Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
U.S.S Voyager VS U.S.S Enterprise D (BETA)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 сер 2024
- Basically Voyager VS the Enterprise. THis video wasn't created to be anything special, it was just intended as a BETA, IE a test for Sony Vegas 8, and i think it turned out alright lol.
All comments are helpful
Enjoy!
![T-800 CSM 101 Arrival | Terminator 2: Judgment Day [Remastered]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XPtVZ69lomk/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG I love how Riker dies then comes back to life like half a second later. Lmfao.
Might've been his stunt double who died.
0:30 Janeway, "I think there's been some kind of misunderstanding...."
Picard: "Load torpedo bays, arm phasers". Picard doesn't care what you think.
Also who heard the random Windows XP tones here and there.
I was going to say good video but no... The video is horrible. Voyager would get obliterated... Enterprise is a superior ship and Picard is a million times a better captain.
So reading comments i agree that voyager is an awesome ship and newer tech than the enterprise D. BUT lets be realistic, voyager is still an intrepid class long range science vessel, Enterprise D is a galaxy class starship (flagship of the federation) .
Enterprise has much higher hull strength( hull HP) , and a higher compliment of phaser banks and torpedo bays. larger capacity shield generator (shield HP)
Also forgetting that enterprise D can separate and form an attack formation.
Voyager has done some amazing things and has added new tech like (borg) but these are two ships in different leagues. if voyager was able to defeat enterprise it would never be in a straight on battle , they would get creative in order to defeat them, come down to what crew is quicker and smarter example : seven vs data, bellona vs laforge etc.
inuyasha0550 Voyager is long range tactical ship...
threshi I didnt argue, i was only correcting your assumption that Intrepid class is a long range science vessel.
"The Intrepid-class was designed for long-term exploration missions." source : memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Intrepid_class.
The Intrepid class ship has nothing to do in tactical class it's an exploration vessel with high capacities in science.
Kaigoshi Sorry, but this is wrong. In the episode Relativity it is "long range tactical", the borg say it, and somewhere else it was said too. Looking for proofs, but this might take a while. If you have, rewatch relativity, im 100% sure it was said there.
voyager has a advance shield than enterprise
Thanks :D Didn't think it was too bad for a beta XD
#2 flies off and dies, then next scene he's perfectly fine. Love it.
I think that Voyager would win... (let's take a comparison of tactical's just in case)
Galaxy class (USS Enterprise-D): 10 phaser arrays, 2 torpedo launchers (fore and aft), 250 photon torpedoes, high capacity deflector shield grid
Intrepid class (USS Voyager): 18 phasers (14 phaser arrays, 4 (additional, seperate) phaser emitters), 5 torpedo launchers (2 fore, 2 aft, 1 dorsal), 2 tricobalt devices, spatial charges, a dozen of transphasic torpedes, deflector shields, ablative hull armour
What a clever video. Not really fussed about who would win in theory. I just thought that it was fun. And the advert at the start was hillarious! Cheers mate!
Thanks allot :D Never noticed that MSN noise till i uploaded it lol =]
Let me just say, voyager never stood a chance it’s a small research vessel vs This Hulking Galaxy class which is massive and heavily armed.
ROFLMFAO!!!!! You guys crack me up with all of your arguing over which ship would win. XD
@kage1979 Actually, not one Galaxy Class ship was destroyed during the Dominion war. they all survived, granted, we saw some taking some hefty damage. This is canon by the way.
Okay i know I'm super late to this game....but this tracks. The Intrepid class was designed as a pocket Galaxy class, with a class 9 warp core that puts out more power than warp cores of its time. It also had the same type ten phaser emitters, and type 6 VS the type 4 torpedos a Galaxy class has. It was also more mauverable and had better computer systems. The advantage the Galaxy class has is more room for redundant systems and heavier shield generators. All in all between the advantages and disadvantages of both class's, it could go either way depending on the skill of the crew and command capability of their respective Captain's.
Woot you go Janeway!! :D 5/5
I love the MSN messenger sound lol
3:16 and 3:17 is funny. One second he is dead, the next, he is alive.
Despite the high-tech enhancements on Voyager, it really depends on what an Intrepid class starship is design for and is capable of versus what a base line Galaxy class platform is design for and capable of. My laptop is two years younger than my desktop and cost a bit more, but capability-wise my desktop still beats the heck out of my laptop.
Anyway, good video! Very smooth cuts that told an easy to follow story.
cool video!! thanks for entering!!
Voyager was a much newer ship, the Galaxy class might be bigger, but it had defects that Voyager's crew would've been well aware of. Voyager was also considerably faster and more maneuverable.
that was good, but i cant help but notice how you have a dark damaged enterprise, then its bran new. but that was well made. i like the way you had adapted the screens, at the front of the bridge to show each ship.
Lol at the "open a channel point"
Actually, and we are going deep into "ubernerd" territory now, the top speed of the Sovvy was never given, but Rick Sternbach, the guy who designed it, said that it would have a top speed of warp 9.980, topping the 9.975 given for Voyager. Only a Prometheus could maybe outrun a Sov. As far as firepower, Voyager is newer, but not more powerful than a Galaxy, and a Galaxy is not more than a Sovvy. But, anything can be souped up, but we are using stock models here.
Um. No.
U.S.S. Voyager was not a war ship it was a science craft.
The U.S.S. Enterprise D was the lead ship of the federation.
How did Katherine Janeway {Awesomeness} defeat Jean-Luc Picard {the greatest captain in Star fleet?
~ Marie7Sheild (STO)
Lt. Captain Natal Marie Sara
U.S.S. Georgia
If anything, Enterprise-D and Voyager would be fighting side-by-side, not against each other. It still seems unrealistic that an Intrepid-class could go up against a starship twice its size.
What would have made the destrucion of the Enterprise better was if Voyager shot one last torpedo at the Enterprise's other nacelle, thus causing the moment of victory to be greater.
Come on Enterprise could wip voyagers ass!!! Enterprise is more than twice voyagers size, and why did Riker get his head chopped half way off and then come back to life...?????????
But the Enterprise could have gone full speed on Voyager separate the saucer section and smash the Voyager. Taadaaa!!!!
It would have had to initiate separation before attempting the maneuver.
But Voyager would have out maneuvered Enterprise (Voyager is more maneuverable and faster than Enterprise; Enterprise's max warp is 9.6, Voyager's 9.975) and used the things they found in the Delta quadrant (Borg systems, Seven, armor from season 7, maybe even the Slipsteam).
@@ppenmudera4687 also enterprise d can only hold 9.6 for 12 hours voyager can hold 9.975 indefinetly and can go faster for short bursts of time.
this is great!!! =D
you just missed 1 thing, first you let Riker die around 3:14. then at 3:18 he's alive and at his post. just so u know. =]
What episodes? TNG: any shots where the crew has the shiny belts are from "Yesterday's Enterprise." The shots at the end where the ship blows up were from "Cause and Effect." The Voyager shots with the line of explosions on the top were from "Year of Hell." Not sure about the rest.
Using Sony Vegas Pro, it lets you basically play about with videos so you can produce different effects etc
absolutely brilliant editing.......but ill tell you THIS, unless it was a large natural chested beauty, i woulda STRANGLED that msn contact for ruining my vid lol. had to rewind it to make sure i wasnt nuts......my msn wasnt even open lol
If you do a comparison between the Enterprise D and Voyager, Voyager can kick it's ass...... Voyager is faster and more maneuverable, can process data way faster then the Enterprise, had more advanced photon torpedoes, phasers, and deflector shields, had better spatial charges, better Captain and Crew, the list can go on........................ Now if the Enterprise E and Voyager fought then Voyager would be screwed because the Enterprise E was more advanced and had more firepower as well...... If the Enterprise separated the saucer section, Voyager would've blown it up to the high heavens because while separating the Enterprise would be very vulnerable and prone to destruction unlike the Prometheus which can still fully defend itself while engaging the Multi-Vector Assault Mode....... Just putting it out there........
Voyager also has Borg technology, not to mention it is around 10 years newer than the enterprise so technological advancement is immense
As Voyager is younger and therefore more advanced she could with out a doubt be evenly matched against Enterprise D and do extensive damage to the Enterprise D due to being small and having more advanced weapons and shields as you said but Enterprise has enough phaser banks to rip Voyager apart if shields were down but would likely miss due to Voyagers speed and ability to out manoeuvre .
@miloootic It seems you don't get sarcasm. It doesn't matter if VOY's crew was 200 or 2000, they won't be shown on TV EVER. BTW, nice description of mentioning whatever is expected of your average starfleet captain as if it somehow were some of Janeway's merits. It was her freaking job!
wow just wow....Enterprise would have kicked Voyagers ass. Just look at the Dominion War,Galaxies everywhere kicking ass not stopping to take names. The only Intrepid we see was a glorified courier.
You also do not see any Sovereigns,Prometheus,Defiants(except the hero ship) does that mean they are bad? it has been officially stated that all 4 classes of ships fought in the dominion war but not on screen,not to mention the times Galaxy classes blew up and had warp core breaches from space dust,the newer ships had more advanced system and better cores.
Riker dies and comes back to life....Iconians D:
Oh yeah, there is more...
"VGR has more advance power systems and survived in the Delta Quadrant"
Thats called WRITING. If it had been Ent-D out there, exact same thing. As far as the power. Episode "Booby Trap", Ent D had its energy sucked outa it for almost a day, til there was almost none left. As soon as force doing it was neutralized, Ent D powered right back up and unleased a torpedo salvo, a large one.
VGR spent most of the first season trying to get its power back. OWNED
@rossco010 Technically you're right, but the very act of attacking began the hostilities. It's kinda like Pearl Harbor. We weren't officially at war with Japan when they hit us, but those ships still were considered casualties of war. Just the first. The declaration was just to make it official that war between the U.S. and Japan was in progress.
Riker: *gets killed from his throat slice*
Also Riker: *survives after getting killed*
Q
LOVE the VGR fanboys and their delusions. "VGR has 13 phaser banks to Ent-Ds 12!"
Yeah, since the two main phaser arrays on Ent-D could wrap around VGR twice. Each bank is hundreds of individual emitters. Ent-D OWNS VGR.
"VGR has four torpedo lanuchers to Ent D's two"
Yeah, and Ent D can fire as many as 8 (canon) or 10 (Tech manl) at a time. Vgr's has NEVER shown to fire more than single bursts alternating between the two tubes either front or back. OWNED
dude freakin awesome
Oh man! I wanted Enterprise to win. Good video though. I could tell most of this was from different episodes, but how did you change what appeared on the viewscreen?
Then again the Sov is bound to have upgraded shield generators compared to the Galaxy as well as its phasers and Quantum torpedoes :P
Screw that. No fucking way would Janeway of all people be able to tactically outdo Jean-luc Picard, not to mention the shear firepower compared to Voyager. I admit, it's a damn tough ship, and very versatile, but there is no way it could stand up to the Enterprise.
great video!!!!!
The Enterprise-D is stronger than the Voyager
It’s definite seriously Voyager is a Multi Mission Science vessel and The galaxy class is a literal warship
I see now without the warp core the Enterprise D would be powerless, while we all been talking about Voyager and Enterprise D and their main phasers, warp core, warp speed, and the techonology of the respected ships we shoud throw in their captains
Captain Jean Luc Picard and Captain Kathryn Janeway we should threw in their skills and leadership in the battle
@NANOFORGE That canon blew ginormous holes THROUGH a Negh'var battleship with SINGLE hits. Right THROUGH the Negh'var's shields as if they weren't even raised. Totally wiped out said Negh'var in five hits. Capable of Warp 13, cloakable, and even though we didn't see it...most likely had Quantum upgrades. Oh, and don't downgrade speculate a Galaxy's torp output. It's a Batlleship, so it will get the top powered torps. Voyager would not under normal conditions, but even if it did..it can't fire 8
Also kudos to the enterprise D being destroyed by a warp core breach . That is a great running gag.
Voyager would be toast. No one on that ship can hold a candle to Data. Riker is a better first officer than Chakotay. Word vs. Tuvok would be interesting to see but it's Worf. Picard is the better captain. It's Enterprise D, easy. (Let Counselor Troi and 7 fight over who gets to wear the distracting suits during the battles. 7 wins that one.)
Glad to see that it was edited where Voyager won! I know in a real fight Enterprise D would open a big can of whip ass on Voyager, but I've always liked Janeway and the crew of Voyager more than TNG crew. I like certain people on the Enterprise, and that ship is always going to be my favorite, but Voyager is like the tough lil brother/sister/cousin we all have!
Voyager did go faster than 9.975, transwarp.
@miloootic So, is that why Picard was the one who took command of SF in the Battle of Sector 001 and not her? Janeway wasn't in Delta quadrant yet AFAIR. Not to mention she got kicked upstairs while Picard is too proud to step down from his starship.
Niice... Voyager sustained heavy damage... but at least they won :D
@BrandisLee ahem..."reality"???
were still talking about a sci-fi show that plays almost 400 years in the future right? ^^
*New and improved versions of battle scenes coming soon =] *
@NANOFORGE at a time PER launcher. In a burst all at once (5 to 6), or a long rapid string of them. Voyager can alternate port/starboard one shot at a time for a max spread of 4. You've got to realize, there are reasons for classifications of warships based off of size and power. Intrepids are Light Cruisers. Akira's are Cruisers, sometimes called Heavy Cruisers. Galaxy's are Battleships and so are Sovereigns. Defiant on DS9 is called a "Destroyer", but is a full warship. Starships are weaker.
thats what happens when you go on msn too much and your a starship captain :(
Hah, good stuff. Though you killed Riker and brought him back. Was sorta funny. Otherwise, nice attempt.
Lastly "Ent D was destroyed by an old BOP while fighting with everything it had...VGR took on GOD and the prophets with no shields and survived without a bit of Janeway's hair outa place!"
First...If you count, during "Generations"...Ent-D took between 18 and 20 direct hits with no shields, including to the engines. (those were just the ones we could see and hear) Thats pretty good since we dont know the true output of the klingon weapons or of the enemies that attacked VGR.
Also voyager was able to go toe to toe with a borg tactical cube, somthing that would have utterly spanked the ent D
@Luvcreole The Federation wasn't in a declared state of war with the Dominion at the time the Odyssey was destroyed. The Dominion War began in Season 5, Odyssey was destroyed in Season 2.
@miloootic So I guess that must be why Picard took FORCEFULLY command of SF? That policy doesn't have anything to do with ranks. Picard still didn't outrank Janeway, yet he was so much more badass no one dared to dispute his leadership. And I tell you again, SF promoted Janeway to admiral because they didn't want her to take another starship ever, but they couldn't kick her out, so they kicked her upstairs. Meanwhile Picard ALWAYS refused his promotion, and that has been stated too many times.
Janeway sounds pissed at 2:04
P.S. It's good for a beta
P.S.S. I would love to make one of these types of videos. Could you possibly show me how?
2:00 AIM/AOL instant message?
@miloootic Again, if Mr. RICKY is in control of Ent-E because Picard had malaria that day, Riker was honeymooning, Data asploded, Dr. Crusher was in the med school and Worf/Geordi were trying to prevent the entire SF from being wiped out, nobody in their right mind would let him to take control of the entire fleet. I think it is you who saw the series, but didn't really pay attention nor have too much of a common sense.
Yeah sure thing, it's easy enough when you get the hang of it. I'm about to start work on another one. Any suggestions? =]
@FleetAdmiral08 Yeah, and while a "Arleigh Burke" class Destroyer is more advanced than even the updated Iowa class WW2 era Batlleships Wisconsin, New Jersey, or Iowa...you don't suppose the Arleigh Burke would stand a chance against any one of those battle wagons, right?
Janeway would be best to not destroy 1701-D. While I believe it would be a close battle, (1701-D is Bigger and more weapons whereas Voyager is faster and more maneuverable) Last I checked, Picard gets a new ship afterwards and the 1701-E ain't nothing to fuck with. Voyager won't scratch the 1701-E and I never seen Janeway get a new ship, just saying
It's the beard ya know!
I don't know the Intrepid class is allot more maneuverable that the Galaxy :P
@miloootic I take it you never watched the VOY premiere? The crew you saw during the series WASN'T the crew Janeway used to have before the series. They were wiped out. Did Kirk lose his crew? No. Did Picard lose his crew? No! And the major consensus AGREES that Janeway was promoted to prevent her from commanding another starship EVER. Deal with it!
well done gr8
Enterprise D would crush voyager!
@miloootic No. When Harriman took command of the Ent-B, he was outranked by a retired Captain of a DECOMISSIONED, LESSER starship just because he happened to be a leader. If the captain is a douché, it doesn't matter if his ship is the strongest, he will get not any authority whatsoever. Your supposed policies have never been stated onscreen. And yes, Janeway didn't lose her ship, but she lost almost the entire crew. That's worse, so they kicked her upstairs. And Picard/Kirk met more species.
MasterMacLeod yeah but they weren't transported to the delta quadrant by the caretaker either. If voyager explored the whole delta quadrant they would have found way more species. And if there somehow was a temporal anomaly and voyager met a rogue enterprise crew, voyager would always win newer tech, better sensors, adapt quicker, better doctor, etc.
There is no way the voyager would be destroyed that’s a galaxy class cruiser
riker your a god!
It's because he's magic!
lol
=]
That's not entirely accurate...Voyager was the fastest ship built in 2371 (top cruising speed warp 9.975), bioneural circuitry (instead of the outdated isolinear chips on Enterprise-D), and Voyager would be more maneuverable as it is smaller (remember the smaller the ship the easier it is to maneuver; picture a speedboat and an aircraft carrier...sure the carrier has brute force, but it can't hit a small, fast target with much precision)...
Anyway, my 2 cents!
@rossco010 Umm...what about the Odyssey? I do believe it was totalled in the first shots that started the war. By a 24th Century version of the Japanese Zero powered "Divine Wind" aka The kamakaze.
Janeway is awesome and did reach Admiral rank before Picard but come on, Picard was a Captain long long before she was and not just any Captain but Captain of the flagship of the enitre federation starfleet, great vid though and both my fav cpts!!
@miloootic That's assuming the captain is qualified to take control. What if ENSIGN RICKY had been in command of Ent-E? Do you really think they would have let him take command of StarFleet? No, right? Your example fails horribly.
No the Intrepid Class is a substitute to the Galaxy Class. The battle should be a tie.
A wizard did it :P
@Luvcreole Well Pearl Harbour was technically a declaration of war. Why openly declare war when you can just attack by surprise? There's been plenty of incidents of one country attacking another without a state of war being declared. North Korea attacking the south only recently. Plenty of naval battles of the past also.
Voyager could have just outrun the big E.
@miloootic So Janeway was too busy at the Dominion War but Picard somehow wasn't because of unrevealed reasons? May I remind you that ALL of SF had to do with that war and the Ent-D/E crew was no exception? How did Picard outrank Janeway? They were both Captains, and no captain outranks another captain, no matter what ship are we talking about. You do not know if Janeway was there or not, but it wouldn't have mattered anyway. FC Borg would have annihilated her ship anyway. VOY borg are plotholes
I prefer Voyager over TNG but the enterprise is more than a match for Voyager.
Galaxy looked much better, She has more graceful lines like a lady, the Intrepid Class looks like a Tomboy!
@miloootic No. You might not remember when Crusher was left in command of Ent-D. All of her emergency crew were unexperienced noobs. So your point is null. What happens when you get your car to race against a pro cyclist but you crash your car against a tree, the cyclist would win ROFLing the entire time. Such a driver happens to be like Janeway.
I have a few more comments for this video: it was very well made the scenes from other episodes, the only two things that bugged me were that riker somehow came back to life after one second. also that captain janeway and captain picard were great friends hmm does that give you something to think about?
Yeah, if she can be alone in that area of space with one battle after another, and still make it home in perfect shape.. I think her captain and the ship did well. :)
@NANOFORGE If you're gonna use time travel to upgrade Voyager (Endgame), then do the same for the Galaxy class too (All Good Things Come To An End). Don't pit a time enhanced Voyager, loaded with tech that most likely wasn't even standard issue on Intrepids of the future (If they were even still in production by the time Janeway made it to Admiral) against a Picard era Galaxy. Use the Capt. Riker version...Galaxy X, with three nacelles, and Phaser rail canon. Prob called a Type 20 Phaser by then
actually the original specs were to have the sov have like 15 or so shield generators. however in the end it had 5 or 6. however the galaxy has 13 shield generators. so really the galaxy IS more powerful than the sov. even though in games like bc. i would bet on an intrepid winning vs anything, depending on the pilot.
I agree, if you clean it up abit it could be a nice battle to watch. But whats wit hthe IM beeps lol Alwell, I've left you a comment on your channle. I hope we can all work something out.
@trekky74205 Riker is now down to 4 respawns
Firstly because A) This is a beta and just need to throw some ending together and B) everyone knows will riker is magic ^^ =]
comcast and the borg formed an alliance and gave us msn
Well i suppose you could contest that Rikers ok but on the d he's a commander not a captain and picard just gives him all the work to do. And Remember Voyagers more advanced especially after it gets back. Imagine Picard in scorpion- he would have been hopeless against the borg
lol at 1:58 you hear the MSN messenger sound cuz he's using a PCI tuner :D
That was pretty interesting....a little work and you've got something a bit professional.