Descendants of Alexander the Great's soldiers - People of Kalash - Chitral Valley: DOCUMENTARY

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
  • More than 1 year ago I did contact "wolstenholme100" from UA-cam. I asked him if he had some videos to share that I can edit and upload on my channel. He was kind enough to send me 14 min. footage. What you see here is 10 min. documentary that I did slightly edit it for my channel. I hope you will enjoy it.
    #WadiKalash #Kalashculture #Pakistan #PeopleofKalash #Pakistani #SoundsofPakistan #SightsofPakistan #Tourism #Tourist #Travel #Kalashpeople #Culture #History #Folk #Documentary #chitralkalashvideo #Kalashvalley #Kalashgirls #Kalashculture #KalashChitral #Kalashbeautifulgirls #Alexanderthegreat #SightsandsoundsofPakistan #sikandareazam #سکندراعظم

КОМЕНТАРІ • 159

  • @clyde3237
    @clyde3237 2 роки тому +7

    The Kalash are a polytheistic people, meaning that they believe in many gods. The gods that they believe in are the twelve gods of Ancient Greece which makes them the only people who continue this worship! Gods such as Zeus, the god of gods, Apollo, the god of the sun, and Aphrodite, the goddess of beauty, are such gods that they pay homage to. Shrines which are found in every Kalash village remind us of the religious sanctuaries we would stumble across in Ancient Greece. They serve as houses of worship where prayers and sacrifices are offered. Oracles who played a major role in acting as mediators and spokespeople between the gods and the mortals still hold a position of importance in the social structure of the Kalash. In 1896 a British explorer by the name of George Robertson visited the Kalash and did a study on them. He concluded that fifty percent of the Kalash’s language derives from Ancient Greek. Such similarities can be found in their gods’ names. Zeus is called Zeo, Aphrodite is called Frodait, the name Dionysus has kept the same pronounciation. The Kalash have words such as demos meaning city-state and use the word ‘ela’ as an imperative command meaning come here. There was recently a tablet found in a village of the Kalash whose message was in the form of hieroglyphics. When the code was deciphered the message read, ‘Alexander the Great lives forever’.

  • @navdeepkumar6708
    @navdeepkumar6708 6 років тому +5

    Fascinating, mesmerizing. Makes oneself to ponder about the means and efforts to preserve such gems of human culture. Salutes to the production house.

  • @scotbotvideos
    @scotbotvideos 3 роки тому +5

    Greetings from Scotland. According to DNA.Land, I have Kalash ancestry. So their genes made it all the way across Eurasia to arrive on Alba's green and rugged shores.

    • @rajakhan-lr1yx
      @rajakhan-lr1yx Рік тому +4

      a lot of people in pakistan are descent of alexandar

  • @Imran-yr6qh
    @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому +4

    2 of my friends, one from chitral and one descendant from these people. very tall, strong and beautiful.

  • @lubaptista6179
    @lubaptista6179 3 роки тому +4

    this is an amazing doc... thank you so much for sharing.

  • @ThingsLike
    @ThingsLike 7 років тому +3

    thanks for another informative video of pakistan. the style of your videos make me feel peaceful, nostalgic, and proud. thank you for your hard work

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  7 років тому

      ok303
      Thank you for appreciating my videos.

  • @MayaRamses
    @MayaRamses 7 років тому +7

    AOA....so beautiful that KALASH is ...wish i could able to get some time to visit there ....well on my wish list ......a very nice and well edited ....BRAVO janab .....plz keep up that good stuff your well wishers are always with you with there prays....sadda khush rahhaye ....AMEEN

  • @decosiddique712
    @decosiddique712 6 років тому +27

    I have been to Greece, kalishi people still looks very much like their ancestors. Very beautiful. People must visit them , to help them.

    • @dionakgamer7769
      @dionakgamer7769 5 років тому +4

      Deco Siddique they aren’t Greek. They are indo iranic people who has retain their culture and tradition.

    • @dionakgamer7769
      @dionakgamer7769 5 років тому +1

      Deco Siddique their tradition is kind of similar to Nepali, himachal and uttrakhandi khas arya people. They worship their ancestors and nature. We worship our ancestors in Nepal and worship nature very much

    • @siddtheukranian3260
      @siddtheukranian3260 4 роки тому +1

      @@dionakgamer7769 it's way too different than people from Nepal i guess

    • @devansh7514
      @devansh7514 3 роки тому +1

      @@dionakgamer7769 but some people in that region have claimed to be the descendants of Alexander, Source, Wikipedia - Some of the Kalash people claim to be descendants of Alexander the Great's soldiers.[57]

    • @abdulbasit-
      @abdulbasit- 3 роки тому

      Kalash are not related to them that's a myth created by some idiots kalash are locals

  • @iamunikk4694
    @iamunikk4694 Рік тому +4

    Similar clothing dances food as Albanians even they’re burrash song and sound is almost identical to Albanian but there will always be a Greek to claim it first I guess

    • @zhaw4821
      @zhaw4821 11 місяців тому +2

      Jealous????

    • @iamunikk4694
      @iamunikk4694 11 місяців тому

      @@zhaw4821 for what?

    • @zhaw4821
      @zhaw4821 6 місяців тому +2

      @@iamunikk4694
      You sound like it ☺️

    • @talzotar7580
      @talzotar7580 4 дні тому

      They are Indo -Iranian people (Aryans) whom have live there before Albania and Macedonia was ever a nation.

  • @wajimoforesq8710
    @wajimoforesq8710 4 роки тому +7

    The government of Greece should work with the Pakistani government so these rich kalash culture can be protected

  • @sindhudegapudi
    @sindhudegapudi 7 років тому +2

    How passionate this video is?beautiful people wearing colour full weaves surrounding beautiful mountains... is this really possible to reach and see them as an Indian? Such a satisfying video... thank you for the upload... I am inspired:) good luck

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  7 років тому +2

      sindhu B.
      First of all I thank you for your beautiful comment. I hope you really really enjoy my other videos. It is possible as an Indian to visit Pakistan but you will need to apply for a visa. I cannot guarantee you that it will be easy because the visa policy of Indian and Pakistan is very strict.

    • @sindhudegapudi
      @sindhudegapudi 7 років тому

      Sights & Sounds of Pakistan yeah, I know right... sad state

  • @SaeedKhan-pj5zf
    @SaeedKhan-pj5zf 4 місяці тому +1

    I'm sure that there is no forceful conversion. Back in 1986 I used to visit Bomborat to enjoy their festivities. They earn very good name for Pakistan because many many foreign tourists used to visit the valley . It is because tarchmir hotel in chitral used to be packed with foreign tourists back in 1986.

  • @MariasBelieves
    @MariasBelieves 6 років тому +2

    Oh wow beautiful very unique people

  • @redstar1287
    @redstar1287 2 роки тому +3

    Beautiful documentary. Do they speak Greek language still?

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  2 роки тому

      No they don't. Kalasha is an Indo-Aryan language spoken by the Kalash people, in the Chitral District in Pakistan.

  • @AbbasAli-32
    @AbbasAli-32 6 років тому +4

    Sir, appreciated.
    One thing I would like to add that while visiting these people don't talk about any religious matters.
    Just stay in HUMANITY.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  6 років тому +1

      I am sorry I don't know what you are talking about please can you eleborate what you are trying to say? Thank you.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  6 років тому

      Aqib Jahangir
      Well no one should be forcefully converted or forced to do anything. I think we can all agree on that.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  6 років тому

      And I do disagree with you. Do you not always try to convince someone if you believe that you are correct? We do that on daily bases. Wether it's about religion or trying to eat healthy food or do the right thing. For me there is no problem in convincing someone or educating them what is right or what is wrong. If you differ with me I respect that but then u will also have to respect me and my point of view.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  6 років тому

      Yes :) You have any problem with my opinion? Deal with it and move on. CiAo.

    • @despinaxenoulis4882
      @despinaxenoulis4882 5 років тому

      They are with the 12 Gods of Ancient Greece !!! NOBODY CAN TOUCH THEM !!! THEY ARE NOT MUSLIMS !!! THEY WILL BE CHRISTIAN ORTHODOX GREEKS !!! ❤

  • @MsRabi08
    @MsRabi08 7 років тому +11

    wow! really informative video about kalash people but it's so sad to see that they have no facilities provided by our government.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  7 років тому

      Totally agree with you Valient Rabi. :)

    • @nilofarmunir5123
      @nilofarmunir5123 5 років тому

      Dear they have all the facilities as the other inhabitants of chitral ...

  • @BugiAnsari
    @BugiAnsari 5 років тому +2

    Islamabad, Nov 29 (Prensa Latina) Pakistan''s age old Kalash ''Suri Jagek'' tradition was reportedly nominated by UNESCO to be included in its list of Intangible Cultural Heritage.
    The decision was taken during the 13th session of UNESCO's Intergovernmental Committee held in Mauritius, geo.tv website posted.
    'Suri Jagek' (observing the sun) is a traditional meteorological and astronomical practice based on the observation of the sun, moon and stars in reference to the local topography by the Kalasha indigenous community residing in the Chitral district of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, province of Pakistan.
    'Suri Jagek' plays a key role for the Kalasha community in important social events such as festivals, feasts, rituals, animal husbandry and farming practices.
    The Permanent Delegate of Pakistan to UNESCO and Ambassador of Pakistan to France Mr. Moin ul Haque described the nomination of the Suri Jagek tradition by UNESCO as a historical achievement and said that this tradition will be protected as part of the shared human heritage of the entire world and will continue to serve its spiritual and utilitarian purposes.
    The ambassador said that the nomination of 'Suri Jagek', being Pakistan's first ever-independent nomination at this forum, was a milestone to ensure a better visibility of the rich folklore traditions and cultural diversity of the country.
    mh/iff/tgj/abm/gdc..
    Suri Jagek: Metrological practice of the Kalasha carried out through the study of the local topography in connection with the Sun, Moon, and Stars.(personal Note as a layman,,,***YES DAWN OF A NEW YEAR*** and Shaman predicts days of Festival's, Ancient Knowledge of the Stars, KEEPER of The Stories, among the Kalasha Dastuur,)...

  • @Asad2711
    @Asad2711 7 років тому +2

    BEAUTIFUL video G 😊

  • @peterstreiff3811
    @peterstreiff3811 Місяць тому

    I ❤ the Kalash ( the true *Macedon's* 🇲🇰)! Pakistan 🇵🇰 zindabad ! Salutari din Elvetia 🇨🇭 Peter

    • @talzotar7580
      @talzotar7580 4 дні тому

      They are Indo -Iranian people (Aryans) whom have lived there before there was an Albania and Macedonia nation.

  • @andreeakoumoushis4143
    @andreeakoumoushis4143 7 років тому +1

    Interesting topic and also a nice cut :)

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  7 років тому

      Thank you very much. I'ts been a long time. I remember u used to comment a lot on my videos. I hope everything is fine with you. I care about all my viewers thus why I ask u this. :)

  • @talzotar7580
    @talzotar7580 4 дні тому

    This Indo Iranian people have been living there for thousands of years in Asia(before Alexander of Macedonia) and the Hindu Kush mountains, before many central Asian tribes like the Scythian's , Turkish tribes and Germanic tribes ( all descendants of Japheth) migrated to the west of the Asian continent they called Europe.

  • @waseemakram-hj2jk
    @waseemakram-hj2jk 7 років тому +1

    Really nice

  • @abdulbasit-
    @abdulbasit- 3 роки тому +3

    I just wanna erase this one misconception that kalash are somehow different then the other people in there region in terms of appearance or facial features the fact is that NO kalash and the their neighbouring people all share the same kind of looks and facial features kalash are not the only ones in Pakistan who have some blonde or redhead people with coloured eyes (blue and green specially) there are other tribes in chitral and KPK which has these features, oh and also the Alexander defendant claim is just a myth and the funny thing is kalsh themselves never even claimed any connection to Alexander or any other nation there were some white British explorers/army officers who when they came here and saw some blondes with blue eyes they couldn't make sense of it and apparantly they had read a little bit about the the history of our region so they concluded that they must be related to greeks (the funny thing is this is that Greeks aren't even blondes with blue eyes themselves they're southern meditation people and these features are not common in Greeks infact these are typically northern European traits/features) dna results shows that these people are locals they've nothing to do with meditation people

    • @normanbates6577
      @normanbates6577 2 роки тому

      It's Mediterranean people not "meditation" people you dumbshit.

    • @clyde3237
      @clyde3237 2 роки тому +1

      The Kalash are a polytheistic people, meaning that they believe in many gods. The gods that they believe in are the twelve gods of Ancient Greece which makes them the only people who continue this worship! Gods such as Zeus, the god of gods, Apollo, the god of the sun, and Aphrodite, the goddess of beauty, are such gods that they pay homage to. Shrines which are found in every Kalash village remind us of the religious sanctuaries we would stumble across in Ancient Greece. They serve as houses of worship where prayers and sacrifices are offered. Oracles who played a major role in acting as mediators and spokespeople between the gods and the mortals still hold a position of importance in the social structure of the Kalash. In 1896 a British explorer by the name of George Robertson visited the Kalash and did a study on them. He concluded that fifty percent of the Kalash’s language derives from Ancient Greek. Such similarities can be found in their gods’ names. Zeus is called Zeo, Aphrodite is called Frodait, the name Dionysus has kept the same pronounciation. The Kalash have words such as demos meaning city-state and use the word ‘ela’ as an imperative command meaning come here. There was recently a tablet found in a village of the Kalash whose message was in the form of hieroglyphics. When the code was deciphered the message read, ‘Alexander the Great lives forever’.

    • @clyde3237
      @clyde3237 2 роки тому +1

      ​@Sankalp Tripathi The Kalash is the original Greek. They're like a time capsule from a bygone era. Modern Greek are much more Mediterranean in appearance nowadays due to past conquest by the Ottoman Empire. Greek and Turkish coffee are prepared using the exact same technique.

    • @gangaaputra9752
      @gangaaputra9752 2 роки тому +2

      You are right bro

    • @hanzoY248
      @hanzoY248 2 місяці тому

      ​@@clyde3237I have no clue why you're on every comment trying to push this Alexander narrative it's very strange. It's like your a white person clinging to your non existent culture so claim the kalash as being European

  • @siamboy596
    @siamboy596 2 роки тому +3

    3:29 😆😆😆

  • @dalina25
    @dalina25 4 роки тому +3

    Why are they not retuning to back to Macedonia or Albania where the Illyrians are from ?

    • @ryanhuntrajput474
      @ryanhuntrajput474 4 роки тому +2

      Because Alexander the Great won that land it belongs to them by blood right.

    • @servantofallah4368
      @servantofallah4368 2 роки тому +3

      @@ryanhuntrajput474 we fought for the whole land and and we own it. But they have full rights to live their lives accordingly to their practices and beliefs here. ATGs army stopped in this land because they were tired and couldn't travel anymore and secondly they loved the beauty of this land while ATG tried to conquer the world. His army men stopped in different parts of world.
      May you be enlightened with the true knowledge of the history. Ameen.

    • @Kk.beauty77
      @Kk.beauty77 Місяць тому +2

      Because they are Pakistani not Greek. This video is false

  • @muhammadbostan4291
    @muhammadbostan4291 6 років тому

    Nice

  • @anetaanetajovanoska4591
    @anetaanetajovanoska4591 8 місяців тому +1

    ❤❤ 10:11 ❤❤maçedonijan people

  • @MariscalMora
    @MariscalMora 6 років тому

    muy bonito

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  6 років тому

      Muchas gracias amigo. Espero que también te gusten mis otros videos.

  • @CostelAxon-rt9gt
    @CostelAxon-rt9gt Місяць тому +1

    Natiunea kalash de limba burushaski detine genealogie gethico-thracica

  • @vinaysabnis1478
    @vinaysabnis1478 5 років тому

    If they are protected by Pakistani govt. then why their population is getting reduced ?

  • @pane53e98
    @pane53e98 Рік тому +3

    ❤🇬🇷❤️ only alexander the great! We trust not albans and Skopja!!!

  • @Alfares392
    @Alfares392 4 роки тому +1

    Love from afghanistan our ancestors alike

  • @malikumairzafar
    @malikumairzafar 7 років тому +1

    اِس مختصر دستاویزی فلم نے کیلاش قبیلے کے چند مسائل کے بارے میں اہم معلومات فراہم کی۔ صد افسوس کہ پورے پاکستان کی عوام، دیگر آثارِ قدیمہ اور قومی ورثے کی مانند کیلاش بھی حکومتی غیرذمہ داری و عدم دلچسپی کا شاخ سانہ ہے۔

  • @daniyalk713
    @daniyalk713 7 років тому

    wow they make roti differently :p

  • @FaizanAhmad054
    @FaizanAhmad054 7 років тому

    Assalam U Alaikum, the month of holy Ramadan is about to begin. It is my request to please upload sehri and iftar videos of Pakistan. At your home, in your locality, in your city and different cities of Pakistan if possible. Love from India.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  7 років тому

      Faizan Ahmad
      Ramadan Kareem bro, yaar mein Pakistan nahin rehta. Agar koye mujhe video send kare ga HD quality mein to phir mein zaroor apne channel par upload karoon ga.

    • @FaizanAhmad054
      @FaizanAhmad054 7 років тому

      Sights & Sounds of Pakistan thanks for the reply. No problem, I thought you are still in Pakistan thats why I asked.

  • @vigneshrk
    @vigneshrk 5 років тому

    unicef will never turn it into world heritage site...i think he means unesco lol

  • @johnbooth1110
    @johnbooth1110 Рік тому +1

    If we are to believe the 6 books on Alexander's campaigns He had 10000 of his men marry Sogdian women, Roxanna was sogdian after all. why the Sogdians ? they were middle men traders on the silk route, when they entered china they name changed to the Su. So Macedonian you can sense were the Kalash came from, the dna of the Pakistan Punjab is 15% Greek

    • @talzotar7580
      @talzotar7580 4 дні тому

      Their is NO Greek(ethnic name) DNA strand that comes with that name attached to it.🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @naumanistani
    @naumanistani 5 років тому

    But it’s not true that they are Greek descendants. I used to believe but research came and it was debunked

    • @AKNandy-wh3jc
      @AKNandy-wh3jc 4 роки тому

      Then what's their origin?

    • @naumanistani
      @naumanistani 4 роки тому

      A K. Nandy I don’t remember now, I always thought Greek but apparently it’s not supporting the evident. They are native I believe so this area. I don’t remember now but another is “aryan” but some believe in that too while others don’t.

    • @adityanawani8134
      @adityanawani8134 4 роки тому +1

      @@AKNandy-wh3jc
      Their origine is alongwith Vedic people.

    • @devansh7514
      @devansh7514 3 роки тому

      @@naumanistani this is what was written in Wikipedia - "Some of the Kalash people claim to be descendants of Alexander the Great's soldiers". this could be highly likely, since alexander did expand his kingdom throughout Asia

    • @zhaw4821
      @zhaw4821 11 місяців тому +1

      Pakistanis have a lot of Greek DNA

  • @zeeshankhan-je3bz
    @zeeshankhan-je3bz 6 років тому +1

    Someone know how I merry with kalash girl

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  5 років тому +5

      Pretty racist and to me you really sound a paindoo

    • @Imran-yr6qh
      @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому

      @@karwanekamran indeed

  • @sdsharama127
    @sdsharama127 3 роки тому +1

    Is its link with Malana people of India

  • @duskojowcewski643
    @duskojowcewski643 3 роки тому +1

    Macedonian brothers and sisters, take care!

    • @abdulbasit-
      @abdulbasit- 3 роки тому

      That's a myth they're indigenous

  • @hassyg4083
    @hassyg4083 Рік тому +1

    they have no link to Alexander the Great..they are native tribe

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  Рік тому +2

      Proof it!!

    • @hassyg4083
      @hassyg4083 Рік тому +2

      @@karwanekamran don't be stupid and inbred go read about it

  • @bhagatsingh9947
    @bhagatsingh9947 6 років тому +4

    Aryan Hindu h

    • @safashaikh2894
      @safashaikh2894 6 років тому

      Aryan nahi hai woh

    • @ryanhuntrajput474
      @ryanhuntrajput474 4 роки тому +4

      @@safashaikh2894 Alexander the Great was Macedonian they do speak a Indo European languages associated with ARYANS

    • @Imran-yr6qh
      @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому

      aur tumh jahil hou

    • @Imran-yr6qh
      @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому +1

      @@ryanhuntrajput474 pakistan is indo-european too. Hindu is a religion, not an ethnicity.

    • @servantofallah4368
      @servantofallah4368 2 роки тому +1

      @@ryanhuntrajput474 he just spoke the "indo European language" wasn't a Hindu. Stop fooling yourself and making a fool out of yourself.

  • @rickyg8462
    @rickyg8462 5 років тому

    But, they're not descendants of ATG's army...based on DNA, correct?

    • @devansh7514
      @devansh7514 3 роки тому

      @HenryDavidT this is what was written in Wikipedia - "Some of the Kalash people claim to be descendants of Alexander the Great's soldiers". this could be highly likely, since alexander did expand his kingdom throughout Asia.

  • @maku8075
    @maku8075 4 роки тому +3

    LoL 😂 they are not descendents of Alexander they are there even before Alexander invasion they are the people of pre vedic religion. They are descendents of ancient Indo-Aryan.

    • @devansh7514
      @devansh7514 3 роки тому +3

      this is what was written in Wikipedia - "Some of the Kalash people claim to be descendants of Alexander the Great's soldiers". this could be highly likely, since alexander did expand his kingdom throughout Asia

    • @devansh7514
      @devansh7514 3 роки тому

      The researchers thus believe they may be an ancient north-drifted Eurasian stock from which some of the modern European and Middle Eastern population also descends. Their mitochondrial lineages are predominantly from western Eurasia. Due to their uniqueness, the researchers believed that they were the earliest group to separate from the ancestral stock of the modern population of the Indian subcontinent estimated around 11,800 years ago.[58] , Source - Wikipedia

    • @Imran-yr6qh
      @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому +1

      @@devansh7514 it's a butthurt hindutva guy dont bother man

    • @Imran-yr6qh
      @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому +1

      @@devansh7514 to lecture someone they first need formal education and indoctrination

    • @servantofallah4368
      @servantofallah4368 2 роки тому

      @@devansh7514 he did.

  • @IshanDuttagglblord
    @IshanDuttagglblord 3 роки тому +2

    I hope India reclaims it back

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  3 роки тому +2

      Seriously?? Just like in Bollywood movies?? ❤ awwwww what a cute thinking. Please don't forget to reclaim rest of Pakistan and Bangladesh as well. 🙄

    • @Imran-yr6qh
      @Imran-yr6qh 3 роки тому

      Come and try

    • @AMR_k400
      @AMR_k400 3 роки тому +1

      So they can stop them from eating beef and lead them head first to malnutrition
      Rather not

    • @servantofallah4368
      @servantofallah4368 2 роки тому +1

      These are historically CHRISTIAN people. They look nothing like you. The look like where they say they came from and know themselves much better. Free kashmir and let muslims in madhya pradesh assam live in PEACE. Why do you want to separate the children of ABRAHAM from the children of ABRAHAM (PEACE BE UPON HIM)? LET THE HISTORICALLY MONOTHEISTS LIVE WHERE THEIR ANCESTORS decided to live. They know where they're root is within this country. Children of ATG army They are.

    • @servantofallah4368
      @servantofallah4368 2 роки тому +1

      We pakistanis and bengalis are info European too but that doesn't make us "hindus". Hinduism is a religion not an ethnicity. Don't sound like an imbecile. And stop making a fool out of yourself. They look nothing like you people.

  • @christoschristos7805
    @christoschristos7805 Рік тому +5

    ΚΑΛΑΣ - ΟΙ ΕΛΛΗΝΕΣ ΤΩΝ ΙΜΑΛΑΪΩΝ ❤❤KALAS - THE GREEKS OF THE HIMALAYAS

    • @shahriartaleshi9848
      @shahriartaleshi9848 5 місяців тому +2

      Finally genetic studies have Kalash people no connections to Greece or Macedonia. They are closer to the Iranian people and are Indo-European.

  • @kaisermalik8191
    @kaisermalik8191 6 років тому

    Ok so we are all appreciative of the beauty of the Kalash and the beautiful natured people but lets stop beating around the bush and come together to help our community . Even if we can can spare few weeks or months or even year out of our time to go there to educate the children the future of Kalash . Teach them English,maths, how to read and wright or even new skills that's what will make the difference .
    Regardless of the cultural,religious or any other differences we are all human and lets do it for the humanity . We don't always need financial abundance to help rise each other do we ? I dont have much but i can help with helping how to read and wright , help with construction of at least a class room ie manual labour . Spread the word across the social media followers and bring back the tourism we have to start some where some ! All for one one for all right . together we can do it . I am up for it lets make it happen :)

  • @sadiamalik9298
    @sadiamalik9298 7 років тому

    Hello

  • @koustubhmehta8506
    @koustubhmehta8506 2 роки тому

    The paterelinal lineage the kalash people is found 97% indian and materilinial lineage is found to be western european in the dna so it is false claim that they are greek descendants.

    • @karwanekamran
      @karwanekamran  2 роки тому

      Thank for your point of view.

    • @anetaanetajovanoska4591
      @anetaanetajovanoska4591 8 місяців тому

      ❤❤bravo decko tvrdoglavi Makedonci ne se predavame deca aleksandrovi pozdravOd Makedonija

    • @athinkok6592
      @athinkok6592 5 місяців тому

      Eιναι Έλληνες από τον στρατό του μέγα Αλέξανδρου.😊