LIVE! Real Lawyer Reacts: Judge in Maya Case Rules on New Trial and Money Reduction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 січ 2024
- #lawyeryouknow #takecareofmaya #netflix
🔴 Do you or someone you know need to speak to a real lawyer about a personal injury or wrongful death case? Please reach out to our firm and we will make sure to answer your questions or find someone who can. Our consultations are always free and confidential. You can call our firm at (727)441-9030 or email us at lawyeryouknow@gmail.com.
✅ For business inquiries contact me at lawyeryouknow@gmail.com
✅ Let's connect: www.tragoslaw.com/
Twitter - @lawyeryouknow
Instagram - @tragoslaw
Facebook - @lawyeryouknow
TikTok - @lawyeryouknow
✅ Join our email list here - bit.ly/33lV3Mb
✅ Get your Lawyer You Know merch here - bit.ly/LYKMerch
✅ Become a LYK Channel Member Here - bit.ly/3OecDDD
SUPERCHATS & DISCLAIMER - 1. Superchats read out are not to be taken as my opinion nor endorsed by me. 2. Questions are answered on best efforts based on my knowledge and jurisdiction.
🔴 NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Intro & Outro Music: DOLYJJVS2W8MGNFM - Розваги
I would be so pissed if I did my job as a juror and spent all that time just for the judge to come and change it. What a big letdown to the jury 😡
FYI - 'Maya' Verdict Upheld, But $261M Award Reduced To $213M
THANK YOU
Thats still alot of money haha. Hopefully that doesnt get reduced again.
NOT ALL HEROS WEAR CAPES
I think it should be reduced further based on the lack of evidence. It was a sympathy verdict.
I also worry about the impact this has on mandated reporting. Clearly they had a reason to report her mother. Hospitals shouldn't fear being sued to protect a child. Giving a child Ketamine infusions which is risky even by admission of the doctor who administered it, is a reason to report her. She was also directing treatment which is outside the scope of an infusion nurse. They have literally no proof of anything else. False imprisonment for 2 days when they were trying to transfer her to another hospital which the mother refused isn't worth over 200 million. The person on the phone call wasn't Cathy B. They had still photographs of her. Didn't even show her being held down. Those were two key pieces of evidence which weren't even proven. The emails from the mum were more incriminating.
@16:08 EPIC response...."well, if u r gonna keep em like u kept Maya, maybe u shouldnt "!
I hate when a judge steps in and changes a juries decision! They did their jobs so leave it!
Exactly. Why even have a trial if your going to start doing stuff like this 🙄
@@labrown6212poor maya and co only getting 200 million instead of 250 million
@@qwerty112311 yes it's so depressing, poor thing
There’s usually a cap on how much can be awarded. The jury isn’t aware of this before hand.
What's the point on having juries figure damages???😡
13:40 - 13:59 When you lose, You complain...Its True...Especially Lawyers...and Children😂❤😂❤
PETER, THIS COMMENT WAS GOLD❤❤❤
😂😂😂😂
Please keep the updates coming on Maya. The hospital should be made to pay for their disgusting and disgraceful treatment of Maya and her family. No excuses ! Thanks for all your work Peter, now onto your next KB video #rewatch from Australia ❤🇦🇺
“I feel _lightheaded_ blowing all that hot air!” 👀😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
This is the ONLY channel that I watch every video. 👍 I don't chat or comment often but always watch no matter what. Been here since 30K subs!!
What is the point of having a jury reach a verdict if the judge is able to step in and change the compensatory and punitive damages awarded by the jury? If that is the case, then why even have a jury trial?
Welcome to reality, where jury verdicts are overturned and reduced regularly, as has been the case forever.
Being on a jury is not looking like a good idea.
I think the jury’s duty is to decide the verdict based on the facts of the case, whether the case has merit to be awarded; however, some states have maximum on punitive damages and the judge has the right to make changes to the damages but not change the verdict of the jury. Lol. Hopefully that makes sense.
Please cover Treehouse case over 5k watching. This case is So Wild! Ty
@@carolsisti7203Exactly. In Depp’s case they went above the max, IIRC. So it had to come down.
But telling juries there is a cap might affect the way they determine their judgement.
I’m a layperson but the way you discuss and breakdown the rulings and comb through all the documents to give us the best possible information has made this one of my favorite channels! Thanks for all the hard work you put into every video for us!
This case is so sad. I am very familiar with RSD/CRPS. My mom was diagnosed in the early 2000. My mom says that it’s like putting her hand/arm in lava. It’s a horrible neurological condition. It’s life long. There is no cure.
My mother has survived cancer twice had two children naturally. This is much worse.
How DARE they remove the child.
I can’t count how many times we have ended up at the hospital and the DRs have told us “your condition is above our pay grade”. This condition they are not familiar with.
The hospital and drs caused my mothers disorder to spread when they don’t pay attention to notes that say “don’t touch right arm”.
I’ve only met one other person that who was familiar with this disorder. Her husband had it.
This issue not only affects the one diagnosed, but the family. I can’t tell my mom that it’s going to get better tomorrow.
Shame on the hospital and cps. There actions caused so much damage and this poor family will already have so much to bear.
I too have RSD. I can relate to how your mom feels. I've had it 20 years. We know the life Maya is headed into.
@@Momtojoshcanpark my prayers are with you and your family. ❤️
@@JennLeeFoster thank you and mine yours...
@@Momtojoshcanpark ❤️
I'm disappointed to see the judge reduced the compensation but very glad to see it won't make any difference to JCACH - despicable that they're trying to get a new trial, not surprising though.
I really like that judge. He says facts just the way he sees them,
Listening to this while getting ready for work. Scary thought is "how many other times did JHACH do something like this to other parents."
I appreciate you continuing to follow up with the Maya case....It truly provides us a valuable opportunity to "see behind the curtain" and gain insight into the reality of what happens after a verdict & award is rendered by the jury in a Civil case. I found today's read through of Judge Carroll's "Order On Post Trial Motions" very educational from a procedural standpoint. I hope you continue to do Maya case updates as it moves through the appellate process. Thank you ! ~~Christy~~
Yes me too….I hope Peter continues to update on Maya’s case. I pray that they get the FULL amount now ruled. If the hospital gets away with what they did to Maya, which was DISGUSTING….they will NEVER CHANGE ! They need to be hit where it hurts to even have a chance of changing their behaviour ! Go team Maya. !
What the jury decides should stand. Dislike the reduction of financial compensation. This case was horrific and awarded monies should match. It’s an insult to the victims to have damages reduced after a jury decided on amounts.😮
It happens, unfortunately. The reduction is not much in comparison to some I've seen.
What a slap in Maya’s face and the jurors. reduce reducing reduced.
I think the hospital should just pay. It’s costing a fortune in attorneys fees and keeping them in a bad light all the while!!
They lost a judgement for hundreds of millions, a few million here and there is nothing. And the hospital isn’t going to lose a dime of revenue, win, lose, or draw. It’s really shocking how clueless so many people are.
@@qwerty112311 I agree; no corporation is just going to lay down and pay out hundreds of millions of dollars; they’ll fight it to the end but it’s always about the money. Sad but true. And that goes for everyone on the case.
@@carolsisti7203just like it’s about the money for maya. And everyone. Ceteris paribus, everyone is taking more money compared to less. People like to hate on companies for “greed,” while they turn around and put money in savings, or buy nice stuff, or ask for a raise. Nobody is going in to their bosses office to ask for less money. Requests go one way.
@@carolsisti7203sadly it’s not the hospital that’s going to pay these funds. It’s the patients and families that will be paying with ridiculous increases medical fees.
I hope that no matter what this judgment amount STAYS !Until the hospital is made to pay and hit them where it hurts they will NEVER change their behaviour …what they did to Maya was disgusting and disgraceful! They should be MADE to pay big time !
With behaviour like this being allowed and considered acceptable by them and continuing to get away, it’s no wonder the health system in the US is so terrible for so many.
We have it bad enough in Australia but the US system and the money they charge is disgusting! I feel for all AMERICANS, trying to navigate their system. I guy I know who died from a heart attack because he couldn’t afford to pay the dr bill to get checked, he was only 44. His employer was dodgey and didn’t give him health insurance and paid him a pittance. Snd yes he was born and in the US, not an immigrant. He was installing tech stuff in home for the weathly, just the boss took all the mega bucks and paid him a pittance. We found this out more after he passed away.
Replay Crew!! Thanks as always Peter for breaking it down. It dropped by $48M, nothing that I think the Kowalskis will be concerned about at all. Hope JHACH “gets it” and soon.
I think JHACH should have to pay whatever the jury assigns except when a specific law limits prohibits it.
What your show is now is great. It is far more interesting and educational. I recommend everyone watch at least a few trials with you to learn how the court works.
Peter, you again did an exemplary job of breaking it down. You are one in a million! Hats off to your Mom and Dad, all the very best to you, your wife, and children! ❤
Net woman you truly are the fairy godmother of the Lawyer You Know (I forget if it was Peter who directly said this or if it was from a SuperChat he read some time ago). The amount of people you constantly give memberships to is amazing, i received one from you a long time ago and have continued my membership since. Thanks you
I ❤ your comment! So Gracious & Kind 😊
I think that the court cutting the judgement for Maya is wrong.
The judgment was $261 million total originally.
Maya and her family accomplished what they set out to do. Makemthis an international "show" and succeeded in punishing a very bad actor who has gotten away with doing these things to others, but this time they did not. I expect they will not reject any adjustments to their money award because they have received more than they probably will ever need. The point was to hit these bad actors so hard that they would have to think about ever doing it again to anyone else and to showmthe worldmwhat they did. It is absolutely amazing that their so-called diagnostics and treatments were not recorded on Maya's medical records. Butmwe all know why they weren't - because then these mistreatments would be even easier to prove. JAHACH should be happy that nobody was punished criminally. But they still can not admit they were wrong, which is highly bothersome. So the only other recourse is to make it too expensive to do this.
already watched Runkle break it down but I'm here for your takes too! 💗
❤ Runkle, EDB, and Peter
Greg said they are at 212 mil. He wasn't thrilled, but wasn't upset either. They want to get the judgement entered asap.
I’m angry that the judge reduced the awards! What is the point of having a jury if the judge can turn around and reduce the amount to whatever he/she feels!
I agree 100%! I didn’t even know this was possible. Sounds shady
Because the award was totally ridiculous. Photos of her prior to and during the trial partying it up while looking so so sad in front of the jury. She is lucky I wasn't on that jury. Her mother was crazy. She's lucky if I would have agreed to a $1M award.
@@joanalexander1942you would have been struck for cause calling beata crazy in void dire anyway. So bye bye
@@joanalexander1942 I don’t want to undermine what Maya went through; however, I must admit I have thought the same thing. She looked pretty healthy to me at the trial?? 🤷♀️ So it makes me wonder but she did lose her mother regardless if she was crazy or not. So I think she deserves something for that. But not 263 million that’s for sure 👍
@@joanalexander1942So she can’t have a good time, ever? She has to always be sad and down? What a ridiculous thing to say. I would imagine going through a trial, that one would need to go out and have fun. They’re stressful.
But your disparaging remarks against her deceased mother are disgusting and shines a light on you. So I’ll weigh you opinions accordingly.
Thank you! Yes keep covering Maya case until the end please. Your explanations on what's going on are brilliant
Thanks, Peter. You're never boring. And "nice" to watch. You also have high integrity and are very fair with what you say and present. You're extremely compassionate, empathetic, and very ethical. The fact that you dont like to see people suffer event if they did something to affect it means you're a cut above most. Are you sure you're a lawyer? Just joking! LOL! You and Emily demonstrate that lawyer stereotypes aren't always true. Sorry, my comments are long-winded. I have that problem with writing too much.
Why have juries decide amounts when the judge can just change it on a whim?
It's not changing it on a whim. Some of the amounts were larger than the statutory maximums.
You allow the jury to decide because a judge is one person that can be bias or can be bought. Multiple jurors is harder to get at.
Let the jurors make their amount determinations and then lower any to the maximums instead of having to teach the jurors about all the different statutory maximums.
@@specialsause949 , then why allow the jury to exceed them from the beginning?
@@robkinney1974because it can affect the way they determine the amount. If they know in the beginning that the maximum for punitive damage is $1M, then they may simply default to that whereas they wouldn’t necessarily go that high.
It is not on whim, the judge clearly spelled out his logic.
@bronxgurl6293 , he explained the medical bills. That is why at the end, he leaves room for Maya's team to file an appeal on the amounts.
Ty for covering this! I love watching your channel even if I'm on the replay crew!
Greg gave an interview on RSDSA.
Great information. Thank you
Please cover Treehouse trial! Over 5k watching now. This case is wild! Ty
I don't think they should be allowed to reduce. Especially when it was not an extreme amount jury awarded
As always, I love the information and how you break things down. Best and honest advice.
And what a wonderful community this is. Great people. Thank you everyone.
Thank you. You have brought content to us that is not only interesting, but also educational to all of us who are in the jury pool.
Whats the point of having a jury if the judge is just going to change restitution to what they think?
What’s the point of having judges if jury verdicts are beyond reproach? This is nothing new, just a lot of arm chair experts who just started watching this guy and have no knowledge of anything other than his videos.
@@qwerty112311 LOL you must be a real pro if you been watching Peter longer! Arm chair expert? I was just asking a question.. Of how being judged by a jury of your peers gets overturned by a judge, i thought the whole point was judge gives guidelines, jury decides on verdict. Sorry for my "arm chair expert" question
Thanks Peter for your thorough and thoughtful analysis.
OMG I just saw that "Innocence Project" is taking up Scott Peterson's case!!! What the heck?
Thank you for all you do! And all the videos! And lives!!! Your just amazing and this is just by far my fav you tube channel for this type of content! And your wife and kids are also amazing to share your time with all of us!!!
You make my day. Thanks again
Absolutely the best channel. Always interesting!!
Caught a live! Yay!
Why have a jury if the judge can just change the award?
Extremely helpful explanation. Greetings from England.
So much going on all of sudden. I've been rivoted to the Treehouse trial but R A covered all this Tuesday
Hopefully all this with Maya/Jhach will be tied up in a nice judgement now by next month
Right?! I thought it was me but there really is just A LOT of big things happening in BIG cases. Kolberger has his whole thing happening also. Watching that one next. I still have to catch up on Daybell too 👀
How do tie treehouse case ? I’ve seen headlines but I haven’t looked in to it. I don’t know anything about it
A defendant acting as his own lawyer in a murder case that happened in the keys. Unlike Darryl Brooks he has done an ok job although sometimes annoying. The prosiding judge is the issue
Rewatch crew! Thank you, Peter.
Team replay but will always show up 💜
Chronic Reginal pain syndrome, I have it due to an automobile accident and multiple injuries some people call it Fibromyalgia.
That pain discription including the nickname "suizide-syndrom" is already "Chronicle Clusterheadache", ICD44.2, or better call it "Bing-Horton-Syndrom" as it is in many cases not limited to the head area at all, as in mine 😢
Thanks Peter love all your content never find your channel boring very interesting.❤
We have learned so much during this trial. And still learning thank you, Peter I’m not sure how I feel about this I feel like they should’ve gotten all the money. I do understand some of the cuts, but I feel like for the most part they should’ve went with what the jury awarded I think it was fair and reasonable.
Although part of wishes the amount awarded had not been decreased it seems to me that it just makes it more likely to stand up to appeal. Still the total is over 200 million which I would hope the heads of John's Hopkins would take notice that they need to fix things in their house.
In the long term this isn't helpful to JHACH they didn't lose enough to help
As long as JHACH pays up that will be wonderful. But I think it will take years to get a penny
If im not mistaken, i ubderstand thar once judgement is entered, the clock to calculate interest, on the modified judgement (per this remititure) of $213M (approx) , begins ticking.. and tocking. Hopefully interest payments are due on a prescribed schedule so that plaintiff's fees can be partially paid ... and that medical and psych treatments for this lovely family can resume.
Definitely still interested and very much appreciate your analysis and commentary
Peter, a question came up for me while listening to your reading of Judge Carroll's rulings. The way this ruling is written it sounds like it was written with a specific audience in mind that would be reading it in the future. Is that audience that he is writing it for the Appellate Court? Also, thanks for the insightful coverage! I find solid legal analysis on cases like this absolutely fascinating.
I think you’re right about the appellate part. A lot of other lawtubers are saying judge Carroll is aiming for an appellate/supreme court job. Also i think part of him is writing to Reddit explaining how stupid they are 😂
I've been on a hiatus due to a move to my home town, new job, etc., etc. I'm so far behind on everything. New trial??? Watching now and catching up as soon as I can. Miss your posts.
Rewatch crew. Thanks for all of this content, Peter! Make sure you don’t burn yourself out between work and UA-cam! ❤
Not happy w/ any reductions on monetary awards. Seems to be a waste of jurors time!!
It helps to appeal proof the case.
I agree! Especially after the behavior of JHACH
💯%! 🫶🏽
It’s worth losing say 30 million if it “buys” the appellate court telling JHACH to F off.
Fancy Peter! Thanks for breaking down the updates
Fancy Peter 😻
Love this type of c9ntent & discussions. This is how we learn all three sides. Love these deep dives. Listen daily, rarely contribute - this took me back to my first view was the Depp trial and been here ever since. Great job today. Thanks. ❤
Replay crew here, just want to thank you, great info ❤
Absolutely important to have these follow ups. I know I’ve learned much more from your channel than any other and it’s because of the details!
Very impressed with this judge.👨⚖️
Peter i think we need you as a factual attorney! Thank you!
If you ask someone, like a jury in this case, to make a decision, you should accept it. They should get every cent the jury awarded. JHACH is proving over and over again that the judgement was to low.
Greg Anderson mentioned something about they could get more money backwards to he thinks the date of the jury verdict included with when the clock starts? I don’t know what it’s called. Have you heard of that.
I think what you’re thinking of was the question of when the interest will start.
Hiya! Why wouldn't the judge be removed? Isn't this a legal problem if it turns out the lawyers are reinstated?
This old lady waited on you Peter lol
i too have a lower extremities disability that ive been in pain for years , they refuse any pain meds but ate prescribing cholesterol and bloid pressure meds for wish i had a lawyer even now , i did have a child ..
I feel that this isn't a huge reduction from what the jury requested. So if the Kowalski's fight these new numbers, it will make it seem like they were all about the money. I truly hope they do not.
Wow… looks like one of the defence team members made a new account.
I agree I thought the exact same thing!
They aren't going to argue the reductions.
I agree. They will be fine with that figure.
@@88jeebsI agree
Foster parent: I was found guilty of child abuse but if you charge me, no one will ever want to be a foster parent.
Ummmm…. Okaaaay
Good point.
Darn I don’t know why I’m not getting notifications? Rewatch crew. Sorry I missed it 😢
Check your notifications- I had mine set to all but UA-cam changed it- I just changed it back 😞
This case hurts my❤
Yes, take it
Hi from the uk, can you please do a summary and advise where we will be going next on the lyndsey Clancy case ❤
Didn't know if I'd have the time to listen to the whole thing, did anyhow and got a much cleaner kitchen at 11pm lolll! Always interesting and engaging as usual :)
I love how they just repeat the cycle of retaliation over and over again
I think the Judge is be being very fair.
They're going to pay over time IMHO. If JHACH and JHU keeps going, all the leaders should be fired. Finish it for goodness sake. They all need to move on.
What is the interest on appeal? Thank you
I haven’t been following Delphi. Is there a place I can go to get a synopsis?
Try grizzly true crime. She’s great
i’m really curious what the jurors think about this.
JHACH's attitude is terrifying. They can't even manage the "mistakes were made" bs. They're delusional.
I've been bouncing from case to case today, what a day
Dapper in a suit!! ❤ But seriously, always love your take on cases, trials etc! You all have developed your channel quite a bit since I first watched you during the Amber Heard/ Johnny Depp trial.
Interesting, what is the amount after taxes?
while i understand what you are saying Peter and yes the jury made its call. I do not think it was the right call. there was another trial with the same drug given by an EMT at a lower dose and the guy died and they wanted to try the EMT for murder. This drug is not FDA approved the hospital had on obligation to admistor it! im sorry her mom passed but that is on her mom not the hospital. This was a way to get money and they got it. She needs to go crawl under a rock and think about what they did.
I agree with everything, except Ketamine is FDA approved.
The difference here is Maya was monitored as you are supposed to be the case with EMT wasn’t. They gave him the drug without even an examination before or after, and the guy had vomited in the mask, which he aspirated. Breathed back into his lungs. That case was just awful and so so sad
Do you think maya or her family will ever see any money or will the appeals go on for years?
It’s all up to JHACH and their attorneys, but the way they have behaved thus far, my guess is that it will be years before the Kowalskis receive any money.
Man, I missed the live 😏
$213 million is still a good verdict for Maya.
Something is wrong with our hospital, theres also this case when Providence Milwaukie hospital in Oregon that kick an dying addict from their ER by calling the cops and put him to jail, it gets so bad the cop aruge with the hospital and refuse to take him and transport him to another hospital, unfortunately he died before the new hospital can treat him..
Does Hospital in the US have any standard of care anymore? Kind of scare to go to a hospital now
WOW there is a lot going on.
No way. The judge was wrong. He should have gone with the decision of the jury considering what Maya and her family went through. There should be no amount too high for the loss of the mother.
Exactly. If he was going to change amount he should have put a ceiling on it.
I wish I had followed my path as paralegal! Law is incredibly interesting and fun to talk about.
No I will call them out on anything I know is wrong