I have kept back watching this video until Friday evening and have loved every issue. There have been more OHHHS and AHHHS from me than the greatest firework display. I enjoyed the background comic talk and hearing all of your views and memories on the different issues and characters. Cheers fellas 😀.
I stopped by this week and picked up a couple books. Also their regular modern dollar comic books are fun to go through. The bookstore is a gem. Thanks!!
Hey Sean...incredible Vid. I went uptown there the next day the Cellar was open and had a blast digging through the books with a few other excited folks who had driven from out of state to see the goods....I was on a tight budget but left with a Handsome little stack with some GREAT deals......the staff there are Awesome......will def. head back there in the future ! :)
I mean these books are in such amazing condition. I hope this family knew the money they were donating. May of been the collectors wishes. I've never seen so many books that old, that nice and glossy like you said.
They probably did not know what they had just wanted to get rid of them. But it did help raise a good amount of cash for the charity book shop. They were glossy but still had wear and foxing so overall probably 3.5-6.0 condition.
Hello there 😺! I'm a big retrospective fan of the old comic books - mostly of the 1960's, 1970's and 1980's. Your channel seems so retrospectively cool, you got yourself a new subscriber from from Vantaa, Finland 🇫🇮. 😺👍
ok so this put a huge smile on my face. just to know that there are comic collections still unbagged and boarded. im a firm believer that comics are not as rare as people say. just millions of books in storage not in circulation
An untouched Owners collection like this is pretty rare, I dont see them that often. But they are out there and is something I se once every few years.
Ooo Space Ghost! I wonder if they still have it? Would love to work on that one. What beautiful books they had! Great upload Sean. Great meeting you at TerrifiCon on that Friday!
the host of Pop Comics is amazing fantastic and also a good connoisseur when it comes to collecting vintage and and present day comic books for the kids andand even for the young adults and teenagers of the American family members ofof the comic book genre sincerely the fork ball kid Jamal Shelly with a Gthank you
G'day Sean, enjoying your videos from the other side of the world in Australia.Made me smile at your comment about an Australian customer in your shop collecting The Phantom as that was very popular here back in the day.Absolutely loved this video and thank you for sharing with us as always.much love from Down Under.Brendon
I only live 30 minutes from the Book Cellar, but I'm resigned to the fact that the best books will be gone by the time I get there. Oh well. This was another excellent video with great comic banter to boot. Thanks, Sean!
A lot has sold but there is still a lot left. I think if you are ok finding some cool Silver age books around $5-$10 its worth a trip, if you only want key issues it might be too late.
Man, how I would have loved that Kenner gun that shoots around corners as child! But on a hot Sydney summer day nothing beat a water pistol fight with friends, then into the 3 foot deep upright pool to cool off followed by lunch and then an afternoon of comics reading. Good times Sean, just really good times. And a great video here, the comics are nice but the chatter is priceless.
I gave them a standing offer if they dont sell so well in the shop I am happy to pay about 50% of the prices we came up with to buy them out but I think we all want to see what they can sell in the shop first so they can get the most out of the Donation. That being said I know if someone walks in and wants a few books they will negotiate on the prices.
Great collection! I was a little concerned with their desire to not "invest" in bagging and boarding these. I wonder if it was due to the perceived cost associated with that, or what? Thanks for sharing!
So the book store is a charity shop that gets donations and all the proceeds go to help programs at the library. It has a great volunteer staff that keeps the place open. Comics they normally put out for $1 so a collection like this was not something they normally deal in or were prepared to bag and board etc. So because of that my friend Spencer introduced me to Don who processes the donations and I volunteered to go and price out the collection and help them figure out what to do with them all etc. I was not expecting to buy anything, I just wanted to make a video to promote the collection and help them price it all out but they did let me buy the ones I needed for my PC for a fair price so I was really happy with that. I brought 100 bags and boards with me and traded for 2 $5 books to give to my friend Spencer, so basically a donation to the shop and a gift to Spencer for helping out. Not only did he introduce me to the shop but he too spent the full day 10am-4PM sorting and pricing with me. He appreciates the store and loves book stores in general so he wanted to see them be helped out as well. As for the remaining books, we stood them up in the box with a divider in the middle so they don't get too rummaged through as people look to buy from them. I am hoping most get into collectors hands this week so they don't get too damaged.
@@pop-comics Thanks for taking the time to provide a lengthy response! Hope this video brings that library some attention and they can sell through that collection to keep on supporting the charity. 😁
Nice collection! I feel its best to price less than FMV due to the low grade conditions of these comics. I would imagine they would want to sell off the collection as quickly as possible. The longer the comics sit around you run the risk of more damage to them especially when people go through the boxes.
Thank you, it was so much fun. If you can make it into Manhattan tomorrow the books will be for sale. Including all the great Batman books. Everything is priced to be a good deal, just not a steal.
Also there were a bunch of books that would have been highish grade but the foxing etc holding them back. I think there was a lot of books that you could work your magic with.
@@pop-comics Those are some darned good circles! I think I loved Kamandi so much because, well, I often wandered around the fields and vacant lots of my hometown as a kid, exploring abandoned houses, barns, junked cars, etc. It was the 70s, so a kid outside on his own wasn't unusual. I suppose I often imagined I was Kamandi (I even had hair that long). Great memories. Thanks for the fun video, as always.
I don't think it sold very well. I actually got two issues of the 70s title as part of a grab bag of random issues bought on eBay. I kept one, but not the other.
@@wylierichardson-tu6zs Oh? I didn't know that. But I think there was a general feeling that the series was just trying to capitalize on the popularity of the Planet of the Apes films (the whole post-apocalyptic thing with talking animals). Maybe that worked against it.
Those 80 page giants look great. About the same condition as mine when I had them. I had a complete run from # 1 all the way through to 56 i think it was. The first 15 & then 16 onwards that were numbered as part of the title run
They look read mid grade copies, I know when I was little the stuff I had when I was 8 was trashed but the stuff from when I was 10-14 was in good shape because I took care of them. I see it all the time in collections, the earliest stuff is trashed then as the kid got older they took care of the books better.
@pop-comics thought it was the Dino cover or does it just look a lot like it? Will have to try amd go back, you said you really like the cover I'll double check would be awesome
Try to figure out which book it is for me, I don't remember seeing a book that much in the piles but if there is one I want to make sure they know. Which series are you talking about? Honestly I dont remember any Black Canary covers at all.
Fantastic Four annual was first Annhiliation…you are missing some great books into the right pile Sub-Mariner, First Sting Ray, Doctor Strange-1st Living Tibunal.
@ it’s no.29 avenger , really good condition… to me any way. My first comic. Think it’s a good steal? Or a rip off at $150? Over a hundred I think is expensive lol
If the whole collection sold on ebay I think it would generate 5-7K possibly a bit more (Before fees and labor, after fees and labor they would make less then selling in person), I suspect they will generate 4K at the end of the day at the shop.
Nothing like a guy who doesn't take the time to see what he has in value (he couldn't be bothered), just bring it to the book store and dump it. I hope he makes some good money, and he's able to stay opened. We are loosing book stores every year.
The guy who donated the books was awesome because it was a lot of value donated to the shop, the book shop is awesome because it is a non profit and all the proceeds go to help programs at the library and my friend Spencer is awesome for introducing me to the shop, and Don was awesome for letting me price the books fairly so everyone gets a good deal, and he let me buy the ones I wanted for my PC for a good price. I think its a win win win for everyone involved.
@@wylierichardson-tu6zs I think he meant it was the most valuable in this collection, I think it ended up being second or third most valuable when I priced them out. Even though it was low grade the DR doom Prototype issue was worth more.
@@pop-comicshey Shawn! I’m Patrick from Alabama, I’m an absolute huge fan! I just wanted to say how awesome it was of you to do this. You do an awesome job at helping others. Very Selfless! Anyways! I wanted to say I’m a disabled/retired firefighter From Alabama, I was part of a search & rescue team sent from Alabama to The World Trade Center during 9/11. So New York citizens are part of my family now. So because of your story I was able to purchase the very last 3 comics available. This is two times mean the world to me! Because of you, and New York itself: I wish I could have your autograph as well! I’m saving these comics as the crew from the Book Cellar are signing some things for me. God Bless you Brother! Me being disabled now, I watch ALLLLL YOUR vids! Absolutely love your 2-3hr vids. It’s like watching movies! Lol! I hope one day to see you so I can get you to sign the 3rd comic which is Hulk 110, 119 & marvel tales 30 SpiderMan. I’d love for you all to autograph the Marvel Ts ales SpiderMan. Thank you so much once again! Those books went quick 😂👍👊😉
Right at 54 minutes, listen to how quiet that owner guy gets when you don't discover Poison Ivy's first appearance. He already picked it I bet. Way to be sneaky. He even says he already organized it. I feel bad for the guy that donated this stuff, he was sitting on a gold mine.
The Book Cellar volunteer took all the high priced books that he recognized for himself before Shawn arrived to help him and for sure he took all the books that Shawn priced that were valuable. I know people that visited the place as soon they opened, all the high end books were nowhere to be found. Very shady move!!!!
Which day where they there? I believe most of the high end books sold on Tuesday. But I was not there so I really don't know what sold. I need to do a video showing which books I bought, I think I only bought 1 Marvel book the Night Rider, and a bunch of the oddball DC books (The Atom, Hawkman, Black Hawk, Doom patrol Etc) Some Justice League and Wonder Woman issues I needed and a chunk of the War Books. I priced out all the Batman and Marvel stuff for the shop since I knew that would sell best for them.
Yes everything is for sale at the book store, I did buy a nice stack for myself. Mostly the oddball DC stuff, war books, and Archie Harvey books. All the Marvel, Batman and and bunch of the other books are for sale at a very fair price. The keys we priced at 75-90% of FMV, the rest 50-75% FMV so there are deals to be had there.
Too bad someone couldn't get a deal. Now that they're priced by you guys, forget that. But I enjoy the video and hopefully it really helps the library.
Everything was priced to be a deal just not a steal. So no, no one is buying $200 books for $1 but were able to get $60 books for $40-$50 and tons of $15-$20 books for $10 etc. At the end of the day the pricing is win win win for everyone.
@pop-comics Ultimately, that's good for the Library. and if buyer is happy too , that's great. I love that they are raw. I am I'll over comics trapped in plastic that don't get read.
The $10-$20 stuff we made a $10 box out of, the Dell and Goldkeye and lower grade books went into the $5 box. The books were mid grade vg-fn condition for the most part so there was not a ton over $20, but we did price the keys higher. These books were at a charity book shop and not a comic shop so we priced the keys at 80-90% of market price and everything else about 50% of market price so it would sell pretty quickly at a fair price for everyone without having to do the work of listing on ebay etc.
I had to double check, I was using the hip app and it listed it only as a $7 issue, so I will have to investigate it further. I thought I must have missed scanning it but I checked back and saw I had. Does look like it goes for more on ebay. Just means there might be some great deals on the books they have for sale at the shop. The Frankenstein I got for my friend Spencer.
While filming I was looking for the 100 best books that fit into Comic Bags, so my brain did not think to pull that one out because it was too big to fit. But afterwords when I priced everything out I believe I ended up pricing that one around $40. I just had to cut stips of paper out and write the grade and price on the paper and put it inside the book.
Oh that was one that was not on my radar, thanks for the info. I ended up buying all the war books from them cheap, but looks like I owe them a bit more for that one.
Only if it was in VF condition, most of these comics had foxing or other flaws that kept them in lower grade. This one was in the $15-$25 range if it was listed on ebay.
I noticed in the comments people complaining about "he's not an expert" he missed blah blah blah. Like as if you need to know everything right away, and you have no resources available to make sure you didn't miss anything. I bet you spent 2 hours just bagging and boarding books for them.
Yup I looked up everything except the dell and goldkeye box, I ran out of time. But that box I think I pulled the books of value and no one mentioned any I missed so I think that box is good. I only had 100 bags and boards though, so I had to decided the 100 I wanted to get protected. Everything else I sorted into a $10 box and a $5 box. The larger size books of value I cut a paper strip and wrote the price on the end of the strip and stuck it in the middle of the book with the price popping out. I also always assume people let me know what I missed in the video so I can let them know after the fact which I did with one book.
In the VG condition it was in, still falls under $30. After filming I went back and resorted them. I don't think I ended up putting it in the top 100 pile though so someone probably got it for a great price.
YOU SHOULD LOOK UP THE COMIC PRICE GUIDES FOR SURE- THE CHEAP PILE HE MADE IS NOT $5.-$10. BOOKS.THE AVERAGE PRICE FOR MOST OF THOSE ARE BETWEEN $100.-$700. THOSE UNEXPECTED BOOKS HAVE PRICES BETWEEN $300.-$700. EACH. THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS MORE TO BE MADE FOR THE LIBRARY.
If they were NM 9.8 candidates maybe, but for the most part they are in 4.0-6.0 low to mid grade condition so no they were not worth Thousands, no one would pay that.
Not true! Most of the books were in low grade condition, covers showed moderate to significant wear, creases, discoloration, fading, many books had lots of foxing, pages were brown, especially the Gold Key and Dell books.
Its more they are a charity shop run on donations, they don't tend to deal in rare comics. That is why I brought them 100 bags and boards to at least get the top 100 comics protected, and the rest we stood up in the boxes so they would be easier to go through without damaging them and added a divider in the middle so they could be flipped through easier without snagging on each other. Sounds like a bunch have sold already so hopefully all the books get into collectors hands soon.
Yeah I always mix up 1st and second prowler. I did go back and price them both out, I think the Fantastic Four Annual #5 was priced in the $40-$50 range in VG condition.
@@pop-comics right on it definitely gets a little nutty when you look through a whole bunch of books you lose your place. I enjoy your videos dude keep it going.
@@RichSensale Yeah there was a lot going on between conversations and trying to sort through all the books. I ended up spending another 4-5 hours after the video scanning everything looking up pricing then figuring out prices that I thought would be win win for everyone and putting the approximate grades on the 100 best books. I ran out of time so I did have to guesstimate all the Dell and Goldkey were cheaper, but I might have missed something. Thinking back I was looking for the 100 best books to put into the bags and boards I brought with me I might have put that one to the side because I could not fit it into the bags etc.
Yes the collection was donated to the Book Cellar. Which is the charity book shop under the Webster Library. All the proceeds go to support various programs at the library. NYC public library system is a real asset to the city.
Its NYC, people die and people clear out stuff to rent or sell apartments etc. Happens all the time. I have literally bought Key issues worth $100s to $1000+ from junk removal guys who got paid to haul the comics away etc. Have had people sell me sweet comics they found on the curb many times as well. Some people appreciate Library and happily donate things to help support. Either way I think the book store raised 3-4K from this collection maybe more so it was super successful for them.
What I showed on the video was to show every one what was in the collection with the purpose of people coming to the shop to buy the books. After filming I spent another 4-5 hours looking up and pricing up everything and pricing it fairly for everyone.
I believe we ended up pricing it at $40, while going through them I was looking for the 100 best that would fit in Bags and Boards. I did not have large enough size for the Annual.
I have kept back watching this video until Friday evening and have loved every issue. There have been more OHHHS and AHHHS from me than the greatest firework display. I enjoyed the background comic talk and hearing all of your views and memories on the different issues and characters. Cheers fellas 😀.
Happy you found time to enjoy the video, It was a very fun day hanging out and sorting comics.
It was so wonderful to see this collection. It's great to listen to you all chatting as you went through the boxes. Great video! 👍🏻 😃
It was a fun day hanging out, chatting comics and sorting through a collection of beautiful comics.
Sean what a neat video! So many cool books, history and nostalgia! Thanks for sharing!
You are very welcome, it was a fun opportunity to share an amazing collection of books.
What an awesome collection there! Sean thanks for giving us a glimpse of the fun things you get to do! Wish I was there! Lol
You are very welcome. I love finding fun comic opportunities to share with everyone, so we call can get a chance to experience it together.
I stopped by this week and picked up a couple books. Also their regular modern dollar comic books are fun to go through. The bookstore is a gem. Thanks!!
Very neat. Yeah after I went through the books for them I ended up buying a pile of Manga for cheap. Really fun shop.
WOW! I would be so overwhelmed with these books.. so out of my price range and so much history and value! DC Gang all day (: awesome video !
I think most of these ended up in the $10 range, pretty affordable to buy a couple for the pc.
Hey Sean...incredible Vid. I went uptown there the next day the Cellar was open and had a blast digging through the books with a few other excited folks who had driven from out of state to see the goods....I was on a tight budget but left with a Handsome little stack with some GREAT deals......the staff there are Awesome......will def. head back there in the future ! :)
That is awesome! There were a lot of fun books for a good price there.
I used to work with BPL i've actually taught art classes there! I want to stop by, currently teaching Comic book/ manga classes now.
I mean these books are in such amazing condition. I hope this family knew the money they were donating. May of been the collectors wishes. I've never seen so many books that old, that nice and glossy like you said.
They probably did not know what they had just wanted to get rid of them. But it did help raise a good amount of cash for the charity book shop. They were glossy but still had wear and foxing so overall probably 3.5-6.0 condition.
Wow! What an experience. Thanks for sharing this!
You are very welcome.
Thanks again for another amazing video. I really enjoyed the conversation and the awesome comics .
You are very welcome, it was a really fun experience.
I’m 15min in and drooling….i just can’t believe the condition this is awesome to see.
It was so fun to see the gloss still on most of those books. Just amazing.
Can't believe I'm just seeing this! I woulda drove up and bought it all!! Everything I love about comics
Right?! So many great books!
Sean, this is cool!! I'm enjoying the books esp. the Marvel box, but listening to Don and the other collector chatting away in Bg, THAT is GOLD...!!
Oh yeah the conversation was the best part, made looking through the wonderful old books even more fun!
Yes, the background convos are very interesting!
I think so indeed!
Hello there 😺!
I'm a big retrospective fan of the old
comic books - mostly of the 1960's, 1970's and 1980's.
Your channel seems so retrospectively cool,
you got yourself a new subscriber from
from Vantaa, Finland 🇫🇮.
😺👍
I do love vintage comics. Thank you for the sub, very much appreciated.
Wow! So many great books!
I know, right?!
ok so this put a huge smile on my face. just to know that there are comic collections still unbagged and boarded. im a firm believer that comics are not as rare as people say. just millions of books in storage not in circulation
An untouched Owners collection like this is pretty rare, I dont see them that often. But they are out there and is something I se once every few years.
Ooo Space Ghost! I wonder if they still have it? Would love to work on that one. What beautiful books they had! Great upload Sean. Great meeting you at TerrifiCon on that Friday!
Oh man I would love for it to be in your hands, other then the stain it had really good bones. I will ask if they still have it.
@@pop-comics thank you Sean!
Don checked for me, he thinks it sold already. Next time I see a decent key that is only flaw is tide lines I will think of you.
@@pop-comics sounds good. Thx for trying anyway Sean! Again, great upload!!
This is such an incredible collection
It really is! It was fun to have the opportunity to sort it out.
This video is so much fun! Loving the whole collection . Love the mainstream but have an equal love for the real off beat titles.
It was fun to go through the collection and see what was there. The offbeat stuff is really fun to me too, you do not see that stuff nearly as often.
the host of Pop Comics is amazing fantastic and also a good connoisseur when it comes to collecting vintage and and present day comic books for the kids andand even for the young adults and teenagers of the American family members ofof the comic book genre sincerely the fork ball kid Jamal Shelly with a Gthank you
Thank you I really appreciate that.
What an incredible donation! I'd buy those DC comics all day long.
Yeah it was a really awesome collection to witness in person.
G'day Sean, enjoying your videos from the other side of the world in Australia.Made me smile at your comment about an Australian customer in your shop collecting The Phantom as that was very popular here back in the day.Absolutely loved this video and thank you for sharing with us as always.much love from Down Under.Brendon
Yeah I have heard that a few times now which is super cool. I would love to be able to collect more silver and bronze age Australian books!
What a fun treasure hunt of books in NYC! Gold Key and Dell need more love! Painted covers are fun!
They definitely do, the covers are amazing.
That tales of suspense was the Dr. Doom prototype awesome.
Yeah a very cool issue!
I've dreamed about finding books like this.
Yeah its not every day you see an old original owner collection like this.
You find all the treasures love those TOS ims. Love your channel.
Thanks for watching
I only live 30 minutes from the Book Cellar, but I'm resigned to the fact that the best books will be gone by the time I get there. Oh well. This was another excellent video with great comic banter to boot. Thanks, Sean!
A lot has sold but there is still a lot left. I think if you are ok finding some cool Silver age books around $5-$10 its worth a trip, if you only want key issues it might be too late.
This is my favorite era of Marvel comics besides modern so cool to see all these different ones
Oh yeah the 1960s Marvels are very fun books.
Our army At War 151... first Enemy Ace. You passed over it.
Yeah that one was not on my radar.
That Capt Marvel #2 is a beauty!! Glossy!!
Indeed!
This sweet! I'm also based in NYC. Would love to meet some day. Great content
We met briefly at The Bronx Comic con.
@@pop-comics that’s right. My brain is not functioning properly anymore. 😂
haha its all good, I am 100% sure we will bump into each other again and can chat more indepth lol
DAM!!!W.O.W.!!!!!! THIS IS A CRAZY GREAT COMIC SHOW!!!! THANK YOU 4 SHARING!!!! UNTIL NEXT ⏰️ ❤😂😂🎉🙏🦸🦹😂😂🤡✌️✌️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️🤖🦸♂️🦸♂️🥳🫶🤣👍🦹♀️😁🐶
Glad you enjoyed it
@@pop-comics ALWAY'S& 4EVER!!! THANK YOU AGAIN!!!!👍🤎
Great video - enjoyed the background conversation. Big fan of 70s Kirby too.
Yeah the conversation was the most fun part.
Man, how I would have loved that Kenner gun that shoots around corners as child! But on a hot Sydney summer day nothing beat a water pistol fight with friends, then into the 3 foot deep upright pool to cool off followed by lunch and then an afternoon of comics reading. Good times Sean, just really good times. And a great video here, the comics are nice but the chatter is priceless.
Yeah would have been a fun toy to play with back in the day. It was a really fun video to make.
Great video, lots of awesome books. 👍
Thanks a bunch!
The glossi is blinding ! Amazing time capsule !
Yes anytime I see gloss on 1960s books its amazing.
What a nice collection!
Will somebody be able to make an offer on all four boxes eventually?
I gave them a standing offer if they dont sell so well in the shop I am happy to pay about 50% of the prices we came up with to buy them out but I think we all want to see what they can sell in the shop first so they can get the most out of the Donation. That being said I know if someone walks in and wants a few books they will negotiate on the prices.
Good run filler collection with a few nice keys.
Indeed!
Great collection! I was a little concerned with their desire to not "invest" in bagging and boarding these. I wonder if it was due to the perceived cost associated with that, or what? Thanks for sharing!
So the book store is a charity shop that gets donations and all the proceeds go to help programs at the library. It has a great volunteer staff that keeps the place open. Comics they normally put out for $1 so a collection like this was not something they normally deal in or were prepared to bag and board etc. So because of that my friend Spencer introduced me to Don who processes the donations and I volunteered to go and price out the collection and help them figure out what to do with them all etc. I was not expecting to buy anything, I just wanted to make a video to promote the collection and help them price it all out but they did let me buy the ones I needed for my PC for a fair price so I was really happy with that. I brought 100 bags and boards with me and traded for 2 $5 books to give to my friend Spencer, so basically a donation to the shop and a gift to Spencer for helping out. Not only did he introduce me to the shop but he too spent the full day 10am-4PM sorting and pricing with me. He appreciates the store and loves book stores in general so he wanted to see them be helped out as well. As for the remaining books, we stood them up in the box with a divider in the middle so they don't get too rummaged through as people look to buy from them. I am hoping most get into collectors hands this week so they don't get too damaged.
@@pop-comics Thanks for taking the time to provide a lengthy response! Hope this video brings that library some attention and they can sell through that collection to keep on supporting the charity. 😁
Sounds like they sold a ton today so they are very happy and I am happy to hear a bunch is going off into collectors hands.
Sean fantastic collection especially Thor tales of suspense and the hulk plus the dc book’s great.
Oh yeah those were great books in decent mid grade condition.
Saw that 1st Living Tribunal
Nice collection! I feel its best to price less than FMV due to the low grade conditions of these comics. I would imagine they would want to sell off the collection as quickly as possible. The longer the comics sit around you run the risk of more damage to them especially when people go through the boxes.
Yup I think the keys we ended up pricing around 80% of FMV and everything else 50-75% of FMV so they are a deal just not a steal.
RE: '60s toy commercial. What a cool story...!!
Yeah it was super cool to find out Don had been in that commercial as a kid. I had seen that before too.
This is torture watching this, the condition, the volume, the art work. I want them all, but I can’t have them. 😢
Yeah so many sweet books, its hard not wanting to buy them all.
There are a lot of collectable issues in the Our Army at Way series. Should be checking those.
I ended up buying those for my PC, I think I looked them up after the fact and there was one with a bit of value. Rest semi cheap.
You found another great stack of books. You could find comics on the moon if you could get up there.
I probably could and those would be neat lol
@pop-comics Lots of cool space helmets, Ray guns, Rocket ships.
and stars.
@@stevedriskell59yes, the issues left behind by Neil and Buzz. 😋
What a great upload.
Thank you, it was so much fun. If you can make it into Manhattan tomorrow the books will be for sale. Including all the great Batman books. Everything is priced to be a good deal, just not a steal.
Also there were a bunch of books that would have been highish grade but the foxing etc holding them back. I think there was a lot of books that you could work your magic with.
Someone took all the major keys out. Still great books
There was still a few in there 1st Silver Age Penguin etc. But yeah I did not see anything super valuable in there.
Sean the villan on XM 23 is Count Neferia, the guy on XM 94...!!
Yes had to look that one up myself.
Kamandi getting some love! My favourite comic in the 70s. It hardly ever gets mentioned, even though it was Kirby.
Oh we love Kamandi in the Pop Comics circles!
@@pop-comics Those are some darned good circles! I think I loved Kamandi so much because, well, I often wandered around the fields and vacant lots of my hometown as a kid, exploring abandoned houses, barns, junked cars, etc. It was the 70s, so a kid outside on his own wasn't unusual. I suppose I often imagined I was Kamandi (I even had hair that long). Great memories. Thanks for the fun video, as always.
Sounds like a fun Childhood, I did similar adventures in my time.
I don't think it sold very well. I actually got two issues of the 70s title as part of a grab bag of random issues bought on eBay. I kept one, but not the other.
@@wylierichardson-tu6zs Oh? I didn't know that. But I think there was a general feeling that the series was just trying to capitalize on the popularity of the Planet of the Apes films (the whole post-apocalyptic thing with talking animals). Maybe that worked against it.
Those 80 page giants look great. About the same condition as mine when I had them. I had a complete run from # 1 all the way through to 56 i think it was. The first 15 & then 16 onwards that were numbered as part of the title run
Yeah very fun books and in pretty decent shape.
if he collected when he was 12 or 13, those books wouldnt be in such good condition.
i would LOVE to have those Metal Men!
They look read mid grade copies, I know when I was little the stuff I had when I was 8 was trashed but the stuff from when I was 10-14 was in good shape because I took care of them. I see it all the time in collections, the earliest stuff is trashed then as the kid got older they took care of the books better.
1st Prowler is ASM 78, not that cover only book you found.
Yeah figured that mistake when I priced it. I always mix the two up
Holy Hannah that Forst black canary (cover you said you liked), is 19k high grade 1.9 low wow just that alone insane donation
Which issue was that? Are you talking about the original Golden Age 1st Black Canary? Would have been cool if that issue was there.
@pop-comics thought it was the Dino cover or does it just look a lot like it? Will have to try amd go back, you said you really like the cover I'll double check would be awesome
@pop-comics darn it was a hawkman with also green Dino my bad Got mixes up
Try to figure out which book it is for me, I don't remember seeing a book that much in the piles but if there is one I want to make sure they know. Which series are you talking about? Honestly I dont remember any Black Canary covers at all.
@pop-comics I was wrong sadly was only an early hawkman 3rd box With simaler looking Dino which is what threw me
RE: Best Kirby inker... Joe Sinnott!!
He did a great job indeed.
wow!I have a lot of comics too.I have two long boxes and seven short boxes.I want you to come to my house next time.I live in japan...
Oh comics in Japan sounds like a fun journey.
@@pop-comics Thank you!
Fantastic Four annual was first Annhiliation…you are missing some great books into the right pile
Sub-Mariner, First Sting Ray, Doctor Strange-1st Living Tibunal.
I did a short about the Fantastic Four book, I just filmed my initial sort but looked up priced everything. ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
I paid $150 for a 29 avengers really good condition… the black on the edges is still very black. Is that a ok deal?
Depends on how old they are, if they are from the 1960s probably a steal, 1970s not too bad, 1980s maybe a bit expensive etc.
@ it’s no.29 avenger , really good condition… to me any way. My first comic. Think it’s a good steal? Or a rip off at $150? Over a hundred I think is expensive lol
So, how much did you eventually tell them that the whole collection was worth?
If the whole collection sold on ebay I think it would generate 5-7K possibly a bit more (Before fees and labor, after fees and labor they would make less then selling in person), I suspect they will generate 4K at the end of the day at the shop.
@@pop-comics If I had the money, I would’ve bought it all right there and then. That’s an amazing little collection.
@@JonsDDVlog I hear that!
sending my lil bro there. Hopefully He is smart and goes.
Did he go? Lots of fun books to be had.
I would have been sprinting down the sidewalk.
Haha I am hoping people do today to grab some of the sweet comics.
Checking out the part I missed...!!
Enjoy!
Nothing like a guy who doesn't take the time to see what he has in value (he couldn't be bothered), just bring it to the book store and dump it. I hope he makes some good money, and he's able to stay opened. We are loosing book stores every year.
The guy who donated the books was awesome because it was a lot of value donated to the shop, the book shop is awesome because it is a non profit and all the proceeds go to help programs at the library and my friend Spencer is awesome for introducing me to the shop, and Don was awesome for letting me price the books fairly so everyone gets a good deal, and he let me buy the ones I wanted for my PC for a good price. I think its a win win win for everyone involved.
Yeah...ff annual 6. Biggest marvel book.
Definitely. I think we ended up pricing it in the $40-$50 range for vg condition.
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
Biggest in what sense? Just curious.
@@wylierichardson-tu6zs I think he meant it was the most valuable in this collection, I think it ended up being second or third most valuable when I priced them out. Even though it was low grade the DR doom Prototype issue was worth more.
@@pop-comicsok ty for clarifying. On a side note, will u be going to any of the NYC cons coming up soon?
Killer Content Brother!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you, Appreciate it.
Someone just gave em away😭
Yup, an amazing donation to the book store!
@@pop-comicshey Shawn! I’m Patrick from Alabama, I’m an absolute huge fan! I just wanted to say how awesome it was of you to do this. You do an awesome job at helping others. Very Selfless!
Anyways! I wanted to say I’m a disabled/retired firefighter From Alabama, I was part of a search & rescue team sent from Alabama to The World Trade Center during 9/11. So New York citizens are part of my family now. So because of your story I was able to purchase the very last 3 comics available. This is two times mean the world to me! Because of you, and New York itself: I wish I could have your autograph as well! I’m saving these comics as the crew from the Book Cellar are signing some things for me. God Bless you Brother! Me being disabled now, I watch ALLLLL YOUR vids! Absolutely love your 2-3hr vids. It’s like watching movies! Lol! I hope one day to see you so I can get you to sign the 3rd comic which is Hulk 110, 119 & marvel tales 30 SpiderMan. I’d love for you all to autograph the Marvel Ts
ales SpiderMan. Thank you so much once again! Those books went quick 😂👍👊😉
Right at 54 minutes, listen to how quiet that owner guy gets when you don't discover Poison Ivy's first appearance. He already picked it I bet. Way to be sneaky. He even says he already organized it. I feel bad for the guy that donated this stuff, he was sitting on a gold mine.
@@CarlRaines-rs9gt possibly or it had been picked at some time in the past
The Book Cellar volunteer took all the high priced books that he recognized for himself before Shawn arrived to help him and for sure he took all the books that Shawn priced that were valuable. I know people that visited the place as soon they opened, all the high end books were nowhere to be found. Very shady move!!!!
Which day where they there? I believe most of the high end books sold on Tuesday. But I was not there so I really don't know what sold. I need to do a video showing which books I bought, I think I only bought 1 Marvel book the Night Rider, and a bunch of the oddball DC books (The Atom, Hawkman, Black Hawk, Doom patrol Etc) Some Justice League and Wonder Woman issues I needed and a chunk of the War Books. I priced out all the Batman and Marvel stuff for the shop since I knew that would sell best for them.
When will these comics be available for purchase?
I got them all sorted out already so I believe you can go and buy them now from the Book Cellar.
They open in 10 minutes
@@pop-comics Thanks, Sean!
You pulled Super goof 2 but skipped over the first appearance of super goof😂😅
I did miss it, but I think it was kinda low grade if I remember correctly.
@pop-comics probably lol that space ghost and Solar were awesome pulls. I'm a big dell fan
Do you know which minute Phantom Blot #2 showed up I cant find it lol I kinda dont remember seeing it, I remember #1 though.
@@pop-comics 1:11:52
Oh that is #1 in vg condition, I dont think Super Goof shows up until #2. Or if he cameos in #1 it looks like it sells for less then $10
Some great books
Indeed there were.
Fantastic four 6 annual is a big book
Definitely, I think we priced that one out at $40-$50 in around a vg condition
@@pop-comics are they selling the books? Love watching your channel
Yes everything is for sale at the book store, I did buy a nice stack for myself. Mostly the oddball DC stuff, war books, and Archie Harvey books. All the Marvel, Batman and and bunch of the other books are for sale at a very fair price. The keys we priced at 75-90% of FMV, the rest 50-75% FMV so there are deals to be had there.
@@pop-comics thank you I appreciate it
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
Too bad someone couldn't get a deal. Now that they're priced by you guys, forget that. But I enjoy the video and hopefully it really helps the library.
Everything was priced to be a deal just not a steal. So no, no one is buying $200 books for $1 but were able to get $60 books for $40-$50 and tons of $15-$20 books for $10 etc. At the end of the day the pricing is win win win for everyone.
@pop-comics Ultimately, that's good for the Library. and if buyer is happy too , that's great. I love that they are raw. I am I'll over comics trapped in plastic that don't get read.
You put 1st Eternity in the cheap pile!
I did miss that one, but in the grade it was in it was still under $20 value so we put it into the $10 box.
@pop-comics someone will be happy with that purchase! This was definitely a prize collection!
Most those books are 20 and up. 5 dollars is like wholesale
The $10-$20 stuff we made a $10 box out of, the Dell and Goldkeye and lower grade books went into the $5 box. The books were mid grade vg-fn condition for the most part so there was not a ton over $20, but we did price the keys higher. These books were at a charity book shop and not a comic shop so we priced the keys at 80-90% of market price and everything else about 50% of market price so it would sell pretty quickly at a fair price for everyone without having to do the work of listing on ebay etc.
That Frankenstein is like 25-75$
I had to double check, I was using the hip app and it listed it only as a $7 issue, so I will have to investigate it further. I thought I must have missed scanning it but I checked back and saw I had. Does look like it goes for more on ebay. Just means there might be some great deals on the books they have for sale at the shop. The Frankenstein I got for my friend Spencer.
You missed the first Annihulus FF #6
While filming I was looking for the 100 best books that fit into Comic Bags, so my brain did not think to pull that one out because it was too big to fit. But afterwords when I priced everything out I believe I ended up pricing that one around $40. I just had to cut stips of paper out and write the grade and price on the paper and put it inside the book.
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
Our Army at War 151 - 1st Enemy Ace
Oh that was one that was not on my radar, thanks for the info. I ended up buying all the war books from them cheap, but looks like I owe them a bit more for that one.
What?? First appearance of Copperhead??
Yes that was there I believe!
@@pop-comics yes it was. That needed a backboard and cover too. Very nice. $100+ comic easy.
Only if it was in VF condition, most of these comics had foxing or other flaws that kept them in lower grade. This one was in the $15-$25 range if it was listed on ebay.
Did a short on the book, double checked ebay it was a $15 book that we put out for $10 at the book store ua-cam.com/users/shorts90zDGTWnhJ0
man you kept interrupting his stories haha. great vid
He did have nice stories, I need to capture more one day. But yeah I was there to show the books.
@pop-comics fair enough, great vid love the content 👌
simply amazing. where do i go to purchase these??
They are for sale at the Book Cellar in the basement of the Webster Library. The address is in the videos description
Wrong Computo killed off one part of Triplicate Girl, not Star Finger. But good guess.
Ah thanks for the correction, still a funny fun idea
Can't believe that guy went all woke at the Swastika 😅
Something they probably would not due today.
I noticed in the comments people complaining about "he's not an expert" he missed blah blah blah. Like as if you need to know everything right away, and you have no resources available to make sure you didn't miss anything. I bet you spent 2 hours just bagging and boarding books for them.
Yup I looked up everything except the dell and goldkeye box, I ran out of time. But that box I think I pulled the books of value and no one mentioned any I missed so I think that box is good. I only had 100 bags and boards though, so I had to decided the 100 I wanted to get protected. Everything else I sorted into a $10 box and a $5 box. The larger size books of value I cut a paper strip and wrote the price on the end of the strip and stuck it in the middle of the book with the price popping out. I also always assume people let me know what I missed in the video so I can let them know after the fact which I did with one book.
Strange Tales 158 is one of the biggest books in the first 20 mins and you put it in the right hand pile. I was screaming "nooo"
In the VG condition it was in, still falls under $30. After filming I went back and resorted them. I don't think I ended up putting it in the top 100 pile though so someone probably got it for a great price.
I did ! :) The 5 dollar Bin and 10 dollar bin were/are Awesome !
Oh fantastic happy you got it.
FF Annual #6!!!!
Yeah that is a good book, I think we ended up pricing it around $40-50 in VG shape.
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
YOU SHOULD LOOK UP THE COMIC PRICE GUIDES FOR SURE- THE CHEAP PILE HE MADE IS NOT $5.-$10. BOOKS.THE AVERAGE PRICE FOR MOST OF THOSE ARE BETWEEN $100.-$700. THOSE UNEXPECTED BOOKS HAVE PRICES BETWEEN $300.-$700. EACH. THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS MORE TO BE MADE FOR THE LIBRARY.
If they were NM 9.8 candidates maybe, but for the most part they are in 4.0-6.0 low to mid grade condition so no they were not worth Thousands, no one would pay that.
Not true! Most of the books were in low grade condition, covers showed moderate to significant wear, creases, discoloration, fading, many books had lots of foxing, pages were brown, especially the Gold Key and Dell books.
Yes that is what I saw too, I think the grades where in the 3.5-5.0 range on average. The foxing being the worst flaw on most of them.
That's not the first Prowler. 78 is.
Yeah the two issues always mix up in my head until I see the number. We priced it properly though.
Wrestling books!!!!!!
I need to go back and try to snag that Superman book!
Not trying to be disrespectful but that guy talking about how “he’s not investing in anything to protect those comics” gives me anxiety 😂
Its more they are a charity shop run on donations, they don't tend to deal in rare comics. That is why I brought them 100 bags and boards to at least get the top 100 comics protected, and the rest we stood up in the boxes so they would be easier to go through without damaging them and added a divider in the middle so they could be flipped through easier without snagging on each other. Sounds like a bunch have sold already so hopefully all the books get into collectors hands soon.
You missed first annihlus you put it in your tent to $30 pile and that also was not first prowler
Yeah I always mix up 1st and second prowler. I did go back and price them both out, I think the Fantastic Four Annual #5 was priced in the $40-$50 range in VG condition.
@@pop-comics right on it definitely gets a little nutty when you look through a whole bunch of books you lose your place. I enjoy your videos dude keep it going.
@@RichSensale Yeah there was a lot going on between conversations and trying to sort through all the books. I ended up spending another 4-5 hours after the video scanning everything looking up pricing then figuring out prices that I thought would be win win for everyone and putting the approximate grades on the 100 best books. I ran out of time so I did have to guesstimate all the Dell and Goldkey were cheaper, but I might have missed something. Thinking back I was looking for the 100 best books to put into the bags and boards I brought with me I might have put that one to the side because I could not fit it into the bags etc.
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
Donated?
Yes the collection was donated to the Book Cellar. Which is the charity book shop under the Webster Library. All the proceeds go to support various programs at the library. NYC public library system is a real asset to the city.
@@pop-comics ok cool
You put 1st appearance of Annihilus on the right side??? $10-$30 pile🤯🤯🤯
this short explains it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
im calling BS....no way someone donated that.
Its NYC, people die and people clear out stuff to rent or sell apartments etc. Happens all the time. I have literally bought Key issues worth $100s to $1000+ from junk removal guys who got paid to haul the comics away etc. Have had people sell me sweet comics they found on the curb many times as well. Some people appreciate Library and happily donate things to help support. Either way I think the book store raised 3-4K from this collection maybe more so it was super successful for them.
@@pop-comics either way, money was raised for a good cause. congrats!
Jeez dude could you be even rougher with those books?
Have no idea what you are talking about.
@@pop-comics You handle the books as if you have never touched one before. Way too rough.
@@Songs-n4u you should see how people who dig through the boxes to by them handle them. I handled them just fine.
Smh why on earth do people that have no idea about comics get called on these finds lol
What I showed on the video was to show every one what was in the collection with the purpose of people coming to the shop to buy the books. After filming I spent another 4-5 hours looking up and pricing up everything and pricing it fairly for everyone.
Need a new comic expert, bro passes up 1st annilus
It did not fully register in my brain first pass, but we pulled it and priced it around $40-$50 in VG condition.
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y
Skipping over all kinds of keys. Sheesh. FF Annual 6 at 7:50 is first Franklin Richards.
I believe we ended up pricing it at $40, while going through them I was looking for the 100 best that would fit in Bags and Boards. I did not have large enough size for the Annual.
I made a short about it ua-cam.com/users/shortsZAGtjV55G_Y