The Early Days of Pakistan | Witness to Partition | Episode 4

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 103

  • @rahamatullamaliki
    @rahamatullamaliki Рік тому +8

    Apne kaha ke doctors india me muslim doctors nahi kam mile. Lekin yaha dubai me maximum Pakistani labour's hai. Indian Muslims and sabhi indian achi positions me hai. Alhamdulilah

  • @monikachhangani2076
    @monikachhangani2076 Рік тому +15

    How a 3 year old kid remember such a lot of things.
    Kuch to gadbad hai bhai

  • @engineerbabu6634
    @engineerbabu6634 Рік тому +16

    Jab ye India Delhi aaya tha 1984 me tab isko doctor nai dikha bol rha but tab tak india k 3 president Muslims the ye nai dikha...

    • @use4kksin7
      @use4kksin7 5 місяців тому

      Jinki Soch pakistanio ki tareh thi wo chale gaye the Jinnah ne yahi to brain wash kiya tha indian Muslims ka during Partition

  • @Karmazov
    @Karmazov Рік тому +11

    How many Hindu doctors are in Pakistan today ?

  • @shahriyarkhan1901
    @shahriyarkhan1901 2 роки тому +13

    Majority of migrants were poor, they traveled on feet and on carts and were massacred in millions. Muhajir are not " Ahsan Faramosh", they enriched Sind and the whole Pakistan.

  • @SurinderBagri
    @SurinderBagri Рік тому +3

    8:46 Dear Dr now situation has changed ; lots of Drs are available in India

  • @raniriaz4592
    @raniriaz4592 9 днів тому

    An unnecessary partition that had killed almost a million people while millions uprooted from their homes. The repercussions continued and as a result two nuclear powers are at each other’s throat ready to annihilate each other. Muslim population remain in high number in the truncated India and some say are better off than their brethren in Pakistan. A country called Bangladesh also came into existence. The partition will remain a dark spot in the history of once thriving Indian subcontinent.

  • @TSheikh-u6m
    @TSheikh-u6m 8 місяців тому +1

    When India was being partioned on the basis of religious grounds we the majority should have made sure that either get rid of all the muslims now and force them to Pakistan or else even after partition the issue of Hindu Muslims will be there forever.

  • @kamrankhan-ws7dn
    @kamrankhan-ws7dn Рік тому +1

    Pilibhit ek district hai U.P ka jo Bareilly division me aata hai nearest district of Pilibhit are Bareilly rampur shahjahanpur etc.

  • @kumarapuramsathyamoorthy4730
    @kumarapuramsathyamoorthy4730 Рік тому +4

    This fellows family had guns & swords as per his version at Philbit UP India.Rouge family.

  • @KhalidKhan-ki9bi
    @KhalidKhan-ki9bi 4 місяці тому

    بہت عمدہ چینل اللہ تعالٰی آپ پر رحمت نازل فرمائے ۔excellent channel.Allah bless you

  • @PrabhjotSingh-ku5nv
    @PrabhjotSingh-ku5nv Рік тому +1

    Peelibheet is in uttar pradesh.. Near sitarganj, nanakmata... I went there many times.. One of my friend living there..still peelibheet has lot of muslim. Poppulation...

  • @khushveersingh3297
    @khushveersingh3297 2 роки тому +20

    Poor people dont migrate during partition. Neither in India nor in Pakistan. Only rich and educated classes migrated to their majority religion country.

    • @KumarNikhils
      @KumarNikhils 2 роки тому +1

      Yes you were right. Partition riots were not as much religious but to loot rich minorities of properties.

    • @Ray-cy3ih
      @Ray-cy3ih 2 роки тому +1

      😑 tujhai lagta hai essay hua nahee

    • @PrabhjotSingh-ku5nv
      @PrabhjotSingh-ku5nv Рік тому +1

      My grandfather was not educated.. Nor rich... But he migrated ... With family and lot others also

    • @dajiedkynsai1669
      @dajiedkynsai1669 Рік тому +1

      Nearly 10 millions of the poor people migrate to either side of the border..

    • @samratvchakraborty5157
      @samratvchakraborty5157 Рік тому +2

      Only for muslims

  • @yashpandey6982
    @yashpandey6982 Рік тому +4

    India mein muslims ki financial condition is better than pakistani muslims ,,,,,,,,because India is a secular country whereas Pakistan became Islamic state since 1955,,,,

  • @R-World62
    @R-World62 Рік тому +3

    Pakistan me Hindu o ki kya halat phle woh dekhiye

  • @meengla
    @meengla 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks!

  • @prashantkatti118
    @prashantkatti118 Рік тому +3

    Please read Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed's book on partition you will know the first Sikhs were killed in Rawalpindi in March 1947 then talk all this

  • @Public_Eye3
    @Public_Eye3 Рік тому +3

    कराची हिंदू बहुसंख्यक जिला था और शहर में भी हिंदू बहुसंख्यक थे इसलिए कराची , थारपरकर और हैदराबाद हिंदुओं को मिलना चाहिए था

    • @ganeshvaylon
      @ganeshvaylon Рік тому

      Sindh ki Partition nahi huee thi isliye nahi mila kus bhi..
      Vaha Muslim CM THA

    • @Public_Eye3
      @Public_Eye3 Рік тому

      @@ganeshvaylon कांग्रेस के बड़े नेता और गांधी ने देश का बटवारा होने दिया और कोई इसके खिलाफ नहीं था ये देश के लिए दुर्भाग्य की बात है

  • @mauroofsultan6887
    @mauroofsultan6887 Рік тому +3

    Alhamdulillah We got. Pakistan we can practice. Our Religion InshAllah. Imran khan. Will come soon. But. The criminals will. Come to end InshAllah

  • @Navnkum
    @Navnkum 3 місяці тому +1

    India mein competition bahut hai , doctor banna aasan nahin , You guys be never be thankful to anyone in their life . Just look at what you have done to that land bhagat singh any many greats that were migrated to india.

  • @Playerone1287
    @Playerone1287 4 місяці тому

    Subbed

  • @sauravkumarjha5434
    @sauravkumarjha5434 Рік тому +2

    Out of 5 Pakistani doctor in Delhi, how many Hindus leave hindu , tell me how many minority there. Educated men thinks from both sides, not one side

  • @samratvchakraborty5157
    @samratvchakraborty5157 Рік тому +3

    India has 49% reservation for dalits and rest all others sit for competitive examinations. The one who is good wins. It has nothing to do with religion.

  • @reevin06
    @reevin06 2 роки тому +9

    Inke doctors toh pahele se hi bewakoof hai..Varna medical visa leke thodi aate India mein..

  • @GurdipSingh-pr7ob
    @GurdipSingh-pr7ob 21 день тому

    Sir u are right but have you ever thought of Muslims left in India. Still they are feeling insecure there. your own country lost East Pakistan. It was horrible.

  • @deepjuyal3244
    @deepjuyal3244 2 роки тому +10

    Sab jhoot hai aaj bhi pilibhit me 35 percent muslim honge wo to Aram se reh rahe

    • @ImranKhan1976
      @ImranKhan1976 2 роки тому +2

      Might be peaceful now liken angrezi zamane mein situation was different.

    • @deepjuyal3244
      @deepjuyal3244 2 роки тому +2

      @@ImranKhan1976 ya but wo log tab bhi wahi the aur unhone yaha rehna pasand kiya
      Meri city me bhi bahut muslims hai we r like family eid diwali pe hum sab ek saath manate hai two nation theory hi galat thi jaha sabse jyada muslim the Hyderabad bhopal jo india ke centre aur South me hai wo kabhi bhi pakistan ka part ban nahi sakta tha aur agar banta to Bangladesh ki tarah alag ho jata
      Muslims ke liye pakistan bana tha aur aaj india me jyada muslims hai

    • @AliHaider-br8gj
      @AliHaider-br8gj 2 роки тому

      @@deepjuyal3244 o bhai bas ker itni chor jitni log yaqeen bhi karen . mera ek muslim dost hay India se wo btata hay k halaat kitne mushkil hain un k liye aaj kal . us becharay ko to job bhi kaheen nahi mil rahi sirf is wajah se k wo muslim hay . har kuch dino baad koi na koi family threats deta hay . "two nation theory ghalat thi " lol seriously ? Hum tumhari soch se zyada khush hain yahan . udher jo musalmano k sath ho rahi sab ko pta hay. Getting persecute d every where

    • @deepjuyal3244
      @deepjuyal3244 2 роки тому +5

      @@AliHaider-br8gj abhi kuch din pehle Muslims ne 3 hinduo ka sir kat diya india me ab batao do u think they r not safe here
      Jaha tak job ki bat hai there is lot of competition here Bina padhe ache grades ke it's not easy aur agar job me discrimination hota to itne sare muslims doctor eng scientist nahi hote india me
      2 nation theory isliye Galat hai ye jinnah ji ka kam tha ki wo muslims ko apne saath safely le jaye but adhe se jyada yaha chod diye even Gandhi ji was also culprit nahi to partition bahut peaceful hota
      Wat abt minority Hindu
      Hindu girls are raped abducted daily religious conversation uske bare me kya kahoge
      Jab se bjp in power tab se muslims ko aisa lagta hai but Aisa nahi yaha sab pyar se ho rehte hai sare festival manate hai baki kuch muslims aise kam karte hai ki awaaz sab pe uthti hai

    • @Chroniclesofkashi
      @Chroniclesofkashi Рік тому +1

      @aurangzeb king Chalo IMF se toh 22 baar loan nhi liya aur Indian Muslims know ki unke liye kya Accha hai aur Indian Muslim yaha kị minority ki population is more than whole Pakistan . Pakistani desh par hi jhooth chalra logic par nhi apne jazbae se 22 baar loan liya aur 23vi baar ki tayari chalri logo ko bewakoof bana kar

  • @cater91
    @cater91 Рік тому +1

    Bhai ye javed akhtar ka bichda hua bhai dikh raha hai. Maa kasam. Kya similarity hai dikhne mein 😂

  • @R-World62
    @R-World62 Рік тому

    India se jitne gaye 70%log saare Aram se khate pite or Pakistan se jo aaye woh sirf10% woh bhi bhukhe

  • @subratdam2115
    @subratdam2115 Рік тому +2

    Most of the Muslims here prefer to study in madarsa so how they will become doctors ...see the condition of Pakistan today....and their doctors...poor state of health facilities....

  • @niya581
    @niya581 2 роки тому +8

    Its all about the vision of one great man Muhammad Jinnah, and the huge sacrifices of our ancestors. Unfortunately we just want to get something or other without giving back and this is common feelings and mentality of our politician down to a common man

    • @dajiedkynsai1669
      @dajiedkynsai1669 Рік тому +5

      You mean One selfish man jinnah??

    • @hoomanbeing638
      @hoomanbeing638 Рік тому

      Jinnah for ur kind information wasn't even a Muslim.... find out the facts first.... he was a atheist..... Well known as well.... what he did was try to get political power for himself.... that's the truth about jinnah.....

    • @_Khanshah_
      @_Khanshah_ Рік тому

      ​@@dajiedkynsai1669Muhammad Ali Jinnah was not wrong, look at the condition of us Indian Muslims now

    • @dajiedkynsai1669
      @dajiedkynsai1669 Рік тому +1

      @@_Khanshah_ if subhas was not dead then there will be no Pakistan.

    • @_Khanshah_
      @_Khanshah_ Рік тому

      @@dajiedkynsai1669 No balki Subhash Chandra Bose ji ke time zyada tarteeb se peacefully partition hua hota.

  • @TarunKumar-uo5gn
    @TarunKumar-uo5gn 2 роки тому +10

    The biggest mistake that stupid Nehru made was in not closing AMU after partition and not settling Ayodhya, Kashi and Mathura disputes.

    • @omeirahmedkhan6155
      @omeirahmedkhan6155 2 роки тому

      Why should he have closed AMU? 😕

    • @khushveersingh3297
      @khushveersingh3297 2 роки тому +3

      @@omeirahmedkhan6155 at least India should have renamed it like Pkistan converted Sir ganga ram college , khalsa college and all minority sikh hindu colleges into islamic named college universities as tit for tat.
      Pakistan thought India would not retaliate so till now instigate India but now India react violently against muslim aggression in India.

    • @zirwasworld5933
      @zirwasworld5933 2 роки тому +2

      We still have a ganga ram college and ganga ram hospital in lahore. Nothing got renamed

    • @SOny-bs1qi
      @SOny-bs1qi Рік тому +1

      ​@@zirwasworld5933But schools were renamed in East Pakistan, even if they had the word Hindu in their name.

    • @adhirbose9910
      @adhirbose9910 Рік тому +2

      Why would Nehru do anything to disturb his vote bank?
      Anybody who is not a politician doesn't understand Nehru and jinnah's logic for partition.
      1) They did not have a choice, it was decided in the early 40's by the British to create Pakistan as a outpost of the British Empire post granting independence to India. But they had to make it appear (to the Americans) as if they were forced to do it due to the demand of the Muslims.
      2) So invent Jinnah in his new avatar as a popular Muslim leader who represents the opinion of the majority of the Muslim population. Jinnah is promised the status of being the leader of the newly created entity.
      3) Nehru is also told to do his part of the plan by opposing the cabinet mission plan and thus ensuring partition. He is also promised the leadership role of the newly independent India.
      So both were just obeying their British master's and doing what they were told to do, in exchange they were given what was promised to them by the British. And the British got what they wanted, a outpost of their Empire bordering the oilfields of West Asia and the Soviet union. Which will be in their control because it will forever remain politically and economically unstable .
      That is exactly what happened, except that instead of the British it is the USA and now China who are using the outpost for their geopolitical interests.
      And nobody gives a damm about a couple of million dead collies , Hindu or Muslim.
      Like Churchill said " they are a wretched race, they breed like rabbit's, let them die".

  • @rajeshpratapsinghsingh500
    @rajeshpratapsinghsingh500 Рік тому

    Agar doctor nahi the , it is due to yr education of madrasa

  • @munnakumar3132
    @munnakumar3132 Рік тому +2

    Pakistan me koi hindu president yaa chief minister haii kyaa
    India me to Muslim bhi president bana chief minister bhii bana haii
    Communal Muslim poor Muslim beggar Muslim

    • @dajiedkynsai1669
      @dajiedkynsai1669 Рік тому

      There are no current Hindu president or PM only peaceful community governed the state of Pakistan

  • @farhanathar2256
    @farhanathar2256 2 роки тому +3

    پاکستان زندہ باد 🇵🇰

  • @MATHEMATICIANMUHAMMADAHMAD
    @MATHEMATICIANMUHAMMADAHMAD 2 роки тому +2

    Horrific partition

  • @unlimitedentertainment117
    @unlimitedentertainment117 23 дні тому

    Alhamdulillah for Pakistan imagine agr aaj hindus k under rehna parta toh kitna mushkil hota😢

  • @byblispersephone2.094
    @byblispersephone2.094 Рік тому +1

    Why are you people so shameless

  • @samratvchakraborty5157
    @samratvchakraborty5157 Рік тому +1

    So without competition Dr. Banne ke liye mulq tod do. Good thought

  • @anandsaini
    @anandsaini 2 роки тому +1

    AMU nhi gye lgte ho

  • @prashantkatti118
    @prashantkatti118 Рік тому +2

    Inko kisne bola tha Pakistan jaane ko. Koi zabardasti tha kya. Aur baaki logo ko kyu idhar chodke Gaye??

    • @myounas4456
      @myounas4456 4 місяці тому +1

      Ur government and people

  • @tahirasaif313
    @tahirasaif313 2 роки тому +2

    Pakistan zindabad Dr Akhtar Jamal Khan zindabad

  • @holywarrior5719
    @holywarrior5719 Рік тому +1

    An evil state created in the name of an evil religion formed out of hatred.

    • @awaischughtai2424
      @awaischughtai2424 Рік тому

      People like we're the cause of partition....you should be ashamed of your existence.

    • @trueman7226
      @trueman7226 Рік тому +2

      Allah hu Akbar ☪️ only true religion Islam in the world ☪️ 🌎

    • @holywarrior5719
      @holywarrior5719 Рік тому

      @@trueman7226 That’s why this desert religion founded by a mad man has destroyed so many millions. Religion is evil dharma is pure and divine.

    • @dajiedkynsai1669
      @dajiedkynsai1669 Рік тому +1

      Peacefool community knows only one thing: Love Jihadi..

  • @liaqatali411
    @liaqatali411 Рік тому

    Long live Quaid e Azam

    • @dajiedkynsai1669
      @dajiedkynsai1669 Рік тому

      Says an Arab wannabe..

    • @Priya19365
      @Priya19365 6 місяців тому

      Jinnah used to drink alcohol and eat pork. He also didn't know namaz. He made Pakistan to become Governor General