Every state should have functioning progressing govt run by smart and accountable leaders who are good at governance rather than just rousing public sentiments using on issues like religion, caste, language, food, statues, etc. Well done Thiru Sri Thiagarajan . Well deserved applause from this non Tamilian who is fed up of national leadership and its hegemony and its bias.
Let him reduce fuel prices instead of blaming every one except himself . What is the achievement of this loud mouth . What was special about the budget he had presented last fiscal . Nothing .
Let him ask to visit usa where he faces court cases by investors who lost their money in his funds. If he visits USA he will be arrested to face investigation.
@@ஜிஜ்ஜக்ஜாமான் if he reduces the petrol prize there will be increase in taxes on other aspects worse than this will happen ,moreover central govt needs to release the gst to tn and they should check the taxes india now in serious inflation if you cut the taxes we are doomed knowing that central govt do that thing.
Wow, at last a minister who knows his subject, can explain his govt's point of view and makes the vital point that a divisive central govt is bound to fail but after doing much damage to the country. Tamilnadu is very lucky
The current union gov does not like wise PPL.. we know what happened to the likes of Raghuram,Aravind. Let ptr do his best in a environment which supports him... hopefully such an environment willncome up in the union soon
Every one get angry if a person didn't get angry then he is not a human. If you know really about ptr you will not tell like this. Even savuku shanker who blasting DMK also told he is the No 1 perfect and good minister in tamilnadu.
Such an excellent talk by Thiagarajan, FM of TN. During his talk he showed what real Class and standard he has. He is also a very highly qualified American returned Person. He is a real asset to DMK and to Tamil Nadu. We wish him all the best.
I came to know for the first time that one Dr.Thyagraj is the Finance Minister of TN. And what a minister he is, clear cut thoughts , studied speech, and self confidence of his, his government, and people of TN. I am seventy+citizen of Satara Maharashtra, but I would certainly like to meet this person if I happen to be in that part of our country.
We as Tamils are ashamed of Nirmalaseetharaman from Tamil Nadu, as this country`s FM while we have excellent Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan.
@@rashikali6403 Is your name a Tamil name Mr.Ali? Is it not Arabic? Since when Bismillah, Ir-rahaman, Ir-rahim became Tamil? Please do not throw stones from inside a glass house.
There is no comparison between India and Tamilnadu finance minister. India need such kind of skill full finance minister. But the most people of India want Hindu Nation not developed nation.
What does it mean that you are saying most peoples of India wanted Hindu nation not developed nation?. The reality is that the people like you with decriminative mind set is living in India so that India is still developing country or developed country. You should leave the country as soon as possible ofcourse will India will be developed nation as soon as possible.
@@nizammvs Are you a real Muslim or converted Muslim. Ofcourse whoever read the history properly, 100% there is no native Muslim like Arab countries. The peoples who saying Muslims in India definitely they were here converted forcefully. Like we can say imported religion from the foriegn countries. If you don't like Hindu peoples, then you cannot live in India peacefully. Becz, on your street your neighbours are Hindus, or food items sellers, milk sellers or in any form without Hindus contributions you cannot live. I think you are more depressed with Hindus. Better you can move to Afghanistan, Pakistan or any Arab Countries. Correct.
@@funn3529 That guy used to have a tea shop. Now he is worth 1000s of crores. Without knowing how to manage finances, do you think he would have made this much money?
This Tamil Nadu Finance Minister really filtered the talks and came down point blank to the subject with clarity. Really appreciate that, he has done his home work very well. His speech is excellent.
@@jaihind3595 Do you have answer for any of his questions ? Or even our Central FM have ? Just telling something not worry about India and keep yourself happy. All the best Also, request you not to keep Nethajis photo here. It is shame to know your carelessness about India.
@@thirupathisundaram2056 she is far better than this chutiyas........centre cut the tax on fuel prices but shameless thiagarajan is not going to lower the taxes .....fucking sucking the blood from common people.
@pudum.. the state once had a CM called Kamarajar(nick named as the king maker) not sure if you find many articles in Hindi or English.. but he is one of the main reasons for TN to be in this position..
@@hrtbeat3124 look boss, I do not fully agree that TN is at good position. My comment was fully inclusive to the virtue of a Doctorate. Very few in Indian politics are at a level of this qualification and importantly of education.
Proud to be the neighbour of Tamil Nadu. I am from Kerala. Strong movements against BJP should come from Tamilians. First movement should be against EVM.
@@sreeram3623 Tamil or whatever. We should not be unduly concerned about his lineage. His eloquence & clarity of thought has to be acknowledged & appreciated
Should have been translated in other languages too, so people can realise how important it is to have knowledgeable, committed professionals as Ministers.
Yes we Tamils know exactly what we do. The peoples without data can't talk or tell people what they should do. There is a big difference between an educated and a normal person.
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd Some might say that but when Congress does that it seems fair to them. They just want to paint tamils as anti bjp. Mostly dmk , muslims and Christians oppose bjp coz they're anti hindu. It's as simple as that. Had it been congress government at the centre with dmk as a part of it then you see no such dramas. Btw, PTR is the best FM for TN now. He's not welcomed by some of his party men for being too good in his job.
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd It's because the previous congress govt was so worse that the people had no other choice. Btw, the MLAs basically belong to congress where, they shifted to bjp. Intrinsically, most doesn't like bjp as a party here, but we had no other go!
எனக்கு ஆங்கிலம் அவ்வளவாக புரியாது ஓரளவு புரியும் தமிழ் மொழிபெயர்ப்பை பார்த்து புரிந்துகொள்வேன் ஆகா என்ன ஒரு தெளிவு என்ன ஒரு தொலைநோக்கு சிந்தனை என்ன சுயநலமற்ற சிந்தனை வியந்து போகிறேன் தமிழ் நாட்டின் பொக்கிஷம் நீங்கள் ஒரு வேண்டுகோள் தமிழ் மீடியாவில் பேசும் தூய தமிழ் அல்லாமல் முக்கிய கருத்துக்களை ஆங்கிலம் கலந்து சொன்னாள் நீங்கள் சொல்லவந்த உன்மை கருத்து மக்களை சென்றடையும் வாழ்க பல்லாண்டு நன்றி
what confident .., the only thing he said is federalism .... if u ask little more about fuel prices he would have gone to his age old drama of language issue .... just say it clearly that u guys are not going to lower down the fuel prices..... don't beat around bush....
@@usdgreat6469 hey can't u hear him? Modi increased 20 rs in 2 months, the state didn't increase its taxes at that time nd then lowered it by ten. If we had increased the taxes like him at that time its logical to ask about reducing the tax. U guys r so wantedly dumb.
@@usdgreat6469 I think you have not understood the real issue. His contention is why should the state reduce when it has not increased the rate in the first place.
Mr.Sushrut Great Comment. We R in Right way to drive our States Economy. So the Country's economy will move faster. Union Government should follow our footsteps of Dr.PTRP.
Really it is our late Mr.Karunanidhi invited him to participate in politics. Previously PTR was not interested to settle in India, but Kalaignar insisted him to serve the country. Then only PTR convinced and returned to India to serve politics of tamilnadu.
Definitely when BJP members or some of its MP or even some union ministers saw this video definitely they think that ###"ok, he is not criticizing our government because he didn't say the word BJP any where ... We are safe , we are the best government and party ...no one can criticize us ...bharat mata ki jai ....hey are u muslim where is ur mosque ... Tell me and go i will come there with my saffron friends """###
@@akkiniraj390 such idiocy is what's not there thankfully in my state of Tamil Nadu and BJP has been for years trying to bend over back to make inroads.. it can only be in their dreams to create such divides in our society based on communal lines as they have been doing elsewhere all across North India where there are senseless idiots supporting such narrow minded politics played by the ruling party in the centre in the name of religion when there are several other teething issues in the country.. diversionary tactics has always been BJP's style of poltics.. and for your kind information majority of the country's revenue comes from the four south Indian states.. which Ji is using to run the entire country..and so much for his inclusive politics..
I received a gift from his father during sports day in my school at Kodaikanal. He was then Tamil Nadu assembly speaker I guess. His father was a great intellect just like his son
What clarity , knowledge & flow of language. TN is really blessed with such a finance minister. Centre without bias should discuss with such professionals irrespective of party and in the interest of the nation.
Last words really attractive.. Delhi decides where the money should flow.. this may leads to poverty and job loss soon in all states except performing state..
Genius... He is giving his full capacity to build up T.N economy damaged by the prior government. He know when to cut VAT because he has not raised it 1% so for. When the economy strengthened he will do it. BJP knows Hindutwa only.
Fantastic Sir. We, Tamilnadu people, are proud to have such a highly educated person as a Finance Minister of our state TN, who has studied finance & economics in depth at US. He can debate with anybody in this country in his area. He has much thorough knowledge in his portfolio & he comes from such a highly talented, educated family background. Had he not entered in politics after his father's demise, he would have gone & served World Bank / some other World's leading banks. We, TN people are fortunate to have him as our FM. In this short interview, he was spontaneously giving very correct technical & fitting answers to Nidhi Razdhan's queries, & she was also struggling to put questions for his appropriate & fitting replies with statistical datas instantly. We are all in TN can proudly say that, he is the No 1 FM in our entire nation... Hats off to him.
He makes valid points. The Centre has been bungling all along and are trying to find scape goats and diversions all the time. This cannot go on. The nation's image is taking a beating with all this digging and stuff.
@@sk7705 You dont need to hold big degrees to lead a nation on path of success. Kamarajar is one of the greatest example. Even in his party KK was not learned but still he did much better
All interviews of Mr. Palanivel Thiagarajan may be translated in all regional languages of India so that the whole India know how a Finance Minister should be.
Bhakts of any religion Eg : Islam, Christianity, or Hinduism" cant understand or relate to finance and intellectual thinking. Its to do with logical thinking and concern for the people.
He is fantastic and too good. His answers were very crystal clear. Seems to be a highly learned minister and is totally thorough with his homework. He calls a spade a spade and hits the nail right in the middle of the head. He does not mince works. He is very practical and does speak just for the heck of it like other Ministers. I wish our country should have more Ministers like him. 👍
Actually Rahul Gandhi is right, our economy is in Deep trouble with double digit inflation and central government completely failed to keep inflation under control
NDTV..... Pls make this circulate in Hindi heartland......by translating in Hindi...... Let them come out of this self imposed blindless. I know it's difficult to make them come out of bhakt mode... Just try.
Stripped off completely !! 🙈🙈 Tamil Nadu is being handled by Mr Stalin very efficiently. Mr. Tyagrajan is sensible and intelligent FM and a good example for other states too. Thanks NDTV for showing this wonderful interview. ** For healthy competition there should be additional PMs for South India, North India, Eastern India & Western India.
What a personality, we respect PTR, very knowledgeable person. When union govt raise many times the fuel prices, they didn't listen to us. When they reduce for their political reasons, we don't want our state government to reduce. We are ok with our govt tax policies.
@@bruce_v4889 This is my nation and If I want to goto Nepal you can be my tour guide. When you say useless govt, tell what did you do to correct it? Many don't even go to vote and now they come and question putting reason behind every act. tomorrow we will say they gave vaccine not to save people but for UP election. Non-sense atleast appreciate something if its done properly. Is he going to pay the old fuel price because Modi reduced it for Gujrat election??
Super. One cannot express in words the excellent interview given by Thamizhe Nadu FM. He has not only rreduced TN deficit , also controlled the inflation of the state below the National level and also increased the state GDP above National level,all of which certified by CAG for FY 20-21. All this improvement in state finance brought within one year of DMK's coming back to power.
This gentleman is good, has a good command/knowledge of his portfolio and also of the English language. Folks like him are few and far between in modi's New India.
I like how the conversation shifted from economics to dictatorship and federalism fast. The anchor just cut him off when he was giving the calculations and economics behind his statement. People don't like having tough conversations because they don't understand and are too lazy to understand. Just shift to my comfort zone. That is what wrong. Ultimately it boils down to "While u follow on with the cut on fuel taxes or not ?"
Wow.....well spoken.....a man of sense. .sensibility and substance.we need more people like him to put things in clear perspective without mincing words Kudos.....👌🙏
There are two serious problems in the Central Government’s fuel policy as far as States are concerned. First, the Centre collects revenues from fuel by imposing ‘cess’ which is not shared with the States. Accordingly, the states lose out on revenues but bear the brunt of inflation through higher costs of goods and services. Since they do not have the power to resort to unlimited fiscal deficit, the quantity of goods and services which they can buy is reduced thereby affecting the poor. Second, as the Minister rightly pointed out, the uncoordinated changes in the fuel taxes. Since the base for fuel taxation includes the cess levied by the Centre, as cess changes, the state revenue flows are also affected creating volatility and uncertainty in State finance. Therefore, it is important that Centre should coordinate with the States as they do in the case of GST.
There is a reason why PM Modi ji also wanted to compete from Varanasi. People of Gujarat who are pro economy will eventually know the fake economy policies of BJP and will turn against BJP, as Dr. PTR said it’s only a matter of when and after how much damage. That’s why our Modi Ji went to Varanasi to have it as a fail solid vote bank as that region is focus only on religious based demands.
No doubt about it Tamil Nadu and Tamilians are well educated and well mannered people I have seen so far.
haha, but Ajeet mentioned well mannered as well which is unlike with maami..
@@akshaybalasubramanian828 but she is a sangi sangis are all arrogant fools
@@akshaybalasubramanian828 She is a brahmin- means aryan. She is not typical Tamil.
@@akshaybalasubramanian828 how come Aryan Brahmins becomes Tamils? Nimmi is not a Tamil. 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️
@@akshaybalasubramanian828
Nimmi is a kannadiga... 🥴
Every state should have such finance minister like Tamilnadu... Hats off to Thiagarajan...
Every state should have functioning progressing govt run by smart and accountable leaders who are good at governance rather than just rousing public sentiments using on issues like religion, caste, language, food, statues, etc.
Well done Thiru Sri Thiagarajan . Well deserved applause from this non Tamilian who is fed up of national leadership and its hegemony and its bias.
👏👏💐💐
Seruppadi guarantee for this NRI
Tamils and Kerala no Bjp effected area , nice place good people
India need this kind of politicians
Unlike the uneducated politicians in north india talk the history they taught from Sakha , and Mandir masjid still
Constitutional rights known by state government....
Feeling jealous... nailed it....
proud to be a Tamilan....
Keep Rocking Bro PTR.....
Let him reduce fuel prices instead of blaming every one except himself .
What is the achievement of this loud mouth .
What was special about the budget he had presented last fiscal .
Nothing .
Let him ask to visit usa where he faces court cases by investors who lost their money in his funds. If he visits USA he will be arrested to face investigation.
@@mukut5ul nice joke from moron people like you
@@ஜிஜ்ஜக்ஜாமான் if he reduces the petrol prize there will be increase in taxes on other aspects worse than this will happen ,moreover central govt needs to release the gst to tn and they should check the taxes india now in serious inflation if you cut the taxes we are doomed knowing that central govt do that thing.
@@ஜிஜ்ஜக்ஜாமான் if you have a intelluctual to understand his words ,you cannot ask this question.
Wow, at last a minister who knows his subject, can explain his govt's point of view and makes the vital point that a divisive central govt is bound to fail but after doing much damage to the country. Tamilnadu is very lucky
National Institute of Technology, Tiruchirappalli (BTech) University at Buffalo (M.S., PhD) MIT Sloan School of Management (MBA) his qualification
Tq
@@raaj_bharath8229 burning ah lol... So pitty on u...
@@johnsonn3479 wt?
@@johnsonn3479 what lol
It's really a proud moment, that we have you as an FM of TN, once again you proved the capability of Tamilian in the world forum. Hats off sir 🖤❤
What a Finance Minister!!! Why is he not in National politics? I wish every state had one FM like him.
The current union gov does not like wise PPL.. we know what happened to the likes of Raghuram,Aravind. Let ptr do his best in a environment which supports him... hopefully such an environment willncome up in the union soon
In his ministry .. inflation is less in TN when compared to other states.. actually he is doing great in TN
@@johnjeevinth have u seen the economic council of PM go n read profile of people in the council.I think there are7 to 12
@@sriramnarayanan62 nirmala seetharaman is the worst finance minister our nation has ever seen
No sir, north people exploits for his prosperous and capabilities
Unless the voters of UP understand what Mr. Thiagarajan says, things won't change in India!
And I am sure that won't change for another generation or so.
Up and logic.. Is illogical
That also includes Bihar , Assam......
Will they ever be allowed to...?
Lol
My fav finance minister pan India.He knows his job.
pan India, wow I like that words
Every one get angry if a person didn't get angry then he is not a human.
If you know really about ptr you will not tell like this.
Even savuku shanker who blasting DMK also told he is the No 1 perfect and good minister in tamilnadu.
PTR on fire 🔥
@@subrayans2428 nalla katharu🤣🤣🤣
Tamil Nadu has one of the best indexes over all from economy to education to wages in India.
Such an excellent talk by Thiagarajan, FM of TN. During his talk he showed what real Class and standard he has. He is also a very highly qualified American returned Person. He is a real asset to DMK and to Tamil Nadu. We wish him all the best.
Wow this is a great finance minister, hats off to this gentleman. He talks sense. A good explanation and a very well prepared minister
She changed the subject because she couldn't understand him and handle him...he is 🔥
11.00 to 12 yes just noticed
He Just tore apart this government economic policies... deserves a standing ovation 👏👏👏
Is Nimmi alive still... 😝
She is born for Tamil but stand BJP, so there will be difference due to where she stand...
He is just avoiding doing his duty. Lol!
@@stayreasonablestayreasonab8133 Oh my God...🤔
yes, he doesn't know to do duties like what Modi is doing...? 🙄🙄🙄
@@thirupathisundaram2056 Exactly!
Ha ha ha this is a barking phenomenon
Called hide the flaws expose the ignorance approach.🤣🤣🤣
What an articulate speaker with a clear vision of how things are. Well impressed!!
I came to know for the first time that one Dr.Thyagraj is the Finance Minister of TN.
And what a minister he is, clear cut thoughts , studied speech, and self confidence of his, his government, and people of TN.
I am seventy+citizen of Satara Maharashtra, but I would certainly like to meet this person if I happen to be in that part of our country.
All the best 👍
🙏🇮🇳
We, Tamil people are feel so proud about our CM and our ministers 👏👏👏 great replies Sir👏
பெருமையாக உள்ளது ❤️
Excellent reply Kudos to TN CM for appointing PTR as the state FM.Such a knowledgeable person
Is Nimmi alive still... 😝
National Institute of Technology, Tiruchirappalli (BTech) University at Buffalo (M.S., PhD) MIT Sloan School of Management (MBA)
Thats why we are not support Modi government
Such grace. Nobody roasts the govt better than this guy in terms of financial aspects.
Hahaha in your wild Dravidian dreams 🤣🤣
Sidharth Sanjeev veshyaputra 🤣
@@lalithadoraisamy4497 enna pa sangi ya
@@lalithadoraisamy4497 he does that on a regular basis, lol. Care to defend the union on this?
@@lalithadoraisamy4497 Thinking process is controlled by brain not by cow dung.
We as Tamils are ashamed of Nirmalaseetharaman from Tamil Nadu, as this country`s FM while we have excellent Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan.
She doesn't have capability to win the election.
Back door idiot she is.
Aryans are not tamilan, their mother tongue is Sanskrit not Tamil. They were invaded from central Asia, so they are not Indian Also.
@@rashikali6403 Just like India is not an islamic nation where you can't question. This is hindu secular nation
@@rashikali6403 Is your name a Tamil name Mr.Ali? Is it not Arabic? Since when Bismillah, Ir-rahaman, Ir-rahim became Tamil? Please do not throw stones from inside a glass house.
@@santoshr4212 Hindu secular is an oxymoron. It is either Hindu or secular as secular means without religion.
Respect to all Tamils in Tamil Nadu for selecting a Capable Chief Minister surrounded by Capable Brave and Intelligent Men and Women!
The current government is the most corrupt, run by a family, 3rd generation in power.
There is no comparison between India and Tamilnadu finance minister. India need such kind of skill full finance minister. But the most people of India want Hindu Nation not developed nation.
What does it mean that you are saying most peoples of India wanted Hindu nation not developed nation?. The reality is that the people like you with decriminative mind set is living in India so that India is still developing country or developed country. You should leave the country as soon as possible ofcourse will India will be developed nation as soon as possible.
Exactly ali
That's the fate of India
@@nizammvs Are you a real Muslim or converted Muslim. Ofcourse whoever read the history properly, 100% there is no native Muslim like Arab countries. The peoples who saying Muslims in India definitely they were here converted forcefully. Like we can say imported religion from the foriegn countries. If you don't like Hindu peoples, then you cannot live in India peacefully. Becz, on your street your neighbours are Hindus, or food items sellers, milk sellers or in any form without Hindus contributions you cannot live. I think you are more depressed with Hindus. Better you can move to Afghanistan, Pakistan or any Arab Countries. Correct.
Kudos to him, he has the guts to talk like this and also perform accordingly.
Dravida thrittu kuttam Talks nonsense , that’s what they are good. Corrupted gov , remove TASMAC liqueur shop as promised. Return 2G money which kanimali /Maran stole
Very articulate without unnecessary embellishment. An educated politician for a change
Tamil translation
@@sreeram3623 Romba Theliva pesirkaaru. Last line ungaluke purinjirukum nu nenaikaren
How lucky is Tamilnadu for having such a person as their finance minister!
He is mental
Im talking about performers. He's clearly a performer. Having people like that in govt is enviable.
What about ex FM ops
@@funn3529 That guy used to have a tea shop. Now he is worth 1000s of crores. Without knowing how to manage finances, do you think he would have made this much money?
@@funn3529 On Ops 🤣😂🤣😂 He was a slave for Jayalalitha, He is a slave for Modi, He will be a slave in future too 🤣
This is how a finance minister is supposed to be.
This Tamil Nadu Finance Minister really filtered the talks and came down point blank to the subject with clarity.
Really appreciate that, he has done his home work very well. His speech is excellent.
Let him reduce fuel prices .
What does Tamil Panchayats Union do relating to petroleum products except levying taxes .
Really well read, inspiringly articulate,......
A professional Finance Minister.....
One of the best finance minister I have seen so far🙏🏻👍👌
He is a comedy piece 🤣
r u comedy me....
@@jaihind3595 Do you have answer for any of his questions ? Or even our Central FM have ? Just telling something not worry about India and keep yourself happy. All the best
Also, request you not to keep Nethajis photo here. It is shame to know your carelessness about India.
@@jaihind3595 educated moron
@@jaihind3595 sanghi
He is the real Finance Minister. He should be Central Finance Minister 👍
If Congress comes at the center, he might get that role.
Please check his qualifications. He was studied in world's number 1 universities
Do not say central, say union
yes full support from Jharkhand
It is union, not centre
I have come to know in your clear speech that the peoples of Tamil Nadu have details. That is why the BJP is not winning in Tamil Nadu
We don't want Bjp we have enough old temples
@@karthisg Not we you. Already BJP is growing well in TN under leadership of Thiru. Annamalai.
@@MrSuperthinker 😂😂LOL
@@MrSuperthinker show the stats. 😂
@@MrSuperthinker you mean aatukutti annamalai 🤣🤣 dude find some other forums to crack your jokes
12:26 Government stops collecting data when it doesn't like the outcome. "TRUE"
He nailed it 👌
I totally agree -- When we fail in exam we will not collect marks card you know !
Tamilnadu is very lucky to have an wonderful Finance Minister and the kind of commitment and integrity he has is exceptional.
@Arun Cheers
@Arun Well said
Sure.
Thanks
😂😂😂😂 but unlikely we have a braineless CM that's the worst part
@@123rajaind hey bro No
How much experience CM choose the brilliant minister in our cabinet??
U think wrong.
Our 56 inch is waste PM
This is a learned professional who is best at his job… don’t mess with him…
Is Nimmi alive still... 😝
@@thirupathisundaram2056 she is far better than this chutiyas........centre cut the tax on fuel prices but shameless thiagarajan is not going to lower the taxes .....fucking sucking the blood from common people.
@@thirupathisundaram2056 😂😂😂
He gave a rotton budget .
How different was it from the one given by OPS .
Foreign educated dumb .
The education speaks here with in its limits of course. Thanks and I not a tamilian.
Same here. I value his. Competence. ...we don't need dictation. From incompetent. People. .
@@sanjaygadhalay My comments stay neutral of up down bias. I didn't mean what you are saying. Byr
See the thoughts first
@pudum.. the state once had a CM called Kamarajar(nick named as the king maker) not sure if you find many articles in Hindi or English.. but he is one of the main reasons for TN to be in this position..
@@hrtbeat3124 look boss, I do not fully agree that TN is at good position. My comment was fully inclusive to the virtue of a Doctorate. Very few in Indian politics are at a level of this qualification and importantly of education.
"Subject Matter Expert" PTR rocks, he is defending his side with valid reason.
Proud to be the neighbour of Tamil Nadu.
I am from Kerala.
Strong movements against BJP should come from Tamilians.
First movement should be against EVM.
I salute this man.He has the interest of the country in his heart & actions in his mind to lead the nation forward
Thanks
Absolutely true sir 🙏
Tamil
@@sreeram3623 Tamil or whatever. We should not be unduly concerned about his lineage. His eloquence & clarity of thought has to be acknowledged & appreciated
So a man who cannot support a common man's plight is a super hero why? Because he opposes the center 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Should have been translated in other languages too, so people can realise how important it is to have knowledgeable, committed professionals as Ministers.
He have is own UA-cam channel. Subtitles will be there. You can check.
True
Only bastards like you have time to listen to this Dog
S, you r 200℅ correct & good idea.
Minister good job. We see such action after years from TN. Bring back TN to glory.
Very capable finance minister. I always listen to him for understanding economic problems. hats off to this minister
Yes we Tamils know exactly what we do. The peoples without data can't talk or tell people what they should do. There is a big difference between an educated and a normal person.
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd
You're ignoramus of Pondicherry politics. By crook as is their wont in other states the BJP came to power.
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd If you don't know learn from puduchery sources. Manipulation and number game. Next time you can be sure it wouldn't repeat.
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd Some might say that but when Congress does that it seems fair to them. They just want to paint tamils as anti bjp. Mostly dmk , muslims and Christians oppose bjp coz they're anti hindu. It's as simple as that. Had it been congress government at the centre with dmk as a part of it then you see no such dramas. Btw, PTR is the best FM for TN now. He's not welcomed by some of his party men for being too good in his job.
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd It's because the previous congress govt was so worse that the people had no other choice. Btw, the MLAs basically belong to congress where, they shifted to bjp. Intrinsically, most doesn't like bjp as a party here, but we had no other go!
If so how did some states reduce????
Wow this man is very articulate. Yes he should speak more.
Speak more work less
@@sripriyaparthasarathy2980 from what I understand from his answers Tamil Nadu is doing quite well economically.
@@sripriyaparthasarathy2980 he is not sanghi. So he works smart. Not like Modi & co afraid of meeting press
What Mrs. Sripriya said was well suited to PM Modi.
எனக்கு ஆங்கிலம் அவ்வளவாக புரியாது ஓரளவு புரியும் தமிழ் மொழிபெயர்ப்பை பார்த்து புரிந்துகொள்வேன் ஆகா என்ன ஒரு தெளிவு என்ன ஒரு தொலைநோக்கு சிந்தனை என்ன சுயநலமற்ற சிந்தனை வியந்து போகிறேன் தமிழ் நாட்டின் பொக்கிஷம் நீங்கள் ஒரு வேண்டுகோள் தமிழ் மீடியாவில் பேசும் தூய தமிழ் அல்லாமல் முக்கிய கருத்துக்களை ஆங்கிலம் கலந்து சொன்னாள் நீங்கள் சொல்லவந்த உன்மை கருத்து மக்களை சென்றடையும் வாழ்க பல்லாண்டு நன்றி
தமிழகம் முழுவதும் உள்ள அனைத்து நம் மக்களும் இவர் யார் என்பதை உணர வேண்டும்.
Brilliant Nidhi ! This guy is a straight shooter, and to the point. No mention of Nehru or Taj Mahal.
😂 Last line 👌
@saga -- well said
Tamil
"the government stops collecting the data, when it doesn't like the outcomes" - PTR
that was noteworthy right?
One man I respect and I admire in whole indian politics... And I wish every state will have such knowledgeable finance minister 😍
Too bro we have IITs.. IIMs what's the use...
Great interaction and Mr. Finance Minister seems very confident about his opinions.
Is Nimmi alive still... 😝
Seems very confident? Well, I would describe him as extremely confident, and rightly so!
what confident .., the only thing he said is federalism .... if u ask little more about fuel prices he would have gone to his age old drama of language issue .... just say it clearly that u guys are not going to lower down the fuel prices..... don't beat around bush....
@@usdgreat6469 hey can't u hear him? Modi increased 20 rs in 2 months, the state didn't increase its taxes at that time nd then lowered it by ten. If we had increased the taxes like him at that time its logical to ask about reducing the tax. U guys r so wantedly dumb.
@@usdgreat6469 I think you have not understood the real issue. His contention is why should the state reduce when it has not increased the rate in the first place.
What a well spoken and well read minister 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
That is Dravidan government 👍🏻🙏🤝
Mr.Sushrut Great Comment.
We R in Right way to drive our States Economy. So the Country's economy will move faster.
Union Government should follow our footsteps of Dr.PTRP.
National Institute of Technology, Tiruchirappalli (BTech) University at Buffalo (M.S., PhD) MIT Sloan School of Management (MBA) his qualification
@@kavyaprince 👏👏👏👏👏👌👍🙏
Without script
I give credits to Mr. Stalin to have him as FM of TN. He know what is he doing and what his he saying. Full of confidence.
True
Really it is our late Mr.Karunanidhi invited him to participate in politics. Previously PTR was not interested to settle in India, but Kalaignar insisted him to serve the country. Then only PTR convinced and returned to India to serve politics of tamilnadu.
He seems to be an extremely qualified and efficient man - quite a rare breed among Indian politicians today!
Not seems to be....HE IS....got masters degree and Ph.D from MIT ...and headed global financial gains for 20 years
We are proud…. Having you in Tamil Nadu Sir. 🖤♥️🔥
It's really refreshing to hear the Tamil Nadu Finance Minister. He is talking sense. But the question is, how many got the sense to understand him?z
😂😂
PM?😂😂😂😂
Good question dude😃
Definitely when BJP members or some of its MP or even some union ministers saw this video definitely they think that ###"ok, he is not criticizing our government because he didn't say the word BJP any where ... We are safe , we are the best government and party ...no one can criticize us ...bharat mata ki jai ....hey are u muslim where is ur mosque ... Tell me and go i will come there with my saffron friends """###
@@akkiniraj390 such idiocy is what's not there thankfully in my state of Tamil Nadu and BJP has been for years trying to bend over back to make inroads.. it can only be in their dreams to create such divides in our society based on communal lines as they have been doing elsewhere all across North India where there are senseless idiots supporting such narrow minded politics played by the ruling party in the centre in the name of religion when there are several other teething issues in the country.. diversionary tactics has always been BJP's style of poltics.. and for your kind information majority of the country's revenue comes from the four south Indian states.. which Ji is using to run the entire country..and so much for his inclusive politics..
Can NDTV bring two Finance Ministers Mrs Nirmala Sitaraman and PTR have direct discussion to know both sides of issues and find solutions?
Nirmala ji will take sick leave 😂
@@jeswantfernandez 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Union fm will never accept this .. and man please ask her to win an assembly from where she born !
Lets add one more, former FM P Chidhamparam Sir and current FM Nirmala Ma'am
@@SiraiparavaiSIK Then Nirmala ji will take extended sick leave with medical letter 😂🤟🏻
We are having a knowledgeable Finance minister,it's showing in our life ✨day to day in Tamilnadu
👌👌👌
Hmmm 🤩... Why not spare some for the common tamilzha get the damn petrol prices lower than the states of BJP ruled states.. appa solungda Tamila
Mairu
I received a gift from his father during sports day in my school at Kodaikanal. He was then Tamil Nadu assembly speaker I guess. His father was a great intellect just like his son
Dr.Manmohan Singh, Shri.Raguram Rajan & in this lineup our ever great PTR. I salute Shri Stalin for appoint him as FM.
What clarity , knowledge & flow of language. TN is really blessed with such a finance minister. Centre without bias should discuss with such professionals irrespective of party and in the interest of the nation.
😂😂😂but CM doesn't have any knowledge and brain
Absolutely
You will teach Centre what is wrong what is correct
Correct!
@@ANKITSAGARSINGH
Centre or state. All are Indians. Accept & recognise talent
Last words really attractive.. Delhi decides where the money should flow.. this may leads to poverty and job loss soon in all states except performing state..
Genius... He is giving his full capacity to build up T.N economy damaged by the prior government. He know when to cut VAT because he has not raised it 1% so for. When the economy strengthened he will do it. BJP knows Hindutwa only.
I don't know about DMK.. But I have confidence on him since he is serving as FM of TN.
Imagine if every minister was well educated like him then we would be like US or European countries.
its not only education.. its the ideology that makes him bold
@@prince8673 what ideology? He is stupid just like you
To the point and precis. Great to have a man of such a claiber as a Minister with his clear views on constitution, state rights.,👍
Blasting with a straight bat without mincing words !!
PTR is the best, knowledgeable, bold, very clear about facts and figures...finance Minister. He should be the financial minister of India'.
Looking forward to that.
true not this sitaram
Modi always hire dumb people around him.. look at the rbi governor, Nirmala etc .. He is allergic of clever people ..
Cannot agree more. With his exceptional knowledge of finance and economy, he may as well become the best FM in history.
Fantastic Sir. We, Tamilnadu people, are proud to have such a highly educated person as a Finance Minister of our state TN, who has studied finance & economics in depth at US. He can debate with anybody in this country in his area. He has much thorough knowledge in his portfolio & he comes from such a highly talented, educated family background. Had he not entered in politics after his father's demise, he would have gone & served World Bank / some other World's leading banks. We, TN people are fortunate to have him as our FM. In this short interview, he was spontaneously giving very correct technical & fitting answers to Nidhi Razdhan's queries, & she was also struggling to put questions for his appropriate & fitting replies with statistical datas instantly. We are all in TN can proudly say that, he is the No 1 FM in our entire nation... Hats off to him.
No doubt a great economist TN has. God bless you PTR. PT. Excellent way of explaining the scenario. மதுரை மண்ணின் மகத்தான மைந்தன். வாழ்க வளர்க.
Don't portray him as Madurai's Gem ... bcoz he is pride to Tamilnadu.
Madurai is pride of Tamilnadu.
He makes valid points.
The Centre has been bungling all along and are trying to find scape goats and diversions all the time. This cannot go on. The nation's image is taking a beating with all this digging and stuff.
What can you expect from a Chaiwala PM? He ruined everything in last 7 years.
Unfortunately the people who are blinded by Fascination of history and don’t know English don’t understand him … superb hats off
What abt mr.Kamaraj then?
@@sk7705 good
by speaking english he is making chutiya out of u ......
@@sk7705 the media was fair then, had equal space for ruling and opposition.. Now media is only PROs of the supreme leader
@@sk7705 You dont need to hold big degrees to lead a nation on path of success. Kamarajar is one of the greatest example. Even in his party KK was not learned but still he did much better
We have never seen such a knowledgeable Finance Minister.....Hope TN makes use of him to the fullest extent
All interviews of Mr. Palanivel Thiagarajan may be translated in all regional languages of India so that the whole India know how a Finance Minister should be.
THE HIGHLY QUALIFIED FINANCE MINISTER OF OUR STATE IS RUNNING THE FINANCE PORTFOLIO IN A QUALIFIED MANNER UNLIKE THE UNION GOVERNMENT.
Big fan sir salute to you n your work .... We need him in the centre .. this the basic difference between well educated n non educated politicians
Superb speech by PTR,but bhakths can't understand this sensible speech.
Bhakts of any religion Eg : Islam, Christianity, or Hinduism" cant understand or relate to finance and intellectual thinking. Its to do with logical thinking and concern for the people.
Centre has been failing to deliver results, how on earth those non performing government can direct states what to do Or not to do.
Finally someone worthy to stand up to the central government. Good job PTR, go all out.
He is fantastic and too good. His answers were very crystal clear. Seems to be a highly learned minister and is totally thorough with his homework. He calls a spade a spade and hits the nail right in the middle of the head. He does not mince works. He is very practical and does speak just for the heck of it like other Ministers. I wish our country should have more Ministers like him. 👍
Actually Rahul Gandhi is right, our economy is in Deep trouble with double digit inflation and central government completely failed to keep inflation under control
NDTV..... Pls make this circulate in Hindi heartland......by translating in Hindi...... Let them come out of this self imposed blindless. I know it's difficult to make them come out of bhakt mode... Just try.
They will listen fully and then say jai sree ram and vote for taklu shah and gang
They are all living zombies of Bjp.. They blindly vote bjp
very true what you said. Its difficult for north indians to come out of bhakt mode. because that needs intelligence
@@prasadraghu2008 🤣🤣🤣
Nirmala seetharaman should learn a lesson from him.
She must go to tution, 1 lesson won't suffice for her, or else she could do an internship under him
I am from ntk but I support our FM, what a insightful speech and data he has shared here. Nirmala mam learn from him. Proud of you FM sir.
India needs ministers like him who bring thier experience and knowledge to the table. Kudos for his being who non-sense leader
Stripped off completely !! 🙈🙈
Tamil Nadu is being handled by Mr Stalin very efficiently. Mr. Tyagrajan is sensible and intelligent FM and a good example for other states too.
Thanks NDTV for showing this wonderful interview.
** For healthy competition there should be additional PMs for South India, North India, Eastern India & Western India.
What a sick idea
@@deepakrajamin977 yeah. Current uneducated pm is enuf 😂
@@deepakrajamin977 know the hidden meaning.
Mr Pazhanivel Thyagarajan, such a learned politician and extremely talented 👏👏 We need such a person in Centre..
What a personality, we respect PTR, very knowledgeable person. When union govt raise many times the fuel prices, they didn't listen to us. When they reduce for their political reasons, we don't want our state government to reduce. We are ok with our govt tax policies.
Is Nimmi alive still.... 😝
Useless Modi govt. Reduced the petrol and diesel prices foreseeing the Gujarath election. Otherwise they never anything good to the common people.
@@ahamedmohideen9875 Gujarat elections are one year away. Any govt. Will lose revenue for one year? There is a limit to being brain washed.
@@bruce_v4889 This is my nation and If I want to goto Nepal you can be my tour guide. When you say useless govt, tell what did you do to correct it? Many don't even go to vote and now they come and question putting reason behind every act. tomorrow we will say they gave vaccine not to save people but for UP election. Non-sense atleast appreciate something if its done properly. Is he going to pay the old fuel price because Modi reduced it for Gujrat election??
@@thirupathisundaram2056 who is nimmy? Are you insane?or lost sense
Super. One cannot express in words the excellent interview given by Thamizhe Nadu FM. He has not only rreduced TN deficit , also controlled the inflation of the state below the National level and also increased the state GDP above National level,all of which certified by CAG for FY 20-21. All this improvement in state finance brought within one year of DMK's coming back to power.
I congrats Mr. PTR for his excellent power of knowledge in finance to lead TN state for better future. I am proud to be the Tamilian. 👌🙏💪
Brilliant BRAIN speaks economy.
This gentleman is good, has a good command/knowledge of his portfolio and also of the English language.
Folks like him are few and far between in modi's New India.
Kudos to you, Mr. PTR.
Excellent words.👏
I am from Tamilnadu I am so proud that we have a finance minister like him. I don't see minister like him in any other states.
Excellent interview by our financeminister.highly exceptional.vast knowledge.
I like how the conversation shifted from economics to dictatorship and federalism fast. The anchor just cut him off when he was giving the calculations and economics behind his statement. People don't like having tough conversations because they don't understand and are too lazy to understand. Just shift to my comfort zone. That is what wrong. Ultimately it boils down to "While u follow on with the cut on fuel taxes or not ?"
NDTV is now owned by ADNAI group
I noticed too...
Exactly what I was thinking too..
Wow!!! Amazing comments by Mr.PTR. Make us feel good that Tamilnadu's finance is in good hands.
Iyoo
@@sripriyaparthasarathy2980 Sangi mami 😂
@@hulkkumar853 🤣🤣😂😂
“Govt stops collecting data when it doesn’t like the outcome” 🎯
Superb
True 👍
Really true statement
True😂😂🤣🤣
What an articulation
Well done Mr.PTR , you have proved Tamilians are courageous and intelligent people
Wow.....well spoken.....a man of sense. .sensibility and substance.we need more people like him to put things in clear perspective without mincing words
Kudos.....👌🙏
There are two serious problems in the Central Government’s fuel policy as far as States are concerned. First, the Centre collects revenues from fuel by imposing ‘cess’ which is not shared with the States. Accordingly, the states lose out on revenues but bear the brunt of inflation through higher costs of goods and services. Since they do not have the power to resort to unlimited fiscal deficit, the quantity of goods and services which they can buy is reduced thereby affecting the poor. Second, as the Minister rightly pointed out, the uncoordinated changes in the fuel taxes. Since the base for fuel taxation includes the cess levied by the Centre, as cess changes, the state revenue flows are also affected creating volatility and uncertainty in State finance. Therefore, it is important that Centre should coordinate with the States as they do in the case of GST.
For a change, I am seeing a Modi with logical clarity and good comprehension. Great boss.
There is a reason why PM Modi ji also wanted to compete from Varanasi. People of Gujarat who are pro economy will eventually know the fake economy policies of BJP and will turn against BJP, as Dr. PTR said it’s only a matter of when and after how much damage. That’s why our Modi Ji went to Varanasi to have it as a fail solid vote bank as that region is focus only on religious based demands.
@@hardnfree great Joke Elections are happening this Year BJP will win based on Modi Ji only
It's very nice to see 👀 such a statement from Modi.
When UG 's actions affecting the states, they must consult the states, otherwise it's an insult to federalism.
I would like to see PTR as our national finance minister...
Yes everyone wish that
What a beautiful message 👍🙏
PTR is Amazing - Huge support from Kerala
Excellent interview! Full of facts and figured countered with logic! 🔥🔥