Do We NEED Carbohydrates? [Are Carbs Essential?]
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 лис 2022
- I've seen so many supposedly reliable sources of health information state that "we need carbs". In this video, I explain why they're all wrong!
- SUBSCRIBE -
Be sure to subscribe to my channel - ua-cam.com/users/drdanmaggs?su...
- NEWSLETTER-
Get my weekly newsletter by signing up here (you can unsubscribe at any time) - www.drdanmaggs.com/newsletter/
- SOCIAL MEDIA -
Website - www.drdanmaggs.com/
Twitter - / drdanmaggs
Instagram - / drdanmaggs
Facebook - / drdanmaggs
Say hi on social and use the hashtag - #carbdodging
- RESOURCES MENTIONED -
What About Fibre? by Dr Zoe Harcombe PhD - • What about fibre? by D...
How Lectins impact your healthy - Dr Paul Mason • Dr. Paul Mason - 'How ...
Fiber and Colon Health On A Well-Formulated Ketogenic Diet: New Insights Question Its Role As An Unconditional Requirement - www.virtahealth.com/blog/fibe...
Does Your Thyroid Need Dietary Carbohydrates? - www.virtahealth.com/blog/does...
- IMPORTANT -
The content in this video is not intended as a substitute for the medical advice of a primary physician. Please regularly consult with your physician in matters relating to your health, particularly with respect to any symptoms that may require diagnosis or immediate medical attention. Due to the variance of individuals’ lifestyles and bodies, the methods elaborated on in this video are not guaranteed to produce your desired result; therefore, the author does not assume any liability to any party for any loss, damage, or disruption caused by the choice to implement any of the following health strategies. - Наука та технологія
![What Breaks A Fast & What Doesn't [The Complete Guide]](/img/n.gif)
When people were duped into thinking margarine was healthier than real butter and sugar was good for you is where the western world turned completely up side down.
Margarine tastes awful, it's like plastic.
Nobody ever thought sugar was good , it been demonized forever
Yeah, people have literally been programed to eat like sh*t and most don't even realize it. "I gotta eat my 12 daily servings of grains"...crazy
Carbs are for the poor
You are being duped by watching UA-cam videos lol
When people say you can't live without carbs and I just mentioned that I've been carb free for 15 months and not only I'm still alive but my health improved by a ton!
I bet you are constipated lol
Vitamin C is a carbohydrate. Do you not intake vitamin C?
@@sindrestokke79 technically there is carbs in eggs too
@@MrSnazzy682 nope. classic misconception that we need fiber to poop.
Carnivore 3 years, and I’ve seen significant improvement in my health - and I’m in my 70s - can’t believe how well I look and feel. Aging in reverse. ❤
Carnivore is the most appropriated diet for us . . . no doubt !
no ! u aint reversing shit .....keto and carnivore are fad trendy bullshit and most of UA-cam proponents of this diet are QUITTING
(suddenly imagines a grandma, wildly headbanging at a metal concert) 🤔
@@sekarmaltum1695 😂
My cholesterol LDL went from 110 to 169 in two months and almost had a stroke ( couldn’t feel my right side of face and feet .
Eat oatmeal mofo’s !
Like Dr Bright said "carbs are entertainment not nutrition".
I agree with you but it’s so hard when eating out. You still have to pay the same when you’ve said “no bun no fries etc” and I hate having to explain myself. I just prefer to eat at home. Thanks for your helpful advice
You shouldn't NEED to explain yourself, do you ask other WHY they are eating this or that? no, so why should you need to tell anyone why you don't eat certain foods. Eat what YOU want & enjoy it. Good luck.
@@malcytull I agree with you. I know I shouldn’t need to. I’m not always asked. Do you find yourself scanning the menu trying to find the best choice before you go?
After a lifetime of eating a lot of carbs, it's hard period, not just when eating out -- while I have cut WAY BACK, I find eating some carbs adds to my enjoyment of life
I just tell the waiter or waitress “I can’t have that” and mostly they assume that I’m allergic. But you can also say you are allergic too which is true really. They take a lot more care with your food at restaurants when there is an allergy as opposed to a diet. Just make sure you are specific on what you want. I ordered a steak once and it came marinated. I thought I was just going to get a plain steak. I had to send it back. Now I’ve learned to say just a plain steak no spices.
You pay more physically and health wise if you eat the bun and the fries.
I did not realize I was addicted to carbs and I did not realize how all those carbs were hurting my mental clarity and impacting my emotional health until I consistently kept my carbs at 20g net per day for about 3 months.
Suddenly, I no longer had the insane cravings I had had at first. But it took consistency, as in no cheat meals or days.
Nobody believes me when I tell them carbs are non essential and completely not required in the human diet. I don’t even bother talking about food choices anymore. I just eat my steak in peace!
Now you can send them this video! :-)
keto and carnivore are fad trend bullshit people use as a excuse to eat tons of eggs,bacon,sausages and burgers! and most of them still looking like shit after years eating this way !!!! by the way most of UA-cam proponents of this diet are QUITTING
The only one I know of that quit carnivore is Salidino. Who else?
I agree, i just given up with people.
@@DrDanMaggs what about your potassium and magnesium our ancestors didn’t have supplements
I had a session with an ADA dietician who insisted I have at least 40 grams of carbs at every meal? apparently their advice is to sell more insulin.
Thanks, Dr Dan, for yet another great video that's detailed-pack..yet totally accessible...much appreciated. 👍
How have I missed this video until today? I've been subscribed to you channel for years. This is the single most informative video about carbs on UA-cam. Thank you, Dr Dan.
Wow, so many comments here sound like talking points from the BBC or ABC. If you're overweight, diabetic, insulin resistant or suffer from a myriad of other ailments, low carb eating will end much suffering for most. Keep up the good work Dr. Maggs.
Clear and concise as always, thanks much Dr.Maggs. Cheers.
The best explanation I've heard yet! Brilliant, thank you Dr Dan Maggs 😊
Well done. I appreciate the way you broke things down. 👍
Clear, concise great vid 👍
A brilliant video, very well explained, thank you Dr Dan. !!
Another great video Dr Maggs. Thank you again.
Well done - hopefully one or two more people will start to look into this harder - very clear
nothing I didnt know before...but elegant and comprehensive and a pleasure to listen to.
Best explanation I’ve seen. Bookmarked as my go to video to explain this to others.
Thank you, Dr. Maggs. I absolutely agree with you.
Thanks Dr. Dan!
We may not need them but we certainly WANT them!
Excellent information as there is so much controversy on the subject. To eat carb or not to eat carbs that’s the question😊 love how you present your answer. 👍
Fabulous vid and straight to the point..... I fully agree with everything he said.
You need to do better research.
You mentioned lectins but not the extreme danger of oxalates particularly in vegetables. I really appreciate your videos and am subscribed. You invited comment.
Personally I’m trying to avoid both lectins and oxalates. After listening to various inputs on the subjects it appears to be a fact that oxalates are the most dangerous.
Thank you for sharing this
Well said 👊
Well done
In normal circumstances carbohydrates may be less important but I work out using light weight ultra high reps for conditioning and some Sprint/speed running Stamina and carbohydrates really help me. Perhaps Carbohydrates are useful in certain situations...
If I am eating very low-carb, but too much protein to go into ketosis, I definitely feel the need to eat some carbs a few times a week.
When I follow this way of eating, I genuinely do feel fitter and healthier and in all honesty happier!and I do loose weight quite quickly, I don’t necessarily crave sweet things after the initial first few days,but I do tend to mourn for them if that makes sense? The only concern/side effect I have is that I definitely do suffer from hair loss,which Is a worry for someone of my age, it’s at this stage that I do start eating carbs once again…
I know what you mean by mourning carbs. I just completed 30 days of strict carnivore and I feel like it completely reset my body. I tried a cookie on day 31 because I was curious if it would trigger my cravings and set me back. I was very nervous! Funny enough, I thought the cookie was so painfully sweet. It actually made my tongue go numb and I didn’t enjoy it like I would have before. How strange. It’s been a few days since that happened and I still am not craving the carbs. The more sustainable thing for me is switching to a more keto diet trying to keep my carbs as close to zero as possible. I definitely see the benefit in significantly reducing carbs, but doing strict carnivore is not realistic for me. With this experience, I feel more confident that I could indulge in carbs once in a while and not fall off the wagon.
New sub! 🎉
Dear Dr Dan, if an athlete is doing low or no carb diets can we assume their glycogen stores are being replenished by gluconeogenisis of excess fats or proteins? I guess what Im trying to know is do keto athletes have more or less the same access to glycogen as a non-keto athlete and therefore so long as the high energy activity is over before the glycogen is depleted then they would perform similarly? For sure if the activity goes much longer the keto guy/gal will bonk and have to slow down without exogenous carb intake
Athletes must consume carbs
Dr Maggs, would you preserve a video on a copper deficiency & all that it can spin out of range or affect? I had an iron overload and thankfully, my dr is informed on copper. It literally corrected my iron without the pain of donating blood.
Should I go all the way keto (
Been keto for almost a year and feel amazing.
Best video I have viewed. Ever.
Hello Dr. Maggs! Great channel, awesome contents, valuable information. I've been thru keto for a long long time, since 2018. I lost 89 pounds and regain an excellent health.
My fasting glucose was around 89 and HbA1c below 5.5. In my last blood results, my fasting glucose was 105 and HbA1c 5.5. My doctor said it is "glucose sparing" ou physiological insulin resistance.
Is this something to worry about? Would like to hear from you. Thanks
I don't believe anything extreme is good for the body. Feeding only on animal protein is also not a good idea as many youtubers promoting. Not everyone fits on a certain diet like carnivore and Keto diets. I tried both to experiment and found that these diets may cause certain issues to many healthy individuals. I had to stop after a few weeks on each diet. Experienced excessive cloudy, dark foaming urine that never occurred in my whole healthy life. Even though I bought high quality meat and poultry products, grassfed pasture raised organic, you name it. After I switched back to my mediterranean diet, these symptoms totally reversed to normal LESS than 48 hours. Note that I am healthy, sporty and athletic person. No need doctor visits, prescriptions and any kind of vaccines, my whole life, at least till now.
There is no diet fits all. Diets are good and necessary, I admit, for people with health problems to fix, and they are only temporary as a treatment.
There are also phytochemicals, polyphenols, etc that are proven disease modifiers in plants.
I'm goin to try a "carb free" Jan 🤞
I drink about one litre of raw jersey cow 5% fat milk per day. So even though i dont eat vegetables, i do get some carbs from the lactose.
This is so good!! I’m already thinking of someone I’m dying to send this too!! Thank you thank you!!
I’ve said, “My energy is already on my body”!? 😂 (About 22 lbs worth)
Meat has all the nutrients we need. I totally agree with toxins in plants (“They don’t have the luxury of running away” 😂)
keto and carnivore are fad trend bullshit people use as a excuse to eat tons of eggs,bacon,sausages and burgers! and most of them still looking like shit after years eating this way !!!! by the way most of UA-cam proponents of this diet are QUITTING
Dr.Dan :
I want to make a
mushroom soup, but
I am worried about the carbs in the creme.
I am very iR !
Should I skip the creme in my soup?
Mike.
Ha! Before I even watch the rest of your video I'm going to copy a comment I just posted on a Ken Berry interview video. 👉 Awesome! Very interesting. But guess what, all I REALLY need to know, and all other human beings need to know, is that we don't want or need to ingest carbohydrates. Ya, sure, "stay hydrated", but carbs are key. Love you guys! Eat Meat Save The Planet. 💪💖 / 💖🙏💖 / 💪🌎 (An interview with Richard Johnson, MD)
I have just come across this video but it is interesting because I have a UA-cam channel & my recent video details my non-scientific anecdotal evidence of what Dr Dan Maggs is explaining. I am 81 years of age & am able to be fully functional at performing feats of extreme athleticism. My dietary intake is much the same as is promoted on this video & the benefits are astounding.
I'm a keen road cyclist and cycle a few 100 miles a week in addition to swimming twice a week, a couple of spinning classes and/or weight training and circuit training. Could I do all this easily without carbs, since, although fat is very calorific, it's slow to digest and convert to energy?
100% you could. It would take time to adapt, but there are plenty of ketogenic endurance athletes out there.
I can't ensure for the performance, but I can ensure you that it's perfectly possible. Since I've fat adapted, I can easily run 10k after 24 hours of fasting. I even ran after a 36-hour fast. Maybe, just maybe, on shorter and more intense runs, having glycogen stored in the muscles may improve performance. However, once you run/cycle beyond one hour, glycogen is depleted anyway, so being fat adapted helps avoiding "the wall" or that constant urge to eat energy bars that is typical in endurance events.
It depends on the person. I’m doing healthy keto and am walking (intense walking like through rugged terrain with steep hills etc) 15,000+ steps a day. I have a lot more energy and endurance without the carbs (I’m also doing OMAD as I feel much better with just the one meal edit - I only walk fully fasted). But some people insist they cannot function without carbs so it depends on the individual!!
Once you cut fruits out of your diet it's actually hard to reintroduce them as they cause digestion problems. I've learned that I basically can't eat strawberries anymore.
Well said... Ketones are neuroprotective.
I am slowly turning my diet into keto, its just hard to do, cause my parents won't listen.
HI! there is a video that explains how carbs creat free radicals and saterated fat is not based on the catabolism process and some electron exchange but i can not find it maybe they delete.Any info on that ?Keep up telling the truth!
I eat a lot of fiber to feed the microbes. They in turn are supposed give nutrients back.
Doesn't Breast milk contain some carbohydrate. Would it be advisable to eliminate all carbohydrates from Birth or post puberty 🤔!
Vitamin C is a carbohydrate, and - as you said yourself - we need vitamin C. So we need atleast one type of carbohydrates.
Vitamin C is in meat particulary organ meats such as liver. Zoe Harcombe covers this as well.
As usual, fantastic stuff Dr. Dan. Question, if I have a heavy carb day, but then do 30-45 mins of moderate cardio, will most of those carbs be burned (and ketosis spared)? Can I eat more carbs with more cardio? Thanks!
I don’t think it works like that - our bodies don’t burn stuff - we utilise foodstuffs for our nutritional needs - foods that cause inflammation cannot support such needs- however I reckon if it’s infrequent- you’re like to be fine ❤️
in my personal understanding. no but it would be better instead if u do the reverse. first burn carbs off and Then eat the said carbs. to refuel ur glycogen stores after some heavy cardio or somthing , however if we r talking carbs in particular.. something like a mango is fine since its sugar and carbs both still convert to glucose anyway
as long as u don't exceed ur caloric deficit , u shouldn't gain to much weight, rather u can maintain it and still produced the desired energy , but ur still going to stay mostly carb dependent , and never fat adapt
andrew huberman actually follows this practice
but keep in mind this all relates to ur health and ur constitution .. if u are someone that is insulin resistant or diabetic or overweight or blood sugar or age etc etc.
I ordered a steak Monday the waitress badgers me for five minutes about my sides. Just the steak thank you
If you need additional information check out Dr Eric Westman’s videos. He wholeheartedly believes in low carb..his credentials are outstanding ❤
fiber bad?what about digestion? fibre in carrots binds to excess endotoxins and cleans our gut,still bad?
Hi! 😊 I discovered your channel 6 days ago and I decided to cut carbohydrates from my diet, and so far it has been amazing, I’ve lost 2’2kg and 390 grams of fat, and I’m very happy and grateful. The only problem is that I have also lost 60 grams of bone mass and it is starting to worry me a lot, does anyone know why it might be happening? Any supplements or food that can help me with this problem? Thank you so much ❤ (and sorry if my English isn’t perfect, I’m from Spain)
Maybe try drinking yogurt? I know it's a good way of getting calcium.
Take a look at the Mediterranean diet. This video is too oriented towards meat eating. If you lookup lectins you will find a less opinionated explanation. As for Carbohydrates, less processing. Your body runs on carbohydrates not fats or protein.
Don't forget K2 ;-) it helps
I'm zero carb carnivore last 6mo.. doing fine
Fat adapted humans can have extremely low glucose levels. I think values of 40 or even 20 mg/dl have been observed.
Hardly eaten any carbs since March this year. Never felt better.
I think it depends on the person. I have an elderly friend who just turned 80. She has been a vegan almost her entire life and is very proactive about her health. This woman is as healthy as a horse! Except for a bit of knee pain, she takes 0 medications and has no known ailments. I know 50 year olds that are not as healthy as her. Myself - I'm a mess. I was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes over 20 years ago and was never advised on what to eat except in the past few years. I ate what I wanted (within reason) and took my medication as I was told. For quite some time my A1C was below 6.0 and my doctors didn't try to change anything. Then, around 2017 my A1C started to creep up to over 7.0. I haven't been able to get it under control since, at least without causing another problem. I've recently started Intermittent Fasting and trying to eat a low-carb diet, but it's hard. I go for bloodwork in June so we'll see how things go.
Yes, for our tongue!
Fibre is food for the Gut bacteria right? How can we maintain gut health without it?
OMG Fiber... I started eating carnivore 9 months ago and I can't tell you how many times I got into arguments with my siblings about fiber. Everyone on this planet seems to be brainwashed that we NEED fiber, which is pure nonsense.
Number one macronutrient consumed in blue zones are carbohydrates. These aren’t greasy highly processed carbohydrates but they are carbohydrates.
fruits and vegetables are almost entirely carbs and you need fruits and veggies or certainly are helped by them. many ppl think of pasta and bread as what carbs are. you don't really need those but you do need fruits and veggies.
so why is it that keto low carbers cannot perform well in some sports?
Depends on the pets also in the activity. For me yes need carbs.
Isn't it the case that to rest the gut one must refrain from high fiber? I believe the elimination diet consists of meat, fish and eggs. That way your system can heal and one can figure out what allergies are contributing to poor health/obesity/etc.
Running on ketones for several days, but not as regular as before and feeling bloated. OMAD and keto. Any suggestions?
The bloating most likely to come from certains plants , what you eat other than meat ?
@@richardcardinale7152 yes, I'm trying to eat a salad and cruciferous veggies with my meat.
@@rickthain8538 There's the bloating.
keto and carnivore are fad trend bullshit people use as a excuse to eat tons of eggs,bacon,sausages and burgers! and most of them still looking like shit after years eating this way !!!! by the way most of UA-cam proponents of this diet are QUITTING
@@richardcardinale7152 keto and carnivore are fad trend bullshit people use as a excuse to eat tons of eggs,bacon,sausages and burgers! and most of them still looking like shit after years eating this way !!!! by the way most of UA-cam proponents of this diet are QUITTING
Hi Dr dan. First let me say love your videos they have helped me lose 50 lb and keep it off, thanks. My question is how long after I go into ketosis does it take to have ketones in my urine? Thanks, Chuck
Do we Need Animal protein or fat? There is no such thing as animal protein or fat deficiency
Good talk. I am on a life long self transformation. I have been managing/mismanaging Diabetes (Type 2). I recently gave up. By that I mean I threw out everything I had tried and began by: reducing the variables. My goal , instead has become: find my current baseline. I have some experience with intermittent fasting (while taking oral medication) and have seen blood sugar levels go down over a 24 hour period, before. But I have still failed to achieve consistent understanding of exactly what my body is doing - which is really the point here.
So. I tossed the meds entirely. I also began intermittent fasting, again. Initially I could only achieve a resting level of 13.5, which is undesirably high. I began tossing food items and simplifying the food intake. The resting level initially did not change, it hovered around 13.5-13.4 ( over a 20/4 hour split - 20 fast/ 4 eating window). I substituted food items with more simply options and read every single label (my god some of them are in tiny font - glasses while shopping is now mandatory). Alas not much changed.
I went to 32 hour cycle which had me in and around 10.5 (28/4). From this I decided to fast for a longer period. I have a fairly physical job and am in my 67th year and had some serious reservations about whether I would be able to cope with that length of fast - there are some unknowns when making that kind of decision. I went to a 48 hour cycle (45/3). I am happy to report that I am headed downward to normal resting sample numbers - my last reading, yesterday, was 8.1. I have tried introducing food items to judge their effects and at times I go up to double figures (as high as 10.5), which means those foods are not currently an option.
I am well on this journey now. My current concern is calorific intake, which is likely less than the prescribed daily norm. I am ambivalent though, since I am finding that my body is remarkably good at sorting out requirements. My approach to diet at present to learn more about foods - with that I would appreciate some feedback on that subject (where can I get calories and what plant foods should I try?). I will keep my system simple - changing only one variable at a time and take some time to find a range of food within which I can live comfortably. In doing this I may be able to adjust the fast interval at some point in the future. I am determined to not fall off the wagon (ie. eat food, offered, that is unsuitable). I do not smoke and have not drunk alcohol since 2017. This has to be the way my life proceeds from here. For now I am content.
My goodness. You have been on a journey. I don’t understand any of your diabetes numbers - in the UK we don’t use the same formula - as far as I know anyway as I’m not diabetic. Have you ever tried a carnivore woe? I too have struggled with my weight all my life and have listened to all the conflicting information over the years. You now describe yourself as content. That sounds like a plus to me. Keep on keeping on 😁
Diabetes sucks. I got diagnosed with type 2 last year. If it was me I would take medicine. Your blood sugar is way too high and you'll sadly be doing a lot of damage. What foods do you eat? Illness will also affect your numbers. If you are overweight lose weight. It does make a difference to your numbers. Allow the possibility that it may take awhile to heal. My blood sugars are progressively lowering. My HBA1C is going down. I eat at of meat, cream, and eggs. Some cheese and a good quantity of butter. I also drink keto chow which has fat of choice. Most of the time I'll do half a cup of cream but sometimes one whole cup. I have now started intermittent fasting and taking berberine. I really feel for you as I felt the stress in your comment. I hope you find some answers.
@@AnnabellaRedwood 8.1 over the weekend. It is coming down, and that is the point of what I wrote above.
I took medication for around 20 years. I'm over it, mostly because I think I can do it without - normal range is 5-7 resting blood sugar level, I can get there.
I my eating window, I start with a slice of vintage cheddar; I eat a large salad (+zero sugar/carbs mayo): lettuce; spinach; capsicum; cauliflower; broccoli; cabbage; small amount of cashew nuts (chopped); Parmesan cheese; onion; tomato. With the salad I might have a slab of salmon or nice piece of steak or chicken legs or lamb shoulder chops or pork bellies. I prefer animal protein with fat on.
The second meal is smaller: fish or meat with some mushrooms and asparagus.
I close the eating window with a smoothie/bullet: whole milk; hemp protein; Brazil nuts; spinach; zero carb/sugar natural Greek yogurt; pumpkins seeds.
So far I have everything as simple as possible. If I change something I change just one something and toss it if the levels are not moving down. My understanding is that for me to achieve this I have to keep plugging away and know my bodies response to every food.
I can do this.
@@AnnabellaRedwood ... so to reiterate ... I am looking for a high calorie food or two to try (remember I have tossed Avocado).
@@eileenharrison7816 those number are short term, from testing. We have long term 3 month figures which run at 50+ for a diabetic. I do not have access to the units of each, right but I find them ill drop them here.
It always amuses me when it's said that plants contain toxins as a defence to being eaten, then show a clip of a creature that eats nothing other than plants.
The body can synthethize all the sugar, that´s not the issue. The issue is that carbs are like the moderator of a nuclear reactor, cooling the metabolic hyperacceleration that eating only (or almost) protein and fat causes. Something that you do not want long term. Maybe you have other means of achieving the same "yin" counterbalance like relaxing and meditating every day, but it´s way more practical to just eat some healthy carbs, like a banana or a potato.
I was thought that eating fibers improves your bowel movement. What is your opinion on that?
8:40 you people dont even watch the video and you are so opinionated 😆
Define "improve ". Eating sand paper might also "improve " your bowel movements when eating lots of empty carbs.
You dont need Fiber, its not even digestible.
Another myth.
Since fibre is not digestible, it irritates the walls of the intestines which in turn produce a mucus to deal with the irritation. This is a laxative effect, which the body will get used to (ultimately not good). In fact, there's a recent study done involving people with chronic constipation. They were broken up into three groups...high fibre intake, moderate fibre intake and zero fibre intake. It was only the zero fibre diet that saw 100% of the group resolve their constipation. Makes sense if you understand that "bulk" simply adds to the problem.....it's like trying to relieve a traffic jam by sending in more cars.
Type 1 diabetics absolutely need exogenous carbs. Outside of that group, gluconeogenesis is a sufficient process for generating glucose from excesses in protein consumption for everyone else so that exogenous carbs are not necessary.
I am on a low carb diet, can't call it keto because I'm not hard enough on food choice. However, without my daily salad, I'd have big problems in reaching satiety without blowing the calorie budget. Also, I've read in many keto sites, that vegetables don't cause insulin spike.
Maybe you need to eat more protein?
Or up the fat!
A salad wont satiate you, meat and fat will.
I react to salad, bad RA flares. A salad is fine if you can tolerate it. Adding more fat, like butter, will keep you fuller.
@@eileenharrison7816 Thank you for the suggestion, but I think I am already at an optimal level with regards to protein quantity. It's also a matter of time it takes for my body to feel full, so if I start dining with a big salad (with olives, cheese, nuts and seeds) I enjoy the later dishes more with less hunger.
I am on the carnivore diet for 3.5 years... anctually, I follow the RAW carnivore diet, that is, I eat the meat and organ meats (liver, kidney, brain, etc) RAW! I eat certain bugs, too. (also raw: grashoppers, cicadas, locusts, praying mantis, May beetle, mealworms, superworms, certain spiders, even earthworms... okay, this last is neither a bug, nor an insect... I drink fresh blood, the natural energy drink...)
And my energy skyroketed, my depression is gone, no itchy skin, no aknes, no low back pain, lost approx. 12 kg of weight, better sleep, no extreme irritability...
Don't eat the bugs, it can poison you due to their chitin having heavy metals.
@@nushia7192 Dear Nushia, the thing is, we humans still have to eat something. Everything we eat has risks. There is simply no such thing as something that is exclusively healthy and has no harmful effects. Unfortunately, this is the case, because stupid humanity has repeatedly polluted the Earth and contaminated every food chain with all kinds of harmful substances, be it plant or animal. A long time ago, our world is not as clean - no more - in terms of food as it was in the Paleolithic. The most we can do to decide which food source we think is the healthiest and least harmful is to eat it and avoid the rest. In my opinion, eating insects has a lot of benefits, because insects are rich in essential amino acids, and compared to this benefit, the risk of any harm is small. I admit, "small" is not the same as nothing, zero...
Sadly to say, but we have to take some risks, because we cannot live on sunlight alone, unfortunately.
Interesting but irrelevant question. The diets of all healthy and long lived populations of people consists of foods like whole grains and beans i.e. foods containing carbohydrates. Low carb diets is associated with higher mortality i.e statistically it increases your risk of dying prematurely. But low carb is great if you want to fit into a skinnier casket.
There’s some really horrid, childish people on the responses to comments- replying to me - swearing etc because I’ve commented on my success on a low carb way of life. That’s two v scathing, insulting replies to my positive progress. 😞 Thought you might want to know
Carbs are king! Dont listen to the low carb zealots
This is absolutely the opposite message to that given by Tim Spector. It leaves me confused. What of the research on the role of our gut biota for immune and mental health, aka the Gut Brain Axis?
Neither promote empty carbs obviously.
This video certainly does have value for everyone. Personally speaking - meat healed my acid reflux, my carb addiction, obesity, insulin resistance , changes in vision, low blood sugar, gallbladder, pancreatitis and kidney problems. As a result I'm able to find the time to conduct research regarding a hypothesis I have regarding one possible fundamental reason as to why many members of both the Greatest Generation and the Baby Boomer cohort were both so late at beginning a KETO journey In one word: Popeye. Beginning in 1929, the creators and publishers of the comic strip and the cartoons began a campaign of what perhaps can be referred to as pro-vegan "Popeye-ganda." part of the popular culture zeitgeist for decades. Popeye of course claimed he was "strong to the finich 'cause I eats me Spinach." As a result, countless parents encouraged their children for decades to "eat your vegetables so you'll be strong like Popeye." Remember also that it was common for kids to watch Popeye cartoons between arriving home from school and sitting down to dinner. Talk about timing. To counterbalance things somewhat, of course, the character Wimpy was something of a carnivore with his preference for hamburgers he couldn't pay for. . One cultural milestone which pushed back against this trend was when President Herbert Walker Bush, certainly and proudly told the world that he simply didn't like eating broccoli. Carry on Carnivore Warriors, proud and strong here in the midst of this glorious holiday season
The problem is this - there are different kinds of carbs - and some are better for you than others. So to think carbs as a whole are bad for you is not the full story. Do your research and eat some good carbs, even if you are favouring keto. I'm not overweight and eat mainly a carb based diet - but I don't eat anything processed - and it is ok - you burn the carbs and it is self maintaining. If you are overweight, going keto for a short time is ok, to encourage your body to burn fat - but once you are at your ideal weight, don't make the mistake of thinking keto is it for life - long term there are problems with it. Once you are at your ideal weight, eat a calorie controlled diet - doesn't need to be keto, it can be anything as long as it isn't processed food - at your ideal weight, the only thing that matters is don't eat more calories than you burn.
Not good science here for aerobic athletes. Pretty simple you need glucose in your bloodstream and glycogen in your muscles and liver to fuel high aerobic exercise. How you do you think these sugars are acquired? LOW aerobic exercise if fueled by fats sure, but an aerobic athlete requires carbs to perform. Period.
You STILL didn't address the issue of vitamin deficiencies. Let's talk about vitamin C. I'm not willing to say I don't need it simply because the Inuit don't; they may have some evolutionary adaptation. I personally get sniffly when I'm not eating enough greens or fruit. I can fix that by eating a couple of kumquats from my tree. There are other vitamins/minerals that are pretty low in meat that can be found in salmon or shellfish, but I and lots of other people can't afford to eat those on a regular basis.
I’m on healthy keto and the bulk of it is green vegetables, cauliflower rice, mushrooms, tomato, and a little meat. I would never do carnivore but feel so much better eating the way I am now :) (and if you got concerned about vit C, a bit of lemon in your water is very low carb)
Everyone is different though and different things work for different people ^_^
plants are bad in moderation,ever heard of hormetic stress? ever heard how carbs effect steroid hormones?
Jeez, not another UA-cam chiropractor talking about nutrition.
Better not eliminate carbohydrates from your diet. It's not an experiment you should be willing to try on yourself on the long term. You ll probably gain nothing and put a great stress on your metabolism. This might be great periodically or under certain medical conditions even therapeutic but not sustainable. No deficiency equals no problem. Are you sure? All macro and micronutrients are potentially toxic. Lipids especially, proteins too, let alone carbohydrates. Brain works far better on ketones! Liver produces glucose from fat so everything is cool and normal! Great narrative!
Hey Dr. Dan, I really enjoy your videos, I did learn a lot from it. But would it be possible to talk a little slower. I do understand most of it even english is not my first language. But for some people it can be hard to follow your conversation becouse theit first language is not enlish 😀
Hi! I always seem to get comments from people saying I talk too slowly! Difficult to make everyone happy. Every video of mine has good quality subtitles/closed captions. Hope that helps you! Thanks for watching.
Why don't you simply slow down the video through speed settings to 0.75x?
gearwheel icon and set playback speed as desired
@@tomikk86 Hmm, never thought on that, ty and I did try it, It works :)
mangos are essential
Yap... Everything you say is true. But, just not the all true.
It's the same just to say that fat is not need for our body, cous it can be made from our body. And if our body need only essential nutrition to exist. That it's better just to make them and take it with some kind of powder mix. And we will be happy 😊 living people 🤔
Do we need carbs? Well, we may do better with fuel injection or battery power. 😔
what do eat to get enough potasium then?
Avocado 🥑
@@thomasrobinson4401 nah thats not enough there not a daliy dose in that
Zero carb diets have completely different requirements. It's shown for e.g. vitamin C and magnesium. Probably true for potassium, too. Some people seem to just eat steak and no electrolytes and are fine.
@@wocket42 idk when you loose weight u wash out electrolytes too right as the body dump some of the water if holds
@@silverbulletin846 Plus, they're expensive and not always in season.
I will save you 11:16. The answer is, no.
TBF I do say this at 0:23!
@@DrDanMaggs You are correct, sir 😁
Try to push your limits and gain muscles at the gym without carbs lol
.. .. We need Protein, yes, we need fats.yes. AND we benefit from basic carbs, although correctly we do not Need carbs -
What about our microbione which NEED the fibers in Carbs. . ?
And do not most problems arising from modern carbs come mostly from : processed carbs,. and high level consumption ? and I would also add " difficult " food combining (protein+carbs) harder to metabolise for many people now .
The bacteria that thrive on carbs and fiber will simply die off and be replaced by bacteria that thrive on fat and protein.