If you look at the McGonnagal vs Snape fight closely, you can see that Snape never attacks McGonnagal, he is always just protecting himself. On top of that it actually is Snape who deflects McGonnagal's spell on the Carrows to protect McGonnagal and the kids while he runs away, keeping his true agency secret for both the Order of the Phoenix and the Death Eaters.
in the book, Snape and Minerva duel with flaming snakes and daggers, and Snape doesnt seem concerned about the children. it's much cooler fight. Movie Snape is a different character altogether. He immediately flees lol.
@@conormurphy4328 Even though the scene itself didn't make the cut, it shows what the intention of Mcgonagall/the filmmakers was here. So it isn't really left up to interpretation.
I like how Snape secretly deflected the spell that McGonagall's spell sent at him during the duel to take out the Carrows, hinting at his real allegiance being to Dumbledore and Harry Potter.
I agree that the leaving out of Dumbledore's backstory was disappointing. I will say this for the film. At least they fixed one the silliest moments in the book, where the Order of the Pheonix decides to go out on the grounds to attack the death eaters, which seems like the worst strategy possible.
William Wehrs Yes, they really should have included Dumbledore’s backstory. And Lupin’s story. Especially since so many people don’t bother to read the books, and Dumbledore’s story with Grindewald is a part of the Fantastic Beasts films, which I’m assuming those same people would like to watch.
re: voldemort disintegrating, i think they did this to show a physical representation of how splitting your soul so many times essentially turns you into nothing. at least that's what i got from it.
I belive that the Malfoys were mentioned in the aftermath of the battle as 'sitting awkawardly feeling they shouldn't be here while everyone celebrates.' I am not 100% sure as I read the books a while ago but I think they were mentioned after the battle.
VOICE-GUY! I want to thank you for these videos. I play them to fall asleep as your voice is so nice and relaxing to listen to. Of course I enjoy them regardless. How about doing a vid on a modern classic like Titanic or Inception?
They picked cat noises for the Hogsmeade alarm because it’s actually a “Cat”erwauling charm. Also, I imagine Harry was just saying something like “Oi, open up!” when he was telling the sink and door to open. That will continue to be my headcanon until proven otherwise.
19:04 I’m surprised you never thought the battle was that brutal to be honest, it’s still bad in the book but the shot in particular of greyback attacking Lavender- Ron’s girlfriend from half blood Prince- really shocked me and thought it showed how bad the battle is and how no one is safe
Thank you for correcting me on that point. I'm not too fluent in the language of plot as much as I am in the analysis of film so I ask - what word/phrase should I have used instead?
They should redo Harry Potter but as a TV series on Netflix or something. That way they could stick 100% to the books and have more time to flesh things out and create a more coherent story.
Joravil You've hit the nail on the head. Harry hadn't acknowledged that you cannot add all the details of such a complex book into just a few hours of a film. Many BBC adaptations over a few weeks can do that. Have you ever seen the FULL version of say Oliver Twist or Great Expectations compared to a 2 hour film? You'd be very surprised how much is cut. Harry's review is deeply flawed.
In the book the Malfoys are actually seen after the battle sitting awkwardly with everyone else wondering if they're actually allowed to be there or if nobody had noticed them.
im glad you also found the "celebration" of voldemorts death, basically everyone drinking tea and hagrid saying harry's name, was pointless. it kind of ruined the end of the battle of hogwarts for me. the book ending was much better great reviews overall. i love hearing comparisons between book and movie
I know they didn’t explain it in the film, but around the 5:40 mark you talked about the alarm in Hogsmeade. I believe the alarm was the product of a Caterwauling charm (in the book) So idk. The word cat is in there. Why not cat screeches am I right? Right? Anyone..?
I think I liked the last film far more than you did, but I will definitely say that if you did not read the book, you’ll be lost on multiple occasions. I read it before watching the movies, but I remember thinking how I understood most of what was happening due to what I’d read before and not what was presented, unfortunately.
Voldemort did not check for a pulse on harry because when he killed harry Voldemort also fainted because harry was a horcrux. It says he seems scared to touch harry.
@@ryanm666 omg this comment is so old but I dont like Harry Potter anymore since jk Rowling is a TERF so it's a shame Voldemort didn't think to use Crucio cause then he could have ended the series early.
The elder wand theory is a plot hole in both versions. There are a few videos that explain this theory, check it out and see for yourself if it's a plot hole. I would also like to add that the way Snape died was only for the convenience of the plot. Voldy could have used the killing curse to kill snape. What's even worse is in the film where Voldemort slits Snape's throat with the wand before killing him. This doesn't make sense since he could have used the killing curse instead of giving him a severe and painful death. The only explanation is for the convenience of the plot, for harry to get Snape's memories.
As a big fan of the books when they came out, this movie was good but not great when I first watched in theaters. And since then, the flaws that bugged me the first time just stand out more and more, leaving a bitter aftertaste for this movie
I did get to see this in theaters and I'm not much a fan of 3d either HOWEVER it was done really masterfully and when voldy kinda disintegrated at the end the entire theater looked like it was filled with the little floating pieces of him and it was incredibly magical to experience.
Yup! I'm aiming to make that video this week funnily enough, not entirely sure what exactly I'm gonna talk about but I'm gonna give it another watch and see what goodies I find inside!
You have an amazing voice for ASMR 😂 and your humor was on point. Love it and subbed! Yes I'm that sad as well now only am i into Harry Potter now. Sorted in Slytherin instead.
Can someone tell me what Cho Chang was doing at hogwarts at the end?... I thougt she was 1 year ahead of Harry so she already should have finished at hogwarts....
Great review, as usual, but I honestly went in expecting a lot more about the Elder Wand ownership switch at the end. Much becuase I don't remember a lot of what happened there, so I was hoping for a refreshment, but still.
Eh, if you saw Hogwarts Jesus rise from the dead YET AGAIN AFTER VOLDY FAILED TO KILL HIM FOR THE EIGHTH TIME, wouldn't you be like "You know, this isn't going to end the way we want it t0" and apparate the heck out of there?
im really curious as to why you want to "run fantastic beasts and where to find them into the ground" aside from the movie sharing the name with the book and the book being mentioned in the movie, i dont think its really about that. it also not technically a harry potter movie and as such shouldnt be compared to them as i see so many people do. i personally loved the movie and i really want to hear your opinion on it and why (im assuming) you didnt like it.
Possible spoilers for crimes of grindlewald........ isn’t credence ariana’s obscurous? Like it was a big twist but I kind guessed it was gonna go that way
Eh I considered Part One to be my least favourite out of all the films - it was mainly just filler, and I disagreed with you regarding Part Two aswell :/ Each to their own i suppose
Sarah Hughes deathly hallows part 1 is my favourite film after half blood prince. It’s such a human piece and really shows the connection of the trio. I just love, love, love the scene with Hermione propped up against the tree in the Forest of Dean where she says ‘maybe we should just stay here Harry and grow old’ it really shows how dire the situation is and gives us a glimpse into Hermiones character. And also DH part 1 has my favourite opening scene and opening music of all 8 films. And Bellatrix as Hermione is great, it feels as if I’m actually watching Hermione in a disguise she got it perfectly
I don't really mind Voldemort not checking Harry's body, to me it makes sense. Time after time voldemort had thought he'd finnaly got Harry just to be triumphed by him. He'd want to put a death eater on the line (one who's disappointed him countless times and doesn't care for them) instead of himself. I think it shows how precautious he was not to have his plan ruined again, even though it did lead to his downfall.
The fun thing is, Dumbledore's backstory is cut from this movie, but I think we might still see it in Fantastic Beasts, considering where this movies are possibly going.
I actually enjoyed the fantastic beasts & where to find them but it really doesn't feel like a Harry Potter film & was a huge stretch. I (& probably other fans) would have appreciated a film that features more of the people & setting i know & love. Maybe a story about dulmbodore or James & Lilly or Harry's kid struggling to live up to his father's name & maybe go an adventure of his own. I would have even preffred a whole new set of people but featuring some of the same settings as backdrops.
Black mirror is now my new favourite show. Before watching it, I watched a series called Philip K dick’s“ electric dreams” another anthology series. Would u mind checking it out and maybe analysing it?!
Could you please review Doctor Who series 3 and 4 as you I also like early Doctor Who and I would love to know your opinion on these series in detail. Thanks
JKR didnt see the need to include Dumbledore's greatest tragedy in the film, but apparently it was entirely necessary to tell Potter fans that wizards shit their pants until the 1800s.
I’ve always has a problem with how easy it was for them to get into the bank. I mean isn’t considered impossible, yet the do it so easily. The goblin they hired didn’t even do anything.
I don’t really like the films as they don’t feel compelled as I seen to first film then read the whole book series before really getting into the films
![DID IT SUCK? - Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows [PART 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gxNPCUl-K4I/mqdefault.jpg)
If you look at the McGonnagal vs Snape fight closely, you can see that Snape never attacks McGonnagal, he is always just protecting himself. On top of that it actually is Snape who deflects McGonnagal's spell on the Carrows to protect McGonnagal and the kids while he runs away, keeping his true agency secret for both the Order of the Phoenix and the Death Eaters.
Thank you for pointing this out! No matter what the other characters thought of him, Snape was always on Dumbledore's side since Lilly death.
@@Cloclo.darkarts he also then takes there wands
in the book, Snape and Minerva duel with flaming snakes and daggers, and Snape doesnt seem concerned about the children. it's much cooler fight.
Movie Snape is a different character altogether. He immediately flees lol.
I hate how much of Lupins story was left out.
McGonagal sends all the Slytherins to the dungeons...because that's where the house's common room is... Calm down lol
There was a deleted scene where all the Slytherins are locked behind bars
Dillon 812 so it’s not in the film
@@conormurphy4328 Even though the scene itself didn't make the cut, it shows what the intention of Mcgonagall/the filmmakers was here. So it isn't really left up to interpretation.
Rafael *ExCePt ThEy CuT It OuT oF tHe FiLm BeCaUsE ThEy DiDn’T WaNt It In ThErE WhIcH ShOwS ThEiR InTeNtIoNs QuItE WeLl*
Rafael probably thought to themselves “would they really lock up a whole house of children? Probably not better cut that out and leave it vague”
I like how Snape secretly deflected the spell that McGonagall's spell sent at him during the duel to take out the Carrows, hinting at his real allegiance being to Dumbledore and Harry Potter.
I agree that the leaving out of Dumbledore's backstory was disappointing. I will say this for the film. At least they fixed one the silliest moments in the book, where the Order of the Pheonix decides to go out on the grounds to attack the death eaters, which seems like the worst strategy possible.
William Wehrs Yes, they really should have included Dumbledore’s backstory. And Lupin’s story. Especially since so many people don’t bother to read the books, and Dumbledore’s story with Grindewald is a part of the Fantastic Beasts films, which I’m assuming those same people would like to watch.
I think the Harry Potter books deserve a TV adaptation with all the books content that was left out in the movies
Yr in luck
re: voldemort disintegrating, i think they did this to show a physical representation of how splitting your soul so many times essentially turns you into nothing. at least that's what i got from it.
I belive that the Malfoys were mentioned in the aftermath of the battle as 'sitting awkawardly feeling they shouldn't be here while everyone celebrates.' I am not 100% sure as I read the books a while ago but I think they were mentioned after the battle.
Can't believe you started this series almost THREE years ago.
VOICE-GUY! I want to thank you for these videos. I play them to fall asleep as your voice is so nice and relaxing to listen to. Of course I enjoy them regardless.
How about doing a vid on a modern classic like Titanic or Inception?
They picked cat noises for the Hogsmeade alarm because it’s actually a “Cat”erwauling charm.
Also, I imagine Harry was just saying something like “Oi, open up!” when he was telling the sink and door to open. That will continue to be my headcanon until proven otherwise.
19:04 I’m surprised you never thought the battle was that brutal to be honest, it’s still bad in the book but the shot in particular of greyback attacking Lavender- Ron’s girlfriend from half blood Prince- really shocked me and thought it showed how bad the battle is and how no one is safe
22:25 You realise a deus ex machina is something that hasn't been set up? The snitch and the resurrection stone were both set up in previous scenes.
Thank you for correcting me on that point. I'm not too fluent in the language of plot as much as I am in the analysis of film so I ask - what word/phrase should I have used instead?
I think what you wanted to say is that the set up/ foreshadowing was so obvious that everyone knew at this point what's in the snitch.
It depends on what you what you were getting at. C Filmer is potentially correct, but I'd also maybe suggest MacGuffin.
Herge Tintin I think this is like the opposite of a MacGuffin.
How so?
They should redo Harry Potter but as a TV series on Netflix or something. That way they could stick 100% to the books and have more time to flesh things out and create a more coherent story.
Joravil You've hit the nail on the head. Harry hadn't acknowledged that you cannot add all the details of such a complex book into just a few hours of a film. Many BBC adaptations over a few weeks can do that. Have you ever seen the FULL version of say Oliver Twist or Great Expectations compared to a 2 hour film? You'd be very surprised how much is cut. Harry's review is deeply flawed.
I mean, if you're just going be 100% faithful to the books, why even bother making a show? Just go read the books then...
Joravil if the acting was good and British
@@stevkyt2374 actually he did multiple times
No
In the book the Malfoys are actually seen after the battle sitting awkwardly with everyone else wondering if they're actually allowed to be there or if nobody had noticed them.
10:50 I’ll never forgive the filmmakers for not putting this scene in the movie. It was so satisfying to read in the book
OMG I feel as though I’ve been waiting my whole life for this!!! I’m so excited love these videos!!’❤️
I'm surprised how, thorughout this entire series, you never talked about how Ron got most of his positive traits taken away and given to Hermoine.
Please do did
It suck hunger games trilogy
OH YEAH
MY FAVOURITE DOCTOR WHO EPISODE!!
the music in the opening scene is so amazing
17:25 they could use Wingardium Leviosa
It would be charming if the spell they started on was the spell they finished on
im glad you also found the "celebration" of voldemorts death, basically everyone drinking tea and hagrid saying harry's name, was pointless. it kind of ruined the end of the battle of hogwarts for me. the book ending was much better
great reviews overall. i love hearing comparisons between book and movie
When I’m too lazy to reread/rewatch Harry Potter I watch your videos instead for a much more brief yet just as fulfilling experience
I know they didn’t explain it in the film, but around the 5:40 mark you talked about the alarm in Hogsmeade. I believe the alarm was the product of a Caterwauling charm (in the book) So idk. The word cat is in there. Why not cat screeches am I right? Right? Anyone..?
Send the slytherins to the dungeons you too harry I know your griffindor but you chose to be there
I think I liked the last film far more than you did, but I will definitely say that if you did not read the book, you’ll be lost on multiple occasions. I read it before watching the movies, but I remember thinking how I understood most of what was happening due to what I’d read before and not what was presented, unfortunately.
Actually, we see Lucius, Narcissa & Draco in the books after Voldemort's death, just chilling by themselves in the Great Hall.
i would watch all the unedited versions of your videos cause you are just that good
Voldemort did not check for a pulse on harry because when he killed harry Voldemort also fainted because harry was a horcrux. It says he seems scared to touch harry.
Voldy could have done crucio or another spell on Harry to check if he was alive...
@@ryanm666 omg this comment is so old but I dont like Harry Potter anymore since jk Rowling is a TERF so it's a shame Voldemort didn't think to use Crucio cause then he could have ended the series early.
@@ryanm666 He does throw him into the air 3 times with the Cruciatus curse after Narcissa checks on him
@@LemonPeeel Are you referring to the book or movie? Because I'm pretty sure he doesn't do this in the movie.
Okay.... and he didn't ask anybody else to check up on Harry Puta's pulse?
Ironic uploading this on April fools
Sad to see it being over now, this video series gave me so much enjoyment
r.i.p gobble 😭💔nevr forget
What
18:34 so sad
What’s a gobble
The best character
WHO!?
The elder wand theory is a plot hole in both versions. There are a few videos that explain this theory, check it out and see for yourself if it's a plot hole.
I would also like to add that the way Snape died was only for the convenience of the plot. Voldy could have used the killing curse to kill snape. What's even worse is in the film where Voldemort slits Snape's throat with the wand before killing him. This doesn't make sense since he could have used the killing curse instead of giving him a severe and painful death. The only explanation is for the convenience of the plot, for harry to get Snape's memories.
Finally great to see this review series end. You did a fantastic Job
As a big fan of the books when they came out, this movie was good but not great when I first watched in theaters. And since then, the flaws that bugged me the first time just stand out more and more, leaving a bitter aftertaste for this movie
I did get to see this in theaters and I'm not much a fan of 3d either HOWEVER it was done really masterfully and when voldy kinda disintegrated at the end the entire theater looked like it was filled with the little floating pieces of him and it was incredibly magical to experience.
Can you make an analysis of the movie: Ex Machina? That would be pretty amazing - :D
Yup! I'm aiming to make that video this week funnily enough, not entirely sure what exactly I'm gonna talk about but I'm gonna give it another watch and see what goodies I find inside!
Let's gooooooooooooo! Been looking out for this so much yet again. Harry you're my main man!
Been waiting to see this great series end for a year and a half now, great end for a great series.
Wow man great job. Well worth the wait keep up the amazing reviews
19:40"Thankfully we get to snapes death" thats exactly how i felt.
The thing in Harry's afterlife scene is NOT the Horkrux- which is destroyed at this point- but what remains of Voldemorts soul.
How have you only got 50k subscribers ive literally just binge watched youre harry potter videos aswell as black mirror and they are all great?!
You have an amazing voice for ASMR 😂 and your humor was on point. Love it and subbed! Yes I'm that sad as well now only am i into Harry Potter now. Sorted in Slytherin instead.
I was literally just watching part 1 a couple of days ago and idly wondering when you were gonna post this. Can't wait to see it.
24:14 Voldabort. What is this movie.
Can someone tell me what Cho Chang was doing at hogwarts at the end?... I thougt she was 1 year ahead of Harry so she already should have finished at hogwarts....
Griphook's goblin balls dropped between movies.
Great review, as usual, but I honestly went in expecting a lot more about the Elder Wand ownership switch at the end. Much becuase I don't remember a lot of what happened there, so I was hoping for a refreshment, but still.
Eh, if you saw Hogwarts Jesus rise from the dead YET AGAIN AFTER VOLDY FAILED TO KILL HIM FOR THE EIGHTH TIME, wouldn't you be like "You know, this isn't going to end the way we want it t0" and apparate the heck out of there?
im really curious as to why you want to "run fantastic beasts and where to find them into the ground"
aside from the movie sharing the name with the book and the book being mentioned in the movie, i dont think its really about that. it also not technically a harry potter movie and as such shouldnt be compared to them as i see so many people do. i personally loved the movie and i really want to hear your opinion on it and why (im assuming) you didnt like it.
I've anticipated episodes of this series more than most movies.
this was definitely worth the wait, cheers harry
Voldemort: I don't feel so good...
Possible spoilers for crimes of grindlewald........ isn’t credence ariana’s obscurous? Like it was a big twist but I kind guessed it was gonna go that way
I still remember seeing this in the cinema and when harry died and the screen went white it really was blinding.
I am trying to learn essay writing from this guy ! He is brilliant
it's alright
31:20 okay great but what do you give part 2??
He says it a minute later. He gave it a 4.
Eh I considered Part One to be my least favourite out of all the films - it was mainly just filler, and I disagreed with you regarding Part Two aswell :/ Each to their own i suppose
Sarah Hughes deathly hallows part 1 is my favourite film after half blood prince. It’s such a human piece and really shows the connection of the trio. I just love, love, love the scene with Hermione propped up against the tree in the Forest of Dean where she says ‘maybe we should just stay here Harry and grow old’ it really shows how dire the situation is and gives us a glimpse into Hermiones character. And also DH part 1 has my favourite opening scene and opening music of all 8 films. And Bellatrix as Hermione is great, it feels as if I’m actually watching Hermione in a disguise she got it perfectly
To each their own....
I think the reason Shamus is a explosives person is the british being salty that irland blew up and rebelled against them.
I like that Take Five around the 10 minute mark
What’s the song at 17:39?
I don't really mind Voldemort not checking Harry's body, to me it makes sense. Time after time voldemort had thought he'd finnaly got Harry just to be triumphed by him. He'd want to put a death eater on the line (one who's disappointed him countless times and doesn't care for them) instead of himself. I think it shows how precautious he was not to have his plan ruined again, even though it did lead to his downfall.
15:18 you can see the green screen in the right corner.
I liked the use of the better call Saul credits theme
Where are all these beautiful illustrations comming from?
I don't know but what I do know of is that this review had more thought put into it than the movies.
After seeing that tweet from you 3 hours ago, I have been STALKING this channel waiting for this video 🤫
Yeah sorry bud my internet connection has been super slow lately
Harry's Moving Castle no problem at all, if anything it just hyped it up for me :) all I need now is a dr who midnight review 😉
Finally... I’ve waited so long
What is that sortve funk transition music you keep using? I feel like I have heard it in GTA5 maybe
The fun thing is, Dumbledore's backstory is cut from this movie, but I think we might still see it in Fantastic Beasts, considering where this movies are possibly going.
17:36 Ascendio??
That's what I thought. We saw Harry use that spell in goblet of fire.
What is the catch background music? Please?
I actually enjoyed the fantastic beasts & where to find them but it really doesn't feel like a Harry Potter film & was a huge stretch. I (& probably other fans) would have appreciated a film that features more of the people & setting i know & love. Maybe a story about dulmbodore or James & Lilly or Harry's kid struggling to live up to his father's name & maybe go an adventure of his own. I would have even preffred a whole new set of people but featuring some of the same settings as backdrops.
I totally agree with you! Part 2 is not good!!!
4:47 "Yup I can't believe I used that word twice either"
Black mirror is now my new favourite show. Before watching it, I watched a series called Philip K dick’s“ electric dreams” another anthology series. Would u mind checking it out and maybe analysing it?!
Have you considered reviewing the various Doctor Who spin offs from the wilderness years cus I'm sure it would get a lot of views
Is that General Hux?
L. T C. U yes
Nate Films81 I guess Fluer divorced him and he didn't take it very well.
Could you please review Doctor Who series 3 and 4 as you I also like early Doctor Who and I would love to know your opinion on these series in detail. Thanks
JKR didnt see the need to include Dumbledore's greatest tragedy in the film, but apparently it was entirely necessary to tell Potter fans that wizards shit their pants until the 1800s.
Been looking forward to this :)
Could you analyze the show Legion?
9:00 : And that is how the Fantastic Beasts Movies were born.
The only loose end that wasn’t tied up was how horcruxes are made
And why didn't Voldy throw them into places where no one can reach them, like the ocean or a volcano?
Does anyone think it’s weird that it’s not Neville or Augusta that kills bellatrix since it’s their parents and Augusta’s son.
Isn't it weird that Voldy has taken over pretty much all of Harry Puta land except for a school? And he's having huge problems taking over it as well?
I’ve always has a problem with how easy it was for them to get into the bank. I mean isn’t considered impossible, yet the do it so easily. The goblin they hired didn’t even do anything.
Will you do Fantastic Beasts???
if voldemort checked harry was dead this book wouldnt work
Sometimes I feel like you forget they can perform magic. Mainly when you mention how did they get from A to B.
Ciaran Hinds ,the actor for Abberforth (probably spelt wrong), his name is pronounced K-ear-an. Just letting you know and how do you spell abberforth
I did the pottermore test too, i got slytherin, well i guess ill just die then
Calm Down Deary!
Fuck, I started tearing up just hearing the music at the very beginning. Harry makes me weak
Harry Puta sucks.
The only reason why it sold so well is because it has a cute boy who can do magic.
I've waited so long
As you are British Im dissapointed that you didn't put the hot fuzz greater good scene in when you said greater good
He probably has never seen that movie.
Looked up old codger dark souls, then saw how to kill the pursuer, by the barron. How the hell did he go from dark souls to this lol?
90 views went a long way back then
Harry's Moving Castle lol
I don’t really like the films as they don’t feel compelled as I seen to first film then read the whole book series before really getting into the films
Does he have a podcast? I would listen.
I wish! Although it's never too late to start...