Which Do I Buy? Speedmaster v.s. Navitimer

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 чер 2024
  • There can be only one! Who comes out on top?

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @DirectorsGarage
    @DirectorsGarage 23 дні тому +1

    Navitimer for me. It was THE watch everyone wanted in the 90s. Probably because of its bling. When it came to buy one, I opted for the 2018 because they brushed the sides and the alternate bracelet links on the modern Navi, and to me, the Navi has always been about big polished chrome. I've never been drawn to the Speedy for some reason. Maybe it's the bezel. If I were going for an Omega, I'd probably opt for the Bond Seamaster-- which should have also gone to the moon in "Moonraker," but unfortunately Roger Moore opted to wear a Seiko in that movie!

  • @WatchMalaya
    @WatchMalaya 4 місяці тому +5

    This is a great video. I own a Speedy and have been looking at the Navitimer for quite some time. I look forward to adding it into my collection soon. Thanks!

  • @WatchesCanBeFun
    @WatchesCanBeFun 4 місяці тому +1

    I like your take on first impressions, we’re told so much on what’s good and bad, but we make better decisions when we trust our own impressions

  • @ChenZachary
    @ChenZachary 3 місяці тому

    Your strap combination is so perfect. I just realized how beautiful they can be on those straps. Now both navi and speedy is on the top of my list

    • @HarrisonElmore
      @HarrisonElmore  3 місяці тому

      hahaha well I suppose that's a good thing! They're awesome for sure.

  • @TheBlacktsoi
    @TheBlacktsoi 12 днів тому +1

    your navi. strap and clasp so cool. Where can buy? any link?

  • @SamuraiJackson
    @SamuraiJackson 4 місяці тому +4

    Very thought-provoking discussion, Harrison. Two points to add:
    1) RE: Your footnote on the B01 being an arguable tie. The B01 has a movement architecture that blows the Speedmaster movement out of the water. The B01 was designed by the same engineer who designed the Rolex Daytona (post Zenith) movement, in fact- the B01 is an IMPROVEMENT over the Daytona movement because the B01 has a modular design where the watchmaker can take out just the chronograph component, or just the automatic winding component, etc. The modular design is also why they were able to take it a step further with the B04 movement (World Time/Traveler GMT addition). The B04 gives you all the functionality of a GMT Master 2 AND a Daytona, with the same quality of movement engineering. (The B04 is truly the ultimate IYKYK movement.) Point being, the B01 doesn't "tie" the Speedmaster's movement; it's on a completely different level. The B01 architecture gives you so much more capability whereas the Speedmaster doesn't even have a date complication.
    2) There really should have been a bezel functionality comparison (you can already see where this is going) given the thoroughness of the other categories. When traveling internationally for business or vacation- set the slide rule to the USD-local currency conversion rate, and it becomes a feature you reference all the time to eliminate the guesswork when you're reading a menu and trying to stay within your per diem. If you care enough to wear a nice watch in this day & age, then that savoir faire you get from knowing the precise currency conversion without pulling out a phone is the type of moment that matters to us watch nerds. That's just one of many examples of how the slide rule can be a game changing feature, compared to- let's be honest, when is the last time anyone used a tachymeter?

  • @rgv_edc8675
    @rgv_edc8675 4 місяці тому

    Awesome video! As just an observer of each of those watches, feel like this was scored fairly. Looking forward to the Speedy videos coming up as I'm leaning towards picking up a Moonwatch this year.
    There are plenty of Speedy vids out, but it's great to hear and see something recent, and current, especially with your perspective and knowledge. Love the content!

    • @HarrisonElmore
      @HarrisonElmore  4 місяці тому +1

      Appreciate it! Glad I could help! Best of luck with the decision!

  • @robertp5123
    @robertp5123 4 місяці тому +1

    Thank you for the analysis. Omega Speedy is definitely for me.

  • @TheMaerki
    @TheMaerki 4 місяці тому

    Your video inspired me to buy a military green strap for my navitime. it looks cool

  • @kristofferglennpfalmer4751
    @kristofferglennpfalmer4751 4 місяці тому +1

    I have a Pelagos 39 and recently got “the call” the Explorer 40. To complete my core collection the speedy is next. Any other watch after that will be in a novelty status - to include the Navitimer which is of interest to me.

  • @JasonJohnson-bc4jy
    @JasonJohnson-bc4jy 4 місяці тому

    Looking forward to the Speedmaster comparisons.

  • @marcelinocastillo2871
    @marcelinocastillo2871 Місяць тому

    I have an Omega Speedmaster Apollo XV 40th anniversary and also a Breitling Navitimer GMT world 46 mm. They are two of the most iconic watches you can get, but also they are so different…definitely you need both in your collection!

  • @zachg9065
    @zachg9065 4 місяці тому

    I have a 40mm Speedmaster racing and I love it

  • @kevinmccalister8197
    @kevinmccalister8197 4 місяці тому +1

    I am waiting for the call from my AD for the newest Zenith El Primero Original black dial. Cant wait.

  • @PyroClit
    @PyroClit 4 місяці тому +7

    Recently got the Speedy , like 3 hours ago, I love it!!!

    • @TheCrystalLakeKiller
      @TheCrystalLakeKiller 4 місяці тому

      Congrats! Hesalite or Sapphire Sandwich?

    • @PyroClit
      @PyroClit 4 місяці тому +2

      @@TheCrystalLakeKiller The hesalite. The glow is just too good. The ring was bothering me the whole time i was tryng on the sapphire. I thought the backcase will bother me after purchasing the the hesalite, but doesnt bother me at all. havent even seen the backcase since buying. . It wont be a daily bcause of work issues. I am so glad i got the hesalite.

    • @TheCrystalLakeKiller
      @TheCrystalLakeKiller 4 місяці тому

      @@PyroClit Great choice! Would be my pick too👍🏻

  • @pheisenberg5198
    @pheisenberg5198 7 днів тому

    I think you alluded to the true answer, at least for me: you have to have both! I have a Speedy and I can't wait to add a Navitimer.

  • @Valera_Scotland
    @Valera_Scotland 4 місяці тому

    Loving my 1861 Speedy. I think it's a great option over the new one, and I actually prefer some of the dial design features, and the older style movement

  • @SIZZO76
    @SIZZO76 4 місяці тому

    Both are ICONIC WATCHES🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @SinnMaster
    @SinnMaster 4 місяці тому +1

    Omega adheres to METAS which is more stringent than ISO.

  • @SIZZO76
    @SIZZO76 4 місяці тому

    I love both🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @lirrfan3879
    @lirrfan3879 4 місяці тому

    I really really had a hard time deciding between the two….so I bought both! 😅 3861 SS and the latest B01 43mm. They are both so good.

  • @robynsjp
    @robynsjp 3 місяці тому

    Eric Wind once admitted regarding the Speedy that there are all those before 1968, and then all those after. I have a 1967 one, a 321. Also a 1969 one, a 861. And the 321 feels like one of the top 5 giants in watches. A very different league. Similar to the Rolex Submariner, the first wristwatch Breguet Reine de Naples and the first Seiko Astron. The 1928 original Longines Hour Angle or the 1940s Grana Dirty Dozen piece may be the nr 5.

  • @timjakubek8100
    @timjakubek8100 4 місяці тому +1

    What are those straps??

  • @chriselley2261
    @chriselley2261 7 днів тому

    My Speedy has been much more reliable than my Navi.
    Both are beautiful, but the Navi has required more service than any other watch I’ve ever owned - and I’ve got some watches.

  • @NintendoPlayBox360
    @NintendoPlayBox360 Місяць тому

    I have both a Speedy Pro and a 2012 blue Navitimer. I adore these watches. The two most legendary chronos in my book. The only thing I dont agree with you is about the daily wear for the Navi. I do daily mine and there are no drawbacks.

  • @radidoc4832
    @radidoc4832 4 місяці тому +2

    I was seriously looking at both, but really wanted better water resitance, vertical clutch and automatic. So got the Tudor Blackbay Panda Chrono. 👍

  • @borassictime918
    @borassictime918 4 місяці тому

    I have no strong feelings for either per se (I’m no fanboi for any brand), but I really want a date window (we’re all different), which means the Speedy is just not for, even on a Tuesday. Then again the Navi’s date window on the tilt at 4.30 is just wrong; if they must put it there (not my fav) have it level (Seiko can manage that, so why not Breitling?). So, I couldn’t bring myself to buy either, even if I had the SRP money 🤕 😂

  • @BN-jk6of
    @BN-jk6of 4 місяці тому +1

    Column wheel > Everything else. Also the Speedmaster worn on the moon was a .321cal which was a column wheel chrono. Current Speedy is downgraded IMO

  • @michaeledwardlenzi
    @michaeledwardlenzi 4 місяці тому

    I would like to own both but have a Speedy now. I can't justify the Navi purchase to myself tho. Maybe the Navi prices will come down? Probably not.

  • @PabloTBrave
    @PabloTBrave 4 місяці тому

    I'd go for a Sinn 903 an improved and legal ( non homage ) navitimer. The 30 m water resistance is a killer, having said that my mate did inherit a vintage pre WR navitimer from his dad amd it's very nice on the odd time hes not scared to wear it. To even the review out a different mate has a speedmaster and my partners dad has a Moonwatch ( modern one) which are also v nice . Aoart feom my nomos my watches are all 200 or 500m WR. As a daily i wouldn't trust myself with anything less than 100m WR.

  • @ShaunChee1998
    @ShaunChee1998 2 місяці тому

    Up the Water Resistant of the Navitimer and it’ll be one of my grail watch

  • @waxy954
    @waxy954 3 місяці тому

    I own both….and for me it is Speedy all the way. The Navitimer is great, but the Speedmaster is so iconic, so cool, so wearable. It is my absolute favourite

  • @paultansey3461
    @paultansey3461 Місяць тому

    Got both 👍

  • @damonc05
    @damonc05 4 місяці тому

    What about Zenith El Primero Revival or Chronomaster line?

  • @jesseGfragrance
    @jesseGfragrance Місяць тому +2

    Yea I think the navitimer is much better

  • @patrickelrafih
    @patrickelrafih 4 місяці тому

    I personally think a speedster sapphire sandwich vs a breathing B09 40mm. would be a better video!

  • @Tnarg-the-clown
    @Tnarg-the-clown 4 місяці тому

    The age old question

  • @donaleeesio
    @donaleeesio 4 місяці тому +1

    I would never waste my money on a hoaxy "MOONWATCH".
    My B01 Navi is lightyears ahead of the charchoal faced Omega in every aspect😂

  • @simonwright6882
    @simonwright6882 4 місяці тому +1

    Both great watches but for the legibility reason alone it would always be the speedmaster.

  • @donniedarko4284
    @donniedarko4284 3 місяці тому

    The Brightling is not ISO rated!!! Only the Omega as part of the Master Chronometer certification… the Brightling that went to space got water egress when the capsule landed in the sea. That watch had 30 meters same as yours… FUN FACKTS and FOoD for thought 😅

  • @lrbrown
    @lrbrown 4 місяці тому

    Don’t make me choose! I’m in camp Speedy, but you can’t really miss either way.

  • @user-zb6el4ks2b
    @user-zb6el4ks2b 8 днів тому

    went into omega store and tried on omega seamaster 300 with metal and rubber straps
    , thought the rubber felt a bit cheap feeling , then went across to breitling store and tried on
    superocean , i like bigger watches as have a good size wrist and settled on the 46mm
    superocean , did not buy from there though £4500 , bought a 6 months old one as new
    from london as brand new and the first buyer purchased the 5 year warranty , bought
    the steel stap version and guess what the first buyer purchased from Breitling
    the rubber strap and deployment clasp as well , managed to purchase for £2800
    so should not loose from that price .
    i do regret selling for £1000 some yyears ago my
    Omega Speedmaster Broad Arrow 3875.20.37

  • @timhopman8120
    @timhopman8120 11 днів тому

    Speed master made a huge mistake with the swatch I’ll never look at them the same. Made them look cheap as hell not an automatic 😮. Breitling owns this without question!

  • @DDWGG1
    @DDWGG1 4 місяці тому

    Kudos to you for having both on straps. Bracelets are overrated!

  • @stevepapa
    @stevepapa 4 місяці тому +1

    WHOA! New set, intro, and graphics?! Nice! I'm taking the Speedmaster for the record!

  • @philiplauzon1743
    @philiplauzon1743 4 місяці тому

    Speedy, no contest for me

  • @geno816
    @geno816 3 місяці тому

    Haven't watched... but I would take the speedy

  • @maromorostar6621
    @maromorostar6621 Місяць тому

    You look similar to the UA-camr Cassidy Campbell if you know him 😆

  • @michaelriera6277
    @michaelriera6277 4 місяці тому +1

    Navi! Navitimer! Navi Nav Nav!!!!

  • @joewhite6875
    @joewhite6875 3 місяці тому +1

    Great vid, brother. As a watch nerd, it feels like blasphemy to say this but I’ve just never been able to get there with the speedy. It’s like I WANT to like the design bc I feel like I should. But I just don’t. 🤷‍♂️

    • @manueljnegrete5048
      @manueljnegrete5048 2 місяці тому +1

      I hear you and feel likewise. I have learned that any dial with printed numerals, etc just feels cheap to me.

    • @watchguy8360
      @watchguy8360 Місяць тому +1

      Felt the same until I tried it on. So nice. It’s classic iconic for a reason.

  • @jesseGfragrance
    @jesseGfragrance Місяць тому +1

    The navitimer is a watch we need to own, it’s got a lot going on , and it makes it really fun to look at ,and operate, they are all very beautiful watches, you need both, it’s good to have both , get the swatch then buy the navitimer 🌍🫰

  • @michaelriera6277
    @michaelriera6277 4 місяці тому +1

    Love the Navi. So special looking. Go for the Navitimer!

  • @user-lv8gz9cu5w
    @user-lv8gz9cu5w 4 місяці тому

    Speedmaster

  • @tab3Gator
    @tab3Gator 4 місяці тому

    Vertical clutch, automatic, column wheel…so why is the Omega movement better?

  • @Andrew-yy2ye
    @Andrew-yy2ye 3 місяці тому

    You can't see heritage or feel it on your wrist

  • @adrianpetreanu9942
    @adrianpetreanu9942 22 дні тому

    the argument that a watch was on the moon... its so ridiculous... riiiight... nevertheless i preferare each day of the year the navitimer.

  • @luisbecerra8128
    @luisbecerra8128 4 місяці тому

    Navitimer all day long.

  • @Rodolfoguerra12
    @Rodolfoguerra12 4 місяці тому

    Speedy is 50m WR

  • @swampThaang
    @swampThaang 4 місяці тому

    If you have 3 or less watches speedy… otherwise Navi

  • @Harisampath
    @Harisampath 4 місяці тому +4

    I agree with you, I'm gonna have to choose the speedy, it's a timeless classic and much better looking than the navitimer. The navitimer dial looks too busy

    • @WatchesCanBeFun
      @WatchesCanBeFun 4 місяці тому +5

      I was getting on a flight and the pilot greeted us. He was wearing a Navitimer and it looked immaculate on his wrist. I think the navitimer looks cooler

  • @ViolinistWilliam
    @ViolinistWilliam 4 місяці тому +14

    My opinion: the Navitimer. The Nav is a status symbol, the Speedmaster is for nerds. I am a nerd.

    • @bertholdbach4959
      @bertholdbach4959 4 місяці тому +5

      Why is the Navitimer a statussymbol? How is the Speedmaster for nerds?

    • @joelyoung5222
      @joelyoung5222 4 місяці тому +3

      The slide rule computer isn’t the watch for "nerds" out of the two? Crazy.

    • @ozmondos
      @ozmondos 4 місяці тому

      Navitimer is as much of a status symbol as the Speedmaster, because Omega is the more recognisable brand.

    • @waterfordrs22
      @waterfordrs22 4 місяці тому

      That makes zero sense. Breitling dropped off everyone’s radar until the last couple years. It does however have a slide rule, something most people won’t know how to use and depending on their eyesight, won’t be able to read. That said, slide rules are for nerds. Nerd pilots in this case.
      The Speedmaster isn’t all that much as status symbols go, it’s actually rather understated.

    • @dyslexicbien
      @dyslexicbien 4 місяці тому

      Why is the speedtimer for nerds? I dont get it. They are both a status symbol watch because they are both luxury watch imo

  • @wristroll_vlad
    @wristroll_vlad 4 місяці тому +2

    Navitimer over Speedmaster. Always!

  • @galhadad341
    @galhadad341 2 місяці тому

    Both great watches.
    Personally, I find the speedy moonwatch a bit boring, maybe some vintage with patina could be cool. The navitimer is great. I went with Zenith El Premiro and IWC little prince chronograph 😅

  • @mbell7498
    @mbell7498 4 місяці тому +1

    Difficult choice. I would simply say that the Navitimer is cooler, and the Speedmaster is more sober. I consider them both better than the Rolex Daytona and I'll stop there.

  • @overkillbliss6535
    @overkillbliss6535 4 місяці тому

    Just silly. Buy what you prefer, there is no "best" of anything. "Best" is a horribly subjective word and really should be eliminated from any evaluation. Such a word is in the same class as "soon" and "maybe".

  • @Valera_Scotland
    @Valera_Scotland 4 місяці тому

    Navitimer looks like costume jewellery. Sorry 😂.. love the Speedy

  • @gentlewolf
    @gentlewolf 3 місяці тому +1

    Neither. Buy a Hamilton for under $500 bucks and it will give you quality time and heritage for a long time to come.

    • @kresimirpleic
      @kresimirpleic Місяць тому

      A new Hamilton? Heritage? Authored by the Swatch group marketing team.

    • @eduardopereira5245
      @eduardopereira5245 Місяць тому

      Ahahahaha 😂😂😂😂 You wish!

  • @matthogg2252
    @matthogg2252 4 місяці тому

    Navitimer is whack