Y'all really missed out not getting to see Prime Michael Vick. Dude had a run game like Justin Fields with a 80 yard missile arm like a Josh Allen. Soooo much fun to watch. All these running QB's are eating now because of this guy.
Vick sucks he is a terrible person. Great player, but a terrible excuse of a human can't stand him. He had it all and blew it. The guy shouldn't be on my TV anymore.
The problem was that Vick couldn't hit the broadside of a barn with his arm. Roddy White didn't become a Pro Bowler until Vick's Dog Incident and Joey Harrington was throwing to him. That's right, Joey Bust Harrington made Roddy White a Star for Matt Ryan to use, not Vick. He was a sub 1k receiver with Vick.
I really appreciate the choice of words in saying Michael Vick made the worst decision instead of mistake. He knowingly and willingly did those things, it wasn’t an accident and using the right words is important in my opinion
Pets are not people but still should not be treated with cruelty. As someone who has two dogs and not a fan of dog fighting, I still think the response and penalty was way over the top. It bothers me when animal cruelty has penalties that often exceed assault on humans.
My favorite Jamarcus Russell story is when the Raiders coaches suspected he didn’t watch film so they sent him home with blank tapes and asked him if he watched the footage the next week and he answered yes 😂
In my opinion, Matthew Stafford is a REALLY underrated QB. He didn't have a lot of playoff success but his regular season numbers aren't too bad especially when he had Calvin Johnson
As a Dolphins fan, i loved Andrew Luck as a QB. Indy did not protect that mann. He took a beating but still played his ass off. And the fans did him wrong by booing him on his way out. He deserved a better offensive line and a ring.
Don’t be delusional if Indy still had Luck you would be in the same place you are today, which is Irrelevantville Indiana. The same place you were before you sucked into the Manning lottery and the same place you’ve been since you drove the only good QB you’ve had out of town.
Carson Palmer was one of those players that if a few more things would have gone right would be considered a legendary player. His career was just snakebit.
As a 49er fan I always liked Alex Smith. He was atrocious as a rookie but got better every year. Year two a 62 yard block by Alex Smith won them a game against Arizona to put them into playoff contention given a terrible division. If it wasn't for an absolutely incredible muffed punt he would've lead us to the Super Bowl, had a good chance to win it given the opponent and would've continued his very good play with Harbaugh's scheme. (That's no shot at Kap as he played as well as he possibly could have those two following years). His comeback following that injury was nothing short of incredible. Niner's did him wrong and I'll say that as a fan. Hats off to that guy both on and off the field.
That’s the Midwest for you love you when it looks good hate you when you’re gone. If you’re not who the media talks about they’ll tear you down even if you had a shit team or O-line
@knoxnottingham194 bro he didn't quit lol his body was breaking down lop he had multiple concussions on top of other injuries, he retired so he can be here for his family
Alex Smith is a true fighter! Huge props to his daughter for supporting him through it all. I can relate-I've been through a brain tumor myself, and it’s an incredibly tough journey.
It’s funny how quickly the world has changed, even since Reggie Bush. His “character issues” are now completely acceptable, as they should be, and no team would consider taking a RB number 1.
He should’ve been able to perform with Deandre Hopkins, Larry Fitzgerald, and A.J. Green on the team but he couldn’t. What’s the excuse? 3 generational receivers
I agree. Per game it's the most physically demanding, but over recent history they only play 16-17 games. Each game it's incredibly taxing. The other good example is playing 82 NHL games of less often contact, but when collisions happen they are often at speeds that exceed average nfl short length sprint speed at a rate 33-50%. I'm not disagreeing, there's a reason NFL teams only play once a week, but based on numbers I don't think it's the absolute example of most physically taxing sport. But according to ESPN screen time, the NHL hasn't existed since Gretzky. So maybe I'm hallucinating a sport that isn't real
I glad you called Rams patriots a casual fans nightmare. A close game that’s controlled by the defenses is still a good game. Casuals just wanna see TDs and crazy plays and when I went to school on that Monday, I knew who the casuals were when they said that was a crappy game. Glad you called it out
michael vick should have never been able to ever play again and should have been in jail longer .. he’s a sick person and the fact they allowed that is crazy
Eli was one of the few people to beat Tom twice and in his day when it mattered most you could count on him. My favorite thing to hear at the time as a giants fan was on nfl network.. and Deion sanders during the highlights of the giants would randomly shout I believe in Eli!!!! Was he messing around sure did he truly believe in Eli, at the time yes he did and his word I’ll take any day because that man’s a legend.
@@pathutchison7688 man who cares anymore Steelers need to worry about winning some playoff games and finding a future qb fuck tj watt always injured when u need him ass.
Just watched this and then got to the part where you showed your face and was like holy shit! this is sweatband tv LMFAO. Instantly put it together with the voice and face. Used to watch your content all the time. Crazy to see you growing yet another UA-cam channel. Respect man
Say what you will but Vick in his prime was something that has never been repeated. Mahomes is great but even he doesn’t compare. Vick was the speed and running of Justin Fields with the cannon of Bret Favre.
Except he never won anything and was nowhere near as accurate as Brett Favre. Bro never made it out of the divisional round and he won’t ever be a hall of famer by his own doing because he missed out on half of his prime years.
Do you remember Phil Dawson the most because he carried Cleveland to the any of their wins they got? Cuz he was the points leader almost every year??😂 He was Cleveland's MVP. Then he turned into the Niner's MVP and carried the Niners and led them in points.😂😂😂 Phil Dawson is a true OG frfr. I could be wrong tho. Did Dawson go from San Fran to Cleve?? Or was i right??
Michael Vick stole dogs.. your dog, my dog, for ‘practice’ fighting, which means they steal dogs so their fighting dog can practice and kill our dog… that’s what Mike Vick did.. that’s dog fighting, it’s sick af
I love football playing at watching it and I love the history behind I'm really happy with what you doing and you speak really well great details I'll be watching more of your videos keep them coming thank you for doing this
Am I going insane or did you just fully ignore Joe Burrow making it to the super bowl? You mention he had comeback player of the year then skip to him losing the AFC Rematch in 2022 but state it as if it was his first appearance in the AFC championship. Great video and super fun watch but I feel like you under researched or under sold Joe Burrow's career thus far
I believe Eli and Rivers from 2004 will be joining the other 2004 Quarterback, Eli's brother, and Eli's Super Bowl opponent in Canton, but unlike Ben, Peyton, and Tom, he won't be first ballot.
Stafford imo is the best #1 pick of all these players. Bro got one year on a well rounded team and won the super bowl lol and he was amazing that post season. His no look pass in the super bowl was unreal. As far as talent he is one of the best to ever play. Arm talent alone probably ranks top 5 all time.
Wow there’s a lot of really good pics and then you get a pic like JaMarcus Russell hopefully Caleb Williams will be good then Bears fans will actually have a reason to watch their team
David Carr was a very talented quarterback but he got beat to death in Houston. It ruined his career. I remember watching games with him in it getting hit so hard that I could not believe he got back up, the defensive lineman would be in his face immediately after he snapped the ball. He had the worst offensive line I have ever seen
that is right. We were at the initial game where they beat the cowboys in their first game ever but even then it was hard to watch how many sacks and hurry ups he had to deal with and it got worse throughout the season. It was a horrible expansion team o-line and then he lost his confidence after the first 2 or 3 games.
The Andrew Luck one still hurts. Never do we get to see a great like Manning, get followed up by arguably the next best thing to him. He had that ability to flip a games momentum. Sucks Grigson never protected him
Same story for every player on this list. They get drafted by the worst teams with the worst owners and have basically zero chance to succeed. The only way any of them make it is to survive with their body intact to the end of their rookie contract and then move to a team that can nurture their talents long enough to see a return for their investment.
American football is the most brutal sport since the age of Roman Gladiators. But as an Australian, I’m so glad you guys play it. Because it’s entertaining as any sport 🏈 played anywhere on the planet. The arguments about rugby or American football being tougher is stupid as hell. Because it’s not even close American football is easily the most violent sport of the modern age!!!
Hey, Indy didn't draft Luck because Manning left for Denver. He was still on the team in 2011 when they sucked, but became a free agent and Indy wasn't going to sign him back because they thought he was still hurt. You made it sound like Manning left indy, it was Indy that didn't want Manning any more.
Carr was beat down in houston by a terrible O-line. Had he gone to lets say andy reid hes a hall of famer. Anyone beat up like he was would never be able to succeed
I get the sense you weren’t around during a lot of this. David Carr was sent to slaughter in Houston. And in 07 the Giants didn’t just beat Tom Brady, they beat probably the best team of all time certainly to that point. Tom hadn’t reached his final form
I don't think there's any doubts that Eli Manning is a Hall of Famer. He beat the Patriots not once but TWICE in the SB... One of those wins denied the Patriots of the perfect season. On the last drive in one of these SB wins, it was all Eli with a great catch by David Tyree. This in addition to his individual numbers is enough to get him a HOF jacket. It won't be first ballot but he will get there
@@atg1338 football is a TEAM sport, correct? Let me answer that for you... YES. So... You can't put the TEAM's overall record on him unless he literally lost the game for his team. I wouldn't consider Mario Manningham's catch "lucky" when you look at his position and the VERY small window he had. That's a SKILL that only a person that makes a living doing it. And you can't argue his INT record... Brett Favre has more than anyone in NFL history and he's in the Hall.
@@atg1338 You're right... I'm ignorant for trying to explain football to someone that can read stats but clearly doesn't understand the difference between team stats and personal stats. Now who's the ignorant one? Or... Are you one of these people I've been warned about? Are you the "I'm a prepubescent that just got my 1st phone and I'm attempting to blend in with the adults?" You did say something that I will agree with tho... However, I'm gonna put a twist on it. I am ignorant in the fact that I'm trying to explain football to someone that is ALL AROUND ignorant. No matter what I do, how I explain it or how dumb I dumb it down, you won't get it. Football = TEAM sport. Team = 53 men. Offense = 11 men. Defense = men. QB = 1 man on offense. While the QB is always the first person to get blamed for a TEAM losing their game, even before the coach, the QB isn't the one that's at fault. Bad play calls by coaches, dropped passes, fumbles, penalties and the zebras are ALL contributing factors to a TEAM's loss. My advice to you is STOP blaming the QB for the loss and look at the ENTIRE game. Most of the time... It's a bad penalty call that costs a team if/when the game is close. If it's a blow out, there's usually several reasons for it. But it's NOT ALWAYS THE QB. If you believe that, pull your head out 💩
Michael Vick was an absolute monster. I actually know a guy who picked off of Mike Vick in college and went to the redskins training camp, before getting hurt. I always wonder if he would’ve made it.
Andrew Luck... Managed to do the right thing when his body began giving out on him. As Patriots fan I saw a lot of him and enjoyed watching him play. I know, easy to say because we had Brady and Indy wasn't as much of a threat as the Peyton led Colts were. Though I remember an announcer would say that Manning was zero and Brady at Foxboro...
Alex Smith was a much better QB than his early stats showed... He was held back by different Offensive Coordinators every season for the 1st 7 seasons, 3 different Defensive Minded Head Coaches who were horrible, & 17 different receivers... Alex Smith did enough to win many of the games... Way too many games were lost due to coaching decisions... the 49ers would be up by less than 7 with 2 minutes or less to go & just need a 1st down to close out the games & the Coaches got conservative & would expect the Defense to hold the opponent & then the 49ers would lose on the final play...
No Eli's NFL Career IMO is not HOF worthy. He was the QB on those 2 wins but wasn't even in the top 5 best player on his own teams, nor was he the reason they won. You don't need a ring to be worthy of the HOF, and having rings doesn't automatically make you worthy to be in it.
Besides his playoff/SB success, eli was incredibly mid. Whether he is HOF worthy is something idk if I'd be able to answer. And I'll still argue that tj watt should have won DPOY in 2023. He was statistically better in almost every way than Garrett.
Playoff and Super Bowl success is much more important than regular season success. If that was the case Tony romo would be a first ballot hall of famer.
Where you get drafted matters, when a franchise gets the #1 pick MULTIPLE times in a 10-15 yr span should tell you something. Eli is gonna end up in the hall of fame and literally is a .500 QB and all his playoff wins came from those two Superbowl runs. Carson Palmer could of been a great if not getting drafted to Bengals and you kinda glossed over he had to retire for a year before Bengals would trade him, should tell you how bad Bengals were back then, literally the only NFL team that didn't have an indoor practice facility.
Eli really doesn’t deserve to be in the HOF he had two magical playoff runs and that’s kinda it. 4 pro bowls isn’t the greatest and he wasn’t a top 10 qb during his era
@@Infinite12334winning two super bowls doesn't mean he thrived. The comment is absolutely right other than two magical playoff runs. The dude did nothing. Plenty of quarterbacks thrived in the Brady era. Eli Manning was not one of them.
@@Chilly_Dawg44 so what you're saying is that it doesn't matter what else he has done, as long as in 2 games in his long career he beat Brady then that makes him hall worthy?
@archmage7813 it's not just 2 games. You have to get there somehow. And we are talking about he beat the greatest qb in nfl history. Not just some qb who showed up in a superbowl like burrow or Jimmy G or Purdy or hurts
Use code FANTASYPHENOMS50 to get 50% OFF your first Factor box plus 20% off your next box at bit.ly/4cN2hbw!
Y'all really missed out not getting to see Prime Michael Vick. Dude had a run game like Justin Fields with a 80 yard missile arm like a Josh Allen. Soooo much fun to watch. All these running QB's are eating now because of this guy.
Fields?....Vick was way better.
Vick sucks he is a terrible person. Great player, but a terrible excuse of a human can't stand him. He had it all and blew it. The guy shouldn't be on my TV anymore.
Maybe everyone here saw him play live. What do you mean we missed it, dumb dumb?
He got out of the ghetto but couldn't get the ghetto out of him, gotta watch who you're friends are
The problem was that Vick couldn't hit the broadside of a barn with his arm. Roddy White didn't become a Pro Bowler until Vick's Dog Incident and Joey Harrington was throwing to him. That's right, Joey Bust Harrington made Roddy White a Star for Matt Ryan to use, not Vick. He was a sub 1k receiver with Vick.
Bro said nothing about burrow leading the bengals to the Super Bowl
Or anything about Palmer leading the cardinals to the Super Bowl against the Steelers
@@ianmeyer4290you mean Kurt Warner? Ur an idiot
@@ianmeyer4290 Kurt Warner not Palmer
I think he's just replaying old content from years ago because he didn't mention Stafford winning it all with the rams
@@Tawfiq.yea he did 😂
I really appreciate the choice of words in saying Michael Vick made the worst decision instead of mistake. He knowingly and willingly did those things, it wasn’t an accident and using the right words is important in my opinion
Pets are not people but still should not be treated with cruelty.
As someone who has two dogs and not a fan of dog fighting, I still think the response and penalty was way over the top. It bothers me when animal cruelty has penalties that often exceed assault on humans.
My favorite Jamarcus Russell story is when the Raiders coaches suspected he didn’t watch film so they sent him home with blank tapes and asked him if he watched the footage the next week and he answered yes 😂
In my opinion, Matthew Stafford is a REALLY underrated QB. He didn't have a lot of playoff success but his regular season numbers aren't too bad especially when he had Calvin Johnson
Alex Smith is a fighter! Big ups to his daughter! I also had a brain 🧠 tumor.
He's beast who comes back after an injury like that
If Joe Namath can be in the HOF you have to add Eli to the HOF
@@atg13382 SB MOST VALUABLE PLAYER says otherwise
Joe Namath sucked
If u put Eli in guck it Phil Simms did the same thing he did
If u put Eli in guck it Phil Simms did the same thing he did
@@youngf.l.y.1467 Eli sucks yall blow him for those super bowls
As a Dolphins fan, i loved Andrew Luck as a QB. Indy did not protect that mann. He took a beating but still played his ass off. And the fans did him wrong by booing him on his way out. He deserved a better offensive line and a ring.
Luck could’ve come to the Dolphins, I would’ve liked that.
@@mlm32809no one wanna go to dolphins
Colts fan here. If we still had Luck, the AFC would be so much different now
Don’t be delusional if Indy still had Luck you would be in the same place you are today, which is Irrelevantville Indiana. The same place you were before you sucked into the Manning lottery and the same place you’ve been since you drove the only good QB you’ve had out of town.
Man even as a Texans fan i was a huge Luck fan.
Carson Palmer was one of those players that if a few more things would have gone right would be considered a legendary player. His career was just snakebit.
Shout out to Alex Smith
As a 49er fan I always liked Alex Smith. He was atrocious as a rookie but got better every year. Year two a 62 yard block by Alex Smith won them a game against Arizona to put them into playoff contention given a terrible division. If it wasn't for an absolutely incredible muffed punt he would've lead us to the Super Bowl, had a good chance to win it given the opponent and would've continued his very good play with Harbaugh's scheme. (That's no shot at Kap as he played as well as he possibly could have those two following years). His comeback following that injury was nothing short of incredible. Niner's did him wrong and I'll say that as a fan. Hats off to that guy both on and off the field.
Colts fans are a disgusting group for how they treated Luck when he retired
@@taewilson94 that’s why they’ll never be good again and seems like Richardson can be injury prone too
That’s the Midwest for you love you when it looks good hate you when you’re gone. If you’re not who the media talks about they’ll tear you down even if you had a shit team or O-line
Colts were disgusting when they snuck out of Baltimore. The only thing worse was the Browns sneaking into Baltimore
Ik man it’s weird bc they’re a great fanbase I’m sure they were just disappointed in luck giving up.
@knoxnottingham194 bro he didn't quit lol his body was breaking down lop he had multiple concussions on top of other injuries, he retired so he can be here for his family
Alex Smith is a true fighter! Huge props to his daughter for supporting him through it all. I can relate-I've been through a brain tumor myself, and it’s an incredibly tough journey.
I can't believe Andrew Luck played with a torn right labrum. Also you missed that Burrow made it to the SB.
It’s funny how quickly the world has changed, even since Reggie Bush. His “character issues” are now completely acceptable, as they should be, and no team would consider taking a RB number 1.
It just proves a QB just needs the right system to have success
Cardinals should ride it out with Murray
@@BrandonHardaker cardinals are never winning a superbowl might as well pick a different team.
We will
Kyler is a beast he just needs more help he’s literally carrying our team
He just had the best game of his career.
He should’ve been able to perform with Deandre Hopkins, Larry Fitzgerald, and A.J. Green on the team but he couldn’t. What’s the excuse? 3 generational receivers
Eli Manning is the luckiest SOB in the history of the NFL.
3:06 I’m sorry, the Falcons started CHRIS CHAN 🤣🤣🤣
With the full power of Sonichu…hater 😂 😂😂
I agree. Per game it's the most physically demanding, but over recent history they only play 16-17 games. Each game it's incredibly taxing. The other good example is playing 82 NHL games of less often contact, but when collisions happen they are often at speeds that exceed average nfl short length sprint speed at a rate 33-50%.
I'm not disagreeing, there's a reason NFL teams only play once a week, but based on numbers I don't think it's the absolute example of most physically taxing sport.
But according to ESPN screen time, the NHL hasn't existed since Gretzky. So maybe I'm hallucinating a sport that isn't real
The video quality is hilarious. It's amazing how fast technology moves.
I glad you called Rams patriots a casual fans nightmare. A close game that’s controlled by the defenses is still a good game. Casuals just wanna see TDs and crazy plays and when I went to school on that Monday, I knew who the casuals were when they said that was a crappy game. Glad you called it out
michael vick should have never been able to ever play again and should have been in jail longer .. he’s a sick person and the fact they allowed that is crazy
You sniff your dog's ass, don't ya?
You sniff your dog's ass, don't you?
If you can throw a ball and run fast people will forgive anything you do
Eli was one of the few people to beat Tom twice and in his day when it mattered most you could count on him. My favorite thing to hear at the time as a giants fan was on nfl network.. and Deion sanders during the highlights of the giants would randomly shout I believe in Eli!!!! Was he messing around sure did he truly believe in Eli, at the time yes he did and his word I’ll take any day because that man’s a legend.
Just found your channel man love your commentary
Eli is hall of famer
If his names not manning he’s not a top prospect and benched way sooner
Anyone who haunts Brady’s dreams should be a hall of famer
@@bradmorgan3797 "I'm Eli Manning and I'm nice. Tom Brady is the goat? Sike I beat him twice" 😂. Gotta agree with that I take back what I said.
“eli manning is hall of famer” 🗿
He beat Brady twice. Brady beat him 4 other times. Sure 2 Super Bowl nice career. It’s the defense that won the superbowl. He was horrible
Garret doesn’t even deserve that DPOY. TJ Watt was better in every stat and in impact.
@@pathutchison7688 man who cares anymore Steelers need to worry about winning some playoff games and finding a future qb fuck tj watt always injured when u need him ass.
Don’t glaze Watt he will never be more impactful than his brother
Bradford o lines were hella elite in his highlights he hardly got touched
He won the Heisman and very few Heisman QBs have had successful careers in the NFL.
Well he had Jeff Fisher as a head coach.
Just watched this and then got to the part where you showed your face and was like holy shit! this is sweatband tv LMFAO. Instantly put it together with the voice and face. Used to watch your content all the time. Crazy to see you growing yet another UA-cam channel. Respect man
@@vizthekid3470 ayeeee it’s a small world! Glad to have you watching brother🙂
@@FantasyPhenoms You’re killing it with the algorithm apparently. cuz this video got recommended to me and was instantly intrigued to click. good work
@@vizthekid3470 thank you!
Stealing two rings from Tom Brady should be a HOF worthy accomplishment.
Im a panthers fan and when I say that watching 2015 highlights gives me tears it really does cuz now I don’t even want to watch them play.
Say what you will but Vick in his prime was something that has never been repeated. Mahomes is great but even he doesn’t compare. Vick was the speed and running of Justin Fields with the cannon of Bret Favre.
Except he never won anything and was nowhere near as accurate as Brett Favre. Bro never made it out of the divisional round and he won’t ever be a hall of famer by his own doing because he missed out on half of his prime years.
he was a better runner and faster than fields. As for throwing, strong arm but very inaccurate.
Do you remember Phil Dawson the most because he carried Cleveland to the any of their wins they got? Cuz he was the points leader almost every year??😂 He was Cleveland's MVP. Then he turned into the Niner's MVP and carried the Niners and led them in points.😂😂😂 Phil Dawson is a true OG frfr. I could be wrong tho. Did Dawson go from San Fran to Cleve?? Or was i right??
Dawson was a Punter you slapdick
Michael Vick stole dogs.. your dog, my dog, for ‘practice’ fighting, which means they steal dogs so their fighting dog can practice and kill our dog… that’s what Mike Vick did.. that’s dog fighting, it’s sick af
You Dog Lovers are a special breed of obsessed....
Kyler deserves another year imo
@@georgesamuels4511 don’t matter never winning a Super Bowl
This aged well. He looks great so far.
Respect for Alex Smith is all the way up to the ceiling 📈 it’s staying up there for the rest of time
I love football playing at watching it and I love the history behind I'm really happy with what you doing and you speak really well great details I'll be watching more of your videos keep them coming thank you for doing this
Am I going insane or did you just fully ignore Joe Burrow making it to the super bowl? You mention he had comeback player of the year then skip to him losing the AFC Rematch in 2022 but state it as if it was his first appearance in the AFC championship. Great video and super fun watch but I feel like you under researched or under sold Joe Burrow's career thus far
I believe Eli and Rivers from 2004 will be joining the other 2004 Quarterback, Eli's brother, and Eli's Super Bowl opponent in Canton, but unlike Ben, Peyton, and Tom, he won't be first ballot.
I think it's only right that I take the videos that made me the most money and mash them all up into one video so I can make more money. Geniius
Legendary
Hey, I'm late to the party. Keep up the good work. You have a great voice and cadence for your videos.
The smartest player on this list is Sam Bradford, he still stayed with his parents when he signed his massive contract 👏🏿 👌🏾
He is Now the Official Backup to Matt Stafford! Big fan of Stet! The Mailman Always Delivers!!!
Stafford imo is the best #1 pick of all these players. Bro got one year on a well rounded team and won the super bowl lol and he was amazing that post season. His no look pass in the super bowl was unreal. As far as talent he is one of the best to ever play. Arm talent alone probably ranks top 5 all time.
Wow there’s a lot of really good pics and then you get a pic like JaMarcus Russell hopefully Caleb Williams will be good then Bears fans will actually have a reason to watch their team
It’s hard for Trevon Walker to stand out with black Josh Allen on his team.
David Carr was a very talented quarterback but he got beat to death in Houston. It ruined his career. I remember watching games with him in it getting hit so hard that I could not believe he got back up, the defensive lineman would be in his face immediately after he snapped the ball. He had the worst offensive line I have ever seen
that is right. We were at the initial game where they beat the cowboys in their first game ever but even then it was hard to watch how many sacks and hurry ups he had to deal with and it got worse throughout the season. It was a horrible expansion team o-line and then he lost his confidence after the first 2 or 3 games.
6 sacks but so many other hurry ups or hits and it was a massacre for Carr even though they won the game.
The Colts did Luck almost as dirty as they did Manning.
The Andrew Luck one still hurts. Never do we get to see a great like Manning, get followed up by arguably the next best thing to him. He had that ability to flip a games momentum. Sucks Grigson never protected him
Alex smith is a dog tho
He really is
do NOT tell Mike Vick
@@maxkiller8165 nah💀
@@maxkiller8165noooo wayyy haha
Personally i think that alex smith is hall of fame material... look at what he overcame just for football
Eli isnt a hall of famer IMO. He probably gets in though on his name.
The Browns deserve what they are getting
Definitely hes a hall of famer. Eli winning when it counted. If i needed a clutch 2min drive to win the game. Elis my pick
Wild Carson Palmer only had 1 fr good season with the bengals.. I guess I just remember him being around and good for longer
Same story for every player on this list. They get drafted by the worst teams with the worst owners and have basically zero chance to succeed. The only way any of them make it is to survive with their body intact to the end of their rookie contract and then move to a team that can nurture their talents long enough to see a return for their investment.
Andy Reid is the ultimate 2nd chance guy
American football is the most brutal sport since the age of Roman Gladiators. But as an Australian, I’m so glad you guys play it. Because it’s entertaining as any sport 🏈 played anywhere on the planet. The arguments about rugby or American football being tougher is stupid as hell. Because it’s not even close American football is easily the most violent sport of the modern age!!!
Hey, Indy didn't draft Luck because Manning left for Denver. He was still on the team in 2011 when they sucked, but became a free agent and Indy wasn't going to sign him back because they thought he was still hurt. You made it sound like Manning left indy, it was Indy that didn't want Manning any more.
It’s amazing how these guys get paid and production goes down
Carr was beat down in houston by a terrible O-line. Had he gone to lets say andy reid hes a hall of famer. Anyone beat up like he was would never be able to succeed
I get the sense you weren’t around during a lot of this. David Carr was sent to slaughter in Houston. And in 07 the Giants didn’t just beat Tom Brady, they beat probably the best team of all time certainly to that point. Tom hadn’t reached his final form
down voting, how did you not mention burrow going to the SB in his 2nd year after beating mahommes?
You cant tell the story of tom brady without eli manning. Hall of fame for suee
@@atg1338definitely can't seeing as he choked 2 super bowls to him😂
@@atg1338I thought the patriot psychos died when Brady left the pats but wow guess not.
@@atg1338the defense didn’t choke the 2007 Super Bowl was a defensive battle the whole game 😂
@@atg1338 no it was patriots giants the year the 2007 patriots went 19-0 then lost the Super Bowl to Eli
@@atg1338 2007 season you know what I meant lmao
Eli is easily a HoFer
Dropped a like can tell u put time in this ty
I don't think there's any doubts that Eli Manning is a Hall of Famer. He beat the Patriots not once but TWICE in the SB... One of those wins denied the Patriots of the perfect season. On the last drive in one of these SB wins, it was all Eli with a great catch by David Tyree. This in addition to his individual numbers is enough to get him a HOF jacket. It won't be first ballot but he will get there
@@atg1338 football is a TEAM sport, correct? Let me answer that for you... YES. So... You can't put the TEAM's overall record on him unless he literally lost the game for his team. I wouldn't consider Mario Manningham's catch "lucky" when you look at his position and the VERY small window he had. That's a SKILL that only a person that makes a living doing it. And you can't argue his INT record... Brett Favre has more than anyone in NFL history and he's in the Hall.
@@atg1338 You're right... I'm ignorant for trying to explain football to someone that can read stats but clearly doesn't understand the difference between team stats and personal stats. Now who's the ignorant one? Or... Are you one of these people I've been warned about? Are you the "I'm a prepubescent that just got my 1st phone and I'm attempting to blend in with the adults?" You did say something that I will agree with tho... However, I'm gonna put a twist on it. I am ignorant in the fact that I'm trying to explain football to someone that is ALL AROUND ignorant. No matter what I do, how I explain it or how dumb I dumb it down, you won't get it. Football = TEAM sport. Team = 53 men. Offense = 11 men. Defense = men. QB = 1 man on offense. While the QB is always the first person to get blamed for a TEAM losing their game, even before the coach, the QB isn't the one that's at fault. Bad play calls by coaches, dropped passes, fumbles, penalties and the zebras are ALL contributing factors to a TEAM's loss. My advice to you is STOP blaming the QB for the loss and look at the ENTIRE game. Most of the time... It's a bad penalty call that costs a team if/when the game is close. If it's a blow out, there's usually several reasons for it. But it's NOT ALWAYS THE QB. If you believe that, pull your head out 💩
Seems like most of the #1 picks never turn out to be the best player in the draft. Especially if its a quarterback
Hard to put up develop with a bad oline, bad receiving crew.
Michael Vick was an absolute monster. I actually know a guy who picked off of Mike Vick in college and went to the redskins training camp, before getting hurt. I always wonder if he would’ve made it.
Andrew Luck... Managed to do the right thing when his body began giving out on him. As Patriots fan I saw a lot of him and enjoyed watching him play. I know, easy to say because we had Brady and Indy wasn't as much of a threat as the Peyton led Colts were. Though I remember an announcer would say that Manning was zero and Brady at Foxboro...
hearing the panthers dominating is something we will never see now...
Should have put the Factor add before Jamarcus Russel
i feel so bad for caleb williams😭his o-line couldn’t be worse right now
Alex Smith was a much better QB than his early stats showed... He was held back by different Offensive Coordinators every season for the 1st 7 seasons, 3 different Defensive Minded Head Coaches who were horrible, & 17 different receivers...
Alex Smith did enough to win many of the games... Way too many games were lost due to coaching decisions... the 49ers would be up by less than 7 with 2 minutes or less to go & just need a 1st down to close out the games & the Coaches got conservative & would expect the Defense to hold the opponent & then the 49ers would lose on the final play...
Shout to Mike Vick for overcoming so much
Cam newton my goat
3:54 that shit is cursed af. Wtf are the falcons and saints doing in the NFC west
No Eli's NFL Career IMO is not HOF worthy. He was the QB on those 2 wins but wasn't even in the top 5 best player on his own teams, nor was he the reason they won. You don't need a ring to be worthy of the HOF, and having rings doesn't automatically make you worthy to be in it.
Carson Palmer was very good
@@brandonskelton3836 0 superbowls … trash .
Da Red Rifle
@JosephFerguson-bi1ul that's Andy Dalton
As a broncos fan, miss watching luck play glad he walked away the way he wanted to.
Baseball had even more rounds
Stafford is definitely clutch
@@atg1338cuz Detroit had terrible coaching. Hard to win games when it’s just You and Calvin Johnson
Fumbled twice to end the game vs cowboys in playoffs. Not exactly clutch.
You started doing that rant about staying healthy and I swear I thought you were gonna start talking about JaMarcus Russell
No way. He had a couple of good seasons. Led NFL in interceptions several times
Besides his playoff/SB success, eli was incredibly mid. Whether he is HOF worthy is something idk if I'd be able to answer. And I'll still argue that tj watt should have won DPOY in 2023. He was statistically better in almost every way than Garrett.
if eli didnt have manning as a last name i think no one would care about him
Playoff and Super Bowl success is much more important than regular season success. If that was the case Tony romo would be a first ballot hall of famer.
@@bradmorgan3797 im trying to get that eli manning isnt that great considering he had seasons where he led the league in interceptions
@@bradmorgan3797Tony Romo should be in Canton just for becoming the starter in Dallas after being an un-drafted 22:23 free agent
Eli in the HOF? No. Not even close.
Rams v Pats is indeed the worst NFL Super Bowl ever. Specially compared to the previous year.
I'm a crazy chif's fan xazafer worthy good old Andy read
if andrew luck could train anthony richardson, they could be on par to go to the playoffs
Matt Ryan and Matt Stafford should be in before Eli
@@isaiahjgomez1501 Matt Ryan has biggest Super Bowl lead blow and regular season he’s balls.
Where you get drafted matters, when a franchise gets the #1 pick MULTIPLE times in a 10-15 yr span should tell you something. Eli is gonna end up in the hall of fame and literally is a .500 QB and all his playoff wins came from those two Superbowl runs. Carson Palmer could of been a great if not getting drafted to Bengals and you kinda glossed over he had to retire for a year before Bengals would trade him, should tell you how bad Bengals were back then, literally the only NFL team that didn't have an indoor practice facility.
Love these videos
If I head another person say Vick is like fields I’m gonna crack. Fields isn’t even close. Vick was like watching a nfl RBs high school highlights.
As a lions fan Matt Stafford is the biggest what if for me any other team I feel like he would’ve been the best
Tim couch is my cousin. dudes career got robbed by the browns such a shame.
VICK SHOULD BE SHIPPED TO SPACE
I miss cam 😞
Idc what anyone says. Eli Manning deserves HOF for beating Brady in the SB, twice. Brady would have 9 rings if Eli failed. That deserves a spot 💯
Eli really doesn’t deserve to be in the HOF he had two magical playoff runs and that’s kinda it. 4 pro bowls isn’t the greatest and he wasn’t a top 10 qb during his era
Name the amount of QBs that thrived to win 2+ Super Bowls in the Brady era
@@Infinite12334winning two super bowls doesn't mean he thrived. The comment is absolutely right other than two magical playoff runs. The dude did nothing. Plenty of quarterbacks thrived in the Brady era. Eli Manning was not one of them.
@infinityblox1 name any questions that has beaten Brady 2x 😂
@@Chilly_Dawg44 so what you're saying is that it doesn't matter what else he has done, as long as in 2 games in his long career he beat Brady then that makes him hall worthy?
@archmage7813 it's not just 2 games. You have to get there somehow. And we are talking about he beat the greatest qb in nfl history. Not just some qb who showed up in a superbowl like burrow or Jimmy G or Purdy or hurts
In hindsight, Mahomes would have been a number one.