Time Team S15-E05 Bodies in the Dunes, Outer Hebrides

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 чер 2024
  • In 2005, a major storm eroded a dune next to the beach at Allasdale, Barra, exposing human remains.
    They were first noticed by Barra artist Moira Bard and identified as human by a local doctor, after which a team of archaeologists was called in.
    The site was clearly at risk from further erosion, so Historic Scotland funded an urgent rescue dig.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 567

  • @PtolemyJones
    @PtolemyJones 3 роки тому +86

    R.I.P. Victor Ambrus FRSA (born László Győző Ambrus, 19 August 1935 - 10 February 2021) What a talented artist, he took whatever medium he had at hand and brought the history to life. What a talent.

    • @spacelemur7955
      @spacelemur7955 Рік тому +8

      I would like to see a book with all of his time team artwork.

    • @Happyheretic2308
      @Happyheretic2308 Рік тому +3

      @@spacelemur7955 ‘Recreating the Past’ - Victor Ambrus, Mick Aston

    • @spacelemur7955
      @spacelemur7955 Рік тому +3

      @@Happyheretic2308 *HUGE* Thank-you. I will try to find it.
      EDIT: I found it here in Sweden. Now ordered.🍻👍

    • @Happyheretic2308
      @Happyheretic2308 Рік тому +1

      @@spacelemur7955 you’re welcome!

    • @bjorreb7487
      @bjorreb7487 Рік тому

      @@spacelemur7955 Häftad från Bokus?

  • @KellyBurnett138
    @KellyBurnett138 3 роки тому +16

    “Cyst is something you lance” love Phil! He is so amusing.

    • @benediktmorak4409
      @benediktmorak4409 Рік тому

      but he was correct. these - things- are called - Kists - and also pronounced like that, because of the shape they have. Most probably from the german language - Kiste- for -a box -. WIKi has more about it...en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cist

  • @davidbrown5628
    @davidbrown5628 3 роки тому +13

    This definitely is one of the most fascinating Time Team episodes!

  • @sm3296
    @sm3296 4 роки тому +16

    A woman of 35-45 would have been a well loved person of the community. A mother, grandmother, perhaps healer, she was buried with such love and honour. Beautiful to see all these years later.

  • @loud6037
    @loud6037 4 роки тому +12

    This episode makes me want to move to Barra. What a beautiful island. I could live out the rest of my days there quite happily.

  • @mefford67
    @mefford67 4 роки тому +42

    *I am ADDICTED to this show! As an American it is profoundly intriguing and endlessly fascinating. I only wish we had a way to “resurrect” the show because it is a wonderful glimpse into history and humanity...* 🙏🏻

    • @royalhilltararanger3947
      @royalhilltararanger3947 4 роки тому

      Hello from royal hill Tara county Meath Ireland 😀

    • @royalhilltararanger3947
      @royalhilltararanger3947 4 роки тому

      Have look at mythical Ireland you tube 🌈

    • @royalhilltararanger3947
      @royalhilltararanger3947 4 роки тому

      Victor should have show as well and Mick Aston no more 🌈

    • @alleeum
      @alleeum 3 роки тому +3

      Look (on You Tube) for the channel "Time Team Classics". They're making new crowd-funded episodes to be shown online.

  • @uw1955
    @uw1955 10 років тому +53

    And the more . . . Haven't seen one answer in here to congratulate Victor for his excellent drawings !

  • @alenkapirc22
    @alenkapirc22 5 років тому +14

    Mike Parker Pearson has an outstanding voice! I could listen his explanations all day!

    • @boojay111
      @boojay111 4 роки тому +2

      Have you watched the wonderful documentaries on Stonehenge that Mike PP did. His voice and demeanour are like liquid gold, perfection

  • @gregcurtis1156
    @gregcurtis1156 11 років тому +54

    Thankyou so kindly for down loading so many wonderful episodes of Time Team. And may I say Rest In Peace Professor Mick Aston

    • @equarg
      @equarg 5 років тому +8

      greg Curtis
      I bet he is hunting for the individuals who used to live on these sites to get definite answers.
      😊

    • @vincerussett7922
      @vincerussett7922 5 років тому +4

      That'd be just like Mick!

  • @chrissmith7669
    @chrissmith7669 4 роки тому +4

    Nice shot by Phil directly into the sieve from a good 10 foot.

  • @veritas41photo
    @veritas41photo 4 роки тому +9

    Skara Brae is an about-5,000-year old Neolithic Village site on Orkney, an island off the north coast of Scotland. It is known as the best preserved prehistoric settlement site in Northern Europe. It was unearthed by a storm off the north Atlantic in 1850, similar to what is being described as the recent unearthing mechanism here. Thus began the modern excavation of the site. I have been at Skara Brae, and walked very close to the oldest foot-eroded hearth stones known in Northern Europe. Skara Brae was apparently occupied for only ~400 years, then completely abandoned ~2,500 BC. Big mystery, as no evidence of war or violence was found to explain this complete depopulation. Scotland is the modern archaeologists' paradise...

  • @thomasbell7033
    @thomasbell7033 Рік тому +1

    In a show heavy with jewels, Mike Parker-Pearson sticks out as one of the most precious gems of them all. A natural teacher.

  • @Schmorgus
    @Schmorgus 4 роки тому +5

    18:39 - That amount of precise accuracy from Phil Harding is so satisying :D

  • @sionainnstafford6821
    @sionainnstafford6821 9 років тому +65

    Love these shows. Just discovered them on UA-cam when I got so sick of the crap on TV that i got rid of the cable. Now I just use my TV time to find this type of programming...so interesting AND educational. In Canada most of our tv programs come from the states and it is total rubbish! Now I can find so many shows that are worth watching from the English programming. Thanks so much for posting these.

    • @BCSoHappy
      @BCSoHappy 4 роки тому +1

      I'm in Canada also and I did exactly the same thing a couple three years ago. Haven't missed it a minute. Apparently so many have done what you and I have done the cable companies are getting concerned.

    • @corneliawissing7950
      @corneliawissing7950 3 роки тому +1

      @@BCSoHappy Not from Canada myself, but gave away my TV at the end of 2012 and never even missed it ...

  • @ExUSSailor
    @ExUSSailor 10 років тому +254

    Thanks for posting all of these! This is a wonderful program and, if not for the Internet, I'd never get to see it. We have nothing like this in the States. Our television is made by idiots, for idiots.

    • @MeagainIA2011
      @MeagainIA2011 6 років тому +4

      where were you when Meet The Ancestors was featured every Saturday afternoon on cable back in the early 2000's? Some of the same Time Team folks were on Meet the Ancestors. Then it changed to the Time Team people, but if I recall, it was called something else. But all these same people! All in America, on cable channel in Oklahoma. It's real hard to find the episode of Meet the Ancestors. One of my favorite episodes was when a medieval grave was discovered, they'd do research on the location it was found (England) DNA was done and and found like 40 people who were actually descended from this medieval fellow. Then there was the one called the Knight of the children. An odd burial where a knight was buried, children were buried all around his grave. Loved this show!

    • @Automedon2
      @Automedon2 5 років тому +11

      Television is now a redundant media.

    • @boojay111
      @boojay111 4 роки тому +8

      made by idiots with money for idiots without. It shows that most tv is only a money grubbing exercise and has very little to do with entertainment or education. The BBC is public owned hence we pay a licence fee to view it and remind those in power and the over paid who in fact does own it when necessary. The BBC is not allowed to peddle misinformation, fake news or adverts., thankfully. It does however play the ratings game which has dumbed down certain areas of it broadcasting for mindless idiots who only deserve mindless trash. I do let them know quite often!!!

    • @baberoot1998
      @baberoot1998 4 роки тому +25

      No doubt...totally agree. I am a firefighter in the US, and when watching the television at the fire station, I like watching the Discovery channel, and watch programs on the universe, planets, and deep space. When discovering what I am watching...some of my colleagues will laughingly remark..."Good grief...you're watching how rocks are made." I just smile...because I find it quite comical, that ignorance, does not know it is ignorant. They would rather watch reality shows, with people fighting, than actually learn something about the world in which we live. Shaking my head...lol.

    • @suzannetodaro5494
      @suzannetodaro5494 4 роки тому +6

      @ Babe Root. Yes totally. I have not watched main stream ir any TV in over a decade, I prefer to read, paint, draw etc. It feel reflects on my main life too in the populace, that people "believe" that their characters on TV shows are "real people. They are so caught up that, that the history like this is lost to them, so no use in trying to educate them on what has already actually happened like the Romans and indoor plumbing lol.

  • @bobmckay7237
    @bobmckay7237 5 років тому +17

    Love watching time team here in Michigan. Tony is one of my favorite brits of all and you have to love Phil what a great character.

    • @memybikeni9931
      @memybikeni9931 4 роки тому

      You should search for episodes of blackadder, Tony Robinson played a dogsbody to his master Edmund Blackadder, Hilarious comedy, 4 series including Elizabethan England and right up to WW1. Very funny. In very early episodes of time team when he still had hair he was still called baldrick. British comedy at its best.

    • @TheMisterMonkeyman
      @TheMisterMonkeyman 3 роки тому

      Same, except watching in California. Peace.

    • @corneliawissing7950
      @corneliawissing7950 3 роки тому +1

      And Messrs Pryor and Matt and Stewart and Carenza and Raksha.

  • @jehugo66
    @jehugo66 8 років тому +14

    Such a fascinating show with a unique and long associated crew of characters making fascinating discoveries.

  • @Yamswool
    @Yamswool 9 років тому +14

    Such a good episode the quality of the archaeology was superb.

  • @gwendolynfish2102
    @gwendolynfish2102 4 роки тому +5

    So good to see Beautiful Helen and Stewart again!

    • @boojay111
      @boojay111 4 роки тому

      I'll tell Helen when I see her :)

  • @ruthwickline1000
    @ruthwickline1000 5 років тому +31

    I so enjoy the way you add the computerized versions of the original areas... well done..

    • @baskervillebee6097
      @baskervillebee6097 4 роки тому +3

      The illustrations really explain the unfamiliar more clearly than academic explanations. Really appreciate them.

  • @BuildingCenter
    @BuildingCenter 4 роки тому +7

    18:39 MASTERFUL shovel work!

  • @gaylewright5320
    @gaylewright5320 7 років тому +87

    Victor's drawings are awesome!

    • @lisakilmer2667
      @lisakilmer2667 7 років тому +12

      He worked on hundreds of books, wona lot of prizes. They were fortunate to have had him as he was probably famous enough to be able to turn up his nose at working in wind, rain and cold.

    • @cathjj840
      @cathjj840 5 років тому +2

      The ones he did of Boudicca's raid on Londinium were absolutely electrifying in their portrayal of the horror.

    • @vincerussett7922
      @vincerussett7922 5 років тому +3

      I met Victor just the once, when Time Team did a programme (in 2005) called 'Big Roman Dig'. As there were long pauses while the production team decided what to do next, I had the chance to chat to him. He was a bit quiet at first, but as we got to chat, I thought what a nice (and quite funny) man he was. He has obviously led an eventful life!

    • @barbaraburton8914
      @barbaraburton8914 3 роки тому

      I'd love to have a few of them to hang on the walls. I may be an American, but I'm about as WASP as they come.

    • @SkunkApe407
      @SkunkApe407 3 роки тому

      Yes they are! I'd gladly fork over a pile of cash for a piece of Mr. Ambrus' work. They're absolutely stunning.

  • @jimthompson2836
    @jimthompson2836 4 роки тому +5

    Absolutely one of the best episodes in the series! Thank you

    • @velvetindigonight
      @velvetindigonight 4 роки тому

      I agree, so multi layered, faceted and full of finds.

  • @poolbear2160
    @poolbear2160 6 років тому +5

    Talking about the two child burials got me. Thinking about small children living in that tough environment 4000 years ago.

    • @makrsk09
      @makrsk09 2 роки тому +1

      Children are so resilient! They wouldn't have known any other life and still would have been happy and cheerful!

  • @takefive4291
    @takefive4291 9 років тому +33

    What a fortunate and fabulous excavation of the female remains! Jackie is the Queen of osteoarchaeologists!

    • @FranklinNewhart
      @FranklinNewhart 9 років тому +8

      3-J Ranch I am particularly interested in this burial in that because of the fact that I am a Mohawk Indian and was brought up in the forest I know a bit about this particular type of burial. I have seen it in modern times. When a person is alone and are dying in a remote location they will perform a self burial. They will but themselves in an enclosed space and cover themselves to preserve their body from predation. I fully believe this is what Time Team has found in this particular burial.

    • @garyrobinson2409
      @garyrobinson2409 8 років тому +6

      +Franklin Newhart Franklin these are not "self burials". There's no connection between this and North American burial traditions. Crouch burials and cist burials are common from the Bronze Age through to Roman times in Britain and are well documented and numerous. Many also include grave goods placed there by the relatives of the person being interred.

    • @lameesahmad9166
      @lameesahmad9166 6 років тому +4

      Franklin Newhart, seeing the burial of this woman and the possible way in which she was buried and your story has touched me. The thought of having to bury yourself is quite something; although I do not believe this lady buried herself. The sensitive subject of how the deceased were buried and the dying burying themselves throughout the world shows how much cultures differ worldwide.
      Can I ask you a question? I have heard that in some of the Indian cultures old men (especially ones with a high status) when they knew their time had come went to caves to die and took articles with them to accompany them into the land of their ancestors. Is this true?
      The media and films which weave stupid stories based on hearsay often depict things which are not true. I would like to know from a reliable source what the story really is. I have heard that the culture of the American Indians is a closely guarded secret and not many know the reality. A lot of people I know would like to hear about the real history of your people and I am one of them. This will help to debunk the 'Spaghetti Western' stereotypes which traditionally have been forced down our throats for propaganda purposes.

    • @robb2055
      @robb2055 5 років тому +3

      Lamees Ahmad I'm not native American but you do understand that there are many tribes here in America. The vast number of tribes means there are many different death and burial rituals based on their beliefs, location, culture, and more.

  • @naui_diver9290
    @naui_diver9290 5 років тому +6

    Absolutely love these videos. The way you super-impose pictures of what the finds looked like is just cracking!

  • @davidshelow5334
    @davidshelow5334 3 роки тому +5

    Great episode! Now that our methods have improved, it would be fascinating if someone could compile a catalog of all the human remains--especially the early ones--and test the mtDNA and yDNA to see how they fit into the genetic history of the Isles. I would also like to see (and hear) a compilation of all the times Phil says "Whacking great ------",

  • @robertlemasters3395
    @robertlemasters3395 10 років тому +38

    The women was buried in a sleeping position and her head on a pillow, and naturally covered with a skin or woven blanket as if asleep. These people were poor of material possessions, a blanket made of shin or whatever and the pillow would have been very valuable and important possessions indeed.

    • @FranklinNewhart
      @FranklinNewhart 9 років тому +17

      Robert Lemasters I am particularly interested in this burial in that because of the fact that I am a Mohawk Indian and was brought up in the forest I know a bit about this particular type of burial. I have seen it in modern times. When a person is alone and are dying in a remote location they will perform a self burial. They will but themselves in an enclosed space and cover themselves to preserve their body from predation. I fully believe this is what Time Team has found in this particular burial.

    • @robertlemasters3395
      @robertlemasters3395 8 років тому +8

      I agree with you about self burial, an Apache friend , school mate, mentioned self burial and ritual.

    • @tomthx5804
      @tomthx5804 7 років тому +2

      And comfy

    • @Philrc
      @Philrc 7 років тому

      it's bollocks

    • @readmycomment3157
      @readmycomment3157 3 роки тому +2

      I actually think they werent poor materially. They would have made things all the time and would have looked after them generation after generation. Most of it was made from organic material so theres no record, but they were no different to us.

  • @toytheater4454
    @toytheater4454 8 років тому +38

    such a relaxing show to watch

  • @voovvoov7590
    @voovvoov7590 4 роки тому +7

    Absolutely loved it. Graphics & commentary were delightful & informative.

  • @arielwright5131
    @arielwright5131 5 років тому +5

    I love this show....I just wish they’d take the time to fully uncover everything they can. You know that area is probably rich in information

  • @InnannasRainbow
    @InnannasRainbow 10 років тому +74

    You know, we take life for granted. When a child is born, we fully expect her/him to reach adulthood and old age. It wasn't like that back then, the death of children was common and survival to adulthood was no easy feat.

    • @christinestill5002
      @christinestill5002 4 роки тому

      InnannasRainbow It wasn't unusual for only 1 or 2 babies out of possibly 6 or more to survive into adulthood.

    • @johnnycobra55
      @johnnycobra55 4 роки тому +3

      mass murder by todays abortionist makes survival of infants even more difficult,,,,,, W have lost respect for life!

    • @wilshirewarrior2783
      @wilshirewarrior2783 4 роки тому +2

      The babies had a better chance survival then than now. Murdering babies is the centerpiece of the Democrat Party.

    • @christinestill5002
      @christinestill5002 4 роки тому +21

      Jeff Martin Its always MEN bemoaning abortion & of course, they are not raising the kids & are the loudest about denying funding to help these moms even w/ health care for mom or the babies! It is a case of "I insist u have this child but then you're on your own! Trump just cut off care for millions of women, and not every woman who gets medical screening is pregnant!

    • @LadyIarConnacht
      @LadyIarConnacht 4 роки тому +4

      @@christinestill5002 No, it's not always men bemoaning abortion, and there is absolutely no need for an abortion at 20 weeks - no need, and no excuse. No need to insist they have their child they had the fun of conceiving, but no need to be ripping fully formed infants literally limb from limb and selling their body parts either. Can you imagine a more excruciating death? Yet we condemn our children to it by the millions. How can the conscience of womanhood survive? Our kids are crying out from the grave.

  • @ThePorkupine73
    @ThePorkupine73 10 років тому +4

    I'm pretty happy to be seeing this series for the first time.

    • @johntate4638
      @johntate4638 10 років тому +1

      Me too :) to bad we discovered it when it was canceled. I saw my first episode of Last of the Summer Wine in 2010 just when it was canceled.

    • @LeeAnneGuerin
      @LeeAnneGuerin 9 років тому +1

      At least you can see almost all episodes from the past year 20 years of TimeTeam right here!!

  • @denisehall4818
    @denisehall4818 4 роки тому +1

    What a miserable day for a dig! Thanks for these downloads.

  • @kikufutaba1194
    @kikufutaba1194 4 роки тому +2

    My favorite episode of all the great episodes.

  • @Olentzaro
    @Olentzaro 9 років тому +13

    I've always wanted to see what could be found about prehistory in the Hebrides. Quite fascinating

  • @cactuswren9771
    @cactuswren9771 4 роки тому +2

    The drawings of the people are so beautiful and evocative. Almost felt as though I could see and touch my MacLeod grandmas or maybe my Irish O'Neills from these isles. Thank you so much to the gifted artist and to you all !

    • @innesmacneil
      @innesmacneil 4 роки тому

      The MacLeod's and MacNeil's were sworn enemies and the MacNeil's were known as the pirates of Scotland and the MacLeod's were very bad people among the scottish people, the 4th chief had 2 daughters that tried to escape the clan, as punishment he buried them alive, there is no evidence of relation between the MacNeil's and the O'Neil's, I have done extensive research on this topic...

  • @rmsmith8098
    @rmsmith8098 5 років тому +1

    The best Time Team episode of all. Fascinating and emotive.

  • @t.j.payeur739
    @t.j.payeur739 6 років тому +7

    This is exactly like my first dig in Maine..a 1200 year-old skeleton eroding out of a seaside embankment..that's where I learned that I don't like handling people's bones..there were some awesome lithics, though, maroon Munsungun chert, they were...Victor's drawings are wonderfully evocative sometimes...

    • @AislingL
      @AislingL 6 років тому +1

      T.J. Payeur where did you dig in Maine? I've always loved going to Maine, but I don't know anything about the archaeology of the state

    • @t.j.payeur739
      @t.j.payeur739 6 років тому +3

      It was '93 and '94..we dug a shell midden (auk bones, multi-pronged antler harpoons, and some nice scrapers made of stone from Nova Scotia) and the eroding bones (1200 years old, the poor guy had a massive jaw infection) in Cape Elizabeth, near Portland, and a 12,000 year old seasonal hunting camp on the south-east shores of Sebago Lake that had awesome lithics...

    • @franlooving4203
      @franlooving4203 6 років тому +3

      I agree with you and I think it's good that you listened to your gut feeling, so to speak-at your dig in Maine. I think some people ignore that feeling, but I also think some people are very sensitive to vibes or whatever you call it/feelings about people who have lived before... It is also a respect thing. I'm not sure how to balance such a thing because I love to see the old living places dug up to learn about them, but I am also very sensitive to the bones and such of those who lived there not being disturbed. (I know that different cultures have a different opinion on this topic too-many Native American tribes for example). BTW, I think Cape Elizabeth is beautiful; only saw it once.

    • @vincerussett7922
      @vincerussett7922 5 років тому +1

      Here in the UK, handling peoples bones is governed by quite strict guidelines produced by the Ministry of Justice. I often tell a tale of when I was contacted about a skeleton (which turned out to be Roman), turning up in a village near Weston-super-Mare, UK. The owners of the property really didn't like it being there, so I offered to excavate it (obviously with proper recording) and take it to nearby Bristol Museum, where it could be properly studied. They asked me if I was worried about carrying human remains in my car - wasn't it unlucky? I said (truthfully) 'Nah! I 've excavated lots of skeletons and moved them around'. Three miles up the road towards Bristol, the tyre blew out on my car. And you know what? I still believe that was just coincidence. I'm a scientist BUT I do respect the dead when excavating, and who knows, they may have been my ancestors. Excavating human remains is not like excavating finds: it's a special experience, and should always be treated as such.

  • @00BillyTorontoBill
    @00BillyTorontoBill 6 років тому +7

    I spent 10 yrs in Newfoundland Canada..... looks the same. wind and rock.

  • @lyndashaffery979
    @lyndashaffery979 3 роки тому +1

    Great show ty for sharing

  • @bokhans
    @bokhans 4 роки тому +1

    Barra airport is super famous among flight nuts like me. Not many commercial airports in Europe on beaches. The shortest flight is also in Scotland, 47 seconds, same type of airplane and same airline, Loganair, as in beginning of this episode.

  • @lonniethompson6909
    @lonniethompson6909 5 років тому +3

    Thank you for explanation. I just very recently discovered the program on you tube and like it. Never saw it before on American TV.

  • @elisabird6245
    @elisabird6245 8 років тому +27

    Would anyone else really love to see that portaloo end up in Glasgow?

  • @stephenspilker9334
    @stephenspilker9334 3 роки тому +1

    i love this series, wish we had a similar one in the states.

  • @SigmunLloyd
    @SigmunLloyd 9 років тому +2

    Thanks for posting!

  • @sherriattaway3615
    @sherriattaway3615 5 років тому +23

    Does anyone know why Mick is usually wearing brightly colored stipes on his sweater or his cap? I think it's cute. It highlights his optimistic and fun personality. Has anyone else noticed?😁

    • @maytagmark2171
      @maytagmark2171 5 років тому +5

      I noticed too but just figure its a Mick kinda thing sorta like the eccentric professor.

    • @LQOTW
      @LQOTW 5 років тому +12

      Sherri Attaway - I seem to recall that Mick began the first couple of seasons on TT wearing the same old blue sweater. When prepping for the next season was underway the producers approached Mick and asked him if he didn't have another, less boring sweater he could wear. Famous last words, I think.

    • @sherriattaway3615
      @sherriattaway3615 5 років тому

      Ha...love it!💖 Thanks for the extra information. At the time I posted that I had just discovered TT and didn't realize how many seasons there were. 😱 Thank you. 👍

    • @baskervillebee6097
      @baskervillebee6097 4 роки тому +3

      I love the way Mick, so often, ends his sentences with the word "look" like a period. 😊

    • @sm3296
      @sm3296 4 роки тому +1

      It suggests to me he had a wife who knit for him with lots of love. I hope so anyway, he was a great guy and total character.

  • @PatrickPoet
    @PatrickPoet 4 роки тому +3

    People (and I've done this with a pottery instructor myself) mix poor clay in water, and let it settle in layers. Then you get a layer of higher quality clay with much of the excess sand deposited in its own layer. So the bronze age potters might have used the poor quality clay, but just made it higher quality before using it.

    • @SkunkApe407
      @SkunkApe407 3 роки тому

      Excellent hypothesis! I'd say that's a very safe bet!

  • @paulbriody297
    @paulbriody297 4 роки тому +2

    Great episode!

  • @BeatlesFanSonia
    @BeatlesFanSonia 4 роки тому +1

    I had to get a sweater because I got cold watching you guys in those windy conditions!

  • @mikeburgess944
    @mikeburgess944 6 років тому +222

    If there is a wheel house in Barra, does that make it a wheel barra?

    • @jamespfp
      @jamespfp 5 років тому +11

      If Nvidia started a company manufacturing high end video cards that had a specific set of instructions for running calculations in parallel -- would that be a Barra-CUDA ?

    • @melissaabbott6829
      @melissaabbott6829 5 років тому +3

      Lol, very funny, both of you!

    • @carpii
      @carpii 5 років тому +6

      It was a wheel barra yes, until they took it south to burn it. Thats how the town of barra in furnace got its name

    • @wbrewer5352
      @wbrewer5352 5 років тому +7

      @@carpii You should be emBARRAssed making such comments....

    • @carpii
      @carpii 5 років тому +5

      @w brewer - Oh, believe me. I am not proud of most of my comments!

  • @karendavis7988
    @karendavis7988 Рік тому

    SUCH AN INTERESTING DIG! Loved it so much. ❤

  • @joannebarton9191
    @joannebarton9191 4 роки тому

    Thank you for saying “thousands” of years, not millions. So exciting to see back in time.

    • @SkunkApe407
      @SkunkApe407 3 роки тому

      Why would they say millions, when humans have only been around for about 500,000 years? Or are you one of those that think the Earth is only 6000 years old?

  • @bevanpope7924
    @bevanpope7924 2 роки тому +1

    Kist vs cyst … massive difference! Love Phil, tell the “some” what’s what!

  • @fusion-music
    @fusion-music 8 років тому +7

    the marks made in the artifact mayy indeed be made by the birdbone (leg). Phil said it almost perfectly fit, which tiesin with clay shrinking up tp 15% after firing.

  • @norinenagle6730
    @norinenagle6730 2 роки тому +1

    This was wonderful - real Iron Age. Just wish the characterization of the area being "weird" was not stated. The world and our sensibilities keep changing. Thank goodness.

  • @nunya7502
    @nunya7502 8 років тому +10

    Regarding that part with the clay having too much sand, you can actually wash the clay out of the sand using a basket...but it's a lot of work.

    • @zarasbazaar
      @zarasbazaar 8 років тому +2

      Opposite problem. The clay didn't have enough sand. That's why it wouldn't hold form.

    • @nicolacampbell5795
      @nicolacampbell5795 8 років тому +6

      And you would think that with all the sand laying about they would just mix some in. I'm sure the Iron Age people living there would've worked that out. They wouldn't have bothered to try and make pots with that clay as it is found.

    • @lisakilmer2667
      @lisakilmer2667 7 років тому +6

      They may also have known to crush bones up and use it in the matrix.

  • @VictorRochaGaming
    @VictorRochaGaming 4 роки тому +1

    This is a great episode. Thanks for sharing.

  • @elizabethmcglothlin5406
    @elizabethmcglothlin5406 4 роки тому +2

    The whole inhumation and cremated remains would not be that different from our cemeteries today. People buried in expensive coffins, near urns, possibly right next to, or on top of grandpa.

  • @pattimartin7250
    @pattimartin7250 4 роки тому +3

    I love that wild coot Phil.

  • @maeve4686
    @maeve4686 3 роки тому +1

    Happened to watch Raiders of the Lost Ark last night. Lo and behold, Dr. Jones referred to a cist with the "c" enhanced instead of a "k" sound. Thought of Phil's pronunciation correction immediately....what sticks in one's mind after repeatedly watching the TT series....

  • @wildeyedgirl
    @wildeyedgirl 5 років тому +2

    Love this show😄

  • @johnbryant8603
    @johnbryant8603 5 років тому +3

    Always on task. Thank you for these shows, they’re very stimulating, & you really don’t need Francis Prior. 🤔🎩❤️

    • @corneliawissing7950
      @corneliawissing7950 3 роки тому

      Oh yes, we do.

    • @richardphillips6281
      @richardphillips6281 3 роки тому +1

      Just because you don't like what Francis said doesn't mean he is wrong or superfluous to the programme. For heavens sake he studied, learnt and wrote about things using the knowledge he gained. As part of TT he has tried to educate us about a history which he knows a lot more about than you or I. It's ok if you don't like religion and it's rituals but its been part of life for all of history.

  • @annk.8750
    @annk.8750 2 роки тому +1

    The wheel house would have been a way to build something that could have been roofed over with smaller lengths of wood to support the roof, when larger trees were simply unavailable.

  • @kittydigs6469
    @kittydigs6469 5 років тому +1

    My favorite episode!👍

  • @lspthrattan
    @lspthrattan 4 роки тому +1

    I love this show! That said, I have a question about the pottery....wouldn't ancient potters, faced with sandy clay, have figured out how to use cloth bags and whatnot to screen the sand out of the dirt, let what's remaining stand for a few days to settle, then poured off the excess water, to purify the clay?

  • @betty5064
    @betty5064 4 роки тому +2

    Someone loved the woman in the cyst, look at the beautiful stones.

    • @underwaterdroneservices7292
      @underwaterdroneservices7292 4 роки тому

      That's what I was thinking. The artist must have agreed because the rendering made her out to be a lost beauty. It seems that lifestyle 3000 years ago would just be the constant struggle to survive but I think this proves that romance was a thing even then. This ended up being my favourite episode and I think it was because of this burial since you can get a sense of the adoration and pain of the loss.

    • @velvetindigonight
      @velvetindigonight 4 роки тому +1

      You two need to meet!

  • @daniellekleynhans8562
    @daniellekleynhans8562 4 роки тому +12

    Concerning the door that had been filled in: what if they filled it up simply so they could take the door away to somewhere else without the house filling with sand or animals? The team stated that wood was scarce on the island, and the reconstruction pictures they showed had wooden doors. That would make the door the most valuable part of the house.
    And with sheep the people may have had to move around a bit to find grazing for them, so having houses in different spots would be useful, but furnishing doors for all of them would be difficult. The solution? Take your door to the house you want to live in, and fill up the doorframe of the house you're leaving with rubble to keep the indoors intact 'til you want the house again.
    Just a theory. Thoughts?

    • @helenscott8202
      @helenscott8202 4 роки тому +1

      Danielle Kleynhans seems very practically reasonable.

    • @guycampbell733
      @guycampbell733 2 роки тому

      I know this is an old comment, but I think it's most likely that the recreation was wrong. It also showed all the round house roofs held up by timber thatched with reeds

  • @bilgeratjim
    @bilgeratjim 7 років тому +19

    @18:37 Does Phil know how to shovel dirt or what?!! ARRGH!

    • @haroldraby
      @haroldraby 7 років тому +2

      Blacque Jacque Shellacque; It's the shovel, it's magic. He sleeps with it under his bed.

    • @KD6OTTEMMA
      @KD6OTTEMMA 6 років тому +1

      Phill is shoveling sand not dirt.

    • @jamespfp
      @jamespfp 5 років тому +7

      IKR?? Yes! And not only can he handle a shovel, but mostly, when he wants to use one, he starts with a bloody great back-hoe, then switches to a trowel for 90% of his time, before using a shovel to throw the piles into a waiting sieve.
      This is utterly sideways to the discussion about Phil -- but did you know that the French word for "cleaning" or "tidying" is "ranger"? When he throws the shovel-full of material into a sieve, he's *ARRANGING* it for even more careful observations.

    • @arthurdewith7608
      @arthurdewith7608 4 роки тому

      beer helps him

    • @meemurthelemur4811
      @meemurthelemur4811 4 роки тому

      @@arthurdewith7608 beer helps everyone 😁

  • @TheSukitani
    @TheSukitani 8 років тому +16

    Beautiful, how they laid the woman to rest.

    • @craigjack260
      @craigjack260 7 років тому +1

      Dooky Boogerflicker she also had a line of boots that she named after herself

    • @haroldraby
      @haroldraby 7 років тому +2

      TheSukitani; I suspect that she was venerated because of her age. At 35 - 45 she was well past the average life expectancy in her family/tribe. Their lives probably ended, on average, below 30 years. But, yes. I see a great deal of respect.

    • @velvetindigonight
      @velvetindigonight 4 роки тому

      So agree............

  • @jonathaneffemey944
    @jonathaneffemey944 9 місяців тому

    Thanks for posting

  • @thomascarven1186
    @thomascarven1186 6 років тому +1

    Great episode. I miss the show!

  • @degmar
    @degmar 5 років тому +1

    18:39 - that's some talent Phil!

  • @bokhans
    @bokhans 4 роки тому +2

    A cist (/ˈsɪst/ or /ˈkɪst/; also kist /ˈkɪst/;[1][2] from Greek: κίστη, Middle Welsh Kist or Germanic Kiste, Swedish: kista.) is a small stone-built coffin-like box or ossuary used to hold the bodies of the dead.

  • @benediktmorak4409
    @benediktmorak4409 Рік тому

    good for the team that there is always a pub around at the end of the day!!!!!!!

  • @markmalasics8413
    @markmalasics8413 4 роки тому +8

    Thanks to the internet, this is now one of my favorite programs. Real people performing real work and getting results. Nothing like this is on American TV, simply because we Yanks are too shallow and stupid to make programming that actually teaches something. Our populace eats up shows like American Idol, The Bachelor, The Bachelorette, America's Got Talent, etc. You can forget any show dealing with anything other than people yelling and screaming (singing?) and hopping and jumping around (dancing?) to become a major hit show; no grey matter required to watch that lot of broadcasting rubbish.
    One thing that I am disappointed in, however, is the idea of the show producers to add a female host just for the sake of making the program more "politically correct". For how many years did this show manage to get along and become immensely popular without the cast being mucked around with in such a major fashion? It's a shame that Mick Aston felt the need to quit because of this, but I certainly understand and agree with his reasoning. The program isn't the same without him, and the introduction of a piece of fluff to the cast has done more harm than good.

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому

      Although she's highly qualified in archæology you are _right._ She hated how she was made to look like a _dumbbell_ and left after one season. The motive behind the changes made at that time were probably to make it more saleable to the *USA* networks. It didn't work.

    • @nastybigJim
      @nastybigJim Рік тому

      Apparently you've never watched british reality shows, they are equally trashy as the american ones and have a huge audience. Watch Pbs specials or Nova if you want to be entertained without the goofy nonsense.

  • @joshwood241
    @joshwood241 5 років тому +1

    In case youre curious I believe this settlement was named Allasdale when it was discovered. As far as I can find though not much has been done with it since this episode

  • @rayerscarpensael2300
    @rayerscarpensael2300 4 роки тому +1

    The sketches are superb, fine artist. Rien Poortvliet like.

  • @OstblockLatina
    @OstblockLatina 3 роки тому +1

    3:40 - I can hardly believe I have to say that but, not for the first time in this show, a kist is basically the same as a chest. It's virtually the same word, just altered a bit throughought the centuries of etymologic evolution. Like "Kiste" in German. Which means a chest (one you would put things in and close with a lid).

    • @lizzy66125
      @lizzy66125 2 роки тому

      in Dutch it is 'Kist',usually referres to a wooden closed box.

  • @pianochannel100
    @pianochannel100 4 роки тому +1

    This one was really interesting!

  •  6 років тому +3

    Some day tent and windbreak technology will arrive on the islands and they'll be able to get out of the weather while excavating.

  • @magdatorruellas9122
    @magdatorruellas9122 5 років тому +1

    Tyme Team ROCKS!

  • @capie44
    @capie44 4 роки тому +1

    I wonder if Archaeologists in the future are going to watch this show to review this site and will think, "Barbaric."

  • @lisakilmer2667
    @lisakilmer2667 7 років тому +6

    I wish I could find this story on the Historic Scotland website. I wonder if they knew they needed to do a rescue and called TT because TT had the infrastructure necessary to activate digs - I mean all the office people plus the archaeologists already lined up. I wonder if Historic Scotland called and TT said, yes we can do this instead of whatever is on our line-up, but our people are only available for three days...

  • @birddog7492
    @birddog7492 4 роки тому

    It seems to me that these were a wonderful people who lived in the islands. Gropes of farmers and hunters as well as craftsmen and fishermen. And we can tell they had great respect for their dead.

  • @gdhse3
    @gdhse3 6 років тому

    So cool!

  • @Tsumami__
    @Tsumami__ 9 років тому +10

    Seven kids in the whole school? *Damn.*
    We're 25-35 kids a *classroom* in America.

    • @mrspone1000
      @mrspone1000 8 років тому +3

      its a very small island

    • @stevenwilson6450
      @stevenwilson6450 6 років тому

      +Spone Mr, with very few small people.

    • @rkbranson2334
      @rkbranson2334 5 років тому

      Ok

    • @bluewolf993
      @bluewolf993 4 роки тому

      Yeah when they said there were 1,000 people there I was mentally comparing that to being a little less than HALF of my daughter’s high school. About 2,200 kids for grades 9-12. That’s a lot more than 7!

    • @innesmacneil
      @innesmacneil 4 роки тому +1

      I'm from Barra and back then, there were many schools across Barra, one in each town, but now there is a one main school in Castlebay with about 150 students in it :)

  • @a.azazagoth5413
    @a.azazagoth5413 Місяць тому

    12:37 that clay was perfect to work with , it just lacked sand which was everywhere near the site.

  • @iwbthree
    @iwbthree 8 років тому +1

    Great program ! Keep it going !

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому

      After 20 years it stopped - sorry. There were a few later _specials_ and *DigVentures* has taken the spirit (it's on YT).

    • @georgedorn1022
      @georgedorn1022 3 роки тому

      @@philaypeephilippotter6532 An update on the future of Time Team:
      ua-cam.com/video/Zj2bjBLSqcE/v-deo.html

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 3 роки тому

      @@georgedorn1022
      Ta.
      I was aware of it and I've said my tupporth there.

  • @MissCattitude63
    @MissCattitude63 11 років тому +11

    Reijer, I suspect you're either Dutch or South-African. Anyway, you don't have to answer that ....
    Thank you for uploading the most informative and entertaining series on the planet.
    I used to live in Britain and I used to watch Time Team all the time. Then I had to move back to the Netherlands (work, one has to eat) and to my dismay, they'd never heard of TT. Probably because most archeology here has been tarmacked over or is being used as a medium for German graffiti. Nobody seems to care...

    • @lizzy66125
      @lizzy66125 2 роки тому

      my story is similar to yours, now back in the Netherlands after 30 years U K.used to watch this on the telly.

  • @adamsjerome1839
    @adamsjerome1839 3 місяці тому

    When my fathers bomber had finished a raid and were returning home they often flew over the North sea. I gathered that he would have taken flack rather then ditch in the North sea .

  • @SandyRiverBlue
    @SandyRiverBlue 4 роки тому +1

    This is really odd. The potter must not source her own clay or she's used to sourcing only high quality clay. There are methods for refining clay to remove excess sand. Its time intensive but doable.

  • @philippenachtergal6077
    @philippenachtergal6077 5 років тому +2

    I love how we get to follow their reasoning.

  • @Philrc
    @Philrc 10 років тому +23

    portaloo? I thought it was the Tardis.

  • @predawntomcat5694
    @predawntomcat5694 7 років тому +13

    I live in barra

    • @No_Fuse8771
      @No_Fuse8771 5 років тому

      My family is from there, I'm a McNeil. As far as we can tell the first one of my family came to the USA in 1889 to Charlotte North Carolina. I have tried twice to go back and visit but have not been lucky enough to make it yet. Yes, our name got changed from MacNeil to McNeil. I don't know why or when.

  • @jimmcintosh9045
    @jimmcintosh9045 4 роки тому

    Walking the beach at Baleshare on Norh Uist I saw the top of a skull where the the ground had been eroded back by the sea. There apparently the area used to be an old burial ground I think from a few centuries ago(18th?). Atlantic storms had also swept away a village between North Uist and the Monach Islands.

  • @peterpoole3311
    @peterpoole3311 5 років тому +1

    Love TimeTeam

  • @simhifree2416
    @simhifree2416 4 роки тому +2

    I'd like to know if each identified Cist had any stones with a natural circle on them. I thought I saw two in the video. Thank you.

  • @lameesahmad9166
    @lameesahmad9166 3 роки тому +1

    I wonder if that wheel house idea progressed into the cashel (Forgive me if I have the spelling wrong) which later was constructed in Scotland?

  • @frankpierco8826
    @frankpierco8826 3 роки тому +1

    'kist', with a 'k', to this day means trunk or , depending on the context, coffin in the Dutch language. That might shed some light on the question of the enclosures being 'cists' or 'kists'?