lol and that Ubi director guy was saying just before release "Skull and bones is not a triple A, it's a quadruple A". Well you can quadruple get the fk off then
If you guys are basing this game off of a review that's your loss. This game is actually pretty good. Fun as hell. If you look at the numbers they released, it don't line up with any of these hater as reviewers. Everyone wanted a sea of thieves clone it seems but this isn't sea of thieves believe it or not there is a game for that. Have fun being late to the party when you finally figure out its fun.
@@mlgbeeler420there is 10 hours of content max before it goes to complete boring.... It's not even a grindy just boring.... Pirates of the Caribbean online was better game play and 10x the content even the free version...
It's just typical Ubisoft, they did the same thing with For Honor. It's like they take an awesome idea, get a master to work on 1 or 2 of its concepts and then have a room full of monkeys build the remaining 90% of the game. I have this theory that Ubisoft employ absolutely anyone to stay competitive, even people who need help tying their own shoes, because they can just tell them "your payment is the honor of working for us" and they will swallow it, that's how stupid they are.
The problem is they left all the pirate stuff out of a pirate game... No land exploration... No sword combat, or ship raiding... What were they thinking???
All that came with the base game.... lol. It pretty much ended up being what it was initially supposed to be. a multiplayer ship combat DLC for Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag, they just forgot to include the functionality with the base game. what a shame, it would of been a great DLC for Black Flag, lol.
@@bartu4818 they dont know because they havent played the game. They just recycle the same shit from other reviewers. God forbid formulating your own opinions these days. LOL. The game is fun and you dont have to board a ship to enjoy it. In fact I would not be surprised in the future we see them implement island exploring. That would be a nice touch to add. But I do not feel like my money was wasted buying this game.
There’s a reason Ubisoft is remaking black flag. Even they know how crap this game is. This was in development hell and at this point they just released it to get it out of the way
They say AAAA Yet you take one comparison of this game to red dead redemption 2 this game literally cannot compare and should be a fraction of the price they are charging. It’s a fun game but it’s not worth full price
This is a great objective review..thank you..keep up the good work..looks like this might be catered to a younger simpler crowd. Not the hardcore pirate RPG serious gamers want
3:18 "It takes all the thinking out of the controls" *100% whiff on the easiest of broadsides* I only really looked into this right before the open beta, and playing the beta yeah there are some issues. However, all of your footage shows only the second ship in the game, the terrible one the tutorial made you build, did you ever get past that to one of the other 5 ships in the beta? Also, its a multiplayer game, did you ever partner with anyone else? I think its a hard sell at $60 comparing to what else is available, especially indy, but I'm definitely going to get $60 worth of enjoyment out of it. The premium edition does not bring the extra $30 of value being exclusively cosmetics after the 16th, but ultimately if you play any game wrong its going to suck. I'm not convinced you fully explored what is on offer here and decided it was mediocre cause you just didn't explore the fun parts, as even your Sea of Thieves clip here shows you on a galleon, a boat that is near impossible to man solo. Had you only played SoT manning a galleon solo, you'd likely have a much different opinion of the game.
There isnt even a broadside. I had a ship with 2 cannons on each side. When broadside to an enemy, those 2 cannons meant that I had 4 shots to lay into the enemy before reloading. Yes, each shot fires after the next as though you were firing a cannonball machine gun. And every shot converged on my reticle regardless of the angle. So its less a broadside, and more a machine gun where the more canons you get, the larger your magazine.
@ansgar_odinson technically the more cannons you get the bigger your magazine is in real life too. But it's just a video game. Does it really matter if the two cannons fires 4 shots? I didn't see simulator in the title
this game perfectly encapsulate modern gaming, it should've been dead and buried long time ago but now its seeing the light of day anyway because ubisoft contract obligation with a whole goddamn country.
shame, because when i first heard about it it sounded amazing. i started getting worried after the delays and then it’s dev cycle got ridiculous. i hope any devs wanting to make a pirate game like this don’t get scared off by what happened
I will play and think I will enjoy it a little. Just wish it came out 10 years ago. Been following the game since 2013 when it was going to be an expansion to AC: Black Flag
I mean the games really not bad, story is alright (haven’t seen more than like 2-3 hours cause I only play for a bit after work) and like you said, graphics are good but apparently at a cost of gameplay. I just bought one month of Ubi+ to try it out and while I do enjoy it a bit, I’m definitely not spending $60/$90 on it. I can wait for a sale
No one has made a pirate game correctly since Sid Myers Pirates. The game is old but they nailed the mechanics of trading, pirating, dealing with diffrent countries and sailing the open world seas. If someone would just take that game and turn it into a modern title it would do really well. Basically we need Sea Of Thieves mixed with Sid Myers Pirates to create the ultimate pirate game. It's not just about sailing your ship. Theres business and deplomacy involved as well. SOT is cool but I want a more realistic pirate game.
HOnestly, if someone sat down with SMP and listed off its features and just remade a 3d, in person version of it in unreal or unity, they would make a freaking fortune.
Looting in Sea of Thieves sucks!. You Can’t carry that much. You do the pirate Skull vault and it takes forever to get all the loot on the boat. Then you have to do it all over again just to sell the stuff.
I had a lot of fun with the open beta and really like the graphics of this game! They put a lot of effort into all those little details on the ship (singing crew, pet, customization options). You can add many different updates (hulls, cannons, furniture) to go for different playstiles. When I saw the healing cannons (that repair ships) and the basilisks, it was clear, that a lot of group dynamic fights will be possible. You can go for ramming and use short range cannons with a tanky ship, or you go long range and heal teamates with a faster but more fragile ship. The wind system and behaviour of the ship is just wonderfull! The influence of waves and the drag to the side if you think you go straight but the wind pushes you to one side is very realistic. If you go fast you have not the same turning radius as if ou go slow, so there is a physics model applied to the ship. There is night and day and weather animation which make the game very atmospheric. If you are overloaded you can't go full speed, your sails can get damaged and your hull can have leaks. I accept this game as what it is, a MMORPG on the water, where PvE, quests and gathering is the main goal. From what I hear here and on other platforms, those who complain looked for a PvP centered hardcore game. I heard the same after the release of New World and now with the release of Throne and Liberty. Idk if we need two versions of each game released or seperated servers those with PVP and those without. I remember the times of Guildwars 2 when there was a very interesting PvP Arena with 3 teams fighting for the win. The winning team went into the endfight against the Endboss of the game to earn a serverwide honorfull mention and great loot. Can't there be a good and meaningfull PvP in arenas? Why PvP everywhere is so important?
I loved when Yves justified the game by saying “it’s massive…”. How many cycles of Ubisoft games have we gone through that are “massive” and absolute borefests? Several generations of Far cry, AssCream, Division, Ghost Recons… and the list goes on…. Quantity is not quality.
I mean i find it like this. Skull amd bones is almost rouge like in some aspects. You can be level 5-7 level 10 will definitely kill you quickly. Reason i like skull and bones is it brings the combat more simple like black flag, the cannon mechanics were virtually the same i know i still play both... skull and bones can be played solo or with friends captaining thier own ship. Sea of thieves is a bit different. You have a multi crew ship and as cool as it is having multi rolls. But can make your dhip options and how far you go based on not only your own skill but that of your crew. Its great when you got people to play with. But skull and bones has many good things to like about it and i have my own issies with the game like boarding or traveling around your own ship would be cool
Do yourself a favor and play Black Flag or Rogue instead (even tho its not a pirate game but it has the same and slightly better naval gameplay of blackflag) Great video btw
Trash game is trash. Ships control like helicopters more than ships, no weight, instant momentum shifts. Worse in every single way than Black Flag. Shocking it took a decade to produce this garbage.
Most frustrating part about Ubisoft is that they actually have some fantastic franchises. But you feel like they are clueless to give fans what they want from them. Exhibit A: Splinter Cell.
It's arcadey as fuck for a game based solely on naval combat - A problem that befalls most pirate-themed games (even AC Black Flag). Ships did not blow up and sink after 3 or 4 quick volleys in as many seconds. It took a damn sight longer to reload guns in real life, and they didnt zip around like speed boats either. Wind direction was everything, but that matters very little in this game. Glad I tried the demo first...realised after 2-3 hours it was a giant bucket of chum. It's currently £20 on Steam and it still feels too expensive.
My first thought was "Hyena" isn't the only multi-million pound disaster. The continuous remodeling over ten years has resulted in a disjointed game of the sum of its parts, and it doesn't work. Add to that the no swordplay, ship raiding, and land exploration and the whole debacle has to hold together on the most ridiculous of sea battles. We have very good onboard graphics of the shipboard life diminishing to cartoon battles where the ships move at the most unrealistic and crazy speeds and laughable cannon action and flames. Nothing is cohesive which happens when a game goes through one re-invention after another. One thing you cannot do in a game like this is take out hand-to-hand combat as that turns all protagonists into bit players. This is most definitely for the bargain basement in a short time. After decades of gaming I have seen so many "Pirate" games come and go. What I would like to see is a triple A pirate game made in the way The Witcher is made. A strong story-line with the sandbox approach. As I see it you have the choice of progression through advancement in the story-line or advancement in combat, The Witcher has both. You can step off and on of the story-line. Like I said, another "Hyena" except that they want £50 to try and recoup their mistake of not dumping it years ago.
I appreciate the more objective review, but I do get a bit confused why so many people compare this game to Black Flag. Like it never claimed to be a game like that, it seems like every comparison seems to be showing how Black Flag does x better, but they’re basically a completely different genre besides being pirate themed.
It… literally owes it’s existence to black flag! People wanted more black flag, skull & bones was literally Ubi’s answer! Looks like they couldn’t even do that right.
LoL you obviously haven't been following this fromm the start. Look at the trailers of what they promised use in 2017 and 2018 and look at what they released today. It's garbage. They deleted all pvp melee and land stuff. Instanced a little land trash and added machine guns, mortars, and torpedoes. I mean come on. It's supposed to be pirates not a pirate themed warships....
Great review, i wouldnt pay full price for it, id get the ubisoft+ sub of £15 pm to try it out, and at least that if i dont like it i can d/l the avatar - pandora game instead
Thank you for your kind words, makes it all the worthwhile. And couldn’t agree more on your strategy… pay the monthly cost, have your fill and then play Pandora. Cheers
Tel me you have no idea how sailboats work, without telling me you have no idea how sail boats work 😀I can't stop laughing at speeds and accelerations this "sailboats" achieve! 😀 😀 They move faster then Cat with twin 500HP outboards and turn sharper then racing jet ski! :-D WTF?! 😀
Mate, it was honestly the number one thing that stood out for me when playing this for the first time. It killed all immersion as I just treated it like a car. I can’t say that I’ve ever captained a Galleon, and I’ll take a stab in the dark and say that you haven’t either, but I think we both know they don’t turn and accelerate like this.
Talk about a police state, YT has removed 2 posts by me and neither was offensive, just a bit too close to the truth. So, let's see if this one stays up or is removed. This is a different take on why this games fails . . . in the West. Although the lack of sword combat, ship raiding, and land exploration automatically makes it a fail. I have travelled the world, extensively, that is a fact not a boast. The peoples of the Far East have a different kind of temperament, maybe a bit manic and excitable. The crazier something is the more animated they get. So, there should be no surprise that if you give a Singapore team the anvilnext game engine, used by the Montreal team to make Assassins Creed, something confusing and disjointed was going to be the hybrid outcome. If you live inside different cultures something will always rub off. Different societies create different influences. The game might be a hit in the Far East, I hope it is, but why try and sell something designed for one culture to a different culture. Where they see it as a whole to us it becomes a game of two totally different styles, the intricate detail as one and the totally different graphical approach of the sea battles as the other. Much, much more work should have been put into the sea battles, particularly as that is the only "action" in the game.
Skull and Bones is exactly what I expected really, not good, not bad, just 'meh'. Also some additional content on 06:23 and to add more clarity... apparently PVP exclusive zones will come in a future content patch, but for now its very much limited, and from what I could gather, you can only really disable other players rather than actually sink them, so it's all a bit pointless really. As always, love to you all, Reggie xxx
Appreciate it mate. I didn’t talk too much much detail on all of the mission types and events, but for me it really doesn’t matter when the basic gameplay elements are as flawed as they are. A real shame.
youve made some pretty good points and i can tell youve actually played the game. the only gripe i have is the unfair comparisons to sea of thieves, fundamentally the game is a MMO action RPG alot of the things you brought are just rpg things and you cant compare to sea of thieves when it was going for something different. i think the comparisons for the most part were fair with black flag. btw ive played for about 18 hours i dont think the game is amazing but i think its better than the credit its given.
More than fair mate. And great point in sea of thieves… I think fundamentally the comparisons get made because sadly (and the industry needs to wake up to this point) is that there just isn’t many pirate games to compare to. I think we all levitate to sea of thieves because that’s the closest, but your points are more than fair.
The graphics ain't THAT big of a step up from Black Flag tbh... And why is 70% of your pirate crew women?😂 All the NPCs on your ship just YAP all the time too🤦🏻♂️
Just found your channel through this review and I really appreciate how civilised and fairly you review things. I'm sick and tired of people just hating on things to get attention without even understanding what they're talking about. Having played basically all the content that was available in the final open beta, I totally agree. Everything is very low commitment and it feels like a very generic MMO with a pirate skin slapped on.
Thank you mate, really appreciate it. And yes, you have to give some fair balance. Skull and Bones is by no means terrible… it’s just not what Ubisoft want you to believe. And like you, I played the open beta to death and was surprised how far they let you go before the final game. A lot of my footage is from early on the playthrough but honestly, not all that much changes sadly. Glad you found the channel mate… and welcome!
Uncharted Waters Online - Still a good fun game with years of content. Games these days have so little content its laughable how people don't notice how much is missing
I think the combats good, lots skill needed to planning needed to fight efficiently, from reducing speeds to turn quicker to equiping mods and wepions that compliment each other and makes you pre plan combat tactics, the resource gathering is standard for open worlds mmo games, the weather does damage and sink ships and even effect ship control, they should do more when boarding ships and plundering settlements and also i think they should allow you to recruit troops also
I enjoyed the shit out of the beta. You can't go in thinking it's black flag, though, because it's not. It's essentially an mmo where your ship is the character. Pvp is where this game shines. Right now, pvp is limited , but its a lot of fun . Id like to see them open an area on the map thats just all open pvp, or even do a faction thing where 2 or 3 iffrent factions are constantly fighting over a trade route, where wich ever faction holds the trade route that fction gets x amount of resources an hr.
So usually we discuss triple A games as being the pinnacle with big studio budgets. Well the top dog at Ubisoft said this game is well worth the $70 and could be classified as AAAA. And thus, a meme was born.
If you are a woman who wants to be a pirate or gay who wants to be a pirate in a gay world of pirates well this is right up your street . A fine woke game made by ticking the right box programmers
Sons of the Forest is looking great if you like survival games and horror. That’s getting a full release next week but early access is out now. A review of course will be coming!
I’m surprised how much you had to say about the game in under 12 minutes. If it had melee combat, it be a Black Flag sequel. I rather enjoy this game, like fine tuning my car to drive it around in rl.
I enjoy how unrealisticly fast the boating is, id hate to be going slow trying to get across the waters and waste an hour of my life trying to travel somewhere and end up passing the fuck out from pure boredom going 1.5 knots, no fucking thankyou, let me go mach 2 and go isle to isle 😂
@@wrecklesstrain1991handle, not top speed. ie these ships accelerate, stop, and turn on a dime. Zero feel of momentum. The opening scene where you fight the british ships was enough to convince me this is not the sail ship game i want. World of warships does this way better
@@mechwarrior13 then by all means play world of warships, thats purely only multiplayer pvp, no explore no coop, just bland old same ol pvp, dont get me wrong that games fun and sick and i played my fair share, but this game is its own category, if it aint yo thang, hav fun on world of warships or any older pirate game like black flag or sea of thieves, me myself thinks this game is fun for wat it is, as i would not giv a fuck about black flag nor sea of thieves
I do try and be objective in my reviews. I gave Starfield an 8/10 which was very much against the grain. My suggestion is watch as many reviews as you can before making final judgement and dispensing your cash. But… if a game is average I’ll call it out for what it is. As a small channel of less than 5k subs, I’m not making any waves by being clickbaity… I just do the reviews because I love gaming and don’t think there’s enough honesty in our industry.
What really sucks is that acute lack of ships. There's only 9 which are mostly ugly but there's no Ship-on-the-Lines which makes it super disincentivising.
i think onfoot combat would give nothing more to this game , really who would spend 2 more minutes boarding a ship for 2 pieces of extra loot , wake up guys everything in mmos is efficiency
sea of thieves is a different kind of game it has no items ship equipment and builds its all cosmetics and has no vertical progression at all , you cant compare this games the only common they have is the pirate theme
I feel strongly the only reason the Game still exits at all is legally Ubisoft couldn't back out on it. It was payed for by the Singapore government. Black Flag absolutely was all around better, but even Odyssey was a better "Pirate" game and it wasn't even a Pirate game. lol
Your last comment about being sick of remakes and remasters is spot on. Lets not forget sequels that are cookie cutter copies of previous games. All of this is why I follow star citizen, they are trying to do something ambitious which breaks new ground in the industry and develops new tech for it. Personally I'm not a huge sci fi fan, but I want them to succeed to help bring the industry something new. And also hope the engine they make one day makes it into other developers hands so someone cane make me a decent fantasy world with it.
The game is not that bad everyone just mainly hates it because there is no hand to hand combat it’s all just ship, which is fine it’s just that it targets a specific audience.
Instead of spending £90 for the premium version I paid for a month of Ubisoft + for £14.99. Having played the game now I honestly wouldn't pay £15 for it. I'll use my Ubi + to play Avatar for a month and then that's it. Well done Ubisoft you've taken 10 years to make a game much worse than Black Flag. *Edit to say great video thanks.
Thank you kindly, appreciate it. And to get this review out, I did exactly as you did! I’ll be cancelling my subscription asap but will smash Avatar. Thanks again.
you clearly reviewing the game with a biased opinion and must favor sea of thieves anyway?... sea of thieves for me and many others are a laugh at the idea of a good pirate game from launch and beyond. at least here we have progression and a little weapon variety which is essentially all anyone wanted anyway. the game is good. especially for just launching. the fact that you base your comparisons off of sea of thieves mean that you like things that weren't fun in the first place? i dont get it?
I knew it was gonna be ass when I saw them collecting resources with the ship and you can't get off and raid the strongholds or castles and you barely get out of the ship... With no melee combat or boarding... It's just insane.. Dumb people working there
It's a great game. I left a 10/10. Once you erase the idea of what you expected and appreciate itnm for what it is, it's an amazing game. Have a good one.
@@yammt3148 it's pretty detailed, i saw an elephant at one point, a flock of zebra, a monkey, different regions. If you guys pulled your Brigantine you googled where to get 6 hour into the game, out of full speed. I'd still rather play this sea of thieves, or any other pirate game. No sword combat? That's fine, i would play the hundreds of other games out there saturating the Dark Souls Genre if i wanted sword and single shots.
@@cockneygamerI was already out when I found out there was no boarding combat or swashbuckling. But the last straw was figuring out that cannons are basically a machinegun. 2 cannons on one side? That means I get 4 shots that go off in rapid succession. Makes total sense!
yay.. Twice the price for Half the content and quality of AC4 Black Flag.
lol and that Ubi director guy was saying just before release "Skull and bones is not a triple A, it's a quadruple A". Well you can quadruple get the fk off then
You know there will be a LOT of dmmies shelling out $70 for this crap on console. Hey its not my money
If you guys are basing this game off of a review that's your loss. This game is actually pretty good. Fun as hell. If you look at the numbers they released, it don't line up with any of these hater as reviewers. Everyone wanted a sea of thieves clone it seems but this isn't sea of thieves believe it or not there is a game for that. Have fun being late to the party when you finally figure out its fun.
Yea exactly the same game lol
@@mlgbeeler420there is 10 hours of content max before it goes to complete boring.... It's not even a grindy just boring.... Pirates of the Caribbean online was better game play and 10x the content even the free version...
Ubisoft - I'm SO comfortable with not owning your games - just like you wanted.
Had you been alive 1000 years ago they would have hailed you a f"cking poet and thrown wife's at you
So, AAAA actually translates to $70 mobile game.
Okay I like Skull and Bones but this comment was funny.
+ macro transactions and typical lame paid seasons
Shallower than a kiddie pool. 10 years and we get this travesty? Once again Ubisoft being the greatest at disappointing.
Never heard so much “sayings” in one piece of text. Love the accent. Keep it up!
Ubisoft is right. I won’t be “owning” Skull and Bones anytime soon!
The game is fine for what it is, but they are asking way too much money for it. I don't see this game lasting a month before its on sale.
It's just typical Ubisoft, they did the same thing with For Honor.
It's like they take an awesome idea, get a master to work on 1 or 2 of its concepts and then have a room full of monkeys build the remaining 90% of the game.
I have this theory that Ubisoft employ absolutely anyone to stay competitive, even people who need help tying their own shoes, because they can just tell them "your payment is the honor of working for us" and they will swallow it, that's how stupid they are.
No hand to hand combat and no exploration,black flag is 10 times better .
The problem is they left all the pirate stuff out of a pirate game... No land exploration... No sword combat, or ship raiding... What were they thinking???
This is a nutshell. It’s such a watered down experience because of it.
Dang I was looking into this game deff won’t get it now lol that is god awful they would not have any of that
All that came with the base game.... lol. It pretty much ended up being what it was initially supposed to be. a multiplayer ship combat DLC for Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag, they just forgot to include the functionality with the base game. what a shame, it would of been a great DLC for Black Flag, lol.
So when you are boarding another ship i just hop n yours to take it? Or how would that work?😅😂
@@bartu4818 they dont know because they havent played the game. They just recycle the same shit from other reviewers. God forbid formulating your own opinions these days. LOL. The game is fun and you dont have to board a ship to enjoy it. In fact I would not be surprised in the future we see them implement island exploring. That would be a nice touch to add. But I do not feel like my money was wasted buying this game.
70 dollars while it also has a battlepass and cash shop. No thanks
ship battles feel like starfield space battles
And that's literally the entire game too...
There’s a reason Ubisoft is remaking black flag. Even they know how crap this game is. This was in development hell and at this point they just released it to get it out of the way
maybe when they remake AC4 BlackFlag, Skull & Bones will go back to original concept. a multiplayer ship DLC for Black Flag.
No one has mentioned that you cant even use your UCOINS to get 20% off the game, like where did that come from.....
They say AAAA Yet you take one comparison of this game to red dead redemption 2 this game literally cannot compare and should be a fraction of the price they are charging. It’s a fun game but it’s not worth full price
This is a great objective review..thank you..keep up the good work..looks like this might be catered to a younger simpler crowd. Not the hardcore pirate RPG serious gamers want
Thank you mate, appreciate your kind comments.
"As awkward as watching a movie sex scene with your parents." Had me rolling on the floor. 🤣
Sadly we’ve all been there!
3:18 "It takes all the thinking out of the controls" *100% whiff on the easiest of broadsides*
I only really looked into this right before the open beta, and playing the beta yeah there are some issues. However, all of your footage shows only the second ship in the game, the terrible one the tutorial made you build, did you ever get past that to one of the other 5 ships in the beta? Also, its a multiplayer game, did you ever partner with anyone else?
I think its a hard sell at $60 comparing to what else is available, especially indy, but I'm definitely going to get $60 worth of enjoyment out of it. The premium edition does not bring the extra $30 of value being exclusively cosmetics after the 16th, but ultimately if you play any game wrong its going to suck. I'm not convinced you fully explored what is on offer here and decided it was mediocre cause you just didn't explore the fun parts, as even your Sea of Thieves clip here shows you on a galleon, a boat that is near impossible to man solo. Had you only played SoT manning a galleon solo, you'd likely have a much different opinion of the game.
There isnt even a broadside. I had a ship with 2 cannons on each side. When broadside to an enemy, those 2 cannons meant that I had 4 shots to lay into the enemy before reloading. Yes, each shot fires after the next as though you were firing a cannonball machine gun. And every shot converged on my reticle regardless of the angle. So its less a broadside, and more a machine gun where the more canons you get, the larger your magazine.
@ansgar_odinson technically the more cannons you get the bigger your magazine is in real life too. But it's just a video game. Does it really matter if the two cannons fires 4 shots? I didn't see simulator in the title
Imagine if rockstar made a pirate game
it would be record breaking for the next 10 years lol
this game perfectly encapsulate modern gaming, it should've been dead and buried long time ago but now its seeing the light of day anyway because ubisoft contract obligation with a whole goddamn country.
shame, because when i first heard about it it sounded amazing. i started getting worried after the delays and then it’s dev cycle got ridiculous.
i hope any devs wanting to make a pirate game like this don’t get scared off by what happened
This game seems like a modded version of any Assassins Creed naval combat. Nothing more, nothing less
Glad I didn’t waste $70-100 bucks on The Division 3: Discount Pirates
I will play and think I will enjoy it a little. Just wish it came out 10 years ago. Been following the game since 2013 when it was going to be an expansion to AC: Black Flag
surprise here is your DLC Black Flag Infinite. they just forgot to include the functionality with the base game. slight oversight.
Same here. I feel like the comsints he mentions I won't mind at all.
Good news everyone, Black Flag is on sale on steam if you never played it before like me, picking that up for the superior pirate game.
I’m jealous you get to play for the first time. Even after all these years it still looks great.
I mean the games really not bad, story is alright (haven’t seen more than like 2-3 hours cause I only play for a bit after work) and like you said, graphics are good but apparently at a cost of gameplay. I just bought one month of Ubi+ to try it out and while I do enjoy it a bit, I’m definitely not spending $60/$90 on it. I can wait for a sale
I really tried to power through and find...something, to keep me going, but did not find it unfortunately
So close to 5k! Keep pushing!
No one has made a pirate game correctly since Sid Myers Pirates. The game is old but they nailed the mechanics of trading, pirating, dealing with diffrent countries and sailing the open world seas. If someone would just take that game and turn it into a modern title it would do really well. Basically we need Sea Of Thieves mixed with Sid Myers Pirates to create the ultimate pirate game. It's not just about sailing your ship. Theres business and deplomacy involved as well. SOT is cool but I want a more realistic pirate game.
I totally forgot about that game!! Haha.
Thank you for making us feel old! Well said though, that really was a fantastic game. Just remake that in unreal engine 5 and we will be set for life.
HOnestly, if someone sat down with SMP and listed off its features and just remade a 3d, in person version of it in unreal or unity, they would make a freaking fortune.
@@TheWorldsprayer Agreed.
I have to say the first pirates if the carribbean publish3d by bethesda was also not bad.
Looting in Sea of Thieves sucks!. You Can’t carry that much. You do the pirate Skull vault and it takes forever to get all the loot on the boat. Then you have to do it all over again just to sell the stuff.
I had a lot of fun with the open beta and really like the graphics of this game!
They put a lot of effort into all those little details on the ship (singing crew, pet, customization options).
You can add many different updates (hulls, cannons, furniture) to go for different playstiles.
When I saw the healing cannons (that repair ships) and the basilisks, it was clear, that a lot of group dynamic fights will be possible.
You can go for ramming and use short range cannons with a tanky ship, or you go long range and heal teamates with a faster but more fragile ship.
The wind system and behaviour of the ship is just wonderfull!
The influence of waves and the drag to the side if you think you go straight but the wind pushes you to one side is very realistic.
If you go fast you have not the same turning radius as if ou go slow, so there is a physics model applied to the ship.
There is night and day and weather animation which make the game very atmospheric.
If you are overloaded you can't go full speed, your sails can get damaged and your hull can have leaks.
I accept this game as what it is, a MMORPG on the water, where PvE, quests and gathering is the main goal.
From what I hear here and on other platforms, those who complain looked for a PvP centered hardcore game.
I heard the same after the release of New World and now with the release of Throne and Liberty.
Idk if we need two versions of each game released or seperated servers those with PVP and those without.
I remember the times of Guildwars 2 when there was a very interesting PvP Arena with 3 teams fighting for the win.
The winning team went into the endfight against the Endboss of the game to earn a serverwide honorfull mention and
great loot. Can't there be a good and meaningfull PvP in arenas? Why PvP everywhere is so important?
I loved when Yves justified the game by saying “it’s massive…”. How many cycles of Ubisoft games have we gone through that are “massive” and absolute borefests? Several generations of Far cry, AssCream, Division, Ghost Recons… and the list goes on…. Quantity is not quality.
I will say The Division has great cities though
I mean i find it like this. Skull amd bones is almost rouge like in some aspects. You can be level 5-7 level 10 will definitely kill you quickly. Reason i like skull and bones is it brings the combat more simple like black flag, the cannon mechanics were virtually the same i know i still play both... skull and bones can be played solo or with friends captaining thier own ship. Sea of thieves is a bit different. You have a multi crew ship and as cool as it is having multi rolls. But can make your dhip options and how far you go based on not only your own skill but that of your crew. Its great when you got people to play with. But skull and bones has many good things to like about it and i have my own issies with the game like boarding or traveling around your own ship would be cool
Do yourself a favor and play Black Flag or Rogue instead (even tho its not a pirate game but it has the same and slightly better naval gameplay of blackflag) Great video btw
I had fun with the demo but I'll probably still wait for a discount until I buy it
Trash game is trash. Ships control like helicopters more than ships, no weight, instant momentum shifts. Worse in every single way than Black Flag. Shocking it took a decade to produce this garbage.
If it ever goes down to like 15 bucks, I can see myself jumping in because this type of game is a niche I want to enjoy and see more of.
so which is it? Quadruple A or ten years in development hell?
Haven't bought a Ubisoft game since Assassins Creed Odyssey and I don't see myself purchasing any of their games anytime soon lol
Most frustrating part about Ubisoft is that they actually have some fantastic franchises. But you feel like they are clueless to give fans what they want from them. Exhibit A: Splinter Cell.
It's arcadey as fuck for a game based solely on naval combat - A problem that befalls most pirate-themed games (even AC Black Flag). Ships did not blow up and sink after 3 or 4 quick volleys in as many seconds. It took a damn sight longer to reload guns in real life, and they didnt zip around like speed boats either. Wind direction was everything, but that matters very little in this game. Glad I tried the demo first...realised after 2-3 hours it was a giant bucket of chum. It's currently £20 on Steam and it still feels too expensive.
My first thought was "Hyena" isn't the only multi-million pound disaster. The continuous remodeling over ten years has resulted in a disjointed game of the sum of its parts, and it doesn't work. Add to that the no swordplay, ship raiding, and land exploration and the whole debacle has to hold together on the most ridiculous of sea battles. We have very good onboard graphics of the shipboard life diminishing to cartoon battles where the ships move at the most unrealistic and crazy speeds and laughable cannon action and flames. Nothing is cohesive which happens when a game goes through one re-invention after another.
One thing you cannot do in a game like this is take out hand-to-hand combat as that turns all protagonists into bit players.
This is most definitely for the bargain basement in a short time.
After decades of gaming I have seen so many "Pirate" games come and go.
What I would like to see is a triple A pirate game made in the way The Witcher is made. A strong story-line with the sandbox approach. As I see it you have the choice of progression through advancement in the story-line or advancement in combat, The Witcher has both. You can step off and on of the story-line.
Like I said, another "Hyena" except that they want £50 to try and recoup their mistake of not dumping it years ago.
Well said mate, absolutely spot on analysis that.
Noone gives us brits the what for when the navy are concerned 😂 subbed 🎉
Rule Britannia good sir!
They really need to add more pvp areas etc.. plus they def need to add hand to hand ship boarding and island fighting
Assassins Creed: Pirates was what Skull and Bones wishes it was.
I thought this was a AAAA game! 😂
I can't believe people still pays for Ubisoft games
The way you say it takes the thinking out of the game how it plays was the selling point for me. I'm in and downloading now. Thanks!
I feel there's way more to the game. Teaming up, events, economic scale...better than getting camped in COD and waiting for load screens
They need to really change their company and come up with new material. I un-installed the beta after two hours of trying to have fun with it
I appreciate the more objective review, but I do get a bit confused why so many people compare this game to Black Flag.
Like it never claimed to be a game like that, it seems like every comparison seems to be showing how Black Flag does x better, but they’re basically a completely different genre besides being pirate themed.
Srsly, what do you smoke?
It… literally owes it’s existence to black flag! People wanted more black flag, skull & bones was literally Ubi’s answer! Looks like they couldn’t even do that right.
it is actually... because thats what we wanted and asked for
LoL you obviously haven't been following this fromm the start. Look at the trailers of what they promised use in 2017 and 2018 and look at what they released today. It's garbage. They deleted all pvp melee and land stuff. Instanced a little land trash and added machine guns, mortars, and torpedoes. I mean come on. It's supposed to be pirates not a pirate themed warships....
So yes. It was SUPPOSED to be Black flag 2.0 x 10. It was supposed to be an MMO. Now it's a mobile like arcade game
Great review, i wouldnt pay full price for it, id get the ubisoft+ sub of £15 pm to try it out, and at least that if i dont like it i can d/l the avatar - pandora game instead
Thank you for your kind words, makes it all the worthwhile. And couldn’t agree more on your strategy… pay the monthly cost, have your fill and then play Pandora. Cheers
Wonder why the big name streamers say its great huh i wonder
Tel me you have no idea how sailboats work, without telling me you have no idea how sail boats work 😀I can't stop laughing at speeds and accelerations this "sailboats" achieve! 😀 😀 They move faster then Cat with twin 500HP outboards and turn sharper then racing jet ski! :-D WTF?! 😀
Mate, it was honestly the number one thing that stood out for me when playing this for the first time. It killed all immersion as I just treated it like a car. I can’t say that I’ve ever captained a Galleon, and I’ll take a stab in the dark and say that you haven’t either, but I think we both know they don’t turn and accelerate like this.
Talk about a police state, YT has removed 2 posts by me and neither was offensive, just a bit too close to the truth.
So, let's see if this one stays up or is removed.
This is a different take on why this games fails . . . in the West. Although the lack of sword combat, ship raiding, and land exploration automatically makes it a fail.
I have travelled the world, extensively, that is a fact not a boast.
The peoples of the Far East have a different kind of temperament, maybe a bit manic and excitable. The crazier something is the more animated they get.
So, there should be no surprise that if you give a Singapore team the anvilnext game engine, used by the Montreal team to make Assassins Creed, something confusing and disjointed was going to be the hybrid outcome.
If you live inside different cultures something will always rub off. Different societies create different influences.
The game might be a hit in the Far East, I hope it is, but why try and sell something designed for one culture to a different culture.
Where they see it as a whole to us it becomes a game of two totally different styles, the intricate detail as one and the totally different graphical approach of the sea battles as the other. Much, much more work should have been put into the sea battles, particularly as that is the only "action" in the game.
I see your comment loud and clear, and appreciate you sharing your thoughts!
this is worth a like and sub, even if you have never been north of Watford
Spat my tea out at this. I won’t lie, I once went further north than Watford when I watched Spurs play Everton. A scary day all round.
Skull and Bones is exactly what I expected really, not good, not bad, just 'meh'. Also some additional content on 06:23 and to add more clarity... apparently PVP exclusive zones will come in a future content patch, but for now its very much limited, and from what I could gather, you can only really disable other players rather than actually sink them, so it's all a bit pointless really. As always, love to you all, Reggie xxx
Actually you can sink them in the pvp events. Good review anyway!
Appreciate you clearing that one up!
Couldn’t agree more. Such an untapped genre.
It really is that simple that, that is all we want yet year after year no-one is capable of producing it.
Good review. Got my sub.
Very kind, appreciate your support and welcome to the gang!
I played the open beta and pretty much fully agree with what was said in this review. Very disappointed unfortunately.
Appreciate it mate. I didn’t talk too much much detail on all of the mission types and events, but for me it really doesn’t matter when the basic gameplay elements are as flawed as they are. A real shame.
youve made some pretty good points and i can tell youve actually played the game. the only gripe i have is the unfair comparisons to sea of thieves, fundamentally the game is a MMO action RPG alot of the things you brought are just rpg things and you cant compare to sea of thieves when it was going for something different. i think the comparisons for the most part were fair with black flag. btw ive played for about 18 hours i dont think the game is amazing but i think its better than the credit its given.
More than fair mate. And great point in sea of thieves… I think fundamentally the comparisons get made because sadly (and the industry needs to wake up to this point) is that there just isn’t many pirate games to compare to. I think we all levitate to sea of thieves because that’s the closest, but your points are more than fair.
The graphics ain't THAT big of a step up from Black Flag tbh... And why is 70% of your pirate crew women?😂 All the NPCs on your ship just YAP all the time too🤦🏻♂️
Try Avatar Frontiers of Pandora was a lot of fun with a twisted storyline
Just found your channel through this review and I really appreciate how civilised and fairly you review things. I'm sick and tired of people just hating on things to get attention without even understanding what they're talking about.
Having played basically all the content that was available in the final open beta, I totally agree. Everything is very low commitment and it feels like a very generic MMO with a pirate skin slapped on.
Thank you mate, really appreciate it. And yes, you have to give some fair balance. Skull and Bones is by no means terrible… it’s just not what Ubisoft want you to believe. And like you, I played the open beta to death and was surprised how far they let you go before the final game. A lot of my footage is from early on the playthrough but honestly, not all that much changes sadly.
Glad you found the channel mate… and welcome!
Uncharted Waters Online - Still a good fun game with years of content. Games these days have so little content its laughable how people don't notice how much is missing
I need to say. What a great review in general. Great vid.
Too kind mate, appreciate you commenting here
Mate, got the $100 version and it’s absolute trash. Digital version so I can’t return this heap of pooh 😢
:-( Reggie mourns for your wallet
So... Skull and Bones is what I thought it is. A little bit of Story and the rest is everyone against everyone. Not for me.
Skulls and Bones feels like chores, not fun at all. Mobile like game play mechanics and MTXs!!!! Do not suckered in FOMO, wait for reviews.
I bought it for xbox. After an hour i requested my money back from Microsoft. The game ia horrible.
at this point It's embarrasing to be Ubi dev...
I think the combats good, lots skill needed to planning needed to fight efficiently, from reducing speeds to turn quicker to equiping mods and wepions that compliment each other and makes you pre plan combat tactics, the resource gathering is standard for open worlds mmo games, the weather does damage and sink ships and even effect ship control, they should do more when boarding ships and plundering settlements and also i think they should allow you to recruit troops also
The combat in pirates of the Caribbean online was better and deeper.... Lmao
My main complaint for this game is always going to be the way you control your ship.
LoL you ever tried atlas? You will hate skull and bones after playing that age you will understand how dumbed down s&b is
Rather Play Black Flag.
I enjoyed the shit out of the beta. You can't go in thinking it's black flag, though, because it's not. It's essentially an mmo where your ship is the character. Pvp is where this game shines. Right now, pvp is limited , but its a lot of fun . Id like to see them open an area on the map thats just all open pvp, or even do a faction thing where 2 or 3 iffrent factions are constantly fighting over a trade route, where wich ever faction holds the trade route that fction gets x amount of resources an hr.
This is like if you asked ai to make a shitty pirate game.
Why is everybody saying “AAAA” and what does it mean?
So usually we discuss triple A games as being the pinnacle with big studio budgets.
Well the top dog at Ubisoft said this game is well worth the $70 and could be classified as AAAA. And thus, a meme was born.
@@cockneygamer okay, thank you.
skyrim on the sea
This game isn't worth $70😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’m annoyed at not calling the price out in the review, because yes, $70 is madness
@@cockneygamer This was the comment i was looking for, great review beside that tho
Yoo ! can you review Granblue Fantasy Relink pleaseee xD
If you are a woman who wants to be a pirate or gay who wants to be a pirate in a gay world of pirates well this is right up your street . A fine woke game made by ticking the right box programmers
UBisoft the next gen AAAA game
ngl bored out of my mind recently so i still might get it but ill wait a little and see
Lol that's me most of the time. It's like I'm so bored that I buy games I probably shouldn't buy😅
Sons of the Forest is looking great if you like survival games and horror. That’s getting a full release next week but early access is out now.
A review of course will be coming!
@@cockneygamer i played it on release with the boys
Love how honest you are Reggie! Really useful and engaging reviews!
Thank you, I love to hear it. I wish I could get more content out but life gets in the way sadly. Thank you for commenting, it makes it all worth it.
Sea of Thieves exists
I’m surprised how much you had to say about the game in under 12 minutes. If it had melee combat, it be a Black Flag sequel. I rather enjoy this game, like fine tuning my car to drive it around in rl.
Totally disagree I thought it was really fun
I liked it a lot too. Typical UA-camrs will trash games to get views. Then the gullible viewers believe it as fact
Enjoy your arcade game from 2014, we won't be playing but hope you have fun!@@Brentt777
All i see here is cry cry cry mybe u should of watched the video befor buying and crying
Ships from the 1600 handle like its Need For Speed lmao gtfo with this trash
Haha, too true
I enjoy how unrealisticly fast the boating is, id hate to be going slow trying to get across the waters and waste an hour of my life trying to travel somewhere and end up passing the fuck out from pure boredom going 1.5 knots, no fucking thankyou, let me go mach 2 and go isle to isle 😂
@@wrecklesstrain1991handle, not top speed. ie these ships accelerate, stop, and turn on a dime. Zero feel of momentum. The opening scene where you fight the british ships was enough to convince me this is not the sail ship game i want. World of warships does this way better
@@mechwarrior13 then by all means play world of warships, thats purely only multiplayer pvp, no explore no coop, just bland old same ol pvp, dont get me wrong that games fun and sick and i played my fair share, but this game is its own category, if it aint yo thang, hav fun on world of warships or any older pirate game like black flag or sea of thieves, me myself thinks this game is fun for wat it is, as i would not giv a fuck about black flag nor sea of thieves
@@wrecklesstrain1991 i dont play world of warships dummy, why the language
UA-camrs get views by trashing games.
but they also save me lots of money by reviewing SHIT games!
I do try and be objective in my reviews. I gave Starfield an 8/10 which was very much against the grain.
My suggestion is watch as many reviews as you can before making final judgement and dispensing your cash.
But… if a game is average I’ll call it out for what it is. As a small channel of less than 5k subs, I’m not making any waves by being clickbaity… I just do the reviews because I love gaming and don’t think there’s enough honesty in our industry.
Eh skull and bones looks garb but sea of thieves lost its heart long ago
What really sucks is that acute lack of ships. There's only 9 which are mostly ugly but there's no Ship-on-the-Lines which makes it super disincentivising.
Except... SOMEHOW its WORSE than sea of thieves LOL!
What bollox you talk
i think onfoot combat would give nothing more to this game , really who would spend 2 more minutes boarding a ship for 2 pieces of extra loot , wake up guys everything in mmos is efficiency
Sea of Thieves showed how that can work perfectly and is one of the best features of naval combat!
sea of thieves is a different kind of game it has no items ship equipment and builds its all cosmetics and has no vertical progression at all , you cant compare this games the only common they have is the pirate theme
I feel strongly the only reason the Game still exits at all is legally Ubisoft couldn't back out on it. It was payed for by the Singapore government.
Black Flag absolutely was all around better, but even Odyssey was a better "Pirate" game and it wasn't even a Pirate game. lol
The first mistake Ubisoft did was to give the SaB project to the Singaporeans for monetary reasons.
I know when Sea of Thieves realesed their trailers I was like:
"Skull & Bones looks so much more fun."
That aged like milk... Sadly
At least you’re an honest man. Sadly true because for all intents and purposes you were spot on… it should be more fun and have a lot of depth.
Your last comment about being sick of remakes and remasters is spot on. Lets not forget sequels that are cookie cutter copies of previous games. All of this is why I follow star citizen, they are trying to do something ambitious which breaks new ground in the industry and develops new tech for it. Personally I'm not a huge sci fi fan, but I want them to succeed to help bring the industry something new. And also hope the engine they make one day makes it into other developers hands so someone cane make me a decent fantasy world with it.
Thank you for the HONEST review.
You are most welcome!
The game is not that bad everyone just mainly hates it because there is no hand to hand combat it’s all just ship, which is fine it’s just that it targets a specific audience.
this really makes me sad because i was expecting a better black flag, such a shame ubisoft can't make good games anymore.....
Instead of spending £90 for the premium version I paid for a month of Ubisoft + for £14.99. Having played the game now I honestly wouldn't pay £15 for it. I'll use my Ubi + to play Avatar for a month and then that's it. Well done Ubisoft you've taken 10 years to make a game much worse than Black Flag. *Edit to say great video thanks.
Thank you kindly, appreciate it. And to get this review out, I did exactly as you did! I’ll be cancelling my subscription asap but will smash Avatar. Thanks again.
you clearly reviewing the game with a biased opinion and must favor sea of thieves anyway?... sea of thieves for me and many others are a laugh at the idea of a good pirate game from launch and beyond. at least here we have progression and a little weapon variety which is essentially all anyone wanted anyway. the game is good. especially for just launching. the fact that you base your comparisons off of sea of thieves mean that you like things that weren't fun in the first place? i dont get it?
Question for you good sir? What modern day pirate game would you compare this to?
I knew it was gonna be ass when I saw them collecting resources with the ship and you can't get off and raid the strongholds or castles and you barely get out of the ship... With no melee combat or boarding... It's just insane.. Dumb people working there
Raiding and pillaging you’d think would be a fundamental part of being a pirate!
@@cockneygamer not in today's Dev visions 😂
Not digging this always online shit.
It's a great game. I left a 10/10. Once you erase the idea of what you expected and appreciate itnm for what it is, it's an amazing game. Have a good one.
I pirate game without pirate things... That's not expectations, that is the most basic thing... Stop trying to make us enablers like you.
@@yammt3148 it's pretty detailed, i saw an elephant at one point, a flock of zebra, a monkey, different regions. If you guys pulled your Brigantine you googled where to get 6 hour into the game, out of full speed. I'd still rather play this sea of thieves, or any other pirate game. No sword combat? That's fine, i would play the hundreds of other games out there saturating the Dark Souls Genre if i wanted sword and single shots.
Im sorry. IMO there is no good game underneath it all. I played the demo, and there is just nothing there.
Don’t be sorry mate, I think that’s a more than fair point!
@@cockneygamerI was already out when I found out there was no boarding combat or swashbuckling. But the last straw was figuring out that cannons are basically a machinegun. 2 cannons on one side? That means I get 4 shots that go off in rapid succession. Makes total sense!