People so often overlook that flexibility is one of the qualities that makes a legendary band. ATR is simply moving in the direction of achieving a fuller degree of flexibility and I personally love this direction. Keep it up guys screaming or touching hearts in softer melody Ill be listening and I know your real fans will be too.
Without doubts, they have grown up like great composers. Now I feel that I could listen your songs every moment of my day, not only when I want scream or feel adrenaline. Love you guys, from the bottom of my heart. Greetings from Argentina!
+Yensuo Maybe if it weren't completely generic and boring now. I wouldn't mind slow at all if Oli still played like he did in the slow parts of say, Regret Not. This band is inspirationally bankrupt now.
this song reminds me of my mom who died in cancer & diabetis last august 13 2021. sorry mom i don't have endless time to tell you how much i really love you..
Powerful song. Heard this after the divorce in 14. A lot of pain almost 7 years later. The kids always hurt the most. Please remember this everyone..... When you give your word to another, keep it. The vows are for a reason. The repercussions are brutal in a family situation.
Divorce sucks... been 12 years since mine was finalized, this song dredged up some memories. My kids are teenagers now but going back in my head to when it all happened it still hurts and I still miss her, you don't spend a decade with someone and make 4 babies and expect it to fade.
I love this song. It makes me think about the woman that introduced me to it. She never really knew how special she was to me because I pushed her away like I always do. 😢😢
I need to meet these guys in person, there music has made me a better man, father, and husband. I know this is a long shot but if you guys read comments.... please reach out to me as I listen to this song, "what if I was nothing", and "probably wouldn't end well" every day! all the haters of this song must not have a marrage to save, or they dont want to admit there at fault! #allthatremains
This is great I love the acoustic guitar work in the beginning especially and the harmonies are great progressive parts. All That Remains is very underrated
For those wondering the song is from the perspective of the kid. I have dealt with a family like what she was going through. The song is describing the slow decay of a family and its either figure out who loves who or move on. Fighting like that not only puts a toll on the parents but the child who is hearing it. With what I have dealt with it makes it to where I have a hard time hearing others fight as it starts to make me panic. The telekinesis I dont know why that is in there, guess to show what she wants to see or have. Thats just what I have to say about it
Hard or soft, ATR is still an amazing band. Most heavy bands can't do soft, only the great one's can. Like Metallica, Slipknot, Korn, etc.. I am a die hard, true fan of All That Remains. They are awesome and badass to be able to go back and forth on Melody changes.
I am assuming that all the people saying how bad this song is has never been a child of a broken home, or in a volatile relationship before, and as that child, wanting nothing more than to fix her parents so her world can be right again. This video gave me chills. Who cares if its heavy? It's about the message! As somebody who suffers from PTSD, I don't see music as entertainment. I see it as art, and something that I can relate to. It has to speak to me in order for me to listen. I know everybody has their own preferences, but to say it's awful is taking it a little far.
This song is beautiful. Only goes to show that they have talent in other areas of musical style. Completely under-rated and emotionally powerful song for those who understand the pain of a lost and ruined childhood.
I love reading these comments. People are saying it sucks that they changed I miss all of their old stuff. Every band tries a different type of music every once in a while. If they played the same type of music that they did prior I bet those people would start complaining they've been playing the same thing forever. I wanna hear them try something new. I personally thought they did, have, and will keep making awesome music.
All these people complaining about how ATR isn't as good as they were, have you listened to these songs? The lyrical meaning behind this album is genius. The only album I wasn't too fond of was a war you cannot win. But I still listen to it without complaints.
"This is not ATR", "WTF happened to ATR". WTF are you all talking about? Seriously, bands make soft songs too. Slipknot did it, Metallica did it. What's the difference? I still think they sound great and if they did just do the same kind of stuff all the time it would get so boring so it's nice to see some diversity in their songs.
their newer songs are good and actually got me to listen in the first place, has it ever occurred to y'all that this guy is getting older and probably don't have the voice to scream and rock as hard as he once did?
Just because they've made a couple of low beat songs doesn't mean "they're not ATR" anymore they are still ATR if you don't like it, maybe your are not true fans.
Many people are disappointed because they actually sing points instead of screaming them sometimes not but I believe his past screaming made him as beautiful as he is today with his voice. Perfect rasp, perfect softness. It’s okay to mellow out and people need to accept that
Excellent song. I have the whple album on my phone and have listened to every song on it. This album has a mix of what some call the old ATR and some of the new. Overall it's an excellent album.
Something I found that brought this song to mind.“When I was little and running on the race track at school, I always stopped and waited for all the other kids so we could run together even though I knew (and everybody else knew) that I could run much faster than all of them! I pretended to read slowly so I could "wait" for everyone else who couldn't read as fast as I could! When my friends were short I pretended that I was short too and if my friend was sad I pretended to be unhappy. I could go on and on about all the ways I have limited myself, my whole life, by "waiting" for people. And the only thing that I've ever received in return is people thinking that they are faster than me, people thinking that they can make me feel bad about myself just because I let them and people thinking that I have to do whatever they say I should do. My mother used to teach me "Cinderella is a perfect example to be" but I have learned that Cinderella can go fuck herself, I'm not waiting for anybody, anymore! I'm going to run as fast as I can, fly as high as I can, I am going to soar and if you want you can come with me! But I'm not waiting for you anymore.” ― C. JoyBell C.
Words carry weight.. Meaning. This song is deep and brings forth lots of emotion if you've been in a place.. In a relationship that produced a beautiful child and have the relationship fail. Not every song ATR writes needs to bring heavy metal riffs and screams. People who cannot get over they're quote "softer" music simply lack experiences and frankly the insight/maturity to see that music is all about how you relate to it. If you want to listen to screams 24/7 angry music you're unrealistic and out of touch. Time and place for everything. Damn good song.
This song is absolutely beautiful. I honestly don't understand all the hate towards the song and the last few albums in general. Soft ain't bad! If they were making the same stuff over and over they'd just get boring and repetitive! I love the soft stuff arguably as much if not more than some heavier albums. That's the charm of the band! I love how flexible they are and the huge variety of songs. I can legit listen to them only and get anything you could ask for a band no matter the genre
this is my favorite band now who cares about how hard or soft they rock listen to the lyrics the meaning in the words and the conviction they play every song with that's what rock is about.this is my favorite song💪
Find this band very recently, like a couple weeks, and I know this is not what they usually do. I mean it's completely different, but I love this song, it's still beautifull and the whole disc is awesome so I don't know why you people complain so much
There is gonna be much hate for this, but I gotta be honest. This song is gorgeous and it truly speaks to me. All my life I've experienced this same problem with constant yelling and fighting. I get it that it isn't what ATR used to be, but every band goes through changes in their life. The songs that are made are inspired by the try feelings of the singer no matter what. You can hate on it all you want, but you can't just demand something that can't be done easily.
Important songs can change lives. This one is great.🤔👍
It helps a lot my wife of 15 years left me with our 4 kids ,thank God for this song
What a badass riff. Only a metal band could make acoustic music like this.
I always dedicated this to my “mom”. She doesn’t deserve that title.. I cried for years to this song.. 💔😞 thank you ATR for being my voice. I owe you.
What happened? Was she a horrible mother? Damn man, im sorry :(
People so often overlook that flexibility is one of the qualities that makes a legendary band. ATR is simply moving in the direction of achieving a fuller degree of flexibility and I personally love this direction. Keep it up guys screaming or touching hearts in softer melody Ill be listening and I know your real fans will be too.
Without doubts, they have grown up like great composers. Now I feel that I could listen your songs every moment of my day, not only when I want scream or feel adrenaline. Love you guys, from the bottom of my heart.
Greetings from Argentina!
Even if they go hardcore or softly they still an awesome band
+Yensuo exactly
+Yensuo Honestly I'd really rather them go this route.
+Yensuo I completely agree with that statement
+Yensuo Maybe if it weren't completely generic and boring now. I wouldn't mind slow at all if Oli still played like he did in the slow parts of say, Regret Not. This band is inspirationally bankrupt now.
+xb0xisbetter you nailed man, it sucks.
That guitar solo is so damn beautiful!
this song reminds me of my mom who died in cancer & diabetis last august 13 2021. sorry mom i don't have endless time to tell you how much i really love you..
This song still gives me chills
Powerful song. Heard this after the divorce in 14. A lot of pain almost 7 years later. The kids always hurt the most.
Please remember this everyone.....
When you give your word to another, keep it.
The vows are for a reason. The repercussions are brutal in a family situation.
Divorce sucks... been 12 years since mine was finalized, this song dredged up some memories. My kids are teenagers now but going back in my head to when it all happened it still hurts and I still miss her, you don't spend a decade with someone and make 4 babies and expect it to fade.
their new songs really are beautiful..damn i cant handle it alone :'(
Beautiful heavy or soft. It’s like metal heads love music
I love this song. It makes me think about the woman that introduced me to it. She never really knew how special she was to me because I pushed her away like I always do. 😢😢
I need to meet these guys in person, there music has made me a better man, father, and husband. I know this is a long shot but if you guys read comments.... please reach out to me as I listen to this song, "what if I was nothing", and "probably wouldn't end well" every day! all the haters of this song must not have a marrage to save, or they dont want to admit there at fault! #allthatremains
Found them a while back and really enjoy their music.
I've met Phil and I also got to meet Oli Herbert..... they're fantastic. I hope you get to meet them too. I'll always love ATR. ❤️
Music is communicating a story vibe what is real for the person writing the song hard soft it's what we all go through a variety of emotions in life
Had a nostalgic night and needed to hear something with meaning. Thanks guys!
Do You ever get that moment when You hear a song play in Your head over and over, until You come back to it? Great song!
This is great I love the acoustic guitar work in the beginning especially and the harmonies are great progressive parts. All That Remains is very underrated
I used to not like that this band was going in a softer direction, but if they keep making songs like this i'll be okay
all that remains is life. thanks guys for getting me through hard times!
2:11 The Force is strong in this one.
For those wondering the song is from the perspective of the kid. I have dealt with a family like what she was going through. The song is describing the slow decay of a family and its either figure out who loves who or move on. Fighting like that not only puts a toll on the parents but the child who is hearing it. With what I have dealt with it makes it to where I have a hard time hearing others fight as it starts to make me panic. The telekinesis I dont know why that is in there, guess to show what she wants to see or have. Thats just what I have to say about it
More on the matter to have control over a situation in general for the peace and to hold the sanity. A want and need sometimes is seen there.
ATR have been one of my favorite bands. This song gives me a lump in my throat when I hear it. I love it!
this band are really talented, been listening to them since their first album, heavy to soft, a change is good, in this case it's a huge change.
RIP Oli so sad to hear this 💔😥
RIP. Only discovered this band yesterday but I can already hear how good he was on guitar.
Hard or soft, ATR is still an amazing band. Most heavy bands can't do soft, only the great one's can. Like Metallica, Slipknot, Korn, etc.. I am a die hard, true fan of All That Remains. They are awesome and badass to be able to go back and forth on Melody changes.
Ik it’s been ages but when did korn go soft??? I can’t remember a song that was soft. (Soft in korns terms at least)
Great song on an underrated album. I especially love the pre-chorus.
Sike, that's my second favourite ATR album after TDH! Fuck the haters, I enjoy good music and that's it!
I am assuming that all the people saying how bad this song is has never been a child of a broken home, or in a volatile relationship before, and as that child, wanting nothing more than to fix her parents so her world can be right again. This video gave me chills. Who cares if its heavy? It's about the message! As somebody who suffers from PTSD, I don't see music as entertainment. I see it as art, and something that I can relate to. It has to speak to me in order for me to listen. I know everybody has their own preferences, but to say it's awful is taking it a little far.
This song is beautiful. Only goes to show that they have talent in other areas of musical style. Completely under-rated and emotionally powerful song for those who understand the pain of a lost and ruined childhood.
I love reading these comments. People are saying it sucks that they changed I miss all of their old stuff. Every band tries a different type of music every once in a while. If they played the same type of music that they did prior I bet those people would start complaining they've been playing the same thing forever. I wanna hear them try something new. I personally thought they did, have, and will keep making awesome music.
"For we are many"... The true listeners of all that remains will now what I mean. This was when they had heavy songs.
Beautiful song! I love their music whether its heavy or melodic..Amazing versatile band..! You Rock, Guyz!!!!!
Some people saying bad things about this band, meanwhile i'm still listening to the band till present. I hope youtube still on in armageddon war.
Amazing as normal
All these people complaining about how ATR isn't as good as they were, have you listened to these songs? The lyrical meaning behind this album is genius. The only album I wasn't too fond of was a war you cannot win. But I still listen to it without complaints.
Long time ATR fan, I love their diversity. Phil and crew rule.
Great message great song great all together band much love ❤ rock on 🤘
"This is not ATR", "WTF happened to ATR". WTF are you all talking about? Seriously, bands make soft songs too. Slipknot did it, Metallica did it. What's the difference? I still think they sound great and if they did just do the same kind of stuff all the time it would get so boring so it's nice to see some diversity in their songs.
Othe relentlessO I agree
Agree still a great song
@ConcernedCitizen you're so wrong
Your opinion not the majority
Each band has their shares
their newer songs are good and actually got me to listen in the first place, has it ever occurred to y'all that this guy is getting older and probably don't have the voice to scream and rock as hard as he once did?
Great song!
This is one of the best songs i've ever heard keep it up guys sing it loud.
3:09 -
That was the saddest part of this music video!
It certainly is dark cruel world for wasted meals...
I remember listening to this song when the music video first uploaded. My favorite music video from All That Remains.
Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful...amazing song.
Essa música é tão massa e me faz lembrar tantas coisas ...
Continuo lembrando, dois anos depois...
i like everything that atr does. all of it. i hope they stick around for a while.
Just because they've made a couple of low beat songs doesn't mean "they're not ATR" anymore they are still ATR if you don't like it, maybe your are not true fans.
Hell yeah
Anyone who says they arent "ATR" anymore is retarded their name is still all that remains so they still are ATR
True that
I have every one of their albums and love them all
Many people are disappointed because they actually sing points instead of screaming them sometimes not but I believe his past screaming made him as beautiful as he is today with his voice. Perfect rasp, perfect softness. It’s okay to mellow out and people need to accept that
I love this. If its all i knew about them it would be enough
Beautiful Song
Met this band in 2015 and miss this being live asking him to play it for me
Excellent song. I have the whple album on my phone and have listened to every song on it. This album has a mix of what some call the old ATR and some of the new. Overall it's an excellent album.
Something I found that brought this song to mind.“When I was little and running on the race track at school, I always stopped and waited for all the other kids so we could run together even though I knew (and everybody else knew) that I could run much faster than all of them! I pretended to read slowly so I could "wait" for everyone else who couldn't read as fast as I could! When my friends were short I pretended that I was short too and if my friend was sad I pretended to be unhappy. I could go on and on about all the ways I have limited myself, my whole life, by "waiting" for people. And the only thing that I've ever received in return is people thinking that they are faster than me, people thinking that they can make me feel bad about myself just because I let them and people thinking that I have to do whatever they say I should do. My mother used to teach me "Cinderella is a perfect example to be" but I have learned that Cinderella can go fuck herself, I'm not waiting for anybody, anymore! I'm going to run as fast as I can, fly as high as I can, I am going to soar and if you want you can come with me! But I'm not waiting for you anymore.”
― C. JoyBell C.
By far 1 of my very favorite songs
Fell in love with this song. Love it
Me gustó mucho el video, y es una excelente canción!! Saludos desde México.
Long live ATR.
Saludos bro también desde México
As wise man once said "heaviest band make best ballads"
Love this song ... So real
I just can cope with how much I love this video.
I'm still love this band.
Wau, what a strong voice............
Essa música tem um dos solos mais lindos!
This is the band that turned me onto rock. They have progressively become better and better. Great music.
His voice is perfect.
Words carry weight.. Meaning. This song is deep and brings forth lots of emotion if you've been in a place.. In a relationship that produced a beautiful child and have the relationship fail. Not every song ATR writes needs to bring heavy metal riffs and screams. People who cannot get over they're quote "softer" music simply lack experiences and frankly the insight/maturity to see that music is all about how you relate to it. If you want to listen to screams 24/7 angry music you're unrealistic and out of touch. Time and place for everything. Damn good song.
this video needs more views. cnt believe there is so few
Awesome song, as everything about ATR
BRASIL, BRASIL, amazing song \,,/
gabriel pettinati Brasil \,,/
*BR PORRA!!!*
Nois!
É TUDO NOSSO!
*AEEEEEEOOOOH!*
This song is absolutely beautiful. I honestly don't understand all the hate towards the song and the last few albums in general. Soft ain't bad! If they were making the same stuff over and over they'd just get boring and repetitive! I love the soft stuff arguably as much if not more than some heavier albums. That's the charm of the band! I love how flexible they are and the huge variety of songs. I can legit listen to them only and get anything you could ask for a band no matter the genre
this is my favorite band now who cares about how hard or soft they rock listen to the lyrics the meaning in the words and the conviction they play every song with that's what rock is about.this is my favorite song💪
Okay now we just need a music video for the greatest generation.
great song.. how can u not like it...
awesome song. love the way it flows.
Goosebumps
The lyrics !! Is to relate,. How it takes me back to the old days where things were complicated and simple at the same time. Hell yeah
on repeat... Awesome song...
Love love love this song.
I love this song 😊💕
Finally a music video for my favorite song!!
I love this song.
Lagu ini mengingat kan ku kepada seseorang yang ada di kehidupan ku
I love this💟🔝
Please keep them coming, and forget the haters!
How bout we just enjoy the diversity of music a talented band creates????
One of the best bands ever
I love this song 😀😀😀😥😥😥💗
Even if you don’t like that ATR is going softer we can all still agree this is better than mainstream pop
Thanks for this!
Find this band very recently, like a couple weeks, and I know this is not what they usually do. I mean it's completely different, but I love this song, it's still beautifull and the whole disc is awesome so I don't know why you people complain so much
This is so good
So preetty amazing!
favorite song off this album
gives me chills
love this
crushing lyrics are better than at first thought
You are awesome! Greetings from México
Beautiful song
I love this video great song and great concept masterfully done!
Awesome
God damn this band knows how to write ballads.
There is gonna be much hate for this, but I gotta be honest. This song is gorgeous and it truly speaks to me. All my life I've experienced this same problem with constant yelling and fighting. I get it that it isn't what ATR used to be, but every band goes through changes in their life. The songs that are made are inspired by the try feelings of the singer no matter what. You can hate on it all you want, but you can't just demand something that can't be done easily.
Best song from this album!