Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Thiagarajan Argues Why States Shouldn't Be Forced To Cut Down Fuel Taxes
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2022
- A day after the Centre reduced excise duty on fuel, several state governments reduced the Value Added Tax (VAT) on petrol and diesel. On Saturday, the Centre had cut excise duty on petrol by Rs 8 per litre and on diesel by Rs 6 per litre to give relief to consumers battered by high fuel prices that have also pushed inflation to a multi-year high.
The excise duty cut would translate into a reduction of Rs 9.5 a litre on petrol and Rs 7 a litre on diesel after taking into account its impact on other levies.
After the Central government’s decision to cut excise duty, several state governments slashed VAT on petrol and diesel.
In an exclusive interview with India Today's Rajdeep Sardesai on News Today, Tamil Nadu's Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan talks about the reduction of VAT on petrol and diesel. Watch here:
#PetrolPrices #DieselPrices #VAT #IndiaToday
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today UA-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
Now I understand why Arnab hasn't invited this man on his debate show.
good catch!
😂😂😂
no one care the lapdog
“Extremely Knowledgeable “. What a man . We are proud of you sir .
I am from Punjab and feeling jealous. Tamil brother are very lucky to have such a knowledgeable fm
You are absolutely right... 👍
Lol, from Tamil Nadu. Go and ask people in TN about him and they will laugh. Just because he speaks good English doesn't mean he is good in financial. TN has 6 lakh crores debt, thanks to this man
🥂PTR is additional power for dravidan party .
@@sancool84sangi it's because of whom?admk right. just tell your sangi govt to give the money TN that you keep on deceiving
@@sancool84 Running a state is not like running a bank. Every developed economy has debt. It is the difference between GDP and Expenditure that matters.
TN's fiscal deficit(diff btw spending and receiving) for first half of 2022 is 3%, which is lower than projected value 5%. Lower fiscal deficit is a direct indicator of developing economy.
BJP is surviving only because of sangis like you.... Poi padi da parama 😆
Kudos to TamilNadu for being fortunate enough to get such a good finance minister !!
lol jain boy. :) DMK slave jain boi.
@Think Right can u list the achievement of bjp ..
@Think Right do u have any means any achievement of bjp led govt
@Think Right see first I don't understand your language and achivement are never hidden .. and i don't read news paper of any language I know the facts as every thing is covered by some news paper .. 1000 dollars means 80 k rs and u said to ration card holder i in hp is living under bjp govt and i never got this 80 k rs .. what are you saying I am asking you the achievement name 10 .. and I ll loose the debate and vote for bjp .. tell me that .. about kashmiri pandit who used to like in Kashmir .. what happened to them is wrong and should not happen to anyone but right now kashmiri pandits in Kashmir are asking for protection and bjp is not giving them any protection.. and they said that they will leave Kashmir .. so talk facts not news paper .. and don't try to be oversmart and write in ur language cause If ll start in my language u won't understand so don't be like bjp .. be like men .. language is a bridge between two people not a barrier .. shame is a word which can be written in different languages but the meaning is same .. shame ..
@Think Right if 1000 donation is a achivement then I guarantee you that make me the prime minister i ll give 2000 dollars
I am too addicted to this interview! I am watching this 100th time. Every time I watch, i am getting high! A strange feeling. Anyone the repeat watching?
Me too
Me 2
me too
I am addicted to see how rajdeep (modi godi media) gets slipper shot
Me too
I Love this statement " that's how i read the constitution" 🔥🔥🔥
He is speaking constitutionally and asking to treat each state equally and independently. Kudos to PTR math working
India has not seen a man like PTR who knows what he's up to. Much respect sir
PTR is a Mr.head weight, Is not having a good knowledge..... He thinks state running Liquor shop is the only way to make money ..... No knowledge of finance ..... Just bla bla... What about other states ...talk about that....
He deserves to be the PM of this country wie!
@@sivapuramsithargal4126 like you ya
India also has never seen a man like Vishvguru who never knows what he is up to.. Wakes one fine morning and announces a hairbrained scheme that he dreams about in his sleep 😄
Thanks Rajiv Sardesai! Keep asking tough questions
First time I see some one who speaks sensible, Tamilnadu people are lucky to have such a intelligent finance minister. looks like He has done all his math well before this interview.👏👏👏
😂😂😂😂😂Why should we feel lucky he is one of us
@@GulshanBajgai55 both are developed
@@GulshanBajgai55 Tamilnadu is better in professional education, healthcare, Industries and Services.
He is right Rajdeep doesn’t know math or constitutional veiw on this matter he does only the political veiw only on this or any matter whatsoever. But I know Rajdeep has really remarkable work in past. He is actually asking a right question but in wrong sense. He should have said “ As the centre has reduced the duty by reduced the duty by 8 percent how you will trickle down this benefit to people of TAMIL NADU”
@@akhlesh1234 useless! PTR is highly qualified person who has Ph.D in Economis in Axford
Most of the Finance Ministers of other states in India will not understand the economics this Tamil Minister is talking about.
Most? None! Not even the union FM!
Yes true.
That is why he led two banks to bankruptcy in US.
@@srm5909 lol. He was not the CEO
@@srm5909 r u idiot???
@@parthatrivedi6853 Exactly.
The Southern states would be better at running India.
But it is unlikely to happen.
Never
Well with delimitation of the lok sabha the representation of south indian states will reduce more significantly. So what you say will only be a dream sadly.
Whoever the best skilled and the best patriotic person must be able to rule the country.
No North South divide.
Now the best person from West India is ruling.
Our former leaders like (kamarajar(king maker)& Karunanethi) were given an opportunity to run the country but they wanted to lead their people to victory not dwell in national politics.. They loved their people and land and language so much and lived by that..
This finance minister is savage. Well qualified and informed. Great argument. Rajdeep was just looking like a novice
Right person holding the right post. People of Tamil Nadu are fortunate to have such leaders.
India needs people like Dr. Thiagrajan as Finance Ministers. Rajdeep couldn't nail him down, dispite his provocative questions. It was the other way round. Dr. Thiagrajan successfully pinned him down.
He called him a cheerleader. Good judgement. He won't ask questions to the BJP. Why?
Too good, Dr. Thiagrajan. Wannakam.
Rightly said
PTR my foot
All journalists are HMV. And are on the pay rolls of the ruling party.
@@PradeepKumar-vp9ti Then, who is above your head?!?
@@PradeepKumar-vp9ti tum jaiso ke bazah se neta head ke uper chadhkrhagte aur mut te hai ...
"Collective insanity" arey FM of Tamil Nadu nailed it 😁
HE IS THE MOST EDUCATED FINANCE MINESTER IN WHOLE INDIAN COUNTRY.
From non recognized university
They why India has many poors and jobless peoples
@@venkatraman2719from when NITs and MIT became non recognized universities?😅
@@venkatraman2719 lmao he is from NIT Trichy and MIT Boston 🤣🤣🤣
@@sachin-ll1by It seems he is from WhatsApp university 😂
We need this type of debates. All States pls appoint finance and commerce background candidates as FM. Thanks to TN Govt. For making Dr. PTR as FM.
Let PTR and debert with Nirmala sirtaran not media
@@ggvggjvj1315 yes nirmala sitharaman should
We have a moron in Kerala, up for sale, but no buyers.
Mr.PTR is one of a kind 🤗
Tamilnadu is fortunate that their Finance minister not only communicate well but he speak from a platform of knowledge and logic .
We are proud of our state Finance Minister Mr.PTR who knows his job very well.
Even 300 years after his death, his name (Aurangzeb) sending shock waves through the spines of sanghies.
Shame on those who dig 300 years old history, playing victim card crying foul.
@⚡️lifewithmishi⚡️ LINDUS ass burning hearing HAZRAT AURANGZEB ALAMGIR name😂😂🔥🔥
@⚡️lifewithmishi⚡️ keep your shit in America. Celebrating 4th of July and coming here educating us about our country. Wait the very next time Donald comes he'll whip all those fake American orses once and for all.
@⚡️lifewithmishi⚡️ aren't you man enough to comment from your own account. Don't use your daughters account man.
@⚡️lifewithmishi⚡️ chutya sanghi bloody tu q bakta hai ,point pe a ja
This guy is a scholar !! great to hear the logic and maths from Mr. Palanivel....looking to see somebody like him to be our country FM; who understands what he is speaking and is implementing in his state.
The same PTRPTR was initially showing dissent to freebies and he declared them unproductive. The DMK Govt resorted to freebies and cash distribution openly with a commercial motive.He knows all that. He knows what is welfare and what is political business. Yet, he is staging a war for his own political mileage. Even if he comes Central FM, he won't reduce a single pie in petroleum prices. Both the state Govts and the Centre jointly levy 54% taxes on petroleum products. No govt is prepared to lose this golden eggs. PTR is cheating his own conscience.
15 lakhs for indians pocket still receiving from 2014. Fraud Modi's 15 lakhs. Think Smartly. Now particular person Privatisation only ongoing subsidy 24 gas petrol diesel essential things rate hike Wavier increased for particular Private Sector. Free for corporate no free for public sector. Think Smartly..
Why can't we have him as our next PM?
Scholars need not be wise. He is not able to see silent aggressiveness by minorities n threatening Hindus.
Proud to be a tamilian and blessed to have such a finance minister. Thank you very much PTR sir. 💯💐
He is dumb person , telling all lies
@@bylaw1987 your comment shows your mindset. You can say in what way he is wrong. Nobody forbid you. What lies he is telling and you must say the truth also
It's really ridiculous to see these sort of dictator attitude in democracy, TN people eat what to elect these family ascendant monarchs in this democratic era
Seripa DMK slave s
Do you know that you are licking karunanidhi family members slippers in this democratic TN era
Imagine if Anna the introducer of DMK have made his family members to ascend as. CM means what could have been happened to Cunning fox karunanidhi family members
It democracy ,party is not karunanidhi family assert
Slave awaken
Now atleast realise democracy is always democracy
Where as family ascendant monarchism is always dictates
karunanidhi family members slippers licking slave in democratic TN era
Answer this why in DMK after Karunanidhi no emminent leaders to lead that party other than Karunanidhi family members,your s and my family also included in this democratic TN?
Why Karunanidhi family members of only promoted to cm chair in DMK party?
Karunanidhi family Kula nashammm than tamil nattu makkkallluku m,DMK virkum ,vidiyal
Vidiya DMK varisul atchii
Frank varisu arasiyal by promoting udyanidhi openly through slave media's ,MPs MLA in assembly speech and so on to add in thier DMK 1 yr achievement
In this democratic era karunanidhi family consistently occupying CM chair in DMK is really a freedom destruction.
Are the TN people are fools and slaves or karunanidhi family members cunning and slaving medias to project them
Whatever TN people slowly moving towards karunanidhi family members slippers licking slaves
@Sunny Gates you are the only knowledgeable person in the universe? You don't have a brain, only cow dung is there. So anyone can't expect decent words from such a person like you.
If you have the brain contact the TN fm and debate with him and prove your brain
@Sunny Gates are you intelligent enough?
I'm just imagining Nirmala Sitharaman doing a debate with the TN FM...
She'll resign
I AM NOT AN ECONOMIST.. I CAN DEBATE AND HE WILL RESIGN... RAJDEEP SARDESAI DOESNT UNDERSTAND ECONOMICS SO HE CANT ASK THE SUPPLEMENTARIES SO HE GOT AN UPPER HAND.... I DONT UNDERSTAND WHY NORT PLACE A PERSON WITH LITTLE BIT OF KNOWLEDGE IN ECON0MICS TO DO THE INTERVIEW.
@@9903943541 why don’t you get a job as a journalist if that is what you wanted to do
You are right
She won't come for a debate 🤣🤣🤣 I'm pretty sure. If she step in Mr.PTR will deal in left hand 😂😂😂
Shiv bhattacharya if you are so proficient in economics why dont you post your questions here itself?
கலைகள் யாவிலும் வல்லவனாம்.. கற்றவர் யாவர்க்கும் நல்லவனாம்..(தமிழன் என்றொரு இனமுண்டு தனியே அவர்க்கொரு குணமுண்டு)...Great Salute to our finance minister!!!
அருமை 🙏
Super
❤
This is the man we need - love from Kerala
Those who have raised the fuel prices ruthlessly.. and reduced a portion of it becomes heroes.. and those who haven't raised it now become villains.. Well said Sir..
Yes Congress raised toomuch.. BJP reduced the price... But DMK only making story...
@@sathishsridharan8797 Sorry bro.. I believed Modi was ruling India for the past 8 yrs.. You opened my eyes in a simple comment 😂
@@sathishsridharan8797 Nehru was the reason 😂😂😂😂 !!
This is the problem with people.. people blindly support political parties despite poor governance and economy… they don’t understand economy that we lost 20 years of growth after demonetization , don’t understand Indian constitutions like they think Hindi is national language. Gosh..Tired of explaining… may be they realize when we have situation like Srilanka…??? May be not , at that time they claim there is SivaLingam beneath White House…
@@jothimsw 🙌
Sardesai sir, don't jump from one to another question before listening the answer to the previous question. The person who answering your question is not a ordinary politician.
Exactly , you are right
@@giveme06 🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@kushjindal2939 Hooo... Sorry 😔 for the error in understanding.
Well said 👏
Its a proud moment , to have our FIN-MINISTER taking state T.N to a better tommorow. We salute you sir
PTR Saab replied wisely n confidently on facts...Salute to you Sir.!
Really surprised to know that Tamil Nadu has educated and talented finance minister. Bravo Tamil Nadu.
What is there to be surprised ??? T N is not Jarkand .😏😣
@@achuthramr5767 lol yes
TN is well educated then and now and ever
It's really ridiculous to see these sort of dictator attitude in democracy, TN people eat what to elect these family ascendant monarchs in this democratic era
Seripa DMK slave s
Do you know that you are licking karunanidhi family members slippers in this democratic TN era
Imagine if Anna the introducer of DMK have made his family members to ascend as. CM means what could have been happened to Cunning fox karunanidhi family members
It democracy ,party is not karunanidhi family assert
Slave awaken
Now atleast realise democracy is always democracy
Where as family ascendant monarchism is always dictates
karunanidhi family members slippers licking slave in democratic TN era
Answer this why in DMK after Karunanidhi no emminent leaders to lead that party other than Karunanidhi family members,your s and my family also included in this democratic TN?
Why Karunanidhi family members of only promoted to cm chair in DMK party?
Karunanidhi family Kula nashammm than tamil nattu makkkallluku m,DMK virkum ,vidiyal
Vidiya DMK varisul atchii
Frank varisu arasiyal by promoting udyanidhi openly through slave media's ,MPs MLA in assembly speech and so on to add in thier DMK 1 yr achievement
In this democratic era karunanidhi family consistently occupying CM chair in DMK is really a freedom destruction.
Are the TN people are fools and slaves or karunanidhi family members cunning and slaving medias to project them
Whatever TN people slowly moving towards karunanidhi family members slippers licking slaves
Why surprised? Is it north India?
I'm surprised by your statement
Great to see someone boldly standing on the facts. We need many PTR's in India to become financially great country...
well said
@Raj Iyer vow...... what a great thought u have.... apt to be in bjp. May be next PM 😂😂😂😂😂
@Raj Iyer Looks like you are a blind follower of Pegasys Spyer Modi Lier. Your name state a lot than your words.
@Raj Iyer then why don't run a ed/cbi test in bjp member's affairs ??! Come on man 🤣🤣🤣 stop using them as tools
@Raj Iyer So afraid of him?
Damn . can't find a better articulated , clear and mouth bashing reply against ridiculed increase of prices . An well educated asset of TN
He is strong enough to handle the "paid news" nonsense from North. Pre-independence we were to fight East india company, now we are fighting out this North Indian bullshits..
This man is my dream Finance Minister. He should be at the Centre.
Yes
But our Modi wants fools should be around him..
So that his incapability should not come out...
Central government needs puppet FM. Modi can't bear him 1 hour even 😂😂
Union there is no center for TN atleast..😅😄
not a pro DMK but so happy that our state finance is in safe hands. matured and detailed FM
Do you know the total debt of your state, about which he hasn't said a word?
@@prasannaraju4895 do you know th debt of nation ?????
@@GarimaGrinds Debt of GoI is 20% of the GDP and the gross national debt(including of states) is 80% of the GDP. No wonder that TN is a significant contributor to the GND owing to the freebie culture prevailing there. TN finance minister should correct it rather than ranting about non issues.
Btw, our GND is much better than other countries among the middle income economies. Large economies are grappling with >100% of GDP debt.
@@prasannaraju4895 dont give lectures to states...when feku cwnt provide 2 crore jobs😆😆
@@prasannaraju4895
Freebie ?
The government is using its income for the benefit of the downtrodden. This is not freebie.
What about all those writing off debts (yeah, i know difference between writing off and waiving off)
When has ever since 2014 Written off amount has been recovered?
If something is given to corporate, no one open your bloody mouth. But when something is spent on the welfare of our simpletons, you call it freebie and shame them.
Shame on all of you. Let the super rich and elites like Ambani and Adani be ashamed for living in poor man's freebie.
Don't bluff without understanding what is social justice and what is accumulated privilege.
Kudos to Mr. Thiagarajan. Excellent.
We the tamilians are very lucky to have him as our Finance minister sir we are very proud of you May God bless you and your family
I am really impressed.. great soul .. solute from Karnataka
This is what you call rock solid literate man .... He is too good ... Rajdeep looked like a illiterate fool
😂😆
It’s not that Rajdeep is illiterate, there isn’t any freedom of press in the country anymore. He has to be sympathetic towards the centre otherwise his channel will be raided by the ED or will be bought like NDTV
I love this guy he is what we all need
Give Some Respect he is our FM
Then come to our state we are always welcome you
Dr.PTR explained with simplicity and clarity. He nailed it!
👌
Not gonna happen 🤣🤣🤣😂😂...
Union FM will not join as she is not having knowledge in finanance.. and PTR is doctorate in finnance.. she cannot stand with him if he ask any simple question...
@@johnsonn3479 keep doing your minority politics. You will remain the same and already Maran Bros are the richest in the TN. Pathetic (Nirmala Seetharaman doesnt know anything that is why she is a FM & this idiot is not even popular within his own cabinet?- same genius said all poll promises are not time bound)
Well said...FM will say go in cycle.
Thyagarajan is a balanced minister. Tamilnadu is a state the other states should follow. Tamilnadu is an intelligent govt. Is peoplecentric.
Tamil Nadu Finance minister is very confident
about his knowledge, experience and his performance : explaining facts and figures.. He knows how to guide his officers. Want such type of talented ministers in their respective field of ministries.
Best finance minister, very bold and educated person. We need such person in central government as well...
all state finance ministers of india should present the facts like him. completely professional .
Professional, You should see him talk Tamizh. All the gaali's, but only if you know Tamizh.
He is neither economicest nor good in finance. We are waiting for that day his announcement of TN government bankruptcy.
@@subramaniyanmanimaran8373 BTW We southies do not comment on what we do not know especially (up top), Unlike our friends from north who claim to know just about anything and everything right from movies to politics of the south. Thought, Vindyas were the only barrier......
@@subramaniyanmanimaran8373 biased statement.
@@subramaniyanmanimaran8373 you mean our beloved oorga maami?
We can fight against the world and we need education. Education is the foundation of a man's courage.
PTR Palanivel Thiagarajan
was born in an honest family. Sir I found only you the courage to speak like Kamaraj sir you told the truth clearly to the media with courage and congratulations live in prosperity people of tamilnadu should excel your service more congratulation to the people of tamilnadu because of PTR.Palanivel Thiagarajan
Apart from Maths, See the beauty of his language flow and the way he delivers!!!!! Tip of his tonge!!!!!! Very Proudof our HONOURABLE PTR Sir!! ✌✌✌✌✌✌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Great
Tamil Nadu - Yes we have our own flaws, but we are sensible, rational people. PTR sir is one of our example mind. Sir huge respect and you made us so proud in north Indian media! Love you loads.
Dr.Palanivel
Proud of you sir
What a talk ?
With good home work
You are the best man to confront godi media
And ardh godis
Will any BJP stupids can claim knowledgeable and compete him? Will Arnab Goswami can make challenge with him on debate? He will screw his happiness.... 👍
Since TN is better with GDP and inflation statistics why can't they pass the benefit of central cut to the public? Also can the Hon FM say what is the amount per litre that the State takes in comparison to the Centre? Truth: much more than Center.
@SRKK K
Ok ...ndhoo
Love tamil minister from Kerala💪💪💪
I’m proud to have PTR as our state’s Finance Minister
I think this should be translated in all languages and sent to northern part of India particularly.
Make this guy the Union Finance Minister. So well articulated. And knows his subject well
Really? 😅😅😅
Southern States are much more Better n Superior than any in Growth, Development, more precisely in Religion & Caste System.
We in Tamilnadu don't divide the state on caste and religion, that's why we are able to keep people playing politics along religion and caste out.
Yedhiku pa DMK kovilgala idhichi thalluranga😡
The centre should return at least 50 paise per rupee out of GST collections to Tamil Nadu. Then it will be quite easy for TN to reduce the petrol price further
Indeed...
Rajdeep tried his best to pin him down but here he had someone superior to his knowledge of Finance. He could have listened to FM instead of continuously talking. Great job FM, Tamilnadu.
TRUE
Well said
Raj Deep got a mouthful from PTR , the pride of Tamil Nadu .
PTR thinks differently and wisely too !
I am hearing PTR for the first time which has created in me a much greater respect for his knowledge and highly convincing arguments. I wish, some day in near future he will be entrusted with responsibility of handling finance portfolio at the Centre.
We want many more such intellectuals from the South.
I belong to a Marathi speaking family of the State of Karnataka and during my professional career of 35 years, have worked under capable Senior Executives from all the four states and can vouch for the intellectual capabilites of many South Indian leaders.
Tamiln voice will be valuable at everywhere ..
We are proud to have you as our Finance Minister of Tamil Nadu. We look forward to seeing you as the Union Finance Minister soon .....
Dr. Thiagarajan take a bow, my only wishful thinking is that there should be more such scholars as you, in all governments. Your arguement was impeccable 🌹🌹🌹
The journalist is thinking he is interviewing a politician from UP or bihar, but boi Thiagarajan is a renowned and sensible minister 😂
South India is the hope of our country!
Well said
😅😅😅
I am from TN, request not to generalize. Personally Knew bright talents from the states you referred.
@@benedictjoseph3832 I mentioned not to generalize, if others have to assess based on our former finance ministers
Countries like india Need Finance minister like Dr.PTR in Centeralcabinet. .proud to be a Fan of PTR..🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
15:50 that's how i read the Constitution 🔥🔥🔥🔥
PTR and Tamil Nadu only have bold to express against BJP
உங்கோப்பணுக்கு அப்பண்டா தமிழன்... தலை வணங்குகிறேன் மதிப்பிற்குரிய PTR அவர்களே....தமிழன்டா....
Wow... Man he nailed out the show with his intellectual. Proud to be a Tamilan❤️🥳👏
He came to India from USA where his funds lost everything of investor money. Investors in fund filed court cases against him. Check his money management track record in investment company.
@@mukut5ul You are a கோமாளி. don't try to make a joke.
P T R 💥
@@mukut5ul company secret ah veliya sollathinga.
@@mukut5ul if you don't l know pls shut up...do you know what is recession? Have you faced it?
I thank God that he gave this man PTR. So much respect on him from my heart. ❤️🙏🏽
Super reply with full knowledge and confidence Mr.PTR, salute to you👍🇮🇳
Awesome speech from TN FM... Need ppl like him to stand up and call the mediocre central policies as useless!! Things are starting to change
When you deal Mr.PTR better prepare yourself ☺️☺️☺️
Wow Our Finance Minister is rocking hats off to TN CM for choosing this gentleman
Rajdeep you can’t question PTR’ns judgment ! He is from another level you have to raise your intelligence to question him
👏👏👏👏👏Mr. Thiagarajan. Loved the way he has his facts and figures at his fingertips and does not hesitate to put forth his points forcefully. Need more FMs like him.
Then why did they give false assurances before TN Assembly Elections?
The bank in which Mr.PTR was working went bankrupt.
He can not talk his mother language Tamil properly.
He has to debate with Mr.Annamalai BJP chief TN with all his facts (???) and figures. I am 100% sure he will fail.
Mr.Ptr has not talked about his own party's election promises to the people of TN.
DMK promised to reduce 5 rupees on petrol, 4 rupees on Diesel and 200 rupees on cylinder.
What they have reduced is only 3 rupee on petrol nothing on diesel and gas.
We have seen dmk's big big election promises from 1967 onwards.
First first they came to power by promising 3 padi ( 'padi' means about 1.5 kg) rice per rupee. But they never fulfilled.
Later they promised 2 acres of free land for poor , but never fulfilled.
This time there are many many promises unlikely to be fulfilled.
@@srm5909 The country for which Modi is PM is getting bankrupt... When will the 15 lakhs be deposited to bank accounts of Indians :)
@@ashleykumar3932
He never said that he will deposit 15 lakhs to anybody's account. This is a made up issue by some oppositions.
If you have proof please give link.
“ You need to do some basic maths “. Loved it. 🥰
Very intelligent finance minister of Tamil Nadu. Loved listening to him. It is tight slap on these Godi media anchors. We need more such intelligent finance ministers.
This minister must become central finance minister
Informative,professionalism,clarity,precise presentation done and especially with the media who is infamous for twisting information. Kudos to you PTR sir!
Educated Ministers like him is what India requires.
Also the political acumen, Manmohan Singh was educated but he did not have the confidence to face the press with PTR’s confidence
Education is only text book knowledge. Experience and sence work much better
@@easyview8566 Manmohan is good in implementation but PTR is a corporate leader who has better speaking skills. That's the only difference between them.
I think he is going to be overtake Chidambaram ....
Does education make him behave like a lout!
Wow... we need such educated minsters. Tamil Nadu is really lucky.
Congrats from Karnataka.
🔥🔥🔥🔥 one of the best fm ever tamilnadu as seen ever 🔥🔥🔥🔥
😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀biggest joke
@@anandr6978 Sanghi naya poidu
That teacher and student moment 😂😂😂 PTR made this guy a low grade student 😂
He deserves...
@@sudaks7363 yeah still he ( and the party slaves him)needs to be reformed more by intellectuals like PTR
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
So happy to have someone who not only knows his job but communicates effectively.Keep it up FM..Truly grateful to our P M for his team .
Being a tamilian very proud to have like this type of FM
We r very lucky to had a Finance Minister like him he is very brilliant 😘😘😘😘
I so appreciate Mr. Thiagarajan, he speaks facts. We need educated and straight forward people in our country. Not the fakus and liars.
he is a cia agent.
He is a nincompoop n so are u.😆
But if he dont want to reduce his taxes, dont do it. No one is forcing him to do so. Dont know why he is getting annoyed when center reduce their taxes
@@jeffmathews363 He is not getting annoyed at centre reducing tax. He is getting annoyed at centre asking states to reduce tax.
When clearly as a well managed and successful state in managing economy, there should be some shame from centre in advising them what to do.
So long we South Indian s are part of North Indian Idiotic insensitive brainless people we won't get educated into politics..
Mr. Rajdeep thanks for such an outstanding interview.
At the same time Indian fanance minister and rbi governor's interview on this imbalances between state and centre must be taken ✅
I salute Hon: Thiyakaraja for his excellent background of financial qualifications and with his qualifications and financial experiences he addressed the issue very well and all the questions raised by the interviewer was well addressed. I am very much appreciate Dr, Thiyakaraja for his brave financial statements and his financial experiences. I believe he is a excellent and appropriate finance Minister for Tamil Nadu and he is even qualifies for Finance Minister of India no doubt. If he appointed as a Finance Minister of India he will do a very good job to the country better than the current buleshit lady finance Minister. Good luck to him.
"That is how I read the constitition" 👍
Ultimate.
My favorite minister. TN is lucky to have this guy.
@@ASMandya "academics achievement " ?? His achievement was closed two international backs due to loss.
😇
@@subramaniyanmanimaran8373 that is during recession
Good guy but in wrong party
@@aprilfool3240 sorry....right guy in fight party..,. that's right you may be a supporter of wrong man in wrong party
This man is a benchmark.
Salute to PTR to Put People in place and you have given the Right reply to the Central People who are riding on people who has no idea on Finance and Basic Maths👏👏..
For the first time Rajdeep seems to be in the backfoot... Don't know why. Exceptional regional leaders emerging, with great skills of oratory and confidence as well. Good informative interview!
Was extremely happy to see the interviewer floundering. This paid channels deserve such awesome snub .
PTR breaks media's nose for their attitude of acting towards the 'master's voice.
The big YES
Are you on drugs. You call sardesai is supporter of Modi
@@jhnknws1751 Really Sardesai is not fully Modi Bakt , he was not earlier, now willy nilly he also has had to toe the line reluctantly .
At least he cooled down to wards the end . And stated his admiration for the extremely knowledgeable PTR.
Jokers like Loud Mouthed Republic TV chap wouldn't have 1) had PTR for interviews 2 ) wd hv tried to shout him down 3) edited the final video .
Desai didn't do this .
Good job palanivel........
@@jhnknws1751 Based on the interview, yes he is and has strongly supported Modi. Will he dare asking any such questions to MoDi or Nirmala. Coward Sardesai...
We need a person like PTR as our finance minister. Its awesome to see his home work
Great Answer From Mr PTR 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👌🏻👍🤝 Knowledgeable Finance Minister
PTR nailed the debate with his financial knowledge and data.
Brilliant brilliant rubattals by Dr. Thiagarajan! There's a lot to learn from this short interaction, not just about the effective state finance management but about the effective use of language as well. Hope to see you as our Union Minister one day.
Hope so 😍
Not just union minister. Want him as union finance minister to improve our economy
I'm waiting!!!
Agreed
It's really ridiculous to see these sort of dictator attitude in democracy, TN people eat what to elect these family ascendant monarchs in this democratic era
Seripa DMK slave s
Do you know that you are licking karunanidhi family members slippers in this democratic TN era
Imagine if Anna the introducer of DMK have made his family members to ascend as. CM means what could have been happened to Cunning fox karunanidhi family members
It democracy ,party is not karunanidhi family assert
Slave awaken
Now atleast realise democracy is always democracy
Where as family ascendant monarchism is always dictates
karunanidhi family members slippers licking slave in democratic TN era
Answer this why in DMK after Karunanidhi no emminent leaders to lead that party other than Karunanidhi family members,your s and my family also included in this democratic TN?
Why Karunanidhi family members of only promoted to cm chair in DMK party?
Karunanidhi family Kula nashammm than tamil nattu makkkallluku m,DMK virkum ,vidiyal
Vidiya DMK varisul atchii
Frank varisu arasiyal by promoting udyanidhi openly through slave media's ,MPs MLA in assembly speech and so on to add in thier DMK 1 yr achievement
In this democratic era karunanidhi family consistently occupying CM chair in DMK is really a freedom destruction.
Are the TN people are fools and slaves or karunanidhi family members cunning and slaving medias to project them
Whatever TN people slowly moving towards karunanidhi family members slippers licking slaves
What a professional finance Manager of Tamil Nadu unbelievable expertise and we Tamilians are proud of you because u dont Mince your words and you mean Business God Bless you respected Sir .
He seems to be very knowledgeable about how to run the economy. If what he said is true then the union Government should take him on board even if he is not from the BJP for the sake of the country.
"Don't be cheerleader" - ptr rocks
Master blaster !
ஒவ்வொரு குடும்பத் தலைவிக்கும் மாதம் ரூ.1000/- திட்டம் (தேர்தலுக்கு முன்னால் சொல்லாத கண்டிஷனெல்லாம் இப்போது சொல்றாய்ங்களே!) சாத்தியமில்லை என்று தெரிந்தும், வாக்குறுதி கொடுத்ததற்குத்தான் "rocks" என்றீர்களோ?
@@malarvizhiut7469 , Which means you doesnt have brain to understand . . .!!!
Wow! What an answer by Thiagarajan with facts and figures, and no beating around the bush.
What facts and figures🤔🤔 he basically dont want to reduce the extra tax he gets on higher fuel prices. Thats all..
@@jeffmathews363 will central reduce then?
@@oscarmicheal3677 yes. Eventually it will go to GST, 28% slab. 14% for centrr, 14% for states. Then you can see states are screaming.
@@jeffmathews363 central earns so much from other sources while state has only this , if they reduce this too wholl pay for the state workers like police and sweepers etc , wholl develop states?? , Central just says it does all job but in reality states provide most of food education and necessities while central wastes money on sources like buying a jet for 35 million which costs 22 million 🤫
@@oscarmicheal3677 dont be a fool., in tamil nadu 48.6% is the petrol tax. State VAT is 30% and center charges 18.6%. This is thr actual problrm state follows.
I never seen Mr.Sardeepdesai has shaken like this in an interview done before.
Well don Tamilnadu Finance Miniater
PTR is a proffossanal politician in tamilnadu.. I have never seen such expert in finance... Keep moving on TN🙏💐
15.50 nailed it 😍. Hands up 🙌 PTR Sir.