MIDSIZE TRUCK BATTLE! -- NEW 2024 Toyota Tacoma vs. Chevy Colorado: Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 576

  • @CarConfections
    @CarConfections  11 місяців тому +12

    Looking to buy a new Toyota Tacoma, Chevy Colorado or ANY new vehicle? Go to carconfections.com/new-car-quotes to get the BEST price and access to invoice pricing info!

  • @mrfrosty11111
    @mrfrosty11111 9 місяців тому +19

    First, you compare Chevy's Z71 vs Toyota's Limited, giving points to the Toyota for options that are purposely not there on the Chevy Z71. The Z71 is marketed for a different buyer--- Limited buyers look at the Denali instead of a Z71. Oddly enough, Denali pricing is right in line with that Limited you loved so much vs that mid level optioned Chevy. So what this vid actually taught us is that you are clearly not truck guys. That's OK. Non truck guys buy GM too, which is why there is a Denali package. So let's say you actually compared like trucks, GMC Denali vs Tacoma limited. The "Shootout" results would have been "Nice trucks. The Denali has more poop for the same prices. Denali wins"

    • @MrLatinBeard
      @MrLatinBeard Місяць тому +2

      Also wins in reliability, believe it or not lol

  • @waydealf1969
    @waydealf1969 11 місяців тому +50

    2024 Chevy Colorado is Motor Trend TRUCK OF THE YEAR.....I'm going with the Colorado.

    • @ayushmalpeddi2793
      @ayushmalpeddi2793 3 місяці тому +2

      Agreed. Has 4.5in of more combined legroom in Colorado, better towing and payload, better base suspension tuning, more comfortable seats and driving position, rear air vents, less expensive OTD price, and a proven 2.7T and 8 speed. I mean Toyota is already replacing transmissions on the new Tacomas 💀

    • @robertedwards3822
      @robertedwards3822 2 місяці тому +1

      I bought. Red ZR2 last week. It’s hands-down and not even close better than the Tacoma. And I’ve owned to Tacomas.

    • @Frankie2751
      @Frankie2751 2 місяці тому

      @@robertedwards3822what the difference?

  • @dtay8913
    @dtay8913 11 місяців тому +98

    I see where the Tacoma won in a lot of categories but for me personally, with my usage of the back seats in my cars, I like the Colorado more. It's weird to see GM have rear air vents over Toyota and yet they do. That plus I find the Colorados rear seats more comfortable.

    • @hellkitty1014
      @hellkitty1014 11 місяців тому +9

      For the life of me, I don't understand why Toyota doesn't address rear seat room accommodation for both the new Taco and Tundra(especially). I was astounded by the lack of truck-appropiate headroom in the Tundra, and this new Tacoma's rear seat doesn't appear to be an improvement in legroom, despite moving to the TNGA-F platform(most vehicles on the TNGA platform don't do so hot in the rear leg and headroom, oddly).

    • @sammy-gd7hw
      @sammy-gd7hw 11 місяців тому +3

      ​@@hellkitty1014 yup I have 8 year old grand kids and the rear seats are starting to get to small for my tacoma.

    • @stevesafety6743
      @stevesafety6743 11 місяців тому +3

      @@hellkitty1014 Ranger has 2” more rear leg room and a Honda Ridgeline is almost 5” more than the Tacoma

    • @seymorefact4333
      @seymorefact4333 10 місяців тому

      don't trust GM to build anything with QDR!

    • @Edward-Norton
      @Edward-Norton 10 місяців тому +15

      This was a biased review. What I mean is he gave Toyota a .5 a point because it included a Bluetooth speaker and .5 point for a manual transmission that no one wants anymore They don't even talk about payload and towing which people specifically buy a truck for, so that is a joke. They don't mention that you can't fit an adult in the back of the Toyota. Plus, they are comparing a Tacoma limited against a much cheaper spec Colorado.

  • @frankheffernan8066
    @frankheffernan8066 11 місяців тому +34

    I have owned Toyota 4x4 trucks since 1986. Their corporate price increases and dealership markups finally made me choose the Colorado Trail Boss.
    Your attempt to explain the Tacoma $50K + price tag was underwhelming and unconvincing.

    • @red.riot.2280
      @red.riot.2280 9 місяців тому +3

      It wasn’t a real comparison. Off-road vs off-road is more on point in price.

    • @pjmagana9547
      @pjmagana9547 2 місяці тому

      Last colorado I owned made me swear off any gm truck, 2018 colorado. It did handle the totaled wreck well though. I wanted to kiss the guy that hit me cause it was his fault and totaled it

  • @dubdub2527
    @dubdub2527 11 місяців тому +28

    $54k for a Taco…no thanks.

    • @scottlowell493
      @scottlowell493 5 місяців тому +2

      But hey, at least it's underpowered!

  • @AdamLoerts
    @AdamLoerts 11 місяців тому +27

    I love both these trucks that said the decisions on some of the points were... interesting. A removeable pod speaker just as important as powertrain differences for example. And giving the Yota a half point for step bars when it's a $7000 more expensive truck and powered steps installed are less than $2000 🤷‍♂

  • @kencoleman8929
    @kencoleman8929 11 місяців тому +108

    Love your comparisons, but I'd like a rematch between the Tacoma Limited and Canyon Denali. A more apples to apples comparison would be fairer. 🍎🍎👍👍😏

    • @chrismarbrey9678
      @chrismarbrey9678 11 місяців тому +5

      better yet, the Tacoma Limited hybrid because all of the GMCs have the high output tune.

    • @kencoleman8929
      @kencoleman8929 11 місяців тому +2

      @@chrismarbrey9678 Great point!! 👍

  • @alexgingue7945
    @alexgingue7945 11 місяців тому +23

    Should have compared the Z71 to the TRD Off road. These trims are not competing for the same customers.

  • @cmryals
    @cmryals 11 місяців тому +90

    That Air Dam on the Tacoma is hideous!

  • @drumanaut
    @drumanaut 11 місяців тому +26

    I feel like the removable Bluetooth speaker isn't worth marking as an advantage. It's such a gimmick and the truck is a lot more expensive.
    Personally I like the taillights more on the Colorado. Having your brake lights and turn signals be one light is kind of dangerous if you have hazards on. It makes it really hard to tell when you're braking since only the third brake light is solid. With the Colorado you get individual lights for the turn signals and brake lights. I also don't think sequential turn signals are really that advantage worthy in that same context of price differential.

  • @kenia7430
    @kenia7430 11 місяців тому +15

    Shouldn't have to pay a monthly fee just to have remote locks

  • @ShaunsJeep
    @ShaunsJeep 11 місяців тому +18

    A subscription just to use the key fob features that were already paid for. Thats just plain money gouging.

  • @jamesbrodd6452
    @jamesbrodd6452 11 місяців тому +14

    Being a safety engineer, sound level measurements should be taken on the same road and weather conditions.

  • @MicahB98
    @MicahB98 11 місяців тому +28

    I like the Taco, trusted reliability etc. but that big screen just looks out of place, it looks like it’s blocking the view out. Chevy all day just looks better all around

    • @marklihsu
      @marklihsu 11 місяців тому +2

      You sure the turbo 4 banger will last as the previous V6?

    • @TomL2025
      @TomL2025 11 місяців тому +3

      I agree, the bigger the screen, doesn’t mean it is better. I need to see the road when driving. if I want a big screen, I have a 65 inches TV at home.

    • @Heatherder
      @Heatherder 9 місяців тому

      @@marklihsualthough the turbocharger may need replacement at 150-200k miles if you slack on oil changes, i think the engine is overall a more robust design than the high feature v6, notably the timing chain weakness should be resolved, and carbon fouling has been addressed better on the 4cyl

    • @ayushmalpeddi2793
      @ayushmalpeddi2793 3 місяці тому

      LMAO your comment aged horribly. Toyota is already replacing transmissions on Tacomas. Colorados 2.7L and 8 speed are proven powertrain options in the Silverado for years now...

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      Looks like the Taco is on track to having more reliability issues than Chevy this year lol

  • @wd8085
    @wd8085 11 місяців тому +56

    I was going to get the new tacoma but after seeing their new insane pricing I changed my mind. I know someone who bought the new tundra with a 700+ payment and after 5 months he has major regrets saying the newness wore off but the payments are still the same. I think a lot of people are like this, buy it cause its cool at that time but then soon gets tired of crazy long high payments.

    • @KParks
      @KParks 11 місяців тому +10

      That's why you don't buy vehicles based on "newness" lol

    • @palebeachbum
      @palebeachbum 11 місяців тому +12

      Yes. Debt is tiresome. We all want nice things, but you have to ask yourself, how much and for how long you want to pay for those nice things? Even nice things lose their luster eventually. I convinced myself by age 30 to only buy cars I can afford to pay off in 4yrs or less and regardless of what it is, learn to appreciate it. If you have a neverending thirst for the latest and greatest, you better find a job that can keep up with your expectations.

    • @johnwhitneykokalis9990
      @johnwhitneykokalis9990 11 місяців тому +3

      I still look forward, every day to getting behind the wheel of my 2023 Canyon
      It is the best truck I have ever financed, and NOT buying into the notion that it had to be loaded with every option that exists, I went with a 2wd and enough options to meet my demands and still walk out the dealers show room with an affordable purchase at just under 42k out the door.I took delivery in March and I still hand wash the black paint almost every weekend.

    • @KParks
      @KParks 11 місяців тому +1

      @@johnwhitneykokalis9990 anything you don't like about the truck so far?

    • @chrisx5127
      @chrisx5127 11 місяців тому +1

      @@johnwhitneykokalis9990 Reliability didn't worry you? On top of it being a turbo?

  • @alflyer9406
    @alflyer9406 11 місяців тому +9

    Subscription for remote start??? Hard pass!!

  • @issileonardo4896
    @issileonardo4896 11 місяців тому +15

    Obviously you are a Tacoma guy...

  • @kabloosh699
    @kabloosh699 11 місяців тому +36

    I think it is a little silly for the grading criteria to give having a 12 inch display over an 8 inch display .5 points and then grade a tow rating rating over 1000 lbs over the other truck as a .5.
    There should be more of a weighted grading criteria for things that trucks are good at doing. So things like bed size/features, tow rating, off road capability, and hauling should get more of the focus over minor creature comforts with a bigger digital display or a heads up display.

    • @wildandblueZL1
      @wildandblueZL1 10 місяців тому +1

      Right. And judging a shallower box as better because it’s easier to reach into is obviously from someone who’s not actually owned/used a truck. Deeper cargo box means more volume (perhaps) and more securely positioned cargo….

    • @stevesafety6743
      @stevesafety6743 10 місяців тому +2

      Who cares on the size of the screen. Not sure what size my screen is in my 2016 F150. But it’s plenty big enough for what I need. Distracted driving, anyone?

  • @MrHand-ih4sz
    @MrHand-ih4sz 11 місяців тому +18

    That front air dam on the Tacoma is HIDEOUS.

  • @Angelbonilla1982
    @Angelbonilla1982 11 місяців тому +28

    Holy!! $54K!! For Tacoma!!

  • @rozzbourn3653
    @rozzbourn3653 11 місяців тому +15

    i think the Colorado won this hands down. you get a more powerful truck that can tow quite a bit more with nearly identical features for $8000 less. the stuff you were giving the Tacoma points for are irrelevant and it all boils down to power, towing capacity and price. you even gave the tacoma points for a removable speaker that the colorado also offers that goes in the tailgate. none of that matters and is just fluff when talking about a truck. if these trucks were priced the same, then maybe the extra little features would add up to half a point, but giving points for all of the nonsense is artificially inflating the score of the tacoma. the tacoma has a lot to do to catch up.

    • @fritty9927
      @fritty9927 11 місяців тому

      The Toyota reputation for reliability has to be factored in also, which was never mentioned. Also when it comes time to trade or sell you can guess which will demand more money(PS: it ain’t the Chevy).

    • @rozzbourn3653
      @rozzbourn3653 11 місяців тому +7

      @@fritty9927 sure, toyota does have a solid reputation on reliability but i think both will have similar reliability in this comparison. the 2.7l in the colorado was introduced in 2019 and there have been trucks getting 200k+ miles in that time. i dont think reliability will be a problem for either truck.

    • @fritty9927
      @fritty9927 11 місяців тому +1

      @@rozzbourn3653 you could be right!

    • @johnwhitneykokalis9990
      @johnwhitneykokalis9990 11 місяців тому +3

      ​@rozzbourn3653 yea, and that 2.7 is basically a diesel engine that runs on gasoline according to the design engineers and the cooling system is not necessarily dependent on running off of the fly wheel but is determined from electronic pumps and thermo sensors so it is always being cooled down, even when it's turned off after climbing a hill or towing. GM put a lot of thought into there engine design and build durability.

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      Toyota had much rougher gear shifts than the colorado while accelerating I would have given Chevy a point for that. Tacos are already experiencing transmission failures lol

  • @TheHugsvilleHorror
    @TheHugsvilleHorror 11 місяців тому +21

    Sticking with my 23 tacoma. Some of us dont want every bell and whistle that they can shove in a truck.

    • @sebg2086
      @sebg2086 9 місяців тому +5

      yeah paying over price for a 2023 tacoma with the technologie of a 2013 chevrolet

  • @jimmycline4778
    @jimmycline4778 11 місяців тому +11

    9:20 No you DONT have to go into touch screen, the headlight button is on the main screen, it’s that little round yellow button , yes you can do it like your showing,but why when it’s on the main screen, also I haven’t needed to turn off my headlights since 1991, so at least Chevy made it super simple to do 👍

    • @CarConfections
      @CarConfections  11 місяців тому

      The main headlights are at the top of the screen (requires 2 taps and can't be done after turning off the truck), but the fog lights are in a different menu. I'm sure we operate the lights more than the average person for filming purposes, but we did find it annoying

    • @jimmycline4778
      @jimmycline4778 10 місяців тому +1

      Annoying 😂 You would never be able to drive a 1978 Silverado!

  • @BUIKPAN
    @BUIKPAN 2 місяці тому +1

    I towed one (Colorado) yesterday and was impressed with the roominess and big feel. Its still tows like a big truck too. (aftermarket issue reason for tow) and it looks great

  • @isaac198428
    @isaac198428 11 місяців тому +10

    Chevy Colorado is obviously the better value for your money. Toyota used to be an economical car company but now over engineered with more things to prematurely break like unnecessary automatic power running boards, power lift gate, lighting controls hidden in the touchscreen display and the worst offender is subscription based features like remote start etc. They’re going full luxury vehicle mode. Not to mention the overall cost of ownership is over $53k which is over $5 more than the Chevy. The Chevy looks nicer in-front without the huge air buffer under the bumper that looks like an afterthought. Almost as if it was an aftermarket add on bought online. The chrome grill and wheels are ugly in the Tacoma.

    • @fritty9927
      @fritty9927 11 місяців тому

      That front air damn is easily removed. It was placed to get a fraction better mpg. Toyota realized most folks would remove it so they made it easy to remove.

  • @docholliday7548
    @docholliday7548 11 місяців тому +8

    Proud owner of '23 Colorado ZR2. Researched midsize trucks x5yrs. When 3rd gen Colorado was unveiled my choice was made. ZERO probs @ 3k miles. Took it up to alpine resort over Christmas, averaged 25+mpg on Bridgestone Blizzaks; just fantastic on the hwy; solid on/off road. Engine is smooth, powerful; pass vehicles effortlessly. I respect the Taco but for me it's NO match for the ZR2 in every category.

    • @freezax4
      @freezax4 9 місяців тому

      He just wanted to make Tacoma look better lol at EOD Colorado is better definitely the zr2

  • @sanjayr8325
    @sanjayr8325 11 місяців тому +5

    Everyone should buy the tacoma.... So I can get my colorado below msrp.

  • @Geca5575
    @Geca5575 11 місяців тому +3

    I am not sure how it is in the new Tacomas but for the 2022 tundra platinum and the 2023 4runner limited, after the remote start trial ends you still have it. You just dont have access to the app features. To remote start almost all Toyotas, you press the lock button three times and hold it on the last press. You can do this without the trial. Remote start on Toyota really isn't the best though since the truck will turn off when you unlock it which defeats the purpose.

  • @Jojo-ni2cg
    @Jojo-ni2cg 11 місяців тому +19

    Great review guys, I am a Toyota guy with a 2023 4runner that i love but on that note i would buy the chevy for 7K less and get more power too. The new model Toyotas are getting very expensive to say the least.

    • @sammy-gd7hw
      @sammy-gd7hw 11 місяців тому +2

      Toyota has a major problem. They are out of the price range of the general population. 😢

    • @Jojo-ni2cg
      @Jojo-ni2cg 11 місяців тому

      yes l believe your correct,the chevy colorado is 7k cheaper and more powerful and looks just as nice!!@@sammy-gd7hw

    • @josephstarnes8747
      @josephstarnes8747 11 місяців тому +1

      I'm a Tacoma owner and I agree. I don't really trust GM reliability, but other than that I think the Chevy wins hands down.

  • @frankzamperini
    @frankzamperini 11 місяців тому +25

    Great video. For me it's the toyota. The running boards the tail gate and the (hopefully) luxury interior. I switched from being a Chevy/Ford driver to a toyota driver in 2008. The reliability of Toyota wins in my book owned 4 Toyotas since 2008 and have had zero problems.

    • @marklihsu
      @marklihsu 11 місяців тому +5

      You'll be switching back now that Toyota went with a turbo

    • @jonathanratliff4780
      @jonathanratliff4780 11 місяців тому +4

      And Chevy knows how to do a turbo better!? 😂😂😂😂

    • @AdamLoerts
      @AdamLoerts 11 місяців тому +2

      There's a $7000 difference, pretty sure you could out real leather and powered step bars on for less than that.

    • @frankzamperini
      @frankzamperini 11 місяців тому

      Time will tell my friends.

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      @@jonathanratliff4780Both are doing these turbo engines pretty well, the one used in colorado has established reliability because they had been using them in the Silverado since 2019.
      Now I don't think the turbo engine is a problem in the tacoma either but they're having transmission failures so far along with some other issues

  • @Wopat2015
    @Wopat2015 9 місяців тому +2

    I bought the Z71 Chevy and 8 love it! Most comfortable vehicle I have ever owned! I upgraded the turbo to 430lb ft of torque and it rocks!

    • @mrfrosty11111
      @mrfrosty11111 9 місяців тому

      Looking at doing the same. What did you use? I have been looking at the JB4.

  • @johnosborne6600
    @johnosborne6600 11 місяців тому +8

    I like the Canyon. I love Toyotas, but the cost difference is immense. Chevy/GMC will be discounting while Toyota dealers will be marking up.

    • @tyler93539
      @tyler93539 11 місяців тому

      the toyota truck will still be running at 400k miles cant say much about a GM running past 150,000 miles

    • @alexanderschklair1945
      @alexanderschklair1945 11 місяців тому

      GMC pay less now and suffer tomorrow. At the of the road, quality and reliability that is the key. Toyota will be running for longer timer with minor issues than the junk of GMC trucks.

    • @Heatherder
      @Heatherder 9 місяців тому +1

      @@tyler93539that isnt a guarantee, additionally we have had several 350k+ mile chevrolets and i currently have a 250k mile one that has lasted 22 years so far. At this point, i have my moneys worth out of it. Plus saving $8,000 now means that money can be put to work to grow to much more 22 years later. Chevy parts are affordable and working on them isn’t too hard. It isn’t like they are total heaps

    • @tyler93539
      @tyler93539 9 місяців тому

      @@Heatherder I don't mean to sound rude, but we are talking about 2024 model years not a 22 year old model year of course the old chevy trucks are amazing all the 22 year old trucks from the big 3 are amazing and will last forever, however the new GM trucks are the most towed trucks they have electrical issues and when they don't start you cant even put them in neutral without using a wrench on the transmission, also the GM 10 speed is the most common transmission in the transmission shop next to my brothers auto shop I've talked to the owner and he sees so many GM 10 speeds needing a full rebuild at 50k to 100k miles

    • @BFConsultingMatHndlg
      @BFConsultingMatHndlg 8 місяців тому

      And there is a reason for that

  • @steveaverett
    @steveaverett 11 місяців тому +5

    I think the Colorado looks better and the cost is a huge factor. No way I'm paying extra for the Tacoma.

  • @keithallsop
    @keithallsop 11 місяців тому +4

    For me, it's the power/torque, towing and cost advantage of the Colorado, versus the expected reliability and longevity and residual value of the Tacoma. Most of the other 'advantages' of the Tacoma are pure fluff, such as a slightly bigger infotainment screen, which do not affect core truck needs.

  • @jabecrowell4247
    @jabecrowell4247 11 місяців тому +3

    I'll take the Toyota hands down. For reliability purposes only.

  • @carlblanco
    @carlblanco 11 місяців тому +10

    I’m personally a Honda guy (owner) but I like the power & ruggedness of this Colorado over the Taco.

  • @hellkitty1014
    @hellkitty1014 11 місяців тому +15

    Obviously, Toyota upped the game of the very long-in-the-tooth Taco. The truck seems to be finally hospitable for folks over 6ft tall. That said, the true competitor to the Taco Limited is the GMC Canyon Denali, which addresses the exterior lighting and interior decor gaps that the Chevy doesn't, which is reflected in its price.
    While I expect the Tacoma to maintain its great resale value, I do wonder about very long-term reliability since it is all 4cyl turbo and soon to be hybrid as well. One of the hallmarks of the Taco is that it is low fuss on maintenance and legendary reliability. Only time will tell.

    • @theinfinitymachine9610
      @theinfinitymachine9610 11 місяців тому +3

      3rd gen Tacomas have documented to clock 300k now. That's pretty darn good in my book since I have the V6 still and rather not have the new 4th gen.

    • @Beanjuice
      @Beanjuice 11 місяців тому +8

      It's not looking good. Look at all the issues they're having in the new hybrid tundras

    • @bench111ful
      @bench111ful 11 місяців тому +2

      ​@Beanjuice what issues?

    • @CarsAreTheSubject
      @CarsAreTheSubject 11 місяців тому

      I think all tree truck play in the same group.

    • @skysteppes
      @skysteppes 11 місяців тому

      Americans: “long in the tooth taco”
      Americans: if only we could get the 70 series

  • @thomasmazzola4760
    @thomasmazzola4760 11 місяців тому +7

    For the price of the Tacoma you could get a GMC Canyon at4 or Denali. You could also get a Colorado zr2 which would dominate every categorie

  • @lucashazel5123
    @lucashazel5123 11 місяців тому +9

    Considering you have to wait over 2 years for the taco I feel like the Chevy wins just based on availability 😅😂. Doesn’t matter how reliable the taco is if you can’t get your hands on one 🤷🏼‍♂️

    • @honestabe1940
      @honestabe1940 9 місяців тому

      AMEN BROTHER!

    • @ayushmalpeddi2793
      @ayushmalpeddi2793 3 місяці тому +1

      LMAO Toyota is already replacing the transmissions on the new Tacomas

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      @@ayushmalpeddi2793Did you notice in the video that the Chevy shifted way smoother than the Tacoma yet these toyota fanboys didn't give chevy a point for a clearly smoother transmission.

  • @palebeachbum
    @palebeachbum 11 місяців тому +13

    If money were no obstacle, of course Tacoma is the better choice. It'll undoubtedly be more reliable and have better resale. Unfortunately, here in the land of reality I'm not made of money to be so generous to gift Toyota an extra $7k, so I'll just split the difference between the two and buy a cheaper and just as dependable Frontier.

    • @jmabs5096
      @jmabs5096 11 місяців тому +1

      2024 Tacoma has barley nothing from the last 3 generations proven reliability, all new engines, new transmissions etc. The 24 pricing at 50+k for a midline truck, your better off with full sized truck at that price. I can already see the 24+ Tacomas are not going to sell like hot cakes just based of the drastic price jump from previous models. Toyta needs to take note with the built in tailgate steps.... My god are they one of thoes "once you have it, you can't ever get back" especially if your truck is lifted its a literal pain to get into my 23 Tacoma bed 😂 I specially bought a 23 last year knowing it would be the end of the generation and toyta is now in untested waters. The chevy has more practical stuff for everyone. New Tacomas has more yuppie features. I wish they put a v6 turbo in the new Tacomas, that would sell hot

  • @FakePersonna
    @FakePersonna Місяць тому +1

    Neither - I got the Chevy Colorado Trail Boss instead.... standard 2" factory lift, wide body, and the TurboMax engine for A LOT less money. I had to spend about $300 to swap out all the halogen light bulbs to LED from LasFit.

  • @kristenburkett4274
    @kristenburkett4274 10 місяців тому +5

    I'd take the Colorado.

  • @KellyBarr-k3x
    @KellyBarr-k3x 11 місяців тому +9

    Chevy Colorado

  • @alwaysiyi272
    @alwaysiyi272 11 місяців тому +10

    Toyota for me, I prefer the look, and the interior design, I also like the fact that it has features that almost any other midsize truck doesn’t have, like power running boards and an automatic tailgate. I also love the dynamic turn signals. Plus that hybrid powertrain coming soon will be sweet

  • @joecovey2235
    @joecovey2235 11 місяців тому +7

    The comparison should've been with the GMC Canyon Denali, much closer in price and features, still an interesting comparison if not quite apples to apples.

    • @C_H_U_
      @C_H_U_ 11 місяців тому +1

      ???????? Must be a Toyota hater lol.

    • @daveintbdaveintb3624
      @daveintbdaveintb3624 10 місяців тому

      Yup, agree, need to compare apples to apples.

  • @StanleyBrandl
    @StanleyBrandl 11 місяців тому +6

    I agree with a comment that you should not compare a Colorado Z71 to Limited Tacoma. Should have used a Colorado Denail for a better comparison. I have owned the 2022 Colorado Denail and loved it but needed more towing power and bought the 2023 Silverado Z71 Durmax. Absolutely Love this truck.

  • @wwz1011
    @wwz1011 10 місяців тому +2

    As someone who has been towing for decades, more important than tow rating is payload capacity. Tacomas in the past have been woefully inadequate on payload capacity. Often, you will run out of payload by the time you are only half way to towing capacity. I don't know if Toyota fixed this issue. Finally, resale value on Tacomas tend to be sky high. So owners will likely recoup the $$ on higher initial price on resale. Hybrid Tacoma will be a game changer.

  • @lrn_news9171
    @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому +2

    The gear shifts were way smoother on the Colorado I would have given chevy a point there, tacoma's are already experiencing transmission issues lol

  • @scottcruikshank138
    @scottcruikshank138 11 місяців тому +10

    My family is both a Toyota and Chevy family. Have had 4 Tacoma's (currently have a 2019 TRD Sport) and three Tahoes. Just bought a 2023 Colorado ZR2. Would have thought about a TRD Pro but I'm pretty sure they will be "unobtanium" for a while and ones that do come in with mark ups will be 65K+ I'm sure. Both my Tahoes and Tacomas have all been reliable. Have to watch the rust on the Toyota's in the North East. Have to use Fluid Film or something similar as the Yota's rust badly underneath the minute they smell salt. Personally I think you can't go wrong with either truck.

    • @rshinn8776
      @rshinn8776 11 місяців тому

      I want that zr2 bad but can't justify the spend right now. How are you liking it?

    • @krasnaludek298
      @krasnaludek298 11 місяців тому +1

      You made a wise choice.
      The ZR2 is light years ahead of the Tacoma. Colorado is the best mid-size on the market & the Tacoma honestly is nowhere near as nice on exterior design nor interior. Easy choice … I’m getting a GMC Canyon AT4 … $48K well optioned.

  • @adkforester5428
    @adkforester5428 11 місяців тому +6

    Curious your thoughts, wouldn't driving through a canyon create more sound echoing off walls and back into cabin vs. driving down road with sound softening forest?

  • @kevinblock2307
    @kevinblock2307 11 місяців тому +9

    Colorado has auto 4wd as well

  • @broughtgiant483
    @broughtgiant483 11 місяців тому +32

    Im taking the chevy calorado

  • @mrchezze84
    @mrchezze84 11 місяців тому +5

    How about a point for the clorado for gas mileage......same as the taco but a bigger much more powerful engine, Yall are definitely Toyota boys....

  • @alpimentel8194
    @alpimentel8194 10 місяців тому +3

    Toyota Guy, tundra and Tacoma holds its value, better overall solid trucks .

    • @76ProudPatriot
      @76ProudPatriot Місяць тому

      You must not be staying up on the Tacoma's. Transmission issues, poor quality from being made in Mexico. The 2024 values are going to tank quickly.....dealers have a ton on their lots and they are not selling.

  • @jmcastaneda1974
    @jmcastaneda1974 5 місяців тому +1

    I own a 2024 Chevy Trail Boss, and I test drove the Tacoma before buying it. In my opinion, the Tacoma is way overhyped and expensive. It's also not as powerful as the Chevy. The Tacoma is a nice-looking truck, but if you want a midsize truck with lots of power, I'd recommend the Chevy over the Tacoma.

  • @queensz350
    @queensz350 3 місяці тому +1

    I’ve been a Toyota fan all my life. Owned a Celica, and 2 4 Runners. But Toyota has lost its mind with their prices. I am most likely getting the ZR2 Colorado.

  • @GH-oi2jf
    @GH-oi2jf 5 місяців тому

    I have a 2nd gen Colorado. The 3rd gen cannot be configured the way mine is, so it is out. I'm not interested in Toyotas, so I don't know if they have a configuration I would like. I'll just be keeping my truck until I can no longer drive it.
    This video illustrates the problem. It goes on and on about features - things I don't need and don't want and which are used to try justify the high price. A truck is just a tool for carrying me and some things from one place to another. There are only a few modern features which I want.

  • @darriontunstall3708
    @darriontunstall3708 11 місяців тому +34

    I would take the Toyota tacoma!

    • @rickeycooley9139
      @rickeycooley9139 11 місяців тому +2

      Two times a day and three times on Saturday!

  • @TDon4eva
    @TDon4eva 10 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for this comparison. I am looking to get the colorado, hopefully i can add the power running board to mine when m ready.

  • @haroldmoran7222
    @haroldmoran7222 10 місяців тому +2

    You can’t order Toyotas with desired options. Colorado you can.

  • @JBUCKNE
    @JBUCKNE 9 місяців тому

    Gents, I often watch/listen to some of the larger channels comparisons and I passed on your channel a few times due to the variety of reviews and honestly your age. I’ve found channels that do wide reviews typically hit highlights and seemingly aren’t that knowledgeable which was also the concern with your age (experience). I was pleasantly surprised with the in depth comparisons and the side by side comparisons throughout was very helpful and appreciated. Great video, I was wrong.

    • @CarConfections
      @CarConfections  9 місяців тому

      Thanks for sharing that! We appreciate it!

  • @BROCK_WARHAMMER
    @BROCK_WARHAMMER 11 місяців тому +5

    Y’all will need to do a ranger vs Tacoma. Hopefully a Trd off road/sport vs xlt fx4 as I feel those two will be more in line with most people’s realistic price ranges. Despite still being ridiculously expensive for mid size trucks. And of particular interest for me, the upcoming 2.7 ecoboost being added to the ranger. I feel that will be a nice option for points toward the ranger. I’m personally so conflicted on what I should get in the upcoming year between these two trucks

    • @CarConfections
      @CarConfections  11 місяців тому

      We are planning on it once we're get hands on with the new Ranger 👍

  • @mustangwl
    @mustangwl 11 місяців тому +5

    Tacoma deal killers...18.2 gal gas tank and have to keep the subscription for remote start.

  • @scottcarter7046
    @scottcarter7046 11 місяців тому +7

    Whats with the ugly snowplow deflector on the Tacoma? Thats huge and ugly

  • @hdfxst1521
    @hdfxst1521 10 місяців тому +1

    One thing also to consider with the Tacoma is that it has the D4S system which is port injection in addition to the direct injection. The port injection is used to clean the intake ports. It’s not always on since the direct injection is the primary system. No catch can needed!

    • @jlynchtx
      @jlynchtx 10 місяців тому

      That’s interesting to know. How does the engine on the new 24 Ford Ranger compare to these two?

    • @hdfxst1521
      @hdfxst1521 10 місяців тому

      @@jlynchtx well I had a 2020 Ranger and the truck itself was fine. It had the 2.3 ecoboost that was strong but I ran a catch can and it would fill with some crud that would have been in the intake ports. Only real issue was it would fill the crankcase with fuel. After about 1500 miles or so the oil level on the dipstick would rise about an 1/8 of an inch and the oil would start to get even thinner. Ford replaced the high pressure pump and an injector. Still did it though. You can research that issue here on UA-cam.

  • @lannylancaster62
    @lannylancaster62 11 місяців тому +3

    I've been a long time Toyota driver. I'll very likely upgrade my Tacoma Prerunner with a new SR.

  • @krasnaludek298
    @krasnaludek298 11 місяців тому +8

    I like the Colorado & especially GMC Canyon much better than the Tacoma. The exterior design is more fluid & appealing with the GMC & the interior is also nicer on the AT4 & AT4X trim levels.

  • @whensheslurpsthetip8903
    @whensheslurpsthetip8903 11 місяців тому +3

    These new midsizes are pretty much fullsized pick ups from 6 years ago. So im guessing the shift over to midsize is the play because of that.

  • @braalo07
    @braalo07 11 місяців тому +10

    I like the look of the Colorado, but the Taco TRD Pro is probably what I would get

  • @wildandblueZL1
    @wildandblueZL1 11 місяців тому +6

    These are trucks and you did not include the truck aspects in your comparisons. Cargo volume, towing capacity, payloads, etc.

  • @ectornkarinaa
    @ectornkarinaa 10 місяців тому +1

    I think a fairer comparison to this z71 is the trd off road with the upgraded packages to match. Pricing will be very similar at that point and the 6 foot bed of the tacoma will make it the winner for me

  • @cinder9950
    @cinder9950 10 місяців тому +1

    Good review. Both trucks look nice especially the chevy appears to be a big improvement over the old model. That air dam on the taco is ridiculous and looks like a snow plow.

  • @johncarter7284
    @johncarter7284 5 місяців тому

    I was considering a new Colorado but the extra bed length is important to me and I don't need 4 doors. I also find that the availability of the manual 6 spd transmission is a plus, so the Toyota with less options suits me best.

  • @morgancoldfirecoldfire8256
    @morgancoldfirecoldfire8256 10 місяців тому +1

    colorado looks nice in and out. The out side front bumper air dam is a after thought on toyota. the tail gate down on the taco and cant step on a bumper to get in is weird. I personal think the interior looks cheap with blank buttons and looks like a big ipad stuck on the dash. Colorado has more power , more payload and towing, the engine they put in halftons . The bigest negative is just the short box only option on the gm product.

  • @carlgentry9326
    @carlgentry9326 10 місяців тому +2

    I'm buying colorado. USA all the way.

  • @HauteModesty
    @HauteModesty 11 місяців тому +1

    Most definitely the Tacoma. They need to talk about the resale value comparison as well. Looking at the TRD Pro.

  • @justindtackett
    @justindtackett 6 місяців тому

    I gotta say, is bigger better with the screens at this point. I think what we really need is a well designs and well placed touch screen.

  • @ThePatriotsrule123
    @ThePatriotsrule123 10 місяців тому +2

    54k is so expensive, a full truck can be had for this price

  • @Livestrong00782
    @Livestrong00782 11 місяців тому +2

    I understand that these are both midsize trucks, but that is pretty much where the similarities end, the Toyota you choose is far more of luxury edition vs the z71, a more close comparison would be the gmc canyon Denali at approximately $53k or a Toyota taco trd sport. Or like a ZR2 vs taco trd off road.

  • @cindysmith8530
    @cindysmith8530 9 місяців тому +1

    add the 10k over MSRP dealer markup on the tacoma all of them are over msrp in my state.

  • @C.C._TJ_Jason
    @C.C._TJ_Jason 3 місяці тому

    Awesome video. For me it’s going to be the Colorado: more power for towing and save a few thousand $$. I’m not a fan of paying for luxury features for a utility vehicle, the Colorado Trail Boss makes the most sense for me.

  • @ericgunnyporter8964
    @ericgunnyporter8964 9 місяців тому +1

    Hey my name is Eric I would take the Colorado Z71 over the Tacoma simply because of the price and power, To say I need the power rear tailgate naw !! I don't see the importance in a power gate so yeah the Chevy is my choice.

  • @extremepcs2807
    @extremepcs2807 11 місяців тому +3

    I'll most likely go with a 2024 GMC Canyon Denali. I don't do any offroading. I think the 2024 Tacoma's will be difficult to buy, and when you are able to, dealers will be charging an additional 5k+ markup.

    • @johnmeeboer8971
      @johnmeeboer8971 11 місяців тому

      and gm dealers will not have mark ups?

    • @extremepcs2807
      @extremepcs2807 11 місяців тому

      @@johnmeeboer8971 They don't on the trucks I've been looking at. MSRP or below, plus GM employee (or family of employee) discount gets you well below MSRP. Sticker on the Canyon I'm looking at is $50k and I can get it for about $46.

    • @xXJBrutalXx
      @xXJBrutalXx 11 місяців тому

      @@johnmeeboer8971 no markups at any of the dealers near me for the new trucks, some actually have some decent rebates

    • @daveintbdaveintb3624
      @daveintbdaveintb3624 10 місяців тому +1

      Me thinking the same way. Been comparing the Denali to the Limited and will prob get the Denali

  • @michoacanom4320
    @michoacanom4320 11 місяців тому +3

    So 55k for tacoma no memory seats pay for remote start and shower ill take the colorado

  • @garyprice359
    @garyprice359 8 місяців тому

    Sorry I'm a Chevy guy so of course I'm motivated to swing my bias but it would've been helpful to know which features you guys added to the Colorado to close the price gap to $7k. The Z71 has a generous standard offering considering the actual $12k entry price difference; each consumer's desire for particular options will vary. Also, wasn't this a 2023 Colorado? As others have said, us GM-loving people would love to see you guys make another video comparing the '24 GMC Canyon Denali vs. '24 Tacoma Limited!

  • @teddonley9594
    @teddonley9594 11 місяців тому +9

    I cant get past how stupid that screen on the Toyota looks. Like they glued an ipad to the dash, lazy engineering. To be fair in a Tacoma hater after many many problems I've had with the last version. Bent tie rods, rusted frames, transmission problems, lack of power, cheap plastic interior squeaking, and popping and multiple electronic issues. They have good advertising and the old reputation of reliability that hasn't been factual for decades. But maybe I just got a lemon

    • @Mwoods-vl4kb
      @Mwoods-vl4kb 10 місяців тому +2

      I've had the same experience. I've had more reliable bmw's. Toyota dealers have given me unfavorable experiences. And once you look at reliability versus the idiots that can't figure out their entertainment systems, the real quality difference is really quite small and not worth toyota prestige pricing.

  • @mike198383
    @mike198383 9 місяців тому +2

    how does the 2024 Tacoma engine perform in high Altitude such as denver colorado?

    • @Heatherder
      @Heatherder 9 місяців тому

      As a rule pf thumb, a naturally aspirated engine loses 3% of its horsepower per 1000 ft density altitude. Density altitude is a temperature adjusted air density compared to an ISA standard atmosphere. On days in denver above 41 degrees F, the density altitude increases accordingly. On a 95 degree day in denver the density altitude is about 9000ft, so the effective loss in horsepower is about 27%. On a 70 degree f day in the Eisenhower tunnel, the density altitude is about 14,400 ft, or 40-45% loss of horsepower.
      A turbocharged car is limited much less than that, with a small loss from the compressor working harder, and reduced intercooler effectiveness, and increases spool time. Still, it will be far less than 10% power lost even at the tunnel.

    • @Heatherder
      @Heatherder 9 місяців тому

      Lol nevermind i see you are a pilot 😅 you probably know all of that

  • @howlingwolf125y
    @howlingwolf125y 8 місяців тому +1

    For the Toyota Adaptive dampers for a better ride on only the high end Limited?? That's disappointing.. That should be on all versions for the Tacoma...

  • @zydrunasnormaliai6997
    @zydrunasnormaliai6997 10 місяців тому +1

    Toyota, because it has a significantly better reputation, is more reliable, more luxurious and an overall better choice

  • @mariolubin4621
    @mariolubin4621 11 місяців тому +5

    Chevy all way

  • @j.e.guerrero5838
    @j.e.guerrero5838 9 місяців тому +1

    Nobody talks about rear seats space, Tacoma is like a Mustang in that department.

  • @thomasmazzola4760
    @thomasmazzola4760 11 місяців тому +2

    You didn’t compare similar trucks. For luxury the limited compares to the Denali

  • @monkeymuggs
    @monkeymuggs 11 місяців тому +2

    I appreciate the review, but what gets me is. Nobody but scotty kilmer ever talks about the Turbo and what can go wrong.

  • @PatriciaToth-ew8cu
    @PatriciaToth-ew8cu 11 місяців тому

    thank you for the comprehensive comparison,but still looking at the more versatile toyota 4 runners

  • @BamaMark
    @BamaMark 11 місяців тому +1

    Actually. I think the Frontier wins. The NA engine that rates higher MPG. You guys are the best. I am retired from the car biz. Have owned 164 vehicles. lol.
    The Taco is way $$$$

    • @jmf3353
      @jmf3353 11 місяців тому +1

      I had a 22’ Nissan pro x and no it doesn’t .. most unimpressive truck I’ve ever owned

  • @GaryDonovan-v1e
    @GaryDonovan-v1e 11 місяців тому +1

    Noticed no antenna sticking up on the video of the 2024 Colorado. Is this a welcome change?

  • @pookitty1
    @pookitty1 3 місяці тому +1

    They both DO NOT have massive air damns... thats the Tacoma my friend... I def feel as though your favor the Tacoma too.

  • @christopherblack4520
    @christopherblack4520 11 місяців тому +2

    My company truck is the Colorado worst truck I ever drove. Heating problems, electric problems, door locks/ignition problems, oil leaks, traction control problems, engine problems. 2017 was in the shop every year had to be towed twice and my newer one 2022 has been in for oil leak and the heat still is poor they did fix the tail gate does not flip open by it self

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      There's been some good model years for colorado but they've missed the mark a few times.

  • @jeffm7669
    @jeffm7669 11 місяців тому +5

    Just ordered a '24 Z71. GM has improved on some areas over the 23 model year.

    • @bladeftw6378
      @bladeftw6378 9 місяців тому

      right but I believe they removed android auto on that, going to a subscription model for their own chevy Operating System... which I would not be a fan of.