Debate: The West Should Cut Ties With Saudi Arabia
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 бер 2019
- On the Intelligence Square stage the BBC’s star international correspondent Lyse Doucet chaired a line-up of Middle East experts including Mehdi Hasan. Who’s right and who’s wrong? Hear the arguments and decide for yourself.
The comments are not disabled when it comes down to criticizing Saudi Arabia. When there was a debate about “ Anti Zionism is anti semitism” all of the sudden the comments are disabled.
I think we can all agree that it would be an all out Digital War there so I can sorta see why they'd close off the comments there
@@stealthyspy1012 The same could be said about this debate. But the comments are open here.
@@rrraynoorrr true but the overall impact seems it me more louder with the Palastine-Israel conflict than the Saudi Arabia issues. Or at least that's how I think of it
Well You can post whatever you want to say about the "anti-zionism is anti-semitism" right here.
yeah, what's up with that?
OK, How come there are comments abled for this talk but not for the Israeli talk?
It's almost like they themselves didn't agree with their end result that anti-zionism isn't anti-semitism lol
I know right
I bet you could figure that out if you thought about it for a minute...
THANK YOU!!!! That's my point!
If there will be racist comments against Arabs here, the comments here they will be closed also
3 years later "The west is looking to strengthen ties with Saudi Arabia".
Wish Mahdi sees this comment 😂😂😂😂lol this fella really thinks the west should cut ties with Saudi Arabia!The west needs Saudi Arabia more than everything now
Who else can we sale arms to to go and kill Muslims? I understand the Zionist regime is doing just that but they won't buy the arms, they get it for free., more than $3Billion each year.
the wc🤡🤡
Saudi people are blind deaf and dumbed by the system of government, they have no right to see the true world from different eyeglasses unless their Saudi style, or will behead or lose their freedom, or will be chopped like Khashoggi, or should scare all their life in their skin if talk truth,
@Beek Hock in da Hos he can do that! He is a Shia and supports Iran !
Mehdi would make an amazing lawyer. He ends the debate and convinces me even if he is the 1st speaker.
A lawyer is nothing. He needs a bigger stage. How about Ambassador or Secretary of the State.
Love how in the Zionism debate they said "why doesn't this guy talk about Saudi Arabia instead of Israel?
Saudi is the culprit!
And that’s how I ended up here.
i cracked it. it's psychopaths. their condition is genetic and evolved around exploiting empathy through language. the estimate of 1% might as well have been pulled out of a hat as they can not be studied. there could be as many as 5% of them. they collect in positions of power as they outcompete others and it is clear to me that psychiatry is a field that is saturated with psychopaths. they can identify each other, a hustler can always spot another hustler and they have a shared interest in keeping the game tipped in their favour. their edge is contingent upon the ignorance of the majority, and so they strive to maintain that ignorance. this is not conspiracy. this is a natural order that breeds conspiracy and oppression and has done since ancient times.
Saw it yesterday. Great observation!
That guy who asked was an idiot
Now do the video "The West Should Cut Ties with Israel"
That will be the day
If that happens, everybody would live in harmony and peace lol
ID LOVE TO CUT TIES WITH ISRAEL THE THIEF OF THIEVES
@@visionarystar8957 you equate Israeli with the way Saudia arabia acts ...twat
@@MBVXONIDE anti semite you are mr
"To know who rules over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to criticise." Voltaire. The comments here are not disabled
And… the Zionist debate’s comments were disabled
@@zthekhan11 exactly
@@zthekhan11 Well considering the habit of Neo-Nazis to flood and circle jerk on any subject talking about Jewish people and the timeframe that video was released saw precious rise in Far-Right activity in Europe and North America, Iq2 did that with that in mind, but going to another video to cry about it is major cope.
@@niceyniceyzoozoo836 If they have to disable comments, they have to disable for every video, jews are unique or better than the rest
I cannot believe 52 people agree with you. This channel hosts an hour long video exposing terrible arguments of zionists and brutal critique of Izrael but since you personally cannot insult the speakers in the comment section, there must be a zionists plot behind it. I'm yet to find a smart person use this Voltaire quote in proper context.
Medhi Hassan is my man. Outspoken, brilliant and funny. He carries the light of Islam the way this great religion was meant to be. I was born Christian and I will remain Christian, but I have the greatest respect for Islam the way it describes our God and the way to Him. No religion is as misunderstood and back stabbed in the western world as Islam and our media makes people believe that Islam is the way IS and Saudi Arabia portrait their religion. Nothing could be further from the truth.
West, mainly US and Britain have double standards.
George Stacey Exactly!
Sure you are correct but also Al Jazeera is the platform for all Islamic Radicals... Qatar and Turkey are the ones who are parenting ISIS... (Not used in Yemen)... Can't you use some logic and think why Al Jazeera is still againist the Egyptians revolution against Muslims brotherhood and calling our revolution a Coup but the numbers of voters to Al Sisi has driven the sectarian Turkey ruler Erdogan crazy....
Only Terrorists condemn Saudi's, and colonialist are preparing the media for another made Iraq and Syria and another Libya which is Process.
If you think that Al Jazeera is the voice for the MiddleEast is like thinking that Hamas is not a Israilian made authority... Dear Western you are brain washed....
@@xunqianbaidu6917
IF doubel standards is the whataboutery you mean...I have the courage to tell you that all Nations have some forbidden opinions upon which citizens will be punished but this is not the motion. for the motion we say UK and US are the reason for ISIS... so they can just do whatever they want with their fake opinions of interests.
@@yasserdarwish6609 Watch this passage and learn from the invention of isis
ua-cam.com/video/OQuceU3x2Ww/v-deo.html
George Stacey absolutely you’re right
Why the comments on this debate is available but on the debate about "anti-zionism is anti semitism" are disbaled?
I prepared my popcorn :(
the Zionism debate is probably just a more hot button topic so they wanted to avoid any huge arguments in the comments
@@omaramr6107 can u imagine the comments on anti zionism !
i cracked it. it's psychopaths. their condition is genetic and evolved around exploiting empathy through language. the estimate of 1% might as well have been pulled out of a hat as they can not be studied. there could be as many as 5% of them. they collect in positions of power as they outcompete others and it is clear to me that psychiatry is a field that is saturated with psychopaths. they can identify each other, a hustler can always spot another hustler and they have a shared interest in keeping the game tipped in their favour. their edge is contingent upon the ignorance of the majority, and so they strive to maintain that ignorance. this is not conspiracy. this is a natural order that breeds conspiracy and oppression and has done since ancient times.
Because zionists sounds a whole of a lot like pure arian nazism
Cause the zionist can't handle more heat 🤣
They always choose Mehdi pictures for theirs videos miniatures, just that mean a lot :)
That's what gets the views. Because many people click on debate videos just because he is in it(I am one of them)
@@cyberanon2463 so true man he's good at debating
@@bakrsalm2499 Exactly
@@cyberanon2463 I am also for this reason
I love Mehdi. He's so well-spoken and knowledgeable - as seen in this debate and the Zionism debate. He's passionate enough about the subject but not in a tacky way.
He's being a little immature and emotional as opposed to measured and precise.
@@sayem619 immature? What are you talking about?
@@cyberanon2463 his arguments are all over the place
@@sayem619 if that was the case then nobody would vote for him. Half the people come there just to listen to his speech. The people are not suffering from an illusion, he makes perfect points backed by trusted sources which he always point out. Also the whole time he talked about the reasons the west should cut ties with saudi arabia which is 100% related to the topic of this debate
Mehdi Hassan is a twelver shia Indian Muslim. I consider him biased. India has many Muslim with Neo Ottoman views who wanted to revive Turkish Ottoman empire over Arabs.
This is why most Indian Muslims such as Deobandis Barelvis and other still follow texts that are anti Arab.
They are not anti Saudi they are anti ARAB altogether.
Every single debate he's in Mehdi ends the debate before he finishes his opening statement
That's 1 of many reasons he is not in most debates...
Watch his interview with Richard Dawkins. Dawkins made him appear silly.
@@tafftastic Just watched the Interview, nobody made any1 look silly.. but was just a talk and not a debate were you win or lose... it was a RESPECTFULL CONVERSATION
@@tafftastic Now the only thing silly is your name sir Pfffffff, and your picture
@Ismael Barrera
Welp.. Didn't Islam is also a religion? Apparently he's a muslim, so what's the shocking issues?
Btw, it’s awesome to see school children in the audience. Children of the world need to know the facts.
i cracked it. it's psychopaths. their condition is genetic and evolved around exploiting empathy through language. the estimate of 1% might as well have been pulled out of a hat as they can not be studied. there could be as many as 5% of them. they collect in positions of power as they outcompete others and it is clear to me that psychiatry is a field that is saturated with psychopaths. they can identify each other, a hustler can always spot another hustler and they have a shared interest in keeping the game tipped in their favour. their edge is contingent upon the ignorance of the majority, and so they strive to maintain that ignorance. this is not conspiracy. this is a natural order that breeds conspiracy and oppression and has done since ancient times.
Thank you my dear.
The should also uncover hidden truth. Western arrogance is a crime. Also USA are racist people. Nearly every European imperialists sucked the blood out of their invaded countries
@@Serkant75 I dont like bin salman but these guys are like we have a saying in my country:the donkey tell to the rooster;oh your ears are so big
What facts 😅 it's just PS
Mahdi always makes a debate worth watching, very intelligent and knowledgeable
The truth is that even they know that because the kept him in the thumbnail
I click when I see him 😂
@@taimur466 same
Yeah he just speaks facts and doesn't loop around unclear claims
Unless the subject is Islam, religions or gods! There he is just another looney, believing in flying horses and other non senses
The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said: If anyone memorized ten verses from the beginning of surat Alkahf, he will be protected from the trial of Dajjal. In another narration: From the closing of surat Alkahf. Allah grants success.
Dajjal is ataturk that destroyed islam in turkey hearth of old ottoman
@ketix 7 great news brother, i wish you memorize the whole surah and Quran, i advice you to read the book of Tribulations and Portents of the last hour in Sahih Muslim, it is important
how is that relevant to this video?
@@fakhrussalhin3149 most of the viewers are muslims
I like that Mehdi in his debates always highlights the impact of not voting for what he stands for. That's his Mortal Kombat style finisher 👍
👍🏽
He would be more effective if he slows down in his speech delivery.
@@willng247 He doesn't speak that fast
@@willng247 go read a book
Thats the british mp at the parliament style
Next one: should the west/most countries in general cut ties with Israel
Spoiler alert: the answer is yes
No. Israel is a good country. Every civilized country have good friendship with Israel.
So, only in your dreams.
Rama krishnan well india is not civilized
Utkarsh Ujjain it’s true India is far from being civilised killings Muslims for cows that’s insane
Utkarsh Ujjain curb your islamophobea
Challenge Drama well hypocrisy at peaks. India is the only country where people of all religions can live in peace. Only trouble making people get into trouble.
As a muslim, I feel courageous and motivated every time I watch Mehdi. May Allah bless you to do more awesome work
what?@@reemyziz
Mehdi’s signature move is good *delivery* of facts to the debate 🔥
Heart rate goes up when he is talking
US: You still got oil?
Saudi: yes
US: Ok '-'
Saudi: You want oil?
US: Yes
Saudi: Ok, you pay more than China who uses more than you.
Seriously, don't you know how it really is?
We barely even import oil from the Middle East anymore, so....
08aoc exactly
😂
@08aoc fast forward to the current situation....
Hasan ur next on the MBS list to be executed, so pls don’t visit any Saudi embassy under any circumstance.
Ur safety comes first. Be very careful.
He thankfully works for Al-Jazeera, which is owned by the powerful Qatari government.
Specially Mehdi Hassan.
@@bensonfang1868 Qatar is a terrorist supporter.
@@kp5602 sure but the're strongly against the saoudian regim
@@aminen2587
And? Qatar is the one who did all the shit you accuse Saudi Arabia of.
The first debater was amazing and I was fueled to cut ties with SA. But the opposition took a pacifist approach in cooling people down, well played...
True, haha. I'm still more inclined to the view of the first speaker though
An excellent expression of Mr. Mehdi is a valuable lesson for me to contribute for my PHD. Examination. Thank you so much.
Hassan Mehdi is a formidable debater and, for the longest time time, I've seen him on the opposite side of the table. I'm so glad to see him on the same side of an issue I agree with. Hassan - you go guy!
I have been following him for years, but I don't see him Changing sides. This is what his personal beliefs push him to do.
@@lonelytraveler541
He didn't say he changed sides, he said he disagrees with him on most other issues.
Gordon Sutton
What do you disagree with him on?
I agree that it's nice to see him on the right side of the table. Unfortunately he'll be right back to supporting unrestrained capitalism with all the damage it does tomorrow.
I am so grateful for young 2 panalist.who were for the mrion.britu2 and westerner SHOULD cut arms deal 199 % to Saudi.do not take innocent lives by giving arms.do not draw red carpet s for murders.my respects to 2 young smart panalist ."no ties at all with saudi".
Mehdi Hassan closed the debate before it started. Thrilling, magnificent speech. Thanks for summing the subject up so eloquently.
@L B - What ever , it was Master Bone Saw that had a guy cut up while he was still alive in an embassy on foreign soil. That is what this is about !
Glenn V.
The speaker didn't address Iran's proxy wars in Yemen, Palenstein, etc...
💞🇬🇧🇺🇸🇬🇧🎈🎈🎈
hes a total Stud
i love that man-- no homo!
@@kccox8516 this debate is about wether the west should cut ties with SA. I don't see Iran anywhere in the motion.
@@MBVXONIDE Al Jazeera is the platform for all Islamic Radicals... Qatar and Turkey are the ones who are parenting ISIS... (Not used in Yemen)... Can't you use some logic and think why Al Jazeera is still againist the Egyptians revolution against Muslims brotherhood and calling our revolution a Coup but the numbers of voters to Al Sisi has driven the sectarian Turkey ruler Erdogan crazy....
Only Terrorists condemn Saudi's, and colonialist are preparing the media for another made Iraq and Syria and another Libya which is Process.
If you think that Al Jazeera is the voice for the MiddleEast is like thinking that Hamas is not a Israilian made authority... Dear Western you are brain washed....
I think this type of a debate, would be central to changing the lives of millions of people if organised in countries that have devastating side effects from having toxic ties with nations like Saudi Arabia. Where cutting ties would mean putting an end to cultural influences from Saudi Arabia and thus would mean revising, rebuilding and maintaining authentic cultural and societal systems of those effected nations.
I was immediately hooked by the first speaker he speaks so eloquently and makes it so that his points are heard loud and clear
I love that there's a lot of young people there. This is an antidote against indoctrination as they get to see both sides of the issue, and it's pretty obvious who's in the right side of history.
indoctrination is like wearing a burqhka but than one for the brain.
BOTH sides of the story?
The story only has ONE side.
Turkish Ottoman empire ruled Palestine and Mecca and Medina.
Neo Ottomans dont want Arabs to rule Mecca and Medina and they dont want Jews to have Israel.
Indian Muslims support Turkish Ottoman empire and want Jews and Arabs gone. This is why Indian Muslims didnt want Pakistan to be created because then Pakistan will have been in the 'British' camp.
Jamal Kashoggi was a Neo Ottoman Turk who brainwashed Bin Laden into imposing khilafah over Muslims and Kashoggis supplied weapons to terrorists worldwide.
when Mehdi Hassan speaks, he quotes and people get exposed and owned🔥🔥🔥 well done Mr. Hassan! You would make an excellent lawyer!
But it's full of hatred statements and pro saudi
@@adenhamdi9160 Full of hatred for the lack of knowledge people have of Islam like you. Saudi gov are being destroyed because of western intervention. Don't be delusional.
but does the snake expose his sunnis⚔️🌙👳🏾♂️🌙⚔️🕋☪️?
Lol, yeah
Mehdi my boyyy ❤✨✨
I like how all of the questions are asked at the same time. It doesn't give the audience time to reconfigure it's questions based on audience response.
Pointing out atrocities by other countries does not justify your country's behavior
.
Nor does it invalide your points.
ua-cam.com/video/UxDnT7rF9eA/v-deo.html
I just dont watch videos that dont have the comments disabled, partly out of principle and partly because the comments are what make the internet interesting
Its ur own whill kiddo dont blame other for it
@@kingofbeaute8980 aye
When a video is about israeli conflict with palestine, there would be literally wars in the comment section between both sides.
And that is exactly the goal of Zionists and their apologists.
They can’t cut ties with Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 because of the honey 🍯 money 💰 Hahahahahaha 😂
Why is the entire conference ignore the elephant in the room. ARMS SALES.
THANK YOU. I nearly did a spit-take when Blunt advised against cutting ties in the fear that it would create a civil war in Saudi Arabia. If the royal family in the UK was an oppressive totalitarian regime routinely violating human rights against its own citizens, all thanks to a foreign country supplying them with weapons and military equipment... I wonder what he'd say if that country then decided that it was best for them to keep supplying the regime with weapons as to not spark a civil war? I'd bet my left nut that he'd take his chance with a civil war in a heartbeat.
If the only reason why there's no civil war is because your supplies help keep the crushing foot of the regime over any form of opposition, you are not keeping the peace, you are feeding and enabling a monster.
it was mentioned by Hassan but gov England will not do >>>> money
Saudi Arabia is a complex situation says Crispin.
But Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan...They were a lot easier to deal with....Clearly
They created Saudi Arabia why would they want to destroy what's already theirs they control all Muslims if they control Saudi Arabia they knew this in the early 1900s
They should cut ties with Pakistan too.
@@jusme4142 ABAY SALAY
This one of the worst things that I have ever seen. First what happened in SAUDIA Arabia is not there business we are happy with our government and I do not understand from where they have the right to teach other people how do they live their won live also they don’t have any right to Ruling, mocking, or demanding a change in the system of government in a country that is not their country. STOP TALKING ABOUT SAUDIA ARABIA leave us alone. Also They are talking and expressing their opinion in a country in which they have not live. I am from Saudi Arabia, and it is the best government in the world in terms of consideration for its people. As for their war on Yemen, did you know that Yemen, which requested Saudi assistance in its war against the Houthis, and that Saudi Arabia received Yemeni refugees, did you know that Saudi Arabia took care of their treatment? And their studies, even at university, and that they have the same right as any Saudi, and did you know that Saudi Arabia is now undertaking a project to remove mines in Yemen at a cost of $40 million?
The King Salman Center has provided aid to Yemen with a value of $9 billion so far
The UAE is restoring schools and rehabilitating children recruited by the Houthis
This Hassan dude is one hell of a debater .
Few can match his skills.
Horse with no name True he is co's the stakes are high and his Agenda is Big especially when he getting paid by
Qatar and Iran
This man is Quicksand
Nah he's just a snarky bastard who has no solutions to the problems he talks about, only able to make rude comments and talk over his guests and make jokes, and use his ability as host to always make the last snarky remark.
I haven't seen this video yet but just from the start I already know he's going to do it agin here. Being rude and shouting is no different from Alex Jones etc
This is hardly a debate! Mahdi is a good questioner, not answerer yet! He has to grow!
@megakids He is a shia muslim, they differ from saudi funded sunni extremist. Educate yourself kid.
1 1 “backward religious bias” that’s a nice way showcasing your personal bias in a bloody obvious way. I mean you can cry and bitch all you want but you’ll never match him on an intellectual level.
Certainly Truth spoken by Mahdi Hasan
I am Saudi female and it's the first time i believe that Mehdi Hassan is talking nonsense. He just relies heavily on his tone and intonation to convince audience.
Well maybe because he was criticising MBS this time. But nevertheless Saudi Arabia is very important for global economy and it doesn't matter what this Clown say's
OK, LET US CUT OUR TIES WITH SAUDI ARA.... Wait, they still have a lof of oil! Let's continue this debate after 50 years!
Haha. - funny😑
many other countries have oil. But the main reason why the west, particularly the US hold ties with Saudi Arabia, is because they keep the USD relevant.
@@winchesterlyon YUP! USA BABY AND TRUMP IS USING IT NOT FUCKING WITH THE EAST OIL NO MORE LIKE THEIR MUSLIM COUSIN OBMER
If you listened properly. America has been the leading exporter of oil for 4 years. More than SA.
I think saudi arabia should cut oil from the west so that the west will get below the poverty line ! ☺️
Mehdi Hassan the true student of the master of peak of eloquence
Beautiful!!!!
Nare Haidari!
Then you should see Shashi Tharoor.
@@aritramj I watched him too, but mehdi hassan is BETTER.
@@ErtizaAbbas
BETTER ONLY AT PROTECTING ISLAM AND FALSE PROPHET MUHAMMAD AND ALLAH.
U CAN'T TELL ME MEDHI HAS NEVER STOLEN OR LIED IN HIS ENTIRE LIFE, BUT YET HIS STILL WALKING AROUND WITH 2 HANDS AND FINGERS RIGHT
Mehdi is soo intelligent
I'm guessing that they blocked the comments on the Israel debate because it could have a lot of anti-Semitic comments which would give the video a low rating for the algorithm which would lose their channel a lot of advertisers money
but on a debate about Saudi where it's equally expected that there could be a lot of comments that are islamophobic, the comments are not blocked.
that shows how acceptable it is to be islamophobic that advertisers don't mind it
If it's not right to isolate another country then why is Iran isolated?
double talk.
and Qatar
Because they dont buy ou weapons
@@stewartfenton9099 No its because they promote terrorism.
Iran is the mother of terrorism. At least saudi arabia had never been proven to have a role in terrorist actijities. Iran under ayatolahs has. A pile of 1000 files related to killing iranians, americans, syrians and iraqi.
How can any decent human being defend Saudis it's beyond my comprehension
$$$$$
@@gopr3117 Excuse me, rationality and logic are not allowed get, gtfo.
Money of Course. Money is God today first and foremost.
@Kaynine
Wahhabism isnt a thing
@@kp5602 1. It's called Salafism, ultra conservatives with a zero tolerance policy towards nonbelievers or alternative thinking. I wouldn't want to live in a country where these pratices were considered normal social behaviour. 2. Wahhad is also a surname of Mohammed Ibn Abd al-Wahhad.
I support Mahdi's views but the lady is clueless and ignorant to the fact that Saudi government is not Islamic. She goes on based on her personal hatred of Islam.
She says the Saudi government is based on Quranic law but actually it is a kingdom and has nothing to do with Quran.
Quran affected the law, but it's true that Saudi is free for all religion
One of the most peaceful region for religion believers
Mehdi Hassan=Superb
His excellent speech is always powerful. I love this kind of energy.
No one should even speak to the saudis but first and foremost NO one should sell them weapons and ammunition!
Trump just illegally sold nuclear secrets which require Congressional approval behind Congress's back, at the same time Kushner got a loan for his overwhelming bad debt 666 New York building.
Fuk off
@@t.dickinson7942
Yup. We can all hang our heads in shame and sorrow, while we ask for forgiveness.
Absolutely!!!!
I would hope God doesn't bless ppl who let their neighbors starve to death.
The west should also cut ties with Israel, yet you won’t do that. I am a Muslim, I hate Saudi-Arabia as anyone else, but that doesn’t mean that Israel is innocent.
none of em are innocent not even USA it's all about power-hungry nations and nations trying to keep their hold on power
Why do you hate the Saudi people
@@ato7142 he doesn't hate the people he hates the government.
Wolf Puppy if he hates our government then he hates our people because we love our country
@@ato7142 nice logic
Thank u guys really loved it
May Allah bless mahedi Hassan brother!
Mehdi’s speech gave me goosebumps!! My favorite journalist, May Allah protect you my friend !
He’s on mosad list
Shukri Mohamed he’s a seek out now
What does that mean ? Can you explain it please
@@zargunahossaini9691 It means he is a great journalist and knowledgeable speaker. What don't you get?
@@robertfenkell1665 No surprise zionists hate him because he spoke facts about them which israel doesn't want people to know
So much admiration for Mr M Hassan. SALUTE FROM AUSTRALIA
Farina Marcina Murders from all right wing extremists are bad, White Supremists and Islamic extremists. One evil does not cancel each other
@ Farina Marcina - Islam literally means - being in state of peace! Please dont live in hate of someone but educate yourself! People in west are educated + reasonable, and hence adopting Islam today - despite their warring leaders/media (esp in US).
Don't be fooled, this Mehdi Hassan is a wolf in sheeps clothing. He is of Pakistani descent and is employed by Aljazeera, the mouthpiece of Hamas and international terrorism. Pakistan is the hub of International terrorism. The country is full of madrasas, indoctrinating the next generation of terrorists. Aljazeera has not made a documentary about the terrorists camps in Pakistan. Brenton Tarrant, a white supremacist and the Christchurch murderer, spent some time in Pakistan, and speaks highly of the country. Very suspicious.
Farina Marcina you are missing the basic point here Farina, that terrorism has no place in any religion. Let alone Islam which literally means peace.
@@TPerm-hj4sf nice and unbaised answer and I am muslim and I am supporting your answer , we are against any bad thing happen by any one and with any one either muslim or nonmuslim we are against voilance
Mahadi is, best intellectual with big data, best speaker I have ever seen, long live for my hero
Alhamduliliah sir for you positive debates .
After the first speaker Mahdi Hassan, the debate became irrelevant to me. It is difficult to see how anyone can argue in support of Saudi Arabia in the year 2020. So it is alright to keep women under subjugation, to continue genocide in an already impoverish country? If not for its oil, Saudi Arabia will be an irrelevance to the greedy western countries. Hope Mahdi Hassan is taking adequate measures for his own personal protection. The Saudi Arabians do not take kindly to such open criticism of its regime.
Agboola Daniel I can’t agree enough with your statement!
Totally agreed👍👍
I had to double check what year we were in.
It has never been more vital to support Saudi than now. They currently have a leader, in Mohammad bin Salman, who is making genuine progress at slowly reforming the country. If we forsake him now, and his political opposition (the Wahhabists) gain influence and power, Saudi will slip back down the path it’s slowly crawling out of.
@@gopr3117 you obviously have no clue to what's going on.
The West should have brought the United States to tribunal for the its action at Abu Ghraib it was appalling
Compared to what? What they did in Abu Ghraib was like afternoon tea compared to what Islamic extremists are doing.
James Hoover, well said. Totally factual.
@@omnipitous4648 oh muh the 100 islamic terrorists are making me more scared than the nation that not only oppresses all around it, but also is backed by one of the most influential nations in the world. Yup, 100% afternoon tea.
Jackass.
@@omnipitous4648 oh right. The famous 9/11 attack that somehow allowed the americans to slaughter millions of afghans. I remember that. Not like you give a shit about it since it's not america getting attacked. Fucking jackass.
Lindy West was put in jail.
Well done Mehdi Hassan ❤️
And every country has its own way of governing itself. Saudi Arabia is an Islamic monarchy and it runs as per the shariah law. Definitely don’t need a 2 cent journalist telling the world what to do and talk about world politics. They could have invited someone more respectable and reputable than Mahdi to speak about these issues. It’s an absolute shame!
I also want my own country, The United States, to start obeying international law and become a social democracy. I don't believe the United States should be given a pass any more than any other country gets a pass. When I say cut ties I don't mean cut all contact but I do mean we shouldn't be allied countries
Yea, well that's not what cutting ties means.
@@bdan6954 Doesn’t it mean to treat the country as neutral entity, completely uninvolved because I think we really do need that.
Thank God your not running the State Department.
@@darbyheavey406 have fun with your dictatorship state
The US will never be socialists.. never going to happen.. why would you destroy something that's done better than anyone else? That's suicide
After Mehdi Hassans intro they all seem so boring 😂😂
That shows that you cant evaluate what's credible and what is not, you lean toward pathos rather than facts. Mehdi said a lot of things that are not factual or credible.
Literally
just watch at 34:12...... lmfao!
@@salyemsalyem5746 Nope, it just shows how much of a talented speaker Mehdi is
@@najeebladha4358 the content of what se said was fkn awesome but the delivery that Mehdi hade was so superior and if he said that everyone would give standing claps. hahaha.
Who came here from the reference in the debate "Anti Zionism is anti Semitism"
yep lol
Was brought here because of Medhi’s debate about Zionism. He’s passionate and makes the most sense and still, comments have been blocked in that important debate. I’m glad that the votes went against the motion in that debate.
Mehdi Hassan is savage..:)
Love him
He is super intelligent
Take me to put him on CNN full time
Mehdi hasan is the type of journalist who makes the opposition say well done to his points
and the 2nd one is an ass....
All countries should cut ties with saudi arabia
The Saudi/British professor just talked about her academic career. Afterwards she became too emotional, said false facts like Saudis cut the weapon deals with Germany, etc. Mehdi Hasan was eager to make Iran, Erdogan and Qatar look like positiv examples for politics in the Mena region. Syrians, Lebanese, Iraqis, Yemenites, Bahrainis, Kurds would not agree with Mehdi Hasan their. And Iran was responsible for a terroist attack in France against opposition politicians. That Mehdi Hasan doesn't like Israel was also very obvious.
Factual argument of truth is much easier and convincing as to put forward. Well said mehdi!
I agree to cut ties with Saudi for sashes crime, why you aren't doing it against Israel?
Saudi Arabia was made to pay every criminal that USA makes to use against Islam or Muslim countries to distablize.
@@OmarAhmed-re7gw war monger people will sit around a round table and decide the outcome of country's
israeli is the son of USA to be used for its own sake
@@OmarAhmed-re7gw ueuhhsujjjnj
@@OmarAhmed-re7gw You people always throw that word around "destabilize" but I don't think that you know what it means
I was sleepy before beginning to watch the video; woke up completely and got motivated during Mehdi hasan and then after him, went back to feeling sleepy.
CHRISTIAN PRINCE on youtube will never put you to sleep
.
Jesus God 😂
I agree with u. He is handsome
No surprise mehdi always gives the positive inspiration and motivation
I don't have to watch the debate till the end of it to know who won, if Mahdi takes part, you know who wins!!! I am a big fan of MAHDI!
Manoun just outclassed Mehdi with profound knowledge ❤
Why the woman said shariah I dont know the Saudi family hides behind Islam they do not practise shariah smh
talib muhammad
They are not muslims, they project to the outside world another version of Islam and not the real Islam.
there is no such thing as shariah in islam you dimwit... Saudis made shariah to control the people more
THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS HIDDEN OF THE FAMILY. THE WOMEN ARE HIDDEN AND WE DON'T HEAR ABOUT THEM. MAY GOD MAKE A GOOD CHANGE.
they are great in harming people more that any other place in the world.
@@funkyworld8118 crap..Sharia is practicing what Muhammad practiced
The world should cut ties with America for arresting Julian Assange.
And for the Edward Snowden-case.
And for the Chelsea Manning-case.
And for the disordering of our world countries all around.
I think we all know that. The question is can we?
Julian Assange is a hologram?
Yasss
readme info most of the world countries apart from maybe west Europe rely more heavily on only China for goods.
Mahdi love you brother this is davoud Iranian American I always follow you on cnbc keep up the good work my brother Muslim
Wow, the lady from Britain was so good. Spoke so fearlessly. God bless you.
Us senator: yeah but who's gonna pay our bribes.
Yes yes
israel
i cracked it. it's psychopaths. their condition is genetic and evolved around exploiting empathy through language. the estimate of 1% might as well have been pulled out of a hat as they can not be studied. there could be as many as 5% of them. they collect in positions of power as they outcompete others and it is clear to me that psychiatry is a field that is saturated with psychopaths. they can identify each other, a hustler can always spot another hustler and they have a shared interest in keeping the game tipped in their favour. their edge is contingent upon the ignorance of the majority, and so they strive to maintain that ignorance. this is not conspiracy. this is a natural order that breeds conspiracy and oppression and has done since ancient times.
@@edenwylie8917 psychopath and physicalists ie. ppl who strongly live with the view that mind is just a word for parts of the brain
Just heard Mehdi Hasan's opening. Brought me to tears. Wow!
Al Jazeera is the platform for all Islamic Radicals... Qatar and Turkey are the ones who are parenting ISIS... (Not used in Yemen)... Can't you use some logic and think why Al Jazeera is still againist the Egyptians revolution against Muslims brotherhood and calling our revolution a Coup but the numbers of voters to Al Sisi has driven the sectarian Turkey ruler Erdogan crazy....
Only Terrorists condemn Saudi's, and colonialist are preparing the media for another made Iraq and Syria and another Libya which is Process.
If you think that Al Jazeera is the voice for the MiddleEast (Fact: Its founders are members in the Knesset) is like thinking that Hamas is not a Israilian made authority... Dear Western you are brain washed....
@@xunqianbaidu6917 I am from Egypt where tens of people were killed days ago by muslims brotherhood which is funded by Qatar and Mehdi hassan is not shedding tears for them... just because we expelled their Brotherhood ruler in our revolution that your media called a COUP because you could not turn us into the way you could in Syria and Currently Libya... I need to know which point you want me to elaborate or proof.
@@yasserdarwish6609 You're acting like the Saudis weren't funding and equipping wahab mosques worldwide with weapons.
The (Wahab) claim is meaningless nowadays, because the people being killed (Killers' Target=Muslims) and COUNTRIES destroyed are not from Wahabi...Leaving the facts about the Western media protecting Terrorism and supporting its logistics and transportation (like from Syria to Libya) is Hypocrisy... to stand for one accusation about (a Political activist with no proof) and leaving thousands of laymen and human beings are not only a Selective Justice and a double standards.. but this is SELFISH GREED, GUILT and Ignorance.
@@yasserdarwish6609 You are a very smart man, my friend. Respect.
why The comments are abled when it comes down to criticizing Saudi Arabia. When there was a debate about “ Anti Zionism is anti semitism” all of the sudden the comments are disabled.
I'm sorry y'all but this debate shouldn't have existed, if they're gonna talk about crimes and deaths and blah blah then we should talk about the entire world not just focusing on one country, that's just pure stupidity ngl
Mehdi Hasaan, the personification of...A TOUGH ACT TO FOLLOW. I trust that he researches everything, ppl like that can put a spin on anything if so they will. I am a great fan.
Me too he knows what he says and doesn't stall and lie he says it how it is
i saw the "Anti- Zionism is Anti Semetism" one and he absolutely wrecked them, they had no chance
@@amalbackerfysal9292 yes
@@amalbackerfysal9292 Not really, it amounted to a special pleading argument on Mehdi and Pappe's part. It was built on the same fallacious grounds right-wingers use to argue against nationalism amongst colonized peoples.
@@JustanothaGuy Well my personal opinion is what i expressed
Pleading is another form of winning in a debate. Really depends on how you debate. Some change attention to opponents some to the judges some to the jury.
That citation from Mehdi of article funded by Mamoon (the Egyptian speaker) at 1:12:55 was the final deadly cut by Mehdi! I'd hate to debate Mehdi, his skills are on another level
Andy Sammy
He is a Shia psychopath
yeah but it was taken out of context and from 30yrs ago. what the egyptian said today is factualy correct
@@Mohamed-jb9yx who?
I wouldn't dare either .....he is feisty.....lol
@@Mohamed-jb9yx your hate for shia isn't much different to Islamophobes hate for İslam. Lol.
I love how the young audience encourage strict actions and more experienced older audience is more inclined towards practicing restraint.
Perhaps older people know the pain of dealing with the consequences better than the young ones
.
Or they're stuck in their dinosaur ways
The problem is that if we abandon saudi china will make ties with saudi
Mehdi Hassan is so good👍
MEDHI HUSSAIN is an outspoken excellent speaker and he does his homework and that is the reason he is successful. May Almighty God bless you. My team and I have been watching you almost as much as we can. Thanks for your wonderful speach and time.
If you want to debate Mehdi Hasan, you better do your research well.
I sure will thanks.
Mehdi Hasan is muslim shia so Of course he against Saudi
Now Muslims around the world are started to wonder if Shia and Sunni really exist? Or just a political card?
We have Quran and saheeh Hadith I think it’s enough for Muslims. Labelling will not get us anywhere.
Well said AH Shadows, thats the true Islam
Black Fox thanks 🙏 really my brother
The question from the young "idealist" boy really summed up the whole decision about cutting ties with Saudi. It's a simple, straightforward understanding. What moral are we holding if we don't condemn vicious and absurd actions of crime?
I'm so happy for the results
Mehdi,
A true Masterclass in logic and reasoning.
Thank you.
Yoga
He believes in god.
@Aaron Sochaczweski you need a psychiatrist😂
Aaron Sochaczweski that’s hilarious since the people who worship satan originally started off as a sect of Christianity.
Reasoning? Lol He believes that allah flied to moon on a donkey.
i cracked it. it's psychopaths. their condition is genetic and evolved around exploiting empathy through language. the estimate of 1% might as well have been pulled out of a hat as they can not be studied. there could be as many as 5% of them. they collect in positions of power as they outcompete others and it is clear to me that psychiatry is a field that is saturated with psychopaths. they can identify each other, a hustler can always spot another hustler and they have a shared interest in keeping the game tipped in their favour. their edge is contingent upon the ignorance of the majority, and so they strive to maintain that ignorance. this is not conspiracy. this is a natural order that breeds conspiracy and oppression and has done since ancient times.
Love you Mahdi all the way from brazen valley of Kashmir ❤❤
Kashmir was a Hindu state. Give it back you evil, manipulative, hypocrite dog! Btw I'm not an Indian.
This was a good listen
00:14 The West should cut ties with Saudi Arabia
03:23 Women's rights activists in Saudi Arabia are facing severe human rights abuses and unjust imprisonment.
08:07 Saudi Arabia is not a significant economic or oil ally
10:26 Cut ties with the pernicious Saudi government
15:08 The West should not cut ties with Saudi Arabia based on selective moral standards.
18:04 The importance of Saudi Arabia and the need to consider multiple factors in international relations
23:22 Jumping to conclusions and linking a whole country to one crime is immature and romantic notion of international politics.
26:19 Saudi Arabia's restrictive laws and policies are causing a significant number of Saudi men and women to seek asylum in other countries.
31:46 The Saudi government's behavior towards women activists has not changed despite pressure.
34:33 The debate is about rejecting unconditional support for the Saudi regime.
39:22 The report concluded that detainees in Saudi Arabia have been subjected to cruel and inhumane treatments, likely amounting to torture.
41:31 Cutting all ties with Saudi Arabia is not advisable, but cutting some ties in certain areas may be necessary.
45:47 Engaging in megaphone diplomacy can be counterproductive
48:20 The debate discussed the concerns about cutting ties with Saudi Arabia and the potential consequences.
52:40 UK has strict arms export controls and highest standards in the world
54:38 Saudi Arabia's influence and support questioned
59:42 We should be cautious about cutting ties with Saudi Arabia due to the potential consequences.
1:01:34 Saudi Arabia's funding of Islamist activities in the UK is a problem.
1:06:02 Saudi Arabia's leadership in question
1:08:34 Saudi citizens face a lack of voice in Western media
1:12:45 Al Jazeera is being blamed for Osama bin Laden
1:15:12 Cutting relations with infidels and not sharing their celebration was preached to British Muslims on satellite television.
1:19:43 The British government should reconsider its relationship with the Saudi regime.
1:22:26 Islam should not be trashed or offensive, it is a fantastic face that shouldn't be just trashed.
1:26:31 Vote for Jamal tonight and all those names you heard tonight.
Crafted by Merlin.
Get Merlin: (merlin. foyer. work)
Use my invite code '99c13116-yt' to register and get 100 free credits
Mahedi is a true speaker and brave man. U are my inspiration.
Dear brother Mehdi Hassan, you are gifted. So proud! Your parents did you right by naming you Mehdi Hassan. We need more people from our community in the world to stand up.
Exactly.
I never thought that someone would read my mind. Mehdi is doing Islsm a great good. Bless him
I have learned so much from him!
Inspired..
No words can explain how best your debate was.
That shouldn’t even be a debate. You become who you associate with.
Even as a non Mehdi fan, he make some good points. Calling out the elephant in the room. Well done Mehdi, credit where it's due.
He is a legend indeed
Mehdi is legend😎
@@stoic_sapien1 facts
Of course you’d agree it’s against Saudi
Probably why your not a fan Of him to begin with
@@UnknownUser-by4le ???
I don't always agree with Mehdi Hassan but he is superb in this debate. Could not agree with him more. Thank you to both, Mehdi Hassan and Prof Madawi Al Rasheed for the excellent and factual rebuttels. Our Governments are all in bed with each other,preserving wealth and power for themselves, while playing out the masses, using religion!
I agree with him on this one, too minus his anti Trump comments lol.
Because it's in your interest
@@mathiasschneider7690 I mean trump has said some outrageous and stupid stuff in the past so it makes sense
I actually lost some of my respect for him in this subject as I am a citizen of a country which the west have cut ties with and have seen what that action can do to the people which live in that country ( Sudan )
I honestly believe that countries and it's people have the right to change what's wrong about their countries when they themselves want to not because it was pushed by other countries that believe they have the moral high ground which histroy proves they actually don't.
The west does not have gaudianship over humanity so they shouldn't behave like they do!
@@mathiasschneider7690 ofc
@msnbc why would you get rid of this guy? He is great. This is exactly what you need for the upcoming election year. I am a black woman from Cleveland Ohio and I need him to be on TV on MSNBC, which is my favorite news channel. Who else would really appreciate somebody like him I don’t know a whole lot about all the things that he talks about, but makes me smarter, I know that I have Palestinian acquaintances in my neighborhood because of where I live and they’re very very nice. And I don’t understand why I can’t be upset because they are getting hurt by whoever it is. No one should have the right to harm them or anyone else. This is the same reason why I support Ukraine. Why did you let him leave? I’m looking at you all with the side eye now.
i could not hear what mehdi said after saying ''patronizing'' when crispin was giving his answer in 59:28, if someone knows please tell me
I heard "Wait 'til you grow up to be a Tory MP, it'll be great"