Debating the existence of God [11/16/2024]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 22

  • @AlanV10
    @AlanV10 7 днів тому +3

    Another great stream, Ian!

  • @ThorsDecree
    @ThorsDecree 6 днів тому +6

    I've always thought logic ought to be a middle/high school class. That would make these livestreams far less entertaining, tho.

    • @dunkawunka2278
      @dunkawunka2278 День тому

      Talks about logic; then derives an ought from an is. Your comment itself is illogical lmao, pot meet kettle.

    • @ThorsDecree
      @ThorsDecree День тому

      @dunkawunka2278 I didn't arrive at that conclusion purely deductively. In fact, I didn't state my method at all. It's an _opinion,_ ya big goober.
      I arrived at that _opinion_ with consideration for how different types of education empirically result in outcomes that better or worse reflect my preferences.
      It's my preferences that ground the "ought," Humebro. I never claimed the _reason_ was logic. You assume too much. You should have a brief chat with Occam.

    • @ThorsDecree
      @ThorsDecree День тому

      @dunkawunka2278 Here ya go
      1. Understanding logic is a prerequisite for a reasonable dialectic
      2. I prefer that people be able to have reasonable dialectic
      C: I prefer that people understand logic
      P2 is a fact about reality that reflects a subjective opinion held by me. The argument itself is just modus ponens. A is B, I prefer B to not B, therefore I prefer A to not A.
      🤷🏻‍♂️ Idk what kind of gotcha your post was supposed to be, but your reading comprehension kinda sucks if what you got from what I wrote was that I think any _objective_ "is" grounds my "ought." To paraphrase The Dude, the greatest philosopher of them all, "it's just, uh, like my _opinion,_ man."

    • @ThorsDecree
      @ThorsDecree День тому

      @@dunkawunka2278 🦗🦗🦗

  • @randomgooberness
    @randomgooberness 5 днів тому +1

    Hey, this type of stuff certainly isn’t for me as an agnostic, but I’m also queer. I have so, so many friends with fathers who are extremely religious and full of hatred towards their children for being who they are. My father has always been accepting if me and loving, and he watches these streams like his own religion LOL. He has always taught me that we didn’t need a church ect to learn that hate is wrong, and streams like this have helped him learn more. Again this stuff is not for me, but I did want to thank you for having content my father can learn from and acknowledge the harm of what people like the ones youre debating would do to me. Streams like these have been his gateway into being more politically educated and learning more about trans and queer things so he could understand me better. Ty for educating people and not letting people brainwash others with hate ❤

    • @dunkawunka2278
      @dunkawunka2278 2 дні тому

      Why do you rely on how others perceive your identity? There is morale disease that has covered this earth since the dawn of man. Does the thousands of years of war history not tell you that people will always be unaccepting of others? Truly if your identity means so much to you, then you won't need to say it, be it. If the world of forms exists; abstract of material, and if you are beautiful abstract from being, you will attract good people. Not everybody in the world is going to accept your ideas. Be yourself and let yourself present itself, you don't need a pressup for identity. You are you. If you spew these classifications for validation then you will be validated by others who validate the word, not you. The same goes for the contrary, the need to be validated by others will either only ever cause a false pretence for friendship, or a false pretence for hatred. Again, if your character is beautiful then you will attract good people. And by beautiful I mean virtuous in moderation. -a straight white man. Now that I have told you my identity classifications, you have no choice but to categorize under a certain school of thought with cognitive biases, albeit good or bad; it doesn't track when you want others to just be themselves, unique in their own rite.

  • @ang3lofsmr920
    @ang3lofsmr920 3 дні тому

    Doomed in the womb is CRAZYYYY

  • @A-L0neDrow
    @A-L0neDrow 7 днів тому +1

    52:50 how could Pharoah or whoever it was "Know" they were not a god and still believe they were a god?? This makes no sense

    • @alexkiaii6548
      @alexkiaii6548 7 днів тому +1

      Well... you can have doubts and then narcissism born from insecurities.

  • @thefub101
    @thefub101 4 дні тому

    Ian, if god uses energy to do things and does not take energy in then god would reduce to nothing right? 😊 just thought that

  • @minotux9945
    @minotux9945 5 днів тому

    I love Flat

  • @kev6979
    @kev6979 8 днів тому +1

    When u getting cc for ur vids?

    • @Electronic_Boyscout
      @Electronic_Boyscout 7 днів тому +3

      Cc is automatically generated, but it takes time. If you take into consideration the length of his streams, it could take a few days for the CC to generate

    • @kev6979
      @kev6979 7 днів тому +1

      @@Electronic_Boyscout ok 👍

    • @Electronic_Boyscout
      @Electronic_Boyscout 7 днів тому +1

      Actually, the CC is already generated as I wrote my above comment so not even as long as I said. I know sometimes for my streams it takes a few days for the live chat to come back on I assumed it took as long for the CC

  • @Eromatics
    @Eromatics 4 дні тому

    Who is that just overdoing their makeup next to Ian? I haven't watched his lives lately...did miss something?

    • @LITZBEATZ
      @LITZBEATZ День тому

      It's sam, shes nics

    • @Iloveliz1495
      @Iloveliz1495 16 годин тому

      She doesn’t over do her makeup. Maybe you’re just upset that you don’t know how to line up that mustache 😅

  • @Tenebris_Sint
    @Tenebris_Sint 8 днів тому +1

    For Dylan,
    Here’s someone with multiple masters in biology proving you wrong/proving me right…
    ua-cam.com/users/shortswOOGhMryi0M?si=3F5ZOeKq7zjv2IIg

    • @Eromatics
      @Eromatics 4 дні тому +1

      Just be prepared to hear, "how do I knkw they are an expert? That could just be anyone saying anything" lol