@@TheWolfbay I'm pretty sure the majority of them are dead. The bulk of Stannis's army was killed at the Battle of the Blackwater, the rest were wiped out during the First Battle of Winterfell, if any survived they would have either fled or joined with Jon Snow at the Battle of the Bastards which I'm sure resulted in massive casualties for both sides. Then going on to S8 if there were any Baratheon Bannerman who somehow survived all of that they would've been present during the Long Night Battle. You'd either have to be extremely lucky or incredibly skilled to have survived all that, and I doubt most these men would've even survived the Blackwater.
@@Wuwarrior-bi2tl dude, learn to read what i said, ikm also pretty sure the most of them are dead what i said is out of those 100000 bannerman there would probably be 1 or more survivors...
This is what I like about Renly: He gives his full and complete attention to the champion, Brienne. Loras is looking at Renly, shaking his head. Margery is looking at him, too. But King Renly is in his regal finest; he requires the approval of no one.
@@JamesJJSMilton Renly’s army had more men than all the others combined. He certainly didn’t need Stannis and if Stannis didn’t happen to have a witch that could birth spectral assassins, he would have died fighting Renly.
@@Colin-kh6kp If, if, if. Renly should have known Stannis wasn't going to recklessly blunder his forces without a trick up his sleeve. He was an arrogant idiot though and didn't think more than 2 steps ahead, just like Robert before him.
@@eldarius237 In the book. Renly asks lady stark if ser barristan is with her son, because he said he was going to serve the true ruler of the throne, and he hadn't showed up to serve renly or stannis yet, so they figured the only other potentail ruler was robb. The whole section was foreshadowing to barristan showing up to serve daenerys
Quotes about Renly: "He knew how to dress and he knew how to smile and he knew how to bathe, and somehow he got the notion that this made him fit to be king." ” -Olenna Redwyne “Robert was the true steel. Stannis is pure iron, black and hard and strong, yes, but brittle, the way iron gets. He’ll break before he bends. And Renly, that one, he’s copper, bright and shiny, pretty to look at but not worth all that much at the end of the day.” - Donal Noye This sums Renly pretty well if you ask me.
I still believe Renly was the better choice. Most of the people loved and respected him he did unite an army of one hundred thousand. He was more wise than Robert and more merciful than Stannis.
maybe if she wasnt flat chested it would have. as it stands, she is the most ill equipped queen consort ever. which actually worked uite well, seeing as her husband was the most ill equipped king ever. dude was so gay he couldnt even fuck her drunk, he tried to put it in her butt.
Probably the most realistic fight in the entire show. We finally get to see armors serving their real defensive purpose and not just being cut and pierced in one strike.
I also like that you could really see the fatigue kicking in. Fighting in full armor + a weapon is pretty exhausting, so it's way more realistic when it's not some over the top fight.
Nat Luzentales you read the books? I'm thinking of Lady Stoneheart (Spoiler warning on that one). Seems she might not show up in the series though, but she's pretty bad as in the books.
3:35 Loras: If Rob Stark wants a pact with us, he should come himself, not hide behind his mother's skirts. Catelyn: *I'm about to end this man's whole career*
+I speaketh the truth the ancient greeks were big into pankration, which was wrestling and striking. outside of sport and competition, they believed that closing the distance and grappling an opponent makes it very difficult to use swords.
+I speaketh the truth Takedowns and grappling were very important in armoured combat. Her technique was well done and accurate to what medieval and renaissance men-at-arms would have done.
"My son is fighting a war - not playing at one!" The best part is that Renly actually concedes the point with his smirk. He knows she's right. And, after the shitshow that was High Garden's fall, I think we know why the Tyrells only play at war and backed down when faced with the Faith Militant....
High Garden's fall was bullshit, because you cant just take one of the biggest castle in realm in one evening. And you cant just move whole fleet/army without enemy knowing about it. Spies, scouts, dragon would learn for sure a few days in advance about movement of lion army and if they would want to move quickly they wouldnt have sige equipment with them. So they would have to build one. Or this is all bs and D&D wanted just to end the show
@@Just_a-guy While the fall of High Garden isn't unplausible, you're correct that it was bullshit. The entire strategy and realism was completely lost in Season 8. As you said, taking a castle in one night is virtually impossible, and High Garden's Larders were probably full. A siege would be pointless and impossible cause Daenerys swooping in with the Dragons would end the siege, all it takes is one Raven to make it out of the castle. The would have to break down the gates, and whilst High Garden may not be very adept at war they are also not completely incompetent. They can't be or they wouldn't be such an affluent House. Really just a shame...
@@cruusha9866 yea it's true, Highgarden was in control of lands completely untouched by war. The Lannisters were dealing with 2 wars with substantial losses and , debt and inflation. While the Tyrell army was effectively untouched the entire time (seeing as they went home after Renly was killed) They also had control over food production in the realm after the wars decimated the Riverlands. They could have done so much to have the Tyrells out of the picture or perhaps part of the Lannister's with whoever took over after Mace (since they decided to remove Mace's two eldest sons from the boks). But Jamie took the mighty Highgarden in less time than it took for him to take a bath.
She is always on point. Got and vikings both managed some of the best casting I've ever seen in my life. But they all also had incredibly good directors and editors because if you ever watched behind the scenes you'll see just how much direction the actors actually get in real time Every one of these actors would tell you that they are nothing without the best writes, directors, and editors
I think was the scene that made me really like Renly. You have all these lords and men disappointed that a woman bested a man, and even Margery who is supposedly a semi-good character is being quite petty with her brother's loss. Renly on the other hand takes it to good heart that his lover got his ass handed down to him, then even accepts Brienne's request despite the others being appalled at the idea.
In the books its even funnier because she totally destroys like five guys that had been mocking her in that melee. Poor Loras was just passing by and ended up being the last man standing in front of her
Gotta be honest, watching these scenes just reminds me of how much more I liked the Robb era on the show than any of the others. It felt like a war drama, now it's... different
Ironic isn't it? The closeted gay man is beaten by the woman everbody assumes is a lesbian! I like the way the show later shows that they both had two things in common: 1) Their dedication to being knights. 2) Their love for Renly.
Why would everybody assume she is a lesbian? She is, in book and show, obviously in love with Jaime Lannister. She practically admits it to Cersei at Joffrey's wedding feast. She's straight, she's just never met a man who's physically attracted to her, and she herself in only interested in strong, noble men, like the man Jaime is becoming.
Ah, ok then. I thought you were speaking of the viewpoint of fans of the series, not characters in it. Yeah, you're right then. That was and is the reaction of pretty much every man Brienne encounters in the series. Though some of them don't even think it through that much and just think 'freak'.
MrReded69 She could just simply be....I don't know...a TOMBOY? They are quite common. These ladies can be very straight girls and yet still have what have mainly been associated as "male traits".
VelmiVelkiZrut well one of his brave scene was in the book when ned stark set on the behalf of the king he send beric dondarrion before that lores volunteer to kill the mountain
@@zxylo786 Yes, in the book he's considered a prodigy. George even said that by the end of ADoD there's a case to be made that he's the most skilled swordsman alive.
People: Robert is a drunken, lustful fool...Renly is a glossy, boy-lover...Stannis...who is this guy? (a few seasons later under Joffrey's reign) People: We sure could use one of those three Baratheons right about now. Tyrion: No shit. I'm all you've got.
Robb almost had The Reach, The north, The Vale and the Stormlands on his side. imagine how the war would have played out if he wasn’t so dumb and if stannis wasn’t fighting his lil bro
It's also mentioned in the books that Loras's prodigal skill lies primarily in the joust. He even admits outright his older brother is a better swordsman than himself, and Jaime is one of the best in the seven kingdoms with a sword. Different knights excel in different things, and even then chance can unseat a famed knight.
While that's probable true, Loras is still notable as being an exceptionally good fighter. He's not Jamie Lannister, but he is very high tier. So Brienne's win over him is impressive and highlights that she's an eliete combatant, even if jousting is his real speciality.
Tempting fate though it is, I actually really like Renly in this scene. At this particular moment, Renly holds the most power militarily, economically (especially after Tywin reveals the Westerland's gold issue), and politically but when insulted to his face he just laughs it off and carries on. Sure, it's nice to trade barbs and insults with your rivals, but to not act like a child and throw threats shows a level of composure not often seen in a brutal world like this. That's my one and a half septims anyway. Then again, I still love the show and the books as separate entities, so apparently I'm already some kind of heretic in most people's eyes. Whoops!
+The One™ Mannis the "Burn your own daughter at the stake for power?" Stannis might have been an honourable man once. But his is a cautionary tale of what it means to lust for power. The allure of the Iron throne was too much for him, and he lost everything he loved, sacrificed everything he held dear over it. The TV Series plays down his religious zealotry. But with the way his arc was going? Pretty soon he'd have become a New Mad King, burning everyone who disagreed with him. Renly might have had the weakest claim of the Five Kings. But he would have been the greatest. Stannis rules by right of birth. Joffrey by right of conquest. But Renly had the backing of the people, and the ability and the wisdom to rule. He'd have allied with Rob Stark. He'd have recognised the threat beyond the rule. Its not hard to imagine he'd reinforce the Wall. I am almost certain he would have reached some agreement with Dany, were she to return to Westeros under his rule. He would have left the Kingdom in the best shape to defend against the Long Night.
Haradion Drogon Stannis recognized that the long night was coming and sent men to the wall. Renly would've just been taking it from Loras and would've indulged in King's Landing. If Renly had been a good guy he wouldve helped Ned install Stannis as King (the rightful heir) instead of squabbling for power himself. Guy starts this scene as Catelyn points out "playing at a war" Renly was all shownmanship and no action. If Renly was smart instead of being a sissy, he could've invaded King's Landing easily.
It's too bad Renly got whacked so early on. I feel the actor was just starting to come into his own as a king. But then the number of interesting characters that have been offed so far...Qorin Halfhand, the guy who Boromir'd himself for Arya & Gendry, maybe Arya's dancing master, et al. At least Jaqen H'gar is still around - cool and harder to kill off than pretty much anybody.
squamish4244 That's what I meant, he's been gone ever since so he might as well be dead. I thought Arya was going to meet him again during assassin training, but nope. Also the last thing he told Arya is that he's dead, so it's kind of true.
Love the attention to detail in the duel Brie is bigger, more likely to get hit because her size is a bigger hit radius so she uses a shield to protect herself. The flower Knight is smaller so he uses a axe with a long shaft to keep Brie at a distance and a axe has alot of stopping power, something you'd want to use against a bigger fighter
That is not how real life fighting works. Plus axes are not spears, because of being top heavy you have to grip it high. Look where his hand are on the axe. In term of reach axes arent great option.
@@Just_a-guy Yup, there's no way axes with spear tips on them would ever become popular. Oh, wait, that's a halberd: ua-cam.com/video/NMUzYDYD_lc/v-deo.htmlsi=5w6U-80BFt9TuI3b You also have this video where he demos some flexibility with range for the weapon. I would have liked to see a longer shaft on the weapon, yes. Battle axes were certainly a thing, though. And even something like a bearded axes can be useful for the thrust in a pinch, and even shaft hits are blunt force trauma that might jar a combatant off their feet or lead to an advantageous grapple for you. Honestly, I found this fight to be fairly realist. Loras even tried to knock her off her feet, but couldn't, because she's just that darn big and strong.
@@roguishpaladin I was commenting this one Axe which is held more like lumberjack one. Of course there were two handed axes (dane axe for example) not just halberd but they had thin blade. This fight wasnt that bad and because it was a final of group fight there isnt much to complain but explanation given in main comment is wrong. Being "bigger" doesnt made Brienne to pick up a shield and Loras didnt had/use that much range with his axe. Overall nice fight, it is good to see armor actually working, grappling and going for dagger is nice but i wouldnt agree with main comment
Feels so weird rewatching these. GoT back then felt like a grounded show with some light fantasy elements, especially with how they treated plate armour. Now its just... different
It seems that Loras is stupid to forgot the bonds between the Starks and Baratheons, to demand Cat to kneel. Stannis, Renly even Robert always treat the Starks with equal and much respect....
And if renly would have supported his older brother, which was his duty, and not proclaiming himself King with no good reason stannis could have had the forces of the stormlands from the begining, attack kings landing and execute joffrey and cersei. ohh renly....
Renly was poised to win the war at this point. The greatest tragedy in the series truly is that his host was scattered, even though I didn't like him that much personally. His demise opened all the doors for the Lannisters
Renly and rob would have been the greatest alliance in this series if renly never died.. Heck I wanted to see the tyrell/baratheon army fight the lannister
That would've worked in the short term but Renly's reign over Westeros would've been as bad a Robert's later reign, if not worse. Not only would he be setting the president that any younger sibling can take whatever they want with a large army, leading to who knows how many deaths. Furthermore, Renly was willing to leave Littlefinger in power and give titles to his friends like Mace Tyrell, who was a corrupt man The Small Council would've been riddled with the same corruption that allowed The Lannisters to thrive under Robert's reign. Come one of the later Seasons, once Daenerys Targaryen arrived in Westeros, many Reach Houses, being Targaryen Loyalists, would've switched sides.
@@gfilmer7150 I would argue that Stannis's reign would of been just as bad. Yes Stannis is dedicated to his duty and I am sure he would put many laws in place that could benefit the realm but his uncompromising nature would see him a short reign. He would never make peace with the Lannisters and the Tyrells would never side with him (due to a list of reasons). He also was heavily against Robb being named King of The North and Trident and even viewed him as a usurper. That's 4 of the Seven Kingdoms already against Stannis. With Renly he was already aligned with the Tyrells and was in talks with Robb of an alliance. He most likely would of crushed the Lannisters but there is possibility he would of made peace with them after taking the throne. That's one reason Stannis could never rule well. You can be as dutiful as can be but you can never be king if all your vassals are against you. Another reason, and one which many people don't take into account, is Stannis's court. Yes Stannis has a few good people in his court like Ser Davos and eventually Rolland Storm, but most of his court and majority of his army (before Renly's death and when he is in The North) are filled with Queens men. These men are religious extremists and have many members (Melisandre, Queen Selyse Florent, Axell Florent etc) that are in high places in Stannis's court and army. We have been already exposed to their extreme behaviour on Dragonstone when they burnt the sept there. If Stannis is to take the throne those Queens men are likely to burn the Sept of Baelor down and I doubt Stannis would be able to stop it since he couldn't stop it happening at Dragonstone and even somewhat cosigned their religion with the burning of the Seven statues. This would then create a war with the faith, similar to King Maegor's. The spread and influence of the Queens men and R'hllor would be a worse corruption than any of the Lords Renly would have at court. And the argument of Lord Mace's corruption in the position of hand of the king falls flat when you look at his Stannis counterpart, Lord Alester Florent, a man that is just as corrupt if not more than Mace, a man that changes his religion to R'hllor as soon as he switches sides from Renly to Stannis so that he can gain favour in Stannis's court. And Stannis names him Hand of the King. About your point of Renly setting a precedent of the younger brother being entitled to the throne, I believe it's impact is way over exaggerated. One reason for this is because its happened before, actually in both Stannis and Renly's bloodline. There was a point in the Durrandon Kings succession line that a younger bastard overthrew his older true born brother who had been King of the Stormlands. That event never set a precedent so why would Renly's claim to the throne do so. The only precedent it would set is that people are able to claim the throne through right of conquest, which was already a precedent. I'd also add that Renly's reign would not be as bad as Roberts. Renly would actually do his job and tend to the realm and attend council meetings as he had been already doing so as Master of Laws. Also whilst the Tyrell influence would be prevelant in Renly's court it would never be as bad as the Lannisters. Robert had the Lannisters do whatever they wanted, allowed himself to be in massive debt to them and even allowed Cersei to influence his Kingsguard and add Lannister cronies such as Meryn Trant and Boros Blount. There is no evidence Renly would allow this as he has a Kingsguard made up of people loyal to him and is not in debt to Lord Mace. Also I would much rather the influence of the Tyrells than that of the Lannisters or Melisandre, Florents and the Queens men.
@@amanimckenzie32 Stannis takes KL, Tywin could try to besiege it if Stannis lops off both Joffrey and Tommen's heads, then there's no Lannister King for Marg to marry as she can't marry the hostage Cersei, making The Tyrell Alliance mute. Ironically, if Tywin besieges KL and the Tyrells bail, Robb may want to hoof it over to the capital to break Tywin and save Sansa (and Arya). I don't think you need to do much math in that scenario to calculate who comes out on top. As for the aftermath, Robb's host would be bloodied and Stannis would still have his sisters. And as for Renly, he says himself he would've made Robb bend the knee and swear an oath of fealty. Even though Renly says Robb can be King, he would've turned Robb into nothing more than a glorified puppet, something Robb wouldn't've been happy about. As for Stannis as King, I doubt he'd let his followers get too rowdy. He may turn a blind eye but not for long, I mean look what happened when his officers demanded he burn people at Crofter's Village. Sure he killed three criminals but he went no further than that, talking down to his men who suggested it. So the problem with Renly is that he is second to last in the bottom of succession, Hell, very last if you include Shireen being above him. I imagine the guy who over threw his brother wasn't the youngest of three, plus that event happened thousands of years ago and people in Westeros only remember was everything after The Conquest. And Renly's reign would have been pretty bad seeing as Mace Tyrell would spread his influence as far as he could and Renly wouldn't go against his father-in-law. Also, the people of King's Landing wouldn't be crazy enough to adopt this foreign religion without a miracle and they'd be more likely to adopt Tyrell gold.
@@gfilmer7150 Firstly there is no way Stannis will kill Joffrey and Tommen both and nullify the Tyrell Lannister alliance (unless you are talking about the show). This is because the Lannisters had a back up plan for if Kings Landing fell and would of crowned Tommen as king at Rosby. This would then continue the alliance. As for Renly's terms for alliance with The North it is not as you put it. He gives Robb the ability to be king and bend the knee. This would put The North in a similar situation to Dorne when they bent the knee. There is also no evidence that Renly wanted to make Robb a puppet, that is just false. With Stannis he straight up names Robb a usurper and orders him to bend the knee having no negotiation about it. This sets Stannis having 4 Kingdoms against him whilst Renly only had one (The Westerlands). There is also no factor pointing to Robb and The North bending the knee once Sansa is in Stannis's control. They are fighting a war of independence and they didn't trade the Stark girls and back down when it was the Lannisters they were against. All that would happen is that the conflict would shift from the Lannisters vs Robb to Stannis vs Robb.This sets Stannis up for a turbulent and probably short reign. As for Stannis and his court, the influence of the Queens men is already overgrown. Much of his council is made up of R'hllor supporters. Just because he stopped them burning a village doesn't mean he can stop them burning the Sept of Baelor. If Stannis was to take Kings Landing its evident that the Sept would of been burnt and there would of been war with the faith. And also when I mention influence of the Queens men I don't mean the people of Kings Landing would turn to the religion, i mean that many of Stannis main supporters and council are Queens men and thus will be able to influence Stannis's court from positions of power. This evidence is seen in his wife and Hand of The King being R'hllor worshippers. Also the Durrandon King thing was even worse than what Renly was doing. Why, because he was a younger bastard. So my point about setting precedences still stands. And it happening years ago changes nothing. All it shows is that through all those years it did not set any precedent. People may not remember it now but people did 5 or 10 years after it happend and a precedent was never set. Yes I agree that Mace would try to spread his influence far and wide but whose to not say the Queens men and the Florents won't do the same. The Florents are just the Stannis counterpart of the Tyrells. And their spread of influence is less to do with people adoping the religion but more to do with putting people that are apart of the religion in influencial places by using their already set status and positions in Stannis's court, influenctial positions such as Queen and Hand of The King. Plus the Queens men are a lot more corrupt and violent than the Tyrells so their spreading of influence would be far worse.
Three powerful and strong women here, each in her own way, but I love how Catelyn is dominant - more assured and ultimately stronger than either of the other two. Her death was one of the great disappointments in the show. I wish we could have gotten Lady Stoneheart.
wow. Someone says how they love the women in this show and people have to bring up how men are considered "stronger" Lol it's not 1930 anymore. Even if a few men are a little stronger, that doesn't mean all Women are weak. if you get what i am saying. it's sad that sexist people still exist.
sinkingships offools You're not very good at reading comprehension are you? Nicole is lame said nothing about women on average being stronger or equally as strong as men.
sinkingships offools i don't think you are just drunk. I think you are stupid too. Very stupid tbh. Also "femanazi" is so dumb. Sorry that I'm fighting for my rights, and equal rights.
According to the books, Brienne is really ugly and also looks clumsy and uncomfortable in both armor and women's clothes. She is constantly ridiculed, but also underestimated, and I think her walk captures this perfectly.
Loras Tyrell is a great warrior. Shame he's been finding himself fighting top tier people all the time in the show lol. Getting jumped by the Mountain and Brienne who subdued Jaime Lannister (albeit severely weakened). I don't remember if he fought anyone else besides participating in the Blackwater.
The respect renly shows for cat and the starks is actually amazing here. I never noticed that. Didnt give two shts bout cat kneeling bc their ties go way back. Promises lannister heads for the injustices’, even wants to team w rob. Man rob really coulda won this war if he made different choices and of course didnt red wedding it up. But. Renly an rob with stannis, the boltons, and the north. Sht that force would of been crazier that eddard and robert and the boys.
@@NeilPower feel like that is the advantage that brinne has in a lot of fights. There are pragmatic fighters, bralwer fighters, and skilled honor fighters in the show. Bronn was a pragmatic fighter largely. he was skilled but he worked around hwo to best exploit his enemy. But this pragmatism makes him more capable of doubt as he will back off if he feels outmatched. Jaime and othesr are skilled honor fighters, they have pride in their refined techniques and abilities and want fights to be clean. When the enemy isn't fighting fair though is when they are at theri weakest. The hound, and the mountain, are both brawler fighters, using brute force and strength vs extra refined technique. One could almost say they fight like animals. Brienne has all three aspects to her fighter style and can and will implement any of them. She was also gifted with exceptional size and strength to help as well.
Renly would probably have made the best king out of all choices in the entire series. He understood the value of playing nice and being friendly but also immediately suggested to Eddard Stark that they should strike first before Robert even died. He was not afraid to be both kind and ruthless when the time was right. Hell and after he created the best chance for victory with his Highgarden alliance and at least neutral and friendly stance with the Stark's. He also worked on the small council before and had experience knowing how to actually rule in peace time.
In the books, Renly was a lot like Robert (both physically and personality wise), just a bit smarter and more politically savvy. Renly likely would’ve succumbed to the same shortsightedness that Robert did.
***** Yeah. REnly is the good heart. Robert was the drunkard but powerful king . And Stannis has the iron will of a king but he is too stone cold. He wants to rule badly
xXp00nslayer_69Xx wouldn't the best king be a combination of the 3 Baratheon brothers? Robert's military prowess, Renly's heart and charisma, and Stannis' will and sense of duty?
3:41. Dude when you think about the contributions Renlys army did. You realized. Yeah. They didnt. Like at all. All they did was make Stannis’s army way bigger. And even then. They lost. During the war if the five kings. The young wolf won the most victories. Gained the most legend. And still lost his head. I fricking worship this show
I liked the character of Renly. He wasn't really a great man. But he was a reasonable one. Didn't really enjoy fighting or bloodshed but he knew how to put on a good front. And he wasn't quick to temper or overly-concerned with how people saw him. In his mind so long as they never saw his true self, the self that loved other men, then he didn't give a damn what people thought of his false persona that he wore around. That gave him a genuine advantage over the egotistical and narcissistic competition for the crown. He was never blinded by a desire to been seen as something more than he was. But he knew what he was and what he could gain. He understood how to use the advantages of his bloodline to take something great for himself. As a king he would have done quite well. Quite fair, well-tempered, not a shred of cruelty or hatred in him. He'd have stacked his council with decent leaders and gone about a good life.
Anyone notice the grunts and moans brienne makes while fighting make her sound similar to Bane in dark knight rises? just makes her that much cooler in my books
Not sure why Varys didn't try to back Renly. He was gentler than Stannis, but stronger than Tommen, and with the right family name. He is loved by the people and nobles, and he is decent at the game. Quite unfortunate that he died.
The show doesn't really make anything of it, but to astute book readers there are many clues that Varys is a lesser scion of the Targaryen house, probably a descendant of Aerion brightflame. He's a Targaryen loyalist at heart. Hence his pact with Illyrio Mopatis, _"Red or Black, a Dragon is still a Dragon."_ In the books he backs (f)Aegon. In the show, Denaerys.
+sinkingships offools wow dude, calm down. It really wasn't that uncommon for women to fight in the middle ages. You had shieldmaidens for example, and also it's fiction, there are dragons and zombies in the show as well if you hadnt noticed
Realistically, if we were going to ignore Melisandre's little deus ex machina, Renly would have crushed Stannis (Renly's vanguard alone greatly outnumbered Stannis' entire force), waited for the Lannisters and Starks (his army was bigger than both combined) to wear each other out, then win without much trouble. Renly even offered that he could be "King of the North" as long as he bowed to Renly. It was the most generous result the North/Riverlands could have gotten.
i love the fact that each one of the baratheons brothers had something the other lacked and viceversa. Had they been able to solve their differences, they would have been an unstoppable force, but i doubt how that would have worked since each one of them wanted to be king alone
Stannis never wanted to be king. "I never asked for this, no more than I asked to be king. We do not choose our destinies. Yet we must ... we must do our duty, no? Great or small, we must do our duty." He was doing what he felt he had to do.
Loras and Brienne are excellent fighters. They were the last two remaining out of all the other men. Such a shame we couldn’t see them both talk about Renly in the future.
"Aren't you just marvelous? Absolutely singular. I heard you knocked my grandson into the dirt like the silly little boy he is!"
Lady ollena 🤣
@@KaliSidharth one of the few people who are eligible for game of thrones
You know your ladies well, my friend. I dub thee Lady @@KaliSidharthof the Queens Guard.
Absolutely singular translated: Absoulte unit
Emma Peel! And she had the last word, alright!
Brienne is literally the only person still alive from this scene.
:0 :'( it's true. Sad true
no she is not, there are 100000 bannermen there :P
@Nerdus Lupin not all of them....
@@TheWolfbay I'm pretty sure the majority of them are dead. The bulk of Stannis's army was killed at the Battle of the Blackwater, the rest were wiped out during the First Battle of Winterfell, if any survived they would have either fled or joined with Jon Snow at the Battle of the Bastards which I'm sure resulted in massive casualties for both sides. Then going on to S8 if there were any Baratheon Bannerman who somehow survived all of that they would've been present during the Long Night Battle. You'd either have to be extremely lucky or incredibly skilled to have survived all that, and I doubt most these men would've even survived the Blackwater.
@@Wuwarrior-bi2tl dude, learn to read what i said, ikm also pretty sure the most of them are dead
what i said is out of those 100000 bannerman there would probably be 1 or more survivors...
My son is fighting a war, not playing one.
Baratheon crowd: OHHHHHHHHHHHH
Tiny Roman Tad Strange "Oh, Snap"
xD
Loras was out of his depth challenging the Lady of Winterfell
that burn.........
Only to die breaking his word over a girl.
This is what I like about Renly: He gives his full and complete attention to the champion, Brienne. Loras is looking at Renly, shaking his head. Margery is looking at him, too. But King Renly is in his regal finest; he requires the approval of no one.
if he had accepted Stannis' offer, the two would have taken King's Landing.
@@JamesJJSMilton Renly’s army had more men than all the others combined. He certainly didn’t need Stannis and if Stannis didn’t happen to have a witch that could birth spectral assassins, he would have died fighting Renly.
Well...he does require the true kings attention
@@Colin-kh6kp If, if, if. Renly should have known Stannis wasn't going to recklessly blunder his forces without a trick up his sleeve. He was an arrogant idiot though and didn't think more than 2 steps ahead, just like Robert before him.
@@jakemitchell7786 you are the only one here typing IFs
Fun fact.
The reason Renly is able to grant Brienne a spot in his rainbow guard, is because he (and stannis both) had one spot open for Ser Barristan.
Loved Ser Barriston 😭
Really? Where was that mentioned?
@@eldarius237 In the book. Renly asks lady stark if ser barristan is with her son, because he said he was going to serve the true ruler of the throne, and he hadn't showed up to serve renly or stannis yet, so they figured the only other potentail ruler was robb. The whole section was foreshadowing to barristan showing up to serve daenerys
or... hear me out... they can decide that they want another person and are not limited by some programming on a maximum number of spots...
@@Xingmey there are only ever 7 members of the kings/queens guard
Margaery really doesn't have the best track record when it comes to marrying Baratheons...
BF4TheWin
nominal Baratheons then.
+BF4TheWin technically he is. His father was a baratheon
+franklin phan his father?? u haven't been paying attention.
+shamsu makudawa Think he means his official father.
+Luqman Osman ...Gendry?
Quotes about Renly:
"He knew how to dress and he knew how to smile and he knew how to bathe, and somehow he got the notion that this made him fit to be king." ”
-Olenna Redwyne
“Robert was the true steel. Stannis is pure iron, black and hard and strong, yes, but brittle, the way iron gets. He’ll break before he bends. And Renly, that one, he’s copper, bright and shiny, pretty to look at but not worth all that much at the end of the day.”
- Donal Noye
This sums Renly pretty well if you ask me.
Thanks for sharing, those are some damn good quotes!
Robert was like wood, it drank and got swollen.
The blacksmith of Storm’s End would know just what the brothers are like
Renly was worth a lot and was a giga had in the books
I still believe Renly was the better choice. Most of the people loved and respected him he did unite an army of one hundred thousand. He was more wise than Robert and more merciful than Stannis.
Funny to see that the only times characters are smart enough to wear helmets are usually in duels.
***** Tell that to Oberyn ...
***** Not to mention armor that actually covers vitals.
ColoBeans Don't most?
Minigun101 Obviously you haven't seen female "armor" designs these days....
ColoBeans Oh I thought you were just talking about the show
The Island of Tarth must be doing just fine during this whole series.
Island of nath too
@@agogreen9107
Naath has nothing to do with Westeros nor Essos
Harley Quinn the arbor too, where the redwyne live
Prolly the safest place when all this war and walker fiasco happened 😅
Renly might have been an even worse king than robert.
Margery's dress wins the fight.
*HIGHGARDEN!!!*
its getting higher...
Now i believe in the god of tits and wine
maybe if she wasnt flat chested it would have. as it stands, she is the most ill equipped queen consort ever. which actually worked uite well, seeing as her husband was the most ill equipped king ever. dude was so gay he couldnt even fuck her drunk, he tried to put it in her butt.
@@Royinszki dilly Dilly
"Brienne, has anyone ever confused you for a girl before?"
"No; how about you, Loras?"
Apply cold water to burned area.
I hope she does to her enemies what you did to that quote.
Nice Aliens reference lol
I've got some Firemilk for that burn if you need it.
River Tam
Preach it River.
Probably the most realistic fight in the entire show. We finally get to see armors serving their real defensive purpose and not just being cut and pierced in one strike.
tbf Jorah beats a Dothraki warrior because of his armor. Though I dont remember if that fight happened before this one.
@@codysellers4151 Very good point. I forgot about that one coz I mainly considered the fights that happened in westeros.
Yet 99% of the time they wouldnt ever wear their helmets again😂
I also like that you could really see the fatigue kicking in. Fighting in full armor + a weapon is pretty exhausting, so it's way more realistic when it's not some over the top fight.
I see dead people
I hope Brienne is next. I hate that bitch.
If you only knew.
Knew what? I'm updated bro
Nat Luzentales you read the books? I'm thinking of Lady Stoneheart (Spoiler warning on that one). Seems she might not show up in the series though, but she's pretty bad as in the books.
Yeah and GRRM himself already said that the show won't feature her at all.
Remember when armor used to actually do something?
D&D: lol no.
Armor is purely decorative and made of plastic in season 8 it seems. Oh how the times have changed.
@@bandolando3265 unless it's plot armor. As we saw last episode it's also fire retardant, especially for Arya
You just gotta give it that tappidy tap with the sword, that beats any armour
What D&D means?
@@atilla1434 Dan and Dave
3:35
Loras: If Rob Stark wants a pact with us, he should come himself, not hide behind his mother's skirts.
Catelyn: *I'm about to end this man's whole career*
Loras your talking to a woman who dies and all it does it piss her off.
@@SalinaMoonfall , you're the first man I've seen in a GoT video to have referenced Lady Stoneheart.
@@ferdinand5223 what got videos have you been looking at lol
she destroyed him
He had no career to begin with
Brienne earned my instant respect for using a tackle in that fight. ITS ABOUT FRICKING TIME!
I speaketh the truth Except most armored duels revolve around MMA style close quarter fighting.
+I speaketh the truth the ancient greeks were big into pankration, which was wrestling and striking. outside of sport and competition, they believed that closing the distance and grappling an opponent makes it very difficult to use swords.
Number09 I'm mainly talking about Medieval Knights and Vikings, but yes.
+I speaketh the truth
Textbook football tackle (USA). Brienne was a middle linebacker for the Tarth Evenstars.
+I speaketh the truth Takedowns and grappling were very important in armoured combat. Her technique was well done and accurate to what medieval and renaissance men-at-arms would have done.
"My son is fighting a war - not playing at one!"
The best part is that Renly actually concedes the point with his smirk. He knows she's right.
And, after the shitshow that was High Garden's fall, I think we know why the Tyrells only play at war and backed down when faced with the Faith Militant....
High Garden's fall was bullshit, because you cant just take one of the biggest castle in realm in one evening. And you cant just move whole fleet/army without enemy knowing about it. Spies, scouts, dragon would learn for sure a few days in advance about movement of lion army and if they would want to move quickly they wouldnt have sige equipment with them. So they would have to build one. Or this is all bs and D&D wanted just to end the show
@@Just_a-guy While the fall of High Garden isn't unplausible, you're correct that it was bullshit. The entire strategy and realism was completely lost in Season 8. As you said, taking a castle in one night is virtually impossible, and High Garden's Larders were probably full. A siege would be pointless and impossible cause Daenerys swooping in with the Dragons would end the siege, all it takes is one Raven to make it out of the castle. The would have to break down the gates, and whilst High Garden may not be very adept at war they are also not completely incompetent. They can't be or they wouldn't be such an affluent House.
Really just a shame...
@@cruusha9866 i thought they implied it was an inside job. who needs to break down a gate when you can have someone open it from the inside
@@insertcognomen I mean, perhaps, maybe, but at the same time they needed to explain that a little more than just "yeah that happened".
@@cruusha9866 yea it's true, Highgarden was in control of lands completely untouched by war. The Lannisters were dealing with 2 wars with substantial losses and , debt and inflation. While the Tyrell army was effectively untouched the entire time (seeing as they went home after Renly was killed) They also had control over food production in the realm after the wars decimated the Riverlands. They could have done so much to have the Tyrells out of the picture or perhaps part of the Lannister's with whoever took over after Mace (since they decided to remove Mace's two eldest sons from the boks). But Jamie took the mighty Highgarden in less time than it took for him to take a bath.
The Manly woman vs Womanly man
Manly woman wins all day everyday.
Well said, my friend
Loras is good but Brienne is bigger she quicker and not is as honrable with in fight is a good thing
Loras is very feminine, but he is incredibly strong and skilled. He unhorsed the Mountain, an eight foot tall heavy armoured knight, in one thrust.
***** Loras Tyrell and Tyrion Lannister are my favorites characters
3:40 Good thing Winter is coming because Loras needs some ice after that burn.
Not just that one
@@joshstroven8284 Rest in piece good GOT 2011-2016
Michelle Fairley (Catelyn Stark) is SO good in this scene. Her delivery of her lines to Loras are fantastic!
She is always on point.
Got and vikings both managed some of the best casting I've ever seen in my life. But they all also had incredibly good directors and editors because if you ever watched behind the scenes you'll see just how much direction the actors actually get in real time
Every one of these actors would tell you that they are nothing without the best writes, directors, and editors
I think was the scene that made me really like Renly. You have all these lords and men disappointed that a woman bested a man, and even Margery who is supposedly a semi-good character is being quite petty with her brother's loss. Renly on the other hand takes it to good heart that his lover got his ass handed down to him, then even accepts Brienne's request despite the others being appalled at the idea.
In the books its even funnier because she totally destroys like five guys that had been mocking her in that melee. Poor Loras was just passing by and ended up being the last man standing in front of her
I adore Margery’s proud sister moment in the heat of the duel.
“Loras! High Garden!”
Loras was a very good fighter. This was a tournament. All of those men fought each other and the last 2 were Loras and Brienne. That says something.
He was an even better Jouster
@@kobi005 cuz he joust into Renly's ass every night. lmao
@@kakashiMEK this is a very underated comment lol
Gotta be honest, watching these scenes just reminds me of how much more I liked the Robb era on the show than any of the others. It felt like a war drama, now it's... different
Ironic isn't it? The closeted gay man is beaten by the woman everbody assumes is a lesbian!
I like the way the show later shows that they both had two things in common:
1) Their dedication to being knights.
2) Their love for Renly.
Why would everybody assume she is a lesbian? She is, in book and show, obviously in love with Jaime Lannister. She practically admits it to Cersei at Joffrey's wedding feast.
She's straight, she's just never met a man who's physically attracted to her, and she herself in only interested in strong, noble men, like the man Jaime is becoming.
Ah, ok then. I thought you were speaking of the viewpoint of fans of the series, not characters in it.
Yeah, you're right then. That was and is the reaction of pretty much every man Brienne encounters in the series.
Though some of them don't even think it through that much and just think 'freak'.
MrReded69 and she is in love with Jaime!!!
MrReded69 She could just simply be....I don't know...a TOMBOY? They are quite common. These ladies can be very straight girls and yet still have what have mainly been associated as "male traits".
***** Nowhere near as much as the Southrons of Westeros would.
Loras seems even more of a child than Joffrey in this scene. Less of the sadism, but the same superiority and sense of entitlement.
VelmiVelkiZrut well one of his brave scene was in the book when ned stark set on the behalf of the king he send beric dondarrion before that lores volunteer to kill the mountain
Unlike joffrey loras had the skills to back up his arrogance like jaime.
VelmiVelkiZrut No. I don’t think it’s entitlement , I think it’s jealousy.
@@finnheisenheim8274 Had he? Because I don't remember a single fight he won. Even the mountain fight he was getting demolished.
@@zxylo786 Yes, in the book he's considered a prodigy. George even said that by the end of ADoD there's a case to be made that he's the most skilled swordsman alive.
I've seen him bested once or twice....
Bro I bet you bested him a few times
They've clashed swords a few times then, eh?
Hahahaahah
Renly Baratheon. The King people wanted.
Robert Baratheon. The King who had seen shit that people needed.
“He can’t be that great, he’s been stabbing Renly for years now and he’s not dead”
Wizardporn2008 wtf
People: Robert is a drunken, lustful fool...Renly is a glossy, boy-lover...Stannis...who is this guy?
(a few seasons later under Joffrey's reign)
People: We sure could use one of those three Baratheons right about now.
Tyrion: No shit. I'm all you've got.
if only thy new this at eddards beheading
Why is no one talking about Renly's line "I've seen Loras bested once or twice but never quite in that fashion"
I bet he is the one who bested loras
Robb almost had The Reach, The north, The Vale and the Stormlands on his side. imagine how the war would have played out if he wasn’t so dumb and if stannis wasn’t fighting his lil bro
He wasn't dumb in the books. I will forever hate the writers of the show for fucking over his character and making him autistic.
It's also mentioned in the books that Loras's prodigal skill lies primarily in the joust. He even admits outright his older brother is a better swordsman than himself, and Jaime is one of the best in the seven kingdoms with a sword. Different knights excel in different things, and even then chance can unseat a famed knight.
While that's probable true, Loras is still notable as being an exceptionally good fighter. He's not Jamie Lannister, but he is very high tier. So Brienne's win over him is impressive and highlights that she's an eliete combatant, even if jousting is his real speciality.
Tempting fate though it is, I actually really like Renly in this scene. At this particular moment, Renly holds the most power militarily, economically (especially after Tywin reveals the Westerland's gold issue), and politically but when insulted to his face he just laughs it off and carries on. Sure, it's nice to trade barbs and insults with your rivals, but to not act like a child and throw threats shows a level of composure not often seen in a brutal world like this. That's my one and a half septims anyway. Then again, I still love the show and the books as separate entities, so apparently I'm already some kind of heretic in most people's eyes. Whoops!
Show Renly would have made a good king, strange as it is to say.
+The One™ too bad he had no real claim over the one true king...Stannis "the Mannis" Baratheon!
zaccaria101 True dat. Forever our Mannis.
+The One™
Mannis the "Burn your own daughter at the stake for power?"
Stannis might have been an honourable man once. But his is a cautionary tale of what it means to lust for power. The allure of the Iron throne was too much for him, and he lost everything he loved, sacrificed everything he held dear over it. The TV Series plays down his religious zealotry.
But with the way his arc was going? Pretty soon he'd have become a New Mad King, burning everyone who disagreed with him.
Renly might have had the weakest claim of the Five Kings. But he would have been the greatest.
Stannis rules by right of birth.
Joffrey by right of conquest.
But Renly had the backing of the people, and the ability and the wisdom to rule.
He'd have allied with Rob Stark.
He'd have recognised the threat beyond the rule.
Its not hard to imagine he'd reinforce the Wall.
I am almost certain he would have reached some agreement with Dany, were she to return to Westeros under his rule.
He would have left the Kingdom in the best shape to defend against the Long Night.
Haradion Drogon Stannis recognized that the long night was coming and sent men to the wall. Renly would've just been taking it from Loras and would've indulged in King's Landing. If Renly had been a good guy he wouldve helped Ned install Stannis as King (the rightful heir) instead of squabbling for power himself. Guy starts this scene as Catelyn points out "playing at a war" Renly was all shownmanship and no action. If Renly was smart instead of being a sissy, he could've invaded King's Landing easily.
"my son is fighting a war, not playing at one". that was a hell of a mic drop.
In what universe is this HD 1080p?
lol ikr
lol @ the clickbait
It's HD so stop your bellyaching!
This..is 1080p... I know this because my Xbox runs the DVD's at 720p and my Xbox looks shit in comparison to this.
GamingMediocrity I don't call anything "HD" if it contains letterboxes on ALL SIDES
It's too bad Renly got whacked so early on. I feel the actor was just starting to come into his own as a king. But then the number of interesting characters that have been offed so far...Qorin Halfhand, the guy who Boromir'd himself for Arya & Gendry, maybe Arya's dancing master, et al. At least Jaqen H'gar is still around - cool and harder to kill off than pretty much anybody.
I'm scared..
All those characters had gone as far as their stories could. By the way Jaqen hasn't returned in the books yet, so he kind of is dead for now.
TheSilentStorm He's not dead, he just disappeared before two books where nothing happens.
squamish4244 That's what I meant, he's been gone ever since so he might as well be dead. I thought Arya was going to meet him again during assassin training, but nope.
Also the last thing he told Arya is that he's dead, so it's kind of true.
Ah I see. Well, I hope this is one character that GRRM decides to bring back, even if he is metaphorically dead.
Love the attention to detail in the duel Brie is bigger, more likely to get hit because her size is a bigger hit radius so she uses a shield to protect herself. The flower Knight is smaller so he uses a axe with a long shaft to keep Brie at a distance and a axe has alot of stopping power, something you'd want to use against a bigger fighter
That is not how real life fighting works. Plus axes are not spears, because of being top heavy you have to grip it high. Look where his hand are on the axe. In term of reach axes arent great option.
That melee starts with dozens of competitors by the end the last two are exhausted and swinging wildly.
@@Just_a-guy Yup, there's no way axes with spear tips on them would ever become popular. Oh, wait, that's a halberd: ua-cam.com/video/NMUzYDYD_lc/v-deo.htmlsi=5w6U-80BFt9TuI3b
You also have this video where he demos some flexibility with range for the weapon.
I would have liked to see a longer shaft on the weapon, yes. Battle axes were certainly a thing, though. And even something like a bearded axes can be useful for the thrust in a pinch, and even shaft hits are blunt force trauma that might jar a combatant off their feet or lead to an advantageous grapple for you. Honestly, I found this fight to be fairly realist. Loras even tried to knock her off her feet, but couldn't, because she's just that darn big and strong.
@@roguishpaladin I was commenting this one Axe which is held more like lumberjack one. Of course there were two handed axes (dane axe for example) not just halberd but they had thin blade. This fight wasnt that bad and because it was a final of group fight there isnt much to complain but explanation given in main comment is wrong. Being "bigger" doesnt made Brienne to pick up a shield and Loras didnt had/use that much range with his axe. Overall nice fight, it is good to see armor actually working, grappling and going for dagger is nice but i wouldnt agree with main comment
Feels so weird rewatching these. GoT back then felt like a grounded show with some light fantasy elements, especially with how they treated plate armour. Now its just... different
It seems that Loras is stupid to forgot the bonds between the Starks and Baratheons, to demand Cat to kneel. Stannis, Renly even Robert always treat the Starks with equal and much respect....
Aw the gold ol' days, when it seemed like the Baratheons and Starks would surely smoke the Lannisters.
Renly: "Never quite in that fashion. Usually he's the one on top."
More of the battle scenes should be like this, with shields and proper helms. It just makes it feel so much more real.
That smile Renly gave after Catlyn gave to Loras " damn that was a cold one "
if stannis didnt kill renly Joffrey's and Cersei's head would be on spikes now, and red wedding never happens. ohh stannis....
and renly would be king...
John royal
Yep and compare that to his predecessors..(Joffrey, Robert and Aerys)
Which would you feel safe under?
TTUploads
doesn't bother me, but i am not stannis.
Not if Melisandre of Asshai had never come to Stannis, but if she wouldn't have, then wildlings would have got over the wall..
And if renly would have supported his older brother, which was his duty, and not proclaiming himself King with no good reason stannis could have had the forces of the stormlands from the begining, attack kings landing and execute joffrey and cersei. ohh renly....
Watching the old episodes. These were another level. Season 8 has spoilt the milk.
Renly was poised to win the war at this point. The greatest tragedy in the series truly is that his host was scattered, even though I didn't like him that much personally. His demise opened all the doors for the Lannisters
'My son is fighting a war. Not playing at one'
Did you just get blown up by wildfire? Because you just got burned
Loras gets rekd in this scene, twice.
Cat did the better beating. If only her son was good at beating others.
Bradley Fletcher dude he beat everyone he fought in open battle he defeated Jamie Lamnister and even Tywin Lamnister himself
Tywin is not a very good fighter he is competent at best.
Bradley Fletcher he is considered the best general in all of westeros i mean he did kill off both house Reyne and Tarbeck
nimbalo gaming That is strategy not fighting yourself
1:33 ;) ;) ;) if you catch his drift ;) ;) ;)
AHAHAHHA, checky
+A Guy renly saw loras bested once or twice. sexual connotation lol. renly's the one who dominates loras in the bedroom
I totally missed it until you guys pointed it out. thanks
Renly and rob would have been the greatest alliance in this series if renly never died..
Heck I wanted to see the tyrell/baratheon army fight the lannister
Would have destroyed the Lannisters.
That would've worked in the short term but Renly's reign over Westeros would've been as bad a Robert's later reign, if not worse. Not only would he be setting the president that any younger sibling can take whatever they want with a large army, leading to who knows how many deaths. Furthermore, Renly was willing to leave Littlefinger in power and give titles to his friends like Mace Tyrell, who was a corrupt man The Small Council would've been riddled with the same corruption that allowed The Lannisters to thrive under Robert's reign. Come one of the later Seasons, once Daenerys Targaryen arrived in Westeros, many Reach Houses, being Targaryen Loyalists, would've switched sides.
@@gfilmer7150 I would argue that Stannis's reign would of been just as bad. Yes Stannis is dedicated to his duty and I am sure he would put many laws in place that could benefit the realm but his uncompromising nature would see him a short reign. He would never make peace with the Lannisters and the Tyrells would never side with him (due to a list of reasons). He also was heavily against Robb being named King of The North and Trident and even viewed him as a usurper. That's 4 of the Seven Kingdoms already against Stannis. With Renly he was already aligned with the Tyrells and was in talks with Robb of an alliance. He most likely would of crushed the Lannisters but there is possibility he would of made peace with them after taking the throne. That's one reason Stannis could never rule well. You can be as dutiful as can be but you can never be king if all your vassals are against you.
Another reason, and one which many people don't take into account, is Stannis's court. Yes Stannis has a few good people in his court like Ser Davos and eventually Rolland Storm, but most of his court and majority of his army (before Renly's death and when he is in The North) are filled with Queens men. These men are religious extremists and have many members (Melisandre, Queen Selyse Florent, Axell Florent etc) that are in high places in Stannis's court and army. We have been already exposed to their extreme behaviour on Dragonstone when they burnt the sept there. If Stannis is to take the throne those Queens men are likely to burn the Sept of Baelor down and I doubt Stannis would be able to stop it since he couldn't stop it happening at Dragonstone and even somewhat cosigned their religion with the burning of the Seven statues. This would then create a war with the faith, similar to King Maegor's. The spread and influence of the Queens men and R'hllor would be a worse corruption than any of the Lords Renly would have at court. And the argument of Lord Mace's corruption in the position of hand of the king falls flat when you look at his Stannis counterpart, Lord Alester Florent, a man that is just as corrupt if not more than Mace, a man that changes his religion to R'hllor as soon as he switches sides from Renly to Stannis so that he can gain favour in Stannis's court. And Stannis names him Hand of the King.
About your point of Renly setting a precedent of the younger brother being entitled to the throne, I believe it's impact is way over exaggerated. One reason for this is because its happened before, actually in both Stannis and Renly's bloodline. There was a point in the Durrandon Kings succession line that a younger bastard overthrew his older true born brother who had been King of the Stormlands. That event never set a precedent so why would Renly's claim to the throne do so. The only precedent it would set is that people are able to claim the throne through right of conquest, which was already a precedent.
I'd also add that Renly's reign would not be as bad as Roberts. Renly would actually do his job and tend to the realm and attend council meetings as he had been already doing so as Master of Laws. Also whilst the Tyrell influence would be prevelant in Renly's court it would never be as bad as the Lannisters. Robert had the Lannisters do whatever they wanted, allowed himself to be in massive debt to them and even allowed Cersei to influence his Kingsguard and add Lannister cronies such as Meryn Trant and Boros Blount. There is no evidence Renly would allow this as he has a Kingsguard made up of people loyal to him and is not in debt to Lord Mace. Also I would much rather the influence of the Tyrells than that of the Lannisters or Melisandre, Florents and the Queens men.
@@amanimckenzie32 Stannis takes KL, Tywin could try to besiege it if Stannis lops off both Joffrey and Tommen's heads, then there's no Lannister King for Marg to marry as she can't marry the hostage Cersei, making The Tyrell Alliance mute. Ironically, if Tywin besieges KL and the Tyrells bail, Robb may want to hoof it over to the capital to break Tywin and save Sansa (and Arya). I don't think you need to do much math in that scenario to calculate who comes out on top. As for the aftermath, Robb's host would be bloodied and Stannis would still have his sisters. And as for Renly, he says himself he would've made Robb bend the knee and swear an oath of fealty. Even though Renly says Robb can be King, he would've turned Robb into nothing more than a glorified puppet, something Robb wouldn't've been happy about.
As for Stannis as King, I doubt he'd let his followers get too rowdy. He may turn a blind eye but not for long, I mean look what happened when his officers demanded he burn people at Crofter's Village. Sure he killed three criminals but he went no further than that, talking down to his men who suggested it.
So the problem with Renly is that he is second to last in the bottom of succession, Hell, very last if you include Shireen being above him. I imagine the guy who over threw his brother wasn't the youngest of three, plus that event happened thousands of years ago and people in Westeros only remember was everything after The Conquest.
And Renly's reign would have been pretty bad seeing as Mace Tyrell would spread his influence as far as he could and Renly wouldn't go against his father-in-law. Also, the people of King's Landing wouldn't be crazy enough to adopt this foreign religion without a miracle and they'd be more likely to adopt Tyrell gold.
@@gfilmer7150 Firstly there is no way Stannis will kill Joffrey and Tommen both and nullify the Tyrell Lannister alliance (unless you are talking about the show). This is because the Lannisters had a back up plan for if Kings Landing fell and would of crowned Tommen as king at Rosby. This would then continue the alliance. As for Renly's terms for alliance with The North it is not as you put it. He gives Robb the ability to be king and bend the knee. This would put The North in a similar situation to Dorne when they bent the knee. There is also no evidence that Renly wanted to make Robb a puppet, that is just false. With Stannis he straight up names Robb a usurper and orders him to bend the knee having no negotiation about it. This sets Stannis having 4 Kingdoms against him whilst Renly only had one (The Westerlands). There is also no factor pointing to Robb and The North bending the knee once Sansa is in Stannis's control. They are fighting a war of independence and they didn't trade the Stark girls and back down when it was the Lannisters they were against. All that would happen is that the conflict would shift from the Lannisters vs Robb to Stannis vs Robb.This sets Stannis up for a turbulent and probably short reign.
As for Stannis and his court, the influence of the Queens men is already overgrown. Much of his council is made up of R'hllor supporters. Just because he stopped them burning a village doesn't mean he can stop them burning the Sept of Baelor. If Stannis was to take Kings Landing its evident that the Sept would of been burnt and there would of been war with the faith. And also when I mention influence of the Queens men I don't mean the people of Kings Landing would turn to the religion, i mean that many of Stannis main supporters and council are Queens men and thus will be able to influence Stannis's court from positions of power. This evidence is seen in his wife and Hand of The King being R'hllor worshippers.
Also the Durrandon King thing was even worse than what Renly was doing. Why, because he was a younger bastard. So my point about setting precedences still stands. And it happening years ago changes nothing. All it shows is that through all those years it did not set any precedent. People may not remember it now but people did 5 or 10 years after it happend and a precedent was never set.
Yes I agree that Mace would try to spread his influence far and wide but whose to not say the Queens men and the Florents won't do the same. The Florents are just the Stannis counterpart of the Tyrells. And their spread of influence is less to do with people adoping the religion but more to do with putting people that are apart of the religion in influencial places by using their already set status and positions in Stannis's court, influenctial positions such as Queen and Hand of The King. Plus the Queens men are a lot more corrupt and violent than the Tyrells so their spreading of influence would be far worse.
Three powerful and strong women here, each in her own way, but I love how Catelyn is dominant - more assured and ultimately stronger than either of the other two. Her death was one of the great disappointments in the show. I wish we could have gotten Lady Stoneheart.
+sinkingships offools so liking strong female characters makes them a sissy? You're a fucking clown.
wow. Someone says how they love the women in this show and people have to bring up how men are considered "stronger"
Lol it's not 1930 anymore. Even if a few men are a little stronger, that doesn't mean all Women are weak. if you get what i am saying. it's sad that sexist people still exist.
sinkingships offools You're not very good at reading comprehension are you? Nicole is lame said nothing about women on average being stronger or equally as strong as men.
sinkingships offools i don't think you are just drunk. I think you are stupid too. Very stupid tbh. Also "femanazi" is so dumb. Sorry that I'm fighting for my rights, and equal rights.
sinkingships offools I'm not sure why I'm even fighting with you. You're a Sexist and Racist pig.
Captain Phasma vs Iron Fist
Most worthless star wars villain ever next to Boba Fett but even he at least managed to capture Han
@@patgogan7324 With an Imperial contingent. Most overrated, for sure.
And yea- Phasma....let's see her record here- none.
Brienne v Loras actually!
Back when Iron Fist was gay.
Wow... Have seen all of game of thrones and iron fist, and somehow never realised the same actor was in both. Mind blown.
Renly: "Our war is just beginning.."
*Dies immediately*
Loras' shocked gasp when Catelyn hands him his ass warms my heart.
1:08 . . . That walk . . . Definitely should have still had the stunt double in there. Slightly humorous.
According to the books, Brienne is really ugly and also looks clumsy and uncomfortable in both armor and women's clothes. She is constantly ridiculed, but also underestimated, and I think her walk captures this perfectly.
"If I'm gonna walk I'll do it myself!."
Loras and Brienne are great fighting against each other, but it's funny how when they try to verbally mob Catelyn they get pwned.
Loras Tyrell is a great warrior. Shame he's been finding himself fighting top tier people all the time in the show lol. Getting jumped by the Mountain and Brienne who subdued Jaime Lannister (albeit severely weakened). I don't remember if he fought anyone else besides participating in the Blackwater.
Ahh yesss, when GOT conversations had me on the edge of my seat.
സ്ത്രീകളെ ബഹുമാനിക്കാൻ അറിയാവുന്ന മഹാനായ മനുഷ്യൻ❤
Probably the most realistic depiction of knight combat in television history. Too bad they forgot all this shit three seasons later
Renly seemed like a good guy honestly. He didn't really have good claims on the throne but I'm sure he would be a pretty good king.
A wise choice to take her for your guard. She's whipped a lot of folks. She damn near killed the hound. She's a scary opponent for sure
The respect renly shows for cat and the starks is actually amazing here. I never noticed that. Didnt give two shts bout cat kneeling bc their ties go way back. Promises lannister heads for the injustices’, even wants to team w rob. Man rob really coulda won this war if he made different choices and of course didnt red wedding it up. But. Renly an rob with stannis, the boltons, and the north. Sht that force would of been crazier that eddard and robert and the boys.
i love how brienne defeats lots of strong knights... jaime, loras, the hound..
The Hound reduced their fight to a down and out street brawl and she managed to pull out a win.
@@NeilPower feel like that is the advantage that brinne has in a lot of fights.
There are pragmatic fighters, bralwer fighters, and skilled honor fighters in the show.
Bronn was a pragmatic fighter largely. he was skilled but he worked around hwo to best exploit his enemy. But this pragmatism makes him more capable of doubt as he will back off if he feels outmatched.
Jaime and othesr are skilled honor fighters, they have pride in their refined techniques and abilities and want fights to be clean. When the enemy isn't fighting fair though is when they are at theri weakest.
The hound, and the mountain, are both brawler fighters, using brute force and strength vs extra refined technique. One could almost say they fight like animals.
Brienne has all three aspects to her fighter style and can and will implement any of them. She was also gifted with exceptional size and strength to help as well.
Renly would probably have made the best king out of all choices in the entire series. He understood the value of playing nice and being friendly but also immediately suggested to Eddard Stark that they should strike first before Robert even died. He was not afraid to be both kind and ruthless when the time was right. Hell and after he created the best chance for victory with his Highgarden alliance and at least neutral and friendly stance with the Stark's. He also worked on the small council before and had experience knowing how to actually rule in peace time.
Reply was a dumbass who equated being popular with being capable and paid the price for it.
In the books, Renly was a lot like Robert (both physically and personality wise), just a bit smarter and more politically savvy. Renly likely would’ve succumbed to the same shortsightedness that Robert did.
The shortsightedness of Robert is what drove Renly to rebel in the first place to prove he can become a better king than Roberts
poor renly. he would have been a good king.
***** Yeah. REnly is the good heart. Robert was the drunkard but powerful king . And Stannis has the iron will of a king but he is too stone cold. He wants to rule badly
xXp00nslayer_69Xx How about King Bronn the best king in the history of the seven kingdoms.
xXp00nslayer_69Xx wouldn't the best king be a combination of the 3 Baratheon brothers? Robert's military prowess, Renly's heart and charisma, and Stannis' will and sense of duty?
Zlockj349 Yep that's called a Triforce lol.
Zlockj349 a drunk, strong, determined, gay charmer
Fun Fact: In the books Catelyn is roasting Randyll Tarly, and not Loras.
Renly understood the value of tact with your enemies.
0:17 I like this guy who's just like "YEEEES FIGHTINNNG"
"Loras! Highgarden!" Love that line.
It shows that Margaery really does care for her brother.
3:41. Dude when you think about the contributions Renlys army did. You realized. Yeah. They didnt. Like at all. All they did was make Stannis’s army way bigger. And even then. They lost. During the war if the five kings. The young wolf won the most victories. Gained the most legend. And still lost his head. I fricking worship this show
a sword swollower ....through and through
I liked the character of Renly. He wasn't really a great man. But he was a reasonable one. Didn't really enjoy fighting or bloodshed but he knew how to put on a good front. And he wasn't quick to temper or overly-concerned with how people saw him. In his mind so long as they never saw his true self, the self that loved other men, then he didn't give a damn what people thought of his false persona that he wore around.
That gave him a genuine advantage over the egotistical and narcissistic competition for the crown. He was never blinded by a desire to been seen as something more than he was. But he knew what he was and what he could gain. He understood how to use the advantages of his bloodline to take something great for himself.
As a king he would have done quite well. Quite fair, well-tempered, not a shred of cruelty or hatred in him. He'd have stacked his council with decent leaders and gone about a good life.
Whos here after Jaime just knighted Brienne?
sup
Yeah
Me to.
Jason Moore “Knighted”
yea he knighted her between her legs alright
Anyone notice the grunts and moans brienne makes while fighting make her sound similar to Bane in dark knight rises? just makes her that much cooler in my books
i'm bane! yes! that's my name!
DoubleGlock45 I'm coming after you Bruce Wayne! I'm smarter, faster, clinically INSANE!
batman and bruce wayne are one and the same!
Renly: He, Lady Stark, we can be buddies right.
Brienne and Loras: He bitch, what you want?
Renly: guys, not now.
They erased Catelyn from her children's memory. She deserves better.
Nagron WillNeverDie ???
Nagron WillNeverDie It's called bad writing mate. They have forgotten a Starbucks cup and a large Fleet in the open sea as well
@@fyedoravna7569 The starbucks cup wasn't too bad, it's a simple error and they happen in the best of media. The writing on the other hand.
I think of the shit she gave jon and i see it as karma
The only time we see Brienne wear a helmet, you know... one of the most important pieces of armour one can wear
Lady Cat Flamed Loras BAD LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Not as bad as Cersei..
Not sure why Varys didn't try to back Renly. He was gentler than Stannis, but stronger than Tommen, and with the right family name. He is loved by the people and nobles, and he is decent at the game. Quite unfortunate that he died.
The show doesn't really make anything of it, but to astute book readers there are many clues that Varys is a lesser scion of the Targaryen house, probably a descendant of Aerion brightflame. He's a Targaryen loyalist at heart. Hence his pact with Illyrio Mopatis, _"Red or Black, a Dragon is still a Dragon."_ In the books he backs (f)Aegon. In the show, Denaerys.
This woman. This woman is everything. She's my hero. I love her.
***** Sorry?
***** Ah! hahahahahaha Sorry, I forgot we can't talk about this in public
sinkingships offools Really? Thank you for the information.
+sinkingships offools wow dude, calm down. It really wasn't that uncommon for women to fight in the middle ages. You had shieldmaidens for example, and also it's fiction, there are dragons and zombies in the show as well if you hadnt noticed
who margary, breinne, or cattlyn?
Realistically, if we were going to ignore Melisandre's little deus ex machina, Renly would have crushed Stannis (Renly's vanguard alone greatly outnumbered Stannis' entire force), waited for the Lannisters and Starks (his army was bigger than both combined) to wear each other out, then win without much trouble.
Renly even offered that he could be "King of the North" as long as he bowed to Renly. It was the most generous result the North/Riverlands could have gotten.
i love the fact that each one of the baratheons brothers had something the other lacked and viceversa. Had they been able to solve their differences, they would have been an unstoppable force, but i doubt how that would have worked since each one of them wanted to be king alone
Stannis never wanted to be king.
"I never asked for this, no more than I asked to be king. We do not choose our destinies. Yet we must ... we must do our duty, no? Great or small, we must do our duty."
He was doing what he felt he had to do.
Sir Loras' Kryptonite: A meat sword.
“My son is fighting a war not playing in one “ love that
Renly had the King look down perfectly
When GoT was great. I'm currently on a nostalgic trip through great scenes from previous seasons, before this once incredible show was butchered.
incredible how in such small scene they accomplish to develop the story a lot.
That was the beauty of GOT. Development. When you heard stories of someone or a place it made your mouth water. It was so good.
@@MUFFINHEAD1985 nice portrait, amazing movie and actress.
"My son is fighting a war, not playing one!"
Brienne: 👁👄👁
Gwendoline is too beautiful to play Brienne.
no she isn't, smh
I miss the sweet helmets and plate armor the characters always used to wear in the early seasons.
This scene alone easily tops most stuff in season 8....
"I do not sit at my son's war councils, I just start the wars, pay attention!"
In retrospective, Loras was a fucking Great warrior for have given Brienne such a challenge.
Loras what the fuck are you doing with that axe
noob
back when the writing in game of thrones wasnt crap
It was such a good show, too bad Dumb and Dumber decided to ruin it.
Loras and Brienne are excellent fighters. They were the last two remaining out of all the other men. Such a shame we couldn’t see them both talk about Renly in the future.
Renly is the most underappreciated character in this scene.
His sigil looks like Bullwinkle.