Wind and Truth Chapters 23 & 24 (My Thoughts)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 23

  • @ExploringTheCosmere
    @ExploringTheCosmere  Місяць тому +1

    Get a free audiobook with an Audible Premium Plus trial: www.audibletrial.com/etc
    Join the Discord → discord.com/invite/fqbqpbGab8
    Support EtC on Patreon → www.patreon.com/ExploringtheCosmere
    Become a Channel Member → ua-cam.com/channels/s2V8xq0AdW6kBZadlY7aSg.htmljoin

  • @passdoutcouchpotatos
    @passdoutcouchpotatos Місяць тому +26

    I cant wait to have a pet flamespren in a rocketship that goes faster on compliments

  • @swinkscalibur8506
    @swinkscalibur8506 Місяць тому +14

    I think the girl who looked up is a myth/parable explaining how humans left Shinovar and points to the beginning of the Desolations when the conflict between Humans and Singers began.

  • @thomazeblen
    @thomazeblen Місяць тому +9

    Navani chapters are my favorites, i love how they make discovires about there world technology, and keep imagining mistborn era 3 and second part of stomrlight thanks to that

  • @ScottMoore1
    @ScottMoore1 Місяць тому +7

    I read that last part as possibly the beginning of Szeth's truthless arc. "Had he stepped on it while dancing?"
    Very awful if it all started because an 11 year old boy accidently stepped on it while dancing.
    And is it THE stone?

  • @mattrush8005
    @mattrush8005 Місяць тому +8

    What if honor is the bad guy? And what if taravangian is right that he’s the hero saving everyone? And what if adolin takes up honor and gives into his rage at his father? Idk maybe I’m crazy lol

  • @coletrain3162
    @coletrain3162 Місяць тому +7

    I would die for Bippy

  • @Topples7
    @Topples7 Місяць тому +8

    Women's script translation, courtesy of External Gills on the 17th shard discord:
    the spren can be convinced to stay in the physical realm and
    enter the fabrial by choice
    proffered hot coal and the
    right tone calms it and
    keeps it from dissipating
    they seem drawn to many of the same
    things we are: recognition,
    identity, belonging
    we are early in this development
    sometimes modern techniques are still
    required
    the spren take on unique traits as we see them as individuals
    flare of flamespren
    gust of windspren
    affliction ? of painspren
    this seems like it could get out of control quickly
    will this create a strain of more
    malleable flamespren? can we
    encourage them to multiply?

  • @undbiter65
    @undbiter65 Місяць тому +2

    There's a lot of time being mentioned in Shinovar. Time stood still. Time slowed. Etc. I wonder if something super invested can affect time. Like a black hole. Kvothe got frozen in his fall from Urithru. By Dalinar. Something is happening.

    • @ExploringTheCosmere
      @ExploringTheCosmere  Місяць тому +5

      That's an interesting thought, we know there's that Unmade in Shinovar, so maybe their effect could mess with time.
      Also, I know you meant Kaladin, but now I'm imagining Kvothe being a character in Stormlight lol he and Hoid would probably get along great playing music together.

    • @undbiter65
      @undbiter65 Місяць тому +1

      @@ExploringTheCosmere lmao didn't notice. Also, Jasnah mentioned the timelines the stormfather and sibling gave didnt match. I was wondering if enough investiture could affect tome like black hole.

  • @Fishie77
    @Fishie77 Місяць тому +3

    What if Rushu is the Kandra?

  • @tingtaiji
    @tingtaiji Місяць тому +3

    Let’s be real, a lot of the cosmere’s problem could be addressed if some of the current gods would give up their power. I mean, honor and cultivation would balance god’s wrath/passion fairly well

  • @Lakefront_Khan
    @Lakefront_Khan 28 днів тому

    I wouldn't have guessed Sevith was that old, because Kals only like 21 or so

  • @FddcbhFfg
    @FddcbhFfg Місяць тому +3

    i dont want to say Brandon going woke but channeling nowadays problems into medieval-like fantasy world...i dont like that (non-binary Rushu) i know Brandon is a master of fan service but i got a bad feelings this book is not going to be as good as WoR or at least OB

    • @stevenhedge2850
      @stevenhedge2850 Місяць тому +3

      Oh calm the heck down. The book already put in “modern day problems” which they aren’t when he made one of his main characters have depression. He’s allowed to put in characters more than just male and female. Heck he already done that in mistborn with the Kandra

    • @onrean
      @onrean Місяць тому

      ​@@stevenhedge2850 I had a serious eye roll when Rushu wasted such a valuable opportunity to talk to the sibling with something so personal, not relivant to the story, and obviously there to win woke points. When given the opportunity to talk to leaders of corporations, I have been expected on pain of losing my job to keep the conversation relavant to the discussion and situation on hand. Employees have been fired for misusing opportunities like that. Most leaders I've met would have chastised me for daring to think I had a right or that level of intimacy with them to discuss something like that. What rapport did Rushu think she had with the sibling to ask that kind of personal question? Regardless of opinions on the actual topic of woke ideology, that scene makes for an unbelievable character interaction requiring a lot of suspension of belief to think it wasn't there just to gain woke points.

    • @stevenhedge2850
      @stevenhedge2850 Місяць тому

      @@onrean rushu’s entire character has been a absent minded scientist who always focuses on things that interest her first before being reminded to focus. Navani actually gave her a chance to ask and rushu being rushu asked things that are importantly to her than just furthering the plot. Also for plot importance the sibling now has someone to connect too, seeing the sibling has all been about not trusting humans and here’s one asking something that isn’t just about trapping Spen into fabriels. . Also it didn’t waste any valuable opportunity relevant to the story it was a quick line that than had the scene xhange . It was clearly important to rushu. What only main characters are allowed to have character development or plot revelant things? Under that kind of thinking we should get rid of Lopen’s scenes

    • @onrean
      @onrean Місяць тому

      @@stevenhedge2850 you don't understand power dynamics between people of differing import. Rapport to talk about something so personal is earned. The Sibling talks to Navani because she is a queen and proved herself over the course of the last book. It was hard earned respect. Rushu has not gained that level of rapport with the sibling. I guess one good thing about this is we know Rushu can't be on the bad team. Modern stories aren't allowed to have woke characters be the bad guy. Otherwise the writer loses woke points.

    • @stevenhedge2850
      @stevenhedge2850 Місяць тому

      @@onrean sibling is not talking to navani because she’s a queen. Have you forgotten that the first person that the sibling talked to was Dabbid? The stormfather talked to kaladin way before he actually spoke to Dalinar the Spren don’t care about human social dynamics. If the sibling was bothered by rushu’s questions do you know what they would do? Just stop talking to them.. also the sibling is clearly still bothered by Navanis science but clearly you’re don’t care go ahead and stop reading no one cares about your out of date opinions Sanderson isn’t gonna miss you not reading his books you can just go ahead and be bored somewhere else