JUDY COLLINS - "Sons Of" 1976

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лип 2013
  • Judy Collins sings Jacques Brel's "Sons Of" at this 1976 taping for the PBS TV program "Soundstage." Judy recorded this song for her 1970 studio album, "Whales And Nightingales," which also includes the Brel song, "Marieke."

КОМЕНТАРІ • 26

  • @GOLDENFLYWARRIOR
    @GOLDENFLYWARRIOR Рік тому +2

    Jacques Brel was a brilliant singer/lyrist/actor.
    This song 'Sons Of' is probably my fav.
    Thankfully I heard it again in the amazing film 'Flashbacks of a Fool', directed by Haille Walsh with much help from the movies star Daniel Craig who without his help the movie wouldn't have been made. Craig was one of the executive producers.
    This song 'Sons Of' is played in the opening of the film and again in part of Daniel Craig's character Joe when an adolescent.
    The film has another song that hit home for me.
    The scene is also priceless. Song is 'If There is Something' by Roxy Music' and it too is played twice in two different important scenes in Joe's life.
    Very good movie yet lots of heartfelt tragedy too. 💔😢💔
    Although Jacques Brel recorded most of his songs in French and occasionally in Dutch, he became an influence on English-speaking songwriters and performers, such as Scott Walker, David Bowie, Alex Harvey, Marc Almond, Neil Hannon, and Rod McKuen. English translations of his songs were recorded by many performers, including Bowie, Walker, Ray Charles, Judy Collins, John Denver, The Kingston Trio, Nina Simone, Shirley Bassey, James Dean Bradfield, Frank Sinatra, and Andy Williams.
    I'm surprised Sting isn't on this amazing list.

    • @remi-tl5lp
      @remi-tl5lp 7 місяців тому

      ua-cam.com/video/3A8pa0qJE3A/v-deo.html&ab_channel=FerMi-music
      Enregistrement studio Barclay à Paris. en 1967 .
      Belle interprétation de Judy Collins.

  • @bjbinmke
    @bjbinmke 3 роки тому +3

    I love this song.

  • @glenn212now
    @glenn212now 9 років тому +3

    Stunning in every way.

  • @CurzonRoad
    @CurzonRoad 11 років тому +2

    Very nice, indeed.... thank you!

  • @keyfla
    @keyfla 10 років тому +2

    one of the best

  • @RamseyMcV
    @RamseyMcV 3 роки тому +2

    You can't comment on any videos that have Judy singing The Patriot Game. On behalf of us who appreciate it we love you. Sons of Ireland love you.

  • @frankjennings4022
    @frankjennings4022 3 роки тому +4

    One of the saddest songs ever written or sung. Her only son died.

    • @67marlins81
      @67marlins81 3 роки тому +1

      Oh no.....sorry I never knew or inexplicably forgot I read that.....is that true, Frank....?

    • @belair90210
      @belair90210 2 місяці тому

      @@67marlins81her son took his life 😢

  • @helmerrodriguez979
    @helmerrodriguez979 5 років тому +1

    ONLY JUDY COLLINS

  • @jackschimmelman4897
    @jackschimmelman4897 9 років тому +3

    brel thought that mort shuman was his most faithful translator. i arrived in paris 10 years after shuman (more or less) but to be there in the early 60's! when shuman and brel ran together.

  • @popbottle2645
    @popbottle2645 8 років тому +1

    hearts have wings

  • @neilmansfield8329
    @neilmansfield8329 2 роки тому +1

    This is a great song
    She covers Nana Mouskouri’s song well

    • @GOLDENFLYWARRIOR
      @GOLDENFLYWARRIOR Рік тому +2

      Song was written and first sung by Jacques Brel in French. MANY famous singers have sung his songs....even Frank Sinatra.
      Sons of the thief, sons of the saint
      Who is the child with no complaint
      Sons of the great or sons unknown
      All were children like your own
      The same sweet smiles, the same sad tears
      The cries at night, the nightmare fears
      Sons of the great or sons unknown
      All were children like your own...
      So long ago: long, long, ago...
      But sons of tycoons or sons of the farms
      All of the children ran from your arms
      Through fields of gold, through fields of ruin
      All of the children vanished too soon
      In tow'ring waves, in walls of flesh
      Among dying birds trembling with death
      Sons of tycoons or sons of the farms
      All of the children ran from your arms...
      So long ago: long, long, ago...
      But sons of your sons or sons passing by
      Children we lost in lullabies
      Sons of true love or sons of regret
      All of the sons you cannot forget
      Some built the roads, some wrote the poems
      Some went to war, some never came home
      Sons of your sons or sons passing by
      Children we lost in lullabies...
      So long ago: long, long, ago
      But, sons of the thief, sons of the saint
      Who is the child with no complaint
      Sons of the great or sons unknown
      All were children like your own
      The same sweet smiles, the same sad tears
      The cries at night, the nightmare fears
      Sons of the great or sons unknown
      All were children like your own...
      Like your own, like your own.

  • @5293278363
    @5293278363 9 років тому +2

    (I think) Queen Noor supports a charity wherein Isralie Mothers and Palistinian Mothers recite poems/homages about children lost to war and the audience has to decide which side has suffered the loss...

  • @stevetaylor317
    @stevetaylor317 3 роки тому +1

    Very strange version - lacks the driving 3/4 rhythm of the Brel and Scott Walker versions, and so seems very lifeless and insipid. I don't think it's Judy's fault - just a very weak arrangement. Her version of Marieke is fantastic.

    • @bjbinmke
      @bjbinmke 3 роки тому +1

      I love this version.

    • @Themanwhocameback2
      @Themanwhocameback2 2 роки тому +2

      I agree. Something's off here. It's disjointed. Her studio version on "Whales and Nightingales" is much more effective.

    • @GOLDENFLYWARRIOR
      @GOLDENFLYWARRIOR Рік тому +1

      Judy just did the song as Judy.
      Many famous singers sung Jacques Brel songs their way in English. Songs were originally in French. Scott Walker does a great version of this song 'Sons of' but I hope to hear it in French one day.... this year if I can locate certain LPs.
      Although he recorded most of his songs in French and occasionally in Dutch, he became an influence on English-speaking songwriters and performers, such as Scott Walker, David Bowie, Alex Harvey, Marc Almond, Neil Hannon, and Rod McKuen. English translations of his songs were recorded by many performers, including Bowie, Walker, Ray Charles, Judy Collins, John Denver, The Kingston Trio, Nina Simone, Shirley Bassey, James Dean Bradfield, Frank Sinatra, and Andy Williams.
      How WOW is that!!
      Greatness of Jacques Brel are lyrist. But he was also a brilliant actor in his later age. Sadly he died too young from Lung cancer.
      I always thought Bridgett Bardot would die young of lung cancer too. The cigarette smoking and sun bathing aged her terribly. But she's one of my heros for animal rights. Go

  • @kitheskethharvey3576
    @kitheskethharvey3576 5 років тому +7

    Oh dear. I'm a huge fan of Collins, but this ain't her best. Behind the beat, under the note, ghastly translation and an unforgivable arrangement which not only mishandles the harmonies of the last two lines of the main choruses, but turns this incomparable song's driving urgency and anger to mush. Do yourself a favour and watch Brel himself sing it. Do Judy a favour and forget all about this one

    • @TepiLizard
      @TepiLizard 4 роки тому +2

      Her album version is a lot cleaner, though iirc, it doesn't include the "So long ago" bits from the original "Alive & Well" revue, as she does here. She's always clearly changed a few key things on her songs - harmonies, notes. They tend to be slight, but they do make her arrangements different enough from the originals to make them gifts to us.

    • @Themanwhocameback2
      @Themanwhocameback2 2 роки тому +2

      Yes. Her studio version on , I believe, "Whales and Nightingales" is much better.