I've been asked FOR YEARS to do a WC3 Heroes tier list... Here it is.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @MrDoesntmatter
    @MrDoesntmatter 7 місяців тому +3784

    I don't even play the game but I need that information

    • @markadamsolomon5871
      @markadamsolomon5871 7 місяців тому +93

      same😂 i prefer watching than playing nowadays

    • @nacholuke8236
      @nacholuke8236 7 місяців тому +28

      I don’t play either but I watched the whole thing lol

    • @anbuhyuga8299
      @anbuhyuga8299 7 місяців тому +88

      We have all installed the game after watching Grubby, thinking we can execute 1% of what he is doing. Then as soon as a fight happens, you completely freak out, A click in your whole army and get deleted while you're trying to just find and select your hero. Apm at 1 per day.
      I'll stick to watching Grubby thank you very much.

    • @TheLordboki
      @TheLordboki 7 місяців тому

      @@anbuhyuga8299 Bruh, few years ago I went to internet caffee to play some vidya with friends. WC3 was chosed. I thought I had it since I played it my entire childhood. I got erased by a guy who said he played it a few times.

    • @DuduRossetto
      @DuduRossetto 7 місяців тому +2

      Hear hear

  • @eren__morwen5947
    @eren__morwen5947 7 місяців тому +1876

    Not me watching this instead of sleeping even though i last played this game a decade ago

    • @Deceit-hx7ey
      @Deceit-hx7ey 7 місяців тому +27

      I haven't played WC once, yet i still watch these videos, something very soothing about them 😅

    • @alishadmand2040
      @alishadmand2040 7 місяців тому +11

      same bro, and i enjoyed it

    • @gamingexes4075
      @gamingexes4075 7 місяців тому +19

      @@Deceit-hx7ey Because grubby speaking about his craft is ASMR

    • @EwokPanda
      @EwokPanda 7 місяців тому +3

      Same, except two decades ago xD

    • @planetary-rendez-vous
      @planetary-rendez-vous 7 місяців тому +2

      Exactly this, why is this so interesting that u ruin my sleep over this :D

  • @SCEmissary
    @SCEmissary 7 місяців тому +921

    To this day I find it funny that Priestess' picture shows her Tiger instead of the Priestess herself. 😸

    • @DaWanderer
      @DaWanderer 6 місяців тому +39

      I realized this today lol.

    • @akosszilagyi2656
      @akosszilagyi2656 6 місяців тому +135

      And that tiger is just a glorified horse. It doesn't do anything. No ability linked to it at all.

    • @alexpopescu8137
      @alexpopescu8137 6 місяців тому +182

      She IS the tiger, just happens to let a night elf archer ride her for extra dps =)))))

    • @pimiento3428
      @pimiento3428 6 місяців тому +67

      @@alexpopescu8137 you know too much... (casts shadow strike)

    • @reynoldswrap26
      @reynoldswrap26 6 місяців тому +1

      To this day

  • @skadehlidooshii4272
    @skadehlidooshii4272 7 місяців тому +751

    This video is perfect to picture how good the hero protraits are great. So much personalities with so few pixels. Great artworks!

    • @GrubbyTalks
      @GrubbyTalks  7 місяців тому +118

      💯

    • @kevingriffith6011
      @kevingriffith6011 7 місяців тому +119

      The only one I can complain about is Priestess of the Moon.
      Unless you think the tiger is the hero and the priestess is just an accessory.

    • @zurcburc
      @zurcburc 7 місяців тому +12

      @@kevingriffith6011well, it is 😅

    • @kevingriffith6011
      @kevingriffith6011 7 місяців тому +47

      @@zurcburc Clearly the modders need to get out there and give the priestess a tiger head and put a giant night elf head on the tiger.

    • @aomafura3374
      @aomafura3374 7 місяців тому +35

      @@kevingriffith6011 Well when you look at it from a Kid's point of view, that's the best part of it. I picked PotM every time because cool pretty Tiger haha
      If I saw a Sylvanas clone, I would've passed

  • @Nuggetheadification
    @Nuggetheadification 7 місяців тому +66

    Havn´t played War3 a decade yet all these hero icons and spell icons are just so iconic, they live rent free in my mind

    • @georgeousguy
      @georgeousguy 7 місяців тому +4

      Also, tho im not sure how it is in english, but russian localisation is a masterpiece of a kind, I still can immideately remember any unit phrase or even voice, its amazing, hope it was as cool in english

    • @PrimarchRoboleonFrenchyman
      @PrimarchRoboleonFrenchyman 12 днів тому

      ​@@georgeousguy same in french, amazing voice acting, iconic quote
      They really did great

  • @jorne6863
    @jorne6863 7 місяців тому +190

    I don't play WC3 since many years now. But this game was just a bit part of my childhood and... I listened 1 hour straight even if it's kind of useless. I just loved to hear your explanations about so much things I loved back in the days. Nostalgia is so strong...

    • @RubenSC_
      @RubenSC_ 6 місяців тому +4

      Just come back :)

    • @Jacob-Pogicat
      @Jacob-Pogicat 3 місяці тому

      Same I forgot how much I loved this OST

  • @Murkshadow
    @Murkshadow 7 місяців тому +126

    It is also really interesting because, like your tier list points out, Elf heroes really aren't that strong. You almost always have to go DH to try and shut down the enemy hero instead. But the race is entirely held up by the strength of Staff of Preservation. Staff makes it so ridiculously hard to get a pick and basically acts like a pseudo hero ability. Human also gets a Staff, but way later with a much longer cooldown and root.
    Something I think is really broken and underutilized, is picking up items from other races in team games. Staff on Orc is broken stupid, but you never even really think about running over to the Elf to pick it up. You can slap Orb of Corruption on your Shadow Hunter for a ridiculous hero killer. Or power creep with Salve, although your Orc will probably get big mad if you keep buying their stock. I remember making a 4v4 strat of just building Orc shops in my ally bases to supply them with fast expansions and healing salves, and business was boomin'.

    • @Roxar96
      @Roxar96 7 місяців тому +3

      Why is that for the shadow hunter ? Do you mean hex change the armor type and the orb reduces it ?

    • @Chayliss
      @Chayliss 5 місяців тому +1

      4v4 my fav

    • @Zeecarver
      @Zeecarver 2 місяці тому +4

      most NE heroes aren't that strong but you only need 1 or 2 in most games and DH was so strong and barely needed any mana, so you could save moon wells for a tavern hero or just HP for your units. So even though most of them weren't that great, even just 1 was enough for the race in general. It just meant... you had very little variety. wahaha

  • @NoSlow78
    @NoSlow78 7 місяців тому +182

    I appreciate the historical background for each hero. I didn't realize they changed so much since 2003! Thank you!

    • @SirTatManTat
      @SirTatManTat 7 місяців тому +4

      I also super enjoyed as a dota wc3 player that I could intuit a lot of what he was saying about heroes before he said it. Dota has a similar incredibly interesting history with balancing and many of these abilities are present in some form on various dota heroes.

    • @LegendStormcrow
      @LegendStormcrow Місяць тому +1

      WC3, SC2, and SC BW all have crazy histories.
      SC2's Reaper has essentially been 3 different units so far, the Raven was in constant flux for years l, and the mothership core is the only Blizzard RTS unit to ever be removed.
      Nothing in Blizzard RTS history is crazier than the Scout being useful early in vanilla StarCraft.

    • @LegendStormcrow
      @LegendStormcrow Місяць тому

      ​@@SirTatManTatI forgot what it was called, but I heard that the DotA successor that came out around the time LoL did had a community that ignored the official names and just used the DotA AllStars names.
      Meanwhile Dota2 took years to change things too. The Skeleton King eventually became a ghost to separate him from Leoric and elven archer had her name changed from Windrunner, since well, she was named after the Windrunner family from WarCraft.
      About the only DotA 2 hero from the original game you couldn't tell from a glance was based off from WC3 assets was Lycan, and he still uses Farseer's Spirit Wolves. He just isn't a giant wolf most of the time

  • @jkirisu
    @jkirisu 7 місяців тому +96

    18:18 It got changed back in 2011 with patch 1.25b: "Hex will no longer disable mana or health regeneration of Heroes."

  • @TheAngriestReptileAlive
    @TheAngriestReptileAlive 3 місяці тому +15

    I have never heard of you, but the second I saw the Pit Lord icon it memory unlocked entire part of my life and partially a defining era in gaming for me and now I guess here we are.
    Pit Lord, Crypt Lord, Dreadlord….I guess I just love the lords.

  • @bryansweeney3077
    @bryansweeney3077 7 місяців тому +193

    You actually were right the first time. Cleave damage ignores armor entirely. You can see this against knights, which have very high armor. The pit lord will often be doing more damage to the knights that are cleaved than the one he is actually attacking

    • @IngensViator
      @IngensViator 7 місяців тому +2

      lol the first time means is this his first correct statement?

    • @elrondmcbong6392
      @elrondmcbong6392 7 місяців тому +36

      which is also the reason stacking battle furys and attacking everything but the main target was a thing in original dota iirc

    • @Winnetou17
      @Winnetou17 7 місяців тому +1

      I guess the rationale is that the cleaved damage is the one dealt to the first unit, that is, after that one is reduced by that first unit armor, right ? Aka, to not be reduced twice by armor. Or the cleave damage is its base damage ?

    • @bryansweeney3077
      @bryansweeney3077 7 місяців тому +15

      @@Winnetou17 That's how you would intuitively think it would work, but I've tested it in the past and the cleave damage is based on the damage before reduction from armor. Cleave level 3 does 90% damage, so as long as the unit you're hitting has more than 10% damage reduction from armor, you're actually doing more damage to the cleaved units than the main one
      Example, with simplified values for clarity:
      Pit Lord is doing 100 dmg, with level 3 cleave (90%)
      PL hits a knight that has 5 armor. Let's say that provides 20% dmg reduction
      3 other knights are within cleave range of the first knight
      The first knight will take 80 dmg, and the other 3 will take 90 dmg

    • @Winnetou17
      @Winnetou17 7 місяців тому +2

      @@bryansweeney3077 Come to think of it, if it was as I said it in the previous post, you couldn't have done more damage to those behind, that was a brain fart on my part.
      Thanks for the info. I remember now from Sven too from DotA :))

  • @VKNoteMe
    @VKNoteMe 7 місяців тому +203

    Grubby, you didnt mentioned one of the most important features of hex, as well, it changes armor type of unit to medium. So it takes additional damage from normal and 100% from spells and magic.

    • @faustomadebr
      @faustomadebr 7 місяців тому +19

      And evasion is disabled, right? At least is how it works in Dota. Haha

    • @Hellwolf36
      @Hellwolf36 6 місяців тому +7

      I... Never knew this

    • @TomXCZD
      @TomXCZD 6 місяців тому +8

      This is not true unless it's been changed recently in Reforged. Heroes retained hero armor in hex when I used to play.

    • @cheeron
      @cheeron 6 місяців тому

      I dont think it's a right feature

    • @Ness173
      @Ness173 4 місяці тому +1

      I think you have hex mixed up with polymorph (it changes non-hero armor to medium). Or atleast that's what I remember like 20 years ago. They might have changed it.

  • @ShadowTheHedgehogCZ
    @ShadowTheHedgehogCZ 7 місяців тому +64

    You forgot to mention for Blood Mage that his Siphon Mana can be used on friendly Units AND Heroes. And when you do that, instead of Blood Mage sucking their mana, he transfers his own mana to the friendly unit/hero. Which is extremely useful when your Paladin runs out of mana for example. And Blood Mage can afford to sacrifice his mana, cause he can steal it from enemies again, because of no real cooldown and cost.

    • @setdan
      @setdan 4 місяці тому +7

      Was scrolling to see if someone would mention this. BM fueling MK is totally nuts. MK is a quick, tough SOB who basically has BOTH undead nukes. Problem is his mana pool is awful. In Reign of Chaos you had to sigh, be practical and pick either Bolt or Clap, with bash. But now, let 'er rip! Dude just melts armies with that robed elf backing him up.

    • @KleberDKurosaki
      @KleberDKurosaki 3 місяці тому +1

      Usually MK is 2nd because of Brilliance Aura also enable bolt spam

    • @beefchalupa
      @beefchalupa Місяць тому

      Some coder randomly decided to cook with the blood mage abilities. They are all more unique and complicated than any others in the game.

    • @TheShapeshifter
      @TheShapeshifter Місяць тому +1

      Holy shit, I did not know this. I definitely should use this to help out my paladin and mountain king next time

  • @lexbeats13
    @lexbeats13 7 місяців тому +19

    TC is my favorite hero

    • @mohammadalward6941
      @mohammadalward6941 7 місяців тому +2

      Oh yeah the shockwave is the best❤❤❤

    • @AntoniIvanov369
      @AntoniIvanov369 7 місяців тому +2

      Maaan, my thoughts are all about the same like yours!

  • @doctorstainy
    @doctorstainy 7 місяців тому +58

    I have not been asking or waiting for this, but its about time we got a hero tier list from the lord of Warcraft. Now we also need a map and unit tier list. Very nice. This is so much more than just ranking heroes, this is like a tutorial for beginners and at the same time so much information for vetaran players.

  • @LemonGingerHoney
    @LemonGingerHoney 7 місяців тому +67

    17:45 I think Fly yesterday, against Hawk, skipped Reincarnation, and went for 3 point in Aura. He got so fast and Hawk didn't even bother to attack TC, not sure if he realized that Fly went for 3/3 skills.

    • @kevin-7091
      @kevin-7091 7 місяців тому +11

      I mean, not attacking late game TC is not the strangest thing, even without reincarnation

  • @willyzh1106
    @willyzh1106 7 місяців тому +77

    Grubby's tier list actually makes a lot of sense. S = indispensable. A = very strong, usually best among options. B = makes important but non-critical contributions. C = highly situational. D = not ideal even in their supposed niche.

  • @DeaddMax
    @DeaddMax 7 місяців тому +17

    One of the great things about you Grubby is how well formulated and thought out comments and ideas are. I might have not played ladder W3 for at least 10-20 years, but I really do enjoy your explanations and context.

  • @189Blake
    @189Blake 7 місяців тому +53

    Cryptlord was my favorite hero. I always thought it was amazing that in the middle of a fight he could use his swarm heal and be ready up for another fight. Kinda sad that he ended up that low. :(

    • @joshuakim5240
      @joshuakim5240 7 місяців тому +21

      Tbf, it's mostly due to Crypt Lord being an Undead hero, meaning that its competition is ridiculously stacked. The general consensus for CL is that it's a good hero fighting for the hero slot against amazing heroes (because Lich and Death Knight are cracked).

    • @Carpatouille
      @Carpatouille 7 місяців тому +4

      At least it's a better solo hero than Lich and most mercenaries

    • @alaron5698
      @alaron5698 6 місяців тому +2

      Aww, now I'm sad on your behalf and also recognize myself a bit. I always tried going either Crypt Lord or Dreadlord first, as I think both of them are cooler than the Lich and certainly than the rather generic Death Knight. Leave it to pro players to stomp on the fun of mere mortals😅 I suppose that the consolation is that at lower ranks, you can probably do a great many unorthodox things and still get away with it, as what's optimal in pro play is so far removed from casual play that it is like two different worlds.

    • @kyraxx
      @kyraxx 6 місяців тому +9

      Indubitably

    • @TheRogueminator
      @TheRogueminator 4 дні тому

      "My might cannot be matched" ​@@kyraxx

  • @gishathosaurus6828
    @gishathosaurus6828 6 місяців тому +9

    Haven't played W3 in like 10 years, but I'm still very familiar with these heroes (not so much their patch notes) and hearing about them coming from a pro like you is always great content

  • @renardor
    @renardor 7 місяців тому +5

    Thanks Grubby. Your people demands a part II with ultimates. Except for a very few, they're so mana expensive that i'd often skip them for basic ability

  • @Vaxsysl
    @Vaxsysl 7 місяців тому +12

    I turned this on while working on something. The audio itself was enough to make me want to reinstall the game and make yet another playthrough. Speaks how great the game is. Thank you for the vid Grubby, it is really interesting!

    • @theshinken
      @theshinken 7 місяців тому +3

      Same! I immediately got an itch to try out all those heroes once again. WC3 is so great that I actually enjoy all heroes. Except BM and DH, from those I get 'Nam flashbacks instead.

  • @neonpeon7886
    @neonpeon7886 7 місяців тому +26

    I wouldn't put Crypt Lord at the bottom, he synergizes brilliantly with the other undead heroes. Cast death pact or dark ritual on a beetle and you get a lot of health/mana back, much more than a skeleton would give, and without wasting a unit that costs gold and wood resources. Also the dreadlord vampiric aura buffs beetles and you can use them to surround/trap enemy heroes with sleep. Also you can put him out in front of your army and let the enemy break themselves on his spiked carapace while you toss death coils on him and buff him and his units with unholy aura. He gives you an undead tank that death knight can actually heal, which is sorely needed prior to abominations.

    • @aprinnyonbreak1290
      @aprinnyonbreak1290 6 місяців тому +5

      Agree.
      He's outclassed by the DK/Lich bromance, for sure, but he's got some game. Early aggression via beetles and his tankiness, deals fantastic damage with his ult in longer games, and is absurdly tanky if he can get going.

    • @lyhjiba
      @lyhjiba 3 дні тому

      Cryptlord is for sure better than PotM the worst hero haha

  • @apxprdtr_mge
    @apxprdtr_mge 5 місяців тому +4

    I haven't played wc3 in years, and never touched it competitively, but what a fantastic video. I was glued to the screen.

  • @oscara1573
    @oscara1573 7 місяців тому +458

    -"Pitlord was a mistake"
    Grubby Miyazaki

    • @philippecote8571
      @philippecote8571 7 місяців тому +50

      "RaRa cleave, then they leave" -Grub'Tsu, Art of Warcraft.

    • @LaraCroft-nh9sw
      @LaraCroft-nh9sw 7 місяців тому +2

      So out of context lol

    • @poilboiler
      @poilboiler 7 місяців тому

      Noooo, they're one of my favorites! :'(

    • @alexpopescu8137
      @alexpopescu8137 6 місяців тому +7

      Pitlord did nothing wrong :((((((

    • @NeonNinaNights
      @NeonNinaNights 3 місяці тому +1

      Pitlord shot first

  • @SwayNoir
    @SwayNoir 7 місяців тому +12

    Seen some people in the stream chat commenting about how in depth and how long this video is gonna take to make. GOOD, could listen to this kinda info all day lol

  • @thebrokenmask8304
    @thebrokenmask8304 7 місяців тому +8

    I havent played W3 in like 10 years but I needed this tier list in my life nway.

  • @АннаЛиберт-ь1й
    @АннаЛиберт-ь1й 7 місяців тому +10

    Dreadlord used to be a bit wacky, true, but at the moment he's a staple vs Hu. Wrecks workshops much better than panda, can be coiled. Placing him behind tinker just doesn't feel right. I beieve he's a solid B

  • @omercelik5620
    @omercelik5620 5 місяців тому +5

    One of the best videos to watch in the office to steal from company's time even though I played WC3 once 20 years ago.

  • @AbdulazizACE
    @AbdulazizACE 7 місяців тому +10

    WC3 is my childhood game, I used to suck and even now.
    Even that I don't play it anymore, I do enjoy your wc3 content!

  • @phoenixlich
    @phoenixlich 7 місяців тому +221

    8:56 "Endurance aura effects every unit around him, fr fr, no cap"

    • @RatKing2137
      @RatKing2137 7 місяців тому +55

      End aura is bussin' making me look mid

    • @mackparker9064
      @mackparker9064 7 місяців тому +20

      enduranceauramaxxing ngl

    • @pepoaudi8253
      @pepoaudi8253 7 місяців тому +3

      Panda is the best neutral hero evasion and critical

    • @ambion19
      @ambion19 7 місяців тому +1

      I think Grubby is not taking into account that the reasons he gives for feral spirit S rank are all much more micro intensive than any other S ranked hero. The early game that apm is affordable, but less so as the game progresses.
      Hard to put FS and AM side by side and conclude they should be the same rank.

    • @Chayliss
      @Chayliss 5 місяців тому

      ​@pepoaudi8253 im finna open TC then panda next I log

  • @dutamulia
    @dutamulia 7 місяців тому +15

    Grubby, have you ever heard of a custom campaign called To the Bitter End? I swear you should cover this master piece, it is a full game within a game.

  • @zytha2890
    @zytha2890 7 місяців тому +11

    Pitlord is bugged btw his rain of fire damage values are wrong when you check it in the editor which is why its weak no matter what rank it is
    When you do some quick math and make the changes it works like its stated lol

  • @RandomWitcher
    @RandomWitcher 7 місяців тому +5

    I am still impressed by how much you know about the game and I love hearing you basically ramble and analyze all that information. I dont even play this game yet I cant stop watching your videos!

  • @Hoop248
    @Hoop248 7 місяців тому +39

    I’ve seen so many hero tier list I didn’t think I’d enjoy this… now I need more! Give us HOTS hero tier list Grub! ❤

    • @AdraVY
      @AdraVY 7 місяців тому +5

      Really helps that this is probably the most well presented and most informative wc3 hero list I've seen, clearly done by someone with both extensive top level experience and a nice presentation style. I've tried looking up wc3 hero lists before and the others just dont do it for me. More pls lord grubs! Unit tier list, campaign missions tier list...anything

    • @mickeyromeo
      @mickeyromeo 7 місяців тому

      Ultras would be under D

  • @VegardKristoffersen
    @VegardKristoffersen 7 місяців тому +4

    The background music added in this video is very appreciated. The Warcraft III music is underrated. Nice to have music to go along with good explanation of the heroes.

  • @kirksaintpatrick3921
    @kirksaintpatrick3921 7 місяців тому +10

    Please do a similar unit tier list!!! Loved this grubby

  • @Chipawapa
    @Chipawapa 7 місяців тому +18

    Holy shit! That story at the end was top notch. People who dont watch all the way through are gonna miss such a gem.

    • @Ness173
      @Ness173 4 місяці тому +1

      I remember watching a youtube video of Grubby commentating on that exact game. It was really amusing!

  • @sdamer4609
    @sdamer4609 7 місяців тому +11

    If they allowed DK heal not friendly undeads, but friendly targets - that would be so much fun. For undeads.

  • @SwayNoir
    @SwayNoir 7 місяців тому +20

    I was never good at RTS but I remember watching a lot of the pro scene back in the day, including your games, and I don't follow the game now but a video like this is still super interesting to me haha. Glad it popped up on my feed.

    • @Copperkex
      @Copperkex 7 місяців тому +3

      Don't be afraid , come with us on a journey, we almost always lose 50:50, I just came to aoe4.
      Not playing is passive ,like our parents, feel the adrenaline , feel life again ,don't be contempt , play ,win ,loose ,feel the excitement.

  • @mattmcgraw9458
    @mattmcgraw9458 7 місяців тому +4

    Grubby, I'm really happy to see this channel taking off. Your positivity and insights make all of your videos, regardless of topic, a joy to listen to!

  • @malt3aserz
    @malt3aserz 7 місяців тому +3

    seeing this summary makes me realise even more so just how awesome wc3 is. The development team back in the date was fire.

  • @pho3nix-
    @pho3nix- 7 місяців тому +29

    Many moons have I waited for this moment

    • @Carpatouille
      @Carpatouille 7 місяців тому +6

      *Night elf music starts playing loudly*

  • @Dumballa
    @Dumballa 7 місяців тому +5

    Appreciate the lesson. In-between the tier list you're still getting all the knowledge.
    The joy and utter fulfillment on that face from the 2019 clips 😀

  • @pizzaforever69
    @pizzaforever69 5 місяців тому +7

    Night elves heroes normal abilities : 💀💀
    Night elves heroes special abilities : 🗿🗿

  • @Iustinfm
    @Iustinfm 7 місяців тому +41

    46:45 "The moment you are starting to get su**ed... the su***ing continues for some time" getting me a bit flustered Grubby

  • @brickstonesonn9276
    @brickstonesonn9276 7 місяців тому +25

    I had to look up a video showcasing shadow hunter because i realized ive never seen big bad voodoo ever

  • @OrpheoTV
    @OrpheoTV 7 місяців тому +3

    Love this video - I honestly love your breakdown of the heroes and even though I played this 15 years ago, I'm seriously considering trying this again - Thanks Grubby.

  • @Khadgar07
    @Khadgar07 7 місяців тому +3

    I won so many games with my orc farseer and 3 grunts rush at first midnight back in the day. Then tinker came out and I won even more with the same strat in 2v2 using factory.

  • @henrymapleton
    @henrymapleton 7 місяців тому +5

    Mercenary tier list next!
    Also Alchemist and Paladin are a fun duo.

  • @TheKiest
    @TheKiest 7 місяців тому +4

    Great Video.
    I didn't know about the Hex effects like denying exp and mana regen.... incredible.

  • @TheNethertyp
    @TheNethertyp 7 місяців тому +3

    I would like to see you play a showmatch as Orc against a Human player, but the heroes of the races are switched, so you get Human heroes at the altar and the Human gets Orc heroes. This would be a fun way to test the relative strength of the races' heroes.

  • @osraneslipy
    @osraneslipy 7 місяців тому +1

    Grubby, I have been following you since 2005. But only in this in-depth analysis I have been able to fully appreciate your knowledge of the game and how complex WC actually is. Take care m8, you rock!

  • @Knuckles2761
    @Knuckles2761 7 місяців тому +4

    27:51 also gargoyles, skeletons, beetles, even acolytes, mercenaries and possessed. Dreadlord was clearly designed as fast farmer and support, devs just didn't think about even faster farm strats. Great design on paper, B/C tier in reality.

  • @Tempest_Murder
    @Tempest_Murder 6 місяців тому +1

    I love how Grubby has the pauses and rhetorical questioning that a university instructor uses, shows how much experience he has with the game.

  • @snakekeeper2073
    @snakekeeper2073 7 місяців тому +36

    "I AM HERO AND OBEY" -what i thought the blademaster was saying back then

    • @fuckingidiots2627
      @fuckingidiots2627 7 місяців тому

      U telling me that he isnt saying that?

    • @Sprintspeed10
      @Sprintspeed10 7 місяців тому +2

      wait what does he say?

    • @georgem589
      @georgem589 7 місяців тому +18

      @@Sprintspeed10 "I will hear you and obey", I think

    • @BanoClan
      @BanoClan 7 місяців тому +10

      My whole life’s a lie

    • @budosanjovan9621
      @budosanjovan9621 3 місяці тому

      I still do😂

  • @htxphoenix1994
    @htxphoenix1994 4 місяці тому

    I played this game religiously 20 years ago for 4 years. Got the 1500 win UD icon on US West. Now i'm randomly here. Cool to see Grubby still around. I'd love to play this game again.

  • @VelvanTivius
    @VelvanTivius 7 місяців тому +49

    Azgalore should be in S+ tier unlike regular Pit Lords.

    • @zytha2890
      @zytha2890 7 місяців тому +1

      Regular pitlord is ok tbh
      The problem is he wasn't made correctly
      Check his rain of fire ability and then look at its damage values in the editor

    • @eafesaf6934
      @eafesaf6934 7 місяців тому

      ​@@zytha2890i don't get it. Explain further.

    • @5chneemensch138
      @5chneemensch138 7 місяців тому +1

      Azgalor or Assgalore. Not Azgalore.

    • @joshuakim5240
      @joshuakim5240 7 місяців тому

      @@eafesaf6934
      The Rain of Fire spell on Pit Lord is mediocre to the point where in most cases it will do comparable damage by just auto attacking with Cleave. Him being a Strength hero also means he can't really spam spells aggressively so in 9/10 situations it's better to save his mana for Howl of Terror (an actually very good spell).
      Basically, having a mediocre DoT splash spell on a hero whose auto attack is splash makes the spell large redundant (and less versatile since it locks the Pit Lord in place while only able to rain on a small designated area). Another major issue is that the Doom spell, his Ultimate Ability, is a slow-acting debuff...which can be easily cleansed with Dispel Magic/Purge/Abolish Magic and it having a massively obvious visual indicator also doesn't help hide it. So the result is that, unless you're going against specifically Undead, the Pit Lord functionally only has 1 spell (Howl) and splash melee auto attacks. The amusing thing is that in the WC3 campaign, there's a special Pit Lord in the Reign of Chaos final mission, Azgalor, who has an entirely different spell kit (Shockwave, Thunderclap, Reincarnation, and Earthquake) which is substantially more dangerous because even 20 years ago, Blizzard's devs were aware of how unthreatening the Pit Lord's base kit is.

  • @Nuvizzle
    @Nuvizzle 7 місяців тому +10

    I don't think Night Elf having generally weaker heroes is that much of a hot take - the same logic of orc and undead being carried by their heroes is true of night elf being carried by moon wells. That's why they've historically been the race that uses tavern heroes the most. Honestly, it's because of moon wells that neutral heroes aren't a strong as they generally should be in my opinion, you basically have to balance neutral heroes under the pretense that they have access to moon wells.

    • @luiousy7329
      @luiousy7329 2 місяці тому

      Panda is still insane though. Level 6 panda is game ending more so than even DH

  • @brandonkellner2920
    @brandonkellner2920 7 місяців тому +3

    21:37 "It's always been like this in Blizzard games"
    When Warcraft 3 was released, it wasn't like that, because I remember when they changed it.

  • @DjTrustNo.1
    @DjTrustNo.1 7 місяців тому

    1:31:02 you had me chuckle, but this is also why i always followed you since like forever. Authentic, at it, inspring and well mannered. Thanks for being around, Grubby!

  • @ryancparker
    @ryancparker 7 місяців тому +4

    Happy got Crypt Lord nerfed after Reforged and he never came back 😢 I still play him at 5k because I’m Kinky! Oblivion awaits!

  • @j.l.4054
    @j.l.4054 7 місяців тому +17

    I agree with the list for the most part (aside from minor discrepancies) but there is one thing I have to point out because I just feel like it's way off...
    I really think that Demon Hunter & Far Seer need to swap places. I think (being an orc main who uses him constantly) that Grubby slightly over values FS - I understand the value of scouting & wolves harass, but after early game there are just SO many matchups where he has barely any value and just falls off so hard. Chain lightning is relatively weak & has very high mana cost, and once you get a few mins it opponent is just constantly dispelling wolves for free xp (or God forbid you end up in a match up against human with breakers or elves with dryad - wolves just set your mana on fire only to be poofed, can't even cast lightning and you're stuck AAing with a hero that has shit attack).
    Meanwhile, Demon Hunter is an absolute menace from the beginning and only gets stronger. Mana Burn is just super oppressive to play against, and even one point in Immo can do some real damage - and of course if you get to 6 Meta is absolutely terrifying.
    I really just can't see any possibility that FS = S tier while DH is only A...

    • @zachariastsampasidis8880
      @zachariastsampasidis8880 7 місяців тому

      Fs is ranged and dh is melee

    • @j.l.4054
      @j.l.4054 7 місяців тому +3

      @@zachariastsampasidis8880 what an incredibly insightful analysis.
      But seriously is that it? Because that's not nearly enough to make up the gap for FS.

    • @zachariastsampasidis8880
      @zachariastsampasidis8880 7 місяців тому

      @@j.l.4054 not everything is complicated. Dh is far more harassable even with moonwells and him being an agility hero

    • @j.l.4054
      @j.l.4054 7 місяців тому +2

      @@zachariastsampasidis8880 so according to you, DH can't be S tier because he's melee... Except Grubby has TC as the best hero in the game, and also has DK in S tier??
      I also think you are drastically overstating how easy it is to harass DH considering:
      - One of the highest armor classes (might even be #1, don't recall off the top of my head
      - Evasion to further mitigate damage
      - Easy moonwell healing (I'm not sure why you are so dismissive of this)
      And that's not even including the fact that DH has top tier movespeed, AND that enemy heroes are disincentivized to even try to ranged potshot unless they're already OOM since even going to normal attack is going to get them mana burned.
      I mean clearly we're gonna just have to agree to disagree here, but I don't think you've made a single argument against DH being S tier that's valid... if you REALLY valued the ranged >>> melee thing that much & wanted to make the case that TC & DK were only A tier as well I could at least understand a consistent position/see the logic, but I don't think you're saying that...

    • @zachariastsampasidis8880
      @zachariastsampasidis8880 7 місяців тому

      @@j.l.4054 I didn't say he is easily killable. Melee heroes are harder to use early game in general where healing is very limited and every poke matters
      I am not underrating him either.
      He is indeed better than fs but is also harder to fully and accurately use him compared to poke and wolf spam, even though that drops precipitously

  • @linuswidell7659
    @linuswidell7659 7 місяців тому +2

    How crazy is it that this game has existed for 20 years+ and this ranking video is uploaded the same week I search for it

    • @ribarl
      @ribarl 5 місяців тому

      And its from grubby 🎉

  • @Drox96-q9o
    @Drox96-q9o 7 місяців тому +4

    If there would be a tierlist for WC3 tierlists, this tierlist would be a D.

  • @StarRightStarTight
    @StarRightStarTight 5 місяців тому +2

    8:59 - endurance aura affects everyone around him - no cap
    🤣🤣🤣
    Unsure if that was intentional but it was brilliant

  • @oOH4deZOo
    @oOH4deZOo 7 місяців тому +7

    loving the list, thanks!

  • @MysterMystical
    @MysterMystical Місяць тому +1

    This is probably quite accurate, I think Druid in A probably makes more sense to me and he's played almost as often as Demon Hunter. Has great lock down utility as you mentioned... His Ult good in and out of combat, thorns Aura boosts your troops, and can be very well played in a kiting strategy.
    Demon Hunter is the fun police and great because of it, but arguably doesn't have the same level of interaction with your army.
    To be fair Druid was put at the Top of B, so probably can't dispute the list too much... Other than that totally agree...
    I'm still playing old non-mastered where BM is still killing it!

  • @drewskiwest5284
    @drewskiwest5284 7 місяців тому +3

    IMO due to Warden's spell kit and design, she should have gotten more Int per upgrade than Agi and Str.

  • @squidikka
    @squidikka 7 місяців тому +2

    This might be my second most anticipated movie release of 2024, next to pannenkoek's nearly 4 hour long video about walls in Super Mario 64.

  • @Bigapple819
    @Bigapple819 7 місяців тому +3

    No way Bloodmage isn't tier A lol... i think we're about to see a lot more of him. Especially with Banish + Holy light combo to save your units and full heal them.

  • @tbone9474
    @tbone9474 7 місяців тому +1

    Havent played the game since a year after the expansion release, but i still love watching your vids. Keep it up:)

  • @Vladimir5024
    @Vladimir5024 7 місяців тому +3

    Idk man. My bottom 50 ranked strat of solo TC destroying everyone works just fine! 😂😂

  • @hoihoi8
    @hoihoi8 7 місяців тому +2

    I'm a sucker for a tier list. I will watch all the WC3 tier lists, lol. Units, Ults, Maps, WC3 players of all time, etc

  • @JanuszDPSu
    @JanuszDPSu 3 місяці тому +3

    I may be wrong, but I think that some of the "weaker" heroes might have been designed with team games in mind rather than pure 1v1. For example based on my limited knowledge Dreadlord should have good syngergy with Orc player in team.
    Back when WC3 and TFT were developed 2v2 was still fairly popular and alive in clan/nation tournaments in SC1 and LAN games were still a thing that wasn't uncommon. Over the years design philosophy has changed and it's all about 1v1 now with team games being just a curiosity, but the original foundation can be seen and modifying it would bring too drastic changes now.

    • @andrewmueller23
      @andrewmueller23 2 місяці тому

      Priestess was devastating with her ult in big team games, especially if you managed to get a potion of invulnerability. Armies and bases were just gone.

  • @bugbeardood
    @bugbeardood 7 місяців тому +2

    Not seeing Demon Hunter and Blademaster in S tier feels wrong somehow. I haven't played in years but my first memories of playing War3 on battlenet was me getting rushed nonstop by those 2 heroes. Its cool seeing TC and ShadowHunter up there. I feel like there was a period of time when people complained nonstop about Dreadlord for a while

  • @a.f.7650
    @a.f.7650 7 місяців тому +4

    Bloodmage is actually VERY underrated due to skill check entry. Fairly placed however since they've nerfed Flamestrike so much it's now painful to play with it.

    • @SilverFan21k
      @SilverFan21k 7 місяців тому

      When did flamestrike get nerfed

    • @a.f.7650
      @a.f.7650 7 місяців тому +3

      @@SilverFan21k it used to have no split on damage to any amount of targets it hit. Not anymore. They also nerfed the initial damage and split it into 3 different consequential strikes + burning in the area. The range of the cast was also nerfed, not even saying about the radius of the spell.

  • @EuginidesGaming
    @EuginidesGaming 7 місяців тому +1

    I've been dying for this video for like 10 years, thanks so much Grubster! Would love to see the ultimates tier list next! =)

  • @Pferdesalami
    @Pferdesalami 7 місяців тому +5

    Demon hunter is s-tier :) I agree with the rest.

  • @Karjalol
    @Karjalol 7 місяців тому +2

    Any chance we can have a tier list for items ? The ones from the shop and also the drops from the creeps camps, that would be awesome ! Thanks for the video

  • @TouristAarchie
    @TouristAarchie 7 місяців тому +12

    Priestess of the Moon

  • @PoutyBun
    @PoutyBun 7 місяців тому

    I need practice in RTS games in general but i have a passionate love for the genre, wc3 and good, applicable knowledge just watching you play and talk so keenly about your strategies and reasonings for things.
    You bet your sweet hiney im going to enjoy watching this list and educated guessing where heroes would rank!

  • @travisdunlap4526
    @travisdunlap4526 7 місяців тому +53

    My main argument would be against the farseer as S-Tier. The main reason, when you look at a lot of the other heroes, you see them in EVERY SINGLE matchup. Death Knight every game, Archmage every game. Farseer is used in several matchups, but in others you won't see him at all. I think they are clearly A, but not S.

    • @TheShadoek
      @TheShadoek 7 місяців тому +9

      Far seer also has a very mediocre ultimate and far sight as a scouting ability is just outclassed by feral spirit in of itself.

    • @Nuvizzle
      @Nuvizzle 7 місяців тому +16

      I think the main reason you don't see far seer in every matchup isn't that he isn't S tier, it's that he isn't very flexible and Orc happens to have a lot of good hero choices (the most, in fact). You basically have to take him as a first hero, and if it's not a game where you want far seer first you'll therefore not make a far seer at all. I don't think being inflexible is enough to bump him down from S, otherwise we could say the same for Death Knight and Archmage who might just be the most S tier heroes in the game, but are also pretty inflexible heroes you always want to build first. You just see DK and Archmage more because Undead and Human's other options for a first hero usually don't offer nearly enough scaling to compensate for giving up the strength of DK/Archmage in the early levels.

    • @HellecticMojo
      @HellecticMojo 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@NuvizzleI think that just says bump the FS down with even more reasons

    • @Igorsov
      @Igorsov 7 місяців тому +1

      I agree on Far Seer. May be A, but not S. Death Knight every game because there are no better options as a start hero for UD. It’s like a must have base hero for UD. UD needs the aura to catch up with other races on creeping..I believe UD is the slowest creeping race. I however wouldn’t probably put DK into the S tier. A - tier yes, but not the S. However, I am not sure I can argue with Grubby since he is pro.

    • @RapidReveal541
      @RapidReveal541 7 місяців тому

      The information games and vision become more important at pro scene. And yes, orc has many good option unlike other races which somehow "forced" to pick the only good first hero.

  • @luckylarry71
    @luckylarry71 7 місяців тому +1

    I remember not 3 years ago, Fly100% went BM + *PL* + SH (unsure on the order of 2nd and 3rd hero) in an Orc mirror against Lyn (I believe?) on Concealed Hill and it was absolutely glorious...!
    It was a one-off, no doubt, but in an Orc mirror with mass Raiders and Shamans, a bloodlusted PL with cleave and HoT was a real force of nature and a spectacle to behold.

  • @gigakvachakhia4777
    @gigakvachakhia4777 7 місяців тому +3

    far seer is not an S alongside with shadow hunter, maybe A for sure, but you simply can not put them next to lich or archmage, they simply fade in scale. due all respect this seems more like an Orc player tier list.

  • @youratl_9367
    @youratl_9367 7 місяців тому +2

    I don't know if this changed since the Reforged version, but back then I remember Pitlord's Cleave ability bypassing armour and could actually deal more damage to the secondary targets than the main one if hitting a bunch of high armour targets, which is quite odd

  • @Dreddx9
    @Dreddx9 7 місяців тому +3

    "the moment you start to get sucked, even if you run away the suckening continues" -Grubby

  • @MrLalabai
    @MrLalabai 7 місяців тому +2

    I feel like Blood Mage is the most underrated hero. Maybe 20 years later he will be meta when people will understand how to play him

  • @rshreyas28
    @rshreyas28 7 місяців тому +5

    Says Blood Mage is the most underrated hero, then immediately proceeds to underrate Blood Mage :D pretty much agree with all the other placements (Orc heroes imba).
    AM/Beastmaster vs Orc brought back some good memories haha, it was my bread and butter back in the day.

    • @Matthew-uv6gl
      @Matthew-uv6gl 7 місяців тому +1

      I think the problem with BM is not so much how he is as a hero, but how important AM is to get past the early game. There are a few heroes like that where they aren't bad, but you can't realistically use them because other heroes are forced choices. Much like the DK for UD, HU kind of need AM to remain competitive at a high level.

  • @irritated_bg
    @irritated_bg 7 місяців тому +1

    Totally accurate list

  • @MrSmitejr
    @MrSmitejr 7 місяців тому +168

    "breakers, sorcerers, and priests, and those three units just happen to be among the best in the human race"
    Not one human in them haha

    • @bryansweeney3077
      @bryansweeney3077 7 місяців тому +135

      "Once again, it's up to the elves"

    • @HellecticMojo
      @HellecticMojo 7 місяців тому +75

      *Garithos noise intensified*

    • @marcinkusmierzak991
      @marcinkusmierzak991 7 місяців тому +45

      "humans" have 3 human units, 3 dwarfs, 4 elves, and 2 machines that should also count as dwarfs. Why do we call them humans?

    • @weirdcoincollection
      @weirdcoincollection 7 місяців тому +29

      @@marcinkusmierzak991 It's a carryover from WC1 and WC2. The same way "Orc" has a bunch of other races as The Horde. But they're Orc as a race in WC3.

    • @shermanator00
      @shermanator00 7 місяців тому +24

      ​@@weirdcoincollectionin russian localisation 2004 orc is "Horde" and human is "alliance ", although the translation is not accurate like Abomination called just butcher, it was old age of goofy translators but it made fun cringe moments for us pirates like Star wars kotor or gta sa earliest localisations

  • @Dudarinho
    @Dudarinho 7 місяців тому +2

    will be nice to see voting on how community sees these heroes in comparison

  • @gilbertchng8202
    @gilbertchng8202 6 місяців тому +5

    "Have you lost your mind Grubby?
    Those of you who have the will to place Pally in B come with me. The rest of you, get out of my kitchen."

  • @ryuudachi
    @ryuudachi 7 місяців тому +1

    Last time I play WC3 was like 8 years ago but I need this hour and a half information for my incoming exam. 👍

  • @sity119
    @sity119 7 місяців тому +15

    angry comment on the youtube video

  • @Valdore1000
    @Valdore1000 15 днів тому

    I absolutely give 0 damn about competetive multiplayer but damn, Grubby 100% matches with my tier list for the heroes. Very nice. Liked it.

  • @boltonjack
    @boltonjack 7 місяців тому +5

    You're one of the few people who can do this properly, so I really wish you would do a breakdown of the lineal iteration of the heroes- how much change they made to the meta at the time. Perhaps it didn't make that much difference to the meta because of other meta changes.. but if it did, I think that would make for great content.
    I used to play Frozen throne with my friend in.. 2005/6, and I always beat him. Again in 08/09 with another friend.. we hadn't played before but I had confidence because I crushed my first friend.
    this new friend mentioned he played and beat people on the ladder, and I remember him mentioning Grubby, though I had no idea who you were. We played a game for $50 and he beat me in the first 10 minutes. I had no clue about unit micro at all. I got completely squashed.

    • @GrubbyTalks
      @GrubbyTalks  7 місяців тому +3

      LOL he was getting good in secret and you didn't realize XD

    • @boltonjack
      @boltonjack 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@GrubbyTalks 😂No, my second friend in 08/9 was different person than in 05/06.. we had never played WC3 before our first and only game- he destroyed me. We played SC Brood War once and I cheesed him with a dark templar rush. He is a professional poker player in Australia, and he told me he was in the top 3 on the WC3 ladder at one point, between 07/09, if I remember correctly.

  • @skennel8884
    @skennel8884 7 місяців тому

    I would love to see more of this for each of the races. Either a unit tier list (or spells), or just an in depth description of each races pay styles/strengths/weaknesses/strats/current and past metas. WC3 is a hard game for me to understand with so much going on.

  • @saltiney8578
    @saltiney8578 5 місяців тому +5

    funny how orc player puts nearly all orc heroes at S

    • @Amplifymagic
      @Amplifymagic 4 місяці тому +5

      You mean pro player knows which race is best

  • @MrOlivaresf
    @MrOlivaresf 2 місяці тому

    I haven't played Warcraft 3 in 20 years and I watched all of this video (and I'm about to watch the Legendary match from 42:03). Thanks so much for your content!