Percival for sure, but Galloway is definitely gets the accolades for being the more intriguing fragrance. This comparison is very interesting to me, and I wouldn't usually expect these two together in a horse race, though I accept the scolding PdM would give me for saying such things! When people pick up on my fragrance, Percival gets the, "THAT smells so nice!" and Galloway gets, "Oooh, what is that you're wearing?" kind of responses.
Great review brother I own them both to me hands down my favorite is Galloway maybe because iris is my favorite note in perfumery. Plus I believe Galloway is more unique we’re Percival to me smells like a common designer fresh sent. Will definitely purchase Galloway again once my bottle is finished. Also the performance on my skin is amazing over 10 hours. Was a pleasure watching 👍
Absolutely on point man. I have observed this as well, im not new with perfumes and for me at least Galloway is just more unique and a better scent in my view. But women for some reason gravitate towards Percival.
I have smelled both, but I ended up getting Percival! It's a nice freshy, and super long lasting. I can always smell it on my shirts after a day, and mind you, I don't spray it on my clothes directly.
I have a soft spot for Galloway. Its less complex but in my opinion more unique. Love Percival too though - it was one of my first PdM purchases. Just recently acquired Sedley after being undecided for such a long time and I have no regrets. I have recently acquired covid (tested positive yesterday) so hoping I can send that one packing ASAP lol
Thank you both for the lovely review. I have also been trying to make my mind for an important meeting coming up that is casual in nature yet serious in content (if that makes sense). I have enjoyed both of your comments and this has helped me greatly. Have a Wonderful Day!
Thank you! I think both are scents that are very versatile and would work very well in any kind of situation, from going out on a warm summer day to sitting in a business meeting. Percival might even edge out Galloway in that sense since it's such a mass appealing and light kind of scent that works so well in both casual and formal settings 😊
I was needing to get decants of Perceval and Sedley for summer, totally forgot about Galloway. I’ll be adding that, need my signature scent this summer.
Galloway easily. Percival dna is in A&B and in MontBlanc but Galloway Luxurious Pepper and musk is a one of a kind. A scent that is simple but not basic.
Percival is probably my favorite scent. I tried Galloway at nordstrom once and was not a fan and neither was my gf. I remember it smelling very sharp and citrusy...too much. Maybe it would grow on me over time.
I have 10 different PDM. Percival is my least favorite. I don’t have Galloway, but would like to smell it. If I’m going with a fresh PDM, Greenley. How’s the citrus in Galloway compare to Perseus?
I just tried Percival and I really don't like it. I get a funky note I don't like that is overpowering everything else. Galloway is my favorite thus far, even more than Layton.
How many sprays of percival for a church environment? Enough to be smelled but without being the “cologne guy who showered in cologne”????? Please and thanks 🙏
I’ve actually been in this scenario and spoke to my daughter who was with me about it. I had on 3 sprays of Percival, and she said she could smell me the whole time, but it wasn’t overwhelming, so I would say 2 sprays. (This was in a huge cathedral)
Awesome review, combined with your Sedly Vs Greenley one, I simply could not make up my mind, but after watching both, I've decided on Perival. Out of curiosity, how would these be relates against Xerjoff's Mefisto?
Thank you! Percival is a fantastic scent and to me it's a 10/10 scent: ua-cam.com/video/r8NVDrBAWF4/v-deo.html All of the more fresh ones from PDM are great scents but they are also a bit different so it's good to do some research before potentially buying. I can't remember how Mefisto smells like so don't know 😊
@@rottenrebels I've now grabbed Galloway on top of Percival and loving both, I'm now after Greenley, but debating over Sedly as well, but again your reviews are pointing me towards Greenley :)
@@sharifradwan4515 Galloway is such a cool kind of freshie! Quite addictive.. Sedley vs Greenley: ua-cam.com/video/OIBDuPx5cjk/v-deo.html Both Sedley and Greenley are wicked. I would say it depends on what kind of freshness you prefer since Greenley's focus is very much on the fruity kind with the apple/citrus in focus and Sedley having a more intense dose of citrusy and aromatic kind of freshness 😊
@@rottenrebels I've already watched that amazing comparison of yours, I have bought Galloway, Percival and now Greenley, purely based on your reviews, and I simply am grateful to you for the reviews or I probably would maybe have not bought them. I love Galloway, followed by Percival, and Greenley is on the way, but it looks like, I'll be getting Sedley as well, as you like them all, so I think based on that, I will more than likely love all 4, just with varying degrees. I'll update when Greenley arrives :). Many thanks :)
I really don’t see it anything good on Galloway. At all! I just smelled at the store. To me smell horrible 🤢🤢🤢🤢 And I sprayed on my hand. I wait around one hour to see if change and I can smell any good in it. Definitely! Smells horrible. I just putted a lot soap and water to remove it out of my hand. Percival! Is beautiful, Lovely super mass appealing.
Hi! thanks for sharing! we all experience scents in different ways so always interesting to hear how other people experience things. To me, Percival is actually the opposite of flat. And that's the reason why I like it so much. I REALLY tried to get to know Kalan. But it's one of few PDM that never really impressed me that much. And it's interesting to see how quite a few of those around me also feel the same. Will it give the 50th try again this week and see if I change my mind 😆
Percival is unique and luxurious? Seriously?) It's a clone of Fierce Abercrombie & Fitch or Montblanc Legend. They came out earlier and have the same dna and same level of performance/longevity. The same story with Galloway (Lalique White). And I'm not saying that they are bad, Galloway is one of my favorite scents, but they are far from unique for sure. And far from "niche")
Percival VS Galloway? Comment below with YOUR favourite 👀😊👍
Galloway.
Nautica Competition
Percival for sure, but Galloway is definitely gets the accolades for being the more intriguing fragrance. This comparison is very interesting to me, and I wouldn't usually expect these two together in a horse race, though I accept the scolding PdM would give me for saying such things! When people pick up on my fragrance, Percival gets the, "THAT smells so nice!" and Galloway gets, "Oooh, what is that you're wearing?" kind of responses.
Galloway is so classy and turns into clean musky scent in the dry down and its very long lasting..its one of my favorites
Thanks for sharing 😊🙏 Agree, it’s a fantastic scent 👍
Galloway is so unique and smells luxurious. The pepper and florals mixed with the musk and amber, simply amazing.
Thanks for sharing! So is Parfums de Marly Galloway your favorite of these two?
I wouldn‘t day it‘s unique, as it smells really similar to le male jpg
I tried so hard to love PERCIVAL, but it doesn’t project and last on my skin at all. I don’t know why. But GALLOWAY does so gooood.
Interesting! Yeah Galloway does flow a bit different in the air! I do spray a ton every time I wear both though to make sure they project well 😊👌
I was thinking about these two all day, and I happened to come across this video. This review is exactly what I needed!
Percival is for me the best Marly freshie 😀
Clean fresh and elegant 😀
It’s such an amazing fresh fragrance 🤩🙌👌
Percival is a banger, and indeed fresh done right😁
YEssssssssssss 🙌🙌🙌😊😉
Great review brother I own them both to me hands down my favorite is Galloway maybe because iris is my favorite note in perfumery. Plus I believe Galloway is more unique we’re Percival to me smells like a common designer fresh sent. Will definitely purchase Galloway again once my bottle is finished. Also the performance on my skin is amazing over 10 hours. Was a pleasure watching 👍
Thank you and Thanks for sharing! Yes, the performance of Galloway is GREAT for it being the scent that it is.. to me both are fantastic scents 👌😊
Absolutely on point man. I have observed this as well, im not new with perfumes and for me at least Galloway is just more unique and a better scent in my view. But women for some reason gravitate towards Percival.
I have both and agree. Love Galloway.
I have smelled both, but I ended up getting Percival! It's a nice freshy, and super long lasting. I can always smell it on my shirts after a day, and mind you, I don't spray it on my clothes directly.
nice!! Thanks for sharing 😊 So is it a like or a love? How would you rate it from 1-10?
@@rottenrebels its a solid 9, and it's going to be my signature scent this summer!
@@DM-nm9dq Perfect signature freshie! 9 is quite a big like 👍, glad you are enjoying it! 🙌
Really enjoy Galloway. Also, I think it’s more unique.
Percival reminds me of Vodka on the Rocks by Killian.
I have a soft spot for Galloway. Its less complex but in my opinion more unique. Love Percival too though - it was one of my first PdM purchases. Just recently acquired Sedley after being undecided for such a long time and I have no regrets. I have recently acquired covid (tested positive yesterday) so hoping I can send that one packing ASAP lol
Sedley is another great fresh parfums de marly aswell 🤩 No good about Covid 😷🤧🤒Wishing for a speedy recovery 😊
@@rottenrebels Cheers Rotten. I'd managed to avoid it until now. Very mild symptoms so let's hope it stays that way. 🤞
Whats your favorite out of the three? I have layton but im trying to find a new one for summer
Thank you both for the lovely review. I have also been trying to make my mind for an important meeting coming up that is casual in nature yet serious in content (if that makes sense). I have enjoyed both of your comments and this has helped me greatly. Have a Wonderful Day!
Thank you! I think both are scents that are very versatile and would work very well in any kind of situation, from going out on a warm summer day to sitting in a business meeting. Percival might even edge out Galloway in that sense since it's such a mass appealing and light kind of scent that works so well in both casual and formal settings 😊
I was needing to get decants of Perceval and Sedley for summer, totally forgot about Galloway. I’ll be adding that, need my signature scent this summer.
Galloway = 👌🙌
Amazing review! Been waiting for the comparison of both, couldn't find it anywhere, but here! ;-) Thank you
Percival
Thank you!!! 😊🙏
🙌
Both are my favourite freshie, your views are exactly what i think. These Two are beautiful.
🙌
Galloway easily. Percival dna is in A&B and in MontBlanc but Galloway Luxurious Pepper and musk is a one of a kind. A scent that is simple but not basic.
Percival is probably my favorite scent. I tried Galloway at nordstrom once and was not a fan and neither was my gf. I remember it smelling very sharp and citrusy...too much. Maybe it would grow on me over time.
Percival 🙌🙌🙌
Congratulations for 9k subscribers we will see your channel with 50k + subscribers by the end of the year 100% 👍 review.
😊 Thank you Elvis!! Appreciate it! 🙏🙏🙏 would be fantastic to reach more people 🙏
This video was very helpful, considering summer is around the corner. Thank you 🙏
I have 10 different PDM. Percival is my least favorite. I don’t have Galloway, but would like to smell it. If I’m going with a fresh PDM, Greenley. How’s the citrus in Galloway compare to Perseus?
Percival got my vote ! It seems more versatile and a safer alternative to me. Galloway is more unique though.
A lot of love for Percival 😊🙌👌
Do a silver mountain water v Galloway v musk therapy video 🙌
Just bought Percivel, great fragrance! How many sprays do you recommend?
Got a decant of percival along with others 2 weeks ago and I'm going to try percival for the first time today.
👌👌👌
Galloway is an expensive freshie with elegance and is long lasting.
I like it a lot! Definitely a unique and well-made scent 😊👌
Percival all the way!
Percival is simple but beautiful I love PDM
Which of all Parfums de Marly is the best for spring/summer season?
I love Sandra's into
Percival 👌
Yes oh yes 🙌
i love them both
😉😊
How many sprays good in Galloway?
Oud for greatness vs Royal Oud
Who has more good projection
Stop putting family against each other. Buy both, the whole line is amazing
I just tried Percival and I really don't like it. I get a funky note I don't like that is overpowering everything else. Galloway is my favorite thus far, even more than Layton.
Interesting.. Thanks for sharing! Galloway is a beauty for sure! Love it..
Percival is a personal favorite that I'm addicted to 🤩
@@rottenrebels Well I changed my mind, I bought some Percival and really like the way it smells on me and lasts.
How many sprays of percival for a church environment? Enough to be smelled but without being the “cologne guy who showered in cologne”????? Please and thanks 🙏
I’ve actually been in this scenario and spoke to my daughter who was with me about it. I had on 3 sprays of Percival, and she said she could smell me the whole time, but it wasn’t overwhelming, so I would say 2 sprays. (This was in a huge cathedral)
I agree the same percival better 🫶🏻
You are literally the most handsome man on Earth! Hahah ❤
Awesome review, combined with your Sedly Vs Greenley one, I simply could not make up my mind, but after watching both, I've decided on Perival.
Out of curiosity, how would these be relates against Xerjoff's Mefisto?
Thank you!
Percival is a fantastic scent and to me it's a 10/10 scent: ua-cam.com/video/r8NVDrBAWF4/v-deo.html
All of the more fresh ones from PDM are great scents but they are also a bit different so it's good to do some research before potentially buying. I can't remember how Mefisto smells like so don't know 😊
@@rottenrebels I've now grabbed Galloway on top of Percival and loving both, I'm now after Greenley, but debating over Sedly as well, but again your reviews are pointing me towards Greenley :)
@@sharifradwan4515 Galloway is such a cool kind of freshie! Quite addictive.. Sedley vs Greenley: ua-cam.com/video/OIBDuPx5cjk/v-deo.html
Both Sedley and Greenley are wicked. I would say it depends on what kind of freshness you prefer since Greenley's focus is very much on the fruity kind with the apple/citrus in focus and Sedley having a more intense dose of citrusy and aromatic kind of freshness 😊
@@rottenrebels I've already watched that amazing comparison of yours, I have bought Galloway, Percival and now Greenley, purely based on your reviews, and I simply am grateful to you for the reviews or I probably would maybe have not bought them. I love Galloway, followed by Percival, and Greenley is on the way, but it looks like, I'll be getting Sedley as well, as you like them all, so I think based on that, I will more than likely love all 4, just with varying degrees. I'll update when Greenley arrives :). Many thanks :)
I dont care Galloway is beautiful Kalan as well and people hate them for no reason
Lol percival wins as far as versatility AND freshness. I don’t like Galloways powderyness
Percival is a winner both when it comes to it's fresh scent and it's versatility! 👌🙌😊
Percival.
Percival yeahhhhh
😊👌
I really don’t see it anything good on Galloway. At all! I just smelled at the store. To me smell horrible 🤢🤢🤢🤢
And I sprayed on my hand. I wait around one hour to see if change and I can smell any good in it. Definitely! Smells horrible. I just putted a lot soap and water to remove it out of my hand. Percival! Is beautiful, Lovely super mass appealing.
Thanks for sharing! I think both are fantastic and I love Galloways unique freshness 😊
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
😊🙏 Tried any of them?
I’ve been wanting to like Galloway, but it smells like a dentist’s clinic to me 🥲
Thanks for sharing 😊
percival is flat no variation...better kalan
Hi! thanks for sharing! we all experience scents in different ways so always interesting to hear how other people experience things.
To me, Percival is actually the opposite of flat. And that's the reason why I like it so much.
I REALLY tried to get to know Kalan. But it's one of few PDM that never really impressed me that much. And it's interesting to see how quite a few of those around me also feel the same.
Will it give the 50th try again this week and see if I change my mind 😆
Percival is unique and luxurious? Seriously?) It's a clone of Fierce Abercrombie & Fitch or Montblanc Legend. They came out earlier and have the same dna and same level of performance/longevity.
The same story with Galloway (Lalique White). And I'm not saying that they are bad, Galloway is one of my favorite scents, but they are far from unique for sure. And far from "niche")
what battle ????????????????
showwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
Sonia is so hot