Coraline by Neil Gaiman | Book vs Movie

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 12

  • @teabbyg-ox8sr
    @teabbyg-ox8sr Рік тому +1

    Man I loved both

  • @tayloredwards4968
    @tayloredwards4968 2 роки тому

    Despite all of their differences. Both the book and the movie are terrifying 😱 and the other mother is the most terrifying cartoon villains ever

  • @prufan
    @prufan 2 роки тому +2

    Coraline and Whybi saved each other, I don't get the issue here?
    He was created so that Coraline has someone to talk too.

    • @prufan
      @prufan 2 роки тому

      And while I liked the book, Coraline was pretty bland in comparison with her movie counterpart, who's got a stronger personality. She's got sass, she's fiery in spirit and she feels things fully. The blue hair was a great touch too.
      Book coraline felt muted in this manner, she was always a little enchanted or a little scared etc.

    • @BookshelftoBigScreen
      @BookshelftoBigScreen  2 роки тому

      Wybie doesn’t exist in the book. It’s not an issue; my own personal preference is the storyline without Wybie because I believe it makes Coraline a stronger character, not having to rely on anyone else but herself.

    • @prufan
      @prufan 2 роки тому

      @@BookshelftoBigScreen " it makes Coraline a stronger character, not having to rely on anyone else but herself." I agree with that in concept, but book Coraline is pretty muted in terms of her character, if it was the movie personality I'd agree completely.

  • @calebpalmer9317
    @calebpalmer9317 Рік тому

    I hate that the movie added the character Whybe as well. I think they did that because they weren't creative enough to deal with the lack of supporting characters

  • @samanthaesquivias8089
    @samanthaesquivias8089 2 роки тому

    I have seen the coraline movie it's my favorite movie

  • @frosty3077
    @frosty3077 Рік тому

    lol cant believe you hated Wybie
    he was a cute add to the movie albeit entirely unnecessary - I mean he does like 1 thing at the very end.
    I loved the movie regardless.
    I dont think Wybie's existence ruins the overall story or lessens Coralines journey in any way.

  • @johntismanariu6978
    @johntismanariu6978 2 роки тому

    hi