Why south Indian states have started a tax movement|
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 лип 2024
- The debate on the north- south divide has reignited. This time, three states are leading what they call the #southtaxmovement against the Modi led union government. Kerala, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu have pointed out that the union government distributes tax revenue unfairly.
In this interim budget, the allocation for one northern state-Uttar Pradesh alone is significantly higher than to all five southern states- combined. While Uttar Pradesh is getting around 2.29 thousand cr, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Telangana combined are getting around Rs 1.93 thousand cr. In this episode of Let Me Explain, Pooja Prasanna looks at how the south faces a discrimination in the allocation of funds and what the solutions are.
#SouthTaxMovement #NorthSouth #Karnataka #Kerala #TamilNadu
Support our work. Become a TNM Member: www.thenewsminute.com/subscri...
-------------------------
▶ Subscribe to The News Minute Channel: / thenewsminute
▶ Subscribe to The News Minute Malayalam: / @thenewsminutemalayalam
▶ Subscribe to The News MinuteTamil: / @thenewsminutetamil
▶ Like us on Facebook: / thenewsminute
▶ Follow us on Instagram: / thenewsminute
▶ Follow us on Twitter: / thenewsminute
▶ Follow all latest stories by TNM here: www.thenewsminute.com
▶ Subscribe to The News Minute’s daily newsletter: tinyurl.com/TNMNewsletter
If you like the video, become a subscriber and support our journalism - www.thenewsminute.com/subscription
Media who always had slave mentality pushing this agenda . Polticis agenda behind it .but after 70 years in the time of internet and strong prime minister allwell educated and they all want India stand with USA and major Power. Thinking of Indian change they feel proud to call Indian ..congress looted and stabbed Indian tradition by every means from insulting gods foods and books
By default every state should get back more than 75 paisa 😢
I did not like the video. The language delivery is painful and I can hardly make out the content when one sentence is delivered at a time. That is not how English works.
Church Funded channel
Y she lies so beautifully? If it is for money, she can use 24 hrs for 24 shots with her good n fair complexion that will surely yield huge money. Madam, u may use even ur 3 days too with INDI Alliance guys. Like Stalin dmk fraud in Tamil Nadu , Kerala n Karnataka r fooling their common people to get votes. This dirty politics was stated by Nehru in 1952. There on Karunanidhi n rest of congress using this route. The finance commission has 6 components. One such is population that carries only 15% weightage. The max is 45% for equity. And all state chief secretaries n finance ministers r part of this finance commission. Every month this meeting happens. When these state finance ministers agree in the commission meeting , but try to fake the news as if the allocation is only done by this commission. Next in Tamil Nadu, Coimbatores belt share is 71% of total Tamil Nadu’s contribution. Districts like Sivagangai, Ramanathapuram , etc contributes less than 1.5%. So y Stalin spends close to 12% of the total to these two districts? Or shall we drop these two districts from development. Or shall Coimbatores gets 71% and the balance 29% for rest of Tamil Nadu that includes Chennai? So when Stalin of dmk in Tamil Nadu does is for social welfare, but if the same formula used by central govt it is north south divide. This is y said this female birth is lieing n fetch money like Rs. 1 lacs per hr. Ok madam?
This is a bigger loot than the British Raj 😢
What about the forces from South India? But we never cried
@@cbuzz9636 Forced what 😂
💯✅
As a North Indian I'm totally in support of south ppl.
@@cbuzz9636bring all air bases to deccan. North must have only army
The debate should be Gujarat vs rest of india, as most of the south and north tax money goes to gujarat development, Olympics preparation, gift city, for adani and Ambani business
Yeah that's true🙂💯
Sir sir, but Gujaratis have Saraswati on their tongue
Source: jUsT TruSt me bRo
@@driasalta4834 source is jai shree ram for north India and for Gujarat is investment, chip investment, Olympic bid, Narendra Modi stadium and many more. If you need more source, go to Pakistan bjp IT crack
@@driasalta4834
Aagaya andhbhakt 😂😂
That nirmala is worst FM in indian history.
It’s not abt Nirmala alone …It’s the Hindi Majoritarian Mindset
😂😂for u and ur slaves😂😂😂
@@kavibharathy5690😂😂😂she is Tamil 😂😂😂🤌🤌🤌🤌 joker ,
Nirmala should resign
The distribution need not be based on population and area alone. There are other factors such as per capita income, GDP rate, literary percentage etc as specified and demarcated in Finance commission which has nothing to do with the ruling party. The rationale behind distribution is, more for less developed states and vice versa. This is based on the principle of development of nation as a whole. Ignoring this fact, carrying on discussion on these topics, would amount to subscribing to partisan attitude which is not a healthy sign.
It's time for justice for South India. Equal justice is a must.
South United to Fight for Our Rights
Correction: Fight for the nationhood, so a better livelihood.
@@sathyansundar then y spread corruption rasissm killing innocent humans we don't want association with you guys so don't eat our money and spread your thoughts to our society
@@sathyansundarreally???😂😂
@@sameer-fk8oy It may be a laughing matter now! Allow this saffron band to rule India for 2 more terms, then it will be a reality! Haha!
@@iaf010 How would you call a person who swindle money from the thieves? I would call them Roti-munching Northies....Already the Sardarji's have started their referendum and boots are shaking everywhere, debating who to call 'anti-indian' in the cow belt. For your information (I believe that you don't read newspapers and editorial columns in your Jai Shri Ram chanting mindset), the mighty Soviet Union collapsed when 3 Baltic States started the ignition, and no one call them 'thieves'. Better enjoy the celebratory mood now on the inauguration of the Ram temple, when the rest of the world ridicule you. Why you are hiding behind Ian Faust identity?
BJP realised that south Indians are getting more Sensible , our MODIJI started hunting intelligently North Indians,who are largely illiterate Andhbhakts,by alloting more central funds for Vote bank Ignoring south Indians .Ex : 3 lakhs 60 thousand crores Rs allotted this yr for UP alone .
True
This is the drawback of our day's democracy that winning election and sticking to power become much more important than any thing else .To grind their own axe , some people sell their souls to the devil.
Right analysis
Modi and BJP team is tricky people
They bring caste, religiously
already divided india
North is completely dominating South people
It's a serious issue but opposition has no strength to overcome BJP it's seems.
People have wake up
It's the death of democracy
True. Better performing high literate people do not like Modi government and that the reason of finance pyracy.If this mindset continue these states may demand finance autonomy.
Ys iam South Indian,and visiting UP, Bihar,Gujrat i understand how poor& illiterate they are,sad for them,they don't know their rights to live
Wonder why no Malayalam media is not showing any of the truth. This should be seriously discussed.
Every one now sold and barking for shitgopi..even manorama.. matgrubhumi..eveeyone..gerti g their m obey monthly
Arunachal Pradesh gets 4300% meanwhile Gujarat gets 30% and Maharashtra gets 8%
What are you talking about ??
Gujarat gets lesser than Andhra, Kerala and Tamilnadu and Maharashtra gets lesser than Karnataka
UP -Bihar are getting 220% combined... meanwhile North-east gets around 3000% combined.
It's clear that most funds are going to North-east because north-eastern states were ignored by all previous govts and there is need of Border infrastructure in Arunachal Pradesh to defend against China.
These presstitutes never mention how Gujarat and Maharashtra are getting even lesser than Southern states because it doesn't suit their North South divide Anti-India agenda. It's not North South divide it's more like Prioritisation driven by Necessity.
At least be honest, study the subject and then ask questions.
Gujarat gets lesser than Kerala, Andhra and Tamilnadu. Maharashtra gets lesser than Karnataka.
it has been seriously talked and on going topic and now it has been the state discussion
Kerala media is being sponsored by Modi team
We need this video in all the regional languages. Hence people can aware of this situation.
Arunachal Pradesh gets 4300% meanwhile Gujarat gets 30% and Maharashtra gets 8%
What are you talking about ??
Gujarat gets lesser than Andhra, Kerala and Tamilnadu and Maharashtra gets lesser than Karnataka
UP -Bihar are getting 220% combined... meanwhile North-east gets around 3000% combined.
It's clear that most funds are going to North-east because north-eastern states were ignored by all previous govts and there is need of Border infrastructure in Arunachal Pradesh to defend against China.
These presstitutes never mention how Gujarat and Maharashtra are getting even lesser than Southern states because it doesn't suit their North South divide Anti-India agenda. It's not North South divide it's more like Prioritisation driven by Necessity.
Dude sice andhra pradesh divided your gujrat came into top place else go see before 2014 in combined andhra pradesh the states with highest income are 1st Maharashtra 2nd Ap your gujarat was not even in top 5 lot of projects are pumped to gujus in bjp rule which is creating income now all important projects and development is concentrated in ahemdabad - mumbai bullet train or gift etc projects and how much money is poured in ncr region gurgaon noida up region
Yes
@@Kkc3126 BJP was rooting for AP to be divided for this purpose only - to make it economically weak so that Gujarat prospers. These people talk about national unity but all their actions are just the opposite.
Equality is a myth.
India will become a country dominated by Hindi-speaking states and imposing their will on non-Hindi speaking states and the tax revenues collected from the South goes to the Hindi-speaking states. Not unlike the British Raj.
South has higher seats in lok Sabha compared to their population. I am hoping you be honest and compare it with British raj too.
@@james432ful😂😂😂 whatsapp University
The tax are already like that
@@james432fulseats are never based on population. Why are you misrepresenting? If you want to go by population, then why higher allocation for Northern States with lower Population?
The presenter is quite apparently a leftist propagandist and she is suggesting that the south should break away. She is stating statistics however not the whole statistics; Even if there are some truth in the bias, she is hiding many. e.g. she has not stated how much Maharashtra contributes and how much they get back.
Its our money spending on North Indians
Go to isreal indirectly😂😂😂
@@ikaspatra4035 go to kailasa
Muslims don't belong to south india.
Dravidian Periyarists can try harder to make you Muslims and christians part of south indian civilization but you people were never ever part of it.
Who will forget tipu's atrocities.
study economics and democratic history. maybe focus on 85-00 economic reforms and state gsdp allocation. Thats all advice I will give you. There is a huge difference, but it is very well justifiable. And about transportation, and schemes, it would be with 90-10 schemes by Gov to states. All your answers.
@@ikaspatra4035go with your daddy north indian terrorist
I support this new movement by the South. We want our voices to be heard...
Fulfill the demands of the Southern people or else allow the southern to pass a law to reduce migration from north. I fully support the tax movement by South ❤
U r exactly right sir
Bengali here. Bengal and S. India must unite to limit migration from north, they come here and follow their own culture (mind u culture not ethnicity) which is usually misogynistic, homophobic and casteist. I don't mind giving my tax for development of northeners, but most of it goes into pocket of corrupt politicians
@@AparnaSen-bk9zythey got almost all air bases army jobs india govt offices still coming other states
SOUTHERN STATES SHOUKD LEAVE THE UNION !!!
orr
FORM A DUAL FEDERAL RULE !
Nice joke.. Constitution forbids this.. Not possible
@@souravsoumendran9051
Accession treaty was sogned with the Crown ..so people of former princely states can activate the Crown to stand by its obligation ...
The constitution ublawfilly has rejcted the accession treaty mm
So its very easy secede from the republic..
Since the republic has reejcted the union of princely states witht the Crwon franchise under govt of india act..
Its going to be done by the people due to the covid scamdmeic mass murder
Its easy to do ..but u have to realise the republic has rejected accessi treaty..and has lied to the people that the republic represennt the people..all states are delhi franchise with delhi republic commiting fraud by rejecting accession treaty
Says a myran malayali from commieland who is cleaning toilets in gelf or north India..
This should not be done ... Instead a peaceful change in allocation of taxes should be done
BJP ruled states mostly Hindi belt are getting most funds
Same question asked by Maharashtra and Gujarat...then why ur mp so hurt at that time😂😂😂
What about West Bengal? It is non-BJP and getting more funds.
because they need votes in the coming election. @@rajx7120
Even Karnataka had BJP in the past. But funds allocation was insufficient even then. Why?
Maharashtra didn't came in north Indian grouping and it also experience same thing till toppling of govt.
South India is South Korea and North India is North Korea. Everything in terms of Education, jobs, infrastructure and medical facilities. Why no North Indian states questions that ? How South prospered and North doesn't. ??
South has sea and other environments so easy for industries. There are many industries in UP PANJAB GUJRAT ETC. in this list south has only shown only those states where it is going more..... But the other states like Punjab... Gujrat get less return. It is full political move which people will not buy.
excuse of poverty@@HB231272
@@darpann3932.... Bihar and UP is a typical problem with caste system. The caste system within backward itself is also very complicated. Forget about the Brahmins and upper caste. But people in other states like the WB.. ASSAM and others does not have strong caste system but the education system was not that driving. Exposure was less for the external world.
Please calculate the percentage of North vs south in armed forces too..
Simple statement they prefer caste we don't 😂 and thts the mantea
South people should protest against this discriminate by boycotting the election
not by boycotting but pushing against the centre through the elections itself.
Divide the south and hindi cow belt.
We will boycott and north will vote for BJP. This will again continues
@@prasanthjack7325 that's also true 😓
@@Jesssco I am seeing the hate of converts. This much hate will spoil your health. I thought kerala is the most educated state and fellows are very decent , but its opposite.
Maharashtra should also raise voice on taxation. This bimaru states are getting our tax money.
Yes, South will be new country if this continue.. all science , money power , technologies are with south.. north always coming to south for job until they get educated well.. sadly this is reality
Not only that, Your language also one day vanish . How many Marathi movies are made in ur state?.
why you are not merge with south india 😁😍🤗
@@govindasamykamalakannan1294 that is a sad truth😞..I can't do anything but just watch my mother tongue getting replaced by another language. I am proud of southern states of what are they doing 👏
@@GNikhil-That is all we want our brother to be separated from the people who are overcrowding our places. But a separate country is an illusional hypothesized belief....It won't happen on paper.
The fact is that Southern states don't want to be a colony anymore
Maharashtra plus south plus goa =
@@rampatil1219you can form deccan and we can support in defence
Won't discuss the freight equalisation policy due to which you guys are rich right now!!
Add odisha also@@rampatil1219
@@amanmaheshwari2554south educated NRIs
We will be happy if our South India goes independent.
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
@@YourFuhrer1933why more than half of east India company's army disobeyed commands during 1857 revolt?
@@KJS3353 so you think Indian soldiers will disobey Army? Pretty delusional
@@YourFuhrer1933 still unanswered?
Don't even think buddy 😂😂😂 mf traitor
Kerala didn't change the NHM name to what the central government asked not just because the word was in Hindi, but 95% of the health system expenses are spend from the state government pocket and just 5% from the central government. Still the central government want the state to change the name as per central government's order... 😮
.yes.. but why a Hindi name in a state that speaks Dravidian language??
Absolutely not necessary to change NHM name
Fool man
Why are you only talking about tax? Why don't you talk about other many things,,,,, what if jharkhand peoplws starts saying that now we will sell coal at the higher price as it is found on our land(btw even today India's energy needs depends on caol) , what if UP and Madhya Pradesh starts saying that now we will sell our food on the higher rates in southern statea at what price india sells to other countries,,,,, what if these 6Crores people(the total population of india giving tax) starts saying that now we will not give tax as why they have to take care of other rest population,,,,, what if northern states starts saying thet now we want our industries in our area which were transferred to southern states by central government due to see connectivity ,,, what if universities like IISc Bangalore, ISI , CMI are transferred to northern part , why our students have to travel towards south for research purpose?? If someone have answer please reple me
Those peoples are fighting on tax which dont pay a single rupee ,, and actual people who pay tax are silent, wow!
Tax is given coz you want it to come back as investment by government to develop the area in multiple ways. So if it is not coming to you and going to other people then why to pay it. In other words the more the tax you pay the more you expect government to do well for you by giving better services, creating employment opportunities, better education and health system etc etc. So it seems fair demand from southern states
It is time that the South Indians should stay UNITED against the atrocities of North Indians and their BEMARU states.
Specially BJP ruled states.
TN minister Mr. PTR has been voicing out this GST issue for the past three years, good that the awareness of this disparity is gaining momentum. The GST collection of southern states if not sent to the centre and utilized among the southern states, the southern economy would be par with developed nations in a few years.
If this has to happen, you all can easily guess what needs to be done...
modi govt,bjp is anti karnataka,anti south india,all 5 south states are being looted,cheated,nirmala is India's finance minister,she is also rajya sabha member of karnataka,but she is backstabbing Karnataka,reason for this is she is not born in karnataka,she is born in other state(outsider),all 5 south india states must fight against this big injustice
This is a shallow argument and cannot be seen in the binary. I am from Tamil nadu. The GST collection has to be distributed and I am for the optimal method to get a fair proportion for every state. In GST, there is SGST and CGST. The central govt. is transferring SGST portion to the states. Now, people need to understand that GST is a consumption tax. A goods or product produced in Tamil Nadu is sold across pan India. Suppose Ram from Bihar bought a car manufactured by Hyundai in Chennai and the unit is sold by the dealer in Bihar, the state GST goes to Bihar state. The consumption state gets the GST portion and not TN. I think this is fair. In another example, a lot of raw materials for Textile industries in Tirupur come from North India. Tirupur only manufactures finished garments/apparel goods but the entire major supply chain materials dependency comes from Northern states. There is interdependency in each state for even Industrial advanced states like Tamil Nadu. This argument of TN will become a developed nation is false logic or sheer ignorance or incompetent to understand the reality of how the whole business ecosystem works. TN industry doesn't't work in silos. If we all work together in unity, co-operate and share resources with the needy states, it augurs well for India's speedy growth. Otherwise even the educated people also will take political sides and speak narratives which will be futile for the future well being of this country. My request to Tamil Nadu being a Tamilian is to rise above petty politics. Please study economics and the business ecosystem to have better clarity on topics like this. Don't go by Television narratives, understand fundamentals of economics, finance, geopolitics, policy, regulation and its relationship to our personal lives. Otherwise the political dynasties will keep fooling us and amaze wealth for their families. Hope we are not going on the path of Brexit. A lesson to be learned out of Brexit, a popular narrative promoted by politicians, voted by people in favor of them, and in the aftermath not the right move. The UK is suffering due to this, a so called 'developed nation'. All that is popular is not right, and all that is right is not popular. 😊 BTW, Mr. PTR himself is sidelined by his own party and could not persuade what he intended to achieve for the state. The right way to approach this is to build the consensus in the GST council and arrive at a better resolution. All state finance ministers sit in the GST council and they should be able to close this matter. By resorting to dharna and protests, they are doing sheer political optics to drive people's emotions for electoral gains. It has to be constructive and you have to hit the right forum, dharna Or protests are just political drama.
South Indian states are good at economics but in no way they could have got onpar with developed countries.
You people have a per capita income of 3500 dollars only a little above 2700 dollars (national average) even China has a per capita of 14000 dollars and is still isn't considered developed.
A developed country has a per capita of atleast 25000 dollars.
@@YourFuhrer1933the disproportionate tax distribution to the northern states did not start yesterday. It's been going on for atleast 3 decades. Now consider this. Tamil Nadu, year on year, grows at about 15% in nominal terms. If you understand compounding, that's a doubling every 4 odd years. 2x,4x,8x, 16x - in 16 years. Now you can argue for a slow down - but that is not coming anytime soon. Infact, all the southern states are accelerating in terms of growth. So - was your comment a sensible one?
Why are you only talking about tax? Why don't you talk about other many things,,,,, what if jharkhand peoplws starts saying that now we will sell coal at the higher price as it is found on our land(btw even today India's energy needs depends on caol) , what if UP and Madhya Pradesh starts saying that now we will sell our food on the higher rates in southern statea at what price india sells to other countries,,,,, what if these 6Crores people(the total population of india giving tax) starts saying that now we will not give tax as why they have to take care of other rest population,,,,, what if northern states starts saying thet now we want our industries in our area which were transferred to southern states by central government due to see connectivity ,,, what if universities like IISc Bangalore, ISI , CMI are transferred to northern part , why our students have to travel towards south for research purpose?? If someone have answer please reple me
Those peoples are fighting on tax which dont pay a single rupee ,, and actual people who pay tax are silent, wow!
As this continues, one day South will start fighting for separation, South is paying more taxes and getting no funds from central. South should wake up and realizing sooner than later.
Instead of fighting a game of political one man ship why does not the south MPs make point to point claims to benefit south states
@@anand1pillai agree, that’s where the whole challenge , south is regional parties centric, it’s quite tough to bring all these parties on common agenda.
raja go and fight in your street raja, they will thorw you out macha....Raja do you think this funds for south is reaching the people or going to that 80 year old ruling political families. first adress the corruption issue and stop taking note for vote macha......
Why always North vs South? You don't even know even languages spoken in North India. You think only Hindi is spoken in North India. If Karnataka is so developed why they are giving free bus services all womans across Karnataka. Giving 2000 rs to every woman. It's from the budget. Maharashtra is much developed than Andhra and Telangana that is sure.
@@Adity2223 bro dont fall in trap with the guys who wants dividie, i am from southren part of india, i dont bother about these, My first prefernce is india. also we expect some respect, instead of questioning south, how many from north knows differnce between telugu, tamil, kannada? so dont fall into others trap and respect all...
Late Miss Jayalalitha strongly opposed GST. but other foolish leaders climbed the bandwagon. Now they face the music.
There is nothing Wrong in Implementing GST , Check with your friends who are doing Business they will tell about the benefits of GST. But the the GST council and Tariff should be Revised to 6 to 12% Tax is max . 18 and 28 % is not helping India to Develop.
@@user-lk8tn3fm5xthe point is is the tax rebate or sharing been done in a proper way? Why is there more share to states that don't want to develop human living standards, healthcare, and which allow human reproduction like rabbits. 1:3:TN:UP?
United states of south India…
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
@@YourFuhrer1933we will see at that time… BJP government can kill its own people to get votes in the north We know that
@@YourFuhrer1933 that person is you... North Indian company can't invade the south...
@@hamidAliC shutup muslim, no one is talking to you
yes
We South Indians feel we are not part of this Nation. Hindi Imposition, delimitation, unjust tax distribution etc.
Better to make your own country with your on Identity we know India bcz of Hindi speaking people not you
@@Hassnian-xq4skDefinitely..it will happen because of people like u …dividing south india always win for us …no more fights ….and north becomes a hell 😂
@@nandhu8004it’s already a hell. India is India because of we south
@@Hassnian-xq4sk if our south india separates, from where u loot money in the name of tax? 😂. I think you North people going to beg
@@Hassnian-xq4skyes a southern nation without abrahamics. I'm a Hindu from Malappuram. This is my greatest wish that I want a nation without abrahamics
We want south india special budget ❤
We have to fight for a separate country
@@jithsunny Special budget gurunchi fight cheyandi chalu
@@shyammadireddy6909
If we fight for a separate country we get a separate budget North Indian politicians always decriminate on south indias
Why you guys problem for everything from language to ego narrow minded. You don't even know unless you know which languages are spoken in North India except Hindi. You need to google it. Why Karnataka is giving free bus ride to every woman. You are saying it's so developed. Giving 2000 rs for every unemployed woman all this budget is used and than you will cry where is my budget. Even in Delimitation for Lok Sabha only Kerala and Tamil Nadu seat share percentage will be less and not for Karnataka, Andhra and Telangana because of Population increase there. Even Maharashtra population has increased a lot.
The railway allocation % difference is mind boggling.This explains the poor quality of rolling stock in the south where people pay and travel
There is really no respect for people who PAY and travel. We have been cheated. There is a very long waiting list even up to weeks.
I couldn't really see any new lines or doubling in Tamil Nadu. Madurai-Thoorhukudi line work started but no sign of any further improvement. Thanjavur-Madurai, Chennai-Cuddallore new lines will never be considered it seems. Many important, much demanding railway projects have been shelved citing as financially non-viable. There is a real bias.
50% State 50% centre must be made
Only 20% can be shared with Union Government that also northern states must group in specified duration!!!!
Because we suffering. Modi government is biased…..
Ur comments don't consider 😂😂😂
lies
@@ikaspatra4035patre in kannada is vessel.
Empty vessels like u make m...e noise😂😂😂
Lol u didn't understand even a second of that video. North Indian illiterates
@@ikaspatra4035 so thier are 100 likes 😀
Looking at the injustice being done to us, the British administration feels better!
The much money is pumped to UP and bihar and still its starving , pure mismanagement of govt….
We people of kerala deserve more
UP and Bihar chooses MPs and MLA with more muscle power and less with brain. Long term stable development and growth requires high education and depth thinking for long term impacts. They cannot develop like this.
Ys bro, they need to spend it for the education system developments instead of statues ..
@@user-of1tk6ih5m that mini pakistan better state then your UP and bihar😂😂😂
@user-of1tk6ih5m but bhakts have gobarsthan and eat gobar
@@user-of1tk6ih5mtoo many UP and Biharis working as a wages in That Mini Pakistan, if you have a capabilities provide your people a job in your states ????
Such a shame politicians from South have sent Nirmala Sitharaman to the parliament. She is so arrogant and indifferent towards the plight of south.
Yea she's dumb
Not sure if you're aware. The FM Nirmala Sitaraman despite being a Tamilian is not an MP from TN. She is not even a Look Sabha MP. She is a Rajya Sabha MP from Karnataka.
Fucker Sanghi , Nimmi Mami was nominated MP da Sanghi ….
She won’t even get passed NOTA if she contested
Yes, she does not dare to stand in Tamil Nadu.
@@user-of1tk6ih5myou mean upper caste Brahmans. Not all.
North Indian politicians think South is a colony to pay tax rather than an integral part of India.
If this cunning attitude continues.....
Very well explained by News Minute. Godi media channels are either not explaining or hiding a lot of details. None of the godi youtube channels like ANI, India Today, Times Now are even talking about 2011 census being used. Tejasvi Surya, Rajeev Chandrashekhar and Nirmala Sithraman are constantly making allegations that congress is trying to divide country but in fact they are smartly diverting people's attention from important questions.
they dont have guts to answer sensitive questions.
The presenter is quite apparently a leftist propagandist and she is suggesting that the south should break away. She is stating statistics however not the whole statistics; Even if there are some truth in the bias, she is hiding many. e.g. she has not stated how much Maharashtra contributes and how much they get back.
U right 👍
Why are you only talking about tax? Why don't you talk about other many things,,,,, what if jharkhand peoplws starts saying that now we will sell coal at the higher price as it is found on our land(btw even today India's energy needs depends on caol) , what if UP and Madhya Pradesh starts saying that now we will sell our food on the higher rates in southern statea at what price india sells to other countries,,,,, what if these 6Crores people(the total population of india giving tax) starts saying that now we will not give tax as why they have to take care of other rest population,,,,, what if northern states starts saying thet now we want our industries in our area which were transferred to southern states by central government due to see connectivity ,,, what if universities like IISc Bangalore, ISI , CMI are transferred to northern part , why our students have to travel towards south for research purpose?? If someone have answer please reple me
Those peoples are fighting on tax which dont pay a single rupee ,, and actual people who pay tax are silent, wow!
@@gaurav_zfe boss you don't seem to understand the discussion at all. This is about taxes that centre shares with states. You are comparing taxes sharing with trading of minerals and other produce ??? You can generate and sell what you want at the price your state wants if there is someone available to buy at that price. How is that connected to tax sharing?
Am from South Indian, firstly am thanks for, doing this show 🎉🎉🎉 reality ❤
If the grudge of south India continues, it is not good for the unity of India.
It's. Not grudge buddy it's equality. If they don't treat us equal this will surely change t.korea
@@Janardhan45 If this betrayal continues, south would feel victimised for better performance- rightly so. Thats not good for keeping India united as a country. This betrayal of southern states by BJP should stop for gaining political mileage.
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
all tax money you putting in up and gujarath . we people od bangalore dont have budjet for metro or outer ring road . dont tell freebies we give freebees for poor people to become middle class .
I think it's better to break off this union if no one can see eye to eye. This country has started to become a Big Joke. If India only favours one section of it's people then I cease to believe in this union. I'm proud to be an India but these jokers of BJP make me want to leave this forsaken place. I think our entire system need a rework. Jai hind
Nirmala sitharam needed Karnataka to get her MP seat. But, when it comes to tax devolution, then we are treated like dirt. Why didnt she stand for elections from Bihar or UP. What has she done for her constituents in Karnataka ?
Tax devolution is done according to Finance Commission's recommendations.. Not at Nirmala's wish... Educate yourself
@@LolithaRosewho is giving commands to financial ministry, rahul gandhi?congress? Or modi government?
Then why nirmala staying as fm ?she dont have any role in finance ministry?
First educate yourself ,we are asking our money ,we don't need your money,north india always shame for india ,looters ,chors
Nirmala is not an elected mp.
@@LolithaRoselol who set the terms?? And what about all the other changes which has made the states earnings to come down?? All done by the union right. So that they can control where the money flows.
Gud question 😂
I hear this news and anger increases as a south Indian
South India could have been growing more exponentially . But all money is been squeezed out and distributed to North indians😢😢😢
Why hasn’t that happened during first 70 years of independence.
@@amithooda1985 oh yes, out of 77 years.. a duration less than 6 years of South Indian as a PM. Well what a discrimination by both national parties
@@amithooda1985because of you North Indians dumb dumb
Excellent analysis!!
Thank you!
Allocate more to BJP rule states and less to non BJP rule states.
Later, they say, more welfare schemes, more development, better living conditions, etc. in BJP rule states than non BJP, and claim BJP govts is better.
South contribution is more to the nation, runs nation economy, provide employment to other states as well (migrant labour), people oriented govt.
What about West Bengal? It is also getting more, though it is non-BJP ruled ?
@@rajx7120 nope. Check the map. WB gets back 90 rupees for every 100 rupees in direct tax. Bihar gets 900!!
@@rajx7120 nope. Check the map. WB gets back 90 rupees for every 100 rupees in direct tax. Bihar gets 900!!
Why defend them and fight ourselves. Its our money, our right.
@@ku5285even Bihar was not ruled by BJP a week ago
We didn't get any reward for controlling birth rates.
We got punished
Delimitation happens and we get punished for our discipline and family plannjng.These northern states gets rewarded for their lack of discipline.Our voice will be muted after delimitation.We would be like second hand citizen in our own country tho we bears all the burden wtf
More south Indians should start speaking and taking up this bias of south Indian states.
I'm a south Indian. I agree that we should start speaking up and saying that this idea of allocating more funds to more developed states and lesser funds to less developed states is absurd to say the least.
South India must have strong regional party especially Karnataka since TN and Telegana are already strong 😂
Learn to spell Telangana before you even drop ur g a y ass comments
It won't happen until religious sentiment are given high value here. TN main strength is their Language and the dravidian parties successfully upheld their motto since independence. Funds have been put on researching about tamil and the results were too good. It makes them proud of their language at the same time do not respect Hindi. Kerala on the other has a communist part hence the socialist ideology, there is no place for religious drama there. Karnataka, we are fools, because summer we fight for kaveri and kannada and the rest of the year we fight for religion. Our ancestors never went to gulf or Malaysia to bring money here, we worked our ass off to build this state and we need to be proud of it. The land of black soil, karnataka❤
@@RecLarynG
I'm from telangana..
The facts is that bjpee can't win in both the telugu states...
Telangana and A.P.
No Regional party is there in Karnataka😂😂 it was Congress doing drama
@@Abhyuday-up4cm True, but I don't know how the politics is in the deccan states, can you explain
south india has to be a seperate country to prosper, otherwise it will be stuck with the northies in stone age
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
@@YourFuhrer1933 you mean Hindi invaders ..
@@YourFuhrer1933 oooo indian army i am scared
@@Aerotyler23 you should be
@@YourFuhrer1933come to banglore too we have nearly 1 crore north Indian labours . why spending all our tax money on up and gujatath. Is bjp government ready to form commite of south india mps and to give document and proof what Bihar and other states doing with our tax money.south commite need power to monitor and order what to build .why gift city dollar city in Gujarat why no gift city in Bihar or odisha . second problem is neet .after neet only rich kids becoming doctor and going to USA .hospitals in Bangalore running out of doctors and they are working 12 to 18 hours .now telling no more medical college on south, is this way to run country .why so much jealous on south and Bangalore.
We want separate country South India Tamil Nadu 🔥🙋
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
@@YourFuhrer1933They know that will be their last march
@@MadhuKallingalthodi 😂😹😂
@@YourFuhrer1933
As one person did, who slaved north indian kings for 1 bucket ganges water.
@@iii0988 live in history
I don't know if it is possible but if the same situation worsens we south Indians must unite together and ask our rights. Karnataka in particular needs to be careful because there are a few groups who play the fake nationalist cards. Andhra and Telangana can't be silent because their economy also requires a huge development and they have pushed back in recent times. Tamilnadu and Kerala remain strong in this regard
Though they are allocating more funds for Bihar, UP and vice-versa, they are still under developed in all the aspects. People are still migrating to South, Especially BLR, CHENNAI, HYD(Both Educated and Non-Educated).
Then, what is the point of allocating the funds to the states where people are reluctant to live/stay. Instead, they should allocate those funds to the southern states according to the population. This will be helpful for both the native and migrated north citizens.
Jai Hind❤ Jai Bharat Mata❤
no use investing in people who cure corona by cow urine
You don't know any idea about migrant labours of Kerala
@@nsha4535Are keralites migrating to North India.
I think what he is trying to say is the migrant workers in kerala from North and eastern part of India. Kerala has one of highest pay for the daily wagers which attracts migrant workers from northern India. @@thirunavukkarasuramasamy3330
UP has come out of BIMARU status in the last 7 years and poised to grow to a 2nd biggest earning state. Just because keralities are in more numbers in Qatar doesn't mean Quatar should allocate funds to Kerala.
South + Punjab because it's the same situation there.
Yes very true
Exactly
bjp investing all india tax money in up and gujaratha
Why are you only talking about tax? Why don't you talk about other many things,,,,, what if jharkhand peoplws starts saying that now we will sell coal at the higher price as it is found on our land(btw even today India's energy needs depends on caol) , what if UP and Madhya Pradesh starts saying that now we will sell our food on the higher rates in southern statea at what price india sells to other countries,,,,, what if these 6Crores people(the total population of india giving tax) starts saying that now we will not give tax as why they have to take care of other rest population,,,,, what if northern states starts saying thet now we want our industries in our area which were transferred to southern states by central government due to see connectivity ,,, what if universities like IISc Bangalore, ISI , CMI are transferred to northern part , why our students have to travel towards south for research purpose?? If someone have answer please reple me
Those peoples are fighting on tax which dont pay a single rupee ,, and actual people who pay tax are silent, wow!
@@gaurav_zfe Southern part is contributing higher than the north for decades ( not past 2years or 5yrs). Ok we accept! because we are brother hood, need to help each other. But what is the outcome? Still those states are not developing and there is no sign...
But in Southern part people strictly followed 2 child for family, improved education it helped to grow faster economy.
But Northern states politicians busy with money laundering, they didn't care about people.
In parliament also we have no voice, UP and Bihar (MP)alone take over all southern part MP's count combined. What to do?
He'll divide the public on the basis of their caste then religion then by biased distribution and finally one day he'll divide the whole country and blame Nehru and Rahul for it. The best Part is that people will still vote for him.
You forgot to mention language.
I have seen enough idiots in northern states, saying they will vote BJP no matter what. Even if they have no jobs and are starving they will still vote for BJP. I have seen videos of them saying this!
@@cryptidhunter9901 They are not fools. As long as they get maximum funds they happily vote for bjp.
வெட்கமா இல்லை...மற்றவர் சோற்றை பிடுங்கி தின்பதற்கு ...
ராமநாதபுரம், சிவகங்கை போன்ற பின்தங்கிய மாவட்டங்கள் கோவை, திருப்பூர் ஆகிய மாவட்டங்களில் இருந்து பிடிங்கி தின்பதற்கு வெட்கப்படவேண்டும்
@@kidukkuppudi9338 அப்படியா ... அந்த மாவட்டங்கள் பின்தங்கிய மாவட்டங்களாக இருந்தாலும் பெரும்பாலானோர் வெளி நாடுகளில் பணி புரிந்து அந்நிய செலாவணி ஈட்டுகின்றனர் . உழைத்து சாப்பிடுகின்றனர் .. ஆனால் என் மாநிலத்தின் வருவாயை இப்படி திருடி தின்னவில்லை .. எம் வருவாய் வட நாட்டின் வளர்ச்சியில் ஜொலிக்கிறது ...
en da percentage padra venna oru mavatamum maanilamum onna@@kidukkuppudi9338
ooran veetu neyya en pondaati kaiye naana @@kidukkuppudi9338
@@kidukkuppudi9338ராமநாதபுரம் சிவகங்கை மாவட்டம் பின் தங்கிய மாவட்டம் என்றாலும் கோவை திருப்பூர் மாவட்ட வருமானம் எங்களுக்கு வருவதில்லை வடக்கேத்தான் போகிறது.
If this discrimination continues, South Indians will come out for South India. This is shameful to the political leaders who will pave the way for this movement in the days to come! How cruel and insidious are these BJP rulers who do so much discrimination in allocation of funds in between South and North Indian's states?
What curse is there the south Indians to get this discrimination? Why these so called politicians who speaks of the South Indians languages like Tamil, Telugh, Malayalam and Kannada...etc when they visit South India as act of showing their Love for these states, but not giving them sufficient funds which is legally belong to them??? Shame on those mindless barbaric rulers whoever do injustice to South India!!!
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
@@YourFuhrer1933 I see that you are commenting the same comment again and again. You better stop or i will personally find you and report you to the indian government for inciting hatred. Trust me when i say this, i have the means to find you. Consider this as a last warning. I know what you are doing by creating a fake new account.
How cancerous one has to be to intentionally hide facts to form Anti-India narrative.
Arunachal Pradesh gets 4300% meanwhile Gujarat gets 30% and Maharashtra gets 8%
What are you talking about ??
Gujarat gets lesser than Andhra, Kerala and Tamilnadu and Maharashtra gets lesser than Karnataka
UP -Bihar are getting 220% combined... meanwhile North-east gets around 3000% combined.
It's clear that most funds are going to North-east because north-eastern states were ignored by all previous govts and there is need of Border infrastructure in Arunachal Pradesh to defend against China.
These presstitutes never mention how Gujarat and Maharashtra are getting even lesser than Southern states because it doesn't suit their North South divide Anti-India agenda. It's not North South divide it's more like Prioritisation driven by Necessity.
At least be honest, study the subject and then ask questions.
Ahh yes the 'Cruel Barbaric Curse' which is highlighted only during the election. After that nobody cares about it until it is brought back for the next election.
The south Indians call out BJP for appeasing Hindus with mandir but will fall for congress appeasement tactics.
The hindi language ban and now this only shows how attention seeking these people are and it will only harm the south in the end. The congress used this tactic in the north to divide hindu and muslim and now they are using it to divide north and south.
@@YourFuhrer1933 Tamils have their own military history! It won't take much time to start an armed struggle. IPKF suffered a shameful defeat at the hands of LTTE!
These issues make people feel more and more aloof and neglected
I believe it's true that South is neglected and centre is bias.
I strongly support for South India.
as a Maharashtrian, i agree,
many from Vidarbha region have to move to Mumbai and Pune for jobs and we actually are choking their localities, these people don't have any space to roam or have garden anymore.
i agree why they resent outsiders. even here with Vidarbha, we have very high literacy, yet we are the farmer suicide capital of the world- see the irony,
Humbly request you all,that time to time change all, so please don't think south indians are always stupids. Financial commission appointed by Union Government. Can't escape to put the blame on Finance commission. Southern states give more revenue than Northern states but get less than Northern states means discrimination to southern states. It will impact our federal system in future. So our Union Government should awake and sorted out this serious problem as soon as possible.
Southern states are stupid that's not uniteing. Afraid of Northern states.
it hints towards further division of india
Bjp is preaching that population must never be controlled
Ur comments don't consider😂😂😂
@ikaspatra4035 I know... bjp has stopped considering south india as part of india
@@fazeelzubair2787 u r not part of india
@ikaspatra4035 see.. u accept that bjp and shakas and perhaps ur religion has taught u not to accept indians as own country men but keep discriminating on basis of multiple points
@@fazeelzubair2787 ur people deserve it not to be considered as a indian citizen 😂😂
It was East India company and English colonization before independence after independence it's North Indian company and Hindi colonization whether it's BJP or Congress it was always like this... things can't go like this anymore
One more problem is that states like UP, which are drawing more money from central coffers than they are contributing, are using this money to build old-age homes for cows/cow ambulances/ temple cities/large statues in name of infrastructure etc. Money is not being judiciously used. Splurging money on vanity stuff should be done when u contribute enough, not by using money earned by other states. Any state which gets more than what it contributes should lose some of it's financial autonomy.
Bihar is getting 5x more than UP. Why everyone blames UP? 😂
States should fight back first revocation of GST, else the day is not far when states will be only having a begging bowl… with the kind back door politics Fuel and liquor may also be included in GST
The concept of Federalism is taking its last breath
So, What will you do?
@@YourFuhrer1933 I left the country already
@@vishnuvijayan7891 nice for you
@@vishnuvijayan7891 Then better promote fedralism in ur respective country. U r no longer an Indian to comment on this issue.
@@JohnWick-uj4gh writing a comment is my right. You can stop reading it if you want to.
If tax seperation is implemented, they'll understand south's growth and north's dirty politics ❤
The situation looks bleak for Southern states as the northern population is increasing and south falling. Almost 90% of key political representation and powerful burecracy is occupied by north indians and situation is going to get worse.
This is unfair. If this continues, as a common citizen, I will be forced to support southern state government's plan to separate southern states from Indian union. I want to know where my tax money is going. Not just this, whatever developments the central government brings in, actually comes first in northern India eventhough south indians contributes large share of income more than the north indians to country's growth. Hence This tax distribution is unfair.
You are getting influenced by the propaganda; The presenter is quite apparently a leftist propagandist and she is suggesting that the south should break away. She is stating statistics however not the whole statistics; Even if there are some truth in the bias, she is hiding many. e.g. she has not stated how much Maharashtra contributes and how much they get back.
Separate from India? So the armed forces will be mostly with North India no? Don't get carried away with propoganda brother use a critical lens to analyse all issues and why this issue is being raised just before elections....Jai Hind
Dear, these are issues for a very long time. The southern states have always complained and in the 80's one Kerala minister went as far as stating that there should be a Punjab model agitation (what ever he meant!) and lost his job. So don't be caught in to the belief that this started only after Modi.
@@anand1pillaiyour listening is only that extent. She also presented Maharashtra case also. She gave the reason for no claim of Maharashtra.
modi govt,bjp is anti karnataka,anti south india,all 5 south states are being looted,cheated,nirmala is India's finance minister,she is also rajya sabha member of karnataka,but she is backstabbing Karnataka,reason for this is she is not born in karnataka,she is born in other state(outsider),all 5 south india states must fight against this big injustice
We are Dravidians, 👍🔥❤️ kannada, tamil, telugu, malayalam, & tulu
We fight for equality.
south india should be its own country rn
Southern states shall be divided completely atleast in economics from rest of India
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
@@YourFuhrer1933 The answer to that person would be, 'guilty consciousness'. If the south cuts its supply chain on the tax revenue, then there won't be enough money to pay the jawans' simple mathematics...But the South is waiting to see the army marching to not only Chennai...but to Bangalore, Thiruvanandhapuram, Hyderabad and Pondicherry as well.
@@sathyansundar There are lot of South Indian People in Army are getting salary from South Tax , so why are you worrying about your Tax money? most of the Keralites are Army officers earning more money than normal soldier came from Bihar. Its not that your money its countries money , go to nearby industrial estate and count the labours doing the Hardwork most of the are from Bihar ,orrisa and UP. the goods they are manufacturing and companies owned by South or west indians. do you think in South India only south people creating all opportunities, And Modi want to Develop north state by creating Infra and Medical facilities , we are well developed with Private and public institutions present in south due to Geographical advantage. Travel like Gandhiji and understand people. we must give something to really needed People , Then only the Migrartion Labour will stop and exploitation of People will stop.
@@user-lk8tn3fm5x Ok Modiji Admirer! Did you not read my 2 words in the 1st sentence - Guilty Conscience. A South Indian Army brigadier, lieutenant, general or an officer won't command a soldier from Bihar to fire over civilians in the South. Just because a saffron criminal Hitler came from Gujarat, it won't make him another Gandhi. BTW how did we lose the Sardarjis in the equation? Just because a Sawarkar trained Chowkidar became a PM, automatically sent the Sardarjis as enemies of India? or they are running a referendum for Khalistan...Stop being a parasite and progress by spending money or building schools, not temples.
On a different note what geographical advantage that Modi is developing, not sure what you meant in that word salad? Robbing the rice-eating panel and paying the roti-munching peter is not development.
This is why more political power becomes important
It has been the norm of our democracy that North India sucks the resources of East and South India. While South provides jobs, tax revenue, science and tech, East India provides abundant natural resources. The whole North Indian business empires are built over this. This must change
Instead of east india company theft ..we have delhi company thef
Kuch bhi. All states are progressing well. Pure propaganda of congress and opposition.
huh? The beneficiaries of East India's demise were South India and Maharashtra...We East Indians were mistreated by central government and freight equalization policy. North Indians have their share of looting but this was clearly a benefit for South and West. Y'all were helped by the central government
@@herazionodias are more similar to south don't count us as bimaru bongs
@@techiepranab6825 Didn't ask if we were similar to south, Amaku exploit kara heithila au ebe bi exploitation chalichi by mining mafia. that's a fact
Divide Uttar Pradesh into four smaller states for better administration. Now U.P has 26 crore population which is imposdible to manage. The western part of UP has Advanced Cities like Noida, Agra, and it has sufficient Tax collection.
Even the Central part of UP with developed cities like Lucknow, Kanpur has sufficient Tax collection.
Only eastern UP and Bundelkhand region is poverty stricken.
So division of UP will help Central govt to concentrate on very poor eastern UP while distributing Tax collections. 😮
Very good presentation. It's shocking the way present govt is doing things according to their whims and for gain. So disgusting.
To add one more point, Agricultural production distributed through subsidy by centre which has no connection with tax collection. North contribute more towards agriculture than southern states. But cost paid by centre and produce distributed through PDS for all states.
Is the central government buying food grains freely from the farmers. They are paying for the food grains. For this they are getting money in the form of taxes from the states. You are talking as if the government getting money fron heaven.
Indian constitution has given right to devide this country when we don't like to live with North Indians.
gaand me dam hai karke dekh liyo saare north India hai army anda para commando me. North Indians are physically strong Punjab Haryana Jammu uttrakhandHimachal and northeast.
Why do u don't like to live with ni
@@rampatil1219 Why you don't like to live with your own TERRORIST blood group DNA Aryan family people, like Aryan Pakistan Aryan Bangladesh Aryan Rohingyas Aryan North Indian. Who has came from Mid of Europe country. your not my culture, language, tradition. Why we need to live with terrorist people?
Pm Narendra Modi is saying that india will become developed country by 2047,Being a South Indian if south india form a separate country by 2037 south india can become developed country compare to north india because south india population is very less and the people of south india know how to control population and in my opinion United States of South india is a best opinion and i will support it...
Southern Indian states need more autonomy and power to solve this crisis. Or else, we may have to do the inevitable which is a separate South Indian state.
Beautiful presentation!
If performing States as penalised and non performing States incentivised why would States like UP ever work?
Totally biased and grossly misleading
@@anand1pillai sorry, don't understand. Is the presentation misleading and biased?
@@jacobcheriyan it is certainly misleading
@@anand1pillai, can you please say what is misleading?
@@jacobcheriyan She has quoted dissimilar statics to win the debate; choosing the trees, disregarding the forest.
It is the dangerous time for the economy and next generation because of new policy 💀.
This is why we need people leading country by educated not those who have thier own evil agendas
Namma Tax Namma Hakku 🙌👍.
Bimaru states are not at all changing since 75 years
they will never
UP is fastest growing economy in India 😅 finish your sambhar rice 😅
@@james432fulI recently visited there best place to get food poison
@@james432fulIf central government gives money more to Up and Bihar, their growth rate will boost artificially but it does not mean these states are generating more money for country. For instance in Bihar, no factories are created and still growth rate is good because center is pumping money.
@@james432ful Lol still a garbage state.
South... don’t pass on GST to central LOOTERS... pass on only the difference after keeping back what is fair for your states....
modi govt,bjp is anti karnataka,anti south india,all 5 south states are being looted,cheated,nirmala is India's finance minister,she is also rajya sabha member of karnataka,but she is backstabbing Karnataka,reason for this is she is not born in karnataka,she is born in other state(outsider),all 5 south india states must fight against this big injustice
Arunachal Pradesh gets 4300% meanwhile Gujarat gets 30% and Maharashtra gets 8%
What are you talking about ??
Gujarat gets lesser than Andhra, Kerala and Tamilnadu and Maharashtra gets lesser than Karnataka
UP -Bihar are getting 220% combined... meanwhile North-east gets around 3000% combined.
It's clear that most funds are going to North-east because north-eastern states were ignored by all previous govts and there is need of Border infrastructure in Arunachal Pradesh to defend against China.
These presstitutes never mention how Gujarat and Maharashtra are getting even lesser than Southern states because it doesn't suit their North South divide Anti-India agenda. It's not North South divide it's more like Prioritisation driven by Necessity.
At least be honest, study the subject and then ask questions.
We don't care @@theniravpanchal
@@theniravpanchalfor every rupees UP gets 17.85 rupees. Stop spreading lies and misinformation.
@@theniravpanchal Gujarat cannot be trusted. I have heard claims (even from Gujjus themselves), that they run Indian government from the shadows.
South will keep on working for the betterment of the nation But UP and Bihar will consume every hardwork done by South indians and they will call themselves as Nationalists
and what evidence do you have to back up this statement ?
go through the datas in india in pixel or map my india websites or niti ayog @@ps6572
@@ps6572 We see it daily. Anyone can see it daily across India. Are you blind? Hindians always trying to impose Hindi and acting like they are the true sons of the soil.
Full support. USA federalism needed. Air forces all bases must be in Deccan and East and north east, army only in north, all navy in south.
If there is one Tamil who has done the greatest damage to Tamil Nadu, it is Nirmala Seetharaman.
haha she's also damaging image in Andhra as she was AP;s daughter-in-law!
Thank you for your episode on financial seeming divide between the North & the South
Now, we know the secret behind the rapidly developing Gujarat and UP model.
Thanks for the video..!
Systemic looting of the federal government at the expense of states via gst, cess etc. And redistribution to its whims and projecting they are developing India with infrastructure etc. And what can we say about our honorable FM..:-)
Railway budget to the south is just peanuts compared to the north. And allocation to UP is more than the entire southern states. Any CM in UP can show progress with that kind of central support.
Puzzles me how state governments have been so quiet for so long..especially southern states.
modi govt,bjp is anti karnataka,anti south india,all 5 south states are being looted,cheated,nirmala is India's finance minister,she is also rajya sabha member of karnataka,but she is backstabbing Karnataka,reason for this is she is not born in karnataka,she is born in other state(outsider),all 5 south india states must fight against this big injustice
They should atleast realize now Southern Taxes se Munkin hai
Do you have any proof or are you just repeating the words that someone said like a parrot.
Do your own research.
By the way, this issue has come forward only during the lok sabha elections by congress party. They know that they will not win seats in north and so they are trying to divide the north and south by appeasing tactics. Won't be surprised if they forget about it after the LS election just to bring it back before the next election. This Jumla will go on and it will harm only south in the end.
"வடக்கு வாழ்கிறது தெற்கு தேய்கிறது"
"The North Lives the South Wears"
Very informative and beautiful narrations. Thank you for enlightening. Let the north realize that the south is not there to feed you. You perform for your betterment. 😮
Solution is more federalism and reducing the power of center. Or else, any party can just spend and favor 3 or 4 large states and can rule India forever, because parliamentary majority can be got from these states alone.
Wonderful Presentation, salute to the whole news minute team, please keep it up.
Modi shall be reminded that he is pm for India...not for north and west India's only...
This divide always existed to some extant.Congress was not much different from BJP in respect of its pro-north tilt,for its obvious electoral calculations but it is the RSS BJP Modi gang that has driven the wedge much deeper in to this divide with their ideological stance and blatantly partisan actions.
The difference between PM and FM is clear .. the former works for Gujarat and the later work for the former and not the states
It is High time that the southern states become a new separate sovereign country.
As one person said -
What's stopping the Indian army from marching in Chennai?
Shashi tharoor had pointed this ongoing strategy years before ..even before 2nd round of bjp rule. Sadly it always takes time for a vast majority to understand his view
Apparently Dr BR Ambedkar has warned about this danger generations ago, and had suggested the south having more political powers, with it's own capital city to reduce northern hegemony. We are heading towards a West Pakistan vs East Pakistan situation.
Kudos to channel for showing this up❤
That's why it's important to have the next prime minister from South India
Even a beggar says thank you when you give them Rs 10 but some people don't thank even after giving thousands of crores.