Jac Shaeffer, the creator of the show, confirmed in a recent interview that Billy is the 🖤 on the original coven list :) but of course Lilia couldn’t write his name because of the sigil. Rio was an amazing red herring, though. This show is so clever.
Nearly every reaction I have watched for Agatha All Along knew or guessed about Teen's identity pretty much from the jump (mainly from being familiar/aware of comics! Billy Kaplan I think) so it is a LOT of fun to hear all the other theories that come from someone who didn't know or guess.
Wait, did you not watch Wandavision at all?? I thought you did. I immediately recognized the dialogue from Wandavision and when he called out "Tommy" I knew he must be Billy. Edit: Tbf, I was already sure it was Billy in Ep.5, since he wore that blue headband and a red shirt, just like Billy's Halloween costume in Wandavision. Also his magic head dress looked just like Wanda's. Regarding Lilia's "absences", it never looked to me like she was posessed, more like she was seeing the future. She is, after all, a divination witch, and I interpreted that as seeing the future and then forgetting or choosing not to tell the others. Either way, it will be clear in Ep. 7. I'm really looking forward to your reaction to that one.
Yeah, I think a Wandavision viewing would have cleared up a lot of the confusions and incorrect theories. But I think there are a fair number of people who went into Agatha blind, which is understandable.
I watched (and loved) Wandavision, but I had to binge it for the first time like a week before I watched Agatha. So I remembered the boys but definitely not their names, and they were some of the last characters I thought would ever be relevant. 🤦🏼♀️
@Gaywatch Oh no, okay then that makes sense. I knew that both of Wanda's sons are superheroes in the comics (Young Avengers), so I was actually really hoping to see them again :)
@@Gaywatchchiming in to say this is completely understandable! If you go into either show with zero comic book or spoilery fan theory knowledge, it is 💯 possible to not pay close attention to the WandaVision kiddos. Why would you?
I love the end scene with Agatha and Billy. It’s the most honest either of them have been with each other up to this point. Agatha did miss Billy, she does want him to embrace being a witch/what makes him special (her eyes are literally glistening with tears during both moments). I also just enjoy that Agatha tells Billy that because she probably needed someone to say that to her when she was young. She wished someone would say that to her so she’s been telling herself that for centuries. God Kathryn’s range just in that final scene is crazy to me. She’s so freakin talented. Sincere to theatric to sinister. I love this woman, let her win all the awards. My biggest complaint about this episode though is I feel we could have cut down on Even Peters’ glorified cameo a bit. Nothing against Even but I feel like we could have summed up that scene a little quicker. I also think the joke with Billy’s side of the interrogation went on a bit long too? But that’s just personal preference most likely.
Is he Nicholas? Wow, what party are you at? Everybody knew who he was before the show started. Nicholas? I don't think I've ever laughed so hard in my life.
Why you gotta be so rude? Not evidence invests 10000% into some funkopop conspiracy and just watched the show as it came out. The show wants you to think it could be Nicholas so it’s ok to think that!
Agatha explained that the person who places the sigil is also bound by it. That’s why Lilia immediately forgets William after she creates it.
Jac Shaeffer, the creator of the show, confirmed in a recent interview that Billy is the 🖤 on the original coven list :) but of course Lilia couldn’t write his name because of the sigil. Rio was an amazing red herring, though. This show is so clever.
Nearly every reaction I have watched for Agatha All Along knew or guessed about Teen's identity pretty much from the jump (mainly from being familiar/aware of comics! Billy Kaplan I think) so it is a LOT of fun to hear all the other theories that come from someone who didn't know or guess.
I agree!
Can't wait for the mind blow next episode
Joe Locke trained in the same movements as Wanda!
Billy is the black heart on Lilia’s list, not Rio as confirmed by Jac Schaeffer.
Wait, did you not watch Wandavision at all?? I thought you did. I immediately recognized the dialogue from Wandavision and when he called out "Tommy" I knew he must be Billy.
Edit: Tbf, I was already sure it was Billy in Ep.5, since he wore that blue headband and a red shirt, just like Billy's Halloween costume in Wandavision. Also his magic head dress looked just like Wanda's.
Regarding Lilia's "absences", it never looked to me like she was posessed, more like she was seeing the future. She is, after all, a divination witch, and I interpreted that as seeing the future and then forgetting or choosing not to tell the others. Either way, it will be clear in Ep. 7. I'm really looking forward to your reaction to that one.
Yeah, I think a Wandavision viewing would have cleared up a lot of the confusions and incorrect theories. But I think there are a fair number of people who went into Agatha blind, which is understandable.
I watched (and loved) Wandavision, but I had to binge it for the first time like a week before I watched Agatha. So I remembered the boys but definitely not their names, and they were some of the last characters I thought would ever be relevant. 🤦🏼♀️
@Gaywatch Oh no, okay then that makes sense. I knew that both of Wanda's sons are superheroes in the comics (Young Avengers), so I was actually really hoping to see them again :)
@@Gaywatchchiming in to say this is completely understandable! If you go into either show with zero comic book or spoilery fan theory knowledge, it is 💯 possible to not pay close attention to the WandaVision kiddos. Why would you?
@@danbruins Not so much.
You're going to die in the next one. I love watching you discover all of this in real time!
I think my 2-year old nephew understood this better than this person.
I love the end scene with Agatha and Billy. It’s the most honest either of them have been with each other up to this point. Agatha did miss Billy, she does want him to embrace being a witch/what makes him special (her eyes are literally glistening with tears during both moments). I also just enjoy that Agatha tells Billy that because she probably needed someone to say that to her when she was young. She wished someone would say that to her so she’s been telling herself that for centuries.
God Kathryn’s range just in that final scene is crazy to me. She’s so freakin talented. Sincere to theatric to sinister. I love this woman, let her win all the awards.
My biggest complaint about this episode though is I feel we could have cut down on Even Peters’ glorified cameo a bit. Nothing against Even but I feel like we could have summed up that scene a little quicker. I also think the joke with Billy’s side of the interrogation went on a bit long too? But that’s just personal preference most likely.
Ah, the pieces are falling in place.
Is he Nicholas? Wow, what party are you at? Everybody knew who he was before the show started. Nicholas? I don't think I've ever laughed so hard in my life.
Why you gotta be so rude? Not evidence invests 10000% into some funkopop conspiracy and just watched the show as it came out. The show wants you to think it could be Nicholas so it’s ok to think that!