NUFC RATE THE SQUAD | Part 1: Reviewing Newcastle's Goalkeepers and Defenders
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
- After a long, difficult season, and the disappointment of not reaching Europe, we look back at each of the players in the squad. We give our reviews of each, overall score, and if we would potentially move them on for next season too. In part 1 we review the goalkeepers and defenders.
Let us know your thoughts in the comments and your player ratings.
Please hit the like button and subscribe to the channel to help us on the road to 8k!
Follow us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/c...
Thanks for all your support.
Enquiries: evermorenufc@gmail.com
#NUFC #NewcastleUnited #NUFCNews
Looking forward to Part 2!
I’ve had a horrid fever all night and hardly slept a wink but to wake up to this has cheered me right up!
Thanks George. Get well soon bud 😁🙏
Should have done this live
Time constraints I'm afraid mate 👍
Thanks, great show lads
Thanks mate 🙏
Very harsh in your marking.If you were on the panel for the Eurovision Song Contest you would most definitely be a nil pwant man 😀
That Hall goal i feel will be similar to Gordons goal. He will have that extra confidence and get a few goals now hes off the mark in the league.
Some seriously harsh marking chaps but each to their own I guess. ⚫️⚪️⚫️⚪️
I think Lascelles is worth a 7 on this years performance, another player that has trained on under Eddie. I think Botman is a Rolls Royce, however you are spot on this seasons performance. I think Schar is a solid 7 and BDB 7 also based on centre back. Great show lads
Trippier 6.5.
Amazing player point blank. But. I've seen 2 players from him. The 2nd not good 😢
For a good offer, sell.
Tino 8.
He's young, a little bit injury prone, but as an attacking FB he's immense! Keep without doubt.
Hall 7.5.
Only 0.5 lower than Tino due to LB defensive work improving, not there yet. But the lad can run! Through the midfield with skill!
Keep!
Targett 3.
Tried, when fit. Sell.
Dummett 3.
Bleeds black & white. Not good enough. Sell.
Krafth 5.
A kind 5. RB on occasion not too bad. CH same. Sell.
Schär 8.
Never didn't turn up and perform as a creative CH!
Keep.
Botman 6.
A harsh 6, due to played with an ACL FFS. Not his 100% problem.
That aside he's absolutely class! Next season he returns!
Lascelles 6.
A solid 6. He turns up, puts a shift in bla bla bla, excellent shithousery, but he has a limit.
Sell. (As 2 other CBs due in)
BDB 6.
As a LB not the best but he really tried. As CH class.
Keep.
Good review. Can I just say (as I’ve seen this common mistake on a few channels). Gillespie does NOT count as one of four home grown (he was not with the academy between 15-21). At present, you are right Miley is under 21 so would not need to be one of four mandatory positions. Joe white would have to take that third position. However it’s all a mute pint as we f@cked up Europe anyway😅. Perfect time to let Dummy go 👍
just a point...under UEFA , home-grown doesnt mean at 'the club your currently in'........'Trained by club or club from
similar association between 15-21':) there are different rules for different associations(italy and england have different rules for domestic leagues for example)...but for EUFA it doesnt have to be at the club you are currently playing for, however..you must include at least 4 players that have been trained at the club for the champions league, have a look at 'the ultimate guide to homegrown players' on football handbook:)
@@noobadoc yes, they were referring to the mandatory 4 ‘trained at club, home grown is the easier more general target to reach. Maybe I should have been more accurate with the wording but I think you know what I am referring to
Tripps is a 6 based on early season, but has to be second choice with the emergence on Tino. Tino himself is a solid 8, Hall is a 5 based only on appearances, first choice left back for me moving forward, his ceiling could be anywhere as with Tino. Kraft is a solid 6 been great since he came in another Eddie masterclass Targett and Dummett need to go, no marks at all as they have done nothing this season.
Pope 7.5
Dubs 3
Dummet 2.5
Trippier 4 (post injury) 8 (pre injury)
Botman (pre injury) 8 (Post injury) 2
Schaar 7
Tino 6
Hall 7
kraft 4
Burn cb 7 lb 4
Laschelles 5
Morning all.
Chris, Mark, I'll score as I watch along.
Pope. Also a 7. You could see what our back 4 missed when he was out. Massively missed.
What keeps him at a 7 is his distribution.
Keep.
Dubs was a great buy. Cheap for £3m.
I use the past-tense "was" on purpose.
A 4.5 for me. Too many errors, the back 4 didn't work with him as we leaked 15 goals way too soon. Not goid enough now. AND then there's manure.
Sell.
Karius let go. Gillespie hard call done so little apart from being a 3rd bench GK!
Do you not think Schar would be a good number 6??
The RKO was on Ashley Young which makes it even worse.
Do you agree now Chris that although we were frustrated at the time Eddie was right to hold Lewis Hall back until he was showing him in training what he wanted
I'd say he was right as his defensive game wasn't on point but now he looks the real deal. He still persevered with Burn at LB way longer than he should've. It cost points.
@@EverMoreNUFC Personally I think it takes a lot to gain Eddies trust but once you’ve proven yourself he will stick by you,but I do agree Burn at left back was definitely square peg in round hole
Schar 7.8 keep botman 7 keep lascelles 5.3 sell burn 5 sell.. Knowing eddie he will keep all.. Cause he likes keeping rubbish... Hoarder😂
Pope keep, Dubs Sell, Karin’s Sell, Gillespie Keep. Schar keep, Botman keep, Lascelles Sell, Burn keep, Trippier sell, Hall keep, Livi Keep, Targett Sell, Dummett Sell, Kraft Keep.
Kamakaze Pope was a 5 at best...even when fit his fault both nunez goals at st james... As for the resst of the keepers dubs 5 other two keepers 1 for stealing a living
Id sell pope... But knowing eddie he will keep... As for rest... Sell if u can get anything for shite
pope7 dubs 4 and dubs is 35 we need better he is awful now so sell