Johnny Depp expert accuses Amber Heard psychiatrist of breaking rules | LiveNOW from FOX
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 тра 2022
- Dr. Richard Shaw, an expert hired by Johnny Depp's legal team, testified that the psychologist hired by Amber Heard's legal team broke rules and was unethical in rendering an evaluation of Depp without meeting with him. Shaw cited the Goldwater Rule, which calls for psychiatrists not to render an opinion of a public figure without having met with them to do a proper evaluation.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! ua-cam.com/users/livenowfox?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
This man is a breath of fresh air. Calm, professional and completely opposite to the lunatic from yesterday.
The complete opposite!
That guy was a hot hot mess
It was fun watching that guy being cross examined 😆
Im still laughing at his antics🤣🤣
@@ashief8794 yes it was
The other guy needs this guy, either as a coach or as his own psychiatrist.
😆😆
😂😂👍👍
🤣🤣🤣
The latter. 😵
Other guy very suitable for entering the entertainment industry
This is what a professional sounds like. Humble, intelligent, intelligible and calm. The other guy needs this guy badly, either as a coach or as his own psychiatrist. either way he NEEDS help.
Lol yes he does 🤣😅🤣🤣
The Gatorade guy? He belongs in a ward as a patient.
Dr. Spiegel need his own psychiatrist ahahahhahaha..
Imagine being treated by him when you have real issues. True distopia. I can't imagine the APA keeps him on board after this.
Imagine that; Jopads0722 had the same opinion word-for-word several days before you.... I'll never understand why people feel the need to steal comments rather than write their own. 🤔
It took 8 minutes and 32 seconds for this dr just to get through all of his degrees, books, teaching history, awards (several) and everything else in between to get sworn in as an expert witness.... Can you imagine it talking almost 9 minutes to essentially tell someone that you're a bad ass and why you're allowed to have that title???
Lol
Well said Jen💯
hell yeah
Great comment. I'm sure a lot of us with careers can do the same. The paths we take are not easy, takes a lot of work and dedication to get there. Along the way we get certs, degrees, and so on. We are all qualified in our respected professions...
Very impressive for sure. He’s extremely humble while doing it too.
As a psychologist, it's nice to see a coherent, knowledgeable psychiatrist. The guy yesterday was a mess.
And so was his hair!
😂😂
Everyone was just baffled why they picked him.
@@usonohoshi6165 crazy attracts crazy, he was perfect
As a person who has been a patient of both psychologists and psychiatrists I found that Dr Spiegel was in fact just stating the facts as they are and his research was correct and true.
He is a true example of a psychiatrist. Gentle, composed, knowledgable, humble, respectful, calm...so professional.
He was actually a bigger creep than the one AH brought in. The constant smirk on his face was very uncomfortable. Pervert.
his voice is really calming
He's a consumate professional for sure
your summary is about PERSONAL individual traits NOT A CAREER PATH
jeeeshhh what a dummy
@@MissAnnabell22 he sounds just like my GP,he’s also very professional and calm.He saved my life.
Oh man… This guy is a REAL psychiatrist not whatever “”Dr.”” Spiegel was. You can tell he lives by these guidelines, which are in place well, for good reason as he noted.
Amber and her team are so discredited at this point. 😂
Yes, as a retired psychiatrist (MD), I would never offer an opinion without an examination. Besides, where I practiced (Kansas & Missouri) it is illegal.
@@barbarahouk1983 I wonder how it could be legal anyway. How could you ever evaluate a person without ever having spoken with her oder him?
Spiegal is Back To The Future Dr Brown, “Great Scott” what do you mean maniac, he was a total lunatic made me laugh 😹
Absolutely. Speigel was very difficult to watch and was unable to answer questions directly
The contrast between the 2 psychiatrist is absolutely astounding. This man is so eloquent on point and fair.He was not doing a show he was purely there for what he was asked to do and he did it well. I congratulations to that very young new attorney fantastic job.
Absolutely. Speigel was very difficult to watch and was unable to answer questions directly
Trained by the NHS and Stanford. This is a true psychiatric expert witness. Unlike the Dollar Store Doc Brown
😂😂😂😂
Used to work for salaries dept for senior medics in the NHS, used to know those in the mental health specialty by how they spoke 🙂
Dollar Store✔ yes. Even $1.25💲💲💲
Did you say Dollar tree 🤣🤣
@CathyB many of them are nuttier than fruitcakes 😂 You get the odd gem like this Dr
Man it’s bad for your case when the people watching are glad and RELIEVED that a witness isn’t a complete psychopath.
👏👏👏😂
Actually, it was very entertaining yesterday when it was confusing wether the "expert" was sane or insane.
🤣🤣🤣
Spot on Lydia 👍🌻🇨🇮
🤣🤣🤣🤣
As wild as this trial has been, I can see this trial being used for case study and scrutinization for law students. It contains so many examples of proper testimony vs improper/inappropriate testimony. Examples of how to relate with a jury and come across as reliable vs testifying with a combative and defensive tone, which typically results in a jury dismissing your “professional opinions” and damaging your ability to win your case. It just has so many good vs poor examples to study and learn from. It certainly has been an entertaining one to watch.
It will be absolutely be studied in part of, possibly, a full seminar or a course on the trial as a whole. Certainly, proper and wrong way to interpret and apply 'The Goldwater Rule'!
@@victrola2007 Exactly! I would’ve never imagined this trial was going to be the rollercoaster ride it turned into. Yes, I expected some inconsistencies vs what’s seen in everyday trials. But for a deformation trial, the fireworks were vast and delightful.
The “expert witnesses” (and I use that term lightly) for the defendants side and “Miss Heards” testimony of her own were just a complete train wreck to watch and hear.
Also, Depps behavior, composure and overall mannerisms were so intriguing and satisfying to watch. For a guy who openly admitted to so many unflattering attributes and habits, he still managed to come across likable and more importantly, sincere and honest. Unlike Miss Heard, who came across extremely unlikeable, unreliable, dishonest and borderline fraudulent.
It was such a genius move for Depp to start off by owning all of his flaws and that way, the defense couldn’t use them against him later on.
But those are just a couple observations of what will make this such an intriguing and productive case study for future law students. And you’re correct! It contains so many rarities that I can already see places like Princeton and HLS including this trial in case method classes/workshops.
This particular case is unquestionably worthy of in depth dissection and scrutinization. IMO, It certainly commands the attention of law schools and students. It will undoubtedly encourage productive, informative and beneficial ethical exploration and study. I can only imagine the discussions and knowledge it will provide future law students with.
I’m actually reveling just thinking about how dynamic, rewarding and gratifying it would be to participate in such a class that includes this in its curriculum. It definitely resulted in being one for the books.
Remember the children's magazines in the Doctors office? Highlights Magazine that had a feature GOOFUS AND GALLANT?
I can confirm aspects of the case/hearing has already made it into three 2L classes at two schools, and this was prior to the closings. I expect it will widen in the coming months and years, and even more so, if the appellate grants an appeal.
@@victrola2007 The AAPL and APA will likely delve into Goldwater and it's applications, specifically regarding forensic expert witnesses.
"Are you Board Certified?"
"Yes."
"Are you a member of any professional organizations in the field of Psychiatry.?"
"Yes."
"Which ones?"
"All of them."
time stamp?
@@elisabethnzanda47850:30
Immediately he is 1000x better than that last psychiatrist. This man seems so caring and measured.. this is what mental health professionals should be like.
Also...his hair looks better. lol
He’s very calming, the mad professor gave me nightmares!
He was using the rules, guidelines and defined role of his profession properly. He was measured, calm and had a good grasp of what he was describing. He was right in describing the previous witness as being in breach of professional rules.
Isn't it amazing that the righteous (this dr) and the wicked goes with their personalities?
Dr Obnoxious Count Olaf seem to be the one who appeared Narcicist.
Sad about Amber's team is, in order to win and get justice, they hired individuals most likely committed a malpractice or have a criminal record or a junkie 😂
Heard cannot and shouldn't win, or even get a pass. She deserve prosecution too and be a good change if her lying witnesses gets charges and fines as well. There should be consequence on their actions. Sold their soul for money then they can used that money to pay for their failures to act like a decent human beings.
Yes💯
What an elegant, well educated and well spoken gentleman.
British, of course..
White America is full of psychos. What's up with that?
Elegant, yes
I could build a rapport with this gentleman but not with the Psychiatrist, Dr Speigel, who testified yesterday. I have Autism trails as most of us do, but I’ve certainly have more than most. I’ve worked with children and adults with Autism and some adults with Asperger Syndrome, but Dr Speigel would appear to be in a league of his own. Am I qualified to say that without proof? No, but then neither was Dr Speigel without having met Mr Depp, no matter what his qualifications are.
Is he married? Is he free to marry? He has to be married... of course...
He lives in Woodside...
I bet....
I love the Bay Area and grew up bear Stanford...
I really like how he is explaining the Goldwater Rule. Thanks to him.
Dr. Spiegel really came across as a foolish character yesterday!!! He seemed mentally ill and very unstable and he appeared to want attention and appeared to be needy of various forms of attention yesterday.
This man has so much integrity for psychiatry it gives me so much hope. And I’m so happy he works with innocent children who need help. Their all in good hands. What a man
He is like a kind grandfather. So soft and loving.
Despite the objections this guy has basically ruined any credibility for Amber's argument on mental health disorders this guy is a true and passionate professional
The difference between each of their psychiatrists is mind-blowing. Amber's one should be stopped from treating anyone evere again.
Can you imagine going to him ,Next thing you'd wake up in Arkham Asylum with a toilet tube hanging out ya arse ha ha
He needs to be admitted to mental institution.
Absolutely agree!! I believe that the guy from yesterday had some terrible reviews.
@@dreamingoffall7694 he didnt care when one of his patients commited suicide
Amber psychiatrist needs one to be called one, specially the one yesterday they have issues by themselves even the lady before the previous week they show just same character like amber so full of themselves.
In a nutshell: what happens when an ACTUAL expert psychiatrist reveals what a crackpot the prior psychiatrist is.
Im in a doctoral Clinical Psych program and I'm taking Ethics/Legal Standards this summer. At the start of class, my professor said "Lets make sure you memorize the ethics codes so you dont break them like the guy in that big hollywood case" lol
@@m_js5709 lol truly
😂😂👌🏽
😂😂😂😂
Amber beard's PA was earning minimum wage, I'd emagine he got $20 and a suit to say what he said 😂
This psychiatrist is BRILLIANT, PROFESSIONAL and totally ETHICAL. Thank heavens he is in the profession to help children and parents. BRAVO! What an honorable member to society. The other psychiatrist is insane! He should not have a license or be permitted to deal with patients.
Yep Dr Spiegel's license should be revoked immediately
If I were still a troubled child/teen I'd feel so comfortable talking with him he seems so genuine, understanding and gentle. Thank you for helping children and adolescents in need ❤️
This gentleman clearly knows his profession, offered expert opinion, and was an AMAZING witness.
and not weirdly aggressive or combative.
I agree. Calm, professional, and composed. No bias. Just sincere and honest opinion. All the former "professionals" should review this and learn from his demeanor.
😅😅😄😀
Totally, unlike the ones from AH's team
He even smiles during every objection because he knows he is right and no one will be able to prove him wrong.
How refreshing. An expert in his field who is humble and knowledgeable.
He also seems to take a neutral stand as opposed to the guy that Heard's lawyers hired who was so biased that he demeaned his own profession
This gentleman is the polar opposite of that spazzy guy that Herd's team brought in .
I believe all the people Johnny's team have brought up have been experts that have treated this hole case very professional.. But the team on Ambers side just ruined their careers.
As one who went to school to be a marriage and family therapist with a masters in psychology, I say to you here here. Exactly. Very few. He is a rare and precious exception.
@@heinrichknierim5666 Yes I don’t know who that devil Amber Heard’s team dragged in. He look like it was from hell I hate to say anything about his appearance but it just shows on your face sometimes when you’re not evil. Just like Amber heard it’s just on her face. So she’s pretty so what. Why would anyone possibly conclude that to indicate any likeliness of any benevolence? But people do believe it or not. That’s OK. I’m praying the truth prevails. And it always speaks for itself in the end no matter what “your truth” is....In the end it is THE truth that wins out; in the end. Can’t be stopped.
Can I just say this man is a badass. He has dedicated his life to working with children and parents who are going through traumatic events at the Children's hospital. Thank you Doc
This is a true professional 👏. I am a licensed mental health professional, and watching the other "experts" was so difficult. The degree of unethical behavior, arbitrary diagnoses was unbelievable. I hope there is disciplinary action by the licensing board
I've been wishing for that to happen to that psycho who said Johnny was a narcissist. I hope his license gets taken from him and pray 🙏 all his current and previous patients get reevaluated by a competent psychiatrist, I pray for them all. 💕
Can you file a professional complaint? Being as how the supposed experts made your whole branch of medical service look like quacks?
Don't forget the marbles in that other guys mouth.
This gentleman is genuine, I believe he truly cares about helping people.
Yes there is an inate genuiness and kindly nature in this man that people can sense.
You can tell straight away he works with children, that other guy would give kids nightmares!
I would send my child to him
Children.
he is david bowie
I find it comical how Amber's witnesses have been so creepy, shifty, and manipulative, whereas Johnny's have been so thoughtful, polite, sincere, and genuine.
Depp called her A gold digger
@@authenticobservant175 is she not?
Turds of a feather - stick together…
This guy Is very intellectually knowledgeable He looked things in different ways and ngles he
I thought the same 😂... Johnny's side very professional... But Amber's side quite suspicious hahah😂
No shouting, no screaming back at the lawyer, and no mouth spasm!!! Two thumbs up!!!
He has such a calming aura. You know, one of those people who you can be completely at ease with.
This is how my idea of a good psychiatrist should compose ones self. Thoughtful insightful calm and collected. Not looking like he's himself a patient of a psych ward..
He really is insightful and calm...a lesson for everyone when speaking in public (esp on a televised court trial.)
His hair was not helping his case yesterday 😂
LOL
@@ej8780 nor the crazy mouth stuff and the possibility he said to Elaine before he took the stand he was willing to lie in his testimony
@@ej8780 two different people bruv. Yesterday was Amber's witness. This man is Johnny's.
Not only is this man a completely competent professional gentleman, he also has the most soothing voice. This is what you want to hear when you're experiencing trauma and seeking help, unlike the tone and demeanor Dr. Spiegel displayed yesterday. I could honestly sit here and listen to this man talk psychiatry for hours.
Exactly his voice is what you want to hear while in therapy instead of seeing those weird traumatizing face expressions from doctor wacko!!! 😂
@@enhanceitall2863 it does feel like a therapy after listening to dr. wacko yesterday 😂😂
I totally agree. His voice is soooooo soothing 🥰🥰 a big plus on top of his professionalism
Agreed, very soothing for trauma victims. Great calming eye contact and demeanor as well.
I think yesterday’s guy was secretly a goat, those mouth movements are very strange for a human but normal for a goat 🤔
I never expected to care about a Hollywood trial but I will literally cry if Johnny wins this. It will make me feel like maybe I didn’t deserve to get my tooth knocked out with a beer bottle or my ribs sliced with a knife by my ex. I have always felt like even though I was abused I didn’t deserve any justice or sympathy because men are supposed to be tough and stoic so I never even got to heal because I didn’t feel like I could talk about it or cry about. But if people support him maybe they will support me too.
You did not deserve to be abused. No one does. Best wishes to you, hope you can get help and heal.
We support you!!!! Your ex was a terrible human. I wish you all the best!
I brlieve you and support you. My father is the battered spouse in my parents relationship.
That is the gaslighting and degradation you have been subjected to that is making you believe you somehow deserved any of that. I hope you realize this is not the case and that nobody deserves to ever be abused, whether that be physically, emotionally, mentally, or sexually. Once you begin to understand this, you can begin to heal.
Only ever had one broken nose in my life and that was from an ex girlfriend. She blind shot me right on the nose because I wasn’t engaging in her argument. I was so embarrassed to tell anyone. She would scratch me, accuse me of cheating, then ignore me. Her own brother was the one to tell me to leave her. He knew what she was really like and felt for me. I hope she’s a better person now. I get how men would be afraid to come out and say these things.
This is, in my opinion, one of the most interesting moments in this trial. To bring a witness to the stand to not simply support/disparage Heard or Depp, but to educate the jury on why the activities of one of the expert witnesses is wholly counter to what is expected of an "expert" of that profession. It makes Dr. Speigell seem less like a practicing psychiatrist, and more like an actor whose roll is to make the jury question how psychological testing can feasibly be conducted.
Very well put.
Spiegel as an actor whose role is ...
He’s a rebuttal witness
Rebuttal witnesses are a fundamental part of trial conduct…
Someone with deep knowledge, proven expertise and a long career. He’s what you call an EXPERT.
deserving of the title fully!
Yes, and he behaves like the professional, he is. He isn’t angry and animated.
Spiegel be like : AN expert, not "THE" expert!!
This dr. just gave us a free seminar on psychology ethical principles, wow
I'd add "wisdom" to your list, which is essentially the combination of knowledge & experience. This is why young people should be exposed much more to our growing elderly population (& vice versa).
You can tell instantly the children he is helping are safe and in the most caring, capable hands. Thank you Doctor.
The kind of people who restores our faith in humanity
Ambers folk all look cheap.
Well said. What a great man and Dr his integrity is obvious and gives me hope.
@@bra1ndrain149 not funny, get a life
@@bra1ndrain149 proof?
I'm just some guy, and even I know that Spiegel was absolutely full of it when he said he wasn't violating the Goldwater rule. It's not complicated. You don't render a professional opinion or diagnosis on a person that you haven't examined.
So true , it's the obvious ! How dare Dr Speigle judge another without proper tests !!!!
Well, this blows her expert witness out of the water. Her witness is a mercenary, giving evidence for money. This guy would turn up for free if it meant Psychiatry was being dragged through the mire.
I want this guy to be my psychiatrist. He's so soft spoken and has a air of complete calm about him.
Me to he's very nice
PLOTTWISTT!!!!!
Same. I could certainly listen to him all day. He’s so knowledgeable and his delivery is understandable.
He has a warmth welcoming voice..
Angela and I both want him to be your psychiatrist. I hope all goes well.
As a clinician, this witness testimony was a refreshing rebuttal to yesterday’s completely unprofessional and unethical “opinions”. I am dismayed that Dr. Spiegel is treating patients and providing “expert testimony”, especially in a area of practice where many individuals struggle to be heard and overcome stigma related to mental illness, self harm and substance abuse disorders. His testimony showed bias and a total lack or empathy, as well as “traits” of projection of his own perceived shortcomings.
dude i am traumatized with hat i heard and saw yesterday from the lunatic lmaooo
Absolutely 100%. Yesterday was scary !!! I’m still mind blown !!
@@billybalm2461 He needs to go back to the future
I think this guy was a big relief to Johnny as well. Johnny rarely looks up but at one point when this guy was refuting what yesterday’s psychiatrist had said, Johnny looked up at him and you could see the vulnerability and appreciation in his eyes. It must have been tough for him to sit and listen to yesterday’s guy tear him apart so horribly.
I’m concerned for his patients.
You can literally feel the genuineness of this man and other JD witnesses. Not something you can say about Heard or a large number of her witnesses.
@One Culture Love Culture xo omg look at you!!! I'm sure you've been in that field just as long as he has, to be able to diagnose him with narcissistic traits!! Good for you!!
@One Culture Love Culture xo Thanks for your "professional opinion" Dr. Spiegel.
@One Culture Love Culture xo But the main case is to prove that Johnny's career was affected because of that op-ed. Right?
@One Culture Love Culture xo the other "expert" gave out unsolicited diagnoses and spoke down on someone because of said unsolicited diagnoses, which violates MANY codes for those in the psychology/psychiatry field.. Dr. Shaw was simply trying to save the integrity of his field. As someone who has seen multiple psychiatrists, I can tell you right now, Spiegel has absolutely NO business working with mental health patients.
@One Culture Love Culture xo Actually, it's an expert pointing out a quack who is making other psychiatrists look bad. But clearly your bogus observation gives you the knowledge to label the better one a narcissist 🙄 Learn how to read a person's demeanor better. You're doing an absolutely horrific job at it.
Such a calm presence. If I needed a psychiatrist, I would go to him, hands down.
Well spoken,dignified and not scary, so unlike of the guy yesterday.
That lunatic was disastrous 😂😂😂
😂😂😂
The Wizard was on one yesterday. 🤡
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Definitely not scary jajaja
This psychiatrist is so much more pleasant and very professional compared to the weirdo psychiatrist that Amber called in yesterday. Listening to this guy is a joy.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣"weardo"
Birds of a feather flock together
@@jodecesaro1921 yeah. Amber and those fighting for her are so toxic, any more toxic and they'd be killing themselves.
Day and night kind of persons like i honestly i just enjoyed listening to his description and speech as for mr. Weardo hes like someone you meet at a pub shouting at the tv screen at a football match and trying to explain some stuff and its all rubbish 😂
😂😂
I didn't want this video to end...he's so good at what he does. This is a true doctor.
He is proud of his work, his profession. It radiates out of him! I love this man. He wasn't argumentative either. Well done, good Sir!
The difference between the “expert” witnesses on Johnny’s and Amber’s side couldn’t be bigger. Johnny’s team can just choose the most professional ones out there but Amber’s choice is limited to people who are willing to commit perjury.
She is looking at this like her greatest performance ever... She brought acting to the table... Nothing more
@@jessicarussell9250 what acting it was so terrible we can all see through it lol
@Kate G: Though I have scant knowledge about this trial, I think it only fair to bring up how the more powerful, influential, or wealthier person can afford better experts. On the other hand, if Heard’s primary motivation is nefarious, she may hire experts who work in the shadier side of “expert testimony”. Either or both explanations are plausible. I don’t have a dog in this fight, just bringing up possible reasons why there seems to be a discrepancy in the characteristics of said experts.
@@catseye1009
Ridiculous.
Both rich, both able to fund their defense as necessary at whim.
2 rich folks getting a fairer trial than anyone could ever receive in the lower 60%.
Your premise is as insulting to actual working class people,
as heards claims are to actual victims
@@catseye1009 She's counter suing JD for 100 million. In her counter, she can add in things like expert witness fees and attorney fees. That is how people get put on an even field.
He doesn't NEED to testify as an expert in psychology. All he needs to do is behave like a normal human being and that alone nullifies the other crackpots testimony
😆😆😆
Crackpot 😂
007 accent helps
I absolutely agree.
Don’t talk about Gimli like that- it’s been hard for sense he left middle earth
So integrity-driven. Assuring to see an expert defending the integrity of a profession
as someone who was inpatient in child/adolescent psych, i could only dream of a professional as knowledgeable and genuine as this man. unfortunately i believe he is a part of a minority. all of my psychiatrists through the years have been terrible. something tells me. unlike the psychiatrist treating me at the time, i highly doubt this man would tell me i "just need to figure it out on my own" upon arriving in emerg after an unalive attempt. i bet this dude would actually do his job.
Glad you survived all the non-helpful docs. There are so many of these!
Gaelic?
@@JohnnyLandscape lmao yes
Unusual to see that name Ceilidh - and the proper spelling too!
@@dmhor7389 i mean yeah in ireland and scotland it's nothing new, but being canadian... everyone calls me sealid 🤦🏻♀️
Well, I can say one thing going for him, is that he doesn't look like he just came back from working on his time machine.
Hilarious! Exactly! He had a bad hair day, too.
Too funny--thank you!
😅😂
Hahaha a great description
Great Scott!
It’s upsetting he got cut off with the objections and they were sustained because he was truly giving great clinical and professional insight onto how unprofessional and how medically and unethically improper dr.spiegel’s “professional” opinion was.
Yeah, it was literally his job there, so I'm not sure why objections got sustained that interrupted his professional opinions.
I was interested in what he was saying, I thought he was going to be able to say things like, everyone has traits of something or other, it doesn't make them have a personality disorder etc etc.
They were getting revealed they always scrambling frantically cry out objections when they’re getting revealed
He gave opinions based on the other psychs records so that’s outside his expert role to just address why the other guys opinions were stupid and unethical
@@formerlyarandompropernameb9327 The hope is that the jury sees what we see. And I love the slight and harmless hint at a dramatic story your name implies.
I love how he’s just swaying side to side in his chair lol. He looks so relaxed and comfortable where he is and confident in himself & the knowledge he has to offer. Much respect for him & his field.
Fake johnny Depp scammers are asking for money
I concur with his opinion. It is highly unethical to make assumptions and diagnose a person you have never meet and certainly never did an evaluation on or tested. We had a long discussion about this and that it has offended those who respect and uphold the ethnics of that profession.
9+ minutes to just cover his credentials, this guy is the real deal.
I get the impression too that he gave them the short list :)
My only hope is that the jury paid attention and weren't bored. It was a bit dry at times, but it was necessary to lay out the information foundation to debunk Spiegel
I was thinking that! Phenomenal
and then the immediate flustered “can we approach?” after the Judge asked for any objections. 😂 im weak. they felt immediately threatened.
Indeed, search and like wow! 👌👌👌
This is what a Doctor of psychiatry looks and sounds like. The weirdo from yesterday was frightening - and I'm in the medical profession! No wonder he called his patients' VICTIMS !
Can't stop laughing
HAHAHAAHAHAHA STOPPP
Right? Did anyone call him on that?
exactly
😂😂😂
This doctor is a true professional. He exudes compassion, knowledge and trustworthiness.
So true , great man and it's a shame that all are not aware as he in his profession!🤔
My God after all this I think johnny needs one gigantic freaking hug man, he needs all the love in the world, it's not easy having to go through all this mess.
Jonny was very true. The're not his fans or employees or colleagues, we are relatives. Everyone he brings is calm, composed and normal. Where as everyone Amber brings has personality disorders
Ain't that the truth.
😂😂
Lol. What coincidence!😁
Birds of a feather.....
😂
I love how regardless of age, gender, race, religion and/or politics we can almost all agree Amber Heard is GUILTY.
Amber turd, bringing people together.
We the public agreed with this statement.👏👏
The issue that even united democrats and republicans!
@@harryisamuggle something I never thought I’d see!! I’m happy to see it though.
Definitely
For educational purposes, I feel this trial has added greatly to understanding abuse /trauma & recovery topics. Great witness.
Prayers for those going through divorce or recovery from abuse. My heart goes out to you; I wish you justice.
There really is no recovery when the abuse caused CPTSD. I'm an expert witness there...
But thank you for caring 😻
basically,, for as long as you say "i'm hopeless, i can't recover", then it's true. you can't progress when your own mind sets a barrier right at the starting line. breaking that barrier of "i cannot get better" is the way you start having the ability to progress.
@@Swampgurl777 ❤. It's been 6 years since I left the narcissist. It's a process; a slow process. Give yourself a lot of space and time, but don't give up❤. I can't say I'm fully healed, but I'm better than I was before. Big hug; I do care.
Just “listening” to this gentleman doctor….I feel healed.
Respect. Knowledgeable, humble and honest. No feelings of supremacy over others unlike Dr Spiegel
He was so aggressive and kept drinking obsessively like Whitney did. Liars are known to drink a lot because they are lying 👁👁 so there’s that lol
@@starbright144 good one
That other guy had Alzheimer's.
Just my openion
My other openion is that chick is done in Hollywood.
She's going to prison.
Her daughter will hopefully go to someone sane forever.
This woman will mess her up.
God made her unable to have babies.
She didn't get the memo.
She's dangerous as a parent.
After the guilty verdict I predict her to play the suicide TRY for sympathy.
Her daughter deserves a better human for a mom
Dr. Sméagol exhibited enough of his own narcissistic personality traits to be a huge red flag for me.
Correct "Dr" Spiegel. :D
This guy's whole demeanor is so much better than Spiegel's. Much more trustworthy and believable.
Spiegels was psycho himself
He has a better demeanor probably cause he’s genuine and does honest work. He’s got nothing to be on guard or feel the need to be defensive in every answer unlike the other guy lol
Yeah he feels like he’d actually help you mentally, not cause you to go mental 😂
Smegal?
Exactly! Dr. Spiegel just came across as hostil, defensive and very unprofessional. He pissed me off 😂
This man was awesome. Period.
The David Bowie of psychiatry! And a true Grand Master Healer! What a legend, gentlemen, and a scholar! May his work live through the test of time....Through a 1000 generations until finally surpassed!
I couldn't think of why his Beautiful calming sounding voice sounded so familiar, until I read your comment and you are right , Mr David Bowie
Thank you 😊
Talking about narcissistic personality disorders, he just described Amber perfectly....
Last day of testimony tomorrow and I 100% believe that Johnny is innocent of everything with the exception of being caught up with addiction.
Addiction was his downfall….. and Amber used it against him as a way to record him she manipulated him and regardless of the verdict Thursday
This whole trial has amplified global awareness of the possibility of men Being victims in our society and beyond. Amber has made a complete mockery of a movement for women in the industry to stand up against powerful men using their money and power against women for leverage to get what they want. The truth is, Amber and her entire defense and her testimony is a collaboration of a projected perception of what she did to Johnny. She did every single thing to him that she has testified he did to her. She is THE ABUSER! She is calculating, she is cunning and now she is CANCELED!
And I still stand with Johnny Depp
He was also wrong about the connection between narcissism and self-entitlement. It is classified as a personality disorder, not a behavioral disorder. But i think he knew that.
so does the definition of psychopath, The most important testimony of the day was David A. Kulber, Johnny's hand specialist. Johnny's lawyer established Johnny could not punch with his right hand, and he also could not grab with his right hand. Amber's sister claimed Johnny grabbed Amber by the hair and punched her. If he had hit her with his injured finger, he would have had to get his cast fixed, which the doctor said he could not do. That would mean he had to have grabbed her by the hair with a hand that could not grab. Any way you look at her testimony it could not happen. Additionally, if he had been able to punch with his pinned finger, the bruise on Ambers face would have been on the other side of her face.
A psychopath is defined as an individual as having a lack of empathy for others, but uses charm and charisma to manipulate people they encounter. Psychopaths are not recognized as an official mental health disorder, but psychopath traits include using people to gain power, money, and more without any regret or remorse.
Page one of the fascist playbook: "Accuse the enemy of that which you are guilty."
This could have been condensed to: Dr Shaw are you the man? Dr Shaw-“yes, yes i am,” Dr Shaw is it the case that Dr Spiegel is a disgrace to your profession? Dr Shaw- “yes, yes he is.”
Hahahahahaha exactly
Hahaha
Lololol
And he’s so cool, he wouldn’t even say “disgrace”… he’d more likely say, “a gentleman who may not have represented himself well”.
@@clairequinlan4723 well said! 😂
The ONLY positive that AH did for anyone was made the world aware of what specialists NOT to hire for ourselves in our lives. Congratulations Amber- not only have you trashed your own career, but you've managed to single handily destroy every single witness that you've put on the stand in your behalf.
The choices made to pick and choose which specialist to hire for Amber's team also clearly indicate and mirror the exact type of characteristics Amber herself reflects. Every damn one of them are nuts. Johnny's were professional, well spoken and highly favored...Amber's were combative, did their jobs half-assed, presented themselves to be extremely argumentative and a know it all...... EXACTLY how Amber carries and portrays herself.
Sidenote- Johnny is right hand dominate, so it's logical to agree that when a right hand dominate person throws a punch in the heat of an argument they would instinctively throw a punch with their dominate hand/ fist.... with a right hand dominate person throwing a right handed punch, any black eyes, bruises or marks would land on the receiving persons left side of their face... Quite odd how all of Amber's bruises, marks and black eyes were ALL on her right side of her face. She is also right hand dominate and instinctively, would unknowingly focus on the right side of her face when concentrating on bringing focus to a specific part of her face such as using makeup to create a bruise.
Good point!!!
Great observation!
BRILLIANTLY expressed!! Thank you! So spot on!!!
First paragraph: my thoughts exactly. It is what it is ;)
Second paragraph: The right hand to the left side of the face is a great observation, but your hand dominate side argument is a bit far-fetched. I'm right-handed. When I shave, I use my right hand for both sides of my face, yet the left side is "easier" to shave, it feels more natural, it's the side I start with. So... dunno bout that part. Cheers!
This guy was awesome. I found myself wanting him to continue explaining things-whether they were related to the trial or not! I just wanted him to keep talking. He was so calm, knowledgeable, and professional. Not being a nutcase helped, too. :-)
Kudos to Johnny's legal team for getting the most professional witnesses to speak on his behalf. It's impressive the level of professionalism these people exude unlike the ones Amber's team has gathered.
Well, when you have a solid case, it’s easy to attract professionals. No one really likes a bully so the opportunity to set things right appeals to people who are in these fields and motivated to help, would be my guess.
Money walks.
@@TheBaumcm spot on
Only crazy people would see it Amber's way
This dude's entire career can be summed up as "compassion". Not someone you want going against you in court.
I agree. In addition I might add that he presents as: competent, compassionate, coherent, calm and courageous.
@@Seeker0fTruth you might say Dr. Shaw and his Competent-Cs
@@Devngel653 ahhhhh I sea what you did their 😉
This man is well educated and intelligent. You can’t make a diagnosis on someone on paper. Even a forensic psychiatrist meets with a perpetrator.
He talked softly, humbly and with confidence.
Listening to this guy is like a breath of fresh air. Calm, knowledgeable, clear, educated and a very pleasant person to listen to.
a big difference from the lunatic who claimed to be a psychiatrist the other day
Amen
that is a truly scientist, all that he had spoken based on data
He has a very soothing, gentle voice. He's in the right profession. It must be awesome being his patient.
@@unclescipio3136 I have to agree, but the "Um" has to go. Maybe the fact that this was driven down my throat through out childhood is what makes it such a glaring distraction for me, nevertheless, it's pretty non-stop in his speech pattern.
This is what a professional looks like. Humble, intelligent, intelligible.
Very Intelligent
No licking chops either!
Dude wrote like 100 books/reviews and somehow it still didn’t sound like he was bragging. Yet Speigel mentioned writing one and it sounded arrogant
Agree my other half presents and speaks the same as this guy and is very well respected and liked in his line of work.
amen 😉
He definitely knows his Job....
This guy is a lethal weapon.
He has such a calm and gentle presence. He could easily make a patient feel at ease and comfortable being open and vulnerable in front of him. The guy from Heard’s side was so aggressive and condescending the patient would probably leave worse off than when they came.
😭😭🤣🤣🤣👌🏴
I'd expect no less from him. He treats children and adolescents, who lack the mental capacity of an adult.
No to mention unethical!
Exactly! Go in depressed, leave suicidal 🤦🏾♀️
@@benjamincakes6356 😂 I shouldn’t be laughing at this, but I am lol
I could listen to Dr. Shaw talk all day. Such a pleasant soothing voice. Professional and concise. No ego. No insanity!
Just like Johnny Depp's voice soothing and could listen to it all day long.
agree! I wish he were my therapist! haha
This is such a positive for Dr Shaw being a professor. His students must enjoy his lectures.
I’m about to see if he has any or is on any channels online- maybe speaking engagements- I want to fall asleep to this calm voice.
And the children’s info wouldn’t hurt- I teach children with emotional/behavioral problems. Lots of trauma and PTSD plus lots of other diagnoses. ❤️
If I ever win the lotto, I'm going to hire him to read books to me. :)
Having worked with so many psychiatrists, it is easy to differentiate psychiatrists who went to psychiatry for the love of serving versus those to who went to psychiatry with the hope that they can either heal themselves or cover up their own personal issues and
usually gets enmeshed with their patients problems & becomes disastrous for the patient.
“Objection your honour!!”
“Ok, what’s the objection?”
“Damaging to our case!”
😆 🤣 😂 THIS. IS. ON. POINT! 💯💯💯
This is what i hope psychiatrist and professor to behave. Speak wisely
professional💯
Yes. Normal ones.
@@wendyhardin5259 he is way better than normal, and i dont need to explain it.
But yeah, any normal person will not talk like that guy from yesterday
@@P.sherman45 yesterday’s testimony, i still couldn’t digest it. To the extent that it creeps me out tbh. Even questioning the psychology area itself. Glad that’s not the case, the APA and AMA indeed have their own guidelines + seeing this Prof testimony and manners
@@dayanazahari7697 thats exactly what they discussed,
That a guy like that will ruin the reputation of that profassion
this man emanates kindness, honesty, caring, and intelligence. much respect
He looks SO approachable. I would feel very safe going to him for a psychiatry review as he seems so down to earth, gentle and genuinely wants you to know what is occurring for you.
The dfference between Spiegel, Heards "specialist" and JDs specialist is stunning!
Holy crap. This guy makes ambers "expert" look like a flat earther hahahahaha
😆 🤣 😂 😹 😆 🤣
It’s the accent lol!
😭
This comment ✋
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Quality comment 😂 😂 high five
This guy is so SOLID. God bless him. He is a credit to his profession.
This gentleman reminds me of my children's pediatrician. He seems so genuine. His voice and demeanor are so gentle and calming. He clearly is very knowledgeable in what he is being asked to explain.
I felt interested in listening to what he had to say about the field of psychiatry for a moment I even forgot I was listening to the trial.. A true professional, calm, collected, easy to listen to.. Totally night and day compared to “Dr.” Smeagol
Agree! I forgot I was watching a UA-cam video of the trial to see what I missed. I completely was focused on every word he said and was inputting it into my brain as information on psychiatry. He was amazing. Was never bored. And didnt see this as me partaking in my guilty pleasure which is what this trial was for me. I didn't feel guilty after watching this because of how much I learned about his field and how Heard's psychiatrist's, all of them, violated their fiduciary duties that one in their profession should have upheld while testifying as an expert witness. That's so sad. And they are still surprised that they lost this case. Come on. Heard and her lawyers are delusional. Honestly if I were Amber I'd sue my lawyers for hiring the "expert" witnesses that they did, and allowing them to testify in the manner in which they did. I know it's hard to defend the guilty but they made it worse for her.
This expert has such a calm, reassuring manner. He must help a lot of folks.
He looks like a therapist. Calm and composed person, choosing his words wisely and speaking very gently..
He has a lovely calming voice and demeanour. I expect this helps put his patients at ease. Dr Siegel however…🤣
Just like jonny
I have great respect for this professional, he is in everyway. The gold water rule basically drowns out the other guy. Well done sir, u do your profession proud.
If David Bowie was a psychiatrist.
Refreshing humour 😂.. this comment is gold 😊
For anyone who is a curious cat like I am, “The Goldwater Rule is a statement of ethics first issued by the American Psychiatric Association in 1973 restraining psychiatrists from speculating about the mental state of public figures. The rule enjoins psychiatrists from professionally diagnosing someone they have not personally evaluated” (psychology today). This means that Dr. Spiegel has broken that rule.
O thank you!! Because I was torn from looking it up and continuing watching.
thank you 😊
This doctor explains exactly what the Goldwater Rule is, with much detail. You just have to listen to his testimony. Which is why we are all here right?
@@dragonsky799 I found out after I posted 🤣
I really want to read this guys peer reviewed documents. His take on the subject is very intriguing
Wow, this guy is on point and smashing Spiegel’s integrity. This guy is clearly someone who follows specific guidelines when it comes to psychiatric evaluations.
well actually the judge didn't really want to hear it because it was too long winded. And Spiegel's main argument that Spiegel kept repeating.. that if examining somebody is required in order to give an opinion, then all sorts of things would be impossible.. nobody has yet addressed that!!!!
@@boliusabol822 *professional opinion, it is in fact required. Sorry you can't diagnose someone over instagram with your psych associates.
@@boliusabol822 but those impossible things mentioned are not required or even useful
@@Viktor_Von_Doom that’s a not a rule more an ethnic and moral conduct of the profession. Are you suggesting that Trump can’t be labeled as a narcissist by his social media posts?
@@goodtimesbadtimes5273 actually that specific example about Trump and his tweets has been picked apart and explained ad nauseam as to why it *still* can’t be an official diagnosis, but dozens of psychiatrists have made private exceptions due to concerns about his level of power over the nation and the world to state their private opinions that he regularly and publicly exhibits more than 5 of the 9 traits for NPD. Spiegel used “snippets” of the UK trial, some deposition material, and (arguably between his own deposition and testimony yesterday) also some of Depp’s acting. So short answer is, no, official diagnosis can’t be made in either case without meeting with the patient, and otherwise the two examples (Depp & Trump) are nothing alike in quality of material reviewed or quantity of professionals consulted. 🤷🏻♀️
Objection, your honor. He's destroying us. >:(
I love how professional this Dr. Is!!! I feel so calm watching his testimony🙏🏽
This Psychiatrist, much like Dr. Curry, exudes genuine, intellectual integrity and can respond effortlessly without theatrics or arrogance...just the honest truth, just like JD♥️.
His voice is like a calming lullaby. Some people are just gifted to be in the field that they’re in unfortunately others landing that same field just get somebody told them they could make some money at it. This wonderful gentleman - his voice is so soothing. You cannot fake genuine. He’s genuine it shows.
Winnie the Pooh vibes
He also gives off potential serial killer vibes. Like the creepy Doctor who does mad experiments in a dark dirty basement. Sorry lol. I watch too many movies. But yes he was a great witness.
Your comment was genuine.
@@capone3167 - Which ONE?
The INITIAL COMMENT⁉️
Then, I Agree.
The After comments, are somewhat delusional, perhaps They could Use His Help.
South African accent
You can already see the difference between an actual psychiatrist and whatever that mad doctor who called his patiant victims and had al over aggressive attitude.
The way Dr. Curry and Dr. Shaw delivered their statement is what I wanted to achieve. Very calm and clear..