Yes i see it.. Western Media always want to blame Hamas even the Occupation Israel Army already kill 15k of Palestinian civillian/Baby and they still want to blame Hamas. I have no ideas for these type of People. Why you kill, then blame someone else. After killing and bombing baby, there was still no Punishment to the Occupation Israel . Are these International Law still exist?
@@elsofieringo is this your way of discrediting her words? are you aware of the thousands of Palestinian hostages held by Israel? and yes they are hostages bc they are imprisoned unjustly and never given the right to trial. have you heard the experience of a few of those Palestinians who were finally released as a result of this whole situation? they too have family and friends that are still being held. they don’t need to say much as their bruised and battered bodies are enough to tell you the conditions in which they were held. im not justifying 10/7 but why is it that you find it so easy to discredit anything related to Palestinian authority but don’t have that same criticism for Israel. i implore you to educate yourself.
in fact, Israeli officials said plainly that they're unhappy she talked to the press because she had not been well "prepared" for the statement. today the ex- israeli PM said "the international media must not be objective" i mean they're saying in front of the whole world: we are twisting the narrative and creating propaganda
What do you think taking hostages and releasing them in good condition after giving them different treatment than other prisoners is? That is propaganda 101.
She said though. People who drove her away on a motorbike towards Gaza, she was between two people on the bike, so it was "hard to breathe" for her. Hamas Tunnel : Lifshitz said she was forced to walk on wet ground and descended into an underground tunnel system she likened to a spiderweb, where she was greeted by “people who told us we believe in the Quran” and promised “not to harm” her and her fellow hostages. Lifshitz said she was initially grouped together with 25 other people before her captors separated her into a smaller group with four other individuals from her kibbutz. She said they slept on mattresses on the floor of the tunnels, ate the same food as Hamas fighters and received regular treatment from doctors during her incarceration. The Large Hall: “They really took care of the sanitary side of things so that we didn’t get sick,” Lifshitz added. Each of the five hostages in her group received their own doctor and there was a paramedic present who supervised medication, she said. “They were very generous to us, very kind. They kept us clean,” Lifshitz said. “They took care of every detail. There are a lot of women and they know about feminine hygiene and they took care of everything there.”
I don't care what she says. Hamas is a terrorist organization who kidnapped innocent civilians. They murder civilians in their homes. Isarel defending itself does not make them "the terrorist" just because hamas are cowards who hid among palestian civilians who are now unintended causalities.
Her not forgetting to shake hands with the man who captured her clearly indicates that he treated her with all respect and mercy and did not harm her. Otherwise, she would have left without paying attention to him.
He is a terrorist! She was his prisoner! I am glad she is free from the butcher terrorists and I wish her well. The fact remains that she was not there by choice. He is not her friend, she was his prisoner. These butchers are evil. You don't shake hands with your captors unless you are being coerced! She might as well be thanking Hitler! Again, he is a vile and disgusting butcher terrorist!
I'm delighted to see that this woman is doing well, and I deeply admire her courage in speaking the truth. As a Muslim, I appreciate her commitment to honesty and integrity.
what truth are you talking about her husband is still an hostage in gaza do you think they didn't force her to say staff so they sound humane if you think hamas are nice people you are as dumb as a sock
@@blackhat2005what if when her family is released and they say the exact same thing, what would you say then? They were paid to say good things about the way they were treated ?
You're despicable. All the released hostages say they were treated well. You would rather they had been mistreated and maybe even killed, wouldn't you?@@fayee8986
Her husband is still be held. If you were told to say nice things about Hamas or your wife or husband would suffer the consequences, what would you do? This channel is perpetuating the Hamas line of propaganda, and you seem to believe it.
A woman of peace unlike her kidnappers that murdred cruelty half of her neighbours in the kibutz. They are completely inhumane though now they try to convince the world that they are human... human people dont cut babies heads, rape young girls and parished families. I'm sorry to say as a jew and as a Israeli citizen that her honesty is the most stupid thing she could do after what these hamas demons did to our nation. I hope the world is enough smart to understand that humanity wasn't around while they decided to murder and torch Israel citizens. This fake humanity that they try now to show to the world has one purpose - to run away from resposiblety and to get what they want from Israel
Your double standard of criticizing other channels for not mentioning the whole truth of what that lady said, while not criticizing this channel seems a little odd. They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground. They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks." Still happy that she told the truth? Or is that specific thing she said propaganda but the kind things she said not? Off course she is criticizing her government. If it was a fun holiday trip there in Gaza she wouldn’t have to criticize the government that she wasn’t protected right? She also said "They gave us a pitta bread, hard cheese, some low fat cream cheese, and cucumber and that was our food for the *entire day* " So this channel is also not completely honest.
Her husband is still a hostage. But your terrorist TV will not tell you such thing. She also told she was beaten upon arrival to Gaza by a mob - but you will not get this info.
They dealt with her according to the teachings of the Qur’an, which commands them to fight those who fight them and to have mercy on children, the elderly, and women, this in the case of war. Otherwise, any blood has its sanctity in a state of peace Everything they did was to get their land back and live free
@@constantineblyuz5786 From what I've seen on YT, the people who watch such content are generally more educated on conflict nuances and can admit your described shortcoming while I presume you won't admit Israeli IDF has done anything wrong towards Palestinians, or add at each situation "'it's because of Hamas". The same Hamas which Israeli intelligence agency Mossad funded initially mind you, to split Palestinian politics. It's true, she was beaten with sticks, saw her friends and community members die, had to walk large distance to and inside tunnels and her husband is still captive, as described in the video. She and the husband have helped sick Palestinians to get to Israeli hospitals to treat life threatening conditions and despite everything she still extended her hand. What an incredible human being.
her body language towards the HAMAS members was in fact very kind and gentle which shows that all the hostages a treated well and she did not endure any emotional harm.
Dont be naive. Her husband is still held hostage, look it up, of course that poor lady cant say anything bad about the ter0rists. When you want to know, how they treat hostages, search names like Shani Louk , Noa Marciano, Yehudid Weiss....
@@JonathanAcademic Jimmy Pacheco a caregiver of 80 years Israeli,he witnessed when Hamas killed ISRAELi that he is caring.There are hostages eat toilet tissue for survival,they are in tunnel estimated 40 deep . Jimmy ask toilet tissue for poop , instead of using he put in his pocket.He said this is food. Every they go to other tunnel ,he dip tissue in the wall so that it will absorb the moisture from cement. He eat that wet tissue.Hamas gave them only 1FITA biscuit and he shared to others the half.
Most western media are showing only selected parts of this elderly woman's testimony without the part of how good they've been treated. I salute this woman for sticking to truth and honesty despite what she went through.
Do you really believe these monsters treated them well??? after they slaughtered and butchered and terrorized thousands of people? Her husband is still in captivity. They tell them what to say when they release them and they threaten them.
What he said about main stream TV especially the US being a catastrophy is so true! I feel physically ill when I see the TV news in my staffroom. Knowing the lies they are telling.
British mainstream media is no better. I don't watch it and I don't buy British newspapers anymore and I cancelled my BBC licence fee two years ago. I watch channels on youtube that I can trust now.
WARNING!!!! We can not hide our sins from God... Jesus Christ loves you and He died on the cross for your sins. Three days later God raised Him from the dead. Jesus has defeated death. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. Jesus Christ is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ and REPENT from the sinful behavior of the world and you will be saved. ACTS 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
Dont forget the way she shook his hand. If people are concerned about the validity of what she is saying, watch that moment again. It was entirely unplanned and she wouldnt have done it for any other reason than respect.
Her former captor (who removed her from her home unannounced while slaughtering her neighbors) is still holding her husband captive. This handshake is saying take care of the other hostages. Don't hurt them.
Well, turns out that that the hostages in Gaza have been subject to sexual torture, rape and gang rape in the months since October 7. This is no surprise and confirmed by the UN, who is generally on the side of the Palestinians. Amy was so eager for her boyfriends in Hamas to be good guys after all, but of course...no.
As usual , After three days after israeli gouvernement " lying" and " denying " that Hamas had proposed releasing the Israeli women over the weekend but Israel refused , in the end , Israeli officials " confirmed " that . Historical insane position of a gouvernement towards its hostages . The hostages after being freed confirm that hamas are more human than what israeli propaganda would tell you . In the other hand , Haarets confirms the torture by Cigarette Burns, Beatings, Attempted Sexual , Assault: Settlers and Soldiers Abused Palestinians Tell me who are the Terrorists now !!! .
she Also said that "Israel bombed us while we were captives, One of the fighters was injured and was treating us at the same time and being treated himself for his wound, They were friendly, They gave us food for the whole day, They were nice, We had a doctor checking in on us regularly, We were given medicines that we need, They treated us very gently, They supplied all of our needs, They considered women's needs and hygiene needs, They fed us from the food they ate: pitta bread, cheese and vegetables. Criticising Israel's bombing, she said the Palestinians have 900 killed and we have killed over 5,000", Israel is the terrorist here
Yes, but the Isra//eli government is very angry about her statement... and there are channels that translated the opposite of what the hostage said... because they did not accept the truth... but I have a feeling that the world is close to discovering the truth that some media outlets are trying to obscure.
Glad someone is speaking truth! People need to question.. if Israel is so concerned about hostages they why do they continue to bomb gaza relentlessly. Smfh
A good woman who spoke the truth, a good daughter who translated her words accurately, and a good husband who got caught up in these events. I wish him well, and hope that he will soon be restored to his family.
@@LuLu-cf9uhquite frankly my dear, your statement is derived from your Islamophobia, insecurities, lack of trust in humanity, hateful bigotry you you think in your narrow mind is justified by an isolated event, rather than the larger context. Cynicism used in a stretch of the definition is a disease of the heart and mind. Forget Hamas, I don’t agree with and reject their agenda and ideology, but having unwavering respect for elders is embedded in Arab culture, whether Christian or Muslim. So any walk of life, whether a militant/terrorist, unscrupulous individual, teacher, nurse, doctor, lawyer,etc, all have on thing in common, unequivocal respect for the elderly not just an 85 year old grandma, but even a person 10-15 years their senior . So nothing should be surprising about that aspect of Arab culture. And another thing, there 2 billion Muslims worldwide, there’s no way you’ll be able to even wish to eradicate them off the face of this planet. I would try to rid that disease resentment, cynicism, mistrust from your heart, while trying to understand people motives through there actions. What’s wrong is wrong what’s right is right. Don’t make a complete conclusion about a situation or an entire group of people, especially out of emotion, because one day, you may have a change of heart and retract your statement. What if your ignorance made someone you know upset, and then you burned that bridge? How will you reconcile that? People are people and their religious, ethnic, or sexual orientation doesn’t define their character.
@@LuLu-cf9uhquite frankly my dear, your statement is derived from your Islamophobia, insecurities, lack of trust in humanity, hateful bigotry. you think in your narrow mind that is justified by an isolated event, rather than the larger context of an unresolved 75-90 year issue?. You approached this with Cynicism used in every stretch of the definition.This is a disease of the heart and mind. Forget Hamas, I don’t agree with and reject their agenda and ideology, but having unwavering respect for elders is embedded in Arab culture, whether Christian or Muslim. So any walk of life, whether a militant/terrorist, unscrupulous individual, teacher, nurse, doctor, lawyer,etc, all have on thing in common, unequivocal respect for the elderly not just an 85 year old grandma, but even a person 10-15 years their senior . So nothing should be surprising about that aspect of Arab culture. And another thing, there 2 billion Muslims worldwide, there’s no way you’ll be able to even wish to eradicate them off the face of this planet. I would try to rid those diseases of the heart you possess while trying to understand people motives through there actions. What’s wrong is wrong and what’s right is right. Don’t make a complete conclusion about a situation or an entire group of people, especially out of emotion, because one day, you may have a change of heart and retract your statements/beliefs. What if your ignorance made someone you know upset, and then you burned that bridge? How will you reconcile that? People are people and their religious, ethnic, or sexual orientation doesn’t define their character.
@@lidiahill5852Biden and Trump are not suitable Presidents. The PARASITIC and ruinous US mainstream mass media is a domestic and an international terrorist. Welcome to THE NEW COLONIALISM. Stupid does as stupid is. The Palestinians can tell you all about it. We are losing OUR country. Expect things in general IN THE USA to continue to worsen. By Frank Martin DiMeglio
Гуля, в руках Хамаса остался ее муж, что она может сказать? Уже нашли убитых заложников пару недель назад. Если бы вашу бабушку похитили, а ее дом сожгли, что бы сказали?
Hahaha, and you lack a brain. She is one of the lucky one. I can care less what she says. Let's ask the bombed Israelis families and festival goers. They are the true victims. Honestly, where is the critical thinking people. She shouldn't been captured in the first place, now we have to be thankful and acknowledge Hamas humanity? It's a no for me.
@@danielwwahai8664hamas was have families and life But Israel bombing they're family *and made beast's* *That beasts have a principle* theay don't kil elders and children But Israel bombing every thing like if she handles with animals * This has dire consequences, and history records everything
@@danielwwahai8664or being married to a journalist famous for exposing Israeli ethnic cleansing of bedouin and living next to and in opposition to a concentration camp for decades led her to have a principled conscience? Rather than, this is inconvenient to me so I'll decide to believe I can read minds....
The IDF always make me think of Hitler's S.S. the way they treat Palestinians, utterly dehumanising them. I guess that's why they're blind to the genocide they're currently able to subject upon the innocent non combatant Palestinian people.
@@sumiben5211 we are responsible and asked to spread the truth of Islam which we will be doing till the end. Considering it as a lie or whatever is up to you bcz in the end no one will be responsible to what they did whether it's right or wrong except their selves.
They still have her husband…of course she will not say anything that will jeopardise his well being. They treated a few well as part of their psychological warfare.
Although she lives on land that was stolen from the Palestinians, a land irrigated with Palestinian blood for 75 years, they treated her with humanity.
I am happy to learn that she is well and hopefully will recovery soon. The fact that she turn around to shake hand with Hamas shows their mutual respect n sincerity she has.. she is telling the truth.
The fact she could turn around and shake her kidnapper hand is proof of her humanity, Hamas did not show that humanity when they kidnapped a helpless 85 yr old women and her husband. Shame on Hamas, how can this bring nothing but shame to Hamas and there cause.
Mutual respect? This is her full testimony: “Hello everyone my name is, Yocheved Lifshitz. Born in 1938. Born here in Israel. I thank you for coming to hear about the tragedy of myself and my friends. We hope to pass through this period. I’ve been through hell. We never thought we’d reach such a state. They went berserk in our kibbutz. They put me on a motorcycle on the side and drove through the fields. They blew up the fence, the electronic fence, that was brought for $2.5 billion, it did not, to no avail. Masses stormed our homes, hit people. They kidnapped many. They did not care about kidnapping elderly. The children. It was extremely painful. They brought us to the entrance. When I laid on the motorcycle. I was on the side. And on the way they beat me. They didn’t break my limbs but it was extremely painful for me. Until we reached the tunnels. There we walked for a few kilometres on the wet ground. There are a huge network of tunnels underneath. It looks like a spiderweb. They took off my watch and my jewellery as they were diving. When we got there they told us that we believe in the Quran and that they will do us no harm and give us the same conditions that they had. We started walking through the tunnels with the wet ground. With extreme humidity. We reached a hall where some 25 kidnapped were concentrated. After two or three hours they separated, from my kibitz, five people. And they put them in a separate room. There guards were next to us with a paramedic and a doctor. We lay there on mattresses. They took care of the sanitary situation. Doctor came every 2 or 3 days to check. A paramedic was there as well. And provided some medicine. There was a guy who was carried by the motorbike. He was wounded very badly in his hands and his legs. It was very difficult to see him. He is in a better condition now. The doctor prescribed some sort of antibiotics. His condition started improving. We were five. In each had a guard that was in charge of us. There were a lot of women there. They took care of the women’s hygiene. They cleaned us up for disease. They feared themselves that they would be contaminated with infections. I do not want to speak about politics. They spoke about all sorts of things. They were friendly in their way. They divided us into groups and according to kibbutz’s. Those took care of our needs I would say that they made sure that we eat the same food that they eat. White cheese and cucumbers. That was a meal for a whole day. Last message. We were very hurt that the aiDF did not know. We were the scapegoats. They warned us three weeks prior. With people who came to the road and burnt fields. Incendiary ballon’s to burn our fields. And the IDF did not address this seriously. Suddenly on Saturday morning when everything was quiet there was a happy bombardment of the communities and with that the masses infiltrated and blew up the expensive fence. Opened the gates of the kibbutz and entered in their masses. It was extremely difficult. I keep having those images in my mind. Why did you shake the hand of the Hamas terrorist. They were gentle with us. Our needs were supplied. They were prepared for this. They were prepared for a very long time. Including the needs of the women. They said once that Israel announced that there were over 900 killed but that they had a 1,000, if not more. I only know about the group that was with me in the room.”
@gustgoris8009 lol. So why did she turn back and handshake? That wasn't really necessary lol. It was a gesture of thanks from what it appears incase you are blind
@gustgoris8009 Do understand how modern medicine works? Forensics? Of course not, youre a Hasbara bot. If she was beaten and walked in the cold this would have been blasted all over the news, this would be an entirely different story, because the hospital would have reported this upon examining her. They didnt, because that didnt happen. On a related note, how much does it cost to pay for a bot to run propaganda comments? Is it a per comment fee or is it by impressions and engagement. Pay per lie? Ive always wondered
@@taniya8629 she was beaten. she had to walk in the cold barefoor. she will not say anything bad bc her husband is still a hostage, shes probbaly scared if she says anything bad than they will hurt the other hostages
Per the comment above: They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle (with her head hanging on one side and her legs on the other side) and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground (barefoot). They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks." Still happy that she told the truth? Or is that specific thing she said propaganda but the kind things she said not?
Well, turns out that that the hostages in Gaza have been subject to sexual torture, rape and gang rape in the months since October 7. This is no surprise and confirmed by the UN, who is generally on the side of the Palestinians. Amy was so eager for her boyfriends in Hamas to be good guys after all, but of course...no.
Why are other media outlets reporting it as if she was treated really badly and tortured? Should we consider banning them on these social media platforms for misinformation?
You don’t think it’s possible that she saying what they want her to say, more or less, because her husband is still being held captive? I can’t help but look at you as having a lot of bias but probably not seeing it. Often times we think our opinion is worthy and intelligent because we hold it, that doesn’t make it so.
does it matter? my grandmother was kidnapped as a child and she was also treated friendly, does that make it ok to kidnap peoples kids though??? Also, did you see all of the videos of the people who were not treated so friendly by them????
This man said something that’s very crucial the Palestinian fight is not with the Jewish people. It’s with the Zionist occupation people make a note of that, make a note of it, and understand it.
Make a note, "from the river to the sea Palistien will be free! " Meaning, the destruction of The Jewish State of Israel. Quit gaslighting and twisting facts to support your antisemitic agenda!
This is one of the few outlets that covered Lifshitz's honest statements that she was treated well. Every other outlet censors her statements and only covers that she endured hell. Thank you Mrs. Lifshitz for your courage and your honestly. I'm glad you are back with your family and hope you will soon be joined by your loving husband.
Really? This is her full testimony. “Hello everyone my name is, Yocheved Lifshitz. Born in 1938. Born here in Israel. I thank you for coming to hear about the tragedy of myself and my friends. We hope to pass through this period. I’ve been through hell. We never thought we’d reach such a state. They went berserk in our kibbutz. They put me on a motorcycle on the side and drove through the fields. They blew up the fence, the electronic fence, that was brought for $2.5 billion, it did not, to no avail. Masses stormed our homes, hit people. They kidnapped many. They did not care about kidnapping elderly. The children. It was extremely painful. They brought us to the entrance. When I laid on the motorcycle. I was on the side. And on the way they beat me. They didn’t break my limbs but it was extremely painful for me. Until we reached the tunnels. There we walked for a few kilometres on the wet ground. There are a huge network of tunnels underneath. It looks like a spiderweb. They took off my watch and my jewellery as they were diving. When we got there they told us that we believe in the Quran and that they will do us no harm and give us the same conditions that they had. We started walking through the tunnels with the wet ground. With extreme humidity. We reached a hall where some 25 kidnapped were concentrated. After two or three hours they separated, from my kibitz, five people. And they put them in a separate room. There guards were next to us with a paramedic and a doctor. We lay there on mattresses. They took care of the sanitary situation. Doctor came every 2 or 3 days to check. A paramedic was there as well. And provided some medicine. There was a guy who was carried by the motorbike. He was wounded very badly in his hands and his legs. It was very difficult to see him. He is in a better condition now. The doctor prescribed some sort of antibiotics. His condition started improving. We were five. In each had a guard that was in charge of us. There were a lot of women there. They took care of the women’s hygiene. They cleaned us up for disease. They feared themselves that they would be contaminated with infections. I do not want to speak about politics. They spoke about all sorts of things. They were friendly in their way. They divided us into groups and according to kibbutz’s. Those took care of our needs I would say that they made sure that we eat the same food that they eat. White cheese and cucumbers. That was a meal for a whole day. Last message. We were very hurt that the aiDF did not know. We were the scapegoats. They warned us three weeks prior. With people who came to the road and burnt fields. Incendiary ballon’s to burn our fields. And the IDF did not address this seriously. Suddenly on Saturday morning when everything was quiet there was a happy bombardment of the communities and with that the masses infiltrated and blew up the expensive fence. Opened the gates of the kibbutz and entered in their masses. It was extremely difficult. I keep having those images in my mind. Why did you shake the hand of the Hamas terrorist. They were gentle with us. Our needs were supplied. They were prepared for this. They were prepared for a very long time. Including the needs of the women. They said once that Israel announced that there were over 900 killed but that they had a 1,000, if not more. I only know about the group that was with me in the room.”
She was well treated by the armed men who took her hostage at the muzzle of an AK47 and kept in a tunnel? Listen to yourself try and justify hostage taking. You suck the big one.
Your double standard of criticizing other channels for not mentioning the whole truth of what that lady said, while not criticizing this channel seems a little odd. They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground. They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks." Still happy that she told the truth? Or is that specific thing she said propaganda but the kind things she said not? Off course she is criticizing her government. If it was a fun holiday trip there in Gaza she wouldn’t have to criticize the government that she wasn’t protected right? She also said "They gave us a pitta bread, hard cheese, some low fat cream cheese, and cucumber and that was our food for the *entire day* " So this channel is also not honest.
Good for her for remaining steadfast to the truth . Even an 85 year old woman in a wheel chair has the bravery to put aside her fears to see the truth for what it is
she was beaten. she had to walk in the cold barefoor. she will not say anything bad bc her husband is still a hostage, shes probbaly scared if she says anything bad than they will hurt the other hostages
@@gustgoris8009 can u share with me when in the clip that she cited she was beaten? On the contrary , she shared that she was bombed by idf while she held hostage by the hamas...infact, she also shared that the hamas member was wounded in that attack. Another israeli woman in another video shared that the hamas fighter asked for permission to eat the banana in her home. She and her kids were not harmed and hamas left her home after 2 hrs. Wld a terrorist ask permission to eat a banana in your home?...he was respectful even about eating her banana....that says alot . Morever, a frail elderly woman like her would have not survived a terrorist attack and bomb blast had she been in emotional distress and was cruelly treated. The fact that she is well makes it more likely that she was indeed well taken care off and did not suffer much distress .
@@sitiaishahabdulrahim9423 Yes, exactly. Thank you. I'm sure some are real bastards, because every group of people has some real bastards, but some of them are likely just polite young men who believe they are doing the best thing they can do for their people, whether we agree with that assessment or not. They're still just *people*. This acting like Hamas are demons or something is gross to me.
What truth? That she was happy to be taken hostage during a gun fight by armed nutters, who murdered her neighbours. She was then kept in a tunnel with other scared people? You mean THAT truth?
her peopel didn't like her sayig the truth, they want her to lie like they do, Arabs since thousand of years know to treat strangers with great hospitality
May this woman and her peers in Israel, Palestine, and everywhere in the world live many more long, healthy, safe, and happy years. Much love and respect to our parents and grandparents everywhere! 🤍
@@yochshap1 “The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve. Indeed, the story of Palestine has been told before: European settlers coming to a foreign land, settling there, and either committing genocide against or expelling the indigenous people. The Zionists have not invented anything new in this respect. Noam Chomsky, On Palestine
You don’t think it’s possible that she saying what they want her to say, more or less, because her husband is still being held captive? I can’t help but look at you as having a lot of bias but probably not seeing it. Often times we think our opinion is worthy and intelligent because we hold it, that doesn’t make it so.b
@@bpo6955can you feel it? the world is waking up to Zionist propaganda. Time is ticking when these lies will have no more effect than the boy who cried wolf.
Thanks to her daughter too who told it "as is" - Which COUNTERS the prevalent/repeated lies by governments ! Apartheid was supported (with aid/weapons/media/etc) by UK/USA until very recently. Same is this case !
@@coffeelover8658 (1) please correct yourself ... there are no palestinian hostages in israel ... only HAMAS TERRORISTS n the like ... (2) there are no "palestinian" babies in israeli jail nor "palestinian" civilian women that have been randomly kidnapped ...(3) the reason why there are "palestinian" deaths in gaza is either they are HAMAS ... or civilians caught in the war because HAMAS hides in "palestinian" women's skirts and in "palestinian" baby cribs .... okay? ... you understand the difference?
Stockholm syndrome is a coping mechanism to a captive or abusive situation. People develop positive feelings toward their captors or abusers over time.
A comfortable lie is better than a painful truth... The Israelis, along with the choir, do not like this. They want to see what the media has been lying to them for many years.
Her full interview stated she was initially beaten. Even on a motorcycle, they beat her. Had to walk barefoot for miles. Once inside the building or tunnel, the elderly were treated well by Hamas.
The irony is in your comment, since this channel edited the 'hell' part out. The full interview is available uncut. Why did Democracy Now leave that out? She said she was beaten with sticks and it felt like her ribs were broken. Why does a channel that stands for human rights do such a disservice to a human rights activist in her time of great need? Her husband is still there. More than 200 are still there. Call for their immediate release.
She said that they had a person with them who fell from a motorcycle and had injuries, and they also treated him well and treated his injury@@KohalaLover
One thing I know and I'm sure I'm not the only person that knows this is that 80 year old person is at a point in their life that telling the truth is important. We all have Elderly family Members that will tell you the truth. Good or Bad and don't care about your feelings. Especially if they're religious.
A comfortable lie is better than a painful truth... The Israelis, along with the choir, do not like this. They want to see what the media has been lying to them for many years.
Great publicity stunt from Hamas. Purposefully treating her well and then freeing her so that she can tell the truth of course to make this barbaric terrorist group look good. Shame on them and you for your for your ignorant comment.
What you said is like saying a rapist who violated a mans daughter but didn't kill her deserves to be given thanks and forgiveness by the Father because he didn't kill her. You would really forgive a grown man for kidnapping an 85 year old woman, tying her up and throwing her over a dirtbike and riding said dirtbike into a country that has a military blockade built into its borders? Heck, my mom is disabled, and if i heard you took her on a bike off-road, without a helmet, even for a ride, i would lose my absolute shit on you. There's a universally understood reason why kidnapping is illegal, and in the United States carries a life sentence in Prison. If you move someones body anywhere without their consent, the Ability for them to die or be hurt increases tenfold. Example being kidnappers locking someone in a trunk. The car could be rear ended and crush them, or fly off the road and into a river or even shallow pond, and the person drowns. So i dont really see how any thanks is brought to the people who did this. In America we literally try to kill people who pull elderly people onto dirtbikes in a f***** warzone. Youre a pr!ck
@@CharlieBarkinTheDogthey didn't rape her, did they? She didn't lose anything. She got no damage at all. You might say, 'what about trauma?' Well she doesn't look traumatic, does she?
God bless this woman, she knows that truth is imperative at her age. Hopefully the respect between her and her captors remains in their hearts and in their prayers to the one God that they love and that loves them.
@@RachelAharon-j2t 😂😂😂 You just need to cover the good deeds by your hatred You wished that she called Palestinians savages to find an excuse for the atrocities made by your Israelis But she said the truth Taking captives is very normal in any war But treating captives well will never be seen in Isreali prisons BTY in 1967 war Israelis killed all the Egyptian captives mercilessly See the difference
The truth is, Israel shot and killed 12 hostages before they got to Gaza, they heard they were in a room and they shot them dead. That s the truth. The truth is, Israel has killed 20002 CHILDREN since October 7 @@RachelAharon-j2t
@@RachelAharon-j2t she is 85 years old she lived her life and they treated her well and I hope all others to What about the kids that being killed 1 month 2 months old what about them
what occupation? U claim Israel stole the land but which year in human history did the current palestinian arab identity have COMPLETE SOVEREIGNTY over the land which they claim is theirs?. plus israel withdrew from gaza in 2005. they were given resources to build and prosper but hamas their terrorist leader took it all to make rockets and to fund their lavish lifestyle in qatar. instead of being against israel u shld be against ur terrorist leader
@@asbs20237Jews lived in all the arab world woth good conditions Arabs were ruled by the Ottoman as one empire so there were no states at the period. As a Syrian my dream is to free Palestine from the occupation but to allow native jews to live freely while the ones who are not originally from the region should go back to thier countries and can visit it anytime as tourists If you want to go back in history then you should at least go back to Abraham
@@bilalattal2707 شكرا أخي رد مفحم تعبت من التعليق على هؤلاء هم فقط لا يريدون التصديق عندما يتعلق الأمر بتحسين صورة حماس و لو قالها نتنياهو سيقولون مهدد
Your God doesn't exist. What exists is the God of the Jews! And to tell you the truth is to be in favor of a terrorist group like Hamas, you mentally ill?!
@@WorldPeace-xyz Where is 7k Palestine man, women, baby and kid? They died, right? and who where the others before this war? In Israe* prison. Don't double the standard.
@@knightoflight8373 (1) those in israeli jails are not "palestinian" civilians, they are HAMAS TERORISTS n the like ... (2) there are no "palestinian" babies in israeli jail nor "palestinian" civilian women that have been randomly kidnapped ...(3) the reason why there are "palestinian" deaths in gaza is either they are HAMAS ... or civilians caught in the war because HAMAS hides in "palestinian" women's skirts and in "palestinian" baby cribs .... okay? ... you understand the difference?
Well, turns out that that the hostages in Gaza have been subject to sexual torture, rape and gang rape in the months since October 7. This is no surprise and confirmed by the UN, who is generally on the side of the Palestinians. Amy was so eager for her boyfriends in Hamas to be good guys after all, but of course...no.
Dressing The Hostages In PURPLE before Freeing Them IS ON ANOTHER LEVEL. MAKES THE WHOLE THING SO OPEN TO THE KIND OF WARMNESS THAT MADE THAT GREAT MOTHER SAY " SHALOM SON!"
Denier of atrocities. Jews have the right to self determination and a homeland - that is Zionism. It does not take away Palestinians' right to self determination and a homeland. You know what happened on 7th October - mass murder, sadism, the filming of executions and of jubilation over the bodies of families, the elderly. But you, you prefer to watch this handshake and be satisfied.
@@Dee78584Hmmmm You just cannot believe there is good humans among Hamas? How about some country having 7,000 hostages of your people, wouldn't you try to capture some of them to exchange and set your people free?
I heard another young Israeli women said that hamas treated them more humanely then their own army who shot their own people & bombed their people & didn’t care about savings saving hostages.
@@enamulhaquejoy6962yea, her name was Yasmin I think. I have saved the interview of he me saying that. Isreal pretty much like they always made up lies to genocide Palestinians. They do mass massacres every few years. A lot of ppl don’t that Isreal is the most evil state and is an apartheid state.
Your double standard of criticizing other channels for not mentioning the whole truth of what that lady said, while not criticizing this channel seems a little odd. They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground. They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks." She also said "They gave us a pitta bread, hard cheese, some low fat cream cheese, and cucumber and that was our food for the *entire day* " So this channel is also not honest.
@@Hmm-xy9qsthat’s a fair statement. But it does shine a light on how each side has their own motivations, even perceptions. That should teach us to look at more sources to discern the full truth. Maybe it will for some of us.
@@Hmm-xy9qs All food and fuel has been blocked from going into Gaza by Israel. There is no fuel to cook bread. I watched a young mans' YT channel just yesterday describing his life in Israel and touring a supermarket, he stated that their regular diet consists of bread and low fat cream cheese.
Impossible to ask them anything. The murdering/torturing Zionists keep them in "administrative detention". That means kidnapped and arrested without charge or trial (same as imperialist U.S. does with innocent Muslims at Gitmo). Their lawyers can't even visit them!
@@ArleeStarr Yes there are Arab Muslim Knesset members, look up Ahmed Tibi and Mansour Abbas if you don’t believe me This is because all Israelis have equal rights
WARNING!!!! We can not hide our sins from God... Jesus Christ loves you and He died on the cross for your sins. Three days later God raised Him from the dead. Jesus has defeated death. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. Jesus Christ is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ and REPENT from the sinful behavior of the world and you will be saved. ACTS 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
Imagine being kidnapped by violent terrorists, held hostage, released and STILL being pissed off at the Israeli government. Their own citizens don’t even rock with them….
Umm...how are you’re gonna call Hamas terrorists and no Isreal/IDF? All the things they said Hamas did turned out to be Isreali propoganda. Other freed hostages also reported Hamas treated them humanely, why is that so hard to believe? They lie to justify genocide and always use Hamas as scapegoats to get rid of Palestinian civilians like they’re doing now. It’d nothing new. Now is not the time to speak from ignorance but educate yourself on what’s really going. I can send you links if you want, because the propoganda has literally deadly consequences for Palestinians!
For not defending her from those said terrorists... Thanks for acknowledging our freedom of speech. Wonder why the other side doenst have any. Must be the Jews
@@rotemle if you look at her body language, you'll see that she's very relaxed despite having spent weeks as a hostage. Her turning back to shake hands with the Hamas soldiers solidifies the point that she was treated well. By the way she's relaxed, she's probably not even that worried for her husband as maybe he is also being treated the same way she was. If she truly was forced to say this, or held any contempt towards these men, she would've NEVER turned back and be the first one to say bye. You can see in the videos that the soldier let's her go and then she turns back and holds his hand.
@@islambh5873في هدي عندك الحق ديجا قريت تعليقات يقلولك زوجها مزال اسير واكيد مش راح تقول كلام ضدهم تخاف عليه هاد الناس مايفهموش والله مانعرف كيفاش طلقنا عليهم شعب متحظر وهوما متخلفين
Actually, she talked earlier in the interview about being abducted and put on a motor bike and having to walk through a maze of tunnels, afraid all the while, I'm sure! But, yes, that that statement was highlighted by mainstream media and not the fact that they were treated well once they arrived...smh.
Excellent reporting. What a kind, wise and godly woman. Her age has in no way affected her reasoning ability. She described things that was occurring before Oct. 7th that should have been a flashing neon sign warning, yet was ignored or not taken seriously. She was able to take the blinders off and to see the humanity even in her captors. So happy that both these ladies were released. More please, every woman, every child, every elderly at the very least released.
What about Palestinians who are in the Israeli prison just because they are Palestinians!!! who is gonna ask to release them!! why nobody cares about their rights and lives!!!?
This could have been a biat for the Islamic Resistance that they fell for it. Just like Pearl harbour there was need for justification of War against the Muslims and Xtians in Gaza.
the reason why hama s kidnapped those people is because they want to bring the palestinians people who are suffering in the israel jails back by exchanging them with this hostages that hama s kidnapped, so it's ridiculous to say please "release more", who would release the palestinians in the israel jails if hama s just keeps releasing all the hostages now without an agreement of releasing the palestinians people? open your eyes and stop looking at only one half of the story and ignoring the other half story.
The two HAMAS men actually walked with the two elderly women with such care and concern as if they were their own elderly grandmothers, like men who had "GOOD HOME TRAINING" as we would say in our neck of the woods while growing up. And Mrs. Lifshitz shook his hand as an elderly woman would naturally do to say with no words, "Thank you, young man. May you be blessed." In our neck of the woods a show of a covered hand shake was a mutual bonding of appreciation. So this kind of behavior is not limited to one people, ethnicity, color, or culture. This is the kind of common behavior, expected of people, real genuine people with real hearts who know compassion and love.
Truth is she is lucky to be alive, lots of people, including children are not. What kind of “good treatment “she’s talking about after all? Is everyone loves the common sense?
@@BlueSpawn you sound like a monkey..the people hammas...obviously treated her so with dignity nd respect..she even turned back to take the hand..she is clearly gonna miss them.. soon she will embrace islam..like many thousands people did since the last 2weeks of genecide
Trimakasih ibu...yg telah jujur..kami muslim sudah perintah Allah untuk tdk menyakiti org tua wanita dan anak , saling menghargai satu sama lain..mereka harus percaya..karna itu ajaran islam..kalau kami melanggarnya kami termasuk org muslim yg tdk baik..kami dimurkali Allah..
@@fauzanalba6589 bu kişi Müslüman bile değil İslam dininde çocuklara kadınlar yaşlılara değer verilir. Hatta hatta başka dinde olanlara saygı duyulur .
What truth? That she was beaten after she was kidnapped? (Who kidnaps an 85 year old woman and sees some good in it???). Or the truth that many other hostages, including her husband, are still in captivity. Do you think that might have influenced what she said?
@@DocnoXXXGod Almighty, even if you say whatever you say, you are one of the Zionist committees that spend billions of dollars on you so that you can be behind the screen and respond with these comments.
Shaking the hand of your captive....this lady is truly a hero! Humanity was shown toward the captives....humanity is stronger than any religion! The eye for an eye tactic will only blind us all!
FFS. She was taken hostage by a man with an AK47 and kept in a tunnel. Shaking someone's hand doesn't make that right in any one's books. Are you that warped that you can't see the shame in taking an 85 year old infirm woman hostage is indefensible under any circumstances?
@@SunRising502 do u want the brutal truth .. ! .. she was stupid enough to think that living in a stolen land where the owners were kil..led or forced to leave under gun point was a good idea . Good hearted people really don't do that .
@nadavshwaytzervideo that's what I want to know?? What are all of those old people doing on the Gaza border and she was walking with no shoes??? Why????
My old grandmother passed away last year. She was also very kind and a nice muslim woman who spent her whole life looking after the welfare of children and society. This brings tears to my eyes for all the suffering caused by this senseless colonialism and the resistance. May God have some mercy on us!
Colonialism? What history books have you read? Palestinians originally came from Syria Palestina - and came up from Jordan after the Roman emperor kicked out the Jews from their homeland of Israel back in 70 AD. Why is it that Palestinians can work and live in Israel today in safety and prosperity, but no Jew can work and live in Palestine?
@@Blurb777Egyptians were controlling all this lands thousands of years before Abraham and its all documented this lands belong to Egyptians not Jews. You are colonizers.
@@Blurb777palestinians are jews who became christians who then became muslims. Its not that hard. Because it is historically IMPOSSIBLE for a palestinians to stay an arab pure ESPECIALLY after the Jews of prophet Moses went there after david killed goliath.. where did those jews go? Yes. Their great grant children were christians their great great grand children were muslims. So saying palestinians are syrians is a dumb argument
@@Blurb777jews HAVE worked and lived in palestine for very long. Even under muslim rule. In fact when Jerusalem was ruled by the christians they were expelled and Muslims brought them back after taking Jerusalem. So indeed. Religion wise. They are muslim. But ancestry wise. I assure u most of them are sons of Israel and Sons of ismail. Arabs and jewish anscestry
Heartbreaking. I'm so sad the world has ended up like this. Our so called leaders have blood on their hands. How on earth do we get out of this mess? Please, let's spread peace throughout the world instead of fighting and killing each other.❤
I'm wondering if the Hamas operation was to capture hostages in exhange for Palestinian prisoners and it went very badly when the IDF showed up and opened fire. Is it possible that the majority of the Israelis killed died during a crossfire fight between Hamas and the IDF? I saw an interview of an Israeli hostage who said all the hostages were alive and treated well by Hamas until the IDF came and opened fire and all the Israeli hostages who died did so in the crossfire. Seems extremely irresponsible of IDF. I normally wouldn't think that a military would murder its own citizens to make a bad situation worse to win international sympathy to take more land from the Palestinians, but the almost pathological level of lies coming from the Israeli leadership and military has me wondering if this in fact was the case. They really wanted their own 9/11 and made sure they got it. Listen to the hostages. They will tell the truth aboit what happened on Oct. 7 and after.
After viewing numerous videos and listening to voice recordings from various Israeli hostages, both current and released, and even those who survived the raid, a consistent narrative emerges. They all report being treated well by Hamas (hostages). They recount instances of the IDF firing on Israeli houses used as shelters by Hamas, even when civilians were present. In one notable case, a tank was used by the IDF. Also these hostages express criticism towards their own government and Netanyahu’s actions. According to a comprehensive survey reported by The Times of Israel, 80% of Israelis oppose their government and Netanyahu’s actions. It’s important to note that the majority of people commenting on this video likely do not live in Israel or have ever visited. Therefore, the voices of these hostages, along with the majority opinion of Israelis, should be taken into account very seriously. When these individuals share their experiences and perspectives from living in Israel, it provides valuable insight into the situation. Their testimonies can help us understand who the true victims are and which side is acting unjustly. This firsthand knowledge is crucial in discerning the complexities of this conflict. It's worth noting that even after the heinous murder of the 6 years old Palestinian-American and his fatally wounded mother by the hands of their 71 years old American landlord who got influences by the Mainstream Media in the US and in the EU, they (Mainstream Medias) still do propaganda to smear this massive "Free Palestine" campaign and do not even have a shame nor even sympathizes with Palestinian children who are literally by definition teared apart by IDF Air-Strike. Recently those Mainstream Medias in the US quietly reduced the air-times, replaced or even straight up fired their Muslim journalists and reporters.
There is so much confusion around what exactly happened on 7th October. I do not know much about Hamas but atleast they are following the Quran in treating hostages well. I wonder why they went against the Quran and the islamic injunctions of not killing civilians on 7th October. I really hope we come out of these times of confusion having peace and with our humanity intact.
most of them are dying from illness and less health care, torturing them, they even put them in separate jails. Israel will gone soon but Hamas is a muslims who wont kill anyone unless people start killing them cuz this Islam " dont kill a child , don't kill a woman" . 2 millions people in Israel jails
You don't have to wonder. They live , mostly like kings in Israeli jail, but how would you know that? How the hell you compare kidnapped innocent elderly woman with Palestinian killers in Israeli jail, SMH.
This lady is surely blessed. We can all only pray at 85 we have our health and mind like she does. God bless her and I m so glad she is home. I pray the husbands also released.
truth is she is an 85 yr old women whom was taken as a hostage along with her husband. Hamas should be holding there heads in there hands in shame. Maybe if her kidnappers pray for forgiveness Allah will be merciful to them.
Stockholm syndrome is a coping mechanism to a captive or abusive situation. People develop positive feelings toward their captors or abusers over time.
What a moment of peace and humility,she shook the MAN'S hand,and said shalom,he responded in kind,nodding his head and waving, we're all human,give restraint a try!
Per the comment above: They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle (with her head hanging on one side and her legs on the other side) and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground (barefoot). They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks."
that's HOW AND WHEN YOU KNOW MEDIA has LIED THE FK OUT OF YOU, your own ppl are telling you the truth and YOU SAY NAHHH, NOT POSSIBLE LOlz, this is hilarious
@@raylax7056Maybe ironic would be a better way to say this instead of Hilarious. There’s absolutely nothing hilarious about this War. It’s a sick, twisted and disgusting occurrence that is happening. I’m not trying to criticize you, but maybe give you a different way of saying things. 🥰
@@karmaakabane4516 no difference if she said: they don't treated me well, at the end they're hostages (you need to read Coran: وَيُطْعِمُونَ الطَّعَامَ عَلَىٰ حُبِّهِ مِسْكِينًا وَيَتِيمًا وَأَسِيرًا this means: In spite of the food's being agreeable and tasty and that they need it (in war period), they give it away to hostages because islam told them, because the coran rules told them and not because they are keeping her husband!! hamas took chalit for 5 years as hostage (a soldier) not a civilian, why they kill a civilian or treat him badly ?
WARNING!!!! We can not hide our sins from God... Jesus Christ loves you and He died on the cross for your sins. Three days later God raised Him from the dead. Jesus has defeated death. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. Jesus Christ is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ and REPENT from the sinful behavior of the world and you will be saved. ACTS 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
@@WorldPeace-xyzthere’s been several that come out sayinng the same thing, one of them was amused too and praised their manners. Where are the captured Palestinian children? 147 have been in Israeli prison since late June. I have never seen a Palestinian come out and say “it wasn’t so bad :D they’re nice” they usually come out needing intensive care both physical and mental…. Or dead.
@@sunkissedtaetae5017 (1) those in israeli jails are NOT PALESTINIAN CIVILIANS but HAMAS TERRORISTS or the like ... (2) there are no palestinian civilian women or babies in israeli jails .... (3) there are indeed palestinian civilian collateral deaths because HAMAS TERRORISTS hidebehind palestinian women's skirts and in baby's cribs. . ...
@emarie0513 you mean Palestinian hostages? Thousands of them are in Prison and thousands of them died in prison. Open your eyes، if you have any moral left
Пожилую женщину только что освободили, но ей не дали хорошо отдохнуть, не дали выспаться, сразу заставили давать интервью. Видимо так хотели и ждали, что она скажет про хамас что-то плохое, что они звери и тому подобное. Но нет, она сказала правду! Большое спасибо ей за это!
@@mohanf5595you can see the way she held the Hamas fighter hand and said shalom before leaves.. did traumatized hostages give good bye like that? Plus, in Islam is forbidden to tortured any hostages or prisoners, while 2 hostages Palestinian just died yesterday after 2 days in captured by israeli prison! learn from Islam, israHELL! !Enough of propaganda…
So Hamas is a humanitarian organization? This elderly woman went there willingly? and kept there because she is ashamed of Israeli government? That is delusional!! You are laughable!! She has a family member captive still… Much respect to the true Muslims and people of sober morals that condemn Hamas actions. Even Yasser Arafat condemned Hamas. Many Arabs, Chaldeans, Copts, , where is DN reporting that? Druze, Yazidis, Amorites, Orthodox Christians Condemn Hamas courageously. Many Israelis and Palestinians have for years worked and come close to peace, to settlement, their government and leadership have missed many opportunities, history and more importantly, God will judge them for their failures and accomplishments. Shame on you for saying and spreading falsehoods that Hamas is good or somehow on the right here and in their quest to destroy Israel and its people as their charter clearly states.
The mother saying been treated well, yet the headline still written "went through hell". That is the "justice" of western media
Yes i see it.. Western Media always want to blame Hamas even the Occupation Israel Army already kill 15k of Palestinian civillian/Baby and they still want to blame Hamas. I have no ideas for these type of People. Why you kill, then blame someone else. After killing and bombing baby, there was still no Punishment to the Occupation Israel . Are these International Law still exist?
But why her husband still a hostages and prison by Hamas?
@@elsofieringo is this your way of discrediting her words? are you aware of the thousands of Palestinian hostages held by Israel? and yes they are hostages bc they are imprisoned unjustly and never given the right to trial. have you heard the experience of a few of those Palestinians who were finally released as a result of this whole situation? they too have family and friends that are still being held. they don’t need to say much as their bruised and battered bodies are enough to tell you the conditions in which they were held. im not justifying 10/7 but why is it that you find it so easy to discredit anything related to Palestinian authority but don’t have that same criticism for Israel. i implore you to educate yourself.
@@elsofieringo do you know,How many Palestinians are held hostage by Israel? Thousands, 50x more, maybe even more than that
Go live in the middle east if you hate the west so much.
Politicians are the problem, not the people. People can come together.
israeli gov is the problem not the people
Totally agree
Really? How many politicians went into the kibutzes and murdered civilians? Terrorists are the problem
and the colonizers in the west bank are not people just lost uno players GTFOH
❤
Notice how whenever she says something positive, they try to interrupt her. Doesn't seem like theyre afterthe truth. Just propaganda.
Yes, I did notice that. I bet they were anticipating her to speak negatively of her experience
in fact, Israeli officials said plainly that they're unhappy she talked to the press because she had not been well "prepared" for the statement.
today the ex- israeli PM said "the international media must not be objective"
i mean they're saying in front of the whole world: we are twisting the narrative and creating propaganda
What do you think taking hostages and releasing them in good condition after giving them different treatment than other prisoners is? That is propaganda 101.
She said though.
People who drove her away on a motorbike towards Gaza, she was between two people on the bike, so it was "hard to breathe" for her.
Hamas Tunnel :
Lifshitz said she was forced to walk on wet ground and descended into an underground tunnel system she likened to a spiderweb, where she was greeted by “people who told us we believe in the Quran” and promised “not to harm” her and her fellow hostages.
Lifshitz said she was initially grouped together with 25 other people before her captors separated her into a smaller group with four other individuals from her kibbutz. She said they slept on mattresses on the floor of the tunnels, ate the same food as Hamas fighters and received regular treatment from doctors during her incarceration.
The Large Hall:
“They really took care of the sanitary side of things so that we didn’t get sick,” Lifshitz added.
Each of the five hostages in her group received their own doctor and there was a paramedic present who supervised medication, she said.
“They were very generous to us, very kind. They kept us clean,” Lifshitz said. “They took care of every detail. There are a lot of women and they know about feminine hygiene and they took care of everything there.”
I don't care what she says. Hamas is a terrorist organization who kidnapped innocent civilians. They murder civilians in their homes. Isarel defending itself does not make them "the terrorist" just because hamas are cowards who hid among palestian civilians who are now unintended causalities.
Her not forgetting to shake hands with the man who captured her clearly indicates that he treated her with all respect and mercy and did not harm her. Otherwise, she would have left without paying attention to him.
Can be Stockholm syndrome
He is a terrorist! She was his prisoner! I am glad she is free from the butcher terrorists and I wish her well. The fact remains that she was not there by choice. He is not her friend, she was his prisoner. These butchers are evil. You don't shake hands with your captors unless you are being coerced! She might as well be thanking Hitler! Again, he is a vile and disgusting butcher terrorist!
OF COURSE THEY TREATED HER WELL, THEY NEEDED HER TO GO BE THEIR PR WOMAN. SHE DOESN'T EVEN UNDERSTAAND THAT SHE'S BEEN USED BY HAMAS.
@@love.is_life💩🐷🐷🐷💩💩💩💩
Yes, especially because her husband is still a hostage...
I'm delighted to see that this woman is doing well, and I deeply admire her courage in speaking the truth. As a Muslim, I appreciate her commitment to honesty and integrity.
The Quran orders the total extermination of all the non Muslims. When are you going to correct the Quran full of errors and of copies?
what truth are you talking about her husband is still an hostage in gaza do you think they didn't force her to say staff so they sound humane if you think hamas are nice people you are as dumb as a sock
Its important to note that she still has family being held hostage. They probably threatened their lives if she says anything negative.
I wouldn't say she has integrity when. Her husband is still being. Held as a hostage in aza.
@@blackhat2005what if when her family is released and they say the exact same thing, what would you say then? They were paid to say good things about the way they were treated ?
After making her confession in several media, I hope this grandmother is fine and healthy, she must be protected from any pressure or threats.
Unfortunalety she's not speaking her truth, her husband is still in prison and his life are on the line if she refuses to say this.
@@yonatanmonneler1744did she tell you that? What about the other hostages that have something good to say about Hamas?
@@Natasha145_yes, she and the same thing for all of them.
It's not a confession. They have her husband.
@Natasha145_ the other hostages also have relatives that are being held.
She's even criticizing the Israel government.
Well there are many Israelis that want Netanyahu ousted for his lack of protecting the citizens of Israel.
Yeah why do you think she was released maybe she ought to stay where she was at she was so treated well. LOL
You're despicable. All the released hostages say they were treated well. You would rather they had been mistreated and maybe even killed, wouldn't you?@@fayee8986
Her husband is still be held. If you were told to say nice things about Hamas or your wife or husband would suffer the consequences, what would you do? This channel is perpetuating the Hamas line of propaganda, and you seem to believe it.
israel will regret her being allowed to go free!! she should be saying hamas were monstrous killers!!!
She's a woman of peace. May God extend her life 🙏
Aminnn Allahuma Amiinnn😇😇🤲🤲
A woman of peace unlike her kidnappers that murdred cruelty half of her neighbours in the kibutz. They are completely inhumane though now they try to convince the world that they are human... human people dont cut babies heads, rape young girls and parished families. I'm sorry to say as a jew and as a Israeli citizen that her honesty is the most stupid thing she could do after what these hamas demons did to our nation. I hope the world is enough smart to understand that humanity wasn't around while they decided to murder and torch Israel citizens. This fake humanity that they try now to show to the world has one purpose - to run away from resposiblety and to get what they want from Israel
may Alllah guide her to Islam. Ameen :') what a lovely human
@@ThinkingFreedom🙏🏾🙏🏾
@@TheIslamFacts🙏🏾🙏🏾
I stopped watching CNN and MSNBC already.
So did I. 😒😑
You think "Democracy later" is any better you are a gullible fool.
There are 787.5 million reasons to never trust Fox News.
@@eternalskepticuou cant even count that high you dork, dont watvh either of them. Other cointry news outlets do a better job
I hold no faith in any media unless they are independent with on the ground evidence.
Don't watch CNN
Well said
They are calling me a liar because I said that I don't watch MSNBC. Damn these fact checking bots.
Your double standard of criticizing other channels for not mentioning the whole truth of what that lady said, while not criticizing this channel seems a little odd. They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground. They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks."
Still happy that she told the truth? Or is that specific thing she said propaganda but the kind things she said not? Off course she is criticizing her government. If it was a fun holiday trip there in Gaza she wouldn’t have to criticize the government that she wasn’t protected right?
She also said "They gave us a pitta bread, hard cheese, some low fat cream cheese, and cucumber and that was our food for the *entire day* "
So this channel is also not completely honest.
@@Hmm-xy9qsno, they're just toying with the translation
CNN exposed who they were when they fired Lamont Hill
@thelatest001 including democracy now
Her turning back and giving him the hand was genuine.
Yes, it says a lot about her ❤
@@Lishal57 and she said a lot about them, i mean they cleaning the toilet for the houstages are another level
Her husband is still a hostage. But your terrorist TV will not tell you such thing. She also told she was beaten upon arrival to Gaza by a mob - but you will not get this info.
They dealt with her according to the teachings of the Qur’an, which commands them to fight those who fight them and to have mercy on children, the elderly, and women, this in the case of war. Otherwise, any blood has its sanctity in a state of peace Everything they did was to get their land back and live free
@@constantineblyuz5786 From what I've seen on YT, the people who watch such content are generally more educated on conflict nuances and can admit your described shortcoming while I presume you won't admit Israeli IDF has done anything wrong towards Palestinians, or add at each situation "'it's because of Hamas". The same Hamas which Israeli intelligence agency Mossad funded initially mind you, to split Palestinian politics. It's true, she was beaten with sticks, saw her friends and community members die, had to walk large distance to and inside tunnels and her husband is still captive, as described in the video. She and the husband have helped sick Palestinians to get to Israeli hospitals to treat life threatening conditions and despite everything she still extended her hand. What an incredible human being.
her body language towards the HAMAS members was in fact very kind and gentle which shows that all the hostages a treated well and she did not endure any emotional harm.
Dont be naive. Her husband is still held hostage, look it up, of course that poor lady cant say anything bad about the ter0rists. When you want to know, how they treat hostages, search names like Shani Louk , Noa Marciano, Yehudid Weiss....
But if she were another hostage whose kid, wife or husband were killed, then what? If she did not shake hands, then what?
@@JonathanAcademic Jimmy Pacheco a caregiver of 80 years Israeli,he witnessed when Hamas killed ISRAELi that he is caring.There are hostages eat toilet tissue for survival,they are in tunnel estimated 40 deep . Jimmy ask toilet tissue for poop , instead of using he put in his pocket.He said this is food. Every they go to other tunnel ,he dip tissue in the wall so that it will absorb the moisture from cement. He eat that wet tissue.Hamas gave them only 1FITA biscuit and he shared to others the half.
Don’t be an idiot.
Troll bot can't understand duress and threats. The truth will come out.
Most western media are showing only selected parts of this elderly woman's testimony without the part of how good they've been treated. I salute this woman for sticking to truth and honesty despite what she went through.
Do you really believe these monsters treated them well??? after they slaughtered and butchered and terrorized thousands of people? Her husband is still in captivity. They tell them what to say when they release them and they threaten them.
@@dben5958The Monster you are refering is Israeli that killed 5000 civilians mostly woman and kids. Yep I agree…
@@dben5958oh come on, you know those nice Hamas fellows didn't tell her to say nice things about them in order to secure her husband's well being.
@@dben5958 you don't even believe to whom you usually believe when it comes to Islam 😂
@@dben5958ignorant
She has a good daughter who didn’t distort her words 😢
Apparently she flew over from the UK to be with her.
It's pitty this channel cut out the part she said they bit her so hard she could'nt breath
@@נעמיבןיערbit? U mean she got "beated" and it wasnt the captors who did it dumbasss lmao
@@נעמיבןיער كاذب والله انت كاذب وهل ظهر عليها اثار تعذيب ايها الكاذب ولماذا عادت وصافحت يد جندي حماس .. قليل من العقل وليس كثير من الغباء
@@נעמיבןיער why you lying tho
What he said about main stream TV especially the US being a catastrophy is so true! I feel physically ill when I see the TV news in my staffroom. Knowing the lies they are telling.
British mainstream media is no better. I don't watch it and I don't buy British newspapers anymore and I cancelled my BBC licence fee two years ago.
I watch channels on youtube that I can trust now.
They have her husband. She's saying what they told her to say.
@@bulld9646 agree with you. She is saying what she has to say to stay alive n get her husband released.
No joke, our media should be held accountable for feeding lies and fueling the flames of chaos and war. It's like they enjoy these horrors...amazing!
@@bulld9646 When her husband is released and affirms how well he was treated then say they have his sister so he was told what to say.
no wonder they stopped hostages from having any interview
She gives her hand for shaking the Hamas guy. This shows me that she has been treated well by them.
LOL SHEEP
Yeh because she didn't have to
She said they acted them like grandma she said they’re very respectful
@@islambh5873 you don't want to shake hands with anybody who treats you badly.
WARNING!!!! We can not hide our sins from God... Jesus Christ loves you and He died on the cross for your sins. Three days later God raised Him from the dead. Jesus has defeated death. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. Jesus Christ is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ and REPENT from the sinful behavior of the world and you will be saved.
ACTS 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
Dont forget the way she shook his hand. If people are concerned about the validity of what she is saying, watch that moment again. It was entirely unplanned and she wouldnt have done it for any other reason than respect.
Her former captor (who removed her from her home unannounced while slaughtering her neighbors) is still holding her husband captive. This handshake is saying take care of the other hostages. Don't hurt them.
I don't buy it. It was saying thank you for letting me go. That's it.
@@joelslifeand you saw that where? Stop hating, not good for your heart
@@JoelUldrych-kh2scit's hurting you so badly that she didn't say anything bad about them , isn't it? You poor thing. That black heart of yours 😮
@@NoName-ke6gq+1
You can see by her handshake she was treated well 🙏
She is 85 her hands won't be steady
@@gemsgemporia6376 هههههههههه أضحكتني الكذب والتزييف والقتل والاجرام صفتكم انتم عنصريين همجيين لا ننتظر ان تقولو شىئا مختلفا ابخا المجرمون المختلون عقليا البعيدون كل البعد عن الانسانيه انتم منافقون ومخادعون وكاذبون وسوف نسترجع فلسطين اجلا ام عاجلا .. انتم اصحاب ازدواجية المعايير عار عليكم لآخر يوم
@@gemsgemporia6376🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Kidnapped is never showing moral good. Nobody should go through that.
@@JoelUldrych-kh2sc it's a war place and Israel have been doing this for 75 years
And in big red writing it reads “I went through hell” meanwhile this lady is describing a better situation then those that are citizens of the city!
Literally, mainstream is clearly biased with Israel
Well, turns out that that the hostages in Gaza have been subject to sexual torture, rape and gang rape in the months since October 7. This is no surprise and confirmed by the UN, who is generally on the side of the Palestinians. Amy was so eager for her boyfriends in Hamas to be good guys after all, but of course...no.
She is saying what professional hostage negotiators told her to keep her hostage husband alive. 🎉Common sense. They beat her and stole her jewelry
@@rinan4058beaten where? also her body language is calm and friendly.
Yocheved is a brave, strong, and amazing person. Glad she is free.
We cannot say that about millions of Palestinians.
As usual , After three days after israeli gouvernement " lying" and " denying " that Hamas had proposed releasing the Israeli women over the weekend but Israel refused , in the end , Israeli officials " confirmed " that .
Historical insane position of a gouvernement towards its hostages .
The hostages after being freed confirm that hamas are more human than what israeli propaganda would tell you .
In the other hand , Haarets confirms the torture by Cigarette Burns, Beatings, Attempted Sexual , Assault: Settlers and Soldiers Abused Palestinians
Tell me who are the Terrorists now !!! .
She is a tipical israrli
How are they terrorist when they treat her nice and the hostages is Israel killing their own people blaming it on in Palestine
@@kingwilson285💯💯💯💯💯
she Also said that "Israel bombed us while we were captives, One of the fighters was injured and was treating us at the same time and being treated himself for his wound, They were friendly, They gave us food for the whole day, They were nice, We had a doctor checking in on us regularly, We were given medicines that we need, They treated us very gently, They supplied all of our needs, They considered women's needs and hygiene needs, They fed us from the food they ate: pitta bread, cheese and vegetables.
Criticising Israel's bombing, she said the Palestinians have 900 killed and we have killed over 5,000", Israel is the terrorist here
💯
Come on, man
Retaliation is a B!TCH !!!
Yes, but the Isra//eli government is very angry about her statement... and there are channels that translated the opposite of what the hostage said... because they did not accept the truth... but I have a feeling that the world is close to discovering the truth that some media outlets are trying to obscure.
Her husband is a hostage she wants him released
Glad someone is speaking truth! People need to question.. if Israel is so concerned about hostages they why do they continue to bomb gaza relentlessly. Smfh
A good woman who spoke the truth, a good daughter who translated her words accurately, and a good husband who got caught up in these events. I wish him well, and hope that he will soon be restored to his family.
lol I could tell the daughter lied just to avoid civic disruption
Are you kidding!?! THEY STILL HAVE HER HUSBAND! She is saying exactly what Hamas told her to say--because they threatened to torture and kill him.
@@WirzxcveShame on your name!Jesus loves the truth..why don't you like them telling the truth?How long will you close your eyes?
@@LuLu-cf9uhquite frankly my dear, your statement is derived from your Islamophobia, insecurities, lack of trust in humanity, hateful bigotry you you think in your narrow mind is justified by an isolated event, rather than the larger context. Cynicism used in a stretch of the definition is a disease of the heart and mind. Forget Hamas, I don’t agree with and reject their agenda and ideology, but having unwavering respect for elders is embedded in Arab culture, whether Christian or Muslim. So any walk of life, whether a militant/terrorist, unscrupulous individual, teacher, nurse, doctor, lawyer,etc, all have on thing in common, unequivocal respect for the elderly not just an 85 year old grandma, but even a person 10-15 years their senior . So nothing should be surprising about that aspect of Arab culture. And another thing, there 2 billion Muslims worldwide, there’s no way you’ll be able to even wish to eradicate them off the face of this planet. I would try to rid that disease resentment, cynicism, mistrust from your heart, while trying to understand people motives through there actions. What’s wrong is wrong what’s right is right. Don’t make a complete conclusion about a situation or an entire group of people, especially out of emotion, because one day, you may have a change of heart and retract your statement. What if your ignorance made someone you know upset, and then you burned that bridge? How will you reconcile that? People are people and their religious, ethnic, or sexual orientation doesn’t define their character.
@@LuLu-cf9uhquite frankly my dear, your statement is derived from your Islamophobia, insecurities, lack of trust in humanity, hateful bigotry. you think in your narrow mind that is justified by an isolated event, rather than the larger context of an unresolved 75-90 year issue?. You approached this with Cynicism used in every stretch of the definition.This is a disease of the heart and mind. Forget Hamas, I don’t agree with and reject their agenda and ideology, but having unwavering respect for elders is embedded in Arab culture, whether Christian or Muslim. So any walk of life, whether a militant/terrorist, unscrupulous individual, teacher, nurse, doctor, lawyer,etc, all have on thing in common, unequivocal respect for the elderly not just an 85 year old grandma, but even a person 10-15 years their senior . So nothing should be surprising about that aspect of Arab culture. And another thing, there 2 billion Muslims worldwide, there’s no way you’ll be able to even wish to eradicate them off the face of this planet. I would try to rid those diseases of the heart you possess while trying to understand people motives through there actions. What’s wrong is wrong and what’s right is right. Don’t make a complete conclusion about a situation or an entire group of people, especially out of emotion, because one day, you may have a change of heart and retract your statements/beliefs. What if your ignorance made someone you know upset, and then you burned that bridge? How will you reconcile that? People are people and their religious, ethnic, or sexual orientation doesn’t define their character.
Долгой жизни этой честной женщине.
She's not honest because if she was honest she would confess that jewISH people are not God's CHOSEN PEOPLE, but in fact are amalek who GOD hates
куда дольше уже. 85 годов.
She is speaking HAMAS truth...they still hold her husband and son!!!
LONG LIFE TO HER HUSBAND AND SON!!!
@@lidiahill5852Biden and Trump are not suitable Presidents. The PARASITIC and ruinous US mainstream mass media is a domestic and an international terrorist. Welcome to THE NEW COLONIALISM. Stupid does as stupid is. The Palestinians can tell you all about it. We are losing OUR country. Expect things in general IN THE USA to continue to worsen.
By Frank Martin DiMeglio
Гуля, в руках Хамаса остался ее муж, что она может сказать? Уже нашли убитых заложников пару недель назад.
Если бы вашу бабушку похитили, а ее дом сожгли, что бы сказали?
This old women is BRAVE WISE and HONEST. Live in peace ✌🏻
Hahaha, and you lack a brain. She is one of the lucky one. I can care less what she says. Let's ask the bombed Israelis families and festival goers. They are the true victims. Honestly, where is the critical thinking people. She shouldn't been captured in the first place, now we have to be thankful and acknowledge Hamas humanity? It's a no for me.
The Hamas released her for the reason, and they took her hostage for the reason, Hamas are not good at all. They told her to come and say all this.
@@danielwwahai8664hamas was have families and life
But Israel bombing they're family *and made beast's*
*That beasts have a principle* theay don't kil elders and children
But Israel bombing every thing like if she handles with animals *
This has dire consequences, and history records everything
@@danielwwahai8664or being married to a journalist famous for exposing Israeli ethnic cleansing of bedouin and living next to and in opposition to a concentration camp for decades led her to have a principled conscience? Rather than, this is inconvenient to me so I'll decide to believe I can read minds....
usual genocide lies. population grew 400% and fattest in ME.@@tg4678
Well done to the lady and her daughter for telling the truth, be safe.
How do you know what is true? Or you always believe confirmation bias?
@@infantryblackbecause this is her own daughter talking. The other news channels show their own false translation
She is lying to protect other hogages.
@@Hose-A She is lying to protect other hogages.
@@Hose-A Yea she doesn't understand what her daughter is telling the news.
The IDF would never ever treat Palestinians like that. I’m glad she is speaking the truth.
The IDF always make me think of Hitler's S.S. the way they treat Palestinians, utterly dehumanising them. I guess that's why they're blind to the genocide they're currently able to subject upon the innocent non combatant Palestinian people.
IDF = nazi
True,
You’re right - the IDF treats people like humans ! Not animals as Hamas/Isis did.. so yes, they treat people much much better!
Oh my eyes!!! I can’t see with all the gaslighting!!!
Thank you to this brave woman, thank you to this channel for honest reporting, peace to all
Are you saying that Hamas the islamic terrorism is a peaceful movement?
@@marleneplasencia3656 Trick, I said what I said!
@@marleneplasencia3656Yes they are doing their best to try to sell us their Islamic lies.
@@sumiben5211 we are responsible and asked to spread the truth of Islam which we will be doing till the end. Considering it as a lie or whatever is up to you bcz in the end no one will be responsible to what they did whether it's right or wrong except their selves.
They still have her husband…of course she will not say anything that will jeopardise his well being. They treated a few well as part of their psychological warfare.
Silence of good people makes this world suffer. Be strong do whatever you can. Let us unite and bring peace.
The silence from the zionist west on Palestinian suffering and deaths over the last fifty years has been deafening !
The Hamas palestinians started this slaughter attack. Israel is the victim here. You are preaching to the wrong side.
Although she lives on land that was stolen from the Palestinians, a land irrigated with Palestinian blood for 75 years, they treated her with humanity.
@@rachelbraly
Éksqusê me,
Are you okéîy ?
.
Do you have brain ?
Does your brain work on you ?
@@hanimohamed-q4r Unfortunately this wasn't the case for all....on both sides.
I am happy to learn that she is well and hopefully will recovery soon. The fact that she turn around to shake hand with Hamas shows their mutual respect n sincerity she has.. she is telling the truth.
The fact she could turn around and shake her kidnapper hand is proof of her humanity, Hamas did not show that humanity when they kidnapped a helpless 85 yr old women and her husband. Shame on Hamas, how can this bring nothing but shame to Hamas and there cause.
Mutual respect?
This is her full testimony:
“Hello everyone my name is, Yocheved Lifshitz.
Born in 1938. Born here in Israel. I thank you for coming to hear about the tragedy of myself and my friends. We hope to pass through this period.
I’ve been through hell. We never thought we’d reach such a state. They went berserk in our kibbutz. They put me on a motorcycle on the side and drove through the fields. They blew up the fence, the electronic fence, that was brought for $2.5 billion, it did not, to no avail. Masses stormed our homes, hit people. They kidnapped many. They did not care about kidnapping elderly. The children. It was extremely painful. They brought us to the entrance. When I laid on the motorcycle. I was on the side. And on the way they beat me. They didn’t break my limbs but it was extremely painful for me.
Until we reached the tunnels. There we walked for a few kilometres on the wet ground. There are a huge network of tunnels underneath. It looks like a spiderweb.
They took off my watch and my jewellery as they were diving.
When we got there they told us that we believe in the Quran and that they will do us no harm and give us the same conditions that they had. We started walking through the tunnels with the wet ground. With extreme humidity. We reached a hall where some 25 kidnapped were concentrated. After two or three hours they separated, from my kibitz, five people. And they put them in a separate room. There guards were next to us with a paramedic and a doctor. We lay there on mattresses. They took care of the sanitary situation. Doctor came every 2 or 3 days to check. A paramedic was there as well. And provided some medicine. There was a guy who was carried by the motorbike. He was wounded very badly in his hands and his legs. It was very difficult to see him. He is in a better condition now. The doctor prescribed some sort of antibiotics. His condition started improving. We were five. In each had a guard that was in charge of us. There were a lot of women there. They took care of the women’s hygiene. They cleaned us up for disease. They feared themselves that they would be contaminated with infections. I do not want to speak about politics. They spoke about all sorts of things. They were friendly in their way.
They divided us into groups and according to kibbutz’s. Those took care of our needs I would say that they made sure that we eat the same food that they eat. White cheese and cucumbers. That was a meal for a whole day.
Last message. We were very hurt that the aiDF did not know. We were the scapegoats. They warned us three weeks prior. With people who came to the road and burnt fields. Incendiary ballon’s to burn our fields. And the IDF did not address this seriously. Suddenly on Saturday morning when everything was quiet there was a happy bombardment of the communities and with that the masses infiltrated and blew up the expensive fence. Opened the gates of the kibbutz and entered in their masses. It was extremely difficult. I keep having those images in my mind.
Why did you shake the hand of the Hamas terrorist. They were gentle with us. Our needs were supplied.
They were prepared for this. They were prepared for a very long time. Including the needs of the women. They said once that Israel announced that there were over 900 killed but that they had a 1,000, if not more. I only know about the group that was with me in the room.”
@gustgoris8009 lol. So why did she turn back and handshake? That wasn't really necessary lol. It was a gesture of thanks from what it appears incase you are blind
@gustgoris8009 Do understand how modern medicine works? Forensics? Of course not, youre a Hasbara bot.
If she was beaten and walked in the cold this would have been blasted all over the news, this would be an entirely different story, because the hospital would have reported this upon examining her.
They didnt, because that didnt happen. On a related note, how much does it cost to pay for a bot to run propaganda comments? Is it a per comment fee or is it by impressions and engagement. Pay per lie? Ive always wondered
@@taniya8629
she was beaten. she had to walk in the cold barefoor. she will not say anything bad bc her husband is still a hostage, shes probbaly scared if she says anything bad than they will hurt the other hostages
God bless this woman for telling the truth !
Per the comment above: They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle (with her head hanging on one side and her legs on the other side) and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground (barefoot). They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks."
Still happy that she told the truth? Or is that specific thing she said propaganda but the kind things she said not?
@@Bellajane127liar she didnt say that
@@blackeagle5392she said that just didnt show the full inteview
@@kinggames5618 give me the full
@@Bellajane127 Pathetic liar
This is such an important interview.
Thank You both . May many get to see this!
Well, turns out that that the hostages in Gaza have been subject to sexual torture, rape and gang rape in the months since October 7. This is no surprise and confirmed by the UN, who is generally on the side of the Palestinians. Amy was so eager for her boyfriends in Hamas to be good guys after all, but of course...no.
Why are other media outlets reporting it as if she was treated really badly and tortured? Should we consider banning them on these social media platforms for misinformation?
I only heard 'she went thoug hell' on other channels!
They own social media as well. Only place you can get uncensored info is X
What channels? I don't have cable or watch corporate media's UA-cam so I truly don't know.
LOL 99% of the zio nist media lie to the teeth
You don’t think it’s possible that she saying what they want her to say, more or less, because her husband is still being held captive? I can’t help but look at you as having a lot of bias but probably not seeing it. Often times we think our opinion is worthy and intelligent because we hold it, that doesn’t make it so.
She said : they treated her kindly. This video exposes Our biased 🇺🇸 media unfortunately 😔. Period
Exactly
اكيد اعلامكم يغيب عنكم الحقائق الظلم والابادة هو ما يتعرض له الشعب الفلسطيني اكثر من 2000 طفل قتلوا ولا زال اخرون تحت الانقاض وكل هدا تدعمه امريكا
does it matter? my grandmother was kidnapped as a child and she was also treated friendly, does that make it ok to kidnap peoples kids though??? Also, did you see all of the videos of the people who were not treated so friendly by them????
@@truthspeaker8863If it's unsafe for the child to be where they are Israel are evil Free Palestine
@@truthspeaker8863just shut up
Oh wow . Finally some USA News stations allowed fair speech.
Thanks Amy Goodman.
... n where r the other hostages? 😅😅😅
@@WorldPeace-xyzdidn't listen to abu obaida speech yet?
lol hamas are a terror group everyone knows that, they left someone to fill their propaganda
Her husband IS still a hostage.
Think before you exposé youtself.
@@sw.7519go tell israel to free palestenian hostage in israels jails
Get good rain before talk
So glad she wasn't a victim of "friendly fire". And she is alive to tell her peace.
This man said something that’s very crucial the Palestinian fight is not with the Jewish people. It’s with the Zionist occupation people make a note of that, make a note of it, and understand it.
True, but that’s a difference without a distinction
Killing and abducting children from farming villages really stuck it to those Zionists.
@@j.daniels1548Huh? It's a huge distinction. Not all Jews are Zionosts or support the occupation of Palestine. Zionism does not speak for all Jews.
If the fight is not with the Jewish people then why did they rape, behead, burn, torture children and women? Baloney.
Make a note, "from the river to the sea Palistien will be free! " Meaning, the destruction of The Jewish State of Israel. Quit gaslighting and twisting facts to support your antisemitic agenda!
This is one of the few outlets that covered Lifshitz's honest statements that she was treated well. Every other outlet censors her statements and only covers that she endured hell. Thank you Mrs. Lifshitz for your courage and your honestly. I'm glad you are back with your family and hope you will soon be joined by your loving husband.
Really?
This is her full testimony.
“Hello everyone my name is, Yocheved Lifshitz. Born in 1938. Born here in Israel. I thank you for coming to hear about the tragedy of myself and my friends. We hope to pass through this period.
I’ve been through hell. We never thought we’d reach such a state. They went berserk in our kibbutz. They put me on a motorcycle on the side and drove through the fields. They blew up the fence, the electronic fence, that was brought for $2.5 billion, it did not, to no avail. Masses stormed our homes, hit people. They kidnapped many. They did not care about kidnapping elderly. The children. It was extremely painful. They brought us to the entrance. When I laid on the motorcycle. I was on the side. And on the way they beat me. They didn’t break my limbs but it was extremely painful for me.
Until we reached the tunnels. There we walked for a few kilometres on the wet ground. There are a huge network of tunnels underneath. It looks like a spiderweb.
They took off my watch and my jewellery as they were diving.
When we got there they told us that we believe in the Quran and that they will do us no harm and give us the same conditions that they had. We started walking through the tunnels with the wet ground. With extreme humidity. We reached a hall where some 25 kidnapped were concentrated. After two or three hours they separated, from my kibitz, five people. And they put them in a separate room. There guards were next to us with a paramedic and a doctor. We lay there on mattresses. They took care of the sanitary situation. Doctor came every 2 or 3 days to check. A paramedic was there as well. And provided some medicine. There was a guy who was carried by the motorbike. He was wounded very badly in his hands and his legs. It was very difficult to see him. He is in a better condition now. The doctor prescribed some sort of antibiotics. His condition started improving. We were five. In each had a guard that was in charge of us. There were a lot of women there. They took care of the women’s hygiene. They cleaned us up for disease. They feared themselves that they would be contaminated with infections. I do not want to speak about politics. They spoke about all sorts of things. They were friendly in their way.
They divided us into groups and according to kibbutz’s. Those took care of our needs I would say that they made sure that we eat the same food that they eat. White cheese and cucumbers. That was a meal for a whole day.
Last message. We were very hurt that the aiDF did not know. We were the scapegoats. They warned us three weeks prior. With people who came to the road and burnt fields. Incendiary ballon’s to burn our fields. And the IDF did not address this seriously. Suddenly on Saturday morning when everything was quiet there was a happy bombardment of the communities and with that the masses infiltrated and blew up the expensive fence. Opened the gates of the kibbutz and entered in their masses. It was extremely difficult. I keep having those images in my mind.
Why did you shake the hand of the Hamas terrorist. They were gentle with us. Our needs were supplied.
They were prepared for this. They were prepared for a very long time. Including the needs of the women. They said once that Israel announced that there were over 900 killed but that they had a 1,000, if not more. I only know about the group that was with me in the room.”
She was well treated by the armed men who took her hostage at the muzzle of an AK47 and kept in a tunnel? Listen to yourself try and justify hostage taking. You suck the big one.
Your double standard of criticizing other channels for not mentioning the whole truth of what that lady said, while not criticizing this channel seems a little odd. They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground. They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks."
Still happy that she told the truth? Or is that specific thing she said propaganda but the kind things she said not? Off course she is criticizing her government. If it was a fun holiday trip there in Gaza she wouldn’t have to criticize the government that she wasn’t protected right?
She also said "They gave us a pitta bread, hard cheese, some low fat cream cheese, and cucumber and that was our food for the *entire day* "
So this channel is also not honest.
@@Hmm-xy9qshow much does the ministry of foreign affairs pay annually?
they treated a very tiny group well to let them go and fool people others are being treated well. It a PR stunt.
Her gesture of turning back, shaking his hand and saying something positive showed the reality versus the western media.
💯💯💯💯💯💯
no idiot it showed they forced her to do it to look good did you hear her interview even she said it was hell and she was beaten with sticks
WETERN MEDI has followers that are denuded
@@73chengosaro4 you dont even know how to type focus your 60 IQ on learning that
Is there an article that the media released which said that she was treated badly?
Respect and love to this woman and all the good people around the world ..God bless her 🙏❤
Good for her for remaining steadfast to the truth . Even an 85 year old woman in a wheel chair has the bravery to put aside her fears to see the truth for what it is
she was beaten. she had to walk in the cold barefoor. she will not say anything bad bc her husband is still a hostage, shes probbaly scared if she says anything bad than they will hurt the other hostages
She would not know the truth if they lived together.
@@gustgoris8009 can u share with me when in the clip that she cited she was beaten? On the contrary , she shared that she was bombed by idf while she held hostage by the hamas...infact, she also shared that the hamas member was wounded in that attack. Another israeli woman in another video shared that the hamas fighter asked for permission to eat the banana in her home. She and her kids were not harmed and hamas left her home after 2 hrs. Wld a terrorist ask permission to eat a banana in your home?...he was respectful even about eating her banana....that says alot . Morever, a frail elderly woman like her would have not survived a terrorist attack and bomb blast had she been in emotional distress and was cruelly treated. The fact that she is well makes it more likely that she was indeed well taken care off and did not suffer much distress .
@@sitiaishahabdulrahim9423 Yes, exactly. Thank you. I'm sure some are real bastards, because every group of people has some real bastards, but some of them are likely just polite young men who believe they are doing the best thing they can do for their people, whether we agree with that assessment or not. They're still just *people*.
This acting like Hamas are demons or something is gross to me.
What truth? That she was happy to be taken hostage during a gun fight by armed nutters, who murdered her neighbours. She was then kept in a tunnel with other scared people? You mean THAT truth?
I'm glad to hear from this woman.
It's spontaneous and sincere.
It's powerful and wonderful.
her peopel didn't like her sayig the truth, they want her to lie like they do, Arabs since thousand of years know to treat strangers with great hospitality
Lol no
U denied the truth?? It so clear The Hamas Treat the Israeli Civilian well...the real terrorist is Israeli Soldies!!@@toledoborn1392
There are only lies...do you think hamas who killed children are treating well ppl...
the lady resembles my jewish grandma (rip) so much that im taken aback right now on the verge of crying
May this woman and her peers in Israel, Palestine, and everywhere in the world live many more long, healthy, safe, and happy years. Much love and respect to our parents and grandparents everywhere! 🤍
What about the 700 Civilians Israel just killed in Gaza in the last two days, sent your fake regards to them as well if you are honest?
After listening to the released lady , it’s hard to believe Israeli version of Hamas Attack
@@kofilhkhanbefore you make yourself look like a complete idiot, watch her full statement. I'll give you a hint, it starts with "it was hell"
@@yochshap1the hell is caused by Israel. You can’t pride gold if what you’re surrounded with coal. But at least yo can provide heating
@@yochshap1 “The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve. Indeed, the story of Palestine has been told before: European settlers coming to a foreign land, settling there, and either committing genocide against or expelling the indigenous people. The Zionists have not invented anything new in this respect.
Noam Chomsky, On Palestine
What he says is spot on. We can acknowledge responsibility and dissonance and keep the humanity
Some people will not believe the truth because it puts their moral sense at risk! Free Palestinian
Free Palestine of Hamas, then they'll be free.
Some people dont want to believe the truth. They are even looking for reasons why she would talk this way about hem.
Free Palestine
@@savannah505 Free Palestine from the occupation.
You don’t think it’s possible that she saying what they want her to say, more or less, because her husband is still being held captive? I can’t help but look at you as having a lot of bias but probably not seeing it. Often times we think our opinion is worthy and intelligent because we hold it, that doesn’t make it so.b
Thank you for showning the whole video and for the truth.
oh yeah, for sure. Somehow, Hamas innocently got caught up in all this. Umm....no.
@@bpo6955What about the palestinian kids in Israëli prison ?I did not hear you about that ?! And the occupation etc etc?so 🤐🤐🤐🤐
@@bpo6955what do you want to say exactly? That the occupiers are right? And the palestinians are the bad guy? Shut up in that case.
@@bpo6955can you feel it? the world is waking up to Zionist propaganda. Time is ticking when these lies will have no more effect than the boy who cried wolf.
Thanks to her daughter too who told it "as is" - Which COUNTERS the prevalent/repeated lies by governments !
Apartheid was supported (with aid/weapons/media/etc) by UK/USA until very recently. Same is this case !
She’s very strong for someone over 80. Amazing
old people are tougher than you think, they have nothing to lose!
... n where r the other hostages? 😅😅😅
@@WorldPeace-xyz where are the Palestinian hostages took by Israel ?😊
@@coffeelover8658 (1) please correct yourself ... there are no palestinian hostages in israel ... only HAMAS TERRORISTS n the like ... (2) there are no "palestinian" babies in israeli jail nor "palestinian" civilian women that have been randomly kidnapped ...(3) the reason why there are "palestinian" deaths in gaza is either they are HAMAS ... or civilians caught in the war because HAMAS hides in "palestinian" women's skirts and in "palestinian" baby cribs .... okay? ... you understand the difference?
@@WorldPeace-xyz also , it was proven , there were no “40 babies” that were beheaded
I don’t think any other released Israeli prisoner will be allowed to talk to media ( without censorship) after this
You can tell by her body language that she was well cared for.
And her poor husbent is still there
I can tell she was starved, beaten and has Stockholm syndrome.
Stockholm syndrome is a coping mechanism to a captive or abusive situation. People develop positive feelings toward their captors or abusers over time.
@@Yah-God. Exactly.
A comfortable lie is better than a painful truth... The Israelis, along with the choir, do not like this. They want to see what the media has been lying to them for many years.
I congratulate a mother and a daughter for being honest that's amazing thank you.
Comparing to how Israel treat Palestinian..
So she describing how well they treated her but news title showing at the same time - "I went through hell"!
What an irony!
Her full interview stated she was initially beaten. Even on a motorcycle, they beat her. Had to walk barefoot for miles. Once inside the building or tunnel, the elderly were treated well by Hamas.
The irony is in your comment, since this channel edited the 'hell' part out. The full interview is available uncut. Why did Democracy Now leave that out? She said she was beaten with sticks and it felt like her ribs were broken. Why does a channel that stands for human rights do such a disservice to a human rights activist in her time of great need? Her husband is still there. More than 200 are still there. Call for their immediate release.
She said that they had a person with them who fell from a motorcycle and had injuries, and they also treated him well and treated his injury@@KohalaLover
@@KohalaLover Dude didn't even bother to listen to her full statement and start making up his imaginary story 💀
One thing I know and I'm sure I'm not the only person that knows this is that 80 year old person is at a point in their life that telling the truth is important. We all have Elderly family Members that will tell you the truth. Good or Bad and don't care about your feelings. Especially if they're religious.
Yes
A comfortable lie is better than a painful truth... The Israelis, along with the choir, do not like this. They want to see what the media has been lying to them for many years.
Not the words nor images that Israel wants the public to see and hear.....Bless her for speaking the truth...
Great publicity stunt from Hamas. Purposefully treating her well and then freeing her so that she can tell the truth of course to make this barbaric terrorist group look good. Shame on them and you for your for your ignorant comment.
What you said is like saying a rapist who violated a mans daughter but didn't kill her deserves to be given thanks and forgiveness by the Father because he didn't kill her.
You would really forgive a grown man for kidnapping an 85 year old woman, tying her up and throwing her over a dirtbike and riding said dirtbike into a country that has a military blockade built into its borders?
Heck, my mom is disabled, and if i heard you took her on a bike off-road, without a helmet, even for a ride, i would lose my absolute shit on you.
There's a universally understood reason why kidnapping is illegal, and in the United States carries a life sentence in Prison.
If you move someones body anywhere without their consent, the Ability for them to die or be hurt increases tenfold. Example being kidnappers locking someone in a trunk. The car could be rear ended and crush them, or fly off the road and into a river or even shallow pond, and the person drowns.
So i dont really see how any thanks is brought to the people who did this. In America we literally try to kill people who pull elderly people onto dirtbikes in a f***** warzone. Youre a pr!ck
@@CharlieBarkinTheDog just hide ur dumbness ..
@@CharlieBarkinTheDogI was thinking similar about this, can’t forget the horrors done to children tho 😞 Andi want to forget
@@CharlieBarkinTheDogthey didn't rape her, did they? She didn't lose anything. She got no damage at all. You might say, 'what about trauma?' Well she doesn't look traumatic, does she?
In muslim and I'm happy to hear that she is doing fine.
God bless this woman, she knows that truth is imperative at her age. Hopefully the respect between her and her captors remains in their hearts and in their prayers to the one God that they love and that loves them.
Oh please
She's a joke
Do you include the Israeli government in this? Or is all your love left for Hamas alone?
Her husband is still in captivity. What respect are you talking about? Poor woman.
After reading this comment, I am convinced that people are mentally ill, the unwavering support of the terrorists groups is unbelievable.
I'm a Muslim and I am very happy that this lady has come out and said the truth.
Tthe truth is that an 85 year old woman was draged from home bitten by innosent civiliens in gaza and could die
@@RachelAharon-j2tyou did worse to German civilians when you entered Berlin
@@RachelAharon-j2t
😂😂😂
You just need to cover the good deeds by your hatred
You wished that she called Palestinians savages to find an excuse for the atrocities made by your Israelis
But she said the truth
Taking captives is very normal in any war
But treating captives well will never be seen in Isreali prisons
BTY in 1967 war Israelis killed all the Egyptian captives mercilessly
See the difference
The truth is, Israel shot and killed 12 hostages before they got to Gaza, they heard they were in a room and they shot them dead. That s the truth. The truth is, Israel has killed 20002 CHILDREN since October 7 @@RachelAharon-j2t
@@RachelAharon-j2t she is 85 years old she lived her life and they treated her well and I hope all others to
What about the kids that being killed 1 month 2 months old what about them
Some people just refuse to believe the truth. Some people just refuse to condemn the occupation or the settlements!!!! Really sad 😢
what occupation? U claim Israel stole the land but which year in human history did the current palestinian arab identity have COMPLETE SOVEREIGNTY over the land which they claim is theirs?. plus israel withdrew from gaza in 2005. they were given resources to build and prosper but hamas their terrorist leader took it all to make rockets and to fund their lavish lifestyle in qatar. instead of being against israel u shld be against ur terrorist leader
@@asbs20237Jews lived in all the arab world woth good conditions
Arabs were ruled by the Ottoman as one empire so there were no states at the period.
As a Syrian my dream is to free Palestine from the occupation but to allow native jews to live freely while the ones who are not originally from the region should go back to thier countries and can visit it anytime as tourists
If you want to go back in history then you should at least go back to Abraham
@@asbs20237Zionists are european converts, Palestinians are canaanites. Learn history first.
@@bilalattal2707 شكرا أخي رد مفحم تعبت من التعليق على هؤلاء هم فقط لا يريدون التصديق عندما يتعلق الأمر بتحسين صورة حماس و لو قالها نتنياهو سيقولون مهدد
@@bilalattal2707 and all the Palistinian refugees can leave Europe and North America and go back to the middle east where they belong
Да воздаст Аллах ей благом за её справедливость и мужество 🤲❤️🌺❤️🌹😍
Your God doesn't exist. What exists is the God of the Jews! And to tell you the truth is to be in favor of a terrorist group like Hamas, you mentally ill?!
That Israeli woman is a brave person in this day and age. It shows her humanity.
... n where r the other hostages? 😅😅😅
@@WorldPeace-xyz Where is 7k Palestine man, women, baby and kid? They died, right? and who where the others before this war? In Israe* prison. Don't double the standard.
@@knightoflight8373 (1) those in israeli jails are not "palestinian" civilians, they are HAMAS TERORISTS n the like ... (2) there are no "palestinian" babies in israeli jail nor "palestinian" civilian women that have been randomly kidnapped ...(3) the reason why there are "palestinian" deaths in gaza is either they are HAMAS ... or civilians caught in the war because HAMAS hides in "palestinian" women's skirts and in "palestinian" baby cribs .... okay? ... you understand the difference?
hamas lies and arabs agree. no truth in islam@@knightoflight8373
Well, turns out that that the hostages in Gaza have been subject to sexual torture, rape and gang rape in the months since October 7. This is no surprise and confirmed by the UN, who is generally on the side of the Palestinians. Amy was so eager for her boyfriends in Hamas to be good guys after all, but of course...no.
"We know too well that our freedom is
incomplete without the freedom of the
Palestinians." -- Nelson Mandela
Apartheid was supported (with aid/weapons/media/etc) by UK/USA until very recently. Same is this case !
Dressing The Hostages In PURPLE
before Freeing Them IS ON ANOTHER LEVEL.
MAKES THE WHOLE THING SO OPEN TO THE KIND OF WARMNESS THAT MADE THAT GREAT MOTHER SAY " SHALOM SON!"
This women is a true jews not zionist
That's true, Hamas fighting not Jewish people a Zoinizm movement 'well said
Really what happened October 7th ?
Except that the genocide of Jews is in their actual charter. But OK…
Denier of atrocities. Jews have the right to self determination and a homeland - that is Zionism. It does not take away Palestinians' right to self determination and a homeland. You know what happened on 7th October - mass murder, sadism, the filming of executions and of jubilation over the bodies of families, the elderly. But you, you prefer to watch this handshake and be satisfied.
So Hamas treats their hostages better than we treat our soldiers? Got it.
This is an 85yr old woman, I don't expect the treatment of the men to be very nice.
@@Dee78584Hmmmm
You just cannot believe there is good humans among Hamas?
How about some country having 7,000 hostages of your people, wouldn't you try to capture some of them to exchange and set your people free?
@@Dee78584truth hurts isnt it? keep telling that to yourself.
I heard another young Israeli women said that hamas treated them more humanely then their own army who shot their own people & bombed their people & didn’t care about savings saving hostages.
@@enamulhaquejoy6962yea, her name was Yasmin I think. I have saved the interview of he me saying that.
Isreal pretty much like they always made up lies to genocide Palestinians. They do mass massacres every few years. A lot of ppl don’t that Isreal is the most evil state and is an apartheid state.
I quit watching CNN a long time ago. That news would put you on tranquilizers. Praying for peace.
Your double standard of criticizing other channels for not mentioning the whole truth of what that lady said, while not criticizing this channel seems a little odd. They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground. They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks."
She also said "They gave us a pitta bread, hard cheese, some low fat cream cheese, and cucumber and that was our food for the *entire day* "
So this channel is also not honest.
@@Hmm-xy9qsthat’s a fair statement. But it does shine a light on how each side has their own motivations, even perceptions. That should teach us to look at more sources to discern the full truth. Maybe it will for some of us.
I didn't sat if I agree or disagree with this story. I said I don't watch CNN That is garbage news that I can live with out.@@Hmm-xy9qs
@@Hmm-xy9qs All food and fuel has been blocked from going into Gaza by Israel. There is no fuel to cook bread. I watched a young mans' YT channel just yesterday describing his life in Israel and touring a supermarket, he stated that their regular diet consists of bread and low fat cream cheese.
@@selecttravelvacations7472 Even when presented with the indisputable, some will deny it and go on to defend the indefensible.
Good advice
Do not watch CNN in the morning.
We Muslim dearly appreciate this lovely woman telling the truth this difficult time.
Now ask Muslim and Christian’s captives in isreal how they’re treated
Impossible to ask them anything. The murdering/torturing Zionists keep them in "administrative detention". That means kidnapped and arrested without charge or trial (same as imperialist U.S. does with innocent Muslims at Gitmo). Their lawyers can't even visit them!
They have equal rights and are in the parliament
Are there Jews in the Hamas parliament?
@@inoovator3756 The Knesset allows captive Muslims and Christians to be members?
@@ArleeStarr Yes there are Arab Muslim Knesset members, look up Ahmed Tibi and Mansour Abbas if you don’t believe me
This is because all Israelis have equal rights
WARNING!!!! We can not hide our sins from God... Jesus Christ loves you and He died on the cross for your sins. Three days later God raised Him from the dead. Jesus has defeated death. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. Jesus Christ is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ and REPENT from the sinful behavior of the world and you will be saved.
ACTS 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
Brave and honest old lady❤️ Glad she is safe ❤
She says we were treated well, but look at the headline? "I went through hell" They have to feed their narrative.
Imagine being kidnapped by violent terrorists, held hostage, released and STILL being pissed off at the Israeli government. Their own citizens don’t even rock with them….
Umm...how are you’re gonna call Hamas terrorists and no Isreal/IDF? All the things they said Hamas did turned out to be Isreali propoganda. Other freed hostages also reported Hamas treated them humanely, why is that so hard to believe? They lie to justify genocide and always use Hamas as scapegoats to get rid of Palestinian civilians like they’re doing now. It’d nothing new. Now is not the time to speak from ignorance but educate yourself on what’s really going. I can send you links if you want, because the propoganda has literally deadly consequences for Palestinians!
For not defending her from those said terrorists... Thanks for acknowledging our freedom of speech. Wonder why the other side doenst have any. Must be the Jews
Her husband and the rest of the family are still there!!!! She can’t said horrible things that they will not harm them!!!
@@rotemle
if you look at her body language, you'll see that she's very relaxed despite having spent weeks as a hostage. Her turning back to shake hands with the Hamas soldiers solidifies the point that she was treated well. By the way she's relaxed, she's probably not even that worried for her husband as maybe he is also being treated the same way she was.
If she truly was forced to say this, or held any contempt towards these men, she would've NEVER turned back and be the first one to say bye. You can see in the videos that the soldier let's her go and then she turns back and holds his hand.
I heard Israel was at the brink of civil war when Netanyahu allowed Hamas to attack them!
Thanks for showing the Truth, Free free Palestine 🇵🇸🇩🇿✊🏻
دك يقولولك هما هددوها
مام إسرائيلية و ما يآمنوهاش كي تولي تقول حاجة مليحة على حماس
@@islambh5873explain??
@@islambh5873في هدي عندك الحق ديجا قريت تعليقات يقلولك زوجها مزال اسير واكيد مش راح تقول كلام ضدهم تخاف عليه
هاد الناس مايفهموش والله مانعرف كيفاش طلقنا عليهم شعب متحظر وهوما متخلفين
Respect for this lady's bravery and honesty. May she recover fully from this terrible experience and continue to ask for ceasefire
Because if she doesn’t her husband is killed by Hamas
But she says she had nice experience!
Brave? She was kidnapped!
No bravery!
even when the truth is in front of you and you turn your back from it, know that your doom is near.
"I went through hell" but they treated me kindly.... ok.....
Actually, she talked earlier in the interview about being abducted and put on a motor bike and having to walk through a maze of tunnels, afraid all the while, I'm sure! But, yes, that that statement was highlighted by mainstream media and not the fact that they were treated well once they arrived...smh.
Excellent reporting. What a kind, wise and godly woman. Her age has in no way affected her reasoning ability. She described things that was occurring before Oct. 7th that should have been a flashing neon sign warning, yet was ignored or not taken seriously. She was able to take the blinders off and to see the humanity even in her captors. So happy that both these ladies were released. More please, every woman, every child, every elderly at the very least released.
What about Palestinians who are in the Israeli prison just because they are Palestinians!!! who is gonna ask to release them!! why nobody cares about their rights and lives!!!?
This could have been a biat for the Islamic Resistance that they fell for it. Just like Pearl harbour there was need for justification of War against the Muslims and Xtians in Gaza.
Maybe they weren't taken seriously because they wanted a war to start...
the reason why hama s kidnapped those people is because they want to bring the palestinians people who are suffering in the israel jails back by exchanging them with this hostages that hama s kidnapped, so it's ridiculous to say please "release more", who would release the palestinians in the israel jails if hama s just keeps releasing all the hostages now without an agreement of releasing the palestinians people? open your eyes and stop looking at only one half of the story and ignoring the other half story.
@@shelleydale9729 Ya think?
The two HAMAS men actually walked with the two elderly women with such care and concern as if they were their own elderly grandmothers, like men who had "GOOD HOME TRAINING" as we would say in our neck of the woods while growing up. And Mrs. Lifshitz shook his hand as an elderly woman would naturally do to say with no words, "Thank you, young man. May you be blessed." In our neck of the woods a show of a covered hand shake was a mutual bonding of appreciation.
So this kind of behavior is not limited to one people, ethnicity, color, or culture. This is the kind of common behavior, expected of people, real genuine people with real hearts who know compassion and love.
It is a religious obligation to treat the hostages well and look after them.
Makes you think, the media made hamas look like terrorists for their agenda.
@@fefe8684
Yes in deed
And it reflects so will from the old ladies words too
The woman was kidnapped for fuck sake.
😢❤🕊🇵🇸
I don't believe this woman totally. She will say anything so that her family is safe.
May she be protected from those who is not happy her speaking the truth ameen
May she be protected from the people who kidnapped her.
Truth is she is lucky to be alive, lots of people, including children are not. What kind of “good treatment “she’s talking about after all? Is everyone loves the common sense?
@@BlueSpawn you sound like a monkey..the people hammas...obviously treated her so with dignity nd respect..she even turned back to take the hand..she is clearly gonna miss them.. soon she will embrace islam..like many thousands people did since the last 2weeks of genecide
@@BlueSpawntypical israeli mind 😅😅😅😅 why they will kidnapp her again 😆 🤣 stupid israeli 10 in mind
@@BlueSpawn well, she was or else they wouldn't have released her.
Trimakasih ibu...yg telah jujur..kami muslim sudah perintah Allah untuk tdk menyakiti org tua wanita dan anak , saling menghargai satu sama lain..mereka harus percaya..karna itu ajaran islam..kalau kami melanggarnya kami termasuk org muslim yg tdk baik..kami dimurkali Allah..
amin bang
SMG mrk men translate bahasa anda k Bahasa mereka... sehingga komentar anda..di baca byk orang..
Aamiin
@@fauzanalba6589 bu kişi Müslüman bile değil İslam dininde çocuklara kadınlar yaşlılara değer verilir. Hatta hatta başka dinde olanlara saygı duyulur .
Hamas killed many women and children on October 7th. They are not good Muslims!
Tell that to Shani Louk and all the other poor victims... hypocrisy at its best
Congratulations on your release, so happy for you thank you for letting the world know the truth
What truth? That she was beaten after she was kidnapped? (Who kidnaps an 85 year old woman and sees some good in it???). Or the truth that many other hostages, including her husband, are still in captivity. Do you think that might have influenced what she said?
@@DocnoXXXGod Almighty, even if you say whatever you say, you are one of the Zionist committees that spend billions of dollars on you so that you can be behind the screen and respond with these comments.
... n where r the other hostages? 😅😅😅
Three days and no reply. Shows you are an ideologue without true understanding of the issues
@@DocnoXXX they beat her? Her life is barely hanging on a thread. You think she can handle a slap from those soldiers?
from an Arab and from Muslim truly thanks you brave lady for your truth and may ALLAH give's you peaceful long life for you and your Barve family
Shaking the hand of your captive....this lady is truly a hero!
Humanity was shown toward the captives....humanity is stronger than any religion!
The eye for an eye tactic will only blind us all!
Agree 💯
Palestinian don't want revenge, they want their gods given rights and freedom that was taken away
It is so human to take an elderly woman hostage, while leaving her husband behind. these people are saints
FFS. She was taken hostage by a man with an AK47 and kept in a tunnel. Shaking someone's hand doesn't make that right in any one's books. Are you that warped that you can't see the shame in taking an 85 year old infirm woman hostage is indefensible under any circumstances?
She shook the hand of a faction that killed most of her neighbour's that's not honorable imo
Western media disproved by 85 y old lady with one move .
Can you please explain to me how she came to be in captivity in the first place? and why?
@@SunRising502 do u want the brutal truth .. ! .. she was stupid enough to think that living in a stolen land where the owners were kil..led or forced to leave under gun point was a good idea . Good hearted people really don't do that .
That 85 y old lady shouldn't even been kidnapped.
@@rollstar954 should , would , could .. are not war terminology , she shouldn't be there in the first place .
@nadavshwaytzervideo that's what I want to know?? What are all of those old people doing on the Gaza border and she was walking with no shoes??? Why????
My old grandmother passed away last year. She was also very kind and a nice muslim woman who spent her whole life looking after the welfare of children and society. This brings tears to my eyes for all the suffering caused by this senseless colonialism and the resistance. May God have some mercy on us!
Colonialism? What history books have you read? Palestinians originally came from Syria Palestina - and came up from Jordan after the Roman emperor kicked out the Jews from their homeland of Israel back in 70 AD. Why is it that Palestinians can work and live in Israel today in safety and prosperity, but no Jew can work and live in Palestine?
@@Blurb777Egyptians were controlling all this lands thousands of years before Abraham and its all documented this lands belong to Egyptians not Jews. You are colonizers.
@@Blurb777 he didnt im sure he knows nothing about history its the classic brainwashed 60 IQ club
@@Blurb777palestinians are jews who became christians who then became muslims. Its not that hard. Because it is historically IMPOSSIBLE for a palestinians to stay an arab pure ESPECIALLY after the Jews of prophet Moses went there after david killed goliath.. where did those jews go? Yes. Their great grant children were christians their great great grand children were muslims. So saying palestinians are syrians is a dumb argument
@@Blurb777jews HAVE worked and lived in palestine for very long. Even under muslim rule. In fact when Jerusalem was ruled by the christians they were expelled and Muslims brought them back after taking Jerusalem. So indeed. Religion wise. They are muslim. But ancestry wise. I assure u most of them are sons of Israel and Sons of ismail. Arabs and jewish anscestry
اللهم احفظ اهلنا واخوننا المسلمين المستضعفين والمجاهذين في غزة وفلسطين واعزهم وثبث اقدامهم وسدد رميهم وكن لهم عونا ونصيرا وارحم جميع شهذائهم برحمتك ياارحم الراحمين اللهم امين يارب العالمين 🤲🇯🇴
Heartbreaking. I'm so sad the world has ended up like this. Our so called leaders have blood on their hands. How on earth do we get out of this mess? Please, let's spread peace throughout the world instead of fighting and killing each other.❤
It’s too late… only God can bring peace to our world if we open our hearts to His love.
@@margokupelian344...which God?
love is the Answer
@@margokupelian344 how the world get piece and some people oppressed. and took thier land killing torturing near 75 years
I'm wondering if the Hamas operation was to capture hostages in exhange for Palestinian prisoners and it went very badly when the IDF showed up and opened fire. Is it possible that the majority of the Israelis killed died during a crossfire fight between Hamas and the IDF? I saw an interview of an Israeli hostage who said all the hostages were alive and treated well by Hamas until the IDF came and opened fire and all the Israeli hostages who died did so in the crossfire. Seems extremely irresponsible of IDF. I normally wouldn't think that a military would murder its own citizens to make a bad situation worse to win international sympathy to take more land from the Palestinians, but the almost pathological level of lies coming from the Israeli leadership and military has me wondering if this in fact was the case. They really wanted their own 9/11 and made sure they got it. Listen to the hostages. They will tell the truth aboit what happened on Oct. 7 and after.
Perhaps Netanyahu doesn't want the Hostages talking...
😑
After viewing numerous videos and listening to voice recordings from various Israeli hostages, both current and released, and even those who survived the raid, a consistent narrative emerges. They all report being treated well by Hamas (hostages). They recount instances of the IDF firing on Israeli houses used as shelters by Hamas, even when civilians were present. In one notable case, a tank was used by the IDF. Also these hostages express criticism towards their own government and Netanyahu’s actions.
According to a comprehensive survey reported by The Times of Israel, 80% of Israelis oppose their government and Netanyahu’s actions.
It’s important to note that the majority of people commenting on this video likely do not live in Israel or have ever visited. Therefore, the voices of these hostages, along with the majority opinion of Israelis, should be taken into account very seriously.
When these individuals share their experiences and perspectives from living in Israel, it provides valuable insight into the situation. Their testimonies can help us understand who the true victims are and which side is acting unjustly. This firsthand knowledge is crucial in discerning the complexities of this conflict.
It's worth noting that even after the heinous murder of the 6 years old Palestinian-American and his fatally wounded mother by the hands of their 71 years old American landlord who got influences by the Mainstream Media in the US and in the EU, they (Mainstream Medias) still do propaganda to smear this massive "Free Palestine" campaign and do not even have a shame nor even sympathizes with Palestinian children who are literally by definition teared apart by IDF Air-Strike. Recently those Mainstream Medias in the US quietly reduced the air-times, replaced or even straight up fired their Muslim journalists and reporters.
@@Pain-And-Gain killer is 71 years old
@@idontcare7922 Thanks, corrected.
There is so much confusion around what exactly happened on 7th October. I do not know much about Hamas but atleast they are following the Quran in treating hostages well. I wonder why they went against the Quran and the islamic injunctions of not killing civilians on 7th October. I really hope we come out of these times of confusion having peace and with our humanity intact.
I wonder how many innocent Palestinian in israel will say the same
most of them are dying from illness and less health care, torturing them, they even put them in separate jails. Israel will gone soon but Hamas is a muslims who wont kill anyone unless people start killing them cuz this Islam " dont kill a child , don't kill a woman" . 2 millions people in Israel jails
@@mohammadhiasat2544 they didn't stick to that on oct 7. Taking an 85yr old woman hostage is disgusting.
You don't have to wonder. They live , mostly like kings in Israeli jail, but how would you know that? How the hell you compare kidnapped innocent elderly woman with Palestinian killers in Israeli jail, SMH.
@@DOTHERIGHTTHING1989kings? One died yesterday bc of torture
@@blalhani8884 Who? Source?
You wont see this in mainstream media
I salute you for this title which is very truthful and not misleading as a lot of mainstream media.
This lady is surely blessed. We can all only pray at 85 we have our health and mind like she does. God bless her and I m so glad she is home. I pray the husbands also released.
truth is she is an 85 yr old women whom was taken as a hostage along with her husband. Hamas should be holding there heads in there hands in shame. Maybe if her kidnappers pray for forgiveness Allah will be merciful to them.
@@richardhayward2800 الان تتحدثون حقا الان تنحدثون انتم كاذبون ومنافقون وماذا عن مجازر اسرائيل طيلة الخمسة وسبعون عاما هه ماذا عن مجازر صبرا وشاتيلا ودير يس وغيرها وغيرها ماذا عن عجائز قتلو في سنين مضت علي ايدي هؤلاء السفاحون قل لي هه وغابت عنهم آلتك الاعلاميه بتضليل وكذب الآن نسمع صوتكم انتم منافقون ومخادعون وفضحت الاعيبكم وسوف نسترجع ارضنا آجلا ام عاجلا
Stockholm syndrome is a coping mechanism to a captive or abusive situation. People develop positive feelings toward their captors or abusers over time.
What a moment of peace and humility,she shook the MAN'S hand,and said shalom,he responded in kind,nodding his head and waving, we're all human,give restraint a try!
Why did he take her hostage in the first place???? Hamas and humanity just don't belong in the same sentence.
Per the comment above: They forget on this news channel to mention that the old lady also said: "They beat me, laid me on a motorcycle (with her head hanging on one side and her legs on the other side) and rode through the fields with me towards Gaza. They brought me to the tunnels; we walked kilometers underground (barefoot). They beat me in the ribs, even with sticks."
@@Bellajane127كذاب .لماذا تقول الكذب كانت تبدو في حالك جيدة بالنسبة لعمرها ولو ضربوها ماكانت لتصافح من ضربها. الا تعلم ان الله لا يقف مع الكذابين.
@@Bellajane127liar
@@Bellajane127 you lie
World need to know this... thank you for your honest answer grandma... thank you...
Even the hostages are siding with Hamas over their government 😂
that's HOW AND WHEN YOU KNOW MEDIA has LIED THE FK OUT OF YOU, your own ppl are telling you the truth and YOU SAY NAHHH, NOT POSSIBLE LOlz, this is hilarious
@@raylax7056Maybe ironic would be a better way to say this instead of Hilarious. There’s absolutely nothing hilarious about this War. It’s a sick, twisted and disgusting occurrence that is happening. I’m not trying to criticize you, but maybe give you a different way of saying things. 🥰
Her husband is still a hostage. What is she supposed to do? Risk her husband’s life by opposing Hamas?
@@karmaakabane4516 no difference if she said: they don't treated me well, at the end they're hostages (you need to read Coran: وَيُطْعِمُونَ الطَّعَامَ عَلَىٰ حُبِّهِ مِسْكِينًا وَيَتِيمًا وَأَسِيرًا this means: In spite of the food's being agreeable and tasty and that they need it (in war period), they give it away to hostages because islam told them, because the coran rules told them and not because they are keeping her husband!! hamas took chalit for 5 years as hostage (a soldier) not a civilian, why they kill a civilian or treat him badly ?
WARNING!!!! We can not hide our sins from God... Jesus Christ loves you and He died on the cross for your sins. Three days later God raised Him from the dead. Jesus has defeated death. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. Jesus Christ is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ and REPENT from the sinful behavior of the world and you will be saved.
ACTS 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
Netanyahu must be pissed the hostages are been treated well😊
😁👍🏼
Crooked as they come! As bad as the Pussy Grabber. They both need to be locked up.
Yeah😂😂
This happened all because of Netanyahu
His hands are bloody, he is a war criminal
The 1000 who were tortured raped and slaughtered would be happy to know this. But They were all Jews anyway so does it even matter?
Incredible to see such honesty and humanitet around this issue. ❤❤❤
Thanks for honesty guys. Following you from Belgium..
A huge thanks to this woman for speaking the truth. Salam ✌️
... n where r the other hostages? 😅😅😅
@@WorldPeace-xyzthere’s been several that come out sayinng the same thing, one of them was amused too and praised their manners. Where are the captured Palestinian children? 147 have been in Israeli prison since late June. I have never seen a Palestinian come out and say “it wasn’t so bad :D they’re nice” they usually come out needing intensive care both physical and mental…. Or dead.
@@sunkissedtaetae5017 (1) those in israeli jails are NOT PALESTINIAN CIVILIANS but HAMAS TERRORISTS or the like ... (2) there are no palestinian civilian women or babies in israeli jails .... (3) there are indeed palestinian civilian collateral deaths because HAMAS TERRORISTS hidebehind palestinian women's skirts and in baby's cribs. . ...
@emarie0513 you mean Palestinian hostages?
Thousands of them are in Prison and thousands of them died in prison.
Open your eyes، if you have any moral left
criminals You mean@@ZIONISTS_ARE_DISGUSTING
Пожилую женщину только что освободили, но ей не дали хорошо отдохнуть, не дали выспаться, сразу заставили давать интервью. Видимо так хотели и ждали, что она скажет про хамас что-то плохое, что они звери и тому подобное. Но нет, она сказала правду! Большое спасибо ей за это!
سلام عليكم إنها رسالة من الله
No she is not telling the truth. Her husband is still with the hamas. If she speaks against the hamas he will be in trouble.😮
@@mohanf5595you can see the way she held the Hamas fighter hand and said shalom before leaves.. did traumatized hostages give good bye like that? Plus, in Islam is forbidden to tortured any hostages or prisoners, while 2 hostages Palestinian just died yesterday after 2 days in captured by israeli prison! learn from Islam, israHELL! !Enough of propaganda…
True
So Hamas is a humanitarian organization? This elderly woman went there willingly? and kept there because she is ashamed of Israeli government? That is delusional!!
You are laughable!! She has a family member captive still…
Much respect to the true Muslims and people of sober morals that condemn Hamas actions. Even Yasser Arafat condemned Hamas.
Many Arabs, Chaldeans, Copts, , where is DN reporting that? Druze, Yazidis, Amorites, Orthodox Christians Condemn Hamas courageously. Many Israelis and Palestinians have for years worked and come close to peace, to settlement, their government and leadership have missed many opportunities, history and more importantly, God will judge them for their failures and accomplishments.
Shame on you for saying and spreading falsehoods that Hamas is good or somehow on the right here and in their quest to destroy Israel and its people as their charter clearly states.
what would you do for freedom if you were imprisoned, your homes destroyed, and land stolen
Exactly
I would not butcher and burn children, rape and kidnap women and children. Obviously you are ok with that.
And your prisoner is backed by his friends?? Great point!!
What all occupied nations through human history did, fight for your freedom!!!