6 Failed Jewish States Before Israel | Unpacked
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лип 2024
- While many associate the idea of a Jewish state solely with modern Israel, history tells a tale of multiple attempts to establish Jewish states in locations as diverse as ancient Babylonia and Niagara Falls. Despite their differences in era and geography, each of these states shared a common fate-they never lasted.
Ultimately, these historical attempts underscore a profound truth: the quest for a Jewish state is as old as the Jewish people itself, but the enduring bond between the Jewish people and the Land of Israel is not just a matter of heritage, but of destiny; Israel is the only place where the vision of a Jewish homeland can, and has truly and permanently, taken root.
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:24 The ancient kingdoms: Ancient Babylonia
02:00 The ancient kingdoms: 5th century Arabia
03:09 The ancient kingdoms: Yemen
04:08 Ararat (Niagara Falls), New York, USA
06:09 Uganda, Africa
07:46 Birobidzhan (Siberia), Soviet Union
09:57 Lublin, Poland
10:39 Madagascar, Africa
12:45 The only place that has stuck: the State of Israel
Subscribe and turn on your notifications so you don’t miss future uploads!
ua-cam.com/users/UNPACKED?sub_...
Recommended video-10 Off-the-Grid Jewish Communities
• 10 Off-the-Grid Jewish...
We have merch! - shop.jewishunpacked.com/?...
Let’s connect:
Website - www.jewishunpacked.com
Instagram - / jewishunpacked
Twitter - / jewishunpacked
TikTok - / jewishunpacked
Facebook - / jewishunpacked
-----------
Image and footage credits:
David Rumsey Map Collection, David Rumsey Map Center, Stanford Libraries
© IWM WPN 219, © IWM IWM 84, © IWM AYY 1163
Un Topo por el Mundo
Yad VaShem
-----------
Executive Producer:
- Barry Skolnick
Co-Executive Producer:
- Shmuel Katz
-----------
Translation credits:
Portuguese: Saymon Pires, www.livrariasafra.com.br, @safralivraria
About Explainers: From ancient Jewish traditions to the modern State of Israel, we explain it all. Diving into anything and everything related to Jewish culture, history, and even religion.
Understand Jewish holidays, Israeli politics, Jewish diasporic communities, and more. Learn about Judaism in pop culture, debunking myths about Jews, and explore obscure Israeli landmarks. We’re asking questions as basic as “What is the Talmud?”, and as obscure as “How did hip-hop boost Kosher wine sales?”, and everything in between.
About Unpacked: We provide nuanced insights by unpacking all things Jewish. People are complex and complicated - yet we’re constantly being pushed to oversimplify our world. At Unpacked we know that being complex makes us more interesting. Because of this, we break the world down with nuance and insight to drive your curiosity and challenge your thinking.
#history #usa #africa
I guess Argentina was missed. There was a plan to construct a state there. It is well documented at Bochorov's writings.
Plan is still alive.
Plan is still alive and is a plan B just in case the israel from the middle-easr gets deleted from the map
Don't forget Ireland, and some others.
I heard they wanted to go back to Ukraine and that’s the real reason why Putin declared war on Ukraine. Because he didn’t want those terrorists right next door.
No such thing. Pure insanity.
Ethiopians weren't forced into Judaism, Axum empire was much bigger than any jew state
Judaism has not existed since the last Sanhedrin dissolved in the 5th century AD. You're talking about neo-rabbinicalism.
And Jews still claim to be native to the land
I'm neutral, but i can i request a video next:
Jewish communities that remained in the Land of Israel and never went into the diaspora
That's a good topic.
You mean the Palestinians who became Muslims ?
You mean the samaritans.
I visited the Jewish Autonomous Oblast of Birobidzhan in 2008. It still exists and some Jews still live there. It has a synagogue, a rabbi, a Jewish cultural centre, Jewish schools, signs in Yiddish using Hebrew letters, and various Jewish cultural monuments. It is an interesting place with beautiful scenery. Apart from Israel it is the only other official Jewish jurisdiction in the world. Its problem is its extreme remoteness. It took a 6 days train journey from Moscow to reach. I went there because it was my grandfather's dream to either live there or in Israel. He never managed to do either. I lived up to his dream by moving to and living in Israel for 6 years, and going to visit Birobidzhan when I went to Russia. I lived in Russia for a year.
How is there an entire "Jewish Autonomous Oblast" and only a few live there? Sounds criminal.
@@ArnaereThat's normal in Russia everywhere . No big deal in that country. Everything there is run on bribery and corruption. It is the norm for everybody.
It’s an uninhabitable shithole
You can easily go to occupied Palestinians whenever you want and move freely in and out, while millions of Palestinians who tried to escape nakba will never get a chance to even set foot in their homeland where they lived for generations.
Major problems with the story about Uganda.
Dangerous animals as a reason not to go there -- this is just silly. Organized people are no match for any animal. It is people who are truly dangerous.
Speaking about people, Masai live predominantly in Kenya and Tanzania. There are a few in Uganda, but not many. Surely their resistance was insignificant. So maybe it was some other people. Who knows.
The British colonists in Uganda were living very well at the time.
Uganda was declined simply because it wasn't historical Jewish land, so the hearts of the people didn't yearn for it.
It is historically apart of the real Israel and they know this thats why they wanted to move there…
I saw an algerian documentary showing there was a jewish kingdom in central algeria called Tamentit
There was also the quixotic efforts of the various socialist Bunds to develop autonomy within the areas of the European diaspora where they lived. These efforts, unlike Birobdizhan, at least had the distinction of being Jewish efforts. But none of them succeeded, and after the Shoah Bundism became little more than a poorly remembered ohase in Jewish history.
Being a New Yorker, I grew up around Jewish Communites and worked once for the UJA Federation in NYC. Love good NYC bagels and lox! Some good insights, again I learned something new
Do bagels really make up for be centuries of war crimes though?
It wasn’t Uganda.. it’s present day Kenya in the Rift Valley region
You forgot about the Kingdom of Semien
Yes , Ethiopians jews reigned for more than 300 years
You didnt mentioned the sefarad in Spain that lead technicallybto a sort of holocoust for us. I guess with Birovidzhan you meant the Oblast, right? Oblast still exist and its still very jew
Wow, I only knew about the Uganda plan, Birobidzhan and Madagascar 🙏
so the promised land depends on what land they managed to occupy
Bingo!!! It changes every few thousand years.... In a few centuries itll be Mars
Actual fact you brought here, their promised land is the land that can be occupied .
@@gabequezada2066 and am all here for their madness 😂
@@decidedby786 so the writers promised it to themselves?😂😂😅😂😂😂
@@gabequezada2066 Exactly. Its a script (SCRIPTure). Its all bullshi*
Aren't you forget Khazar Khaganate?
Yes .. Khazars of Khaganate, not of Palestine!
The Khazar elite converted to Judaism. Whether a significant amount of the masses also converted is an entirely different question.
Please can I get the materials and brief regards this presentation,
You can see the credits in the description. What exactly are you looking for?
I always thought that a Jewish state in New York would make sense given the high Jewish population there. I'm surprised that there had been one there in the past. This was a very interesting video.
There is a city / village depending on your definition that is largely Hasidic Jewish
The area in New York State in question is much closer to Toronto, Canada, and to Cleveland than to New York City or even Albany. In this context, it's crucial to distinguish New York City from New York State. While New York City has lots of Jews (and indeed has the highest Jewish population in the diaspora), New York State much above the Catskills (anywhere from Albany to Plattsburgh to Jamestown) has far far far fewer Jews.
That ended badly.
These are your best videos!!!👍👍
You missed out Argentina, 1889. What an amazing omission!
Crazy mythic belief systems produce crazy results.
The Jewish state in Himyar lasted about 135 years. The kingdom of Simien in Ethiopia existed almost 200 years. The state of Israel is just shy of 76 years old. What makes you so sure it will last longer than it's ancient predecessors? The fact that it's located in the historic home of the nation?! Well so was the Hashmonean kingdom, which lasted only 77 years. I'm pessimistic about the chances of Israel to outlive me, unless I'll also be sloughtered as many of my people.
It wasn't a state in Himyar and Ethiopia.
That was a good video, lots of great information, not too keen on the propaganda at the end though.
The Khazar Khaganate is complicated But it didn't fall quickly. The traditional date for the conversion of at least some of their nobility was 740 CE with 860 CE being an alternate date. Either way, they last it is an Empire until 967 CE and the last Khazar polity was destroyed in 1016 CE although it was led by a Christian.
what about argentina???
how about the N a z that arrive there with false vaticave passports?
@@lizbethartemis4886 Nazis and Zionists. Perfect fit.
And then there was that Baron’s buying up tracts of land in Argentina that many Jews moved to.
That is fake , read and investigate
Actually, it's true. I was born in Buenos Aires but my mother and her parents were all born in La Pampa, Argentina. They lived on lands purchased by Baron Hirsch. I believe it was my great-greatparents (or even their parents) who came from Eastern Europe circle 1850-1890 to work that land, forming a company to export their produce to local consumers.
Lots of the Argentinian Jewish community shares this story.
30K Hungarian jews moved there.
There wasn't even a Babylonia in the first century. It was a part of the Parthian empire.
Thank you.
There was a jewish queen called Yodit in ancient ethiopia, she destroyed most of the city of Axum
Yodit was treated horribly by the church and came back for revenge
WHat about Khazar khaganate?
This is beyond saddening how they treat another human being just bc of their religion.
I still do not understand the need to create a “religious state.”
Luke 6:31 - treat all like you want to be treated …
@@lizbethartemis4886Israel is NOT a religious state, it's secular. Jews are first and foremost an ethnic group, probably the most ethnic group in the world.
Who’s they
@@McGoogger Israel OBVIOUSLY
Maasai in Uganda?
The state of Israel that was once proposed to be established outside the Promised Land failed miserably. 8 proposals to establish the State of Israel in various parts of the world, each as follows:
1820 Virginia, Ararat city (USA)
1903 Uganda “Scheme” (Italian colony at that time)
1940 Guiana (Italian colony at that time)
1928 Russia (Autonomous Oblast/Jewish Autonomous Oblast)
1930 Japan (Fugu Plan)
1938 Madagascar (Madagascar Plan)
1938 Australia (Port Davey)
1936 Ethiopia
It was also recorded that The State of Judea - many Israeli settlers in the West Bank are considering declaring independence as the State of Judea if Israel withdraws from the West Bank. In January 1989, several hundred activists met and announced their intention to create such a state if Israel withdrew from the region.
The right name to use is Judea and Samaria not West Bank.
Galveston, Texas scheme - some 10,000 Jews relocated between 1907-14
Not to mention the Saramacca scheme in Suriname just after WWII.
What, on earth, are your sources, especially for the first few?
not that hard to find it just google it
they are gods chosen people,they don't need sources,whatever they say you have to believe it no matter what,otherwise you're anti semitic
So fascinating, thank you
I’m ashamed to say this is the first time I’ve heard of the first three you mentioned. Keep up your good work✡️🇮🇱
Same here
You should be more ashamed of that flag
Learn your history. I probably know more than you do about your own history.
At the beginning that was during the time of the Parthian Empire.
Why do some orthodox Jewish groups say jewish people are in axial till the messah comes?
Because that's their belief. According to Jewish faith, when the "Geula" (salvation) will come, with the messiah at its end, the Jews will come to Israel. But it never specify what is Geula and when it will come. Many Jews believe it's already here, in the process. Many also believe that they should actively work to bring Geula and the messiah. It's a long conflict that dates back to the creation of Zionism. Also there's atheist Jews who don't care about all that.
The video confuses New York City (where the largest Jewish population in the entire diaspora is located) with Upstate New York, where the Ararat colony was located. In fact, that part of New York State is in Western New York, far away from New York City and pretty close to Toronto and Cleveland.
Jewish people and the land of Israel is one. There is no other place in the world that can be Jewish state. It was all autonomies. So stop confusing ppl with your misleading narratives.
Oh ..Yes .. Khazars of Khaganate, not of Palestine!
Don't forget the mighty Turkic Jewish state of Khazaria in the 8th century
It's not Turkic .. just Khazars
When i visted Israel for the first time this past January i could feel a special connection to the land
I cant imagine id feel that if i had gone to Madagascar and i certainly didnt feel it when i was at Niagara falls lol
When I spent a year living in Israel in 2022-2023, I met a 93-year-old woman who said: "Eretz Israel doesn't belong to us, we belong to Eretz Israel. This is our people's eternal home."
Israel is indeed the only Jewish home we need.
@@diegoflores9237 Sounds like you skipped all your Ancient Near-East history classes. 🙂
@@diegoflores9237 I would rather die than stay in soviet occupied eastern Europe
Oh No. So the Zionists Wanted to Steal Some Other Lands Too. Shocking
@@jonl3696stfu your ancient history by your logic Roman Empire belongs to Nigeria, because Roman Empire is Christian and Nigeria is Christian du-mbass Just by being Jewish you have no rights in an ancient jewish land while having Polish dna, closest people to ancient Israelites are Samarites, Druze, Palestinian Arabs, Lebanese Arabs, Middle eastern Jews, Assyrians, Iraqis and Syrians none else, not some Ethiopian German Yiddish and Spanish Jews
@@user-hr9ce3zb3xthat’s your homeland my brother not Palestine, not Israel
❤❤❤great video
Is they we’re concerned about the Masai people but not the Palestinian people hopefully, soon the failed state of Israel will be added to this list
They were concerned about the Palestinians, but when the latter started killing them they were more concerned about staying alive.
So you want to say, that maybe just maybe the problem is that people don't like to be replaced by a settler colonial state?
You mean the Arabs from Arabia of course 🙄
Thanks
Why not live together with other ethnicities rather than trying to grab real-estate all over the world. There are many ethnicities and unique religious sects who don't have a separate country and they still co exist peacefully most of the time with other ethnicities, especially in Asia, Europe, South America and the middle east.
Which major world religions don’t have a country where they are a majority? Which groups that have been around for 3,000+ years, and who’ve undergone the persecution the Jews have, don’t have a count in which they are a majority?
@@UNPACKED having a state before the arrival of the messiah is against Judaism
@@UNPACKEDjews don't deserve a country.
Is saying that anti Jewish?
It's the same with saying kurds don't deserve a country.
Why do you think your special?
Victim mentality, narcissistic
@walkerjobe6964 Are you Jewish? Because if not, please don't make statements about what is against Judaism, especially when it's false.
I'm curious where you live, and what gives that country the right to exist? Saying that every current country deserves to exist except for the one Jewish country, which has more ancient roots than pretty much any of them -- yep, that's anti-Jewish
@@UNPACKED zionists are hilarious, you do not even follow Judaism.
You don't even grow your beard, yo cut your hair in a wrong way.
Yet, you want be called Jewish
Is it just me or is this video incredibly biased
How so?
dehydration, starvation?
Why do religions need a state?
I mean if you can live in a country where all religions are respected, do you need your own state?
Add to that the fact that you already come from a country (probably in Europe) where you speak the language and your ancestors have lived for a thousand years.
Again, why the need for a Jewish state?
Religion alone is not a good enough reason...
Jews are not a religion. There's atheists Jews. Jews is a race. And any race, any ethnicity have a natural right to self determination in any way they please.
@@itaiharshoshanim-ib6kpKurds don't
@@UA-cam..Enjoyer
Why not? Everyone do. Of course you can't destroy the other's right to a state in order to get your own, but you can compromise, and Israel are trying to do that.
@@itaiharshoshanim-ib6kp So if the kurds now start to attack Iraq and seize 70% of the land, that would be justified according to you?
@@UA-cam..Enjoyer
No because that would be destroying the other's right to a state. What would be ok is to try and get to a compromise like a two state solution or a two ethno state.
And what did Israel is not that either. Palestine was never a country. It was a region that consisted of Jews and Arabs, and both wanted a state. But unlike the Jews who were ready to compromise, the Arabs wanted it all, and starting attacking the Jews, trying to ethnically cleanse them of the region. And as you said yourself, that's not justifiable.
All truth! 💙💙💙
I love the video but there has never been any “masai” community in Uganda. Next time do some good research before naming any tribes in Africa.
Guys.... I love the Jews okay If I could, I'd invite them to live in my backyard but Uganda?😂 Like how does that make sense 🤣?
Because part of North Uganda was controlled by Ancient Israel. G-d told Abraham that Israel will start in the Nile River of Egypt. The white Nile River starts in Uganda.
@@MiguelDLewisOf course the magic man from the sky conveniently told the people that believe in him that they own all the land.
Disgusting
@@alucardhellsing7435 That's where they were born first of all, so of course they own the land. And "Magic Man" is a strawman fallacy. Without God, there is no objective morality. Imperialism and colonialism are morally good by your standard.
@@MiguelDLewis imperialism and colonialism u say. Do I have to say anything? Anyone who will read this comment will laugh at what u said. Stop killing children and move on to peace. askheNAZI
@@alucardhellsing7435 jealous? 😎
You might want to research your history ...
Long before the involvement of the Aksum Empire, after conversion to Judaism, the Himyarites expelled pagans and tolerated Christians.
It was when Christian persecution elevated that the Aksum empire became involved.
The Himyarite/Aksum conflict brought allies, from the region, to both sides.
Ironically, close to a century later, an Arab (whose ancestors were pagan) tried to compromise the evolving states of Jewish and Christian beliefs and Islam was born.
Khrob khun mah khrap 🙏
This youtuber talks as if his telling children a bed time story. The audacity to tell convoluted truth is quite annoying.
Do this history match the biblical history?
You have forgotten the Jewish state in historical Nomedia (modern-day Algeria). The last Nomedian Monarch was Queen Dehia (The Kahena) a Jewess who fought the Arab invasion to the Maghreb region. The oldest synagogue in Africa is in the Sahara of Algeria. The Jews there came after the destruction of the temple and many Amazigh tribes AKA Judeo Berber, converted to Judaism. She was a Queen and a warrior who died in battle after years of keeping the Arabs at bay, they had to prepare 5 years to try her again. Unfortunately with her fall in battle North Africa and Spain were invaded. She was loved by her people who still to this day hold her dear, hated by her enemies who did not allow her a burial, took her severed head to Damascus and threw her body in a well. Algerians still visit that well in remembrance of their Queen. That is a state and a Queen that should be remembered. It would be great if you can do an episode on that part of the forgotten history.
Khazaria?
I think it was better that they would have choose Madagascar which might have avoided crazy blood war going on. Plus the Madagascar would be much more developed with the help of Jewish settlers.
Just a random thought.
But Madagascar is not the ancestral and eternal Jewish homeland 🤷♂️
@@UNPACKED I understand, but still - as far as I know, jews needed a state of their own to protect themself from persecution which I guess was top priority than returning to the ancestral land.
Why go to for ancestral lands which then arabs ruled and claimed the land for hundreds of years? You know they will give you a tough time, so instead go to the place where resistance is minimum.
ofc this is hypothetical scenario, but the thought process of choosing the location could be better.
It's a good question you're asking. And actually the Jewish people did almost go with Uganda - you can learn about that here: ua-cam.com/video/ldlXYFMn48g/v-deo.html
But the point of Zionism is not just to escape persecution, it's also to build a flourishing Jewish civilization in the ancestral Jewish homeland.
In terms of opposition: since the 1920s, the land of Israel wasn't ruled by Arabs, but by the British. And for hundreds of years earlier it was ruled by the Ottomans but not as Palestine nor as a particular focus of that colonial empire. But also just because some colonialist empire occupies a land doesn't mean that the indigenous people should give up on their 2,000 year old dreams!
@@UNPACKED Thanks for the reference video. The reason all the Jewish communities were united was ancestral homeland. 'What ifs' are tantalizing 😅
Abu karbia still thought like a Muslim if he converted people, this is not what Jews do
Muslims didn't even exist then, Einstein
all very interesting until the last 2 sentences hahahah
🇮🇱🎉
المعنى الاصح لعنوان الفيديو السرقة والارهاب بطريقة قانونية😂🖕🏻
🇵🇸💙🇱🇾
Ancient jews/ hebrews were invested in the idea of paying 'interest' when trading, which many other ancient societies and cultures frowned upon. This belief stuck throughout many civilization thtouout the years. This is why so many failed states after. But in current times interest is more prevelant and growing due to increase in mutual greed of capitalist elites / governing bodies. Ancient arab/ muslim states said no to interest but tax was allowed. However, back then tax money actually benefited everyone living in the state. Ancient Muslim/ arab state was the only state to have all three religions christians, judaism, and islam living and functioning together in unison for nearly 500 years.
As long as Islam ruled supreme, non Muslims were tolerated. The Dhimmi tax was more of a “protection racket”
Mafia movie 2:23😁
This video has just described tribalism which is what is still happening today
Beautiful video. Thank you so much for this!
Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱
*_The establishment of the state of Israel_*
This is the product of the founding of Israel in 1948 through the forcible expulsion of Palestine’s existing Arab population and of the three-quarters of a century of brutality and mass murder that followed.
The non-binding vote at the United Nations General Assembly in November 1947 urging partition, and a Jewish state on Palestinian land alongside a Palestinian state, was the result of the machinations of rival powers determined to maintain control over such an important geostrategic area. It played on and manipulated the enormous public sympathy for the European Jews who had suffered so terribly at the hands of Nazi Germany and now found themselves denied entry to the West.
One of the most cynical elements of Zionist and imperialist propaganda is that Israel is routinely declared to be the “only democracy” in the Middle East. But its founding, in an already existing country, where Jews, even after mass immigration, constituted just one-third of the population in 1947, could never be achieved democratically.
Israel’s own historians, using the state archives, have documented the crimes carried out by the political antecedents of the gang of far-right nationalists, religious bigots, and former generals running the country today. Netanyahu’s Likud party is the political heir of the Irgun, whose leader Menachem Begin was prime minister from 1977 to 1983, and the Stern Gang, led by Yitzhak Shamir who became prime minister in 1983. These terrorist gangs waged a brutal war on the Palestinians and British officials during the period after World War I, when Britain ruled Palestine under a League of Nations Mandate. They killed several thousand Palestinians in a roughly 30-year period up to 1948, resulting in the retaliatory deaths of 1,300 Jews.
The massacre at Deir Yassin in April 1948, where more than 200 men, women and children were slaughtered, is one of the best-known examples. Historian Benny Morris explains in his ground-breaking book The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem 1947-49 that this was one of the most important factors in “precipitating the flight of Arab villagers from Palestine.” Between November 1947 and the end of the British Mandate in May 1948, more than 375,000 Palestinians became refugees, driven out by a combination of force, atrocities and a campaign of terror including killings.
The war that broke in May 1948 between Israel and its Arab neighbours after David Ben Gurion, Israel’s premier, declared the establishment of the state of Israel led to the deaths of some 13,000 Palestinians, twice the number of Israelis killed, as well as an estimated 3-7,000 soldiers from Egypt, Syria, Jordan and Iraq. Israel denied uprooted Palestinians the right to return to their homes, forcing most to eke out a wretched existence in refugee camps in the Gaza Strip, the West Bank, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria. Largely denied citizenship in the Arab states, except in Jordan, they and their descendants became registered refugees. Many now live elsewhere in the Middle East, while others have moved to the West.
Ben Gurion himself encouraged the Haganah-the forerunner of the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) and largely under the control of the Histadrut/Mapai Party, later to become the Labour Party-to expel the Palestinians from their homes. There are at least 31 confirmed massacres-including the horrific massacre in October 1948 by a Haganah batallion made up of former Irgun and Lehi forces-of between 100 and 120 Palestinians in the village of al-Dawayima, near the southern city of Hebron. A soldier who witnessed the events, part of the IDF’s Operation Yoav (October 15-22, 1948), explained, “There was no battle and no resistance. The first conquerors killed 80 to 100 Arab men, women and children. The children were killed by smashing their skulls with sticks. There wasn’t a house without people killed in it.”
No one was charged with the massacre. According to the United Nations Refugee Relief Project, the Gaza Strip’s refugee population rose from 100,000 to 230,000, due to the ethnic cleansing of the southern region.
By the end of the war, only about 200,000 out of 1,157,000 Palestinians recorded in a 1947 British census remained in the parts of Palestine that became Israel. The takeover of Palestinian-owned land was even more dramatic. In 1946, Jews had owned less than 12 percent of the land in what became Israel; this rose to 77 percent after the 1948-49 war when the Israeli government enacted the Abandoned Property Ordinance to take control of the property of Palestinians who were expelled or fled.
Founded on terrorism and ethnic cleansing, Israel could only sustain its twin policies of expulsion and dispossession through constant repression and warfare. Ben Gurion’s Labour imposed military rule until 1966 on those Palestinians who remained in Israel and became citizens. This was only months before imposing military rule on the newly occupied West Bank Palestinians that has continued ever since.
The IDF repeatedly fought one-sided battles with Palestinians who sought to return to their former homes or visit their families after 1949, with Ariel Sharon’s Qibya massacre in 1956 that killed 69 Palestinians one of the most notorious. Between 1949 and 1967, the Fedayeen war between Israel on the one hand and Egyptian armed forces and Palestinian militants on the other killed between 2,800 and 5,000 Palestinians, around four times the number of Israelis killed.
In June 1967, Israel used President Gamal Abdul Nasser’s expulsion of UN forces from the Gaza Strip, which Egypt controlled, and Sharm el Sheikh, where they were guarding the Straits of Tiran, and the closing of the Straits to Israeli shipping to launch a pre-emptive but long-planned strike against Egypt. An estimated 20,000 Arab soldiers lost their lives, compared to less than 1,000 Israeli deaths.
During the five-day war, Israel seized Syria’s Golan Heights, the Jordanian-controlled West Bank and East Jerusalem, which it annexed, and Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula, as well as the Egyptian-occupied Gaza Strip. It forced another 250,000-325,000 of the 900,000 Palestinians in the Jordanian-controlled West Bank to flee to Jordan and 100,000 Syrians to flee to Syria.
The 1967 war was to lead to another war in October 1973, when Egypt and Syria launched a surprise military attack-ultimately unsuccessful-on Israel aimed at securing the return of the Israeli-occupied lands. Their defeat was to result in Egypt’s signing a peace agreement with Israel and the abandonment by all the Arab bourgeois regimes of any support for the Palestinians.
The 1967 defeat of the Arab armies created the conditions for Yasser Arafat and his Fatah organisation, with its commitment to achieving a Palestinian state through armed struggle, to take the leadership of the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). This began a vastly unequal military struggle between Israel, armed to the teeth and supported politically and diplomatically by US imperialism, and the Palestinians, now isolated and abandoned by the Arab regimes.
Source: *_Israel and the Palestinians: A state founded on dispossession and ethnic cleansing; Jean Shaoul_*
Those are the facts that modern day Israel is purposefully not admitting to, and allowing the world to know through control of msm.
Perfectly said. People of every background, especially Christians, need to know what you just posted. It explains why Menachem begin himself said he and Israel were the world's greatest terrorist state. Keep telling the truth.
And remember people, Israel is made of 12 tribes, not just the tribe of Judah.
There was a time that the Philippines offered the island of Mindanao or at least a part of it for Jews.
Imagine Israel and Philippines neighbors 🥰 I am sure China wouldn’t bully us with Israel having our backs 👍
China wouldn't be able to bully the Philippines if that happened because the Filipino population would have been displaced into tiny strips of land and the colonists would have denied the Filipino right to statehood.
Be glad that you have a country that can be irritated by Chinese fishing vessels entering your territorial waters. There are much worse things in the world than that and you only have to look at Gaza for an example.
Judaism is a religion among the other religions we don't need a state.
Wasn't there an American J secretary- of - state during Jimmy Carter. Her name Mandilyn Ohara..maybe..She jokes about trouble Israel has w neighbors. Saying they Js should move to American Midwest lol...
Thank god they skipped Africa, otherwise it would be a war against Sub Saharan Africa and their descendants Jews and African Americans relationship would be a nightmare in America.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
ill minded IL supporter
Thank you very interesting. Well this is why Israel is 100% A Jewish home. Christians stand with Israel 💙🤍💙🤍🇮🇱
Israelis can be pretty hostile to Christian clergy, which is understandable given how anti-semitism was promoted by the church.
Stand with the ones to feel superior than you.
Christians stand with the true jews absolutely
@@aubriellemorganSo, not Israel.
Sounds like a pattern is forming here. Perhaps Israel should have studied and learned from history. Then they wouldn't be repeating it.
In Islam, there's no religion other than Islam. All prophets came to this earth till Muhammad, PBUH. THEY ALL MUSLIMS. Don't twist.
The people of Uganda weren’t happy about them taking their land??
Imagine how the Palestinians feel
The Palestinians have a state. It is called Jordan.
What about the kazars the belived in jewdaism
Yeah try building a state on your own land! 😉
Israel fina become the seventh.
Inshallah
They needed to take palestine bc it made it easier to implement their yinon plan
"The only Jewish land we need" - Long live Israel
Need is one thing, want is another. Why are so many here in America?
@@dmurphy5689 Because they are Americans! and you??
@@sainta2667 Im an American, who doesnt buy into the indoctrinated chosenite bs. Its a hoodwink. Anyone supporting genocide is evil. When karma comes knocking, dont cry about it.
@@sainta2667 Says a lot when jews (specifically those not working towards the agenda) would rather live here, than that hellhole. The Greater Israel Project is about destruction. The West has been on the hit list for a very long time. If America goes, its a wrap. Nothing but misery, afterwards.
@@sainta2667 I did reply back. Of course my comment was deleted. Free speech is hated by the lying c0mmun!st frauds.
I propose a new area for the final settlement of Jews. Hokkaido, the northern island of Japan is sparsely populated. Hokkaido has huge fertile land, many popular winter resort destinations, and there are sunny days in winter without any snowfall. It's a great place to settle without having to displace local inhabitants.
Jews in Israel are actually native to the land and decolonized the place. So I propose you learn to deal with it, otherwise you will intoxicate by your own poison.
So if people just got their act together with the New York thing you might have avoided the Palestinian murder-sprees?
And you even acknowledge that the locals in Uganda wouldn't like being occupied by foreign settlers 🤔
*6 Places huh*
It's almost as if that magical number six just seems to attach itself to everything "Hebrew" related.
Y'all should do a video on how many times the number six seems to pop up in y'all's history.😊
Even the israel flag has the “666” hexagram on it.
7th time is the charm 🇮🇱
I feel like this is symbolic of something.
And God said "You shall not flush your meds down the toilet."
@@Vorname_Nachnahme he never said that stop blaspheming and you got ratioed big L
@@yamiscape Well, it was ironic/sarcastic. I'm well aware that God doesn't exist and is a made up phantastic entity by people who want to implement a parallel justice/justification-system here on earth/in reality. Like Israel: *_"God gave us, God told us, God wants us to [...]"_* ,the typical aggressor's speech to justify his crimes ...
@@Vorname_Nachnahme Why are you even on this channel if you do not believe in God. Stop trolling. If you had God in your life, then it would actually have some purpose, rather than just soulless absurdism.
@@yamiscape The one who is "trolling" is basically You, because your "argumentation" is utilizing phantastic elements like 'God' and happenings in phantasy books like the 'Bible', while me is just simply using arguments which are real world entities or backed up by evidence.
Coz ur not the real Hebrew from the bible
Yes he is, DNA proves it.
Dhu Nuwas was a horrible jew
They promosed land.was Israle
the fact that we’re not even asking for more land than israel and yet people still call us colonisers evil terrorists is crazy , lol
The best proof is that isreal gave land back to eygpt (old rich land too!)
All this is the product of the founding of Israel in 1948 by the violent expulsion of the resident Arab population and the subsequent three-quarters of a century of brutality and mass murder.
A non-binding vote in the UN General Assembly in November 1947 called for a division: Next to the state of Palestine, a Jewish state was to be created on Palestinian soil. This was the result of the machinations of rival powers determined to retain control of a geostrategically important area. It used and manipulated the enormous sympathy of the population for the fate of the European Jews who had suffered so terribly under Hitler’s Germany and who were denied entry into the West.
A particularly cynical element of Zionist and imperialist propaganda is the repeated claim that Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East. But its founding - within an already existing state, in which the Jews constituted only one third of the population in 1947 despite mass immigration - would never have been possible with democratic means.
Israeli historians who had access to the state archives have documented the crimes of the political forerunners of today’s ruling gang of far-right nationalists, religious fanatics and former generals. Netanyahu’s party Likud is the political heir to Irgun, whose party leader Menachem Begin was prime minister from 1977 to 1983, and the lechi ("star gang"), whose leader Yitzhak Shamir became prime minister in 1983. These terrorist gangs waged a brutal war against the Palestinians and British officials in the post-World War I period, when Britain ruled Palestine under a League of Nations mandate. In the approximately 30 years to 1948, they murdered several thousand Palestinians, whereupon 1,300 Jews were murdered in retaliation.
The massacre of Deir Yasin in April 1948, in which more than 200 men, women and children were murdered, is one of the best known examples. In his groundbreaking book "The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem 1947-49", historian Benny Morris explains that this was one of the most important factors for the escape of Arab villagers from Palestine. Between November 1947 and the end of the British mandate in May 1948, more than 375,000 Palestinians were displaced by a mixture of violence, atrocities and terror, including murder.
The war between Israel and its Arab neighbors, which broke out in May 1948 after Prime Minister David Ben Gurion proclaimed the founding of the State of Israel, led to the deaths of about 13,000 Palestinians - twice as many as Israelis - and about 3,000 to 7,000 Egyptian, Syrian, Jordanian and Iraqi soldiers. Israel denied displaced Palestinians the right to return to their homes and forced most of them to live miserably in refugee camps in the Gaza Strip, the West Bank, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria. In the Arab states except Jordan, they were largely denied citizenship, so that they and their descendants became registered refugees. Many now live in other Middle Eastern states, others have moved to the West.
Ben Gurion himself encouraged the Haganah, the predecessor organization of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), to expel the Palestinians from their homes. The Hagana was largely under the control of the parties Histadrut and Mapai (precursor party of the social democratic Awoda). There were at least 31 confirmed massacres, including the terrible massacre in October 1948, in which a battalion of Haganah from former Irgun and Lechi members murdered between 100 and 120 Palestinians in the village of al-Dawayima near the southern Israeli city of Hebron. A soldier following the events of IDF Operation Yoav (October 15-22, 1948) said, There was no battle and no resistance. The first conquerors killed 80 to 100 Arab men, women and children, and their skulls were smashed with sticks. There was not a single house where people were not killed."
No one was ever charged with the massacre. According to the United Nations Refugee Relief Project, the number of refugees in the Gaza Strip increased from 100,000 to 230,000 due to ethnic cleansing in the southern region.
At the end of the war, of the 1,157,000 Palestinians recorded in a British census in 1947, only about 200,000 were left in parts of Palestine that became Israel. The takeover of Palestinian land was even more dramatic, with Jews owning less than 12 percent of the land in later Israel in 1946. After the war of 1948-1949, this share rose to 77 percent. The Israeli government had passed a law on abandoned property to take control of the property of displaced or refugee Palestinians.
Since Israel was founded on the basis of terrorism and ethnic cleansing, it could only maintain its policy of expulsion and expropriation through constant oppression and warfare. Ben Gurions Awoda (Labour Party) imposed military rule over the Palestinians who remained in Israel and became citizens until 1966. Only a few months later, Awoda placed the occupied West Bank under military rule, which continues to this day.
The IDF repeatedly engaged in unilateral fighting with the Palestinians who wanted to return to their former homes or visit their families after 1949. Particularly notorious is Ariel Sharon’s 1956 Qibya massacre, which killed 69 Palestinians. Between 1949 and 1967, between 2,800 and 5,000 Palestinians were killed during the Fedayin War between Israel and Egyptian forces and militant Palestinians - about four times as many as Israelis.
No one was ever charged with the massacre. According to the United Nations Refugee Relief Project, the number of refugees in the Gaza Strip increased from 100,000 to 230,000 due to ethnic cleansing in the southern region.
In June 1967, President Gamal Abdul Nasser expelled the UN troops from the Egyptian-controlled Gaza Strip and Sharm el-Sheikh, where they guarded the Strait of Tiran, and blocked this route for Israeli shipping. Israel used this to launch a long-planned pre-emptive strike against Egypt. An estimated 20,000 Arab soldiers lost their lives, compared to less than 1,000 Israeli deaths.
During the five-day war, Israel occupied the Syrian Golan Heights, the Jordan-controlled West Bank and East Jerusalem, which it annexed, as well as the Egyptian peninsula of Sinai and the Gaza Strip previously occupied by Egypt. It forced another 250,000 to 325,000 of the 900,000 Palestinians in the Jordanian-controlled West Bank to flee to Jordan and 100,000 Syrians to flee to Syria.
The 1967 war led to another war in October 1973, when Egypt and Syria undertook a surprising and ultimately unsuccessful military attack on Israel to achieve the return of the territories occupied by Israel. Their defeat resulted in Egypt signing a peace agreement with Israel and the Arab bourgeois regimes abandoning any support for the Palestinians.
The 1967 war led to another war in October 1973, when Egypt and Syria undertook a surprising and ultimately unsuccessful military attack on Israel to achieve the return of the territories occupied by Israel. Their defeat resulted in Egypt signing a peace agreement with Israel and the Arab bourgeois regimes abandoning any support for the Palestinians.
The defeat of the Arab armies in 1967 created the conditions for Yasser Arafat and his Fatah organization, which sought a Palestinian state through an armed struggle, to lead the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) could take over. This marked the beginning of an extremely unequal military conflict between Israel, armed to the teeth by US imperialism and supported politically and diplomatically, and the Palestinians, now isolated and abandoned by the Arab regimes.
Source: *_'A state founded on expropriation and ethnic cleansing'; Jean Shaoul_*
If it was your family that was included in the 30,000+ killed I’m sure you’d see it as evil and colonizing as well. It’s all about perspective…since it doesn’t affect your daily life you view it differently than innocent civilians sleeping in tents 🏕️ going through it because their home was bombed.
@@harpersworld6549 nobody is downplaying the fact that loss of innocent human life is a tragedy. If you believe that number, you have to remember 12,000+ were militarized terrorists. My heart goes out to those now living in tents, but what do you propose as a more ideal way of defeating the terrorists who are hiding amongst civilians and have been misusing their resources for 20 years?
No more innocents should suffer under the rule of H*m*s
@@harpersworld6549 12,000 were h*m*s terrorists
Pray for Israel.
More like Pay for Israel more. Cuz that's the only reason they have the balls to break international laws time and again.
Wtf is wrong with u guys
Why?
Propaganda
What kind of Jew are you bro?
Thief?
@@Vorname_Nachnahme
Gypsy Jew? 😆
The eternal search for the promised land, the kingdom of heaven is within you.
This one will also fail because Judaism a religion and not a nationality. You cannot create a state at the expense of another people.
Jews are an ethnoreligion , just like hindus and some native american tribes .
@@KougarManx468 Really so the blue eyed light haired azkanazki and the brown middle eastern jews are the same ethnicity? Or the mountain jews in the caucuas mountains? or the central asian Bukharan Jews or the black ethiopian jews? They only thing they share is religion. They are not the same ethnicity.
Jews is an ethnicity. There's atheist Jews.
@@gwejay Yeah and there's DNA researches that prove it.
DONT MENTION THE CHAZARDS 🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐👿
Can anyone name one thing Palestinians have ever said that is not a lie?
@@wavechapelle7896 Palestine originally included Jordan.. the Arabs got their part (Jordan) and the Jews were supposed to get theirs.. but the Arabs were greedy and lost almost everything. Even Judea and Samaria and Gaza did not belong to Israel at first.. The Arabs lost it in the war they started.
@@wavechapelle7896yes and wnna k o why ? Because of the Greeks and the Roman’s the Jews in hat land didn’t call it “Palestine” it was always Israel and before that it was called Canaan. Which had multiple kingdoms Israel being the largest at its peak there existed no “Palestinian” people or kingdom. Never in its history was it ever sovereign
@@wavechapelle7896yeah by the British Empire even the Arabs didn't call it that back then
❤
@@Stoicsaiyanit was Judea when the Romans took power. After the uprising, the Romans named it Syria-Palastinia. I get what you are saying but Israel had ceased to be an autonomous state long before. Judea is where the term Jew came from.
As we can see Israel failed also...🥺
First
rude