Recording Info: Pinion 0:00 Wish 3:33 Last 7:18 Help Me I Am In Hell 12:10 Happiness In Slavery 15:03 Gave Up 20:04 Physical (You’re So) 25:17 Suck (Extended) 29:57 Pinion Video & Audio: Mudstock ‘94 Wish Video: Beside You In Time & And All That Could Have Been Audio: And All That Could Have Been Last Video & Audio: Holmdel, NJ 6.06.09 Help Me I Am In Hell Video: With Teeth Summer Tour Footage & Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2014 Audio: With Teeth Summer Tour Footage & November 24, 2018 - New Orleans, LA Happiness In Slavery Video & Audio: November 24, 2018 - New Orleans, LA (Video compiled by Videotape for their CBI Tour video, which is frankly incredible) www.youtube.com/watch?v=wg2v5... Gave Up Video: Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2014, Another Version Of The Truth, Panorama Festival 2017 Audio: And All That Could Have Been, Another Version of The Truth, Panorama Festival 2017 Physical (You’re So) Video: Atlanta Wave Goodbye DVD 2009 Audio: 2018-12-11 Los Angeles, Hollywood Palladium Suck Video: October 29, 2005, New Orleans, LA, Voodoo Festival & July 11, 1990, Washington, DC, 9:30 Club Audio: July 08, 2000, Wiesen, Austria, Forestglade Festival & 1992 Radio Session Performance
@@laz001 not all of them, I'm afraid, but there are enough Fragile-Era songs that weren't on the album (such as Metal, The Perfect Drug, etc) that I can fill in the blanks and make up for it
Surprised you didn't make us watch 360 seconds of nothingness/silence before "Physical" and "Suck". However, this is an awesome tribute to an amazing record.
Well shit, guess I'm doing one of these for The Fragile! (I say like I hadn't already started anyway 😉) I'll take a lot more time on that. This video was done in a week, just for fun and to see if you guys wanted more. I've already put in a week of work for The Fragile, hope to have it out by August. Currently sifting through 17 different recordings of 'The Way Out Is Through' to see which one is the best audio-wise, and which has the best performance
This actually took 3 different attempts. First attempt I was an idiot. I ripped the video for Wish directly from my DVDs but there was a tiny scratch so the audio was funky. My dumbass thought "no worries, I also have the live CD! I can sync that with the video!" Little did I know that the DVD audio was different from the CD. The end result sounded echo-y and disjointed and terrible. Second pass happened because i realized that the 2 audio sources I'd tried to sync for HMIAIH were off by milliseconds, and while the effect that created sounded really cool on my speakers, listening in headphones was awful. Small stuff, but they ended up being very time-consuming. But hey, what better way to spend quarantine?
Ok - watching this, and you have done an EXCELLENT job! Thank you! Gotta love the NIN community, are any other fans so active in creating this sort of stuff?
I know that there are more, but these are prime examples right now that I draw from Of course, the NIN archive: ua-cam.com/users/RITCNIN ThisOneIsOnUs: ua-cam.com/users/ThisOneIsOnUs And Videotape. They only have one NIN concert thing up, unless you count the post about Fragility backing videos, but it's so amazing Trent himself put it in the NIN newsletter ua-cam.com/channels/tc7np5w4xxGe1ERljWBumQ.html
That distortion on his mic in Suck was great. He should consider using it more often. Maybe a little less here and there cuz it hides the age in his voice well.
Oof. Just now realizing that the drums in HMIAIH don't line up with the audio 😳🤣 that's what I get for using 4 sources and being distracted by pretty lights
@Matt Dunphy yeah, Wish was really weird. Everything else with the exception of I think Happiness, I'd ripped directly from CDs or source NIN archive files. But my AATCHB DVD had a slight scratch that made for random volume changes during Wish so I kept the video and pirated in the audio 😂 it works but is still a bit off
Must be a little strange to be a Superstar since your first record release. Trents been a household name like 30 yrs. crazy. Seems like yesterday he was on Rolling Stone Cover and the story was like whose this mad,destructive musical genius recording and living at The Manson Massacre Home”
Don't you doubt me. That was a PHM tour track originally, that always leads into Terrible Lie every single time it is played, so obviously.... ua-cam.com/video/Dad3C4WGHPA/v-deo.html
I get what you're going for but I really find the notion of using audio that's synced up disparate video sources jarring. Trent in 2000 doesn't sound like Trent in 2008. The post chorus 1 synth riff in Gave Up played by Charlie Clouser plays when you have Alessandro on screen and they don't play or sound anything alike. You're using footage of Physical from 2009 but with audio from 2018 with completely different band members and setup. It's really just feels like a disservice to every musician's performances to mask them with completely different video sources.
I get what you're saying, but the thing is the best performances were often older and didn't have any footage (or the footage that existed was terrible quality, where you can barely make anything out; similarly, to take your Physical example, there are no professional sources for that song besides 2018, and the lineup for 2009 was almost identical to the CBI tour). My goal is sonic and aesthetic pleasure. So while I do think I should make a second pass at this, but the most important thing is for the drums and trent's lips to sync up. The point of this is to sound the best, and look as good as it can, and honestly 95% of fans aren't as hardcore as you. It's a sad truth, but most don't know one lineup from the others. And it's the majority that I want to please with this series.
As for the Gave Up part, that *was* Alessandro playing it.... and Clouser. Doubled up to give it a more eerie feel. But the bulk of that performance was the 2008 AVOTT one, with some bits from 2000 and 2017 mixed in to try and elevate the sound
I am using this to get back at my neighbor upstairs who is listening to his music too loud. Damn it, it's not working and I don't really want to have to turn it up any louder because I can barely stand listening to NIN now that I'm not a depressed 90's teenager!
Recording Info:
Pinion 0:00
Wish 3:33
Last 7:18
Help Me I Am In Hell 12:10
Happiness In Slavery 15:03
Gave Up 20:04
Physical (You’re So) 25:17
Suck (Extended) 29:57
Pinion
Video & Audio: Mudstock ‘94
Wish
Video: Beside You In Time & And All That Could Have Been
Audio: And All That Could Have Been
Last
Video & Audio: Holmdel, NJ 6.06.09
Help Me I Am In Hell
Video: With Teeth Summer Tour Footage & Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2014
Audio: With Teeth Summer Tour Footage & November 24, 2018 - New Orleans, LA
Happiness In Slavery
Video & Audio: November 24, 2018 - New Orleans, LA (Video compiled by
Videotape for their CBI Tour video, which is frankly incredible)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wg2v5...
Gave Up
Video: Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2014, Another Version Of The Truth, Panorama Festival 2017
Audio: And All That Could Have Been, Another Version of The Truth, Panorama Festival 2017
Physical (You’re So)
Video: Atlanta Wave Goodbye DVD 2009
Audio: 2018-12-11 Los Angeles, Hollywood Palladium
Suck
Video: October 29, 2005, New Orleans, LA, Voodoo Festival & July 11, 1990, Washington, DC, 9:30 Club
Audio: July 08, 2000, Wiesen, Austria, Forestglade Festival & 1992 Radio Session Performance
If you guys like this when it airs let me know. I'm planning to do The Fragile next if this is successful
Is it possible? Are all the fragile tracks done live?
@@laz001 not all of them, I'm afraid, but there are enough Fragile-Era songs that weren't on the album (such as Metal, The Perfect Drug, etc) that I can fill in the blanks and make up for it
Surprised you didn't make us watch 360 seconds of nothingness/silence before "Physical" and "Suck". However, this is an awesome tribute to an amazing record.
Well shit, guess I'm doing one of these for The Fragile! (I say like I hadn't already started anyway 😉) I'll take a lot more time on that. This video was done in a week, just for fun and to see if you guys wanted more. I've already put in a week of work for The Fragile, hope to have it out by August. Currently sifting through 17 different recordings of 'The Way Out Is Through' to see which one is the best audio-wise, and which has the best performance
"Last" is such a good song!!!!
This actually took 3 different attempts. First attempt I was an idiot. I ripped the video for Wish directly from my DVDs but there was a tiny scratch so the audio was funky. My dumbass thought "no worries, I also have the live CD! I can sync that with the video!" Little did I know that the DVD audio was different from the CD. The end result sounded echo-y and disjointed and terrible.
Second pass happened because i realized that the 2 audio sources I'd tried to sync for HMIAIH were off by milliseconds, and while the effect that created sounded really cool on my speakers, listening in headphones was awful.
Small stuff, but they ended up being very time-consuming. But hey, what better way to spend quarantine?
Best year. Best line up. My opinion. Band was like a well oiled machine. Just flawless
This version of Last. Damn it’s so good. Lol
The way he sings it is cool
Just going to pre-thumbs-up this.
Update: I was right, this rules.
@@GuntherSchmidl i did half way into pinon
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!
i guess i was excited
Awesome
come come come on you got a fix me up
I needed that...thank you!
So damn good! Great work.
Been loving all your uploads! Thank you much!
Great work
Ok - watching this, and you have done an EXCELLENT job! Thank you!
Gotta love the NIN community, are any other fans so active in creating this sort of stuff?
I know that there are more, but these are prime examples right now that I draw from
Of course, the NIN archive: ua-cam.com/users/RITCNIN
ThisOneIsOnUs: ua-cam.com/users/ThisOneIsOnUs
And Videotape. They only have one NIN concert thing up, unless you count the post about Fragility backing videos, but it's so amazing Trent himself put it in the NIN newsletter
ua-cam.com/channels/tc7np5w4xxGe1ERljWBumQ.html
That distortion on his mic in Suck was great. He should consider using it more often. Maybe a little less here and there cuz it hides the age in his voice well.
Fair play , awesome
Thoroughly enjoyed this.
Awesome. 🖤
Oof. Just now realizing that the drums in HMIAIH don't line up with the audio 😳🤣 that's what I get for using 4 sources and being distracted by pretty lights
@Matt Dunphy yeah, Wish was really weird. Everything else with the exception of I think Happiness, I'd ripped directly from CDs or source NIN archive files. But my AATCHB DVD had a slight scratch that made for random volume changes during Wish so I kept the video and pirated in the audio 😂 it works but is still a bit off
:)
Must be a little strange to be a Superstar since your first record release. Trents been a household name like 30 yrs. crazy. Seems like yesterday he was on Rolling Stone Cover and the story was like whose this mad,destructive musical genius recording and living at The Manson Massacre Home”
Is Chris Vrenna playing drums at this live performance?
Who missed the drop-kick at 4:45?
the hell was that? lol
you could of added now im nothing.....just saying
Don't you doubt me. That was a PHM tour track originally, that always leads into Terrible Lie every single time it is played, so obviously....
ua-cam.com/video/Dad3C4WGHPA/v-deo.html
man no one is ever just happy being able to hear and see this , always want more
I get what you're going for but I really find the notion of using audio that's synced up disparate video sources jarring. Trent in 2000 doesn't sound like Trent in 2008. The post chorus 1 synth riff in Gave Up played by Charlie Clouser plays when you have Alessandro on screen and they don't play or sound anything alike. You're using footage of Physical from 2009 but with audio from 2018 with completely different band members and setup. It's really just feels like a disservice to every musician's performances to mask them with completely different video sources.
I get what you're saying, but the thing is the best performances were often older and didn't have any footage (or the footage that existed was terrible quality, where you can barely make anything out; similarly, to take your Physical example, there are no professional sources for that song besides 2018, and the lineup for 2009 was almost identical to the CBI tour).
My goal is sonic and aesthetic pleasure. So while I do think I should make a second pass at this, but the most important thing is for the drums and trent's lips to sync up. The point of this is to sound the best, and look as good as it can, and honestly 95% of fans aren't as hardcore as you. It's a sad truth, but most don't know one lineup from the others. And it's the majority that I want to please with this series.
As for the Gave Up part, that *was* Alessandro playing it.... and Clouser. Doubled up to give it a more eerie feel. But the bulk of that performance was the 2008 AVOTT one, with some bits from 2000 and 2017 mixed in to try and elevate the sound
I am using this to get back at my neighbor upstairs who is listening to his music too loud. Damn it, it's not working and I don't really want to have to turn it up any louder because I can barely stand listening to NIN now that I'm not a depressed 90's teenager!