@@zabers5818 First Order stormtroopers are trained from childhood. Fin never had a birth name he remembered, that's why he had to make up Finn from FN-2187
I also loved how Mando basically had no idea how to do facial expressions. He always had a weird, shell-shocked look on his face because nobody had seen his face since he was a child.
That's actually an awesome observation, that without the social necessity to develop visual cues his 1k yard stare from his childhood trauma is permanently etched onto his face. I love continually finding new things to love about Star Wars!
Oh my god thank you. I had to watch this back a few times. You're 1000% right. The glance and correction, he's not used to people seeing where his eyes go. The slow head turn that would look cold in a helmet but revealing his anxiety without it, almost turning like he's used to the weight or something. You have a good eye
Yo, I just noticed who it was. I think they called him goat in that movie, but all I remember is him being insane and cutting himself when he said god's name in vain lol
He immediately picked up on his killing intent. The actor did really well expressing Meyfield's outward smile and casual chatter but with building rage and killing intent underneath.
Honestly it didnt even feel like acting to me as a long time Bill stan, this is the energy he has talking to entitled people like Bill Maher (not saying hes a bad actor by any means)
He didn't think he was a good actor either, but after his role in B.B, it was hard to prove he wasn't. Especially after his second showing on Mandalorion.
I especially love, as a dude who’s learned to not give a crap about a lot of stuff that doesn’t truly matter, this character is pretty similar to him; he does as he likes but there are important things he really cares about. Best trooper-turned-hero story to come from Star Wars
@@brettxsmith comedians generally can do serious dialogue/drama well because they already understand cadence and timing from doing comedy. It's great to see, Bill can actually act, I think he'd do great if given the opportunity.
Which version? The old ps2 or the ps4/5 version? I played both but I don't remember either. I have no access to the ps2 version. This definitely makes me want to replay the ps4 version though. I appreciate the info, this is cool.
I loved Meyfield in this story. The whole time he talked about how he didn't care about anything, but the moment he's reminded of the injustice he and his friends faced, he made an emotional decision, risked everything, because he's only human
A few years had passed. Still, it's a bit like someone talking about minute details of the vietnam conflict in the 90s. 20 years is hardly "history". Its barely any time at all to a trauma survivor.
@koboldsage9112 Hadn't even been that long. Operation Cinder was right after Endor, the Empire fell a year later, and that scene is five years after that. So the Empire wide funeral pyre that was Palpatine's deadman's switch (which was stupid for myriad reasons) was six years prior. That's like saying you know your history when discussing 9/11 in 2006.
@@theneonorangegecko1576 if you're playing the newer bf2, I believe it's in the single player/solo menu options. Haven't played the game in a few years so my memory is a little hazy. But as far as I'm aware, it was never removed so should still be in there.
The way that the imperial officer’s eyes look away into a 1000 yard stare for a split second after the mention of Burning Khon is superb acting. I definitely recognize the actor but I couldn’t tell you what I saw him in, which is honestly the true accolade of any actor
Bill can mf Act! And the greatest character arch progression I. The History of anything ever. Amazing writing. Best part is how Bill makes it work. I honestly do not think it would have worked with any other actor.
Not going to lie this was one of my top three of my favorite episodes from the Mandalorian you'd think Mayfield was just a one-off character but they actually gave him story and I like how they left it off
What always amused me about this scene is how he held a grudge for the death of numerous Imperial troopers, yet he blows up that facility, filled with numerous Imperials, right after lol
Seconds later Meyfield will be looking as his hand having drawn his blaster and slain that officer like it had a life of its' own. A split second of hesitation and processing what he's just done and then some other soldier walks in and he snaps out of it and just shoots. Then all hell break loose. Best Star Wars acting ever.
@@DecetiveTheDev I do believe this is from The Mandalorian . Someone please correct me if I'm wrong bc I stopped watching after Season 1 due to time constraints.
Bill be like, "Eh, you know, I uhhh, I just dont really care about Star Wars, you know?" And, "Eh, you know, im not some great actor" and then has some of the best acting for the most popular Star Wars TV show lol
This was the most memorable scene in the whole series for me. Somehow, watching a fictional soldier character get emotional over a fictional war. Really well done scene both actors.
Bill did what no one else really ever tried to. He played it as a soldier, his attitude, his cadence, the guy treats his role here like hes a marine swapping horror stories with a superior. Hes not a storm trooper hes just a soldier whos seen terrible things. Something everyone else seems to forget. Take away the laser swords and fantasy setting, storm troopers are rank and file military at the end of the day. The attitude of a soldier is what they should have. Not whatever the fuck Finn was.
Probably one of the best and most human dialogues in all of Star Wars. Meyfeld was cool in season one, but he became incredible in this second season episode.
Meyfield ended up being a nicely layered character with an interesting past in just a couple of episodes Those where the episodes that where amazing to watch
Director: I need you to be bitter about all the wreckless spending and deaths in war and the decisions of Pompous Leaders in Power. Burr: I see your a fan.
Bill becoming a more renowned actor than a comedian is a testament to his ability and the shining potential of how we as humans can have different political views and still enjoy each other's presence.
The fact that this is a fucking comedian man.....bills acting chops are no joke...hes fucking ice cold in this scene. The underlying threat and rage in his voice....just...fuckin amazing.
*Did I ever tell you the Tragedy of Imperial Sharpshooter Mayfield?* It's ironic... he was labeled a comedian, but on that day, he wasn't funny, and the joke was on the Empire.
Left out the best part... Where you could see him tearing up inside... Struggling between what he wanted to do and what he knew he SHOULD do. Burr killed this scene.
Using famous quote: "This scene gave Meyfeld better ex-stormtrooper arc than Finn had in three movies".
But he wasn't a stormtrooper... He made it extra clear when first met him.
@@DejectedCat He was probably in the Imperial Army like Han Solo was like in Solo
He wasn't a stormtrooper, wiseass!
Wasn't Finn a new recruit?
@@zabers5818 First Order stormtroopers are trained from childhood. Fin never had a birth name he remembered, that's why he had to make up Finn from FN-2187
I also loved how Mando basically had no idea how to do facial expressions. He always had a weird, shell-shocked look on his face because nobody had seen his face since he was a child.
That's actually an awesome observation, that without the social necessity to develop visual cues his 1k yard stare from his childhood trauma is permanently etched onto his face.
I love continually finding new things to love about Star Wars!
Oh my god thank you. I had to watch this back a few times. You're 1000% right. The glance and correction, he's not used to people seeing where his eyes go. The slow head turn that would look cold in a helmet but revealing his anxiety without it, almost turning like he's used to the weight or something. You have a good eye
Is this Pedro? How do you know so much? Lol
Watching the show @@Elitepear
That's actual an observation at Pedro pascals lack of acting talent
Bill killed it as Migs. He made the right choice in saying yes to the character
He said yes because as he stated he has made fun of star wars and us geeks for so long he felt should get in on it
@@travisphipps8480In his defense most Star Wars Scripts aren't like this.
@@travisphipps8480Apology accepted
@@Auvas_Damaskwasn’t really an apology
@@nickmiller9910I mean Bill
The imperial officer is such an underrated character. He was the crazy solider in the 2005 doom movie. He has a unique voice for sure.
Yo, I just noticed who it was. I think they called him goat in that movie, but all I remember is him being insane and cutting himself when he said god's name in vain lol
@@willofbarbariayou are mixing up two characters.
You want a kiss?
I was wondering why he looked familiar lol
He was also the therapist in Until Dawn I’m pretty sure
Din’s look of “Don’t fucking do it” killed me lmao
Din also not knowing how to subtly look side to side because he’s worn a helmet with limited view for nearly all of his life 😂
He immediately picked up on his killing intent.
The actor did really well expressing Meyfield's outward smile and casual chatter but with building rage and killing intent underneath.
@@tenjenkfor real. I thought I was gonna see him pull a blaster. Haven't seen the show so no idea what happens after
@@jmsgridiron5628 He ends up shooting the officer and then they kill their way out of the facility lmao.
@@aJamBiscuitDude! Spoilers.
/s
I was absolutely blown away by his acting in that scene. It's always funny when a comedian shows his acting chops
Bill’s mastery of sarcasm, I hear the edge in his voice growing the more he’s talking, great acting - he hates the Officer and the contempt is clear
Honestly it didnt even feel like acting to me as a long time Bill stan, this is the energy he has talking to entitled people like Bill Maher
(not saying hes a bad actor by any means)
They understand timing.
Hes done a few serious roles in his career, he kills it every time
Robin Williams comes to mind.
It's funny, Bill Burr, a man who openly didn't give a fuck about Star Wars, ending up playing one of it's best characters ever
He didn't think he was a good actor either, but after his role in B.B, it was hard to prove he wasn't. Especially after his second showing on Mandalorion.
@@dragonsword7370
Hell yeah!
I especially love, as a dude who’s learned to not give a crap about a lot of stuff that doesn’t truly matter, this character is pretty similar to him; he does as he likes but there are important things he really cares about. Best trooper-turned-hero story to come from Star Wars
I loved his performance in this role. It cut before the best part though.
Best character ever? 😂😂😂
God I love this man's ability to convey anger: loud, cursing rage to seething, cold loathing. Under rated as an actor.
mid at best
@@alphaHero100obviously you’d be better off
The reason he's good in this role is because it's not that far off his stand-up persona. I doubt he has much range beyond this.
Its because he does it in real life
@@alphaHero100somebodies acting/influencing/founding isnt working out
Bill can act
for real, he does a great job in serious roles wich is cool considering he is a comedian
Dude can actually deliver on timing and cadence. It helps that he has lots of practice with personas that barely contain their anger and frustration.
‘T
So you play a pend up aggressive guy with a pinch of lovable charisma.
"so i play myself?"
@@brettxsmith comedians generally can do serious dialogue/drama well because they already understand cadence and timing from doing comedy. It's great to see, Bill can actually act, I think he'd do great if given the opportunity.
This hits different as a Battlefront 2 player. Iden (your character) literally comments on how all the troopers here will die.
It sure does. The gravity of those decisions still rocks the emotions just with the mention of operation cinder.
Ugh now I need to replay it again
Which version? The old ps2 or the ps4/5 version? I played both but I don't remember either. I have no access to the ps2 version. This definitely makes me want to replay the ps4 version though. I appreciate the info, this is cool.
@@TheRealJade103 Battlefront 2017.
Incredible game. I'm an Xbox player so I can't speak for PS but the game is still active here.
@@theCantinafan good to know lol I'm downloading it now
Well, I refuse to play that shell of a Battlefront game. This isn't changing my mind
I loved Meyfield in this story. The whole time he talked about how he didn't care about anything, but the moment he's reminded of the injustice he and his friends faced, he made an emotional decision, risked everything, because he's only human
Mando: Don't do it
Meyfeld after five bodies: I never saw your face!
Mando:😳Ummm okay.
Funny.
He was saying that he didn't see his face out of respect for "The Way" not as a look back on the action.
@@madsam7582 I know that 😆😆🤙
First two seasons of the Mandalorian were so good, man.
I thought the third season was good, not as good, but good
Yeah, then it became the Womandalorian.
Mayfield was testing him. The moment he saw he had no remorse and smiled at the sheer death his fate was sealed.
It’s crazy how bill burr’s rage you only get to catch glimpses of in his comedic, is OUTSTANDING material for acting.
"There's a man that knows his history."
Dude, it was only a few years ago.
Bet like all the real world governments they buried it..
A few years had passed. Still, it's a bit like someone talking about minute details of the vietnam conflict in the 90s.
20 years is hardly "history". Its barely any time at all to a trauma survivor.
@koboldsage9112 Hadn't even been that long. Operation Cinder was right after Endor, the Empire fell a year later, and that scene is five years after that.
So the Empire wide funeral pyre that was Palpatine's deadman's switch (which was stupid for myriad reasons) was six years prior.
That's like saying you know your history when discussing 9/11 in 2006.
Its less likely a time thing and more like "that Op was not widely known about, you know your stuff."
@@gs4011 The near entirety of the Imperial war machine tried to burn the Empire to ashes.
They weren't subtle about it.
If they made a show staring Burr id watch it as long as he brings this emotion an realness to it.
Did you watch f is for family? Based loosely on his own life
"I'LL PUT YOU THROUGH THAT FUCKING WALL!" kills me every time
@@hamoostaffat
Press "F" for family.
This one scene made my entire BF2 campaign playthough worth it
Battlefront 2 has a campaign?
@theneonorangegecko1576 both Battlefront 2 had campaigns. Both good.
@@Merc7734 how do I access the campaign? I dont see it on the home screen
@@theneonorangegecko1576go to single player tab
@@theneonorangegecko1576 if you're playing the newer bf2, I believe it's in the single player/solo menu options. Haven't played the game in a few years so my memory is a little hazy. But as far as I'm aware, it was never removed so should still be in there.
The way that the imperial officer’s eyes look away into a 1000 yard stare for a split second after the mention of Burning Khon is superb acting. I definitely recognize the actor but I couldn’t tell you what I saw him in, which is honestly the true accolade of any actor
Richard brake. 2-3 rob zombie movies, a Hannibal lecter movie etc. guy’s brilliant in everything 👍🏽
Pretty sure he played one of the Russian people in Peaky Blinders
Honestly, I think Richard Brake may be one most reliable and under-rated supporting actors working today.
Could not believe how many comments I had to scroll past to get to the truth.
Was looking for a Richard Brake comment! Incredibly underrated actor
My introduction to him I believe was this show but the most recent thing of his that I’ve seen was R.I.P.D. 2
This added so much depth to Imperials.
Then they got right back to using them as cannon fodder. Makes absolutely no sense...
Bill is such a badass, excellent actor and amazing comedian. One of my favorites!
Having an Imperial commander with a southern accent hits different.
it's because libs hate America. It's their MO.
Instead of emanating a European fascist like typical Imperials, this guy emanates the southern gentleman turned slave-owning KuKluxKonfederate.
It's more middle south, like Virginia, Tennessee, or the Carolinas. Fits pretty well for an officer
@@filmandfirearmsThat would be an Appalachian accent. Appa-latch-ian.
@@Robert_Douglass No, Appalachia has their own accent. I was referring more to the east, like Richmond
Dude can play a serious part. Respect to a comedian who can utilize more than just comedy to deliver
Comedians make some of the best dramatic actors
I still remember seeing this for the first time, sent chills down my spine when I heard Operation Cinder
I was so surprised and impressed by his acting. Instantly became an amazing character with depth and great writing. Bravo!
Amazing scene. He lived the horrors of war, and the evil leaders of the empire.
Bill can mf Act! And the greatest character arch progression I. The History of anything ever. Amazing writing. Best part is how Bill makes it work. I honestly do not think it would have worked with any other actor.
Damn Bill has the acting chops
I love how bill always plays himself and it works
I always loved how Bill getting an acting role is few and far between but he is always one of the enjoyable and likable characters.
Legit one of the best scenes in any Star Wars films or shows ever.
This is one of the best written scenes in any Star Wars content that we’ve seen in the last 15 years
Hahaha Bill just decides "Yeah I'm gonna go ahead and checkmate this Officer before he tries to checkmate us"
Not going to lie this was one of my top three of my favorite episodes from the Mandalorian you'd think Mayfield was just a one-off character but they actually gave him story and I like how they left it off
The disrespect of saying they’re just a small sacrifice.
Seeing these three interacting... in a Star Wars universe. Wild
I remember seeing that for the first time. I got emotional. He an underrated character and in this role. He nailed it,and brought his humor into it.
He does a great job of portraying cold rage. Smirking knowing however this conversation goes he will kill this man.
Bill burr sells the calm anger, i know hes like that normally but it translates well for a vet.
What always amused me about this scene is how he held a grudge for the death of numerous Imperial troopers, yet he blows up that facility, filled with numerous Imperials, right after lol
I think I’ve just watched the best scene in all the Star Wars franchise. Good work gentlemen. 🙏
The way mando looks at him , he knows it’s about to go down 😂😂
Bill became one of my favorite characters in Star Wars. He's so grounded and relatable.
Bill showed how damn good of an actor he can be
Mando's face was like "Bro, just DONT! as much as i love to myself, just NOPE!"
Seconds later Meyfield will be looking as his hand having drawn his blaster and slain that officer like it had a life of its' own.
A split second of hesitation and processing what he's just done and then some other soldier walks in and he snaps out of it and just shoots.
Then all hell break loose.
Best Star Wars acting ever.
This is the best scene Disney Star Wars has produced to this point and it’s not even close.
Both phenomenal actors who need to be casted in more films
Bill Burr is really an underrated actor. Loved him in this role!
The intensity of this scene was insane.
One of the most compelling imperial moral quandaries in the entire series. Good people doing horrible things, gets me every time
Best episode in a long time
What show is this?
@@DecetiveTheDev I do believe this is from The Mandalorian . Someone please correct me if I'm wrong bc I stopped watching after Season 1 due to time constraints.
@@Steeze_Gaming yep it's mandalorian, season 2
I always said that a good comedian can also act well in a serious role.
👏🏽 Bravo Bill Burr 🤗
"I don't just know it. I lived it."
Bill burrs character arc kept me around. Wish he would do more rolls like this. Cool guy
Bill be like, "Eh, you know, I uhhh, I just dont really care about Star Wars, you know?" And, "Eh, you know, im not some great actor" and then has some of the best acting for the most popular Star Wars TV show lol
This was the most memorable scene in the whole series for me. Somehow, watching a fictional soldier character get emotional over a fictional war. Really well done scene both actors.
easily one of THE best scenes in Star Wars history, and I'm not using hyperbole.
These actors absolutely nailed it like a Tarantino scene.
Comedians often make great actors because they understand.........................timing.
I loved this whole episode cuz mando was so uncomfortable the entire time having his helmet off and Migs just killed it carrying them through this
Bill did what no one else really ever tried to. He played it as a soldier, his attitude, his cadence, the guy treats his role here like hes a marine swapping horror stories with a superior. Hes not a storm trooper hes just a soldier whos seen terrible things. Something everyone else seems to forget. Take away the laser swords and fantasy setting, storm troopers are rank and file military at the end of the day. The attitude of a soldier is what they should have. Not whatever the fuck Finn was.
Probably one of the best and most human dialogues in all of Star Wars. Meyfeld was cool in season one, but he became incredible in this second season episode.
Meyfield ended up being a nicely layered character with an interesting past in just a couple of episodes
Those where the episodes that where amazing to watch
Director: I need you to be bitter about all the wreckless spending and deaths in war and the decisions of Pompous Leaders in Power.
Burr: I see your a fan.
I forgot that they referenced the friggin CAMPAIGN STORY FROM BATTLEFRONT 2 in this series, that's amazing.
I always forget that bill was in the mandalorian. I fuckin love this guy.
I had just played Battlefront 2 when this came out, and it was a flashbang to hear Operation Cinder being dropped
That line "man it was like 5, 10k people" sounded so incredibly organic.
This whole table killed it. Al three actors made one of the best scenes in Star warsa
This whole episode was amazing
Back when the writing & dialogue was competent🤦🏾♂️
That's an officer who knows he's about to be fragged but can't back down without losing face 😊
Everyone in this scene did freaking fantasticly
Watching his commedian shows and then seeing him play amazing roles like meyfield, crazy.
I love how Mando looks so embarrassed and keeps his head down
He did such a good job in this scene
How can a guy show more in one scene than some people can show in a whole book or movie?
I've watched this episode so many times, it's incredible.
Bill becoming a more renowned actor than a comedian is a testament to his ability and the shining potential of how we as humans can have different political views and still enjoy each other's presence.
The fact that this is a fucking comedian man.....bills acting chops are no joke...hes fucking ice cold in this scene. The underlying threat and rage in his voice....just...fuckin amazing.
*Did I ever tell you the Tragedy of Imperial Sharpshooter Mayfield?*
It's ironic... he was labeled a comedian, but on that day, he wasn't funny, and the joke was on the Empire.
Left out the best part... Where you could see him tearing up inside... Struggling between what he wanted to do and what he knew he SHOULD do.
Burr killed this scene.
This scene hit hard...Bill killed it, as did the Imp...a narrative that continues on today.
This is the best star wars that has ever been made.
Have you by any chance seen ep4?
truly one of top 5 best scene out of all starwars
These two episodes could have been an entire series.
This might be my favorite scene from the whole show
Love the part where pedro is looking at him like Please don't do this😅😅
Don't mess with people from Space Boston.
One of my favorite episodes in the mandolorian
This whole scene is amazing
I practically jumped out of my seat when I heard him say operation cinder
He's not even acting at this point, he's really good at pushing buttons convincingly
I loved how they just start talking about how he "died" at the end of the episode and just walk away reminiscing as he exits stage left
This is an amazing scene, probably top 10 in the series. Bill Burr is the goat
Unironically one of the best moments out of a Disney star wars show.
Bill burr. You beautiful cynical man.
You have range.
You just never use it.
He looks at Mando like: I'm about to kill this guy
Mando: please don't 😅