Which QB Will Have the Best Rookie Season?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 тра 2024
- Which QB Will Have the Best Rookie Season? Caleb Williams, JJ McCarthy, Bo Nix, Jayden Daniels, Michael Penix, & Drake Maye all could start at some point during the 2024 NFL Season. Which rookie quarterback produces the best debut season? #broncos #vikings #bears #patriots #nfl #falcons #commanders #commanders #quarterback #rookie #brandonperna #thatsgoodsports
Subscribe:
ua-cam.com/users/thatsgoo...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @thatsgoodsports
My Coffee Company, Benchwarmer Brew:
bit.ly/3oFe1op
Patreon Website:
/ thatsgoodsports
MERCH: thats-good-sports-merch.creat...
Charity: solvingkidscancer.rallybound....
Writing Help by Will Keys @GuillermoLlaves
Editing @johnny_barks
PO BOX
21699 E. Quincy Ave.
Unit F BOX 139
Aurora, CO 80015
Patreon Website:
/ thatsgoodsports
Twitter: / brandonperna
Facebook: / thatsgoodbroncos
Instagram: / brandonperna
Arizona Cardinals, Atlanta Falcons, Baltimore Ravens, Buffalo Bills, Carolina Panthers, Chicago Bears, Cincinnati Bengals, Cleveland Browns, Dallas Cowboys, Denver Broncos, Detroit Lions, Green Bay Packers, Houston Texans, Indianapolis Colts, Jacksonville Jaguars, Kansas City Chiefs, Las Vegas Raiders, Los Angeles Chargers, Los Angeles Rams, Miami Dolphins, Minnesota Vikings, New England Patriots, New Orleans Saints, New York Giants, New York Jets, Philadelphia Eagles, Pittsburgh Steelers, San Francisco 49ers, Seattle Seahawks, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Tennessee Titans, Washington Commanders - Спорт
Perna's copium dealer is putting down payments on a yacht
Down payments? Man bought it outright
I thought he bought the yacht already and was starting a remodel on his house next?
In this case it isn't copium, it's hopium. The copium dealer comes into play mid-to-late season. Plus he's still in Fiji from last year's earnings.
@PapaTroll86 probably the same dealer just different products
Wouldn’t be surprised if by this time next year, he’s finalizing the purchase of his own private island.
I have watched 30 seconds of this video and I am already certain that perna is going to say Bo Nix. He will dress it up nicely and fairly, and then take a left turn and pick Bo Nix because “fuck you, go broncos”
Fuck me, I’m good.
@@jasonhendrick1271yeah bro 😂😂😂😂 I’m like halfway in and this man is really on some hopes and dreams. Hating on the Seahawks while coping over hiring their coaching staff. What a laugher 😂
Hope rules in the off-season
So why are you here? 🤔
Is perna a hopeless romantic? Yes. Do we love him for it? Also yes.
Bo Nix will have a great rookie season as he sits on the bench and learns from Zach Wilson 😂
Yep. He'll learn what NOT to do😂
Perna’s gonna ban you for this lmao
As a jets fan, you will see bo nix by week 4
@@priestsonaplane2236 Do not fuck the coaches number one.
He's going to learn how to pick up moms 😂😂😂
That Poles/Williams laughing clip almost drove me insane
that shit had me dead😭💀
Caleb time mf
I wonder who the bears are going to draft as their new franchise QB in 3 years?
As a rabid bears fan, it made me laugh pretty good
@@munchenonyou3774 I'm a bears fan also but I was unprepared for that sequence.. almost gave me a stroke 😆
Perna's copium dealer: "This man is putting my kids through college!"
He must've gotten the copium lased with lsd and hopium
To be fair he probably will. Whether that's another season of "the new^25 worst game of all time" or its "the greatest rookie QB game 1-2-3"etc 😂
I’m not sure what he on rn 😂
I honestly belive he's set up to do well. He has his favorite reciver, he can throw and doesn't play hero ball, the o line is pretty good. Caleb has a terrible coach, bad line, and does too much. Daniels is up in the air and more competitive division. Drake has a poverty twam. JJ's problem is that division, he has Jefferson with a good O line and RB
Bo Nix may know football but Bo don't know the Broncos management 😆
Zach does, their wives. Just saying.
@@thomasdeas1941 ha ha 😄
poor Brandon. Suffering from DHS - Delusional Hopium Syndrome. I kinda hope Nix does well or else we'll see Perna's supervillain arc commence.
I love Perna and I have nothing really against Bo Nix, but I'm ngl I kinda hope he's terrible just to see Perna's mind crumble
As a cardinals fan i had that in 2022. Rough stuff
I wanna see that arc lol
@@natem1579Perna after Nix's first start - "I love the pain.... The pain is the truth".
Thank you Brandon for talking yourself into this, seeing you suffer is not the same if you are not horribly optimistic before.
Perna is smoking that good shit from the rocky mountains again 😂😂😂😂
Brandon "I never tire of having horrendous takes that come back and bite me" Perna
It's all for the algorithm baby, you say crazy shit and people can't help themselves
Plot twist it’s actually Joe Milton 😂
Ngl it would be hilarious if Kirk gets benched at some point this season and the Falcons find out Penix is better and that they just wasted $100+ million on their backup
I hope they both play like crap and they somehow end up drafting another QB in the 1st round next year, even funnier
The big mystery: is there an injury clause in Kirk's contract?
Common sense says yes but Kirk’s ego says no
@@plantex625 Saints fan?
Most likely what will happen.
I'm getting retread feel of Brandon when he was drunk on Russel Wilson saving the Broncos.
The "go fuck yourself" at the end got me 😂😂
Watching this channel for a while still hasn’t prepared me for the oddly random apple fetish that’s been tracking for the last couple of months
Before I clicked on this video: "I know he's gonna say it's Bo Nix, but I wonder what else he has to say."
The Bears O-Line isn't nearly as bad as Justin Fields made it look. Not just because he held the ball too long, he more often than not stepped outside of his pocket and then set up. Tyson Bagent 4.3% sack rate in 3 games. Fields 12.9% either the o line Hated Justin or he was the problem.
Ah yes let’s compre 3 games to 3 years.
@@Disxreetare you trying to say Bagent would eventually be sacked that much also? If so you're wrong. It isn't a stat that usually fluctuates a whole lot, you are who you are for the most part. Fields spent 3 years running around as soon as his 1st read was covered, sometimes he made an amazing play but most of the time he made things worse. You Fields truthers are nuts.. we all know why you do it, but come on. It's 2024, he got every opportunity.
@@AceManning18Dude ....Fields wasn't it, neither is your new Fields. Brace yourself for that.
@@troymash8109Caleb doesn’t play like Fields
@@Disxreet dalton, foles, siemian, peterman, and bagent (qbs who started > 1 game for the bears the past 3 years) all had lower a sack%
The Bears OL was not good last season? According to ESPN analytics the Bears OL ranked 2nd in the NFL in run block win rate and 5h in the NFL in pass block win rate last season. Which is pretty remarkable given how bad Patrick and Whitehair were at center and backup guard. The Bears replaced them with Shelton and Bates which represent a fairly big upgrade even if they are just average.
Justin Fields was responsible for a large percentage of his sacks last season. One of his many issues that dates back to Ohio State.
Those ESPN stats are absurdly bad. The Lions offensive line was considered at worst a top 5 unit and yet according to ESPN they were 13th in both pass and run block win rate. I'm sorry but the Bears o-line was not twice as good as the Lions.
Not only that, they also have the Lions 31st in run stop win rate when the team LITERALLY allowed the 2nd fewest rushing yards and 3rd fewest yards per carry.
Not a single Lions defensive lineman made ANY of their rankings despite a top 3 run defense and Alim McNeil and Aidan Hutchinson are objectively no worse than top 15 at their positions.
AND Penei Sewell is possibly the best tackle in football AND he's a better run blocker than pass blocker and yet again ESPN doesn't even have him listed at all in their run block win rate rankings.
Oh and none of the Lions interior lineman made the pass block win rate rankings either despite yet again being objectively great players.
It's not just my opinion, like it's straight up fact that these ESPN stats are egregiously inaccurate. I love stats and I've never seen a site with stats that are just unfathomably wrong. Like truly just wrong. You don't even have to look at other sites, you can just see if with your own eyes.
And I think the Bears are going to be good. Those 3 receivers are all great. Caleb BY FAR should be the best rookie QB. I'm just blown away how Brandon could even come up with this shit. I love him but this video was just sad.
Bo Nix has barely any weapons to throw to, an average offensive line, and a defense that's not going to help much. The Broncos legit have one of the worst rosters in the league. I don't know how anyone could possibly think Bo Nix is not only going to be good, but the best rookie? Come on man. It's Caleb and its not even close.
@@MrBigShottyou just sound like a lions fan
Can’t wait to see him throw lots of Nix-Sixes
That laugh loop of Caleb Williams and Ryan Poles had me in stitches
Caleb of course
I genuinely enjoy your videos. And agree with you on most things
Man the comedy clips in this video were just ourstanding. I was wheezing I was laughing so hard at the dan snyder one and the bourne one. This is why we love you so much Perna, you educate, but you hide it under a sweet coating of comedy so we don't even realize we're learning!
Dj moore is a top 5 wr and keenan allen had 100 catches last year. I dont think bears fans are in the wrong for thinking we have a top 5 wr room. Odunze is just the cherry on top.
Vikings fan. If we’re just comparing the top two guysom each team, I’d take Jefferson and Addison, but yeah, the Bears go three deep, and the Vikes can’t compete with that.
Top 5 wide receiver? No. He's very good, but top 5 is crazy.
JJ
Jamar Chase
Tyreek
AJ Brown
Davante Adams
CD Lamb
Then you have guys like Cooper Kupp [when healthy, better] Deebo, DJ Moore, etc
Bears fans, I swear
@@AceManning18DJ Moore was 6th in receiving yards last year with a Quarterback whose career high in passing yards in a season was just over 2500.
Put him with any of the QBs of the top 5 guys and a guarantee you he’s in the conversation at minimum.
Pfp checks out
@@AceManning18DJ Moore ranked 10th in the NFL last season per PFF. He was top 10 in yac. Allen ranked 11th in the NFL last season per PFF and was top 5 in 3rd down conversion. The only other team with WR’s ranked higher was Miami with Hill and Waddle if I am not mistaken.
Bo nix glaze is strong with this man
Ya Know BP, after receiving much lolz from your suffering over the years. I truly hope this kid works out for you man, you are a true fan and I appreciate that about you.
Another great video. keep it up
If anyone is curious, fast forward to 15:19 for Maximum Pern
I don't think I want to be exposed to a "gut instinct" like that intro again
I love seeing you have hope. That's going to make the end of next year that much more satisfying.
Bro that bo nix finding lumps joke had me in stitches
“Darnold might fuck around and look great”. Best line I’ve heard in a long time.
Looking forward to the 600k subs like an odometer rolling over awesome I’ve been watching since 60k!
damn the bias is insane
my english teacher saw the title and had a stroke
I wish I was smart enough to understand why
@CokeZorro I think it's because of "which". It should refer only to things, never to people - so the correct form would be "WHAT Rookie QB..."
I think so at least? Don't trust me, I'm not a native speaker lol
I never understood why English was a class. I speak English. At least pretend to be teaching us something. Then they'd get mad at me for falling asleep.
@@taynanvasconcelos7392 if the correct word is indeed “what”, I am gonna have to protest because it sounds infinitely worse.
Naw, 'which' is correct in this case. Like, 'Which teacher is better at teaching English? instead of 'What teacher is better at teaching English?'
Oh Perna…I’m a big fan. Been watching you since the “worst worst” game ever. Your channel grew as Denver crashed and I think you have a TON of growing to do now. Nix is going to make people forget Leaf and Jamarcus Russell as far as busts go…and I’ll tune every week to get your reaction ✌️
That’s the hottest 💩 take so far
So basically, you're saying you haven't been following Perna for very long at all
@@fastpitchwhiz I’ve been here before superbowl 50. I’m saying if you think Nix is going to be worse than Russel and leaf- you have shit for brains. Funny how Brandon liked/responded to everyone but your comment; says enough.
One thing no one seems to mention when it comes to the 2023 Patriots is the OL injuries. They had eight different starting OL combinations and the run game AND QB issues stemmed from that. When healthy, they were good, and if they can stay healthy this season it will improve the offense dramatically
Good Lord they better tell Drake Maye to ride pine for a year and let Brisset mildly simmer.
@@toyotaecwI have a feeling Jake Brisket with a good Oline will smoke a lot of teams.
I’ll see myself out.
@@903lewI think he could put together a solid 10-7 season if the OL is good, the run game is strong, and the defense remains top 5 in the league. I just don’t think he’s ever gonna be the QB that “cooks,” he just manages the game like he’s supposed to. Hence, mildly simmer.
@@toyotaecw He smokes. Because he’s called ‘Jake Brisket’. Low and slow. Keeps it juicy.
they don't mention it cause they don't keep up with all the teams lol
So nice to see Perna hopeful for the next season 😊
I love what you said about the beard I’ve been saying that my damn self 😂
1) Caleb Williams
2) Caleb Williams
3) CALEB WILLIAMS
4) SERIOUSLY I HAVE PEOPLE TIED UP IN MY BASEMENT AND IT HAS TO BE CALEB WILLIAMS OR ELSE
Most normal Bears fan
Bad news for you
Williams is a head case, he'll bust and bust hard and fast
@@theblackflame4002 thanks for the analysis, please do not ever become a GM of any team
@@masonmacomber Kid runs into the stands to curl up with this mother. What's going to happen when he has a game where the line gets him sacked five times and he throws two picks? Talent is there, but nothing else.
We have 9 (maybe 10 if tampering suspends Kirk for a bit,) underclassmen starting Qbs this year. That feels really fucking impressive.
3:40 Caleb Williams had only a 3% clean pocket scramble rate last year, which was one of the lowest among top QB prospects over the last 5 years
I don't understand the hype in this guy honestly. I think Michael Penix and Jaydon Daniels are better.
Perna's vacation uploads feel like he's speaking to us from beyond the grave
I bought an Eberfluss at IKEA. Great toilet!
The way these prediction videos are rolling out I'm waiting for both a 2025 and 2026 mock draft 😮
So close to 600k!!!!!
Oh shit gotta hop on the alt accounts
Everyone out here arguing over which QB will have the best rookie season
Me, just wondering when the TGS theme music/intro changed
He uses both now! But I love that new one. I noticed it first thing a few weeks ago
The old intro still had the old Instagram logo from before 2016 so it’s safe to say a change was welcome “though I do miss it”
14:53 ouch that screenshot hurts, that game was a thing of nightmares
you should make more rookie skill position analysis
you looked like Seth Rollins in that picture of you topless 😅😂
Preordered my Nix jersey while watching. He’s indeed been blessed.
Watched 3 different videos with 3 different projections. Guess we will have to wait and see.
This is the second UA-cam channel I've seen that has used that "rocky mountain hi" clip hahaha
Lol saying Keenan Allen didn’t do anything with Herbert- did he call a timeout when the Raiders were going for a tie that would’ve put both teams in the playoffs? Did he blow a 27pt lead to the Jags in the playoffs? Did he not have to carry the offense when Mike Williams went down with an injury and then Brandon Staley finally did enough to get himself fired?
Yes I’m looking forward to seeing what he can do knowing he doesn’t have the worst coach in football and is expected to be the #2 possibly #3 option on offense. 🐻🔽
Red Delicious disrespect will not be tolerated Perna 😡
I don't know who will be the best QB in this class. Or who will have the best rookie season. But I can say that if it's JJ McCarthy I'll actually be stunned.
McCarthy is the next GOAT.
How? Bro is basically getting put in an identical situation he was in Michigan, and he won a championship so he should do great
Williams will have best rookie season, best career, best everything
Idk, Stroud had a phenomenal rookie season
Yeah, no way Caleb beats CJ. Even with the weapons in Chicago he's got issues that need refinement.
@@HippyHousepretty sure he’s talking about this years QB class. Don’t think it’s even close honestly.
Disagree
False
Fun fact about red delicious apples: they were previously developed as the name implies, a taste oriented apple, and were deservedly favorite for a long time. As supermarkets became bigger and more about appearances and aesthetics, the variety slowly changed from being a taste oriented variety to being a looks oriented variety, with larger and more bruise resilient apples within the type becoming dominant and the tasty ones becoming less dominant. Thus, the nasty, mealy Red not-at-all Delicious apples we have today.
Off season video idea. Rank every NFL teams final draft pick of the year. Talk about what there ceiling/ highest potential is and things like that. Could be talking about the next Brock purdy before anyone knows it.
As someone who is reading American Prometheus that plutonium reference was 👌
Is it just me or does it seem like you jinx the Broncos with videos like this lol. Whatever happens to Bo it's your felt 😂😂
Finally someone talking rational about Caleb Williams. You have to have a well-run organization for a QB to succeed, which the Bears haven't had for a long time. They're all on the hot seat, that's why they went out and just tried to grab all the biggest names they could. Good players can't fix bad leaders.
Caleb Williams will be the only day 1 starter. Marcus Mariota will start until week 3, Jacoby Brissett will start the whole season, Sam Donald will revive his career in Minnesota, Zack Wilson might start until week 6 and the only way that Penix will play is if either Cousins gets hurt or they secure a 1st round bye in the playoffs
Yeah, Penix and Nix did not give up a lot of sacks....while also not playing in a strong defensive conference.
Loved that Jayden Daniels will be getting T’d off on because we’ll be down 5 scores and the only change we made, according to this video, was hiring Dan Quinn.
Not like we signed a number of good defenders in FA, and had a hell of a draft…
Informative video. You sure get deep into the details.
There will be 6-7 new starters on their defense.
I want to hold the same optimism you have for Nix in Denver, even though I'm not a broncos fan. but given the broncos reverse Midas touch with signal callers after manning, it shall remain to be seen. more teams should draft their QB's in the 7th round anyway. Sure, you're more likely to get Swag Kelly than Brock Purdy but you may just find Brock Purdy!
As usual, top tier edits on today's video with special shout out to Dan Oppenheimer Snyder 7:29 ...that was epically done
When you talk about overall efficiency from staff, coaching, teammates, & system. I would put my money on McCarthy. He has all the weapons necessary, a great offensive coordinator/head coach KOC, & the Vikings facility & staff is rated one of the best in the league.
Here I was looking for a video from you, And viola, Here you are.
Bo nix made macorkle look like a manning in their two college matchups
It’s bc he does not have that good of accuracy his completion percentage is highly inflated due to screens and rpos
Nitpick: Bears got Odunze with the 9th overall pick, not 10th.
The bears offensive line was ranked #2 in run block win rate, #4 in pass block win rate, and #4 in total block win rate. Our biggest problem was Justin fields holding the ball too long the problem is Caleb does that too sometimes but our O-line is way better than what he had in college so hopefully we can train that out of him.
How’d I miss this 😅🥲
I'm leaning towards Bo Nix. He does everything well and will be the starter from week one.
On Shane Waldron: He more or less called the same plays, the OC before him called, so it is rumored that Pete Carrol had him call the plays he wanted. For example he nver used to throw over the middle of the field, just outside. So as for his new OC job, his real playcalling style will show itself.
HOPEFULLY we get a decent class 3 years from now.
Snyder quoting the Bhagavad Gita was brilliant.
Another banger
Odunze was the 9th overall pick, not 10th. And accrd to ESPN, Bears had top 5 pass protection and top 3 run blocking...
Brandon knows to upload so I can listen on my drive home
Keep your eyes on the road
Almost 600k
Honestly, Nix has a solid situation, so I wont argue hard. Honestly if JJ gets the start in Minn, he'd be my guy, just because Bears and Wash have question on their Olines.
QBs these days sure do love wearing that number 10! I don’t blame them tho. When I created QBs in Madden I used 10 often
Aaron Rogers goes down on the 4th play of the season again. Jordan travis takes over the team and wins offensive rookie of the year.
Who is Jordan Travis? Tyrod Taylor is the Jets backup QB…
Congrats on 600k perna!
3-5 i definitely agree. I could see Nix over Williams...I also could see Willams over Nix😂
Ultimately it will have to do with Williams and any drama he may bring for me to say he will be #1. I just cant past that
As a Broncos fan….im here for the bias Broncos content
GOD BLESS BO NIX
Excited for that 4-13 season from the broncos with Nix having 15+ interceptions lol
I almost completely agree with your list, but I'd flip-flop JJ and Caleb
you are fucking hilarious Perna ... and that taint no lie
New Season, New Broncos QB and Perna is back!
There goes that broncos optimism again. Can't wait for the retrospective episode at the end of the season.
Your boy Bo Nix is my sleeper for OROY.. it’s gonna be between him Caleb and MHJ or Nabers. A 4 man race. Another sleeper is Legette in Carolina.
"this is still Washington" is something you can say about Chicago too
That gut has gotten us this far, don't let us down now
as a pats fan that take was solid
Might fuck around and look great, shit was funny!
Jordan Travis. 5th round 3rd string qb at the Jets. He will end up playing 7 games this season and will win the starting job.
At best, Nix is sneaky athletic. If anything, he is gritty.
Perna isn’t even huffing copium at this point. Man is just straight up mainlining it through an IV . For your sake I hope your dude works out.