Why France is on its Fifth Republic

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 сер 2020
  • France is on its fifth republic. That's a lot of republics since 1789, but the reason they're on republic number 5 is perhaps the most interesting.
    Project France playlist: • Project France
    ➤ Support this channel with my Patreon!: / emperortigerstar

КОМЕНТАРІ • 565

  • @EmperorTigerstar
    @EmperorTigerstar  3 роки тому +174

    Be sure to check out the other people who contributed to Project France. The playlist is in the description. I also uploaded another video yesterday so be sure to check that out too!

  • @athingwhichexists
    @athingwhichexists 3 роки тому +367

    *Frances African Colonies:* We want independence!
    *France:* are you sure?
    *Frances African Colonies:* Yes!
    *Gabon:* Actually I kind of want to sta-
    *France:* Ok you can ALL have your independence. Especially Gabon.

    • @zerefsunlimitedshipworks
      @zerefsunlimitedshipworks 3 роки тому +16

      *YANDERE GABON YANDERE GABON*

    • @jmr1090
      @jmr1090 3 роки тому +8

      I think the "close" relationship France has with her former colonies, especially Gabon, is known as Francafrique

    • @gutsjoestar7450
      @gutsjoestar7450 3 роки тому +3

      i am French, and i support colonialism only when it's profitable
      West Africa, was too poor and too unproftable and ruined France
      but about Vietnam and French Indo-China and Algeria
      they should've been kept
      but native didn't think so

    • @gutsjoestar7450
      @gutsjoestar7450 3 роки тому +1

      @@Soviet00000 your name is soviet, and you got anarchy logo
      don't talk to me,
      everyone has a plan until they get punched int he face
      if you wanna settle this, let's meet in a MMA arena

  • @Etrune
    @Etrune 3 роки тому +571

    It should be noted that during the last presidential elections, several candidates proposed a 6th republic.

    • @Alfonso162008
      @Alfonso162008 3 роки тому +24

      What would be the difference between the two? What would make a change a new Republic instead of a new Constitution, for example?

    • @jakubegermajer9841
      @jakubegermajer9841 3 роки тому +101

      @@Alfonso162008 Benoit Hamon and Jean-Luc Mélenchon both proposed a "6th Republic" with a more parliamentary system and a less powerful presidency. Something like a compromise between the 4th and 5th republics - similar to Germany perhaps, a parliamentary democracy but with a strong executive (the Chancellor and his cabinet) responsible before the parliament.

    • @Alfonso162008
      @Alfonso162008 3 роки тому +14

      @@jakubegermajer9841 why would that constitute a 6th Republic instead of a change in the Constitution? Why the need to call that an "nth Republic"?

    • @luc-zq7ku
      @luc-zq7ku 3 роки тому +71

      @@Alfonso162008 We can amend the constitution . It have been done numerous time during the 5th republic . But any mahor change, like a change in the balance of power would result in a new one .
      It's the french administration "why do simple when you can do it complicated" it's our slogan .

    • @jakubegermajer9841
      @jakubegermajer9841 3 роки тому +41

      @@Alfonso162008 Well such a substantial change could hardly be achieved by simply amending or revising the current constitution. And in France a new constitution means a new republic.
      edit: Also it's quite catchy as a campaign slogan, as it promises a substantial and permanent political change.

  • @coolkib12345
    @coolkib12345 3 роки тому +429

    France to his African colonies: Guys please don’t leave!
    Gabon: OK I’ll stay!
    France: never mind you guys can leave!
    Gabon: ):

    • @jmr1090
      @jmr1090 3 роки тому +8

      It's crazy to think the countries that made up French West & Equatorial Africa are still paying France.

    • @plumebrisee6206
      @plumebrisee6206 3 роки тому +13

      @@jmr1090 Look like this Myth is still alive while it has a lot of proof it's fake .

    • @plumebrisee6206
      @plumebrisee6206 3 роки тому +7

      Gabon literally wanted to be annexed by France ,CDG said no ,and when they had to choose a flag for the country ,they wanted to add a little French flag in it (Like Australia/New Zealand flags have a UK flag in it) ans CDG still said no.

    • @jmr1090
      @jmr1090 3 роки тому +5

      @@plumebrisee6206 What do you mean? I've read how the West & Central African Francs at least a portion of those still go to the French treasury. I'm not looking for a fight I'm just curious?

    • @tern7913
      @tern7913 3 роки тому +2

      Gabon are the most loyal colonies

  • @marcello7781
    @marcello7781 3 роки тому +259

    France: no country changes their government like I do
    Latin American random country: hold my cerveza.

    • @compatriot852
      @compatriot852 3 роки тому +19

      Also France: colonizes and interferes in Latin America for money.
      Pastry war.....

    • @Guanaco17
      @Guanaco17 3 роки тому +2

      El Salvador had 5 goverment Changes in the 20th century.

    • @procyon6370
      @procyon6370 3 роки тому +20

      Hold my American intervention

    • @jeffersonclippership2588
      @jeffersonclippership2588 3 роки тому +4

      Not really the same. Sadly, Latin America has only ever had presidential republics with a couple random monarchies (Mexico and Brazil).

    • @kingdomofbird8174
      @kingdomofbird8174 3 роки тому +7

      Brazil has actually six Republics in few time

  • @Spongebrain97
    @Spongebrain97 3 роки тому +327

    Remember in Spiderman Homecoming when that teacher comments on a captain america video saying "im pretty sure that guy is a war criminal now"? Thats what happened to French school kids in the 50s when talking about Philippe Petain

    • @Cancoillotteman
      @Cancoillotteman 3 роки тому +12

      Well without the admiration. A huge bunch of the population called for his head on a spike, but Petain was actually graced and under house arrest until the end of his life. Graced by De Gaulle himself, after all until 1934 (not sure at one year close) the two were pretty good friends. They started an argument about the kind of reforms the army needed and who between Germany and communism was the biggest threat. The rest is history

    • @Compucles
      @Compucles 2 роки тому +4

      @@Cancoillotteman So like the friendship between Dumbledore and Grindelwald in the "Harry Potter" franchise?

    • @Kerys23a
      @Kerys23a 2 роки тому +2

      @@Compucles Read another book.

    • @jeffreygao3956
      @jeffreygao3956 Рік тому +2

      @@Kerys23a OK! I got American Revolution: Battles and Leaders.

  • @AverytheCubanAmerican
    @AverytheCubanAmerican 3 роки тому +166

    Don't mind me, I'm just waiting for the 69th Republic. The nice one

    • @james_baker
      @james_baker 3 роки тому +5

      It will probably just eat it's self

    • @malthevlds9667
      @malthevlds9667 3 роки тому +5

      420th

    • @jeandarwin9143
      @jeandarwin9143 3 роки тому +11

      Unironically, France has a strong movement for a 6th republic

    • @cjthegood
      @cjthegood 3 роки тому +1

      You mean the EPIC ONE?😁

    • @Titi-lq1tj
      @Titi-lq1tj 3 роки тому

      When it's the 69th we all need to go to nice at France

  • @ash9280
    @ash9280 3 роки тому +43

    France: ''This is isn't even the final form of our government yet.''

  • @maxbuster1508
    @maxbuster1508 3 роки тому +213

    History Matters viewers : Hey! I've seen this one!

    • @TheLocalLt
      @TheLocalLt 3 роки тому +8

      Yeah but history matters messed up by saying that the state is officially known as the “fifth French Republic” which isn’t true, it’s colloquially known by that name but officially simply the “French Republic”, just like the previous 4 except for when the 3rd republic became fascist and renamed itself the “French State”

    • @maxbuster1508
      @maxbuster1508 3 роки тому +12

      @@TheLocalLt While true that "Fifth French Republic" isn't the real official name of France today, "Fifth republic" and "French republic" are.
      Aka it's a small nitpick.

    • @TheLocalLt
      @TheLocalLt 3 роки тому +5

      MaxBuster interesting, I wasn’t aware that even “fifth republic” was used in any official context. But I did find the term on the French Republic website so it appears it’s true www.gouvernement.fr/en/how-government-works

    • @adi_drawshd4904
      @adi_drawshd4904 3 роки тому +1

      "True."

    • @d3thkn1ghtmcgee74
      @d3thkn1ghtmcgee74 3 роки тому

      History House Production viewers watch History matters: Hey I seen this! 😂

  • @Scenariania
    @Scenariania 3 роки тому +163

    Time travellers from the past: how many republics does France have: yes

    • @mohdadeeb1829
      @mohdadeeb1829 3 роки тому +4

      Dude you are becoming a comment star , I am seeing you everywhere .

    • @TheSkeletonjelly
      @TheSkeletonjelly 3 роки тому +4

      This is a Keanu chungus wholesome 100 breathtaking 100 moment

    • @Scenariania
      @Scenariania 3 роки тому +3

      @@mohdadeeb1829 hey there! I just have a very random video reccomender all the time, so I'm a yt wizard

    • @Scenariania
      @Scenariania 3 роки тому

      @um mapping lmfao how
      next up ill be on the other side and you'll still fina way to get to me

  • @ThisisBarris
    @ThisisBarris 3 роки тому +87

    Both of my great uncles actually took part in the Algerian war of independence. Brutal war apparently. I should do a video about it one day. Great video Tigerstar. Merde!

    • @hegoney5841
      @hegoney5841 3 роки тому +11

      War against terrorists is always brutal.

    • @dr.vikyll7466
      @dr.vikyll7466 3 роки тому +18

      @@hegoney5841 Says the person from the country which started a war which killed millions in the early 1800s

    • @hegoney5841
      @hegoney5841 3 роки тому +12

      @@dr.vikyll7466 I'm not British.

    • @jeffersonclippership2588
      @jeffersonclippership2588 3 роки тому +10

      @@hegoney5841 that's a weird way to spell freedom fighters

    • @hegoney5841
      @hegoney5841 3 роки тому +7

      @@jeffersonclippership2588 Well, and how do you spell arabs who fought for the french democracy? Algeria isn't a free country still today... Many islamists in those rebels... Things are not so easy.

  • @hughg8995
    @hughg8995 3 роки тому +119

    Every other nation: Well we had a revolution, time to enjoy a period of stability for the next few centuries
    France: *_GAS GAS GAS_*

    • @compatriot852
      @compatriot852 3 роки тому +8

      Speed running before it was cool

    • @QuizmasterLaw
      @QuizmasterLaw 3 роки тому +3

      You clearly have not read up on German Italian or most any other European countries constitution. Most all of them run through them like toilet paper.

    • @sovietmuffin501
      @sovietmuffin501 3 роки тому +1

      Ann Onymous Germany hasn’t fallen from its own revolutions though. The German empire was only replaced by the entente, and nazi Germany was replaced by the allies. Their only real revolution is the rise of the Nazis
      As for italy, they haven’t had a single revolution. Mussolini was appointed prime minister and then consolidated power. Then, he was replaced during wwii by the king, who appointed a different prime minister.
      Meanwhile France has had at least four revolutions of its own people replacing their own government violently

    • @QuizmasterLaw
      @QuizmasterLaw 3 роки тому +1

      @@sovietmuffin501 you sorta had me up to 4 revolutions, that's just bullshit. My point was all these countries ran through constittions like toilet paper for similar and related reasons and that none of them are particularly unique. Vichy was the lawful government and was fascist. Germany had plenty of revolutionary activity, so did Italy (benny got his start as a marxis then flipped). You want to act like fascist regimes are hum drum normal no biggie when in fact they are the monopolization of power in a dictatorship and the erasure of hte public private distinction.
      Four revolutions lol in ur imagination maybe.

    • @cpp3221
      @cpp3221 3 роки тому +5

      @@QuizmasterLaw Nope, that's not a joke, as a French I garantuee that he tell the truth. In France we had:
      -1789 revolution
      -the revolution of 1830
      -the revolution of 1848
      -The "Commune de Paris" (1871).
      Yeah, four revolution.
      And I didn't count all the coup and the less famous insurection.
      Like:
      -Two failed attempt of Napoleon the third to restore the Empire and one succesfull
      -The insurection of the worker under the IInd republic
      -The "100 jour" (return in 1815 of Napoleon the first before Waterloo.
      France wasn't very calm during the XIXth century

  • @aerohydreigon1101
    @aerohydreigon1101 3 роки тому +58

    France: *has 5 republics*
    Sixth Republic of Korea: *_Are you challenging me?_*

    • @sunjasonjb2773
      @sunjasonjb2773 3 роки тому

      Lmao I was just thinking the same thing

    • @elbentos7803
      @elbentos7803 3 роки тому +8

      Add to the 5 republics (in chronologic disorder) :
      - one "État français" (Vichy),
      - two empires (Napoléon I and III),
      - one ancient régime (before 1790),
      - one chartiste monarchy (1814 and 1815-1830),
      - one constitutionnal monarchy (1830-1848),
      - one "gouvernement de défense nationale",
      - one "gouvernement provisoire" (1871 and 1944-1946), as well as
      - Paris commune (1871)...

    • @candyneige6609
      @candyneige6609 3 роки тому +3

      Spain : I had 3 republics.
      France : Well, i had 5 republics.
      South Korea : Amateurs !
      France : What was that, punk ?
      South Korea : *Amateurs !*

    • @Polavianus
      @Polavianus 5 місяців тому

      ​@@candyneige6609 I look up and now
      Spain only have two republics
      Currently, Spain is a constitution monarchy
      P.S: Unless if you are counting Franconist Spain as a Third Republic

    • @candyneige6609
      @candyneige6609 5 місяців тому

      @@Polavianus A constitutional monarchy is a de facto republic because in a constitutional monarchy, the title of "King" (or "Emperor" or whatever) is an elected position, where the people gets to vote on who becomes the King (or Emperor or whatever), and not only that, their term as King (or Emperor or whatever) usually only lasts a few years before new elections are held (though the rules of re-election differ by country). By contrast, in an absolute monarchy, the title of "King" (or "Emperor" or whatever) is a hereditary position, leading to power being held by a single family, known as the royal family, and in addition, when a member of that family becomes King (or Emperor or whatever), they get to keep that title for life, in other words, they get to remain King (or Emperor or whatever) until they die, in which case, the title usually passes on to their eldest son (though the exact rules of succession differ by country).
      Going back to Spain, we know that the country is currently a constitutional monarchy, and therefore a de facto republic, meaning that, counting de facto republics, Spain is currently on its Third Republic
      Actually, the United Kingdom, despite its name would tell you, is also currently a republic, albeit a de facto one, since it's currently a constitutional monarchy, and therefore a de facto republic, meaning that, when counting de facto republics, the United Kingdom is currently on its Second Republic, since it already had its First Republic, known as the Commonwealth of Great Britain.
      By contrast, Saudi Arabia is an absolute monarchy, and therefore not a de facto republic, since their title of "King" is hereditary and is therefore passed down through inheritance, and the current King of Saudi Arabia, Salman, is the son of Ibn Saud, who was once King of Saudi Arabia until his death, in 1953.

  • @memoris3038
    @memoris3038 3 роки тому +266

    The very existence of Project France itself makes me happy for being a baguette.

    • @luc-zq7ku
      @luc-zq7ku 3 роки тому +25

      Hey, baguette brother .

    • @chiangkaishrek5123
      @chiangkaishrek5123 3 роки тому +16

      *Angry British noises*

    • @coulochonou6376
      @coulochonou6376 3 роки тому +7

      @@ggkproductions1632 shut up why do you always have to go against French people like that

    • @memoris3038
      @memoris3038 3 роки тому +13

      @@ggkproductions1632 I mean, I can surrender to the fact that France was the most victorious country in world history. >w>

    • @chiangkaishrek5123
      @chiangkaishrek5123 3 роки тому +4

      Memoris Surrendering even in victory that really do be a France moment

  • @cjthegood
    @cjthegood 3 роки тому +30

    The Philippines 🇵🇭 is also in its Fifth Republic 😁
    • 1st Republic - 1898-1902 (declaration of independence from Spain to the American occupation)
    {American occupation and Commonwealth - 1898-1942, 1944-1946}
    • 2nd Republic - 1943-1945 (Japanese puppet government)
    • 3rd Republic - 1946-1973 (post-WW2 to Martial Law)
    • 4th Republic - 1973-1986 (Martial Law to 1st EDSA Revolution)
    {Provisional or Revolutionary government/"Freedom Constitution" - 1986-1987}
    • 5th Republic - 1987 (adoption of the new Constitution) to present

    • @alezacrespublik6655
      @alezacrespublik6655 3 роки тому +4

      I guess we'll have 7th republics before the end of the century

    • @candyneige6609
      @candyneige6609 3 роки тому +1

      Dude, Spain is on it's 3rd republic.

    • @jeffreygao3956
      @jeffreygao3956 Рік тому +2

      @@candyneige6609 ...Nope! It's a kingdom!

    • @candyneige6609
      @candyneige6609 Рік тому +1

      @@jeffreygao3956 A "kingdom" that is actually a republic that is, because Spain is actually a crowned republic, where it behaves as expected from a usual republic, except that there's a king, so Spain is indeed on it's 3rd Republic, just that this particular republic is crowned.

    • @Polavianus
      @Polavianus 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@candyneige6609 No?
      Republics are types of government that don't have a monarchy as a head of state

  • @waldek323PL
    @waldek323PL 3 роки тому +15

    History of France, every month but each time a Louis is crowned it get's faster.

  • @age3801
    @age3801 3 роки тому +89

    So de Gaulle was the last president of the 4th french republic and the first president of the 5th republic ?

    • @nicolas.p331
      @nicolas.p331 3 роки тому +58

      Not exactly, he was the last prime minister (président du conseil) of the fourth Republic and indeed the first president of the fifth Republic.

    • @jakubegermajer9841
      @jakubegermajer9841 3 роки тому +23

      René Coty was the president until January 1959, so technically he was the last president of the 4th republic and the first one of the 5th, but nobody really cares about René Coty.

    • @memoris3038
      @memoris3038 3 роки тому +30

      @@jakubegermajer9841 Except Hubert Bonisseur de La Bath.

    • @jakubegermajer9841
      @jakubegermajer9841 3 роки тому +2

      @@memoris3038

    • @TheLocalLt
      @TheLocalLt 3 роки тому +3

      Yeah he was effectively given dictatorial powers to figure out the Algeria crisis and change the constitution

  • @QuestionEverythingButWHY
    @QuestionEverythingButWHY 3 роки тому +54

    "Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power."
    -Abraham Lincoln

    • @marinerproductions1315
      @marinerproductions1315 3 роки тому +5

      @33 SixtyNine, he was leading his country into fighting a civil war, obviously some things need to be done that would be considered "radical."

    • @marinerproductions1315
      @marinerproductions1315 3 роки тому +1

      @33 SixtyNine, okay, I will admit, that is true.

    • @Vitorruy1
      @Vitorruy1 3 роки тому

      True

  • @himlingpatrice
    @himlingpatrice 3 роки тому +32

    The most interesting is the fact that the 5th Republic has changed completely since 1958. Without changing the number of the constitution.
    In 1958, the president was elected by a college of grand electors (mayors and other elected officials) since 1962, the president is elected by the people.
    In the 1958 version, there was a balance of power between the President and the Prime Minister. After 1962, the regime had clearly become "semi-presidential".
    In 1958 the President was elected for 7 years and the assembly for 5. Since 2000 the President is elected for 5 years.
    Before, a President could face an opposition parliamentary majority (this happened between 1986 and 1988 then between 1993 and 1995 and finally between 1997 and 2002) he then had virtually no power (except in the area of diplomacy).
    Since 2000, the President is elected in may and the assembly is elected a month later. Those who voted for the President give him a majority.
    To sum up, in 1958, the Fifth Republic was a parliamentary system with a President elected by a college of grand electors. The President worked with a Prime Minister responsible to the assembly.
    Since 2000; 5th Republic is, de facto, a Presidential regime with a Prime Minister who is nothing more than a "chief of staff" of the President.

    • @candyneige6609
      @candyneige6609 3 роки тому

      While France is a presidential republic, it's neighbours went the other direction of being a parliamentary republic where the head of state is just a simple figurehead and a sepreate head of government actually has all the powers, Switzerland is the odd one out where it has a system that doesn't fit into any category of republics.

  • @mix3k818
    @mix3k818 3 роки тому +36

    Will you do "why Poland is on its Third Republic"?
    Or is it too short to explain in a separate video?

    • @luc-zq7ku
      @luc-zq7ku 3 роки тому +6

      well, how long do it take you to say neighbor ?

    • @RoNPlayer
      @RoNPlayer 3 роки тому +3

      I think the interesting thing in this video was mostly the transition to fourth to fifth, because it happened post WW2 through a coup-attempt. I think polands transitions are more obvious...

    • @Artur_M.
      @Artur_M. 3 роки тому +6

      This is actually a very good question that requires a bit of explaining and is worthy of a video, especially when you realize that we do count the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth as the first of these three and don't count the Polish People's Republic.
      The regular modern word in Polish for "republic" is _republika_ but the Polish Republic is Rzeczpospolita Polska. Rzeczpospolita is a direct translation of the Latin term Res publica, used by the old Polish-Lithuanian state to refer to itself. It gets translated to English as "Commonwealth" in this context because calling a polity made out of a union of a Kingdom and a Grand Duchy and still having a monarch (even if elected) as its head a "republic" would be an oxymoron in any normal country. ;)
      Due to the gradual Polonisation of Lithuanian elites (multiethnic to begin with) the old Commonwealth (Rzeczpospolita) was by the end of its existence often referred to as Polish, or simply Poland even in some legal documents including the 1791 Constitution, even though the separation between its constituent parts; the Crown of the Polish Kingdom (usually just called the Crown) and the Grand Duchy of Lithuania was technically kept. When an independent Polish state was reestablished in 1918 it viewed itself as the sole and direct successor of the old Rzeczpospolita, calling itself the Second Polish Republic (Rzeczpospolita Polska).
      BTW the words Rzeczpospolita and Republika traditionally were used interchangeably for the other republics (like the Roman or Venetian) but now Rzeczpospolita refers exclusively to the Polish one.

    • @Artur_M.
      @Artur_M. 3 роки тому +5

      Regarding the Polish People's Republic (Polska Rzeczpospolita Ludowa), we came to the conclusion that it was a stinky communist, Soviet puppet-state that didn't really deserve its name and therefore doesn't count.

    • @marinerproductions1315
      @marinerproductions1315 3 роки тому +3

      @@Artur_M., damn, son. That was a neat story.

  • @CivilWarWeekByWeek
    @CivilWarWeekByWeek 3 роки тому +10

    France is like fashion it changes every 5 minutes and no one really understands it.

  • @mork7315
    @mork7315 3 роки тому +3

    Small correction at 3:53. Operation Corse was the takeover of Corsica, the planned seizure of the mainland was called Operation Resurrection

  • @GlobalHistoryHispano
    @GlobalHistoryHispano 3 роки тому

    Excellent video!

  • @JagerLange
    @JagerLange 3 роки тому +2

    I saw yesterday's Canadian video and thought "huh, no mention of Project France, must be coincidence". Turns out you are involved with it after all :D

  • @mathieuleader8601
    @mathieuleader8601 3 роки тому +7

    France is like the time lord answer to countries with many incarnations

  • @andrewaslakson5220
    @andrewaslakson5220 3 роки тому +37

    History matters literally just made the same video.

  • @comradeofthebalance3147
    @comradeofthebalance3147 3 роки тому

    Your video is more in depth in the transition between the Fourth and Fifth Republic than History Matters which is limited to quick videos.

  • @edgelord8337
    @edgelord8337 3 роки тому +43

    France:
    *gets rid of monarchy*
    *gives liberties and freedom to the people*
    *installs monarchy*
    *gets rid of freedoms*
    *gets rid of monarchy*
    *gives freedom*
    That's Frances history in a nutshell
    Also some decolonization
    and GERMANY

    • @Jim63071
      @Jim63071 3 роки тому +5

      If you think Revolutionary France gave anybody freedom, you're naive beyond measure.

    • @jeandarwin9143
      @jeandarwin9143 3 роки тому +4

      @@Jim63071 they literally emancipated everyone legally and gave them equality

    • @Jim63071
      @Jim63071 3 роки тому +3

      @@jeandarwin9143 And then starved and guillotined thousands, seized the gold of countless more and converted it into assignats, abolished property rights, destroyed churches, exterminated the population of entire regions (the Vendée), and had a secret police apparatus govern the state (Committee for Public Safety). Oh, and they imposed CONSCRIPTION for the first time in French history. Did you know that they did not have universal suffrage? The only people who were emancipated by the Revolution were a bunch of Nobles and bourgeois, who were always fighting with the King for power anyway. It's their history you've learned, which is why you're so ignorant. But hey, a piece of paper said everyone was equal, so it must have been a good thing, right?

    • @pretzelstick320
      @pretzelstick320 3 роки тому +4

      Kerberos it was still better than the monarchs reign, as there was already starving going on. The first revolution was a rough start but ensured greater freedom in the future, and in the 1850s, this was achieved with the spirit of the French people and inspired by the first republic’s promises.

    • @sonyvegas9838
      @sonyvegas9838 3 роки тому

      @@Jim63071 when he said it gave people liberties, he didn't went on the matter about if they were truly implemented or not

  • @kreeperface397
    @kreeperface397 3 роки тому +5

    What do you meant when you said "Independance = losing french assistance" ? France stopped supporting countries which gained their independance with a war such as Algeria and Vietnam, or unilaterally declared independance, like Guinea. But the other countries stayed under heavy french influence for several decades. Even today France still have a special influence on most of its former african colonies (but this influence is collapsing in favor of other neo colonial power such as China)

    • @firecreeper2249
      @firecreeper2249 3 роки тому

      official assistance, I'm pretty sure they didn't know france was gonna keep meddling into their affairs after independance and it's not like its wrong anyways since the aid money that france is giving isn't comparable to their work on their actual oversea territories. also you're confusing assistance and influence.

  • @mohdadeeb1829
    @mohdadeeb1829 3 роки тому +5

    France went from
    A Monarchy to a Republic to Dictatorship to a Republic again to Monarchy again to a Dictatorship again to a restored Monarchy to a Republic but Napoleon 3 felt cocky and brought back Monarchy then lost a war against Germany and went Republic again in just 90 years .

    • @liaml.e.5964
      @liaml.e.5964 3 роки тому +2

      Well, they are persistent, if anything...

  • @Scenariania
    @Scenariania 3 роки тому +5

    South Korea: Finally! A worthy opponent! Our battle will be legendary.

  • @jaojao1768
    @jaojao1768 3 роки тому

    Useful explanation

  • @josephjacquescesairejoffre70
    @josephjacquescesairejoffre70 3 роки тому

    Yay finally a new video

  • @TheGreatCooLite
    @TheGreatCooLite 3 роки тому +5

    I was just looking at the wikipedia page for the French fifth republic

  • @QuestionEverythingButWHY
    @QuestionEverythingButWHY 3 роки тому +42

    “History is a set of lies agreed upon.”
    ― Napoleon Bonaparte

    • @kreeperface397
      @kreeperface397 3 роки тому +2

      Probably one the dumbest thing he said tbh

    • @chiangkaishrek5123
      @chiangkaishrek5123 3 роки тому

      France noob

    • @LZin-uk5nh
      @LZin-uk5nh 3 роки тому

      @Sugarz so with this logic, in order to confirm that jumping off a building kills you, you should check it out on your own by jumping off a building?
      I also assume you need to check out if putting your hands on a hot stove is as sad as your parents claimed it to be. Do you see where I'm going with this?

  • @housesports000
    @housesports000 3 роки тому +9

    France is that one kid who enters a new phase every year

    • @Suite_annamite
      @Suite_annamite 3 роки тому +1

      No, because France doesn't have borderline personality disorder, more like a kind of narcissism. LOL

  • @Pablodiovisuel
    @Pablodiovisuel 3 роки тому +3

    Knowing your history through classes : ):[
    Knowing your history through french historic videos : ):[
    Knowing your history through Emperor Tigerstar's videos : :)

  • @user-es3dr5xk8f
    @user-es3dr5xk8f 3 роки тому

    Thx for new video History Matters

  • @DiamondTurtleGamer
    @DiamondTurtleGamer 3 роки тому

    Oh thank God another collaboration

  • @GregThatcher
    @GregThatcher Рік тому

    Thanks!

  • @algerianchaouki5705
    @algerianchaouki5705 3 роки тому

    A video about Algeroa would be quite nice!

  • @user-jv3mm6vt6e
    @user-jv3mm6vt6e 3 роки тому +7

    Well, the french republics have gone through more generations than your sound recording device.😂

  • @justinpachi3707
    @justinpachi3707 3 роки тому +1

    Have another Revolution of Draw 25
    France: Draws 25 cards from the deck

  • @explosivereactionstv7414
    @explosivereactionstv7414 3 роки тому +3

    Last time i was this early, Charlemagne was the emperor of The Holy Roman Empire

  • @wildanfatihg
    @wildanfatihg 3 роки тому +5

    So when will France v6.0 be released? I heard the beta version is still being tested.

    • @johnbridger1403
      @johnbridger1403 3 роки тому

      There's actually a left extremist in France that wants to create the 6th Republic, but nobody likes him so it's ok

  • @felixlandproductions4552
    @felixlandproductions4552 3 роки тому

    Nice job.

  • @dangerthomas4747
    @dangerthomas4747 3 роки тому

    Well, that was a really quick video to explain all of that. Maybe a little too short, even you must keep it short for UA-cam. Talking about the future of the V republic, after 1958, would also be cool.

  • @hilairelemoel8268
    @hilairelemoel8268 3 роки тому

    Kinda fun to hear as much about this subject in 6 minutes than in 1-2 hours in history class in French high school.

  • @Viguier89
    @Viguier89 3 роки тому +2

    Nowadays in France DeGaulles is perceived as the same ways that the Founding Fathers are seen in the USA somehow. Everyone in the political spectrum refer at him and he clearly still have positive opinion in the population (he has been idealized through the years.) There is some kind of consensus around him. I suppose only a fringe of the population openly despise him, even his former ennemies (like the LePen clan) refers themselves as "Gaullist" nowadays. (Which is a HUGE joke, because Marine LePen got her party from her father, who founded his party in opposition to DeGaulle's policies.)

    • @kreeperface397
      @kreeperface397 3 роки тому +3

      Only the far left and some part of the left don't define themselves as gaullists (maybe some parts of the far right but that's marginal)

    • @kreeperface397
      @kreeperface397 3 роки тому

      @Sugarz Oh, you are refering to Bonapartism. It looks like it isn't right or left but most of the time it is right wing with some really minor aspects on left wing. Napoleon's rule for exemple was a regress on several things "won" by the revolution (and the previous Directoire wasn't really something you could define as left wing). He just kept all the symbols of the revolution such as the flag, which indeed was a left wing thing, but that's just something symbolic.
      I really thought the same thing as you, but several things made me change my mind other time. If you are francophone and don't mind to see an opposite view of yours on bonapartism and gaullism, and (maybe) challenge your opinion on it, you should watch the youtube video "ni gauche ni droite, bonapartisme et confusionisme" from "Esprit Critique" The author is left/far left but is honest about it and when something is its opinion rather than objective facts he usually says it.

    • @kreeperface397
      @kreeperface397 3 роки тому

      @Sugarz yeah, people are probably not educated enough to make a democracy such as what EC think it should work. It would need decades to reach this point, but there is probably some in between than this model of democracy and the fifth Republic...

    • @Viguier89
      @Viguier89 3 роки тому +1

      @Sugarz With our current standard Athens would not be considered a democracy and the average french is much more educated than the average Athenian of the antiquity.

    • @Viguier89
      @Viguier89 3 роки тому +1

      @Sugarz The part of the Athenian population that had access to such education was less than 1%. The part of the french population that have PHD is superior to that. In Athens only a really small part of the population had the right to vote and only a small part if that population was highly educated.

  • @buingockhoa1998
    @buingockhoa1998 3 роки тому +7

    Considering how much the French like to revolt, I kinda find it surprising that they are not on the sixth republic right now

  • @loganstill4390
    @loganstill4390 3 роки тому +1

    Is “history matters” part of project France bc this video is very similar to a video by him 3 weeks ago

  • @Kardia_of_Rhodes
    @Kardia_of_Rhodes 3 роки тому +6

    Vichy France lasted longer than the Second Republic.

  • @SonOfCar_
    @SonOfCar_ 3 роки тому

    Just found channel. TIgerstar is one hundred percent from the Warrior Series :D

  • @kuroazrem5376
    @kuroazrem5376 3 роки тому

    Finally, I understand this, thanks.

  • @gabem.5242
    @gabem.5242 3 роки тому +4

    "You know... we've sent our King in exile now and we're looking for a new Republican setup. Let's try this... Fourth French Republic but let's add also a good dash of Weimar in it, what can go wrong?"
    - Italy, June 2nd, 1946.

  • @fahoodie1852
    @fahoodie1852 3 роки тому +1

    0:45 there wasn’t a power vacuum by this point. In 1869 Napoleon III set up a parliamentary constitutional monarchy which caused the emperor to lose most of his powers. His decisions were often ignored, including increasing the army size as Prussia was strong. During the Franco Prussian war, the emperor made his wife regent and left for war, effectively ending any sort of ceremonious or legislative power he had left

    • @olidojosephd.9054
      @olidojosephd.9054 3 роки тому +1

      It would be better if he transitioned France into a constitutional monarch in 1852 instead of 1869 though.

    • @fahoodie1852
      @fahoodie1852 3 роки тому

      @@olidojosephd.9054 France would probably collapse if that was the case. He needed the dictatorial powers in the beginning to make sure the new regime remained stable for a while, and once it did he began to soften his rule. It was good until the opposition got too strong and basically dragged him wherever they wished.

  • @TheSchlunzer
    @TheSchlunzer 3 роки тому

    02:55 It bothers me so much that on the left map aren't any rivers or lakes and on the right it's difficult to find Algier.

  • @leumasecir9369
    @leumasecir9369 3 роки тому

    What's that jazzy background music?

  • @whilryke
    @whilryke 3 роки тому +2

    Making fun of how many french republics there were is all good, but you know what's even better ?
    South Korea, they had SIX republics since their post-WW2 independance.

  • @dylan_not_dillon
    @dylan_not_dillon 3 роки тому +3

    2802: Welcome to the 24th French Republic!

  • @BalekduNom
    @BalekduNom 3 роки тому

    Very very good video 👏👏👏👏 🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷

  • @DimBeam1
    @DimBeam1 3 роки тому

    4:23 Famous war hero? He didnt do anything but walk down a road.

  • @Weeljak
    @Weeljak 3 роки тому +3

    I really liked this video, and as a French, I will do my very best to make it obsolete.

  • @leninbilalexander6754
    @leninbilalexander6754 3 роки тому

    4:48 Presidents in the 3rd and 4th Republics also had 7- year terms. However, this changed to 5- year terms in 2002.

  • @IVaV1
    @IVaV1 3 роки тому

    Hey, didn't historymatters upload a video about the exact same topic a couple weeks ago?

  • @user-ji3ex6bl4o
    @user-ji3ex6bl4o 3 роки тому

    Can you do the algerian war in time line

  • @merrittanimation7721
    @merrittanimation7721 3 роки тому

    Now to see how they'll get to number six.

  • @PJTheSimple
    @PJTheSimple 3 роки тому

    Can you make a map video about the Franco-Dutch war.

  • @empirehistory7626
    @empirehistory7626 3 роки тому +1

    Today I published my first historical mapping.

  • @Waffles9255
    @Waffles9255 8 місяців тому

    You can't change my mind that EmperorTigerStar and History Matters (rip ten minute history) have made a secret collab I mean both channels made the same video in the same year.

  • @gerardonv3296
    @gerardonv3296 3 роки тому +6

    History Matters subscribers incoming

  • @tylerthecooltexan5979
    @tylerthecooltexan5979 3 роки тому

    Maybe one day you could do: Algerian War Of Independence, Every Day/Month/Hour. However long the war lasted

  • @eduardoel-haderfantini2267
    @eduardoel-haderfantini2267 3 роки тому +1

    Brazil also is on its fifth Republic.

  • @chelvo56
    @chelvo56 3 роки тому

    Nice URL,

  • @annasantiago6997
    @annasantiago6997 3 роки тому +1

    france in a nutchel, it's complicated

  • @uniuni8855
    @uniuni8855 Рік тому +5

    We're witnessing today another republic change in France, and you left a lot of details like the role of french aristocracy and rich conglomerates in these events

  • @briguy345
    @briguy345 3 роки тому +1

    Did you hear about Lichtenstein? I don't know maybe it could be bonus material for you. Their royalty wants Czech land "back" I guess

  • @jeffreygao3956
    @jeffreygao3956 2 роки тому +2

    Five republics? How quaint. South Korea has but six in the course of far fewer years.

  • @Anwwoo
    @Anwwoo 3 роки тому +1

    For some reasons, Korea also in Sixth republic somehow.

  • @baronofbahlingen9662
    @baronofbahlingen9662 3 роки тому

    Got hooked in by Atun-Shei.

  • @Compucles
    @Compucles 2 роки тому +2

    It really makes you appreciate just how well the United States did on just its second try well over 200 years ago and only needing to ammend it 27 times since then.

  • @jeffh9427
    @jeffh9427 3 роки тому

    Kind of late, but IMO the Generals Putsch of 1961 should be included as it's a pretty important event in solidifying civilian control in the 5th Republic and not military

  • @FlagAnthem
    @FlagAnthem 3 роки тому

    Italy still can't decide if the second republic is over yet

  • @uncitoyen_8614
    @uncitoyen_8614 3 роки тому

    As the Convention, the Directory and the Consulate were different regimes, we could speak about "7 republics" !

  • @Richard_is_cool
    @Richard_is_cool 3 роки тому

    2:28 Lybya. Or how to be on the safe side of the y's.

  • @Balthazare69
    @Balthazare69 3 роки тому +3

    Gabon is like "but I want to go with u, to share life with u", and france is like "I think u have to go, u r too little for me, I like big thing like Algeria" xD

    • @jmr1090
      @jmr1090 3 роки тому +2

      Newspaper: Oil discovered in Gabon!
      France: *Going through a rough patch with Algeria. Sees Gabon* Hmmm, au revoir Algeria.
      France: *To Gabon* Bonjour Mademoiselle
      Gabon: Francafrique now!

  • @Justanothaguy
    @Justanothaguy 3 роки тому

    France has 5 republics
    South Korea: I'm gonna do what's called a Pro-Gamer Move...

  • @phoenixport1270
    @phoenixport1270 3 роки тому

    Hmm, I could have sworn I saw History Matters make a video on this very exact same topic.

  • @potok395
    @potok395 3 роки тому +1

    Even if I’m french, I didn’t knew most of the things in the video !

  • @razareg0808
    @razareg0808 2 роки тому

    France: “I’m on my fifth republic!”
    Philippines: “I did it faster.”

  • @LunarFresh
    @LunarFresh 3 роки тому +1

    Looks like History Matters already beat EmperorTigerstar to it.
    Good video tho

  • @charlenobyle
    @charlenobyle 3 роки тому

    ''even if it meant loosing french assistance''. Man I wish.

  • @mbathroom1
    @mbathroom1 3 роки тому

    Awesome. I'm literally in France right now

  • @ameliarodriguez7667
    @ameliarodriguez7667 3 роки тому

    Didn't History Mattters already done this video?

  • @breadcrumb382
    @breadcrumb382 3 роки тому +1

    Korea (not the DPRK) is in its 6th republic 😔

  • @BloodRider1914
    @BloodRider1914 3 роки тому +3

    France must be super regretful now that Gabon has oil

    • @Viguier89
      @Viguier89 3 роки тому

      France still managed to exploit that oil, my grand father worked for Elf in Gabon, a former french oil company (now part of Total.)

    • @ey6713
      @ey6713 2 роки тому

      Total : 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I thought my jokes were bad

  • @laugechristophersen9913
    @laugechristophersen9913 3 роки тому

    Wait Beyond the Brick is a pateron of yors? That is based man

  • @petersmythe6462
    @petersmythe6462 2 роки тому

    South Korea: "You have no idea."

  • @ringo.maxxx123
    @ringo.maxxx123 3 роки тому +1

    What happen with next Sixth French Republic

  • @marciomorais2759
    @marciomorais2759 3 роки тому

    subtitles?