Logitech MX Mechanical vs MX Keys S: Logi Flagship Keyboard with Numberpad Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 45

  • @k.6160
    @k.6160 22 години тому +1

    I Just checked the box and found the cable! I didn't know i needed one and didn't know it was in there,! I'm so glad i watched and rechecked the box! Thank you!!

  • @walterpedro7675
    @walterpedro7675 8 місяців тому +7

    Got the MX Mechanical about a month ago for €129 on Black Friday. It's my first mech keyboard and it's the best keyboard I've had by a long shot, ever. I've gone through quite a bit of keyboards (mostly Logi) since I use 'm for my work. I had to go for the board with NumPad because of heavy use of 3D software and so far it has improved my working experience a lot. I can recommend this keyboard to anyone who wishes to upgrade from the "standard" keyboard feel (let's face it, the MX Keys S still feels like a laptop keyboard).
    Edit to add : I went for the tactile brown switches and they are perfect.

    • @tonigloupy6209
      @tonigloupy6209 4 місяці тому

      I am very happy with the mechanical. The touch is so comfortable. The battery last pretty well. Still much better experience than mx keys to me.

    • @fikalagom3481
      @fikalagom3481 3 місяці тому

      Also got the tactile but mine gives an annoying “ping” sound by pressing a button.. Returned it.

  • @hundebubi1410
    @hundebubi1410 6 місяців тому +5

    Saw your Mx mechanical switches video and again exactly what I need. Not sure yet if Ibwill buy the Mx keys or the mechanical with tactile switches, but thanks to your vids I was able to narrow it down to one or the other.

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  6 місяців тому

      What kind of work and setup do you have?

    • @hundebubi1410
      @hundebubi1410 6 місяців тому

      @@adamtalkstech It's mostly for work in home office and some gaming. Bought the MX Keys S today. Will geht it next week. Mostly because it 's more quiet and closer to the K800 I am using at the moment. Again thanks for the Video.

  • @cosmosben6726
    @cosmosben6726 11 місяців тому +7

    Great video. I like the noise test.

  • @eurodudenj
    @eurodudenj 21 день тому

    Thanks for the comparison and sound tests!
    For work use (and likely / potentially faster typing) , I personally prefer the MX Keys S to the MX Mechanical Tactile (tried both out in a store side by side):
    To me, the MX Mechanical Tactile version is a nice keyboard (especially form someone who wants that mechanical feel without the extreme noise), but it is still rather loud, especially for work use or for Zoom use when hosting a call and typing in parallel.
    By contrast, the MX Keys S is very quiet and actually fast to type on since scissor style keyboards have less travel. It seems there is a slightly better feel and more key travel on the new MX Keys S version than the older [non-S] MX Keys keyboard (I have both). One review siter noted the additional key travel. That said, the reason I got the S is because my old one MX Keys Non-S (from 2020) developed 2 holes in the Left Shift key!!! I never moved it (always used at home only).
    It obviously depends on needs and personal preferences.

  • @sayedhusson3876
    @sayedhusson3876 11 місяців тому +2

    Great video, you deserve so many more subs. Keep going, stick to it!

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  11 місяців тому +1

      Thank you! That means a lot to me. Make sure you subscribe and keep following the journey!

  • @javijavv
    @javijavv 24 дні тому

    could you do a comparison between the G915 TKL vs the MX Mini Mechanical?

  • @DC-CLIENTEFAN
    @DC-CLIENTEFAN 4 місяці тому

    Thank u so much for review

  • @npinjest7779
    @npinjest7779 9 місяців тому

    Thank you for the review. How are they in a darker setting without back-lighting, is one better suited for with illumination off?

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  9 місяців тому

      I’d say they are equal. Keys are very close in color.

  • @lucapazzaglini9539
    @lucapazzaglini9539 7 місяців тому

    Wondering if the mini versions run with a numberpad of another brand (actually I'm using a Microsoft sculpt which has a separate numberpad). That because I use the numberpad on the left.

  • @robertl6442
    @robertl6442 9 місяців тому +2

    May I ask how the noise / amount of pressure compares to the mechanical linear and the mx keys s? My best buy only had the tactile switches. I'm coming from a laptop and the tactile keys seems both a little louder than I'm used to and required more "force" to push

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  9 місяців тому +1

      Linear is a little less force. I preferred the keys s to linear though.

    • @robertl6442
      @robertl6442 9 місяців тому

      @@adamtalkstech thank you for your quick reply! I appreciate it. I might get the MX Keys S and the MX Anywhere 3s (upgrading from a 2s) - I'll see if you have a video comparing the mice first though.
      Keep up the great content creation!

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  9 місяців тому

      @@robertl6442 great combo. I do prefer the master to anywhere but the anywhere is a sweet lil mouse

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  9 місяців тому

      ua-cam.com/video/N_EqkSzJ_Wc/v-deo.htmlsi=jImw1_uoR5NZrEV6 check this video out.

    • @robertl6442
      @robertl6442 9 місяців тому

      @@adamtalkstech Thanks!

  • @ct7643
    @ct7643 7 місяців тому

    My MX Mechanical keyboard number pad started acting up. Works when i key in password but noy work when i type an email. May i know why? Is there something I accidentally disabled? the top panel number keys are still working, but very frustrating when the number pad on the right is not.

  • @syunukiya
    @syunukiya 7 місяців тому

    I love the Mx mechanical but it's getting harder for me to work long hours due to the increased height of the keys and it makes my wrist hurt!

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  7 місяців тому

      Ah that stinks. I never had that problem but everyone is different

  • @quillaja
    @quillaja 10 місяців тому

    Any idea if the right hand command buttons on these keyboards can be remapped? I never use right hand start of fn, and would STRONGLY prefer the right ctrl to be closer to the spacebar (use it all the time in vscode). I __assume__ it's easy to swap keycaps on the Mechanical (is it?), but can the keys on the Keys be swapped?--again, to rearrange the command keys and make their physical appearance match their function. Oh yea, windows 11.

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  10 місяців тому

      Not from the Logi options app but maybe with third party remapping software. I"m not too familiar with that kind of software.

    • @matijacash4555
      @matijacash4555 9 місяців тому

      MS PowerToys

    • @quillaja
      @quillaja 9 місяців тому

      @@matijacash4555 Nope, tried it. PowerToys doesn't recognize Fn has a normal key you can remap, at least not on the MX Mechanical. I sent that keyboard back to Logitech and got a NuPhy Air75 V2, which is overall a much nicer keyboard and more configurable. (Also preordered the Air95 V2, to see which size I prefer.) MX Mechanical only wins in battery life, though I don't mind charging my keyboard occasionally (and you can still use it while it's plugged in).

    • @matijacash4555
      @matijacash4555 9 місяців тому +1

      @@quillaja I will check that keyboard, thank You! Currently I am using MX Keys in office, but I need new low profile keyboard for home.

    • @quillaja
      @quillaja 9 місяців тому

      @@matijacash4555 Keychron K3 Pro is also an option for a 75% layout (and I think Keychron has some low profile kbs in larger layouts too). I haven't used a Keychron, but folks have said the bluetooth wake time is a bit too slow. Keychron also uses a more angled key profile than logitech or nuphy (both of which are very flat), so that's something to consider as well. Although I wanted to stay in logitech as I've been using a K360 kb with a M510 mouse for years, and looked at the Keys and Mechanical, I'm overall glad I made the switch to the nuphy keyboard instead of sticking to the Mechanical.

  • @kennethmanuel5823
    @kennethmanuel5823 Місяць тому

    Honestly, I feel that the Cougar Luxlim is way better and more durable keyboard than the Logitech MX Mechanical keyboard. The Cougar Luxlim is a low-profile, Red switch keyboard and the actuation is way better too, making for a great typing experience.

  • @SuperJaggermaister
    @SuperJaggermaister 8 місяців тому

    Are there compatible with PS5 ???

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  7 місяців тому

      Should work just fine! I'm not a gaming expert tho

  • @mutantthegreat7963
    @mutantthegreat7963 4 місяці тому

    In the old days, you just didn't have a choice! :)

  • @tonigloupy6209
    @tonigloupy6209 5 місяців тому

    Mx keys s is a disastrous experience to me, beside I don't like the touch of the keys, the laser engraving deteriorates since day 7 or so. And the battery length is really bad. Mechanical is much more comfortable. We ll see with time

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  4 місяці тому

      Sorry to hear that. I've loved both of them

    • @Trooper12944
      @Trooper12944 4 місяці тому

      i had mx keys s for more than 8 month now love it every time no damaged at all even typing all day I wanted a mini keyboard too so was confused between mx keys and mechanical I went with mx keys mini

  • @NikitaDugin
    @NikitaDugin 6 місяців тому

    I can't believe you've really just said it costs $160 when the price on the screen was $169.99. That's just outrageous.

    • @adamtalkstech
      @adamtalkstech  6 місяців тому

      Yup got it wrong when I filmed and didn't catch that!

    • @NikitaDugin
      @NikitaDugin 6 місяців тому

      @@adamtalkstech I mean, it's OK. I don't mind. No offence. I just can't believe it works. Lol.