same could be said about the starship tho i would probably put my bets on the 1a5 in a non scripted battle if both players are at an equal skill level.
Well, in stationary hull-down engagements the Starship is consistently superior due to its indirect fire capabilities. In any other case, the Leopard is superior. The reason why the Gaijin judged the Starship to be "better" is because they clearly assumed that stationary hull-down engagements are the overwhelming majority. Personally I expected that the Leopard wins out due to the thermal sight that allows him to spot the starship far earlier the Starship the Leopard. Nevertheless, Gaijin has a point in overemphasising the indirect fire capability because on a large terrain where there is a plentiful hull-down cover, a well-organised Starship army can always win against a well-organised Leopard army simply because the Starships can kill a hull-down hidden Leopard meanwhile the leopard cannot kill a similarly hidden starship. The only exception is when some Leopards can infiltrate or flank the frontline which rather characterises the competence of the Starship crew then the vehicle itself.
The Leo 1A5 should've definitely won that one, it's Thermals, and Sabot are obviously superior to the starships low muzzle velocity, and lack on thermals.
What is the point of comparing the slowest POS supposed ATGM carrier with a thermals equipped, fast MBT with APFSDS at a whole BR above it? You would have made a decent point if you took the M60A3 instead of the M60A2, and come to the conclusion that the M60A3 should be down-BR'd as it is much less reliable than the Leopard 1A5 while at the same BR.
That reminds me of when they compared the t-72 and m1 Abrams. The Abrams lost in every category but reverse speed being unable to pen the t-72 and saying it is easily penned by the t-72 .And then they called the match unfair because the abrams is 10.0 and the t-72 is 9.3 so they did it again vs a better soviet tank and it won too
I love tanks but Helicopter modes need some love. My wish list for helicopters- to make it fun again!!! 1- Add utility/ transport helis Utility helis need to have infil and exfil objectives throughout the map in which AI ground troops attack objectives and need to be picked up to conduct air assaults on subsequent objectives. Also enables Medevac objectives back to friendly lines/ landing zones/ field hospitals. 2-Add light/recon helis- enemy convoys/ objectives are no longer randomly populated on the map, all enemy objectives must be discovered by these light/ recon helis (points for spot bonus). Other enemy units are discovered once they fire on players/friendly AI or when discovered by other players. 3- bring back PVP in a separate mode- top tier players want it- give it to em 4- allow utility helicopters to carry equipment and light vehicles (based on real world data) to support AI attacking objectives (think slingload operations light vehicles/ artillery.) 5- bring in night missions! Also- rewards for NOE flying in combat conditions at night- will add another dimension of challenges for conducting these missions in the dark. 6- Lastly add specific close air support objectives for the ground AI- (add points for providing CAS and not allowing the friendly AI to get wiped out will make players care about friendly AI
What a bulls.... So this whole series is about who gets in fire position first and doesn't miss like a complete Dumbo. Tbh this show is nonsense, put the money into thundershow that's a lot better
"Man you guys, the M60A2 is super OP, Gaijin better move it up in BR." Whatever completely incompetent Leopard player allows themselves to die to an M60A2
It isn't even a good comparison. The starship role is way different from a fast reloading mbt. The better match up would be the 1A5 VS the AOS. But props to Gaijin for simulating how german players are.
This match wasn't fair enough and player with the Leopard did some mistakes. The usage of the machinegun againts the ATGM was nice. However the first match: this tank has a fantastic gun depression he should went to the fortress and try to snipe from there. Or as we saw the M60 starship was there so he can easly flank it. But let's say the first match was correct. It wasn't so obvious that the M60 is there. The 3rd match: i have one question. That wasn't a huge problem we can't see just the commanders cupola. If he use the correct ammunition it could hurt for the M60. Why the Leopard guy didn't just back up but manouver far from the M60 for example behind a hill, repair the tank and then go to fight. Second thing I saw gameplays from both, I tried both, but the Leopard1 is significantly better than the M60. Especially in longer ranges. And the Leopard player haven't use this advantage. To be honest I thought "Oh come on, long and mid ranges, the Leopard1A5 with the DM33 terminates that scrap into the ground" and then: short and mid range. What?! And please everyone be honest, because all of knows that the long 105mm gun is undoubtedly superrior to the tanks with such guns like the starship has. I smell a bit of American bias
They'd do it like to movie Fury tiger fires one shell and misses entirely and the jumbo fires 8 shells with unquestionable accuracy because the tiger loader had a stroke
If I was that Starship, I would've just hide since there's no way im fighting a MBT that already knows where I am and since at this BR mostly have laser rangefinder and stabilizer, they can just cap me before my missile hits the enemy tank.
get 2 players of equal skill and face them off against each other, then base what you say off who wins. Scripting it feels unnatural and the fact that the STARSHIP of all things beat out a Leopard 1A5 is kinda sad. I know this is meant to just be fun and that we shouldn't care about what tank wins and all that, but it still feels rather odd to have quite possibly the WORST 8.0 tank in the game win against a 9.0 APFSDS slinger (with thermals, mind you)
1st Why is the Leo just standing still out in the open? 2nd The starship "looks around" while immediately stopping and turning the turret directly to the Leo. 3rd Why does the leo move about 100 yards into OPEN ground with smoke to repair instead of moving behind the terrain to slow the Starship's time?
Despite reacting to an APFSDS round that fast, I can confirm, in game, this is accurate. I love the M60A2 and main germany and have had my fair share of kills in the 1A1. Unless on completely flat terrain, the starship has a large advantage, especially with its great turret armor and gun depression. Also the shillelagh looses its rocket boost after 500m and can be hard to see coming in even with thermals on. However, in real life, the M60A2 is know to be very complicated and faulty
Hey gaijin,I think there should be a feature where you can reset your Tree,like if you go on USA and want to get a British jet,I think it should be like that,where you can reset the whole entire tree to go into another tree
It would be more entertaining to face 2 recognized youtubers in the tanks of their choice from the same BR. Example, PhlyDaily vs. DOLLARplays or Hunter
Why wouldn't you compare the m60A3 with the era against the leopard? They're the same br and more similar than these 2. Then you could have really shown the strengths and weaknesses for each. One is faster with less armor and the other has era. Both have similar guns too unlike a 152 missile launcher vs a 105 shooting sabots
I like how the whole video looks, its great, especially with the SloMo of the rounds flying, but i think the conclusion it isn‘t very meaningful cause its scripted
In Sim: Finland fights alongside the Red Army against the KV1B and finnish skin German T34 (that despite being finnish can't use finnish roundels anymore because they are restricted to Sweden only) Are you serious? And this after denying Finland being independent from Sweden last year?
If that Leo was at all competent it would’ve had that easily
same could be said about the starship tho i would probably put my bets on the 1a5 in a non scripted battle if both players are at an equal skill level.
Well, in stationary hull-down engagements the Starship is consistently superior due to its indirect fire capabilities. In any other case, the Leopard is superior.
The reason why the Gaijin judged the Starship to be "better" is because they clearly assumed that stationary hull-down engagements are the overwhelming majority.
Personally I expected that the Leopard wins out due to the thermal sight that allows him to spot the starship far earlier the Starship the Leopard.
Nevertheless, Gaijin has a point in overemphasising the indirect fire capability because on a large terrain where there is a plentiful hull-down cover, a well-organised Starship army can always win against a well-organised Leopard army simply because the Starships can kill a hull-down hidden Leopard meanwhile the leopard cannot kill a similarly hidden starship.
The only exception is when some Leopards can infiltrate or flank the frontline which rather characterises the competence of the Starship crew then the vehicle itself.
That wouldn’t be realistic to a German player tho
Germany suffers
If the Starship had been portrayed realistically the gun-launcher and fire control would fail every few shots requiring a day of repairs...
The moment you realise that this is staged so who ever wins is who ever gaijin wants to win
"Truth is ... the game was rigged from the start"
-Benny
So you're implying the Khrizanthema will win next week? 💀💀
bruh, you think that they just put two gaijin employees (brain damaged) against each other?
I think these are just made for viewer entertainment at this point
You ought to realize that when you see Breda501 didn't use HE when meeting the flak88
Ah yes, the sad 8.0 ATGM carrier, vs the 9.0 MBT, I wonder who'll win.
Its the snail 🤐
IT-1 wins
Looks like ATGM.
Sad ATGM carrier, lol.
The thing is a fairly good tank.
Still tho the leo lost
I swear I got killed by a BT-5/7 a lot more often than M60A2 in my Leo 1A1/1A5
Whoever wrote this script was obviously trolling knowing these narrators have never played high tier their entire lives 💀
This format is a joke at times, the Leo should by all means win this easily. But I guess this means we can swap their BRs if you think otherwise huh?
This is an outrageous, Leo obviously shouldn't be at 9.0
@@Infinity_Squad obviously it doesn't, I just wanted to undermine the absurdity of this episode
I think y'all take this show too seriously...
@@Eire_Aontaithe they are, they are just a bunch sweaty gameds
@@ishuikamakura272 I agree with you
Imagine the one of the worst 8.0 tanks winning against one of the Best 9.0 tanks thats what i call the skill issue
More like staged
@@txni.040 bro they take random players that want to participate XD its not possible to have same skill
@@gigachad8425 I was just joking😅
Well the M60A2 is definitely one of the best 8.0, I have it and I average 3 kills at the least with it, very exceptionally good tank
@@jackmcguinn9643 no it isn't
Your just good at the game
The Leo 1A5 should've definitely won that one, it's Thermals, and Sabot are obviously superior to the starships low muzzle velocity, and lack on thermals.
Even got a big boy apfsds 💀
What is the point of comparing the slowest POS supposed ATGM carrier with a thermals equipped, fast MBT with APFSDS at a whole BR above it? You would have made a decent point if you took the M60A3 instead of the M60A2, and come to the conclusion that the M60A3 should be down-BR'd as it is much less reliable than the Leopard 1A5 while at the same BR.
they should just do these comparison if oppennent vehicles have same BRs both.
@@kocayrklibirinsan3056 I don't understand how this is not a strict requirement...
That reminds me of when they compared the t-72 and m1 Abrams. The Abrams lost in every category but reverse speed being unable to pen the t-72 and saying it is easily penned by the t-72 .And then they called the match unfair because the abrams is 10.0 and the t-72 is 9.3 so they did it again vs a better soviet tank and it won too
I don’t think I have ever been killed by a starshit in any vehicle let alone a 1a5
Speedy APFSDS slinger with Thermals and LR vs. Explosive Watermelon launcher whose top speed is also that of an elephant. Not very fast.
This feels like I'm comparing a German transmission from 2020 to an American Transmission from 1917.
Whoever is responsible for this show seems to not have any idea about anything whatsoever.
Ya'll really like to get carried away.
"When the people making the video have never played the game..."
This video perfectly displays that Gaijin have no idea what's going on in their own game.
Leo 1 represents perfectly a typical german main. Not even surprised why Straship won.
I love tanks but Helicopter modes need some love.
My wish list for helicopters- to make it fun again!!!
1- Add utility/ transport helis
Utility helis need to have infil and exfil objectives throughout the map in which AI ground troops attack objectives and need to be picked up to conduct air assaults on subsequent objectives. Also enables Medevac objectives back to friendly lines/ landing zones/ field hospitals.
2-Add light/recon helis- enemy convoys/ objectives are no longer randomly populated on the map, all enemy objectives must be discovered by these light/ recon helis (points for spot bonus). Other enemy units are discovered once they fire on players/friendly AI or when discovered by other players.
3- bring back PVP in a separate mode- top tier players want it- give it to em
4- allow utility helicopters to carry equipment and light vehicles (based on real world data) to support AI attacking objectives (think slingload operations light vehicles/ artillery.)
5- bring in night missions! Also- rewards for NOE flying in combat conditions at night- will add another dimension of challenges for conducting these missions in the dark.
6- Lastly add specific close air support objectives for the ground AI- (add points for providing CAS and not allowing the friendly AI to get wiped out will make players care about friendly AI
Gaijan is not gonna read ur Comment not even try your suggestion
I've learnt that these videos are way more fun when you dont care for eighter of the vehicles to win!
Thanks I think we all should learn that
Why not the actual M60's at/around 9.0? Wouldve been a more interesting video
Did you have children driving the Leopard? Totally decided even before the match began. 1st round, they just sat there waiting to be killed.
A certified unbiased Gajing classic.
Yes people, we see flashes from the other side of the map a dodge APFS coming your way.
Please bring your 8.0 tank to a 8.7 battles.
I’m only to spot that the smoke is from a previous update . It’s not the version of today. That mean that all the video are already prepare
Too bad the real-life Starship was an over-engineered, unreliable mess that constantly kept breaking down.
Why the hell would the starship use an HE round at that disntant
To load the atgm ?
please explain where
What a bulls.... So this whole series is about who gets in fire position first and doesn't miss like a complete Dumbo. Tbh this show is nonsense, put the money into thundershow that's a lot better
"Man you guys, the M60A2 is super OP, Gaijin better move it up in BR."
Whatever completely incompetent Leopard player allows themselves to die to an M60A2
Also great episode in my opinion the 1a5 is better at close quarter engagements in urban areas with more cover
Can’t agree, Starship is made for close encounters while Leo is a sniper
@@charlesleethesonandfathero14 guess so tho if the m60 misses the leo can technically have 2 shots on it but thats just my opinion
M60A2 in this just had every environment it could perform better in except for 1 match all maps that it won allowed it to abuse poor ballistics
This new series hurts my brain.
They didn't my boi the starship wrong. They took away the upgraded transmission it had
WTでの単独行動は基本"見敵必殺""先手必勝"なので装甲をぶち抜ける弾があるなら後は操縦者の索敵力と運次第なのでは…((((
Please do a tank versus of the L3 33 v the AMR.35 ZT3 which is a French version of the L3 essentially
Meaning of this video: The Leopard 1A5 is a weaker than the M60A2, so I will REBALANCE.
Would be better if it was something like the Type 74 (G) and Leopard 1A5
I keep my promises to keep watching this type of videos Gaijin. I LOVED THIS so much!
this would be an academic example of fake news in a university career
The starship should have fought the amx 30 acra ,why it fought the leo ?
This is ridiculous. I mean, if you have to choose between these two, I guess everyone’s answer is the Leopard.
Do you guys even play the game, seriously? The Leo would own that fight
They should do this with planes 1 vs 1 dogfights :)
F14 tomcat vs F222.2
That commentary was so exciting
Tank versus is such a good concept but all 4 videos have been bad simply because of what they compare...
This video is just as unnecessary as the addition of drones XDD
Elon musk mustve pissed that starship is being blown up xD
M60A2: we must stand for civil rights soldiers 👏
bruh it looks like they let the AI drive the leopard in the 1st round
It isn't even a good comparison. The starship role is way different from a fast reloading mbt. The better match up would be the 1A5 VS the AOS. But props to Gaijin for simulating how german players are.
Well done Gaijin for staging such an intense battle
Can you make a video of M1A2 SEP vs T-80 BVM
Q:Will there ever be an update where it shows when the tank was produced?
YES WE NEED THAT. like an
@@oshadow-hypixelandtutorial3781 that's what im saying
Also a symbol that shows what varient of vehicles that was most produced like the p51d5 or spitfire mkix
This one had me enthralled, I seriously didn't know who would win :)
Hello is there a Chans that the Bismarck will be added in the next update sense there has been no water base update
you know you should do a thing like this to the fighter planes and jets also
They'd make the me262 dogfight a spitfire and claim it should be lower in br
Anyone else feel like this is biased and staged?
Af
This match wasn't fair enough and player with the Leopard did some mistakes. The usage of the machinegun againts the ATGM was nice. However the first match: this tank has a fantastic gun depression he should went to the fortress and try to snipe from there. Or as we saw the M60 starship was there so he can easly flank it. But let's say the first match was correct. It wasn't so obvious that the M60 is there. The 3rd match: i have one question. That wasn't a huge problem we can't see just the commanders cupola. If he use the correct ammunition it could hurt for the M60. Why the Leopard guy didn't just back up but manouver far from the M60 for example behind a hill, repair the tank and then go to fight. Second thing I saw gameplays from both, I tried both, but the Leopard1 is significantly better than the M60. Especially in longer ranges. And the Leopard player haven't use this advantage. To be honest I thought "Oh come on, long and mid ranges, the Leopard1A5 with the DM33 terminates that scrap into the ground" and then: short and mid range. What?! And please everyone be honest, because all of knows that the long 105mm gun is undoubtedly superrior to the tanks with such guns like the starship has. I smell a bit of American bias
man, do I always look forward to seeing these awesome tank vs vids!
I want to see jumbo 76 vs tiger 2p, please try and argue the jumbo is somehow better, I’d love to see you try xD
They'd do it like to movie Fury tiger fires one shell and misses entirely and the jumbo fires 8 shells with unquestionable accuracy because the tiger loader had a stroke
Nobody mentioning the cologne duel intro
Excellent! Now, can we have our leopard move to BR 8.0?
Why is the Starship even fighting the 1A5? It should be something at or around the 1A5s BR like the TTS or even the RISE (P)
is the opening animation a nod to the battle of cologne?
If I was that Starship, I would've just hide since there's no way im fighting a MBT that already knows where I am and since at this BR mostly have laser rangefinder and stabilizer, they can just cap me before my missile hits the enemy tank.
Q: When will the people use their brains to make a balanced match?
Can u add a Canadian tech tree? I just want to see the Avro arrow in game
get 2 players of equal skill and face them off against each other, then base what you say off who wins. Scripting it feels unnatural and the fact that the STARSHIP of all things beat out a Leopard 1A5 is kinda sad. I know this is meant to just be fun and that we shouldn't care about what tank wins and all that, but it still feels rather odd to have quite possibly the WORST 8.0 tank in the game win against a 9.0 APFSDS slinger (with thermals, mind you)
da merkt man wie intensiv ihr eurer Spiel spielt
When are you adding the French Navy ?
I love that the Female narrator's last name is Sherman
It's not about the tank it's about the person playing the game
Gaijin forgot to update the german flag... i don t think the national socialist party built the Leo 1A5 in ww2
Very realistic
The moment you realize this is so redundant 😂
Q. can you do a tank versus between the rooikat 105 and the premium centuro love the show
Now we need to see the obj 120 vs m60
Next tank verus: the French FCM.36 vs. the Russian T-80BVM (the FCM.36 wins easily)
Next one must be Strv 42/Eh against italian P40
if this is the attempt to justify the downtier/uptier system, you've done it so badly.
1st Why is the Leo just standing still out in the open?
2nd The starship "looks around" while immediately stopping and turning the turret directly to the Leo.
3rd Why does the leo move about 100 yards into OPEN ground with smoke to repair instead of moving behind the terrain to slow the Starship's time?
Good old gaijin trolling us with the german player smoking to repair, and not move.
lmao next your telling me gaijin is gonna compare the f86 against a mig 21 if they have a air version
Despite reacting to an APFSDS round that fast, I can confirm, in game, this is accurate. I love the M60A2 and main germany and have had my fair share of kills in the 1A1. Unless on completely flat terrain, the starship has a large advantage, especially with its great turret armor and gun depression. Also the shillelagh looses its rocket boost after 500m and can be hard to see coming in even with thermals on. However, in real life, the M60A2 is know to be very complicated and faulty
can we get remach for a19? you fugged up round selection!
Hey gaijin,I think there should be a feature where you can reset your Tree,like if you go on USA and want to get a British jet,I think it should be like that,where you can reset the whole entire tree to go into another tree
All I am saying is that we should be able to restart The treachery and put all the rp into a different treachery
It would be more entertaining to face 2 recognized youtubers in the tanks of their choice from the same BR. Example, PhlyDaily vs. DOLLARplays or Hunter
Why youtubers?
Commentary gave me anexiety
I feel that in the third round the Leo could've loaded a hesh round and hit the commanders cupola potentially causing an overpressure into the turret
M60A1(AOS) vs T55A
in Round one I knew the leopard would loose as I heard C ... u ignore C on this map
tbh i love the starship but its not better than the 1a5
It’s not like the starship has atgms or smth
old smoke graphics?
GeMaNy SuFfErs
Why wouldn't you compare the m60A3 with the era against the leopard? They're the same br and more similar than these 2. Then you could have really shown the strengths and weaknesses for each. One is faster with less armor and the other has era. Both have similar guns too unlike a 152 missile launcher vs a 105 shooting sabots
And still the Leopard is the overall better vehicle
Summary of the comment section: Wtf is the point of this series?
I like how the whole video looks, its great, especially with the SloMo of the rounds flying, but i think the conclusion it isn‘t very meaningful cause its scripted
ohhhh my god DM33 in 10 m have 408 km pan and still can't pan front armor of T72AV
In Sim:
Finland fights alongside the Red Army against the KV1B and finnish skin German T34 (that despite being finnish can't use finnish roundels anymore because they are restricted to Sweden only)
Are you serious? And this after denying Finland being independent from Sweden last year?
Bro what
Can someone let me know how the aim adjusts automatically as soon as the range is found? All ik is I have manually adjust the aim.
Laser range finders
@@KageKrigeren Oh it's for those tanks br 8 or above huh. Thanks
sturmtiger vs tankette
i think the tankettr would win
most skill issue/staged fight ever