As a German atheist, I support Israel and the right of the Jewish people to have their own state on their historical soil. I am a Zionist! Although I love having Jewish life in my own country and can only take responsibility to ensure that the Shoah never happens again. Never again is now! Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱❤️🇩🇪🎗️
A whole video about zionism without a single mention of how theodore herzl opposed a jewish state if it meant stealing it from natives. An entire video about jewish self determination without asking the question "what about palestenian self determination?". I watched a few other videos on this channel and i was impressed with how educational and fair it was. This video is a decent into bias. What a shame. You couldve been a channel dissemenating important unbiased information to the masses. For the record i am not pro isreal nor pro palestine. Just an observer who recognizes that this problem cant be solved if people are fed biased one sided narratives.
@@UNPACKED i just watched this video you linked and it is god awful how one sided it. "they keep rejecting our proposals", they were never even invited to the negotiating table and had unfair deals pushed onto them, ofcourse theyd reject it. honeslty you guys are making the problem worse with the content your creating here. the people here on youtube need a source that can show both sides.
“They were never even invited to the negotiating table” - where do you get these ideas from? Do you know what happened at Oslo? At Camp David? You should learn some more history - you can start here: ua-cam.com/video/5SIAW4cX62I/v-deo.html and
@@UNPACKED i meant there were never invited to the 1947 UN resolution, they were never invited to the table when britain declared teh 1917 borders. And its funny you mention camp david because palestenians were not invited to the camp david accords, that one was mainly between egypt and isreal. funny that you lump palestenians and egyptions as the same people, all arabs must be the same to you huh? Oslo was one of the only times palestenians had a seat at the negotiating table and it is regarded as the closest we ever got to peace. The deal got signed. we were at the finish line, but then netanyahu sabotaged the deal by telling them they are going to steal the west bank after its they sign (which he openly admited to and there is video evidence of on youtube look it up). and then coincidentally the isreali leader who signed the deal gets assainated by a far right isreali extremist, hmm quite a coincidence considering netanyahu represents the far right aint it
Ah I see you’re not so educated so you never learned about Camp David in 2000 where Israelis and Palestinians were brought to the negotiating table by Bill Clinton. After Israeli PM Barak offered most of what the Palestinians wanted, Yasser Arafat just walked away without even responding 😬 You can learn more here: ua-cam.com/video/G7zG1ox91DY/v-deo.htmlsi=UmtzRDw-SO3nZtoD And why do you say Arabs (there were no Palestinians back then, so yes, back then all Arabs basically lumped themselves together) weren’t invited to 1947 negotiations? Did you know that the Arab states refused to collaborate with UNSCOP, which had extended an invitation for liaison also to the Arab Higher Committee. I do think you’re onto something about 1917 - and the Sykes-Pocot Agreement (is that what you’re referring to?) where nobody was consulted. But that’s also the way empires worked back then, and there was no Palestinians to speak of, nor many present-day Palestinians or Arabs there either. You can learn more about that here: ua-cam.com/video/MuSwp17e4fI/v-deo.html And wait- you think Netanyahu sabotaged Oslo? You should watch the video again: ua-cam.com/video/5SIAW4cX62I/v-deo.html He definitely benefited from it collapsing but that was mostly due to the sabotage and suicide bombings of Hamas. Thankfully, Hamas has now been basically eradicated :)
What I just find so hilarious about these types of explanations is how disconnected these sentiments are about the violent removal of the people who’ve been living there just as long just because they’re not Jewish. Horrific stories about the heart wrenching stories about the Jewish people are used to excuse the launching of an ethnostate that enforces apartheid.
Exactly, Palestinian have more Hebrew dna than the zionists flooding back to their homeland. Palestinian have jewish ancestry but are being persecuted because they accepted another religion. It's so messed up.
Are you a DNA expert? And does DNA make someone Jewish? ua-cam.com/video/O2AJdphzrFY/v-deo.html Also no one is being persecuted for being Palestinian or Muslim - they’re being ‘persecuted’ for being terrorists and trying to kill Jews 🤦♂️
@@UNPACKEDno bro your wrong, there are hundreds of thousands of innocent lives that have been killed and so much land that has been stripped from the Palestinian people. Even though the land has been theirs for centuries. Stop your propaganda and lies. We all see through the smokescreen. Resistance to apartheid will never be unjustified. It’s nothing new for people to push back against white supremacy and considering that majority of the people in Israel now trace their ancestry to white Europe i think it’s befitting to identify Zionism as such.
@UNPACKED Oh the irony, yet the Israeli colony was founded on terrorism. Palestinians are not resisting because of your Jewish faith or for simply being jews, they are resisting a colonial power which is ethinically cleansing them from their lands. They would resist anyone, even if it was another Muslim country. So please stop your propaganda. Palestinians and Lebanese (Cannanites) are actually the indegenious people to the land, and they were there long before the Isralites. Who are the Isralites? They are the progeny of Jacob (also called Israel). Israel is a person, not a geographical location! Jacob's father was Issac, Issacs father was Abraham, who was from the city of Ur (modern day Iraq). Abraham migrated with his wife and nephew to what is today occupied Palestine. He was accepted into the land by the Cannanite king Melchizedek (Hebrew 7:3). Now, coming back to jacob, his son Joseph was sold by his brothers to Egypt. Josepths progeny lived in Egypt for about 400 years before Moses took the people out of the land and to what is today occupied Palestine. The isralites made their kingdom; King David and King Solomon, but then the Babylonians destroyed the first temple and the Romans the second. So, if you look at history, the Israelites originate from Jacob, and his grandfather Abraham is from Ur(Iraq). The cannanites have always been on their land and they have more Hebrew/Jewish dna than most ashkenazi Jews. With the passage of time, many Jews converted to Christianity and then Islam. Why this this so hard to fathom.
I am an ex Muslim from Bangladesh. I believe the oppressed jews must have their own land, and that's their homeland. If that makes me a Zionist I am one. 🇮🇱❤❤
Do you recommend any resources for us to learn more about our Bengali friends and neighbors? Most are devoted muslims, and while its great to talk with them and learn directly from them about themselves, your perspective is extremely valuable.
Some of the statements from anti-zionists have been baffling to me, so I asked. I never got one clear answer, but it's basically the Protocols conspiracy theories of Global Control, of all other interests being "puppets" of Jews, etc etc, grafted on to the real part about the Judean people living in Jerusalem and Judea with self-determination and self-defense. B.S. nonsense about the Fed being privately owned* by a Jewish family. Mind control through the media. Cherry picking quotes and fake quotes from 5722 pages of Talmud arguments compiled over several centuries. All the stuff Candace talks about. * Nobody can own shares except Fed member banks, bank corporations like the one you use which are like licensed and regulated franchise operations, banks are required by Law to purchase shares and hold them indefinitely while their business is operational. No stock trader would even want to own Fed shares, because 100% of profits are returned directly to the US Treasury, instead of the IRS. Who would want to own shares in a corporation that can never earn net profits, by Law, because of the requirement to give all profits after expenses to the Treasury every 3 months? Ironically, some Jews in Israel are having ALL banking access blocked by America, so they can't pay their household bills or operate a business, because they participated in a peaceful protest in Israel, or because they defended their lives, who were never charged or convicted of any crime. These Jews were accused by some Leftists tied to America and Democrats of being insufficiently nice to Hamas or mean to Palestinians, accused of some action that impedes the "two State solution" dream of the Biden admin, this "peaceful solution" that Palestinians have REJECTED with VIOLENCE for more than 100 years, each time it was offered, including with Saudi diplomatic intervention.
In the past, Jews were Arabs, and there were no European Jews at that time. Christians and Muslims also belonged to the same Arab race, and those religions spread after the commercial interactions between different peoples. Even God, in all the holy books, was addressing Arabs. The original Arab Jews currently in Palestine oppose the occupation of their homeland, Palestine, by Europeans and the renaming of it to Israel. They believe, based on their religious texts, that the establishment of a Jewish state could be a sign of the inevitable end of the Jewish people
Did Israel take over Palestine? ua-cam.com/video/0BasXaiHiiI/v-deo.htmlsi=-CwE59SJQZUj9_x6 And that’s not a real Jewish belief you quote at the end 🤷♂️
God bless you. It's good to see a sane person among all these bloodthirsty raving lunatics. The bible has passages about people who thought violence was okay because they were hebrew. The idf will face justice on earth and in the afterlife.
@@PJGenovese251 I don't think anyone wants to spend their days being the light in the darkness. You Christians sure know how to take the most sinister ideas and twist them into something that sounds lofty & pure.
My great grandmother immigrated to the USA and never told her husband that she was Jewish. It wasn’t till the 1990’s I got my ancestry test done and found out I am a Christian who is also Jewish!
Many Jews gave up being Jewish because it was so much easier being like everyone else and avoiding discrimination, prejudice, and violence. Most Jews who left never wanted to be reminded. That is why it is so strange about the Jews for Jesus. Why spoil all the benefits of being like everyone else?
@@davidh4374 If you have a Jewish soul but can't prove it, convert to Judaism. There is a Jewish tradition that all Jewish souls were present at Mt. Sinai for the the giving of the Torah. Some explain that Jewish souls get trapped in Gentile bodies and that is why they have an urge to return to Judaism and that is why these people convert to Judaism because they were Jewish souls at Mt. Sinai. More than 30 years ago, I heard a lecture by Rabbi Yonassan Gershom and a few of us met privately with him afterwards. He is the author of the book, Beyond the Ashes: Cases of Reincarnation from the Holocaust.
The Romans conquered Jerusalem in 63 BCE, destroyed the Second Temple in 70 CE, and expelled many Jews. In 637 CE, Muslims under Caliph Umar peacefully took over Jerusalem and allowed Jews to return. The Crusaders conquered Jerusalem in 1099 and expelled Jews and Muslims. In 1187, Saladin and the Ayyubids reconquered it, and Saladin invited Jews who had been living in exile, especially in areas like Egypt and North Africa, to resettle in the city. Jewish communities slowly re-established themselves in Jerusalem under Ayyubid rule, which reflected the general atmosphere of religious tolerance during his reign. So islam was the religion that brought back jews to their land. For the most part, Jews in Jerusalem were allowed to live and practice their faith under Muslim rulers, and compared to European experiences, they generally faced less persecution.
Yet the vast majority of Jews have been persecuted and expelled from Muslim countries throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. Most of those refugees escaped to Israel where they sought protection from persecution. Today, the descendants of these Mizrahi Jewish refugees constitute the majority of Israel's Jewish population. The Jewish people can not trust anyone for their personal and cultural survival apart from themselves. Because there will always be periods in every foreign country where the antisemites get hold of power.
I genuinely thought people weren't Zionist anymore because the goal has already been accomplished. But I think I would qualify myself as a zionist. I'm secular, I dont have a religious attachment, and I'm willing to share the area with the Palestinians, as long as they're willing. And with the Samaritans too, for that matter. But I do think a Jewish state is an important asset for the world.
@Sploberrie 100% agree. Problem is that the Palestinian people have been brainwashed to want to kill the jews. Palestines will never be free as long they their lives revolve around figuring ways to kill the news. Free free Israel from radical racist Islamists.
lol the Elders of Zion would have laughed you out of the building. They were openly and proudly colonialist and explicitly outlined their Zionism movement as "something colonial".
@@EnclosedPoolArea I'm a Zionist. I would have differences with some of the original Zionists, sometimes in substance and sometimes in semantics. The fact of the matter remains: A group of people returning to their ancestral and cultural homeland for safety and self-determination is NOT colonialism. Missteps, mistakes, bad policy, and failures of leadership does not change that fact... Jews have been in the land for at least three thousand years, and have prayed and yearned for return for two thousand years. That isn't colonialism - that is peoplehood. I'm all for criticism the secular state of Israel. I'm all for criticism of the founders of that state. Just don't get it mixed up - Israel has every right and reason to exist.
@blueizumi I have seen it. I don't agree with what's going on in the disputed areas. Let me try this again: Bad people do bad things, and when that happens you DON'T support them. When Jewish "settlers" take what isn't theirs that's wrong. This isn't an "all or nothing". When people on "my side" are assholes, I call them out. That doesn't mean I'm not a Zionist. Life is about complexity.
@@alabamapilot244 A non-colonial Zionist is like a non-religious priest. You're disagreeing with very foundations of the idea. And it wasn't just the founders of the movement either who felt this way. Up until very recently it was widely accepted by Zionists as a colonisation project. The complete rebranding is a relatively recent PR move after the colonised world made their voices heard and "colonisation" became a dirty word.
I’m a Arab who use to hate Jews and Israel, than I did more research after Oct 7th and learned more about the Jewish culture and religion with this channel, thank you and stay safe
Oh my god! The short clip from 13:35 is from my Tasim in Bney Akiva! I thought to myself seeing it "damn, that looks like Tasim lol" and then I noticed the one with the dark blue and green sweater is my best friend which was with us back then. You must have saved it for a long time since this is from like 2015, when we were 10th graders lol. Love your work!
Historically i’m a leftist Israeli, self-hating, self-criticizing, secular, pluralistic… but since October 7 the world’s response is just making me more and more of the opposite
Yeah because that’s when history started and pretending to be a leftist is fun until it affects the home your grandparents took from some poor villagers. I bet they even told you they bought the homes or they won it in some fake war. I guess it helps you sleep at night pretending not to know the truth
@weiss1377 ... I hear you. It's a hard wake-up call. Unfortunately the entire left, including China, is in bed with Jew-hating Russia. (Whose 'Protocols' has infected the entire world with vicious antisemitism.) Jews have no choice but to stick together.
@@EnclosedPoolAreaJews ARE the natives fool! Jewish ethnicity is indigenous to the Levant in Judea emerging in the Bronze Age 3,500 BCE learn history.
@@EnclosedPoolAreaJews ARE the natives fool! Jewish ethnicity is indigenous to the Levant in Judea emerging in the Bronze Age 3,500 BCE learn history.
@@EnclosedPoolAreaJews ARE the natives fool! Jewish ethnicity is indigenous to the Levant in Judea emerging in the Bronze Age 3,500 BCE learn history.
Any decent human being would recognize that Jews have the right to self determination in their historical homeland, and join in celebrating this marvelous modern day miracle.
This was very educational and helped learn more on the history! Thank you so much for this! I'm a non-Jew but I will stand with the Jewish people and Israel. I stand with the facts and will fight against the lies of the Jew haters. I wear a Star of David because I like the symbol but also to show Jewish people that I'm an ally, and it is safe to be around me. I don't care if the haters will attack me or even hurt me, I stand for what is right! 😊
I don't know, I fundamentally believe it's morally right for the Jewish people to have their own homeland and nation-state. What it looks like and form it takes matter, and it's not for me to say, really, but realistically, it's important for Israel to exist. And I'm speaking as a non-Jew.
Yeah because being Jewish means being a colonialist who occupies natives brutally and then acts like the victim when they escape their prison. This is not Judaism
The vast majority of the protesters are anti-colonialists and consider that Zionism is the last expression of the old Western colonial model, before Western colonization became economic. The problem is not that the Jews have a state, the problem is that this state was constituted against those who inhabited the country where they settled and not with them. The problem is that this state was constituted thanks to the Western powers and not with the collaboration of the local populations, who were not consulted, and of the Arabs, who were betrayed by the English and the French (Sykes-Picot agreements). From the beginning, the worm was in the fruit. What is really unfortunate is that now, the fruit is really rotten and that this state created as a refuge for the persecuted has become the kind of persecutor who fails to recognize the other as a fellow man and dehumanizes him as he was dehumanized.
I just wanna place the national anthem of Israel - "The Hope" here: As long as deep in the heart, The soul of a Jew yearns, And forward to the East To Zion, an eye looks Our hope will not be lost, The hope of two thousand years, To be a free nation in our land, The land of Zion and Jerusalem.
Don’t let these videos for you don’t go to these protest and I’m pro Israel and I’m an Italian poorJew from Philly and I constantly called these cowards #simpsforhamas I was on the train with them the other day they didn’t say nothing to me when I confronted them. They all turned their heads and were quiet so we just need more Jews like me to stand up to these cowards. It’s not always a popular thing to do, but it’s a necessary thing to do.
@@UNPACKED thank you for replying to me and no problem. I stand with Israel. I am an Italian Jew from Philadelphia. I go to a lot of protest and I see all the propaganda like the one in the University of Penn when they got arrested it was seven students and 31 homeless people so they use homeless people and tell them they can sleep there so the numbers are bigger so I know what it is. I fight back and we’re not going to let us interrogate us and push their lying narrative but thank you again I stand with the people of Israel and the seed of Israel, not no made of country that was made up by an Egyptian Arab in 1967
Brilliant work, please keep these up. I used to be very much an atheist myself, but got quite religious in my 30s. My family is Christian/Jewish (non-religious though) which is why I started watching channels like this one. And I know some in Israel and strongly believe it has a right to exist.
Bla bla bla. No it's faith recognizing God said.. set your eyes towards Mt Zion, because that's where he had displayed His power that they would never forget..
Thank you for your hard work, this will come in handy in combating Antisemites under the socialist burqa of Antizionism. P.s. Will you please consider to cover the rescue of the Bulgarian Jews during WW2?
K&K Monarchie, hungary was cosmetically a separate kingdom, but Austria was half of Europe.Thus austria didn't join the other germn speaking Kingdoms into Germany, as only the minority (thoough the ruling minority) spoke German.
@@stephenfisher3721 Most of us spoke German or Jiddish back then but still identified Hungarian. No big deal. Most of the Hungarian nobility had German origins and were bilangual as well. The Kingdom of Hungary used to be an amazing multi ethnic country before the wars and retarded ideologies ruined it. Otto Habsburg speaks in 5 languages.
I like how there’s a slide with Jabotinsky saying the most important characteristic is that Jews MUST maintain the majority, as if there’s nothing problematic about that😵💫
Zionism is secular. Judaism is a religion. Read your Old Testament. God said only if you kept his covenant you could stay in the land. You got kicked out two thousand years ago because you rejected the messiah. The modern state of Israel has nothing to do with biblical Judaism.
If a Jew born in New York has a right to self determination and a state in the Levant - then so does a Palestinian born in Ashkelon, Raffah, Jerusalem etc
@@UNPACKED that’s the thing - I don’t agree that those early Zionists that flooded the Levant had a right to do so just because their ancestors settled there for a while, a very very very long time ago. So did mine (Romans). The thing is - by the time European and American Zionists decided they wanted to move back to that part of the world - society had long established that conquests and invasions are no longer how we do things. There were people there who had grown up there, so had their grandparents. And they didn’t want their homeland to be renamed Israel and under to become primarily a Jewish state. No country would accept this from any group.
@@UNPACKED the first Palestinian national congress rejected the Balfour declaration in 1919 and demanded independence. The majority (Palestinians) living in those lands voted to oppose a new state being formed on their lands. Eventually, the Zionist fathers went onto create terror groups that would be proscribed by the British - smuggling in weapons (being caught doing so in Raffa airport in 1935). They spread their ideology and stole land by force, with the motto of the stern gang being “only thus” with a picture of a rifle on top of a map showing “eretz Israel” - as in “only by the gun will they achieve eretz Israel”. It was open policy that they intended to use force against the people already inhabiting those lands.
So you’re saying that if Palestinians leave their home for a long time - maybe like 75 years - then by the time their great-great-grandchildren want to return, they lost that right? That’s an interesting way to solve this conflict.
It's a miracle that the Jewish people are still around considering the horrific past i stand with Israel 🇮🇱 and for what it represents long live Israel 🇮🇱 !!!!!!!
Then why are they burning the olive trees which the Palestinians grew? While the Israelis burn the trees the Palestinians are crying saying the trees are their children.
Its good too see people appreciate this concept for what it is❤. Justice. And a force that has saved a people from being gaslighted and persecuted out of the world and their deep history❤
I fully understand what Zionism means. What I still don’t understand and what this video doesn’t answer is where should the people that were and are living on the land promised to Jewish people supposed to go? And if by forcibly expelling those people from their current homes is that not the same pain and violence that’s been inflicted on Jewish people? It makes it sound like one people are owed more rights than another people?
Who said they had to go anywhere? You do know that there was a proposal to share the land and no one would have to leave, right? You can learn more about it here: ua-cam.com/video/EDSxwh3uu9c/v-deo.html The Jews agreed to it, the whole world voted in favor of it - and the Arabs instead waged war. They lost that war they started, and, like in most wars, refugees were created. You can learn more about that here: ua-cam.com/video/jB6IhmHYzWs/v-deo.html Whose fault is that?
I'm an American Christian, I believe God chose the Jews to be His people, and that they belong in the land of Canaan, that is now The nation of Israel. 🇮🇱 God bless Israel and the Jewish people. If that makes me a Zionist, I would gladly take that name with me forever 😇
I'm an American Christian too!!! And I believe that JESUS DIED FOR ALL PEOPLE, PALESTINIANS TOO!!! THEIR LAND HAS BEEN STOLEN AND THEY ARE BEING SLAUGHTERED!!! GOD sees the ATROCITIES!!! SHAME!!! NAKBA. Look up Former IDF Soldiers speaking out, called Breaking the Silence. Look up Dr. Norman Finkelstein! He's excellent! Look up Miko Peled! The General's Son. Look up the Nakba! Look up MAPS before 1948!! Look up pictures of Israel, BEFORE 1948!!
The person who made that statement is undeniably stupid. However, it can not be ignored that Jews also lived on the land that constitutes the West Bank for thousands of years. It's true, they were expelled during different periods. For example, by the Romans in the 2nd century AC and by the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan in 1947. Therefore, they don't constitute a majority in that territory today. Thus, I believe Jews have a right to live in the West Bank, but as long as it is done legally. Because moving into a territory that is not self-recognized by Israel as a part of its country as an Israeli citizen without applying for residency there, is like a foreign citizen trying to enter another country illegally. This case is more complicated because most Israeli citizens moved there when the West Bank had no foreign ruling authority and Still live in area C which has no foreign ruling authority. But it's still sketchy because it's like they are living in a no man's land with other people holding a different passport. The case of Israel's rebirth and the movement of Israelis into the West Bank are two completely different things. In the first case, Jews either lived there already or mostly moved there as refugees legally by receiving permanent residency and buying land. Whilst, in the second case, Israeli citizens move there Illegally(under the Geneva conversion).
Love the video Unpacked. I'm a European Nationalist and I also beleive that my native Sweden should be majority White and governed by Indigenous Whites. 🇪🇺🇸🇪❤️❤️🇮🇱
Wow bending the rules. What else can we expect from successors of the following: The Israelites were required to strictly keep the Sabbath which meant that they may not engage in any worldly activity; they may not cook, nor make their slaves or cattle serve them. Those who violated these rules were to be put to death. The Israelites, however, publicly violated these rules. In the days of the Prophet Jeremiah (between 628 and 586 B.C.), the Israelites carried their merchandise through the gates of Jerusalem on the Sabbath day itself. Jeremiah, therefore, warned them that if they persisted in their flagrant violation of the Law, Jerusalem would be set on fire. (Jererniah 17: 21-7.) The same complaint is voiced in the Book of the Prophet Ezekiel (595-536 B.C.) who referred to their violation of the Sabbath rules as their major sin. (Ezekiel 20: 12-24.)
Ancestral homeland? I believe that honor goes to the darker skinned people living in the desert. You know, the non-chosen people who evolved to live there without skyrocketing rates of skin cancer. Also, what about the non-zionist jews who publicly protest against it?
What is Zionism? Its a form of ethnonationalism. And it comes with all of the problems of every other ethnonationalist movement. The closest comparison is to the Phalangists of Lebanon, if you know who those guys are.
Zionism is from the word - Zion, which means Jerusalem/Israel there's written text dating back the Babylonian exile of the Jews with referring to Zion that was a long time before political movement.
Hey brother I am a Muslim. I like you argument I understand that Jewish people have been suffered a lot. That's why I argue that both parties the palestinians and the Jewish people have a right to their land. I understand that Jewish is discriminated thousands of years. And as for the Palestinian argument Palestinian wants their land because they also have no way to go. Currently Israel had 8 million Palestinian, they can go nowhere in the world. Similar to the Jews palestinians also won their land. That's why I support that two nation theory will be best in the situation. And Palestinian will accept two state theory completely I think. If they don't it have to be enforced to them. But if Israel zionist will not give the land to the palestinians which belongs to them before 1940. Then there is a massive problem. And Israel is not addressing that problem at all. The way Israel is being constructed Israeli people cannot be secular with the palestinians. Because history engraves phones right now. I accept that Israel should to support that their people. For the same reason I also want Palestinian state to exist. I am secular Muslim. You could judged that from my stand. But right now what Israel is doing with palestinians in West Bank and Gaza it is not acceptable at all. Why don't you understand a simple thing. If you don't want to divide your country because nobody wants divide their country at all. Then they exist only one solution and that is of one state solution. And for one state solution to be a real solution you have to make it a lot neutral ideological grounds. The best solution will be two state. Or you can keep killing palestinians. It's you have to choose. If you have any other solution in mind then please comment below me. You can see I am not against Israel. I just want that Palestinian Nations to exist so that palestinians are also happy. Both sides have to compromise a little. Peace and justice should be given to the both side. The things that Adolf did Israel is moving towards that. I never understand Muslim and Jewish people are like 95% same in their religion. These two religions are so so so similar that many of the word seem similar. Then why this hatred and animosity was there. We have to come to the common terms. I think human can solve any problem if they want to by talking. Bad condition is both side have to compromise.
As a German atheist, I support Israel and the right of the Jewish people to have their own state on their historical soil. I am a Zionist! Although I love having Jewish life in my own country and can only take responsibility to ensure that the Shoah never happens again. Never again is now! Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱❤️🇩🇪🎗️
We love you 🤍🤍💙💙
🫶🏻✡️🇮🇱
why don't you give your home to zionists and start living somewhere else?
😂😂😂😂
@@wedontdoit You can laugh as much as you want, but remember, he who laughs last, laughs best. And that won't be those with hate in their hearts
A whole video about zionism without a single mention of how theodore herzl opposed a jewish state if it meant stealing it from natives. An entire video about jewish self determination without asking the question "what about palestenian self determination?". I watched a few other videos on this channel and i was impressed with how educational and fair it was. This video is a decent into bias. What a shame. You couldve been a channel dissemenating important unbiased information to the masses.
For the record i am not pro isreal nor pro palestine. Just an observer who recognizes that this problem cant be solved if people are fed biased one sided narratives.
Why should Zionism negate Palestinian self determination? Why not share the land? ua-cam.com/video/1kYWII25cxM/v-deo.html
@@UNPACKED i just watched this video you linked and it is god awful how one sided it. "they keep rejecting our proposals", they were never even invited to the negotiating table and had unfair deals pushed onto them, ofcourse theyd reject it.
honeslty you guys are making the problem worse with the content your creating here. the people here on youtube need a source that can show both sides.
“They were never even invited to the negotiating table” - where do you get these ideas from? Do you know what happened at Oslo? At Camp David? You should learn some more history - you can start here: ua-cam.com/video/5SIAW4cX62I/v-deo.html and
@@UNPACKED i meant there were never invited to the 1947 UN resolution, they were never invited to the table when britain declared teh 1917 borders. And its funny you mention camp david because palestenians were not invited to the camp david accords, that one was mainly between egypt and isreal. funny that you lump palestenians and egyptions as the same people, all arabs must be the same to you huh?
Oslo was one of the only times palestenians had a seat at the negotiating table and it is regarded as the closest we ever got to peace. The deal got signed. we were at the finish line, but then netanyahu sabotaged the deal by telling them they are going to steal the west bank after its they sign (which he openly admited to and there is video evidence of on youtube look it up). and then coincidentally the isreali leader who signed the deal gets assainated by a far right isreali extremist, hmm quite a coincidence considering netanyahu represents the far right aint it
Ah I see you’re not so educated so you never learned about Camp David in 2000 where Israelis and Palestinians were brought to the negotiating table by Bill Clinton. After Israeli PM Barak offered most of what the Palestinians wanted, Yasser Arafat just walked away without even responding 😬 You can learn more here: ua-cam.com/video/G7zG1ox91DY/v-deo.htmlsi=UmtzRDw-SO3nZtoD
And why do you say Arabs (there were no Palestinians back then, so yes, back then all Arabs basically lumped themselves together) weren’t invited to 1947 negotiations? Did you know that the Arab states refused to collaborate with UNSCOP, which had extended an invitation for liaison also to the Arab Higher Committee.
I do think you’re onto something about 1917 - and the Sykes-Pocot Agreement (is that what you’re referring to?) where nobody was consulted. But that’s also the way empires worked back then, and there was no Palestinians to speak of, nor many present-day Palestinians or Arabs there either. You can learn more about that here: ua-cam.com/video/MuSwp17e4fI/v-deo.html
And wait- you think Netanyahu sabotaged Oslo? You should watch the video again: ua-cam.com/video/5SIAW4cX62I/v-deo.html He definitely benefited from it collapsing but that was mostly due to the sabotage and suicide bombings of Hamas. Thankfully, Hamas has now been basically eradicated :)
What I just find so hilarious about these types of explanations is how disconnected these sentiments are about the violent removal of the people who’ve been living there just as long just because they’re not Jewish. Horrific stories about the heart wrenching stories about the Jewish people are used to excuse the launching of an ethnostate that enforces apartheid.
You should learn more about that: ua-cam.com/video/jB6IhmHYzWs/v-deo.htmlsi=4eEbmc_yCVjjBUNN
Exactly, Palestinian have more Hebrew dna than the zionists flooding back to their homeland. Palestinian have jewish ancestry but are being persecuted because they accepted another religion. It's so messed up.
Are you a DNA expert? And does DNA make someone Jewish? ua-cam.com/video/O2AJdphzrFY/v-deo.html
Also no one is being persecuted for being Palestinian or Muslim - they’re being ‘persecuted’ for being terrorists and trying to kill Jews 🤦♂️
@@UNPACKEDno bro your wrong, there are hundreds of thousands of innocent lives that have been killed and so much land that has been stripped from the Palestinian people. Even though the land has been theirs for centuries. Stop your propaganda and lies. We all see through the smokescreen.
Resistance to apartheid will never be unjustified. It’s nothing new for people to push back against white supremacy and considering that majority of the people in Israel now trace their ancestry to white Europe i think it’s befitting to identify Zionism as such.
@UNPACKED Oh the irony, yet the Israeli colony was founded on terrorism. Palestinians are not resisting because of your Jewish faith or for simply being jews, they are resisting a colonial power which is ethinically cleansing them from their lands. They would resist anyone, even if it was another Muslim country. So please stop your propaganda.
Palestinians and Lebanese (Cannanites) are actually the indegenious people to the land, and they were there long before the Isralites.
Who are the Isralites?
They are the progeny of Jacob (also called Israel). Israel is a person, not a geographical location!
Jacob's father was Issac, Issacs father was Abraham, who was from the city of Ur (modern day Iraq).
Abraham migrated with his wife and nephew to what is today occupied Palestine. He was accepted into the land by the Cannanite king Melchizedek (Hebrew 7:3).
Now, coming back to jacob, his son Joseph was sold by his brothers to Egypt. Josepths progeny lived in Egypt for about 400 years before Moses took the people out of the land and to what is today occupied Palestine. The isralites made their kingdom; King David and King Solomon, but then the Babylonians destroyed the first temple and the Romans the second.
So, if you look at history, the Israelites originate from Jacob, and his grandfather Abraham is from Ur(Iraq). The cannanites have always been on their land and they have more Hebrew/Jewish dna than most ashkenazi Jews. With the passage of time, many Jews converted to Christianity and then Islam. Why this this so hard to fathom.
I am an ex Muslim from Bangladesh. I believe the oppressed jews must have their own land, and that's their homeland. If that makes me a Zionist I am one. 🇮🇱❤❤
The Kuran itself is a Zionistic book that said that Israel belongs to Allah chosen people Bnay Israel (the Jews).
Do you recommend any resources for us to learn more about our Bengali friends and neighbors? Most are devoted muslims, and while its great to talk with them and learn directly from them about themselves, your perspective is extremely valuable.
Love from Canada brother
I follow 5 Religions. Boni Israil Zindabad. 🇧🇩🇮🇱@@davidh4374
You’re brainwashed then
Vast majority of protestors don't even know what zionism is.
just means jew to them
Some of the statements from anti-zionists have been baffling to me, so I asked.
I never got one clear answer, but it's basically the Protocols conspiracy theories of Global Control, of all other interests being "puppets" of Jews, etc etc, grafted on to the real part about the Judean people living in Jerusalem and Judea with self-determination and self-defense.
B.S. nonsense about the Fed being privately owned* by a Jewish family.
Mind control through the media.
Cherry picking quotes and fake quotes from 5722 pages of Talmud arguments compiled over several centuries.
All the stuff Candace talks about.
* Nobody can own shares except Fed member banks, bank corporations like the one you use which are like licensed and regulated franchise operations, banks are required by Law to purchase shares and hold them indefinitely while their business is operational. No stock trader would even want to own Fed shares, because 100% of profits are returned directly to the US Treasury, instead of the IRS. Who would want to own shares in a corporation that can never earn net profits, by Law, because of the requirement to give all profits after expenses to the Treasury every 3 months?
Ironically, some Jews in Israel are having ALL banking access blocked by America, so they can't pay their household bills or operate a business, because they participated in a peaceful protest in Israel, or because they defended their lives, who were never charged or convicted of any crime.
These Jews were accused by some Leftists tied to America and Democrats of being insufficiently nice to Hamas or mean to Palestinians, accused of some action that impedes the "two State solution" dream of the Biden admin, this "peaceful solution" that Palestinians have REJECTED with VIOLENCE for more than 100 years, each time it was offered, including with Saudi diplomatic intervention.
The majority of protestors don't know a lot about anything. Ignorance at its best.
Judaism + evil
@@proof.120 how are us zionists going to get the atheist jews to come home?
🖐️🖐️ here is a raised hands for being a hard core Zionist from my deepest spiritual parts of my Jewish Soul 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
In the past, Jews were Arabs, and there were no European Jews at that time. Christians and Muslims also belonged to the same Arab race, and those religions spread after the commercial interactions between different peoples. Even God, in all the holy books, was addressing Arabs. The original Arab Jews currently in Palestine oppose the occupation of their homeland, Palestine, by Europeans and the renaming of it to Israel. They believe, based on their religious texts, that the establishment of a Jewish state could be a sign of the inevitable end of the Jewish people
Did Israel take over Palestine? ua-cam.com/video/0BasXaiHiiI/v-deo.htmlsi=-CwE59SJQZUj9_x6
And that’s not a real Jewish belief you quote at the end 🤷♂️
Zionism is destroying the jewish dream. Im all for having your homeland but you need to give Palestinians equal rights because it’s their land too!
God bless you.
It's good to see a sane person among all these bloodthirsty raving lunatics.
The bible has passages about people who thought violence was okay because they were hebrew.
The idf will face justice on earth and in the afterlife.
Jews and Arabs (Palestinians) have exactly the same rights in Israel.
@@mariasharapan7131 Until there are too many Arabs.
Not to me it isn’t, Israel belongs to us and was promised to us by Hashem
How certain are you that God even exists? Where is the proof?
@@VladfishTheMagnificentEverywhere!
@@PJGenovese251 Hashem promised me that would never happen
@@tuckerbugeater And indeed, I hope it doesn't.
@@PJGenovese251 I don't think anyone wants to spend their days being the light in the darkness. You Christians sure know how to take the most sinister ideas and twist them into something that sounds lofty & pure.
My great grandmother immigrated to the USA and never told her husband that she was Jewish. It wasn’t till the 1990’s I got my ancestry test done and found out I am a Christian who is also Jewish!
Many Jews gave up being Jewish because it was so much easier being like everyone else and avoiding discrimination, prejudice, and violence. Most Jews who left never wanted to be reminded. That is why it is so strange about the Jews for Jesus. Why spoil all the benefits of being like everyone else?
Stop begging. So you're Christian.
What do you do if you have a Jewish soul but can't prove it?
@@davidh4374 convert!
@@davidh4374
If you have a Jewish soul but can't prove it, convert to Judaism.
There is a Jewish tradition that all Jewish souls were present at Mt. Sinai for the the giving of the Torah.
Some explain that Jewish souls get trapped in Gentile bodies and that is why they have an urge to return to Judaism and that is why these people convert to Judaism because they were Jewish souls at Mt. Sinai.
More than 30 years ago, I heard a lecture by Rabbi Yonassan Gershom and a few of us met privately with him afterwards. He is the author of the book, Beyond the Ashes: Cases of Reincarnation from the Holocaust.
עם ישראל חי ✡️🇮🇱✡️🇮🇱
The Romans conquered Jerusalem in 63 BCE, destroyed the Second Temple in 70 CE, and expelled many Jews. In 637 CE, Muslims under Caliph Umar peacefully took over Jerusalem and allowed Jews to return.
The Crusaders conquered Jerusalem in 1099 and expelled Jews and Muslims. In 1187, Saladin and the Ayyubids reconquered it, and Saladin invited Jews who had been living in exile, especially in areas like Egypt and North Africa, to resettle in the city. Jewish communities slowly re-established themselves in Jerusalem under Ayyubid rule, which reflected the general atmosphere of religious tolerance during his reign. So islam was the religion that brought back jews to their land. For the most part, Jews in Jerusalem were allowed to live and practice their faith under Muslim rulers, and compared to European experiences, they generally faced less persecution.
Yet the vast majority of Jews have been persecuted and expelled from Muslim countries throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. Most of those refugees escaped to Israel where they sought protection from persecution. Today, the descendants of these Mizrahi Jewish refugees constitute the majority of Israel's Jewish population.
The Jewish people can not trust anyone for their personal and cultural survival apart from themselves. Because there will always be periods in every foreign country where the antisemites get hold of power.
Zionism is about returning to Zion, not to Poland.
-- Yehudah ben Aryeh, of the tribe of Yehudah, the Kingdom of Yehudah, the Land of Israel.
💡
With what happens in the world not only it's not dead . It's stronger than ever 💪
Pride for Israel has honestly never been higher! 🇧🇷🇮🇱
Thank you! You might like our new Portuguese channel: youtube.com/@UNPACKED_PT Please watch, subscribe, and spread the word!
@@NaProbablyNot 🤣🤣🤣your hilarious
I genuinely thought people weren't Zionist anymore because the goal has already been accomplished. But I think I would qualify myself as a zionist. I'm secular, I dont have a religious attachment, and I'm willing to share the area with the Palestinians, as long as they're willing. And with the Samaritans too, for that matter. But I do think a Jewish state is an important asset for the world.
@Sploberrie 100% agree. Problem is that the Palestinian people have been brainwashed to want to kill the jews. Palestines will never be free as long they their lives revolve around figuring ways to kill the news.
Free free Israel from radical racist Islamists.
Zionism is one of the greatest anti-colonialist stories ever told!
lol the Elders of Zion would have laughed you out of the building. They were openly and proudly colonialist and explicitly outlined their Zionism movement as "something colonial".
@@EnclosedPoolArea I'm a Zionist. I would have differences with some of the original Zionists, sometimes in substance and sometimes in semantics.
The fact of the matter remains: A group of people returning to their ancestral and cultural homeland for safety and self-determination is NOT colonialism. Missteps, mistakes, bad policy, and failures of leadership does not change that fact... Jews have been in the land for at least three thousand years, and have prayed and yearned for return for two thousand years. That isn't colonialism - that is peoplehood.
I'm all for criticism the secular state of Israel. I'm all for criticism of the founders of that state. Just don't get it mixed up - Israel has every right and reason to exist.
LOL you should watch the recent BBC settler video if you seriously think that 😂 “if I don’t steal your home someone else will steal it” - 2021
@blueizumi I have seen it. I don't agree with what's going on in the disputed areas. Let me try this again:
Bad people do bad things, and when that happens you DON'T support them. When Jewish "settlers" take what isn't theirs that's wrong.
This isn't an "all or nothing". When people on "my side" are assholes, I call them out. That doesn't mean I'm not a Zionist. Life is about complexity.
@@alabamapilot244 A non-colonial Zionist is like a non-religious priest. You're disagreeing with very foundations of the idea. And it wasn't just the founders of the movement either who felt this way. Up until very recently it was widely accepted by Zionists as a colonisation project. The complete rebranding is a relatively recent PR move after the colonised world made their voices heard and "colonisation" became a dirty word.
I’m a Arab who use to hate Jews and Israel, than I did more research after Oct 7th and learned more about the Jewish culture and religion with this channel, thank you and stay safe
You're just a bot paid by the zionists to put the same narrative out on many posts. Get a real life dude.
Oh my god!
The short clip from 13:35 is from my Tasim in Bney Akiva!
I thought to myself seeing it "damn, that looks like Tasim lol" and then I noticed the one with the dark blue and green sweater is my best friend which was with us back then.
You must have saved it for a long time since this is from like 2015, when we were 10th graders lol.
Love your work!
Historically i’m a leftist Israeli, self-hating, self-criticizing, secular, pluralistic… but since October 7 the world’s response is just making me more and more of the opposite
חיבוק לך❤
Yeah because that’s when history started and pretending to be a leftist is fun until it affects the home your grandparents took from some poor villagers. I bet they even told you they bought the homes or they won it in some fake war. I guess it helps you sleep at night pretending not to know the truth
@weiss1377 ... I hear you. It's a hard wake-up call. Unfortunately the entire left, including China, is in bed with Jew-hating Russia. (Whose 'Protocols' has infected the entire world with vicious antisemitism.) Jews have no choice but to stick together.
@@weiss1377 You should watch the Matt Lieb shorts about liberal Zionists.
The world rarely approves of genocide. If that is what gets you to abandon your beliefs then they weren't all that strong in the first place.
Amazing video, and very well spoken at the end. As a non-Jew, I'm glad Israel exists and it continues to guarantee the safety of Jews globally
❤
I am not a Jew, not even Israeli but I support the Jews in their fight for their own land. Let the people of Israel live!
It's not their land. It's stolen from the natives.
@@EnclosedPoolAreasame as the way white people stole the Americas. But Israel has historical connection with the land.
@@EnclosedPoolAreaJews ARE the natives fool! Jewish ethnicity is indigenous to the Levant in Judea emerging in the Bronze Age 3,500 BCE learn history.
@@EnclosedPoolAreaJews ARE the natives fool! Jewish ethnicity is indigenous to the Levant in Judea emerging in the Bronze Age 3,500 BCE learn history.
@@EnclosedPoolAreaJews ARE the natives fool! Jewish ethnicity is indigenous to the Levant in Judea emerging in the Bronze Age 3,500 BCE learn history.
Any decent human being would recognize that Jews have the right to self determination in their historical homeland, and join in celebrating this marvelous modern day miracle.
This was very educational and helped learn more on the history! Thank you so much for this! I'm a non-Jew but I will stand with the Jewish people and Israel. I stand with the facts and will fight against the lies of the Jew haters. I wear a Star of David because I like the symbol but also to show Jewish people that I'm an ally, and it is safe to be around me. I don't care if the haters will attack me or even hurt me, I stand for what is right! 😊
Thanks, learnt about the different strands of Zionism
I don't know, I fundamentally believe it's morally right for the Jewish people to have their own homeland and nation-state. What it looks like and form it takes matter, and it's not for me to say, really, but realistically, it's important for Israel to exist.
And I'm speaking as a non-Jew.
Sounds like you know quite a bit!
It's never morally right to steal other people's land or commit the atrocities being exposed.
So they can take lands and homes from people living there? Huh
Are you talking about the British?
@@UNPACKED The people doing it right now are the Z 's.
Excellent, excellent video. Don't ever forget what history tells it's people.
See Norman Finkelstein and Ilan Pappe.
I thought I couldn't get more Zionist but since Oct7 I am an even BIGGER Zionist. You can't be a Jew without being a Zionist.
Yeah because being Jewish means being a colonialist who occupies natives brutally and then acts like the victim when they escape their prison. This is not Judaism
I met some jews who were anti-zionist while traveling through New York.
The abused becomes the abuser
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️💯❤️💯
These protesters don't even understand the bronze age and the iron age
Haha I’m not so sure to many people in general would know the difference
Exactly! They don’t know their calling for Jews to be removed from their indigenous homeland since the bronzes age 3,500-1150 BCE.
Is rale is in those.
The vast majority of the protesters are anti-colonialists and consider that Zionism is the last expression of the old Western colonial model, before Western colonization became economic.
The problem is not that the Jews have a state, the problem is that this state was constituted against those who inhabited the country where they settled and not with them. The problem is that this state was constituted thanks to the Western powers and not with the collaboration of the local populations, who were not consulted, and of the Arabs, who were betrayed by the English and the French (Sykes-Picot agreements).
From the beginning, the worm was in the fruit. What is really unfortunate is that now, the fruit is really rotten and that this state created as a refuge for the persecuted has become the kind of persecutor who fails to recognize the other as a fellow man and dehumanizes him as he was dehumanized.
Pro-🇮🇱🤟🏻🙌🏻
I just wanna place the national anthem of Israel - "The Hope" here:
As long as deep in the heart,
The soul of a Jew yearns,
And forward to the East
To Zion, an eye looks
Our hope will not be lost,
The hope of two thousand years,
To be a free nation in our land,
The land of Zion and Jerusalem.
Why don't you?
@@lforlight lol idk why it didn't paste wait a sec I'll edit
As a Nigerian Christian Israel has the right to defend themselves from terrorist.
Don’t let these videos for you don’t go to these protest and I’m pro Israel and I’m an Italian poorJew from Philly and I constantly called these cowards #simpsforhamas I was on the train with them the other day they didn’t say nothing to me when I confronted them. They all turned their heads and were quiet so we just need more Jews like me to stand up to these cowards. It’s not always a popular thing to do, but it’s a necessary thing to do.
Thanks @Chestermcfly420 !
@@UNPACKED thank you for replying to me and no problem. I stand with Israel. I am an Italian Jew from Philadelphia. I go to a lot of protest and I see all the propaganda like the one in the University of Penn when they got arrested it was seven students and 31 homeless people so they use homeless people and tell them they can sleep there so the numbers are bigger so I know what it is. I fight back and we’re not going to let us interrogate us and push their lying narrative but thank you again I stand with the people of Israel and the seed of Israel, not no made of country that was made up by an Egyptian Arab in 1967
How exactly did you call them out?
I am a jew and is always proud to be one
Thank you for sharing our history!
Brilliant work, please keep these up. I used to be very much an atheist myself, but got quite religious in my 30s. My family is Christian/Jewish (non-religious though) which is why I started watching channels like this one. And I know some in Israel and strongly believe it has a right to exist.
Thank you and thank you for your donation!! It helps our channel to keep making amazing content :)
I am no Jew and I am Zionist.
Good little goy
I am a zionist from Massachusetts who is 72 years old. I have been to Israel seven times.
You still alive mf?
Zionism is ethnonationalism
This whole channel is ethnonationalist apartheid revisionist propaganda.
Bla bla bla. No it's faith recognizing God said.. set your eyes towards Mt Zion, because that's where he had displayed His power that they would never forget..
@@Ashley-rf6ex lmao even the Islamists ascribe their ideas to G-d.
@@ahmedisl8 And? Havnt you got something better to comment on. If your going to why don't you share some real revelation.
Thank you for your hard work, this will come in handy in combating Antisemites under the socialist burqa of Antizionism.
P.s. Will you please consider to cover the rescue of the Bulgarian Jews during WW2?
Thank you! We are working on more videos about the Holocaust so we'll add this into our list of ideas
Beautiful! God bless Israel!
I am a Zionist and I would have lifted my hand if I were on that subway.
Same! 😊
😂
That end minute did give me a tear in my eye. Jews truly have a home❤
Proud Zionist to the core of my Jewish soul 🩵🤍🩵. All the hate right now only proves how relevant Zionism still is. Haters - fuc*ing sue me 😘
Allah sizler için cehennemi hazırladı..
Ne mutlu insan kalbi taşıyanlara
More hasbara when confronted with their sadism.
Proud Brazilian Zionist 🇮🇱
You might like our new Portuguese channel: www.youtube.com/@UNPACKED_PT
@@UNPACKED English is fine, but thanks!
If you can help us spread the work to Brazilian Jews/Zionists, that would be appreciated!
@@UNPACKED you bet I will! Love you guys
Bro, Herzl is not Viennese. He was born and raised in Budapest. His family moved to Vienna when he was 18.
There are a number of errors in the video, although none is major enough to warrant a re-do.
K&K Monarchie, hungary was cosmetically a separate kingdom, but Austria was half of Europe.Thus austria didn't join the other germn speaking Kingdoms into Germany, as only the minority (thoough the ruling minority) spoke German.
Herzl was a German speaker born and raised in the Austro-Hungarian Empire.
He very much identified with Vienna where he went for education and work.
@@stephenfisher3721 Most of us spoke German or Jiddish back then but still identified Hungarian. No big deal. Most of the Hungarian nobility had German origins and were bilangual as well. The Kingdom of Hungary used to be an amazing multi ethnic country before the wars and retarded ideologies ruined it. Otto Habsburg speaks in 5 languages.
Did you enjoy the debate between Candace Owens and Rabbi Smuely?
Never. Because people don't even know what Zionism is.
I like how there’s a slide with Jabotinsky saying the most important characteristic is that Jews MUST maintain the majority, as if there’s nothing problematic about that😵💫
zionism only grew stronger, the youth of israel realised the hate against them around the world and the movements importance in the first place.
Fact: Kibbutzim were the first successful communes
Yep! ua-cam.com/video/RIf2f77tjJ8/v-deo.html
They were not successful in the broad sense and were very far from the first. They also had nothing to do with socialism.
I am a Zionist, Am YiSrael Chai! God bless Israel.
But it's very easy to identify Islamists
Having an amazing 5 week holiday in Israel now. Beautiful people.
I was last year working at Berkeley university, if they knew what i think i would not be here today.
I had to move after living there for 20 years.
Zionism is secular. Judaism is a religion. Read your Old Testament. God said only if you kept his covenant you could stay in the land. You got kicked out two thousand years ago because you rejected the messiah. The modern state of Israel has nothing to do with biblical Judaism.
LMAO im a jew and 0 afraid standing between these mobs, all bunch of cowards
They can’t even speak for themselves. They’re taught slogans, not debate points.
the end got me crying
Give the Jews their ancestral land, there is so much land elsewhere aside from Eretz Israel.
God bless Israel!
*Free Temple Mount*
Strong Israel, strong world.
If a Jew born in New York has a right to self determination and a state in the Levant - then so does a Palestinian born in Ashkelon, Raffah, Jerusalem etc
Sure - so why not share the land? ua-cam.com/video/1kYWII25cxM/v-deo.html
@@UNPACKED that’s the thing - I don’t agree that those early Zionists that flooded the Levant had a right to do so just because their ancestors settled there for a while, a very very very long time ago. So did mine (Romans).
The thing is - by the time European and American Zionists decided they wanted to move back to that part of the world - society had long established that conquests and invasions are no longer how we do things. There were people there who had grown up there, so had their grandparents. And they didn’t want their homeland to be renamed Israel and under to become primarily a Jewish state. No country would accept this from any group.
@@UNPACKED the first Palestinian national congress rejected the Balfour declaration in 1919 and demanded independence. The majority (Palestinians) living in those lands voted to oppose a new state being formed on their lands.
Eventually, the Zionist fathers went onto create terror groups that would be proscribed by the British - smuggling in weapons (being caught doing so in Raffa airport in 1935). They spread their ideology and stole land by force, with the motto of the stern gang being “only thus” with a picture of a rifle on top of a map showing “eretz Israel” - as in “only by the gun will they achieve eretz Israel”. It was open policy that they intended to use force against the people already inhabiting those lands.
@@UNPACKED are you going to brush over the fact that Palestinians don’t have the same right of return as Israelis?
So you’re saying that if Palestinians leave their home for a long time - maybe like 75 years - then by the time their great-great-grandchildren want to return, they lost that right? That’s an interesting way to solve this conflict.
*From river to sea, Israel will live for good forever* 💪
Wishful thinking. The mask is officially off.
It's a miracle that the Jewish people are still around considering the horrific past i stand with Israel 🇮🇱 and for what it represents long live Israel 🇮🇱 !!!!!!!
😂
I understand the argument which asks "where else could they go?" But isnt that the same concern we have for the displaced Palestinians?
The Palestinians are Arab and there are over 20 Arab countries. Israel is the land of the Jews and the Jews have 1 country.
The zionist is the olive tree
Deeply rooted in the holy land .❤🫒
Then why are they burning the olive trees which the Palestinians grew? While the Israelis burn the trees the Palestinians are crying saying the trees are their children.
Actually it is the tavor oak, that is Israel 's national tree, olive trees barely have roots and they grow in desert areas
Its good too see people appreciate this concept for what it is❤.
Justice.
And a force that has saved a people from being gaslighted and persecuted out of the world and their deep history❤
Long live Israel
I fully understand what Zionism means. What I still don’t understand and what this video doesn’t answer is where should the people that were and are living on the land promised to Jewish people supposed to go? And if by forcibly expelling those people from their current homes is that not the same pain and violence that’s been inflicted on Jewish people? It makes it sound like one people are owed more rights than another people?
Who said they had to go anywhere? You do know that there was a proposal to share the land and no one would have to leave, right? You can learn more about it here: ua-cam.com/video/EDSxwh3uu9c/v-deo.html
The Jews agreed to it, the whole world voted in favor of it - and the Arabs instead waged war. They lost that war they started, and, like in most wars, refugees were created. You can learn more about that here: ua-cam.com/video/jB6IhmHYzWs/v-deo.html
Whose fault is that?
Based zionism vs cringe assimilation
Zionism *is* assimilation.
Rev 3:9
I am a Zionist. Am Yisrael Chai.
Yup....I'm a Zionist! Love the video!
I am proud to be a Jewish Zionist!!!
You hate yourself.
You're proud of killing Jesus?
Why u didn’t say anything about the ocupaciones and the greater Israel??
We will work to support the building of Zion.
I'm an American Christian, I believe God chose the Jews to be His people, and that they belong in the land of Canaan, that is now The nation of Israel. 🇮🇱
God bless Israel and the Jewish people. If that makes me a Zionist, I would gladly take that name with me forever 😇
I'm an American Christian too!!! And I believe that JESUS DIED FOR ALL PEOPLE, PALESTINIANS TOO!!! THEIR LAND HAS BEEN STOLEN AND THEY ARE BEING SLAUGHTERED!!! GOD sees the ATROCITIES!!! SHAME!!! NAKBA. Look up Former IDF Soldiers speaking out, called Breaking the Silence. Look up Dr. Norman Finkelstein! He's excellent! Look up Miko Peled! The General's Son. Look up the Nakba! Look up MAPS before 1948!! Look up pictures of Israel, BEFORE 1948!!
ציוני שלא מקיים את התנך, איזה ציוני הוא?
אתה מסביר יפה. ישר כח.
As long as I am alive it won't be.
Edit: Original title was "Is Zionism dead?" I guess I successfully persuaded Unpacked.
Won't be what?
@@alphadog3384 you feel like you achieved something now?
@@ShantyIrishmanhistory lesson.
I, too, will help keep Zionism alive.
@@drdonna4915 I took in my own way. Thank you.
Is this channel funded by AIPAC?
“If I don’t steal your house someone else will steal it”
The person who made that statement is undeniably stupid. However, it can not be ignored that Jews also lived on the land that constitutes the West Bank for thousands of years. It's true, they were expelled during different periods. For example, by the Romans in the 2nd century AC and by the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan in 1947. Therefore, they don't constitute a majority in that territory today.
Thus, I believe Jews have a right to live in the West Bank, but as long as it is done legally.
Because moving into a territory that is not self-recognized by Israel as a part of its country as an Israeli citizen without applying for residency there, is like a foreign citizen trying to enter another country illegally.
This case is more complicated because most Israeli citizens moved there when the West Bank had no foreign ruling authority and Still live in area C which has no foreign ruling authority. But it's still sketchy because it's like they are living in a no man's land with other people holding a different passport.
The case of Israel's rebirth and the movement of Israelis into the West Bank are two completely different things.
In the first case, Jews either lived there already or mostly moved there as refugees legally by receiving permanent residency and buying land. Whilst, in the second case, Israeli citizens move there Illegally(under the Geneva conversion).
Love the video Unpacked. I'm a European Nationalist and I also beleive that my native Sweden should be majority White and governed by Indigenous Whites. 🇪🇺🇸🇪❤️❤️🇮🇱
Zionist has only one God === Money💰💰💰
Anti semite
Wow bending the rules. What else can we expect from successors of the following:
The Israelites were required to strictly keep the Sabbath which meant that they may not engage in any worldly activity; they may not cook, nor make their slaves or cattle serve them. Those who violated these rules were to be put to death. The Israelites, however, publicly violated these rules. In the days of the Prophet Jeremiah (between 628 and 586 B.C.), the Israelites carried their merchandise through the gates of Jerusalem on the Sabbath day itself. Jeremiah, therefore, warned them that if they persisted in their flagrant violation of the Law, Jerusalem would be set on fire. (Jererniah 17: 21-7.) The same complaint is voiced in the Book of the Prophet Ezekiel (595-536 B.C.) who referred to their violation of the Sabbath rules as their major sin. (Ezekiel 20: 12-24.)
❤❤❤❤❤🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Ancestral homeland? I believe that honor goes to the darker skinned people living in the desert. You know, the non-chosen people who evolved to live there without skyrocketing rates of skin cancer.
Also, what about the non-zionist jews who publicly protest against it?
So far Haniyeh RIP
Deif RIP😂
God gave Israel to the Jews.
What is Zionism?
Its a form of ethnonationalism. And it comes with all of the problems of every other ethnonationalist movement. The closest comparison is to the Phalangists of Lebanon, if you know who those guys are.
I love your channel, thanks for great videos! I have learned a lot.
I'm a Zionist & ain't dead yet 😏 so Zionism isn't neither 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
it's over
Zionism is from the word - Zion, which means Jerusalem/Israel there's written text dating back the Babylonian exile of the Jews with referring to Zion that was a long time before political movement.
Hey brother I am a Muslim.
I like you argument I understand that Jewish people have been suffered a lot. That's why I argue that both parties the palestinians and the Jewish people have a right to their land. I understand that Jewish is discriminated thousands of years. And as for the Palestinian argument Palestinian wants their land because they also have no way to go. Currently Israel had 8 million Palestinian, they can go nowhere in the world. Similar to the Jews palestinians also won their land. That's why I support that two nation theory will be best in the situation. And Palestinian will accept two state theory completely I think. If they don't it have to be enforced to them. But if Israel zionist will not give the land to the palestinians which belongs to them before 1940. Then there is a massive problem. And Israel is not addressing that problem at all. The way Israel is being constructed Israeli people cannot be secular with the palestinians. Because history engraves phones right now. I accept that Israel should to support that their people. For the same reason I also want Palestinian state to exist. I am secular Muslim. You could judged that from my stand.
But right now what Israel is doing with palestinians in West Bank and Gaza it is not acceptable at all. Why don't you understand a simple thing. If you don't want to divide your country because nobody wants divide their country at all. Then they exist only one solution and that is of one state solution. And for one state solution to be a real solution you have to make it a lot neutral ideological grounds. The best solution will be two state. Or you can keep killing palestinians. It's you have to choose.
If you have any other solution in mind then please comment below me. You can see I am not against Israel. I just want that Palestinian Nations to exist so that palestinians are also happy. Both sides have to compromise a little. Peace and justice should be given to the both side. The things that Adolf did Israel is moving towards that.
I never understand Muslim and Jewish people are like 95% same in their religion. These two religions are so so so similar that many of the word seem similar. Then why this hatred and animosity was there.
We have to come to the common terms. I think human can solve any problem if they want to by talking. Bad condition is both side have to compromise.
Palestinians have 22 arab countries to go to
@@tfbrooks1668
That's not how it works. Israelis also us and uk to go to. 2 states solutions is the best possible solution according to my opinion.
this is better than my history classes
I raised my hand when they said " Raise you hands if your a Zionist" 😅Lol 😁