Palestine Talks | In conversation with Rabbi Shapiro (Part 1)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro discusses the origins of Zionism and how, contrary to prevailing Western views, it is fundamentally opposed to Judaism.
#PalestineTalks #zionism
Subscribe:
trt.world/subsc...
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
Twitter: trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/insta...
Visit our website: trt.world
From hearing and seeing the entitlement /propaganda attitude of Zionist in LA, this helps explain so much!
I would take Zionism over islamic nationalism any day of the week
Great and simple way of explaining how zionisim was created, really enjoyed watching this interview 👌
The way the Rabbi speaks of Judaism and how it is more than just like saying they believe in God , deen Islam is the same and many do not realize this. He is correct when he says it governs our lives because it is whole lifestyle. Very very informative thank you
This is brilliant! Thank you, Rabbi Shapiro.
He clarified so many points I didn’t understand before.
Seen a few of Rabbi Shapiro’s talks, and he always makes obvious the ridiculousness of Israel as an Idea, and the position of Judaism to it.
I see Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro, I click.
He is the Noam Chomsky on Zionism. No one I have watched yet comes close to explaining Zionism than Rabbi Yaakov.
@@den264 💯
@@Aiel-NecromancerChomsky is secular Jewish and has many similar views to Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro, but Chomsky is more of a US critic which is why he critiques Israel as well
And the ancient Hebrew Israelites were black all of them were black
@@b.m168 depends on where they came from. prophet abraham from Babylon (present day iraq) people from that region is brown and mosas was black. the native living there before Abraham migrated to the land, was canaanites, a dna which palestinian still carry to this day according various study. edit: mosas was from the darkest (skin color) tribe according to islamic history and hadith.
The kind of saphiro we need
Yes 😂
You can keep him, we don't need him.
@@gaulishrealist Of course and with pleasure. There's no place for his ilk in a genocidal terrorist state.
@@gaulishrealistzionazi
@@uneti463
Typical argument from a muslim.
The good Shapiro
I dunno Josh Shapiro is pretty cool
@@thomashottersall5204🐘
@@thomashottersall5204 he means Ben Shapiro
My thought, 100%
@@asusmushroom4778who? *mariah carey's hair flips*
Every time I listen to this Rabbi I learn new things. He makes perfect sense
He has spoken the truth
Fine comment..."The Truth" is singular..
The truth encompasses all together
@@fibanacci8 Facts and the history are PROOFS. Only the willfully blind refuse to see.
@@fibanacci8haarva agreement….
Controlling opposition through established false narrative around positive sentiment toward Jewishness and Judaism, yet Orthodox Jews are regularly seen displaying vile behavior toward people. This is all a game to them to control the anti-Zionist opposition.
Finally, a 'Shapiro' worth listening to
Bravo to the interviewer, unlike most fools he didn't interrupt and let the rabbi speak so eloquently.
Yes, he shows a great professional humbleness.
When you are an interviewer like him seeking the truth and knowledge, and you don't fear hearing other people's ideas, you can let them speak freely.
It is the very insecure powerful elites or their 'journalist' minions who have to interrupt and cut off someone speaking the truth, if they ever let them on the channel to begin with.
Yes, this journalist is great, highly respectable as is his guest.
I’ve watched this video 5 times now, because it’s that good.
Watch the film Israelism ⚠️
Definitely gonna check out! Thank you
Fine recommendation..
Watched it this weekend 👏
Each and every word deserves to be transcripted as a book!! The most genuine explanation I have ever had!
Not quite...he doesn't mention, from the beginning Zionism was a ROTHCHILDE operation. Like the American Civil War was. It's wake wake time...
His book is called The Empty Wagon: Zionism's journey from identity crisis to identity theft
Brilliant!
As an orthodox jew, I condemn the terrorist acts and war crimes of Israel. I support the creation of a free and independent Palestinian state. This will end all the violence. As Jews we need to accept that Israel is the occupying force and we need to do the right thing and give Palestinians their own independent state free from Israeli interferences. CRITCIZING ISRAEL ISN'T ANTISEMITISM!!! JUDAISM HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH ZIONISM !!!!
Lololol - I see we have one of those "AS-A-JEW" fakers. C'mon you don't fool me for one second. ✡
70% of Mandatory Palestine went to the Syrian Arabs to form Jordan. Your argument has zero merit.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I give thee a Jewish person. Great job @ParissaKhoury, well said.
Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro, you hit the nail on the head. I agree with you 100%.
Pilate (A Roman Governor) said to the Jewish leadership why am I crucifying this man (Jesus) he did no evil. Pilate washes his hands and he say I'm innocent of this mans blood and the Jewish leadership said his blood is on us and our children. Israel will pay for their Sins. Jesus king of Bethlehem Palestine. Book of Revelations Chapter 6 Google that. King Herod paid for the baby deaths in Bethlehem.
💯
THIS SAME BENNY ALLOWED MEN TO RAPE HIS FELLOW SOLDIERS NOW IN THE ARMY. HE SAYS IT'S GOOD AND BOOSTS THE MORALE OF THE SOLDIERS. RAPE HELPS SOLDIERS, YES I PERSONALLY SAW AND HEARD THAT AND HE SAID IT PERSONALLY. Oooo YAS HE DID 💩💩💩🤮🤮🤮
I totally agree with the.speaker.
Truly..
I'm blown away by this. Thank you, my cousin, in faith! Stay strong 💪
He is amazing! As a non Jewish person I could not for the love of God understand why the state of Israel behaves the way it does. Their idea of homeland and Jewish state. Rabbi Shapiro, has presented a dissection of Zionism and an embedded antisemitic nature of Zionism with a lens that is seldom presented. I am hugely impressed by his eloquence and his intellect.
Good explanation, but the simple explanation is that zionism is a kind of FASHISM.
disagrees with the timing but has the same goal re-settling to palestine
@@MyVan111 ..you clearly didn’t watch the interview. Jews in Jerusalem still pray for “Next year in Jerusalem” because what they are referring to is entirely spiritual - not literal.
@@dra2033wrong
@@sfu4028 why then, do Jews in Jerusalem pray for next year in Jerusalem?
Freedom to 🇵🇸 from pissraevil
I could watch Rabbi Shapiro all day ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ma'shaa Allah, Rabbi Shapiro is shining light on a delicate & complicated subject. May he be guided! - Ameen
@rosebud679 I think he is allready guided? He belongs to the jews who follow the Torah. Wa Allahu yalam.
The Torah that Allah revealed has been altered and cannot be found anymore. Besides, a person alive after the Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم was sent must follow him and abandon Judaism and Christianity to enter Jannah, otherwise they are still a disbeliever.
@@malenedietl3369 There is a Hadith in Ahmad where the messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم says “By the One in whose Hand is my soul, even if Mūsā was alive, he would have no choice but to follow me”. (English translation of meaning).
@@malenedietl3369the great Rabbi is already very well guided. Love him ❤
@@malenedietl3369 Please - I think the original comment was meant with great respect.
Thank you Rabbi!
I could here him all day what amazing individual. A free palestine where Christians jews and Muslims have equal rights end apartheid.
Historical information . The Rabbi has simplified so much for me . Thankyou
They have equal rights inside of Israel. Tell me how many Jews live in Gaza and in the areas controlled by the Palestinian authority.
This video literate me a lot on the issue of Zionism and Judaism. I will never say any bad word against Orthodox Jew.
That's the most comprehensive 25 min explanation of why Zionism fails I've seen so far.
Seems successful this far
Zionism = Fascism
It has only been successful in pulling the wool over everyone's eyes. That's why they are SO concerned with controlling the narrative engines of social media. Do you think TikTok got the ax because our leaders were actually concerned with what China is doing? The head of the ADL was caught on a hot mic giving the whole scheme away! They have been meddling in the affairs of FREE PEOPLE for far too long.
@@knicks252525 "Successful" in digging a large hole into humanity while trying to drag the nations in the west into that abyss.
only eleven minutes past, i'm learning a lot from this man. and it's very much in accordance with Islam than Christianity.
Christian Zionists are just so fckedd up!
Thank You for the clear explanation, Rabbi Shapiro 💐🦋🍃
Much respect and admiration for Rabbi Shapiro. May Allah 🙏🏻 protect him from the enemies of the truth. Very pleased to finally see him here. 🤩
There is a lot to learn from this post.
Correction: Zionism *IS* antisemitism.
I am a Scottish Catholic, there are English Catholics, German Catholics, Argentinian Catholics etc. But the Catholics in the world have never had the urge to all go and live in Italy.
Catholicism is not a race, it is a religion. And that is the same for bonafide jews. The Zionists were the ones who attempted to merge or conflate Judaism with nationalism.
Wow d’en,,,,,,,,,it the nail on the head❤❤❤❤❤
Zionism = Islamism = Christian Nationalism = Religious supremacy and bigotry
He's the real Shapiro
The one and only. The others are imposters.
This video should be shared with the whole world.
You're joking. The MSM and Zionists will make sure that never happens.
Zionisim is colonialisim
Exactly. Israel was created by British Christians and supported by most of Christian oriented Europe to get Jewish people out of Europe where they'd been wrongly persecuted by Christians for over a thousand years. This conveniently utilized and triangulated Jewish people with Muslim Palestinians whom Christians have also persecuted over religion and racism since they lost Jerusalem during the Crusades. The goal is to eradicate Palestinians, colonize the land, extract resources and throw Jewish people under the bus when the world sees the apartheid in Gaza. It's all a facade for imperialism, Evangelical Christianity and colonization.
0.2 % is J. They are not colonized any place.
Zionism = Islamism = Christian Nationalism = 💩
@@Maryculligan European settler colonialism disguised under certain ideologies?
Of course
Wow, I'm blown away by this information. I knew it all in pieces, but hearing it clearly and logically laid out like this helped me to really understand. Thank you Rabbi, peace, respect and love to you from your cousin in faith.
I was about to write the same thing
The words that came out of the Rabbi's introduction could have easily come out of a Muslims mouth. Islam is more than a religion, it's a lifestyle.
I agree!
Did you know Netanyahu's real last name Mileikowsky and is Polish?
Israelis are not semites. DNA testing proves Palestinians are semites and the owner of Israel. It's illegal for Israelis to do DNA testing.
So is this man. He is Polish American. What is your point?
@@NopeOnARope_ its just a fun fact im sharing .
WOW this discussion is SO Important due to all the evil that's happening these days it's making me cry 😭......
Very interesting interview 👍
Wow
My greatest respect to all Jews that are like this respectful rabbi ❤️
This is a fantastic and informative video
He seems like a good and honest man.
Not seems, truly is.❤❤❤
OTH you can tell right away what a dishonest, evil man the Zionists have chosen to be their leader.
Clear speech! I was so relieved, yes, relieved, when I heard rabbi Shapiro the first time. I didn't understand the difference between zionism and judaism, now I do. Thank to rabbi Shapiro.
Gives hope about peace with jews
Yeah, although Zionists who claim to be Jews make it very hard to do so.
Thank your the information allowing us to understand history and propaganda.
Thank you And May Our God Watch over you my Brother , Peace Be Upon You
This isn't a conversation, it's a lecture. A good one, but Salvatori couldn't get a word in edgewise!
He didn't need to - "If it ain't broke - don't fix it".
That was excellent. Very informative.
I am a Palestinian. I used to live in Gaza before my house in Gaza was destroyed. I have four children. When the Israeli army bombed my house, I was alone in it. Thank God I survived, but my right foot was amputated. I am now in Egypt and my circumstances are very difficult because I cannot work because of my foot. I have four children and I have no income. Please help me or refer my case to any charitable organization. Do not leave my children
Thank all the gods for these voices of reason, amidst all the madness ❤❤
So true,,, at least someone is sane in these f-up'd times.
❤🎉Alhamdulillah syukur rezeki bawa 4 biji teluk x 3 sen x 365 = 4,380 sen menabung❤❤
Ben Shapiro's good twin 💀
As he said on a different interview if he was related to Ben Shapiro he would never admit it 😅
I could hear this guy talk for hours. I love the way he describes/explains Judaism and everything surrounding it. He has a good voice and accent to listen to as well.
Thank you Rabbai Shapiro. You opened the eyes of many people. You showed me a new perspective on the matter. Salute to all real Jew of the world. Zionism is the destroyer of the greatJewish religion .
Jesus Christ. That was a fascinating lecture.
The good, good, human being this Rabbi is. Soft spoken, smart, articulate. Love him dearly❤❤
Thank you for the Jewish history lesson rabbi Shapiro . Your deep knowledge and insight is inspiring and valuable to everyone who wants to learn about the roots of this conflict in the Middle East.thank you again.
Saying antizionism is antisemitism is easily shown to be invalid:
Antisemitism (hatred of Jews, for being Jews) is morally wrong...
Antizionism (e.g. opposing genocide by Israel, or any state) is morally right...
Therefore, Antizionism (morally right) cannot be Antisemitism (morally wrong).
The first Australian-born (and Jewish) Governor General of Australia, Isaac Isaacs: "Following the King David Hotel bombing in 1946, he wrote that "the honour of Jews throughout the world demands the renunciation of political Zionism". Isaacs's main objections to Political Zionism were:
1. "A negation of Democracy, and an attempt to revert to the Church-State of bygone ages.
2. Provocative of anti-Semitism.
3. Unwarranted by the Balfour Declaration, the Mandate, or any other right; contrary to Zionist assurances to Britain and to the Arabs and in present conditions unjust to other Palestinians politically and to other religions.
4. As regards unrestricted immigration, a discriminatory and an undemocratic camouflage for a Jewish State.
5. An obstruction to the consent of the Arabs to the peaceful and prosperous settlement in Palestine of hundreds of thousands of suffering European Jews, the victims of Nazi atrocities; and provocative of Muslim antagonism within and beyond the Empire, and consequently a danger to its integrity and safety.
6. Inconsistent in demanding on one hand, on a basis of a separate Jewish nationality everywhere Jews are found, Jewish domination in Palestine, and at the same time claiming complete Jewish equality elsewhere than in Palestine, on the basis of a nationality common to the citizens of every faith."
Salute to this rabbi for his unbiased and informative comments.
Very interesting. I learned a lot.
Good history lesson
Wow 👏🏻
My word, I was so locked in. His explanation was so clear. It was a lot of information, but explained perfectly. More people need to watch this.
Judaism and Islam sound very similar. But racism and nationalism tell us to not see the many similarities.
Zionism and Islamism are the same too.
The human Shapiro ♥ 👏
Ben Shapiro ❌️
Rabbi Ya'akov Shapiro ✅️
Like Night and Day!
One of his points actually held true in the early United States as well. Most of the Founding Fathers after 1776 still didn't think of themselves as "Americans" in the broad national sense of the term. Rather, they thought of themselves as citizens of their own State first and foremost, as when Thomas Jefferson referred to Virginia as "my country." The later extreme nationalism, firmly cemented in place over eighty years after the Founding by Lincoln's Gettysburg address, which totally warped and destroyed the original meaning of the Declaration of Independence, has led to the total warmongering government and foreign policy we have today. "Nationalism" in any form, e.g. Christian, political, etc. is the source of nearly every problem in these United States themselves, as well as the horrors and injustices we fund and contribute to around the world.
The important thing in the Declaration of Independence is the idea that human liberty and freedom to self-divinity are more important than loyalty to an abstract nation or state as an identity. I think even the idea of state loyalty is just more nationalism. Our loyalty should be, first and foremost, to the well-being of our human species and protecting our individual freedoms.
You don't know now , but you are my friend dear Rabbi .much respected
Being Muslim this is my faith all the prophets send to the children of Israel are true God chosen on true path they are my brothers I love 💕💕💕💕 them all i wish stand beside them on the day of judgement, they did what God told them to do, they were God fearing always calling people to worship God alone and good News of glad tidings of paradise hereafter, Torah, Gospel and Quran are the revelations from same God, my message to all humans fear the day when God will judge us all for our actions we did in this short life.
I have total respect for this Rabbi . ♥️
Clear, rational and superbly delivered. As a non-Jew and non-rel
igious person, I learnt a LOT and am very appreciative. Thanks Rabbi Shapiro
Rabbi are u related to Ben Shapiro?
Rabbi: that’s a strong No. and if I was, I wouldn’t admit it
As a Catholic, I find this Rabbi very compelling and helpful in a world full of falsehoods and distortions.
Extremely enlightening and confusing at the same time. Thank you for giving some clarity nonetheless. This religion versus ethnicity versus nationality is hard to make sense of, but one of the most essential things to unravel.
This is very educational
Fantastic. Everyone NEEDS to see this.
I agree!
All my respect to this rabbi.
Its wierd to see a sane and intelligence and calm shapio
The Pogroms happened for the same reason that the genocide in Gaza is happening. The more powerful group blames the weaker one for all of the acts of terrorism or violence that are committed by some members of the weaker group.
The massacres by Hamas were conducted because the Hamas Billionaire elite were bought off by zionist warmongering neocon profiteers, to discredit and destroy Palestine.
The IDF were odered to stand down for 9 hours after the breach on October 7th. The IDF were removed from the gaza perimeter region on the night of October 6th.
Yes those in power will use that power against minorities
@@larryc1616, *against everyone
Two differences: 1. Gazans aren't being picked on because they're Arabs, so it's not a genocide. 2. Gaza is under siege because of October 7th. No Jew attacked Russians which brought on the pogroms.
@@chatisawasteoftime, they're not Arabs. Some Arabs migrated there, but most Palestinians are not Arabs. It's like saying that Americans are English. But this is all semantics. Most of the Israelis aren't ethnically Jewish - they're European.
I like this Shapiro better than the other one 😅
Within Europe the Jewish identity became also an ethnic identity ....but in the Middle East (for example in Aleppo and Baghdad) Jews called themselves Arabs, when insisted Arab Jews. The so called anti semitism never existed in the middel east....maybe some religious competition (my way of worshipping our God is better than yours) not more than between any other sect of moslims or Christians in the Middle East . The European Ashkenazi judaism destroyed the Arab jewish culture and identity that existed for thousands of years by forcing to make the Aaliyah ....initially many Arab Jews refused the name given to them by the Ashkenazi (the made up name Mizrahi) ....but slowly gave in to the pressure. Very sad.
Conversations like this are needed more than ever. It is essential to understand who people are and build relationships based on that understanding. Who are you? What do you think? What do you want? Why do you want it? How are you going to get it? Answering simple, straightforward questions honestly is an opportunity to peacefully connect. Asking questions is an invitation to build a relationship.
The important thing being glossed over is-European Jews were persecuted by other Europeans because they believed in a Semitic religion. Europeans were trying to be a “Western Christian” empire… This is what made Europeans practicing Judaism “non white”… THEY HAD A NATIONALITY-European… Jews were all over the world because Judaism started with Afro-Arabs-whom have had a culture, language & land… for centuries.
While Jesus himself DID NOT TEACH THAT!?
@@nurlindafsihotang49 Jesus absolutely said not to bring his gospel to the gentiles… so, you’re wrong.
The main ideas that the professor seems to be trying to convey is:
1. Judaism should be viewed solely as a religion, not a national movement, allowing Jews to live anywhere (America, China, France, etc.) while being connected through their faith (religion and not through the idea of nationalism). Thus, Israel and its government, including Netanyahu, cannot claim to act in the name of all Jews (living in America, China, France, etc.).
2. Israel should function like any other country, representing its citizens rather than a specific religious group. Under Zionism, Jewish Americans or Jewish French people see Israel as their nation-state, with Netanyahu as their prime minister. However, this concept blurs the lines of citizenship and nationality, with non-citizen Jewish nationals being excluded from voting.
Some of the quotes by Rabbi Shapiro:
- "Who made them (Israel and Zionism) the spokesman for the Jews? Nobody. They just unilaterally declared themselves such. They declared themselves the spokeman of the Jews, the speakers of the Jews, the country of the Jews and the nation state of the Jews, their prime minister is of the Jew's."
- "The reason Israel isn't a one state solution already is because Israel is the state of the Jews and not the state of the Israelis."
-"If we want to end Zionism, Israel must become the state of the Israelis, not the state of the Jews."
(These are only cherry picked quotes, be sure to watch both part 1 and 2 for the total picture)
When people in your own group aren't doing the right thing, it is SO HARD to publicly go against what they're doing. When Catholics in Northern Ireland were committing acts of terrorism, most Irish Catholics wanted to focus on the acts of terrorism and oppression committed by the Protestants to justify the terror attacks committed by people in their tribe. But some Irish Catholics were brave enough to stand for peace at a time when it was unpopular. Their reward is great. We can all learn from the example of Rabbi Shapiro.
A Jewish Rabbi. Not a Zionist Rabbi. Zionist ≠ Jew.
I am a Christian, but Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro is my Rabbi
What the Rabbi explained in the beginning is also Islam in a nutshell
Very insightful
Rabbi Shapiro is the rock star of truth and humanity. ❤
Very interesting perspective, I’m glad I watched this video, I learned a lot from it. Thank you for sharing 😊
What a light is giving its amazing, peace on you.and all
He is turning you all around his little finger,
And you all do not even have the ability to see it.
Let me tell you something love, a Rabbi who knowingly and intentionally contradicts explicit Jewish texts from a range of Jewish sources, starting from the prayer book, out of which he prays everyday and ending in the holly bible, is a very problematic Rabbi (to say the least).
I'll tell you one more thing, the man is a devout Zionist (though a troubled, and a deeply disturbed one).
The only substantial dispute he has with the state of Israel is about how and when.
Meaning, at the end of the day, he also believes that eventually the Jews are to live freely in a sovereign Jewish state or kingdom in the land of Israel.
You should also know, that as a Jew, despite of all those Mitzvos (religious good deeds) that he is decorating himself with every day, he is quite a sinner for doing a very basic, elementary, "NO-NO", that even most secular Jews are doing their best to avoid.
All the rest of what he says comes out of pompous arrogance and self-righteousness filled with hate.
Please do not take my word for what I just wrote.
Check it out for yourself.
The information is free and available to all.
Best of luck,
Your Jewish brother.
Very well explained. It's a pity this gentleman doesn't get enough air time to educate people
Thanks for explaining the origin of Zionism.
Fantastic to hear Rabbi Shapiro speaking and explaining the true identity of true Judaism.I have always admired the religious Orthodox Jews who live by the law of Torah the holy book of Judaism.The law in Torah teaches to be godfearing,Peaceful,living in harmony with all others who share their land.What a wonderful,enlightening talk by the Rabbi.
Elaborate explanation about zionism , thanks a lot Rabbi, now we have more knowledge about Zionist movement and the idea of creation of Israel