Toyota Tacoma vs. Ford Ranger vs. Chevrolet Colorado: Midsize Truck Comparison Test

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 986

  • @edmundscars
    @edmundscars  7 місяців тому +26

    It’s a close race between these three midsizers. Which are you picking for your garage? Let us know in the comments below!

    • @naveenthemachine
      @naveenthemachine 7 місяців тому +6

      Easy. The one that’s not an uncompetitive Toyota always wins. I predicted the Tacoma would be DOA and very quickly outclassed by the competition. And I’m so glad it turned out that way 😁

    • @theoutdoordad7395
      @theoutdoordad7395 7 місяців тому +13

      I’ll take the one most likely to last 10 years or 200k miles - the Toyota-why don’t you bring up that?

    • @Torch4Life
      @Torch4Life 7 місяців тому +4

      AT4X

    • @naveenthemachine
      @naveenthemachine 7 місяців тому

      @@theoutdoordad7395 because Toyota reliability is a myth. Theyve gone downhill with their quality and reliability

    • @adrianhosein7698
      @adrianhosein7698 7 місяців тому +7

      @@naveenthemachine Outclassed? really? did you miss all those quality issues and re-calls the chevy had? or are you just blind?

  • @sanji_alvarez
    @sanji_alvarez 7 місяців тому +95

    I was originally suppose to get the 2024 Tacoma. Instead got a 2024 Colorado Trail Boss. I like it.

    • @FakePersonna
      @FakePersonna 6 місяців тому +4

      I just ordered a Trail Boss. Can't wait until it arrives.

    • @devbuck6112
      @devbuck6112 5 місяців тому +5

      I got a Trail Boss over a Taco too. No regrets

    • @Heatherder
      @Heatherder 4 місяці тому +7

      I test drove a trail boss, and i really loved it. But for now I will be sticking with my 23 year old S10

    • @BudgetBoysGarage
      @BudgetBoysGarage 4 місяці тому +4

      Best thing you'll ever do is keep your old car for when the new one fails. Never thought I'd say that but not really having a lot of faith on them plastic stuff on these new carsb​@@Heatherder

    • @TriggaPapi24
      @TriggaPapi24 4 місяці тому

      I’ve always had full size trucks GMC, Ram, Chevy almost went with the Taco had fun with my Gladiator rubicon, but went with the Black Chevy Trailboss it’s been almost a week and I love it!

  • @willcarter495
    @willcarter495 7 місяців тому +78

    Bought the Colorado trail boss. $42,500 with the 360 camera, remote start, adaptive cruise, factory bed liner, blind spot monitoring, trailer brake control and 7700 tow capacity.
    A comparable XLT Ranger is about $4k more and I like the appearance of the trail boss with the factory lift more than the fx4 Ranger. Plus you’ve got more power and towing.
    Yeah it’s a ton of money for a mid size truck but beats paying the Toyota tax for a taco that was made in Mexico.

    • @chuckgoodman3828
      @chuckgoodman3828 7 місяців тому +7

      Yep, I got the 24 Z71, don’t regret it at all! Ranger looks good but still a hard sell for me, and the Tacoma is butt ugly plus the Toyota tax is a no go for me!

    • @markwatts1101
      @markwatts1101 7 місяців тому +4

      Ranger is still faster....the new transmission will make it even quicker.

    • @bobbythomas6520
      @bobbythomas6520 7 місяців тому +23

      @@markwatts1101if you’re buying a truck for speed you shouldn’t be buying a truck lmao

    • @robertopics
      @robertopics 7 місяців тому +5

      ​@@markwatts1101that's until it breaks the r80 version of the last ranger had multiple issues. What's worst even there was like a 1-2 month waiting period for dealers to be willing to make an appointment. I had to wait one month for a dealer to take the appointment for the repair and one month to determine the problem and one more month to repair and I only got a rental for the last three weeks. I liked the rangers drivetrain even compared to my current Zr2 but 3+ months to have a known issue repaired is absurd.

    • @engineer_alv
      @engineer_alv 7 місяців тому +1

      @@robertopics There are millions of 10R80s on the road as Ford has used it extensively over the last 7 years. Mine's got 190K and other than it likes doing 2-4 and 3-5 shifts on a regular basis it's been flawless. Of course forums will always list the bad ones first and bad units will always be possible. The 2024 Ranger has a revised transmission and skipping gears is part of its programming but Bronco and Explorer users haven't had widespread issues with it so it looks like it's doing fine.
      Let's not forget GM also had issues with the 8L45 and 8L90 for a few years. Delayed shits, hesitation to downshift, rough shifting among other issues. It would be good to know if this has been fixed on the new Colorado and full size trucks.

  • @Cavemol5823
    @Cavemol5823 7 місяців тому +53

    Ford Ranger is probably Best Buy at decent price . Visibility is important

    • @4rr44E
      @4rr44E 7 місяців тому +13

      I think the Frontier Pro-4X is actually the hidden gem.

    • @Cavemol5823
      @Cavemol5823 7 місяців тому

      @@4rr44E yea it would been those 2 for me

    • @ayushmalpeddi2793
      @ayushmalpeddi2793 7 місяців тому +1

      All 3 have amazing visibility compared every car that isn’t a truck lol. Amongst themselves it’s a close call

    • @dawsongranger4940
      @dawsongranger4940 7 місяців тому +1

      @@ayushmalpeddi2793No the Tacomas visibility is horrible

  • @lsx_moe
    @lsx_moe 7 місяців тому +46

    After months of research and a few test drives, I purchased a new 2024 Colorado ZR2. It was nearly fully loaded for less than $52,000 including lane keep, adaptive cruise control, 360 camera etc. after primarily looking at the 2024 Tacomas, I was left feeling as if it was just a very mid truck. That’s the best way I can describe it. It was just meh with no personality. The mid spec trd sport/offroads at my dealer were over $53,000 with much less features than the zr2, I was not a fan of that. Can’t imagine how much the trd pro will cost when they come out, more than likely over $60k and even then the $51,000 zr2 will still compete. I test drove a manual 24 Tacoma and an automatic 24 Trd offroad, as well as a 24 Colorado z71 (hard to find zr2 in stock so I could only guess how it felt) but I am so very happy and pleased with the Colorado zr2. Tacomas power plant was very buzzy and felt very gutless. I’ve had my zr2 for almost a week and I’m passing through 500 miles and have been on it very hard the past few days. It is incredibly fun offroad and makes tons of torque, 430lbft if I recall. The 4wd launch control on it is actually quite impressive, gives a nice whiplash! I was really pleasantly surprised. I couldn’t be any happier with my choice so far!

    • @Vec135
      @Vec135 7 місяців тому +8

      Yeah man I was saving up for the new Tacoma Trailhunter. Put my deposit last May, a year later I’m looking to choose the ZR2 as well. We don’t know the Trailhunter pricing yet but we all know it’s well over 60k.

    • @lsx_moe
      @lsx_moe 7 місяців тому +6

      @@Vec135 I was so excited about the new TRD offroads, had a deposit down on a solar octane one but decided on the zr2. Personally I prefer the aggressiveness on the zr2 but I’m sure people would prefer the less “boy racer” theme. I can’t say enough good things about it.

    • @RCian2000
      @RCian2000 7 місяців тому +14

      The TRD off road costing as much as a ZR2 is a complete joke. I have almost 40K Miles on my Colorado so seeing the Tacomas front diff failure on TFL was surprisingly hilarious

    • @rjejames28
      @rjejames28 7 місяців тому +3

      Nice I went ranger raptor

    • @donays8241
      @donays8241 6 місяців тому

      ​@@Vec13563k

  • @mholmes9262
    @mholmes9262 7 місяців тому +175

    Never thought the day would come when I'd have to admit a Chevy had a better interior than anything else.

    • @naveenthemachine
      @naveenthemachine 7 місяців тому +20

      It’s okay to say Toyota quality isn’t good
      Other brands including unreliable ones have surpassed Toyota

    • @mholmes9262
      @mholmes9262 7 місяців тому +9

      @@naveenthemachine so true

    • @shashankshekhar2611
      @shashankshekhar2611 7 місяців тому +10

      agreed, but they get recalled more than Walmart meat :P so choose wisely.

    • @mholmes9262
      @mholmes9262 7 місяців тому +10

      @@shashankshekhar2611 For sure, comment was only about the interiors. GM interiors used to look like hot garbage, they actually look pretty nice these days. But yeah they still scare me a little bit in terms of quality. I haven't bought a GM product in more than 20 years lol.

    • @lsx_moe
      @lsx_moe 7 місяців тому +9

      @@shashankshekhar2611 I think every manufacturer is gonna need some time to iron out the issues on early production models. The 2023 Colorado’s had an update issue that could drain the battery, I believe it’s been resolved but I’m sure the software has kinks to be ironed. The Tacomas have a front diff recall and a few other things but I’m sure most manufacturers will have them straightened out in the next year or two!

  • @wallaceharris4490
    @wallaceharris4490 4 місяці тому +16

    I bought the Frontier. No gimmicks, just a dependable reliable 3.8L V6 and I have gotten up to 29.6 mpg. I am not concerned with 0-60 speed or towing. I am not racing or hauling. I don't like all the hype sales pitches for vehicles that out of the gate are already having problems. Suit yourself on which one you buy, but I put my money on dependability.

    • @EricEsquivel-713
      @EricEsquivel-713 Місяць тому

      I’ve been looking into frontier and that’s mainly because they’re naturally aspirated and not many changes on transmission and engine.

  • @commbubba1990
    @commbubba1990 7 місяців тому +24

    the rear back seat lift and secure via a strap/button was a huge fail for toyota. atleast ford's works correctly.

    • @ALMX5DP
      @ALMX5DP 7 місяців тому +4

      Yeah such a weird cost cutting type decision. I really like having a split seat though to accommodate stuff and people simultaneously so there is some trade off depending on the want or need.

  • @dmegahan
    @dmegahan 7 місяців тому +40

    If ford comes out and reliability is on the higher end, they will be number 2 and maybe eventually back to number 1 in this segment.

    • @theoutdoordad7395
      @theoutdoordad7395 7 місяців тому +3

      BIG IF

    • @dalea4350
      @dalea4350 7 місяців тому +5

      Gigantic if. Reliability and Ford rarely are mentioned in the same sentence (personal experience)

    • @theoutdoordad7395
      @theoutdoordad7395 7 місяців тому

      @@dalea4350 oh mine too! Electrical, HVAC, build quality issues to name a few….

    • @cwqrpportable
      @cwqrpportable 7 місяців тому +2

      @@dalea4350Tons of quality over 45 yrs of experience. Different experiences…

    • @dmegahan
      @dmegahan 7 місяців тому +8

      @@dalea4350my anecdotal evidence is opposite. I have amazing luck with my ford cars and truck. I buy brand new and take great care of them. My fusion is over 250k. However I know that the newer stuff overall is not at the top of anyone’s reliability list. That being said, the old Ranger and even other current trucks are pretty reliable. All I am saying is that there is a chance they have good reliability. Especially if they get through this first year bugs that happen to every automaker.

  • @ZoomZoom81
    @ZoomZoom81 7 місяців тому +8

    Emme you are the Queen of vehicle reviews & off-roading. Top notch quality review & presentation as always. I have watched every one of your videos since your TFL Car days, even if I don't care about the subject material. You're awesome! Keep up the great work. Thank you!

  • @truthserum5310
    @truthserum5310 7 місяців тому +50

    For me, I'm going Ranger Lariat 4x4 FX4 2.7 V6

    • @sharpsbattle
      @sharpsbattle 5 місяців тому

      That definitely seems like the best option.

    • @DavefromCA2023
      @DavefromCA2023 5 місяців тому

      V6 lariat sounds as expensive as the raptor

    • @sharpsbattle
      @sharpsbattle 5 місяців тому +3

      @@DavefromCA2023 Here in Canada, ranger raptor is $80k, lariat is $60k. F150 xlt is about $85k.

    • @DavefromCA2023
      @DavefromCA2023 5 місяців тому

      @@sharpsbattle ah thank you, I’m still going for the raptor at that price point lol

    • @Paradoxical124
      @Paradoxical124 4 місяці тому

      I have the Australian sport model with the 3.0 V6 diesel. I wonder how the EcoBoost compares since it has more power but less torque.

  • @richkestrel7416
    @richkestrel7416 6 місяців тому +46

    Nice job Emme! I would have liked to see the Nissan Frontier in this comparison...

  • @dutchstorm7824
    @dutchstorm7824 7 місяців тому +35

    Emme, you just get better every year. Your insights are always the best!

    • @9663mu
      @9663mu 2 місяці тому

      I respectfully disagree. Just too Loud

  • @slingerriggin5226
    @slingerriggin5226 7 місяців тому +68

    Bring on the Ranger Raptor please…

    • @wgnwheels333
      @wgnwheels333 5 місяців тому

      We have that here in New Zealand and it's a beast

  • @lazurzabound
    @lazurzabound 7 місяців тому +7

    Thanks, Emme for not being a Toyota fan-girl, and giving us an honest review.

  • @ALMX5DP
    @ALMX5DP 7 місяців тому +11

    It’s definitely a hot segment right now. Ranger looks remarkably polished. Would be a tough decision depending on local selection, pricing and feel from the drivers seat during a test drive.

    • @CPScott16
      @CPScott16 7 місяців тому +1

      The Frontier is severely underrated

    • @ALMX5DP
      @ALMX5DP 7 місяців тому +2

      @@CPScott16 yeah Frontier is a wolf in underrated clothing for sure. Not sure on how it’s held up in terms of the 3.8/9-speed but haven’t heard too much so it’s probably a fairly decent pairing.

    • @toxicavenger6172
      @toxicavenger6172 7 місяців тому +2

      ​@@CPScott16Nissan has been lacking the technology department for a while but other than that they're definitely a decent choice. Idk why they weren't included.

  • @Yormsane
    @Yormsane 7 місяців тому +44

    Base trim King Cab Nissan Frontier, for me. Simpler mechanicals, steel bed, analog gauges, simple climate controls, small screen, conventional gear lever... easy win.

    • @Clarc115
      @Clarc115 7 місяців тому +14

      And 6 cylinder?

    • @hugogutierrez5279
      @hugogutierrez5279 7 місяців тому +5

      ​@@Clarc115 Yes

    • @Matt93Wittman
      @Matt93Wittman 7 місяців тому +9

      And it's not a uni body frame like the others as well. Everything Nissan uses is tried and proven worthy

    • @spyder000069
      @spyder000069 6 місяців тому +3

      @@Matt93Wittman None of these trucks are unibody frame. Only the maverick, ridgeline, and santa cruz are unibody.

    • @tomm1109
      @tomm1109 5 місяців тому +1

      and a gas guzzler which defeats the purpose.

  • @hwirtwirt4500
    @hwirtwirt4500 7 місяців тому +15

    Very close competition, all three are really nice trucks. My preference would be the Ranger equipped with the V6 twin turbo engine.

    • @Twistedoff2
      @Twistedoff2 7 місяців тому +5

      All the above with a LOCKER! I have a 2.7 in my work 1/2 ton and I average 21mpgs. It's loaded up all the time with gear too. The Ranger should be better in all ways.

  • @davemassoth
    @davemassoth 7 місяців тому +5

    What a great video!!! I am a ford f150 guy but have been thinking about the Colorado trail boss. This video provides great insight and reinforces some of my thoughts. Thank you!

  • @surviveitforbeginner
    @surviveitforbeginner 5 місяців тому +9

    I went with a new frontier and I love it

  • @erickisel8668
    @erickisel8668 7 місяців тому +7

    Edmunds Cars: GM has full time 4 wheel drive. Have to go to Limited trim in Taco and Ranger Raptor to get that. No ventilated seats in Ranger either. No rear vent in Ranger. Rear seat space in Taco is much smaller than other two. GMC Canyon offers more value than the others in my opinion while Ranger has best proven powertrain. Ranger styling is way too conservative too, others much more aggressive.

    • @stevel6371
      @stevel6371 3 місяці тому

      Haha I prefer the less aggressive look. To each their own

  • @drivetheday
    @drivetheday 7 місяців тому +14

    Buttons instead of screens all the way! Everyone will be getting into accidents fooling around with their truck televisions. How is that legal.

    • @pbwmanagement
      @pbwmanagement 7 місяців тому +4

      In Europe, they have started deducting safety points (stars) from vehicles that have basic functions like HVAC hidden in the screen. Hopefully, this approach will catch on over here.

  • @kavynryan3159
    @kavynryan3159 7 місяців тому +5

    I have a 2022 Colorado myself. Z71 fully loaded. My buddy has a 2022 tacoma TRDpro. We kept arguing about who's was better so we both took a ride in each, drove each ourselves. Judged them on everything and even raced them. We both agreed my Colorado was better in almost every single category, even winning the race, gas mileage, and having the nicer interior. We agreed the ride was smoother and a nicer drive than the tacoma, but being the TRDpro his was better offload, especially since I had street tires and he had all terrains

  • @PrepperDawg
    @PrepperDawg 5 місяців тому +14

    Still have my 2004 Toyota Tacoma here. Still running strong. If buying today, it would be the Colorado.

    • @lelenbates3367
      @lelenbates3367 4 місяці тому +2

      2005 Tundra double cab TRD. Not selling it.

    • @BudgetBoysGarage
      @BudgetBoysGarage 4 місяці тому

      I had a 2011 f150 3.5 Ecoboost with 225k when one of the turbos was on its way out. Super clean and reliable truck. Super hesitant on all these new ones with turbos and stuff that will eventually fail. Electronics won't be dyi friendly. Parts and everything definitely higher prices for maintenance. I own a 94 bmw 325is with 275k miles easy to maintain and cheap. Been looking for older Tacoma's and no one wants to sell them lol but I might pull the trigger on this 2024 Tacoma

    • @kiddb.3020
      @kiddb.3020 2 місяці тому

      Me the Tundra premium

  • @aidenarkham
    @aidenarkham 7 місяців тому +16

    I'd probably get the Nissan Frontier because its the only one with a naturally asperated V6

  • @User.Joshua
    @User.Joshua 7 місяців тому +23

    Only clicked for Emme. Enjoy her reviews.

    • @rjdavis7503
      @rjdavis7503 2 місяці тому

      Yep, Emma should be a country music superstar!

  • @arthurmendoza6926
    @arthurmendoza6926 7 місяців тому +34

    I’m buying the Ford ranger 2.7

    • @BC08
      @BC08 7 місяців тому +9

      No one will be able to compete with that truck.
      Ford knocked it out of he park with the the ‘24 Ranger

    • @marklihsu
      @marklihsu 7 місяців тому +9

      The Chevy got smoked by the base ranger engine 😂

    • @JK-qe6qq
      @JK-qe6qq 7 місяців тому

      Sure you are!!!

    • @engineer_alv
      @engineer_alv 7 місяців тому +2

      @@BC08 they can't get them soon enought, should've re-labeled them as 2025 MY

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      @@marklihsuFord also comes with V6 which is attractive

  • @tensing89
    @tensing89 7 місяців тому +16

    I'm definitely between the Colorado and the Ranger. I prefer the look of the Colorado and the offroad features + 4-Auto (which I use both quite a bit), but I like the quality, powertrain, and day to day features of the Ranger. Tough choice... will have to go with my gut feeling! or maybe will be based on if one of them has a nice discount at the time of purchase :) P.S. I really don't mind the headlight controls on the chevy. Having owned a tesla, it's not an issue at all.

  • @brooklyn5466
    @brooklyn5466 7 місяців тому +3

    I have a Red Ford Maverick Tremor and I love it.It’s not heavy duty at all but for basic needs it’s fantastic.

  • @lutomson3496
    @lutomson3496 7 місяців тому +8

    im a toyota person but the Ranger is a world platform all over the world, and proven to bad we cant get the diesel here...was driving one in Vietnam a couple weeks ago great vehicle

  • @phonemeunit1973
    @phonemeunit1973 5 місяців тому +7

    I just got a '24 Ranger XLT FX4. Best truck I've ever owned by a long shot.

  • @jimf.625
    @jimf.625 7 місяців тому +36

    Not going to choose at this time. Let's revisit this question at 100k, 200k, and 300k miles. Last truck standing wins.

    • @edgarrmartinz
      @edgarrmartinz 4 місяці тому +5

      Toyota

    • @chriss1757
      @chriss1757 3 місяці тому +8

      @@edgarrmartinz Reminder, that Tacoma doesn't have a motor that we have examples of with 200000 miles on them.

    • @EXB14_
      @EXB14_ 2 місяці тому +6

      It’s going to be the 2.7L on the Colorado. One of the few things GM has done correctly in the past years. New gen Tacomas are unreliable

    • @thatsTylerDurden
      @thatsTylerDurden 2 місяці тому +1

      Has anyone ever actually seen those Colorados with the four cylinder diesels?

    • @SeanJordanMusic
      @SeanJordanMusic 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thatsTylerDurden I currently have one at 120,000 and its been in the shop so many times in the last two years

  • @nestr2007
    @nestr2007 7 місяців тому +15

    Why no frontier?

  • @williambellew767
    @williambellew767 7 місяців тому +32

    I have had my Colorado almost a year and never needed my headlight switch.

    • @stephenzerfas5307
      @stephenzerfas5307 7 місяців тому +3

      I was going to say the same. I like physical controls but on all of my vehicles including the 12 year old F-150 I leave it auto year round. Almost everyone auto lights with wipers on too.

    • @CDX7
      @CDX7 7 місяців тому +2

      It’s a meme and these reviewers feel like they need to mention it for credibility. That’s the only explanation I can muster. I’ve also owned a Colorado for 6 months now and never touched it. Auto is fine.

    • @losr98
      @losr98 7 місяців тому +2

      Right!? I've had mine for a little over a month and have yet to notice there's no physical switch because there's no need to even touch it. Even before that I had a grand Cherokee with a dial and never touched it. They act like automatic lights don't exist

    • @CDX7
      @CDX7 7 місяців тому +2

      Since I commented before I saw a reviewer mentioned they need to mess with the lights a lot for pictures and footage reasons. But again, it’s not something a normal user experiences

    • @kevindust2712
      @kevindust2712 Місяць тому

      I agree. Given that the GM twins are equipped with auto headlights, the headlight switch being moved to the infotainment screen is a non-issue. If we are going to nitpick, a much bigger miss is the fixed rear seatback and the manual sliding rear window on all trim levels including the Canyon Denali. This is inexcusable on a $40-60K truck.

  • @BrendanMacieAutos
    @BrendanMacieAutos 3 місяці тому

    Colorado Z71 here, not once needed to use the manual headlights in the screen, for day to day it's not a problem, it's easy to pick it out without owning one. Awesome video!

  • @Spikasaurus
    @Spikasaurus 7 місяців тому +14

    Don't get why every reviewer acts like the headlight switch is a big deal. Haven't had to touch the headlight switch in over 20 years with GM's auto headlights.

    • @Tiovergudo
      @Tiovergudo 7 місяців тому +6

      Same here. And some of the other brands dont have auto lights and see them at night with no lights on just daytime running lights. Mostly foreign brands

    • @robhtwo
      @robhtwo 7 місяців тому +4

      I would have to touch it almost daily going through security gates at night so you don't blind security. I also often travel in Safety Corridors that require your lights on during the day.
      That is one expensive light switch if and when it fails as you have to fix it, no option if you're going to drive at night or even some places during the day.
      This is an absolutely horrible idea!

    • @jeffreyjohnson3103
      @jeffreyjohnson3103 7 місяців тому

      @@Tiovergudo And Fords.

    • @jeffreyjohnson3103
      @jeffreyjohnson3103 7 місяців тому

      @@robhtwo There's so much functionality controlled by the touchscreen in any of these trucks, if it fails you are going to have to get it fixed. It's not like the light controls on the Colorado screen are going to fail all by themselves.

    • @robhtwo
      @robhtwo 7 місяців тому

      @@jeffreyjohnson3103 I'm not aware of any other settings I need to change on the screen to safely drive it if the screen stops working. What other functions do I need to change when I'm driving? It's not like it's the ECU/ECM.

  • @masterchief6280
    @masterchief6280 7 місяців тому +12

    Out of all three I got a Nissan Frontier.

  • @Ashoud_Anobetah
    @Ashoud_Anobetah 5 місяців тому +10

    none of these have a V6, the Frontier outshines all of these, the larger displacement has less wear over time compared to a 4 cylinder running at a higher RPM to get the same power, that's why the previous Toyota engines in V6 and V8 last so long, they run at lower rpms, this new 4 banger in all these models shown will not have the longevity compared to a NA engine, also Dont forgot to factor in the cost of a turbo replacement can be 3-4K$ so what ever fuel savings you make, keep it handy

  • @dannyb2349080
    @dannyb2349080 5 місяців тому +2

    GREAT REVIEW!!! Felt like you were really honest and unbiased in your review of these trucks! Really helped me make up my mind. Keep up the good work and yes you were funny too.

  • @border411
    @border411 7 місяців тому +7

    No Ridgeline or Frontier in the comparison?

  • @joeqb5992
    @joeqb5992 Місяць тому

    Last year I was ready to get a Tacoma but went to Chevy dealership next door I wanted to checkout the nice looking red stripe on black Colorado displayed at the front of dealer. I bought the Colorado. Love it! No regrets.

  • @Manihsi
    @Manihsi 6 місяців тому +3

    "I own a 2008 Tacoma TRD Sport package with 220k miles, and it has never given me any issues. I was waiting to upgrade to the new 2024 Tacoma, but the disappearance of the 4-cylinder turbo engine option has disappointed me, so l've decided to go with a Ford Ranger instead."

    • @dennisclouser3458
      @dennisclouser3458 6 місяців тому

      ????? I thought the Taco came with only 4 cal turbo???

  • @sharpshooter012345
    @sharpshooter012345 7 місяців тому +7

    Should have included the frontier!

  • @joeldavila3185
    @joeldavila3185 6 місяців тому +11

    Nissan frontier has a simple more reliable engine than these three. No one asked for everything to be turbo charged.

    • @ZeroTheHero6920
      @ZeroTheHero6920 6 місяців тому

      Speak like someone that has never worked on a turbo car before it really isn’t anymore difficult than an na car

    • @kevindust2712
      @kevindust2712 Місяць тому

      We asked for more torque and that is what the turbo delivers.

    • @joeldavila3185
      @joeldavila3185 Місяць тому

      @@ZeroTheHero6920 buy a bigger truck

  • @chadbrinkley6358
    @chadbrinkley6358 7 місяців тому +1

    I have 27,000 miles on my '23 Colorado, the headlight switch is a non-issue when you actually drive the vehicle daily. It takes as much time and effort as moving your left hand down and turning a knob. On the other hand, I can't imagine having to use the screen to lock diffs, turn on ventilated seats, etc, like on the Ranger!

  • @DavidNWallis
    @DavidNWallis 7 місяців тому +9

    The Chevy Colorado's available towing capacity is 7,700 models, but models like the ZR2 can only tow 6,000 pounds. The Ford Ranger maxes out at 7,500 pounds, but its Raptor model only musters 5,000 pounds of towing capability.

    • @marklihsu
      @marklihsu 7 місяців тому +3

      5,500 on the raptor actually

    • @rjejames28
      @rjejames28 7 місяців тому +2

      If your towing more the 5k you should get a half ton

    • @huahin6149
      @huahin6149 6 місяців тому +1

      Because off road models ride is meant for bumps not towing .
      Apples and oranges . Better towing capacity means rougher ride off-road. Like an f150 vs a f250

    • @DavidNWallis
      @DavidNWallis 6 місяців тому +1

      @@huahin6149 f150 is a half ton f250 is 3/4, not the same as a mid-size

    • @huahin6149
      @huahin6149 6 місяців тому +1

      @ElementoftheGods3094 yes I know. Jfc It's an. exaggerated example of a vehicle having heavier suspension for towing vs one that's not. Clearly some don't understand why the zr2 is rated to tow less lol and act like it's a bug when it's am actual feature

  • @Boogy3000
    @Boogy3000 4 місяці тому +2

    Edmunds video team killing it. Kudos

  • @nvpoolshooter
    @nvpoolshooter 7 місяців тому +6

    Not buying a truck with a 4-banger. Period. Frontier is a far better option in so many respects to these three options.

  • @DirtRoadRemedy
    @DirtRoadRemedy 7 місяців тому +6

    i'm 9 seconds in, and you're right. I'm just going to go out and buy a Taco!

  • @Pioneer_Valley_Foods
    @Pioneer_Valley_Foods 4 місяці тому +5

    What if I want just a basic mid-sized 4x4 truck?

    • @jamesbuff3619
      @jamesbuff3619 2 місяці тому +2

      Nissan Frontier with a naturally aspirated V6

  • @rideSYV246
    @rideSYV246 3 місяці тому

    Great video! Thank you for the comfort rating!! Very important for long drives...

  • @reeeddd590
    @reeeddd590 7 місяців тому +3

    lol..."Orange you glad" + 10 pts for the dad joke 😃have now compared all 3 (And yes, have owned previous gens of all 3) and couldn't agree more with the ratings. Great comparo.

  • @laurabegin9736
    @laurabegin9736 4 місяці тому +1

    Thank you for showing features I was unaware of. This is great.

  • @HuronRiver-ke8xn
    @HuronRiver-ke8xn 7 місяців тому +20

    If i only had these three to choose from, i think i would buy the Ranger. Unfortunately for the difference in mpg and interior room I opted for the Maverick. If i was towing more weight i would have probably bought the Ranger or F150. Besides saving at the gas pump I also saved thousands on the purchase, ka-ching, laughing all the way to the bank.

    • @Encourageable
      @Encourageable 7 місяців тому

      A Maverick isn’t a truck though.

    • @HuronRiver-ke8xn
      @HuronRiver-ke8xn 7 місяців тому

      @@Encourageable
      Did you research that comment or is it an opinion or an insult. No matter just for the record.
      en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Maverick_(2022)#:~:text=The%20Ford%20Maverick%20is%20a,marketed%20by%20Ford%20Motor%20Company.

    • @VulcanXIV
      @VulcanXIV 2 місяці тому +1

      My '24 XLT fully loaded Maverick hybrid is nice too, only a month since purchase, but I still find myself watching these videos because the midsize truck scene is killer right now. Wish I could enjoy such good looking off-road beasts honestly.
      Love my Maverick, but the days of it being a mid 20k purchase are long gone, unless you buy it barbone... And that's no way to live. If you are single and are financially responsible before a vehicle purchase, dishing out 10k+ more for one of these midsizers makes sense to me. Then again, I'm sure someone with a maverick AWD or tremor would disagree. Maybe I'm the true idiot for going fully loaded hybrid 🥴

    • @HuronRiver-ke8xn
      @HuronRiver-ke8xn 2 місяці тому +1

      @@VulcanXIV Definitely not, I think in 24 about 50% build were hybrid. With AWD being available in hybrid, I see that percentage going up. I was on the fence and actually waiting for the AWD with hybrid. When Ford made it a $1500 option and I actually sat down and did the numbers, it was a no brainier. That was for me living in rural and Midwest with snow the AWD and AT tires were a must. So given that the eco was 29 hwy vs hybrid 33 FWD hwy I ordered the ecoboost. I think one's driving needs, location and requirements (towing, payload, off road) defines one's purchase. If it doesn't satisfy these needs the consumer is looking for something that will.

  • @chriss1757
    @chriss1757 3 місяці тому +1

    Great review. Would've liked to see a Frontier in the mix. I'm disappointed in a few things with the Toyota, the biggest of which is the cabin is still really small, especially for as big as the truck is! I feel like the Frontier offers a lot of equivalency to the Tacoma for much less money. The Ford and Chevy are the better trucks, but I'd like to see what they are like at 10 years old with 100,000 miles on them. As for the lights in the Colorado, yeah, they won't get touched. I have a 20 year old Malibu and I don't think the lights have ever been off auto!

  • @jeffreybaker4727
    @jeffreybaker4727 7 місяців тому +3

    Long term reliability and resale will prove the value of the Tacoma

  • @joshuajohnson1036
    @joshuajohnson1036 3 місяці тому

    I just bought a Colorado and, I’ve driven it all week. It’s really nice and the gas mileage is better than what I expected

  • @jimjim0058
    @jimjim0058 7 місяців тому +5

    Love my 2019 Frontier.

  • @joegrahe3958
    @joegrahe3958 7 місяців тому +1

    Just bought a 2024 Canyon Elevation for 40k pretty well equipped. Liked the 11 inch driver screen standard as well as the factory 2 inch lift. We also have a 2017 Tacoma TRD Sport with 135k miles which has never seen the shop for anything but routine maintenance, so switching to the GMC is a leap of faith. I couldn't get past the steep price increase (Paid 31.5k for my Tacoma, and similiarly equipped 2024 was going to run 47k), the inability to order a truck exactly as we wanted it spec-ed, and that new engine looks atrocious with the plethora of potentially leaky hoses. Time will tell obviously.

  • @ZeroCool_1220
    @ZeroCool_1220 7 місяців тому +37

    FRONTIER BABY! V6 low key winning all day....😂

  • @tomcurran8470
    @tomcurran8470 6 місяців тому +1

    Great info and an excellent presentation. You get an "A" in Public Speaking. No extraneous info, like, the weather, your dog, etc.

  • @mr.commander3947
    @mr.commander3947 7 місяців тому +8

    I BET money on FORD ranger,,, man

  • @GPCCPA
    @GPCCPA 7 місяців тому +1

    Totally agree with the ranking ….. I’m waiting for the Ranger 2.7

  • @CustomerService-ut9tj
    @CustomerService-ut9tj 6 місяців тому +8

    You lost me when you began praising Fords back up technology. Considering that Ford has been the most recalled auto manufacturer in the world over the last four years, and the litany of problems they are having with $70,000 bronco engines failing, bronco sports with rear end problems and F-150 Lightning trucks with only fractional range, we need less technology and more durability and reliability.

  • @compasspropertiesnow
    @compasspropertiesnow 5 місяців тому

    Best delivery and presentation of any car/truck reviewer on UA-cam. E-V-E-R. She definitely gets it!

  • @Smcat913
    @Smcat913 7 місяців тому +2

    Sorry if I missed this in the video, but isn’t the Colorado the only one that has full time four-wheel-drive in the lower trims?

  • @anibalbabilonia1867
    @anibalbabilonia1867 Місяць тому +2

    I’m going with the new Chevy Colorado! I think Chevy finally has a winner here! And I was never a Chevy fan before!

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      By far the best looking new truck on the market. Not even close. Most bang for your buck too

  • @chaleowin7732
    @chaleowin7732 7 місяців тому +7

    Ford Ranger can hold a full sized 4x8 sheet of plywood. That's big in my world where I use my trucks, as work trucks.

    • @chadbrinkley6358
      @chadbrinkley6358 7 місяців тому +1

      If you use your truck for actual work, you can't see the floor of the bed anyway.

    • @chaleowin7732
      @chaleowin7732 7 місяців тому

      @@chadbrinkley6358 My comment was for how the sheets of plywood fit. You don't need to put this in cockeyed. It's kinda a big deal.

    • @chadbrinkley6358
      @chadbrinkley6358 7 місяців тому

      @@chaleowin7732 My Colorado also holds a 4x8 sheet of plywood

    • @chaleowin7732
      @chaleowin7732 7 місяців тому

      @@chadbrinkley6358 Between the wheel wells in the bed?

    • @chadbrinkley6358
      @chadbrinkley6358 7 місяців тому

      @@chaleowin7732 no, I usually carry tools and other equipment there.......

  • @garrettw99
    @garrettw99 7 місяців тому +1

    9:03 “Check the tech” gives me nostalgia for the days of Emmie making videos at CNET 🥺

  • @huss1205
    @huss1205 7 місяців тому +4

    Will always pick the Toyota...

  • @andrewr022488
    @andrewr022488 Місяць тому

    Great review but one thing I’d like to point out. The specific Tacoma you’re reviewing doesn’t have wireless charging. They’ve got an option for it but unfortunately the one you’re reviewing isn’t equipped with it which is why you’re unable to get it to work. I had a Tacoma as a loaner this past week and it was great, I need to test drive the three trucks mentioned here but I liked the Tacoma for the week I had it.

  • @CP-pb3pj
    @CP-pb3pj 7 місяців тому +3

    I like to keep my cars/trucks for at least 15 years. Reliability is a huge factor especially for a daily driver. Next is interior comfort and climate control button/knobs functionality.

    • @toxicavenger6172
      @toxicavenger6172 7 місяців тому

      Don't get the ford or Chevy then lol.

    • @CP-pb3pj
      @CP-pb3pj 7 місяців тому

      @@toxicavenger6172
      Could be right. Tacoma is a new design so it’s unproven. Rented a Ranger a few years ago and that 2.3 turbo is a smooth engine. Comfortable too.

    • @toxicavenger6172
      @toxicavenger6172 7 місяців тому

      @@CP-pb3pj the ranger and Chevy designs are both unproven too. Ford so far hasn't had a great track record with that Ecoboost engine.

    • @randycupp5925
      @randycupp5925 7 місяців тому

      ​@@toxicavenger6172Not really, GM has been using the 2.7/8 speed in 1500's since 2020. The 2.7 has been great, but the 8 speed has had issues that have supposedly been worked out in the last year or two.

    • @CP-pb3pj
      @CP-pb3pj 7 місяців тому

      @@randycupp5925
      That 8 speed had a suspect transmission fluid from the factory. There is a “supposed” shudder fix by changing the fluid to mobile 1. It is done by the dealership. My uncle has a Canyon.

  • @christopherclark6383
    @christopherclark6383 7 місяців тому +1

    I have always liked your videos, I think you’re one of the best

  • @Ishliss2012
    @Ishliss2012 7 місяців тому +5

    Been back and forth on Colorado or Ranger for my next ride. And I just can’t get over the derpy front end of that Ranger. The availability of the 2.7 V6 is the only thing keeping me from buying a Colorado right now.

    • @just4ivaylo92
      @just4ivaylo92 7 місяців тому +1

      The frontend of the Ranger looks like shit.

    • @arkhsm
      @arkhsm 7 місяців тому +5

      @@just4ivaylo92 Totally disagree, it's the only one that doesn't have a face from Alien vs Predator !!

    • @toxicavenger6172
      @toxicavenger6172 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@arkhsmit looks like something a soccer mom would be driving though. More akin to the ford flex or even the escape.

    • @randycupp5925
      @randycupp5925 7 місяців тому

      I have the same exact thoughts. I like the 2.7/10 speed power train option in the Ranger, but the front end looks like crap.

    • @engineer_alv
      @engineer_alv 7 місяців тому

      @@arkhsm the Canyon has a better front end than the Colorado. Problem solved

  • @MsBranNu
    @MsBranNu 5 днів тому

    Now this is the video I needed to watch

  • @trizlet
    @trizlet 7 місяців тому +4

    I don't think your Tacoma actually has wireless charging. It doesn't look like it has the indicator lights for charging like I've seen in other videos...

    • @ohscheisse2192
      @ohscheisse2192 7 місяців тому

      It has wireless charging but if it’s the same technology as in the third gen let’s go ahead and say it doesn’t. 😂

  • @FakePersonna
    @FakePersonna 6 місяців тому

    I just ordered a 2024 Colorado Trail boss (TB) w/ the standard 2.7L TurboMax engine (310 hp/ 430 Torque). I got it loaded (Convenience II, Safety, Tech, Adv Trailering, 20" Wheel, spray in bed liner), it was also much cheaper than a comparably equipped Ranger. The TB has a factory 2" lift and can be flat-towed behind a motor home. Neither the Ford or the Toyota can be flat-towed.

  • @jamesdonaldson7396
    @jamesdonaldson7396 7 місяців тому +3

    It's very frustrating that the Tacoma and Frontier are the only mid-size trucks with 6 ft beds.

    • @randycupp5925
      @randycupp5925 7 місяців тому

      Ain't that the truth!

    • @richardlee2642
      @richardlee2642 7 місяців тому

      If you want the 6-speed manual in the Tacoma, the 6-foot bed isn’t an option. Crazy…

    • @RobertLitwinski-s8g
      @RobertLitwinski-s8g 6 місяців тому

      You forgot the Nissan Frontier. My 2023 SV model has the 6 ft bed.

    • @jamesdonaldson7396
      @jamesdonaldson7396 6 місяців тому

      @@RobertLitwinski-s8g yep, mentioned it.

  • @G-Force_70
    @G-Force_70 7 місяців тому

    The Ford and the GM are assembled in the US. Tacoma which I loved is now assembled exclusively in Mexico and the Pro4X is now starting at $65k.

  • @deancm9302
    @deancm9302 7 місяців тому +39

    Nissan Frontier! V6 engine normally aspirated!

    • @Gadfly2025
      @Gadfly2025 5 місяців тому +4

      Heavily discounted $$$ right now as 6/24’
      $9k off pro models openly priced in Florida dealers . SV 4x4 crew cab V6 9spd under $30k

    • @carrebanks5890
      @carrebanks5890 5 місяців тому +2

      @@Gadfly2025 which dealership is offering those prices, details pls.

    • @Gadfly2025
      @Gadfly2025 5 місяців тому

      @@carrebanks5890 many nationally especially in Florida . If they can sell low so can your local . Cars.con or other search engine , include Florida

    • @shanewinters3009
      @shanewinters3009 3 місяці тому +2

      @@carrebanks5890none of them.

    • @carrebanks5890
      @carrebanks5890 3 місяці тому

      @@shanewinters3009 I ended up leasing a Chevy Silverado at a good price and so far I am happy with it.

  • @technicallyreal
    @technicallyreal 7 місяців тому

    Loved my 2019 Ranger Lariat and would definitely buy one again if I needed a truck, especially given all the improvements they made to it.

  • @arthurmendoza6926
    @arthurmendoza6926 7 місяців тому +20

    I am going to buy the Ford Ranger 2.7

    • @JK-qe6qq
      @JK-qe6qq 7 місяців тому

      Sure you are!!

  • @markab5019
    @markab5019 Місяць тому

    I bought a Colorado in June and it has been back at the dealer for close to a month with injector and quality problems. GM knows of the problems but either doesn’t have a solution or the replacement parts are not available. Now what do I do?

  • @busslayer4790
    @busslayer4790 7 місяців тому +7

    I find the Chevy and Toyota are trying way too hard with the styling. They look like they are trying to make real life versions of something they sell at a toy store.

    • @JK-qe6qq
      @JK-qe6qq 7 місяців тому

      They look better than sissy looking for Ranger

  • @zzremington
    @zzremington 5 місяців тому

    Owned a 2O Tacoma TRD for 13 years, was a care-free truck, overdrive it - just got a ‘24 Canyon AT4, love it, but big shoes to fill where reliability is concerned. No sunroof in the Ranger made my decision.

  • @vica7667
    @vica7667 7 місяців тому +14

    Most important factor for me is looks. Tacoma and Colorado look mean and tough. Ranger looks curvy and non-intimidating. I bought the Colorado

    • @timetraveler7990
      @timetraveler7990 7 місяців тому +4

      Lol😂😂😂 congratulations for winning the worst comment in the world🤦‍♂️

    • @vica7667
      @vica7667 7 місяців тому +3

      @@timetraveler7990 must be a Ranger fan 🤦

    • @Eatinbritches
      @Eatinbritches 7 місяців тому +1

      looooool looks are your most important factor in a truck? Are you twelve? Doesn't matter which one you picked, it's ridiculous to judge a truck on it's looks.

    • @robertchapman4488
      @robertchapman4488 7 місяців тому +2

      I own a Tacoma but I still like the way the new ranger looks from the front.

    • @drivesanoldcar
      @drivesanoldcar 7 місяців тому

      you are for real. most b will tow once in awhile only or maybe never. If you really want the truck to work buy a toyota for reliability and suffer the ride otherwise cruise into the work parking lot in a stunner.

  • @michaelahl7692
    @michaelahl7692 6 місяців тому

    I'm buying a Colorado next weekend. Love that truck!!!

  • @carejimgjw3nz852
    @carejimgjw3nz852 7 місяців тому +3

    TOYOTA all the way! Any day. I’ll go with the one that sells the most and has better resale value.

    • @chrisedwards8726
      @chrisedwards8726 6 місяців тому

      Hold up a bit on the Tacoma. The new ones are too expensive and if the new Taco is as reliable as the new Tundra, that would not be good. Toyota has lost their way with trucks, that’s what happens when you try to copy Ford.

    • @wayne1916
      @wayne1916 9 днів тому

      @@chrisedwards8726 You have snatched the pebble from my hand, Grasshopper!

  • @grobballer
    @grobballer 6 місяців тому +1

    Emme Hall is an amazing presenter

  • @aidenarkham
    @aidenarkham 7 місяців тому +3

    Talk about reliability, thats the most important thing lady.

    • @lrn_news9171
      @lrn_news9171 Місяць тому

      No one knows which model is going to be reliable they're new lol

  • @rjeepster8640
    @rjeepster8640 5 місяців тому

    Such an amazing job of presenting all the facts, so articulate! Love it

  • @netcowboy007
    @netcowboy007 7 місяців тому +19

    What about the new Nissan Frontier?

    • @RobertLitwinski-s8g
      @RobertLitwinski-s8g 6 місяців тому +3

      Yes, why not was the new redesigned Frontier included?

    • @alexandercarl30
      @alexandercarl30 6 місяців тому +4

      Because they're not playing ball. Nissan is sticking with the working class. These 3 are leaning toward becoming luxury brands.

    • @edgarrmartinz
      @edgarrmartinz 4 місяці тому

      What about it? Lol jk

    • @JasonBartholomew-d7r
      @JasonBartholomew-d7r Місяць тому

      Lol

    • @kevindust2712
      @kevindust2712 Місяць тому +1

      @@RobertLitwinski-s8g The Frontier styling was redesigned in 2022, the chassis is from model year 2005. The Frontier isn't in the same league as these three and it would be outclassed is every single category.

  • @dfwxplorer1833
    @dfwxplorer1833 7 місяців тому +1

    The Tacoma has dominated this market for a reason. I will be test driving a Colorado this coming week though, just to see.

    • @teddonley9594
      @teddonley9594 7 місяців тому

      Only in this country. Americans are kinda dumb is the thoughts around the globe. The Hilux sells pretty well, but it's still number 7. The Ford F series isn't just the best selling in this country but in the world. Look it up.

  • @ItsAlive111
    @ItsAlive111 7 місяців тому +5

    Just wait for the Check Engine Light popping in the Ranger or Colorado and then play this 16:15

  • @travisleitzel1523
    @travisleitzel1523 4 місяці тому

    Just want to add for any parents out there that how smooth the ride is can be super important to keep sleeping babies sleeping and something most of these comparisons never mention is how much extra seat room there is with a car seat. nothing sucks more than needing to have your front seat all the way forward bc theres a carseat behind it.

  • @CPScott16
    @CPScott16 7 місяців тому +6

    The Nissan Frontier

    • @dennisclouser3458
      @dennisclouser3458 6 місяців тому +2

      Isn't it funny that Edmund's overlooked it? Redesigned just a few years ago, standard V6 and priced less than all three of these. Maybe for a Lowe's run, a turbo 4 would be great for picking up mulch and weed killer. I can't imagine a real truck buyer dealing with a Hybrid system.

  • @gyuder
    @gyuder 5 місяців тому +2

    Nissan Frontier is Mid-Side Truck on Platform F-Alpha Mid-Size Full-Size Since D40

  • @drivescene6747
    @drivescene6747 7 місяців тому +3

    Tacoma hands down. Toyota has been killing it with these new models.

  • @fgonzalez78959
    @fgonzalez78959 5 місяців тому

    Wanna back up a trailer easy..
    1.Put your hand at 6 o clock on steering wheel.
    2. Now turn the steering wheel what ever way you want trailer to move in your mirrors.
    3. Pull up a bit if need be till you get it right.
    Small trailers move quicker then longer ones!

  • @dudeski934
    @dudeski934 6 місяців тому +4

    The Ford Ranger will be #1 with in a year it’s the only truck with 3 engine options. Hopefully they make a kingranch version with the 3.0 V6 as an option. Then Dodge will come out with the new Dakota with the inline 6 Hurricane Engine