY2
'Buying New Soul' from 'Recordings' [2001] - ua-cam.com/video/KViXRn_c2nE/v-deo.htmlsi=WviXXgIfzdPaEa-j
'Open Car' from 'Deadwing' [2005] - ua-cam.com/video/xuORaGlbBoQ/v-deo.htmlsi=L6bPiaUaWvr1ysV9
... and solo releases by Steven Wilson:
'Impossible Tightrope' from 'The Harmony Codex' [2023] - ua-cam.com/video/qbGkZ31Fmp8/v-deo.htmlsi=9bJ4v0sYPu_z1Xrm
'Home Invastion/Regret #9' from 'Hand. Cannot. Erase' [2015] - ua-cam.com/video/6L1T7tfMQ88/v-deo.htmlsi=Q2cB-1bCVX5kBPdW
'Remainder the Black Dog' from 'Grace for Drowning' [2011] - ua-cam.com/video/zjwPt1eNF9A/v-deo.htmlsi=mAljDs25a2OIqy5I
'Vermillioncore' from '4½' [2016, recorded live at the North Sea Jazz Festival] - ua-cam.com/video/jkYJJYK7S48/v-deo.htmlsi=MMKEav9O5mQJewrG
'Eminent Sleaze' from 'The Future Bites' [2021] - ua-cam.com/video/kUKmOkrcMig/v-deo.htmlsi=fTQe5q7omAa3R4rL
'Luminol' from 'The Raven That Refused To Sing (And Other Stories)' [2013, recorded in Mexico City 2012 and released on the live album 'Get All You Deserve'] - ua-cam.com/video/EM-5EBAJ7tA/v-deo.htmlsi=0eIsdhwve8HOt1Lk
Amazing band
Omg. For the love of god do “Open Car”. Please!