The Kalasha and the Crescent | Short Documentary

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 чер 2013
  • Rumoured to be the descendants of Alexander the Great, the Kalash people have in fact inhabited northern Pakistan's Chitral valley since long before the legendary conqueror came to the region. They uphold a rich cultural heritage, with polytheistic beliefs, seasonal festivals, and a variety of other traditions that are at odds with Pakistan's dominant Islam.
    ➔ Today, even as the the majestic peaks of the Hindu Kush mountains shield the Kalasha from the region's worst violence, their culture faces a variety of pressures: poverty, tourism, and Islamism are all contributing to the erosion of Kalash identity. Still, a dedicated group of Kalash advocates are fighting to keep their culture alive.
    ➔ In May 2013, director Iara Lee traveled to the Chitral valley to document the Kalash spring festival, Joshi. 'The Kalasha and the Crescent' uses the festival as an entry point into this vibrant community and the tough questions facing it.
    ⁉️What does conversion to Islam-whether forced or spontaneous-mean for Kalash identity❓Can Kalash traditions withstand the challenges brought by globalization on the one hand and by religious tensions on the other❓Join members of the Kalash community and observers from around the world as they reckon with these questions.
    ===========
    🔔 SUBSCRIBE to our channel for more
    Check out our website for more info: culturesofresistancefilms.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 302

  • @caveman861
    @caveman861 10 років тому +21

    Loved it except for the occasional interludes of bigoted "tourists". I hope the situation of Kalash people improves so they can sustain their culture and prevail.

  • @muhammadaslam1539
    @muhammadaslam1539 3 роки тому +5

    Please save the kalash culture.....💖

  • @vibhupande
    @vibhupande 7 років тому +7

    what a beautiful documentary. thanks for showing such a vibrant culture. the thread of language (a mix of Hindi and Punjabi and Urdu) connects to such remote regions as these. they have such ingenuity in survival in such harsh conditions, hats off to them.
    wish traveling to pakistan were easier for and indian in todays's world - they seem secular/tolerant and very honestly share their annoyance at too many cameras clicking too many of their children on the streets, but don't come off as menacing. chitral valley is so colorful and they add to it, and deserve any help possible.

  • @Vagabund92
    @Vagabund92 3 роки тому +22

    5:00 "Everything in Islam is good!"
    "Look the Kalash are drinking Wine! That's a sin! They dance! That's a sin! " ...They have music! That's a sin! They have fun! That's a sin! They have tradition! That's a sin! They are peaceful! That's a sin!
    how patheticall twisted his mind is...

    • @Kevin14henrY
      @Kevin14henrY 2 роки тому +2

      Drink a wine is SIN.
      Killing and bombing are NOT SIN.. 😎

  • @hadiaahmadzai
    @hadiaahmadzai 11 років тому +3

    Iara, you yet again amazed me. Brava!

  • @sunharilalyadav9766
    @sunharilalyadav9766 7 років тому +5

    I send my good wishes for retaining their own culture even in such a country as Pak. Even Hindus Christians and Shikhs inPapistan on the verge of declining because of radiclization of Islam everywhere.

  • @yiotisvra
    @yiotisvra 11 років тому

    Great work!

  • @RenzoColameoIrlanda
    @RenzoColameoIrlanda 11 років тому +2

    Great !
    Thanks.
    Hugs from Ireland.
    Renzo *

  • @Punjabiitotay90
    @Punjabiitotay90 4 роки тому +11

    Love my Pakistani fellow Aakif Khan promoting "they should be given a chance to explore other ideologies". Sure. Pretty sure in Muslim areas of Pakistan Islam is pretty much fed as "facts" to kids too since young age. Hypocrite.
    Stop presenting ideologies as facts in general throughout the world, if you are going to explain Islam to these people, do it, sure - but it is unjust towards them as humans to just give them that ideology. Instead, present all different ideologies and possibility to them to explore and learn from and let them make their own choice!

  • @lsavage3
    @lsavage3 11 років тому +4

    Beautiful culture!

  • @kaisismail9277
    @kaisismail9277 11 років тому +2

    Lindo!! Parabéns!!

  • @iluminatiiluminati7823
    @iluminatiiluminati7823 8 років тому +2

    Amazing people tradition and culture,they are open society and feel themself and have a lot of self confidance.

  • @kenikriezispirasspatas8982
    @kenikriezispirasspatas8982 6 років тому +5

    Pra desh means (Now naked ) ka lash means. At the swim place. In Shqip Albanian language..

  • @francescolaruffa3441
    @francescolaruffa3441 4 роки тому

    Truly enchanting people, culture and religion!

  • @sanyanayar
    @sanyanayar 9 років тому +8

    Watching a documentary on them from the year 1976 and comparing it to the current potrayl in this video, I totally feel grieved. They used to practise free Islam, were much happier and doing well for themselves. It burdened my heart to know that 'many of them committed suicide in order to refrain from converting into Islam'. How I wish I could do something for them sitting in the neighbouring country.

    • @asianshaheen974
      @asianshaheen974 8 років тому +4

      Mind your own business if you care so much stop suppressing Kashmir and Kashmiri culture

  • @abhinavbharadwaj13
    @abhinavbharadwaj13 8 років тому +13

    himachal Pradesh state of India shares much of this culture than any other place in the south asia

    • @benisturning30
      @benisturning30 6 років тому

      Abhinav Bharadwaj I

    • @12SPASTIC12
      @12SPASTIC12 6 років тому +5

      That's not what he implied at all, what are you even talking about. All he said is that Himachal Pradesh has a similar culture to that of the Kalasha. He never even suggested moving the Kalasha anywhere.
      Neither did he make reference to Malana; in fact, based on their language, the Kanashi of Malana are probably not related to the Kalasha at all.
      And let's not get on our high horse and pretend that unsolved murders, theft, bribery, and begging don't also happen in Pakistan because you know they do. Why so defensive Bari?

    • @subisays
      @subisays 6 років тому +3

      Bari Usmani hey asshole no one said that. Pakistani's like you in their hatered of India and Hinduism would take take just an observation like this and spin in around in their head because of their bigotry they have in their heart.

    • @bikkichettri5554
      @bikkichettri5554 5 років тому

      @@bariusmani4557 research about Kash tribe of Himalaya you will get your answer

    • @bikkichettri5554
      @bikkichettri5554 5 років тому +2

      These people are Lost people from Kash Tribe of Far Himalayas Hami autai Ho we are one Himachali Kumoun Garwali Kashmiri Dogras Arayan Gorkhas shares same Samanic Hindu Tradition and worship there own Local Diety

  • @CharlesBrooks4358
    @CharlesBrooks4358 11 років тому +1

    Thank you for this ethnography filming . I notice the shells and other symbols of earlier cultures, also it is interesting that the notion of the Alexander, the barbarian influence and many middle eastern ideologies have adopted, especially when it comes to the treatment of women.

  • @samidu492
    @samidu492 5 років тому +3

    Varun, you are right. These are remnants of old vedic culture

    • @kshatriyarajput4908
      @kshatriyarajput4908 5 років тому +1

      @kit kit Dumb Moron Vedics Were not Invaders...Even at The Time of Real Vedic era The Social classification was Flexible.
      So far Archaeologists didn't Find any Sign of Invasion...What they Found is Same Continuous Culture
      And For Vedics Nomads Like Pashtuns,Kalaash even Nomads of North India are also Non-Aryas.

    • @kshatriyarajput4908
      @kshatriyarajput4908 5 років тому +1

      @kit kit Where British Get Vedas from? Did they Get From Eurassia,Afghanistan or from Tribal Nomads of Chitral?😂

  • @talimbazik
    @talimbazik 11 років тому +1

    Nice

  • @33maraba
    @33maraba 10 років тому +25

    Im a Pakistani muslim and i love all kalash people, i really feel sorry for the conditions they are suffering from the fucking taliban terrorists, if i was rich i would have donated all my money for the preservation of kalasha people. i would do anything for these people !!!

    • @bhavin105
      @bhavin105 9 років тому +1

      Amen Brother.

    • @mzmoemission6256
      @mzmoemission6256 6 років тому

      33maraba I don't know you but I know that you have a most beautiful soul. I am so proud to know that I am sharing planet earth with a person like you.😊

    • @carteunu467
      @carteunu467 Місяць тому

      Taliban is their brothers.
      Beni Israel.
      All related
      They look Semitic.
      Are of the lost tribes of Israel. Both Dan and Simeon.
      The blond ones are of the same genetic background as the tribe of Dan that colonized Black Sea region of what became Thracia, Russia, also Scandinavia and Western Europe . The dark ones are related to the Roma.

    • @Honeycomb2403
      @Honeycomb2403 Місяць тому +1

      @@carteunu467shut up why are you copy pasting everything in every reply of other comments as well as .

  • @colourofritual
    @colourofritual 11 років тому +1

    Iara. Parabens num trabalho que certamente tera' um efeito positivo na consciencia global.. bjs

  • @stylewithme365
    @stylewithme365 3 роки тому +1

    Are they related to Pangi tribe in Himachal Pradesh? Same head gear, colors & clothing!

  • @kristinam7928
    @kristinam7928 3 дні тому

    Beautiful culture

  • @mtkerrig
    @mtkerrig 11 років тому +1

    Absolutely a spectacular film. I'm left questioning whether cultural preservation and missions (not just the religious or forceful type) are mutually exclusive. Why must we all be the same? How would we be able to enjoy the beautiful culture, rich in color, song and dance, if the Kalashis all dressed in the typical drab blues and greys of Western culture?

  • @maku8075
    @maku8075 4 роки тому +10

    I read that kash people follow a pre-vedic Indo-Aryan tradition.
    There traditions need to be kept live and we can also learn how the pre-vedic people live. Sad they live in a Isalmic country.

    • @francescolaruffa3441
      @francescolaruffa3441 4 роки тому

      True.

    • @carteunu467
      @carteunu467 Місяць тому

      They look Semitic.
      Are of the lost tribes of Israel. Both Dan and Simeon.
      The blond ones are of the same genetic background as the tribe of Dan that colonized Black Sea region of what became Thracia, Russia, also Scandinavia and Western Europe . The dark ones are related to the Roma.

  • @stylewithme365
    @stylewithme365 3 роки тому +1

    In Hinduism Kalash/a is an auspicious pot with mango leaves & coconut. It's always near our deities. Shared cultures

    • @maltase4331
      @maltase4331 2 роки тому

      yes bro from karnataka we call it kalasha

    • @kranthi3967
      @kranthi3967 Рік тому

      ​@@maltase4331kalasa is different from kannada kalasa.

  • @sultannawab4251
    @sultannawab4251 8 років тому

    bohat hi khubsurat log hain kalash k or bohat hi khubsurat ha kalash
    we love u kalash
    pakistan zindabaad

  • @varunb82
    @varunb82 8 років тому +22

    Proud of Hindu aryan heritage. Love Kalash and nuristani people. The last remnants of hinduism in its original vedic traditional form. India must give these people honorary Indian citizenship and offer to relocate to Himachal Pradesh.

    • @varunb82
      @varunb82 8 років тому +1

      +asif mohammad ignoramus pig! deserve no notice nor my spit. Fcuk off!

    • @user-zw5gh5wo9f
      @user-zw5gh5wo9f 8 років тому +1

      +asif mohammad
      Go worship that criminal Mohammad. He was imprisoned and couldn't even think of his own book, so copied the Old Testament and called it Quran. Then married and foricbly had sex with 14 year old Ayesha. LOL what a religion.

    • @khorasan123456
      @khorasan123456 8 років тому +1

      +Arya they would rather die as to convert to pissdrinker religion.

    • @asianshaheen974
      @asianshaheen974 8 років тому

      +Elias baraki so true

    • @tabassumkhan4450
      @tabassumkhan4450 7 років тому +2

      Varun B .shut up they r Pakistani first facilitate ur own citizens and and stop killing of kashmiris ok get. lost

  • @angelamalini6852
    @angelamalini6852 7 років тому +4

    Seems like the scattered tribes from Manala Village in Himmachal Pradesh . North India

    • @thakurpuneetsingh1686
      @thakurpuneetsingh1686 7 років тому +1

      Michelle Viccario
      Well personally I do agree with you. I have no doubt that the custom, tradition and culture of Kalasha community resembles with Us (Himachal Pradesh )and have common tree of oldest tribes (ARYANS -----Vedic Culture) . And even in the far upper Mountains part of Kashmir, UttaraKhand and Nepal have the same culture which is not like of 1000 years, But almost 5000 years Back. But offcourse for us proof is there in terms of written literature as the oldest written sacred Text in world is RIGVEDA around 1200---1500 Bc. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rigveda
      But My point is its not the heritage of one particularpeople/ place but of the whole world, as we all need to preserve the oldest customs and traditions of all around.

    • @zeezee5379
      @zeezee5379 3 роки тому

      @@thakurpuneetsingh1686 they are not aryan but dardic

  • @PragnyaBMishra
    @PragnyaBMishra 4 роки тому

    CHOICE ?

  • @kapilgyawali4758
    @kapilgyawali4758 3 роки тому +2

    Similar culture exists in Nepal as well but is heavily influenced by Hinduism. Problem with that part is that islam has completely changed the tradition but not in Nepal

  • @0551273
    @0551273 9 років тому

    nic

  • @nooruddin6091
    @nooruddin6091 9 років тому

    what is your promlem

  • @mbugi
    @mbugi 10 років тому +1

    Dear IARA LEE
    Good Job you have Done in Filming Kalash Tribe of Pakistan,,,,and i have HEARD that your entire shoot was upto the Point,it was fast in a short Time by Cultures of Resistance GOOD Job We had Lost three Other Petitions due to Blockage by Face Book This one-was also blocked, 5 Times, Months after months YET we carried on This was the latest Petition, Minimum requirement By UN is 1000 Signatures we are pleased to announce that we have reached 1500 SIGNATURES AS OF TODAY,,,,Good will ambassador's Of UN based in Geneva are Also Helping US To Move Forward,, Privately separately Thanks for the Graceful CO-Ordination HELP PRESERVE KALASH BE DECLARED A UN PROTECTED SITE

  • @mbugi
    @mbugi 8 років тому

    In the Historic Case of Kalash old name, The Greek Historians mentioned, in 326 BC-Quote*HERE we have met a tribe which worships similar to GREEK god of wine Bacchus-and also this is historically documented that Alexander the Great spared the Life of thirty Tribal chiefs of Kamdeh-Old Kalash areas, in exchange of 5000 cattle and 300 Horses, with in one month the tribe revolted and Alexander had to come back to re conqueror, the areas,late r on he went to swat areas to Besiege a fortress high in the Mountains,quotes-FROM FOOT STEPS OF ALEXANDER THE GREAT*...Kalash as seen By Kalash Themselves-in Pictures-Daughter and Grand Daughter of Mine Friend Bashara Khan Kalash-

  • @ace3442
    @ace3442 5 років тому +2

    Amazing people, and I hope people just leave them alone. Trying to convert them to other religions is just so wrong.

  • @sanatanvoice6709
    @sanatanvoice6709 10 місяців тому

    आपकी कोशिश कामयाब होगी
    आपके साथ कलशी लोगो के साथ श्रीखंड कैलाश महादेव हैं और जो कलशी इस्लाम मे कन्वर्ट हो गए हैं चित्राल नुरिस्तान या हिन्दूकस के लोग वो सभी शिव के कृपा से पुनः कैलाशी और अपने संस्कृति कल्चर में आएंगे
    ये सब होना तय है 5 वर्ष के अंदर
    जय आकाश भैरव

  • @RizwanJutt-po9ee
    @RizwanJutt-po9ee 2 роки тому

    😘🌻

  • @Crankydude55
    @Crankydude55 4 роки тому +2

    Any kalashi here??? Your head gear is similar to pangi tribe of Himachal Pradesh India... Can you do a video in your own language????

  • @MarieLouiseLa
    @MarieLouiseLa 11 років тому +2

    Beautiful cinematography, with a script presenting a depth of understanding that is much needed in the west.

  • @mbugi
    @mbugi 9 років тому +1

    Recent-***FLOODS IN KALASH-***very very hard times. So sorry and sad to hear this. But I know assistance and relief is on its way. For people, animals, food, water, medical and homes. Attention is heard. So many big natural disasters, partly man made in some places by companies moving the water tables and taking out trees and creating a big imbalance in the ecosystems and water levels. Also nature is big this year in heat and storms and earthquakes. Bless those in their times of struggle and rest their fear to hope for a change for bright future and help for those in immediate need. Blessings and love to all heart .(^_^)

    • @mbugi
      @mbugi 8 років тому

      thanks Tord Victor-have a Look at the Most Recent News from Kalash-vimeo.com/143838137

  • @zik-zakgamer6578
    @zik-zakgamer6578 4 роки тому +1

    no one can force somebodies heart to convert in islam. but if you are happy with what god has given to you is very easy to find islam.

  • @fieeedahusssain8407
    @fieeedahusssain8407 Рік тому

    Government need to protect this unique culture

  • @AdrianaNYC1
    @AdrianaNYC1 9 років тому +4

    they are beautiful looking people.. i would love to visit them one day, maybe it would feel like visiting my blood relatives,, either they are or they not albanian, they are ballkan people..

    • @NarkisaSofiaGki
      @NarkisaSofiaGki 9 років тому +1

      GREECE IS NOT BALKAN COUNTRY ADRIANA

    • @AdrianaNYC1
      @AdrianaNYC1 9 років тому

      ***** since when? and who said they greek?

    • @NarkisaSofiaGki
      @NarkisaSofiaGki 9 років тому +1

      Since ever in both cases

    • @AdrianaNYC1
      @AdrianaNYC1 9 років тому

      ***** ur an idiot then

    • @NarkisaSofiaGki
      @NarkisaSofiaGki 9 років тому

      I do hv when u insult me my studies teach me to reply to people of ur kind as they deserve

  • @sanyfin
    @sanyfin 11 років тому +1

    and good local wine

  • @orianjaku5630
    @orianjaku5630 3 роки тому +1

    If someone from hunza's people is reading this message come and visit MIRDITA, a city in the north of Albania.
    You can speak if your want even Hunza's language there and the people will understand you.You can see as well your traditions,symbols,flag,clothes,even if your want to see that autochthon dog which you can find it only in alps of albania and in Hunza.Hunza's people are 100% illyrians pure blood!.

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому +1

      The original Hunza and Kalashi people is from Albania 🇦🇱 to see the document. دستاویز کو دیکھنے کے لئے اصل ہنزا اور کلشی لوگ البانیہ سے ہیں ua-cam.com/video/qoiGhRGCHtQ/v-deo.html

  • @dionakgamer7769
    @dionakgamer7769 5 років тому +1

    Damn!!
    Dances and music are almost same to Nepali traditional music. It’s the same

    • @dikshachettri5026
      @dikshachettri5026 3 роки тому +1

      They should really move to Nepal. We can protect them

  • @sayantikadas1121
    @sayantikadas1121 5 місяців тому

    One indirect way to convert is to not allow/prevent financial growth for them in such areas, not creating autonomous areas for them. Eventually due to poverty they themselves will think of conversion. That way snake is killed and stick is not broken too.
    Very ingenious way of govt.

  • @sylvester63
    @sylvester63 5 років тому +1

    The Oldest Living Civilisation of the World. The Kalash are caught between cultural preservation and modernisation. Its regrettable, but conversion of the Kalash people to Islam will eventually dilute their culture, traditions and primitive lifestyle forever. And, its equally sad to see and know that people everywhere, take advantage of others with little or no education.

  • @mbugi
    @mbugi 6 років тому

    For Me as an Artist ,The efforts to Save Kalash a tribe in the Hindukush Mountains from getting instinct, started actively in 1980, as I went for the first time in spring into The Kalash Valley's My Lungs could not Breathe as it was such FRESH AIR Totally Pristine,,,,,as i MINGLED with Kalash, I was shocked Kalash lived in bonded slavery of Compound interests then,Illiteracy was the main reason ,slowly education, Vaccines, schools, summer MEDICAL camps came to Kalash . I met the Australian High commissioner later in 1989 and the British High commissioner where I expressed the same views. Help Preserve Kalash a vanishing tribe ._DON'T_ LET THEM INTO OBVIATION,
    Soon time's changed after studying Kalash Cultural conference of the Hindukush and each and every book that was ever written about Kalash.... I returned to Kalash in 1989 with Boxes Full of colors papers and art materiel , FIRST Kalash Art work shops in the valley on Massive level , 2008 I was on the world tour again visiting Kalash after so many years , so all these things together is an attempt to save Kalash from extinction , Help preserve Kalash with declaration of World heritage site,
    Sign the Petition
    Secretary General of United Nations: Help Preserve Kalash a tribe in Pakistan for United Nations Protected site-
    CHANGE.ORG

  • @abhinavbharadwaj13
    @abhinavbharadwaj13 8 років тому +4

    I think you are more like himachal people with all dances and traditions and seosonal fairs...check "chamba pangi himachal on you tube

    • @tb3867
      @tb3867 7 років тому +1

      Abhinav Bharadwaj they are like tamil people actually, pure hindus

    • @kshatriyarajput4908
      @kshatriyarajput4908 5 років тому

      @@tb3867 😂😂😂 Tamil? Seriously

    • @stylewithme365
      @stylewithme365 3 роки тому

      Same thought

  • @akashjago3205
    @akashjago3205 2 роки тому

    Any people save culture and freedom for culture

  • @anthonymoala308
    @anthonymoala308 7 років тому +5

    YEA allow them to convert to islam and then say they cant leave islam once theyre in lol

  • @mbugi
    @mbugi 7 років тому +12

    “You are free; you are free to go to your temples. You are free to go to your mosques or to any other places of worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion, caste or creed-that has nothing to do with the business of the state.”
    ― Muhammad Ali Jinnah

  • @arational9920
    @arational9920 3 роки тому +1

    UNITED NATIONS SHOULD SAVE THEM.

  • @saeedullah3726
    @saeedullah3726 7 років тому

    we respect the culture of these innocent and beautiful people, no body has right to interfare in the affair of these people.

  • @skenderbegthegreatiskender4667
    @skenderbegthegreatiskender4667 10 років тому +3

    I believe that these tribes should come back to where thay migrated from... Come back to Antion fathers land come back to Albania you will live a happy and beautiful life with your forefathers.... The culture the ppl the clothing their eyes everything of thise ppl reminds me of Albanians and their lifestyle! I feel your plain my ppl got to convert to Islam by force to!! Some 5/600 years ago

  • @rahulmojumder6936
    @rahulmojumder6936 Рік тому +1

    Reminants of old vedic culture.

    • @AI-ok1ch
      @AI-ok1ch 15 днів тому

      NO CONNECTION TO TANATANCX DRAMA

  • @mehmetmuhadri7271
    @mehmetmuhadri7271 Місяць тому

    Kta jan Poplli i Aleksandrit te Madh Shipet ❤

  • @kingofstreetfighter2500
    @kingofstreetfighter2500 3 роки тому +1

    Kalasha 🇦🇱🙌👌🦅🦅🦅Illyriens

  • @simonbakov6762
    @simonbakov6762 9 років тому +1

    Everybody miss the point of the documentary

  • @alamicrodev6526
    @alamicrodev6526 4 роки тому

    People in the comment section here are being stupid, they don't understand the difference between culture and religion. You can be an American and a muslim, you can be a Punjabi and play basant or do Punjabi bhangra and be a Muslim. The worry about them is their culture, as for the religion it's their choice if they wanna convert they convert if they don't wanna convert it's their choice. But what they must keep alive is their tradition like traditional clothing etc

  • @innosanto
    @innosanto 3 роки тому

    These were mixed partially with Greeks in ancient times they say.

  • @waggawaggaful
    @waggawaggaful 7 років тому +6

    If people think this region is poor, then they obviously haven't visited Mississippi.

    • @nabeelkh
      @nabeelkh 4 роки тому +3

      That is a strawman argument. Poverty is a lived experience and always relative.

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому +2

      The original Hunza and Kalashi people is from Albania 🇦🇱 to see the document. دستاویز کو دیکھنے کے لئے اصل ہنزا اور کلشی لوگ البانیہ سے ہیں ua-cam.com/video/qoiGhRGCHtQ/v-deo.html

  • @Honeycomb2403
    @Honeycomb2403 Місяць тому +1

    I’m from Uttarakhand state in India ( Himalayan state ) I’m kumaoni and these like the culture practices are a lot similar to us . To be honest more simlilar to Himachal and Uttarakhand both . If you talk about relating their dress is very similar to ( the one they wore in the head going backwards ) kinnauri. Even though Kinnauris got Buddhist elements mixed but it’s too much similar to the cultures of Himachal and Uttarakhand of India

    • @AI-ok1ch
      @AI-ok1ch 15 днів тому

      HINDUS ARE DIFFERENT
      KALLLLUZ

    • @Honeycomb2403
      @Honeycomb2403 10 днів тому +1

      @@AI-ok1ch no wonder Pakistanis are so jahil and gawar I said culture is similar not the religion idiot . Go find some books and read them . Brainless . If you see punjabis they are not only Pakistanis there are Indian punjabis similarly I compared you idiot . Because these states in india are Himalayan in region . We have mixed facial features . For examples my father has different coloured eyes and so does my brother but I have mongoloid features . And moreover in these states majority of the skin colour varies from wheatish to very light fair skin . And we are bloody open minded in terms of women and a lot of drinking culture unlike some gawar person like you . I didn’t even mention any religion seeing you talking like this seems very accurate no wonder Pakistanis lack civic sense and are racist .

    • @Honeycomb2403
      @Honeycomb2403 10 днів тому +1

      @@AI-ok1ch idk why my reply ain’t showing up but no wonder Pakistanis are so poor in real life as well as in their mindset . The states which I’m talking about are himalyan states . I didn’t even talk about religion . Their is a clear difference between culture and religion . We are called as pahadis commonly and then dividing into many subgroups . As you are poor so I’ll give you knowledge here . Majority of these states people have wheat to very light skin tone . For example my father has green eyes so does my brother but I have mongoloid features as I’m central pahadi I’m mixed . So I guess education their is illegal plus racism isn’t funny bro . Get a life

    • @Honeycomb2403
      @Honeycomb2403 10 днів тому

      I guess they keep deleting the comments but one simple sentence : why y’all are so racist
      😊

    • @Honeycomb2403
      @Honeycomb2403 10 днів тому

      @@AI-ok1chmoreover I talked about culture not religion

  • @karannegi3203
    @karannegi3203 3 роки тому +1

    They are trying to convert them

  • @asadsieo4172
    @asadsieo4172 11 років тому

    Comparing a culture to a religion is not a fair act, for BOTH, culture and religion. I find it more about what Islam had done to them than what do they do or have! so yes, it is aggressive in a way.
    in the full documentary, i hope i can learn more about Kalasha culture and less about the methods taken to provoke them to stay Kalasha..

  • @iliryandardanautochthon8021
    @iliryandardanautochthon8021 6 років тому +3

    Aleksander are illyrian

  • @AS-jo8qh
    @AS-jo8qh 2 місяці тому

    Why are kalash men not wearing traditional dress?

  • @kujawedann4961
    @kujawedann4961 2 роки тому

    The old culture of Parsi tajik people

  • @unejam7369
    @unejam7369 7 років тому +3

    albanien

  • @bcvan9999
    @bcvan9999 Місяць тому

    Kalash people follow the old Indian customs (that are still followed in some rural areas in India). They probably belong to the old Rig Vedic era. They obviously came in contact with Macedonians around 300 BC. India and the UN should help them financially to protect their culture. Pakistan should stop Islamization.

    • @AI-ok1ch
      @AI-ok1ch 15 днів тому

      they are not KALLU TANATANIS
      NO ONE FROM THEWM CLAIMS TO BE RUNDIAN

  • @jrbelmonte1466
    @jrbelmonte1466 3 роки тому

    Greece needs to take them.

  • @cellibitstorm4287
    @cellibitstorm4287 10 років тому +7

    There is generally the assumption that Kalash as Pagans should begin moving into India. They could live much better with Hindus, Brokpas, and Sufis.

    • @tb3867
      @tb3867 7 років тому +2

      Cellibit Storm They will be killed for eating beef and not speaking Bhojpuri

    • @mrwani610
      @mrwani610 2 роки тому

      @Adhishree Singh But beef is banned all over india
      and their festivels starts with beef and at beef

  • @stylewithme365
    @stylewithme365 3 роки тому +1

    Resist conversion. Disgusting people taking advantage of Kalash people. RESIST! ✊

  • @UDAYSINGHful
    @UDAYSINGHful 8 років тому

    See the comments of the pakistani tourists intent on forcing their way through , and turning them into peaceful talibs

  • @carteunu467
    @carteunu467 Місяць тому

    They look Semitic.
    Are of the lost tribes of Israel. Both Dan and Simeon.
    The blond ones are of the same genetic background as the tribe of Dan that colonized Black Sea region of what became Thracia, Russia, Scandinavia and Western Europe . The dark ones are related to the Roma.

  • @rajtrip55
    @rajtrip55 3 роки тому +1

    Kalash will be khalash. And it will be forgotten history like Taksilla and Bamiyan. Either they convert to Islam or get ready for massacre.

  • @lookoi9363
    @lookoi9363 7 років тому +4

    bad luck to be born minority in Pakistan.

  • @Stoned.records
    @Stoned.records 7 років тому +3

    Ilyrien Albanien

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому

      The original Hunza and Kalashi people is from Albania 🇦🇱 to see the document. دستاویز کو دیکھنے کے لئے اصل ہنزا اور کلشی لوگ البانیہ سے ہیں ua-cam.com/video/qoiGhRGCHtQ/v-deo.html

  • @Route-mf6pk
    @Route-mf6pk 3 роки тому +1

    What is about Hunza People, becouse Hunza is ILLYRIAN People from King Kliti Albanian ILLYRIAN =YLLI =STAR and RI =NEW so NEW STAR.
    Dance Burrashka :Burra =Manns.
    And this Spring fest ist like us in Albanian Pagan fest and now Katolik celebration on the Church. The Coat is by Albanian People the very important . Alexander and Kliti fight together , and 6000 solders from Kliti stay in Hunza and married with Pakistans women. Hunza of Albanian ist HUNDËZA =NOSE in Englisch .And you are Arian , with White Skin. I want some Day coming and Visited my Old People. Greatings from Albanian Mann lived in Germany.Sorry my Englisch no so perfekt.

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому +1

      The original Hunza and Kalashi people is from Albania 🇦🇱 to see the document. دستاویز کو دیکھنے کے لئے اصل ہنزا اور کلشی لوگ البانیہ سے ہیں ua-cam.com/video/qoiGhRGCHtQ/v-deo.html

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому

      Ju tregova me nalt se qa jom hunza kallasht edhe burnisheta qa jon kreit shiptar

  • @PragnyaBMishra
    @PragnyaBMishra 4 роки тому +2

    India is offering you citizenship. Please come.

    • @dikshachettri5026
      @dikshachettri5026 3 роки тому

      I wish we could bring them

    • @lollol-wi8im
      @lollol-wi8im 3 роки тому

      No we are happy in pakistan❤️ pakistan zindabad🇵🇰

    • @xiuhcoatl4830
      @xiuhcoatl4830 2 роки тому

      @@lollol-wi8im you're not a kalasha, you're just another abdoool preaching terrorism to them

  • @hasanullalhasansaff4524
    @hasanullalhasansaff4524 3 роки тому

    They belive in one God !!!❤️

    • @xiuhcoatl4830
      @xiuhcoatl4830 2 роки тому

      no they don't. Stay away with your disgusting cult and your pedophile prophet

  • @toheedanwarllc
    @toheedanwarllc 5 років тому

    Kalashi are so innocent and Loving peoples I’ll
    Marry from there Insha Allah ❤️❤️❤️😘😘

  • @ShervMidi
    @ShervMidi 5 років тому +2

    Kalash are an Aryan *Indo-Iranian* people with no Greek ethnic admixture, it's been widely dismissed that they're of any Greek admixture. So it's really a myth that these people are decendants of Alexander the great. Speaking genetics, the Kalash lack typical Greek Haplogroups.

    • @TheAfghan72
      @TheAfghan72 5 років тому

      They are indo-aryan meaning, their language is more close to Indian ones then Indo-Iranian.

    • @kshatriyarajput4908
      @kshatriyarajput4908 5 років тому +1

      @@TheAfghan72 They are Dardics In Mahabharata they are mentioned as Darads Along with other mlechha Tribes Living at Boundaries and outside of Aryavarta Like Pakthas,Rishikas,Kamboja,Parasika,Huna,Khasa,Parads,Yavanas.

    • @TheAfghan72
      @TheAfghan72 5 років тому

      क्षत्रिय भारत Aryans were Mleecha and all those tribes you mentioned like the Pakhtas were Aryan tribes mentioned in the rigveda. Mahabharata is not a source but hindu fairytale stories.

    • @kshatriyarajput4908
      @kshatriyarajput4908 5 років тому +1

      @@TheAfghan72 Yeah Pakthas are Mentioned in Rigveda but the Other Tribes of Mlechha (Non-Aryan) I Said Like Rishikas,Yavana,Kamboja,Parasik,Dravid,Keral,Chinas,Ashwakas,Para,Darad etc are Tribes of Mahabharata and also mentioned in puranas and you can Read these names from Mahabharata.
      Pakthas, Anu, Alin,Druhyus ,Bhalan,Daasa,pani,Dasyu were just Early semi Nomadic-pastaroalists Non-Aryan Slaves of Vedic Aryan Tribe Purus And Bharatas.
      Which Fought against Bharat Aryan Tribe of Whole North India.
      Mahabharata is not some Fairy Tale of Desert like that Tale in which a Illiterate pedophile broke Moon into two Pieces..... It's ITIHASA which means "this is How it happened"
      Morever Rigveda was Text of Bharat and Purus.
      All Other Mlechhas were just Animist and Pagans.

    • @kshatriyarajput4908
      @kshatriyarajput4908 5 років тому

      @@TheAfghan72 and Aryans were not Mlechha .
      Get Your Facts Right there is Clear Distinctions b/w Mlechha and Arya.
      Morever Mahabharata is not a Text of Tribal Adivasi Hindu but it is a History of Post Vedic Puru & Bharata Dynasty of North India or say Āryavarta.

  • @NarkisaSofiaGki
    @NarkisaSofiaGki 9 років тому +4

    THESE PEOPLE WHERE THERE BEFORE ALEXANDER BUT HE LEFT HIS SOLDIERS TO MINGLE WITH LOCAL WOMEN AFTER THEY HELPED THEM WIN SOME BATTLE YOU SEE CUSTOMS, DRESSES, FACES SIMILAR RO MACEDONIAN AND GREECE MOUNTAIN AREAS

    • @NarkisaSofiaGki
      @NarkisaSofiaGki 8 років тому

      R u crazy? U will teach me the history of my ancestor

    • @NarkisaSofiaGki
      @NarkisaSofiaGki 8 років тому

      +Super Wog obviously y r reading wrong material i will not waste breath on an uneducated brainless being cos the minimum if u ask even a child will know Alexander was blonde with blue eyes

    • @arianparian
      @arianparian 6 років тому +1

      SOFIA PURE PROPAGANDA YOU SPEAKING. WE PEOPLE FROM REPUBLIKA MACEDONIA HAVE LOT SAME WITH KALASH. HE TELL YOU TWO TIME HE IS MACEDONIEN NO GREEK.

    • @bikkichettri5554
      @bikkichettri5554 5 років тому

      @@NarkisaSofiaGki miss I request you to do your research on Kash tribe and there Tradition these people were Kings of the Mountain they have ruled Himalayan onced they are Nature Worshipers

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому

      The original Hunza and Kalashi people is from Albania 🇦🇱 to see the document. دستاویز کو دیکھنے کے لئے اصل ہنزا اور کلشی لوگ البانیہ سے ہیں ua-cam.com/video/qoiGhRGCHtQ/v-deo.html

  • @amordadian
    @amordadian 8 років тому +3

    they are indo-iranian please stop sharing bullshit
    even their language sounds indo-iranian

  • @israrkhanisrarkhan5685
    @israrkhanisrarkhan5685 7 років тому +2

    Pakistan is the country of tasty and sweet people ..

  • @ARSLANKHAN-yp2tb
    @ARSLANKHAN-yp2tb 5 років тому +2

    Everything regarding relegion is stupid answer to a stupid question .

  • @TheYuvleFandom
    @TheYuvleFandom Місяць тому

    some of the tourists are pathetic

  • @kujawedann4961
    @kujawedann4961 2 роки тому

    Hello everyone.
    The are the old culture khurasan nation party Parsi people.
    Wey call than Norstany men’s light. People.
    they believe on zrstyan religion the respect the fire and the have the zrstyan logo in temple in 1857 wen the afgha government started the help of east India company in 1959 Beg fight against khurasanyan khurasan nation the help of ptan Pashto and east India company and theirs fight happens against Norstany people and the khurasan side became Muslims and south khurasan left andr the east India British company the have on old culture. They had on king Dom and the music culture it’s in tajik party Parsi people khurasan the sem .
    100 years back when the tajik victory against the east India company the afgha king trib wasn’t happy because of his afgha government meed bay east India company it was in dongers he gave back the south khurasan to east India company to sports he’s government in khurasan and he meed the afgha trib town Afghanistan fake name on khurasan officially and south khurasan became under d east India company to sports afgha king government in khurasan the separate khurasan nation .
    To day khurasan name back to people none afgha trib of khurasan.

  • @Babatareen-jd5qv
    @Babatareen-jd5qv 9 місяців тому

    Kalash is a oragional pashtoon this is a (Cyrus the grate taim ) request Al pashtoon these culture and these girls dress than you

  • @Narimo512
    @Narimo512 10 років тому +9

    Alexander the Great spoke a language that was neither Greek nor Latin, it is in the old history book. it is illyrian !

    • @Narimo512
      @Narimo512 9 років тому

      ***** what?

    • @Narimo512
      @Narimo512 9 років тому +2

      ***** Greeks have no identity. The traditional costume is Arvanitas. Arvanitas called Albanian in Greece. It's like a Kosovar but Albanian. It's like a Macedonian but Albanian. It's like Montenegro, but Albania. It's like the South of Serbia, but Albanian. traditional story written before the revolution does not explain the Greek of today. assimilation is the strong point of the Slavic. Orthodoxy is the basis of assimilation. This basic request to change his identity to be part of orthodoxy. A name will add a suffix (if it was not possible, we change it) and give -ic -iq -iv ov -ovo ....... We remember Cameri yet to understand what happens to those that even today, people are forced to change their identity in order to hope for a better life. The Greek-Ottoman laws against Albanian.
      Before it was difficult to obtain archives. Today, we highlight what is said at one time. The lie is not last year. The usurpation of identity and history made by the Greek-Turkish slaves against Albanian and other people is in the process of collapsing.
      The world is just beginning to realize the barbarity of the Greek-Turkish Slavs in the east europe during the past millennium.
      If you can prove me wrong, MAKE.

    • @elikrisos9972
      @elikrisos9972 9 років тому +1

      He speak greek only greeks by pure greek blond can partecipate in the Olympic games you are not illyrians was exsterminated by romans

    • @elikrisos9972
      @elikrisos9972 9 років тому +1

      ***** Roman illiricum times have nothing in common with the ancient tribe of illyrian but a part of albanians are local bakcan peoples but only a part the others are intrusers Alexsander fight the illirians how you think he was illyrian or even of turcic and huns and gypsies descendents as claim the fyromians only because absorbed preexisting people and they diluited and take the dna Alexsander come from royal bloodline is not enough that you have an haplogroup because you submitt local people your genetic evolution is different

    • @Narimo512
      @Narimo512 9 років тому

      ***** ***** Albanians are called during the period of Rome, the Romans of the Eastern Europe. They said Roman to themselves with the traditions and rituals specific to Illyrians. Not with pleasure, but simply because the occupants of that time were stronger. Moreover, Rome has grown a lot, and this thanks to the Illyrians. It's the same for the Ottomans. It's the same for Greece. It's the same for Serbia. It's the same thing for Macedonia. It's the same in Montenegro. The Albanians say without hiding and we keep this from generation to generation, that they moved.
      What is called the Greeks are not the Hellenes. Before the Hellenes, the parties now in Greece, lived in peace. The Greeks before the Hellenes are Arvanites. You are the occupiers. Contracts concluded with the Ottoman Empire created the Turkish-Greek. For the simple reason that the real opponents of the Ottoman Empire, those who can not stand to lose their land are Arvanites Albanians. Thanks to Gjergj Kastrioti that caught the Ottoman army during his lifetime. This is the second Alexander the Great! It was he who had the same emblems used today and even Alexander the Great. This market has given an anti-Albanian law (for language, culture, school). Having a law that gives the choice between losing their heads or live with your family, what should we choose? This lasted for over a century. Today, we forget what we ate yesterday. You can imagine how quickly we forget when you have to. This law is stipulated in a major newspaper of Pelepones in 1999. The contracts with the Slavic have created the Serbian-Greek. Albanians have had the mosques while Slavs, Greeks have had the land. The mosques do not teach you as a school and especially you "lose" your time to pray.
      Prohibit the instruction is the biggest genocide of all time of Turkish-Greek-Slavic.
      Why? For an educated Albanian was always the fear of the Ottoman Empire. In a statement, (I forget the name) general or lieutenant of the Ottoman Empire says "we must never learn that the Albanian history, otherwise it will be the end of all."
      All these background markets are the cause of all these problems. The identity of the Albanians was usurped. Its history has been manipulated. A part of its culture has been stolen. Its lands are shared by thieves. Ormis his blood and his word are his own.
      Alexander the Great is not Greek and did not speak Greek, the Greek language did not exist in his time. There was the Illyrian, the Albanian language today. He has not defeated the Illyrians. He put some order in his own house before conquering the world. The Albanian language has evolved but always kept his footprints. The Pelasgian are not Greek today. Observe the language almost identical to the Albanians today. It's not that the Illyrians Pelasgi Albanians come from these countries. They simply were the people with the same language that had lived for a long time. What was Macedonia before, now is not Macedonia but especially not Greek or Hellenic. Knowing this, your "pure Greek" support does not exist, because history shows us that the Turco-Greek are not the Turkish-Albanian.
      You want everything in the story but your story begins in 1821 thanks to Arvanites. You were not alone and not nearly as many as you claim today ... because, as just mentioned above, a Arvanites says to himself Hellene because he prefers to live with his family.
      The state of Greece is not a child of Heart. Just remember the Genocide Cameria massacre. Just remember how was populated by Greeks that part of Epirus. Epirus is Albania at the time. This is known for a long time.
      Enjoy the monuments of antiquity and keep the identity, I think you have nothing to teach us in this direction. Of course, Pirro, Ulysses, Zeus, and more engravings on rocks and others with Pileus Qelesh are definitely Greek? The Qelesh folds on the head of illustrious person or God is not a coincidence. This is Illyrians Albanians. And It is the Joker factor of history.
      The Joker factor here is not an error. It is a coincidence in the fact that when we absolutely trying to hide something, like a criminal hides the evidence, there is always the little things that we do not think that will emerge. The Joker will be the revelation of the century on the biggest lie in history with its background markets. This Joker is Arvanites Albanians Illyrians.
      No more lies in history. Play cards on the table. If in an old book, a stele is written Pelasgian, do not write Greek. If it says "opasdfjioahguajkdfnasdf" => write "opasdfjioahguajkdfnasdf" simply.

  • @xochitl7489
    @xochitl7489 Рік тому

    What is religion for? Does it help you in any way? Of course not, just to believe this and that, is that enough? No, the person becomes dumb, because their mind becomes conditioned.

  • @iliryandardanautochthon8021
    @iliryandardanautochthon8021 6 років тому +3

    This is illyrian peopel

  • @brezaillyria1472
    @brezaillyria1472 7 років тому +3

    ALBANIANS

    • @DigoronKavkaz
      @DigoronKavkaz 5 років тому

      Thats a myth and DNA doesn't back it up. These people are remnants of isolated Indo-European people

    • @ShervMidi
      @ShervMidi 5 років тому

      Lol, not even once

    • @farazbhat9832
      @farazbhat9832 5 років тому

      Dardics

    • @francescolaruffa3441
      @francescolaruffa3441 4 роки тому

      Nope!

    • @ademjashari6447
      @ademjashari6447 3 роки тому +1

      The original Hunza and Kalashi people is from Albania 🇦🇱 to see the document. دستاویز کو دیکھنے کے لئے اصل ہنزا اور کلشی لوگ البانیہ سے ہیں ua-cam.com/video/qoiGhRGCHtQ/v-deo.html

  • @papasconey641
    @papasconey641 5 років тому

    They speak albanian language

  • @seenakakar2013
    @seenakakar2013 8 років тому +4

    remove islam

    • @asianshaheen974
      @asianshaheen974 8 років тому +3

      It's our country not yours so shut the fuck up

    • @seenakakar2013
      @seenakakar2013 8 років тому

      +Geminijet127
      it is my country.

    • @seenakakar2013
      @seenakakar2013 8 років тому

      +Geminijet127
      ok

    • @seenakakar2013
      @seenakakar2013 8 років тому

      +Geminijet127
      Pakistan is not my country but chatral and northern areas are my country.

    • @asianshaheen974
      @asianshaheen974 8 років тому +2

      +Seena Kakar the north is a part of the Islamic republic if you have a problem then get the hell out of here

  • @lookoi9363
    @lookoi9363 7 років тому

    they are too colourful for pakistan.black is beautiful for ladies.white for men.

  • @monaiql655
    @monaiql655 8 років тому

    Very bad urdu.