David Seymour: Treaty principles, Pharmac, and being minister for regulation | Q+A 2023
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Incoming regulations minister David Seymour talks about how he wants to use the portfolio to change lawmaking, along with his plans for changes at Pharmac, and the Treaty Principles bill that National has only committed to supporting as far as select committee stage
Subscribe to Q+A: bit.ly/QandASu...
Join Jack Tame and the Q+A team and find the answers to the questions that matter. Made with the support of NZ on Air.
WATCH SUNDAY 9AM ON TVNZ1 OR CATCH UP ON DEMAND: www.tvnz.co.nz...
FOLLOW Q+A ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Facebook:
/ nzqanda
Twitter:
/ nzqanda
For stories that matter to you and the very latest from Aotearoa and around the world: 1News.co.nz/
I'm glad that the comments are enabled in this video so that people can discuss and express their own opinions. I wish that other NZ news channels did the same.
Indeed. Very annoying. But maybe, we should take the time and register on that platform. Then we can enter the debate.
I hate the smug smile on the face of the “idiot presenter” on that programme.
Change of gov- more free speech-
Closed captions would be nice too though
It should be a mandated thing. Freedom of speech should be protected and news platforms shouldn't be able to stifle discussion like they do brazenly.
@@L3monsta Moderation of speech should be “outsourced” to those who comment.
Shame those who use have silly ideas and use anti social language.
The platforms can even become profitable and useful sources to monitor speech so that journalist can improve their journalism. Seeing where people are heading down a rabbit hole and then provide well researched opinion pieces.
Like in the old days. Reward good journalism. Wipe the smirk off the faces of bigoted journalists and editors can send them to the political desk in rural towns to report in the free handouts until they have graduated.
10k to get approval from council to build a double garage on my own freehold property I have owned for 30 years. Took 4 months and no idea of the cost up front. Local council are a disgrace.Emotionally and mentally draining.
Absolutely, the councils are a bit inhuman too. I built an office 20mm to close to my neighbors Property (which was a firewall) and had to pull the whole thing to the ground. 30K wasted.
Fur coats. Give a dog a bone. Master keys. No one is more important than ##, sry I meant us.
Should be a quick consult with immediate neighbours (if any) and a quick look at utilities, etc. impact from council, then go ahead. More human negotiation and compromise I reckon. And if construction sucks that’s up to next buyer if they’re happy enough with the standard to buy or not. Common sense isn’t so common anymore!
Yeah but problem is you also have scummy landlords that build heaps of poor quality sleepouts and try shove uni students in
Councils are a mafia organisation extracting money out of people.
Not sure I have ever heard such clear answers by a politician.
Yes, clearly idiotic.
Hes an expert at talking nonsense
amazing what a change in govt does for Jack's attitude eh
Nice to hear some clear, concise and educated answers.
Educated? I'd say he just got his ideology down pat more than anything. His Productivity ministry is an absolute joke. Even getting rid of regulations requires regulations, and that means employees and contractors. He's in for a wake-up call.
What a joke. He is an idiot. He even has "resting dumb face".
@@Alfonso_111 Thanks, Lefty.
Clear straight answers which make sense.
David really does do great interviews. Clear answers, easy to understand.
Yes Refreshing!! Note all others
I get the feeling ' good interviews ' is all David is capable of ... He is about to be nutted by the reality of Winston and the duplicity of the National party ... His ' treaty ' referendum is already dead in the water , out-manoeuvred by professionals .
Clear and easy to undestand, are you sure? I think there are a lot of layers to the things he says. On the surface, for the unwary, it all seems clear and easy to understand. But I think it's designed to be that way, and under close scrutiny many of the thing he says which seem like common sense will turn out to actually be quite radical.
For instance, right now we have free speech laws that allow anyone to go anywhere they want and say whatever they want, provided that they are willing to live with the consequences of what they say. Engaging in hate speech has consequences, as it should. What Seymour is proposing is not really about enabling free speech - we already have that - it's much more about removing the consequences for hate speech. He does a wonderful rhetorical job of dressing it up as being about free speech though.
@@spiltichor1192Perfectly said🎉
@spiltichor1192 hate speech isn't a real thing.
0:00 Welcome
0:10 The negotiations process
1:08 Seymour's new portfolio
7:15 The Treaty of Waitangi referendum
9:10 Re-writing the firearms act
11:28 Updating Pharmac
14:57 Reserve Bank targets
16:33 Free speech policy for tertiary institutions
Like your Time-Stamps Glen, can slide 4ward to the Subject of Interest. 'preci8'd.
@@-KAIX-0405-NZ agree... Glen has done more for society in a time stamp post than the last Labour government did in an entire term of office. 😂
@@peterlattimore6013 Hit it on the nail Peter, see how it plays out, with the Double Deputys onnboard. Should be interesting.
Although not all the policies that i wanted to see change, i have never been so optimistic about the future of NZ.
There's optimism and then there's thankfulness. Concerns me to know there were still Labour supporters willing to lead our country into oblivion.
So refreshing to hear actual problem solving being created in these talks on issues that have been center front for six years or more, congratulations to the newly elected gvt well said David.
You're literally supporting fascists wtf is wrong with you
David is very at the talk part now lets actually see how good he is at the harder walk part as cutting things like fishing regulations and having "talks" about things like the Treaty is the easy part actually creating things is far harder.
He is all talk theoretical political technocratic with no practical experiences in governance.
@@chrismckellar9350 Just like "Straight outta Uni never worked a real full time Job" Ardern?? or do you mean hes not a lifetime professional politician? He's been there 8 yrs,longer than some,shorter than others.
@@carlngatai7201 - Seem my comment.
David is one Hell of a Intelligent guy.
Ahahahahahahahaha what interview did you watch?
Guess that depends on the intelligence of the viewer.
Dave's certainly got great commonsense over a broad sector of the beauocracy. Reading the two other comments made me realise we aren't all pragmatic.
I thought Dave was off on some sections, but over all, he's twice the politican Hipkins is or 5 times more competent than a Greens Politican (And I was a founding member of the Waikato Greens, back in early 90s, until realising, they're unhinged an illogical shadow jumpers).
@@peterlattimore6013 lmao okay Peter. Thanks for the illuminating comment 😂
@@Alfonso_111 It's New Zealand by the way, not Aotearoa. So if it depends on the viewer, then that means your comment isn't very intelligent.
David is great. Clear. Logical. Concise. So refreshing from the usual whaffle we have been hearing from the previous government
It's easy to be concise when you're an idiot whose plan is detached from reality 😂.
@@Kereru Look in the mirror cuzzie bro, take a long hard look at yourself, you're the delusional one I'd say.
Yea I think he's an intelligent man. He has a balanced approach and he makes sense
Fantastic David. Breath of fresh air! A stark contrast to the oxygen sapping last 6 years.
You are literally supporting fascists wtf is wrong with you
Love how David fully answers the questions. How refreshing.
He is all talk theoretical political technocratic with no practical experiences in governance.
@@chrismckellar9350 thoughts precede actions
@@chrismckellar9350 I'm not interested in your conspiracy theories, Chris... You're so narrow minded by your biased view point, it's comical.
@@chrismckellar9350Well now he has an opportunity to put his ideas into practice. I say, give him a fair shot
@@peterlattimore6013 - I can say the same about you. It seems that you are stuck in the past.
A NZ news channel that is open for comments, the rest a closed.... free speech hey Tova
Well done David Seymour, I look forward to seeing you in action.
Oh you’ll see him in action alright, 😂
David Seymour is the best politician nz has seen in many a long time imo.
In your little mind he is lol
cap
@@Badest187wonder who this guy thinks is good, greens 😂 Tmp 😂
He is one of the most naturally stupid that I've seen. Jacinda was naive and egotistical in her second term but this guy is just an imbecile.
What an articulate, clear-thinking, practical person!
He is all talk theoretical political technocratic with no practical experiences in governance.
Good observation
@@chrismckellar9350He is a breath of fresh air. A realist rather than an idealist.
@@DavidSmith-yi8ou - How is he a breath of fresh air when is peddling right libertarian ideals? Look what has happen of 37 years of 'for profit at least cost' neoliberal economics and so less governance has done by successive governments creating the social and economic mess the country is currently in. David Seymour is all theory and like with Luxon have no practical ideas who how to decrease inflation and cost of living, the $29 billion deficit in our balance of payments and the looming storm clouds of global geopolitical, trade, economic, supply chains, manufacturing uncertainties and the disruptive effects of a warming planet.
@@Adogsmate4267 - Grow up and stop being an idiot. It seems that you don't like free speech.
Good interview thanksJack because of few interruptions and agenda bias.
Dave you are in fire 🔥👍
Jack's had to tone it down when his team didn't win
@@avcomm100 lol I did think that too. Seymour is his new boss so he better stfu lol.
But it seriously annoys me when the interviewer ( including tame) constantly interrupts trying to impose their bias agenda 💩
So he's now not allowed to challenge these people? Sounds like a dictatorship we have entered into@@mikebirminghamnz
To get a licence for commercial fishing you have to be a fit and proper person , I know a fisherman who's been to prison for holding someone for ransom, still takes and sells drugs yet he has a commercial fishing licence, he even got convicted of fisheries, so ask yourself is he a fit and proper person even known by police,
ive heard him speak a couple of times and he is clear and lucid
Good stuff. Especially appreciated the ratio of Seymour talking time to Tame
God I’m absolutely loving this new government. Exactly what I voted for.
Yes if you voted for Trump style racist dog whistling and policies 🤮
They haven't done anything except talk so far ... The three Amigos and the chaos cabinet ...
@@weehudyy and yet the majority in NZ feel more positive than ever. The last lot of idiots had 6 years and achieved only to send us backwards. The muppet show was was we called Labour and the Greens.
You hope😂 bunch of idiots if you ask me .
Funny to see Jack calm TF down and give David respect to answer questions now he’s in power. Pre election he was salty and rarely allowed David to answer without interruption.
🥱 you need to carm tf down karen lol
cap, he did it for everyone, don’t take the victim stance
@@twiidle7158not for Rawhiri Waititi he didn't
@@twiidle7158
Yes and it was bloody annoying and a turned.
The real issue is sounding slick and composed but having little facts or dynamics
I'm excited as a New Zealander for this change.... its long over due... and finally people get the change they deserve because the last few years in New Zealand has been horrific. As for the treaty that my people (British ancestors) made with the moari means nothing now... that was then... this is now... let's unite as kiwis as one people!
The treaty has been crucial to date to the survival of Māori without it Māori may not have survived as a culture. For example many tribes have been able to claim recompense for loss of lands confiscated by the British Government allowing those tribes to then develop and grow commerce which in turn has educated their people. The treaty meant something then and means something to Māori now.
@@venomidas many forget the Treaty stopped Maori tribes from waging wars against one another. I find it funny how some critise Colonisation for Maoris demise, but in reality it brought Maori together in unity.
@@peterlattimore6013Maori were said to have arrived between late 1200 early1300...The British arrived 500 years later and settled in the 1800s 500 years of war didnt put a dent in Maori civilisation but 100 years of colonisation has almost completely wiped out the culture and its people. If we were thriving we wouldn't be a minority. Colonisation isn't good for anyone except the colonizers.
@@venomidasIt helped Maori from heading towards wiping each other out.
@@autumnedwards45We don't hear of many Maori retreating to the Ureweras to lead the good life of old.
Can anyone tell me what the overseas debt . Everyone in Govt in NZ avoids the subject. I wonder why?
Good interview. So glad to hear what David is saying.
Inflation in NZ is only so high as direct house prices (new build costs are in the CPI) were removed from the CPI like the USA did. This is simply absurd given houses are the biggest consumer item. Interest rates would have never gone so low during covid had direct house prices been included, and not would inflation and interest rates be so high now, given average house prices are falling.
What a clear interview. Feeling positive
Kudos for keeping the comments open
Jack is an old fashion leftie, but let David have his say here!
Good stuff David
Don’t forget to get feedback from the builders, teachers, nurses, farmers etc etc as to how the new plan affects them. There are skilled people out there who can foresee the actual outcomes including unintended consequences.
I wouldn't ask the average teacher...Some aren't that intelligent and understanding of "unintended consequences".
One teacher I dated was an alcoholic who often had a Friday or Monday off because she knew there were relief teachers available. Another young woman I knew via other means, stopped smoking dope and went to meth, because the testing process made it impossible to detect after a day or so.
Comes down to mind set... one is either a follower (insecurities) and can't think independently or they're a leader (able to think independently) and understands the importance of logical thought processing).
Yep, 100% agree, See all the unintended poor consequences that have occurred over the last 6 years from supposed good social policy.
Regulations - as someone who lived in Latin America for 5 years NZ’s regulatory scheme is a dream. We’re also regularly one of the best in the world for ease of doing business. I wonder just how much better our regulatory scheme can be made without breaking what is already working.
Of course our regulatory system is superior to Guatemala, Cuba etc. Having been a farmer and property developer there is definitely room for improvement.
Less regulators might help
Yep, can always improve. Positive attitudes a must!
And deregulation increases chances of corruption
If your a government worker who's had a cruzy ride for years, nice bonus, inflation adjusted salary increase, not really needed.....you'll be shivering with fear after hearing this
Good management the three of you. A lot of damage done by previous incompetent mob.
By far the smartest person in government
What a huge breath of fresh air Sir! Thank heavens the country voted those reactionary ideologues out. Congratulations New Zealand. "Onwards".
@@dakkerrins6344 Your reply is reactionary. Capisce?
@@dakkerrins6344 The
@@dakkerrins6344The meaning of REACTIONARY is relating to, marked by, or favoring reaction - Webster.
What ever makes you happy. You might consider drinking more spring water, if you know my drift. FYI: Websters was nominated by my Alma Mater (both post graduate university and College) as the reference dictionary.
@@dakkerrins6344 huge draught of spring water in your case.
Thanks David you are the man
My first thought after opening this video:
"Holy shit! The comments are on!"
Like 1News, first time I've seen Comments open to discussion, strange, how long has that been going on? Interesting tho'.
I'm always impressed by David Seymours pronunciation of Te Reo.
I agree, it's beautiful to listen to compared to Luxon haha.
It's the only reason why I voted for David to be honest 😅
@@Rrrr-pz3dxI heard he is part Māori but regardless, love the effort he makes to pronounce words properly 😊
he is part maori, but which part i am not sure
@@Jesssssss93Pretty fluent too I believe.
With regard to animal treatments, legislation that alternated quite different compounds for a specific pest each two years and a breeding program that breed male pests with no exposure or resistance to treatments might help one industry in particular.
Then after treatment a number of males could be introduced to dilute the residual pests resistance selection.
Good questions and explanations
Jack was pretty tame here. No pun intended. The pattern of this show seems to be sitting government, pass; opposition, rip in.
Yeap, Jack is an old fashion leftie who loves vaccines and lockdowns!
Yes, all these policies definitely not Jack's cuppa tea 😂😂
He wasn't smirky smart arse now
Wait...do you guys think Jack writes his own questions?
Jack aligned with Nats n act before election l❤😂😂
Amazing how comments are now allowed!
Good interview
Good questions
Good answers
David once again showed his good character, and the jumped up jack's tone and arrogance has somewhat scaled - down in this interview.
Excellent, about time
Jack interrupted as soon as as it looked like Jacinda might be criticised.🙄
I have high hopes David and this government are going to sort things out for us all.
Lets never forget how backwards our country went under Labour and co
With an immigration off 200.000 per year under a skills shortage how can you justify staff cutbacks with better services which is a clear contradiction statement.The labour prime minister is correct saying the coalition agreement has many contradictions and the biggest contradiction was making the cost of living cheaper by letting foreigners back in to purchase expensive realestate on a 15% tax which will inflate house prices making them even more overpriced. Can you comment on how the cost of living will be cheaper by overpriced property values your comments are welcome GOOD OR BAD
Great point!
This is the real reason where going backward, the sell out epmherisl over tangabile.
The poor half are being sold out and don't get told hard truths about education.
Well done David. Score David 10 Jack 0 and this I predict will continue against our woke MSM.
I can't believe comment sections are open again on NZ politics.
Go David 👍
Looking forward with positivity to the next three years I recall Like Mr Luxon , Ardern also said post the Labour election victory labour would govern for all NZers so hope my positivity is not a fantasy
It is a fancy. It will be business as usual as nothing much will change, Already the new Minister of Finance has put her foot in it, with her comment about repealing the ban on tobacco sales so excise tax on tobacco to pay for some of the tax cuts where 1.4 million house holds will get a tax cut on average of $15.00 per week, social and health costs will increase, increase criminal activity and ongoing ram raids.
Common Sense to prevail !! Giving NZers hope again for the people and our country.
REFRESHING - HASN'T CHANGED WHEN VOTED IN. GOOD TO SEE, HE IS HONEST & NOT A LIAR.
Hang on the 15000 public service jobs cuts that were "vital to get things in order" are now "at most" 10000 and given David's talk that number will fall way down to becoming insignificant over all.
Yeah. He told you day one he's a fascist. And you are supporting fascists
@@humanwithaplaylist "Everything I do not like is fascism."
Predictable and very reflective of our education system.
hopefully the tv news channels will change their " paid by labour " hard left woke stance and deliver the news in a truthful balanced way, also get rid of the girly boys and activists from the channels in favour of normal journalists.
What bs
that’s total bs, news hub is propagandically reported by act supporters and right wing supporters, using words towards act and nat to make them sound nice whereas te pati maori and greens are always talked about negatively in their segments
@@girowinters is that it ? the best you can do ?
@@speeddemon9555I thought it worthy of the gold medal.
i love that some people's idea of normal journalism and journalists isn't being critical of both sides, its' just being critical of those on the left and having yes men journalists for the right. Touch of irony there. And don't even try to say they weren't critical of the last government cause you know very well they were.
A fit and proper person won't work, I know someone who went to prison and deal in drugs and got a fit and proper person, so a bit of a joke
Your comment makes no sense.
interesting to see that the comments section is now open on the NZ news sites youtubes now that we have a center left government, weren't allowed when the far left were in....
💯
Labour is right wing you chucklefuck
More free speech. Good!!👍
Wait... you think this new govt is centre left and Labour are "far left"???@@mattyfras123
Freedom of speech on!!!
Mate the Food Stuff Market Industry definitely needs Regulations implemented asap, Price of food these days are absolutely Ridiculous
David Seymour is a rock star and know’s his stuff, shame about the silly interviewer…..
Sorry I can't watch Jack Tame. Too smarmy.
great interview.
That is the most amount of sanity and sound reasoning spoken by any NZ politician I've heard in decades. Bravo David!
Go on David!
You are supporting fascists wtf is wrong with you
@@humanwithaplaylist You do not know the meaning of the words you use.
a breathe of fresh air......well done and lets get back to working utilizing common sense!!!
What common sense.
Common sense, meaning funding tax cuts by increasing access to cigarettes, giving more power to landlords and the rich. Cool story bro.
Peters should not hold any port folders at all. He can not be trusted. Kiwi
What a breath of fresh air for a change.
The experts for the treaty have done the work so go and ask them Seymour if you need to know anything instead of trying to change things,
What experts? I work in science and experts can't agree on anything. Why should they decide, we live in a democracy not a dictatorship. If they decide NZ is some wierd racial purity state, where if you happen to have a certain percentage of genes from one group then you get better treatment (just because their ancestors got here a few hundred years earlier). I think many people won't want to live here anymore.
Finally the wokes are out and the three wise men are in.
Yes, our side are just appeasing you liberals mate. @@costomame3895
I give it six months or even less before all the advocates for this government are back in this thread complaining about how crap a job they're doing
Only the wokes will be complaining. Get ready for three terms of common sense.@@user-wt4ie6iu6p
Sounds good. Time will tell.
Lets get nz working! :D
Doing what exactly as David gave no hint of any actual plans that create jobs.
Get working on what?
@@jackohere1878 providing conditions that encourage businesses to grow and therefore employ additional staff. Basically, get the government out of small, medium and large businesses way.
@@chrismckellar9350off the dol
His problem will be with government bureaucrats, not so much with politicians
David’s paymasters have a list of regulations he needs to cut
Profit before people
Smooth talking
Get them david
Reduce civil service broadcasting.
The adults are back.
This government is going to be fantastic
hahahahaha
Go David
Very smart and pragmatic guy…he will do a good job😉👍
He is all talk theoretical political technocratic with no practical experiences in governance.
Why don't you just give Phamac more money
Removing regulation leads to things like Pike River. Industry won’t self regulate as a whole and will eventually end in disaster. Public service in general is cost effective and the substantial cuts to budgets will lead to reduced services not efficiency.
I really hope people give David a chance regardless of their feelings on what are clearly emotive topics. My hope is that we can all become one people in NZ and move forward.
We had excellent race relations prior to the Tribunal which was the worst decision ever made
Many Thanks Jack
Left lane Tame needs to be careful. He's not completely stupid. Needs to keep his snout in the trough.
The Treaty is between Maori and the Crown not between what David wants it to be. He calls maoris ideas racism he should look at his own views. Yes he's wants to change the meaning of the treaty to suit his Pakeha side and trying to fool maori that what he is wanting to achieve is a good thing, guarantee it won't be for Maori. Who is he trying to fool? He keeps saying everyone should be one but really he's saying in a naive way I want to do this to benefit Pakeha. He couldn't give a toss about Maoris. The Maori and Pakeha experts for the treaty are the ones to listen to not this idiot and his select sub committee process which guarantee will be majority Pakeha voting who aren't even experts in this area with maybe one or two brainwashed Maoris. Leave it to the experts Seymour because you're certainly not one in this area.
Jack was a very good boy in this one. Now go put dads suit back on the hanger n go back to eating sand in the sandpit.
😂
The fisharys need inovation and care not noises and stagnet methods.
Thank goodness the woke nonsense seems to have been sent a message by the majority of Kiwis. Seymour has the right attitude to take us forward. Jack he is too smart for your tricky crap.
"Lobbying in its own right is not a bad thing" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Just look at the mess in the USA
The Treaty is between the Crown and Maori. The public were never involved in the signing back in 1840 and shouldn’t be involved now full stop. The principles were defined and established by the Waitangi Tribunal in the 80s and are well-known.
AE Pono.dont mean every one eals from other countries.that seymour is trying to say. He's a colonial racist idiot like that KUPAPÀ shane jones.
25% maori in the Crown Parliament but you believe they're seperate? Maori did nothing to be seperate if they did their areas of land would have been populated with towns.
@@StGammon77 not exactly sure what your point is mate. Articulate it a bit better and then come back to me
I honestly learn something valuable just about every time I watch David. To those that blindly hate him. Please consider if it’s his intention to harm you/your life or institution. I would genuinely believe he would be more than willing to discuss with someone who takes issue with his policy. He comes from a profession that dealt with using critical thinking, and it feels like he is leveraging that ability as a politician as apposed to behaving like a salesman like jacinda/marama/Winston/rawiri.
Agreeing with Seymours views on the Treaty is a confession of profound ignorance. His referendum is absolute nonsense. Politicians can pass law, but it is up to judges and courts to interpret it. You can't keep the Treay in place but take away the judicial systems ability interpret it. The whole thing is just a way for him to dog whistle the ignorant masses.
He's trying to make our society more productive thus we all benefit
So glad Seymour has this new role.
The interviewer makes his personal agenda a little too evident.
Sooooo eroding workers rights??? This ideas that NZ and New Zealanders arent productive is ridiculous!!! What industries exactly is he referring too??
Local government for one…..
Unproductive maybe but also a different argument… also not exactly an industry and not what Seymour’s signalling here I imagine!?
@@xanderthurteen he is indeed signalling that. In fact, it is a stated objective of the three part agreement.
You do not think that local government affects industrial productivity?
Banking, electricity generation, manufacturing……. law enforcement, education….everything that needs and are regulated… now you know.
Unproductive, have a look at faulton hogan on the roads and tell me they’re productive, bleeding the system dry.
@@briankemp2116 cones, cones, cones….
3 waters is coming back when they check the pipes and budgets, just another approach attacking burocrocy.
Slips and storms will be an iratant to idealist.
What is anti Maori about these proposed Principles!!
* The New Zealand Government has the right to govern all New Zealanders
* The New Zealand Government will honour all New Zealanders in the chieftainship of their land and all their property
* All New Zealanders are equal under the law with the same rights and duties
The above seems very reasonable given that the Treaty says we are one nation
No Māori in writing
Yeh it's very generic not sure why McMurries are concerned they seem to label everyone who doesn't want to conform to their jubberish as racist.
His tie highlights him as a 🤡